Authenticity of Hadith
َ َ ات ِه َو ُيزَ ِّكي ِه ْم َو ُي َع ِّل ُم ُه ُم ا ْل ِكت
اب ِ س ِه ْم َيت ْ ُلو َع َل ْي ِه ْم آ َيِ ُوال ِّم ْن أَنف
ً سُ ث ِفي ِه ْم َر َ َل َق ْد َم َّن اهللَُّ َع َلى ْاملُؤ ِْم ِن
َ ني إِذْ َب َع
3:164 - ٍض َال ٍل ُّم ِبني َ ح ْك َم َة َو إِن َكانُوا ِمن َقبْ ُل َل ِفي ِ َوا ْل
Deductive argument:
شي ٍْء فَ ُر ُّدو ُه إِ َلى
َ األ َ ْم ِر ِمن ُك ْم ۖ فَ ِإن تَنَازَ ْعت ُ ْم ِفي
ْ ول َوأُولِي َ س ِ ِ ِ
َّ َيا أ َ ُّي َها ا َّلذي َن آ َمنُوا أَطي ُعوا اهللََّ َوأَطي ُعوا
ُ الر
4:59 - يال ً س ُن تَأ ْ ِو َ خ ِر ۚ ذَٰلِ َك
َ خ ْي ٌر َوأ َ ْح ْ ِ ول إِن ُكنت ُ ْم تُؤ ِْمنُو َن ِباهللَِّ َوا ْل َي ْوم
ِ اآل ِ س َّ اهللَِّ َو
ُ الر
Inductive argument:
Companion: writing down hadith
Chinese Whisper:
Khabar Mutawatir
Khabar Wahid- Ghareeb, Azeez, Mashoor,
– The chain of narration should be complete and without aws
– All narrators of hadith should be of good characte
– All narrators of hadith should have good memor
The conditions pertaining to the text of Khabar Wahid are
– The text of the hadith should be supported by evidence from the Quran and other
ahadit
– The text of the hadith should be supported by actual fact
• Sahih (Authentic): A hadith which perfectly ful lls the criteria of evaluation regarding the chain
of narration and the text.
• Hassan (Good): A hadith which ful lls the criteria like Sahih Hadith BUT there is one narrator
in the chain of narration who does not have good memory.
• Za’eef (Weak): A hadith which has a broken chain of narration OR there is one narrator in the
chain of narration who has committed mistakes.
• Mawzu (Fabricated): A saying which is wrongly attributed to the Prophet (S.A.W)
h
fi
fi
y
fl
: