Sbti Call To Action Guidelines: Twg-Inf-004 - Version 1.6 April 2020
Sbti Call To Action Guidelines: Twg-Inf-004 - Version 1.6 April 2020
2
1. About the Science Based Targets initiative
The Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) champions science-based target setting as a powerful way of
boosting companies’ competitive advantage in the transition to the low-carbon economy. It is a
collaboration between CDP, World Resources Institute (WRI), the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF),
and the United Nations Global Compact (UNGC) and one of the We Mean Business Coalition
commitments. The initiative defines and promotes best practice in science-based target setting, offers
resources and guidance to reduce barriers to adoption, and independently assesses and approves
companies’ targets. Learn more about the SBTi on our website.
3
Benefits of joining the SBTi Call to Action
The SBTi defines and promotes best practice in science-based target setting and offers resources and
guidance to reduce barriers to adoption. The initiative is backed by four of the most prestigious
environmental organizations: CDP, UNGC, WRI and WWF. Through the initiative, these partner
organizations conduct a comprehensive quality assessment of the targets and provide multiple
opportunities to showcase approved targets.
4
Company SBTi
Fill out the relevant commitment letter
and send it to SBTi sends a confirmation e-mail
commitments@[Link] together with a Comms Welcome Pack
If needed, Lead Reviewer asks company 3. Desk review: Lead Reviewer performs
for clarifications / missing information the desk review to assess the targets
using query log against the SBTi crtieria
If needed, Lead Reviewer asks company 5. TVT discussion: Target Validation Team
for clarifications / missing information discusses the target and the desk review
using query log done by the Lead Reviewer
5
Step 1: Commit to set a science-based target
How to commit
Companies that wish to commit to set a science-based target should review and complete the
commitment letter and send it to commitments@[Link]. Signing the commitment
letter indicates that your company will work to set a science-based emissions reduction target aligned
with the Science Based Targets initiative’s Criteria, wherein there are two available temperature ambition
pathways, well-below 2°C and 1.5°C.
Please note that the commitment letter outlines a separate process for the oil and gas sector and financial
institutions due to the unique nature of these sectors (please see the commitment letter for a definition
of these sectors).
Oil and gas sector
The method for assessing oil and gas impacts and targets is being developed. Therefore, we cannot yet
review or approve any targets submitted by oil and gas companies. In the interim, we invite such
companies to publicly commit to setting science-based scope 1, 2 and 3 targets when a methodology is
available by signing the commitment letter. We will also invite all committed oil and gas companies to
participate in the consultation process for the method being developed. Once a target setting method is
finalized, all committed oil and gas companies will be notified and asked to develop and submit their
targets for validation, get them approved and published within two years.
For the purposes of the target validation by the SBTi, “Oil & Gas” includes, but is not limited to, integrated
Oil & Gas companies, Integrated Gas companies, Exploration & Production Pure Players, Refining and
Marketing Pure Players, Oil Products Distributors, Gas Distribution and Gas Retailers. The SBTi will assess
companies on a case-by-case basis to determine whether companies will be classified as Oil & Gas
companies for the purpose of SBTi validation, and if so, reserve the right to not move forward with their
validation until after the SBTi Oil & Gas sector development has been completed.
Financial institutions
The method for assessing financial institutions’ scope 3 impacts against a well-below-2°C emissions
trajectory is still being developed. Therefore, we cannot yet review or approve any targets submitted by
financial institutions. In the interim, we invite such institutions to publicly commit to setting science-based
scope 1, 2 and 3 targets when a methodology is available by signing the commitment letter. We will also
invite all committed financial institutions to participate in any process to develop target setting methods
for the sector. Once a target setting method is finalized, all committed financial institutions will be notified
and asked to develop and submit their targets for validation, get them approved and published within two
years.
1
Please note that the above infographic does not apply to the target validation route specifically for Small and Medium Enterprises. For more
information please see page 12-13 of this document.
6
Small and Medium Enterprises
Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are not required to sign the standard commitment letter but they
should use the “Target Setting Letter” specifically designed for SMEs. To learn more on the definition of
SMEs and the target setting process, consult the section entitled “Small and Medium Enterprises” on page
12 of this document.
Business Ambition for 1.5°C
Companies are urged to aim for the highest level of ambition in their targets setting. The SBTi encourages
companies to join the Business Ambition for 1.5°C Call to Action by signing the Business Ambition for 1.5°C
Commitment Letter that indicates your intention to align your emissions reduction targets to 1.5°C. For
companies not currently committed to the SBTi, the Business Ambition for 1.5°C Commitment Letter
constitutes as your commitment to develop and submit emissions reduction targets aligned with the SBTi
criteria.
