Chapter 2.
Operations and Supply Strategy
Operations Strategy & Competitive Dimensions
Order Qualifiers and Winners
Strategy Design Process
A Framework for Manufacturing Strategy
Service Strategy Capacity Capabilities
Productivity Measures
1
Operations Strategy & Competitive Dimensions
Setting broad policies and plans to utilize the
firm’s resources optimally to support its longer
term competitive strategy.
2
Competitive Dimension
Competitive Dimensions include:
Cost or Price
Make the Product or Deliver the Service Cheap
Quality
Make a Great Product and (not or) deliver a Great Service ( X vs
Mercedes)
Delivery Speed
Make the Product or Deliver the Service Quickly
Delivery Reliability
Deliver It When Promised
Coping with Changes in Demand
Change Its Volume
Flexibility and New Product Introduction Speed
Change It, more frequently then GM or Ford, who is this company?
Other Product-Specific Criteria
Support It
3
Trade-Offs
Focus and trade-offs, can’t do it all at the same time
Lexus can’t be made and sold for $25,000. T or F?
A few examples:
Generally low-cost strategy is not compatible with
flexibility or speed of delivery
Cost
Flexibility Delivery
Quality
High quality and low cost tend to be incompatible
Straddling occurs when a firm seeks to mimic a
competitor’s position while trying to maintain their
original (successful) position.
4
Order Qualifiers and Winners
Order qualifiers are the basic criteria that permit the
firm’s products to be considered as candidates for
purchase by customers
Through the 1980s “nobody got fired buying IBM
products”
Order winners are the criteria that differentiate the
products and services of one firm from another
Caterpillar “48 hours parts/service guarantee”
Class examples:
5
Steps in Developing a Manufacturing Strategy
1. Segment the market according to the product group
2. Identify product requirements, demand patterns,
and profit margins of each group
3. Determine order qualifiers and winners for each
group
4. Convert order winners into specific performance
requirements
6
Service Strategy Capacity Capabilities
Process-based
Capabilities derived from activities that transform material
or information and provide advantages on dimensions of
cost and quality
Systems-based
Operating capabilities that are broad-based involving the
entire operating system and provide advantages of short lead
times and customize on demand
Organization-based
Organizational ability to master/implement (learn) new
technologies, faster new plant/product introductions
These capabilities are more difficult to replicate thus provide
a strong operations-based competitive advantage
7
Productivity
A common, seemingly simple but very complicated
measure
How a country, region, industry, company, business
unit, department, ... uses its resources (relative to
others).
Broadly defined as the ratio of OUTPUTS to INPUTS
Total, partial, or multifactor measures:
8
Productivity Example
9
Some Partial Productivity Measures
Business Productivity Measure
Restaurant Meals per hour
Retail Store Sales per square foot (meter)
Chicken Farm Kilo of meat per Kg. of feed
Utility Plant Kilowatt per ton of coal
Paper Mill Tons of paper per cord of wood
10