Chapter 13
Chapter 13
Question 13-1
A liability entails the present, the future, and the past. It is a present responsibility, to sacrifice
assets in the future, caused by a transaction or other event that already has happened. Specifically,
“Elements of Financial Statements,” Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 6, par. 36,
describes three essential characteristics: Liabilities–
1. are probable, future sacrifices of economic benefits
2. that arise from present obligations (to transfer goods or provide services) to other entities
3. that result from past transactions or events.
Question 13-2
Liabilities traditionally are classified as either current liabilities or long-term liabilities in a
classified balance sheet. Current liabilities are those expected to be satisfied with current assets or by
the creation of other current liabilities (Committee on Accounting Procedure, American Institute of
CPAs, Accounting Research and Terminology Bulletin, Final Edition, p. 21). Usually, but with
exceptions, current liabilities are obligations payable within one year or within the firm's operating
cycle, whichever is longer.
Question 13-3
In concept, liabilities should be reported at their present values; that is, the valuation amount is the
present value of all future cash payments resulting from the debt, usually principal and/or interest
payments. In this case, the amount would be determined as the present value of $100,000, discounted
for three months at an appropriate rate of interest for a debt of this type.
This is proper because of the time value of money. In practice, liabilities ordinarily are reported at
their maturity amounts if payable within one year because the relatively short time period makes the
interest or time value component immaterial. Accounting Principles Board Opinion No 21, “Interest on
Receivables and Payables,” specifically exempts from present value valuation all liabilities arising in
connection with suppliers in the normal course of business and due within a year.
Answers to Questions (continued)
Question 13-4
Lines of credit permit a company to borrow cash from a bank up to a prearranged limit at a
predetermined, usually floating, rate of interest. The interest rate often is based on current rates of the
prime London interbank borrowing, certificates of deposit, bankers’ acceptance, or other standard rates.
Lines of credit usually must be available to support the issuance of commercial paper.
Lines of credit can be noncommitted or committed. A noncommitted line of credit allows the
company to borrow without having to follow formal loan procedures and paperwork at the time of the
loan and is less formal, usually without a commitment fee. Sometimes a compensating balance is
required to be on deposit with the bank as compensation for the service. A committed line of credit is
more formal. It usually requires a commitment fee in the neighborhood of 1/4 of one percent of the
unused balance during the availability period. Sometimes compensating balances also are required.
Question 13-6
Commercial paper represents loans from other corporations. It refers to unsecured notes sold in
minimum denominations of $25,000 with maturities ranging from 30 to 270 days. The firm would be
required to file a registration statement with the SEC if the maturity is beyond 270 days. The name
“commercial paper” implies that a paper certificate is issued to the lender to represent the obligation.
But, increasingly, no paper is created because the entire transaction is computerized. Recording the
issuance and payment of commercial paper is the same as for notes payable.
The interest rate usually is lower than in a bank loan because commercial paper (a) typically is
issued by large, sound companies (b) directly to the lender, and (c) normally is backed by a line of credit
with a bank.
Question 13-7
This is an example of an accrued expense – an expense incurred during the current period, but not
yet paid. The expense and related liability should be recorded as follows:
Question 13-8
When a company collects cash from a customer as a refundable deposit or as an advance payment
for products or services, a liability is created obligating the firm to return the deposit or to supply the
products or services. When the amount is to be returned to the customer in cash, it is a refundable
deposit. When the amount will be applied to the purchase price when goods are delivered or services
provided (gift certificates, magazine subscriptions, layaway deposits, special order deposits, and airline
tickets) it is a customer advance.
Question 13-9
Examples of amounts collected for third parties that represent liabilities until remitted are sales
taxes, and payroll-related deductions such as federal and state income taxes, social security taxes,
employee insurance, employee contributions to retirement plans, and union dues.
Question 13-10
1. Current liability — The requirement to classify currently maturing debt as a current liability
includes debt that is callable, or due on demand, by the creditor in the upcoming year even if the
debt is not expected to be called.
Question 13-11
Short-term obligations can be reported as noncurrent liabilities if the company (a) intends to
refinance on a long-term basis and (b) demonstrates the ability to do so by a refinancing agreement or by
actual financing.