We Mean Business
We Mean Business, a coalition of organizations working with thousands of the world’s most influential
businesses and investors, provides a platform for businesses and investors to be recognized for their
climate action. Through the We Mean Business campaign, companies can commit to setting science-
based targets as well as other actions such as procure 100% of electricity from renewable sources or
put a price on carbon. By default, companies that commit to the Science Based Targets initiative count
towards the We Mean Business Campaign. However, companies that commit to set science-based
targets through the We Mean Business Commit to Action Campaign are required to sign the SBTi
commitment letter to be formally recognized by the initiative.
Companies that have already committed to other closely related We Mean Business initiatives such as
RE100 or EP100 are likely well-suited to set a science-based target. Likewise, those committed to
science-based targets should consider how committing to 100% renewable power or improving their
energy productivity would support their emission reduction efforts.
Benefits of committing
Signing the commitment letter indicates that the company will work towards setting a science-based
emission reduction target. If the company already has an emissions reduction target, the letter confirms
its interest in having its existing targets verified against a set of criteria developed by the SBTi or
developing new targets that will align with these criteria.
After a company submits its commitment letter (either the general commitment letter or the Business
Ambition for 1.5°C Commitment Letter) to commitments@[Link], it will be recognized
as “Committed” on our Companies Taking Action webpage, as well as the We Mean Business and CDP
websites. Companies who are engaging in the UN Global Compact will also be recognized on their
website. The list of committed companies is updated every week. Companies that have committed will
7
receive a “Communications Welcome Pack” with more information on how to communicate their
commitment.
CDP Questionnaire
Companies can also be recognized for their science-based target setting efforts through the CDP
disclosure platform. CDP considers targets approved by the initiative to reflect best practices in
science-based target setting. Accordingly, CDP is incentivizing the adoption of science-based targets
in its Climate Change Questionnaire. Targets approved by the SBTi earn leadership points, which are
the highest scoring level in the questionnaire. For further information, please see CDP’s Technical
Note. Targets need to be submitted by June 15th, 2020 in order to count for CDP leadership points
should the target be approved.
8
SBTi criteria and recommendations
Targets must meet all the SBTi criteria in order to be approved. The criteria and recommendations were
developed using the GHG accounting and mitigation expertise of the SBTi’s partner organizations, with
support from the SBTi’s Technical Advisory Group. Note that the SBTi criteria will be updated on an annual
basis as per the timeline below as begun in 2019. Companies should make sure they are using the latest
version of the criteria when developing their targets. Please see the timeline for 2020 below.
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Criteria V4.0 effective Criteria V4.0 and V4.1 effective Criteria V4.1 effective
Grace period for revised criteria SBTi develops improvements to the criteria
from April 15th, 2020 to July 14th,
2
2020
9
Targets do not necessarily have to be developed using one of the listed science-based target setting
methods on our website as long as they meet all the SBTi criteria. However, if the target was developed
using a recognized or recommended method, it should be noted in the Target Submission Form to help in
the target validation process.
Target Submission - Entire submission form must be completed, unless seeking feedback on specific
Form scopes.
10
Reviewed by - TVT, and if needed TWG or SC
Validity of decision - Approved targets modelled with an old version of tool(s)/method(s) are valid
only within six months after the issuance date of the most recent
tool(s)/method(s). After that period, the targets must be recalculated using the
new tool/method.
Communications - Companies are assigned an opt-out publication date for the SBTi website one
month from their approval date (when deliverables were sent). This is
communicated in their approval email. However, should this date not be agreed
upon, companies must announce approved targets publicly within six months of
the approval date.
3
As defined by the Department of Economic and Social Affairs of the United Nations Secretariat in the World Economic Situation and Prospects
2018. See FAQ E7 for more information.
11
Item Target validation service
Who can be assessed - Any company that passes the initial screening. Note that the cost for companies
headquartered in developing countries and economies in transition can be
waived
Target Submission - Submission form must be completed as required per the validation requested,
Form indicating if the company is using the full service or the resubmission option
Level of feedback - Detailed feedback is provided for each round of assessment 4 through a:
provided o Comprehensive target validation report including recommendations to
address non-compliances if applicable
o Written decision letter
o Up to 60 min of feedback conversations with a technical expert from
the SBTi, upon request, and prioritized for companies who are not
approved
Turnaround times - Written decision letter and target validation report within 30 working days
Communications - Assistance with formulating the final wording of a target (if approved)
4
The standard cost of the target validation service is 4950 USD (+ applicable VAT) and includes two rounds of assessments. Each round of
assessment includes the following: the submission form is completed by the company; the submitted targets are assessed against the SBTi criteria;
a report, a letter, and a feedback call upon request are provided. Please our FAQs page, section titled “Target Validation Service” for more
information.
