Effective Interviewing Techniques in Healthcare
Effective Interviewing Techniques in Healthcare
PDR 2
AUGUST 11,2021
DR. WILFREDA G. SABANAL
EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION
1. Verbal communication
2. Non verbal communication
several forms:
a. eye contact
b. mannerisms
c. touch
d. gestures
e. tone of voice
f. posture
[Link] communication
[Link] feelings
[Link] content
[Link] experience
COMMUNICATING IN SPECIAL SITUATIONS
2. The doctor must disclose the bad news using emotive words with care.
2. The doctor should discuss the treatment options and involve the patient
in decision-making and plans.
[Link] patient
[Link] patient
[Link] patient
4. Emotional patient
[Link] patient
Noncompliant patient
THE MEDICAL INTERVIEW
PDR 2
THE MEDICAL INTERVIEW
-important in establishing
rapport with the patient
1. Primary History
-centers on HPI,
-based on chief complaint
2. Secondary History
-centers on ROS
- Elaborates the HPI with certain amount of interpretation
3. Tertiary History
- Centers on the PMH related to HPI
Overview : Components of the Adult Health History
Chief Complaint /s
- The one or more symptoms or concerns causing the patient to
seek care.
-amplifies the CC
WILFREDA [Link],MD.,LPT,MAED-EM
PDR2
AUGUST 25,2021
Demonstrating Cultural Humility—
A Changing Paradigm.
Many of these topics trigger strong personal responses related to family, cultural, and
societal values. Mental
illness, drug use during pregnancy, and same-sex practices are examples of issues
that may evoke biases that affect your interaction with the patient
Several basic principles can help guide your response
to sensitive topics:
Guidelines for Broaching Sensitive Topics
1. The single most important rule is to be
nonjudgmental.
Your role is to learn from the patient and help the patient achieve better health.
Acceptance is the best way to reach this goal.
2. Explain why you need to know certain information. This makes patients less
apprehensive
[Link] opening questions for sensitive topics and learn the specific kinds of
information needed for your shared assessment and plan.
For women, you can ask these questions during the Obstetric/Gynecologic section
of the Past Medical History.
You can include the sexual history in discussions about Health Maintenance, or in
the Personal and Social History as you explore lifestyle issues and important
relationships.
In a comprehensive history, you can also ask about sexual practices during the
Review of Systems.
Do not forget to cover the sexual history in older patients and patients with
disability or chronic illness.
The Mental Health History
Cultural constructs of mental and physical illness vary widely, leading to
differences in social acceptance and attitudes. Think how easy it is for
patients to talk about diabetes and taking insulin compared with
discussing schizophrenia and using psychotropic medications.
Ask open-ended questions initially. “Have you ever had any problem
with emotional or mental illnesses?”
Then move to more specific questions such as
“Have you ever seen a counselor or psychotherapist?”
“Have you ever taken medication for a mental health condition?
“Have you ever been hospitalized for an emotional or mental health
problem?”
“What about members of your family?”
Watch for mood changes or symptoms such as fatigue, unusual
tearfulness, appetite or weight changes,
insomnia, and vague somatic complaints.
“Have you ever had a drinking problem?” and “When was your last
drink?”, especially if the night
before.
The most widely used screening questions are the CAGE questions about Cutting
down, Annoyance when criticized, Guilty feelings, and Eyeopeners.
If you detect misuse, ask about blackouts (loss of memory about events during
drinking), seizures, accidents or injuries while drinking, job problems, and conflict
in personal relationships.
.
Illicit Drugs.
The National Institute on Drug Abuse recommends first asking a highly
sensitive and specific single question:
“How many times in the past year have you used an illegal drug or used a
prescription medication for nonclinical
reasons?
