Health Economics: Efficiency & Market Dynamics
Health Economics: Efficiency & Market Dynamics
01
HEALTH ECONOMICS
October 8, 2019 | Jeriel R. De Silos, MD, MPM-HSD
Transcriber/s: 2A
BLUE - past trans GOAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS
OUTLINE ● Pursue both EFFICIENCY and EQUITY
● Efficiency:
Constant resource → Maximum benefit
I. Introduction or
○ Economics Minimum resource → Constant benefit
○ Health Economics
1. Productive Resources PRODUCTIVE RESOURCES
2. Scarcity ● Many productive resources are considered by economists
II. Efficiency as MEASURABLE, and all of these can be expressed in
○ 3 Main Elements terms of MONEY.
1. Technical
2. Cost-effective
3. Allocative
○ 3 Major Analytic Techniques
1. Cost-effectiveness
2. Cost-utility
3. Cost-benefit
III. The Market
○ Market and Privatization
○ Market Demand
○ Market Supply
IV. Market Failure
○ Major Problems
1. Externalities
2. Public good
Figure 1. Productive resources.
3. Information asymmetry
4. Supplier-induced demand
(SID) Question:
5. Monopolies and In an economic sense, is money a productive resource or not?
incomplete markets
OBJECTIVES Answer:
1. Define Health Economics and other related terms NOT a productive resource
2. Discuss Economic Efficiency as to: ● Money is not considered by economists as a productive
a. Elements resources
b. Evaluation ● It is only used as a medium of exchange of productive
2. Discuss the concept of Market in terms of Supply and resources
Demand ● It can also be used to measure economic values
3. Explain the causes of Market Failure in health care
● These are when raw materials are selected and utilized for
I. INTRODUCTION
production (because resources can be subdivided into many
ECONOMICS
categories).
● One of the greatest issues in the country (eg. rice shortage,
inflation rate)
CLASSIFICATIONS OF PRODUCTIVE RESOURCES
● The study of how individuals and societies choose to allocate
1. Human resource – TIME AND ABILITY
SCARCE PRODUCTIVE RESOURCES among competing alternative
● Time is limited. Sometimes, it may not be possible
uses and subsequently to distribute the 'products' from these
to serve all patients with a limited amount of
uses among the members of a society.
time.
● Ability – proper allocation of health providers to
HEALTH ECONOMICS
the services needed by the patients. Some simple
● The study of how scarce productive resources are
conditions may require services by generalists
allocated among alternative uses for the care of sickness
while specialists cater to those with specific needs
and the promotion, maintenance and improvement of
that need their abilities to avoid wasting of time.
health.
● It further includes the study of how health care and health‐
2. Capital – FACILITY AND EQUIPMENT
related services, their costs and benefits, and health itself
● knowledge in general. In business, they have the
are distributed among individuals and groups in society.
concept of consultant-- these people ar selling
their knowledge or skills to a company. It has a
price
1 of 10
● Specialized equipment need to be placed in the ○ Look at the producer's’ perspective.
tertiary hospitals while basic equipment should ● 3 → CONSUMPTION (DEMAND)
be present in primary level health facilities. ○ Look at the consumers’ perspective
3. Natural resources – has indirect influence
● Metals may not directly affect the way a doctor
handles his or her patients, but these may be THREE MAIN ELEMENTS OF EFFICIENCY
useful in the construction of facilities. 1. Technical efficiency – to save up on raw materials
● Water and food are also necessary. 2. Cost-effectiveness efficiency – to save up on production cost
4. Knowledge of production process – knowing how the with good quality and quantity
health system works in a given community. This will include 3. Allocative efficiency – to continuously satisfy demand of clients
the knowledge of where to refer patients or where the
specialized services located in the area. TECHNICAL EFFICIENCY
● Requires that for any given amount of output the amount of
SCARCITY inputs used to produce it is minimized.
● A fundamental problem facing all societies (and economists) is ● Alternatively, the requirement can be stated such that
that productive resources are INSUFFICIENT. maximum output is produced from any given combination of
● There are not and can never be enough resources to satisfy all inputs
human wants and needs. ● In general, there will be several technically efficient
● There is a constant conflict among alternative uses of productive combinations of inputs (for example, combinations of labor and
resources, and a constant need to choose among alternative capital) for a given level of output.
allocations. ● If this condition is not met:
● Assessed in terms of OPPORTUNITY COST. ○ Obtain more output through a different configuration of
○ Opportunity cost – the other outputs that must be given up resources.
in favor of a preferred output because productive resources To produce more outputs, we can reconfigure our resources
are committed to it like using catalysts in producing chemicals or use better
technologies to aid in the production of our outputs.