12
process for these companies.
As defined by the SBTi, a SME is defined as a: “non-subsidiary, independent company which employs fewer
than 500 employees”. SMEs are invited to submit targets through a dedicated target validation route,
solely limited to SMEs.
In order to join the SBTi, SMEs shall complete the following steps:
1. Complete the company information details in the Target Setting Letter.
2. Select one of the target options in the Letter.
3. Fill-out the emissions profile section.
4. Complete the contact details, sign the letter and pay the USD 1,000 target fee.
5. Send a digital copy of the letter in PDF format to targets@[Link].
After submitting a target setting letter to targets@[Link] and paying the target fee, a
company will be recognized as having approved science-based targets at our Companies Taking Action
webpage as well as on our partners’ websites at We Mean Business and CDP. Companies who are engaging
in the UN Global Compact will also be recognized on this website.
Validation process
Process overview
After the target is submitted, the target validation process follows the steps described below. For
processes and timelines regarding validations for CDP scoring, companies can refer to CDP’s Technical
Note on SBTs. Targets need to be submitted by June 15th, 2020 in order to count for CDP leadership points
should the target be approved.
I. Initial screening
A member of the SBTi team performs a review to ensure that the company has properly and completely
filled-out the Target Submission Form, and that certain basic SBTi criteria (for example, the timeframe of
scope 1, 2 and 3 targets) is met. The form may be sent back to the company outlining sections of the form
that are missing and/or unclear. Once the form is deemed complete, a Validation Team is assigned. If basic
criteria are not met, the company will receive a decision letter at this point.
The initial screening is performed before the Terms & Conditions are signed and before the invoice is sent
to the company, to ensure basic criteria is met. If the initial screening is met, companies will be asked to
sign the Terms & Conditions and will receive an invoice with payment information after the signature
process.
II. Validation team assignment
The SBTi will assign a validation team for the target which includes a lead reviewer (LR), who is a qualified
professional from one of the SBTi’s partner organizations, and an appointed approver (AA) who is a
qualified professional from a different partner organization as the reviewer. The LR will be the main point
of contact between the company and the SBTi. Teams are assigned in a way that ensures that any real or
13
perceived conflicts of interest are avoided. Note that if the company had submitted a validation
previously, the same reviewer will be assigned whenever possible.
III. Desk review
The LR will thoroughly assess the accuracy, relevance, completeness, consistency, and transparency of the
information provided by the company in the submission form and any accompanying documents. The LR
may send clarifications or information requests to the company summarized in a query log. The company
must respond in writing to the query and send it back to the SBTi. After all queries are answered, the LR
evaluates the company’s target against the SBTi criteria and fills out a target validation report with her/his
decision and sends it to the AA.
Please note that queries received from the validation team throughout the process must be answered by
the company within 2 business days if the company wishes to receive the validation deliverables within
the 30 business day timeframe.
IV. Appointed Approver review
The AA reviews the assessment done by the LR and completes the target validation report, confirming
that all validation criteria have been assessed. If (s)he agrees with the recommendations from the LR, the
LR sends the report for discussion within the Target Validation Team (TVT).
V. TVT discussion and approval
The LR submits the target validation report for discussion to the SBTi’s TVT. If needed, the LR may ask the
company for further information. Once all comments from the TVT are addressed, the LR forwards the
recommendations for final sign-off on the validation outcome. On specific cases where the validation
process is particularly complex, the target discussion will be escalated to the Steering Committee for
appraisal and final sign-off on the validation outcome.
V. Steering Committee approval (if needed)
For specific cases where reaching a decision is particularly complex, the TVT might request that the
Steering Committee provides final sign off on the validation decision. In those cases, the Steering
Committee discusses the case and makes the final decision on the target submission.
VI. Communicating decisions and feedback
For each assessment, companies will receive one comprehensive target validation report including
recommendations to address non-compliances if applicable, and a written decision letter within 30
working days. Companies will also receive up to 60 min of feedback conversations with a technical expert
from the SBTi for each assessment upon request, and this is prioritized for companies who receive a target
rejection. These feedback conversations should happen within the 15 business days after the decision or
feedback letter is sent.
VII. Submission(s)
Two rounds of assessments will be provided for the cost of USD 4950 (+ applicable VAT). That means a
company will be able to submit twice under the same service if needed. For example, if the company’s
first submission is not approved, it can update its targets considering the recommendations and feedback
14
received and resubmit for a second round of assessment.