If there is a positive response, ask specifically about nonclinical use of illicit
and prescription drugs
: “In your lifetime have you ever used: marijuana; cocaine; prescription
stimulants; methamphetamines; sedatives or
sleeping pills; hallucinogens like lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD),
ecstasy,mushrooms…; street opioids like heroin or opium; prescription
opioids like fentanyl, oxycodone, hydrocodone…; or other substances.”
For those answering yes, a series of further questions is
recommended.
Another approach is to modify the CAGE questions by adding
“or drugs” to each
question. Once you identify substance abuse, probe further with
questions like
“Are you always able to control your use of drugs?” “Have you
had any bad reactions?”
“What happened . . . Any drug-related accidents, injuries, or
arrests?
Job or family problems?” . .
. “Have you ever tried to quit? Tell me about it.”
Intimate partner Violence and Domestic Violence
Violence is the leading cause of serious injury and the second leading cause of death
among U.S.
women and men experience rape, physical violence, or stalking by an intimate
partner; these are groups that experience high rates of mental health disorders
And substance abuse.
Sensitive interviewing is essential, since even with skilled inquiry, only 25%
of patients disclose their abuse experience.
Disclosure is more likely when probing questions lead and then in depth
direct questions follow.
“Are you in a relationship where you have been hit or threatened?”
with a pause to encourage the patient to respond.
FORMS OF COMMUNICATION
ACTIVE LISTENING SKILLS
COMMUNICATING IN SPECIAL SITUATIONS
r
[Link] '.-ir.l!Ni\R[O
Mari:llt, fi O, is diagn os!id to h:1vc hn·a'.:t cancer, :;tagc :-\ . Upon consultation, she hr-
comes so anx iou:-; and asks lier phv:;ician " Why 111<.:r
..... ______ ·------ -· --- - --- --·· ·- - --•··--- ·- --· -·---- --· -- -- --- --------
Dealing with patients and their family, coupled with correct diag-
nosis and management, is an important asset of a physician. An effec-
tive and relatively satisfying doctor-patient relationship can make the
difference between succe d failure . T eed for better communi-
canon promote trust, rapport, d n the part of the pa- "'""'=--~
tient. Commumc 10n s · s are nee ed i 1 ascertaining patients'
concerns and worries in the process of diagnosis~ explaining~-
2ent options, ,2) informing them of the I_BDice a£ rbeic illoess..i the
therapeutic intervention and its side effects, 4) addressing psychoso-
cial problems, and 5) counseling.
FoRMs oF CoMMUNICA.T!oN
VERBAL COMMUNICATION
Much of the time m the clinical interview 1s spent on verbal
27
i
1hc
_ 1 Fili · . Pl- · - . . - •. .
-
ptno 1ys1cian Today
28 29
l'he Filipino Physician Today ,..._
28 29
_, _; - - ..:J
Today
•.:
Patient: lvfy blood pressu re is on the rise because J ,tm both-
story. [r c m usu:illy bt: :rnswc rt:<l with ::i wo rd ,) r :.1 b rief scn rence,
ered? ,l lot ofthings at home. The kids are very noisy tlnd keep
runmng around My husband is alway s shouting even at lit:tle which is usu;illy an cx::ict d :ira [Link] gives rhe pJ. cient littl e roo m for
things_ My mother-in-law has a poker fa ce. expl;ination. Examples are: '' W h;it is you r name ;" '' Where J o yo u
live?" "What is your job?"
Doctor: You mean you have a lot ofproblems right now. Am
I right? -2. Yes-no questions are those answerable by ei ther "yes" or "no"
and are used for obtain ing the fa mily history or fo r the review o f
2. LEADING SKILLS CLUSTER . systems.
- - - - -- ---- - ~his_cluster includ~[Link]:_e_c5 leading.!._~rec~ ~~~-i~~• focusing, and 3. Confrontation questions are based on an observation by the
quest1orung. - ---- - - - -------- ,:·- - - - - - --- physician that po1nrs- i:o- a pacienr's striking behavior or pr~~~- - -- --
- l d" h l
l n d zrrct , statement. Examples are chose which start with the word why. They
/ ea mg e ps the patient get started and gives him a. cue to ,
are not recommended for use since they connote a threatening im-
. keep the interview go ing. An example of indirect leading would
pact on the patient. Bue they could be modified so char the word why
be your nonverbal. communicarion such a.s nodding or hand ges- i, •.
