Facilitation
Topics covered
Facilitation
Topics covered
I Facilitation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
4. Meeting Formats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
5. Planning Tips . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
II Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
6. Agreements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
7. Appreciations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
8. Ball Toss . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
9. Blackout Bingo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
10. Brainstorming . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
12. Clustering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
25. Intentions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
30. Pop-Ups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
40. Thirty-five . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
III Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51
Recommended Reading List . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52
We are Sam Laing and Karen Greaves. We have worked in software our whole lives. With Type A
personalities and a strong work ethic, we have both done our share of overtime on death march projects.
Eventually we knew we had to find another way. Agile brought us together when we worked at a company
trying to do Scrum for the first time.
In 2012, we took the plunge and started our own business, Growing Agile¹. Since then we have been doing
the work that we are passionate about - introducing and improving agile. Best of all we have a positive
impact on other people’s lives.
One of the most important skills we have learned as coaches and trainers is the skill of facilitation. We
can’t believe we had never learned this in our jobs as managers. When we facilitate meetings for clients
they can’t believe the difference it makes to meetings, and how energetic and engaged everyone is in the
meeting.
Once you’ve read this book, we’d love to get a Feedback Letter from you via email info@[Link]²
or Twitter @GrowingAgile³.
Enjoy!
¹[Link]
²[Link]
³[Link]
i
I Facilitation
1
1. Introduction
Welcome to our book on Facilitation. This book is a collection of facilitation techniques we continually
use in workshops, training courses, meetings and retrospectives. Although we will use the term meeting
as a general word in this book, it applies to all of the above.
It’s taken us several years to master the skill of facilitation, and it continues to amaze us how few people
learn the skill, or even understand what it means. People spend much of their lives in meetings, and yet so
many meetings lack facilitation. We hope this book will inspire you to grow your own facilitation skills
and improve the meetings in your organisation.
Anyone who attends meeting can benefit from this book. However we are specifically aiming the book at
people who regularly run meetings, workshops or training sessions. You might call yourself a facilitator
or trainer, but more likely you have another title and meetings are just how you interact with others to
get things done.
We have used these techniques in many contexts:
Obviously not every technique works remotely as well as it does in person, and some techniques work
better for smaller groups than larger ones, but most techniques can be adapted to your context given a bit
of creativity.
About Facilitation
When training others in facilitation we like to use the following definition from Mindtools¹.
What a facilitator does is plan, guide and manage a group event to ensure that the group’s objectives
are met effectively, with clear thinking, good participation and full buy-in from everyone who is
involved.
From this definition you can see that there would be many benefits to a well facilitated meeting. Here are
some of our favourites:
¹[Link]
2
Introduction 3
One of the most important things you need to do as a facilitator is prepare for and plan the meeting. This
is an often overlooked activity. According to Jean Tabaka in Collaboration Explained², it can take twice
the length of the meeting to prepare adequately for a meeting. We believe this can be less (about the same
length as the meeting) with lots of experience and a well developed toolkit.
²[Link]
2. How to use this book
The techniques in this book can help you prepare and plan for a meeting. Although there are a number
of different meeting formats you can choose to follow, we find most meetings include 4 key parts.
These are:
• Starting
• Diverging
• Converging
• Closing
Starting
Lots of people use the term ‘ice-breakers’ to refer to an activity at the start of a meeting to get people
talking to each other. We don’t like the phrase, maybe because we’ve seen people use the phrase for
activities that are completely unrelated to the topic of the meeting. We prefer the phrase ‘Check in’.
For us a check-in activity has 3 purposes:
• To get everyone in the room to talk in the first 5 minutes of the meeting. Evidence suggests that if
they do, they are more likely to contribute in the rest of the meeting.
• To connect people to the topic of the meeting, and in particular how they feel about the topic, or
what they know.
• To connect people to each other and establish some trust or relationships in the room. This is greatly
dependant on: who the audience is, if they know each other, and how much trust you need in the
room for the meeting you are going to have. All of these are things you need to consider in your
preparation.
Diverging
Most meetings require participants to brainstorm a wide variety of things. For example topics to discuss,
challenges to address, decisions to be made, etc. For anything like this it is important to include activities
that help people diverge. That is to create lots of ideas before they decide which to focus on. The reason
for this is that most of our best thinking doesn’t happen immediately. It also helps a group collaborate
and create an idea together by building on each other’s ideas. We call this the diverging part of a meeting.
Depending on the type of meeting you might have several diverting parts to your meeting.
Converging
While creating lots of ideas is a really useful technique, meetings that don’t bring those together into an
agreed decision or action step, are often a waste. Therefore most meetings require a converging phase
where participants select which ideas they want to try, or choose the best course of action. A converging
phase follows a diverging phase. Again you could have multiple of these in a meeting.
4
How to use this book 5
Closing
Wrapping up or closing a meeting is also crucial. Many meetings that run over time neglect this part
completely. Closings can help people feel their time was valued. It also gives the facilitator an opportunity
to get feedback on their facilitation. Finally it is a great time to wrap up by reminding people of their
actions, and agreeing the next steps that will happen.
Below is a list of these 4 phases. Under each we have indicated which techniques that you find in this
book could work for those phases. Note some techniques work well in more than one area. You can use
this list to quickly find techniques you need to plan your meeting.
Part Techniques
Starting Agreements Ball Toss
Blackout Bingo Failure Bow
Fast Pass Five Personal Questions
Intentions Meet a Stranger
Pair Share Parking Lot
Pop ups Recap Cards
Scenario Cards Shout Out
Silent Cards Speed Dating
Standing Survey Think and Write
Thirty Five Treasure Hunt
What would we be if
• 4C template
• Agreement Cards
• Appreciation Cards
• Facilitation Checklist
• Meeting Template
• Powerful Question Cards
• Room Setup Guide
• Scenario Cards
• Silent Cards
• Treasure Hunt template
You can download the Coach Toolkit from Leanpub or on our website¹.
Please print these out. If you plan on using them often consider getting them laminated to last longer.
¹[Link]
6
4. Meeting Formats
One of the first things you need to decide when planning a meeting is what kind of meeting format you
will use. Often the format is related to the purpose of the meeting.
Here are 5 popular meeting formats we use, as well as the meeting purposes they best suit. We describe
each meeting format in more detail below.
Many meetings exist for people to generate ideas and make decisions about a course of action. In order to
do this successfully for a group there needs to first be a divergent phase, followed by a convergent phase.
To learn more about this and why it is important we recommend: The Facilitator’s Guide to Participatory
Decision Making¹ by Sam Kaner.
If you are familiar with the book Agile Retrospectives² by Esther Derby and Diana Larson, you already
know this pattern. Esther and Diana use 5 stages, but the format essentially follows the diverge, converge
model, with an emphasis on actions since that is the key outcome of a retrospective. In our experience, the
majority of meetings follow (or should follow) this format, which is why we chose it in the introduction
as an index to all the exercises.
4Cs
If you have read any of our other Coach’s Guide books³ you should already be familiar with the 4C format.
This format works well for workshops or training courses where the goal is for people to learn a new skill
or technique.
The 4C technique comes from a training style called Training from the BACK of the room⁴ (TFTBOTR)
developed by Sharon Bowman.
TFTBOTR is based on how adults learn and is focused on maximising learning and retention. TFTBOTR
describes four parts that should be included in any training plan. These parts are known as the 4Cs and
are described below.
• C1 - Connections: To get participants to connect with each other and the trainers, and to connect
participants to what they might already know about the topic.
¹[Link]
²[Link]
³[Link]
⁴[Link]
7
Meeting Formats 8
In this book look under Starting Activities for C1 ideas, Closing Activities for C4 ideas, and Diverge and
Converge for C2 and C3 activities.
Another important part of TFTBOTR is making sure you use a variety of methods to keep people engaged.
Read more about it in this article on the Six Trumps⁵ by Sharon Bowman.
Note
Occasionally it makes sense to swap the order of the C2 and C3. For some topics it is better for
people to experience what you are talking about with Concrete Practice first, and then for you
to teach the theory. This is especially true if you have a great game or simulation to illustrate
the point. When we do this we just put the C3 in the C2 block of the template, and vice versa.
We drive all our workshops and courses from these 4Cs plans. If you usually train from slides this might
take time to get used to. We print out the 4Cs plans and refer to them during the course or workshop to
see what’s up next and if we are on track.
We have created our own template for the 4Cs plans, you can find it in the accompanying Coach Toolkit.
• The box in the top left corner is for the name of the topic.
⁵[Link]
Meeting Formats 9
• The big clock icon gives the time for the entire plan; the smaller clock icons in each quadrant gives
the time needed for that section.
• The box in the top right corner has a space for you to enter the time for a section. For example 9:00
to 9:30 am. This helps you stay on track during the training. These are not filled in on the training
plans we provide. We suggest you fill them in when you have planned your training.
• The rest of the page has a quadrant for each of the 4Cs.
• At the bottom of each quadrant you can circle what the participants are doing in each section: Move,
Speak, Draw, Listen, Write. This helps ensure that you have sufficient variety in each topic.
Lean Coffee
Lean Coffee⁶ is a simple meeting format that works well to maximise the number of topics covered. It was
invented by Jim Benson and Jeremy Lightsmith as a format for group discussions about Lean. However
we have found it an effective format for any meeting where you need to cover many items, especially
status meetings for executive groups that have a lot to get through in a short time, or for Question &
Answer sections in a training course.
Here are 8 steps to running a Lean Coffee.
Open Space
Open Space Technology⁷ is a technique that can be used on a large scale for conferences with thousands
of people over many days, and on a small scale for a single team meeting.
The premise is to set a theme and create some space and time slots, and then let attendees self organise to
create the agenda with their own topics. Facilitating the opening circle is something that takes some skill
and we highly recommend attending an open space event before you attempt to facilitate one yourself.
You can read more about it on [Link]⁸.
⁶[Link]
⁷[Link]
⁸[Link]
5. Planning Tips
This chapter is our list of tips for things to take into account when you are planning to facilitate a meeting.
If you go through this list as a mental (or physical) checklist as part of your preparation each time, you
will quickly master the art of facilitation.
Purpose
The first thing you need to establish for any meeting you facilitate is what the purpose of the meeting
is. The purpose and the desired outcome will influence the type of meeting structure you use as well as
how you allocate time. Often just asking this question reveals common problems as many people who
schedule meetings haven’t even considered this.
Once you understand the purpose take a look at the meeting formats to choose the most appropriate
format for your purpose.
Roles
It is also critical to understand your role in the meeting. Often people confuse the role of meeting owner
or chair with the role of facilitator. Make sure you are clear on what your role is. We define these roles as
follows:
The meeting owner or chair is the person who is calling the meeting and is invested in the outcome of the
meeting.
The meeting facilitator is the person who will plan the structure and activities of the meeting and keep it
on track.
It is most effective when the owner and facilitator are two different people. Facilitators should stay
impartial during the meeting and not contribute to the content of the meeting. This is often difficult
if they are also the owner of the meeting and therefore invested in the outcome. In this case consider
asking someone else to facilitate for you.
Attendees
Next you need to consider who will attend the meeting. There are a number of different things to consider.
First is the number of participants. Every activity you plan will need to take numbers into account. You
need different activities and facilitation techniques when dealing with large groups (more than 12). See
the section below for specific notes on dealing with large groups.
Now consider how well the attendees know each other and what level of trust they have between each
other. Consider the organisational hierarchy or rank of different people. Inviting the CEO to the same
meeting as a group of new hires will significantly impact the meeting dynamics.
If the group are strangers or have low trust, consider using a starting activity to establish some trust, and
create a safe space for the duration of the meeting. The level of trust you have will impact the types of
activities you can use. Very few people will standup in a room of strangers or colleagues they don’t trust
10
Planning Tips 11
and offer their opinion, or admit their own mistakes. Also consider how many introverts and extroverts
are attending (if you can find that out in advance), and especially if there is someone in the room who
likes to talk a lot (like Karen!).
Time
Consider how much time you have, as well as how much time you need for the purpose of the meeting.
You might need multiple meetings if you don’t have a lot of time and need to get consensus in a group. If
time is short, consider if something can be sent to participants in advance to prepare them for the meeting.
However be ready if some people do not do this preparation work.
Next decide how much time you will plan for and how much time you will allow as a buffer. We usually
allow 10 minutes of buffer for every 90 minutes. However as facilitators we are very good at sticking to a
time box. If you find you often overrun, then increase your buffer.
The buffer might also be dependent on the attendees. We have one client where we consistently only plan
for half the time of the meeting and leave a 50% buffer, because they are difficult to timebox, often include
food in meetings (which can steal time), and they like lengthy discussions.
One of the most common reasons that meetings overrun is that they don’t start on time. Many
organisations we work with take 10 or 15 minutes of a meeting to even get started. This is particularly
bad with remote meetings where technology like video and tele conferencing are common. See more on
remote meetings later.
Our advice is to always start on time. Close the door and start the meeting on time. If people arrive late,
let them in, but don’t catch them up. They should feel like they missed out on something by coming late.
Also the fact that they are obviously disturbing people by opening a closed door can make them feel
guilty. Do this a few times and you might notice that people start attending your meetings on time. Even
in companies that are consistently late for meetings, we can usually get people to come to our sessions on
time after about 4 meetings and using this approach. You can also reinforce this behaviour after people
come back from breaks. Tell them when to be back and start on time whether they are back or not.
Of course to start on time you need to be ready and in the room on time, and the previous occupants of
the room need to have left. If this is a common occurrence in your office, book the meeting room for 15
minutes before the start time in order to have sufficient time to setup for the meeting.
You also need to be sure to end on time, or ideally 5 minutes before the end to give people time to get to their
next meeting. This is easy to do if you plan well with a buffer and keep track of the time throughout. If you
realise you are going to overrun, stop the session and discuss what you should do with the participants.
Either everyone agrees to continue for another 30 minutes (if they have no other commitments), or you
decide to reconvene at another time, or you make a decision quickly on the outstanding items. Never leave
this conversation until time has actually run out.
Breaks
People are unable to focus for long periods of time without a break. Also people need breaks for coffee,
water, the bathroom, smoking, to check urgent phone calls etc. If you plan for regular breaks you are much
more likely for people to be engaged during the meeting. We plan for a 20 minute break every 90 minutes,
and allow an hour for a lunch break on meetings running the whole day.
Don’t skimp on breaks because you have a lot to cover like in a backlog grooming session, or training
workshop. If people are tired you are just wasting the time in the meeting, rather than giving them 5 extra
Planning Tips 12
minutes to be refreshed. People do process what you’ve been discussing during breaks, so sometimes a
long break in a heavy thinking session actually helps people have more ideas.
Energy
Although you might plan breaks in advance, also pay attention to the energy in the room. If it is low and
people are checking out either shift a break, or have a shorter adhoc break to get the energy back. You can
even just take a mental break by having people standup and stretch without leaving the room.
You can also plan activities to make sure you have diversity and especially movement regularly. This keeps
people energised and paying attention. Be especially careful with what trainers call the graveyard shift.
This is the 90 minutes directly after a lunch break. People have just eaten and their natural instinct is to
feel sleepy, especially if lunch included lots of sugar (very common at conferences or training venues).
Try to plan activities with lots of hands on action and movement for this timeslot. Avoid anything where
one person talks and others listen. Activities like drawing posters and building Lego are perfect for the
graveyard shift.
Space
Consider the venue or space available for the meeting. The layout of the room can have a big impact on
how people interact in the meeting. Once you start paying attention to this, you will notice patterns. For
example large board room tables are terrible for collaboration. And classroom style seating is usually bad
for learning!
