Bernard Magee's Acol Bidding Quiz: Number One Hundred and Thirty-Seven May 2014
Bernard Magee's Acol Bidding Quiz: Number One Hundred and Thirty-Seven May 2014
1. Dealer West. Love All. 4. Dealer East. Love All. 7. Dealer West. Game All. 10. Dealer East. N/S Game.
♠ 9 8 6 4 3 ♠ 8 7 3 ♠ 4 2 ♠ A 8 7 6 5
♥ 7 N ♥ 7 6 5 4 N ♥ A K 3 N ♥ 3 2 N
W E W E W E W E
♦ A K J 7 6 ♦ K 4 3 ♦ K 8 7 ♦ J 9 7 4
S S S S
♣ A 2 ♣ 7 6 5 ♣ A Q 8 7 3 ♣ J 2
West North East South West North East South West North East South West North East South
? 2♣ 2♦ 1♣ 1♠ 2♦ 2♠ 1♥ Pass
? ? 1♠ Pass 1NT Pass
?
2. Dealer West. Love All. 5. Dealer West. N/S Game. 8. Dealer East. Love All. 11. Dealer West. N/S Game.
♠ A K 8 6 5
♠ A K 8 7 6 5 4 ♠ A 8 7 6 5 ♠ A K Q 6 5
♥ J 5 2 N ♥ 3 N ♥ 4 2 N ♥ 2 N
♦ A K 3 W E ♦ 7 6 2 W E ♦ K 8 7 6 W E ♦ 9 8 7 W E
S S S S
♣ 3 2 ♣ 5 4 ♣ J 4 ♣ A K 8 3
West North East South West North East South West North East South West North East South
1♠ Pass 1NT Pass 3♠ 4♥ 4♠ 5♥ 1♥ Pass 1♠ Pass 3♠ Pass
? ? 1♠ Pass 2♣ Pass ?
?
3. Dealer South. N/S Game. 6. Dealer North. Love All. 9. Dealer North. E/W Game. 12. Dealer West. Love All.
♠ J 7 6 2 ♠ 4 2 ♠ J 8 5 4 ♠ A 2
♥ A K 3 N ♥ K Q 7 6 N ♥ 9 8 3 N ♥ A 4 3 N
W E W E W E W E
♦ A Q 8 6 ♦ K Q 4 ♦ 8 7 ♦ A K 9 8 3
S S S S
♣ K 2 ♣ Q 8 7 6 ♣ J 4 3 2 ♣ Q 5 3
West North East South West North East South West North East South West North East South
1♥ 1♥ 1♠ Pass 1♠ Dbl 2♠ 1♦ 1♠ Pass 2♠
1NT Pass 2♣ Pass ? Pass Pass Dbl Pass ?
? ?
Join Mr Bridge, the crew and staff of Voyager, as we cruise into Summer 2014. Enjoy duplicate bridge every evening
after dinner. On days at sea there are morning seminars and afternoon bridge sessions. There are also exclusive drinks
parties hosted by your Mr Bridge team.
Aboard Voyager, a friendly, stylish and comfortable ship, you will experience an award-winning Guest Speaker
programme and plenty of opportunities to relax, as well as visits to both popular and off-the-beaten-track destinations.
BRIDGE
Ryden Grange, Knaphill,
1 Bidding Quiz
by Bernard Magee
5 Mr Bridge
6 Bidding Quiz Answers
2 Cruise into Summer
on board Voyager
3 Subscriptions to BRIDGE
4 Cruise to Ancient
BRIDGE
Surrey GU21 2TH (1-3) by Bernard Magee Civilisations with
Make sure you
( 01483 489961 Voyages to Antiquity don’t miss your
9 Bidding Quiz Answers
[email protected] (4-6) by Bernard Magee 5 Denham Grove favourite monthly
11 Bidding Quiz Answers Filming Weekend 2015 articles by taking
www.mrbridge.co.uk
(7-9) by Bernard Magee 6 Croatia out an annual
shop: www.mrbridge.co.uk/
13 Bidding Quiz Answers with Bernard Magee subscription.
mrbridge-shop
(10-12) by Bernard Magee 7 Mail Order Form
Managing Editor Names and Addresses l Acol Bidding Quiz
14 Simon de Gautoy’s Trap
Mr Bridge & Answers
by David Bird 8 Bridge Event
Bridge Consultant Booking Form Bernard Magee
16 How Should You
Bernard Magee Bid a Freak Hand? 8 Bridge Events with l Ask Julian Pottage
[email protected] by Julian Pottage Bernard Magee
l Julian’s FAQs
Cartoons & Illustrations 17 David Stevenson 9 Better Hand Evaluation
Marguerite Lihou Answers Your Questions l Misleading Cases
www.margueritelihou.co.uk 10 Bernard Magee DVDs as reported by our
23 The Diaries of
11 QPlus 11 court correspondent
Commissioning Editor Wendy Wensum
David Huggett 24 Readers’ Letters
12 Bernard Magee’s l Ask David
davidhuggett Tutorial Software Stevenson
@mrbridge.co.uk 26 Mary’s Fifth Lesson
by Liz Dale
13 Bridge Events at l David’s SPECIAL
Customer Services Elstead Hotel FAQs OFFER
Catrina Shackleton 27 Diary of a Director PRICE
18 S R Designs Leather Gifts
by Richard Wheen l Mary’s
[email protected]
19 Duplicate Bridge First Lesson
29 Defence Quiz
Technical Consultant Rules Simplified
by Julian Pottage l Helpful
Tony Gordon 20 Genesis Choice
30 Declarer Play Quiz Conventions
Typesetting & Design Travel Insurance
by David Huggett and Related Quiz
Ruth Edmondson 22 Bridge Events at
[email protected] 30 Bridge and Travel Tips l Defence Quiz
The Olde Barn Hotel
Proof Readers 31 Julian Pottage 24 Bridge Events at l Tales from
Answers Your Questions Sherwood Forest
Tony & Jan Richards Clifton Park Hotel
Richard Wheen 35 Letter from Overseas by David Bird
24 Clive Goff ’s Stamps
Hugh Williams by John Barr l Things You
25 Rubber/Chicago
Office Manager 36 Fourth Suit Forcing Bridge Events Should Know...
Rachel Everett by Andrew Kambites
26 We Are Survivors Teatowel l Catching up
[email protected] 38 Fourth Suit Forcing Quiz
by Andrew Kambites 28 2014 Festive Season l Seven Days
Events & Cruises with Mr Bridge
( 01483 489961 39 Declarer Play Answers l Jeremy Dhondy
Rosie Baker by David Huggett 29 Tunisia with Mr Bridge
l Sally Brock Tip
[email protected] 40 Answers to 38 Charity Events
Jessica Galt Fourth Suit Forcing Quiz
l Travel Tip
39 Mr Bridge Playing Cards
[email protected] by Andrew Kambites l Readers Letters
41 Mr Bridge
Megan Riccio
42 Defence Quiz Answers Just Duplicate Bridge
[email protected] Special
by Julian Pottage 44 Bridge Events at
Sophie Pierrepont
[email protected] 43 May 2014 Blunsdon House Hotel Introductory
by Jeremy Dhondy
Clubs & Charities 47 Tips for Better Bridge Subscription:
44 Catching Up
Maggie Axtell
by Sally Brock
48 Cruise to Classical Greece £20 for twelve
[email protected] and Byzantium with
45 Seven Days by Sally Brock Voyages to Antiquity monthly issues.
Address Changes
( 01483 485342 See mail order
All correspondence should be addressed to Mr Bridge.
Elizabeth Bryan form on page 7.
Please make sure that all letters and e-mails carry full
[email protected] postal addresses and telephone numbers.
bridge cruises to
ancient civilisations
ROVINJ sharing
N
♥ 7 W E ♥ J 8 5 2-level. This means that your
♦ A K J 7 6 S ♦ Q 3 partner does not promise two
♣ A 2 ♣ K 6 5 4 3 spades, he could even have a
void.
You should consider re-
West North East South bidding 2♠ after a 1NT re-
? sponse only when you hold six
spades. Your best partscore is
1♠. With two five-card suits, likely to be 1NT, so you pass.
open the higher ranking suit.
Rovinj is situated on the western coast of Istria in Croatia, the largest You will notice that there is
peninsula on the Adriatic coastline, a one hour drive from Trieste, 2.5 no reference to the quality of 3. Dealer South. N/S Game.
hours from Zagreb. Boasting a rich, natural and cultural heritage with
beautiful landmarks such as the old town, the Golden Cape Park Forest, the suit and this is because of ♠ J 7 6 2 ♠ Q 10 9 8
N
protected islands and coastal area, Rovinj has many loyal visitors from all the age-old guideline: ‘length ♥ A K 3 W E ♥ 7 6
parts of the globe and has developed into a popular tourist destination. is strength’. You want to bid ♦ A Q 8 6 S ♦ K 4 2
The climate is warm and semi-dry, with more than four months a year spades first so that you can ♣ K 2 ♣ A 7 6 4
without wind. Such a mild microclimate is characteristic only to Mali find your eight-card spade fit.
Lošinj and the Brijuni archipelago. There are 134 sunny days in a year,
which makes Rovinj the third sunniest spot in the Adriatic. At the same You can have the auction:
time, it is the least cloudy place. 1♠-2♣-2♦-3♠-4♠. West North East South
Hotel Eden is wedged right between a peninsula covered by a one If, instead, you open 1♦, 1♥
hundred year old park forest and a quiet cove. The old city centre of then after 2♣ you will have to 1NT Pass 2♣* Pass
Rovinj is just a 20 minute walk away. rebid 2♦ and the spade fit will ? *Stayman
Rooms: All rooms are equipped with a direct phone line, LCD SAT be missed.
TV, mini-bar, safe, bathtub or shower, toilet, hair dryer, balcony, air 2♠. The key to this hand is to
conditioning/heating. Suites are available, details on application.
identify what your partner’s
Singles: There is a sole occupancy supplement of £10 per room per 2. Dealer West. Love All. 2♣ bid means. In standard
night. If you are a single bridge player, please do not worry about being
on your own. We will always be able to find you a partner and you can
♠ A K 8 6 5 ♠ 2 Acol, your system includes
N
always have a game. As well as there being other singles in the same ♥ J 5 2 W E ♥ 10 9 8 4 Stayman in response to a
situation as yourself, there is the Mr Bridge team who will be happy to ♦ A K 3 S ♦ Q 8 7 5 natural no-trump bid which is
partner you if required.
♣ 3 2 ♣ K Q 9 8 the first natural bid from your
Entertainment and excursions: In the hotel, an evening side.
programme of entertainment with live music and dance shows is available
Here, you made a 1NT
for those not wanting to play bridge. During the day and planned around
the bridge programme there will be excursions to Venice, Pula, Postjona West North East South overcall, showing a strong
Caves and Opatija to name just a few. 1♠ Pass 1NT Pass no-trump type of hand and
Beaches & Pools: The playful curves of the pool offer refreshment ? you should play your normal
in the summer with a salty breeze coming from the natural stone and system of responses: Stayman
pebble beach only a few steps away. The vast outdoor pool will cool you
Pass. Your partner has (and transfers if that is your
down after a day of lounging in the freely available deck chairs. There is
an indoor pool for invigorating laps or afternoon refreshments. Swirl the shown 6-9 HCP. With 15 HCP system).
aches away with massaging water currents in one of the hotel’s whirlpools. of your own, you know that Identifying your partner’s
Terms and conditions apply. there is no chance for game, bid to be Stayman means
Packaged with and bookings by Tunisia First ATOL 5933. which means it remains only you should respond by show-
to choose the right partscore. ing your four-card major: 2♠.