- will be in the middle of the question. You can therefore ask, "Is there
[Link]. A verbal statement such as "What can I do for you?" is { any reason why you ;_.ere not able to take your meditations?"
another example. ,
4 . .Probing questions explore the previous statement of the pa-
Direct leadinu focuses the topic more specifically. It encourages
o ciem. An example:
the patiem to elaborate on what he is saying. This can only be
used if indirect leading has been done. An example: Parienr: I have had this headache since last week. It has be-
come intolerable today. It's as ifsomething is pressing on my right
Patient: Dr. Sison, I've been having this chest pain for th e head. I self medicated with paracetamol but there was no relief
last nvo weeks. ft usually occurs when I am studying my lessons.
Dr. Sison: Kindly explain to me the circumstances that Led Doctor: Aside from studying, is there any other incident that
to yuur chest pain. could have provoked your headache?
Focusing is used when there is confusion on the part of the physi- 3. REFLECTlN G S1<1u.s CLUSTER
cian because the patient tries to mix confounding data.. An ex- Reflecting is one way of expressing to the patient that the phys i-
ample is as follows: cian is in his frame of reference and shares his deep concern. There are
Patient: Three days ago, I had this headache. I also lost ap- three areas of reflecting: feelings , content and experience.
petite and my hands seem to be trembling. I experience it any Re;1ecting feelings determ ines what feel in g the patient is express-
time ofthe day . . ing_ Observing his reactions and asking for feedback regarding
Doctor: It seems that you have a lot ofproblems. Let us go the reaction will help. Probing can lead into reflection also. An
over them one at a time. So let's talk about your headache first. example:
QUt:Stionint may be conducted in the form of o~en-ended or_closed- ·Patient: I cannot understand why I am having this head-
. . b d propnarely The different ache far three weeks now. lvly grandmother also had the same
ended questions , but it must e use ap . . d
. b I·no yes -no quesr10ns, a n thing fast year and she died ofit.
forms are direct quesr10ns , pro o•
Doctor: So you're afraid that the same thing might happen
confi-onracion quemons -
.fy d dd detail co the to you_
I. Direct questions serve ro clan areas an a
31
30
Reflecting cont 1 ·
h k'
- • .. . . ... v
I I
,· uy1>1cun ·today
32 33
·-: ··!
; '.
'
I
The filipino
■!
!
.
Physician loctay
■·
•
,
'
•• • '
the caregiver that [Link] has co be done rega rding the patien r's
hygiene.
• The emotional patient tends to overdramarize to se~k attention .
The physician has co address psychosocial issues raised because
these might have a bearing on the patient's medical problem.
--·--·------ -- -XHE -NONCOMPLIANT-RATlENT-- ----- - --- ---- - - --~- - ------ - -· - --- --------- -
Compliance is often seen as one of the problems encountered in
clinical practice. Among patients who seem to forget their medica-
tions as well as their follow-up with the physician, the physician is in a
firm position to influence compliance. For e~ample, if he wants to
check for compliance, he should ask the patient who might not be
always reliable. It is important that the question should never start
with why; instead, it should be face-saving, nonthreatening, and
nonjudgmental. An example is:" Most p~ople find it difficult to take
their medications. Did you miss any ofyour pills since the last time I
saw you?" If the answer is in the affirmative, the doctor should not get
angry at the patient but instead try to explore issues why he 'missed it.
Then, he should handle the patient's distress.
The guidelines mentioned will help you deal with ·difficult com-
~unication situations. Bear in mind, however, that practice is needed
m order to master these skills?
