Evatt Trophy National Finals 2012 Guide
Evatt Trophy National Finals 2012 Guide
+
Brisbane, December 9-14th 2012.
delegate handbook
2 1
Lily Bentley Competition Convenor 3 2012 Evatt Trophy Competition National Final
2 1
+
from the chair of the evatt national final
Dear Delegates, Warmest congratulations on your selection to represent your school and your division at the National Final of the Evatt Trophy Competition. Your selection demonstrates that you are a talented diplomat, an exceptional researcher and a compelling speaker. You should be extraordinarily proud of your achievements thus far. The week of debates at the National Final of the Evatt Trophy Competition will no doubt test and extend you. The organising committee, together with the judging panel, have prepared a diverse array of resolution themes to demonstrate your insights into international affairs, critical thinking and problem solving abilities. We trust that you will find the standard of debate at the National Finals to be of the highest calibre. At the National Final, you will be judged by a panel of eight judges, with one impartial judging Chair. All judges have had extensive experience judging the Evatt Trophy Competition at both a divisional and national level (and many have participated in Model United Nations Debating internationally). In all, the judging panel will observe you in just short of twenty hours of debate, and deliberate upon your performance for more than twenty-four hours. In addition to this guide, you have been sent our explanation of the structure of the competition, a breakdown of the criteria that we will use in judging and hot tips from the judges themselves as to how you can have the best shot at taking home the coveted Evatt Trophy. At different times you will find the Evatt Trophy Competition National Finals challenging, rewarding, exciting, frustrating, interesting and (we hope) enjoyable. Though the Evatt Trophy is a competition, you should also treat it as a fantastic learning experience. I encourage you to go with an open mind, be ready to adjust your strategy and have your ideas tested and to act with honesty and integrity. Though only one team can leave with the Evatt Trophy, you all stand to leave with new friends, fresh ideas and a truckload of knowledge that you didnt have before. You have been given a unique opportunity to engage with some of the brightest debaters from around the country so throw yourself into it head first! Best of luck,
Tim Matthews Chair 2012 Evatt Trophy Competition National Final On behalf of the Evatt Trophy Competition Judging Panel
2 1
welcome to brisbane!
AUSTRALIAS NEW WORLD CITY
It is with great pleasure that we invite you to Brisbane, capital city of sunny Queensland, for what will be an incredible week. Over the week you will explore both sides of the beautiful Brisbane River, around our city is built. You will debate in the modern campus of the Queensland University of Technology in the heart of the city, and stay at the suburban hub, the University of Queensland. the c ompet iti on. Please ensure you pack enough clothing to last you the entire event.
OUR ACCOMMODATION
We will be staying at Cromwell College, located on Walcott St, Saint Lucia. You will be housed in single-sex floors, in single rooms, with shared bathroom facilities.
Each delegate will be issued with a single key to their room and an access fob for common areas of the college for the THE WEATHER duration of the event. Keys/fobs cost $25 Brisbane in December is going to be to replace if lost. Should you lose your warm, there's no doubt about it! The average 3pm temperature for December is key/fob, you will be personally required to 27.1C, and the monthly mean maximum is pay the replacement fee. 25.5C. You might want to bring a light A map of the college is included below. cardigan for the evening, as it will reach Your rooms will be located in Dowling or not-so-chilly lows of around 21C. Hancock. Please also bring a good hat (not a baseball cap!) and some sunscreen. A water bottle will be provided to you.
STUDENT PARKING
DINING ROOM
TO BO THA P 5 TT TC 0-6 O H 4 M ER 35 -4 9
The Amazing Race and Sportsball! activities are outdoors, and require light, casual clothing including a hat. Please pack appropriately. Th ere wi ll be no a ccess to l aund ry fac ili tie s whi lst at
ENTRANCE
CI IN PR
Smart casual dress is appropriate for our mix-up dinner evening. There will also be a formal dinner on the final night of the event - for girls, knee-length, semi-formal or cocktail style dresses will be appropriate, and for boys, trousers, a business shirt and tie will suffice. Suit jackets are welcome but optional.
