Aromaticity and NMR
Aromaticity and NMR
4
Benzene
➢ Benzene (C6H6) is the simplest aromatic hydrocarbon (or arene).
➢ Isolated in 1825 by Michael Faraday
Benzene
➢ Benzene has four degrees of unsaturation by formula, making it a highly
unsaturated hydrocarbon.
Benzene Reactivity
➢ Does not react like unsaturated hydrocarbons such as alkenes, alkynes and
dienes i.e., No addition reactions
Reactions of benzene: substitutions
➢ Benzene does react but only in the presence of promoter/catalysts
and the reaction is a substitution of ‘H’, not an addition.
1. Nitration
C6H6 + HNO3, H2SO4 → C6H5NO2 + H2O
2. Sulfonation
C6H6 + H2SO4, SO3 → C6H5SO3H + H2O
3. Halogenation
C6H6 + X2, Fe → C6H5X + HX
4. Freidel-Crafts alkylation
C6H6 + RX, AlCl3 → C6H5R + HX
Kekulé di-Substituted benzenes
➢ But having three alternating bonds means that benzene should have three
short double bonds alternating with three longer single bonds.
➢ In benzene all C—C bond lengths are equal and is 1.39 Å (by X-ray analysis) 9
Any Proposed structures of benzene must account for
In addition,
Its lack of reactivity towards electrophilic addition.
10
New representation
• Later Kekule proposed the structure of benzene as a resonance
hybrid of the two Lewis structures, with the dashed lines of the
hybrid indicating the delocalization of the bonds. This fits well
with the requirements
• We will use one of the two Lewis structures and not the hybrid in
drawing benzene. This will make it easier to keep track of the
electron pairs in the bonds (the electrons).
• Because each bond has two electrons, benzene has six
electrons.
12
Stability of Benzene and Aromaticity
13
Stability of Benzene and Aromaticity
1 kcal = 4.18 kJ
1 kcal = 4.18 kJ
15
Resonance Energy
17
Delocalization / Resonance Energy
➢ The huge difference between the hypothetical and observed
heats of hydrogenation for benzene cannot be explained solely
based on resonance and conjugation but by delocalization.
18
Delocalization/ Resonance Energy
19
Delocalization/ Resonance Energy
21
Molecular Orbitals Theory
➢ In the quantum mechanical model of the atom, a nodal plane is a region around
the nucleus where the probability of finding an electron is zero or almost zero. 22
Molecular Orbitals Theory
• The two pairs of MOs with the same energy are called
degenerate orbitals.
23
Molecular Orbitals Theory
The combination of two p orbitals can be
➢ constructive: with like phases reinforcing, or
➢ destructive: with opposite phases cancelling.
25
Molecular Orbitals Theory
26
Molecular Orbitals Theory
27
Molecular Orbitals of Benzene:
➢ The six MOs are labeled 1- 6, with 1 being the lowest energy
and 6 being the highest.
➢ In the quantum mechanical model of the atom, a nodal plane is a region around
the nucleus where the probability of finding an electron is zero or almost zero. 28
Molecular Orbitals of Benzene:
1: zero nodes
2 and 3: one node
To fill the MOs, the six
electrons are added, 4 and 5: two nodes
two to an orbital. The 6: three node
six electrons completely
fill the bonding MOs,
leaving the anti-bonding
MOs empty.
non-bonding MOs
All bonding MOs (and
HOMOs) are completely
filled in aromatic
compounds.
No electrons occupy
antibonding MOs.
29
Molecular Orbitals of Benzene:
➢ In the quantum mechanical model of the atom, a nodal plane is a region around
the nucleus where the probability of finding an electron is zero or almost zero. 30
Molecular Orbitals of Benzene:
31
Benzene vs. 1,3,5-hexatriene (acyclic)
32
Molecular Orbitals of Cyclobutadiene
33
Is there an easy way to draw Molecular Orbital picture?
34
The Inscribed Polygon Method (Frost Diagram) for Predicting
MO’s and Aromaticity
35
The Inscribed Polygon Method (Frost Diagram) for Predicting
MO’s and Aromaticity
36
The Inscribed Polygon Method (Frost Diagram) for Predicting
MO’s and Aromaticity
37
Other Examples
38
The Inscribed Polygon Method (Frost Diagram) for Predicting
MO’s and Aromaticity
39
The Criteria for Aromaticity
Four structural criteria must be satisfied for a compound
to be aromatic.
41
[3] A molecule must be completely conjugated.
42
[4] A molecule must satisfy Hückel’s rule, and contain
a particular number of electrons.
Hückel's rule:
43
Note: Hückel’s rule refers to the number of electrons, not the
number of atoms in a particular ring.
45
Note the relationship between each compound type and a similar
open-chained molecule having the same number of electrons.
46
The Basis of Hückel’s Rule:
48
For the compound to be aromatic, these bonding MOs must be
completely filled with electrons, so the “magic numbers” for aromaticity
fit Hückel’s 4n + 2 rule.
49
Cyclopropenyl cation
H 2 3
4n+2=2
1 n=0
H H
aromatic
cycloprop enyl cation
2 -electrons
Cyclopentadienyl cation
H
4 5
H H 4n=4
2 3 n=1
H H
anti-aromatic
cyclopentad ienyl cation 1
4 -electrons
Cycloheptatrienyl cation
6 7
H H
4 5 4n+2=6
H H
n=1
2 3
H H aromatic
H 1
cycloheptatrienyl cation
6 -electrons 50
Cyclopropenyl anion
H H H
+ B: + B:H
4n=4
H H H H
n=1
cyclopropenyl anion
anti-aromatic
4 -electrons
2 3
1
Cyclopentadienyl anion
H H H
H H H H
+ B: + B:H
4n+2=6
H H H H
n=1
pKa ~ 16 cyclopentad ienyl anion aromatic
6 -electrons
4 5
2 3
1 51
Annulenes
➢ Annulene's are the family of completely conjugated, monocyclic
hydrocarbons
➢ The annulenes are named as [n]-annulene where n is an even number
that represents the number of C atoms in the ring.