Question 13-12
A loss contingency is an existing situation, or set of circumstances involving potential loss that
will be resolved when some future event occurs or doesn’t occur. Examples: (1) an unsettled tax
deficiency assessed by the IRS, (2) a possible uncollectible receivable, (3) being the defendant in a
lawsuit.
Question 13-13
The likelihood that the future event(s) will confirm the incurrence of the liability must be
categorized as:
REASONABLY POSSIBLE– the chance the confirming event will occur is more than remote but less
than likely.
Question 13-14
A liability should be accrued if it is both probable that the confirming event will occur and the
amount can be at least reasonably estimated.
Question 13-15
If one or both of the accrual criteria is not met, but there is at least a reasonable possibility that an
obligation exists (the loss will occur), a disclosure note should describe the contingency. The note also
should provide an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss, if possible. If an estimate cannot be
made, a statement to that effect should be included.
Question 13-16
2. Cash rebates and other premium offers — these inevitably involve expenditures, and reasonably
accurate estimates of the total liability for a period usually are possible, based on prior experience.
Question 13-18
Several weeks usually pass between the end of a company’s fiscal year and the date the financial
statements for that year actually are issued. Any enlightening events occurring during this period should
be used to assess the nature of a loss contingency existing at the report date. Since a liability should be
accrued if it is both probable that the confirming event will occur and the amount can be at least
reasonably estimated, the contingency should be accrued.
Question 13-19
When a contingency comes into existence only after the year-end, a liability cannot be accrued
because none existed at the end of the year. Yet, if the loss is probable and can be reasonably estimated,
the contingency should be described in a disclosure note. The note should include the effect of the loss
on key accounting numbers affected. Furthermore, even events other than contingencies that occur after
the year-end but before the financial statements are issued must be disclosed in a “subsequent events”
disclosure note if they have a material effect on the company’s financial position. (i.e., an issuance of
debt or equity securities, a business combination, or discontinued operations).
Question 13-20
When an assessment is probable, reporting the possible obligation would be warranted if an
unfavorable settlement is at least reasonably possible. This means an estimated loss and contingent
liability would be accrued if (a) an unfavorable outcome is probable and (b) the amount can be
reasonably estimated. Otherwise footnote disclosure would be appropriate. So, when the assessment is
unasserted as yet, a two-step process is involved in deciding how it should be reported:
Question 13-21
You should not accrue your gain. A gain contingency should not be accrued. This conservative
treatment is consistent with the general inclination of accounting practice to anticipate losses, but to
recognize gains only at their realization. Though gain contingencies are not recorded in the accounts,
they should be disclosed in notes to the financial statements. Attention should be paid that the
disclosure note not give "misleading implications as to the likelihood of realization."
Exercise 13-1
Requirement 1
Requirement 2
Requirement 3
2004
Sept. 1
Interest expense ($10,000,000 x 9% x 8/12)* ......................... 600,000
Discount on notes payable ................................................. 600,000
Exercise 13-5
Requirement 1
Cash........................................................................................... 5,200
Liability – gift certificates ................................................... 5,200
Requirement 3
The liability for gift certificates is part current and part noncurrent:
Gift certificates sold $5,200
x 80%
Estimated current liability $4,160
Gift certificates redeemed (1,300)
Current liability at December 31 $2,860
Noncurrent liability at December 31 ($5,200 x 20%) 1,040
Total $3,900
Exercise 13-7
Requirement 1
Requirement 2
Requirement 3
Exercise 13-8
Normally, short-term debt (payable within a year) is classified as current liabilities. However, when
such debt is to be refinanced on a long-term basis, it may be included with long-term liabilities. The
narrative indicates that Sprint has both (1) the intent and (2) the ability ("existing long-term credit
facilities") to refinance on a long-term basis. Thus, Sprint reported the debt as long-term liabilities.
Requirement 1
This is a loss contingency. There may be a future sacrifice of economic benefits (cost of
satisfying the warranty) due to an existing circumstance (the warranted awnings have been sold)
that depends on an uncertain future event (customer claims).
