Online vs Traditional Banking Analysis
Online vs Traditional Banking Analysis
1
Project Report
Submitted by
Supervised by
2
Annexure- I
Supervisor’s Certificate
The project report, which she is submitting, is her genuine and original work to
the best of my knowledge.
Place: Signature:
Date: Name: Twinkle Agarwal
Designation:
Name of the college: Shri Shikshayatan College
3
Annexure: II
Student’s Declaration
I hereby declare that the project work with the title ONLINE BANKING VS.
TRADITIONAL BANKING submitted by me for the partial fulfilment of the
degree of [Link]. Honours in accounting & finance under the University of
Calcutta is my original work and has not been submitted earlier to any other
university for the fulfilment of the requirement for any course of study.
I also declare that no chapter of this manuscript in whole or in part has been
incorporated in this report from any earlier work done by others or by me.
However, extracts of any literature which has been used for this report has been
duly acknowledged providing details of such literature in the references.
Place: Kolkata Signature
Date: 30/06/2021 Name: TWINKLE AGARWAL
Address: C/o- Twinkle Motors, Soro
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I express my thanks to the Principal of our college for providing the excellent
infrastructure for completion of this project work.
My sincere thanks to Prof. Sapna Shaw who have provided support directly or
indirectly for completion of my project.
I am also indebted to my tuition sir, my friends and my family members who have
extended support and help for completion of this project.
I am grateful to all other teachers of The Shri Shikshayatan College for their
valuable suggestions. I express my sincere thanks to our librarian and all staff
member of our Library Department for their kind co-operation during the
execution of this project work.
5
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Most people are very familiar with how a bank operates. The concept is very
simple; you take your money to the bank and they will keep it safe for you and
you can collect it later. There are other uses of a bank, such as loans and interest.
But with nearly everything going digital, including money transfers, paychecks,
bill payments and debit cards, cash is practically becoming obsolete. And while
some might be slightly nervous to make the switch to an online-only bank, there
are some terrific benefits to online banking. Some of the best online banking
services
People are probably very comfortable walking into your local bank and
depositing a check or making a withdrawal. However, you are also probably very
familiar with the lines associated with doing even the most basic tasks. And in
order to get into the building, you will have to keep in mind all the federal
holidays and other banking days when the bank won’t be open. And if you need
to visit the bank past regular business hours, forget it, it ‘ll just have to wait until
the next day. Traditional banking has some serious flaws in hours of operation
and convenience, which is why online banking can be so appealing.
With online banking, you will not ever have to worry about full access to your
account. You ‘ll have quick and easy 24-hour access from anywhere in the
world. The online bank will not ever be closed for a holiday or for maintenance.
You will not ever have to rush over to the bank after work and fight lines because
with online banking, you can access your account from any computer with an
internet connection. Also, because online banking services don’t have to rent a
building, they often offer higher interest rates with their savings accounts.
6
Depositing funds and using the online banking services is simple and quick. The
most common and easiest way to use the internet bank is to have a direct deposit
established with an employer. Most employers prefer direct deposit and setting
up an account is free and simple. You can also move funds into an online bank
via an online transfer or money transfer. Most online banks have check scanning
and check entry money depositing options as well. And, of course, there’s always
the standard United States Postal Service mailing system to deposit funds as well.
When you need to withdraw funds from your online banking service, you can use
a debit card or a standard ATM card. Many of the cards have very similar setups
as the standard and more traditional banks. You can use the debit card for any
online or retail shopping and the ATM cards work in any ATM machine. There
is almost no difference between the ways you would use an online banking
service card and a card from a traditional bank.
Online banking can be intimidating if you are new to the idea. But with the
added convenience, higher interest rates and overall better-quality service, it is
an appealing option for many.
TECHNOLOGY in Banking
Many of the largest and most successful banks in the world emerged from the
technical changes, they can recognize at an early stage. India’s Banking sector
has a long way to go before it can compete globally. Situation is especially
maintained in the late introduction of ICT in Indian banks. Our information
technology is designed to compete with information technology in the world and
when we are in the area very quickly, it may be difficult for us to benefit from
liberalization.
In future, the banks freed from the constraints of a delivery channel. They can
create package, market, and product niches and because the tumbling price of
the technology, they can do so cost-effectively.
