Kentucky IGCC Fuel Cell Design Report
Kentucky IGCC Fuel Cell Design Report
BASIS OF DESIGN
Submitted to:
and
Submitted by:
G. Steinfeld, Project Director
FuelCell Energy Inc.
3 Great Pasture Road
Danbury, CT 06813
DOE Intellectual Property Disclaimer
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
Executive Summary 1
Design Basis 2
9.0 Layout 13
i
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF TABLES
1 Site Data 6
2 Syngas Analysis 6
4 Water Analysis 8
5 Plant Interfaces 9
ii
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Design of the syngas processing system for the original KPE site in Trapp, Kentucky
was initiated by preparation of a preliminary PFD and material and energy balances.
Due to the planned change of site to the Wabash River site and the differences in the
gasification/clean up system, the design of the syngas processing is being updated for
the new location.
1
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
DESIGN BASIS
The Fuel Cell Power Plant will be based on FCE’s standard natural gas-fueled two-
module Direct Fuel Cell (DFC) power plant design, adapted to operate on syngas after
its initial operation and checkout on natural gas. Its balance of plant (BOP) components
will be sized to enable plant power generation of up to 3.0 MW (net ac) using future
technology replacement Fuel Cell Stack Modules containing FCE’s “mature” generation
of fuel cell stacks. It will be highly modularized, and will feature high efficiency, quiet
operation, low emissions, and a small footprint.
The Syngas Fuel Preparation Facility will convert the treated syngas from the Wabash
gasification plant into fuel gas suitable for the Fuel Cell Stack Modules. This will be
accomplished by (1) Additional desulfurization of the syngas to lower its sulfur content
further, and (2) methanating the syngas (in order to utilize the cooling effect of the
endothermic methane reforming reactions within the fuel cell stacks). The Syngas Fuel
Preparation Facility will be located adjacent to the Fuel Cell Power Plant.
2
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
• Electrical Characteristics
• Height 25 feet
All fuel cell stack modules will be preconditioned before being installed at the site.
The plant will be designed for unattended operation with local and remote
dispatching/control. The control system will be able to communicate with a remote
monitoring station located at FCE’s facilities in Danbury, CT for diagnostic purposes.
Control of the plant will be accomplished using a Scaleable Process Control System
(SPCS). The majority of control and monitoring interfaces to the process will be via
“Smart Type Transducers” communicating over Foundation Fieldbus segments, Modbus
Links to PLC’s controllers with classic I/O providing, motor control and multiplexor
interfaces to the non-smart instruments.
The SPCS controllers, power supplies, bus interface modules, I/O racks, data
historian/WEB server and an Engineering Operator Work Station with a laser printer (for
maintenance) will be housed inside the Electrical Equipment enclosure located inside
the plant Inside Boundary Limit (IBL).
The WEB server will interface via a telephone modem for remote communications and a
telephone pager for annunciating alarms.
The metallurgy of piping and equipment will be selected to ensure the purity and
freedom from particulates (including pipe slag, rust, etc.) of the anode fuel gas and
cathode oxidant gas supplied to the fuel cell Stack Modules.
On-site equipment and controls will be designed for electrical classification per code
(e.g. Class 1, Division 2, Groups B & D).
FCE will manufacture the fuel cell stack modules. The balance of plant equipment will
be manufactured by subcontractors and delivered to the site by FCE.
4
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
Global Energy is responsible for providing the following gases and utilities at a regulated
pressure to a tie-in location adjacent to the plant site: syngas, natural gas, electricity,
municipal water, and sewer connection for process waste water.
• The stack modules and balance of plant equipment (BOP), where applicable, will be
designed to withstand pressure spikes induced by internal deflagrations by adequate
structural design.
• Leaks of treated syngas downstream from the Feed Treatment System and fuel gas
will not be detectable by smell. Strategically located combustible gas detectors will
be provided to detect methane gas and fuel gas leaks in the Fuel Gas Preparation
system.
• Carbon monoxide, present in significant concentrations in the fuel gas from the
Gasification facility and anode exhaust gas, is highly poisonous. Strategically
located combustible gas detectors will be provided to detect CO leaks in the fuel
gas, anode exhaust gas piping and the Oxidizer.
Site and climatic design conditions for the WREL Gasification site are listed in Table 1.
