Apples Oranges
Apples Oranges
COPYRIGHT
This book is protected by COPYRIGHT LAW and international treaties.
No part of this book may be reproduced, used or distributed in any form or by any means, in whole
or in part, without the prior written consent of Celemiab Systems AB. An unlawful disposal or use
of this material may result in severe CIVIL and CRIMINAL PENALTIES. Celemiab Systems AB will
bring judicial proceedings if this provision is violated.
Please report violations to: violations@[Link]
Copyright © 1992-2017 by Celemiab Systems AB. All rights reserved.
2
Contents
Make a difference 5
Glossary 66
3
The Business Finance Model
Money is
exchanged for
material and labor
Products and
services are
exchanged for
money
The Business Finance Model is by far the most widespread of all conceivable
models of a business. Actually, in most countries (if not all) the use of this model
is mandatory by law.
4
Foreword
Make a difference
For good reason, there is a lot of talk about how important it is that we all see
and understand the big picture of the business (firm or enterprise) we work for.
The problem is that people tend to use all sorts of more or less complex models
to describe different aspects of their business. The so-called big picture comes
in all shapes and sizes and not all of them are easy to grasp – unless, of course,
you already understand the reality they claim to portray.
Models tend to come and go depending on what’s hot and what’s not ...
There is one model that has stood the test of time for hundreds (some say
thousands) of years: the Business Finance Model.
This model is used to inform stakeholders about the business’s economy, and it
is used within companies serving as the basis for making business decisions.
Unfortunately though, it is not always easy to see the forest for the trees – which
actually happens also to those already in the know. Some even say that they
occasionally feel intimidated by Business Finance jargon.
The purpose of this booklet is to change that.
The idea here is to provide a shortcut to understanding the big picture as well
as a source of inspiration.
Our hope is that perusing this guide will help you discover how you can make a
difference in your day-to-day area of responsibility.
Klas Mellander
Co-founder, Celemi
5
PART I:
The big picture
It’s all about adding value
You buy material or expertise, you add value in several steps by doing some-
thing with it and you deliver the finished product to the customer: It is a chain of
activities, and in each step you add value of some sort; this is a Value chain.
Every industry and every business has its own, more or less complex, Value
chain.
The Value of the finished product is essentially determined by the customers –
by how much they are willing to pay for it (22m in the example at the right).
The Cost of making the product or service is the sum total of what you had to
pay in each step of the Value chain (18m in the example). This is the value of the
product or service seen from an accountant’s point of view. In accounting terms,
it is called the Book value.
And this, as you will see, is the foundation of Business Finance and Reporting.
The goal of any business is to create more value than the total amount
spent for making the finished product – the Book value.
---
PART I will introduce you to the simple logic behind the basic financial state-
ments – the Profit & Loss Statement, the Balance Sheet and the Cash Flow
Statement.
6
Value Chain
A very simple example, just to make the point:
You purchase raw materials such as wheat, sugar, yeast, water ... > you
make the dough > leave it to ferment > and put it in an oven to let it bake.
> The finished bread is stored > then packaged > and finally delivered to
the customer.
In each step, value is added; and in each step you need to spend some money
for material and labor – thereby increasing the Book value.
Rule #1
The cost of your goods and
services sold equals what you
spent to make them.
10 + 8 = 18
18 22
Rule #3 Rule #2
The idea is to have more money coming in If the customer is willing to pay
than going out. more, you are in business.
So, basically the value 18m (your expenses) is still in the company as an asset,
but it has been “transformed” from cash to materials and labor – and eventually
to the finished product.
Next:
• When you transfer ownership of the product to the customer, the value
18m leaves the company – now the 18m are regarded as a cost.
• In return, the customer owes you (and will eventually pay) 22m. This is
regarded as your income (more often called Sales or Revenue).
And then the circulation of capital starts over again: You pay your supplier ...
Let’s conclude:
A business is a merry-go-round of capital – and as you will see later, its
speed matters.
8
“A step-by-step transformation of resources“
Costs
18m
+10m +8m
Expenses
-18m Sales
22m
To many people an expense is the same thing as a cost. From a strict account-
ing point of view though, there is an important distinction:
When a value (an asset of any sort) leaves the company, and only then, it
is regarded as a cost. *
*The only exception is, for example, when you pay back a loan or pay Dividends (a portion of what
the company has earned over the years) to the shareholder(s).
Costs are normally put into three main categories as shown in the picture
at the right:
Blue line: Direct variable costs – attributed to the production of the goods or
services sold. Hence they are often Cost of goods sold or Cost of services
sold (or even Cost of sales). These typically include cost of material and
labor used to make the goods or services, but not indirect expenses.
Green line: In addition, you have costs that are more or less fixed, here
referred to as Overhead. They do not change regardless of the volume you
produce, so some actually call them Fixed costs. Overhead costs include
things like Sales and Administration as well as the (fixed) costs for running
the factories and Research & Development (R&D). Here we have chosen to
enter R&D as a separate item, Development.