C LO
4 17 3Y 17 LE
TO P 18 N TT OR -34 O TH A M 117 A
VISITOR PARKING
AP CH
EL
PA
LS
S RE
EN ID
BO
CE
P TO
CO
TT AG E
N to ew b B Fe e c uild b o ru mp ing ar le y te du 20 d e 11 in
AI
TE N
AN
CE
SH
ED
TO D MID P 85 L O OW 74 -94 -8 W 4 ER LI 65 N G -7 3A
& WHAT TO PACK For debate, and other formal sessions of the competition, it is compulsory that you wear your school uniform. If stockings, blazers, or other heavy items usually compose a compulsory part of your uniform, you do not have to wear these throughout the competition. For arrival and departure days, as well as the evenings of the event, please wear comfortable, casual clothing. There is a requirement at our accommodation that footwear is worn at all times, so please bring a pair of thongs or sandals for wear around the grounds.
WHAT TO WEAR
CAMPUS LODGE
CROMWELL COLLEGE
2 1
+
TECHNOLOGY
All delegates will have access to power points, but not the Internet, at our accommodation. Should teams be selected for the Grand Final, Internet access will be provided the night before so that you may research your new country. We encourage delegates to bring their computers if they have them; we will make arrangements for delegates without computers but this is helped most if delegates who have them, bring them. Note, however, that delegates wi ll not ha ve ac cess t o pri nti ng, a nd t hat we str ict ly enfo rce a no sc reens pol icy in t he deba te c hambe rs th emselve s (thus phones, tablets, and computers cannot be taken into the chamber). Bringing your own printer is not permitted. However, you should bring lots of paper, pens, and appropriate additional stationary materials. Finally, we strongly encourage delegates to bring mobile phones with them, especially for the rare but not unknown case where delegates become separated from the group. Please note, however, that phones must be switched off for the duration of debates.
BRINGING PARENTS, TEACHERS
supporters to reside in the College accommodation or to accompany delegates to and from the debate venues. In addition, we draw your attention to the following provision of the Evatt rules: 77. Coaching of any kind by anyone must cease after the delegates arrival at the Evatt National Finals. Coaching during Evatt includes any verbal or written materials provided to a delegate that relate to the content of the debate, or the delegates past or prospective performance in an Evatt debate or other part of the simulation,
Please note that there is no good-faith exemption from this rule for people who are not facilitators and this rule is, in order to ensure fairness, strictly enforced. If you have any questions about this or any other rule of the competition, we encourage you to contact your Head of Delegation.
& FRIENDS
In general, we do not encourage the attendance of your parents, guardians, teachers, or friends (unless theyre your debate partner!). Please rest assured that our facilitators are rigorously trained, highly qualified, and completely capable of looking after you for the duration of the week! All debate sessions are open to the public and your supporters are able to watch you if they desire. However, it is the nature of Evatt debate to take place primarily behind the scenes, and thus formal spectatorship is often quite unsatisfying. We are very happy to take photos or videos of your students if you request it. However, if your supporters would like to attend the debate live, then they may attend all debate sessions. If they are from out of town they will need to make their own accommodation and transportation arrangements. In particular, we cannot permit
& DRINK All transportation and meals are provided as part of the conference fee; theres no need to bring your own food or drink! If you have special dietary requirements that you did not indicate on the registration form, please contact the Convenor immediately at evatt2012@[Link] so we can be sure to accommodate them.