Details of the bridge programme ( 01483 489961 Although 1NT sounds as Your partner would then raise
if it should show a balanced you to game. ■
✄
Mr Bridge MAIL ORDER If you have not
contacted us recently,
PLAY SOFTWARE TUTORIAL DVDs NOVELTIES
please enter your
QPlus 11 NEW £92.00 ......... 2011 Series – £25 each Mr Bridge details in the box
Torch Pen (boxed) £5.00 .........
QPlus Trade-in £50.00 ......... Ruffing for Extra Tricks ......... below to re-register:
Competitive Auctions ......... Mr Bridge Pound for Life
QPlus 10 (S/Hand) £50.00 .........
Keyring £5.00 .........
Bridge Baron 24 NEW £69.00 ......... Making the
Name (Mr, Mrs, Miss)
Most of High Cards ......... BOOKS
Bridge Baron
Trade-in for 24 £35.00 ......... Identifying & Duplicate Bridge Rules ...............................................
Bidding Slams ......... Simplified £5.95 .........
TUTORIAL SOFTWARE Play & Defence of Better Hand Evaluation
Address ................................
Begin Bridge/Acol £66.00 ......... 1NT Contracts ......... Bernard Magee £14.00 ........ ...............................................
Acol Bidding £66.00 ......... Doubling & Defence Tips for Better Bridge
to Doubled Contracts ......... Bernard Magee £14.00 ........ ...............................................
Advanced
Acol Bidding £96.00 ......... All 6 DVDs Robin Hood’s Bridge Memoirs
as a boxed set £100.00 ......... Postcode ..............................
Declarer Play £76.00 David Bird £12.00 ........
Advanced 2012 Series – £25 each Bridge Adventures of Robin Telephone .............................
Declarer Play £81.00 Hood – David Bird £12.00 ........
Leads ......... E-mail ....................................
Defence £76.00 ......... Losing Trick Count ......... MR BRIDGE DIARIES
Five-Card Majors with Making a Plan as Declarer ......... for 2015 (end of June)
Strong No-Trump £89.00 ......... Please send a sample
Responding to 1NT ......... Red .... Maroon ..... £6.95 ........
Better Bridge 2011 with copy of BRIDGE to the
Bernard Magee. Special Signals & Discards ......... Navy ..... Ivory ..... £6.95 ........
following enthusiasts:
Spring Offer £35.00 ......... Endplays ......... Club Prices 10 for £35 ........
Bundleware Offer All 6 DVDs Luxury Kidrell Covers
Any two CDs £140.00 ......... as a boxed set £100.00 ......... & ball-point pen: Name (Mr, Mrs, Miss)
Ruby Red £14.95 ........
TEA TOWELS 2013 Series – £25 each ...............................................
Bottle Green £14.95 ........
Life’s a Game, but Hand Evaluation .........
Club Prices 10 for £90 ........ Address ................................
Bridge is Serious £7.00 ......... Pre-Empting .........
The Pot Boiler. A Double Splinter & Cue-Bids ......... SUBS ...............................................
Dummy Problem £7.00 ......... (Introductory Rates)
Avoidance
......... ...............................................
10 Commandments for 12 Months £20.00 .........
Bridge Players £7.00 ......... Pairs Play & Defence .........
24 Months £35.00 ......... Postcode ..............................
10 Commandments for Thinking Defence .........
Duplicate Players £7.00 ......... 36 Months £50.00 .........
All 6 DVDs Telephone .............................
25 Road Traffic Signs for as a boxed set £100.00 ......... 12 Months Overseas:
E-mail ....................................
Bridge Players £7.00 ......... Europe £50.00 .........
PICK ‘N’ MIX
We Are Survivors £7.00 ......... Any 6 DVDs £105.00 ......... Outside Europe £95.00 .........
Address..............................................................................................................................................................................
...............................................
E-mail ....................................
................................................................................................
Postcode .................................................................................
( ...........................................................................................
Elstead Hotel
Special requirements (these cannot be guaranteed, Bournemouth BH1 3QP
but we will do our best to oblige).
Holiday Inn
................................................................................................ Newport, S Wales NP18 2YG 21-23 Elstead Hotel
£245 Doubles
Please give the name(s) of all those covered by this booking. 20-22 Olde Barn Hotel 28-30 Blunsdon House
£245 Finding Slams £245 Distributional NEW
................................................................................................
Hands
Please send a non-returnable deposit of £50 per person per place by SEPTEMBER
cheque, payable to Mr Bridge. An invoice for the balance will be sent
26-28 Holiday Inn, FEBRUARY 2015
with your booking confirmation. On receipt of your final payment,
28 days before the event, a programme and full details will be sent
Newport, S Wales 20-22 Inn on the Prom
together with a map. Cancellations are not refundable. Should you £245 Doubles £245 TBC
require insurance, you should contact your own insurance broker.
Individual DVDs. £25 each. Individual DVDs. £25 each. Individual DVDs. £25 each.
Boxed Set of 6. £100. Boxed Set of 6. £100. Boxed Set of 6. £100.
l Comprehensive manual
£92
promise 10+, he can use a 1NT response ♠ J 8 5 4 ♠ 2
N
or negative double if he is not so strong. ♥ 9 8 3 ♥ A K Q 4
W E
So you know that game is on, but ♦ 8 7 S ♦ A 10 4 3
which game? You have a minor suit fit, ♣ J 4 3 2 ♣ A K 8 5
but would love to play in no-trumps if including UK post and packing
your partner has a spade stop. You can
ask him whether he has by bidding the West North East South
opponents’ suit. A bid of 3♠ shows great
strength and generally when you are bid-
Pass
1♠ Dbl 2♠
Pass Dbl Pass
QPLUS
ding minors, it asks for a stop in the suit.
If East does not have a stop, he reverts to
?
TRADE-IN
diamonds. Here, he is able to bid 3NT. 3♣. Your partner made a take-out
double on the first round, but you did
OFFER
not have to respond because South bid
in between. Then your partner doubles Return any QPLUS CD
8. Dealer East. Love All. again: showing a stronger hand and and booklet with a
♠ A 8 7 6 5 ♠ 2 pleading with you to show your best suit. cheque for £50 and
♥ 4 2 N ♥ Q J 10 5 3 Do not disappoint him.
W E receive wonderful
♦ K 8 7 6
S
♦ A 4 2 You must not pass 2♠ doubled: you
♣ J 4 ♣ A K 6 3 pass a take-out double only as a posi- QPLUS 11.
tive decision; if you expect to defeat 2♠.
Here, with so little strength and poor Order with confidence.
West North East South spades, you should have no such de-
1♥ Pass signs on defending. Instead, you simply
1♠ Pass 2♣ Pass bid your best suit: 3♣.
System: 8mb RAM, CD-ROM,
? You have shown no strength and your
Windows XP, Vista, 7 or 8
partner should simply pass: you will
2♥. As responder, when you are weak make 10 tricks in clubs, whilst the oppo- See Mail Order Form on page 7.
and your partner has not shown any nents can probably make 2♠. ■
Make your cheque payable to Mr Bridge and send to: Mr Bridge , Ryden Grange, Knaphill, Surrey GU21 2TH
( 01483 489961 www.mrbridge.co.uk/mrbridge-shop
System Requirements: Windows XP, Vista, 7 or 8, 8mb RAM, CD-ROM
Answers to Bernard Magee’s
Bidding Quizzes 10-12 on the Cover
would need to jump to the 3-level. cue-bidding. You do not have a control in
10. Dealer East. N/S Game. Here, your partner would pass your 2♦ diamonds (you might lose the first two or
♠ A 8 7 6 5 ♠ K 2 bid and you would finish in a comfortable three tricks), so your aim is to see if your
N
♥ 3 2
W E
♥ A K 7 6 contract. 1NT would probably scrape partner can show a control (ace, king,
♦ J 9 7 4 S ♦ Q 10 8 5 home, but you might outscore that by singleton or void) in the suit. You start by
♣ J 2 ♣ A 7 5 making 2♦+1. showing your club control by bidding 4♣
and you are hoping your partner will bid
4♦ – showing a diamond control, after
West North East South which you can use Blackwood.
1♥ Pass 11. Dealer West. N/S Game. However, this time your partner is not
1♠ Pass 1NT Pass ♠ A K Q 6 5 ♠ J 10 4 2 able to show a diamond control: he
N
? ♥ 2
W E
♥ A K 6 responds 4♥, showing a control in hearts
♦ 9 8 7 S ♦ 4 2 instead. At this point, you know slam is
2♦. Your partner has rebid 1NT, which ♣ A K 8 3 ♣ Q J 10 5 not on – there are two diamond losers –
shows a stronger balanced hand than so you sign off in 4♠.
the 12-14 with which he would open 1NT.
In modern Acol, the 1NT rebid is used to West North East South
show 15-17. With only 6 HCP, there is no 1♠ Pass 3♠ Pass
chance for game, so it is just a question ? 12. Dealer West. Love All.
of finding the best partscore contract. ♠ A 2 ♠ 7 6
N
Generally, when you are weak and 4♣. You have a strong opening hand, ♥ A 4 3 W E
♥ 987
have a distributional hand, it pays to try with a singleton too, so slam might well ♦ A K 9 8 3 S ♦ 5 4
to play in a suit contract. By rebidding be within range. 16 HCP + 1 for length ♣ Q 5 3 ♣ J 10 9 8 4 2
2♦, you give your partner the choice of + 2 for the singleton (19 total points) or 5
two suits and, hopefully, you will find losers for those who use the Losing Trick
your best partscore that way. You are Count. Use an ace-asking bid only if you West North East South
not showing any extra strength: two level have control of all the suits: if you do not 1♦ 1♠ Pass 2♠
rebids are weak; to force to game, you have control of a suit, then you need to try ?
Simon
de Gautoy’s
Trap
T
he Sheriff of Nottingham The session started and on the The Sheriff had rarely heard such
stroked his moustache. ‘Tell first round the Sheriff faced a local nonsense. He’d get a surprise, all right,
me, Gisburne,’ he said, ‘Have landowner and his wife. if he passed out 3♠ and missed a cold
you the slightest inkling of an idea game.
why this quarter’s tax coffers are so far Garside won the heart lead with
below target?’ Dealer South. Love All. dummy’s ace and drew trumps with the
‘Er, well, my Lord,’ stammered ♠ K J 10 8 4 king and ace. He continued with the
Gisburne, ‘Could it perhaps be that ♥ A 3 ♥K and a heart ruff, returning to his
your tax collectors have been unduly ♦ K 7 5 hand with a trump. When he played a
lenient?’ ♣ 9 6 3 low diamond from his hand, Gisburne
‘I doubt it,’ replied the Sheriff. ‘Not ♠ 7 3 ♠ 2 played the ♦8 and dummy’s king won
since the extremely protracted and ♥ Q J 10 2 N
♥ 9 8 6 5 the trick. Gisburne won a second
W E
painful demise of the last collector ♦ A Q 8 S ♦ J 10 9 4 3 round of diamonds with the ♦Q and
who exhibited that fault.’ ♣ A Q 7 2 ♣ J 10 8 then played the ♦A, surprised to see
The Sheriff walked up to Gisburne, ♠ A Q 9 6 5 declarer discard a club on this trick.
staring him in the eyes. ‘It is caused by ♥ K 7 4 Since a fourth round of hearts would
a failing of an entirely different sort,’ ♦ 6 2 give a ruff-and-discard, Gisburne then
he continued, ‘The total incompetence ♣ K 5 4 had to play a club. Declarer scored the
of my captain of the guard in ♣K and the game was made.
capturing Robin Hood. His brigands ‘You blundering oaf!’ cried the
have deprived my treasury of a fortune West North East South Sheriff.
over the past year.’ Guy of Hulda The Audric ‘There was nothing I could do, my
‘It’s not for want of trying, my Lord. Gisburne Garside Sheriff Garside Lord,’ Gisburne protested. ‘He played
Only last week I…’ 1♠ it well.’