The difference between Sales (Revenues) and Cost of goods sold is referred
to as Contribution – implying that it should contribute to cover the Overhead
costs. (Gross profit is another often-used term.)
Yellow line: The cost of the Property (buildings) and machinery and other
equipment is a little trickier even if the principle is quite simple:
If you purchase a machine for 25m and expect it to last five years, you should
regard 5m as a cost each year (1/5 of the purchase price): Each year the
value is reduced by 5m which is regarded as a cost, called Depreciation.
(There will be more discussion of Depreciation later.)
Costs that are not attributed to the production of the goods or services sold are
viewed as Common costs.
All of the above is roughly what you will find in a Profit & Loss Statement –
often abbreviated P&L.
10
Profit & Loss Statement
Costs
Material & labor used for production 50m
Sales
Cash - and what the customers owe you 100m
Outgoing and incoming value (money) over a certain period of time is summa-
rized in the Profit & Loss Statement.
Sales + 100
Cost of goods sold – 50
Contribution (Gross profit) = 50
Overhead – 35
Development – 5
Depreciation (25%) – 5
Total common costs = 45
Operating profit (EBIT) = 5
Current assets
In the outer region you find what are generally called the Current assets:
• Inventory: the value of stock of material, ongoing production and stock of
finished goods
• Quick assets: cash at hand and what your customers owe you (Accounts
receivable)
These are called “current” as they are constantly moving, coming full circle
several times each year – as opposed to the Fixed assets that move more slowly
and stay in the company for several years.
Fixed assets
These include:
• The value of land and buildings (Property)
• The value of your machinery, furniture and such. (Plant & Equipment)
Total assets
All of these assets combined are the means necessary for the business opera-
tion – they are the company’s Total assets.
They are summarized in the Balance Sheet.
20
The Profit & Loss Statement shows The Balance Sheet shows where the
how values are going out and coming different assets are, and in what form,
in over a certain period of time. at a given point in time.
What we’re talking about here are the monetary assets, the capital. But, of
course, you have many other assets, such as patents, goodwill, copyrights, cul-
ture, brand image, competencies, know-how ... which we will come back to later.
12
The Balance Sheet
The Balance Sheet provides a snapshot of your Total assets and where in the
company they can be found at a given point in time
Inventory
Fixed assets
40 20
Property Plant & equipment
Accounts
Cash receivable
9 11
Quick assets
Balance Sheet
(in millions)
Assets
Cash and bank 9
Accounts receivable 11
Materials 4
Work in progress 6
Finished goods 10
Total current assets 40
Plant & equipment 20
Real property 40
Total fixed assets 60
100
TOTAL
Even if it is as simple as that, it can be difficult for many people to wrap their
mind around the concept of Depreciation. Why is that?
The possible trap:
It is easy to confuse costs with what was paid for them during the year.
That though, is reasonably true for Cost of goods sold and Overhead as they
tend to be close to what you paid for them during the year (approximately 90m
in the example below).
Depreciation, on the other hand,
50m is a cost that you do not pay: the
equipment was already paid for
40m
when the investment was made,
40 25 20 5m maybe some years earlier – just
like your bike.
Plant & Equipment
Value reduced by 5m
Total cost: In this example the total cost
95m
was 95m, but only 90m was
Paid from cash ≈ 90m paid for (from cash).
14
Depreciation
Depreciation is simply the yearly decline in value of your Fixed assets. As such it
is a cost – although a cost that does not affect your cash.
Original
investment
25 20 5m
Something to ponder:
As Depreciation is based on some sort of a standard formula, you have good
reason to ask: How well does the Book value (the remaining value after Depre-
ciation, the so-called Residual value) reflect the true value of the assets?
More costs
In addition to the costs that we talked about earlier, you also have to pay for the
money you have borrowed: you pay Interest.
Finally, you need to take Taxes into account. What is left is the Net profit – the
famous bottom line.
So we need to add these costs to the Profit & Loss Statement – as illustrated in
the picture at the right.
---
On top of that you (sometimes) pay the owners a portion of what the company
has earned over the years. These are called Dividends. Dividends do not ap-
pear in the Profit & Loss Statement though, as they are not regarded as cost or
an expense even if they reduce the assets as well as the Equity.
16
How this is reported in the P&L and Balance Sheet:
4 6 10
40 20
Assets
9 11
Owners 80 Equity
Interest 2m
Lenders 20 Liabilities
Taxes 1m
Society
Cost of
4 6 10 50m goods sold
Overhead &
40m
Expenses & investments
development
40 20 5m Depreciation
Accounts
Cash receivable
Sales
9 11 100m
Owners 80 Equity
Interest 2m
Lenders 20 Liabilities
Taxes 1m
Society
18
The financial statements
Profit & Loss Statement:
The flow of incoming and outgoing value over a certain period of time.
