0% found this document useful (0 votes)
32 views15 pages

Change in Climate Impact vs. Total Operating Costs For Different Technologies

The document discusses various aircraft technologies and their impact on operating costs and climate change, focusing on turboprop and turbofan engines using different fuels. It highlights the collaborative efforts of over 165 scientists from 20 institutes to assess and innovate aviation technologies for future aircraft designs. The ALICIA project aims to aggregate results and evaluate the environmental impact of these technologies in the context of climate-compatible aviation.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Topics covered

  • Aircraft Performance,
  • Aeroelastics,
  • Impact Assessment,
  • Aircraft Design,
  • Transport Infrastructure,
  • Network Scenarios,
  • Energy Price Scenarios,
  • Aerodynamics,
  • Flight Mechanics,
  • Fleet Optimization
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
32 views15 pages

Change in Climate Impact vs. Total Operating Costs For Different Technologies

The document discusses various aircraft technologies and their impact on operating costs and climate change, focusing on turboprop and turbofan engines using different fuels. It highlights the collaborative efforts of over 165 scientists from 20 institutes to assess and innovate aviation technologies for future aircraft designs. The ALICIA project aims to aggregate results and evaluate the environmental impact of these technologies in the context of climate-compatible aviation.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Topics covered

  • Aircraft Performance,
  • Aeroelastics,
  • Impact Assessment,
  • Aircraft Design,
  • Transport Infrastructure,
  • Network Scenarios,
  • Energy Price Scenarios,
  • Aerodynamics,
  • Flight Mechanics,
  • Fleet Optimization

Network Scenario: Energy-Price Scenario: Assumptions:

Turboprop: No value of speed assumptions


20%
Medium: No CO2 abatement costs
No contrail avoidance
High: Green Electricity Mix
100% DAC
15%

Turbofan 2015
Sy n. Kerosene
Turbofan:
10%

Change in total operating cost


5%
Turbofan 2015
Turbofan LH2
Mild-Hybrid Change in climate impact (total life cycle, CO2eq) Fossil Kerosene

Green LH2
0%
-100% -90% -80% -70% -60% -50% -40% -30% -20% -10% 0%

Turbofan
-5%
Sy n. Kerosene
Turboprop LH2
Mild-Hybrid
Green LH2

-10%
Turbofan
Fossil Kerosene

Turboprop
Sy n. Kerosene
-15%

Plug-In Hybrid
Green Electri city /
Sy n. Kerosene Turboprop -20%
1 Plug-In Hybrid Fossil Kerosene
Green Electri city / Fossil ®
Kerosene

-25%

Change in climate impact vs. total operating costs for different technologies
200 scientists discussing latest findings and future collaborations
Open rotor propulsion offers great energy efficiency but bears acoustic challenges
Jennifer Ramm explaining the implemented Life Cycle Assessment
Overall System Requirements and Scenarios
Top-Level-Aircraft-Requirements, Technology bricks, Economic and Ecological boundary conditions

Aircraft Level Impact Assessment Energy Carrier


Higher-Fidelity
Global air traffic forecast

Energy Carrier Demand


Propulsion & Fuselage &
LH2 Storage Aero- Cabin
On-Board Wing Energy Carrier
& Systems dynamics Acoustics Global fleet assignment
Systems Structure Production
Networks &
Low-Fidelity Mid-Fidelity
Infrastructure

Fully described Aircraft Family


Propulsion &
On-Board
Systems High-Speed Emissions modelling
Performance
Conceptual LH2 Storage
& Systems Cabin Design Synthesis
Aircraft Design
Low-Speed
Fuselage & Performance

Energy Carrier Costs & LCA


Climate assessment
Wing
Structure
LCA & economic assessment

Energy Carrier
Production/ Operation Operation
End-of-Life Life-Cycle
Shorter Family Mission Performance Acquisition (Flights) (Ground)
Assessment
Members Post Processing

Global Ecological and Economical Results

Lifecycle Assessment comprising the aircraft, operations and the energy carrier
Daniel Silberhorn introducing the collaborative design methodology in the EXACT project
3

Capit al
Fees 18%
1
22%
Ecological Future Air
Climate In-Flight Fleet Network Aircraft
Tur bofan
Life-Cycle Traffic
SynFuel Cr ew
Impact Emissions Optimization Design
3
15%
Assessment Demand
M aintenance
1 17%
Ener gy
28%
1
Economic Flight
1
1 3 Assessment Mechanics

Energy Carrier
HiFi
Production &
Aerodynamics
Transport

3
Structural
Airport
Design &
2 Infrastructure
Aeroelastics

On-Board
Maintenance
Systems

LH2 Storage &


Cabin Cabin Digital Electric Propulsion Processing
Acoustics Design Backbone Power-Train architecture System
®

Digitally integrating competencies


▪ > 165 scientists from 20 institutes
involved
▪ considering short- to long-range future
aircraft concepts

More than 100 scientist from 20 DLR institutes model all relevant aspects of aviation
Innovation market: 40 technology bricks were discussed in detail in small groups
Collaborative design based on the CPACS data model is enabler for system competence
Fossil Synthetic Battery
LH2
Kerosene Kerosene Hybrid
Reference
Year

