0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 951 views49 pagesGlobal Arbitration Review
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
AL ARBITRATION
REVIEW
ee ue cei nerean)ITRATION
Pisa
Editorial
&“COMMUNITY NEWS
ICC rings the changes
The ICC inlernational Court of
‘bration has chosen AUstatan
Smon Greenberg as fi deputy
secretary general The appointment
‘was made four weeks after Jaron
Fry offclaly Began os the cout’:
secretary genera
Fat saa on ? Never serving
‘Chor Chance LLP nr wr ed ben
ae whe on
‘Sparen ec Go rig”
Kant Nie hed of emo sen
for Lenton 2 Saks rps Ste Menge
hang ono fhe Bl ait
‘eon fae nits el che
sweeter Rael eengh Moker
Trt Coin vein 93 he ed
Ew ee avin to Pr in 193,
‘coming pera 1998 He na brazen nd
tor fh High Cour of New Zend nd
‘atctr of he Spree Coo Eagdod
Chesnais pe
‘ioe od wil bang enue ane
of experienc hight et of inerton
‘shen wath othe 1"
Given, 33 jo on Desh ELE whee
be wars ene aocine He ngs ir
ity wo eng th KCC in Here
ry ssa deed th Sons
{esd rord ir wh de weing of,
Procedures sa trata oped I
Fy a th Geb rig ode
arom portance tthe OC cu”
‘Genie hare eu scery
gerd fhe Aus Ce fr eer
{Commer Atiato, sd ep the cee
Ceca yt lt to be joining
he {CCS secs dane erate em
‘he seal Hosnen commas wing dpe
‘elon ods Bae Meera os Daher
{goin Grebo pond foro Conder Ben
Php Daan a panes in Dechert
scan aren prope we
te en oc
bit tren er Katy ew hy ae
Perez-Llorca elects
arbitration partner
spanish law frm Perezlorce hos
lelocted Fax Montaro ato partner of
ne higoton ond craton group.
ons at ke up paces ay
‘Aitgh Momo en #0 pr cen
io son rn cei
‘Ds rs wo ld he em biton
enon pre ect awa Te on
is a ht wok ang sean we
hice epee nero
icy a3 Crome y sid whee be
esd we adn Spt bro erado
rem He hn bel Soi eon
pending Spnt Cran} Commer
tater Cot md Bacon Adio
Go He tran sve o prey 2
tc do oe heal ome
eo cing de ICC res Hi
pecan mermionlcomtine stanky
‘ne pe Pe le Ua “High
suey dad oes mch ge
[pom Bera Came 8 Cnmsery
cad. member Cid Aan Resoh
eer bar wie Mom el"
exe een Tn gh hh
"Cries y Aish fan he GAR
Herbert Smith recruits Kirby
The deputy secretary genera of the
ICC, Jennifer Kiby. i jorning Herbert
Smith inthe new year, bolstering
‘ne frm’ Pors olfce. Kiby became
deputy secretory general three years
‘990. overseeing thousands of cases
Garrinistered by the ICC.
ity Sse" TOC hal the Bene
eine work fl che maj peo
i aoiy tthe top ofthe ue Tey wey
aber oe hie by ong Sis She wa
‘ppoianent 22 coup emer ing th
Fr ung a-c acquied oaghBer
‘urpuoed tnowledge ofthe ICC procs,
xpi in rte pce” be
scat apne ey Hl fre
gb rain Shree
ine Jere seni and nding
{he ronal bein comm
‘Mbcaon poctonsen Hebe Sou ark
pln and Mic mg Afr sh ji te
soup pene an ang ele
Inia ~ she ban tlh
Towle ses oud ost work
ity seemed he OC a be Usted
(pow dated i mod i on abn
te onton el Hay spends Chel
the ICC he worked ot Sinson Tchr LLP
$d Prize Ree LPCOMMUNITY NEWS
Jingzhou Tao picks firm
Jingahou Tao, the former head of
DLA Piper China anc an international
‘rbiration speciast, has jomed a US
tw fr.
“jie Joes Dy praia
Novena wha he in Being "The
Yok Pris and tcl Jones Dy
Broth Hea member of the ineratinl
Enger Commer of he Chis eto
pc a ilen& Overy LL gs
arth san escent rove Jones Da
Stephen Brg, managing aes Jone
amis to pace li Price sl ee
hance fe Dips by ose cea oud
‘he wold He wl es ec on™
roe October ending to epee thes Be
‘edcabed with he i norgig deer
Jatt hea f he eran abiton
in DUA Fe Mas Stade
"Any Shepp an erin bin
Spleen He dct py tn
‘nates he hap espnce of Coders
‘cts bo am eo wl owe oes
ert bod md tan in he cuenta
{Fe nnn he of me
French duo on the
Infemational ebiration specie
dear Louk aevaNG and Jean
ouche news tft Shadbot & Coles:
thon a yecr ater jiring
te rech bog fn Hewry Quen rt
Date Roache Baie jning Sb & >
se Spee dy pc ne ie
‘ebali pdKosch yh Sha
oto "meg peg a ro ems
teh Bury Quen as ae the dpe
“Ferg Quen snd Pack Mare
Mat rnc tHrory Quenin Mais
SJenLoust and Je experience nbn
“lng Se re hams pte
on stirs He mente fe Lend
Coit of nerscned Anon» firmer
move again
Erpean Ue Co
‘ui bron Acation ede Cai
ing wo abt EE
spre Sheseran Sting LLP in Pai 93
‘Beene "apa the Prt he fe
‘bron let ae ys ete and
Rocce wil brings pho expr andy,
pein pln a8 Texte
‘Dell features inthe corer edition of The
erin he ho f Conn Sai,
Feary Quentin Mut Delve Rothe hare
Roce elacted to Civ board
‘Te sppterme which tomes cea
Jamar 2016 hs foe Yad
Sows br moe te Rey he
bn Link son weer
Ber Lebo Swede)
Igor Garmarsen ei)
COUNSEL TO ANDERS KEN THE
eaTeAnON
Panne es Tit i Soca
coe, ro oer xy HORE ES
{COURT OF APPEAL Ait SWEDISH SU
Bikes 8 Meese Atoka KB
Purr ons Beano in Sst,
ite by Aden pe
ORE INE SWEDSH SUPREME COURT
Tews geen cout Ande ee
Selien
‘Award issued in Philippine bank
dispute
A buna ting under te nematona!
Gromer of Commerce der has ved
craved nocmbael ae bolween
Pippne bars about heise a! a ea
caseompany.
RBC Copal isms Ovoter One tor
‘eds Sng opinion KCBC Capt =
‘Sang USSU lb ages plesCASES OF THE MONTH
CCOUNSIL TO me BUROFLAST GROUF
na hgh cat cmpary_——_| merit a swe smd vino fhe | + Bate Dy Aco
ular fom Bue PCL Bank The her | Spee ‘nen Cas Pp Dr andVicese
‘ought anon hing ht Baka Tach pay wa onde pops conm | Baad Rio in Mes Cy
Foc semen were crue nd
ror conpiy with gee mee ceourng | ARBTRALTRBUNAL
Fc sd rae been rots The | + Domi ore ca (U5) ‘Swedish appeal court rejects need
Ion ped th here bad ects evo | > Machel Kan (US) for reasons
foe poe erp counting pence. |* Wil Ssions (US)
One er dpe ‘Awe appal cout hat oad 0 et
‘tbl PCI Sook i ce at ei COUNSELTOSPECTRUM PHARMACEUTICALS side slocthom Cheba’ ot Canmore
Getter meiner amon | Ragan Neca OF irl artseck Sem moins
esing wih rst approach
‘ARaoRAL AUN ‘counse. 10 68 WonECH “The cot jee Tah comracton
Tan Harker QC (New Zand) |» Cann Bang LP nga gunet the ll
Ne Rap CBE GC CUR) ‘rere Tey Hem nt ERigpey in| lec mand der the Seah
5 Santa Kure Phin) ‘Wang DC sed ty Hen Ra Emly | Aion At of 1999 by fing ge
COUNSEL TO REBC CABAL “The See Couto Appa one fi Such
pnp be Concepcion Rep & Cruz appr cou, od uc re ol not
Eo Ose (nccRALA) | Consolidated contact arbitration | Ssuc snxem fh hls mania,
Stir pe noes Crt nd pamner | settled "ed Wenerola of earls Abo
‘nn Corp in Maat Cy ane by ‘2 Soctoin count Hose ppd
Jobe Pp Sno Acompiscontac!amitoon beveen | the th desig tans ol
‘esican and canada comporirin he | be chlege on tha ating "Chaengng
COUNSEL TO EQUTARLE PoIBANE Plenty har been ete occuring | snl omega us us cept
Sip Sn Hernande Gas Lae | fe sete arita wih he cule ake ne ye ado Wenner
oie ‘Te dpe sn 53 panne {Sp "iewoseminetrwhe bd poeee
ren Reber San jn an Neon | machine aden hed by acl sberzoe | pur can we thera qurion th
ttre Cont rb ‘cement of gd
| "pao te ween br ey be "eae la oman agpeons
ICDR panel rejects pharmaceutical |smplemente! In Onober pan mousing | made arge cute ICC als rng
claim ‘chine minwer Engel Canin ec | conte eoing rlwade sl ok
amet oe machines fom Mean plc | be bene far ter trl ode, “Pars
Anarira panelhar ded wih o German | ements rer Dari, sch wa ry | tae bat op fx gl fae,
Sharaceuicalcorpary ina matraten | sore ation The cart aad bce | sowing fre te-conag en co
‘Soter contact depute win oUS porner | warn conalion a sel peep. | ato hes
“The pel tering the caw verb er of | Ione oh onl cima ae of ‘Scltn Chnr of Comme ret
tected the ai of eat USEL aon on put Doon 3 oom ‘bison Ae enon he ois
Rowen raed i Geman em GPC “The an were conoid n 200 by he | gene compan the te nt
Birch door braced concen US | ICC ble the sponte fewer | upto he ae a el oso dee
tompany Speco Pace | tas Eee Go of That roti | whether aon eee,
‘Sjecrum Paras muphearaion | od Sin Men who ed a Eng! ‘See vin of oe Diy LAR con
s.2006 10 whe depute sbot payments Cam ws the ovrer othe mach td—_| forthe Tek conten com Sop
tomeced to Supe dap ray hve | Dara hao ar sh The pares | sy wit Be clang ef cn Seton
to ng ence 1 Dumpla c comply SSeTCes the Sud amber do nt rie
Sjeetam Pharmacia chined dari was | " On the arqistion of Drop by hid pry | svat fret oe.
sao ceme payments esied ty GPC | Pity Esl de Mise she moet Eel | "The Cou Appel alg exp aes
Tec fom npn snd US paren | Catan pape fr the mcs om | ia SOC ube” "The canbe
to aged tht GP Bich ad tected | Gd yd Ge pte ened Inyo enforce ow lr worn.
Serevent reo # loo conned Spee So ae the gay of ln
Pheiacousr stow de pomoson othe | SOLE ARSTRATOR Sh Spat colt athe et
Sepia te US ania! not en he ecary | La Emig Gram (Meso) | freer ponds eee company oad
sept hve he dg pre by rpsory oe powe he ck of emi nde che
cherie [COUNSEL 10 ENGEL CANADA end inorec|
Bernd Sonngreshicfoeatve of GPC |S Won & Bes SC Tan trie wih Gi Aint Roe
bans ace very ae "We | | + Gaerne 9 Lone Abed ‘poem of he SCC he tne pode
fr plned hath unl onan oped unr Ene Mae Gar Ferinderin | fnaion mating wt compe ch
eal ot Spoarans spore wee omthane | Mesco Cay Sain nto se ng er(CASES OF THE MONTH
1 eal "yo tok the ICC have ar yt whe cosn any |_ The US coun judge wi ace
eri etch ats eit brand erm | prueba HCSID ales | en om he a ner wae med
frnce wich mn ks gee get hemes hep hc smene ty | epaBu Emon ny ner ele enone se
‘eo Franke sl" won 8 socing ings leer othe Foal gone! jag fr why omen =)
he can dy ling ce san Pre ale | exp cepting of eacn oe ‘Arps can il pty ose the sad
‘Stine mews tate mena fo | (SID wide od nal 120 sp rhe dec on pore
{cad othe sone pte fr ‘Te pd wheal sn cerily | nad tac Agent ai ay of
‘cca egty toning mate ‘een pomp y hms’ atmo Present | ene fn IID Eon il ot be be
Hse and sconce Sok orgealy| Corer dcsionotke 99 pr cena acgn | ele the US dg the rg
‘wets rimaon overs USS mullon bag | compe cae lve it ced s | tnd whie let apcion pending
‘eonnon peje Macon Both aie | eta deol Cones ed the wid ox | "A hun sth rate Cre
‘ned gut he de fr dlr in capleing| orm 30 er cee in tae Serle of lave ips Wagon
‘he pet Te gin SCC titan chred "| "Cau oon the wet in aiteson | DC med Earn reget pve
by rer Metso Anand rincply | apse Endorse compan ad | nt cy ying chat company a
[four ofthe opondet Hoc Heche | warmed Qu hat thy wore binenl—_| fad gua ey arg de en.
lees th ebm ein ws neg esenent ay wbiecon he governene | Ea ted sand we on Aree
Sora se ws nace spnion et sea nh ts pln Een goal sclenty| US ie nese ey ea al
of wich ealence wed, tow tw ee, engine angen at nding fr | hl od et agen hd besche
‘Shy espe poe ss not eowe nd how "| CSIDabason unrated eseens | Staion oped eae een
{heer ede acon eae lope efecare We dk he
ny de ype court ralng nes | uments no ep me uscourr
Soya ee tape 13 November rae | Lesh hat ver compares ve p= | US Dats Court Suter Dio New
I cers crerng whether So. tempted eco decison by perce cme, | York
or Pe il mcr ee lhe (Geng thems pt ont Dati Jlpe Nomi Ree Buh
Arscon Rene ane so | eStB'whedhr a any we reas be
‘epic gen ht any wl oe oct ARBORAL TRBUNAL
YEA COURT OF APPEAL TRRUNAL ‘Spoom "Sea Eeablet | * Fania Ormgo Vea, pies (Chie)
fen Bvt (a) tree abo oer wtiratonskermee DICSID, | Albert nwa eng ee) *
Tipe anand ‘Sekt UNCITRAL the urea 2 Blom You Tihs Gram
Lm Fon "a btn pine Qt who abo
sk ot be med ares ht he oaeton | * spin owing he een of Hor
‘ORNAL ARATRAL TABLA fae ede ep eft “Bensdr baal | Gr El (Urge
Pere ele (ha (Ac) ovement ee ste dt ose oto |
2 Kayak meen) ‘Show be soe uray he ps | course 10 eiRo% CORPORATION AND
Se ees (German) FONDEROSA ASSES
Ccounse.10 vaR ing Spting LLP
Pont Day LLP US court recognises award Pers Dak Bap ond Cig Miles
Peer Spa vin Pa
e's loge! eam ar urpes ne sens on | Argentina
CCoUNsE To HoH ‘gerne fo begin poyng eS aware | + MM Booch
Seer Ant ‘The US Dare Court ofthe Souter Dirkz_| "Parnes Gad Tl nd He i
Per Ped Wear in Scckholn | NewYek oer Ear USSG milion | dancin gare Mad iva
sued by mace Roba Ryder ‘bien sad pe Arent 0 Mack
Nomi Know cnn vem | COUN 1 ARGUING ENC
‘ecm ifthe twee lager chs | * roan de Tod
Investment cases "rover pel: Onalo Ci
“Te cour confmed Arges wl | Gan
ating USES ao, caring peso
‘eto neat USS mon esing oe
euador partially withdraws from the arto 20 una the def ese
IcsiD Mo ICSID rejects US challenge to
eA hac in the US Enemy | Aaya
Ecvotorhos paral wiharown fom the | ey tose hm bt dos emt ne
‘iematenal Cente er Sotament emu enind sean enfocrbie US com |The United Soles hs le tb to
SnvesimentDipuesinWeshgion, OC. judgment fe. remove aren fi preter Ym he
ICSID har sfondi ee os ‘One eration bition secs _| panain Grona ver eter Si Noone
Erne Geigy eines ing verti hatch US jdgent-ps pene an genie | The ery ged he lero
‘neha he ICSID Comes The erty the san ty er tan ce | Cote Sete fees Dope
{hive on 4 Decker The efecto poets theetpens ong pote efrenent | Wain DC Ars Plson weed he
fare dius owe mining mdhyocrbom pce —notjuein he US bt ter | USS chung on 3 Newer ar ney i
‘rom beng ere he ene ous wher i eight ae an ‘now of meting and ester one
‘Sipe tng‘CASES OF IHE MONTH
‘The Unie St wate aes An ric oe have he apport conti | opr | + mann hk independ or
rowretvnicr UNCITIAL techie mon ith cur og worl wact™ | paral
ofr Nite Arras lies ama gh |S Raton yt US mest lowing | They ad ht wou ove rou eve
‘ommaioe et ir inpaiy eno guonen, | curdmebecwees sete omens | cme fr any airy sen san
“Thesnnery pede ceo now ed | anda etre compene eo acre | ster econ feo ee wa en
‘hin jae oui Among the es | pin th own es bowen. ‘Mtematlysec th par sace,
fens Anas sateen tthe le op on tng they honing odo wt the | "The ra ahve Ning at ong
‘vhs warkeo ecomes UN pec | ste hwo, Sx Romina py hanes | apa Ain by furor cops Sot
aren ils of dats ito eon real] to ay | apd Soda! Genel Je Agus de Baers
The US aged ini lng ator er shoud heer rere he teen, eign clan ned noe by
prosper mn em foc ed ‘The seis beng hed uncer UNGITRAL | nwa eves neler Agar an on
‘Sroepotin tts bhavouri unc | rue wih CSID a appt ada ‘eb Weds Unies The al hao
Trcic ede il crepes ‘er tering thd can ge by UR wer
toad the hile a afin esuat emp AWG
“One penn nium Gat evormad | + Farman (nn) Pen) “Poe puis cing see eb
thee andere em nd who = aka Cook feral ects Rana Rb ibe
coment wah th cain uncon bot |e Ana clan spond bio,
sl veqened ony) yeoToe US Ta her sponding the aprons of
‘eng na sr abo, Pond | COUNSEL TO CLAMANS org Kasia Karl th ort he
the chalga ony bunched afer an ener Camel Momear'n Honiton, | inp nd eee epee ore
mvt ng hd ben made Tey pated | Ono Trend coop witch day ache
Flot oncom betes sakings | Pane Leola Rare Lady ia | Ageing hs hdnged ass ros
Piped dso” New Yok Cy se 1C31D and other ums Resend oboe
"The US lnc challenge fe rig of | + Cae Moning CLP 15 US bry od ener ering
Anaya won rte Dine ly ofWesare | Hatnr At? Ain Wain, DC UUNCITRAL lat toh spa oy Nena
‘teh Nate Amer tt ging toe eu Anor shalogeeh CC concurs
US prone fr igo aco an 1 ARBTRATON COUNSEL Dosh ener Aer on a nyo
Nooo 2a Geno Mein Cry Jesh prodetof the Wes Bee a
“Ap apse ef the hur si cpr emote ene mal ln
commision onteafefhe Danan March, | COUNSELTOUS ‘onited cn rough ost pent by
“Thelema ther tng te__| US Sete Deprten. Of of eran | Canal cmon on emp ates.