‘You will have him under lock Dbl 3♠ Pass 4♠ ‘You thought that leaving yourself
and key by the end of the year or I All Pass with the ace-queen of diamonds was a
will replace you with someone who good idea?’ persisted the Sheriff.
can!’ thundered the Sheriff. ‘In the Gisburne led the ♥Q and down went ‘But if I rise with the ♦A, my Lord,
mean time, perhaps you can display the dummy. what then?’
somewhat more than your usual The Sheriff gasped at the strong ‘By the Saints, you continue with
competence at the bridge table. I was hand that appeared. ‘Only 3♠, she the ♦Q, what else?’ thundered the
not greatly amused last week, when we says?’ he enquired. ‘Do you play that Sheriff. ‘How can you be end-played
finished second to a couple of scruffs as forcing?’ after that?’
from the castle kitchens. I doubt they ‘My wife likes to have a bit to spare Hulda Garside smiled sweetly.
can even write their own names.’ for her bidding,’ Audric Garside ‘That’s why I bid only 3♠,’ she said. ‘I
‘It wasn’t entirely my fault, if you replied. thought 4♠ would be too high if they
recall, my Lord. Had you not ducked ‘That I do,’ declared his wife, whose defended properly.’
the first trick on that…’ flowing garment failed to conceal her A few rounds later, the Sheriff faced
‘Be silent!’ cried the Sheriff. ‘You capacious size. ‘Then my Audric gets the pair who had dared to outscore
made more mistakes than I would in a pleasant surprise when the dummy them the previous week. He ended at
a month’s play.’ goes down.’ the helm of this small slam contract:
West North East South
Will Guy of Alf The
Snyde Gisburne Nokes Sheriff
1♦
Pass 1♥ Pass 2♠
Pass 4♠ Pass 6♠
All Pass
‘Should you boys not be in bed at this continued with the ♦6 to dummy’s
Looking distinctly nervous, Will Snyde hour?’ he queried. ‘It’s past 8 of the jack, West playing the ♦3. East allowed
led the ♥10. The Sheriff won in hand clock.’ the jack to win, following with a decep-
and drew one round of trumps with the ‘Very witty, my Lord,’ replied Simon tive ♦7. Gisburne paused to digest this
ace. The best plan was surely to set up de Gautoy, who was close to six-foot development. If the ♦7 was a singleton,
dummy’s hearts. Against a 4-2 break, tall. ‘Mama has allowed us to stay up, he could lead through West’s remain-
this would require two heart ruffs in just this once.’ ing ♦K-10-4, restricting him to one
his hand. How could he achieve the ‘You must give my regards to her,’ trick. The slam would be made but no
necessary entries to dummy? continued the Sheriff. overtrick would be possible. What if
After a few moments, he spotted The players drew these cards: East had begun with ♦10-7 doubleton?
the solution, leading the ♣Q from his Then an overtrick would be possible.
hand. Snyde won with the ♣K and He could return to his hand and lead
returned a trump. ‘Jack,’ ordered the Dealer South. Game All. the ♦Q. Whether or not West covered
Sheriff. ♠ K J 7 with the ♦K, the ♦10 would be pinned.
The Sheriff ruffed a heart in his hand ♥ 8 6 5 Gisburne led a club to his ace and,
and re-entered dummy with the ♣J. ♦ A J 5 2 with a look of expectant triumph,
He then ruffed another heart with the ♣ K Q 6 placed the ♦Q on the table. The colour
♠K. After the ♦A and a diamond ruff, ♠ 10 8 6 5 ♠ 9 2 drained from his face as West spent a
N
he drew the last trump and claimed ♥ 10 7 4 2 W E ♥ Q J 9 3 moment considering his discard, even-
the contract. ‘Twelve tricks and I never ♦ 3 S ♦ K 10 7 4 tually producing a club. There was no
needed to score my ♣A!’ he exclaimed. ♣ 10 9 8 2 ♣ 7 4 3 way now to avoid two diamond losers
Gisburne looked in turn at the two ♠ A Q 4 3 and the slam was one down.
serfs. ‘You do not see fit to commend ♥ A K ‘You imbecilic berk!’ cried the Sher-
my Lord’s play?’ he demanded. ‘Speak ♦ Q 9 8 6 iff. ‘Play a low diamond to the queen
up or I will have your tongues cut out.’ ♣ A J 5 on the second round and 12 tricks are
‘Er… yes, his Lordship played it so guaranteed.’
well, I was stunned into silence,’ Alf ‘My Lord, not in front of these young
Nokes declared. ‘Rarely have I seen a West North East South boys,’ pleaded Gisburne.
better played hand.’ Bertrand The Simon de Guy of ‘You allow yourself to be fooled by a
‘Brilliant, I call it,’ added Will Snyde. de Gautoy Sheriff Gautoy Gisburne defender only recently out of the cra-
‘Best play for ages.’ 2NT dle?’ persisted the Sheriff. ‘No wonder
The session was reaching the half- Pass 6NT All Pass Robin Hood runs rings around you.’ ■
T
he official definition of a freak With Hand A, you do not really care With this stronger hand, you are too
hand varies. Some say any hand whether partner has spade support. good to adopt the same tactic. You
with a void or two singletons. Even facing a void, you have just one open 1♣ correctly. Should you now
Others say a hand with at least eight spade loser. With Hand B, by contrast, reverse into 2♦; after all, the hand
cards in one suit or eleven cards in two you might easily lose three trump comes out as only four losers on the
suits. Three-suited hands with a void tricks if partner is void. You would be losing trick count?
rarely present a problem. If partner much more inclined to open 4♠ with You should beware of using the
bids your short suit, you proceed cau- Hand A than with Hand B. With both LTC when you have not found a fit.
tiously. If the opponents bid your short Hands, you would expect the trumps You need to remember that you have
suit or if partner bids one of your long to play for no loss facing A-x. only 12 HCP and that you have a
suits, you will bid more vigorously. With a two-suited hand, it is usually void in partner’s suit. Moreover, as
important to show both your suits. the opponents have remained silent,
If you play in the wrong suit, which partner probably has a few spades as
♠ A J 9 3 is clearly a risk if you show only one well. It is highly unlikely that you will
♥ K Q 6 5 N suit, you may find yourself forced and miss game if you make a simple 2♣
W E
♦ Void S
running out of trumps. rebid. By contrast, if you rebid 2♦ and
♣ Q 8 7 4 2 partner’s hand does not fit yours, you
could easily go overboard.
♠ 7 On that hand, there were two
West North East South ♥ Q N warning signals of a misfit: a bid from
W E
1♦ ♦ K J 8 4 3 S
partner in your short suit and a lack
Dbl ♣ K J 9 5 3 2 of opposing bidding. A third possible
warning signal is if the opponents bid
West North East South no-trumps.
1♥/1♠ Pass Should you open 1♣ or 1♦ with this
4♦ hand?
The answer really is neither. If you ♠ Void
With this hand, you make a take-out pass, you might well get the chance ♥ A Q 10 7 4 3 N
W E
double of an enemy 1♦ opening, or a to make an unusual 2NT (or 3NT) ♦ A 7 4 S
splinter raise if partner opens one of overcall (if an opponent opens in a ♣ K J 8 2
a major. Conversely, if an opponent major) and show both your suits at
opened one of your long suits, you once. Of course, if partner is the one
would probably pass; if partner opened to open 1♥ or 1♠, you will know of the West North East South
1♦, you would make a simple change- probable misfit and take the auction 1NT Pass 3NT
of-suit response. slowly. ?
When you have a long suit, much
depends upon suit quality. When the Partner probably holds six spades (you
quality is poor, fit becomes important. ♠ 7 2 would expect the opponents to find
♥ Void N an eight-card spade fit if they have
W E
♦ A Q 8 4 3 S
one) and is likely to be short in hearts.
Hand A Hand B ♣ K Q J 8 5 2 Bidding 4♥ would be foolhardy. A
♠ K Q J 10 8 4 3 2 ♠ K 9 7 6 5 4 3 2 much better action is to double. As the
♥ 8 ♥ 8 meaning of such a double is, ‘please
♦ 7 3 2 ♦ Q 9 2 West North East South try to find my suit,’ this should deflect
♣ 6 ♣ J 1♣ Pass 1♥ Pass partner from a spade lead to a heart
? lead. ■
Can I Make 15
Tricks After
a Revoke?
Q Q
My partner, I would appreci- when opponents make a and ♥J would remain
Nick, and I ate your expert mistake you always gain. and lose to ♥Q with
were in 6NT, advice on the It is correct that when an no further penalty.
making 13 tricks, following at our club: insufficient bid is condoned I can’t find a section
owing to a successful then it has become legal in the yellow book or
finesse. There was an North South and the bidding continues. the blue book to cover
established revoke by 2♥1 4♣2 For all West knows, two this but could be look-
the opposition, which 4♠3 5♣2 kings might not have been ing in the wrong place.
gave us 2 tricks, making 5♠4 5♥5 enough for slam, but he has Was the ruling correct?
15 in all. Does this 1
Strong with hearts allowed them to play at the John Hamilton by email.
qualify for the Guinness 2
Gerber five level. He might just as
A
Book of Records? 3
2 aces well point out the insufficient It is true that the
Ann Roberts by email. 4
2 kings bid and let the penalties for Law book does not
5
Insufficient an insufficient bid apply. If cover this situation
A
Unfortunately not: he does not gain that is just directly, but since the ♥J
only tricks made West thought about life, but he might gain. was played prematurely, it
by the opposition the insufficient bid, certainly becomes a pen-
are transferred. Since they made no comment ♣♦♥♠ alty card, so the ruling looks
made no tricks, no tricks and passed, thereby correct in every detail.
Q
are transferred to you. condoning the 5♥ call. I would appreci-
West stated that ate your words ♣♦♥♠
♣♦♥♠ he was in a lose-lose of wisdom on the
Q
situation. If he asked following which hap- We have been
Q
When I, declarer, for the bid to be made pened at a pairs event leaving the bid-
played from my good, South could have recently. East was play- ding cards on
hand instead of changed his bid to 6♥ ing in a heart contract. the table until the first
dummy, the defenders ie a cold contract. During the play, South lead, but a new member
pointed out my error and North, recognising that led the ♠4. North and recently told us that this
asked me to play from 5♥ was an insufficient West (dummy) were is illegal and quoted
the correct hand. They bid pointed out that, out of spades and East BRIDGE as his source.
also insisted I play the since West had passed, was not. Dummy held Apparently it stated
same suit. Is that legal, he could still make a bid several trumps includ- that the cards must be
or can I play another suit and could correct to 6♥. ing the ♥Q. Before East put away immediately.
from the correct hand? Claude Stokes by email. called for a card from Shirley Etheridge by email.
Roger Francis, Burbage. dummy, North tabled the
A A
West has no idea ♥J, immediately pointed The new member is
A
No, the rule that whether 6♥ is mak- out as being out of turn. completely wrong.
you had to lead ing or not, so is The ruling agreed upon The bidding cards
the same suit from not in a lose-lose situation was: ♥J was a major are left out until the opening
your hand was abolished at all. Furthermore, there penalty card, East could lead is faced: this has not
about thirty years ago. is no rule in bridge that ask for ♥Q from dummy changed.
Q
The following If South really alerted her
hand occurred own bid when North was
recently. clearly unsure, then I think
that first the director needs
to explain the procedure to
Dealer North. N/S Vul. South and second the result
♠ A 5 4 must be changed since
♥ A K 3 the 4♥ bid clearly takes
♦ A Q advantage of the alert. I
♣ K Q 9 8 3 would change the score
♠ K J 10 7 6 3 ♠ Q 8 2 to 3♠ doubled 75% of the
N
♥ 5 W E ♥ Q J 7 6 time, 3NT 25% of the time.
S
♦ 10 9 8 7 2 ♦ 6 4 If, on the other hand, you
♣ 7 ♣ 10 6 5 4 meant that North eventually
♠ 9 alerted and said he was not
♥ 10 9 8 4 2 sure then there seems no
♦ K J 5 3 reason to adjust. South has
Q
called. He asked for a South held three
review of the auction, trumps: A-6-5. He
then asked North if their followed with the
system included transfers. five and six on the first
North replied he was two rounds of trumps, but
unsure and the director discarded on the third
ruled that the bidding round. Declarer (West)
continue. North bid 4♥, lost two tricks in normal
which made 11 tricks. play, including one to
The board was played the outstanding ace of
13 times, once in 3♠x, trumps, but North scored
by West losing 500, 3 him as making twelve
times in 4♥ making 650, tricks. Is that right?
6 times in 6 hearts for Tom Power,
minus 100, once in 5♥x Ardglass, County Down.
doubled for 850, twice
Exclusive to S R Designs.
A
Despatched by first class post or DPD Courier service for in 3NT by North for 690. Since the revoking
The director was recalled player did not win the
just £4.99 per order.
and ruled that the score revoke trick, but did
PHONE 01483 750611 should stand. Is the win a trick subsequently, the
or order online at ruling correct? If not what other side will get one extra
should it have been? trick as a penalty. Adjusting
www.bridge-tables.co.uk J Macleod, from eleven tricks to twelve is
Stornoway, Isle of Lewis. thus correct.
Q
Yesterday, we should say in the actual perhaps with a weak hand penalty or something else.
had this bidding circumstances. You should and a long suit, then So, ignore the bidding
sequence: never have reached this there is nothing wrong sequence, a take-out double
position. All four players are and the result stands. of a natural suit bid is not
West North East South at fault, since there is a duty If East got confused and alertable, any other double is
1NT 2♠ 2♦* on every player to call the did not know how to show alertable. Some people say
Pass 3NT All Pass director as soon as someone 17 points and decided to that means an alert says it is
*When the insufficient bid was points out the insufficient bid. bid 1NT because she did a penalty double: not so: any
pointed out, South changed his The correct ruling is that, not know what else to do, other double is alertable, for
bid to 3♦. since 2♦ was artificial, North then there is nothing wrong example an optional double.
must pass for the rest of and the result stands. What happens if it is not
Before leading, East the auction. If asked then In other words, there is a natural suit bid? Then,
asked North what he what 3♦ means the best nothing actually wrong in without an alert, a double
understood by answer is probably, ‘Since bidding 1NT with a void. is for penalties, whether it
South’s bid. What he knows I am forced to What could be wrong is if she is a double of an artificial
should North say? pass, presumably he is is playing a convention and suit bid, or any no-trump
1. The 2♦ was guessing that playing in did not let you know. If she bid. Above 3NT, doubles
a transfer. 3♦ is best for our side.’ bid 1NT because she and her are not usually alertable.
2. In our system, 3♦ is partner had agreed it would
intermediate/strong with ♣♦♥♠ be a strong take-out bid, ♣♦♥♠
long diamonds but not showing heart shortage and
Q Q
a weakness take-out. East overcalled he forgot, then the failure to 1. My partner,
3. I think he didn’t see North’s opening alert it is misinformation and faced with an
the 2♠ bid, transferred bid of 1♥ with you could get an adjusted alertable bid
and then bid 3♦ when 1NT, which became the score if you are damaged. from me, removes the
told it was insufficient. final contract. At the alert card very shyly
Antony de Fraine by email. end of the hand, the ♣♦♥♠ from the box, flashes
director was called as it as surreptitiously as
A Q
I never really East was void in hearts. If you open a possible for about half
understand why How should he rule? weak two, say in a second and replaces
players give rulings P J Evans, Wolverhampton. hearts, the next it equally quickly. This
at their table. The whole idea player bids diamonds translates as, ‘I know I
A
of duplicate bridge is that it is It depends exactly and your partner need to alert that bid but
controlled by a director, who what has occurred. If doubles for penalties, I really hope you won’t
is someone who is meant East mis-sorted her is that alertable? notice I have alerted it
to be helpful and who sorts hand and thought she had Martin Epstein by email. because I may not re-
out problems. Nevertheless, two red suits, so bid 1NT by member what it means
A
players create no end of accident, then there is nothing Yes and it has been if you ask for an expla-
alertable for many, nation.’ Is this legal?
many years. It 2. Also, if a player is
was decided several years slow to alert, perhaps
DUPLICATE BRIDGE ago to make the alerting
of doubles simpler.
through some off-
table distraction
Website: www.bridgetravelinsurance.co.uk
Genesis Choice
When commencing the online quotation please ensure you Clarence Court, Clarence Street,
enter MRB in the “Unique agent reference” box at the head Southend on Sea, Essex SS1 1BD
of the quote page. Be assured the site is very user friendly
Tel: 01702 34 34 96
and the medical screening process is all online.
Email: [email protected]
You can save the quote by entering your email address,
you can retrieve the quote or purchase the policy at a later Genesis Choice is a trading name of Acumen Insurance
date. The site is very easy to use and the medical screening Services Limited who are an appointed representative
comes in the form of multiple options. of ITC Compliance Limited, Financial Conduct Authority
Reference No.313486
Payment
Payment can be made by either Visa, Goodtogoinsurance.com is an appointed representative of
Maestro or Mastercard without any Ancile Insurance Group Limited which is authorised and
extra charges. regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority – No 471641.
Ask David continued was found later in had seen North’s ♥3 East seat. I was told
the card container. and, in her opinion, he that I must sit West and
The only explanation should not be allowed to North had to sit East.
is that someone had had change it, so called the At my usual club, I have
A
1. Whatever the only 12 cards and hadn’t director. As the ♥3 could been told that when N/S
reason for your noticed. North, being be seen only by East, the have to change to E/W
partner using the a rather competitive director said the trump they can elect which of
alert card in this way, it is type, insisted on was allowed and the the two positions they
illegal and you might get scoring 60 + 30 despite ♥3 was to be a penalty like, providing that they
adjusted against. If an our protestations. card. East was adamant maintain this position
opponent does not see it Apart from counting she was disadvantaged throughout the session,
because it is not shown better and being more and found it difficult similarly E/W can
properly, then he has not alert, what should to accept the director’s elect which of the N/S
been alerted and that is have happened? ruling. Was this correct? positions they prefer.
misinformation. It is better Dr C Godden by email. Norman Scott, Can you please tell
to alert boldly and, if Crook, Co Durham. me which of these
A
asked, tell the opponents You do not say views is correct?
A
that you are not sure. whether this was No. It is quite Norman Taylor by email.
2. Yes, calls may be rubber bridge or irrelevant whether
A
changed because of duplicate bridge. If it was declarer could see Both are correct.
corrected misinformation rubber, then once play is it: the question is whether It is up to the
[and that includes late alerts] finished, the deal stands South could see it. Not club whether they
so long as partner has and the card is deemed to whether South did see it: if it make such a rule or not.
not called subsequently. have belonged throughout was exposed to South but he
to the twelve card hand. was looking the other way, ♣♦♥♠
♣♦♥♠ So, if he has failed to follow then it cannot be changed.
Q
suit when he could have, But if, as seems likely from With three cards
Q
Please can you that counts as a revoke your description, it was in a left, I (West) led
advise when a with the normal revoke position where South could a trump to clear
card is played? penalty. In effect, the card not see it even if he was one from table and one
Is it when declarer is added to trick thirteen. looking, then it has not been from declarer’s hand.
has stopped touching If it was duplicate, played and may be changed. Dummy played the
it or when withdrawn then despite what North But it does not become a ace; partner discarded
from the hand says, it is dealt with by penalty card: it just goes and so did declarer.
although not shown? calling the director. In back into North’s hand. Declarer then took the
Cathy Graves, fact, in other respects, East might have been less last two tricks, the last
Tadworth, Surrey. the ruling is the same. upset if the director had one with a trump in her
Note that it would be read the relevant Law as to hand – hence a revoke.
A
Neither, actually: for different if it had been when a card must be played The director said that
declarer it is when discovered, say, three tricks from the Law book, and because the player who
the card is placed on earlier: the deal still stands then the director might have revoked had not won the
the table, or held stationary at duplicate, but is thrown realised there is no reason trick, the penalty would
above the table, or held in a in and re-dealt at rubber. for it to be a penalty card. be only one trick. Is this
way that is obviously played. Note that since East told right, given that declarer
♣♦♥♠ the table what card North plays both hands?
♣♦♥♠ intended originally, South Lona Finch,
Q
East was playing has a perfect right to take Waterlooville, Hants.
Q
We had an in 4♦. During the note of that information.
A
extraordinary play, she led a The revoke laws
misdeal recently small spade from her ♣♦♥♠ treat declarer and
when, on the first hand hand, covered by South dummy separately,
Q
of the evening, in a and the winning ♠K from Playing at a so it is a one trick revoke if
contract of 2♥, North dummy. At this point, different club dummy wins the trick and de-
claimed the last 3 tricks North (with no spades) from my own, clarer revokes. Of course, if
making an overtrick. was holding the ♥3 on the first round I was this actually cost the defend-
A moment later, North ready to play it, but then sitting South. At the ers two tricks, the director will
asked who had held the changed it for a trump, end of the first round, give them two tricks to restore
♣A. Everyone denied thus taking the trick. we had to change to equity; if there is no such
it and indeed the ace Declarer said she E/W and I sat in the problem, one trick it is.
Q
Can you of 4♥ over 1♣ or 1♠.
adjudicate In the modern style, single
in a heated jumps are often played as
discussion we are pre-empts, examples being
having? I maintain the weak twos, weak jump over-
term pre-empt refers calls and weak jump shifts.
only to the first call of an
auction. Any bid after the ♣♦♥♠
opposition have opened
Q
the bidding is an overcall My partner,
not a pre-empt and if playing in a
it by-passes a level or club contract at
levels, then it is a jump rubber bridge, ruffed a
9-11 May Gwen Beattie £179 overcall. A pre-empt is spade and then promptly
Overcalls an opening bid at the led a spade. I told my
three level, by-passing partner that he had
16-18 May Just Duplicate Bridge £169 two levels. If you plan to revoked. My LHO said
pre-empt 3♥, but then that there would be
6-8 June Bernard Magee £245 you have 1♠ bid in front a two-trick penalty. I
Bidding Distributional Hands of you, then surely you said there should be no
do not have to by-pass penalty as my partner
13-15 June Just Duplicate Bridge £169 two levels and bid 4♥ could correct straight
to show a pre-emptive away. However, my
20-22 June Bernard Magee £245 hand. Am I going crazy? LHO insisted on her
Finding Slams Alan Mansell by email. two pounds of flesh.
Warren Bagust, London W4.
