Ethics in Human Actions Explained
Ethics in Human Actions Explained
Human Values - lessons from the lives and teachings of great leaders,
reformers and administrators;(crux of teachings, Quotes, etc.)
Note: [I'm sharing my notes and will update them as soon as I discover any
important facts or theories,concepts etc.]
Note: I covered the most from my point of view; the last exam was held
in 2013. I can't predict the difficulty level of the exam.
I just analyzed PYQ of 2013. If you have some ideas or insight from
anywhere, please DM me on Twitter so that I can add it to these notes.
Essence, determinants and consequences of Ethics in-human
actions
1. Essence of Ethics:
- Definition: Ethics refers to the principles and values that guide human behavior,
distinguishing right from wrong.
Some examples of different ethical theories are: Aristotle’s virtue ethics, Kant’s
deontological ethics, Mill’s consequentialism (utilitarianism), and the Bhagavad Gita’s
nishkam karmayoga.
2. Source of Ethics:
Determinants of ethics:
1. Person: Depends on the mental make up of the individual. It depends upon how the
person has internalized personal attitudes and values regarding ethical behavior.
2. Place: It refers to the external environment which includes family, school, etc. For
example, as kids we were told by our parents and teachers not to steal things. As
we grow up we tend to carry such knowledge and apply it to the real world.
Similarly, the workplace teaches us ethics of teamwork, punctuality, responsibility,
etc.
3. Time: Different individuals, societies and cultures have different sets of moral codes
at different times. It was once considered ethical to own a slave. But today such a
practice is unethical.
4. Object: It is unethical to lie despite any circumstances, purpose or intention. Telling
a truth to intentionally harm a person is also unethical as the intention of telling a
truth is not pure.
5. Circumstances: Stealing is unethical. But a poor person stealing to feed her
children reduces the act. Such situation ethics bring subjectivity as it often makes
morality subjective.
6. End purpose: To give donation to a poor person is good but if such donation is to
lure poor person to do something for you, then it becomes immoral
- Individual Integrity: Ethical behavior fosters personal integrity and a sense of moral
responsibility.
- Trust Building/ Credibility: Ethical actions enhance trust in relationships, both
personal and professional.
- Safeguarding society: Often ethics succeeds law in safeguarding the society. Ex:
Technology is growing at a fast pace. By the time a law comes to regulate it, its
dimensions easily change. So laws can’t probably safeguard its misuse, only ethics
can.
- Social Harmony: Shared ethical values contribute to a cohesive and harmonious
society.
- Legal Compliance: Ethical behavior aligns with legal standards, reducing the
likelihood of legal issues.
- Improving decision making: Decisions driven by values are sustainable, equitable,
fair and just.
Important TERMS:
Deontology: Means more important than the ends. Lying is always wrong.
Utilitarianism: Ends are more important. Maximum good to maximum number of
people.
Applied ethics: Applying rules of ethics to real world
Theorist in Details:
Socrates:
● Quotes:
○ "The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing."
○ "An unexamined life is not worth living."
● Dialectical Method:
● Socrates is known for his method of questioning and dialogue to stimulate
critical thinking and illuminate knowledge.
● Moral Philosophy:
● Emphasized the importance of virtue and the pursuit of moral excellence for
a fulfilling life.
● Ignorance and Wisdom:
● Claiming that acknowledging one's ignorance is the beginning of wisdom.
● Individual Morality:
● Focused on individual moral responsibility and the importance of
self-examination for personal growth.
● Trial and Death:
● Faced death rather than renounce his philosophical convictions, emphasizing
the integrity of his beliefs.
● Influence on Plato:
● Served as a mentor to Plato, influencing the development of Western
philosophy through his teachings and methods.
Immanuel Kant:
Quotes:
● - "Dare to know! Have the courage to use your own intelligence!"
● - "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time that it
should become a universal law."
Deontological Ethics:
● Upholds a duty-based system of ethics.