‘eee gel cep the clenge ely" | Chain nd tween Dips "ico pecs pi may
Eitrget train ti mens ofthe US| | Chief NAFTA aon finn Anne be Lying pmo jy om tment
“aes wee oe of nm ‘emer Wig DC Sal aero py Begg alg
‘ih wk se eof apne Ost ‘eee os pase deermiton Epon
Tomer tteting pet how oh they run
‘ions ot vsppisnce ec becomes cae ICSID tribunal stands by
‘concn to be US oooh ‘Koufmann-Kobler mA Pan
“heft ht Per Aan sero Pl See (Pen (US)
elie tn camel rhe Unie St nthe | Two aircon al the nteatonal Canta | Gate Kain ls ken
"hoon over i pts deta | fr Saterent of Wertman Okpvterin | Bebo Nien (esr
yon cen sve gg in be cold | Washington DC have ehnea requ! by
over any cieamsunce Ait alent tbe Agena fo domes he waromber of hor_| COUNSEL 10 CLAMAMTS
“Kecunngts Dood lacking of Leon | Anerson ain Gabi Jeanne Gann
Chern toon chen know ‘tna ar seme om berpreece | + leche come Soccer de
Imonmdenerason inte epson, | ld apt Ageia thea The earl | + chute oun Vien Girt
Sr Haceng:"Te minder of calengeo | ran ate company Cong de Apa del| + Irhowe coun AWG gop: Fan
sic igp t be ea
(Fons tsotresh fh sen die | val Swe of be US led hee war no | Prahiells Bruckhaus tinge LP
‘hates ws ecedandworying eee | ced San sno Rana | "Panter Nigel cay od curl ie
are the US cling rtrinhis | sp down fm he el whch is ring hee | Paden Fu nd aie Na Maio
"To Grison-Wi»peci oo NAFTA |" The iio id they ef Arentinns | Argentina
chine ad reed he Gama" | he Kaan Kater Beene" woe | + Carden Di Ci Rosen
‘Shona comly Sor kone tosh | ot edn ely manner sod bere led | Lace Abosdos,
‘iy econ ty the US change We Parner Bera Inn Boro lt(CASES OF THE MONTH
Brn Cin ac Fees in Baer
‘Aroney Gener Ona Cer Gupeiino
‘Veeder and Paulsson step down in
Venezuela case at
Invosmen! teat tron Satwaen
‘tn Raber Er of Le &
Ise cn wet cit oe
‘ere Exes Court Chae
sin ahs edt ee
‘Seco hear wh» une fg fa he
‘hens ype ia Poco ayo ke
‘eococ, Conoco nthe het the
fechas parted eqsed abseson spi
“hen psa hak he eis
fale apd pos ser haben er
Flowing» hen
"inno Verne sought tien the
Intraoral Com fr Senet of test
adeeb nee ey
i he en i
‘oes he rn oc tiny
inc iy Crna nd USES non
nV bough 95 percent
snk in Mine La Cerin wich be
‘np a pred gh itt
mc ad fal pretion decay
“Toe aan wc ne
Rober Brn pent Send*
Chala N Brower (0)
eget ance ®
* spointed lowing he wsgnson oF
Neer Qc (UR)
‘ponte loving the iain on
ian race
COUNSEL 10 VANESSA VENTURES
Parner obs Tee Toe
veNeEL.
Neer nt cis ie
Sihng on he eee te Sem
‘ame Red Goninon (ow Foley
ong LL ale Ds ho (om 2 rod &
Pac LLP) an Gc Ging es ow
roi ore LLP a Washo, DC
Selomebel cated by chim |
of bias bs
Felons request rr Spon
eotng on ivermentratyortoton
poral war ws mde in 208 Stl
"laa Bucs pu-apointed ebro 9
‘Wises Pond caenge to Sheth
‘aod ed ht Sct pi
sueione ree fh comes ow
{rm Side Arn LLP The Sr coal 0 US
pany Carl nan aed aeons
Cee Scheel pects nde
rt ner fy us lug he
ply works dong
Palinalleged at cones sh ae
cite Seb sed cue! wih Siey
‘iene Ino oe Sb nd Sly
cpany "inna peed ht he pent
‘sta Broa Cour snort joe Score
‘len dng seo inten comply
2. epectegto ak cota a he oping
emt fe er
‘SoReal ee wea a.
toe el ed Te Bae Ce
‘Sin agen nde
{Sedlmge odo Bude eudogto e
‘ome soe eee US bl
"Teco ed eon cD Ober
“Yoo Foi president (Com
Sseper Sete (U9)
+ Jen Raj nd
Nesta
Prone Dini Sei, eter Hai, Gai
Majer ant Ox de Wit Wij be
ow eed Redan wee ed by
Mac an Leen
COUNSEL FOR FRC - 1 T0 se ASIDE
Oprah inal ince om
ater hn a er Hage Bes wh
‘or ie hy San Bie
fre Jy ees a Pri ond pain
ty Cae Monod
OSE ASE Anas AND RECLSA
Prete Lea Simon Vines Marc
iby Rae a
‘nee Rae ioral
Brus Cour App
COUNSEL FOR STEEN CHWEREL = RECUSAL
Puen Pere in Onna wl CineSULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP
EXCEPTIONAL REPUTATION.
Sullivan & Cromwell's international arbitration
practice is recognized as one ofthe leading
Intemational dispute resolution practices world
ide. The Firm has handled international disputes
for more than a century and has unparalleled
‘expertise and experience inthis area In particular,
‘we offer expertise in intemational commercial
arbitration which has beccme a part of mary, if
ot mest, major international disputes.
BROAD EXPERIENCE, GLOBAL APPROACH.
ur arbitration experience extends to all regions
(of the world and encompasses a wide range of
Industries and issues S8C’sarbitration group isan
Integral part ofthe Firms international tigation
practice and the Firm as.a whole. Drawing on the
Firms global resources andits leading position as
‘2 corporate and financial aw frm, our lawyers take
‘a multdisciplinary approach to every matter
Lawyersin our arbitration group form seamlessly
integrated teams with lawyers across relevant
practice areas and jurisdictions and are prepared
‘to handle any elated or follow-on matters that
arise in the course of any Itigation or transaction,
DISTINCTIVE CLIENT SERVICE.
Sullivan & Cromwell's hallmarks are the highest
{quality independent advice and intense dedica-
tion to solving client problems. The Firmsarbitra
tion lawyers analyze issues and draft medation
and arbitration clauses in international joint
venture and other financial and commercial
agreements. They advise on business decsions
and plans that pose arbitration and itgation
risks. They develop strategies to resolve complex.
international disputes such as those involving
‘multiple claims, muitipe parties, multiple juris
dictions and parallel or closely related atitral
and judicial proceedings,and they represent
clients in arbitration, mediation and other
alterative dispute resolution proceedings
The International Arbitration Practice of Sullivan & Cromwell LLP
James [Link]
‘areyesuleromcom
John L Hardiman (London)
hraimajesseromcom
Robert M.03g00d (London)
‘sppousllramcon
Dominique Bompoat(P
Brendan P-Cllen (Palo Alto)
‘easton
Maree Leeuw (New York)
ecsoumérsioomcom
‘Theodore Edelman
(Condon, New York)
sseinonOuloomcam
Robin [Link] (New York)
fevekoutcromcom
looriuteromcom
7
parsapslromcom
Margaret K Pier
(Washington, 0.¢.)
(ew York)
Robert [Link], Je
Daryl [Link] (Washington,0.¢)
‘Adam . Paris (Los Angeles)
Joseph E Neuhaus
ieuneusj@sulizomcom
(ew Yor Mark. Rosenberg (NewYork)
resenergmiuvom com
Robert A. Sack (Los Angles)
‘scereairmcom
JereyT. scott New Yor)
‘eotjOuseromcom
Wiliam Snipes (New York)
snipesnesitconcon
David [Link] (New York)
‘uinsbzlcomcom
John L Warden (New You)
\erdesuteromcor
Pltetulramcom
“Theodore 0. Rogers
regestoulzoncam
1 agcles-Pale Ako = London = Pari = ranktr Toyo + Hong Kon
‘[Link]ASAN ARBITRATION
THE BEST PROVIDERS FOR ASIAN
ARBITRATIONS
Competition between arbitral instirutions for Asia-related matters is creating greater choice for
users, Graeme Johnston, a partner at Herbert Smith LLP in Shanghai, compates the best seats
craig iepaton ofthe Mn | intiion so amincer an abineion with a/c be fie ripen wo pst eple
conan eo se soa srem has | Chinese vx in crsisering chosing ICC__| terol ton sch c=
Isdtoan enieatnofconpeston | sen witha tin mnkod Chi soot | sasman ptm sues
tn nas = for Ase cae ‘Some co wi be of mere gacnce in| Mechan or appsnting peding orale
conse of aan ern The eran Ife prin ute o age presiding
ose sar tet on ey es Whee [righ ppt ce on en
Meese doce hy end be moc on ‘ensng tel wl on dfn
{Megt diac oes oes a eto a eld on ee
Tee pote tice {eat nonly shal bet enor
re tongh aes mate nore iio | The se] f nn eae nea oa
ty theta ta nrieny powaton on | The selection of {erie whees sym ges pu feta
sore inorenspyckemptuses |an arbitral seat and {2 egg ation lesson om sppiing
‘sho rally ow aourche pies eante | institution is by | Sie cmpeure pears dhe esp
Shee Soe |po means rational ro Spe
Tivaicsinstohipsommenty ignorance, emotion and assert ‘clr wae rte
Sinstkavesseeema ses” | Prejudice all play a part | So useThathcs wes
Since ogame a
Feraihecaraicreciny tiny Degen
un coats tes emcee
eS eine
ey tau ofan arbraon cen to ‘bed polities ee eee non,
‘naar ars pase of oping ping sen
‘The selection ofan bal set an intition|__ Alle id he flowing six pie sghe | fet nhonay fn eps many
isbynomenersonsgorne emodea and | analy o gonna hen in | ee nny encomfrete wher esd
Fesudee elev mathsingor oppo, | inal curse orca nr pra, | wth hn cde mnt alan
‘mutry mermaid de car thao
seplcton or ater more Fredom fei fabian nd guaty
‘peste al pays The fon weigh | are pal Sepporve sein Iw an cour sem,
Imeem ta he ui peopie sod | In an aban ceo pi wih » | et word seeaang where la tes
tamactor men wh howe mr depts | dcesmember whan cach py sabe fee | tnny npr of aietion ad whetee
‘okison echanan en ane le experen |e apoio sarees fom ey le the cal ot spare cy The
Iopenting these mechs x he spend | peo uit apne y the imaeon | fener canbe aad ly ly hte er
‘Conpaty pois inpol fam hequres| or witht bong tet ct pul at| a tl aoe In de 9 ae
sedloal corms prcacs can sesbarct | all~akhough sponte tte ee on) es Pas the ox pore reer
Seal ha, Psy nme iene ako deaialee_| req pes fr senton semen
"The che fare compat by ‘Soot get mporance wo termine whether | ol rth ry enemy barn,
rerio oi ana Nan ione_| nnn npc som —_| stan nl be
cota cres., (etiaasene: |anrsseeASIAN ARBITRATION
snes nd tl as i ony be ot
Proce fr dig wih cons
Independence 0 th pr of aan “Banc
dere al poten tnd wings to a
daly hers ci tone
‘pn dein wit od ches backed
py a depends our yen A ek of
nor sol aes and an bees of
The regrettable fact is
that malpractice is still
widespread in certain
Asian jurisdictions
Qa ofteay wale anys
‘The gy fare and cou en he
sea itan porate come, Quay spins
[ip know aed jue neratond
Sphinn poe en ao
Inpro fey The gree
‘Gest malpnicesuch ex pare conc
‘erwen abit partes poppe
‘al idee ei an pion
(fcoune s wsaly poise prove
freer oct he pels pra
Sec pnts to here pocone A
‘oon enc see aly Be aed
Sola conte sen acetal yan
‘rerehelning on oll pacer it
shader rote
| Gropp comes nina
[Atoka parks my comer is
‘ol pte ot to be afr pcaly
"er earings tobe edhe Secs pe dt
[iti ato
re which eins be be hohe
“porary ox bn
| Thee poi hove heya Fe cory
‘Soveecoend emote ees
ES Saeed ida oe
|i go fy
| tere ten ct Sow cg
"eee ecm th tem
sind fom te te
aespomored Soh onsoninp ne nce
the Weal ena CETAC ir exp
house he mae sent rg ade
erate wth bua con Nor
{ethene al he much re portant
‘ion wher an depend oan
[ Rosa be poled an le 3
inn fs
Aiough nt en cme by tote chosing
| ta ttn dee ore Sct
"peat fen mach higher dae Hong Kong
| tenatoral Aion Cen ono I wor
Toki he lr net end
pains he rtf ao abo!
‘noun so ees mac ape
“The mon cpt a ico eide
‘he Comer yen ae Baia sd Ta
itn Chi i, Hone Kone
{ht Nac) ae pone bina Chine
fore rngeents Hong Keng adr
How do the ios Min bition pons
ome ot
(ise Ty wa sie
‘esol sion es Ass
Iieranoml Anon Cres we ony
bie in 8S nd 191 spc
(Now however, atbieabon Ai is elise
nope Sol be op 10 gb! son
‘arco by mtr tron arson
gs ore heya) CHET i ang,
Keng lnnaonal Arttos Cee)
[Store ner ron Cone)
|i sticton Conon) Kose
‘Comma Assan Bora (eran
ers Coe
meven ol hee oa?