Balance Sheet:
What’s inside your company at a specific moment: your assets
and to whom they belong.
Sales + 100
Assets
Cash and bank 9
Cost of goods sold – 50
Accounts receivable 11
Contribution (Gross profit) = 50
Materials 4
Overhead – 35
Work in progress 6
Development – 5
Finished goods 10
Depreciation (25%) – 5
Total current assets 40
Total common costs = 45
Plant & equipment 20
Operations profit (EBIT) = 5
Real property 40
Interest expenses – 2
Total fixed assets 60
Profit before taxes = 3
100
Taxes (33%) – 1 TOTAL
Net profit/loss = 2
Liability & Equity
Short-term liabilities 5
Long-term loans 15
Total liabilities 20
Beginning balance 78
Net profit/loss this year 2
Total equity 80
100
TOTAL
-90m +100m
• Incoming cash is when you get paid – the customers pay what they were
invoiced.
• Outgoing cash is when you pay – wages, invoices from your suppliers, et
cetera.
• The difference is ... the Cash Flow.
Obviously: if you increase prices, if you sell more, if you reduce cost et cetera,
your profit will increase and, most likely, so will your Cash Flow.
20
Free up cash
In this example the company reduced Inventory by streamlining the production
processes – all the way from purchase to delivery.
They also got the customer to pay sooner, thus tying up less capital in Accounts
receivable.
As a result: Cash Flow increased by 6m.
Before After
–2
–1
–1
+6
20
Property Plant & equipment
Investments Assets
Cash
Financing
Equity Owners
Liabilities Lenders
Society
The example right shows what a Cash Flow Statement could look like. This
company was expanding its’ business and invested in a new factory.
Here are a few highlights:
• Operations: The news was that the company managed to convince some
customers to pay in advance, adding 30m to the Cash Flow.
• Investments: They sold some older property and equipment (+200m)
and invested in a brand new plant (-600m).
• Financing: They also asked the shareholders and the bank for money:
a loan (+200m) and issuance of stock (+100m).
22
Cash Flow Statement, example
Operations
Cash receipts from Customers
For products delivered + 1 000
Payment in advance of delivery + 30
Cash paid for
Material & components – 400
Wages expenses – 200
Common costs – 200
Interest – 20
Income taxes – 10
Net Cash Flow from Operations = 200
Investing Activities
Cash receipts from
Sale of property + 150
Sale of equipment + 50
Sale of share in other companies + 0
Cash paid for
Purchase of property – 400
Purchase of equipment – 200
Making loans to other companies – 0
Net Cash Flow from Investing Activities = -400
Financing Activities
Cash receipts from
Issuance of stock + 100
Borrowing + 200
Cash paid for
Purchase of shares in other companies 0
Repayment of loans 0
Net Cash Flow from Financing Activities = 300
Hindsight or Foresight?
Analyzing a business’s performance carries the risk of looking too deep in the
rearview mirror.
Ponder this:
“Hindsight is of little value in the decision-making process. It distorts our
memory for events that occurred at the time of the decision so that the
actual consequence seems to have been a ‘foregone conclusion.’ Thus, it
may be difficult to learn from our mistakes.”
Diane F. Halpern, Thought & Knowledge
24
Diagnosis
KPIs are used to diagnose current performance of the business, mainly to find
ways to make improvements.
The “financial outcome” may provide the necessary indicators, but you need to
dig deeper to find (and treat) the root causes.
Diagnose based
on other KPIs Diagnose based on
Financial KPIs
Financial
Outcome
Straight from
the financial statements
Many people find the map at the right a helpful way of organizing the Business
Finance data, as it captures all major items and shows how they are related. The
upper section represents the Profit & Loss Statement, and the lower section
represents the Balance Sheet.
The map also shows the answer to the overarching question about performance:
Sales + 60 Assets
Cost of goods sold – 24 Cash & bank 12
Contribution (Gross profit) = 36 Accounts receivables 10
Total common costs = 25 Inventory 20
Operating profit = 11 Total current assets 42
Interest and taxes – 5 Total fixed assets 24
Net profit/loss = 6 66
TOTAL
26
The Business Finance Map™
Sales
60
25 6
Quick Assets
17% 14%
22
Balance Sheet
Current Assets Equity
Plus
Inventory 42 Total assets 43
Plus
20 Fixed Assets 66
Short term Liabilities
24
8
Long term Liabilities
15
Improving or declining?
This version of the Business Finance Map (right) includes data from two con-
secutive years, allowing us to gauge the progress of the company’s business
performance and to understand the reasons for the change in performance
level.
28
Sales
Year 1 Year 2
60 82
25 32 6 8
Balance Sheet
Plus Year 1 Year 2 Year 1 Year 2
20 25 Fixed Assets 66 75
Year 1 Year 2
Short term Liabilities
24 27 Year 1 Year 2
8 9
Long term Liabilities
Year 1 Year 2
15 15
3 4 5 6
Operating performance
– EBIT or EVA?