A
27-29 June Just Duplicate Bridge £169 I do not know about
A
crazy, but you are As dummy, the only
11-13 July Just Duplicate Bridge £169 certainly wrong. irregularity you
A pre-emptive bid, often may point out is an
1-3 August Just Duplicate Bridge £169 shortened to pre-empt, is unestablished revoke, so
a bid which is designed to you were wrong to point this
29-31 August Diana Holland £169 take up opponents’ space one out. While you can warn
Rubber / Chicago without showing a strong partner against revoking,
hand and is based on good once partner has played to
12-14 September Just Duplicate Bridge £169 distribution. Examples are a the next trick and thereby es-
3♥ opening, a 3♥ overcall tablished the revoke, it is too
26-28 September Gwen Beattie £179 over a 1♣ opening by late for you to say anything.
Declarer Play RHO and a 3♥ response The opponents were due their
to partner’s 1♣ opening, two-trick penalty (one if de-
10-12 October Bernard Magee £245 though not many people play clarer won no tricks after the
Endplay & Avoidance
the last any more. These all revoke), whether you pointed
show weak hands with long it out or not. ‘Two pounds of
17-19 October Just Duplicate Bridge £169
suits. Usually, pre-empts flesh’ is a rather unfair way of
are double or triple jumps. putting it: your partner failed
31 Oct – 2 Nov Just Duplicate Bridge £169
Jumps to game level may to follow the most basic rule
also be pre-empts, though of bridge and you should
14-16 November Will Parsons £179
tend to be made on either expect to be penalised.
Doubles
very weak or somewhat This reply would have been
stronger hands since there is the same at duplicate. ■
28-30 November Just Duplicate Bridge £169
I
t was a lovely summer evening. was still in the shorts. Millie was not on which Millie discarded her last
The River Wensum was winding impressed. ‘If men’s knees were meant diamond and George a heart, then I
its way slowly through the city to to be seen in public, they wouldn’t be switched to the ♠Q. George played the
join the Yare on its eastward journey so hairy,’ she commented loudly and king and Millie won with the ace and
to the North Sea. Millie and I sat out- with some venom. Wisely, George did took her two winning hearts. Then
side the bar on the veranda sipping not react. I had a sense of foreboding; she led the ♠6 to my jack. I returned
our pre-bridge drinks. We were dis- the evening was not starting well. the ♠2, allowing Millie to make two
cussing and finalising our switch to The opening board was uneventful more spades, thus ensuring that our
reverse attitude signals on the opening but the second one had a greater im- side took nine tricks for plus 400 as
lead, whereby a low card indicates en- pact. I was West and passed as dealer. George’s contract drifted four off.
couragement. ‘It’s not often you walk ‘Could I have done better?’ George
past a jogger,’ said Millie right out of asked his partner naively. With two top
the blue. ‘What do you mean?’ I en- Dealer West. N/S Vul. tricks in both hearts and clubs together
quired, puzzled by the sudden change Sarah with the ♦A, the answer appeared to
in the conversation. ‘Exactly what I ♠ K 7 5 3 be overwhelmingly yes and dummy
said,’ continued Millie. ‘I was walking ♥ K 9 4 answered in the affirmative. Millie
here to the Riverside and overtook an ♦ 5 4 and I left the table to refill our glasses,
only-just-moving jogger and there he ♣ 10 9 8 5 avoiding the heated exchange between
is now.’ I looked round to see George, Wendy Millie our opponents that followed. Soon
still in his running shorts, heading ♠ Q J 2 N ♠ A 9 8 6 Sarah joined us at the bar. ‘George
slowly for the bar to quench his thirst. ♥ J 7 W E ♥ Q 10 8 2 should do better than that, shouldn’t
S
‘I hope he is not going to play bridge in ♦ K J 3 2 ♦ 10 9 7 he?’ she asked. Millie confirmed this
that outfit,’ I mused aloud. ‘If he hasn’t ♣ Q J 6 3 ♣ 7 4 analysis with a nod and a smile. On
got trousers with him, I hope he will,’ George our return to the table, a glum George
Millie responded with some logic but ♠ 10 4 sitting alone asked Millie imploringly,
also with some disdain. George ap- ♥ A 6 5 3 ‘I couldn’t have done better, could
peared on the veranda with his usual ♦ A Q 8 6 I?’ ‘No, no,’ Millie reassured him
pint of bitter and lemonade. ‘I thought ♣ A K 2 mischievously. As the director called
we had an understanding, George,’ the move, Sarah returned to the table
Millie announced rather belligerently. and their debate continued. As we
‘You don’t wear shorts near me and I The auction was straightforward: progressed to the next table, I refrained
won’t push you into the river.’ George from tackling Millie on the subject of
slipped quietly back into the building West North East South her meddling behaviour, but instead
as Millie remarked dismissively, ‘He’s Sarah George congratulated her on her first use of
the only jogger I know who runs slow- Pass Pass Pass 1♦ our reverse attitude signal, namely
er than he walks.’ Pass 1♠ Pass 2NT the ♥2. ‘What are you on about?’ she
As we entered the bridge room, All Pass inquired looking puzzled, ‘the two was
the director beckoned us to a half discouraging. I wanted an immediate
table. ‘You’re limping,’ noted Millie A club or perhaps a spade was probably switch to a spade.’ With Millie in this
sympathetically. ‘I’ve just dropped the usual lead, but as hearts had not mood, I decided, reluctantly, not to
the box of bidding boxes on my toes. been bid, I led the jack from J 7 hoping make any further comment.
They have turned red,’ he lamented. ‘I to find Millie with five cards in the suit. At the end of the session, we found
thought the boxes were red already,’ George won with the king and Millie ourselves back on the veranda over-
remarked Millie without any visible encouraged with the two using our looking the river, Millie with her tra-
hint of humour. ‘I meant my toes,’ new reverse attitude signal. Declarer ditional brandy and me with a coffee.
said the TD with some emotion tried the diamond finesse by playing The light was fading fast, but the cathe-
but maintaining his dignity. ‘You towards the queen and I won with the dral spire was highlighted in the even-
shouldn’t tease him,’ I chastised her. king. As instructed, I returned my ing glow. ‘Isn’t that a wonderful view?’
She just smiled and shrugged her last heart, won in hand with the ace. said Millie suddenly, ‘I like Norwich. I
shoulders. ‘Oh, he’s such a hunk. I can’t Presumably hoping clubs were three- like living here. I hope Justin will too.’
help it,’ Millie replied. I reminded her three, South then played ace, king and At that moment, I felt reassured and
that she was engaged to be married, another club on which Millie threw strangely moved. ‘Another brandy?’ I
but she just smiled and shrugged a diamond. After winning the third suggested ‘Yes, a double please,’ was
her shoulders. At the table, George club with the jack, I played the queen, the comforting reply. ■
Park
drive again. I am reluctant
LETTERS
to prevail upon friends and
associates to transport me
Hotel to any of the three bridge
clubs to which I still belong.
St Annes on Sea Obviously, it will also be
FY8 1HN sometime before I can
FLIGHTS TEMPUS FUGIT resume my regular dance
Can I make a plea through ...or a figment of our classes, jazz club and table
your good self to the imagination influenced tennis. Time now goes slower.
administration of Voyages by our changing However, that does afford
to Antiquity? I have booked perception of time. me time and opportunity to
to go on a cruise in July I was most interested catch up on my much ne-
and asked to go from to note (issue 131) your glected reading and making
Manchester. Yes – I am going comment on time flying far more use of QPlus. As
from Manchester but it is by as we age (graciously, if to be further punished,
to connect to a flight from of course), since I also I now have problems with
Heathrow and vice versa. experience this apparent rush that. Every time I switch the
Now I know there are towards the celestial bridge program on, I am directed
direct flights from our club. My theory goes like this: to enter a ‘password’. Also,
JUST regional airports to our As children, nothing seems when playing teams, I am un-
T
washers, tumble driers, electric
blankets, air conditioners, drip-dry elephone numbers had opener (responder). Alasdair points for game, ie 13+
clothes . . . and before man walked been exchanged by the again reminded the learners HCP and he has five cards
on the moon. group last week and that it is the responder who in the major bid. Responder
We got married first and then now Mary started to receive makes the decision on the is asking whether they have
lived together (how quaint can home invitations to practice. final contract. ‘Once an an eight-card fit in the major.
you be?). We thought ‘fast food’ Mary had surprised herself by opening bid of 1NT has been Responder is inviting opener
was what you ate in Lent, a ‘Big
Mac’ was an oversized raincoat accepting two invites during made, responder makes to bid 4♥/4♠ if opener has
and ‘crumpet’ we had for tea. We the week and, although it was all the decisions.’ This was 3+ cards in the bid suit, but
existed before house husbands, difficult to play without the emphasised again and again. if not, they have not got an
computer dating and sheltered mentor on hand, the practice The learners were left in no eight card fit in the major
accommodation was where you really did help. Not as much doubt – partner is in charge. and opener should just bid
waited for a bus.
bridge was played as you ‘If the responder has a 3NT, as partner has promised
We were before day care centres,
would have thought because balanced hand with no enough HCP for game.’
group homes and disposable
nappies. We never heard of FM everyone kept looking at 4-card major and 11 HCP, Yes, again everyone agreed
radio, tape decks, artificial hearts, their notes. The notes were he should bid 2NT inviting on the logic but said they
word processors, or young men invaluable but they did opener to bid 3NT (game) couldn’t guarantee they would
wearing earrings. For us ‘time take up so much time. if he has 14 HCP. The logic remember it. Alasdair said,
sharing’ meant togetherness, a
Revision of last week’s being that 14 plus 11 equals ‘Not to worry, if at least you
‘chip’ was a piece of wood or fried
potato, ‘hardware’ meant nuts lesson on 1NT openings, 25 HCP which should make could understand the logic
and bolts and ‘software’ wasn’t weak take-outs, Stayman 3NT. However, opener should you were well on your way
a word. and Stayman responses were pass the 2NT bid, if he has to success.’ Much laughter.
Before 1940 ‘Made in Japan’ repeated and repeated over 12-13 HCP, the logic being Finally, Alasdair moved on
meant junk, the term ‘making and over again, not forgetting that the partnership has a to the last group of responses
out’ referred to how you did in
the announcements. The combined total HCP just for responder. ‘If responder
your exams, ‘stud’ was something
that fastened a collar to a shirt mentors at each table worked below the 25 required for replies by bidding ‘stop’
and ‘going all the way’ meant tirelessly to ensure patterns game, so it is likely that if 4♥/4♠, responder is stating
staying on a double-decker bus to were learned and understood. opener bids on to 3NT, the that he has enough points
the terminus. In our day, cigarette Satisfied, Alasdair (teacher) contract will go one down.’ for game, ie 13+ HCP and
smoking was ‘fashionable’, ‘grass’
said that the learners were Yes, everyone agreed on 6 cards in the major bid.
was mown, ‘coke’ was kept in the
coalhouse, a ‘joint’ was a piece of ready to move on to the next the logic of this rule. ‘If the Responder knows that opener
meat you ate on Sundays and ‘pot’ two groups of responses to responder holds 13+ HCP has at least two cards in
was something you cooked in. the 1NT opener, those of and a balanced hand with no the suit. Opener will pass,
‘Rock Music’ was a fond mother’s 2NT and 3NT responses, 4-card major, he should bid confident that the partnership
lullaby, ‘Eldorado’ was an ice-
together with 3♥/3♠ and 3NT immediately. If responder has at least an eight-card
cream, a ‘gay person’ was the life
and soul of the party, while ‘aids’ 4♥/4♠ responses, identified bids ‘stop’ 3♥ or ‘stop’ 3♠, he fit and enough points for
just meant beauty treatment or by the partner of the 1NT is stating that he has enough game.’ ■
help for someone in trouble.
We who were born before 1940
must be a hardy bunch when After a 1NT opening, partner (responder) bids:
you think of the way in which
the world has changed and the
2NT = 11-12 HCP, no 4-card major.
adjustments we have had to make.
No wonder there is a generation Opener passes with 12-13 HCP, bids 3NT with 14 HCP.
gap today . . . BUT
3NT = 13+ HCP, no 4-card major. Opener passes.
By the grace of God . . .
we have survived! 3♥/3♠ = 13+ HCP, 5 hearts/spades.
Opener bids 3NT with 2-card support, 4♥/♠ with 3+-card support.
Printed in the UK on a
100% cotton tea-towel
4♥/4♠ = 13+ HCP, 6 hearts/spades. Opener passes.
£7 from Art Screen Prints
( 01287 654481
diary of a director
This month’s report takes the form of the diary of a newly qualified Tournament
Director, during an evening of bridge at the Erehwon Duplicate Bridge Club
7.15pm: called to Table 5. Am in- needing all the remaining six tricks finesse, so he led ♥9 to West’s ♥K and
formed that South (declarer) has, af- for his doubled no-trump contract: dummy’s ♥A, cashed ♣5 discarding
ter making the first seven ♥8, then led another spade
tricks in his 1NT contract, for a second finesse. This
conceded the rest. As the time West won the trick
other players were scoring with ♠Q and led ♥J for his
and discussing the deal, partner to overtake with
East announced that he ♥Q and take the rest of
did not accept this conces- the tricks. South then real-
sion. I thought this was ised that West had revoked
just East being kind to earlier and called me over.
South (effectively suggest- I produce the Rule Book
ing that South might, if and read out Law 64.A.2.
the hand were played out, As West did not win a trick
have made another trick or with his ♣4, the penalty is
two) but that was, appar- simply the transfer of one
ently, not the point at all. trick from East/West to
It turned out that South North/South. Bad luck,
(whom I did not know) South, but the result would
was a serial revoker and no doubt have been exactly
East wanted the play to the same if West had played
continue in case South re- a low spade on the first
voked and had to concede round of the suit, so he has
a trick (or two) to the de- nothing to complain about.
fenders, thereby defeating PS. As mentioned above,
the contract after all. West played ♥K when South led ♥9,
As the players have by now looked ♠ 8 3 2 so that when West won the later trick
at and discussed each others’ cards, it ♥ A 10 with ♠Q, he could lead ♥J for his part-
is too late to play the hand out. I leaf ♦ Void ner to overtake with ♥Q and win the
through the Laws of Duplicate Bridge ♣ 5 remaining tricks. On reflection, I am
(Laws 68 et seq) and can find nothing ♠ Q 6 5 ♠ 9 7 so impressed by West’s play that I de-
which deals with this situation. I ask ♥ K J N ♥ Q 4 3 2 cide to cancel the earlier transfer of
W E
how often South revokes. I am told that ♦ Void S ♦ Void one trick from East/West to North/
it is roughly every second hand (not ♣ 4 ♣ Void South (awarded for the revoke).
disputed by South). So I award North/ ♠ A K J 10
South an average minus on the hand ♥ 9 8 ♣♦♥♠
and East/West an average plus, which ♦ Void
seems fair. Memo to EBU: please con- ♣ Void 8.25pm: called urgently to table 17,
sider amending the Laws of Bridge to where voices are raised and clearly all is
cover this sort of thing explicitly. not well. Just as I get there, South (who
Declarer led ♠2 from dummy and seems to be defending) flings his cards
♣♦♥♠ took the finesse. On this trick, West at declarer and stands up, fuming. I
played ♣4 (it was tucked away among remember that, under Law 81.C.1, my
7.50pm: called to table 11, where there his spades), which drew no comment duties as director include maintain-
has been a revoke. The position was from anybody. From declarer’s point ing discipline, so (having come fully
that North (dummy) was on lead in of view, the discard was good news as prepared – my day job is teaching in
the following situation, with declarer he could take another ‘marked’ spade a boys’ public school), I whack the
1. ♠ J 5 3 3. ♠ Q 3
♥ Q 9 3 2 ♥ 10 8 6 2
♦ A Q 10 5 3 ♦ A Q 10 6 3
♣ A ♣ K Q
♠ A Q 10 6 2 ♠ A J 10 7 6 2
N N
W E
♥ 74 W E
♥ 4
S ♦ K 2 S ♦ 8 7
♣ K 9 4 3 ♣ A 9 6 2
DECLARER PLAY
QUIZ SMALL
by David Huggett IS BEAUTIFUL
(Answers on page 39)
S
♦ 6 5 4 2 ♦ A Q 6 ometimes your side’s Imagine that you have
♣ A J 10 3 ♣ J 10 8 4 longest suit is solid reached the dizzy heights
but you need to use of seven spades and West
N N
W E
it to get from one hand to leads the three of spades.
W E
S S the other. Often, this is the How do you plan the play?
trump suit, but it can be a You are going to need
♠ A K 4 3 ♠ K Q J 8 2 long suit, say a 5-4 fit, in a 4-3 heart break and a
♥ K J 10 5 ♥ J 7 3 a no-trump contract. Your 2-1 spade break, but even
♦ A Q ♦ K 2 low cards can be as impor- so you need to handle the
♣ Q 9 2 ♣ Q 9 3 tant as your high ones. trump suit properly. That
♠2 in your hand is precious.
Play a high trump from
You are declarer in 3NT You are declarer in 4♠ and ♠ Q 10 4 dummy at trick 1 (don’t play
and West leads the ♦J. West leads the ♥2. How ♥ A K 8 6 5 2 the two from your hand)
East plays the ♦7. How do you plan the play? ♦ 8 7 and ruff a heart high. Cross
do you plan the play? ♣ 9 6 back to dummy with a me-
dium trump, retaining that
N
W E
precious two. Ruff another
S heart high. Now, you can
cross to dummy by playing
2. ♠ 8 6 5 4. ♠ K 7 4 ♠ A K J 9 6 5 2 your two to dummy’s four.
♥ 2 ♥ K 8 2 ♥ Void Run your hearts, discarding
♦ A Q 5 4 3 ♦ 8 5 ♦ A 6 5 your four minor-suit los-
♣ A 9 8 5 ♣ A Q J 7 5 ♣ A 4 2 ers and claim your grand
slam. ■
N N
W E W E
S S
W
♥ A 7 ♥ A Q 7 4 hen you’re visiting a new city or country,
♦ J 2 ♦ 9 7 3 it’s tempting to stick to the well-trod
♣ K Q J 7 4 ♣ K 10 4 2 tourist routes and tick off the ‘top ten
sights’ recommended by the guidebooks. However,
when you can, try visiting the smaller sites – the
You are declarer in 6♣ You are declarer in 4♥ and quirky nook-and-cranny museums, the off-the-
and West leads the ♥Q. West leads the ♠Q. How beaten-track eateries and owner-run B&Bs. They’ll
How do you plan the play do you plan the play? present a truer piece of the destination’s identity
(trumps split 2-2)? and support small businesses.
Q Q
You say that Playing SAYC this and that both of your
you do not play (1NT opening ♠ J 8 5 3 four-card suits are poor, I
Asptro. What 15-17) when ♥ Q 9 3 suspect the winning action
do you recommend the bidding goes: ♦ J 8 4 2 in the long run is to pass.
instead as a defence 1♠-Pass-2♠-Pass-2NT, ♣ K 2
to a weak no-trump? the 2NT has been bid ♣♦♥♠
Esme Bailey by email. at the lowest possible
Q
level. What would the I passed and some- With a 6-card
A
Bernard and I point range be and one said that I should suit, A-K-Q-10-x-
both recommend what would it show? have bid Stayman. I x, opposite a
playing Landy. Caroline Villa, Pontarddulais, did not think I had small singleton, do the
2♣ is an artificial bid near Swansea. the right shape. odds favour a finesse or
showing both majors. Name and address supplied. playing to drop the jack?
A
Usually, partner gives You ask a good Bill Thomson by email.
A
preference between the question. I am not The idea of using
A
majors or, with equal sure that there is Stayman on this type The right play
length, bids 2♦ to ask the a standard answer. Since of hand (weak with depends upon
overcaller to choose. the 1♠ opening promised tolerance for three suits) is to your objective.
Many people playing a 5-card suit, 2NT cannot pass whatever partner bids If you are playing for
Landy play 2♦, 2♥ and mean that opener has only next in the hope of improving six tricks, finessing gains
2♠ as natural, which four spades. I would take it the contract. Some people against J-x-x-x onside; it
has the advantage of as 17-18 (maybe a poor 19) call this ‘Drop Dead Stay- loses to J-x or J-x-x offside.
simplicity and is what we and the sort of hand where man’. The classic shapes (I am ignoring the layouts
recommend in club play. you want to be in 3NT if re- are 4-4-4-1 or 4-4-5-0 where your play makes
If you would like something sponder has no ruffing value: (short clubs in each case). no difference.) Unless you
more sophisticated, you Using Stayman on this have reason to place the
can play Multi Landy. If you particular hand might hand against which you
watch on BBO Vugraph, ♠ K 9 4 3 2 improve the contract if might finesse with length
you will find many pairs ♥ Q J 5 partner has four spades or in the suit, playing for the
playing Multi Landy. ♦ A Q 5 four diamonds. It seems drop offers the slightly
2♣ is the majors, same ♣ A Q unlikely that a 4-3 heart fit better percentage chance.
as with simple Landy. 2♦ will play better than 1NT. If you are aiming to make
shows one major (like a One problem is that you will 5 tricks, finessing is best,
Multi 2♦ opening, albeit a ♣♦♥♠ not necessarily find a 4-4 gaining against J-x-x-x-x
bit stronger) while 2♥ and fit even when you have one. onside and losing only to
Q
2♠ show the major bid After a 1NT Partner will rebid 2♥ rather a singleton jack offside.
plus a minor (like a Lucas opening than 2♦ with 4-4 in the reds ‘Suitplay’ is a great piece
2♥/2♠ opening, again from part- and 2♥ rather than 2♠ with of software for analysing suit
a fraction stronger). ner, my hand was: 4-4 in the majors. Given combinations.
Q
Could I ask you sound club raise, it fits the Stayman, she would have you play double as for
whether an bill. If you bid 2♦, it may be bid 3♥ – fine, but if she penalties, you do not really
adjustment bid difficult to play in clubs. If bid 3♦ where do I go? have a good option. If you
indicates any strength? you bid 3NT, you run the risk Beryl Pattinson by email. have 3-card heart support,
I, South held: of playing the contract from you could raise to 2♥; even
A
the wrong side (if partner With some methods, that is a slight underbid.
has ♠Q-x for example). there is no perfect
♠ 9 4 2 solution. If you use ♣♦♥♠
♥ 10 7 3 ♣♦♥♠ Stayman, you risk missing a
Q
♦ J 9 6 4 2 5-3 spade fit. If you transfer I was South with
Q
♣ J 3 After partner and pass 3NT, you risk this 7-point
opens 1NT missing a 4-4 heart fit. If hand. We
and the next you transfer and then bid were playing pairs.
West North East South hand doubles, you 4♥, you risk playing at the
1♠ Dbl Pass 2♦ can redouble with a four level without a fit.