[Ph ec r on-Ae ene nae
come with As contre ely
Hong Kong eral Anan Cente
‘snd Sng inereton Artarton Coe
Ts chi low pres ero fc of
unmet eoematon by te cere
{be chalnged where snd ony whee
tee ajc doa 0s eta
npr otndpennce ne a8
“sce tem nce oon ch calenge
‘The best choices for non-
‘Asian businesses to make
are usually Hing Kong
and Singapore
| hey do ot it ai aii to hme
| ppiacng ute an when cng hemes
|S aepsinnng sthorcy, hare a epuaon
eeapoiang vob uy depen
biz who ae pope ranente TheyASIAN ARBITRATION
ave nen tition lr bed othe
Shey he atc ended
184 peed war Thee se he oy Anan et
"Tce caked bine
fnnetons so bart fm a pl eee cova
{pel ckground ee imp and
Independence Tey en om ae
scale lc tha ee surly corre
for pole fo x we vio pce Alough
free some dnt eee he Hang
ong ern ibnon Ge wo
ou shold has be peepee emproie
{Cen lien bec th ee
tecween ean th ce pon oe
‘Stcond coi th ding no ha
SESE putty cho on oft tah
‘ein mamas ch ICGAIGDR
CIA wear opined rocon
Jordin sah Seinen Pace or Eng
‘Aihoogh t's popu coe ty ere ae
front din ta pT ot ree
inn res th the Hong Rong
ecome nergy cat ous nang
‘onan with nau eat exe
Soke he ete ogy a he Spat he
Tres fas Aly Ig oi
‘ae he none gl cm with epen
“hig or Shinght ter ar mico-munsing
“erting foo esguiebckln Eo 8
‘onal fo ag aero oo
Man ictal cna
sepisend Ame! depen aon |
wc cpio |
indo: Lane lan pe
pons fo Hing Kg ea iran“
Crake Spee inc
Comat HER petted
Hose KBHTIBS pore oa es,
to wt in aro non-A stan a
Tadd iw incr be at
pecs iy may aay ih he eer
one goer om Aan For ele fone ts 4
Ghia apn aan at
ote ee ben pet in Earp ely
to bestowe to gray compe wa ne heed in
Spore or Heng Kong sie boc en
commen at Loo (a particu) gly foo
| apeaive fr an brat come e probe
‘As the Hong Kong and
ingapore systems have
grown more credible, it
has become increasingly
difficult to justify
chBosing arbitration with
a non-Asian seat
‘5
ong ong torn iron Ca nd
td conan The ae oxida
tage 1CC ton Aa
Jf elo Exon ees Th tbe
ie meio rene ora se re
sg wh Aan cine ogy
gaping ne une ccs
Goh prer an sere sate ere
oe ek of td weld wre
real onthe rte ht xt raping he
‘ener depen on pena epee (ot
Scan wh awh th sh.
tak Whmitng tough an ony fone
Ties eof sn near aban
‘nan iy hy ee
psn te brs erry of a,
me pry the pte hen ey a
{etna fh ce i cand et
ernie be own wtf te
“The mater pry within the cone fhe
(Gov ch de tater of nc bon
tte oe cour tn td he pvr
‘Acumen sod wailed conte
‘arian rice gp th ea sped
‘ae Ale tne tn eth fhe ene
ose on reek Ont hy
Freier th coming eae at
wane toe ow oA rk ny
locate slew a di tes ae
‘eae og Kong of Soe The
aly non-A natn hate ay
there hom pent em ICC. och
parece fr the Sci, Cer
fem n Che cs The ma
lect oction bebe ether Ae cn
“ay tha thoy wl oe make sista pore
‘ha de sn ive ea he dont pt
eb icicle snd fer rie ri
‘What lhe pedicions— proper
eos tine hope dh he hugh proces
Shtving hele wl et ent
‘hep wows sth are
ns Pf Hoke Sth LE pie xs
|b when oa fx ne bt
‘ep frflet arSIDLEY)
INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND
ARBITRATION PRACTICE
Helping companies, governments and trade associations
navigate the challenges of globalization
ur International Arbitration practice of more than 50 lawyers spans Sialey’s entire global footprint of
1S offces, in Beijing, Brussels, Chicago, Dallas, Frankfurt, Geneva, Hong Kong, London, Los Angeles,
New York, San Francisco, Shanghai, Singapore, Sydney, Tokyo and Washington, D.C.
Sidley’s team manages a aspects of international dispute resolution:
+ Investment Treaty Arbitration — an elite practice inthis high-profile field
‘© International Commercial Arbitration — representing cliants before all major
international arbitral institutions including ICC, LCIA and, HKIAC
+ WTO Disputes — involved in over 200 cases since the WTO's inception
Contact Us
Weastington New York semen ruses
tehianaars tstnaei sD wise 223080035 eaetsantor
SSieanérorBrieycom —sbirman@sileycom IersenBsidleycom ———bilensDetleycom
Wastngton 0. Les Anges Hong Keng London
Naren. Carteon Seva arate Hien Cem Dora Cory- wright
‘[Link] skim@[Link] ‘dcory-wright@sidieycom
wun [Link] aeINTERVEW
THE VOICE OF THE CCIAG
Jean-Claude Najar, a senior lawyer with GE Commercial
Finance, is the driving force behind the Corporate
Counsel International Arbitration Group, which intends to
give a voice to user: of arbitration, With the group about,
to begin selecting projects, he agreed to be interviewed
Whar pomped yore yp te CCUG? | he dno
of compeng There | 206 we dhe CCIAGY nna mesg
‘he is ume ved tk bot hs ws ceain thing hey amor kal ht we | the GE fe in Pr Twente compan
Sn CIA Europes Use’ Counc mecing red efor ving my sen weno | mie ned hcg some gee
1s Perio which gral come seme | Sad whee foal, ume ee we a ne gon
‘opis had soe ed “Ther of toate coal a shed | lel an Pacem pasate LCA Cone,
imo «mice one howe coum! we | sn Aan Win dcr gee a
When wt hi ning? sor complanc finan noes They | taped Abo we he ovks
Term ine een se 10 yea aga, Mary | ne oth npc eum ad anes Melt om he Queen May Cage thot
‘the geen couel ist how ap We mere puacaedbosh luge snd rember ofthe | ftnenatonal Anon and Gs Lear
the abiaon proce, complained about che | so rk manager’ They play «par in defining | ndings of dc survey on corporate atitader 3d
Ihc freeman compres don | keno eiying lng acu in meron tenon Thre ws
alsonmied“Weeaethe chow couse! |Our cman tet fom he pe stacte | nly ewan on he ory Bee ncn
shen theyre nndee" Aran metng | imalveneat bras kina thes ore | some exelent aeons a Pion
served he sberce af cou counl fra Ou view amen change The pape | pre ner pons by be IA whe
“ote nies aoe me To fe prope cmouge er ice | Mate Gn ee Sethe necang t
‘ss aed grvng eng of sghe~ | coum o come moe engage pe tie | iid he at pom a es
“iy eon ‘oe en reir " eos ‘oe Tse i
Cano hae ile cae they Geet” | bt wy pve enon tant wane-_ | enna Now wie lng ewe ote nt
‘cue eae rir et now | coma ie eer aay 308 en | ethene
the age bod eon Tree pede ft LCI Caras come
nig The LCI wr ey wey we | Se ew’ be a ei?
‘Se your pecapson vr he oceinnly me | send nce pr “Thr ml be le oa mesg. Once we
proplthnk ey aow whut af rason Now ought stout ore sch sce mean a cok we
Somborne rs ‘deta esemed bt etshin | wil ten wel re whether mesh be
lrg pecs ey won honors wth fst Bat -dnymek peaead
‘howe couse hey pot ow he eon in dened nnn the pes, What eh pions fh group an the
‘port pry dont Kew te chleger jour de to anion yor oe oo ft ttf The spon of te pup ito be te we
fn res ats bop Beenie Jouwaneou pp rhe aap eng ve We wnt ope te aaINTERVIEW
Tee sho ae ome of sere ape
[anmedinely emtang on 0 any ret.
‘rliaton cemlinonad the fr of ADR.
{Me inoeengh big ed snd edo ma 0
‘ate hom the ope ofthe CCIAG
‘Sot ino seeing bis
‘Theat pe ce ns
sedemonng the tht corperatom Bee
‘i ooh ing cornet tie
Thee en tab he x penal
{he gral cmbenkip Whew a in che
proce fang pte emer wee
‘hig pees crip io ar
ew yan we wi he Bt we ining
250 10 cooper aregiee
She Gin ask ac ie ci the
tmesng ate Bucy Be he oe
Shoe members Whe I euched he ea mat
tha ind expend eee ery at,
sew re amore Be wpa
lk We he fend embegey
{einbowe ound woking in compass
cee eogl or ee in weranl
ty five mre nde nar The ex 7
hi ge wr how member ter’
feorcing me oro dep ha. Anew Cle
‘Sf asonbobh et ie, by wing wee
‘perating gids, the application form and
{ guoscomie wel ome el ik
“Thee lb er prs reid eben
{eausng te CCIAGS pres cons
eniey Blo
“Wo you gn enol of rein?
ge you te"Whar ae the prop eon
‘oon co ian” a"Do yo
‘ibn Gop shuld be eying eo
‘st how he can ine?
Ferthe sete thew mo Epc
‘iota mpeenten ple om he
‘de Ea atin Ae, or the Al
lng worl af owth by eer cones
Prop cone pole hey tna Bat we want,
‘Stone ember ay eprtion
“I want the CCIAG to
be action- and result-
oriented so that when
the proactiveness and
the effectiveness of the
group gets around, more
companies will want to
participate. So the key
will be to agree on few
but deliverable goals”
the ering comm
Ther edn ety chi Anew
(Gen tous Ae Nel oA
Din of x Kobo Seon Try
(Cana of NenwopGranman, Brice Whiner of
[Re Produc, al rong Tata Chapa of
‘wl bling bad» epreeion
spose we want to pie poy wo tha who
‘eily perce te pony wil
{rods meen wh ibe de ent
‘attr: eso tn god he
‘iil ana?" oop wl bea good
‘ego tees wat opti
rotor ew leno eum
{poepwil go nowhere
Do pol tk you shat Bee comment
eyed a wat Sou yt eae
[otto tr pono ent
treed whoa epson Obra be
terol Cy"A ht ge aj
[esnmare owe cp undone
nim pperting them ae eres Your
\iowtTte send qui "ee eye
[roe Now othe ane bg Wee muse
Jong he CCIAG fe ba we ech cen
‘eee oe wil be ang orl
entbton pot or dy-a-day operons
tal te cnrbn wl poy be
1 imap he or tig on hp of my a
our sends iehow uch ne wil Fine
{> deve ocig™~ bu sna ew Wy
‘machine al
ee ie forthe op hy afr he nape
Imig an hou ar pg to
‘Bentsen bard ioor iat he
‘eee wet Pepe may Deum ie
{men wh wl peda ot woking oo
onan ae sed prin eon
ost seme wane eae sed
Iteyor secede Te el ple
Ss pnp modo nnn eng
Fore br someone wn aon et
Stacey skews stessone her charre
‘wee rs pon od pane nes a
Frigate pj ly
‘ain
Whaat he ton th soup bee?
Erne pone and storages,
ose edict» win vac
Bsc a erase
they sou er the ae vote They
‘ponded tees we god deed wet
‘Spud aude ac penn? Sgt 0
[rot tb eps few on how let
singly meonng th oup There ave been
‘pl eel wo French as oe EgINTERVIEW
renin ae ater hating ea
‘Mout he CIAG dough + oan,
“The ne hing rupee mo me
Sous coal wed tae sation een
‘he eld wry wl ee We duende
‘hem Haw yoo bel are sion
sera hy ona oe
‘Sac for wine ee ~ sd ou pd
‘ong ene sang tes ae cou
weno pariprd mach ey cols
hve Thee gig the mone
srotking gam conerenor ce sod eee
‘ence an ely ak of wo rch
Iatele Hiv of ce Teor snd Cine
Few oe gen tt compen ae the mi
tee et ko ering loge
‘oan hl no depot hr woul Be 27
‘Mbt Seg cn be wed
1 eke ant op uation a pany
ther of whan sd ev red
‘more then oe, b al wl th poe
ing thew of he companies beard
She as nie gle ae hen orase
‘ul snd iron een a the
etn ey nape seg?
Neher me fachos cont pci
egped ue he cured spy nt
‘Send i unis bce mio ws iy
‘Whar angel tt or wih be
Ion pr ton cum wn
"Sc oy Bape sy egy
ge decay nda cap Tey 8
(Sehngp e ang see
Simp ng wn mee
‘Savegames
Soe ho mn eo
sthiesion re you a ea efcve | ito the CCIAG enon a ae
febenion co wy of grag mate e__| poe he pop rene pera
rth ele hve heel ou you dont | eng wbiron The grap my thn doe
‘sepa fondo noty hn our ie | pact on the bt fo ly
ear oping shot oe ee
dice oe wi yo make ize ou nt at king
{cine ate one commen Theft uy. | shop? Howl you make rea ou
Some rte pacidonen we wondrng wht | fa lal eng
the pup wil ome o the dete arene | By sting 2 50 may pcan by
Inner pei "bood cc ingests | dering ven ache at oe ga in
bean cold be hep” orb | gen eh Bete than wake sos
sone ant wt" The rpms wre meshed | seo and mt derng sy theme Te
(oe guess mim infra pule- | the CCIAG be etn einen
‘hag sion show th os com's ideed | th when the posthenmaa theeectence
‘inporantconcm or crprton wing | oft poop gro em were compe wi
Sinton brat hee sen ay oter_—| nam uta Soe Ly wl ta on
iaeynich te dine tesa ae cond, | Ge bt dele oe
the going wpe of coe ern eae
‘onde Sy ad force of eva | let cle tame wi nade doping
‘Sotbesm not oly to ot the manta | common echo fn ngmen
“abi 0 ey The eon ste at
ring pei og by ae Too ely wy They al god be,
Seen ad be ee open ero So
‘emthng bow malig inn nor wer | Hw doy el how Ue go a theme
‘Geol ore cet nl lacy inpove pena?
‘he poce sno prin ening th rl. | in eee optimise erection
‘be amo poe eh era
et ting pr occured pt on sl byw
fetes evn to Wl e__| fm ve etd pote ac om
po prs the eel ply ping | al eine When he eo th eon
| ened frat atimaonafasracine | fhe CCING lee 1CE Cor preset
‘son el yee? Raber Bie enouged corp come
MevTepurciqte imply sone | togoys peter paint mek te TCC,
urge inh comen a Sighs or | Ha cea Pare Tec ned he
SBE CCIAG to besos tJ —| ev a we Se nee AKA IEDR athe
Selae eamary gener UN Commision on | Irae fat er Cod Proven
Intro titan UNCITRAL fs Kindly and Rese. Garman abo otion
speed ote he CCIAG tthe Fbrary 200 | DiS ld they bee de acange af
Seon othe wring gop on meson | eons na iran soy sd wth es
"NewYork an Iwao hunk hin frogs | of alert pe mln etna af
een abled precy for ti ype finite: | conebue to the eh Pere ian diy
‘soe corte paced he | Sn 80H The LEIA fs nt on seb at
Shue and onto tone tae Seed | it eed 0 he ina Were
‘ep roy The CCING spud wo cal | ume ped mae pry
‘Mont ens ec change Labeyng to Paon an Akon Wit Te
‘tality eo stow sow | chs ponte anne ack rung
Boronce the pp ices peng |! ery gd abot he CCIRG wl pos.
Pa lb pw te ering comes
{deh membentp expr wet die | You mind elm compe of Ses
suid bes wore me ‘ow do yor new war a i hy
‘inyoe ned 2 tsp opty?
an os cent on it quot as eing We si 503 me ered on
‘bcuoc-Mewe dew tj nein | he express fra ceed hak
{thee indy mary arses aely__| hale An enon song at
‘enpanae ounel pops mania tiee | a eben Wed ne hve bon
goes ect whee coun ve sy | pues wepeenon gon fo
{nd cpl proce ith ovens ei ou indies We nt oes dere
‘Whee te stiovan sak 9 cu thane Fao | tenn onto Btwn we ye
ayer om pc n=) | he aw stoi th ne
Steeda sanding he yaa eisem | men ban bow epoca me
prego outer ie ive wel ng | Tha yo,GLOBAL
COMPETITION
Ra DAs
‘The international journal of competition policy and regulation
‘An annual subscription comprises 10 issues of the journal, including the
special survey issue ‘Rating Enforcement’, plus ‘The GCR100' survey
supplement and 10 special reports.
Each issue offers:
+ Exclusive interviews with leading competition authority officials and
economists, providing insight into the development of policy worldwide
+ Briefings and comment on competition policy in over 50 countries
+ Indepth market analysis and
country surveys.
For further information,
please visit [Link]/subse!
e-mail subscriptions@[Link]
or telephone +44 20 7908 1185
[Link]POSTSUBMISSION HEARINGS
THE SACHS-WALDE-REICHERT METHOD
Faced with parties who wanted different approaches to post-hearing submissions, one tribunal
found a model answer. Julie Bédard, senior international arbitration associate at Skadden Arps
Slate Meagher & Flom LLP, describes the method
es they bt niece
‘rin rove Por wrong by lokig ctl
ihe de pec with ees dee
‘hee omen Whether sg with he
‘nae! tana cong of lus
Sac (Caan Per Tho Wie nd
ls Reicher lod ch tne and se
‘Cour ronal aon Ache end
(he proc be coer opposing
‘ye The lana gh sgn
“Tec ded sede groond
‘ubmasion up that pote = which ncaded
Flentings nites ere nd iene oe
beste rl pierre down,
eau waged ea ep
eng wo reting e Sgoes wcly ble
The bal aed ced ner with
Th pha om en he Bt
rca os oe
‘Sp en fsa
irk
‘Fool pein
(cy ok ebro hn
enon ee eo
ings, atesing pec cad pt
ie teh ba denned we
(Seti The bua round pec
‘cues with he pve the pry in
Tne dhe of quo he har
ered he ut ein ns be dese
Ine ton Thon ted ach py to
pte hae ce
More and more
international arbitrators
and counsel are looking
critically at their duties
st ot dep en
fern the inl on pre of ie
Sos oe et ting a ey bul The
‘ul ect ofthe ute wing
sean ep fd
fea nb fig se pe
‘ft aay lp
Seren lst pe
a fi el fo ea
otk as es apt
‘Spot met ol fee es
‘ome al eet
a,
‘heen ld he par tht th ceato was
soo ting edd nx ep Endosof
ft Coal he a mcd the dey
"The te
2 scompronie tone he pute poor
cede tion spec peompede
‘hemos ecient way orl» pate
The nas goto of te sprosch
fe Sene Wale cher lc
‘dete wie pre sce of
Sevens a the mer of he cael the
‘Sucre sar Panes at
‘iy ht comiser whee ach on apne
oh in eer ecg he cao oe hewn
‘Sete sd wheter te ao hol comet
‘he pce
‘pen etre of national aon re
Mor isto beon re er aa
‘rl wth ihe acetone procedure
{dhe nal fe prin we roewing Be
pin age onthe oni fh at
Proce and enough
once witb ay tc al
‘omibl ppotty oping ees
tog wih ut of ppc Ti ther
rors ot the dopo pects
shy erepeePOST-SUBWISSION HEARINGS
Although LCA Res provi at he
etn sol op poser ae
‘oneconry dey expen poe 2
the porte dpe” Grice 1G they
ot cover habs pow lta hen
‘ly ping ten te apa es
‘ncaa cola na ea
The tribunal's approach
prompted the parties
to settle. The most
noteworthy feature of
he approach is that it
indirectly shared with
the parties some of its
views on the merits of
the case
“The“Tegus or Coating Test
conn Arba ope play he
TCC Commis on Aer a Ase
a exp fe eon bo
‘ony re Se ei om
Siem wih ong came ki
heh ue pact aed ld in ee
td he sie fhe pare de Whe
Sh Aarcon does notre tere
‘pn oh alana Te epart
{nrmig egret ae Be so ele
Slorpo of he date a aya daring he
out ofthe onoing ation ter ot
‘Siete hop ay om FAD.
im coma the BA Godlnes on Con
of tt i nero Arbon ewe
‘heal oa rer a mea
foe sumed bythe Sache Wale Racer
Ty rig Son tea my
uc may dot any mage ofthe proceeding”. | aeons in intron ition
The ppton ofthe bier denen | the poten of wich ema wep
roves hugh wage to ove ey conte | ~ he gpa of he Sa Wor Rec
asaror wi mor bead or ening | prmuary dacsson wit th paces
‘cence abtreifelemen rgtinons fl." sre ore race in Calor, Sopeior
‘Theconiton stecensy mw ivadesymemaie cout jnige thet peshewng of eos on he
‘abogs ote owing parison | sere othe eee The cout nay ee
Sodan ins memes ore ‘one pon th wl Seam he Gal
[done tage to sna popess
“Taking the pale afer he heaing ‘ehh fhe pare ea change
Ppecaucacmpmaettcne’ | Sewperit amuse acs
Sevens spent ea pon
iar by aw (dee gbetng wna
Fyne rasta nar tr |
Faterng hic ae way stectie_ |
Siheyacs thn he ed |
‘consider relevant-The more sent and pasive che
‘Stone moe parts yet ce
Sheu ich ese ta ren oe
Sec Ne tn kre
exalt oe Adc be missing
Sought being mone
{ery oe” wa of tourer
‘The etna wl ly ve adc
| nto i dp
‘ting en ooh dhe ig
trig aking al vl ad ctl se
sean ft key he sb ea
nce nd ocr fr bol ©
‘row doa ci eal sn eg noc a ke
‘Wn bncd ooh eco
|e ng prs mayb ced
‘Stuer are scene ceo moing
‘he need fr poche abin sgt
The narrowly focused
post-hearing submissions
did save the parties time
and costs,
econ ofthe ae, ty deol
eho af roting within So heed of
the being ope on oe dco
ater aan wk mora er Though de
‘Sino bein hn ecm sae | wing bans i tpi and
‘gh vie te pars the poten | cons ema with ly eed poring
‘Miramar certin es Hwee the | mem The un pred weer
‘Sewer re he nl em > ive hn i ee nor teal ward,
ety oe kat ome ooo te | which woul he fwd ons ions
Inet othe cae spina he mosses | sed ooh cui mold pest eer
{nd dour dant Woe one of | th st oo the pr con sgh
‘the cv wit he prs an eeiog | Th lt xd oft a
‘Qesoon On th ne hd. you coal pet | fh eat te ati oo
Eryarnc ald ot been by psd | thn Bi i mm of he IOC Comin
Src of cree mig ge rt ue poces | ven oe i a
once Onegin mana the Sei of | tiDRCAFA
PLAYING BY THE RULES
DR-CAFTA’ dispute resolution mechanism will help to promote the rule of law in Central
America and should give investment arbitration a good name, says Christian Leathley, of
Clifford Chance LLP
loving» Ca Rise een | rating apy m DR-CAFTA) | enh he a et fel een
atiniacficgrnena |octmennd bestow Site. | eu ems press ip
Suber deetaagrctee | Erelearbupdinasesijaniatn | Caaikereweacioercantan
scondite OneSasCmanrcar’ |wurteSinctosteintw const | Souter Co Retean
icin Rope RetieAgeanne” | hewand rh dope sean | Cova ow fe ale een
Bogen Reston — |G Gean smc | Suva nu bued nm coe
Themen perce Comou te | nmanng eam chieto manent | lekGutes Hee Nesaer lh
Dunks koqale HSivis; Gere” |nsnttaid ye heen nas” | Shoes a enagtn es
Mario Mcp Ured Sect |i metus'arSeng sheberen "| sacle So te
ihogh Gesanenaroramrenee |opedopensept ik orsaied tiamwe | Score Coanl ane Coot ce
[USEngrimemenbnccart nuts | Meno ancote There sb tenet | vce none OS
‘imronsy cpp aed | ger tua miedo
en pret te Protein feos
Sep rem DRAFT crs mentee
{i pmecon contained inthe Noch Amerson | roe wonpaces eae
facta homens nd tee TS dc oer nol emp a
‘jet emai Spe sn nce pope gin ccc
‘Nicer! on emt ns tec cia
“in pn posed ne Thera pce hae ose eed
DR-CAFTA 3s critical for US investors in the The investment in the agreernent are primary consistent with
CNcGuscemienimeioens nsshun, | protection provided stl ponc dh wen pay
Sonat mt cen paces | Oe tT CARTA oni yn neste
tht it th the . ‘See late ith te dd
sina ongcraeen Thee teen | is critical for US. media ms St
tenon contenpoan proccss ofiwentonl | investors in the event of Tovestors eno the fllowing ype of
Spurn riciogainme” | government interference | Mtiomte che aOR CAFTA
Sppoling wre othe dis poco ‘isl mec fared mee
‘Boch lms ol ome 1 sce wih cna ero
Doman Repu of DR CAFTA we onicrmmtary eemenconpe ith
‘member of FSD SID ara oof ‘Lime mesons wel tion
Be opens ey he pee er bee ‘mente eeepc eon Sess
lovee bin ling fen wha ‘See cpoprtons fee taro ind
‘ouldbe docrted ws goongpare tect | By aning om enericac ander the | eed eset uso eer
‘Sch orgn testo inthe non wale | NAFFA cafe ofthe BR-CAFTA lk to fine | equine” and the aby te ky
‘hwo uke conf Gom the dpe ton | eed cen hs Ey eine he per | mame a wos evn.
‘pom ord ty be DR-CAFTA anda’ | ene durhae cued pvrera 0 gcsion The eon of ieee A
‘Frei TeSIDL i noc emily cn Ssenmen strain lepimaryThoughoat leet omer ot cio
Te adlnc, tng tara wy before hey | chapter 10 ofDR-CAFTA. whch pi Gin esa emp ent mes aoa
Invent ron ging ough someting. | gue wpe fo the nga of dco ake mating rar a ay ase a he
slant nsecene The owt pr bdced | by NAFTA earl ty of nar eer The poe
heen hsm o | Inadton wpe Ce Anan one i ul may lb
otlem For nla tr er abo, Baia at | cunt are ado how recent deem oe ech atonal he ee
‘ikinw fon (ID Veer and Necgar | rato nde inratonl rac lw reer domo nd eee esiDRAMA
nvr oo con dy orn,
thc te chances of exes,
ic the comme of ep rer
‘sumption of ri) vant ation coe
“hed ces hie ede en inept
DR-CAFTA tries to
control tribunals in this
respect by providing a
more specific definition
of fair and equitable
treatment. The treaty
also seeks to particularise
NAFTA‘ definition
of “expropriation” in
a way that may affect
an investor's ability to
establish an instance of
indirect expropriation
DR-CAFTA ws com wah i chi
rept pong» more ec defion
‘er and equal een The ey sho
‘nls ew ey fon US
‘Cone wih US or expe,
reitory aor sped ape to prot
Dinpce arising betwen + member st nd
CAFTA seer ee ck sey
may inch we of soning. ipo
tan ment epee be led
‘Sesto otto wth ers of
“To ser cint in ipo
‘Bag ao of a rach
‘overstate dgpne semen pecially
(ocr por of cette
Fenton pete
"Rho nent ptr whee
the raponen neers pre
{peed norton ea 9 i bere
‘ge Berea very een Ti
fin been hehe DRAFT wt
‘Chae an bebe! ete Sowing
ec ICSID Conca and he ISID ees
Fried hbo he ode dhe
‘Somat comping ener ene
nr the ONCETRAL nano le
hd FES raw she ent ha ech
‘Shir abr de erm of DRCCAFTA
compa the otc bron wih ¢ he
Fertig he igh lucha cone fs de
Ahrwgh thr dt rerement prcedrs Tht
‘teone pte car ego aneh
retin he pape of money aoe
rpendet se rome acon ve
fore sl pups of seo he canes
orient = igs and ess doing
the pany ofthe sn
| rsa he ned ofeach of he
‘cna hc it bd nar ko ages
‘The way soup cana png
sien when thy he end ben
Fresing f leged exche o€ DRCCAFTA
nd wenger a der NAFTA Herings
he agemenladechka 0 err cat
“The opecten inde spec rvson bad
SUS cour allwing wl da
los dims ely on ans lye
ef ty sed inl od oe
‘un Ana Ena wn we on fe
teemen curing Soe i a al but Con
Ich member ca at ps egeig
group ae with rein an pele bos of
SE toner sence by tib
der her [Link] nepsing ro nt
owiehe DR-CAFTA cra wi» ds
The arbitration process
under the agreement
is more open and
transparent than under
NAFTA
‘Thee pons sme wy 0 eng
What iy conte oer barge
su toe who ees sepa oe the
{her ofereent anton om
‘Tho changer aude de geome owen
‘hth pe-exsting NAFTA jrprene ll
‘ered upon by DR-CAFTA stil tan,
nd ely np ni tt wl ot eo
‘re reo DR-CAFTA aura
chins ie ee er deco te | ending eeHONG KONG AND CHINA,
ENFORCEABILITY OF AD HOC AWARDS
‘The China Supreme People’ Court has confirmed that awards made in ad hoc arbitration
proceedings in Hong Kong are enforceable in the People’s Republic of China, answering
questions about reciprocity. Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer parmer Peter Yuen and associate
John Choong explain
season the pcr binding ime by coped Chine atl cmminons | __ In aleter dd 25 Ove: the Chis
mechani for reslrng Siw fonign | enforce Hang Kong Thar | Sapeme Pople Cour take vw ta ad
Distes dua Hove Kong wthe | ovagpeio that ster ef ecpmcry, | hee eae seh ate soc Kecg
iting nemaon ene forsee atom | ous mae by lng Kong seed fire mang Chie nt, howe
Ince yrs Hog Ko nnn!” | itor se efreateia maid Cina, | that cme fac ar bps
eon Cente hs een ined ince | een ough te nach rcion sed Waele Tae coat sangeet Ne
'2 100 shensom sr wher akeat ane of |e agement Inde ncn ae | lg anesthe were se aed
the aise inland Chim. Bong | phd doped fr Chins seosh gin | ten Yk Camenen ru eae
ong ear braton proceeding can | tle a Hog Kong th angen os" | tnoremet of sy snd eet us
becondacetin evo ways Fenton] | ht mild cours age oe emacs | Snce
bron, ars ope wtiaton rer | made in Hong Kong in seers wach Heng | The Chia Supe Pee Cac eer
‘fan aint ong arian erdance wou tae | rth sew expe fy 9 eco
Stan rnd hai of | py cel we done | oa tyes me Cen
Commerce) Theis wl ply be Sond. s wot crase wheter Chis | Macon aed ong al ere exch
minster te ination pune to s9__| lr is tron seh te wth he | ser ton sae aca, Hone
Iitaon les Seondyin af he sans, aan oth HongKong neon Kong apc nse gino
they ea aon the aly el UNCITRAL | Arter Case ition ora ad | Roles Repco Chand eps bene
beocion emo Bele xbizson | hc ant The smite ois prom | China cu oes eng Rong
‘procedure. In such cicumsane pares may not_| bythe Hong Kong International Airaion arrangement A the press conference anounsing
cl ce the amine eve ofan_| Conse sn HongKong sac se mare | he Maen atte Cou aca maeprad
Shit mcrae Tinto the te etna" le | few ud had bo tao woe
‘ered by Chie wil commons” | common Maca He wot on ote
Ad hoc shienions no scold under en imigh Chie bw ote eu
Chine ow (peering os boner ie Rew
ner th fv for cour eens Sk Caorenon ry wea ied
ig freer anal 8 boe | oputetnd ee oe st Cisne
‘bern al Coneqont le cours gator te would rope ao th
‘a wee rece a efre en Ide ober satan sae, el a oe
‘rd on etait und wo ‘ra wn ther lito an
aan Ths ihe ewes Chin eh a Maa,
‘the award is feign or lal wo the pce of ‘Ad hoc awards made
wer cn matam |i Hong Kong are | pecausqueehtvcamtee
agement oie rns aeaion enforceable in mainland eee
‘htiaon omtccdn nnd Ci ms | China ‘cna a per oss
Scr yn se tne Song ing gr
"ats cvmino) Tee ‘Src ane UNCHTRAL sen
Seton ower wey | Senor ah Hg Kone
Shen he ped nC | eran eso ed
es ihr en soe psn neo oe
tie othr aoe sn ad ong cndy ot ed proces
‘mace in Hong Kong whether the arbiteation | most stable thes earmacion, that bing
romataseeediy Can oem | Grete he eg mk
Secu ch | ‘Sebermogucd un ent eChan a
“ime nef concmin | Ceo ought hata
Heng angen om Prenton’ eae “he Chin Spe op Coe
‘geen grange mal ennanet | jon ap arn eb or_| ao som wht pet es Cee
sion shen id Cian | ocean main Ch lng ag | kv ey efor ean eet
Fen ep ate ra | rma ans Sioinhtche ate pce sceHONG KONG AND CHINA
ot the goreng iw of he conto me
“reopen Chie sul ees
(One howe ht ei unseled
Saher Chie ne wan he es poe
verdant Chee prio aera de
‘Seni tos puri faci owned Choe
“este cour ical xparaton of why
‘a Chine come ee The ci
othe ths oer th it a
‘Nodang inthe New Yr Coston pss
fee ltr ute beeen oo ome
(Chane) companies being ced te
rene jaro br om ace VN) sd
‘Eni fea cooenon eal Be red
‘ehngenrnest af gn se gh
er Chane oe lanes ape cept
[Bene yt ow ote pce a8
Snore spy ane Cinese lw the
by Sippere hich coin rion
nubs eon ove te slender Chine
‘aed cont povding rab by
‘Ses Ci Sey oe oe
bor and emul oa wt owe
‘sy mone fel cs Drege
Coke e
COMPETITION
Reaa TAN
Gain full access to
GER Daly News Emit Britieg
news onchange the priate sector
Inlet for scan oi ad Seveverents
wis wong fo whore
GER Agencyaton Ema Boting
wa and rai focuses on competition
‘rforcerent agence woriide
‘args noone” ad ouput
‘arene win enforcement ofa
GER Onine News Archive
sencnale resource empriing thousands of
tows stores published sce 3087
poee tn
Pope rere
aeJAPAN AS A CENTRE: PART TWO
JAPAN
In answer to a suggestion that Japan has a long way to go to become an international arbitral
centre of note, Haig Oghigian, a partner at Baker Mckenzie in Tokyo, presents a contrary view
an mpi ne peal pt fh
‘eran ait pe il vty he
lef ete ha evo er oo
‘Fil ig tee
“his ws he condi hed By Heber
Sth pete Pet Gob nape ce:
nope replied ane 3,
Aloogh i gre wth of
Codi esr ange
‘ond com at hea pl
ip on kn dering loi» penne
‘eamatonl bon set a es
ene Gon ee pn Sr
Sees hte be oe a ht
‘timing Tayo to wl ere er
oumeri bron ester ai vile
Sl cea ites dings i
lee he own and aos
Ini is at comment wh sa
‘he won vcd get ean ah ep
ower soa ened he whe th
‘ay numer af betes ing pice nue
‘cfr hn ater one ete
Comply dhe sent nage ad 0
beste her ante mr ee
CCIETAC or se Hong Yong Ineo
4 208, he nen ap 2 per et of
i cas beeen 0 on and bl
{Us90.00 o USES nln). Another 30 per’
ot of caw hve cin rae fore dan
“Winn (USS, Few in To weal
nn he cy became cote fe on
‘enn ome ene he
‘Codi orm dere te tao
view = hops Corpor se dpe
treme any cote and ml en he
(aba commer pronta tee opis
fee Thema ceo nt de at he
1905 his red he see apa ew
be dapat a puny athe anon
not the = pomng accept of higaon
fem of ite con wl cme a
recom pa arponion peti na |
neni he one
Seether non-ete ndelerned e
‘rca Thiol tres mae te
| el pine
Myotis oem fr
| nt he hs tony
etn eck of eas ep ep
‘evr of expesece! stati nd co
Imad Ad rice 72 of he Beng
fee nd cot eo |
‘tho en ene i tron sree
‘epteschton in er |
Tet eamin thaw sean reer
euihongh i recent aka tg
ib niyo wt Te oh
bet, or ale doe le in|
‘Ais oand gene cose we 20
‘bjecave worth exploring |
Cup i ih ead sein eres
fica om pa Misi Fore Ale
ih ocd tha pn mas tp ong
‘aly ona mating ome tad mone
Sec lagen geeramen to pee
alma ning ne |
Icon! wtirnen yf ros
| stsaton sed coer ch thee
| sftason Asoc an the joes Cormeie
Second whieh son brn pa i
soul going would pene Got
‘Se Se ket ome eed
iter) hood be eae tad ping |
sen yang tn member of th Sgn
Isao a dein ston sod le
ft ony pa aa Ingen
rer ct i fe aon
a i oe coty Bathe pen Aas
‘Azceato,dby Tenigoc Sn ane
[bron Commer Abo ato
ty Yona So nd Na Sehr
howe era itachi nebo
‘oust bane ho he anges of
iran commer wron i he
oman pss cen.