Subsequent resubmissions under the target validation service cost USD 2490 (+ applicable VAT) per
submission. Resubmissions will only include one target assessment. The resubmission price is available to
companies that 1) have submitted at least once using the paid target validation service, 2) already have
approved targets but need to update them, and/or 3) were approved through a preliminary validation
under the free service.
15
Acronyms/ Abbreviations
Appointed approver AA
Lead reviewer LR
16
Glossary
Appointed approver (AA): A technical expert, directly employed by one of the SBTi partners, who
performs target validations and reviews assessments made by LRs. Within a Validation Team for a specific
target, the AA is from a different organization than the LR.
Initial screening: A review for completeness of the Target Submission Form, to ensure the company has
provided all information required to assess the target and if the target meets certain criteria that are
assessed at this stage (e.g. boundary, timeframe).
Lead reviewer (LR): A technical expert directly employed by one of the SBTi partners, who performs target
validations including the following activities: reviews submission forms, assesses targets against SBTi
criteria, liaises with companies, and submits assessments and recommendations.
Query log: A record of questions or requests for further information sent to the company and the
company’s response.
Resubmission: When the company sends a new or improved target back to the SBTi for evaluation after
a previous official validation determined that the target did not meet one or more of the criteria.
Round of Assessment: Process from when the company sending a completed submission form to when
the SBTi issues a decision on proposed targets and the related deliverables after the targets have been
assessed against the SBTi criteria.
Science Based Targets initiative partners (SBTi partners): SBTi is a joint initiative by CDP, UNGC, WRI and
WWF, commonly referred to as the partner organizations.
Steering Committee: The decision-making body of the SBTi initiative composed of one representative
from each of the four SBTi partner organizations. One of its functions is to provide the final sign-off on
target validation decisions that are particularly complex.
Target Submission Form: The form the company fills out with its inventory and target information. The
SBTi uses the information in the form to determine if the targets meet its criteria during target validation.
Target validation: Evaluation process that a target must pass in order for the SBTi to endorse it as science-
based. Only positive results are communicated publicly. The target validation is not a negotiation of a
company’s target(s), rather an assessment of the target(s) against the SBTi criteria.
Target validation service: A paid service for the target validation process that aims to provide a faster
process and additional feedback to companies.
Target Validation Team (TVT): The technical arm of the SBTi that conducts target validations. Lead
Reviewers are typically members of the TVT but they might be supported by the TWG to act as AA and/or
external consultants hired to assist with the desk review portion of the target validation process.
Technical Working Group (TWG): The technical arm of the SBTi that develops tools and sector-specific
developments. The TWG might also support the TVT as Appointed Approvers.
17
Appendix I - Target-setting resources
The Science Based Targets initiative highly recommends companies review the resources below before
setting their emissions reduction targets. Please note that this list is comprehensive but not exhaustive.
GHG accounting standards and guidance
The Greenhouse Gas Protocol is the most used global standard for how to measure, manage, and report
greenhouse gas emissions. Before setting a science-based target, companies should first ensure that their
inventory is accurately calculated following these standards and guidance or other equivalent standards.
● GHG Protocol Corporate Standard: A step-by-step standard that companies can use to quantify
and report their GHG emissions.
● GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance: How to measure emissions from purchased or acquired
electricity, steam, heat, and cooling.
General guidance
● What is a science-based target?: The short video below provides a high-level overview of main
science-based targets concepts.
18
Scope 3
● GHG Protocol Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard: A standard
that provides requirements and guidance on calculating and reducing value chain emissions.
● GHG Protocol Scope 3 Guidance: Links to more detailed guidance on calculating emissions in each
of the 15 scope 3 categories.
● Scope 3 Evaluator: A web-based tool developed by the GHG Protocol and Quantis to estimate (i.e.
screen) scope 3 emissions.
● CDP Supply Chain Program: This membership program provides a platform for companies and
their suppliers to capture climate change data, which can be useful for emissions reductions
related to purchased goods and services.
19
Document History
1.1 Original version of the SBTi C2A March 2017 March 2017 to February 16th
Guidelines 2018
1.2 Small updates on timelines and February 16th 2018 February 16th, 2018 to June 1st
other details 2018
1.3 Added the criteria revision timeline June 1st 2018 June 1st 2018
and adapted to criteria version 3.0
1.4 Integrated information on the October 15th 2018 October 15th 2018
target validation service and other
details
1.5 Updated information on the target April 17th 2019 April 17th 2019
validation service and other details
1.6 Refinement of minor details to April 15th 2020 April 15th 2020
ensure up to date and relevant
information
20