Scribd
Upload
3K views1 page

Sunni Scholars Took Hadith From Shimr (L.a) (Killer of Imam Hussain A.s)

1) Sunni scholars such as Ahmed Ibn Hanbal and Ibn Dawood included hadiths in their books that were narrated indirectly through Shimr bin Dhi al-jawshan, the son of a Sahabi named Dhi al-jawshan. 2) While the hadiths do not explicitly mention Shimr, scholars of Ahlsunnah admit that Shimr was the intermediary between the narrators and Dhi al-jawshan. 3) Bukhari suggested that Abu Ishaq, one of the narrators, did not directly narrate from Dhi al-jawshan but rather from his son Shimr, and this information was likely

Uploaded by

Shia Books For Download
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
3K views1 page

Sunni Scholars Took Hadith From Shimr (L.a) (Killer of Imam Hussain A.s)

1) Sunni scholars such as Ahmed Ibn Hanbal and Ibn Dawood included hadiths in their books that were narrated indirectly through Shimr bin Dhi al-jawshan, the son of a Sahabi named Dhi al-jawshan. 2) While the hadiths do not explicitly mention Shimr, scholars of Ahlsunnah admit that Shimr was the intermediary between the narrators and Dhi al-jawshan. 3) Bukhari suggested that Abu Ishaq, one of the narrators, did not directly narrate from Dhi al-jawshan but rather from his son Shimr, and this information was likely

Uploaded by

Shia Books For Download
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

SUNNI SCHOLARS TOOK HADITH FROM SHIMR

BIN ZUL JOSHAN (L.A) IN THEIR HADITH


BOOKS
Amed Ibn e Hanbal and Ibn Dawood narrated from Shimr ibn Dhi al-jawshan (indirectly as i
will explain) and his father Dhu al-jawshan is sahabi

The hadith dont mention Shimr but the scholars of ahlsunnah admit that the medium between
Abu ishaq (one of the narrators of the hadiths ) and Dhu al-jawshan is the son of dhu al-
jawshan : Shimr Lanatollah alih

Here is the 3 hadiths from Musnad Ahmed : Musnad Al-kufyeen :

   ‫  أ‬، ‫      أ إق اا‬،   ‫ !م‬


‫ ر‬#‫ أه‬% ‫ * أن ('غ‬+,‫ و‬, .‫ ا‬,/ 0‫ ا‬12‫ أ‬: ‫ل‬5، 67‫ ذي ا‬

2)    : :5 ، %  +;‫< وا‬06 ‫  أ  ;'  أ‬.‫ا‬0 
+,‫ و‬, .‫ ا‬,/ 0‫  ا‬67‫    أ     ذي ا‬... .

3) '6 ‫ أ‬67‫ا‬ ‫ل  =ن  أ اق  ذي‬5 ‫د‬0  % 
0?‫ا‬
As for Abu Dawood he narrated in his sunan :

67‫  أ إق  ذي ا‬، ‫' أ‬0‫ أ‬،      ‫د‬% 
+,‫ و‬, .‫ ا‬,/ 0‫ ا‬12‫ أ‬: ‫ل‬5 ‫ب‬
ِ 0ّ?‫ ا‬% #‫ر‬
but the interesting thing is what bukhari said :

‫ وآن‬، 0?‫' ا‬6 ‫ أ‬67‫د  =ن  أ إق  ذي ا‬0  % ‫ل‬5
67‫ ا  ذي ا‬% * :‫ أرا إ‬:‫ اق و‬D ‫ا  رًا‬
Narrated Muhammed Ibn Abbad Narrated Sufyan from Abu Ishaq from Dhi al-jawshan the
father of shimr al-dhababi and his son( he means shimr was a neighbour of abu ishaq
and i believe he narrated from the son of dhi al-jawshan( meaning shimr )

Sufian also said that Abu ishaq didnt narrate directly from Dhu al-jawshan but from his
son Shimr and i dont think such information was not known by ahmed ibn hanbal and
abu dawood

So congratulation to Ahmed and Abu Dawood for narrating from this ugly creature

You might also like