Effective diffusion on riemannian fiber bundlesThanks: Partially supported by CONACyT grant 135106.
Abstract.
The purpose of this paper is to provide equations to model the evolution of effective diffusion over a Riemannian fiber bundle (under the hypothesis of infinite diffusion rate along compact fibers). These equations are obtained by projecting the diffusion equation onto the base manifold of the fiber bundle. The projection (or dimensional reduction) is achieved by integrating the diffusion equation along the fibers of the bundle. This work generalizes an put into a general framework previous work on effective diffusion over channels and the interfaces between curved surfaces.
1. Introduction
Understanding spatially constrained diffusion is of fundamental importance in various sciences, such as biology, chemistry and nano-technology. However, solving the diffusion equation in arbitrarily constrained geometries is a very difficult task. One way to tackle it consists in reducing the degrees of freedom of the problem by considering only the main direction(s) of transport.
For example, the study of diffusion on thin channels can be carried out by reducing several spatial degrees of freedom to a single one by means of a projection method. More concretely, consider a process in a channel modeled by a density function that obeys the diffusion equation
subject to the restriction that there is no density flow along the channel’s wall(s). We can construct an effective density function by letting
| (1.1) |
where the region is the section of the channel within two transversal cross sections that are an arc distance of apart over a base curve that “follows” the channel’s geometry (see Figure 1.1), and the variable is the arc-length parameter on this curve. It turns out that this effective density function obeys in an approximate manner an equation of the form (known as a generalized Fick-Jacobs equation)
| (1.2) |
where is given by
| (1.3) |
The function is known as the effective diffusion coefficient and it encapsulates the effect of the channel’s geometry on the diffusion process along the base curve. Much work has been done (see [1, 8, 3, 4, 12, 6, 5, 7, 10, 11]) to find explicit formulas for in terms of geometrical quantities associated to the channel, so that the Fick-Jacobs equation models the evolution of as closely as possible . We can distinguish two cases.
- (1)
Infinite transverse diffusion rate. In this case it is assumed that the density function stabilizes instantly in the transversal directions of the channel. In mathematical terms this means that is constant along these transversal directions. This assumption results in an effective diffusion coefficient that depends on the curvature function of the base curve and -th order geometrical quantities of the cross sections, such as width or area.
- (2)
Finite transverse diffusion rate. In this case the finite time of transversal stabilization of is taken into account. This is characterized mathematically in that the resulting formulas for involve the curvature function of the base curve, and tangential and curvature information of the channel’s wall(s).
The selection of the base curve is very important in the dimension-reduction technique described above. This is demonstrated by the fact (see [11, 10]) that if for channels of constant width the base curve is chosen properly, then the formulas for coincide for the finite and infinite transversal diffusion rate cases.
Motivated by the above discussion, we know describe the main purpose of the paper. We develop a very general theory, in the infinite transversal diffusion rate case, for projecting the diffusion equation in a space of dimension to a base space of dimension with . We do this in the context of the theory of fibre bundles. Such objects have a total space , a base space and a projection map . In the case discussed above, the total space is the channel, is the base curve, and sends points on the transversal cross sections (fibers) to their base point in the base curve. The process of passing from the density to the reduced density is a particular case of a very well known construction: that of integrating a differentiable form along the fibers of the bundle. Using these tools we are able to give global and coordinate-free proofs of all our results. In this general setting, the effective diffusion becomes an endomorphism of the tangent bundle of , i.e for every in we have that is a linear map in the tangent space of . We will compute the effective diffusion using local frames instead of local coordinates, which results in a simpler and more geometric way of doing calculations. The paper is organized as follows
- •
In section 2, we show how to reduce the continuity equation in the fiber bundle to a reduced continuity equation in its base space . We prove that if Fick’s law holds on (for a constant diffusion coefficient ) and if we have infinite diffusion rate in fiber direction, then the reduced continuity equation becomes a diffusion equation in (see Proposition 3). This last equation involves an effective diffusion coefficient , which is a bundle endomorphism of the tangent space of .