FOOD
Please be aware that the Evatt National Finals 2012 are a drug a nd a lco hol free a cti vity . Delegates who bring or consume alcohol or drugs at any point in the competition risk being disqualified and sent home at their own/their parents/guardians expense. If you have any questions about our drug and alcohol policies, please contact the Head of Welfare, Harry Midalia, at vpoperations@[Link].
daily itinerary
Time 11.30am Location Junior Common Room (JCR) Dining Hall Cromwell College UQ Campus Cromwell College Dining Hall JCR JCR JCR The Chapel Cromwell College Cromwell College Activity Delegate Registration Opens
Lunch Registration Continues THE AMAZING RACE + Afternoon Tea Free Time Dinner Informal Opening Judges Briefing Get to Know You! Priest of the Parish Free Time Lights Out
Monday December 10th Time 7.00am 7.45am 8.00am 9.00am 9.45am Location Dining Hall Dining Hall Chancellors Place QUT Science & Engineering Centre: Kindler Theatre QUT SEC: Kindler Theatre Activity Breakfast Morning Briefing BUSES DEPART Official Opening: Her Excellency, Ms Penelope Wensley, The Governor of Queensland Keynote Address: Professor Gareth Evans Morning Tea On Diplomacy: Caitlin Byrne Lunch Debate Session One
QUT SEC Foyer QUT SEC: Kindler Theatre QUT SEC Foyer Blue: The Forum White: P505 QUT SEC Foyer Blue: P505 White: The Forum QUT Cnr George/Alice Streets Cromwell College The Green West End/Southbank Cromwell College
Tuesday December 11th Time 7.00am 7.45am 8.00am 8.45am 9.30am 9.45am 10.00am 11.15am 11.30am 11.45am 12.00pm 1.15pm 1.30pm 2.15pm 2.30pm 3.45pm 4.00pm 4.15pm 4.45pm 4.50pm 5.30pm 6.30pm 7.00pm 10.00pm Location Dining Hall Dining Hall Chancellors Place QUT Science & Engineering Centre: P512 QUT SEC/157 Ann St QUT SEC: P505/The Forum 157 Ann St QUT SEC Foyer King George Square QUT SEC: P505/The Forum 157 Ann St QUT SEC Foyer 157 Ann St QUT SEC: P505/The Forum 157 Ann St QUT Kidney Lawn 157 Ann St/QUT Kidney Lawn QUT Campus Cnr George/Alice Streets Cnr George/Alice Streets Dining Hall Cromwell College JCR Cromwell College Activity Breakfast Morning Briefing BUSES DEPART Andrew Bartlett: Refugee Rights in an Australian Context White Chamber walks to 157 Ann St Blue: Debate Session Three White: Debate Session Three Blue: Morning Tea White: Morning Tea Blue: Debate Session Four White: Debate Session Four Blue: Lunch White: Lunch Blue: Debate Session Five White: Debate Session Five Blue: Afternoon Tea White: Eat + Walk to QUT Tour from Student Ambassadors Board buses BUSES DEPART Dinner Free Time Games Night! Lights Out
Wednesday December 12th Time 7.00am 7.45am 8.00am 9.00am 10.30am 10.45 am 11.00am 11.15 am 12.30/12.45pm 2.00pm/2.15pm 3.45 pm 4.30pm 5.00pm Location Dining Hall Dining Hall Activity Breakfast Morning Briefing/Move to busses Chancellors Place BUSES DEPART QUT SEC: P512 Securing Our Resources: Q&A QUT Foyer Morning Tea QUT Foyer Blue: Start walking to debate venue (walk and eat) White: Morning Tea QUTSEC: P505/The Forum White: Debate Session Six 157 Ann Blue: Debate Session Six QUT SEC Foyer/King White: Lunch/ Blue: Lunch George Square QUT SEC: P505/The White: Debate Session Seven/ Forum . /157 Ann St Blue: Debate Session Seven 157 Ann Board Bus The Green (back at Afternoon Tea college) Oval Sportsball!
Dinner Grand Final announcement JCC: Briefing and Prep for JCC/Grand Final: Country Allocation and Prep Lights Out
Thursday December 13th Time 7.00am 7.45am 8.00am 9:00am Location Dining Hall Dining Hall Chancellors Place Parliament House/P506506A Parliament House/P506506A Parliament House/P506506A Cromwell College Chancellors Place Rydges Rydges Cromwell College Activity Breakfast Morning Briefing/Move to busses BUSES DEPART GF: Resolution One/JCC: Session One Morning Tea GF: Resolution Two/JCC: Session Two Lunch GF: Resolution Three/JCC: Dels to watch GF or relax in Botanical Gardens Bus boarding back to College Getting ready for Final Dinner Board Bus Closing drinks and Final Dinner/Announcement of prizes/Dancing Board busses back to college Arrive back at college
7.00am 7.45am
8.00am Various
10
activity breakdown
AMAZING RACE
Arrival day is no excuse for sitting still! A mad race around UQ campus with checkpoints, challenges and tasks along the way will ensure that the true competitors rise to the top! Loose, comfortable clothes and shoes are a must for this activity preferably, clothes that you arent very attached to! Things might get messy!