‘ip hope fe Charred atte of
‘brat ade op of gs wy cing
‘er Goda) a riper a
the die oth sh Cher of Conmene
‘ej ns eed in 25h caper
‘heli hol, dng te Urry
Cag tow ofr tran conned
al Godwin taba rig aboot che
importance of Sala comple dein wth
Sern yale 72 oe Bega ve
‘The soone th done the ber Te fc at»
len puee poten oem Seas See
ao ore 2 wpe mp to dace
fhe eration bre the Ac a te
Ferg Anon Land och parce a
ict eine os crippling comply "The
Ferg Arey La ow tor ay woter
2 feign ewyer maya a and
these in ac perma me
em Be Ine be dang +
omc fra cna xp ton
the outa my be on ree on ed
“anouscto in iste wy the the eed
‘ono cub acd Te cane wold be
intl le wuld wae depen
sn hngage
‘Godin apt Gt eat
cle fing pn a seed ya
Gating wih oem He twee od
ow ob ot core nd be epi
Jip as an trial
tnt mal geiko ew wh
sendy sehen(CONFERENCE REPORT
FROM ADVOCATE TO ARBITRATOR
First arbitral appointments can seem elusive. Alison Ross reports on a session at the Fall Forum
of the American Bar Association’ international section, where panellists reflected on ways to
ensure they arrive
Casimectiure
tect
Ss hh ttn rt
coceimtae e s oats
Shoei
‘rege at
situ finite
Fannie net
‘seal iale bt
‘hier ne
sacar se
numa aiostse
Sec fc png
snopes tr ral
Sera te
Senate
Siopibrenarscr eran
Seegoecice stra he
LSet
cnn as ing
scan pe
ra fetta
eterna ced
7 ston
fame cheat
Stator coc
Senin nected chose
sot a pi re leh
So ta at ace nen
SUT cerns
SSE craaah came ln
Sihoacas
SUEZ siete the wvomers
|emean ea oe pox
sn Spe a oti
Sicalielumene "Detter,
Sed ae se
| RSS a po leh ee
Sotelo tart
Sie eed ty
esrreeemeereyers
tp stn een oc,
iEeece oes pecan Spe
ries pra dy me
‘sry noc pT pi
TSE ergata
he eed ens ln
eestor eee
Sapa ln cco
Smeets
attain ropeg er
SUCLNE ecto
ae Sai aged etme
| ‘jected suggestions from the floor thar was
polit st peop
|Site anatase
ieee urs
Peck n ASAD a a pie
Cpe ga einen
reread ifannnbshecme
tar se member wich bio waappined
vc pre
The phe eared xin waned
sn ape vp by De Hsing Leto
‘Chabon in London “ses ya ft
Bpuortuemer interim use aes
Ete ppd Haig wn of
PANELLISTS
‘oRsTeN
oes
recertINTERIM MEASURES
A PATH THROUGH THE MAZE
Parties to arbitration sometimes find that some kind of action is necessary before delivery of
the final award. Phillip Capper, Clare Connellan and Markus Duigstallet of Lovell LLP explain
when it makes sense for parties to seek interim measures from an arbitral tribunal rather than a
state court
"Tost tiated
res ey sor mie wes
{ely one gent coe te
‘ie oedg) om on come
Sint meng oe erence
Sprceaetyeesencenty i yey
‘ic, tn
Scr The tn gs
{Seni poem rein mc
cerca ee
+ epoca pi nl ae
‘rein meio ile eh re
Sane
+ TRENT ol go wth aie
‘Ml a coro ed
+ pec oft ee son
nersn grt ner meu by cooing
sri a i ston
san cour ep btr the coos of
Sci etn er we he
‘les expen poe th spain fo out
‘aD vor be damned war ete urns
Tce ale 23) povies the inl
‘rie 252 perme the parser py
{ay compte il try ee
hear ond aig te
+ TGtA ee 25 na ony pode the
‘nl huh! nee power ore on
| sprint any elem ve | mi wen cooing he ef ainson The
wero gon in aswel rier for | UNCTFRAL Mos La snd moan
the powe to kr sci fr come whieh | us noegy eo node ean
+ DIAC aa The 07 Dab ‘Seq the po he nse al
lezen Arizona Cente ales sho | ass we he bl de ing
alow shal ny priser | ob se cou
| See nn |
Spon sl ne fe ison
Pps em pa ene
Sic nr min es ay
|= Greist 6 ponies eeie|
deere meesay and thevch mere | Parties should be careful
REUNCHTAL wong up 2 that applications to state
ccadewamaingdarmiaeiniae courts do not infringe
| Seectuao proon re ;
ene beter or waive the arbitration
eon devteniegeeanfet [agreement
emacs Arie of tecomenson |
Some seund dna oeenencs
( SEAROSNI cht pcan
Seren py gh
‘tnd weemenig pa ee
"heey cn eno em The Medel Law elie ee pron
[SID ol may aoe he uboriy | ty UNEITRAL epi oes
tweafoeprovona meaner spins” cont eacing pro heme
reskin rtp ewig _|legelaon Lgalsen bord om he Mo ae
{Sabey recommenscon Gam tbl, | harbecn spt hy mow ta 3 cowie,
| nocteasbcaae a riba an ake ary! | at vel a sewer sate inthe US. 2,
{aro doo ia conserion when UNCHTRAL mend the Mal Ln eiing
Sn ee rena ng in mtr ot ten
‘emo wih het nd es
‘The anon lw sche ete ahiton | greminen mo ee
(the pce whee dhe rd eed bead | prs
‘eel may empower the webu 0 | rien mare ener -opon
deiner meses Pessoal ee hs | plein sh rome cour nerINTERIM MEASURES
tte oy i i i | ght ran As 6 | egw co ei
Sheree pve by tab ba-Tax THe Engh Arnaton Ac 196 ge much | the Se fe pry reed hy che
‘orem ete egueing uy pode fbe Pre uy pe he ian! aor
[Shane cony whew dbase tose powerta are ona proviral nj ee | + the pe wher an mar wil be ef ot
Gclckersiwre uh pronton'e mcsaryt [ori wouldve porto gratina ed | Som mony
Sesh pres Are 17 dere he | sar ayer abet the bras a
Sil cmsans in whch contny rece | suka adhe eb il sear nt” | The ein wil doped won he ae af
[Rcopaven oenocemet a imerinmextne |” Mowe conemianls the ows the | sours mi ao be fcr In Snorer
‘wun ayouctncnshc ance fsa bat to we ch ade arent eeeary | pl Wo rc nat conned er be
fect roo {Shree evden ramen inl ayes | Soppona our oul gant Being ren
ene cur wi ony seis pry aera | tgpat of baton Te Snape Core
atone parmanon othe ha or | Appl hs Bl ced So ore
‘rien ace ofthe ote ari nay Mafia Meat Soper coarse
Scclceu as acyiorwiaecam” | jetdesn pa npn Gro
|$SrCetwod spree setae eas" | Xecpcedg yw se bie
See Seem
: i tena ion, | aig ma
Parties RO are itor ‘order befie it has been formed. Yet paris 6 “international arbitration is crucial The general
frequently find that they | Shmsoefentyttartey edie | smn aro tars to poe oe
ree ee nese cacjen 2 munaneebaoe etm trten che | rae wo dmg ins en
need an inte + Atm suecdey ho nore cet May” | spend gos ton ange
before the tribunal has smite mss sora Ting pay en pn al
been chosen Soe feo hae upto | rspprie ie fm cou, pec
ss ce yg re | Sep
[Graces tare | att me dea
‘Slpcana cies pucchre sd he__| New Cameo ar See eee
ewany sted pacing nr ets | tien arin eee Aa
SE Tiwi Cia in
Sater can et ce mow pay | Tene
‘ew Zend Aiton Amendment As 2677" “The aeiment 4 eh ICSD abion
New 2nd marae feito sly n AM sane» ral iy ne
Mada ten’On often moat the ean ilk pare ay wa regu r
Sa ee, eee Being able to seck
Sogeees sismenirtntitttas linterm measures in
ean [SEE ese [international arbitration
ee des recreate
‘Law (without the new article 17) is Austria ‘he wibunal promptly upon it constitution”. The al
teri cerned acura
Settee cetera te oor eae
ee eee | eee
‘ee: The bal aye sch meet
ml eco te mae efrnene oe | Whe cose?
‘Rim ce peer inepe eto either of same prt enol wre ew
tie prio Ton powerboats wither natal our ave tepowe 0
Rc urs may cee wr gly gore eet nn mene snd wheter te prir_ | Pri ou ee ot scout nt othe
‘ner ein sefenest hes shoul On space tba Where the le | powers hen othe und he a
[Binet lee! of ie olny coe: Uner Sos ot ae ch eps prion he eee | procul ul, ba ao he ton we of
Ute ec any aya eqs eon ncore, ofc wll pnd om he tenner of ck | thee of he bon Bie though pis
tec dig bia proces rn | ee ie chs mien ste ours ll oer
Srpwcee meus Aur hc axed | Ua py mi ph choot gan cour, | sit Much leper on wih ral ane
fe Shnge he Mel Lv cco ope fee ae coro ‘chet he pres he od he ae
(Sheet oft abit | SecretoAROTRAL CULTURES COmPAxEL
ANCIENT AND MODERN
Northern Europe offers at least seven arbitral systems, each with different traditions. Partner
Petri Taivalkoski and specialist counsel Helle Lindegaard of Roschier Finland, and associare Per
Franke of Roschier Sweden, provide a guide to Scandinavian and Baltic arbitration,
anni and the iconic ane» | Sweden ad Finland a anes pe ith pie om a ay
ae! aen bering Enon tral | Abercorn Smee at Gr many | m0 eet cour n geet
nachiney stand oew wheres Seer erin Sweden abd Pad sron ba bear | mot commen pe ion soon
snfowionpactsencn hei orn nui tal se oom pats mom | hae te amt sean a
‘practice arbitaton a ng ben opie | ween A ely 1588 porains | way imag us Boe Chis Re
"Nov bat ol ay ch the counryConeningaberon spel Sud | the former Soa enn prs fee
‘avodeped mentors Ea afte | legen adhe neon cathe | US and Wenera Eos he Sooner
sorte jini = fol —_Sevtoin Char of Commerce ind | en ede el aon
serum andatheen othe Model tx: | Cental Chamber of Caan of nd wil | Saucy b se Sct ong hay of
For ithe dieenos comparson ‘eke dh 1h anverrswit he pea | soho ve elton of
fscen diene rented | ede ret sophie Boy ron ce
ures in Nore Eup ste canon "To rypond wo the demand oe rening | lw and iets are
‘ae Aton well gute shough not | teoaonaco wat, be Sea Tee exer tthe monte finriona
ernie a raniioy wes Gowns and the Rona teron a wee med bition cnn 0 ee ih a
te soon een bee ofthe | inthe 198 addy bth cami ingiton | she tas coment meno sets
Sebi in grant fis Te come, eco UNCTTRAL Ma wom Invern reat rie or Seas
cused below fae allied the New ode | Itraoal CommenstAtraion Te | Chamber of ane snes atthe
Contin Togs the signs fosndow | speach fhe onal oun ban Sey | Energy CharT eos ab de
gree snuenn end popety ore | and Fda steeper ee, ‘Shar eof med mabe of apa
‘pen ata en Dargie ae 1 ere Sct | an ah
‘chinks tf Commerce hs expenencedseidy | Ava sebero of iced ber
| ince ofitradonal acu The chanter | oimeenaon! aaron doney ete
Chamber noes te ni fwd me
te To a mh sgn members
Mobumed Aboa-Eain yp Pe Kase
[Swiaeind~vcechimat, Acne
Kamar Rui) Dvd Rivkin 038)
oder QC (agin an Way Seng Chang
(Coin he chs tet eon
2» rls eck feo he at he
{ee yen at ae
“hn ent sorte
Pet the demand of tron cme
‘eon af
‘rberl rocediy tng ino
ashi! proceedings conducted Senden
Fld = wel th other Not oan
te gnc cae by pga sd
‘nay ond we fone on ceeding
‘he nets sn wie othe sic pas
Sipe eed ey ce ane
‘Swedish an international css ned bythe Stckan Chamba of Conners
100
s
8
In Nereay nd Denk bia hs ho
oe a = a Tong been ed ete corm apt
eal (in Novy: mine cpt in ur).