- •
- •
In section 4 we compute the effective diffusion endomorphism corresponding to the interface of two equidistant surfaces in 3-dimensional space. We do this by showing that the principal directions of the base surface are eigenvectors of , and then computing the eigenvalues of in these directions. Using this result, we show that the calculation of made by Ogawa in [9] for an elliptical cylinder, is just an approximation to ours obtained by only considering the two first terms in a series expansion of the function arctanh (the inverse of the hyperbolic tangent).
- •
In section 5 we compute the effective diffusion on the surface (not the interior) of a circular channel over an arbitrary curve in . The main point of the calculation is to illustrate how our techniques still apply to fibre bundles whose fibers are manifolds without boundary (in this case, circles).
- •
In the Appendix we make a brief review of the geometrical concepts needed for the construction of the effective diffusion endomorphism.
2. The effective diffusion equation
Let be fiber bundle over an -dimensional manifold , having compact fibers (with or without boundary) of dimension , and projection map . We will assume that and are orientable, and with Riemannian metrics and
The continuity equation
The continuity equation on the fibre bundle is given by
| (2.1) |
where the density function is a time dependent function on , and the density flow is a time dependent vector field in . The divergence of is given by
| (2.2) |
where is the differential operator acting on differentiable forms in , is the Hodge star operator, and the -operator converts vector fields to 1-forms (see the Appendix).
Integrating the continuity equation along the fibers
Since we are assuming that the fibers of are compact, by integrating along them we can define the operator sending -forms in to )-forms in . For any form on we define
where
and is a lift of , i.e . Observe that is defined on the whole fiber
Neumann Boundary conditions
We will need adequate boundary condition on in order to write equation 2.4 as a continuity equation in . If the fibers of are manifolds without boundary then commutes with (see [2, pg. 62]), i.e for any differential form we have that
| (2.6) |
When the fibers of are manifolds with boundary we will assume that vanishes on all the vectors perpendicular to the boundary of . This last condition is equivalent to the assuming that there is no density flow across , i.e is parallel to the boundary of . This last condition ensures that formula 2.6 still holds.
Integrating the density flow along the fibers
We will now use formula 2.6 to show that we can write 2.4 as a continuity equation in . We need to find a time dependent vector field in such that
Using formula 2.6, and the definition of the divergence of , we can write the above formula as
This last equation is satisfied if we let
| (2.7) |
where the -operator converts 1-forms to vector fields (see Appendix).
The effective continuity equation
We will refer to the time dependent function given by formula 2.5 as the effective density function, and to the time dependent vector field given by 2.7 as the effective density flow. We proved above that these objects satisfy the equation
| (2.8) |
which we will refer to as the effective continuity equation.
The diffusion equation
Fick’s law establishes that
where for in we have that is a linear operator from to , i.e an endomorphism of . The simplest choice of is to let it be scalar multiplication by a constant . By using more general ’s we can model the inhomogeneity and anisotropy of . Assuming Fick’s law, the continuity equation in becomes the diffusion equation
| (2.9) |
In our work we will always assume that the endomorphism on is multiplication by a positive scalar , in which case the diffusion equation becomes
where the laplacian operator applied to is
Problem.
If Fick’s law holds in for , does the effective density obeys a diffusion equation in ?
There is an important case when we can answer the above question positively (see Proposition 3 in the next paragraph).
An effective diffusion equation for infinite fiber diffusion rate
If the fibers of are “small enough” compared to the “size” of , then it is to be expected that the density will stabilize faster along the fibers than along . If we assume that this stabilization occurs infinitely fast, then must be constant along the fibers of . We borrow the nomenclature from the physics literature, and refer to this situation by saying that there is an infinite fiber diffusion rate. Under this assumption, can write
for a time dependent function in . Using 2.5 and the projection formula (see [2, pg. 63]) , we obtain
which allows us to obtain in terms of as
| (2.10) |
where
| (2.11) |
Observe that if is a region in then
| (2.12) |
If Fick’s law holds in for , then we have
where is the pull-back of forms under . Hence, we can write the effective flow 2.7 as
| (2.13) |
If we define by
| (2.14) |
where stands for composition of operators, then by combining formulas 2.10 and 2.13 we obtain
| (2.15) |
The above formulas now lead to the following result.