● Actions are inherently right or wrong, regardless of consequences.
Categorical Imperative:
● Introduces the principle of universalizability for moral actions.
● One should act according to rules that could be applied universally.
Autonomy and Rationality:
● Values autonomy of the individual in moral decision-making.
● Emphasizes the use of rationality to determine moral duties.
Human Dignity:
● Believes in the intrinsic value and dignity of every human being.
● Rejects treating individuals merely as a means to an end.
Absolute Moral Laws:
● Argues for the existence of absolute moral laws.
● Rejects situational ethics and moral relativism.
QUOTE:
● - "The worth of a state in the long run is the worth of the individuals
composing it."
● - "Actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; wrong
as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness."
Utilitarianism:
● Emphasizes the principle of the greatest happiness for the greatest number.
● Actions are morally right if they maximize overall happiness.
Higher and Lower Pleasures:
● Distinguishes between higher and lower pleasures.
● Higher pleasures, related to the intellect, are considered more valuable.
Individual Liberty:
● Advocates for individual freedom and autonomy.
● Supports personal liberty unless it harms others.
Harm Principle:
● Introduces the harm principle: The only purpose for which power can be
rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community is to prevent
harm to others.
Progressive Values:
● Encourages social progress and improvement.
● Believes in adapting institutions to promote the well-being of society.
John Rawls:
Quotes:
- "Justice is the first virtue of social institutions."
- "Each person possesses an inviolability founded on justice that even the welfare
of society as a whole cannot override."
Justice as Fairness:
● Proposes the original position and veil of ignorance to determine fair
principles of justice.
● A just society is one individuals would choose behind a veil of ignorance.
Two Principles of Justice:
● Equal basic liberties for all.
● Social and economic inequalities should be arranged to benefit the least
advantaged.
Veil of Ignorance:
● Decision-makers imagine a society without knowledge of their own
characteristics.
● Ensures unbiased principles that consider the interests of all.
Maximin Rule:
● Advocates maximizing the welfare of the least advantaged.
● Prioritizes the well-being of the most vulnerable members of society.
Fair Equality of Opportunity:
● Supports equal opportunities for all, regardless of social class or
background.
● Aims to eliminate arbitrary factors determining success in life.
While Mill focuses on maximizing happiness and individual liberties, Rawls emphasizes
fairness, justice, and equality in societal arrangements.
Dimensions of ethics:
1. Normative:
a. Prescribing behavior based on values.
b. Study of the standards and rules that guide our moral choices and actions
➔ Focus:
◆ Emphasizes virtuous character traits for ethical behavior.
➔ Approach:
◆ Character-based, not rule-based.
◆ Cultivates virtues like courage, justice, and temperance.
➔ Development:
◆ Acquired through practice and habit.
◆ Practicing virtues leads to the development of a virtuous character.
➔ Nature of Virtues:
◆ Virtues are dispositions, not rigid rules or principles.
◆ Example: Courage is a disposition to face danger with determination.
➔ Goal:
◆ Concerned with leading a good and fulfilling life.
◆ Not just about doing the right thing but living meaningfully.
◆ Aristotelian virtue ethics focuses on nurturing virtuous qualities, contributing to
individual and societal flourishing.
Deontology Simplified:
Definition:
➔ Duty-based ethics.
➔ Acts are inherently right or wrong, irrespective of consequences.
➔ Moral agents have duties to follow moral rules.
➔ Principle:
◆ Relies on rules to distinguish right from wrong.
◆ Associated with Immanuel Kant.
➔ Application:
◆ Follow set rules and duties without evaluating outcomes.
◆ Intuitive approach aligning with ethical rules.
➔ Example:
◆ Civil Servant's Duty:
● A civil servant must adhere to rules and regulations regardless of the
consequences.
➔ Limitations:
◆ Rigidity Issues:
● Rigid adherence may lead to unacceptable results.
◆ Emotional Exclusion:
● Ignores human emotions, lacking empathy in certain situations.
