Effective Communication & Conflict Resolution
Effective Communication & Conflict Resolution
COLLEAGUES &
CUSTOMERS
&
DEALING WITH
CONFLICT SITUATIONS
1
Table of contents
WORKING WITH COLLEAGUES AND CUSTOMERS
Unit Descriptor 3
2
DEAL WITH CONFLICT SITUATIONS 48
Unit Descriptor 48
3
Working with colleagues
and customers
Unit Descriptor
This unit deals with the interpersonal, communication and customer
service skills required by all people working in the tourism and hospitality
industries. This is a core unit which underpins all other competencies
dealing with colleagues and customers and applies to all levels and
sectors of the industry.
4
Element 1:
Communicate in the
workplace
The situations and contexts in which this unit might be applied include:
in an office
back of house
front of house
reception area
on tour
on site
using a phone or mobile phone.
Again, this highlights the wide-ranging nature of our role within this industry,
and the continual way in which we interact with all manner of individuals.
5
All communications with customers and colleagues should be
conducted in an open, polite, professional and friendly manner.
In dealing with other people, the non-verbal cues are often used –
consciously or subconsciously – in making judgements about people,
about what they say and about their honesty and/or deceptiveness.
7
The physical position in relation to the person we are
communicating with, and the posture we adopt, all have the
potential to convey signals.
Standing side-by-side tends to indicate compliance and a
willingness to assist: standing in front tends to indicate
confrontation.
For this reason it is seen as unproductive to conduct an interview of any
kind with the two parties sitting opposite each other, especially across a
desk: arm
chairs at ninety degrees, and a low coffee table are preferred to
encourage a non-threatening, non-confrontational situation.
Other examples of the impact of position and posture is the effect
that a standing person has on someone who is sitting, the
impression that hunched shoulders conveys, and the different
impression that standing upright with, say, hands on hips gives.
Similarly, a person who talks to you while they continue walking and
doesn't stop to communicate, gives a certain impression that is
different to a person who stops and talks.
Facial expressions
Facial expressions are the ones that humans are best able to control.
While much can be read from them, it must be remembered that they
can be controlled or manipulated, and must be interpreted together with
the verbal messages.
Eye movement
Eyes contribute a significant amount to total body language.
Eyes can indicate interest when regular, but intermittent, eye contact is
maintained. Very long periods of eye contact can indicate a desire for
intimacy and is therefore to be avoided in a business or workplace setting.
The listener looks at the speaker far more than the speaker usually
looks at the listener.
Gestures
Movements of the arms, legs, hands and feet all send information. They can
be used to supplement information given verbally. Here are examples of
some body movements and their
meaning or purpose:
pointing (to reinforce the direction given)
throwing up the hands in alarm (to reinforce emotions)
8
moving the head or other body parts to stress certain
things (to support the spoken word)
using wide and energetic gestures (to convey a certain
personality type; to express self-image)
mirroring the stance etc of the other person, where two people are
talking about something they share (to indicate agreement or
submission; to express or reinforce person-to-person relationships)
Other factors
There are other factors that can be included in non-verbal communication.
These factors convey to the receiver messages that are not obvious.
Silence
Many people will say that 'silence is golden' but in reality it is not.
However, it does have its place in genuine communication when the receiver
of a message keeps quiet to allow the sender to send their message.
Time
The interpretation that a person puts on 'time' is very much an individual thing
– one person may regard a 30-minute conversation as a brief natter,
while others see it as a long ordeal.
9
It is therefore obvious how important the observation of non-verbal
communication is in the hospitality industry. As with other aspects of life, we
need to practise the observation of non-verbal communication in
order to make use of on what it can tell us.
10
Unfortunately this attitude is often used as an excuse to provide sub-
standard service, below par facilities and at times to ignore, or be
rude to, foreign visitors.
As a result, hospitality staff will find that foreign guests could have
differing views in terms of:
customer expectations – many staff would benefit from viewing
advertising that promotes Vietnam overseas. For many visitors, time is a
critical factor. They expect to have their time in the country fully
occupied, and for their time to conform to the expectations created by a
variety of promotional sources. Vietnam may be presented, in instances,
as a land of beauty, of amazing food and of wonderful, friendly
hospitality;
forms of address – each establishment will have house rules to follow
in regard to talking to guests and these must naturally be adhered to. In
general terms there is an expectation by some that Vietnam is informal
a country where everyone is treated as being equal. Many tourists will
be pleased to be greeted by a genuine and informal welcome, but there
is a time and a place for this and in the dining room, at reception or in
the room are not those places. Other guests – and many will not be
here as tourists, but for business purposes – will expect to be treated
deferentially and have their status as revered guests acknowledged,
and be correspondingly addressed;
levels of formality and informality – in general terms the hotel should
adhere to a formal level of operation allowing other tourist/business establishments to provide the
informality. Where there is doubt, house rules should be followed, with the individual guests being
allowed to set the degree of formality/informality required. Experience will be a big factor in
determining what is appropriate in each instance, but the style of promotion the establishment
engages in is a pretty good guide about the standard or level of formality that the guest can expect;
The initial greeting should generally be formal and direct, and you
should be ready and prepared to apologise where difficulties/problems
surface. For some international guests though, they find that
Vietnamese go overboard on the apologising front, saying sorry for
even the most minor things – this is another example of what makes up
our culture in that continually saying sorry has got us out of potentially
problematic/difficult situations, so we keep doing it. In addition, as
Vietnamese are so willing to please they often say yes, when the
response should be an alternative.
2) Establishment organisation
The way in which an establishment is organised and the way it
functions on a day-to-day basis can provide the platform for more
effective cross-cultural communication.
12
communicating basic needs and wants are not a part of this language
play. Providing documents in different languages (eg, registration,
menus, directions, instructions), and multilanguage establishment
signage will also encourage overseas guests. It will also increase their
feeling of being made welcome.
3) Language difficulties
Many visitors to Vietnam will have almost no knowledge of the
Vietnamese language, and problems in communicating can often
occur.
13
In addition, when speaking with overseas visitors, staff will find it helpful to:
speak clearly and – but do so without inferring that the
customer/guest is stupid;
remember to speak at
normal volume –
people won't
generally understand
better if you shout;
avoid idiomatic
language as this is
frequently extremely
confusing for the
foreigner and may be
misinterpreted as an
attempt to belittle them;
give the guest your
full attention when
communicating with
them, and show that you are trying to be of assistance; and
be alert for signs that there has been no real understanding of what you
have said, and be prepared to repeat yourself, restate what you have
already said in different terms, or expand on what you have said.
It is common for some staff to categorise anyone who can't speak
English as 'being stupid', but it is a sobering thought for them to
consider how well they would cope in a strange land, speaking a foreign
language and trying to cope with different habits.
They also look to body language to help them infer meaning, and to
help make sense of the spoken word.
14
Smiling is another non-verbal expression that – especially in the
hospitality industry where staff are encouraged to be friendly – we
need to be careful about. We may find smiling to be
representative of happiness, friendliness and a warm
and welcoming approach, but many Asians interpret
it as a means of covering up embarrassment,
displeasure or dissatisfaction.
5) Stress
Stress comes from two sources. Visitors are often under a great deal of
stress – in a foreign land, confronted with an alien language and not
having even the basic day-to-day working knowledge that everyone
simply takes for granted. And the staff who deal with them are also
usually a bit stressed by the normal work routine, plus the challenge of
having to cope with a difficult situation.
Finally, when the situation arises, take steps to create a quiet and
calm environment in which to conduct the communication.
To conclude
Be aware of the potential problems and difficulties. This is the first
step in effectively dealing with cross-cultural communications.
Accept that people from different parts of the world will interpret
their world, the people in it, establishments, and actions using a
different frame of reference from us.
15
Realise that differences between people are not indicative of
superior or inferior status.
Endeavour to find out about the culture and communications
of the countries of your guests..
Be alert to the need for you to clarify what has been said – speak
clearly, rephrase and don't be afraid to use written communication.
Do not approach dealings with people from overseas with an
attitude that it is up to them to learn Vietnamese.
Make sure you do not allow preconceptions or national stereotypes
to influence your attitude to guests. As has been stated in earlier
notes, guests are individuals and must be treated as such.
Don't assume that overseas guests will like or dislike the same things
that you or your friends do: your values and your way of seeing the
world is not the only acceptable and proper way of seeing it.
Listening
Listening is sometimes referred to as the neglected
skill. It is without doubt a much under-rated skill,
especially when you consider we have two ears,
and only one mouth!
We have two listening options. One involves listening only (active listening).
The other involves your giving verbal feedback that ensures the channel of
communication continues clear and without conflict (reflective listening).
16
1) Active listening
When engaged in active listening, you do not speak, but listen. You
allow your body language to encourage the speaker. Active listening is:
showing sensitivity to the talker, showing all due respect;
displaying empathy with
the person speaking;
demonstrating your
attention in all your
non-verbal signals;
not interrupting;
encouraging the other
person to continue by
encouraging behaviour
– nods, murmurs,
short words of
encouragement;
concentrating on what is
being said and not thinking of something else;
not being judgemental.
2) Reflective listening
In this variation, you still listen to the speaker, but you encourage
them to continue with your words rather than non-verbally.
Questioning
The asking of questions is a powerful tool in communication.
17
as its name states, reflective questioning puts the words in the shape
of a question.
It frequently begins with the word 'So ...', for example, "So you feel
really angry when you see someone walk out of the room and not
turn out the light?".
18
Take notes – don't be afraid to write down vital points – it
demonstrates interest and that you are taking things seriously.
Help where necessary – where the speaker pauses, prompt them
into continuing.
Reflect on what has been said – re-state a point the speaker
has made: eg, "You said that ...".
Keep quiet – realise that interrupting is a major
cause of communication breakdown.
19
Unhygienic conditions – rooms and/or facilities or utensils show
lack of proper attention to detail and incorrect housekeeping and
hygiene practices
Low comfort levels – rooms too cold/hot, too noisy, too crowded,
bed isn’t firm enough, curtains don’t
block out enough light
Rowdy and unacceptable
behaviour displayed by other
patrons – this can be in a bar
area, in an adjacent room in
the accommodation area, at a
function, or in an eating area
A mistake with an account –
being billed for something they
didn’t receive, being charged
more than expected, being
overcharged, eg, not having a
deposit deducted from the bill
Error in the reservation or reservation not found – room not
available, the booking has resulted in the wrong table or a room
with the incorrect facilities, view or location within the premises
Special requests not being adhered to – forgetting a wake-up
call, no birthday cake for the party.
Being treated unfairly – not being served in their correct turn,
being charged an amount that is different to what someone
else was charged, not receiving the same treatment/benefits
that others received.
Warning signs
There is a lot of merit in the old saying, "An ounce of prevention is
worth a ton of cure" (or whatever the metric equivalent of that is!),
especially in relation to dealing with conflict situations.
20
A customer may:
Look angry or aggressive
Appear flustered, frustrated
or exasperated
Raise their eye-brows, roll their eyes, sigh
loudly, droop their shoulders excessively
Glance around as if seeking assistance
Physically touch another guest or
colleague to gain their attention
Become loud and rowdy
Slam the door, fling papers down on
a table/desk or perform some other
action in an exaggerated fashion
Throw something in frustration
Be argumentative.
The moment you identify a warning sign, do everything in your power to stop
further problems occurring: take swift action and act in a tactful manner.
21
text
email
speaking face-to-face
telephone
two-way communication systems
simple written messages, eg, restaurant
bookings or phone messages
standard forms and proformas.
22
Personal qualities
Clarity – speakers need to
express themselves and their
ideas clearly. Speech should be
jargon free and without long words
(where they are not necessary). In
addition, diction (the way people
pronounce their words) should be
clear, so that what is said may be
clearly heard.
Personal appearance – the way you look will influence how people
react to you, so it is important that your appearance (cleanliness,
tidiness and dress) is in-keeping with how others expect you to be.
Vocal qualities
Pitch – a high pitched voice can be annoying, and a deep pitched voice may
give the impression of a snob. Relaxation can be used to help voice pitch,
especially to eliminate tension which can lead to a high pitched voice.
23
Speed – the rate you talk at affects the conversation: talking quickly
indicates a sense of urgency, but your pronunciation may suffer and
cause you to be difficult to understand. Speed of speaking should be
varied to match the message and its relative urgency/importance.
In general
When speaking, either in the workplace or elsewhere, there is more
to the communication than just the message.