➢ We have already met the first 3 members of the series, [4]-, [6]-, and [8]-
annulene but we called them cyclobutadiene, benzene and cycloocta-
tetraene respectively.
➢ Higher members of the annulene series have also been synthesized and
investigated in relation to their aromaticity.
➢ Remember that according to the Huckel rule, (4n + 2) π electrons
systems are expected to aromatic whereas 4n π electrons systems are
not.
Annulenes
cyclobutadiene
Benzene
➢ Tub shape, not planar
[10]-annulene 10 -electrons H H
(non-aromatic) 4n+2 = 10, n=2.
H H
H
H
H H
H H
Naphthalene
➢ Stable because of locked geometry
12 -electrons
4n=12, n=3
54
16 -electrons; 4n=16, n=4
(not planar)
H Cl H
+ AgBF4 BF4 + AgCl
H H H H
H Cl H
H H H H
+ AgBF4 BF4 + AgCl
H H H H
H H H
pKa ~ 16
H H H H
+ H 2O + H 3O +
H H H H
H
H Br
H H H H
H H Br -
H H
H H 61
H H
Resonance Energy (Kcal/mol)
Other forms of Carbon
➢ The two most common elemental forms of carbon are diamond and
graphite.
➢ Their physical characteristics are very different because their
molecular structures are very different.
63
Buckminsterfullerene: Is it Aromatic?
64
Anti-aromatic compounds and Ions
cyclobutadiene cyclopropenyl
anion Cyclopentadienyl
cation
heptalene
Homoaromaticity
➢ Homoaromatic compounds possess an interrupted π system but display thermodynamic
stability and many of the spectroscopic, magnetic, and chemical properties associated
with aromatic compounds, due to through-space or through-bond interactions.
➢ This formal discontinuity is apparently bridged by p-orbital overlap, maintaining a
contiguous cycle of π electrons that is responsible for this preserved chemical stability.
➢ Positive homoaromatic
species are well known.
➢ It is used to study a wide variety of nuclei: 1H; 13C; 15N; 19F; 31P
NMR Spectroscopy
Where is it?
When the Nucleus Meet the right Magnet and radio wave
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance
69
Nuclear Spin
➢ Nuclear spin is characterized by a quantum number I, which may be integer,
half-integer or 0.
➢ Only nuclei with spin quantum number I ≠ 0 can absorb/emit electromagnetic
radiation.
➢ Nuclei are positively charged spherical spinning objects, which is like tiny magnet.
➢ Nuclear magnetic moments : The circulation of nuclear charge would generate
a magnetic moment along the spin axis
E and
Magnet Strength
The energy difference between the two spin states depends
on the strength of the magnetic field
randomly
oriented nuclei
(no magnetic field)
➢ In a 1.41 T field, a 60
MHz photon is required
to flip a proton.
Diamagnetic Shielding
➢ If all protons absorbed the same amount of energy in a given magnetic
field, not much information could be obtained.
Ethanol = CH3CH2OH
Diamagnetic Shielding
➢ The electrons in a bond (-bond or s-bond) shield the nuclei from the magnetic
field.
➢ So, if there is more electron density around a proton, it sees a slightly lower
magnetic field, less electron density means it sees a higher magnetic field
This represents the electron density of a C-H bond. How much electron
Z density is on the proton depends on what else is attached to the carbon. If Z
C H is an elelctronegative atom, the carbon becomes electron deficient and pulls
some of the electron density away from the H. if Z is an electron donating
group, more electron density ends up on the H.
Diamagnetic Shielding
➢ How do the electrons shield the magnetic field?
➢ By moving or circulating. Can be represented
➢ Moving or circulating electrons create an induced as Beff = Bo( 1 - s )
magnetic field (secondary field) that opposes the
external applied magnetic field of our NMR
machine.
➢ So, the magnetic field (the effective field
strength Beff) felt by the nucleus is always less
than the applied filed strength (Bo) and is
dependent on the surrounding groups and atoms.
➢ It’s not a huge effect, but it’s enough to enable us
to distinguish between different protons in our
sample.
CH3
H3C Si CH3 Tetramethylsilane (TMS)
CH3
➢ Since silicon is less electronegative than carbon, TMS protons are highly
shielded.
➢ In general, organic protons absorb at higher frequency (to the left) than
➢ There are protons which absorb at lesser frequency (to the right) than the
Residual Residual
Solvent B.P. °C 1H signal (δ) 13C signal (δ)
tetrahydrofuran-d8 65.0 1.73 & 3.58 ppm 67.4 & 25.2 ppm
NMR Machine
NMR Machine
shielding
deshielding
shielding deshielding
shielding
deshielding deshielding
shielding shielding
Homoaromaticity
shielding
Ha = -0.3 ppm
deshielding
Hb = 5.1 ppm
H1 & H7 = 6.1 ppm
H2-H6 = 8.5 ppm
➢ Paratropic
behaviour
(paramagnetic
ring current)
shielding
deshielding deshielding
deshielding
shielding
shielding
Temperature effect
Temperature effect
Two Energy States for proton
➢ The magnetic fields of the spinning nuclei will align either with the
external field, or against the field.
➢ A photon with the right amount of energy can be absorbed and cause
the spinning proton to flip.