Proposition 1.
For the case of infinite fiber diffusion rate, the effective density function satisfies the equation
| (2.16) |
where is the vector bundle morphism defined in formula 2.14.
Proof.
This follows from the effective continuity equation 2.8 and formula 2.15. As defined by formula 2.14, sends vector fields in to vector fields in . To prove that for any in it is in fact linear map , we show that for any smooth function and vector field in . We have that
Using this and the projection formula (see [2, pg. 63]), we obtain that
and hence
∎
Definition 2.
We will refer to the endomorphism of , given by formula 2.14, as the effective diffusion endomorphism.
Proposition 3.
For the case of infinite fiber diffusion rate, there exists a metric in such that the effective density function satisfies the diffusion equation
| (2.17) |
where is the effective diffusion endomorphism. Furthermore, this choice of metric is such that for any region in we have that
3. Constant-width channels on the plane
In this section we compute the effective diffusion function of a channel of constant width over a curve on the plane. Such a channel can be represented as the set
where is a unit normal field to . For a reasonable curves (e.g compact) and small , the space is a fibre bundle with projection map given by where
Let be a unit tangent field to that makes the frame positively oriented. To perform integration over the fibers of we need to compute the lift of to . If we define
then is such a lift of (see Figure 3.1), and . Let be the dual field to , and be the dual frame to . The matrix of in the frame is given by
Computing
The volume element in is
and hence
Since the volume form in is we conclude that
Computing
4. The interface between two equidistant surfaces in 3-d space
Let be an orientable surface in and a unit normal field to this surface. For small and a “reasonable surface” the space
| (4.1) |
is a fibre bundle over with projection map given by where
The surface has principal directions fields and , with corresponding principal curvatures and . If we define
then and are lifts of and , and . The metric in is represented in the frame by
We will let be the dual frame to .
Computing
Computing
Using formula 7.1 in the Appendix we obtain that
From these formulas and the identities , we obtain
By evaluating the above integrals, using formulas
and the fact that the matrix of the metric is the identity, formula 2.14 yields
where
| (4.2) | |||||
| (4.3) |
We have just proved the following result.
Proposition 4.
Remark.
At an umbilical point of (i.e where the above proposition is still valid for any pair of orthonormal vectors in .
It is important to observe that if we want to write the effective diffusion equation 2.17 in coordinates, we need to express the principal direction fields and in terms of the corresponding coordinate fields. The reason for this is that the divergence operator that enters into the effective diffusion equation needs coordinates for its computation.
Remark.
We can express eigenvalues of in terms of the gaussian and mean curvatures
by using the identities
We now discuss some applications of Proposition 4 to specific families of surfaces.
Spheres
Recovering the one dimensional case
Let be any curve on the plane with curvature function , and let . The principal fields of are the unit tangent to the curve and , with corresponding eigenvalues and . Using formulas 4.2 and 4.3 we obtain
Hence, the eigenvalue of coincides with the case of curves in the plane discussed in section 3 (see Formula 3.1).
We will now show how to write equation 2.16 in local coordinates. Consider the coordinates in where is the arc-length parameter of the curve and is standard -coordinate in . The coordinate fields
are the principal direction fields of , and
Since the metric matrix is the identity, we have that
We conclude that in this case formula 2.16 becomes
| (4.5) |
If we use the series expansion
we obtain
If we use only the first two terms of the above series in equation 4.5 we obtain
This last formula is that obtained by Ogawa in [9].