Causes
Factors that increase the chance of communication failure or
breakdown (called 'communication liabilities') include:
hidden agendas – where the real message behind the
communication is something other than the message being sent;
negative feelings – bad feelings built up in you by actions or
words from others. You might feel that they were giving you the
cold shoulder, insulting you, or putting you down;
personal traits – the way that an individual's personal characteristics
affect their natural communication ability: a person may naturally be an
'avoider', a 'joker' or a 'blamer' and these traits will affect both the
24
messages they send and the way they receive and
interpret messages.
Barriers
Noise is not the only barrier to
communication. Other barriers
can be:
25
personal prejudices – individuals tend to have personal
standards, likes and dislikes and this affects communications. If
someone distrusts overweight males with beards and glasses,
then they will tend to not act on or believe the information sent
by such a person despite how well it is sent;
source evaluation – the receiver will make judgements about the
person sending the message and where they believe that the sender
does not have the 'qualifications' to send accurate messages, they will
tend not to believe the information despite its validity; and
incompatibility of non-verbal communication – where the ears hear
one thing but the eyes see something that is not in-keeping with it,
there will be a breakdown.
In terms of the workplace, communication breakdown can lead to frustration,
confusion, danger, guest dissatisfaction and general conflict situations.
Get someone who really knows to spend some time with you explaining:
how to fill in the form
what goes where
what terminology is generally used
what jargon and/or
abbreviations are used
when the forms are used
what time frames apply
who receives the form
where the forms are kept
whether or not it has to be
approved or signed before
it’s passed on.
26
Element 2: Maintain
personal presentation
standards
The following notes are about personal presentation within the contexts of:
enterprise requirements
work location
occupational health and safety issues
impacts on different types of customers
specific requirements for particular work functions.
27
work boots, hats), or a certain aesthetic standard may be
required in order to blend in with the overall image of the
establishment or department.
28
• poise and deportment – this is how you
carry yourself when walking in the
establishment, and how you stand and
conduct yourself when standing at tables
or at the bar.
It is associated with non-verbal
communication and says much about our true
attitude, and our real orientation to the job.
• Hair care
− tie long hair back, and/or wear appropriate hair net/hat;
− shampoo and use an appropriate conditioner regularly; and
− maintain hair at a suitable length and/or in an appropriate
style for the establishment/job.
29
• Jewellery
− don't wear dangerous jewellery that can dangle into
machinery and become caught;
− wear jewellery that is simple, not gaudy;
− remember the potential food poisoning problems presented
by rings – food can lodge into rings, especially ornate ones
and drop back later into other food thereby contaminating it
– stones may also fall out of rings into food and present a
physical contaminant;
− be aware that guests may be peeved if you wear
something they think is above your station.
• Make-up
− be sparing with it;
− get professional advice if you are unsure about what colours
and shades suit you;
− match the make-up to the time of day, the occasion and
where you are working;
− be very sparing with perfume – it shouldn't dominate or intrude;
− check and adhere to any establishment policies in this regard.
30
determine which garments require dry cleaning in preference to
machine washing and ensure they receive the appropriate treatment
– look at the 'care label' or seek advice when unsure; and
spot clean dirty spots as soon as possible, and where you can't
get the stain out, make sure you let the laundry/dry cleaner
know the source/type of stain.
Pressing techniques
as with cleaning, take advantage of in-house ironing where
this is available;
ensure ironing follows the correct lines, pleats and creases;
make sure the iron is not operating at too high a temperature;
use an ironing aid especially on garment areas that are
notoriously difficult to iron, or which are traditionally trouble
spots such as cuffs and collars;
cover/hang garments as soon as they have been ironed
ready for wearing.
Transportation of uniform
adhere to establishment policy in relation to uniforms where it is
a requirement that uniforms never leave the premises – this
relieves you of transportation worries completely;
realise that it is against the law for food handlers to wear their uniform
to work as it risks contamination attaching itself to the garments;
acquire a fully-covered hanging suit bag to help keep your
uniform both neatly pressed and clean during its travel;
don't forget your shoes – keep a small shoe shine kit at work that
can be used at any time to give your
footwear a final brush up.
31
Element 3. Provide
services to
colleagues and
customers
3.1 Identify customer needs and
expectations
There will be many customers who come to you with special
needs – and in some way it is possible to say that all needs are
special needs – they are a product of a person’s situation,
immediate wants and their cultural heritage.
American
Australians and (north) Americans share a common
language – English – but be prepared to restate and clarify,
as Australian English has a different accent to American
English
Initial contact via a firm handshake and direct eye
contact is acceptable: men usually wait for women to
offer their hands rather then initiating the handshake.
Realise that when an American gives you a detailed food or
drink order (even down to what sort of bread they want for
their toast, and how they want it done), this is what they do
at home – they aren't trying to be difficult, obsessive or
irritating.
Take some time to show an interest in the very fact that
they are American because they expect Australians to be a
friendly lot – maintain eye contact during conversations.
.
They find silence in conversations uncomfortable.
32
Make an effort to explain things to Americans – by their
nature they are used to asking questions before making a
buying decision and expect respectful, intelligent and
helpful answers.
Americans at home are used to being supplied with a
bottomless glass of iced water at table – ensure this is
supplied where you work.
Asian - other
Your appearance – dress and personal presentation – will
be expected to be immaculate as a sign of respect to their
position.
Be patient when attempting communication – refrain from
showing frustration at an inability to understand: do not make
the mistake of translating a communication difficulty as
stupidity.
They will make enquiries in order to obtain information and not
as a means of annoying you.
Asian guests will expect staff to have a high level of
product knowledge that they can avail themselves of
before making a buying decision.
Their home country shopping experiences have made them
used to being dealt with as one of many who require service.
This means that when you are busy, they will not be offended if
you simply answer their query and then go on to serve
someone else – our orientation to professional service is one
that rotates around personalised service (where staff deal
wholly and solely with one guest/table to the exclusion of all
else) but they will not expect this style/level of service.
Realise that Asians do not use eye contact in the same way we
do: when an Asian breaks eye contact it does not necessarily
indicate that they have lost interest, but can merely mean they
are attempting to maintain their personal detachment.
German
The initial handshake is
usually a brief
encounter with only one
or two shakes, rather
than an extended affair.
Provide quick, efficient,
no-frills service.
Germans will interpret a
sloppy personal
appearance and
presentation as
potential incompetence.
When speaking with
them remain polite and
treat them respectfully
using "Sir" and "Madam"
to indicate your recognition of their position.