In most companies general business performance is evaluated based on Oper-
ating profit (not Net profit). The reason is that the financial side of the business
is of a quite different nature than the “main business” and generally managed by
a totally different set of people.
So: If you are responsible for the operation you will be evaluated based on how
much Operating profit you have been able to generate – Earnings Before Inter-
est and Taxes (EBIT).
The finance department will then be evaluated based on how much of the EBIT
is left on the famous bottom line – Net profit.
However, there are a few problems with this.
For example: Who is responsible for how much capital is tied up in things like
inventory and consequently for the interest on borrowed money? Even if the
finance department can negotiate a low interest rate with the bank, you (as head
of the operation) are responsible for how much the company needs to borrow.
Another example: You launch a massive marketing campaign one year and the
cost appears in the P&L of that year. In reality, the campaign should perhaps
be seen as an investment for the next few years. The same is true for things like
education ... is it a cost one year or an investment for the years to come?
In addition, we want to know when the amount of profit is good enough and
when it is not: Have we created ... or maybe destroyed value?
* Economic Value Added® and EVA® are registered trademarks of Stern Stewart & Co.
30
The EVA method in short
Step 1: Calculate the true profit.
First you need to adjust some of the values in the Profit & Loss Statement and
the Balance Sheet to better reflect reality.
It is mainly about reconsidering whether a certain expense, registered as a cost,
should be seen as an investment instead … and vice versa.
The Operating profit will change accordingly.
From this you deduct the Taxes and you will get the Net Operating Profit After
Taxes (NOPAT). This is regarded as the true value you have generated.
Let’s say that it was 90m.
And tallied:
• Total capital was 1000m (200m+800m).
• Total Cost of capital was 74m (10m+64m).
• Equalling an average interest rate of 7.4%.
This is called the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC).
Using the table “the other way around”, you could say that today’s value of 180
in five years is 100 – given a certain interest rate (12.5%).
This is called the Net Present Value (NPV) of future earning.
32
When is an investment worthwhile?
Here’s an example to answer the question.
• You intend to invest 300.
• You expect the earning per year to be 100.
• You believe that this will go on for 5 years.
This means that you pay 300 now, and get 500 back, eventually …
Not bad, or …? Let’s see.
You want your 300 back, but you also want a return, say 12.5%.
355
300
300
34
Cash Value Added
If you are able to exceed the expected 100 per year, this is regarded as value
creation. This can be measured as Cash Flow Return On Investment (CFROI)
or Cash Value Added* (CVA®).
Like this:
• Operating Cash Flow: 120
• Capital charge (the demand): minus 100
• Cash Value Added = 20
Expressed as a ratio, the CVA index is 120/100 = 1.2
The main advantage of focusing on Cash Flow is that you do not need to worry
about the way the Operating profit is calculated, whether or not your equipment
is correctly valued, et cetera.
We have said it before:
“Profit is an opinion, Cash Flow is fact.”
This rings true to investors and business managers alike.
Questions to consider
Even if the above describes a simple method, it is not completely free from dif-
ficulties.
Some major issues:
• What should be regarded as an investment? It is easy when it comes to
the purchase of new equipment. But what about replacing old equipment?
• How should you regard the purchase of spare parts?
• Is the development and launch of a new brand or investing in creating a
new brand profile an investment or not?
• What is the economic life of the investment? Will the investment generate
Cash Flow for five years or ten years?
These types of questions are typical of companies who are adopting the meth-
ods of Cash Value Added.
36
The principle of an Intangible Assets Monitor
(Karl-Erik Sveiby)
“Market value”
Tangible Intangible assets
assets
Our equity
Customer Knowledge
according to the
base capital
Balance sheet.
The value of
(Total assets minus Our Our
Liabilities) our customers’
knowledge and organization people
image The value of The value of
our tools and our people’s
processes competencies
Growth
Innovation
Efficiency
Stability
Even if sophisticated figures and formulas are used to calculate these indica-
tors, when communicated it is sometimes enough to indicate the general trends
(as done here).
See also Balanced Scorecard (following pages).
Finance
Learning &
development
38
Example
A Balanced Scorecard allows you to monitor performance along a range of criti-
cal success factors so that, depending on your area of responsibility, you can
take action accordingly.
In this example the performance is illustrated by a black bar – from red to green,
from low to high performance.
---
PART III is intended as a source of inspiration: How do you find potentials for
improvements and what can you do to tap into them?
A lever is something
that could turn small efforts
into major achievements
40
A simple example, just to make the point:
This picture shows a stylized version of how a company has mapped what it is
that drives Cost of goods sold in several tiers.
Product
design Purchase Sales
Quality
Culture Tools
Utilization Cost of
Technology of material
Leadership goods sold
Scrapping
Sense of & rework
belonging Labor Common
Attitude costs
Raw material
Skills size
...