The liability is probable because product warranties inevitably entail costs. A reasonably
accurate estimate of the total liability for a period is possible based on prior experience. So, the
contingent liability for the warranty is accrued. The estimated warranty liability is credited and
warranty expense is debited in 2003, the period in which the products under warranty are sold.
Requirement 2
2003 Sales
Accounts receivable ......................................................... 5,000,000
Sales ............................................................................ 5,000,000
Actual expenditures
Estimated warranty liability ............................................ 37,500
Cash, wages payable, parts and supplies, etc. ............ 37,500
Requirement 3
Warranty Liability
_________________________________________
112,500 Balance
Exercise 13-16
Requirement 1
Requirement 2
This is a loss contingency. Classical can use the information occurring after the end of the
year and before the financial statements are issued to determine appropriate disclosure.
Requirement 4
This is a gain contingency. Gain contingencies are not accrued even if the gain is probable
and reasonably estimable. The gain should be recognized only when realized. A disclosure
note is appropriate.
Requirement 5
Requirement 6
Exercise 13-18
Exercise 13-21
The note describes a loss contingency. Dow anticipates a future sacrifice of economic benefits
(cost of remediation and restoration) due to an existing circumstance (environmental violations) that
depends on an uncertain future event (requirement to pay claim).
Dow considers the liability probable and the amount is reasonably estimable. As a result, the
company accrued the liability:
($ in millions)
Exercise 13-22
Problem 13-2
Requirement 1
2003
a. No entry is made for a line of credit until a loan actually is made. It would be described
in a disclosure note.
c. Cash.................................................................................. 2,600
Liability – refundable deposits ................................. 2,600
2004
Requirement 2
CURRENT LIABILITIES:
Accounts payable $ 252,000
Current portion of bank loan 2,000,000*
Liability – refundable deposits 2,600
Sales taxes payable 246,000
Accrued interest payable 300,000
Total current liabilities $2,800,600
LONG-TERM LIABILITIES:
Bank loan to be refinanced
on a long-term basis $10,000,000*
Problem 13-3
Requirement 1
a. The requirement to classify currently maturing debt as a current liability includes debt that is
callable by the creditor in the upcoming year – even if the debt is not expected to be called. So,
the entire $40 million debt is a current liability.
b. $5 million can be reported as long term, but $1 million must be reported as a current liability.
Short-term obligations that are expected to be refinanced with long-term obligations can be
reported as noncurrent liabilities only if the firm (a) intends to refinance on a long-term basis
and (b) actually has demonstrated the ability to do so. Ability to refinance on a long-term basis
c. The entire $20 million maturity amount should be reported as a current liability because that
amount is payable in the upcoming year and it will not be refinanced with long-term obligations
nor paid with a bond sinking fund.
d. The entire $12 million loan should be reported as a long-term liability because that amount is
payable in 2006 and it will not be refinanced with long-term obligations nor paid with a bond
sinking fund. The current liability classification includes (a) situations in which the creditor has
the right to demand payment because an existing violation of a provision of the debt agreement
makes it callable and (b) situations in which debt is not yet callable, but will be callable within
the year if an existing violation is not corrected within a specified grace period – unless it's
probable the violation will be corrected within the grace period. Here, the existing violation is
expected to be corrected within 6 months (actually 3 months in this case).
Requirement 2
December 31, 2003
($ in millions)
Current Liabilities
Accounts payable and accruals $ 22
10% notes payable due May 2004 1
Currently maturing portion of long-term debt:
11% bonds due October 31, 2014,
redeemable on October 31, 2004 $40
12% bonds due September 30, 2004 20 60
Total Current Liabilities 83
Long-Term Debt
Currently maturing debt classified as long-term:
10% notes payable due May 2004 (Note X) 5
9% bank loan due October 2009 12
Total Long-Term Liabilities 17
Total Liabilities $100
The Company intends to refinance $6 million of 10% notes that mature in May of 2004. In March,
2004, the Company negotiated a line of credit with a commercial bank for up to $5 million any time
during 2004. Any borrowings will mature two years from the date of borrowing. Accordingly, $5
million was reclassified to long-term liabilities.