33
Do not be offended by what you may see as brusque
treatment and speech – there is no hidden meaning behind it
other than an attempt to obtain what they want.
They expect as a matter of course to be served quickly and
may become annoyed at having to wait, especially where no
reason for the delay in service is provided.
An upright thumb, means "one", and rapping of the knuckles
by guests at table is a way of saying hello to the others there.
Refrain from attempting to entertain them as there is
always the risk that your humour will either not be
appreciated or will be misunderstood – leave the
entertaining up to professional entertainers.
Attempt to give Germans accurate and decisive information,
rather than vague generalities.
Realise that the direct method of communication is the
accepted way of Germans and that there may be little regard
for what we may consider to be the niceties of general
conversation: they may not use "Please" and "Thank you" to
the same extent that we do but this is not to be misinterpreted
as ill-mannered or uncivil action, but rather a representation
of the fact that different people are, simply, different.
Japanese
Japanese, of course, are Asians, but the following list especially
details Japanese customer needs and expectations.
Greet them with a polite but short bow and not the traditional
shake of hands: they will, however, adapt quickly to the Western
tradition of shaking hands, but favour a gentle grip as a firm grip
can signal aggression.
Do not use guest's
first name as this is
seen as too intimate,
and lacking in respect.
Use "san" after the
guest's last name
(male or female), or
stick to the traditional
"Sir" or "Madam"
where there is difficulty
with pronunciation.
Avoid using slang,
idioms and
Vietnamese
expressions.
Do not pat them on the
back or stand very close
Excessive gestures,
being demonstrative and shouting should be avoided as they
have a high regard for restraint.
Jewish
There are variations on the degree to which individual Jews
adhere to the principles and requirements of their faith: do not
expect all Jews to act in the same way.
Their traditional religious day (the Sabbath) is Saturday – many
Jews will refrain from much
activity on this day
including driving a
car, and using
electrical appliances.
Catering may be
required to be done
by a Rabbi and there
may be special
requirements
regarding cooking
areas, equipment
and cutlery.
Pork is unacceptable
and meat, including
chicken, must be
specially slaughtered
and prepared.
35
Fruit and vegetables are acceptable, but the modern hybrid
types are shunned.
Traditional Jews will drink Kosher wine, which is usually
presented unopened to allow the guests to open it themselves.
There is an expectation that guests will be able to wash their
hands under running water.
Jews may bless their food prior to consumption and so may not
thank service staff in the same way that others might.
Fish meat should only come from fish with scales and fins.
36
to be heard and understood – which is why we listen to
complaints and adopt the role of their advocate whenever
there is a complaint, problem or dispute: we want to fix their
problems, not create new ones.
When you think about it, these are pretty much what you would want,
aren’t they?
37
common sense indicates they should stay confidential), remain private:
discretion is a characteristic of staff in the hospitality industry
having an awareness of local attractions and services – if you
don’t know what there is locally, how can you ‘sell’ it to
others? If you haven’t been to your local attractions – go!
having product and service knowledge – you absolutely must
know all there is to know about your venue – or at the very least,
know where to go, who to talk to, to get it.
You must always give the customer time to explain themselves fully –
this means never cutting them short when they are complaining, or
putting words into their mouth.
38
A six-step method has proved to be effective when dealing
with all complaints:
1) listen: listen to everything the customer has to say; recognise
and respect the customer's thoughts and feelings
39
When a complaint situation has arisen, time is critical, and your failure to
notify the relevant person has the potential to greatly inflame the situation.
And, as we all know, when you are upset or annoyed, one minute
seems like ten.
This is quite easy to say, but often proves much more difficult to actually do!
40
Element 4: Work in a
team
And, you have to walk your talk – you can’t just say you trust, support
and respect: you have to do it!
This means:
Never participating in gossip
or running down any (repeat
any) staff member
Don’t spend time with customers
who want to criticise work mates
Don’t blame any work mates for
anything – even though you
may suspect it was their fault
Don’t take the credit for what
another staff member has done
Support a decision that a
colleague has made – for
instance, in refusing to
serve a person with alcohol
Treat co-workers in keeping
with any cultural individualities
A team must work together and it is frightening to see how quickly it
can be torn apart by just one person with either an axe to grind
(because of a real or imagined act), or a prejudice to air.
The truly sad thing about a lack of trust, support or respect is that no-
one wins: someone can be ‘on the winning side’ of a lack of trust, etc,
but they still lose.
The key is to remain detached, stay professional and let your actions
speak for themselves.
Trust the people that merit your trust – the ones that prove they do.
41
Support those who warrant your support – the ones whose actions
have shown that they warrant it.
There may well be times when the customer must truly come first in
these situations, too. On other occasions, you might have to support a
colleague even when you don’t want to.
What do you do in these cases? You give them the support their
position demands. Like it or not, these situations simply ‘come with the
territory. It is, after all, very much a people business.
42
team building to foster a co-operative group working effort rather
than a splintered approach to work;
questioning in order to accurately determine the root causes for
the dissatisfaction rather than assuming you know the reasons;
observing body language to gauge how proceedings are going and
whether or not there is still underlying and unresolved tension; and
seeking advice or assistance from others within the
workplace or professionals from outside the establishment.
In addition, positive moves can be made in advance of problems by:
creating a climate of tolerance;
implementing team building exercises;
providing training and education; and
providing mediation and counselling.
43
A far better working environment where you will be inclined to take less
time off, and where you will actually look forward to going to work
Less clock watching, and more pats on the back – from
management and patrons
More innovative and creative ideas – a situation will emerge
where you are encouraged to try out new (but nonetheless
intelligent) ideas, concepts and “what ifs”
More learning – not just about the establishment and the
industry, but also about co-workers, group dynamics and
interpersonal relationships
Higher levels of achievement than anyone thought possible – the
power of ten people is far greater than 10 individuals, and there is
also the momentum and power that a group decision brings with it.
A key for you is to participate actively in any team decision-making
process: be a contributor and not just someone who ‘shuts up and goes
along’. The whole idea of team goals is that the whole team helps
establish them, and you are part of that team.
A word of warning though: there will be plenty of times when the team
comes to a decision that is not what you wanted – it is at these times
when you have to demonstrate your character and still contribute 110%.
The others will be watching to see how you respond. And what better
way to start building trust, support and respect for yourself!
44
Given the ‘service oriented’ nature of our industry – which essentially
means a person-focussed approach – this should come as no surprise.