Presuming that you’re looking for ways to lower the Cost of goods sold, the
diagram offers several possible drivers.
Let’s say that you find that Utilization of material is rather poor and declin-
ing. You consider a range of possible causes and decide that Scrapping and
rework seem to have the greatest potential for improvement. And you ask,
“What can we do about it?”
Then you continue to work backward in the cause-and-effect chain: “What has
the greatest impact on Scrapping and rework?” That could be anything from
flaws in the product design or the production equipment to the quality of the
purchased components.
It could even be that people just do not care.
If it turns out to be the latter you need to ask, “Why are people careless?” You
may find that the employees lack a sense of belonging, that they feel alienated
and cannot see any point in trying to be more responsible.
You may conclude that this in turn is an effect of poor leadership.
You have found the root cause and that is what needs to be fixed – and this is
probably where you will get the strongest leverage of your efforts.
You have pulled the right lever – just as they did in the case stories presented
on the following pages.
“
We were not happy with the predicted profit for the year and made a decision
to look for short-term, easy-to-grab opportunities – regardless of their size. We
scheduled a series of brainstorming workshops, most of them with people from
different functions, to get fresh ideas ...
42
All in all
We also needed some extra marketing efforts and some more help from the
support functions. But it paid off ... as you can see, the EBIT almost doubled!
Not too bad!
cus_on_EBIT
What we achieved Effect on EBIT
Sales (volume) +2%
Prices +2%
Cost of good sold -4%
Marketing & sales +2%
Support functions +1%
Support functions
Cost of goods
EBIT +98%
Profit & Loss Statement
Before After
Prices
EBIT before
“
To us, cash is king. So at one point, we asked ourselves: What would it take to
double the Cash Flow?
As we also strived to improve on profitability, we knew that this in itself would
improve Cash Flow – which we actually did by reducing the Cost of goods by
2%. The approach was mainly to ask people in Production to ask themselves,
‘Why do we still do things like this; is there a better way?’
But there was more to do:
We examined the inventory levels – as we had done several times before – and
to start with, we actually did not find any room for improvements worth going for.
Until one day when our purchasing manager happened to see a pile of material
close to one of our machines. She asked the first line manager, ‘Will you use all
of this today?’ and the response was, ‘No, not today, but next week. But I do not
want to risk not having it here when I need it.’
As it turned out, most of the first line managers did the same thing. It had been a
longtime habit to order material from stock way in advance of when it was actu-
ally needed. The reason? In previous times it often happened that production
stopped due to delivery delays. That problem had been solved years before, but
obviously the habit did not change.
A crash course in Cash Flow and Cost of capital for the first line managers was
all that was needed.
And as a result, the inventory level could be reduced by 5%.
Then we asked ourselves, are there more bad habits prevailing from the
time they were good habits?
And there were.
In the old days we did not dare to ask important customers to pay their invoices
on time – ‘they might be upset’ was the thought. We also had (have) a tendency
to offer more generous credit terms than the customers asked for. On average,
the customers pay within 55 days after sales are made. By getting them to pay
only 4 days sooner, we were able to reduce Accounts receivable by 7%.
To encourage this new habit, we played the song “What a Difference a Day
Makes” daily in the cafeteria.
44
Changing bad habits
Another bad habit that we were able to change was to accept the suppliers’
payment terms without really negotiating them. Only a few days longer payment
terms resulted in an increase in Accounts payable by 4%.
All in all
So as you can see, changing habits could double Cash Flow!
”
What we achieved Effect on Cash flow
Cost of good sold -2%
Inventory -5%
Accounts receivable -7%
Accounts payable
Accounts receivable
Profit & Loss Statement
Before After
Cash flow before
“
It is common knowledge in our industry that ‘a lost hour is gone forever.’
The same is true for airlines, cinemas, restaurants ... you name it. An empty chair
is a lost opportunity to earn money, but you still have to pay the cost for it.
Fortunately, the reverse is also true: Whatever you can charge someone for
occupying that empty chair will more or less fully appear on the bottom line.
46
The result was staggering:
• Less overtime was needed which reduced the cost of staff by 2%.
• As we offered a bit more value we could raise prices by an average of 2%.
• As the portion of billable hours went from 60% to 66%, we had more
hours to sell without having to recruit more people or pay any other extra
costs: Sales went up 7% and all of it was pure profit.
All in all
It took some time to get there, but it was worth it, as we eventually tripled the
EBIT – like for like.
”
What we achieved Effect on EBIT
EBIT +200%
No. of hours sold +7%
Price per sold hour +2%
Salaries
Utilization 66% (60) +6%
Salaries (prof. staff) -2%
Utilization
“All hands on …”
The store manager has this story to tell:
“
Tougher competition, more demanding customers, higher staff costs, market
slow-down ... There were many ways to explain why the store’s performance did
not live up to expectations. However, no one on the management team fell into
the trap of (just) blaming the circumstances. We all knew that it was up to us to
‘fix it,’ as somebody said. After a lengthy discussion about several ‘how-to-fix-it’
ideas, we concluded:
We need to engage every single individual in this store and ask for his or
her contribution.
