Some Body Measurements As A Management Tool For Shami Goats Raised in Subtropical Areas in Egypt
Some Body Measurements As A Management Tool For Shami Goats Raised in Subtropical Areas in Egypt
Abstract
Background: This filed work was conducted to describe the morphological features of Shami goats in subtropical
areas in Egypt. The study covered Southern Sinai and Noubaria districts in Egypt. Data were collected from 30 goats
of different age groups. Fifteen were males and 15 were females.
Results: Results show that male was heavier and longer than female. The mean live body weight (LBW) of the male
group was 35.40 kg, while that of female group was 33.46 kg. However, these differences were not significant
(P > 0.05). The body length (BL) of male recorded 77.80 cm, while that of the female was 74.73 cm. Similarly,
the heart girth (HG), as well as withers height (WH), was also higher (P < 0.05) in male than those of the female. Both
HG (r = 0. 98) and neck circumference (NC) (r = 0.96) presented the highest correlations with LBW of males, while the
measurements of BL and head length (HEL) presented the highest correlations (r = 0.95–0.86) with LBW of females. Live
body weight of the male was accurately and significantly (P < 0.01) predicted by the measurements of HG and NC with
R2 = 0.98. While BL and paunch girth (PG) were significantly (P < 0.01) used to predict LBW of the female with R2 = 0.92.
Stepwise regression analysis determined that BL and HG were the major significant contributors to the LBW prediction
equation of total (male and female). Body length was the first independent variable to enter the model followed by
HG, NC, and PG entered the best-fitted regression models. Thus, they were the variables entered to obtain the optimal
regression models. The high correlation values between predicted and actual live body weight measurements give
credence to the validity of using these models for predicting live weights of Shami goats.
Conclusions: From this data, it could be concluded that the live weight can be predicted with high accuracy from some
body measurements which can be exploited by goat producers for management, selection, and genetic improvement of
Shami goats and could be used successfully in new breeding programs in Egypt.
Keywords: Body measurements, Management, Regression, Shami goats, Egypt
resource may lead to underutilization of that resource, its Use of Agricultural Animals in Research and Teaching,
replacement, and dilution through crossbreeding despite Federation of Animal Science Societies (FASS, 2010).
their local adaptation to prevailing environmental con- Two groups which contain 30 of bucks and does of
straints (Manzi et al., 2011). Several breeding programs Shami goats. The first group (southern Sinai region) in-
were applied on Shami goats in Syria, Cyprus, and volved 16 heads (10 males and 6 females), aging 1.5–3.5
Lebanon. However, in a review on goat breeding com- years, while the second group (Noubaria region) was
paring the performance of many of the world breeds, formed by 14 heads (5 males and 9 females) aging 1.4 years.
there was a little reference to the Shami (Damascus) According to the environmental conditions at the two
goat (Shrestha and Fahmy, 2007a and b). Shami goats sites under study, all goats were kept under equal man-
obtained importance in recent years, as it is a special- agement and the ration was offered daily in two parts at
ized breed that could increase the productivity of 9 am and 4 pm, approximately. Fresh water and salt
Egyptian goat and reduce kid production costs. Al- blocks were available continuously during the experi-
though, weight is an important objective in a selection, mental period. All animals were fed on concentrate feed
the potential for genetic improvement largely depend mixture (CFM), consisted of 17% wheat bran, 15% cot-
on the genetic and phenotypic parameters of this trait ton seed meal, 50% yellow corn, 15% sunflower meal, 2%
upon which selection may be applied (Mavrogenis et al., limestone, and 1% salt, according to their live body
1984 and Das et al., 1996). Moreover, environmental influ- weight (NRC,1981), plus free available green Acacia and
ences can be controlled and corrected to permit more Atriplex or bean straw, where Acacia saligna and Atriplex
accurate identification of genetic differences between indi- halimus were collected daily from the experimental farm
vidual goats (Hermiz, 1998). During selection of goat, at- in El-Tor city, South Sinai.
tention should be given to the age, growth rate, LBW, HG,
BL, and WH. The prediction of BW and its relationships
Data collection
to other morphological measurements produces appre-
ciable knowledge for breeding investigation with regard to
Assessment of live body weight (LBW) Goats were
meat production per animal (Janssens and Vandepitte,
weighed individually by using a pallet balance of 500 kg
2004; Yilmaz et al., 2013 and Iqbal et al., 2013). The net
capacity, where this body weight was recorded in the
result of dependence on estimated live body weights is
morning before the animals were fed.