We can’t possibly know what customers or guests will want, but we
must nonetheless make every effort to satisfy what they want.
In our industry there are often situations where you can’t possibly
accomplish something on your own – usually these are service peaks
that require some help for 5 – 10 minutes and then it's over.
Examples include:
The arrival of a coach of
tourists who all require a
quick check-in, and their
luggage portered to rooms
A group arrival in the restaurant
– all needing to be seated,
supplied with their first drink, and
have their order taken
A sudden rush in the bottle shop
The first half hour of trade
when the nightclub opens
45
That one day when every room service tray has been
requested at 8.30am.
The people you may ask to assist can vary, but will commonly include:
Others from your team
People from other, but related, departments
Managers and supervisors.
Our industry has little room for prima donnas. Those who don’t pitch in
and help, for whatever reason, will soon find themselves excluded by
the other staff: you may have a very good reason for not helping BUT
this is not good enough!
Co-workers will judge you by how much they can rely on you in a pinch,
and you have to make the effort to be there when needed. The other
work has to be reprioritised, and done later.
The whole intent of helping colleagues is to ensure that team goals are
achieved, excellent service is delivered and customers tell others and
come back.
46
Take the negative feedback in the right way – see it as an opportunity
to improve, and a challenge. Make sure you don’t dwell on the
negative message and start getting everything out of perspective –
this is a common and very damaging response that causes much
tension, anxiety and workplace conflict.
Above all, don’t shoot the messenger! If a staff member delivers this
negative message, realise that they are not making the criticism. They
are just doing their job, and, If you think about it, would not be doing
their duty if they didn’t bring the negative to your attention.
The key is to listen to the criticism ,determine objectively if there is truth in it,
and determine how to rectify things so that it doesn’t happen again: we are all
human after all, so mistakes will happen. Like the old saying goes “there
hasn’t been a world champion who hasn’t had a glove laid on them”.
For example, you may be told that the group due in at 7pm have cancelled,
that the Chandelier Room will stay open for today’s function until midnight
instead of the previously arranged 10pm, or that due to a problem in the
cellar there will be no draught beer for the next 5 – 6 hours!
Are there things now that don’t need to be done? Do things need to be
re-organised, priorities changed? Are there now things to be done that
didn’t need to be done five minutes ago? Do you now need help? Are
there others who now need your help?
Where you have spare time or capacity, and the situation merits
it, be proactive and offer assistance without waiting to be asked.
47
4.8 Negotiate changes
In many cases, you will be expected to accommodate the day-to-day
changes that traditionally occur in the industry. There is an
expectation that you will get through the designated work for the day
as well as manage the unforeseen issues that are bound to crop up.
48
Deal with conflict
situations
Unit Descriptor
This unit deals with the skills and knowledge required to handle difficult
interpersonal situations – both with customers and colleagues. The unit
covers the conflict resolution skills required by all people working in the
tourism and hospitality industry to address the conflicts which may
arise in day-to-day work activities. It does not include formal
negotiation, counselling or conducting mediation.
49
Element 1: Identify
conflict situations
Ignoring the warning signs and failing to act only inflames the situation.
A colleague
There may be many reasons why conflict may flare up amongst colleagues.
50
A customer
Once again, there may be many reasons for a conflict situation to
arise with a guest. Here are some examples:
Lack of service, or poor, service – this can involve the guest
having to wait 'too long', the quality of products
being sub-standard, staff who are
disrespectful, rude or offensive
Expectations not being met – the
advertisements that your venue runs,
coupled with word-of-mouth
advertising, create these expectations
and they may often be unrealistic
Dissatisfaction with the accommodation
or services – a steak may have been
tough, the room too noisy or the view
not what was anticipated
Unhygienic conditions – perhaps the room showed a lack of
proper attention to detail and incorrect housekeeping practices
Low comfort levels – an area of the property could have
been too cold, too noisy, or too crowded
Rowdy and unacceptable behaviour displayed by other patrons – the
gaming room may have been patronised by a noisy and boisterous
group who were swearing loudly, and making suggestive comments
A mistake with an account – the guest account may have
charged for items that should have been on someone else's bill
Error in the reservation or reservation not found – the guest may
have arrived, late at night, after a long drive in bad weather only
to find there was a problem with a booking that they had been led
to believe was guaranteed and problem-free
Special requests not being adhered to – the flowers and
champagne that were ordered for 4pm were not delivered and
spoiled a very special occasion.
Warning signs
At all times during a shift, the employee should be aware of various 'warning
signs' which may be displayed by either another colleague or by a patron.
51
The warning signs given by a workplace colleague are usually quite
different to those that we may observe in a guest.
52
indicates they are seeking it: it is part of our job – whether it is
in the job description or not – to look for these signals and to
respond appropriately
Physically touch another guest or colleague – this can be the real
signal that the guest has a problem and that conflict could ensue.
Most people are reluctant to invade someone else's space, let alone
touch a stranger, so this action is highly indicative that a problem
exists, and help is being sought
Become too loud – as the guest becomes more
and more annoyed, their volume level rises: this
is another method of attracting help (they hope
someone will help them so as to shut them up),
and a way of inflaming the situation (by letting
others know about whatever it is the problem is)
Slamming room doors – this is a
characteristically frustrated response. It is
obviously socially unacceptable to hit someone,
or to break something but the guest can find a lot
of satisfaction in releasing frustration by
slamming a door. When, and if, this does happen, it is a common
mistake for the 'discussion' to then focus on the 'door slamming
episode': the smart operator will recognise the slamming as a
symptom of a bigger problem, and strive to fix the main problem
rather than getting bogged down in arguing over the door
Throwing something – this is a variation on the 'door slamming'
although with the obvious potential for more damage or injury. If
nothing is damaged or injured it may be better to ignore the action
and focus on the problem that caused it. On the other hand, security
may need to be informed. The key, though, is to see the 'throwing'
for what it is, rather than misconstrue it simply as a hostile act
Being argumentative – this is very common and stands to reason.
What else can the guest do? If we are not prepared to listen to
them, or to remedy a problem, there is little else left for them to do.
By identifying the risk of a possible conflict via a warning sign you will
have a greater chance of stopping a conflict from escalating into an
unwanted situation.
The moment you identify one of these warning signs, you should do
everything in your power to stop the problem getting worse. This means
you must take swift action and act in a tactful manner: not acting is the
worst thing you can do.
