Management of benign paroxysmal
positional vertigo (BPPV) in the emergency
department
1,2, 1 1
Khalid Bashir *, Furqan Irfan , Peter A Cameron
ABSTRACT
Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) is a common medical condition that can be managed by emergency physicians.
Vertigo sufferers usually complain of the room spinning associated with certain head movements such as getting out of bed, looking
up and bending down. BPPV can be diagnosed clinically from history and examination and does not require any investigations.
BPPV can be effectively treated at the bedside by using one of the Canalith repositioning maneuvers (particle repositioning
maneuvers). This treatment has been proven to be effective in randomised controlled trials and carries minimal risks. The common
complications during the procedure include nausea, vomiting and vertigo. There are no absolute contraindications. BPPV can
resolve spontaneously but symptoms may last for weeks in most patients, to years in others. Failure to respond to physical
maneuvers and an unusual pattern of nystagmus may suggest a central pathology. Diagnostic strategies and physical manoeuvres
are described in this narrative review. Future directions and recommendations also discussed.
Keywords: dizziness, BPPV, Epley, Dix-Hallpike, nystagmus, vertigo
INTRODUCTION
Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) is defined as a spinning sensation by changes in the head
relative to gravity. BPPV is the most common cause of vertigo. It can occur spontaneously in the 50-70 year
age group. In younger ages the usual underlying cause is trauma. Almost 5.6 million Americans attend the
hospital with complaints of dizziness every year, and 17 to 42 percent of these are ultimately diagnosed with
1-3
BPPV.
Vertigo and nystagmus can have central (brainstem and cerebellum) or peripheral causes.
It is important to differentiate between these two as the central cause will require investigation. The nystagmus due to
central cause usually persists as long as the head is kept in the provoking position however, the nystagmus due to
vestibular cause is always transient. In addition to the direction of nystagmus, its latency and fatigability may strongly
suggest a peripheral vestibular cause of vertigo and does not usually require any investigations. Clinical features such as
headache, visual symptoms, speech disturbance and weakness would all suggest a central cause. In one study, a central
cause was found in cases of treatment failure for BPPV in 3 percent of cases. A central cause should be sought if the clinical
4
features of BPPV are atypical or refractory to treatment.
It has been known for BPPV patients to wait months or years for adequate treatment and to receive inappropriate medications
5
such as vestibular sedatives and unnecessary diagnostic tests. In one study, 9 percent of elderly patients who were undergoing
assessment for non-balance related problems were found to have undiagnosed BPPV. Older patients with BPPV may experience a
greater incidence of falls which may cause injuries such as fractures, secondary brain injuries and may lead to permanent disability
6
and increased care costs due to hospital visits and nursing home admissions.
BPPV is the most common cause of peripheral vertigo responsible for almost 50 percent of patients with
peripheral vestibular dysfunction. Misdiagnosis of BPPV can incur unnecessary costs, and one American study
7,8
estimated that US$2,000 per patient had been spent on consultations, laboratory tests and scans. BPPV
effects the quality of life of the sufferers and it is usually restored after successful treatment by physical
9
maneuvers.
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
The inner ear consists of snail-shell like structures called cochlea, and semicircular canals [Fig 1]. The cochlea is concerned
with hearing and semicircular canals help to control balance and posture. There are three semicircular canals (anterior,
posterior and lateral) and they are roughly at right angles to each other. Inside these bony canals, there is a system of
narrow channels which contain fluid
Figure 1. Anatomy of the left inner ear showing displaced otoconia from the utricle and saccule to the posterior semicircular canal
(with permission from Hain,
called endolymph. The movement of endolymph in the semicircular canals helps with the rotational balance i.e., head
movements including side to side, forward, backwards and up and down. The semicircular canals are connected to the
cochlea through a large fluid filled compartment called the vestibule. The vestibule contains the utricle and saccule. The
vestibulocochlear nerve which arises from inner ear to the brain transmits information about balance and hearing to the
brain.