Problem 13-5
a. This is a loss contingency. Eastern can use the information occurring after the end of the year in
determining appropriate disclosure. It is unlikely that Eastern would choose to accrue the $122
_______________________________
Note X: Contingency
In a lawsuit resulting from a dispute with a supplier, a judgment was rendered against Eastern
Corporation in the amount of $107 million plus interest, a total of $122 million at February 3, 2004.
Eastern plans to appeal the judgment. While management and legal counsel are presently unable to
predict the outcome or to estimate the amount of any liability the company may have with respect to
this lawsuit, it is not expected that this matter will have a material adverse effect on the company.
b. This is a loss contingency. Eastern can use the information occurring after the end of the year in
determining appropriate disclosure. Eastern should accrue the $140 million loss because the
ultimate outcome appears settled and the loss is probable.
_________________________________
Notes: Litigation
In November 2002, the State of Nevada filed suit against the Company, seeking civil penalties and
injunctive relief for violations of environmental laws regulating hazardous waste. On January 12,
2004, the Company announced that it had reached a settlement with state authorities on this matter.
Based upon discussions with legal counsel, the Company, has accrued and charged to operations in
2003, $140 million to cover the anticipated cost of all violations. The Company believes that the
ultimate settlement of this claim will not have a material adverse effect on the Company's financial
position.
c. This is a gain contingency. Gain contingencies are not accrued even if the gain is probable and
reasonably estimable. The gain should be recognized only when realized.
Though gain contingencies are not recorded in the accounts, they should be disclosed in notes to the
financial statements.
_______________________________
Note X: Contingency
Eastern is the plaintiff in a pending lawsuit filed against United Steel for damages due to lost profits
from rejected contracts and for unpaid receivables. The case is in final appeal. No amount has been
accrued in the financial statements for possible collection of any claims in this litigation.
d. No disclosure is required because an IRS claim is as yet unasserted, and an assessment is not
probable. Even if an unfavorable outcome is thought to be probable in the event of an assessment
and the amount is estimable, disclosure is not required unless an unasserted claim is probable.
Memorandum:
Below is a brief overview of my initial thoughts on how Western should account for the four
contingencies in question.
1. The labor disputes constitute a loss contingency. Though a loss is probable, the amount of loss
is not reasonably estimable. A disclosure note is appropriate:
_______________________________
Note X: Contingency
During 2003, the Company experienced labor disputes at three of its plants. The Company
hopes an agreement will soon be reached. However negotiations between the Company and
the unions have not produced an acceptable settlement and, as a result, strikes are ongoing at
these facilities.
2. The A. J. Conner matter is a gain contingency. Gain contingencies are not accrued even if the
gain is probable and reasonably estimable. The gain should be recognized only when realized.
Though gain contingencies are not recorded in the accounts, they should be disclosed in notes to
the financial statements.
4. The Crump Holdings lawsuit is a loss contingency. Even though the lawsuit occurred in 2004,
the cause for the action occurred in 2003. Only a disclosure note is needed because an
unfavorable outcome is reasonably possible, but not probable. Also, the amount is not
reasonably estimable.
_______________________________
Note X: Contingency
Crump Holdings filed suit in January 2004 against the Company seeking $88 million, as an
adjustment to the purchase price in connection with the Company's sale of its textile business
in 2003. Crump alleges that the Company misstated the assets and liabilities used to calculate
the purchase price for the division. The Company has answered the complaint and intends to
vigorously defend the lawsuit. Management believes that the final resolution of the case will
not have a material adverse effect on the Company's financial position.
2. Current assets are sufficient to cover current liabilities in both 2001 and 2000:
Comparing liabilities that must be satisfied soon with assets that either are cash or will be converted
to cash soon provides a useful measure of a company’s liquidity. A current ratio of 1 to 1 or higher
sometimes is considered a rule-of-thumb standard. However, the current ratio is but one indication
of liquidity. Each ratio is but one piece of the puzzle.
3. From Note 3 we see that the two largest accrued expenses for FedEx in 2001 were insurance expense
and compensated absences. An accrued expense is an expense incurred during the current period,
but not yet paid. FedEx recorded these as adjusting entries at the end of the reporting period with
debits to the appropriate expenses and credits to related liabilities. This helps achieve a proper
matching of expenses with the revenues they help generate.