MIX-UP DINNERS
Its not all work and no play at Evatt 2012! In groups from all divisions, you will head out for dinner in Brisbanes West End and Southbank area. Cultural experiences will abound as you sample either Thai, Indian, Malaysian, Eritrean or Italian food for the evening. Take this time to forget about debate and get to know the other great delegates at the competition.
& MOVIE SCREENING What does it sound like? Prepare to be thoroughly thrashed by your facilitators in Scrabble, Scattergories, MouseTrap and (if youre lucky) 500. Well also have a movie showing for those who feel like tuning out for a while. Make the most of this down-time, as its a rare occurrence!
BOARD GAME NIGHT SPORTSBALL!
After three long days of debate, its time to get outside and enjoy the Queensland sunshine! Whether its soccer, netball or Frisbee, theres a game for you this afternoon.
PREPARATION FOR NEXT DAY
Those teams who are selected for the grand final will be allocated a new country, and be given time for research. Those teams not participating in the grand final will be participating in a high-risk, realtime crisis simulation.
FINAL DINNER!
Does it really need explaining? Looking out over the lights of the Brisbane River, this is going to be an amazing night, with speeches, announcements, and a lot of trashy pop music. Get keen.
11
speakers
12
DR RUSSELL TROOD
Dr Russell Trood is the Special Envoy of the Prime Minister of Australia for Eastern Europe and an Adjunct Professor in the Defence and Security Program, US Studies Centre at the University of Sydney. He recently completed a term as a Liberal Senator for Queensland in the Australian Parliament. While serving in the Senate, Dr Trood served terms as Chair of the Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade and as a member of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, among others. Dr Trood holds a PhD in international relations from Dalhousie University in Canada. Prior to his election to the Senate in 2004, he was Associate Professor of International Relations at Griffith University. He has also been a Visiting Fellow at the Lowy Institute for International Policy and is currently a member of the Council of the Australian Strategic Policy Institute. He is also the current National President of the United Nations Association of Australia.
ANDREW BARTLETT
Andrew Bartlett represented Queensland as an Australian Democrats member of the Senate from 1997 to 2008. He was the leader of the Democrats from 2002 to 2004, and deputy leader from 2004 to 2008. A consistent and vocal campaigner for refugees and asylum seekers, Bartlett is the only Australian parliamentarian to have visited every refugee detention centre in Australia, as well as those on Christmas Island and Nauru, where he has been four times to meet with detainees. More recently, Andrew contested the lower house seat of Brisbane at the 2010 federal election as a candidate for the Australian Greens. Bartlett came third in the seat, gaining 21.3% of the vote with just over a 10% swing to the Greens. This was the only seat other than the seat of Melbourne where the Greens gained a swing higher than 10%. Currently, Andrew writes a blog, found at [Link], and announces for local radio station 4ZZZ.
DR CAITLIN BYRNE
Caitlin Byrne is an Assistant Professor of International Relations at Bond University where she teaches courses in global statecraft, EastWest diplomacy and Australian foreign policy. She began her professional career with the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT). From 1994-2001, Caitlin was engaged in roles encompassing legal and foreign policy, diplomatic and consular representation, and service delivery. Highlights included appointments as Second Secretary (political) and Consul to the Australian Embassy in Mexico City, and subsequently as State Manager for the Queensland Passports Office. In 2001, Caitlin left DFAT to expand her career interests in social policy projects and reform agendas, with domestic and international policy implications.
13
MR GERALD MILES
Gerald Miles is The Nature Conservancys (TNC) Regional Director for External Affairs and Policy Asia Pacific based in Brisbane. He has worked in the mining industry, urban planning, government policy and development assistance within Australia, the Asia-Pacific region and globally. He was responsible for the Pacific Island preparations for the Earth Summit in 1992 and the World Summit on Sustainable Development in 2002; was an architect of the Global Programme for the Sustainable Development of Islands; advised the Indonesia, Philippines and Pacific Constituency of the Global Environment Facility Council and is actively involved in the negotiation of the United Nations Conventions on climate change and biological diversity. In 2005 he completed the Sustainable Financing Options for Palaus Protected Areas Network that led to new political commitments to conservation across Micronesia. He received the Conservancys Outstanding Performance Award (2007) for his role in inspiring political support for conservation at regional and global scales the Micronesia Challenge has led to similar commitments by heads of Government in the Caribbean, and through the Coral Triangle Initiative. His work to build a broader constituency for conservation led to the establishment of the Global Islands Partnership that is now hosted by the World Conservation Union (IUCN).
14
CAROL BOND
Carol is currently completing her PhD in the area of mining company-community relations and conflict management. Her research interests include: grievance resolution, human rights, and discovering opportunities to proactively reduce conflict between stakeholders with differing worldviews. Carol has a Master of International Studies (Adv) in Peace Studies and Conflict Resolution from the University of Queensland; a Master of Theological Ethics from Yale University Divinity School; and a Bachelor of Arts in Comparative Religion from Carleton College (USA). Carol is also a Research Technician for CSRM. She began work at CSRM in 2008 as a summer scholar on a collaborative project between CSRM and Harvard Kennedy Schools CSRI. The research focused on how international mining companies respond, internally, to grievances when they arise at the site level. Since then, Carol has worked in the area of Water, Mining and Human Rights to investigate discourses that might be practically applied at the site level by extractives companies. She has four years experience conducting interviews for social impact assessments and grievance mechanism evaluation for mining operations in Australia and South America.
CARLY STEPHAN
Carly has had several years experience managing and working on development projects in the Asia-Pacific region, in areas including governance and leadership and resource sector community development. Carly currently manages FDC projects within the governance and gender arena, with a focus on the Pacific region. Carly has previously had experience as a project coordinator for programs ranging from environmental sustainability to law and justice. Carly combines her project management background with extensive researching and teaching experience in the areas of: governance, refugees and security, teaching methods and international development success and efficacy. She speaks Bahasa Indonesia at an intermediate level and holds a double degree in Political Science and International Business, a first class honours degree in International Relations (University of Queensland) and a Masters of Development Studies (University of Sydney).
FIONA SIMPSON MP
Fiona was elected to the position of Speaker in the 54th Parliament of Queensland in March 2012, making her the Parliaments first female Speaker in its 150 years. In 1992, Fiona won the newly created seat of Maroochydore at which time she was the youngest woman elected to the Queensland Parliament. During her time in office she has served in shadow portfolios such as health, transport, main roads, tourism, women, communities and housing, and has post graduate management qualifications. In addition to a Bachelor of Arts in Japanese language, Journalism and Government, she has a Masters in Organizational Leadership, a graduate diploma from the Australian Institute of Company Directors and has undertaken an executive leadership course with John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard. Before entering parliament, she was an award-winning journalist (Dalgetys Excellence in Rural Journalism Award).
15
our sponsors
The Queensland Department of Communities, Child Safety and Disability Services. The Office of the Speaker, Queensland Parliament. Clayfield Fruit Market. Teresa Gambaro MP.
16
welfare information
18
important contacts
CONVENOR:
Lily Bentley: evatt2012@[Link] 0408 762 567
CHIEF OF STAFF:
Damian Maher: [Link]@[Link] 0435 804 752
HEAD OF WELFARE:
Harry Midalia: vpoperations@[Link] 0419 600 045
19
evatt 2012
UN Youth Australia, Inc.
evatt2012@[Link]
20