Hi sec, Mi esvaina: | in cir Say gute nce an atARBITRAL CULTURES COMPARED
coi etn po gle abrtion
(Secmprtente mma sod aap 0
bon at eet re May 205
{tc che presen Dah bionion ea one
3s ho heen sx ae bad on he
Modal aw nd apy dameni we =
“Sm iq ane of the new Narwegn
oe as a pec aes
(Scere agree bythe prin
‘cl ects a he bial ed aot
ote Tid prey ay howe be
rset bing the ble prceding an 0
tn Dea ar pred by the Da ote
[rAthon so im Nowy ye Arson
‘revs baton wer ony ocd
(Boar of Up ae pins sso 8
wee cone the ct ofthe ep
[Sf Eioun on he Abraon Cour ae
Eee Chub of Caress ny
"The cence int on 11 and eae
thos atsrton The no Eo san
pe bd marl open be
the Este pl pe pec with pec
{2 eli) i gly sdcced by he Goran
Ie ys Self the boat prosone
‘te Geman Cit Prcere Cae the
thee ot ne ede awe
“Tn mn nie eifereeserce
iti, tien of sinc
“td a al sy Ena fe
rhe ea pe oe
I en pa mt
Sera
“The pa pe pens ft
“Fc cao rn becwen the
requ atone eterno
“She rl bl ay een
en to be cfr by Exons ou
‘Ar wo ny ony Ye ode
proper tice ping he ppomenent of
sn beer svt ben even oflowing | equi Lai cine be comieed a Mods
‘per nthe tind preceeding ft cam | Lew cory
‘prenmed ht hth reryoce he” |”Aterta inceningy popula
(home afte tee Model Lr dow not_| Lan Pat fanaa be Lan wo
Sela the meray eee, bon ate lean coc pate:
De toe muy af Eni gon, | "am cor ae oe om pot
cout pase ha ie hace eee The | whe appneent ower
Spee Court howe ecopnsed one | «Lan cour do nt in ing
Fae gewnly tld rnc of maton |" ence
“theaton dat ner elected prea + Siig te abil ceding pie came
inde oprny id hn cote he ‘bee Lae ear
Jpplebiy cfc Now Yo Comenan onthe | + py wh equ ecu for
Reeeaon nd Enfcemer of acge Aber | "hin, mut ket requot 03 out
‘ein Eos tet sing tl proceeding
‘er he lars been ered
[only pont clenge he sar 2
Laima th coy cod mambo
‘orbecon nT ie sey 12
‘eon senor sted ye Mniey
One of the most
remarkable features of ‘of Juice of the Republic of Latea. Arbitiation
arbitration in Latvia is | Sem tet ren of
the country’s record ‘ion Ion nde ty anc at
umber of apitation | Smet oe
institutions | Sets Sot tos Art ete
| Gidiecetaat's rand Sse
“Cried tannin
‘Sik nowt Come
meu ab oo ton
Sorta Cn efcormene
eit gul meant | ae thi teed ben
csnmci nte aon | Co bebe tn as Co
COUT AES Soe yEatee” | Soe tonrmaont Ate Car ne
SUindet tarsiindor'atecarme | ubaniee ls ofmer fio noe
muspartitaca comers tow | Senden iu atta bp
Secs Stetina | runt atinnn tha oh
See atte
[Link] Tacs core! | Ne oe ci Coa
| (ne ofthe at eal nas of wiaton
Sie dg het ed | Canmeta een
Gjpe aoe itn sd Bnd oe | 28
‘io out dos ce pie beta om
Sond Aten appmid by he sae | 20 =
‘rely bye and Een se Eoin
ig ct ely Be appointed by he eron
‘eon hy he prt the apa |
|
“hearin Cl rca Cade pie
for gl eet bth neon
td doa awit mag ny
‘Sinton bereen Seon Whe the ode
compase rend Mol aw ponies a ser
‘teh conpinc compe payARBTIRAL CULTURES COMPARED
‘ote devon. Arbrain nos in Lavin | annlmen shoul epoca ta he Court rembing fom al pcs aired
‘ahve tf btn andthe pies | eC Appe of Lana Decne ping | by an Earn elon rs heme,
se taints anders parcaramin’s | tbeanoaen atl wae yhe S| enwne witout on ond echaon
‘uly bev w be lec only fom tht | Goat of ppd ar nec to eve by te_| of ecoemere by nonin sour IP arg
Samet hn Sree Court of Laban This wide ces | tah been decd evo
‘otevew chalenge af whit wanes | Esai squealed onthe
Litho led cto and the edo nt ces | ted pry yo spf olen of
asap aw a0 Comme toovch ecu aly to be coed” | th deci nh Eni,
‘Abitaton 8 995, ed on he Mode Law and |i commecion poe reps 2005 919 appro foe
‘pole hector aod ratonalabrsion. | seme Insp the mde acer somck | eftenen ite ae snd
{och dips towews Therese oly 20:0 | sara ma Revnly hr aly been | sed er ot pai m curse ering
cornea yarn hana, | ne ayn wich ee abil wad we | bw may fetes cml Se
ensued with tr tan {00000 cd apes | sel ‘element fp sed
Bld by be sate cnr ech pee Tihs cure he ry al ~ hac
‘When ing tour commer won | spratianson ppach eb mopion
in tehanin pactaly ecyting ete | telniocment of rnb eats Fo
Sond he Vane Cane of Com “Ht 2 ecogton sal eae
‘een Th ston ne ended ‘ny ected in one ee oo) Regus
{201 dough neg wen ean ‘ete cogion wd elect of reg
(Cort ie eel hes of. sie suas ed byte Cos of Apes
(Commer of han od Vie tera
(Conmenil Asiessn The ose ad
‘hans Raye sel most ete
Lithuanian courts have | ssh tr se nets Ee,
smmalteeiiiem. |S eryiibeal= that; | Seereaestas Casares
Surime ter eae atten | prO-arbitration | stoners ae trees
Pemeieteemte™ |~approach tothe | Messina”
‘itn Bais ethene eon | recognition and soem lew Lunn
[Road Caren’ Anotion te Asean
< ‘lpr ro ate ad eed
Sit'Gaiasc’Cament nan | enforcement of foreign
hoa eps of whe lng
‘ser de nth arcane wa | 2° DHtral awards ‘sins cent ene
4 the Lithuanian Lae’ Asean, The ft | iss done bythe disses cove pon requ.
thet tone bees ue bya
‘Appared by ich bod and poe eo4p
sf poyer in Lituanan hoa cone
{unc the reatiy a uy fe ee
Some ul sr ofthe Litas a
‘The i ot dco ato teto
nue wt of ecuton yb pes che
ihm sho posse Ail ar eet
ude of Lehane come cle ser
on arbiaton eof anne fr bin | Efrem ‘opi bythe Cort of App of saan,
Sete dps re Sweden, ian, Nery Dena Enon, | te Spee Cou Lite i ae of
+ Gps ling competion hw may not | Lani an Lions aad New | Spey Wias oeaann mpeg cn
Sesutmited sbimoe ie Letwai | York Cameson ‘Ml norte el ye Con of Appel
‘tis che chara ofthe permanent ‘A foreign abil aman canbe enfored in| of Luan, is not pou eo appeal sich
‘braion mason” whchin pace | Sweden snd Fab wheter at note county | dee
iti the chaeman othe Vat Cou of | n't psy we New
{Commerc Arberason since ts the nty_| Yank Comers, ote Scena Pd tes
th maie te enc oeeeton Unk e | Nore Eaape ica aon ea ein.
NewYork Comenson nde Mel Uw aon-_| The Sictoln Chamber ef Conus hrs
eshoul oro fr sce | wbiaby opt er nh aw do | logan sigue ayo seca
Sey amor apee one spinner of | noc vn or fing coger of | imo bens el he eo
bere fnorement of vgn wba da Fal | tes ch ree yo
sth hitman of ein Cou of | Myjorpo el Supos a lq | commer perl, one
{Creal bination to whom parses | Fund stl me ae asomplad | iceangpopaty wil hap cere ok now
Shoo ey wah ocalenge an | wth ear | Ht ot ee ow adel pe on poe
senor Tn Sweden eafrcensot ely denied) | cine
+ Gechimman of he Vins Cou of ty the cour tn nt ow she
Conese Arron a tas competence | cement ben dei ha en fo | ig ope ean wi he
te deermie te mane or ck st neg cence: rice Tena ier ed Pe ap of
{fet oan be end Conputory nicemen ofa! ware | Rad 6 oar Eso Csi nd Mae
Isppeason fhe amuinet ofan | made a Ewen merc oe mcneonal | Hake a, ges hanon ons,
bl od maybe ade on he rods | “reqs copiion and econ | and Rima Sao Non & Per
Sone in he Mota A gpewion be | corre an aa cote Ae awe | ane(Our ADR lawyers have represented major Canadian and intemational companies and
governments on a wide range of issues in hoth domestic and intemational arbitrations and
mediations.
“The focus of our practice is on the energy industry (ol and gas and electrical), mining and
corporate commercial ircluding commodity pricing agreements), construcion agreements,
cost overruns, share purchase agreements, misappropriation of corporate opportunity,
telecom and contractual interpretation
For more information, please contact Jack Marshall at jack marshall@macleoddixon‘Gom or
(403) 267-8282.
Detach our Narco tele Col Reeluy
peau
COR On Ono CORONDISCCVFEY IN ARBITRATION
REASONS TO EMBRACE SECTION 1782
RULINGS
Section 1782 of the United States Code has been criticised for putting US companies at a
disadvantage in international arbitration, In fact, extending section 1782 is a feasible and
“well-balanced” step argues German lawyer Martin Ilmer
he sermah of ee Apion f Raz non-US pry Mary sto ian im, | thn be bj dicey aden by US com,
“hing and pen f One Gap, ch eof apd Grany end ss
28 of the United Sones Code on foreig: private | arian, The mater i bowever tte | Some even expect summer hat
tshirt They fer diary becwen US an | he sory ef het th mathe ep Ee bt ern wre he
‘Sue parts oa oe pate atiason | abtmnon but een oth cence | Engand pedo ony hh
Sere enantio |stn a ee etpca e |
rUSporinn docibd'm whame anes” |BcUS wold msc poe | Te elder of enete
{Cilia Rt Thee eras | Sf steno, Dang te open of | Spgs 1 pte eran
Seren thie en neuer decisoen” Seton 1792 weld rch Eat sn ety son the sly slong et
Sudha NBC Br Sams © Coand Res | cng the pron of US pres ewoud | ening eerie he US el oars
(feces Bremen Inia which |e ence evden hee the US sgn | ses ance bene ie ene
ply doed the potion of ction 1782 pre mbit se ‘hig evidenes nd cone he ces
‘ort ttc. i} fhe naa tno pens Dern
Ths re dcr at si provid otis the pple fan 1782 ol eae
snaps eran schon A | $e pry ekg eens ce dee US
[Nor tbe parpont deal ame amas ich eting App eton 78 oe
‘the US Sone our agen el {ie bison dw at howe open the
AND aa opty the drt sour a ioral endence ough Rese sector
the Rae Tig he On Cal | sts dscreton on te eng eo
‘ae acour of he nia ean Te
“he disparate "hatred te US Supe Cur june
[Denying the application | smtetrsiemme
Section 12 the mow ml a Gr he
rer ein pate btn pce
‘om US fer cours The Hague Comesaon |OF Section 1782 would. for discovery onde Ie strates the ladder of
cinmntiteiaiociy, ring-fence evidence | Swearing,
nl bands cep ed he located in the US pn
once Perera tea
mioerbocoermon fans Seueuyocares
fieerlegeetorrtr Soereteenaas
Sane | neither eo,
See | seaenentoramen,
fates araeas Sas
‘contra, mighe hawe 3 good chance to obrain. arbitration however, sai to result in disparicy | has to consider issues of imibalince becween theDISCOVERY IN ARBITRATION
Thi cry nr by 3 US cour nt
tenuous arian the vd by
‘heb eb The abl bal ay el
‘Beste docunna or ne tren ie
‘hse ve dat th wy ey re phe
decane par ence or other pec of
{hae dco the ri of te ce
The section confers
discretion on the court, |
enabling it to take |
account of the individual
circumstances
xt in ors wh wh eed
the eine im queso. Even dnery
‘rr sogh ton ey geben boon
Sntywihia enone etemgaon ch
US cour may std he US cy pat se
rece teparios fing oder
tes
“Asin thse hl ae i
ott opp tion 182
evo ale ut wtp ode
To hee pry bowen pre nd seve
The amon fue i he nin exe.
‘isughsspranon arn TS y the
Tome nur nay oc oxicaay oe che
fhe by he Saprome Cat ne» AMD,
i he thrsgh eptnf te genes
ty te loner comet ae rearing vere
hac eiplenton wile
fer apc on wort sen of
scion 1982 mee ot ped th
sepa meri
epnding on whut the dace sled by
‘emer cue 182 weal pin che
"Seo ite a oh wi the pom lt
sha cou apie sn psa
Derg metas nhe diet tora
Proc! nn cou ee» Susy rng,
{Sat poe dnl fj! mance The
incl lope ich ngewe
‘sence on od of dap cone
even non-paty to che dpute isin penciple
‘tect the lv a bene cou cing
{hea on he gringo ing of eden
‘Te Bapsh sotcon
‘Neomputne gimp he Engl son
‘crm tenon ded he corset
19s a Eg cou te por er
a ses esr Eth
(CovCaut» Lt Unde pe toe
feck arte above for ping eon 1782,
‘hting a shorting lain be doe
‘Sevan guering by apn pene
tric eth Engh co open per of
vein pete eon, neo me
rene paring se the fh
Frocein wAn Bagh ry =r ee one
fary ch ws wate igen oe
{line res Such ao open te 2
‘ence Ie be perag fence whe
Regen epi
‘ane oi any ak ts appro
Reon Fez by US cue, bar swap of
‘Bio Se i a py
‘heme lime maean of epee
‘hoy apt thy re ee exp exe
{nsppaon of tion 172 me son
‘haan even ht drson~ wood
| Sova ei domi of he apo
| thr eton1760‘The me con yr
| epee nad any ares by rg
tebe MA Ras onthe Ting of Erne
rs ave oppor to ols woe
‘rem fede ering bing om
{orn raonl oon is Ap + US coat
feed with an ppnson wer secon 172
‘Sheen cet wold tele pry 0
Sve he mechan proaed ye A
sty ah ing US coroner
The real issue is how to
achieve parity between
the parties and serve the
interests of justice
Secon 82 in teas Gr eching ta:
‘Aap poe rool atta
pplction sabe o wo a all-o- nothing
tl wctlned ge fil te
‘owing te US cour 0 cone he
Merny sr ch eat Ma
les Conant oo Its!
‘Lr HodGERMANY
GERMAN-SPEAKING GROUPS HOLD I
JOINT EVENT
Dmitry Marenkov of Germany's Office of Foreign Trade in Cologne reports on the first three-
way meeting of German speaking young arbitration practiliuners
‘opin hei epecton rpg asso | dat excepto ew documents mde
I he German aeoation a young Jedthe weight ofendece toh parser He | gue br dcoey Te pes nd spake
Mien psionokyine | ibhe andl eepwtaravininehe | fon torioecrmerteeet age
inch on 2 Octo tetenebe | nogend wins freon nen | Soya ma
remind thie Swat dSA ow Oat |ragatip nha ace Set | mops aaae eke ae
‘Kretaitarioiertece—netenkes ac iceatarmuagenes oe
Mor 0 arco fos cowee | econo ined" cen cee sen
Nosy sored hoes sbo_| wenn in itmgesieoontberag, lacunae mand gay
sme =miene teem leone | Ermine yin nd oyu” Sat nye ae
at ie il aw Coen Le | nen ty aon ty othe aon oe
eased wher he ppc sod inert | he Fang Bein tert
“king evidence in nteraions ahr:
ftom tw eoltrity rato | et corben Sag commen I a eee
{pani on manna ans e | eee agua ogs ter peer _|
Siosiemty = stor hk ther | Centon camaae ada | Sota eNews be ean
GovacnyenninbeOeedarhis | Egintomsanreke eons Soe eegecteteee ea
Hanif pe mck ene cc | on aah cot
enh hl wes eee Poe [lec one ted omy eed
occa ae teaee| fsccoteertecncte ents
Estraier) peal nes stam pe
nde oom of ro | Rote Sem Srp a
‘enon tr pn” ‘ts lor a he yrom eng
-Weien an ot procedaes | Common law arbitrators | 295 22 eee en
Schascoe scompioneftemertoy | 4tE More likely tc ‘Seon cree nae pace
sd hil w approaches to ween sa ri order disclosure and to | spending onthe ll background stan
Ech amieniitat |eolerate witness cross- | Sage ma eo
Eesiciaeee eee’ | txamination mirereet Toe
Sieticmerac | oat
‘econicerteioene he ade Bt of | seminal wana sd ade te lowing
She coum a ato ioled The moe |The hl par Scn Repro ker | * apa ftehigus shuld woe
Soa, ‘epochs semen ofa eae ih mdcovery | slr tol cies wot
Sten Kil ook wp he wip crim | induced th oucome Bcd be ‘don wines esninsion big
fbn’ inceningSownes aespens,” | cil wma oF tne nd co He age cha | nce Al ems of ene se
indie comquet low fatrncnes He | rere could be eslanono | teamed the inthe the
[Foentd te model f2"pro-acove bine” | arent roblens bt quitned te ning | aim ofthe dre eo
a solton. Une ths poponhezbea | fhe mjry of bron abpeths yes | = henge shoal a
‘rl hud ben teeing ena ens, | ice od lr re pep nd work, | rye nth ey ao
tn soul each fran amiateneee | seca abe ping meen ‘niece he ay he pcg se
‘oll anghased te imporance of priney | ugh plied cee ca amour | conde ne
Cae margaret dacisionnn whhabeaton | an“ehsne soy owning ean agedGFRMANY
pri cml enim ney |edit pio tenis | ci er he on
poctunscVemmscy” (Suter see ace om [geo es ese
eeeaeacepaciie’ — |SSmwrctwinctnecogstiees | imeyestuphoue am
Site ce Cemed e(sscichcnmr Totnes |
Pec teilaay tenet iste a Sngeced nv oe mae perl
eprom sgn. [Seuio end O ote
taf Wl Wage te ght [ccc ar con
MRURS INS UEEgacasteke[peciet eirwrs me in
Shun Evens ban conde cee Ionian He dese the ducason on he
‘Say ote, heed nated cou © poral perez conmon a
Mh Cant ete al, [flasher ao
nl peed The speakers agreed leplioarument| between abinuon when came w te extent | Civil law arbitrators are
Shemebten cunts Geaigematsmen stan more likely to stracture
Souaieigtoa tees” Pe miaedesehatas proceedings, to rsist on
‘Hance which wiaesst be wilieaon what sbitaton pactce And be mptiator on he |eadlines and to take
ee me egcrckemaeymen’ partial decisions
Sree ncarereaten raat
citkararmmmem sce
Set henteysope a
fSteact Sigece een one
Si cemcnay omer
mrss
eed
3 The nec preprint comers shot tate igh pene sacha ame
Attorneys want tO WiN (pant sarees ad core owned cost _|solion eto eae yl wea
cases irrespective of cite {Ger tnage te of resin the eee
|e cami hepa ant |i Ch aro emoge
personal preferences for maniacs Gui aot |r tenn nur y epee
z Tiuksitter ince urtsens”_ Pou mama i sa rs
common or civil law erect Gombe ssn: company |i henge anion
wycgns ype Seth |e ee og
(Sota minh [a be
fon Dem uskbucepenene, | ny deen wale pode Nr Ba
| eta sey sold mite hem" woed | uemed deo orig! nog
‘Ser prem eely sn reictons vie [over gato sore eo en
(Sue aos slre le Bender | Coon frm of date roan no
| ewed ht ol lw enn se more tyler el oe
{eeu pocesings tear on dealin | Lats Kn f he Rater Bosch Gop
Stewie pl drone Auer empire rsp Between»
none counts dare eons | compu teaser or uppers igh
al ee ney ore lyon hewings_| pony Sf great mgorance vee 0
She of ended The ermer_| so fn er de ay coe Copia
seeing rong cil lwo common low sppach cae tea money slice | nt nine decom ich the
‘Shen act choice of tonon tle, | ici, ew Aloe the ng of endece, |e bat ho the os of ots Flowing tse
froce nd birators iin ase moc yok oon | peso Sc Raber Bah al oy bee
Fins Fea fens Unie spied | henaieste spe npr request mere | mole in round 1 bom in 120 y-
Shatpiconiiraton eto openers |r tn come, cna nw atbrtrshsory The cof wt ul oppor
San farsa nnesia chong heen ef [apples npr for al tes dpe low for young pacenen exchange des on be
‘Mion Ue rear tase uae (crannies ae ota | caret wend ier bain The et
WOkmunool soemonbectnicene, folate mmber finer Boe | DSW cones wl ake pein Mach io
Rowing areene tyson cure Newly ened hemo sod wen se emo | ApelExpens) ACE
Global Visigay
in International
Arbitration
Arnold & Porter LLP has one of the most
‘experiznced and largest international
arbitration groups worldwide, renowned for
its long-standing expertise in Latin America,
Europe, and beyond, Our attorneys serve as
advocates, advisors, and arbitrators in disputes
between sovereign governments and private
sin commercial arbitrations.
tional transactions,
investor
arising from
Puan LosGLOBAL BRIEFING.