Our preferred layout for nearly every meeting we run is round tables that cater for 4 to 6 people. This is
often called banquet or cabaret style seating. This layout naturally allows people to work in small groups,
which is necessary to ensure engagement. For a small group of 6 people we just need one table, but the
table should be such that everyone feels equal. Not a table with an obvious head, or so large that people
have to cluster around one corner.
Sometimes you might even want a room without a table, especially if you want a more intimate setting.
For example, for a retrospective where a team has high trust. Also consider where you will sit yourself,
and what message that sends to the group. If you stand at the front of the room it creates a very different
dynamic to if you sit at the table with everyone else. Try these out and notice the impact. You might use
your own placement according to the atmosphere you need to create in the room. For a large rowdy crowd
at a conference standing in the front is usually a good option to get attention. For subtle guidance in a
brainstorming meeting where you don’t want to influence the content, sitting behind people, away from
the table might work better.
Experience tells us that it doesn’t matter how clear we are with our room requirements, we usually arrive
and find we need to rearrange the room. If you are not familiar with a venue, always arrive 30 to 60
minutes beforehand in case you need to make a plan with a bad layout. You might even need to change
activities in your meeting plan because of the venue.
We created a Room Layout document to use for clients and conference venues, it is in the Coach Toolkit
for you to use.
Materials
Whenever we plan for a meeting we make a note of the materials we will need and make sure we either
take them with us, or make arrangements that they will be available. You can put together a fairly standard
Planning Tips 13
facilitation kit for yourself that has most things in it, then just add the extras for specific techniques.
Here is an idea of what we’d recommend in your standard kit. There is a checklist in the Coach Toolkit
for you to print out and use.
• flipchart markers
• whiteboard markers
• visible timer for timeboxing activities. We use Timer+¹ on an iPad.
• camera to take pictures
• soft ball that can be thrown around without injuries
• masking tape for sticking up posters
• coloured markers and pens for each table
• sticky notes for each table
• index cards for each table
• Agreement cards
If you are doing a lot of training, we recommend investing in some high-quality markers in different
colours. Our favourite markers are from Neuland². They offer large, refillable, water-based markers in a
great range of colours. Try not to use whiteboard markers on flip charts, they dry out quickly and are too
think to be seen on the other side of a room.
We recommend using a iPad with a timer that you can make visible to all. If you don’t have this, you
can use your phone as a timer. However be aware of the signal you send to participants if you use your
phone during meetings. It sends the message that it is okay for them to use their phone. We prefer to have
specific agreements about people not using phones and laptops in meetings, and model this by not using
them ourselves. The iPad is a great solution because everyone can see that it is only being used as a timer.
We also print out our meeting plan on paper and take it along. We once used a plan on an iPad and again
it sent the signal that we were looking at other things during the session. Even if you are only referring
to the plan, the fact that people can’t see what you are doing is a problem. If you are going to make use
of a laptop in a session for a task board or note taking, make sure the screen is displayed on a projector
so that everyone can see how it is being used.
A common mistake that new facilitators make is to assume they are responsible for taking notes during a
meeting and sharing these afterwards. They also try to capture everything that happened in the meeting
(for example as minutes), when that is not actually required.
Before taking any notes for a meeting decide on the following:
In general we only use 2 types of recording in meetings. Firstly we take photographs of any items created
in the meeting, like posters or mind maps etc. We do this because it is an accurate recording of what
happened and quick to do in the moment and send out directly after the meeting. However, this is not
always necessary. Check if anyone wants photos before you do this. You can decide in the meeting if you
need a photo of anything and then take one.
The second type of recording we do is to note actions. This is probably the most important output of any
meeting. Our preference is that the person taking ownership of the action, writes it down for themselves
on an index card or sticky note and physically takes that item with them out of the meeting.
Followup
Facilitators also fall into the trap of making themselves responsible for following up on actions from the
meeting. Don’t do this.
Instead, structure the meeting so that the group discuss exactly how followup will happen, by who and
by when. Make it specific. For example: Instead of We will share the survey results try this Jane will send
the results of the survey in an email to all the meeting attendees by 2pm on Friday.
The more concrete actions are the more chance there is that they will actually happen.
How to improve
There is a lot of information in this section, and you won’t master it all immediately. However facilitation
is a skill best learned by practicing it.
The best ways to improve is to get feedback from another facilitator. Asking participants for feedback is
one thing, but someone else who know what you are trying to achieve can give you much more specific
feedback. Find someone else looking to learn this skill, and try observing each other and giving feedback
to each other about what you noticed. Pay attention to how participants reacted, energy, content flow
of the meeting, how much people contributed, how engaged they were, how time was managed, where
things and people were positioned in the room, etc. Sometimes just watching someone else helps you
realise things for yourself.
An alternative is to try pair facilitation. We pair work exclusively so we love this approach. We’ve
encouraged others to try it and most people find it preferable to facilitating alone. Here are the benefits
we find to pair facilitation:
Large Groups
If you are dealing with large groups there are a couple of things to be aware of. Firstly, with a larger group
everything takes longer. It takes longer for people to move because the room is bigger. It take longer for
people to find a partner, because there are more people in the room. It takes longer to give instructions
Planning Tips 15
because there is a higher chance that someone misunderstood. Debriefing and consensus take longer
because there are more opinions in the room.
To deal with this the best approach is to divide people into groups of 4 to 6. This size helps to prevent
passengers (people not engaged in an activity). Any activity you would do for individuals you now do as
a group (e.g. brainstorm in your group).
You can also save time by not debriefing to the whole larger group. Maybe ask one or two groups to share,
and then use techniques like the gallery walk for others to share their ideas.
Give one instruction at a time and write it up on a flipchart if you can. In a large group someone will not
be listening or will misunderstand. It also helps to check in with each table group once you have given an
instruction to make sure they understood and are on track.
With a large number of groups you need multiple facilitators so that you can be within earshot of every
group to guide them as necessary. We recommend 1 facilitator per 2 or 3 tables.
Use hand signals that you introduce at the beginning of the meeting and a loud timer or bell for activities
in large groups because they can become very loud and difficult to control.
Correct misunderstood instructions quickly. If you ask someone to share one word and they share a
sentence, correct it immediately otherwise the next person will also share a whole sentence. For 6 people
this only wastes a few minutes, with large groups this can be disastrous.
Remote
More and more people are working remotely. This means as a facilitator it might be necessary for you to
facilitate remote meetings. We have been getting lots of practice doing this, and our advice is to embrace
it rather than to push for everything to happen face to face. As much as we are fans of face to face
communication, we believe that the technology we have today enables very rich remote communication.
Here are our key tips for remote facilitation.
Test the technology and explore different tools, try to make sure you have a backup if one tool is not
working. There is nothing worse than a remote meeting where no one can hear each other and people
don’t know what is happening. So often we arrive at clients for remote meetings and no one knows how
their video conference facility works. Test it out long before the meeting, and until you have it down to a
1 minute setup, schedule 15 to 30 minutes before the meeting to sort out the technology.
Make sure everyone has the same experience. Try to avoid 5 people in a room with a whiteboard and one
person on the phone with no view of the whiteboard. Rather have everyone in front of a laptop with a
shared electronic whiteboard. Also make sure everyone can edit the whiteboard not just one person.
Good audio is better than poor video. Bad video is distracting. If you have online tools like shared
whiteboards you don’t necessarily need to see the person. If you have bandwidth constraints rather kill
the video to ensure the audio is clear. It can also help for people to mute themselves when they are not
speaking, this reduces feedback and background noise.
Learn to respect silence. With everyone on a phone call there will be awkward pauses where no one says
anything and then moments when two people speak over each other. Prepare people for this at the start
of the meeting, and explain how you plan to deal with it. We suggest telling people that silence is okay,
and that if 2 people speak to both stop and the facilitator will then call on them one at a time to share
their insight.
At the start of a remote meeting we introduce the idea of Bottom Lining. On a call, time can seem to feel
longer, so don’t share your thought and how to came to have that thought. Rather just bottom line and
Planning Tips 16
share your thought. If anyone needs more of an explanation they can rather ask for it. We explain that
during the call we might ask someone to ‘bottom line’ if they are being a bit verbose.
