Trump's Fraud Trial: A Character Study
Trump's Fraud Trial: A Character Study
Former President Donald Trump speaks at his Mar-a-Lago estate, February 16, 2024, in
Palm Beach, Florida.
(CNN) – Donald Trump’s way of doing business is a window into his soul.
So his devastating loss Friday in a New York fraud case that threatens the empire on
which he built his art of the deal mythology encapsulates more than a legal defeat.
It offers a character study of the behavior, beliefs and worldview that define the DNA of
an irrepressible figure and unchained force who is again tearing at American unity,
institutions, democracy and the rule of law as another contentious election looms.
A trial, which Trump tainted with histrionics and contempt for the judicial system, and
Judge Arthur Engoro’s final, stinging judgment, revealed four foundational codes that
explain Trump’s tumultuous path through a life that he simply sees as an endless stream
of business and political deal he must close.
- Trump thinks rules are for other people. He will always break them in seeking
more wealth, more attention, or more votes.
- If reality doesn’t get the ex-president what he wants, he conjures a new one.
- Trump is compelled always to fight – even when stepping back would be smarter.
- And when accountability finally arrives, he sees justice as an act of persecution by
his enemies.
These Trump traits leap out of a staggering 92-page ruling handed down by Engoron,
which left Trump facing a half-billion-dollar hole in his finances because of penalties
and obligations in this and other cases.
The judge encapsulated the former president’s brazen refusal to play by the same rules
under wich everyone else must live – and that in this case are the key to a functioning
banking and economic system – with the words: “The frauds found here leap off the
page and shock the conscience.”
But evidence never swayed Trump before and will not now, despite his crushing
defeat. Whenever he loses, he just doubles down with a bigger falsehood – in this case
that a fair legal process was a simply a political attack by President Joe Biden.
“All comes out of the DOJ, it all comes out of Biden,” Trump said. “It’s a witch hunt
against his political opponent, the likes of which our country has never seen.”
The climax of the case deepened the extraordinary legal morass facing Trump who is
embroiled in multiple cases and faces the first of his criminal trials next month. The
judgment portrays Trump, his adult sons and the Trump Organization, flouting
business ethics, rules and laws to pull valuations for their property assets out of the air
to get favorable loans, and then even more remarkably, refusing to accept the facts of
their conduct when confronted with the evidence.
Practically, Engoron’s decision will impose severe financial and personal strain on
Trump as he’s emerging as the almost certain Republican presidential nominee. While
Trump boasts of being a billionaire many times over, it’s unclear if he has the liquidity
to pay what he owes or if some of the “beautiful buildings” and golf resorts over
which he often waxes fondly in campaign speeches are at risk. An emperor has no
clothes moment that reveals the ex-president as less wealthy than he claims could
threaten the mogul’s mystique on which he built his political brand and his self-
identity.
Warnings signs for Trump
Perhaps most concerning for Trump, Friday’s defeat suggests the shield of impunity
that has allowed his rampaging political and business career is fraying. It comes only
three weeks after a jury in a defamation case in Manhattan awarded the writer E. Jean
Carroll $83 million in compensatory damages for public statements he made in 2019
disparaging her and denying her rape allegations.
While the ex-president's strategy of basing his legal defenses on a political argument
that he’s a victim of persecution from the Biden administration may be working in the
campaign – at least for now – it is no match for the exacting standards of a court of
law. At a defining moment of Trump’s fraud trial, when he was effectively making a
campaign speech from the stand, Engoron asked Trump’s lawyer: “Can you control
your client?” Of course, no one has ever been able to do so. But Engoron’s ruling
shows that the legal system has the power to constrain Trump and impose
consequences that the political system lacks, despite two impeachments and a lost
presidential election. This must be a worry for Trump as he faces four criminal trials,
and may partly explain his desire to win back power since presidential authority could
help him block or reverse convictions – at least in federal cases.
Trump is also absorbing a double blow from New York, the larger-than-life city and
state where he built towering skyscrapers and an outrageous personality based on an
all-publicity-is-good-publicity attitude to 1980s tabloids. On Thursday, another New
York judge locked in March 25 as the start date for this first criminal trial – over hush
money payments to a former adult film star. The next day, the real estate empire that
literally changed Manhattan’s skyline was rocked by Engoron’s verdict.
Trump has long since decamped to Florida, but Engoron’s ban on him running a New
York corporation for three years will still sting. New York brashness and high stakes
made Trump who he is. But his outlandishness has also repeatedly made him a
Manhattan outsider. And now the city is rejecting him again, as part of a longterm
trend that surely shaped Trump’s political super skill - his capacity to identify and
harness the frustration of Americans who feel themselves rejected and condescended
to by East Coast political, economic and media elites.