CHILE: COURT ENFORCES
ARBITRAL CLAUSE UNDER
THE MODEL LAW
CCrteon courishave recent rendered
‘Snotner Section hel conttms Mek Bro
‘titan Hend Felipe Osta ofl &
Carepers
Folowa he easenet ofthe UNCITRAL
Mail sw on nena Commer
‘tro 20, Cea eours sed 2
‘Neher of cin hat ip bing Che der
{ois gil of becoming leing tras
(poe tad te Sec of
Coupe el de wa Bly id
‘Sonor withthe Mad! Law ade New
“ek Comer rina Chan omar
Tes tough shim bee Chak ol cou
ao Dani Nee We yo,
Sap scoped nde US os Prosi
‘Seren tha he dfn wrogity
‘Sune dbo agree ted
‘Sin 204 and eqn compensa
(he davoge ht we Dana Nee Wer
Hh changed te deo Ces
orl coursing sng oe gy ae
ie datibton pecmen gong oe the
es re i era
‘Spore ake ng md
‘sow lel tt a
‘rae ai Dad a ae
‘Sw Afar a fn,
What Cre tree
tm ht of oe
‘shi aihough ms separ Sacemer ere
el pre of he buon pene
ait ation atcorce wa ce
Apa terw ek Cameron ae ale
{0 the Moe Ls Or None
{Cs ae pl he jr blog
‘Sringeri
“Tite eee epoch
(Chen cout ene a tla der
feather ees chalet
eval dc by Clean cours oy
‘Bemets fthe cin he Seon In
car hws, the dente permed
owt the sconce ith the NewYork
‘Coretta clege
”
prin inte a hole decided | he inion re hat Se-up ely
rots coming te se ins ain Baba ed of bon ace
‘Scondy oe abil cue stich woe | Eo ete amend it send
efor ad fs wich render | fel cee ato ew wl ee
{his ema nce by fens to | icon bt i pan a he
Sepa dicomenc and kn yma se | when of epson nme ey ©
idiot pve eons eae mane | the al cnet pt cee Ca oc
fbecnle dap peo fhe puri the | tire dap where oe dese
rei tte enn feo when de dpe sas on
Tai eect word anog tthe | ice bt sere he or enon
cucane ofthe ce ay he been ae ‘ont nected wi bunds
{Tice pee dp re "Pee paper melee per at
cr ofcoumrnd Menor, | jot becouse Snel cone son aw
“US tenor ln 1998,Mercomrimplernemed an | cha will supervise and suppoct any arbiation
Imemacnd Commer Atirccn geement, | tow th cal cen wan ie
‘sich emis pear promsos wih eped | sles The Enc cen core rn Ieance,
‘Sorhroson cscs Ae i) om dota | atdApea) a Eglin cout whee
cements abate ge an uti | jie ae wer common jg fom
‘omen vo oth urine akon | nnd New Zeid Snore td Mais.
‘Sone (ues te aninerly | A umber of hm ne lxag ges i
Siti by one the pre). Arle #2} Father | Insnuseal emer abeton The cur
Prone tare agemmen to sbitontallbe | jon confined oc nd commec
iced nemo ensting pot within | ute cnseted ssme way to te DIFC.
Sie comace wih vou appertocaclee | butanol ae enforoe robot he
Itcerpraten yore UAE The cour ar sen nnd ere
Tate deco sd gon crs xe on ebay 207 weg i Bet
tothe defend In seen wh Chilean Iw | a i Nowmber he pao Bt Maes
‘Sane thatthe pha wo feone | lejuncon a Deenter he pan
| ovis omen te ocnting bore wes Marion,
Gan Sica, "The UAE gowcament ben woking
‘on aner UAE stato ew wh 3 ewe ©
| {Er teron Ender re at hw
GULF REGION: REFORMS ile Griomch cheng ne government
Poe To coming yo iyo eon cn
PAVE WAY FOR LCIA | moc interesting year for arbarasion inthe Mile
Goverments and tanjers have Ear ape esac Sn tam
cca cscttemncie | mais epodor say abou pa
SStivaon inne tose Cosh oor, | enn wim
Porticloyn NeUnted arab Emirates
Sn Save Arca Philp Punwar ofA
Nomimi ® Compenyinbusdirapers
INDIA: COURT CLARIFIES
bi as bene fo umber fines,
EES SES STL | WHEN ARBITRATION ACT
‘uleoew obs ems taessn | APPLIES
Etec Mento Reso nde sae |
Reese ad rn Pe He |
oe wich waned 205 by he
The Supreme Court of indihos sed on
when nla’ AXbtraton Act opps n
‘Carer ooted broad. Als Chale ty
(Chitle & Ascciates @ New Dall reports
1 Naat An Cop ting eatin
| ihiconing trae Gece nde ‘er nis bern At ecient of
“an emporan elopnear i ion ow | swat onde dpa beeen
moun! Deb eratond Fuca | the pre Cmte 10 Be pwemen bee
‘Cone (OFC) on 28 Neeser 207 the tt_| Nal Agia nd Ga Tig roid
[LepSEae LEIA Ant Uns Camel Spnpomun, freee of apn yeseson The
Secon tthe calc na gngto bon ested ha ime
Source sje eee whe Lcttvande dpe cs be eacedami te maar
wich er wll cogs he unc pu hol hn be reed eo eld
lo ado cae ae mated ston | by arbiion i HongKong, in acorge wahGLOBAL BRIEFING.
‘he poison the er ar ay oe ssary and compenaton Saige a phceVireni | ein am lt «py hd
‘woleaten ease or ancien in oee | othe me pon mtd acer mario | emproruarg macnn ag
whe ie loves inthe Wat coneoion all ehoagh | Sopra ast one
Tr rapon 6 Sn Agr ocr mace of make ors atom ta sh ph nd
Iimocion ofthe ates semen Cast | ronal ‘i pay nde pei,
Tring refed comply ig |The eal cmp Cb Kaufan
apeon fr pptmmen ssl stares, | Kole Cat Berl es aj Willa ‘Thats wing slewing ae
‘ais Tang etd peso on the | Rowley (rien, naling on the merit | suds gel nee cig bye
srommér dt he eemencaamng he fthe pats he leaded are | Feito de Exper Compe etn
sbiionapecnen wan no lngein face cndhet oF Touma cond a ase’ _| (ie epee on re Bese
{nd tha pesto or appninent ofan | eapicion el ns nh athe ps | etacy pr, Amctane Seay
‘biewor wa ec mananale Gun Tidy | of and epee fonder | epee he Asean te ot
earthiness emo | Gt cen spe
these oftieason in ind Ashe vow of | man, Veal and try Compania | by aoc mat nang es ces
sbicion ough was HongKong. ponsns_| de Ags de Acongui hen ogi ln as | ope oneness
srr pian he Spee Caurt_| mapa ot end oe onigl | wes Wa eet sts dog tn
eto prion apoican abe. 30-yar concn period (125 hand ona | mo waamhip wht caer mse ee
‘Toe Sopeme Cour meted Garang | dacamel crow ml ‘mena wing seer od mg yer
angen anda te pon rll | Ti hy ed ma aig | od ery ro dW ey
‘ws aicaon shel na he poisons of | ur aa hae" acto th the | ete malt eo reser any
the tema pty and pare Feo deviate | cancion pein» gg emu Yee, | par a at tcp nee cai
‘nyo he eet permited yer pr | ring and ser CAA er one on| Sovehy wou ach oped panel at
[ft Act Incas of ersten cme | a According tte ard emer | atoms oad compenaton fs ok ak
‘ican hed onside ache At mod | er oor ny ara ppc | went coat>The neo soe
‘ep ule he atid aged to exe lt ening damages Faced wh oly ed. | oy no sopoant lg he on
{tay ofits povatns In teehee or | evidence fr ihr ton ces he | Fete ling dr ae soso
fa chosen by he ae wou pr Fane jeced he cio lorie inode | th conan coal a clad at.
Sas heather at grr sha Hong_| bypass andes seth concen, | mics main tie enna So
‘Kong shoul beh dos ot man hat we | the meshing he wnat to | he pre ang Secon yh cna opt
‘fire n Hong Rong sal spy The abiztan_| the 1998 jedomet ofthe Permanent Co of |S eon "on psa’ be eng
Sle cel sate the ew spy Ik | nenaional cen the Chorney i | te anes waa caer en
‘lgonrn te mppinnen fbr he {Jepntoe muta frespoe coral | ton wr es mv sel et
‘feeac of dpa od he ene proc and | eons ea dwt te | ah epee oe" Th es la
Freed of abircon url ese mde | nuevo mi wp td | shed an afer eso nates ee
Sod gee det The car io bd ht rent | mtd rm em ‘he aril pnel dor nee cep yor ptr
the perrmance fhe con comes om nd oan med
on acon of [Link] or bec of | The ral pn! ho conde chat was—_| Of coume mans oben a nd fr
once won agement weld are spp onc compenaten bani ome tue USS lon Novel ea
‘cea froin tie wing | eps nt "gwd | na
|‘Seedetascemsinhe
“Dinyonen th poner bead | NEW ZEALAND?
MONEY COLUMN: MARKET ost eutto¥nca sal emmensot | PARLIAMENT UPDATES
VALUE IN THE VIVENDI CASE «rast conpanded smal ie om te | ARBITRATION ACT
The Monat the Vive cass pd | ment wl mena ee | Ss ben Wagar of lb Waker
Eroperneed once avarang | Te ha nen posh none | COmBbeH Welt of bo! Woe
{ok meaket vohio—then chregarded "| Vien te ame poon if had are | SS na arnonon Ariecorent
thar: Mask Kantor Os3 why esi nae canon sa Chor
[Act 207. The changes updote Now
Toolana's Ariraion Act 1996 wich ie
boved on the UNCITRAL Madel Law
Fron high are th Vie coal ne
‘ee puri heme pion wf rpsine
Ina Aug CSID eee it
trod ie ang unaing te een
Vinod Uninenal and Ageia zing tthe | ume meaty =f Veh nthe) The enc change ail 17 ofthe ACT
1995 priinon by he Argie jvc of | wae conenoninrrens at rion | ae ain othe 290 erin the
Tucan of mau oncom Peiones | bid soapbl who eat tion The | Model La on ution tne ers
ss col il diver the ringer Beach | ence namo be sad unre | an primary ones ew Zsa ono
ofr meno bt ve shuld | long appacher of ours gen the fox counos oop ie hage The
ale pre momento cnet wesnent_ | Adit worse re | sane scat cena
toca stmewur of mew unin the | aon a per noone wa
ihe rtd othe sown of competion
‘ou eflioepaessnen Tena aed jail cen hy nee
poe by Aetna, The bl pad popes
tect he ropa athe Chr Fotry | Won San Cooma sania | front comune ive pee mt
Sint“ me vale a enenase of | body roe 3 man eal rte | Uh ge a spa ow ed ae
conpenation The abstr ten poceded wt crus dens iets wr | on quan le The andes hep NewGLOBAL RRIFFING
"Te amending a ed on
comune ied 2208 pr by
{Te Now Zeng aw Commi ad he 26
eminent the Motel Le
diene ily oe x woe Mast
testo mpc ti a mae
sr exp hn 2 yet to carton
Te bican san pte ern es
{Tene so dy es oat athe
Sie pone tal bul eer in
mown mor faces nd ht at
‘row nde rn sc cove
osfiesig
“Tete ct ace nw tne in the
(pone ur eprom he
‘rnc ot dee conde ao,
oti claifing teeing
[Nene he amen dee he ch
Intranet
‘thar eta ote igh Cour
es th tl al fr he High Co
remit fn atron) ome
{rs permiting dco fh rion
‘conden pb, whe persia he
‘Sh te poten he peri.
oben care te put eee in
the open cont ofa pectin The
rcupon ena at pps eeaone
‘Sito! be onan pe
onan aban apersents
The 1996 a ge pc prc ©
nme y pig oer
‘heron eens” enencs berwen te
{connec fries The
{to inner impos ha eoetion Dy
Tony ence whe they ered
‘ethene he
usames aot he orb ag
Tctappen wen te sin pete
beled v3 compel cot the e
the god ea
Scope of pes
itor! pcedral ler apppng wo domense
“hon, roster espa on nd
aoe gues fb Te 207 at ees
tote sh dw ppd By a oF
ace vdence Thi 2 pom nb
‘wenn step cunct chalege 2
‘sien dig = ing veins fi
POLAND: ARBITRAL
BODIES ANNOUNCE
COOPERATION
AGREEMENT
in the 2012 European footbat
Chamois onthe hon,
Eonsuctionb expected to boom.
Tomasr Wards of Words
Wepsiniey reports on mecsures Polat
‘ed Ulralne ore toting 10 pr-07%p he
Inoviabe ceputes
‘hoses by UBEA to corhom the 2012 Euro
Feral happen the pense
‘Spectator eres
‘Scion For bot kd td Urine he
‘xpring one ~ the event wll provide an exellent
Sproat fr pomion
expert in oi coun ck wot
‘Shona aan anced mary eo
‘Sati ere ies wl be ntl
‘repr rE 201 a Recon oe
[the main sh and Ueno ros
‘cu On 19 an 207, he baron Cae of
homer o Cec andy Kier
ine pec poet of ba
‘oat hot Newer een nd esr
oben in Urine ted gine
pected wth othe cnsmscon sco, Be
‘so een wal por ck tbe in
‘gun commend stanon who oe
[rane sp el of ptr sed
Soin er peso a ace,
tek Urns oh ter the
(Disab nie scl th
‘tert enact eames:
+e al cana nema sod
‘cic ding wither
fh conc ining ond seni
a imporane fr anfictbe he nWse
i th te prepen fate
‘semen y he epee cue ele,
‘mene ed ye ue Acer 0
‘Nowa owburdoe onan coral at
(edie pomp rane ps ing rng
oateston ot oun ney eon
‘rier cuany Abenand mdon
(Parse rome role of cons thot
‘rng orn os
since s cdr dhe cote ating tha
eal wil be sed by nttaion Ode
{epee Nowacp efi wl et bogged down
Sprain, manta eer
‘oe re ring been des sa
och cod ra ee! medal Se
ti ns b-ball ain a
ran fore comm ig 08
Sher be on oie sma wih one
oer moa be dewey at Novae
Comsacion cnn wang we
sine me member po de
eon da’ cna eae
‘heal conte sing fom epee of
the cnet bed oar
‘Sf sir nol and Urine bse
en ty pang leita
‘co of te chumplontie lane, Uae
‘kur pene miner ad Pood he pty
‘gn nae mer Wit Sa re
‘angionsiepeparson.