And so we did … and we had a pretty clear idea about what we should ask for.
These are the questions we asked – and a summary of the answers we got:
Q: How do we increase floor traffic, the number of visitors?
A: By making buying in this store such a good experience that custom-
ers want to come back and also spread the word.
(Effect: 2% more visitors.)
Q: How do we convince more visitors to actually buy something, to
become customers?
A: By seeing to it that they can get what they are looking for.
(Effect: Portion of visitors actually buying went up by 3%).
Q: How do we get customers to buy a bit more?
A: By seeing to it that they not only get what they want, but also what
they did not know they wanted. (Effect: Average purchase up 1%).
Q: How do we get more profit out of the Sales?
A: We need to promote the higher-margin products more effectively
and we need to reduce waste. (Effects: Profit margin increased by 1%
and less waste reduced the Cost of goods sold by 1%.)
48
All in all
It did not take long before we could harvest the result. I believe these numbers
(below) say it all! We had doubled the profit and were (almost) back on track.
And yet, we have only just begun …
EBIT +100%
Margin +1%
Cost of goods
Cost of goods sold -1%
Avarage purchase
No. of customers
Margin
Profit & Loss Statement EBIT before
Before After
“
We agreed that the captured knowledge was poorly utilized and came up with
some suggestions for making better use of it, for example in training new hires.
As the discussion continued we realized that there was one important aspect
missing in these stories and hence possibly in our own minds:
What about all the situations where ‘we do not know what it is we don’t
know?’
It was like a blinding flash of the obvious. When we tell our stories we are very
rational, we have an explanation for every outcome: why we won this order, why
we did not win that order. What if we actually do not know exactly why we won
or lost certain orders? What if we just think we know?
After a while we realized that in spite of (or possibly due to) our vast experience,
we take it for granted that we sold the right things with the right arguments
while the customer might have signed the order based on (slightly) different
criteria.
We picked up some twelve recent cases where we had tough competitors to
pitch against (50/50 won and lost orders). And we discussed them in-depth.
We found that in at least one third of the cases we couldn’t give a credible
explanation of what it was that eventually tipped the balance.
It was then that we realized that ‘we do not know what it is we don’t know,’ and
we decided to change that. We asked a highly regarded sales performance
consultancy for help – and we got it.
We have now become (a little) better at reading and understanding the custom-
ers’ needs, including (and this is important) the needs the customers did not
know they have. And this in turn changed the dialogue with the customers as
well as the precision of our proposals.
50
As a result …
Our hit rate (portion of won orders) soon went from 25% to 27%. We also
increased the number of opportunities by 2% and we got a 1% more ‘requests
for proposals’ from our opportunities.
And that was actually enough to double our profit.
EBIT +100%
Portion requests 51% (50%) +1%
Hit rate 27% (25%) +2%
Hit rate
Opportunities
EBIT before
Superior products
Innovation
Differentiation Products and
Product range, value-added services services offered
Pricing – customer needs
and demand
Marketing messages
Brand values Customer
Selling awareness
Targeted customers and perception
Competition
Product quality
Delivery excellence Customer Sales
satisfaction,
Customer support
reputation
– repeat business
Utilization of labor
Planning
Multiple skills
Development Common
Responsibility costs
Utilization of
machinery
Planning and equipment
Maintenance
Product design
Hours per day
Cost of marketing
and sales,
development and
Alignment support functions
Focus
Simplicity
52
In search of opportunities
As the previous case stories (pages 42-51) demonstrate, a range of small im-
provements can make a huge difference on the bottom line – providing that you
have found the right levers to pull. If you don’t, you may end up merely address-
ing the symptoms rather than the root cause of a certain problem.
To identify opportunities for improvements and find the right levers, you need to
have some general idea of the “moving parts” of your business: What is driving
what? What is the magnitude of the different drivers’ impact? And et cetera.
As mentioned earlier:
A business is an organic system, and as such quite complex.
To get the most out of this section, browse through the following eight pages
seeking to identify potentials for improvements in your own company – and,
possibly, to come up with ideas about leversExample
(drivers) worthwhile
of possible drivers pulling.
Which of the statements in each pair is closest to your own reality?
This is what we suggest: Superior products?
We are mainly trying to sell what We are mainly trying to offer
For each pair of statements (bubbles), we have to offer. what we can sell.
statements, mark one of the middle Actually, our offerings are not as
unique as we pretend.
We definitely stand out from
the competition.
circles.
Product range, value-added services
Our product portfolio is far from Our customers keep coming
where our customers expect it back as they know they can get
to be. what they are looking for.