Try making use of a chat window as well as a voice call. We find it works well for things like dot voting
or checkins with 6 participants. Our favourite tool is Google Hangout for a number of reasons:
17
6. Agreements
When to use
This sets a tone and expectations near the start of a meeting. It helps the participants know what the
boundaries of the meeting are, and what behaviours are acceptable.
It is best to have each agreement on a card and to go through them near the start of the meeting. These
are in the Coach Toolkit.
How to do this
Decide which agreements are appropriate for your participants and meeting. Explain them clearly and
simply near the start of the meeting.
You can also ask participants if there are any agreements they would like to add.
We change these depending on the type meeting we’re running. Over time you will learn more techniques
and so this list will keep evolving.
Here are some of the cards we have:
• Take Care: Take care of your own needs. You don’t need to ask permission to go to the bathroom,
or to get coffee.
• Cellphones: Keep your phones on silent please. If you need to take a call, just leave the room. We’d
rather you were paying attention than worrying because your boss/wife/child is calling.
• Right to Pass: You have the right to pass in any activity or exercise we do. Just sit to the side and
observe.
• Workbooks: These are yours to keep. Please take notes. We will let you know when we are doing
specific exercises in the books.
• Timeboxing: We give a specific end time for each break. We will start at that time whether you are
back or not. It’s up to you to choose to be on time or not.
1
Agreements 2
Various people over the years, many from Sharon Bowman¹. We came up with the concept of using cards
to remember all of the things we wanted to say.
¹[Link]
7. Appreciations
When to use
To build a culture of appreciation within a team and make the team members feel valued. Helps with
collaboration amongst team members.
Nothing
How to do this
In any meeting introduce this technique by saying you would like to provide a space for people to recognise
and appreciate anyone who has helped them recently. Ask people to try to give personal appreciations to
individuals rather than to the whole team.
Take the lead and give an example by appreciating someone, e.g. “John, I’d like to appreciate you for the
courage you showed in today’s session by voicing your doubts about the new process.”
Then be quiet. If this is the first time the group does this, it may take some time for the first person to
speak. Just hold the silence, someone will speak. Remember to allow about a minute of silence before
closing this session as some people take longer to speak than others.
• We have also asked participants to write down an appreciation, and pass it to that person. These
are in the Coach Toolkit.
• Start with a ball of string and say an appreciation, throw the ball to the person you appreciated, but
keep holding the end. They now give an appreciation and throw the string to that person. At the
end you can see a web of how everyone is interconnected and collaborate together.
3
8. Ball Toss
5 5 - 25 Movement
minutes people Feedback
When to use
A good way to close a meeting with some movement, and to give people an opportunity to share their
thoughts and give you some feedback.
A soft ball.
How to do this
Ask people to stand up and form a circle. If you have the space to do this away from tables then do so,
but if not create a circle around the tables.
Explain that the ball is the speaking token. Then explain that you will pose a question for them to answer.
If they would like to answer, they should signal to the person with the ball and they will gently toss it to
them. They can then answer the question you posed.
Remind people that once they have answered they should look for someone else signalling that they want
the ball. Often people get flustered and just throw the ball when they are done answering. Ask people a
question about the meeting. Its a good idea to make this a one or two word answer to avoid any lengthly
answers. For example: What is one thing that surprised you in this meeting?
Wait for someone to ask for the ball, then gently toss it to them. Once the ball stops moving for a while,
you can signal for the ball again, and close the meeting by thanking people for their time.
• Use this to close the day on a one-day training course, by asking people to share one word that best
describes the day for them.
• Use this to close retrospectives by asking people what their hope is for the next sprint.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
4
9. Blackout Bingo
When to use
Helps people stay focused and engaged during a meeting. Adds an element of fun to meetings and
potentially helps people break habits of using catch phrases.
• Printed Bingo sheets and pens for each person in the meeting.
Make Bingo sheets by printing a sheet of paper with 8 blocks on it. Fill each block with a word or phrase
that might occur during a specific meeting or training session, e.g. “improvement”, “collaboration” or
“impediment” for retrospectives. If someone has a habit of using a particular phrase like “stuff”, put that
on the sheet.
How to do this
Hand out a Bingo sheet to each person at the start of the meeting or training session. When one of the
words is said in the meeting, the person colours in the block. When all words are coloured on their sheet
they shout “Bingo!” You could have a small prize for the first person to get Bingo.
• Make each sheet different and have one sheet per participant.
• Get people to create their own sheets with words they think will be said.
• In a training session, have key learning points on the sheet (1 - 2 words). This helps as a refresher
of topics.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
5
10. Brainstorming
When to use
How to do this
Tell people the goal is to generate as many ideas as possible in a short amount of time. Remind them not
to filter ideas yet, and wacky ideas and stupid ideas are allowed, as they might spark other ideas.
Ask people to write one idea per sticky note so that they can be clustered later. Remind them to write
legibly.
As people write their ideas down you can ask them to share them out loud. This sometimes sparks an idea
for someone else.
Give people a large goal to aim for e.g. 30 ideas per person. It doesn’t matter if they reach this number,
but the large goal will push them to create more than they might have done otherwise.
Remind people of the topic or questions they are brainstorming about, and maybe write it up on a flipchart
or whiteboard. Give them a timebox of 5 or 10 minutes. Near the end of the timebox when writing has
slowed down prompt them with some unusual ideas of your own to get the creative juices flowing, or ask
a powerful question.
You can also do this as a silent brainstorm where people write their ideas in silence. This helps if you don’t
want participants to anchor each other, and works particularly well with introverts or participants who
are new to a group or more junior than others who might be hesitant to contribute.
6
11. Brain writing
When to use
To help people come up with ideas and let them think out the box.
How to do this
Ask a question or state something. Now ask everyone for 5 minutes of silence to write down everything
that comes into their minds, e.g. ideas, questions, etc. Explain to them that they will be passing on the
paper and so to write neatly and not take up all the space on the page. After 5 minutes pass ask them to
pass on the sheet to the person next to them.
Allow another 5 minutes to read and write thoughts on this new sheet of paper. They can add to ideas,
make new ones, etc. Keep passing the sheets around for about 20 minutes or until everyone has written
on all the sheets of paper.
We experienced this many years ago, but can’t recall who shared it.
7
12. Clustering
5 5 - 12 Prioritisation
minutes people
When to use
Group ideas from a brainstorming exercise into related topic or themes to reduce the number of items you
have, and get rid of duplicates. Often used before dot voting.
How to do this
Ask people to gather either around a table or wall space. If the sticky notes have not yet been placed, ask
people to place them on the table or wall.
Now ask people as a group to cluster sticky notes together that have similar ideas.
Tell them the goal is to identify key themes or topics. For example desk space and coffee machine might
be grouped under Facilities.
Encourage everyone to get involved and actually move the sticky notes around, rather that letting one
person dominate, and resist the urge to cluster yourself as the facilitator.
Ask people to give the clusters a title which represents everything in the group.
We use this in nearly every workshop we run. It’s a great way to make sense of the output of brainstorming.
• You can also draw a circle with a large marker around the clustered sticky notes.
We have been using this technique for many years and often see others use it. We are unsure where it
originated.
8
13. Debrief Matrix
When to use
This helps visualise lots of information to help people make sense of it. Helps groups discuss 2 aspects of
any ideas or problems so that they can pick a couple to focus on.
• Pick 2 variable for your matrix, e.g. effort and value for actions, or frequency and impact for
impediments.
• Masking tape to draw a cross for the matrix on a wall or on a flipchart
• Sticky notes for actions or impediments
• Markers
How to do this
Use this after an activity where lots of ideas, actions or impediments have been generated and written on
sticky notes.
Draw a cross on the wall or on a flipchart (intersecting X and Y axes). Label each axis with the 2 aspects
you have selected, e.g. make x value, and y effort. Now the left end of x is low value, and the right end is
high value. The bottom end of y axes is low effort, and the top end is high effort. Now ask the group to
put up the sticky notes where they think they fit based on effort and value (or your selected variables).