5
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
The Fuel Cell Power Plant will be supplied with treated syngas from the WREL
Gasification plant after acid gas removal. The gas analysis shown in Table 2 is
representative of the range of compositions estimated for the coal gasification plant.
When syngas is not available from the gasification plant, and during initial startup and
commissioning, natural gas will be used as feed to the fuel cell power plant.
1
DFC basis used for plant performance projections and design of equipment.
2
This wind load of 30 PSF is based on a wind speed of <90 mph and Exposure C. Exposure C is defined
as “Open terrain and scattered obstructions have height generally <30 ft” (American Society of Civil
Engineers standard ASCE 7-88).
3
Snow load is equivalent to a ground snow load of 40 PSF and a snow exposure factor of 0.7 (Uniform
Building Code UBC-97)
6
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
Natural gas can be used as an alternate fuel for the fuel cell power plant and is used in
the thermal oxidizer for the pilot and as startup fuel to heat up the plant. The natural
gas analysis for the site is shown in Table 3. The reference gas and range/limit data
are the basis of design for the equipment in the DFC power plant.
Inert Gases
Nitrogen, vol % 0–3 1.1 0.34-0.39 0.35
Carbon Dioxide, vol % 0–3 1.1 0.96-0.99 0.97
Total Inerts, vol % 0–6 2.2 1.3 - 1.38 1.32
Pressure, psig 15 – 20 15 15
Temperature, °F 40 - 75 60 60
4
Source “Power Plant Needs List” E-mail from Jeff Stockton WREL to George Steinfeld (FCE), dated
6/24/02
5
The Performance Gas Composition is estimated from the average of the range.
7
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
Municipal potable water is supplied to the plant to meet its process water requirements.
The data in Table 4 shows the range of water compositions that the plant is designed
for. The performance water criteria listed in the table is the basis to be used for
estimating the plant’s water treatment requirement and flow at rated output and the
WREL water is representative of the municipal water supply at the WREL site.
Properties
Temperature, °F 40 – 90 59
Pressure, psig 50 – 65 60
Notes: 1. Source: “Fuel Cell Power Plant Needs List”, E-mail from Jeff Stockton WREL to George
Steinfeld (FCE), dated 06/24/02.
The process gases, utility services, and control interfaces listed in Table 5 will be
required for the fuel cell power plant. WREL is responsible for line sizing, pressure
relief, and pressure regulation up to the plant interface location.
8
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
Process Gases
Utility Services
Potable Water
Electricity
Sewer
Flare
Control Interfaces
The WREL Fuel Cell Power Plant will be designed to operate on syngas from the WREL
gasification facility when operating on either coal or pet coke or a blend of both. During
periods when syngas is not available the fuel cell power plant can operate on natural
gas.
The design of the Syngas Preparation Unit is based on receiving a syngas from the
WREL gasification plant that has been desulfurized but can have up to 320 ppmv total
sulfur content. The sulfur is primarily a combination of H2S and COS and has to be
reduced to 0.1 ppm. A sorbent such as ZnO can be used to capture the H2S and the
COS can be either hydrogenated or hydrolyzed to form H2S, which can be captured by
ZnO. After desulfurization the syngas will be methanated in three stages with
intercooling. The resulting methane rich gas is fed to the fuel cell power plant.
The Natural Gas Fuel Preparation System will treat natural gas for use as a fuel within
the fuel cell plant as follows:
9
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
The Nitrogen Gas Supply System will provide low pressure nitrogen gas for purging
operations and protecting the Fuel Cell Stack Modules during Plant Shutdown/Trip
modes. The Nitrogen Gas Supply System consists of pressurized gas cylinders.
Additional nitrogen will be required for use in certain maintenance activities.
1. Collect the cathode exhaust gas exiting the Fuel Cell Stack Modules
2. Utilize waste heat from the cathode exhaust gas to
a. superheat the anode fuel gas, and
b. humidify and preheat the feed natural (or peak shave) gas
3. Vent the cooled cathode exhaust gas to the atmosphere.
The system includes a portion of the cathode exhaust gas piping to the Heat Recovery
unit. The Heat Recovery System will include an internal bypass to limit the heat
addition in the humidifier and thus control the exit temperature of the humidified fuel gas
such that the operating temperature limit of the downstream Preconverter is not
exceeded.
The Oxidant Supply System will also burn desulfurized natural gas in the pressurized air
stream to generate a hot effluent gas to achieve the temperatures and flow rates
required for controlled heating and cooling of the fuel cell stack modules during plant
startup, shutdown, and standby operation.
The Oxidant Supply System is designed to integrate the operation of the fuel cell
anodes and cathodes during power generation by:
1. Utilizing the residual fuel energy and sensible heat in the anode exhaust gas to heat
air to the required oxidant gas temperature, and
2. Recirculating the carbon dioxide generated in the fuel cell anodes back to the fuel
cell cathodes to support the cathode reactions. All components of the Oxidant
Supply System will be located on a single skid.
1. Receive superheated anode fuel gas from the Fuel Gas Preparation System and hot
cathode oxidant gas from the Oxidant Supply System,
2. Generate dc electric power for the Inverters by converting the fuel energy in the
anode fuel gas to electrical energy, and
3. Discharge anode exhaust gas to the Oxidant Supply System and cathode exhaust
gas to the Heat Recovery System.
The Fuel Cell Stack Module System will include two Fuel Cell Stack Modules
(containing four fuel cell stacks each).
Inside the fuel cell stacks, anode fuel gas will be reformed and electrochemically
reacted with the cathode oxidant gas to generate dc power according to the following
reactions:
The Fuel Cell Stack Module interfaces with the BOP process piping will be designed to
enable changeout of the Fuel Cell Stack Module.
Each initial generation stack module will be nominally rated at 1.0 MW (net ac) power
output based on natural gas fuel. The plant may be derated somewhat for operation
with a syngas fuel derived from gasification. The stack modules will be gas-tight to
provide environment containment at operating pressures up to 2 psig.
11
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
(1) Purify chlorinated municipal water for use as fuel gas humidifier makeup; and
(2) Provide a 10-hour service capacity of treated water for use during water
purification equipment outages.
The system is designed for operation with makeup water that meets the performance
water criteria in Table 4, and will be easily amenable to upgrades to accommodate
makeup water qualities outside these design limits.
The Water Treatment system is designed for continuous, reliable, and automatic
operation.
The Instrument Air System will produce dry, compressed air and distribute it to
pneumatically operated control valves and panel purges in the balance of plant (BOP)
equipment. Oil-free, rotary type air compressors are used.
The Electrical Balance of Plant converts the DC electric power generated by the fuel
Cell Stack Modules to AC electric power. The Electrical Balance of Plant contains all
electrical system protective devices and the distribution and control devices for auxiliary
loads.
1. The fuel cell’s cathode exhaust exiting the exhaust stack. Air emissions in the fuel
cell exhaust gas are nearly negligible. SOx emissions are essentially zero because
the fuel gas feed to the fuel cells contains less than 0.1 ppmv sulfur, and NOx
emissions are low due to the low operating temperatures in the Oxidizer and fuel
cells. VOC’s and carbon monoxide emissions are also very low.
2. The liquid effluent from the plant during normal operation includes
reject/regeneration/backwash water from the Water Treatment system. The quality
and temperature of the effluent water stream are expected to be satisfactory for their
disposal into a municipal sewer.
Solid wastes generated in the plant require disposal intermittently. These include spent
sulfur absorbent and deactivated catalysts. The spent material is collected in waste
bins prior to being shipped off-site. The Preconverter and oxidation catalysts are
suitable for recycle/sale to catalyst reclaimers. The spent sulfur sorbent will be returned
to the supplier for regeneration or disposal. Other intermittent wastes will occasionally
be generated, such as used lube oil that must be replaced per equipment vendor
specifications.
12
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
Rainwater or washdown water from the site can be directed to a stormwater drain. Oil
leakage beneath rotary equipment is contained to allow clean up during the regular
maintenance.
Note: (1) Values listed are wet-basis based on concentrations measured on sub-MW
scale DFC operating on natural gas. PM concentration adjusted for stack temperature.
9.0 Layout
Most of the plant equipment is packaged in modules or skids, which are placed on
concrete foundations. The skidding philosophy consists of combining equipment on
common skids in order to minimize the plant footprint, and reduce the interconnection
activities in the field. The plant requires a rectangular footprint. The plant height will not
exceed 25 feet.
The plant’s piping and structural interfaces with the fuel cell stack modules are designed
to be identical to those planned for all other megawatt class DFC Fuel Cell Modules.