inefficiencies in both the management of animals and
inconsistencies in prices of goats which all work against
the farmer. Availability of a weight band and farmer Assessment of body linear measurements The linear
training on how to use it would assist resource-poor dimensions measured included the following eight linear
farmers in implementing good animal husbandry prac- body measurements: heart girth (HG), wither height
tices. The present experimental work, therefore, was (WH), body length (BL), chest depth (CD), head length
undertaken to characterize some body characteristics of (HEL), paunch girth (PG), shank circumference (SC),
Shami goat and has been used to determine the and neck circumference (NC).
best-fitted regression model for prediction of live body The height measurement (cm) was done using a gradu-
weight in subtropical districts such as South Sinai and ated measuring stick. The measurements were taken in the
Noubaria in an effort to develop local goat breeding strat- morning, with the animals standing on a flat surface with
egy in Egypt. head held up and held by three field assistants. The length
and circumference measurements (cm) were effected using
Materials and methods a tape rule. All measurements were carried out by the same
Description of the study area person in order to avoid individual variations.
During the period between 2015 and 2016, sampling was The measurements were taken as follows:
carried out in two selected governorats in subtropical
areas in Egypt, namely Southern Sinai and Noubaria region, 1. Heart girth (HG) was measured as a circumferential
respectively. A total of 30 Shami goats (15 females and 15 measure taken around the chest just behind the
males) located in two selected states. Experimental area has front legs and withers.
an arid climate with hot dry summer and cool winter pre- 2. Wither height (WH) was measured as the distance
vailing in this area. from the surface of a platform to the withers.
3. Body length (BL) was the distance from the base
Experimental procedure of the ear to the base of the tail (where it joins
Sampling procedure the body).
All procedures and experimental protocols were con- 4. Chest depth (CD) was measured as vertical distance
ducted in accordance with the Guide for the Care and from sternum to withers.
S et al. Bulletin of the National Research Centre (2019) 43:17 Page 3 of 6
5. Head length (HEL) was the distance measured from Bivariate correlations between body weight and
nodule of the horn to the upper lip of the animal. measurements of Shami goats
6. Paunch girth (PG) was measured as the circumference The correlation coefficient between live weight and body
of the body immediately after the abdomen just before measurement of the two sexes are shown in Table 2. It is
the hind legs. clear that the majority of correlation coefficients between
7. Shank circumference (SC) was measured from the measurements were high and significant (P < 0.01) in both
left mid metacarpus. males and females. The highest and strongly positive correl-
8. Neck circumference (NC) was measured as the ation (P < 0.01) was recorded between live body weight and
circumference of the neck at the midpoint. heart girth (0.98) for the male and of body length (0.95) for
female goats. On the other hand, lower estimates were re-
corded for the correlation of LBW with both CD (r = 0.76)
Data analysis for male and of NC (r = 0.69) for female does.
The program SPSS (2008) statistical package designed
for windows was used for the statistical analyses. Means Prediction of body weight from body measurements
were separated using the two-tailed, two-sample t test. Based on the importance of the independent variables in
Differences were considered to be significant at P < 0.05. predicting the live weight of Shami goats, three body
Relationships between the several body measurements measurements, namely BL, HG, and NC were found to
were calculated by Pearson correlations, and regression be more efficient. Body length was the first independent
equations were established. Live body weight was regressed variable to enter the model followed by hip HG, and NC
on linear body measurements using stepwise multiple linear entered the best-fitted regression models. Thus, they
regression analysis. The coefficient of determination (R2) were the variables entered to obtain the optimal regres-
was used to assess the accuracy of prediction equations sion models. It is necessary here to say that live weight
between live body weights and linear body measurements. of Shami goats can be predicted from BL and HG with a
Separate prediction equations were developed for the male coefficient of determination 0.92 and HG and NC with a
and female. coefficient of 0.98 for Shami male. Heart girth was not
the best variable to estimate live body weight for female
goats. It was the BL and PG with a coefficient of 0.93,
Results which was used to estimate weight for female. The
Descriptive analysis of body weight and morphological traits best-fitted regression models in each group were in-
Descriptive statistics of LBW and morphometric traits cluded in Table 3.
of Shami goats are shown in Table 1. The results
showed that there was a numerical mean difference be- Weight values corresponding to HG and BL measures for
tween males and females in all morphometric measure- male and female of Shami goats
ments. However, these differences were not significant Predicted live weights based on HG measurements had
(P < 0.05) indicating for HG, WH, BL, CD, HEL, and a 0.96 correlation coefficient to the actual live body
PG. Average live body weight was not significantly (P < weights for male, while predicted live weights obtained
0.05) higher in males than in females. While male had using BL model gave a correlation coefficient of 0.90 to
higher (P < 0.05) SC and NC. the actual live body weights for female (Table 4).