This study is needed to find out the working of online banking in respect to
traditional banking system and its importance to customer as well as to bank.
8
1.3 Review of Literature
Rogers,1983 identifies and describe the adoption issues that exist in Indian banks
regarding internet banking, I have read many articles like diffusion model by
analyzed consumers’ attitude towards direct banking (Lockett and Littler,1997).
The main advantage that I found in these researches regarding internet banking
is that its availability 24 hours a day and 7 days a week. The main disadvantages
associated with direct banking, however, included its complexity and the
security risks involved in using it. The results of this exploratory study are used
to confirm the choice of approach to the main study.
In December,2005 the global internet access exceeded the 1000 million mark;
this was one of the most important milestones in the internet revolution
(IWS,2006). According to ABA (2004) and FOX (2005) internet-based strategy
is more effective than the traditional banking as according to reports it is more
profitable, loyal, and produces committed consumers. According to Black tabs
(2002)-In the new banking environment, internet banking is increasingly
managed as an operational activity and an important component of multi-channel
strategy.
9
1.4 Objectives of study
Type of Data: -
A. PRIMARY DATA: -
10
B. SECONDARY DATA:
METHODOLOGY: -
A well-structured questionnaire was administered among 30
respondents of which 25 respondents are aware of online banking.
Simple graphical tools are used as methodology.
11
CHAPTER 2
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
12
Traditional banking in detail
13
2.2 Advantages and Disadvantages of online banking and
traditional banking
ADVANTAGES:
ONLINE BANKING:
It's generally secure. But make sure that the website you're using has a
valid security certificate. This lets you know that the site is protected from
cyber-thieves looking to steal your personal and financial information.
You have twenty-four-hour access. When your neighborhood bank closes,
you can still access your account and make transactions online. It's a very
convenient alternative for those that can't get to the bank during normal
hours because of their work schedule, health or any other reason.
You can access your account from virtually anywhere. If you're on a
business trip or vacationing away from home, you can still keep a watchful
on your money and financial transactions - regardless of your location.
Conducting business online is generally faster than going to the bank. Long
teller lines can be time-consuming, especially on a Pay Day. But online,
there are no lines to contend with. You can access your account instantly
and at your leisure.
Many features and services are typically available online. For example,
with just a few clicks you can apply for loans, check the progress of
your investments, review interest rates and gather other important
information that may be spread out over several different brochures in the
local bank.
14
TRADITIONAL BANKING:
DISADVANTAGES:
Online banking
Discrepancies between what were expected by the customers and what were
delivered by the bank were found in the availability of the instructions in only
two to three languages. This is alarming because human interactions occur so
seldom and when they occur, they do so in critical situations. If these high-touch
interactions of the high-tech service process fail, there are fewer opportunities to
recover the mistake than in high-touch service processes. Indeed, based on the
nature of the relationship with customers, banking services involve a continuous
flow of interactions between the customer and the service provider.
India has one of the lowest broadband connectivity penetration rates in Asia as
compared to Japan, Taiwan, Korea, and Singapore. While the bigger cities such
as Mumbai, Delhi, Chennai, and Bangalore have relatively better broadband
penetration rates, PC users in smaller cities and towns still use dial-up options to
15
connect to the Internet. Slow connectivity speeds often dampen the online
banking experience for many customers, eager to use such services.
Ubiquitous and prevalent online threats about hackers, identity theft, stolen
passwords, viruses, worms, and spyware tend to make customers wary just like
in any other country. Conservative Indian bank customers used to years of saving
in an erstwhile mixed-socialist economy are always fearful of losing hard-
earned savings in online scams. These customers are also not sure about the
efficacy of banks’ websites and their commitment to allocate funds for reliable
16
encryption mechanisms and robust back-end technologies and systems.
5. Other Problems
Traditional banking
Limited Accessibility
Less Efficient
Getting in the car, driving to a bank, and waiting in line to be served takes up
your valuable time. It is more efficient to do your banking online, where you can
open new accounts, set up auto bill pay, check account balances, and transfer
funds all from your own computer.