It’s too early to tell how Trump’s loss on Friday will affect his political campaign. The
dizzying lune-up of cases against him has only cemented his bond with Make
American Great Again voter who bought into his expertly crafted narrative of
persecution that rescued an initially lackluster 2024 election campaign and has him on
the verge of capturing his third straight Republican nomination. The advantage of
Trump’s sense of victimization is that every reverse further fuels it. One of his closest
allies, Rep. Elise Stefanik of New York, therefore was able to ignore the
overwhelming evidence revealed in the case of his malfeasance to declare: “The
American people will not stand for this; they will elect President Trumps as our 47 th
President of the United States. “
But for all of Biden’s political vulnerabilities, it’s hard to see how Trump’s increasing
list of legal losses will improve his standing with the suburban moderate, swing state
voters who paved the way to his loss in 2020. His remaining GOP foe Nikki Haley is
making this point in her rallies. “March and April, he’s in one case court case. May
and June, he’s in another,” Haley said while campaigning on Thursday ahead of the
South Carolina primary. “He’s already said he’s going to spend most of this year in a
courtroom, not on a campaign trail. That’s not a way you win.”
Friday’s ruling may turn out to be another blow to Republicans in a week in which
they lost a key special election in New York and the GOP House majority bolted
Washington in disarray. Biden, after a rough trot dominated by questions about his
age, had a better week, as Tom Suozzi’s election win cooled panic among Democrats
over their 2024 prospects and after the FBI charged and ex-informant with lying, in a
move that eviscerated the GOP’s impeachment inquiry against him.
Flouted rules, new realities and a busted legal strategy
Trump’s belief that the rules are for others defines his business and political life. It’s
essential, for example, to his claim now before the Supreme Court that presidents
enjoy absolute immunity and cannot be prosecuted for their actions after they leave
office.
Engoron, meanwhile, marveled at the ex-president’s audacity in flouting business
ethics in inflating the values of his real estate and then his refusal to accept the truth of
his actions when confronted with evidence. “Defendants are incapable of admitting
the error of their ways. Instead, they adopt a ‘See no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil’
posture that the evidence belies,” he wrote. Engoron explained that such a crushing
verdict was necessary to account for Trumps ill-gotten gains – because he believes
they will continue in the absence of a painful price: “Donald Trump testified that, even
today, he does not believe the Trump Organization needed to make any changes based
on the facts that came out during this trial.”
Trump’s willingness to create a convenient reality is also at the heart of the case filed
against him by New York Attorney General Letitia James, which rested on accusations
that he serially inflated the values of his holdings to obtain better terms from banks
and financial firms and to ultimately make more money. The ex-president claims that
there were no victims from his behavior and that everyone made money. Yet regular
Americans wouldn’t get away with such conduct in their far less lucrative financial
lives and investments. And Engoron argued that he was obligated to “protect the
integrity of the financial marketplace and, thus, the public as a whole.”
[Link]
Kissing Jacob Elordi, dancing with Julia Stiles and becoming Timothée Chalamet:
Chloe Fineman’s buzziest ‘SNL’ sketches
(CNN) – Chloe Fineman might be known by some as the chief impressionist at ‘SNL’,
but she says that she might walk away from the 49th season with a new moniker.
“I’m ‘Girl who’s hoisted by hunky men’ this year, and I’m really not mad about it,” she
joked to CNN recently, making reference to two memorable sketches that had her
jumping into the arms of “Aquaman” star Jason Momoa and “Euphoria” star Jacob
Elordi, respectively.
Indeed, it has been quite the season for Fineman, who has been on the long-running
sketch show since 2019. It’s seen her do street ballet with Julia Stiles and come face-to-
face with Timothée Chalamet after doing an uncanny impression of him.
In the midst of promoting her new campaign with NÜTRL Vodka Seltzer, Fineman spoke
to CNN about some of her buzziest sketches from what has arguably been her best
season yet.
Speaker of the House Mike Johnson talks to reporters during a news conference at
the U.S. Capitol Visitor Center on February 14, 2024 in Washington, D.C.
(CNN) – House Speaker Mike Johnson had the fate of a democracy and a people in his
hands.
It’s not the United States, which will survive – even if the coming general election results
in another existential test for the constitutional system.
The country Johnson has the power to save is Ukraine, two years after Russian President
Vladimir Putin invaded, decreeing that it didn’t have the right to exist.
Ukraine’s soldiers – trapped in a World War I-style hellscape of trench warfare – are
running out of bullets. There are signs that Russia may be about to break a stalemate and
tip the war its way.
Johnson, a backbencher who was the last-ditch choice to lead the mutinous House GOP
majority last year, could relieve Ukraine’s agony and help ensure its survival as an
independent nation in the coming days. He could allow a vote on a bill that includes $60
billion in aid that the Pentagon says is needed to allow Kyiv to continue to effectively
fight. It would likely pass with a comfortable bipartisan majority.