Tr Sep Ri pie ao ge
get pected
{ming ete pcre eve
With comtacion ofa boned etry
wo and nol as ers fo Pod
UKRAINE: NEW ICAC RULES
IN'KIEV
crtsitanotonal commerce ethan
Court wih new vs. Taana Spach
‘oot pare of Von KEI & arines
ititov, onder Euneland of 1 Servi
UP intondonrepor
‘Atoton Coats Olina Carer of
{Coe dts: Th eau was ceed
nee of PrfeororPbebenko
Son he clipe of Sov Union he
(tng fede forthe pate epeeGLOBAL BRIERNG
op tie owe cours wbhin er din) Hosein “he detonate Howe f Ln a
‘kein dsp Micon There obser insodsced gly | Pon Naf Pes Lane not» Pl
“The growth of the court ha atracted wide | to the abit procedure The language ofthe | Shing Canpuny Lime gos scone way
eotin Aer the inal eid of tid poh, | aron wlbe Uanan Ge Riot he | toremovig hee ie accel sae
the cout hs xtered april flay Over | putt ee omsoy erage | meso thc ionic ie ence
Se pt yean serge af 375 cape or "The ine ee ending naw’ | Jom gna ne ae ownage Re
wee mee aiowon whe curt Since edt be monte a ef meigt_| she maser eer dpc cmb man
is creton the coe a rane 5124 nell ofthe rae of im and pment othe In heen concerned he epracion oo
‘near ner he ert fnsionand_—_|crponiing ee bat ude the iw enahe_| ation coe rie ofspeng come
‘toting pres or 12 cou, fecod ox mom ced fom he da tae reson uly age
fe corp was formed Th actat | comme ones whe che ing
vied le lee a ve wes othe ad peved | dpe seaon under erie
[Net we lope in Ap 2007 nd te othe ul the peed | Thee ong elo Sapte ng
fern fc Jone They ele te Signs cogs ve Ken node in| undethe pacer Te dgwe i
vio eon of 188 and eect mayo the | he rat mesg the pce ttn chat | ho betwee pir woe ieee
‘Sree the newer rls of ter shia” | hc pres my ren documents only | Pron Nata oe he soe a
insta ow apes ha ssn aes tara thot sig ea py ay_| been ean y beryl soneseces
ova Meg of ppm ID yn ‘ak frie mero econ sence | cout rece The dna sppowed 2
‘Une endinen seu be what the | There ak pe chars ary ry aendor_| Sonor and Pe Need secon
|
‘nasi he td when peicdealy | sappement ea rds yp tes | er econ 7 ote Arbon Ac ss
‘ting niet The coun cron The | eno peel ete | prego eso ad
‘Sibi ofthe new sateen prow | dei Th cident cer | cae the coc a ned dhe
‘ction and ace wih heading, stempig | earn fm thea woe pee | terme tse
‘omohe ete prions ‘ennai aft pry con taney age | Fa Shp snug oy Pon Naa
"Thi no hang othe jinn of The rl open sph pss ins | soupneeang on he bas hey wre
the cou ich depend on he Urania Law| ei yj te abit pcre | poem by puter sponse eee,
‘tnt Cane tensa | tk papa od pa | no mbm ce Sy wets
"94 whch vain in pce The cou ernie | alia apcomet oar pote Tae as | the pense ary sake ees on he
compet come pues atng fon st he appt pce apy | een “ingot ae la conan
cnc coher cw origin | on ‘Sree pups ding tic,
‘he come ff rade ander om | The now ules big Uses eiztion The aw Ler pang ppc wich
‘neon even nlsos proved ac__| vn sero aaron | ad aeny ben endo! te OS Gees
the pc of sins of ee co ofthe ats | hd wit eg psa cone! by proving od Amn co mae sx sec
‘ted oni Ukraine, Frtet an inporaet_| mow guidince nthe conduc th nearons| Ln olin i wat te contain
“errs wah eign mere ened | Sesmmpioe ae ue ae
{2 Uti ad dps nen eds usnesren tere ty to ae ened ha
(ong on den) nc ai The | UNITED KINGDOM: (mee oe oy en
Dubin ance dies wes sch_| QB ATION] CLAUSES, ‘ich hye swe eed he
Fao vert sod ter jer of Uke ‘amen The cre sh comet
INCLUSIVE RATHER THAN | isnince wih hr pum no the
Ieision cra gut cer rc sae we
“The rales with respect to jurisdiction have wot EXCLUSIVE 1 be exchuded from the aebitrasion’ jursdiction,
Sencha sopting go ere | hehrenicta coma tenctman | Tan'ansoutnce sn
lnvharoreeyaccay enhance #8, |terherrapans aochetencwre | mpesnk eee ew nae cee
Usaowdehoedbn tarda se | cemecn Fiige Can ayrsown | i uagstestn come se
Seipecainrrogrdimtterans | worsted lpson Und nk smi ec
«question fr its president. At this early stage of an | che second quaton — whether rescision of 2
Minna tepetiarsndoaokericer | Ont min tle wih geeenao | cera Tame mon
Soren romana anc psclt” | stim sshe pace oe Santty_| nog ae te te
etiordarteceentrsejrcion | piney ne ou fr campetsa. nd | ees ete oe
tc nem Sway nwt | Earth gare mse Shen | Sc eae et
Notre nerterpons tray | Soc wen yy co peeing me" | teenie eae se shee
comms with oir pay ding. |eagimdrcomiate mitrgeamy” | psec apenas
Sete wr coe se cae ow | iy a egy sh ey
ssn fos him ponte aten cejomten | deta
Tein rthor te ean | hoe rsaersnerprnnegn scars |The cn been ay
Canal teas Curia arn _| onageestinatioc ymin | abun tapos sous pace ais
poet protic ctned_| gly ge nseagapene’ | enone ead ar cn
Fvakoiyinpice ony Sent rvcy” | dope oepes ween neAtionen | Sapeahgeetets wate Ws ee
cust ep up or techn main in fce | Act Wh acon Pht pene oante | erecting nt saber oat anes
cnt eal wa Theres ye that» party boul ke nade epee cnt | hh lw ede the eee
cua po ete cour frre | whch cman rasa ae compere cul het
stp Sco fain geomet wi be wit
kom. annerearion nevisw sGLOBAL BREANG
sn inne whe the mee ofthe pu, | Afr he one ued ne 29 KBC,
{nt wat enormous cat nd ine hang ob | Retin fied tn nthe Can
‘Sounedn sobiing de Ga pantcers| Land ekg te esr seed nd
|
movie ta preonac rea |
‘Sead er |
|
UNITED STATES: SECOND —_ ‘ue ute nour nt espe
CIRCUIT UPHOLDS ANTI. Sitesszijy tet teen ein rahe
SUIT STANDARD aren Camano i,
She Now Yr eel drt our ing
‘Roma nmin the Co nde
(Pere teen dg ei
An oppea cou" has extended the
‘cope othe fest sod when onvisuit
injunctions ae sought. Hogi El ct
ghar Hubbera & Reed LP ropors
nied ace ours ve lng ged cfd engin ae aga ce ae
Snvvsinjontors an be eds poet” arin he ie ads the opens
‘Minted Tecpel te anh el ore
Eutmetnatenemas | Sqeirmtaratss
Scmeivicrsmtesipeane! |ipyel ot ed
Mickipectgctemete Renters sng yr of
SemNet Somer irate. nent se
wage pre sm dpre etig | cry png bss sg nd rin 10 create the authoritative
siurtmirnses |cebeeemuty at sr aceean
rN ect ew | Spt pve
Crmun)he US ance ayper fre” Mpls al jgoe os Ans ow leading private
Copeadecseeeene "ae ies oa pres ees
STeaimamnenseese qatar Sgt
‘The International Who's
Who of Business Lawyers:
ory fm sing cpio aie 2 | ots one tng st ae uncon, |
|
poet Secon es. 77 sine practi
Tne ieats | meio arent ae ry
ees eeeee fee reece
ame asemietringon aces ane (rer 7,00 of the word’
Cayman nds mie sity company snd a numberof scrinnry factors hing Toole deere
Fumie clsndgecmpy end he | whee ong ip mo
igi aflnonsorense sev" ome py be enn ee ver 100 rational
‘Sophousnl donopretpeid Sort ea Surisictions
"Rico pimen ratel peut cerwecmnoe| Over 1100 lead
Swine seking damage sn lowpass | fcomiency orice wo jet prohiensl Hlomepkiea
Spc op Pots md a he _| phigh Chin Teo he Sd Cat lly revised and
‘Sutera orn doce cones | hel ht wie th eu popcy updated 2007 edition
etowady RRC when por Sored fe doesn ret ad
‘nearer Te ab pl ected | ed eo lane teow Clu Tn eld Prin 70
‘Soom dowel KDC nce bas | egress, Of ce to een
US milan nde ogden | Se pce Spe cored whe he
“owt gone ag whch RBC jee ft New elas ort
hae jnigent contin ete | wo ay rahe te Co and con,
‘Rin fotos el touring xch_| Foun amen Dg ba ee
fey id went pte otc | Coy uk Hao se Soi sion
[em cout im tndrezan Tera Newton | dat RBC hal made fade potion he
{lel tat cot aeceenty coed the | Sern Chea held tae dpm of he
‘Tu urement an reed Penne | Te an New Yok cous whic contd
to wrn etfs om tcl NewYork ek | and ele the Si ded = woul
‘Resune oe the ont nly mae te Cayuse gonCORPORATE COUNSEL
in Piro Lenton Mae inert
‘anaes tel beh of oe he
| wonton
ich do you prefer: insttvtionel or ad
hoc arbiration?|
ter Hong Kong li fortron sion
‘We ao te Sigapore apd he compa
‘pun oman Chie ne ee dg
‘eon tee 00 One tng weave in
bers thew of Eng Asa Alera oy
How co you diene aiaton ackice
Name: Bamey Joseph
fo tha tigoters ana worsactonal lowers
hoe Eee
Company Monon | stereo
Intermatioral what wee cach working 20 we ca discus
nl we ie nt necting wth he
‘tole group © beer pt ec Our
‘races ds ting or
sc atthe ing ge ep
‘ena caer hc wei on inch
‘Ss i in is ay.
rbot ean es ln br ood
Title: Vice president and
senior counsel ~ ifigation
Winer cid youre
‘Unter of Mart Cage Pak di
Howard Unie Schoal fain Wang,
DC Bee ong Mo, warn ac
‘he Hogaann depute a Salon & Crome
‘yer Gm art! son a
threesome tig thee of Eh
ewe dk neon oe
coneie
How bigs yourcompany'scurent
Socks! |
sbiraom ope|
hots your process fr slecing
‘counealé.
arering ne bay 9p cet of
he igen or aan wk ne he goes
"hough thes ts onekng a abe
Soe a oni the we ok es
eth espee nthe eect er ie
imprest ron Fr er
‘ue Herbert Sth LL? in A Tht ep
‘Sad shout opt yrs agp on steno
$n HongKong Th wa rronmended by
‘ve ooo US parnerng ems Ayu bce
‘oe rational yuo ne pope
[rth ou do sot em ue you and
ep you sd seo pal,
How many monbers of the department
Speciale adie esobon®
oes, |
inthe hagion deren ede US.
to ipsa date ease nl
‘or over Ais ithe Me Ea a
Do you tack parila reas of tow?
comme ington By coma
tne become the pay easton US
Dinbites Ae on od ance gion
‘Ne you prepered 0 use the fem that
Sroted fhe contact n question?
‘Genera nT yb eee wee 3 US
{heen nw nih eof conc.
‘the pope wo cae sofa om he
Tio he parr wen hey spe =o
o you have ary xs potcies on
ware tosis on oiraon ara wnch |
ros fo use?
‘Mot of depen we he due ae or
sere the hte sen he Male Ene
ines petewnce eC sien, condos
Pr So her ae ne hen ce aon ce
Saha nas prs ded eel i
ou mach anton whee On pre de
{te Mies bpp There an inhewse
‘Chic ome teen one pre antag.
{epoet th ems meno wang
Beparer anders trond thee ne
Ingo repent x Oar he
‘hee ty dre the Bm eat
ese tesa Sept eg fom
‘The last thing you want
is the lawyer represent-
ing you to have a partner
become a fact witness in
|the dispute
Wat tos would you give to someone
who wos new to alee
swe dont hr jane igh ot fy schoo
‘Genny th opi we hr hae woke te
‘Sens and bane gl experience We ns.
soup ein them sd Jr rest
‘ved ie ote ig My cet
‘out the ines nf you ne guess, ak
‘ouch ald eek oa,
Which fr erngviual 0 you
regulary go to fe extemal nteatonal
‘rBirokon oaice?
eve ued myers om Wie & Conny
Jevonfradie ad we we Hebert Sh
‘snd we es mater af loam If
{os end pi alo cor yo ne mene
‘tho knows he wy soa hay may
‘ncn One othe tgs congas at
| Semel teen wend ae oe
| See thee ge matte! ar shoul‘CORPORATE COUNSEL
dena we dont ned olny dong. | dive pole wishing onc er ines ou won| our dg in our Aion wat et coy
trommende dat wee oalcunlitmat |g ne omeine pee worn | te Want of dacrcy ri, re mist
{fetheyte working om pe Hello
‘What quoie: makee good external tha We nol ie ew pep pte tur | Frying couse more eB ta walt
{Course'ferfiemotonal tion? none hat then rm hen you eed | bee a i he cond they ale, ee
Ghrncr oboe thao aeron by lam expand wal be nce > know shout teing al ine Tie co eat
themes torn do the ct gs tet an seco hw ol
SCubvniow ining wine anes What can on etrater do to make 2
Scones re Ma fe poo brpronion yout ‘a! wis woud you gun youn 0
ome stow geting 8 So wn tear oe gud py a | make Your working ie eoser’
sho es pring ute king si So_| you want em tone an soe epee | Ta ld cot my wodow wich Thx
ietve and how it works wi ele ancerview the wbitatrbut I woud ike to look | busy one month and another the next month
feanal heuer ei ime e acece pear | outdo Ices bse Th uae
sek slow do te Je loin ose someone wit agence, | WHO! the mos wel ore resource
Crow andundovoning stow Selepl | iths patie acon rm aoien | oe house cous Wh i poetotoe
Snlbuinee acter wok peso. | skrend, nth so hee some peed | athe US we ane te Anocaton of Capone
aw we i Tees job | den tat bana ‘outel who hve + uct eh bes rate,
‘ur oveside byes Asa customer of ‘he arbitiation chings~ fase that fen We alo very
Frocsc” ore thee woye you Mnkit | gone the Aman Hu Acca wie
Wat nats do some exlemnal counsel Eid be eevowed eet nas yout at oat
‘oan that you wim toy wou" nk ot ot cold be cd The me
nd he te the wy es 9 ek
ae LATINLAWYER
The LATINLAWYER 250 is the first and only authoritative
guide dedicated to the legal market and leading law firms
of Latin America, a key resource for clients looking for
guidance in instructing outside counsel in the region.
The fully updated and revised 2007 edition of the
LATINLAWYER 250 is the essential directory for anyone
involved in business law in Latin America.
at [Link]/[Link]a ~
a
Contributing editor Susan Hutton
a
a ea eau as
“This is a most interesting and useful
Publication. The overviews provided of the
various jurisdictions are concisely pro-
‘sented in 2 manner that enables easy and
Immediate comparison.”
Business artairs
FAM Music (Austr
Intellectual Property &
Antitrust
Intellectual Property & Antitrust addresses the
‘most important issues and gives “frst step” advice
from local experts, covering such areas as:
+ Intellectual property law and competion law
+ IP enforcement proceedings
Merger analysis, challenges and behavioural and
structural remedies involving IP rights
+ Jurisdiction of competition and IP agencies
Cartels
+ Price maintenance
+ Abuse of dominance
+ Remedies
ISSN: 17530628
Buy the book: £200
‘Subscribe to the series: £650,
JUST PUBLISHED
Re Cg
AE score meu vate Cl clacy‘CONFERENCE DIARY
\CONFERENCE DIARY
JANUARY 2008 19 19:74 Anna International Corpote
3t Slntrantinal Contaton Comal Conarnee
Contact sad Reston fDupate Plt
18-7: Notting, Deng snd
124-25-The Reson of Date Under Managing International Contacts and
tee ce
25. ASA Continence 2008 27 Bafosing the Final Decision
ow Reale? i
2: New Statape in Intrmonal eon
ion Fhe rc Deng
Coneence of he Ataris
[ELCIA Join Symposia (Latin Amelan-
Garisban User Counell sd North
‘American User’ Comal)
Tae Grom UK,
3-9 wits Vi East) Moot
[Link] Aitation Det Hong Kong
ICCAIAC/ABARUYANP 12cm bition 2008
ow Yne 15 1UNCKTRAL Now Projects and
2:UCIA Noth Ametian Un! Council Viton
Symposia
1) 19g Syempesion
Bom Aint 2106 Anivnary ICC Ain Ret
Moot Caure Intemational mesment APRIL
Protection Law 35.208 Spring Metin
nak None
akin Intro Aron Cause ABA Tes Son
2-4ADR Workshop
{120d Corporate aw inate
“Te Urey Law Shad
24-25 ADR ater NAFTA
saalcon,
2 11LGIA European Ue! Come
Wey ta
E'LCIA Haropen Uses Coun
10 ICCA 206 50m Amivrary of he
‘NewYork Connon
Dakin
{9617A Annual Worksop
Date