The torus
For a torus with inner radius and outer radius we have that
where is the variable parametrizing the parallels of the torus. In Figure 4.1 we show the graphs of and obtained by using the above values of and for specific values of and .
5. Effective diffusion in the surface of a tube
Let be a curve in three dimensional space, and let be the corresponding Serret-Frenet frame. We will let be the set of points of the form (for a constant radius )
We want to construct a lift of to . To do this, consider and as functions of the arc length parameter of . From the formula
we obtain
where (using the Serret-Frenet formulas)
for and the curvature and torsion of . Hence, if we define
then is lift of and . The metric matrix in the frame is
Computing
The volume form in is
so that
and hence
Computing
We have that
and
so that
Hence
6. Conclusions
We have shown that the diffusion equation on the total space of a fiber bundle can be projected onto a diffusion equation on its base space, under the hypothesis of infinite diffusion rate along the fibers. We provided a general formula for the effective diffusion endomorphism of the reduced diffusion equation, that we later applied to obtain explicit formulas for diverse fiber bundles. Of particular interest was the computation of the effective diffusion endomorphism associated to the interface of two equidistant surfaces in 3-dimensional space, in terms of the principal curvatures of the base surface.
7. Appendix
The sharp and flat operators
We can see a 1-form as a vector field defined by
where is the metric of the space under consideration. Similarly, a vector field can be seen as a 1-form defined by
For a local frame the metric can be expressed as a symmetric matrix with coefficients
and we will write
Let be the 1-forms forming the dual frame to , so that . For a vector field
we have that
For a 1-form
we have that
Hodge star operator
The Hodge star operator maps -forms to forms, where is the dimension of the space under consideration, and it is defined so that for -forms and we have that
where is the volume form of the metric. For monomials
where the ’s and the ’s are 1-forms, we have that
The -operator satisfies the duality relation, where for an -form we have that
If for a local frame of vector fields we have the metric matrix , then the coefficients of are
The metric volume form is given by
Using the above formulas we obtain
and
| (7.1) |
where
and the hat in indicates that that term has been removed as a factor in the above wedge product.
References
- [1] Anatoly E. Antipov, Alexander V. Barzykin, Alexander M. Berezhkovskii, Yurii A. Makhnovskii, Vladimir Yu. Zitserman, and Sergei M. Aldoshin. Effective diffusion coefficient of a brownian particle in a periodically expanded conical tube. Physical Review E, 88(054101), 2013.
- [2] R. Bott and L.W. Tu. Differentiable Forms in Algebraic Topology. Number 82 in Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer Verlag, 1982.
- [3] R.M. Bradley. Diffusion in a two-dimensional channel with curved midline and varying width. Physical Review E, 80(061142), 2009.
- [4] L. Dagdug and I. Pineda. Projection of two-dimensional diffusion in a curved midline and narrow varying width channel onto the longitudinal dimension. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 137(024107), 2012.
- [5] P. Kalinay and K. Percus. Extended fick-jacobs equation: Variational approach. Physical Review E, 72(061203), 2005.
- [6] P. Kalinay and K. Percus. Projection of a two-dimensional diffusion in a narrow channel onto the longitudinal dimension. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 122(204701), 2005.
- [7] P. Kalinay and K. Percus. Corrections to the fick-jacobs equation. Physical Review E, 74(041203), 2006.
- [8] P. Kalinay and K. Percus. Aproximations to the generalized fick-jacobs equation. Physical Review E, 78(021103), 2008.
- [9] N. Ogawa. Curvature-dependent diffusion flow on a surface with thickness. Physical Review E, 81(061113), 2010.
- [10] N. Ogawa. Diffusion in a curved cube. Physics Letters A, 377:2465–2471, 2013.
- [11] C. Valero and R. Herrera. Projecting diffusion along the normal bundle of a plane curve. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 55(053509), 2014.
- [12] Robert Zwanzig. Diffusion past an entropy barrier. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 96(10):3926–3930, 1992.