Online banks are typically able to offer much lower interest rates than traditional
banks because they have much lower overhead costs. An October 2016 study by
[Link], revealed that the average interest rate for a savings account at
an online business was 0.569 percent, while it was just 0.123 percent at a
traditional bank.
17
2.3 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ONLINE BANKING AND
TRADITIONAL BANKING
Online banks are the way of future. Online banks seem to have it all: relatively
high interest rates, stellar customer service, low fees, and the added bonus of
24/7 access to your finances with the click of the button.
Still, online banking is not for everyone, and the line between the two concepts is
becoming blurred as more banks ramp up their web presence to compete
1. SECURITY- This is one issue that scares many people away from taking
their banking online. Even traditional banks have all your financial
information stored in a big data center that could be vulnerable to hackers.
“Data theft” is the very real risks these days, but, unfortunately, as a
consumer, it doesn’t come down whether you choose to bank online.
RICHARD BARRINGTON said.
2. FEES- online banks are friendlier to smaller depositors because they
typically required lower monthly balances. Barrington said, Traditional
banks require an average of about $4700 to be kept in your savings account
without charging you a nominal monthly maintenance fee. For online
banks, the number is much lower at $350. In additions, online banks are
about twice as lightly to offer free checking, he said.
3. ATMs- Banking is all about getting cash when you need it, and Barrington
said, people should look at a location of a bank’s ATMs before they open
an account. “you want to make sure you choose a bank where the
geographic footprint of the ATM network is similar to your regular
movements” Barrington said.
Traditional banks have ATMs allover in many major cities. Online banks often
have agreements with ATM networks at all points with surcharge free
withdrawals and most others offer to reimburse customers up to certain sum for
using out of network ATMs.
18
4. DEPOSITS-Web based banks offer a few different options to deposit physical
checks. You can always mail them in, but most online bank also offer e-deposits
in which you can take a picture of the front and back of each check and upload it
to your account for deposits. A lot of people still would rather deposit a check
with a teller than a text message, but the options out there.” People are for the
most part checking their balances online, getting information online, but when it
comes to depositing a check, they’d much rather hand it to a teller,” Barrington
said.
5. INTEREST RATES- Online banks typically have better interest rate than
traditional banks because they don’t need to take any funds to operate brick and
mortar buildings. In recent study, online banks were found to have about six times
higher interest rates than the nationwide average.
6. CUSTOMER SERVICE- If you like to deal with the people managing your
money via email or over the phone, go digital. If you would rather have someone
to talk things through with face to face, stick with a regular bank. Nearly all banks
also have call centers and online message centers as well. Online banks are rarely,
if ever, “closed.” But if you would rather use a traditional bank to complete your
transaction or get question answer in person, you will need to visit your bank
during normal business hours and make sure it’s not a bank holiday.
19
If people are comfortable with technology and do not feel like they need to face
time with the people handling your cash, keeping their savings in an online bank
is a great option. Their money will grow faster with a big bank, and they will pay
less in fees. As far as checking accounts go, online and traditional bank are pretty
much neck in neck.
The common denominator is that online bank is cheaper for banks to provide
because they are not supporting a physical branch and people to staff that branch.
Even banks that offer both are like to offer you high rates and lower fees if choose
online options.
20
paper concludes that in years to come e-banking will not only be acceptable
mode of banking but preferred mode of banking.
National scenario on traditional banking-The banking industry in
India has a huge canvas of history, which covers the traditional banking
practices from the time of Britishers to the reforms period, nationalization
to privatization of banks and now increasing numbers of foreign banks in
India. Therefore, Banking in India has been through a long journey.
Banking industry in India has also achieved a new height with the changing
times. The use of technology has brought a revolution in the working style
of the banks. Nevertheless, the fundamental aspects of banking i.e., trust
and the confidence of the people on the institution remain the same. The
majority of the banks are still successful in keeping with the confidence of
the shareholders as well as other stakeholders. However, with the changing
dynamics of banking business brings new kind of risk exposure. In this
paper an attempt has been made to identify the general sentiments,
challenges and opportunities for the Indian Banking Industry. This article
is divided in three parts. First part includes the introduction and general
scenario of Indian banking industry. The second part discusses the various
challenges and opportunities faced by Indian banking industry. Third part
concludes that urgent emphasis is required on the Indian banking product
and marketing strategies in order to get sustainable competitive edge over
the intense competition from national and global banks. This article is a
small seed to existing branch of knowledge in banking industry and is
useful for bankers, strategist, policy makers and researchers.