Skip over items you find less relevant, and if–Ouryou miss something,
pricing is based on costs
or the prices offered by the justvalue
add it. – as per-
Our prices are based on the
of the products
competition. ceived by the customers.
Superior products?
We are mainly trying to sell what We are mainly trying to offer
we have to offer. what we can sell.
Innovation
We tend to “look in the rearview We are truly innovative in find-
mirror” in our product develop- ing new, breakthrough products
ment. for the future.
“If it is not broken, don’t fix it.” “If it is not broken, break it.”
Differentiation
Actually, our offerings are not as We definitely stand out from
unique as we pretend. the competition.
Pricing
Our pricing is based on costs Our prices are based on the
– or the prices offered by the value of the products – as per-
competition. ceived by the customers.
54
Sales
Customer awareness and perception
“What is not communicated does not exist,” a marketer said.
It is a matter of sending the right messages to the right customers via the right
channels.
Marketing messages
Our messages are merely Our messages are based on
reflecting how we see ourselves deep customer understanding
– Inside-out. – Outside-in.
Brand values
Our brand values reflect who we We live our brand values in
want to be, not who we are. everything we do.
Selling
In our sales we focus on our In our sales we focus on the
“points of sales” – product customer’s “points of purchase”
features. – customer benefits.
Targeted customers
We tend to be all over the place, We have identified our pre-
trying to be all things to all ferred customers and focus our
customers. sales efforts accordingly.
Competition
We compete against the com- We compete for customers
petition rather than for custom- rather than against the competi-
ers. tion.
Product quality
It is too costly to secure 100% Our customers say, “We never
quality. have any complaints at all.”
Delivery excellence
We tend to forget that the Our customers say, “Always
delivery is as important as the on time, in the right place and
product itself. to specification.”
Customer support
56
Cost of goods and services sold
Purchase of material and components
The purchase is far from just getting what you want at a good price.
What you must look at is the total
Landed costs of your purchased
material and components.
Landed costs include all costs of the
purchase when it has “landed” on
your doorstep: the purchase price as
such, transports, handling, temporary
storage, insurances, import fees and
more.
Purchasing efficiency
We tend to wait far too long be- We have top-notch proce-
fore we renegotiate the contract dures for how to look for and
with or replace old suppliers. evaluate suppliers as well
as how to negotiate win-win
contracts.
Supplier loyalty
We tend not to bother too much We are constantly monitoring
as long as we get what we want our suppliers’ performance and
at the price agreed upon. give them a helping hand when
needed.
Supply chain
Our supply chain is far from We have a holistic view of the
streamlined – it looks more like total supply chain – upstream
a patchwork, developed over as well as downstream.
many years.
Waste
Our coworkers are not aware of Our coworkers are fully aware
the cost of waste – and they act of the cost of waste – and they
accordingly. act accordingly.
Product design
We have a high scrapping We keep scrapping costs at a
cost because the design of the minimum by designing compo-
components is not done with nents with Utilization of material
Utilization of material in mind. in mind.
Waste handling
Most of the waste is just thrown Most of the waste is recycled
away. in one way or another.
58
Cost of goods and services sold
Use of Labor
The meaning of Use of Labor (or Labor utilization) is twofold:
Productivity: To what extent people’s
working hours are used to create value.
Capability: To what extent the company
makes use of people’s competencies,
desires and capacity to grow.
Planning
Most of the time we are either We have a lean production
understaffed or overstaffed. model that allows us to staff
production in an optimal way.
Multiple skills
Our people cannot handle Our people can handle several
different tasks so they cannot different tasks so they can be
be used where they are most used where they are most
needed at a given time. needed at a given time.
Development
We keep track of our vacancies We keep track of our people’s
and needs and recruit or place competencies and desires and
people accordingly. try to place them accordingly.
Responsibility
Our workers seem to be reluc- We know that if we inform and
tant to take responsibility. engage our people they cannot
avoid taking responsibility.
Planning
Productivity suffers from Our production plans are well
unplanned, time-consuming coordinated with sales and
changeovers. delivery plans.
Maintenance
Most stoppages are a conse- Almost all maintenance is
quence of poor maintenance preventive (and done when the
– we tend to prioritize using the machines are idle) and aims
machines before maintaining them. at keeping stoppages at a
minimum.
Product design
The design of our products We design our products with
does not allow us to make the efficient use of machinery in
best use of the machinery. mind.
60
Common costs
All other costs
There was a time when the Common costs (such as Sales and Administration)
were a fraction of the total costs. Most of the cost was Cost of goods sold.
Today it’s different. In many industries the Common costs even exceed the Cost
of goods or services sold.
This makes it a bit more difficult to gauge how these costs actually add to the
value the customers pay for. Or, put another way: How profitable are these
costs?
To compensate, companies typically try to attribute as much of these costs as
possible to the relevant product category or business area. (The Contribution
remaining when these costs are deducted is often referred to as “Contribution
margin 2.”)