Allow people to move them around until there is a general consensus and things stop moving. Now label
the 4 quadrants in the matrix, i.e. high effort and high value, and discuss which quadrant it makes sense
to address first.
• After placing items in the matrix, and deciding on a quadrant, ask participants to dot vote to select
items to focus on.
We have been using this technique for many years and often see others use it. We are unsure where it
originated.
9
14. Debrief Poster
When to use
Use this if you need several groups to summarise a discussion or learning points. A good activity to use
if you want to introduce drawing into a session for variety.
How to do this
Split the participants into groups of 4-6 people. Ask each group to summarise what they have discussed
or learned in a poster. Tell them they will have to present the poster to the other groups when they are
done. Give the participants an explicit timebox (10-15 minutes) and let them know when only 2 minutes
remain. Now go around each group and ask them to hold up their poster and give a brief, under 1 minute,
explanation of their poster.
• Ask each group to prepare a poster on a different topic in training to help reinforce multiple topics.
• Hand out items that they could stick on their posters to cement some learning points.
10
15. Dot Voting
When to use
• Sticky dots
• Sticky notes
• Flipchart or wall
How to do this
List the items you need to decide between on separate sticky notes and stick them up on a flipchart or
wall. If there is duplication in some of the items or they are at different levels of granularity, first group
the similar items together in clusters by moving the sticky notes.
Get the participants to write new sticky notes with an appropriate title for the group of items, or simply
circle the group of sticky notes using a marker.
Give each person in the group a number of dots, e.g. 3. Note that each person gets the same number of
dots.
Now ask each person to place their dots next to the items they care about most or in the circle if its a
cluster. They can put one dot on each of the 3 items they care about or, if they wish, all three dots on the
item that they are most passionate about.
When everyone has voted, add up how many dots are next to each item. The ones with the most dots are
the highest priority.
• If you don’t have dots, just ask people to draw dots with markers.
• Get the team to do this silently, including the clustering.
11
16. Failure Bow
When to use
This technique encourages risk taking and takes the stress out of failure. It is good to use in a meeting
where you would like creativity.
• Practice your failure bow. Stand arms up in the air, bow down low, with arms still out, and remember
to have a huge smile!
• 2 balls for every 4 people.
How to do this
Get everyone to stand up. Explain and demonstrate the failure bow and tell everyone to applaud you.
Then do it together as a group and get everyone to applaud.
Split into groups of 4 and give each group 2 balls. The idea is to throw the balls as quickly as possible
to one another. When you drop a ball practice your failure bow and your team must applaud. Remind
everyone that the aim is not to never drop the ball but rather to take risks throwing faster and practice
the bow.
• Any other game that will allow the failure bow to be practiced quickly.
• With a new group, we usually model a mistake early on, and offer a failure bow.
Tobias Mayer¹
¹[Link]
12
17. Fast Pass
10 - 15 6 - 20 Movement
minutes people Trust
When to use
An activity to connect participants to each other through content related to the meeting. This is a great
technique to use at the start of a meeting, so people who arrive early have something to do.
• Flipchart pages stuck up on a wall, with questions. Have a minimum of three (for six participants)
and a maximum of five (for 20 participants).
How to do this
At the start of a meeting stick up the prepared flipcharts around the room and place the instruction
flipchart near the front of the room.
13
Fast Pass 14
En-
courage people to read the instructions if they don’t notice them, and let them know they can start
whenever they like.
We often use this at the start of training courses, or large group meetings, especially if people don’t know
each other. It is a great way to get strangers talking at the start of the day.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
18. Feedback Circle
When to use
Use this for quick feedback at end of session or after an agile game to go through learning points. This
technique allows everyone to feel equal and share freely as the circle creates a safe place and feels
protective.
Nothing
How to do this
Everyone stands in a circle, shoulder to shoulder, including you. Now ask questions about peoples
experience in the previous exercise.
Ask powerful questions like:
• What happened?
• How did it feel?
• How can this be related back to our day jobs?
Be patient and wait for people in the circle to answer. The physical closeness helps people share more
deeply.
• Jumping Circle Close: to get quick feedback at the end of a session with a large group. Depending
on how much fun and learning you had, jump up and down fast or alternatively just stand still if
you had no fun or no learning happened.
15
19. Feedback Door
When to use
To enable you to incorporate feedback into your meeting at the earliest possible moment.
How to do this
Think about what you would like feedback on and how many people are in your meeting. The more
people, the simpler and quicker this needs to be otherwise the door will be blocked. We normally use,
“How did you find this meeting?”.
Provide sample answers like: Not worth the time, O.K, Awesome.
From the start of the meeting mention the Feedback door and ask people to make a mark when they walk
out the door. If you have dedicated breaks, then remind them at each break as well. Remind everyone at
the end of the meeting.
Many people use different versions of this, we were inspired by Jurgen Appelo¹.
¹[Link]
16
20. Feedback Letter
When to use
How to do this
Explain to the group that you would like some feedback on how they found the meeting.
Hand out the paper and pens and ask people to write you a letter starting with “Dear <your name>” giving
their thoughts on the session. Ask everyone to do this in silence.
Once they are finished they hand you the letter, only read the letter when you are alone.
• At the end of a retrospective, or coaching session. Explain that people can leave once they have
finished their letter.
• Ask permission to use the letters as testimonials.
• For groups with low trust allow people to do this anonymously and drop the unsigned letter in a
box.
17
21. Five Personal Questions
10 - 15 2 to 20 Introduction
minutes people Trust Building
When to use
Use this to get to know other people on a personal level. It’s a great tool for building trust and strong
relationships in team.
How to do this
Split group into pairs, if you have an odd number create one group of 3.
Let everyone know they have 5 minutes to discuss some questions, and then at the end they will have to
mention just 1 interesting thing they learned about their partner. Reveal the questions to the group.
At the end have the group share the most interesting snippet with everyone.
18
22. Gallery Walk
5 - 15 6 - 50 Movement
minutes people Sharing
When to use
An activity to allow participants to learn from each other by sharing information created on posters. It is
also a good way to introduce movement into a meeting.
How to do this
Ask people to stick up their posters around the room. Make sure each poster is easy to get to, especially if
there you have a large group.
Tell people they can now walk around the room and look at the posters created by the other participants.
If people have questions about posters they can ask those who created them. Let participants know how
much time they have, and end the activity once people stop looking at the posters and just start chatting.
Use this technique right after a section where people created posters with their personal input as explained
in Debrief Poster.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
19
23. Group Discussion
5 - 30 5+ Communication
minutes people Collaboration
When to use
This is a technique to allow everyone an opportunity to talk about a topic. It scales well for large groups.
The room should be setup so that it is easy for groups of 4 to 6 people to gather together, either around a
table or a group of chairs or wall space with a flipchart.
How to do this
Ask people to form groups of 4 to 6. They may already be in groups from a previous activity, or because
the room was setup that way at the start.
Ask people to discuss the topic, or a particular question in their group. It is helpful to write up the topic or
question on a flipchart as some groups might go off track. It is helpful for them to see this to guide them.
Tell them how long they have. At the end you can ask a few volunteers to summarise their discussion.
However it is not always necessary to do this, especially in large groups.
We regularly use this in training and workshop to allow participants time to discuss how a concept applies
to their own context.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
20
24. Impact Mapping
30 - 90 2 - 10 Strategy
minutes people Goals
When to use
Impact mapping is a strategic planning technique to generate ideas that will help you achieve your
strategic goals.
• Pens
• Large sheet of paper or whiteboard
How to do this
Preparation
Before you create an impact map, you need a strategic goal or goals. Find out what these are first, or
allocate time to decide on these.
21
Impact Mapping 22
Why
The first question you need to answer is “Why are we doing it?”. This should be your strategic goal. For
example, we want to sell lots of copies of our latest book. It’s a good idea to start with only one goal. If
you have many, you can always expand the impact map or create another one later.