International scenario on online banking-Internet banking involves
consumers using the Internet to access their bank account and to undertake banking
transactions. At the basic level, Internet banking can mean the setting up of a Web page
by a bank to give information about its product and services. At an advance level, it
involves provision of facilities such as accessing accounts, funds transfer, and buying
21
financial products or services online. This paper is an attempt to explore the various
levels of Internet Banking services provided by banks using the secondary data. It also
compares the traditional banking systems with net banking. It lists out the various
advantages of internet banking and the successful security measures adopted by
different banks for secured banking transactions. It also analyzes how E-banking can
be useful for banking industry during this global financial meltdown.
International scenario on traditional banking- The traditional branch model of
bank is now giving place to an alternative delivery channels with ATM network. Once
the branch offices of bank are interconnected through terrestrial or satellite links, there
would be no physical identityfor any branch.
22
CHAPTE 3
14
12 Based on age
10
8
votes
6
Series1
4
2
0
18-28 29-40 40 and above
age
Based on sex
16
14
12
10
votes
8 Series1
6
4
2
0
male female
sex
23
Analysis based on occupation
14
Based on occupation
12
10
6
Series1
4
0
BUSINESS SERVICES OTHERS
occupation
20
VOTE
15
Series1
10
0
yes no
RESPONSES
Findings: The figure shows the % of users who are aware of the online banking
system across the past few years. The above figure shows the increased number
of users who are totally aware of this system.
24
2. What kind of banking do you prefer
12
10
6
Series1
0
COMPLETELY PARTIALLY NOT AT ALL
FINDINGS: This shows us the preference of the people towards the type of
banking. They prefer to use the services of both the online and traditional banking
rather than a particular type.
Preferences of people
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40% Column1
30%
20%
10%
0%
online traditional
FINDINGS: The people understand that online banking is better than the
traditional banking because of its nature. While a few of the people are still not
fully convinced.
25
4. Do you feel your account is secured in online banking?
50%
40% vote
Percentage
30%
20%
10%
0%
Yes No Can't Say
Security
FINDINGS: Majority of the people think that their Account is secured, but not
all. Their security concern should be eradicated. This will attract customers.
50%
45%
40%
35%
Percentage
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Weekly Monthly Regularly Rarely
Time period
26
FINDINGS: Most of the people do not need the services of banks regularly or
maybe there is no need. They may transact with the bank on monthly basis for
most of the time.
12
SATISFACTION OF CONSUMERS OF
10 ONLINE BANKING
8
NO OF POPLE
6
Series1
0
COMPLETELY PARTIALLY NOT AT ALL CAN’T
RESPONSE SAY
FINDINGS: The satisfaction level of people with the online banking services of
their banks has a mixed review. This may be due to multiple reasons.
50%
40%
Percentage
30%
20%
10%
0%
Check Balances Payments Transfer of Funds Other
Types of transactions
27
POLL out of 25: Check balances- 11; Payments-7; Transfer of Funds-2; Other- 5
FINDINGS: The utility of the online banking in service, is not used to the
extent it should be and it is being majority used for the purpose of checking the
balance in the account. The reason for this is the low volume of transaction
among people
12
No of people
10
8 Series1
6
0
yes no cant say
Responses
Finding: people feel that online banking will definitely make a rapid growth in
its fields. Maximum people have trust on it while some still rely on traditional
form of banking and the rest have mixed responses.
28
9. Does e- banking makes life easier?
100%
80%
60% Series1
40%
20%
0%
yes no
answer
Findings: There is no one who thinks that online banking has contributed
nothing in making our life easier. Every other person knows that apart from its
limitations it has made our life easy
29
CHAPTER 4
CONCLUSION:
31
RECOMMENDATION:
After analyzing the entire study on online banking with respect to both the
primary and the secondary data, the following recommendations are put forth: -
32
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Sites consulted
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link] [Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
• REFERENCE BOOKS:
33
Questionnaire
THANK YOU
35