Table 1 Descriptive statistics of the morphological traits of Shami goats based on sex
Traits Shami goats (n = 30) Male (n = 15) Female (n = 15)
Mean SE SD CV (%) Mean SE SD Mean SE SD
LBW 34.43 1.95 10.68 31.01 35.40a 3.05 11.82 33.46a 2.51 9.73
HG 76.43 1.85 10.18 13.31 78.73a 3.04 11.79 74.13a 2.07 8.03
a a
WH 64.96 1.18 6.51 10.02 64.80 1.94 7.54 65.13 1.43 5.56
BL 76.26 1.84 10.09 13.23 77.80a 2.54 9.86 74.73a 2.69 10.43
a a
CD 34.83 0.74 4.06 11.65 35.80 1.06 4.12 33.86 1.00 3.88
SC 8.40 0.21 1.19 14.16 8.86a 0.36 1.40 7.93b .180 .700
a a
HEL 17.93 0.31 1.74 9.70 18.06 0.45 1.75 17.80 .450 1.78
PG 33.20 0.69 3.82 11.50 32.93a 2.13 8.28 33.46a 2.11 8.20
a b
NC 33.06 1.20 6.62 20.0 36.26 1.93 7.48 29.86 .920 3.58
Superscripts a and b mean within rows are significantly different (P < 0.05)
SD standard deviation, SE standard error, CV coefficient of variation
S et al. Bulletin of the National Research Centre (2019) 43:17 Page 4 of 6
Table 2 Bivariate correlations among morphological traits and LBW of male (above diagonal) and female (below diagonal) Shami goats
Traits LBW HG WH BL CD SC HEL PG NC
LBW – 0.979b 0.940b 0.905b 0.764b 0.922b 0.854b 0.854b 0.961b
HG 0.830 b
– 0.969 b
0.871 b
0.731 b
0.923 b
0.779 b
0.879b
0.915b
WH 0.796b 0.761b – 0.821b 0.593a 0.899b 0.699b 0.785b 0.853b
BL 0.947 b
0.774 b
0.805 b
– 0.792 b
0.831 b
0.915 b
0.860b
0.887b
CD 0.715b 0.718b 0.799b 0.729b – 0.782b 0.753b 0.721b 0.820b
SC 0.776 b
0.482 0.714 b
0.766 b
0.727 b
– 0.786 b
0.727b
0.871b
HEL 0.858b 0.806b 0.637a 0.839b 0.563a 0.559a – 0.742b 0.892b
PG 0.846 b
0.842 b
0.786 b
0.765 b
0.712 b
0.490 0.707 b
– 0.811b
NC 0.692b 0.487 0.674b 0.700b 0.696b 0.733b 0.578a 0.569a –
a
Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (two-tailed)
b
Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (two-tailed)
Table 3 Regression equations developed to estimate weight from linear body measurements of Shami goats
Groups Model R R2 Adj. R2 S.E R2 change F change Sig. F change
a
Total 1 0.917 0.841 0.835 4.34079 0.841 147.846 0.000
2 0.961b 0.923 0.918 3.06535 0.083 29.148 0.000
Model summary Regression equations
a. Predictors: (constant), BL LBW = − 200939.582 + 0.970* BL
b. Predictors: (constant), BL, HG LBW = − 46.726 + 0.542* BL + 0.521* HG
Male 1 0.979a 0.958 0.955 2.52153 0.958 294.891 0.000
b
2 0.992 0.984 0.982 1.60140 0.027 20.231 0.001
Model summary Regression equations
a. Predictors: (constant), HG LBW = − 41.864 + .981* HG
b. Predictors: (constant), HG, NC LBW = − 35.829 + 0.611* HG + 0.637* NC
a
Female 1 0.947 0.897 0.889 3.23887 0.897 113.568 0.000
2 0.966b 0.933 0.922 2.72650 0.036 6.345 0.027
Model summary Prediction equations
a. Predictors: (constant), BL LBW = − 32.589 + 0.884* BL
b. Predictors: (constant), BL, PG LBW = − 48.080 + 0.675* BL + 0.347* PG
Superscripts a and b mean within rows are significantly different (P < 0.05)
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed)
S et al. Bulletin of the National Research Centre (2019) 43:17 Page 5 of 6
Table 4 Predicted live body weight (kg) of Shami goats given predictors to assess live weight according to reported that
HG (cm) for male and BL (cm) for female heart girth in males is a good predictor of live weight in
N Male Female Bengal goats. The result is generally in agreement with Taye
HG (cm) ALBW (kg) PLBW (kg) BL (cm) ALBW (kg) PLBW (kg) et al. (2010) who reported that HG is the best predictor of
1 83.00 44.00 39.38 87.00 42.00 44.32 weight. Nevertheless, HG parameter is the easiest way to
2 96.00 53.00 52.31 93.00 50.00 49.62
use for live weight prediction in field conditions.