An access zone capable of supporting the module transporter and the crane used to
install and remove the Fuel Cell Stack Modules and other equipment skids, and which
enables access for catalyst/sorbent/brine salt removal and replacement, will be provided
adjacent to the physical plant boundary. A laydown area will be provided adjacent to
the plant during construction.
The fuel cell power plant will first operate on natural gas then it will operate on clean
syngas supplied by the coal gasification plant. The design philosophy is to develop a
standard Direct Fuel Cell (DFC) power plant optimized for natural gas and rated for 2.0
MW, then determine its performance using syngas fuel. The syngas is treated in a fuel
preparation unit to increase the methane content. The plant can therefore use the
cooling effect of the endothermic methane reforming reactions within the DFC fuel cell
stacks.
A block diagram of the power plant configuration is shown in Figure 1. Fuel (natural
gas) (shown in dotted lines) enters an electric heater and then the cold gas desulfurizer.
The desulfurizer contains activated carbon beds to remove contaminants from the gas.
13
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
Low Temp
Desulfurizer
Syn Gas
Water Natural Gas
Processing
Unit
Fuel Cell
Modules
Water
Cathode Power Plant
Exhaust
Syn Gas from Anode
Gasification Plant
Preconverter
Cathode
Anode
Oxidizer
MO2788
Air Blower 42602
The desulfurized fuel is humidified and preheated using waste heat from the fuel cell
exhaust. The stream is fed to a deoxidizer (not shown in Fig 1) to remove O2 present in
natural gas and peak shave gas and then to a preconverter. The preconverter reforms
higher hydrocarbons generating hydrogen. The stream is superheated using the waste
heat from the fuel cell exhaust and fed to the anodes in the fuel cell modules.
The depleted fuel from the anodes goes to the oxidizer, where the unused fuel is
catalytically oxidized with air supplied by the air blower (shown in blue lines in Figure 1).
The exit stream from the oxidizer is fed to the cathodes in the fuel cell modules. The
exhaust from the fuel cell modules is used to supply heat for the fuel treatment
processes. These heat exchangers are located in the Heat Recovery Unit (HRU). A
catalytic polishing unit is also installed in the HRU to recover heat by oxidizing any
combustible gases that may be present in the cathode exhaust.
The plant also contains a startup system (an electric heater and blower) that is used to
initially raise the temperature of the fuel cell modules from ambient to about 150°F. A
nitrogen gas supply system provides low-pressure nitrogen for purging operations
during plant trips and shutdowns. A water treatment system supplies deionized water
for fuel gas humidification.
There are two fuel cell stack modules each containing four stacks. Inside the fuel cell,
the anode fuel gas is reformed and electrochemically reacted with the cathode oxidant
as to generate DC power:
14
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
The electrical equipment in the plant contains inverters to convert the DC electric power
generated by the fuel cell stack modules to AC electric power, transformers and
switchgear required for the plant. The electrical/control center incorporates a
Distributed Control System (DCS) required for operating the plant.
During syngas operation the fuel stream from the gasifier will pass through a syngas
processing unit that desulfurizes and methanates the syngas from the WREL
gasification system.
The overall plant footprint is 2935 ft2. The Clean Coal Fuel Cell Power Plant is highly
modularized, consisting of the Fuel Cell Stack Modules as well as mechanical and
electrical equipment skids. The skidding philosophy, combining equipment on common
skids, has resulted in a smaller plot plan. All components are designed for outdoor
installation and are truck-transportable to the site using standard or customized trailers.
Figure 2 depicts a 3-D model of the fuel cell demonstration power plant. This does not
yet include the syngas treatment facility to be built in two skids that will be placed next
to the fuel cell power plant.
There are four BOP skids, from left to right, the Fuel Processing skid, Anode Gas
Oxidizer/Heat Recovery skid, Water Treatment/Instrument Air skid, and the Power
Conditioning skid. Two fuel cell modules, shown in the cylindrical vessels, and a start-
up blower complete the power plant.
15
FuelCell Energy, Inc.
Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC21-95MC31262
The BOP equipment skids will be pre-assembled and tested at the fabrication shop
before shipment to the site. The Fuel Cell Stack Module will be assembled and
conditioned in the FCE Danbury, CT conditioning facility. Inter-connecting piping
between skids has been minimized in the plant design and will be fitted at the skid
fabricator to insure proper fit. The instrumentation and electrical components on the
skids will be pre-wired, with all connections terminating at junction boxes.
16