The underlying cause of BPPV is believed to be the presence of calcium carbonate crystals in the semicircular
10
canals, in particular the posterior semicircular canal. These crystals are understood to have migrated from the
utricle [Fig 1]. The crystals in the canal cause abnormal deflection of the canal receptor, the cupula, resulting in an
illusion of movement. The canalith repositioning maneuvers (CRM) help to move these crystals out of the semicircular
canals back to the utricle to provide relief of vertigo symptoms. Inspite of being a common medical problem, BPPV is
11
still underdiagnosed or misdiagnosed by clinicians.
The posterior semicircular canal has been found to have otoconia in 85-95 percent of patients as compared
to the horizontal canal. Approximately 85 percent are unilateral, and in 8 percent both posterior canals are
involved. The horizontal canal is affected in about 5 percent of cases and involvement of the anterior canal is
rare. In 1992, free floating particles were identified in the posterior semicircular canals during operative
12-15
procedures. This finding is in favour of canalithiasis theory regarding causation of BPPV.
In most cases aetiology remains unknown however, various conditions that can predispose to BPPV include
head injury, menieres disease, acute labyrintitis, postoperative ear, facial or brain surgery, and infections of the
8,16
inner ear.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The earliest description of symptoms of BPPV has been attributed to Dr Robert Barany who in 1921 reported a case of a 27-
17
year-old patient with vertigo induced by various positions. He also described it as a disorder of the otolith organs. Dix and
Hallpike in 1952 described the symptomatology of BPPV in detail, based on their experience of treating 100 patients. They
called this positional nystagmus of the benign positional type. The commonly used diagnostic test called Dix-Hallpike test is
based on re-production of these symptoms during various head positions.
In the 1960s, Harold Schukmecht confirmed the presence of small masses through basophilic staining of the
18
posterior semicircular canals in patients with the diagnosis of BPPV.
In 1979 Hall et al., and in 1993 John Epley explained all the symptoms of BPPV based on the presence of free floating
particles in the semicircular canals. This theory is called cupulolithiasis and is still the most widely accepted explanation.
Based on the cupulolithiasis theory, various successful treatment such as Epley and other Canalith repositioning maneuvers
are being used throughout the
page6world.13,19-21
Patients usually complain of recurrent episodes of vertigo which can last for months. These episodes are
provoked by various head movements such as looking up, bending down or rolling over in bed. These attacks
may be associated with nausea and vomiting.
Patients with BPPV typically have no other neurologic complaints, in contrast to those with central causes of vertigo.
Some patients have evidence of prior inner ear damage. Approximately half of patients complain of imbalance between
8,22
attacks, even after successful treatment.
Some patients may develop anxiety episodes mainly due to fear of symptoms returning. These symptoms
may have implications on certain jobs such as drivers, underwater divers and machinery operators as sudden
vertigo attacks may endanger their life.
Medications are commonly given to vertigo sufferers to improve the spinning sensation and to control nausea and
vomiting. The American Academies of Neurology and Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery do not recommend routine
23
use of medications such as antihistamines and benzodiazepines for the treatment of BPPV. There is no evidence to
24-27
suggest that these medications are effective or provide alternative treatment to Canalith repositioning maneuvers.
The diagnosis of posterior canal BPPV is made after performance of the Dix-Hallpike maneuver [Fig 2].
During this maneuver, the following are the usual findings:
. Recurrence of vertigo symptoms
. Vertigo and nystagmus usually appears after a latent period of a few seconds
. The nystagmus is rotatory with the fast component towards the undermost ear
Page 4 of 7
Bashir, Irfan and Cameron. Journal of Emergency Medicine Trauma and Acute Care 2014:3
Figure 2. Dix-Hallpike maneuver
. When the patient sits up the nystagmus will beat in the opposite direction
28
. The intensity and duration of nystagmus decreases with repetition of this maneuver.
The diagnosis of lateral canal pathology is made by supine roll test. During this test, there is usually a
horizontal nystagmus with the fast phase towards the ear being tested. This test can be performed in the
outpatient clinic [Fig 3].
Figure 3. Supine roll test starting from the left side. [modified with permission from Hornibrook J, I J Otolaryngology 2011.
New Zealand].