There is an old saying that you should 'nip it in the bud', and it is very true.
Being tactful means that you have to show a sense of what is appropriate for
the circumstances at the time. It means being considerate when dealing with
others – to their emotions and their needs. It also includes showing skill
53
and sensitivity when dealing with people, and ensuring that they
know you are doing your best to help them.
54
this may be aimed at a staff member or intended to smash a
window or mirror.
in other instances, patrons can sometimes become involved in what
they see as an 'innocent' game of throwing something around
(someone's hat or mobile phone, or a football): this presents a problem
in that there are potential dangers involved, plus those who are not 'part
of the game' quickly become annoyed and offended. This can lead to
other problems, especially where groups are involved, and the one
group decides to put a stop to what the others are doing!
erratic and/or irrational behaviour – when people are affected by liquor or
other substances their behaviour can become quite erratic, unpredictable and
dangerous. While we will naturally monitor what happens in our bars, etc, we
can never tell what a person has had to drink (or smoke, etc) before they
arrive at our premises: this means we have to be constantly alert to signs of
erratic behaviour and investigate it at the earliest opportunity
harassing behaviour – it is a common law requirement that we
provide a venue that is safe and this means that patrons (and
staff members) are entitled to be free from harassment when
they enter our premises. The harassment is often physical, and
may be intimidatory or physical touching: verbal harassment is
similarly unwelcome and must also be monitored and eliminated.
55
been unsuccessful in defusing the situation, but there may be situations
where you are on your own and your judgement is that involving the
police is the best option. Where you do elect to call the police, it may be
best that the people causing the problem do not see you making the
call, or it could cause them to erupt, damage property and assault
people, and then leave the scene before the police arrive
take action yourself if necessary, and only if authorized by the
appropriate person in your workplace – you should always remember
what it is you have been employed to do: have you been engaged to
work security? Or have you been employed to work behind the bar?
Your actions will greatly depend on the situation that is occurring and to
what stage the conflict has escalated.
56
Element 2: Resolve
conflict situations
The solution to the conflict will vary depending on the type of conflict
encountered, and the type of conflict will also help to dictate the
actions to take.
If you are involved in such a conflict, then it may need to be you who
makes the first move: there is no admission of guilt or responsibility,
and no admission of blame in being proactive in trying to resolve a
situation – it really is to everyone's benefit!
57
Also remember that house responsibilities vary between properties: the
level of responsibility and authority for a bar attendant at one venue will
not necessarily be the same as at another premises.
The following notes examine the role of certain staff positions in relation
to conflict, but the practical reality is that all staff must take some level of
responsibility for conflict resolution – even if that responsibility extends
only as far as notifying the relevant and appropriate person.
The receptionist
Depending on the level of authority, the receptionist may be
responsible for dealing with complaints directly related to any aspect of
the hotel, and the services it provides. The receptionist may witness
conflict themselves, or they may have a report of conflict phoned
through to them by staff members elsewhere within the venue.
In particular, they will notify security or the police where any conflict has
been identified as posing a threat to the safety of colleagues and guests.
58
Involving management in these conflicts is not a 'cop out': it is a
sensible and proactive thing to do. It is usually managers who have the
authority and discretion to take the necessary action to solve the
problem: staff do not usually have the required authority.
In addition, involving management is usually what the guest wants: in fact, they
will often say "I want to talk to the manager!" Involving management further
shows the guest you are taking their problem seriously and bringing in someone
who can make the necessary decisions and take some appropriate action.
Remember that all people are different, and your personal feelings, beliefs
and attitudes are not necessarily those of the other person involved.
Therefore, try not to regard another person’s feeling or thoughts negatively
just because they may not be the same as, or agree with, yours.
Just because they are different doesn’t mean that your opinion is less
worthy or valued, or that the other person's should be less respected:
the two points are simply different – nothing more, nothing less.
59
2.3 Use effective communication skills – refer
to pervious element
60
Cultural factors:
Until they are identified and addressed, any of the following factors may
be at play influencing or sustaining a conflict situation::
their native tongue – whether or not English is their first or second
language: many disputes and conflicts are caused, and perpetuated, by
simple misunderstandings brought about by language difficulties
personal values – these can often
be created in us by our family and
we are rightly very protective of
them, and sensitive when they are
questioned: when trying to resolve
a conflict situation we must make
sure we do nothing to threaten or
doubt a guest's personal values
religious beliefs – there is an absolute
need for us to be respectful of any
religious beliefs that a person holds.
These beliefs may extend to what they
are allowed to eat, drink, and wear
culturally-based dietary needs – certain
cultures have taboos on what they can and cannot eat: it is up
to us to cater for these requests whenever possible and to do so
in an accommodating manner rather than in a begrudging way.
It is beneficial to meet with kitchen staff to identify what special
dietary needs can be catered for.
Socio-economic factors
Our guests are likely to come to us from a wide variety of socio-
economic backgrounds, and all these backgrounds carry with them
differences in fact, and differences in expectations:
income levels – those who are
financially challenged may be looking
for value-for-money and can get upset
when this is not provided: similarly, if
they have been saving for years for a
once-in-a-lifetime holiday and we fail to
deliver on those expectations, they will
likewise be very disappointed
spending capabilities – the level of
disposable income varies enormously
between different socio-economic
groups: those with high levels of spending money usually
expect some form of deferential treatment – to be treated
'according to their station' – and can become annoyed if we fail
to recognise their 'position in life'.
61
Health factors
Not everyone enjoys good health, and the needs and wants of those
with less than perfect health can be the cause of conflict situations:
dietary needs – see above, and also try to accommodate any dietary
requests made by guests when they are with you: again, speak to
the people in your kitchen and compile a list of what can be provided
to cater for the dietary needs of certain people. Common demands
are for items that are low in fat, sugar-free, low salt, and gluten free
mobility – people with injuries may have impaired ability to get around: they
may be using crutches, a wheelchair or simply have restricted movement or
be unable to walk for long distances, or to climb stairs. It is important to
respond to their needs and assist them in moving about the property.
62
Age
The needs of children, adolescents, teenagers, middle-aged people and
the elderly will all differ: they will even differ between individuals within the
same age category.
When dealing with members of the public/guests we need to remind
ourselves that not everyone is going to be pleased with the same
thing, and that a person's chronological age could have a great impact
on their orientation to things and their interpretation of events.