References
D239 D300 D369
2030

D239plus

D300plus

Retrofit
2035

D369plus

D250-TF D250-TP D250-PHEP D250-TPLH2-MHEP D250-TFLH2-MHEP


2040

D350-TF D350-TFLH2

New Concepts
2045
Entry Into Service

D450-PHEP D450-TF D350SR-TF D400-TF D400-TFLH2


2050

Short- & Short-Medium-Range Medium- & Medium-Long-Range Long- & Ultra-Long-Range


Design Range: 1000-3500 NM Design Range: 3500-6500 NM Design Range: 6500-8500 NM

Multiple technology options for different aircraft classes are investigated concurrently
Patrick Ratei provides a live demo of the ALICIA dashboard for impact assessment
The ALICIA project aggregates detailed results and assesses the impact in the future
Prajwal Shiva Prakasha explaining the relevance of quantified impact assessment
PANEL DISCUSSION
HOW TO CATALYZE CLIMATE-COMPATIBLE AVIATION

Prof. Eike Stumpf Sébastien Dubois Prof. Dimitri Mavris Daniel Reckzeh Dr. James Hileman
RWTH Aachen University Clean Aviation JU Georgia Institute of Technology Airbus The Boeing Company
University Professor Head of Programme Development Regents Professor Senior Manager & Aircraft Architect VP and Chief Engineer
& Head of Institute & Communications & Director of ASDL Airbus Technology Sustainability & Future Mobility

Moderated by
Prof. Joachim Szodruch
Hamburg Aviation
Chairman of the Executive Board

Architecting Future Aviation


1-2 April 2025
ZAL, Hamburg, Germany
Joining forces between different research initiatives to maximize our impact!
• 15 z jö • U Y Z SAA, CISTE & CAE > Online > 24.08.2020

Architecting the Future of Aviation Together!

Common questions

Powered by AI

Climate-compatible aviation faces numerous challenges, including the need to develop and implement new propulsion technologies such as turboprop and open rotor systems that offer greater energy efficiency but have acoustic challenges. Furthermore, the transition to new fuel types like hydrogen and synthetic kerosene requires significant advancements in storage systems and the development of cost-effective, sustainable energy production networks. Collaborative efforts across research initiatives are essential to overcome these infrastructural and technical barriers effectively .

Liquid hydrogen (LH2) as a fuel offers substantial environmental benefits by significantly reducing greenhouse gas emissions during the fuel's life cycle. However, the limitations include the current lack of infrastructure for efficient LH2 storage and distribution, as well as the need for technological adjustments in aircraft design to safely and effectively use LH2, all of which require substantial investment and research .

Diverse scientific backgrounds contribute to sustainable aviation through interdisciplinary collaboration, which integrates varied expertise in scientific research, engineering, and environmental sciences. This diversity enables a more comprehensive approach to solving complex problems related to new aircraft designs, propulsion systems, and life cycle assessments, facilitating innovation across technology domains and enhancing the viability of sustainable aviation solutions .

Transitioning from fossil kerosene to synthetic kerosene involves economic implications such as increased production costs due to the energy-intensive nature of synthetic fuel production. This transition may also lead to higher operating costs for airlines in the short term. However, long-term benefits could include stability in fuel prices and reductions in emission-related penalties, as well as alignment with international environmental commitments .

The collaborative design methodology integrates digitally enabled competencies across multiple domains, fostering a holistic approach to sustainable aviation development. By combining the expertise of over 165 scientists across 20 institutes, this methodology facilitates the co-evolution of aircraft design, propulsion technology, and life-cycle assessments, ensuring that ecological and economic factors are balanced to achieve viable future aircraft concepts .

Global air traffic forecasts are influenced by factors such as economic growth, regulatory changes, technological advancements, and environmental concerns. These factors impact future aviation strategies by necessitating a focus on developing technologies that can increase fuel efficiency and reduce emissions. Strategic planning must also consider fleet optimization and the adoption of alternative fuels to align with projected demand and regulatory requirements .

The life cycle assessment shows that using synthetic kerosene and hybrid technologies, such as plug-in hybrid systems with green electricity, significantly reduces climate impact compared to conventional fossil kerosene. However, these technologies can lead to an increase in operating costs due to higher energy prices and the need for new infrastructure. For example, the use of LH2 (liquid hydrogen) offers a substantial reduction in climate impact but requires overcoming challenges in storage and infrastructure development .

Aircraft lifecycle assessments consider a range of environmental and operational factors, including emissions from production, in-flight operations, ground operations, and end-of-life processes. These assessments are vital for evaluating the ecological footprint of different aircraft technologies, identifying areas for improvement, and helping define strategies to minimize environmental impacts throughout an aircraft's lifecycle .

The EXACT project leverages digital backbone technology to enhance aircraft design and integration by facilitating a seamless integration of diverse data and expertise across multiple technical domains. This approach allows for more accurate simulations, improved system compatibility, and adaptation of new propulsion systems, all of which contribute to the efficient development of next-generation aircraft .

The ALICIA dashboard plays a critical role in aggregating detailed results and providing a comprehensive assessment of the impacts of future aviation technologies. It enables stakeholders to visualize and analyze various metrics related to environmental and economic impact, supporting informed decision-making for developing sustainable aviation strategies .

You might also like