3 97.00 53.00 53.29 83.00 41.00 40.78
4 72.00 30.00 28.77 85.00 44.00 42.55 Live weight values corresponding to HG and BL measures
for male and female Shami goats
5 75.00 33.00 31.70 70.00 30.00 29.29
The R2 value of 0.96 for the exponential model with HG
6 80.00 33.00 36.54 60.00 22.00 20.45
as the sole finding of this investigation in the study is in
7 82.00 36.00 38.58 60.00 23.00 20.45 close agreement with de Villiers et al. (2009), who used
8 58.00 14.00 15.00 74.00 33.00 32.83 nonlinear regression models on data collected from 1202
9 69.00 23.00 25.83 81.00 41.00 39.00 Boer goats and reported an R2 value of 89.4 for a heart
10 61.00 20.00 17.97 67.00 25.00 26.63 girth-based prediction model. The high correlation values
11 83.00 43.00 39.56 77.00 27.00 35.48
between predicted and actual live body weight measure-
ments give credence to the validity of using these models
12 96.00 52.00 52.31 79.00 41.00 36.75
for predicting live weights of Shami goats. Also, the ob-
13 72.00 30.00 28.77 78.00 40.00 36.36 tained results of this study is in close agreement with de
14 75.00 32.00 31.71 60.00 20.00 20.45 Villiers et al. (2009), who indicted that measurements give
15 82.00 35.00 38.58 67.00 23.00 26.63 credence to the validity of using these models for predict-
ALBW actual live bodyweight, PLBW predicted live body weight, HG heart girth, ing live weights of Swazi goats.
BL body length
Funding Isaac JL (2005) Potential causes and life-history consequences of sexual size
This research was funded by “The project (Technology Transfer for the dimorphism in mammals. Mammal Rev 35:101–115
Development of Small Ruminant in Southern Sinai) in cooperation with Islam MR, Saadullah M, Howlider MAR, Huq MA (1991) Estimation of live weight
Animal Production Department, National Research Centre. and dressed carcass weight from the different body measurements of goats.
Indian J Anim Sci 61:460–461
Availability of data and materials Janssens S, Vandepitte W (2004) Genetic parametres for body measurement and
The privilege of using and accessing morphological data used in this study is linear type trait in Belgian Bleu du Maine, Suffolk and Texel sheep. Small
available to Animal Production Department. National Research Centre. Rumin Res 54:13–24
Khan H, Muhammad F, Ahmad R, Nawaz G, Rahimullah, Zubair M (2006)
Authors’ contributions Relationship of body weight with linear body measurements in goats. J Agr
All authors wrote, read and approved the final manuscript. Biol Sci 1:51–54
Manzi M, Rutagwenda T, Kanuya N, Hatikobo PC (2011) Phenotypic
Ethics approval and consent to participate characterization of goats raised under traditional husbandry systems in
All procedures and experimental protocols were conducted in accordance Bugesera and Nyagatare districts of Rwanda. J Anim Veternary Adv 10(24):
with the Guide for the Care and Use of Agricultural Animals in Research and 3297–3302
Teaching, Federation of Animal Science. Societies (FASS, 2010). Mavrogenis AP, Constantinou A, Louca A (1984) Environmental and genetic
causes of variation in production traits of Damascus goats.1. Pre-weaning
Consent for publication and post-weaning growth. Anim Prod 38:91–97
Not Applicable. Moaeen-ud-Din M, Ahmad N, Iqbal A, Abdullah M (2006) Evaluation of different
formulas for weight estimation in Beetal, Teddi and crossbred (Beetal x Teddi)
Competing interests goats. J Anim Plant Sci 16(3–4):70–74
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Morand-fehr P, Lebbie S (2004) Proposals for improving the research efficiency in
goats. Small Rumin Res 51:145–153
NRC (1981) National Research Council. Nutrient Requirements of Goats: Angora,
Publisher’s Note dairy and meats goats in temperate and tropical countries. National
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in Academy Press, Washington D.C., p 250
published maps and institutional affiliations. Ott RS (1986) Breeding soundness examination of bulls. In: Morrow DA (ed) Current
Therapy in Theriogenology. W. B. Saunder Co., Philadelphia, pp 125–136
Received: 6 June 2018 Accepted: 3 January 2019 Prasad B, Singh CSP, Mishra HR (1981) Note of body weight-measurement
relationship in Black Bengal goats. Ind J Anim Sci 55:880–882
Shrestha JNB, Fahmy MH (2007a) Breeding goats for meat production: a review.