This indicates that the way we address, respond to and deal with guests
must be modified to factor in the age of the individual we are dealing with.
Personality/mood
Our guests will also come to us with a wide variety of personalities and
moods: these may be their 'normal' moods, or they may be due to the fact
that they are on holiday, in a strange/unfamiliar environment, or because
they are angry and frustrated.
We must endeavour to read people's moods and
personalities and respond appropriately. People may be:
timid – this means we need to ensure we are
not over-loud or too familiar: it also means we
shouldn't attempt to make them the centre of
attention or take it upon ourselves to draw
them out of their shell
shy – shy people can be quite happy being shy!
We should respect their orientation and not try
to 'force' them to make new friends, participate
in group activities or mix with others
bright – this person is usually described as 'bright
and bubbly' and expects others to be pretty much
the same. There is nothing worse for this sort of
person than to have to deal with others (including
staff!) who are complaining, downcast and seem
to have the weight of the world on their shoulders
extrovert – this person is a good mixer and likes
everyone (although that perspective may not be
reciprocated). They expect others to be like
themselves – they want to talk, to spend time with
others and to get out and do things. Anything that
doesn't align with this is seen as 'strange' and indicative
that the person is 'a bit weird'
moody – lots of people are moody: it's all part of the human condition
– laughing and happy one day, complaining and unhappy the next. In
the hospitality industry, we have to learn to pick people's moods and
respond appropriately. If they are a bit quiet and 'out of sorts', then it's
63
a safe bet that they will appreciate a bit of a 'shoulder to cry on'.
If they are vibrant, alive and outgoing, then they will expect you
to take your part in their enthusiasm.
While the techniques presented here are widely recognised and used,
you should be aware that your individual workplace may have a
different approach: naturally, house rules and policies must be
followed where they differ from what is presented here.
Various tools have been tried and tested and found to be useful in
helping to help reach a resolution. Some of those tools include:
Show empathy
Empathy means showing understanding and understanding another
persons feelings. The employee should always try to put themselves
into the other person’s shoes.
Within the limits of your authority and/or discretionary power you should
aim to 'take the guest's side': it is useful if you can become the advocate
for the guest rather than be seen as an 'enforcer' for the venue.
Being empathetic also involves recognising, and doing this verbally, that you
realise not only the problem that has caused the conflict/dispute, but that you
64
also appreciate the emotions and feelings that are now caught up in the
whole thing.
Compromise
To compromise means finding an acceptable solution that is less than the initially
expected position: the steak may have been tough and cold but that's something
that can't be changed – ever. The question is, what can we do to try to put it right?
Perhaps we can offer not to charge for it. Perhaps we can offer a free
item and a verbal apology from the chef/manager. Perhaps we can …
: the possibilities for compromise are endless – you just have to make
sure that you don't step outside the limits of your powers.
Cooperating
When handling a conflict situation, you may decide it is best to
cooperate with the parties involved.
This generally means agreeing with the parties in a positive
manner and working with them to find a speedy resolution.
In most conflict situations, cooperating is an excellent technique to use
because it gets the guests what it is they are after. However, you must
never agree with the parties’ requests or demands if they are not in line
with the establishment’s policies and procedures, or if they are beyond the
limits of your personal jurisdiction.
You should then make sure that all parties involved are in agreement
with the summary you have given: it is important that you have not left
out any points that the guests see as critical. Be prepared to amend
your summary to factor in any further points that are made.
65
Developing solutions
Any solutions decided on with the conflicting parties will greatly depend
on the guidelines set out in the workplace policies and procedures.
Example one
A hotel may permit their reception staff to give away a complimentary
restaurant meal to a guest who has complained, while another property
may stipulate that only managers are authorised to give away
complimentary restaurant meals to guests who have complained.
Example two
The policy of one venue may state that a guest cannot check in
without leaving a credit card imprint, while another hotel’s policy
may state that a guest can check in without a credit card imprint,
but must leave a room deposit.
In some cases, you may choose to ask the conflicting parties what they
would consider to be a satisfactory resolution to the situation: this saves
you having to try to determine what they are seeking – there is always
the risk that you may misinterpret their demands when you don't ask
them specifically what they want. Misinterpreting demands – even when
done innocently – will only serve to inflame the situation.
At all times when handling a conflict situation, you will need to display certain
personal characteristics. These have been found to be useful and effective
when trying to negotiate a solution to
a problem, and they include:
66
acting on workplace policies and procedures – like it or not,
there will be certain boundaries that you must not cross: where
you believe these boundaries should be crossed, you should
involve a more senior person who has the power to do so
exercising patience – you must realise that no conflict can be
solved instantaneously: most people demand an opportunity to
voice their displeasure, vent their anger or 'get it off their chest':
in many cases it is only after this has been allowed to occur, can
real progress be made on finding a solution
showing tolerance – there are many times where you will be told that
you are the worst in the world, and you must be prepared to accept
and put up with that. People will often take their frustration out on
you, but you should bear in mind that what they are saying is not
personal, even though it may sound and feel like it! When dealing
with the paying public, being 'dumped on' goes with the territory –
you can't change that, it's just the way it is. Accept the abuse and
criticism as a part of the resolution process, and get on with finding
the solution – don't let it cause further conflict.
understanding the total picture – try to see things from the
other person's perspective. Take into account their feelings
as well as considering what has happened to them
compromising – be prepared to negotiate a way out of the conflict
being consistent – when dealing with guests it is vitally important to
be consistent. Failing to be consistent sends a message that certain
guests are rated differently – and that is likely to spark a whole new
rash of conflict situations!
67
Element 3: Respond to
customer complaints
TRAINING ACTIVITY 3.1 – Research
As mentioned above, you may elect to ask the guest what they want
done to fix the problem.
In most cases, the complainant will tell you what the problem is, but their
offering is certain to leave out relevant information: this information may be
information which lessens their case, or which puts a different slant on their
68
allegations. Or it may be information that would really help them if
they only knew it.
The fact remains that you must talk to the guest and ask questions to flesh out the
full nature of the conflict. In the first instance, this detective work may simply serve
to alert you to the fact that the issue is beyond your ability or authority to remedy,
thereby indicating that a manager needs to become involved.
