Air Service Development ICF PDF
Air Service Development ICF PDF
Development
Presented by:
Jared Harckham, Vice President
Carlos Ozores, Principal
Airports • Airlines • Aerospace & MRO • Asset Advisory • Safety & Security
Calgary Birmingham
Boston
Salt Lake City Denver
Baltimore-Wash.
Los Angeles DFW
Seoul Incheon, Atlanta
Korea Los Cabos Miami
(GAP) Guadalajara
(GAP) San Juan
Puerto
Vallarta
• Mexico 9 additional GAP (GAP)
Colombia (National Study)
• 4 ASA airports Mexico City
metro area. Quito
National study for
Sec. of Tourism Peru 12 Airports
Montevideo
AVIATION INVESTMENT ADVISORY QUALIFICATIONS & EXPERIENCE
RPK = Revenue Passenger Kilometer, or passenger transported one kilometer. Standard industry measure of traffic.
1. Financial Incentives
2. Organized Stakeholders
3. Quantitative Analysis
1. Creating an air service development strategy
2. Understand how airlines plan
3. Conduct a route forecast
4. Create effective Business Cases
Quantitative
Analysis
Financial Coordinated
Incentives Stakeholders
11
Risk sharing and commitment are sought by many airlines, by way
of Financial Incentives
Other Stakeholders
Financial incentives from the
airport can take many forms, – Discounts on hotel,
including: transportation and meals for
airline crew overnights
– Discounts on traditional
airport fees – Preferential rates for airline
vacation programs at hotels
– Creative solutions (e.g. and tourist attractions
rebates, fuel savings)
– Pre-purchase of airline tickets Examples of airport discounts
by local businesses for future – Landing Fees
use – Security screening
– Revenue and profitability – Jet-bridge
guarantees
– Parking
Broader sources can provide – Rental of check-in counters
– Funds for advertising and and office space
promotion – Passenger Fee
Successful Air Service Development in today’s environment
requires three basic elements
Quantitative
Analysis
Financial Coordinated
Incentives Stakeholders
13
Coordinated Stakeholders are key
Quantitative
Analysis
Financial Coordinated
Incentives Stakeholders
15
Quantitative Analysis in an Air
Service Development Program
16
Quantitative Analysis: How to develop new routes
Route Development
Strategy
Identify and prioritize
objectives for new
routes/airlines
Business Case for Each
Airline
Communicate the
business case with the
potential client
Defining an Air Service Development strategy involves a
diagnostic of the airport, establishing a strategy and creating an
implementation plan
Air Service Development Strategy Business Cases
1Diagnostic
2
Define
Strategy 3Implementation
Plan
Introduction to the Market
Demand Statistics
Benchmarking Identify Define
Opportunities Communication
Historical Plan
Proposed Itinerary
Evaluation Estimate
Demand Conferences and
Airline Strategy Meetings
Traffic/Revenue
Projections
Prioritize
Support
Channels Incentives
Benchmarking
– Compare the service offering (destinations, airlines,
frequencies) of your airport vs. competitors in the same
region
Airline Strategy
– Understand how airlines operate (Hub, point to point),
evolution of alliances, aircraft orders, etc.
Example: Comparison of UIO’s international service vs. other
airports in the region
Weekly Seats by Airport (‘000s)
June 2014
350
Domestic
300 International
250
200 206
150 93
92
100
161 69
50 100 100 3 50
82 34
52 48
28 22
0
PTY LIM BOG SCL SJO CCS UIO GYE
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
SDQ YYZ SCL PUJ DFW EWR FLL LAX
5 5 5 5 6 4 4 3
# of Competing Airports with Flights to Destination
With fewer airlines in the region, air service will be concentrated on a few hubs.
From an air service development perspective, there will be fewer airlines to work with.
Source: OAG
The diagnostic allows you to define a strategy, focusing on and
prioritizing objectives to increase air service
Establish priorities
– Prioritize opportunities in the short, medium, and long-term
– Understand the effort needed to achieve each objective
Lastly, the best method of implementing the strategy should be
determined – attending meetings and taking advantage of other
support channels
Define how to contact the airlines of interest
– Conferences and/or direct meetings with airlines
– Begin with the regional office or directly with headquarters?
– Contacting the right people saves time: Planners
Choose the conferences/frequency of attendance that best
fit your strategy
– Regional, global conferences
• Routes, Jumpstart, Tourism conferences for vacation markets
– How many times per year?
Take advantage of external support channels
– What other stakeholders can support the effort to develop air service?
Airline Route Planning Process
25
In order to make logical and interesting route proposals to airlines,
it’s important to understand how airlines think
Strategy
Fleet Planning
Product
Network Design Markets Finalize
Facilities Staff
Itinerary Structure Final Itinerary
Preliminary Itinerary Availability of staff/gates
Rates/Slots
Strategy
Fleet Planning
Product
Prioritization of markets
Network Strategy
– Net new aircraft (orders minus
retirements)
– Hub(s) structure
– Strategy for short/long haul
– Strategy for Latin America
– Alliance strategy
300
Active
246
250
Orders
200
172
150
122
111
100 81 87 85
73 72
59
47 48
50
26 27
Source: ACAS
For airlines, route planning is a question of finding the best use of
limited resources
34
Overview of the route forecasting process
Key Factors
Aircraft range
Operating restrictions
– Runway length
– Height above sea level, temperature
– Noise restrictions
There are a variety of current and future widebody aircraft
that should be analyzed
Widebody Maximum Range vs. Average Seat Capacity
550 Next Generation Widebody Aircraft
A380-800
500
747-8
450
Average Seat Capacity
A340-300
747-400ER
747-400
400 777-300ER
A340-600
777-300
A330-200
350 767-300ER A350-1000
787-10X
777-200 330
A350-900
300 A330-300 787-9
777-200ER
A350-800
250
787-8
200
5,000 5,500 6,000 6,500 7,000 7,500 8,000 8,500 9,000
Maximum Range, Nautical Miles
Possible Passenger
Flows
Local Types of
Connections
Connecting
Online
Interline
With Code Share partners
Example of local and connecting passenger distribution on flights
from UIO
Continental IAH-UIO
Local 15%
Others 1%
Local
11%
Connection
at ATL
88% Others
1%
PaxIS
– Captures tickets purchased through all travel agencies that participate in
IATA’s BSP and includes:
• Origin and Destination airports, Connecting airports
• Airline that markets and operates each segment, Point of sale
• Month of trip, Fare class
– PaxIS supplier, IATA, estimates full market size
Market Information Data Tapes (“MIDT”)
– Captures reservation data from the primary GDS systems (Amadeus,
Sabre, Worldspan y Galileo). The level of detail is similar to what is
provided by PaxIS
However, neither MIDT nor PaxIS capture direct sales…
MIDT/PaxIS data should also be calibrated to estimate direct sales
1,000
800 395
Pax/Month
600
400
200
0
D 7
D 8
D 9
Ju 7
Ju 8
Ju 9
Fe 7
Fe 8
Fe 9
7
9
A 7
08
A 8
09
A 9
10
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
-0
0
0
n-
b-
n-
b-
n-
b-
ct
ct
ct
pr
pr
pr
ug
ug
ug
ec
ec
ec
O
O
A
10
5
Arrivals
to PTY
-5
Departures
from PTY
-10
7:00
8:00
9:00
10:00
11:00
12:00
13:00
14:00
15:00
16:00
17:00
18:00
19:00
20:00
21:00
22:00
Source: OAG Schedules
All of this information is needed for the essential analysis of the
Business Case: the forecast of market share, passenger traffic, and
revenue on the proposed route
ICF SH&E uses NETWORKS, a proprietary tool that models route schedules
to estimate the market share of each airline
– Currently used by British Airways, Copa Airlines, Virgin Atlantic, oneworld
NETWORKS is “QSI” (Quality of Service Index) model, an industry-accepted
methodology for calculating carrier share
NETWORKS quantifies the market share of each segment (the “QSI”),
taking into account:
– Type of service (Online, Interline, Etc.)
– Frequency
– Number of stops and connections
– Total travel time (between origin and destination)
– Type of aircraft (size, jet vs. turboprop)
– Etc.
What is a “local” passenger?
IAH UIO
What is a connecting passenger?
NRT
IAH UIO
ORD
QSI example: SCL – NYC market
Option Time Frequency Stops Cxns
LA nonstop 10:50 5x weekly 0 0
MIA LA via LIM 12:30 Daily 1 0
AA/LA AA via MIA 13:40 Daily 1 1
AA DL via ATL 13:55 Daily 1 1
SCL LA
NYC
LA
LIM LA
QSI Share SCL-NYC
DL June 2010
DL Others
10%
DL
14%
ATL LA
41%
CM
6%
AA
29%
Source: SH&E NETWORKS based on OAG schedules June 2010
NetWorks quantifies each service in the market and allocates
traffic and revenue according to its market share
“QSI” is calculated
based on several
service perameters
53
The Business Case should answer the following questions:
56
Mexican Pacific Airport Group (GAP) Route Proposals
Prepared by
October 2013
Mexican Pacific Airport Group (GAP) maintains and operates
12 airports in Northwestern and Central Mexico
GAP Airports served over 22.1 million people between September 2012 through August 2013; increasing 6% year over year
MXL
0.5
TIJ -4%
4.1 Passengers, Millions
10% Year over year % Change
HMO
1.3
2% GAP is owned by a world-
class group of investors,
Airport Airport LMM including Spanish airport
Code 0.2 operator AENA
Guadalajara GDL LAP 7%
0.6 GAP shares are listed on
Tijuana TIJ 4% AGU the NYSE and BMV
Puerto Vallarta PVR
GDL 0.4
Los Cabos SJD
SJD 7.8
12%
3.3 6%
Hermosillo HMO 13% BJX
1.0
Leon BJX PVR 5%
La Paz LAP 2.7