◆ Unfavorable Consequences:
● May have unfavorable outcomes for the majority.
◆ Consequence Ignorance:
● Criticized for overlooking the consequences of actions.
Utilitarianism Simplified:
➔ Definition:
◆ Ethical theory focusing on outcomes (consequentialism).
◆ Aims for the greatest good for the greatest number.
➔ Principle:
◆ Most ethical choice produces maximum benefit for the majority.
➔ Example:
◆ Death Sentence for Terrorists:
● Justified under utilitarianism for saving innocent lives, maintaining
peace, and aiding national development.
➔ Limitations:
◆ Unquantifiable Happiness:
● Hard to quantify happiness, neglects emotions, culture, and justice.
◆ Minorities' Well-being:
● Disregards the well-being of minorities like LGBTQ communities.
◆ Black-and-White Morality:
● Presents a simplistic moral view—something is either right or wrong
◆ Uncertainty about Consequences:
● Unable to predict future consequences of actions with certainty.
Natural rights:
● 17th-century English philosopher John Locke discussed natural rights in his
work, identifying them as being "life, liberty, and estate (property)", and
argued that such fundamental rights could not be surrendered in the social
contract.
2. Descriptive: "What do people actually do?"
a. Empirical investigation of the moral beliefs and practices of different people,
cultures, and societies.
b. It does not prescribe or evaluate moral actions, but rather observes and
explains them.
c. Theorist:
i. Anthropologist Ruth Benedict, known for her work in cultural relativism
ii. Scholars like David Hume look into how people behave morally in
different cultures.
6. Social Ethics:
a. Concerned with the ethical aspects of societal structures and systems.
b. Theorist: John Rawls, known for his contributions to social justice and the
concept of the "veil of ignorance."
Source: ResearchGate
Ethics - in private and public relationships.
Private Relationships:
3. Confidentiality:
a. Maintaining confidentiality is important to respect the privacy of
individuals.
b. Sharing sensitive information without consent is an ethical breach.
5. Conflict Resolution:
a. Ethical conflicts in private relationships should be addressed through
open communication and understanding.
b. Avoidance of conflicts may lead to unresolved issues
Public Relationships:
Public Trust:
Accountability:
● Ethical responsibility involves being accountable for one's actions in public
roles.
● Holding individuals and organizations accountable promotes ethical
behavior.
● Public relationships require fair treatment and equity for all stakeholders.
● Discrimination or favoritism can lead to ethical concerns.
Transparency:
● Public officials and organizations should avoid conflicts of interest that may
compromise their objectivity.
● Full disclosure and recusal from decision-making when conflicts arise are
ethical practices.
Social Responsibility:
● Mahatma Gandhi:
● Emphasized the values of non-violence (ahimsa) and truth (satya).
● Advocated for simplicity and self-discipline in personal and political life.
● Believed in the power of compassion and forgiveness.
Philosophy: Rich individuals should act as trustees of their wealth for the benefit
of society and the state.
Basic Needs: Excess wealth of the rich can contribute to society's welfare,
addressing fundamental needs like food, clothing, and shelter.
Features:
■ Trusteeship serves as a reform tool for capitalism.
■ State regulation is essential to ensure peaceful implementation.
■ Rich individuals cannot use extra wealth for personal satisfaction or
anti-social activities.
■ No private ownership; acquisition requires societal consent.
■ State sets a fixed maximum income for a fair wage and balance.
■ Aims at voluntary collaboration for societal welfare.
Challenges in Application:
Gandhi's Talisman:
Nelson Mandela:
Mother Teresa:
Buddha
Mahavir:
Guru Nanak:
● Background:
● Founder of Sikhism, a monotheistic religion blending elements of Hinduism
and Islam.
● Born in a Hindu family, had a mystical experience leading to a universal
message of God’s love.
● Teachings:
● Wrote hymns expressing devotion, compiled in the Guru Granth Sahib.