Whether this is the case or not, there are a few overarching drivers worth con-
sidering:
Alignment
Different units seem to have All units are going in the same
different priorities and agendas. direction with a common goal.
We are viewed as many compa- We are seen as ONE company.
nies under one umbrella.
Focus
As we tend to see market We have clear ideas about
potentials all over the place, where our market potentials lie,
we have difficulty focusing our and we concentrate our efforts
efforts. accordingly.
Simplicity
We are far too sophisticated to To us, simplicity is the ultimate
even come close to simplicity in sophistication – and typical of
how we do things around here. how we do things around here.
To find out, go to [Link] and look for “Celemi Profit & Cash Flow simu-
lator.”
This is how it works:
Click the + – buttons (top right) and see the effect on Profit or Cash Flow.
You can choose between different types of businesses and you can use pre-set
data or enter your own.
1
iPad
Input
data
Reset
Home
Demo
62
63
Business finance in a nutshell
Terms used in this book and examples of commonly used synonyms and related
terms.
Sales
Revenues (US)
Turnover (UK)
Contribution Interest & Taxes
Income Statement
Profit & Loss Statement
Income
Gross profit Related term:
Minus Sales profit Financial costs
Cost of goods sold Contribution margin 1 Operating profit
Cost of services sold EBIT
Minus Operating income
Direct costs
Variable costs Common costs Contribution margin 2 Net profit
Operating costs Net earnings
General expenditures “Bottom line”
Indicators
Related term:
Return On Capital
Employed – ROCE
Quick assets
Includes:
Cash & bank
Accounts receivable Current Assets Equity
Balance Sheet
Includes:
Plus Share capital
Inventory TOTAL ASSETS Retained earnings
Includes: Related terms:
Stock Plus Capital employed
Work in progress Fixed Assets Working capital Short term liabilities
Finished goods Includes: Includes:
Real property Loans
Plant and equipment Accounts payable
64
Glossary
Here you’ll find the most important terms used in this book. Also included are
common expressions that mean the same thing (=) or approximately the same
thing (≈), as well as some terms not discussed in the book but that are widely
used.
The explanations presented here are brief; if you want to learn more, we recom-
mend visiting
[Link]
Just enter the term you want to learn more about.
66
Finished goods Lenders
The value of finished goods in stock. Primarily banks and other credit institutes,
but suppliers and customers can also
Fixed assets act as lenders (the former by providing
The part of the company’s assets that is supplier credits and the latter by paying in
tangible Property and is not expected to advance).
be converted into cash for some years.
They are fixed as opposed to current. See Liabilities
Current assets. Money borrowed from a bank or other
lenders.
Fixed costs
The costs that a company always has, Liquid funds
regardless of whether production is taking Means roughly the same as Cash (be-
place, such as wages and rental costs. cause money deposited in a bank is also
considered cash). Called “Cash and
General expenses equivalents” or “Cash and bank” in the
Overhead. Balance Sheet.
Gross profit Long-term liabilities
Contribution. Loans for which the company has negoti-
ated a pay-back term of several years.
Income
Defined here as an incoming value that Net profit
increases the company’s assets (e.g. sales The famous “bottom line” of the Profit &
income, financial income). Loss Statement.
Income Statement NOPAT
Same as Profit & Loss Statement. Net operating profit after taxes.
Incoming payment Operating profit
Money that enters the company (cash and Sales less Cost of goods/services sold
cash equivalents). and Common costs. Also called EBIT
(Earnings Before Interest and Taxes).
Indirect cost
A cost which cannot be directly attributed Outgoing payment
to a specific product. May be allocated to Money that leaves the company (from
specific products or departments through Cash and equivalents).
various cost accounting methods.
Overhead
Intangible assets The Cost of sales and support, et cetera.
Assets that are not tangible, e.g. the value Included under Common costs.
of the company’s methods and processes
or people’s competencies. Owners
The people who own the company or,
Intellectual property more precisely, who own the company’s
For example: copyrights and patents. Equity.
Inventories Prepaid expenses
= inventory capital. See below. Advance payments to suppliers for goods
and services that have not yet been
Inventory capital delivered. The supplier is indebted to the
The sum of the values of materials in company until delivery is made.
stock, work in progress and unsold fin-
ished products, i.e. the portion of Current Profit
assets which does not consist of Quick See Net profit and Operating profit.
assets.
Profit & Loss Statement (P&L)
Landed cost A summary of sales, costs and expenses
The total cost of a product, including during a certain period.
purchase price, freight, insurance, and all
other costs up to the port of destination. Property
In some instances, it may also include the The value (Book value) of the real estate
customs duties and other taxes levied on (land and buildings) that the company
the shipment. owns.
Quick assets
Liquid funds + Accounts receivable.
68
All you need to understand Business Finance
The contents in a nutshell:
Serious fun
People engaged in an Celemi Apples &
Oranges™ business simulation seminar –
to-date experienced by more than a million
participants around the world