TREATMENT
Treatment for BPPV is by returning or repositioning the detached otoconia back to the utricle.
The commonly used techniques are the Epley Canalith Repositioning Procedure [Fig 4] and the Semont
21,29,30
liberatory maneuver [Fig 5] .
The Epley maneuver starts with the patient sitting up and the head being turned towards the effected side, right side in Figure 4.
The patient is reclined with the head overhanging the bed or pillow. In this reclined position, the head is turned towards the left. The
head is turned further left as the patient is
Figure 5. Semonts maneuver for treating right sided BPPV.
looking towards the floor. Finally, the patient is sat upright with the neck flexed. Each position lasts for 30
seconds.
Semonts maneuver starts with the patient sitting straight up on the examination table, the head is turned away from
the bad side. The head is first lowered to the side causing the vertigo. Then lying down, the patient looks up at the
ceiling. This position is held for approximately 2-3 minutes.
The patient is then quickly moved to the opposite side without stopping in the upright middle position. Again, this
position lasts for 2-3 minutes and then finally in the upright position for 2-3 minutes.
The lateral or horizontal canal is less commonly involved and the maneuver that has been used to
treat lateral canal BPPV is, the roll maneuver (Lempert maneuver or barbecue roll maneuver). This
31,32
maneuver is performed by rolling the patient 3608 in a few steps.
Anterior canal BPPV is rare, and symptoms may improve by performing the maneuvers
recommended for the posterior canal. One study of 14 patients with anterior canal BPPV showed
33
resolution of symptoms following the posterior canal maneuver.
POSTURAL RESTRICTIONS AFTER CANALITH REPOSITIONING MANEUVERS
Over the past two to three decades, BPPV patients were advised on the following postural restrictions, to maintain an upright
posture for 1-2 days after the particle repositioning maneuvers, to avoid sleeping in a bed and to sleep in a chair instead and to
avoid any bending over and looking upwards. Some physicians also used to recommend a soft collar to help patients to adhere
to these instructions.
Patients were also instructed to avoid sleeping on the affected ear for several nights. The rationale was
to prevent the crystals re-entering the semicircular canals.
34,35
Some recent studies have shown that these restrictions are not necessary for recovery of BPPV. However, there
is a systematic review in the Cochrane Library which concludes that the postural restrictions have significant (though
36
clinically small) effect on recovery. As the restrictions are easy to comply with and have no side effects, they should be
discussed with the patient.
SURGICAL TREATMENT
In rare intractable cases, surgical treatment is considered as a last resort. Surgical management includes
posterior semicircular occlusion (plugging) and transection of the ampullary nerve supplying the posterior
semicircular canal. Both procedures are associated with complications such as disequilibrium and hearing
23,37-40
loss.
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
Current evidence suggests that CRM improves symptoms in BPPV sufferers. This is based on the theory of free floating
crystals in the semicircular canals. However, it is not clear as to why many patients get better without treatment. The
exact pathophysiology is still not well understood, partly due to inability to visualize the inner structure of the
semicircular canals in detail. There is need for robust scientific studies to explore this condition in more detail which may
help in defining clear understanding about
RECOMMENDATIONS
The following are recommendations by the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck
Surgery in the management of patients with BPPV:
1. A physician should diagnose posterior semicircular canal BPPV with symptoms of vertigo being
associated with positive Dix-Hallpike test. These patients should be treated by one of the Canalith
repositioning maneuvers
2. A physician should perform a supine roll test if there is history suggestive of BPPV and there is negative
Dix-Hallpike test. Patients with positive supine roll test should be treated by one of the Canalith
repositioning maneuvers
3. All above patients should be reassessed within one month of the physical maneuvers.
4. A physician should differentiate BPPV from other central causes of imbalance, and vertigo
5. A physician should investigate further only if there is treatment failure
6. There is no need for routine radiographic imaging in patients with history compatible with BPPV. However, if there is
treatment failure or atypical symptoms then imaging may be needed
7. There is no need to treat BPPV routinely with medications such as antihistamines and benzodiazepines
A physician should counsel patients with a history of BPPV on their safety, recurrence and follow up