○ Release some of the resources to alternative uses without
sacrificing any current output.
○ Remove some of the insufficiencies and transfer those to
another production. For example, construction of a large
hospital in a small rural town.
● EXAMPLES:
○ Hospitals that are larger than they need to be to serve their
communities is an example of technical inefficiency.
○ Praziquantel 40mg/kg is comparable to 60mg/kg in treating
Schistosomiasis caused by S. japonicum
○ Non-MDR PTB treatment success in TB-DOTS centers is
comparable to tertiary hospitals
● TECHNICAL INEFFICIENCY = “OVERKILL”
*insert recording explanation here This is the reason why most business people resort to cost-cutting.
II. EFFICIENCY They want to utilize the least amount of input to produce a certain
● Measures how well resources are being used to promote social output. For example: Potency of drugs. Drug X can cure TB for 500 mg
welfare. of its dose. Another drug manufacturer was able to produce a drug
● “Get the most out of scarce resources”. similar to Drug X but can cure TB with the same effectiveness for
250mg of its dose. In terms of technical efficiency, the new drug is
The THREE MAIN ELEMENTS of Efficiency can be simplified as: better and more technically efficient than Drug X.
1. Do not waste resources.
○ In the production, usually there are wasted resources. COST-EFFECTIVENESS EFFICIENCY
There should be ways to minimize wastage. ● Takes into account the relative cost of different inputs
2. Produce each output at the LEAST cost. ● It requires that, in addition to technical efficiency being attained,
○ In the production, there is a need to use the least expensive inputs be combined so as to minimize the cost of any given
raw materials. output.
3. Produce the types and amounts of output which people value
most. “Before cost-effective efficiency is attained, technical
efficiency must first be achieved.”
An EFFICIENT ALLOCATION of resources is one which simultaneously
meets all three requirements. ● Alternatively, the requirement may be stated such that output is
● 1 & 2 → PRODUCTION (SUPPLY) maximized for a given cost.
2 of 10
● For any given output in a particular setting, there will normally ○ Surgery in a well-known teaching hospital vs same surgert
be only one combination of inputs that will be cost‐effective. done by the same surgeon in another almost unknown
● Cost-effectiveness can be measured by comparing all possible hospital
combinations of inputs used for the same purpose. ○ Taking a drug to treat allergy four times a day vs a more
● While cost‐effectiveness can inform the question of how to expensive alternative to be taken once a day
produce an output at least cost, it does not address the question
of whether the output should be produced In common language, then, efficiency means both “DOING THINGS
RIGHT” (technical efficiency and cost‐ effectiveness – ensuring that
● EXAMPLE: production will lead to the right product), and “DOING THE RIGHT
○ If labor is abundant and inexpensive relative to capital in THINGS” (allocative efficiency – ensures the products are intended for
one economy compared to another, then least‐cost the proper end-user).
production methods will employ relatively more labor in
the first economy. Reason for producing products in China SO, HOW DO WE ANALYZE EFFICIENCY?
because cost of labor in China is cheap.
○ Strategy of Apple: they jump up the use of their products ECONOMIC EVALUATION
and they claim that their product is high quality. They claim ● Defined as the comparative analysis of alternative courses of
that the product is “matibay, maganda, etc.” therefore action in terms of both their COSTS and CONSEQUENCES
many people will buy. (Drummond et al., 1997).
○ A 50 peso per tablet Amoxicillin 500mg vs a 5 peso tablet ● Both costs and consequences are required for a study to be
Amoxicillin 500mg to treat an infection considered a full economic evaluation.
○ Cost of surgery in a tertiary private hospital vs cost of the
same surgery done by the same surgeon in a government
training hospital
3 of 10
because of the treatment itself and a gradual decline in health over
that time. If individuals valued the first 10 years at 0.75 on the above
0-1.0 scale, and the last 5 years at 0.50 on the same scale, then what
is the QALYs generated by dialysis?