Next you need to make your strategic goal measurable. So instead of “lots of books”, we say 100 000 copies
of the book by 31 December. Making the goals measurable is important later on, so that we can check
back and see if we have succeeded in our goal or not.
Write the goal in a block on the piece of paper.
Who
The next question to consider is “Who will help us?”. It is very easy to get distracted into what you will
do to meet the goal. If that happens, bring the question back to “who”. Write down all the players would
could help. For example: customers, vendors, partners.
For each person or role that can help draw another block off the why block. Add each person/role to their
own block. You might even want to add people who will actively NOT help, like competitors.
Try thinking broadly at this step. Listing different roles that you don’t usually consider is a great way to
generate new ideas that you haven’t thought about yet.
Using our example above, one ”Who” would be other coaches in the world.
How
The next level is “How will they help (or hinder) us?”. For each person/role on your diagram, think about
what they could do that would help you. For example, customers might recommend you.
Add another level to the diagram for “How”. You can have multiple “How” branches for each person, if
they can help in multiple ways. Again try to go as broad as possible here. Be careful not to talk about
what you will do yet. Here you are focusing on the other people’s behaviour and actions.
Using our example, other coaches can help by recommending our book.
What
The final level is “What are we doing?”. For each “How” branch, think about what you can do as a company,
or product to help the person do these things. For example, you could offer an incentive scheme for
referrals. Again, you can have multiple what branches for each how branch.
In our example, we can send the book for free to other coaches, and ask them to recommend it if they find
it valuable.
Now what?
At the end of the meeting, you might be overwhelmed with the large number of ideas you have generated.
The goal is not to do all of them. Take a look at the ideas and decide which are most likely to help you
achieve your goal - the WHY.
Pick one or two items to implement. Ignore the rest for now. After those ideas have been implemented,
check how you are doing on your goal. If you have achieved your goal, you are done, no need to do
anything more. If you haven’t achieved your goal, look at what you did and the assumptions you made
about how that would impact your goal. Using this new information, update your impact map. Maybe you
have realised that incentives don’t work for your customers. If so there is no need to try other incentive
scheme. Instead try a completely different who, how or what branch to see if it impacts your goal.
Impact Mapping 23
We use impact maps to plan our marketing campaigns for our online products (books and courses). We
have generated ideas we never would have thought of using this technique.
Impact Mapping was created by Gojko Adzic¹. His book Impact Mapping² is a great guide to this technique.
¹[Link]
²[Link]
25. Intentions
5 4-6 Commitment
minutes people Openness
When to use
This technique allows people to consciously set intentions about things they will do differently. It also
helps people understand the benefits of changing their behaviour.
How to do this
Ask each person to think about an intention for the next week about something they want to do.
Get them to phrase it as follows: I will .. so that ...
Have each person write it down on an index card as a reminder.
• Often at the end of a retrospective, coaching circle or meeting that has resulted in people taking
some actions.
• You can ask people to find a buddy to follow-up with during the week to hold them accountable.
They need to discuss how and when they will follow up with each other.
• You can also ask people to share their intentions in pairs or with the group.
• Have lego and an index card per person available. Ask each person to build their intention with
lego and write it on the card. Give them 15 minutes for this. Invite each person to explain their
intention.
Lyssa Adkins¹
¹[Link]
24
26. Meet a Stranger
10 - 15 6 - 60+ Respect
minutes people Trust
When to use
Creating a personal connection with someone you don’t know early in a meeting creates a bond and starts
to build trust between participants.
• name
• workplace
• job title
• favourite dessert
• super power.
For each table: index cards, markers, glue, scissors, stickers etc.
How to do this
Near the start of a meeting ask participants to introduce themselves to someone they don’t know. Ask
everyone to pair up. Explain that they need to create a name card for each other with that person’s name,
workplace, job title, favourite dessert and super power.
25
Meet a Stranger 26
Remind them to be as creative as they want. Let participants know that they will be introducing their
partner to the room afterwards.
Allow around 5 minutes for card creation. If you have less than 10 people let people introduce their partner
to the whole room, otherwise let introductions happen at table groups (with a maximum of six people at
a table).
• You can have any criteria on the introduction card. Try to have some fun ones.
• When we explain this we usually introduce ourselves as an example - this allows the participants
to get to know us a bit better as well.
• If you have an odd number of people, as the facilitator you can pair up with the last person.
5 5+ Morale
minutes people Motivation
When to use
This gives a relative measure of satisfaction. It is usually used to measure customer satisfaction, but this
version can be used internally to measure employee satisfaction. Good to use on a quarterly basis.
How to do this
Hand out one ballot sheet to each person and ask them to make a check mark in the block that best
represents how they feel. Collect the ballots anonymously in the ballot box.
Calculating the score
Count any checks of 6 or below as detractors. Count any checks of 7 or 8 as neutral. Count any checks of
9 or 10 as promoters. Your net Promoters score is: ( Promoters - Detractors ) / Total votes.
The first time you do this you may be surprised at the result. The score is not as important as the trend.
You want to track if this measure is going up or down over time.
• We have changed the question to measure satisfaction on various other things i.e. the product, team,
working hours etc.
• We tracked this once a quarter at the start of the release retrospective using anonymous ballots.
• Karen also used this as in a dev manager role to measure how she was doing at creating an great
environment to work in. She didn’t share the data with the teams, she used it as a metric with her
boss to see how she was doing as a manager.
27
Net Promoters Score 28
We know of many people who use this technique, we got it off Wikipedia¹.
¹[Link]
28. Pair Share
When to use
A great way to get people to talk about their thoughts, or to recap what they have just learned. You can
use this early on before trust is established as it is easy for people to share with only one other person. It
is also an easy way to introduce movement into any meeting.
Nothing.
How to do this
Explain that Pair Share means that you need to find a partner and share with them. After a short time
swap and have the partner share with you.
Ask people whatever question you want them to discuss, then ask them to find a partner and Pair Share.
If you want to include movement ask people to pair with someone from another table.
• Ask people to share an action they will take after a session. It is easy to share this with one person,
rather than a whole group.
• Use this early on in public training to help connect people who don’t know each other.
• Use this to recap a section of training by asking people to share what they have learned in a
particular section.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
29
29. Parking Lot
When to use
Often important topics come up during a meeting that you can’t deal with at that point in time, without
diverting from the focus of the current [Link] technique allows for the parking of these topics.
How to do this
At the start of a meeting or training session introduce the parking lot, and let people know that in order
to stick to the time box, some items might have to be parked for discussion later. When this happens, ask
the person to write up a reminder on a sticky note and stick it on the Parking Lot poster.
Let people know when parking lot discussions will take place so that they are comfortable that their issues
will be handled. It is good to leave a short time (20-30 minutes) at the end of the meeting to discuss the
parking lot issues.
• Draw the flipchart page as a parking lot where each space will fit one post it note.
• Get people to prioritise whatever is on the parking lot using dot voting and only address the top
items, if the list is too long.
• Discuss issues that are only important to a few during tea or lunch breaks.
• Run a lean coffee as explained in Meeting Formats for 30 minutes near the end of the day to go
through topics.
We have been using this technique for many years and often see others use it. We are unsure where it
originated.
30
30. Pop-Ups
When to use
Nothing.
How to do this
In any meeting where you want to introduce movement, and you need to get individuals to speak, you
can use Pop-Ups.
Explain that a Pop-Up means that you need to stand up before you speak, otherwise you can’t here what
they are saying.
Ask people whatever question requires input from them. Remind them to stand before they speak.
Often this results in someone shouting out without standing. To counter this we act dumb and ask “Sorry,
what was that?”, “I can’t seem to hear you?” until the person realises and stands up. Also good for a few
laughs in the class.
• You can ask questions where people have to stand if they think the answer is yes.
• Use Pop-Ups to brainstorm ideas. Ask a question like, “What are some aspects of a great team?”
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
31
31. Powerful Question Cards
When to use
Some questions can create new possibilities, they can also transform how you are thinking about a
problem. They generate curiosity, surface underlying assumptions, invite creativity, stimulate reflection
and dialogue.