● Composed the Japji Sahib, a morning prayer summarizing Sikh beliefs.
● Taught the concept of Ik Onkar, emphasizing the oneness of God.
● Rejected multiple gods, idols, rituals, castes, and superstitions.
● Introduced the three pillars of Sikhism: Naam Japo (meditation), Kirat Karo
(honest work), Vand Chhako (sharing blessings).
● Advocated for social justice, equality, challenging religious and political
authority.
● Engaged in interfaith dialogue and traveled widely to spread his message.
Aristotle:
● Background:
○ Student of Plato, tutor to Alexander the Great.
○ Founded the Lyceum, conducting extensive research and teaching.
● Philosophical Contributions:
○ Wrote treatises on logic, physics, biology, metaphysics, ethics, politics,
rhetoric, and poetics.
○ Developed deductive reasoning with the syllogism and classified various
types of arguments.
○ Proposed the four causes—material, formal, efficient, and final—to explain
existence and change.
■ Four Causes:
● Material cause (what it's made of)
● Formal cause (its shape)
● Efficient cause (what made it)
● Final cause (its purpose)
● Example: Statue - bronze (material), human shape (formal),
sculptor (efficient), art/worship (final)
○ Substance Theory:
■ Introduced the concept of substance, defining the essence or nature
of a thing.
○ Advocated for a balanced life guided by the golden mean and analyzed
forms of government.
● Quote:
● "Excellence is an art won by training and habituation."
● "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without
accepting it."
Virtue Ethics:
Plato:
● Background:
● Disciple of Socrates.
● Founder of the Academy, the first institution of higher learning in the Western
world.
● Philosophical Contributions:
● Wrote dialogues exploring ethics, politics, metaphysics, epistemology, and
aesthetics.
● Developed the theory of forms, positing ideal, eternal realities accessible
only through reason.
● Created the allegory of the cave, illustrating the dichotomy between
appearance and reality.
● Advocated for a utopian society ruled by philosopher-kings with wisdom and
virtue.
Rabindranath Tagore:
Tulsidas:
● Devotion to Rama:
● Devotee of Lord Rama, author of Ramcharitmanas, an epic poem in Awadhi.
● Considered one of the greatest poets and saints of Hinduism.
● Teachings and Legacy:
● Emphasized bhakti (devotion) to Rama as the supreme and personal God.
● Taught values of dharma (righteousness), evident in Rama's life.
● Founded the Ramanandi sect, initiated Ramlila (folk-theatre on Ramayana).
● Wrote about the glory of Hanuman, the monkey-god and devotee of Rama.
Kabir:
● Disciple of Ramakrishna:
● Played a pivotal role in the revival of Hinduism.
● Spread Vedanta and Yoga to the West.
● Philosophical Emphasis:
● Advocated the unity of all religions.
● Emphasized the divinity of every soul.
● Global Representation:
● Represented Hinduism at the Parliament of the World’s Religions in Chicago
(1893).
● Delivered his famous speech “Sisters and Brothers of America.”
● Founding Organizations:
● Established the Ramakrishna Mission and Math in 1897.
● Founded the Vedanta Society of America in 1898.
● Literary Contributions:
● Authored influential books on Hindu philosophy and spirituality.
● Notable works include Karma Yoga, Bhakti Yoga, Jnana Yoga, and Raja
Yoga.
● Nationalist Leader:
● Active in the Indian independence movement against British rule.
● Contributed to the development of a new system of spiritual practice.
● Integral Yoga:
● Developed Integral Yoga for individual and societal transformation.
● Aimed to bring down the supramental consciousness.
● Retirement and Collaboration:
● Retired from politics in 1910, settled in Pondicherry.
● Collaborated with Mirra Alfassa, known as the Mother, in 1920.
● Literary Works:
● He wrote extensively on various aspects of his vision, such as The Life
Divine, The Synthesis of Yoga, Savitri, The Human Cycle, and The Ideal of
Human Unity.