References (2) Crossbreeding and formation of composite population. Small Rumin Res
Abd-Allah, S. (2014). Application of some crossbreeding and feeding programs to 67:93–112
improve the productive performance in Baladi goats. Ph.D. Thesis, Fac. of Shrestha JNB, Fahmy MH (2007b) Breeding goats for meat production: a review
Agric., Al-Azhar Univ. Nasr City, Cairo, Egypt. (3). Selection and breeding strategies. Small Rumin Res 67:113–125
Abd-Allah S, Mohamed MI, Abd-Elrahman HH, EL-Kady RI (2016) Assessment of SPSS (2008) Statistical package for social sciences for window, version 17.0. SPSS
some productive performance of Boer goats and their crosses with Egyptian Inc., Chicago
Baladi goats. Int J ChemTech Res 9(12):259–265 ISSN: 0974–4290 Taye M, Bimerow T, Yitayew A, Mekuriaw SH, Mekuriaw G (2010) Estimation of
Abd-Allah S, Salama R, Mohamed MI, Mabrouk M, El-kady RI, Kadry AI, Ahmed SM live body weight from linear body measurements for Farta sheep. Online J
(2015) A comparative study on reproductive and productive performance of Anim Feed Res 2(1):98–103
Boer and Baladi goats raised under similar environmental conditions in Vargas S, Larbi A, Sanchez M (2007) Analysis of size and conformation of native
Egypt. Int J ChemTech Res 8(9):225–236 ISSN: 0974–4290 Creole goat breeds and crossbreds used in smallholder agro silvo pastoral
Abdel-Mageed I, Ghanem N (2013) Predicting body weight and longissimus systems in Puebla, Mexico. Trop Anim Health Prod 39:279–286
muscle area using body measurements in subtropical goat kids. Egyptian Yilmaz O, Cemal I, Karaca O (2013) Estimation of mature live weight using some
Journal of Sheep and Goat. Sciences 8(1):95–100 body measurements in Karya sheep. Trop Anim Health Prod 45:397–403
Alsheikh SM (2013) Prediction of daily milk yield using different body
measurements of Shami goats in Sinai. Egypt Am-Eurasian J. Agric Environ
Sci 13(2):218–221
Bhattacharya B, Ghosh TK, Duttagupta R, Maitra DN (1984) Estimation of body weight
in Black Bengal goats from body measurements. Indian Vet J 61:406–408
Das, S.M., Rege, J.E.O. and Shibre, M. (1996). Phenotypic and genetic parameters
of growth traits of blended goats at Malya, Tanzania. Proceeding of The
Third Biennial Conference of the African Small Ruminant Research Network.
ILRI. p: [Link], Kenya
De Villiers, J.F., Gcumisa, S.T. and Gumede, S.A. (2009). Estimation of live
body weight from the heart girth measurement in KwaZulu-Natal goats.
Applied Animal Husbandry & Rural Development 2009, Volume 2.
Retrived June 5, 2013
Dubeuf JP, Morand-Fehr P, Rubino R (2004) Situation, changes and future of goat
industry around the world. Small Rum. Res 51:165–173
FAO (2007). Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations. Global
plan of action for animal genetic resources and the interlake declaration.
Rome (Accessed 07/ 01/ 2014)
FAO (2012). Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations.
Phenotypic characterization of animal genetic resources. FAO Animal
Production and Health Guidelines No.11. Rome, Italy
FASS (ed) (2010) Federation of Animal Science Societies. Guide for the care and use
of agricultural animals in research and teaching, 3rd edn. FASS, Champaign
Hermiz HN (1998) Additive and multiplicative adjustment factors for milk traits in
Iraqi local goat. Iraqi JAgric 3(2):164–173
Iqbal M, Javed K, Ahmad N (2013) Prediction of body weight through body
measurements in Beetal goats. Pakistan J Sci 65(4):458–461