3%
Mexicali MXL MLM
Morelia MLM
ZLO 0.4
0.2 2%
Aguascalientes AGU 19%
Los Mochis LMM
Manzanillo ZLO
Source: GAP
58
International markets to Mexico have seen steady
growth since the economic downturn of 2009
Passenger Traffic Trend Nationality of the Foreign Visitors to Mexico
Passengers Visitors 10 Top Countries
(‘000) Mexico International Market1 (‘000) % Growth
Jan-Jul 2013
4M (Y-O-Y Change)
35,000 2,000 60%
MX Ceases
Financial Ops Visitors ('000')
30,000 Crises 50%
% Growth
25,000 1,500
40%
20,000 30%
1,000
15,000 20%
10,000 CAGR YE Jul 09 – YE Jul 13: +4% 10%
500
5,000 0%
0 0 -10%
% Growth
YE Jul09 YE Jul10 YE Jul11 YE Jul12 YE Jul13
The Mexico international market has The United States ranks first among foreign
shown positive growth over the past visitors to Mexico with 56% of the total
five years, rebounding to above 2009
From January 2013 to July 2013, the number
passenger levels
of foreign visitors to Mexico grew by 8%
compared to the same period of the
previous year
Market Overview
of Los Cabos
Prepared by
In January 2014, Los Cabos will have non-stop services to/from 30 cities across
Canada, Mexico and United States
Total 30
Source: GAP 62
Los Cabos offers a range of infrastructure including all-inclusive
resorts, times shares and boutique hotels
Lodging in SJD
2012
Source: Mexican Tourism Ministry, Mexican Ministry of the Economy, Statcan, Government of Baja California Sur, RCI 63
Well-known international hotel chains, all inclusive resorts and
boutique hotels offer visitors to Los Cabos a wide variety of
accommodation options
Los Cabos Hotel Occupancy Rate
80% 69%
65% 62% 63%
57% 58%
60% 54%
40%
20%
0%
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
1,200
International
+2%
1,000 +12%
400
200
0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Charlotte (CLT) 1
Atlanta (ATL) 7
NOTE: 1\ Code-share fights are not considered in the connecting services. Includes only single connections. The online connecting frequencies reflect only the number of actual
entries into the respective final destination. The airline may offer multiple options to get to the connection.
Source: OAG 68
For the JFK-SJD schedule, GAP and ICF SH&E suggest suitable timings
for leisure passengers appropriate for the hotels’ check-in and check-
out jetBlue Schedule for Proposed New York-Los Cabos Nonstop Service
Daily Flight on an A320
City
Notes:
/1 GAP and ICF SH&E further adjust PaxIS Plus data to insure accuracy on mark et sizes
/2 Based on IATA Traffic Forecast for the period YE May 2013-2014 using a growth rate of 6.0% between the U.S. and Mexico
/3 Air fare data sources do not include taxes and commissions
Source: ICF SH&E/GAP Analysis, OAG Schedules, ICF SH&E Networks 70
The NYC-SJD market represents a unique opportunity for
jetBlue to become a major player in the Los Cabos market
jetBlue Schedule for Proposed New York-Los Cabos Nonstop Service
Daily Flight on an A320
Other
Delta 12%
5%
American
Airlines
9% jetBlue
56%
United
18%
GAP and ICF SH&E assumed a stimulation of 50% with the addition of a daily jetBlue flight from JFK to SJD
When jetBlue entered the New York – Cancun market, the market was stimulated by approximately 50% despite already
existing nonstop service
Source: ICF SH&E Analysis using ICF SH&E NETWORKS and OAG Schedules 71
jetBlue’s new air service to Los Cabos will be well supported
by a strong route committee formed by major federal and
state entities that work closely with GAP
Los Cabos new air service will be well supported by GAP and main entities in the
region that will bring resources for the new service:
72
jetBlue’s new air service will be supported by a strong advertising
campaign funded by the Los Cabos Local Government and
Mexico’s Federal Government
The Baja State Fund Trust together with Mexico’s Federal Government
through the Ministry of Tourism and the Mexico Tourism Promotion
Council will join efforts to offer the following incentives to promote
jetBlue’s new service:
73
Los Cabos International Airport Overview
Los Cabos International Airport (SJD) is one of
the most successful airports in Latin America
– Traffic has grown almost 50% since year 2000
ICF SH&E uses NetWorks©, its proprietary and proven airline planning
tool, to evaluate new schedule scenarios, forecast traffic and
profitability, and develop new schedules
Network & Schedule Analysis
systems and services Relevant Capabilities
Hub Connectivity Analyses
Service Share (QSI), Passenger Share
[ ] and Gap Analyses
Evaluation of Appropriate
Frequency/Aircraft Size Combinations
What If and Impact of Competitive Actions and
Alternative Responses
Forecasts Traffic, Revenue, Costs and
Profitability on an Individual Flight Level
Alliance and Code-Share Impacts
Used together with OASIS schedule
routing model