Create a card deck using the index cards. Write each powerful question below on an index card, with the
other side being blank.
32
Powerful Question Cards 33
How to do this
This technique is for mining data. Use it once you have timeline up or some data after brainstorming etc.
Stack cards face down and shuffled. Go around in a circle. Each person takes a card and needs to answer
it in one minute. Encourage the person to say the things that pop into his/her mind rather than thinking
to much. Have someone scribe what the person is saying (on whiteboard or flipchart). After the minute,
move on to next person and card.
Once everyone has had a turn, use a debriefing technique to discuss what came up.
• For more people: Have each person pick a card and write down their thoughts on stickies in silence.
Then go around group and ask everyone to share.
• You can keep this exercise more conversational by flipping over a card and having everyone just
discuss their thoughts.
We got the questions from a workshop by Carlton Nettleton¹ and then adapted the questions to cards.
¹[Link]
32. Problem Solving Tree
15 - 30 6 - 12 Creativity
minutes people Actions
When to use
Come up with the problem statement or large action. You can do this as a preceding activity in the same
meeting.
• Sticky notes.
• Markers.
• Flipchart paper or large wall to build a tree.
How to do this
Start with an problem you need to solve. Write this on a sticky note, and stick it at the top of the tree.
Now ask what participants what you can do to solve the problem. For each different idea put a sticky note
below the first, at the same level.
For each of these nodes do the same and build up a tree structure similar to an organisation chart. Stop
when you get to a level low enough where you have something everyone understands and believes can
be done.
Bob Sarni¹
¹[Link]
34
33. Recap Cards
When to use
How to do this
Prepare the recap cards by deciding what you would like to recap. Create one card per item to recap.
The card should just have a word or two on it. For example to recap around agreements it might say:
cellphones.
If you have more attendees than points to recap make multiple sets so that each person gets a card.
Ask people to form groups. The group size should be equal to the number of recap points.
Give each group one set of cards. Tell everyone to pick one card (when the cards are face down), so that
no one knows what card they are getting.
Now tell each person to in turn explain the concept on the card to their group. The group can correct them
if they remember it differently.
We use this as a starting exercise on the second day of a two day training course. Each card is a topic we
covered the previous day. It is a good activity for public courses because people can start it as soon as they
arrive, so it helps to give early arrivers something to do.
We do a variation of this with Fast Pass posters, where each poster is a recap poster and we ask people to
write down what they remember about a particular topic.
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
35
34. Scenario Cards
5 - 10 up to 10 Collaboration
minutes people Trust
When to use
Allows people to learn a little more about each other in a safe and fun manor.
Create some cards, with various questions on them. These are in the Coach Toolkit.
eg:
How to do this
Have the group sit in a circle facing each other. Pass the cards round in a bag and ask the first person to
select one, read it out loud and answer. Then pass the bag on.
The cards could have actions on them instead. The person should act out the card, with everyone else
guessing the action. Eg: Act out your favourite sport, Pretend to be a celebrity chef, You are a horse racing
commentator.
Thorsten Kalnin¹
¹[Link]
36
35. Shout Out
When to use
Great to introduce some energy into a session. A good way to connect a group to a topic, or a different
way to brainstorm a list.
How to do this
Decide what you’d like input on. For example: What are out current challenges? What needs to be
discussed?
Phrase the question to attendees and ask them to shout out their answers.
If you need to capture the output for a follow on activity write things down as they shout them out. It can
be helpful to have multiple scribes for this to keep the pace fast.
37
36. Silent Cards
5 4-7 Collaboration
minutes people Trust
When to use
To allow a team with a very low trust levels to communicate in a safe manner.
Create a pack containing the 3 cards for each person in the room.
Prepare statements that you would like answers to, that the team could answer using the cards. Eg:
How to do this
We created this many years ago when working with a team that weren’t comfortable speaking in their
retrospective.
38
37. Speed Dating
6 - 10 8+ Collaboration
minutes people Listening
When to use
Helps team members quickly get other perspectives or see what they have in common with their
teammates.
Decide on the questions you will use, i.e. “What frustrates you most at work?” or “What was your first
exposure to agile.”
How to do this
Ask each person to think about the questions you have posed. Tell them to find a partner, preferably
someone they don’t know. Now one person must share their answers to your questions with the partner.
Do this for one minute then let them swap.
After 2 minutes they have to find a different partner and repeat.
Repeat this for 3 to 5 rounds depending on the size of the group.
Arrange people in 2 concentric circles with the same number of people in each circle. When it is time to
swap partners let the one circle rotate one person to the left.
Thorsten Kalnin¹
¹[Link]
39
38. Standing Survey
When to use
This is a great technique to introduce movement into a meeting as well as visualising information.
Decide what questions you will ask, and how you will ask people to arrange themselves in the room.
Having some open space in a room without tables and chairs is useful.
How to do this
Ask everyone to stand. Explain that you want them to organise themselves in the room according to some
criteria (e.g. amount of Scrum experience).
Explain how to organise themselves (e.g. a single line, with no experience near the door, and most
experience near the other side of the room).
Allow time for people to move around the room.
Remind people to speak to others to see where they should stand relative to each other. Ask people to
notice where other people are relative to them.
• how easy you think something will be to implement (easy: one side of the room, impossible: the
other)
• how well you know people in the room (close to those you know, far from those you don’t)
• people’s roles within an organisation (a quadrant with a different role in each corner of the room)
• where people are from (in the centre: close by, edges of the room: far away).
Lyssa Adkins¹
¹[Link]
40
39. Think and Write
When to use
Useful to give people time to think about something and write it down. It can be used to get feedback, to
express hopes or expectations, or to capture actions.
How to do this
• Think about what you experienced in this workshop. Write down one thing you will do differently
as a result.
• Think about the meeting we are about to have. Write down one expectation you have for this
meeting.
You can end the exercise here or you can ask people to share what they have written, either by reading
it out or sticking it up on a flipchart. If trust is low, you can ask people to swap cards anonymously and
read the card they get, sometimes it is easier to read someone else’s idea than to share your own.
We regularly use this for people to write down things they want to change as a result of a meeting.
We use this to get feedback on a training session by giving people 2 cards and asking them to write down
1 thing that surprised them and 1 thing they found useful. This often gives us insight into what people
found valuable.
41
Think and Write 42
Sharon Bowman¹ shared the generic think and write technique. We learned the surprise and useful
variation from Dan North².
¹[Link]
²[Link]
40. Thirty-five
15 8 - 20 Prioritisation
minutes people Collaboration
When to use
A technique to get a large crowd to write down ideas, and prioritise them.
You also need to prepare an open-ended question, e.g. “What is the one most important thing that will
make this team exceptional?”
How to do this
• This can scale up easily by just increasing rounds and number of responses read at the end.
• You prepare the responses. Hand them out and then only run the swap/vote part.
43
41. Thumb Vote
When to use
A quick way to get consensus during training or a meeting from all participants. For any question where
you need a yes, no or maybe this technique works well.
Nothing.
How to do this
Explain to the participants that you are doing a Thumb Vote. If you agree with the statement hold your
thumb up, if you don’t mind either way hold your thumb sideways, and if you disagree with the statement
hold your thumb down.
Then give the statement you want people to vote on, and count to three. On three, people should show
their thumbs.
If everyone votes up or sideways you have consensus. If someone votes down, you don’t have consensus
and probably need to spend more time discussing the topic.
• We have used this for two-day training where some people have asked to move the start time.
44
Thumb Vote 45
Someone proposes a new start time, we ask for a thumb vote, and if no one disagrees we move to
the different start time. This way everyone feels involved in the choice.
• We also use this technique if someone has asked a question. After a brief explanation, we ask the
class if we can move on. If someone is still unclear, they vote with their thumb down, and then we
ask what we still need to clarify.
We have been using this technique for many years and often see others use it. We are unsure where it
originated. It is sometimes called a Roman Vote.
42. Treasure Hunt
10 6+ Communication
minutes people Trust
When to use
A great way to get people who don’t know each other talking at the start of a meeting. Also a good trust
building activity since people get to know personal details about each other.
• Treasure Hunt handout for each person. These are in the Coach Toolkit.
How to do this
We regularly use this on public workshops or conferences where attendees don’t know each other. We
give it to people as they arrive so they have something to do while we wait for the start time.
We created a more complex version of this where we asked specific questions like: How many people in
the room have children? And who in the room works as a project manager. The result worked really well
as the group started working together to solve the questions before the session even started. It was the
loudest we had ever heard 20 strangers get within 10 minutes!
Sharon Bowman¹
¹[Link]
46
43. What Would We Be If
When to use
Allow everyone a quick, safe way to express their view of something. It is a great technique at the start
of a meeting get everyone in the room to talk.
• A flipchart and some stationary to write up the statement and answers for all to see. Come up with
a statement and multiple answers. Make it fun and unusual, e.g.: If we were a commando, and our
mission was the last retrospective/meetings actions, we would be ___.
• awarded medals
• promoted
• ready for another mission
• court-marshalled
• dead
How to do this
Read the statement out loud and hand out markers for each person. Ask them to mark on the flipchart
which answer they would pick.
• You can also just go round the room and have each person say their answer.
• If we were an Oscar-nominated actress, and (project name/retrospective scope) was our film, we
would be ___. (Possible answers: ready with champagne on ice, quietly confident, nervous, drunk,
not even at the ceremony.)
• If we were a dog show judge, what breed would (project name/retrospective scope) be?” or “what
category would it win?
• If we were an interviewer on the Today programme, what question would we ask (project
name/retrospective scope)?
• If the project were a tv show it would be ___
47
What Would We Be If 48
30 - 60 12 - 60 Collaboration
minutes people
When to use
World Cafe is a great technique to use with large groups to get them to discuss topics in detail, in smaller
sub groups. With the benefit of built in note taking so it is easier for groups to summarise at the end.
• Flipchart paper
• Marker pens
• Round tables for 4 to 6 participants each
How to do this
• We often use this after generating a list of topics to delve a bit deeper into some of the topics.
• Instead of the strict time box rotations, we sometimes just allow people to move between tables at
will for a longer time box.
49
World Cafe 50
We don’t remember who first introduced us to the technique, but it is widely used. You can find out more
about it here.¹
¹[Link]
III Appendix
51
Recommended Reading List
Books
Websites
Retr-o-mat¹⁵
TastyCupcakes¹⁶
Facilitation Tools¹⁷
²[Link]
³[Link]
⁴[Link]
⁵[Link]
⁶[Link]
⁷[Link]
⁸[Link]
⁹[Link]
¹⁰[Link]
¹¹[Link]
¹²[Link]
¹³[Link]
¹⁴[Link]
¹⁵[Link]
¹⁶[Link]
¹⁷[Link]
52
About Growing Agile
At Growing Agile we help companies create great teams that build exceptional software. We are agile
coaches passionate about helping you get the results you are looking for.
We are based in Cape Town South Africa, but work with clients from all over the world. We provide
phone based individual or group coaching sessions, as well as online courses for Scrum Masters, Product
Owners and Teams.
Find out more about us at [Link]¹⁸.
Our personal goal is to help influence a million people on their path to becoming agile coaches. Our
books and videos are ways we can spread that influence further than what we can in person.
We are also exploring new ways to do this. One of our latest projects is [Link]¹⁹. A community
resource of links, courses, books, and ideas to help you find your own learning path as an agile coach.
If you’d like to stay in touch and hear about our new ventures, please sign up to our monthly newsletter²⁰.
¹⁸[Link]
¹⁹[Link]
²⁰[Link]
53
Growing Agile Online Courses
We offer several online courses aimed at Scrum Masters, Product Owners and Agile Teams.
If you are ready to get a taste of what our online courses are about sign up for our FREE five week Scrum
Master²¹ or Product Owner²² email course.
Our online courses are a little different to regular online video courses. We’ve applied the principles of
Training From The Back of The Room to our online materials. That means each course comes with a
workbook and exercises for you to do, as well as video’s to watch and techniques that you can use with
your teams. Each activity is intended to deepen your knowledge of an area, so we suggest doing the course
over a few weeks and taking the time to do all the exercises.
Check out our offerings here [Link]
²¹[Link]
²²[Link]
²³[Link]
54
Growing Agile Books
We have been training teams in Scrum for about three years. During this time we have spent many hours
preparing training plans and creating workbooks, flipcharts and slides. This book will help you plan and
deliver interactive, fun Scrum training for anything from a short workshop on a particular topic to a full
two-day course.
Growing Agile: A Coach’s Guide to Training Scrum is available on Leanpub²⁴.
Our requirement workshops are aimed at different stakeholders ranging from business, to Product Owners
and teams. This book is a collection of some of those workshop and can be used to help improve the way
²⁴[Link]
55
Growing Agile Books 56
Often Product Owners can’t see the forest for the trees and there are so many items in their backlog
and not enough hours in the day to groom it. We run short workshops where we work with the Product
Owner’s actual backlog. The workshop is a working session, and an hour later the Product Owners emerge
with an improved backlog.
Growing Agile: A Coach’s Guide to Mastering Backlogs is available on Leanpub²⁶.
We often hear people say “We’re agile, we don’t need a plan”! or even worse “We can’t plan”. This is just
not true. We run Release Planning workshops with many organisations. This book is a collection of our
workshops that will help you run similar workshops to create agile release plans. We include teaching
points on a range of techniques like Story Mapping and release burnups to help you explain to other’s
how to use these methods effectively.
Growing Agile: A Coach’s Guide to Release Planning is available on Leanpub²⁷.
If a team believes they are agile, but nothing has changed about the way they test, then there is still much
to learn. We teach 5 key principles that explain why agile testing is fundamentally different to traditional
[Link] books includes a collection of workshops to help teams grasp these principles and adopt an
agile testing mindset. It’s not just for testers. A key part of agile testing is that the whole team is involved,
so we always run these workshops with everyone in the team.
Growing Agile: A Coach’s Guide to Agile Testing is available on Leanpub²⁸.
It’s taken us several years to master the skill of facilitation, and it continues to amaze us how few people
learn the skill, or even understand what it means. People spend much of their lives in meetings, and yet
so many meetings lack facilitation. We hope the collection of tips and techniques in this book will inspire
you to grow your own facilitation skills and improve the meetings in your organisation.
Growing Agile: A Coach’s Guide to Facilitation is available on Leanpub²⁹.
This series provides a collection of training and workshop plans for a variety of agile topics. The series
is aimed at agile coaches, trainers and ScrumMasters who often find themselves needing to help teams
²⁵[Link]
²⁶[Link]
²⁷[Link]
²⁸[Link]
²⁹[Link]
Growing Agile Books 57
understand agile concepts. Each book in the series provides the plans, slides, workbooks and activity
instructions to run a number of workshops on each topic. The interactive workshops are all created using
techniques from Training from the Back of the Room, to ensure participants are engaged and remember
their learnings after the workshop.
The series is available in a bundle on Leanpub³⁰, or you can purchase the books individually.
Flow
Do you have a never-ending to do list and not enough hours in the day? Imagine getting everything on
your to do list done without stress or worrying. Imagine being twice as productive in half the time.
We have over 30 proven tips and techniques to help you achieve a state of flow, where time stands still
and productivity soars. With these tips you will deliver value to your customers sooner in practical and
simple ways. You will also be happier and less stressed.
Flow is available on Leanpub³¹.
Collaboration Games
Add an element of fun to your meetings or workshops using these 12 short games that teach principles of
collaboration.
Collaboration Games is available on Leanpub³².
This book is based on the original Who Is Agile book, only this is a regional version for South Africa. It’s
a collection of interviews with passionate South African agilists.
Who is Agile in South Africa is available on Leanpub³³.
³⁰[Link]
³¹[Link]
³²[Link]
³³[Link]