When talking to the person(s) you should attempt to find out various bits of
information – the more detailed and accurate the information, the better:
Names of those involved
Promises that the establishment may have made
Service or products that failed to live up to promises or
expectations, including how they failed to deliver
on quality or expectations
Timelines relating to the complaint
Costs, money or charges involved
The factual details, as far as can
be determined, as to what was
said and by whom
Actions – or inactions – taken
(or not taken) by the staff
When you have uncovered all the details about the issue, repeat them
back to the person to ensure you have interpreted correctly and to give
them an opportunity to clarify points or to add further comments.
The next step is to seek agreement about what can or should be done to
fix the problem.
69
Some of the points set out below have been covered earlier, but is
useful to see the model laid out in one place in its entirety:
Listen carefully
Listen, listen, listen to everything the customer has to say (even
though it may be the last thing that you feel like doing!) – recognise
and respect the customer’s thoughts and feelings: show genuine
interest in their needs and expectations.
Acknowledge
Establish the scope and nature of the problem along with any history
that might accompany it, or the complainant. Verbally summarise the
conflict and ensure that the parties involved agree with your summary.
Respond
Inform the customer of the action you wish to take – this course of
action may have been proposed by them, by you, or arisen through
negotiation – and check to see if this action is deemed acceptable.
Make sure the action is in-line with establishment policies and
procedures and that you have the authority to make that decision. If
not, seek information from a higher authority.
Inform them of the timeframe that you expect to apply to
implementing the resolution.
Never make up excuses or blame another colleague for a problem –
even if it may be true!
Take action
This is usually what the guest wants you to do!
You now have to act to implement the agreed upon solution within a
reasonable time frame: if ever there looks like being a delay in executing
the resolution you absolutely must inform the guest at the earliest possible
opportunity and provide a full explanation of the hold-up. Never let a delay
just drag on and on, without keeping the guest up-to-date and informed.
Report
It is part of your role to inform a higher authority of complaint
where necessary.
These instances are usually where the person:
was very, very irate
made threats
indicated they would complain in writing
damage was done
is a regular patron.
Follow-up
There may be an in-house to debrief with other staff and/or management,
or to complete relevant documentation as requested by the establishment.
70
There is commonly a timeframe within which such follow up must
occur – within 24 hours is common.
Case studies
The following scenarios are examples of how to turn a complaint
into an opportunity:
71
In the above examples, the customers could quite possibly be more
than satisfied with the prompt response by staff to finding an
immediate resolution.
72
Effective complaint handling strategies include listening attentively to the customer's issues, showing empathy, and taking responsibility for resolving the complaint. Personnel should gather detailed information about the complaint, acknowledge the problem, and seek agreements on solutions. Employing techniques such as offering a private space for discussion and summarizing the complaint back to the customer strengthens understanding. The Six-Step Method, including listening, acknowledging, and taking action based on the customer's feedback, is a recommended approach to resolving complaints satisfactorily .
Cultural differences affect customer expectations, perceptions of service quality, and communication styles. Hospitality staff can accommodate these differences by being knowledgeable about various cultural norms and preferences, such as differing attitudes towards time management and eye contact. Providing multilingual resources and avoiding idiomatic language are essential in helping guests feel comfortable and respected. Recognizing and understanding these variations enable staff to bridge cultural gaps, enhance service delivery, and ensure guests have a positive and authentic experience .
Communication barriers, such as language differences and misunderstandings of non-verbal cues, can significantly impact the experiences of overseas guests. These barriers may lead to confusion, misinterpretations, and dissatisfaction. Solutions include providing multilingual signage and documents, training staff in basic foreign language skills, and employing interpreters when necessary. Additionally, being culturally sensitive and avoiding idiomatic expressions can enhance understanding and create a more welcoming environment for foreign guests .
The hospitality industry can tailor services for overseas guests by offering multilingual resources, providing familiar food and beverage options, and incorporating cultural elements from guests' home countries. Services such as featuring homeland news, music, and employing staff from guests' countries can make visitors feel more at home. Attention to cultural sensitivities, such as understanding appropriate non-verbal cues and communication styles, and ensuring clear communication can significantly enhance the overall guest experience and satisfaction .
Non-verbal communication plays a crucial role in enhancing service quality as it aids in accurately interpreting customer needs and emotions, which allows staff to respond appropriately. By observing body language, gestures, and mannerisms, hospitality employees can detect unspoken concerns and preferences, enabling them to provide tailored services, rectify potential issues proactively, and improve customer satisfaction. The ability to read these cues can elevate service from standard to outstanding, making guests feel valued and understood .
Empathy is crucial in resolving conflicts as it fosters understanding and creates a connection with the aggrieved party. Staff can demonstrate empathy by actively listening, acknowledging the guest's emotions, and showing genuine concern for their issues. By putting themselves in the guest's shoes and advocating for their needs, staff can defuse tension and work towards a mutually beneficial resolution, while maintaining the guest's dignity and trust .
The use of space significantly influences power dynamics and interactions within hospitality settings. Individuals with more authority often have access to larger, more private spaces, which visually reinforce their status. Guests and staff may adjust their physical proximity based on perceived authority and influence. Recognizing these spatial cues and adjusting environments accordingly can help hospitality staff manage interactions more effectively and ensure guests feel appropriately respected and accommodated .
Recommended practices for clear communication with guests who have language difficulties include speaking slowly, using simple language, and avoiding idiomatic expressions. Staff should maintain a normal volume, offer visual aids when possible, and ensure attentive listening to gauge understanding. Providing written translations and employing interpreters can further assist in bridging language gaps. Emphasizing patience and a willingness to clarify information can enhance mutual understanding and improve guest satisfaction .
Cultural customs in non-verbal interactions, such as eye contact and gestures, vary significantly between cultures, impacting guest relations. For instance, direct eye contact may signify honesty in some Western cultures, yet be perceived as rude or intrusive in others. Similarly, gestures like smiling and personal space boundaries can differ widely. Misinterpretations of these non-verbal cues can lead to discomfort or perceived disrespect. Understanding and adapting to these cultural nuances are essential for maintaining positive guest relations and ensuring that all guests feel respected and valued .
Effective communication in the hospitality industry encompasses both verbal and non-verbal elements. Key elements include clear purpose for each message, matching messages to receiver's interests and abilities, eliminating unnecessary words, and ensuring clarity and conciseness. Additionally, proper tonality, speed, volume, and inflection are crucial. Non-verbal cues, such as body language and gestures, also play a significant role in conveying messages effectively .