4 of 10
● A market is simply the result of the interaction of supply and DEMAND
demand ● Desire and ability to pay a price for a given good or service
● In a COMPETITIVE MARKET….
o A large number of producers compete with each other to ● NEED vs WANT:
satisfy the wants and needs of a large number of ○ Need – required for survival (medicines and vaccines)
consumers. ○ Want – a felt need that is not necessary for survival (Wifi,
o Producers aim to make optimal use of resources. mobile data)
● When someone NEEDS SOMETHING and is willing and able to
pay for it, then that 'need' is translated into EFFECTIVE DEMAND.
9 CONDITIONS FOR COMPETITIVE MARKETS ● But if they WANT SOMETHING (i.e. iPad Pro) and are unwilling or
Buyers/ Clients unable to pay for it, then suppliers of iPad Pros have no
1. Able and willing to pay customers and a market for iPad Pros cannot exist.
2. Informed
3. Rational “Demand becomes EFFECTIVE when customers come forward and
4. Time to shop express their wants in a WILLINGNESS and ABILITY TO PAY”
Goods/ Services
5. Homogenous (similar) inputs and quality
Question:
6. Price known in advance
What will happen if people need something that they think is
Producers/ Suppliers
necessary but unable to translate it into an effective demand?
7. Many sellers
8. Free entry
Answer:
9. Free exit
Competitive markets will NOT supply these people with the
services they need without special provisions. This happens in poor
● Here, we do not want monopolies. There needs to be a
communities Markets will only operate if people can translate their
large number of consumers.
needs into effective demand through an ability to pay.
● Free entry - no one in the producers’ side should prevent
newcomers
Hindi matatawag na effective yung demand kung walang may
● Free exit - for those who became bankrupt in the market
kayang bumili. Kung walang bibili, walang magbebenta.
MARKETS AND PRIVATIZATION
Question:
PRIVATIZATION
From an economic perspective, how can the market
● process of transferring ownership of formerly public
accommodate the needs of the poor?
enterprises, organizations or agencies to the private sector
Answer:
● In a SEMASHKO SYSTEM, the public sector takes full
Special provisions can be put into place to help the poor translate
responsibility for the country’s health goods and services
their needs into effective demand:
○ Market is non-existent
● Government can pay for the needs of the poor
○ Privatization is not possible
● A non-government sponsor can pay for the needs of the
○ Options or variations is little
poor
● In a BEVERIDGE or BISMARCKIAN SYSTEM, governments:
○ Increase the role of the private sector in the PROVISION of DEMAND CURVE
health goods and services ● Simply a plot of demand vs price
○ Retains considerable responsibility and control over the
means to finance those health goods and services Must fulfill 3 things:
○ Markets for health provision do prevail, or are being 1. Quantify how much of a good or service people want—and
stimulated, as when governments 'sub‐contract out' will demand—at different prices;
2. Get real data from functioning markets and record how
● In a DECENTRALIZED SYSTEM, governments: demanded quantities increase or decrease, as prices
○ Make greater use of the private sector to provide health increase or decrease;
goods and services 3. Plot the data to make the actual demand curve.
○ May actually decide to reduce the number of public
providers they manage and fund by selling these to a ELASTICITY OF DEMAND - the rate at which the quantity of a good or
private sector group who will: service changes with a change in price.
▪ Manage them; ○ Elastic - if demand changes a lot when the price increases
▪ Put them into competition with other hospitals; ○ Inelastic - if demand changes only slightly when price
▪ Sustain their operations through revenue earned. increases
MARKET DEMAND
5 of 10
PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND - method of quantifying the rate of 1. Lower its price (this would not shift the demand curve! It
change in demand that accompanies a change in price. would only move the demand towards the right, along the
○ Elastic - if demand changed a lot when the price increases initial curve);
(>1.0) 2. Lower the price of a complement;
○ Inelastic - if demand changes only slightly when price 3. Increase the price of a substitute;
increases (>1.0) 4. Increase tastes for the good and service.
MARKET SUPPLY
● Private sector producers supply goods and services as a way of
making a living and/or generating as much surplus or profit as
they can.
● PROFIT
○ Any money a producer/supplier gets to keep from
the sale of a good or service after all costs to
produce the good or service are met.
● If a private producer/supplier fails to sell a good or service at a
profit, they can go slowly or quickly bankrupt.