● Works covered various aspects of Integral Yoga and spiritual philosophy.
● Socialist Leader:
● Co-founded Congress Socialist Party and later the Socialist Party.
● Member of Lok Sabha, actively participated in the independence movement.
● Opposition to Emergency:
● Opposed the Emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi in 1975.
● Arrested multiple times during British rule, tortured in Lahore Fort.
● Multifaceted Writings:
● Wrote extensively on politics, economics, history, and sociology.
● Notable works include "Marx, Gandhi and Socialism" and "Wheel of History."
● Seven Revolutions Concept:
● Propounded Seven Revolutions including gender equality, caste abolition,
economic justice.
● Advocated decentralization of power, protection of civil liberties, world peace,
and universal education.
● Integral Humanism:
● Formulated political philosophy of Integral Humanism.
● Emphasized nationalism, democracy, and decentralization.
● Literary Works:
● Authored books on politics, economics, and culture.
● Notable works include "Integral Humanism" and "Politics of Distorted
Development."
● Founding Publications:
● Established Rashtra Dharma, Panchjanya, and Swadesh.
● Founded Deendayal Research Institute for rural development.
● Critique of Capitalism and Communism:
● Criticized both capitalism and communism.
● Proposed a third way based on Indian culture and values.
● Minister of Education:
● Served as the first Minister of Education in independent India.
● National Education Day celebrated on his birthday.
● Champion of Unity and Secularism:
● Advocated Hindu-Muslim unity and opposed partition.
● Supported Khilafat movement and non-cooperation movement.
● Multilingual Scholar:
● Proficient in languages such as Urdu, Arabic, Persian, Hindi, and English.
● Wrote extensively on religion, philosophy, and culture.
● Founding Educational Institutions:
● Established Jamia Millia Islamia University and Darul Musannefin Shibli
Academy.
● Founded Indian Council for Cultural Relations and Sahitya Akademi.
● Visionary Modernist:
● Advocated for scientific education, women’s empowerment, and cultural
exchange.
● Emphasized preserving India’s diverse heritage.
Kautilya:
Role of Society:
Mental and Intellectual Development:
● Society provides the environment for mental and intellectual growth.
● Cultural preservation and transmission enhance individual development.
Morality and Ethics:
● Imposes moral restrictions on individual behavior.
● Shapes individual discipline and ethical conduct.
Tolerance and National Integration:
● Living in diverse societies fosters tolerance.
● Contributes to national integration by embracing diversity.
Collective Struggle Against Evils:
● Societal efforts combat social issues like caste discrimination.
● Collective struggle for positive change.
Imbibing Conformity:
● Society influences behavior through peer pressure.
● Conformity to societal norms, including lifestyle choices.
Role of Family:
Informal Learning:
● Family imparts informal education through love and compassion.
● Values like sharing and caring are instilled through daily interactions.
Emotional Attachment:
● Strong emotional bonds in the family influence ethical behavior.
● Emotional attachment can motivate members to adopt positive habits.
Observational Learning:
● Children observe and unconsciously adopt family values.
● Respect for women, compassion, and other values are learned through
observation.
Freedom and Support:
● Families provide the freedom to pursue individual interests.
● Supportive environment for career choices and personal development.
Gender Equality and Respect:
● Family dynamics influence views on gender roles.
● Respect for women is cultivated through positive family interactions.
Emotional Support and Counseling:
● Families offer emotional support during challenging times.
● Counseling within the family helps address negative thoughts.
Encouragement of Extracurricular Activities:
● Families encourage participation in extracurricular activities.
● Reduces academic pressure and promotes holistic development.
Joyful Atmosphere:
● Creating a positive environment at home.
● Engaging in joyful activities and discussions to re-energize family members.
Role of Teachers and Educational Institutions:
In summary, teachers and educational institutions play a pivotal role in shaping individuals
by providing a platform for holistic development, influencing leaders through mentorship,
and instilling ethical values that contribute to the overall socialization process.