2♥ 3♣ Pass 3♦ weak hand asking Personally, if I had to ♠ 8 5 4
3♠ 5♣ for clubs. What is a choose, I would rather risk ♥ 9 2
rescue bid asking for missing a 5-3 spade fit and ♦ Q 8 3
North was disappointed hearts or spades? use Stayman. Perhaps if you ♣ K Q 8 6 4
in my hand. Doreen Parrington, bid 3♠ over 3♦ then partner
Rupert Timpson by email. Lancashire. will get the message that
you have five spades and West North East South
A A
Your 2♦ bid showed If you do not play four hearts, which will give 1♥ 1♠ ?
no strength. Partner’s redouble as natural, you the best of both worlds.
double forced you to you need to discuss After I bid 1NT, someone
bid. The same does not go this with your partner as ♣♦♥♠ suggested that I should
for your 3♦ bid. With a weak you have a choice here. have passed as I did
Q
hand, you should have taken If you want to make sure I am North with not have a stopper
the opportunity to that the doubler ends up on a balanced hand in spades. Do you
pass your partner’s non- lead, you can play everything and 16 points. advise pass or 1NT?
forcing 3♣ bid. You as transfers: redouble to Penny Blower by email.
had already said you clubs, 2♣ to diamonds, 2♦ West North East South
A
had diamonds, so there to hearts and 2♥ to spades. 1♦ Pass 1♥ The opposing
was no need to adjust/ Perhaps the more common 1♠ 1NT All Pass overcall means
correct 3♣ to 3♦. arrangement is to play you do not have to
that redouble asks opener After the play, someone respond 1NT merely to keep
♣♦♥♠ to bid 2♣ but does not suggested that I should the bidding open. Partner will
promise a club suit. You not have rebid 1NT get another chance to bid
Q
Playing Match then pass with clubs and because I did not have even if you pass. If you do
point pairs with otherwise correct to your a stopper in spades. anything at all, it should be
neither side real suit. The advantage Is this correct? to make a negative double.
vulnerable, North holds: of this arrangement is that Kerry Drew, Llanfilo, Powys. Bidding 1NT shows a spade
immediate bids (not via the stopper while the hand is
A
redouble) can show two When the opponents too weak for responding
♠ A 7 suits including the suit bid. bid a suit, it is 2♣. I thus advise passing.
♥ J 6 5 customary for a
♦ A K 4 2 ♣♦♥♠ no-trump bid by your side ♣♦♥♠
♣ J 10 7 5 to indicate a stopper in that
Q Q
My partner suit; this is especially the What can you
opened 2NT with case when you are over the use a 4♣ bid
West North East South 21-22 points. opposing suit. You expect the for other
1♣ I had enough points opponents to lead the suit. than Gerber?
1♠ ? for game and held 5 If partner has a stopper, it Dennis N G Law,
spades and 4 hearts. may be better to have the Nailsworth,
Lloyd Lewis by email. I bid 3♥ (transfer); 3♠ lead come up to partner. Gloucestershire.
A
Other possible uses Someone somewhere will consideration at matchpoints. Playing 1♠-2♥ as showing
are as follows: nearly always have underbid At slam level, you five hearts helps you to find
or reached some silly normally want to play in a 5-3 heart fit when one is
1. Natural: contract. Merely by making the safest slam. Having a present. You will not miss
your contract, you will beat trump suit often gives you a 4-4 heart fit because, if
You Partner anyone who has done so. extra options in the play. you respond 2♣, 2♦ or 1NT,
1♠ How big a risk you are 2. Without slam interest opener has room to rebid 2♥.
2♥ 3♣ willing to take depends or extreme distribution, Playing the 2♥ response
4♣ upon how common you you will usually just raise as showing five hearts
estimate the contract to be. partner’s 1NT to 3NT when is standard not just in
2. A control-showing cue bid: If you and your partner each your long suit is a minor. It Acol but also Standard
have balanced hands, no is often easier to make nine American and Precision.
You Partner major suit fit and 26 points tricks than eleven. If the Believe me, if everyone
1♠ 3♠ between you, it is a fair bet 5-card suit is decent, you plays something the same
4♣ that most of the field will be can reasonably add on a way, there is a very good
in 3NT. In this case, anything point for it and raise 1NT to reason and you do not want
3. A splinter: offering 60%+ chance of 2NT with only 10 points. to try something different.
an overtrick, you are going 3. In traditional methods,
You Partner to go for. By contrast, if you you jump to three of your ♣♦♥♠
1♦ 1♠ are in 6NT with 29 points major to show a hand with
Q
4♣ between you, it is unlikely at least game values and In the Acol
that other pairs will have doubt about either the framework,
4. A fit-showing jump reached the same contract, denomination or level of the is it practical
so you play the same at final contract. If you play and/or desirable
You LHO Partner RHO matchpoints as you would at transfers, you may have to play sequences
1♠ 2♦ aggregate or IMP scoring. other options in addition such as 1♥-Pass-1♠-
4♣ to the immediate jump to Pass-2♣ as having an
♣♦♥♠ three of your long suit. 11-18 HCP range?
Believe me, these come up For example, with a I am used to
Q
far more often than when you I have read that, 5-card major and a 4-card opener limiting his
would need 4♣ specifically as playing Acol, in minor, you might transfer hand on rebid.
asking for aces. If ever response to a into the major and then Jim Claricoates by email.
someone were to offer a 1NT opening, 3♣ and 3♦ bid the minor. If you have
A
prize for the worst bridge show slam interest and a 6- or 7-card major and The idea is that a
convention invented, promise a distributional a shortage on the side, jump to 3♣ shows
Gerber would be one of hand with about 16 HCP. you might transfer into the a hand worth going
the favourites to win. If you 1. Does this mean, ‘I major and then jump in the to game, which means 19+
play in a tournament or if am interested in a slam short suit as a splinter bid. points for 3♣. You
you watch matches on BBO in the suit bid.’ Or is it can, of course, take shape
Vugraph, you will hardly an expression of slam ♣♦♥♠ and suit quality into account
ever see Gerber in use. interest in no-trumps? and upgrade some 18
Q
2. Holding a 5+ card Why does point hands to a 3♣ rebid.
♣♦♥♠ minor, with 10 to 15 HCP, responder Moreover, some 2524
what should I respond? need to hands would better suit a
Q
In the absence 3. If I hold 16+ have five hearts to 2NT rebid (showing 18-
of any clues in HCP, with a 5/6 card respond 2♥ to 1♠? 19), so actually it will be
the bidding or major, how should I R Hemming, Poole, Dorset. rare for opener to hold as
play, at pairs would you show slam interest? many as 18 for the rebid.
A
just play for whatever Tony Mann, Kidderminster, One of the objectives Yes, once in a while, you
distribution has at Worcestershire. in bidding is to will have 17 facing 8 and
least a 50% chance, discover whether stop in 2♣. Of course, if
A
or if not, how bad 1. At game level, your side has a fit. A fit responder gives preference
a split would you you usually prefer in a major is particularly to 2♥, as will often happen,
guard against? to play in no-trumps important because major opener can show extra values
Stephen Down by email. rather than a minor because suits score more than minor by bidding again.
Q
1. With the 15-17 and responder 0-7. to the queen (2 points are unbiddable, so the
Losing Trick There will always be total), 2 doubletons percentage for slams
Count, I believe some hands that do not fit and a singleton. at the table would be
you should take off half a particular range. A small Is it reasonable to more like 5% of deals.
a loser for each trump minority of pairs play that bid 4♦? What should
over four you have a 1NT opening denies a partner do with 18 ♣♦♥♠
in the agreed major. 4-card major. Overall, most points, evenly
Q
Playing 4-card majors, people are happy to play distributed and After my
if you have six trumps in the occasional wrong no diamonds? partner opened
you take off 1 loser for part-score by opening 1NT Margaret Williams by email. 1NT, the next
the additional 2 cards. when in range to do so. hand overcalled a
A
What happens if you play If you play 4♦ as natural 2♦. I held:
5-card majors – do you ♣♦♥♠ pre-emptive in that
take off just half a loser? situation and you are
Q
2. Very often, I have My wife was not vulnerable, your 4♦ bid ♠ Q J 10 2
a 1NT (Acol) opener West on this seems reasonable. Partner, ♥ 8 7 6 5
and had I opened one deal: with a misfit, should pass. ♦ A
of a major would have In a tournament, few pairs ♣ K Q 10 7
finished at the 2 level would be playing 4♦ as
with support from West East pre-emptive. I usually
partner (making) when ♠ Q 9 3 ♠ A K J 5 play it as a splinter (raise to Should I double to
1NT does not make. If ♥ A K J 6 ♥ 8 2 4♥ with a shortage in ask partner to
partner has 0-10 points, ♦ 6 4 2 ♦ K Q 9 8 7 5 diamonds). Some play it bid a major?
they do not use Stayman. ♣ Q 7 3 ♣ K as a fit-showing jump Frances Freedman,
The trouble with opening (raise to 4♥ with a side Chigwell, Essex.
in a major is you do suit of diamonds). Once
A
not have a rebid unless 1NT (12-14) 2♣ (Stayman) you know partner has fair Some people play
you lie to partner with 2♥ 3♦ values, it is better to use the double as
a 4-4 shape. Is it just Pass these jump bids in a take-out, some as
tough or is it down to constructive sense. penalties, some as showing
hand evaluation? 3NT would have made a raise to 2NT, some as
Ann Mckellow, (clubs were 6-3 with ♣♦♥♠ replacing Stayman.
Stoke Poges, Bucks. the ♦A in the short club Other than ‘penalties’,
Q
hand) and 4♠ would Are there any the hand fits reasonably
A
1. Although I am have made too. statistics showing into the other categories.
not familiar with the What is your verdict? the expected However, for rubber
precise adjustment John Collins, number of slams, bridge players and some
you suggest, I agree you Welwyn Garden City. games and partscores duplicate players, penalty
need to be cautious about per hundred deals remains the normal
A
treating hands with 4-card It seems that East is dealt? meaning here. If you have
support in the same way playing 3♦ as forcing John Hankin by email. no agreement, the safer
as hands with 3-card whereas West is way to ask partner to bid
A
support. I often add half not. The important thing is Sorry, I cannot a major is to bid 3♦.
a loser for a hand with for the partners to agree. I think of any official Since an overcall of a
only 3-card support. play Stayman followed by a source for the 1NT opening is quite a
2. Sometimes, you will miss new suit at the three level as information. My experience, common occurrence, it is
a 4-4 fit in a major if you forcing, as I think do most assuming double-dummy worth discussing the
open 1NT and partner has people. In this case, West play on both sides, is a situation with your partner
an unsuitable hand for using has to find a further bid, split roughly as follows: before it comes up
Stayman. While you will 3NT presumably. True, East partscores 50% again. ■
not reach the wrong game might have bid 3NT over 2♥,
this way, you can indeed though that might not be so
find yourself in 1NT when clever if West had three low E-mail your questions for Julian to:
2♥ or 2♠ would be better. clubs rather than three low [email protected]
Note that you cannot diamonds.