● Goal: minimize production cost to earn profit
SUPPLY CURVE
● Simply a plot of supply vs price
● Must fulfill 3 things:
1. Quantify how much of a good or service producers are
willing to supply at different prices;
2. Get real data from functioning markets and record how
supply quantities increase or decrease, as prices increase or
decrease;
3. Plot the data to make the actual supply curve.
Figure 2. The demand curve. Demand = boxes of medicines. Figure 3. Supply is the reverse of demand.
6 of 10
demand is high, supply is not directly influenced. If demand is high,
asking price decreases. If demand is high but supply is not, cost
decreases (because people look for alternatives where cost is
reduced). If demand is high, there is no way to reduce it because the
consumers are the ones asking for it, so the plan is to increase the
supply to the amount of demand needed to achieve equilibrium.
● If you want to increase the supply of a good or service:
Sometimes, demand or supply may be difficult to alter therefore the
1. Increase its price;
government may intervene. However, the “invisible hand” should
2. Reduce costs of producer inputs;
actually work without the help of the government, and intervention
3. Invent new technologies that yield more output per input.
only comes in when the need arises.
PUBLIC GOOD
● Goods from the consumption of which no one can be
excluded and the consumption is non-rival
○ If person A consumes this good, the consumption
of it by person B is in no way reduced.
○ Examples:
■ AM/FM radio
■ Drinking water
■ Clean air
■ Public sewage system
Figure 5. “Correction” of price means that there is equilibrium (green
circle in the middle). There is both acceptable demand and supply. If
7 of 10
● The market will typically not produce the good because of 1. Doctors are at liberty to set their fees as high as they want—
the problem of FREE RIDERS (people who do not pay but patients have no choice but to pay if they want treatment
still enjoy the benefits). because there are no alternatives.
2. There are no incentives for doctors to provide high‐quality
INFORMATION ASYMMETRY services in order to retain their patients, for the same
● Case where the provider of the service knows more than reason that patients have nowhere else to turn to.
the consumer about the good or service applied. 3. The patients have no market power and cannot force
● Consumers of health services face the problem of not being physicians to perform better, more, and at lower prices.
fully aware of all treatment options that are available for
their complaint. ISSUES IN FREE ENTRY
● Therefore, rely on the physician to choose the appropriate 1. In the case of health markets, this condition is usually not
treatment on their behalf. present, since physicians are required to be licensed by a
professional association or by the government.
2. Medical education, including specialized trainings are very
AGENCY long.
● Asymmetry of information leads to a relationship of agency. 3. The long duration of the training and the licensing puts a
● Agency - situation which arises whenever a principal (a barrier at the entry point in the market.
patient) delegates decision‐making authority to another
party, the agent (physician), who is expected to provide the
lacking information. ISSUES IN INCOMPLETE MARKETS
● There is a CONFLICT OF INTEREST, since the agent is also 1. This happens when, for instance, in very remote areas,
the provider or “seller” of goods or services. there is either not enough demand to sustain a market or
● In the demand curve, when the demand shifts to the right, there is not enough supply, or both.
the price increases. 2. In these incomplete markets the government or other
● In the supply curve, when the supply shifts to the right, the altruistic providers will often step in to alleviate this
price decreases. situation and provide basic services.
● Can lead to MORAL HAZARD, or the possibility of one of the
parties to change its behavior to its own benefit and usually
at the cost of the other party. REFERENCES
1. Able and 5. Homogenous/ similar 7. Many sellers* [Link] is an example of _________ resource:
willing to pay inputs and quality 8. Free entry* a. Natural
2. Informed 6. Price known in 9. Free exit b. Production Process Knowledge
3. Rational advance c. Capital
4. Time to shop [Link]
8 of 10
c. Human 54. The market demand is said to be ______ if demand changes a
d. Production Process Knowledge lot when the price increases
a. Inelastic
45. The most recent treatment guideline for a disease is an b. Elastic
example of ________ resource:
a. Human 55. When the absolute value of the computed ELASTICITY OF
b. Natural DEMAND (/x/) is > 1.0, it is said to be:
c. Capital a. Inelastic
d. Production Process Knowledge b. Elastic
[Link] that are larger than they need to be to serve their 56. When the absolute value of the computed ELASTICITY OF
communities is an example of ________ SUPPLY (/x/) is < 1.0, it is said to be:
a. Allocative Efficiency a. Elastic
b. Cost-Effectiveness Efficiency b. Inelastic
c. Technical Efficiency
For nos. 49-51. For each scenario below, determine which are
examples of economic evaluation.
9 of 10
10 of 10