The Lousiana Republican’s reluctance to do so is a commentary on the growing power of
GOP front-runner Donald Trump, the sharp turn of his party away from its globalist pro-
democracy heritage and perhaps even his own ambition since borrowing Democratic
votes to finance Ukraine’s defense could cost him the speakership.
The speaker is coming under extreme pressure on multiple fronts, at home and abroad, as
coinciding crises that he’s postponed over his young speakership come to the boil at once.
Most immediately, without a budget deal with the Democratic Senate, the government
could hurtle into a partial shutdown by the weekend.
His predicament will be highlighted at a meeting of the top four congressional leaders at
the White House on Tuesday called by President Joe Biden.
The quiet Louisianan is besieged by intensifying calls among Republicans opposed to
more Ukraine aid, especially from the pro-Trump wing of his conference, as he seeks to
cling to his job longer than his ill-fated predecessor Kevin MacCarthy. But Johnson’s
lonely dilemma is being sharpened as the administration singles him out as the one man
who can thwart or enable Putin’s attempt to wipe Ukraine off the map. President
Volodymyr Zelensky starkly warned in an interview with CNN’s Kaitlan Collins that his
country could not succeed in repelling Russia without the aid. Foreign governments that
fear the Western coalition against Moscow could crumble without US cash and influence
have been calling on the speaker to act. And the pressure of Zelensky’s forces facing
battlefield defeats threatens to hand Republicans the blame if desperately needed arms are
not soon rushed to the front.
It is daunting picture for a speaker who rose from obscurity only months ago, and who
lacks the experience, vote-counting nous and leverage needed to cajole a Republican
majority into shape.
So far, Johnson has offered little evidence that he has the political dexterity to navigate
himself out of his dicey spot. But even a master of parliamentary muscle flexing might
struggle with such a weak hand. His minute majority means he can afford to lose only a
handful of votes among GOP members to pass a bill – a reality that gives extremist
members outsize influence. The fate of MacCarthy, ousted last year by his own side, casts
daily doubt on Johnson’s ability to survive. The threat comes the speaker’s own far-right
flank of a party that is increasingly nationalist, populist and isolationist after being
transformed by Trump. A $60 billion aid package to a foreign democracy is incompatible
with the “Make America Great Again” creed of the ex-president’s movement – and is
largely opposed by GOP voters at the grassroots.
So even if Johnson wants to rescue Ukraine, it may be politically impossible to do so.
Nothing can be guaranteed in a fractious Congress, with a House GOP majority that has
rendered the United States close to ungovernable and is threatening America’s global
leadership role.
A TENSE WHITE HOUSE MEETING IN PROSPECT.
Johnson will find himself outnumbered Tuesday. Joining him on the Oval Office sofas
will be House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, Senate Republican leader Mitch
McConnell and Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer – all of whom support the
swift and significant dispatch of funds for Ukraine.
“There is a strong bipartisan majority in the House standing ready to pass his bill if it
comes to the floor,” Biden national security adviser Jake Sullivan Said on CNN’s “State
of the Union” on Sunday. “And that decision rests on the shoulders of one person. And
history is watching whether Speaker Johnson will put that bill on the floor. If he does, it
will pass, we will get Ukraine what it needs for Ukraine to succeed.” Sullivan added: “If
he doesn’t, then we will not be able to give Ukraine the tools required for it to stand up to
Russia, and Putin will be the major beneficiary of that.”
[Link]
ballot-dispute/[Link]
<<write it>>
(CNN) –
[Link]
[Link]
China Says US TikTok ban ‘an act of bullying’ that would backfire.
Taiwan needs more babies. But conservative traditions are holding back
some fertility solutions.
Taipei, Taiwan (CNN) – for married Taiwanese men Alan Hung and Danny
Huang, the process of having a biological child together was never easy.
The couple dreamed of starting a family soon after tying the knot in 2019,
around the time Taiwan became the first Asian jurisdiction to legalize same-
sex marriage.
“Many of our friends already had their own children, and we also hoped we
could show our parental love,” Huang said.
But gay men are not allowed to access artificial reproduction tools in Taiwan,
so the couple – both university professors in their mid-40s -had to look
abroad.
First, they spent more than a week at a fertility clinic in Russia, only to find
out the procedure couldn’t be completed due to regulatory changes. Later,
they found success with a surrogate in the United States – but with a hefty
cost in excess of $160,000.
Cases like this are troubling to Chen Ching-hui, who last month became the
first fertility specialist to win a seat in Taiwan’s parliament.
“Taiwan’s medical technology is well ahead of many other countries, so why
are we making people spend large sums of money to travel overseas?” she
said in an interview with CNN.
[Link]
hnk-intl/[Link]