E
very summer, Kitzbühel hosts a yesterday’s session (both played with Dummy (above) was everything I had
professional tennis tournament partners I had never met before) were hoped for.
and the Sportspark, the sports ‘interesting’. On the first hand of the The diamonds broke 2-2, so six clubs
stadium, is transformed into a mini- afternoon I held: made, with five spades also making as
Wimbledon for a couple of weeks. On the heart ace was over the king, and
the hill at the far side of the stadium, the opposing clubs split 3-0.
winding its way through the trees, is ♠ Void On the last hand, at game all with
the Streif, the piste on which the fa- ♥ 4 West the dealer, the auction started
mous Hahnenkamm ski race is run. ♦ A 7 6 5 4 one club, a one diamond overcall from
This year, the only British interest ♣ A K Q 10 7 5 2 my partner and one heart from East.
was Andy Murray’s brother Jamie Although I had only 10 points, I had
who was playing in the doubles with two stops in each of the opponents’
Australian John Peers. I watched After my RHO dealt and opened one suits, so I bid 2NT which partner
their second round match against the spade, I realised that my partner and raised to game and East doubled
number two seeds, which was a real I had not agreed what our jump over- rather loudly.
roller coaster for supporters of either calls were. Although I did have both
pair. Murray and Peers won the first minors, I felt that the imbalance be-
set 6-4 before losing the second 0-6. tween the holdings made 2NT inap- ♠ A Q 10 9 6
They finally won the super tiebreaker propriate (even if 2NT would have ♥ 5
(played instead of a third set) by a been unusual, another unknown), so I ♦ K Q 7 6 5 4
score of 12-10, having saved a match settled for a quiet two clubs, confident ♣ 3
point along the way. Phew! that the bidding would not end there. ♠ K 8 7 ♠ 4 3
N
In addition to the Sunday and Left hand opponent bid four spades ♥ J 4 3 W E
♥ A 10 9 8 7
Tuesday club sessions at Kitzbühel and, when that came back to me I ♦ A 3 S ♦ 10 9 8
bridge club, there is informal rubber ventured five clubs. The opponents ♣ K 8 7 5 4 ♣ A 6 2
bridge most afternoons. The venue pushed on to five spades and doubled ♠ J 5 2
varies with the time of year. In when I bid six clubs. ♥ K Q 6 2
the summer, the choice is the sun ♦ J 2
terrace of the Hotel Seebichl by the ♣ Q J 10 9
Schwarzsee lake. In the winter, rubber ♠ 7 3
bridge is often played in the cosy bar ♥ K 6 5 3
by the indoor practice tennis courts at ♦ K 10 9 8 West led a heart to the ace and a second
the Sportspark. ♣ J 8 3 heart was won by my king.
Just before Christmas, there is a I ran the spade jack, played a spade
mass migration from to the nine and, when
the four corners of both opponents fol-
Europe towards Kitz- lowed, I knew the
bühel and the num- spade suit was good
ber of rubber bridge for five tricks. I now
players more than set about the dia-
doubles. While it is mond suit while I still
great to see so many had a spade entry to
new faces, a new face dummy. The defend-
at a rubber bridge ta- ers could cash their
ble is an unknown, four top tricks, but
which can be danger- could do nothing to
ous – whether they stop me making this
are your opponent rather unlikely 3NT
or your partner. The contract and winning
first and last hands of the rubber. Phew! ■
About Fourth
Suit Forcing
I T
f three suits have been bid, Suppose East has Hand D after the he fourth suit at the two
it is very rare that the correct start to the Auction in A. level is forcing for one
contract has the fourth suit round only.
as trumps.
Hand D There are a number of different
Auction A ♠ A Q 6 5 4 approaches but the following is simple
West East ♥ 9 7 and practical.
1♥ 1♠ ♦ 9 7 6 If West makes his third bid at the
2♣ ? ♣ A J 9 two level, it can be passed. Suppose the
auction starts thus.
T
he time you need to bid (like D) unbiddable. (Some people might have raised the
the fourth suit is when you So what should West do if East 1♠ response to 2♠ in preference to
haven’t got values there. continues Auction A with 2♦? rebidding 2♣).
T
♠ K 4 ♠ K 7 2 he fourth suit at the one Hand R Hand S
♥ A Q 8 7 6 2 ♥ A Q 8 7 6 level is usually played as ♠ A Q 10 8 5 4 ♠ A Q 8 7 2
♦ 8 ♦ 9 natural and forcing. ♥ 8 ♥ 8
♣ A Q 7 6 ♣ A Q 6 5 ♦ A 7 3 ♦ A 7 3
There is only one such sequence: ♣ A 4 3 ♣ A Q 4 2
West East
Hand L Hand M 1♣ 1♦ With Hand R, it might seem OK to
♠ 7 ♠ K 8 1♥ 1♠ jump to 3♠, however that bid is not
♥ A Q 8 7 6 ♥ A 10 7 6 5 forcing. The solution is to bid 2♦
♦ A J 9 ♦ 7 In this sort of sequence, West may be (fourth suit forcing) and plan to rebid
♣ A 10 6 5 ♣ A K J 5 2 4-4-1-4 shape so finding a fit in the 3♠ or raise 2♠ to 4♠.
fourth suit may be crucial. With Hand S, you want to support
If responder wants to use fourth clubs, but no immediate club bid does
With Hand J, West’s jump shows his suit forcing, he jumps to 2♠, justice to this hand. Again, you can
six hearts: 3♥: game forcing. ie 1♣-1♦-1♥-2♠. show strength by starting with 2♦ and
With Hand K, West shows his 3-card Here, we see an example of finding a continuing with the lowest legal bid in
spade support: 3♠: game forcing. fit in the fourth suit. clubs.
With Hand L, West shows his
diamond stopper: 3NT. This use is rare and somewhat
With Hand M, West shows his fifth Layout P more sophisticated than normal
club: 3♣: game forcing. ♠ K J 8 7 ♠ A Q 4 2 use of fourth suit forcing. I would
♥ A 9 3 2 N ♥ Q 4 recommend that you fully master the
W E
By the time East has bid ‘fourth suit ♦ 8 S ♦ A 7 6 3 2 first five points of this article before
forcing’ and West has made his third ♣ K J 6 5 ♣ Q 3 trying it.
bid, East is likely to know everything
there is to know about West’s hand ♣♦♥♠
and should be able to decide upon the West East
T
final contract. 1♣ 1♦ he use of fourth suit forc-
However, occasionally investigation 1♥ 1♠1 ing should be alerted as it
is needed and the general principle 2♠2 4♠ is a conventional bid.
is that if anybody bids at the three
level, the auction becomes game 1
Natural: four spades. As always, it is the partner of the
forcing. 2
Minimum with four spades. conventional bidder who alerts. ■
Hand R: 3♥.
10-12 October £199
Blunsdon House Hotel
Show your fifth heart.
Dealer East. North/South Vul.
♠ Q 10 8 5 2
Friday site, etc.
After breakfast, the bridge starts. We
♥ 7 3 I have lunch in London with old are playing Swiss teams with Richard
♦ J 7 6 schoolfriends, Clarissa and Julia. We and Gerry. We start well with a 20-0
♣ A 9 3 go to Bistro 1 in Covent Garden and win, helped partly by our first board:
♠ J 4 ♠ K 9 7 6 3 have an excellent meal for very little.
N
♥ 10 8 6 4 2 W E ♥ J Then I go back to Shepherds Bush.
♦ 8 4 S ♦ Q 3 2 The plan was to drive back to High Dealer East. Love All.
♣ K Q J 10 ♣ 8 7 6 5 Wycombe, but Barry has some work ♠ J 10
♠ A to do before he can leave and I’m keen ♥ A 9 7 5 3
♥ A K Q 9 5 to get back. He offers me his car but ♦ Void
♦ A K 10 9 5 in the rush hour the train is the better ♣ K Q 8 7 3 2
♣ 4 2 option. ♠ Q 9 7 6 3 ♠ A K 8
N
Briony picks me up from the station ♥ K J 10 4 2 W E ♥ Q 8
and we head for home. We both had ♦ 10 2 S ♦ K Q 8 7 6 5
After East passes, I open one heart with big lunches so all we do is graze a bit ♣ 5 ♣ A 6
my monster and Andrew has to find for dinner. She is spending lots of ♠ 5 4 2
something exciting to do at favourable time researching her trip, getting a lot ♥ 6
vulnerability facing a passed partner. of conflicting information on India. ♦ A J 9 4 3
He chooses to overcall three clubs! We’re hoping her passport comes back ♣ J 10 9 4
My partner passes and East raises to soon so she can get off.
four clubs. Perhaps I should just bid a
simple four diamonds but it needs so When there is a lot of distribution
little from partner for eleven tricks in
a red suit, so I jump to five diamonds Saturday flying around, it often pays to keep
on bidding. Even if you are wrong in
which ends the auction. Barry turns up at about 10am and the theory, you may be right in practice.
Robson leads a top club which I win three of us head off north. First stop Here, according to Deep Finesse, the
in the dummy and play a diamond to is Nottingham for lunch with friends. analysis program, four spades goes
my ten. I now play two top hearts and Then further north. down: ace of hearts, heart ruff, ace
when East ruffs the second and plays a Barry and I are heading for York. of diamonds, diamond ruff. And
club, I am down. Briony drops us off at the Park Inn and five clubs loses the obvious three top
Perhaps I should have taken East’s then goes back to Bradford to spend tricks. But …
jack of hearts seriously (instead I took the next 24 hours with Toby. They At our team-mates’ table, the
Robson’s three club overcall seriously). book into a Holiday Inn, order room bidding is:
If I change tack here and draw trumps service and watch movies together.
instead (still making my contract Barry and I are there to play bridge West North East South
when hearts are 4-2 or better), I can tomorrow. 1♦ Pass
play another top heart and discover First we meet up with friends and 1♠ Pass 2NT Pass
the bad break. Now, because Robson have a drink. We go out to dinner with 4♥ Pass 4♠ All Pass
holds all the clubs higher than the Ben’s girlfriend Dana who is a non-
nine, I can succeed. I simply play off bridge player. With difficulty we find Their North does not find the ace of
the rest of my trumps. Robson can’t an Italian restaurant that is not full hearts lead and four spades makes
afford to throw a heart; if he discards and have a pleasant meal, discussing easily enough.
anything else, I can throw him in with this and that. At our table, this was the auction:
a club (he will have had to discard one We wander back to the hotel just
of his spades), having first cashed the about when the bridge is finishing. West North East South
ace of spades, forcing him to lead into Now is the time to hear the sob stories 1♦ Pass
my heart tenace at the end. and talk about the hands. It’s a late 1♠ 2NT* 4♠ 5♣
It is a really enjoyable evening, night but fun all the same. Pass Pass Dbl All Pass
CRUISE TO CLASSICAL
AUG 7 CORFU Greek Islands midnight 2.00pm
AUG 8 DUBROVNIK Croatia 8.00am 2.00pm
Cruise the islands of Hvar and Korcula
BYZANTIUM
Disembark Aegean Odyssey and
transfer to Venice Airport for flight home
Join Bernard Magee on this unforgettable fares from just £1,995pp include:
summer bridge voyage from Istanbul to Venice •SCHEDULED FLIGHTS
•EXPERTLY PLANNED ITINERARIES
Departs July 30, 2014 •SHORE EXCURSIONS IN MOST PORTS OF CALL
Enjoy daily duplicate as you cruise to the classical •EXPERT ANTIQUITY GUEST SPEAKERS
sites of the Aegean, Dalmatia and the treasures of •WINE WITH DINNER ON BOARD
Byzantium and Venice. •OPEN-SEATING DINING
•GRATUITIES ON BOARD
• EXCLUSIVE MR BRIDGE COCKTAIL PARTY
•DAILY BRIDGE
MR BRIDGE GREAT VALUE FARES
CAT M Standard Inside £1,995pp
CAT J Standard Outside £2,450pp
CAT D Deluxe Balcony £3,450pp
V OYAGES TO A NTIQUITY
10093
ABTA No.Y2206