CASE RESOLUTION
Apnlvino •1Miun lict,,ninfl •lr'll I ·1 · ·
~.JuS
. .. 1"" , .... b - - · "' -'-"'"'-'•Ullt, 'N,1L.e n1terv;cwing ~lan .. : ,h.. ,l.. ~1-. • .... · · ·
ccssfully elicit the impact of illness o _aa.ua.11 , u,e p11y;iiCiai1 IS able to sue-
is then able to ide tif I f n her by probing on her statement "Why me?" He
- n y ier ears and consequently address them.
34
HISTORY TAKING
CASE SCENARIO
Maria, 60, consults because of chesl pain. She is overweight and is fond of eating oily
food.
____________________________ __,,/
37
The Filipino Physician Today 1- ,1:, 10 ,. y T .,,-.H lt:,
\)1--- - ~
Focusing upon a topic Tab le I. l'O ll MAr l) FTI IE \ ll'lllCll . lll'.:Tl 11t'/
-u,d\-/ -~ lh~@oo1
~
Analyze the information given by the pacicm in ordcr to deter- HISTOll'f DATA BASE OUTLIN E
mine the problem. If there arc sever:il pro blems d iciced , focus 0 11
✓\I
Key Content Areas - Check if discussed
it one at a time. Problems may be both medical and psychosocial. ,. ,I
A. GENERAL DATA
- --~- - -- - - - - - - - -- '/JVA,
- i
4. Obtaining specific information B. CHIEF COMPLAINT _ __ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _
I
Elicit relevant data from the past medical , social, work and family
C. HISTORY. OFTHE PRESENT ILLNESS
II
hiscories of the patient. Us ing the same techniques as the first three ====-o 1. Characteristic of 0 8. Patient's expectations
phases, yes-no questions and direct questions may be used. Symptoms 0 9. Patient's reason for visit
0 Location 010. Preferences for end-of-life
5. Closing the interview 0 Radiation _;_. care (if appropriate)
0 Quality D. PAST MEDICAL HISTORY
Summarize what transpired during the interview by highlighting 0 Severity/Intensity
0 1. Childhood illness
the key points. Present some suggestions and alternatives, along 0 Timing (onset, duration)
0 2. Immunizations
0 Sudden, gradual
with their probable outcomes, cost and adverse effects. Give a 0 3. Adult illness/ hospitali-
0 Acute, chronic zations
follow-up schedule in order to monitor the patient's progress as 0 Frequency/Pattern 0 4. Operations
well as compliance with the management of illness. (intermittent, continuous, 0 5. Injuries/Accidents
0 Aggravating/Exace rbat g
0 6. Obstetric History
0 7. Transfusions \
factors E. CURRENT HEALTH STATUS
The primary history centers on the history of-present illness. Based 0 Alleviating factors O 1. Medications -
0 Associated manifestations 0 2. Allergies and Drug
on the chief complaint, you have to elicit the location, radiation, Reactions
0 2. Associated active medical,
quality, quantity, duration , frequency, aggravating and relieving surgical or psychiatric 0 3. Health Screening (prior
factors, associated symptoms, and effect on· function. problems which may exc!ms, cholesterol, etc.)
impact the Chief 0 4. Diet, Sleep, Exercise
The secondary history centers on the review of systems. It will Complaint O 5. Tobacco, Alcohol, Drugs
0 3. Past experience with F. PSYCHOSOCIAL HISTORY
help expand the history of presem illness. Unlike the primary his- symptom(s) 0 1. Marital status
tory, a cenain amount of interpretation is needed. 0 Prior Treatment? 0 2. Living arrangements/
Response? Data from past Family structure
The tertiary history centers on the past medical history which charts? 0 How are things at
may have a bearing on the patient's illness. O What has patient done home?.
about the symptom(s) O 3. Support/Secondary Gains:
0 4. Significant positives and
are there people you can
FORMAT OF THE MEDICAL HISTORY negatives.
rely on for help? How have
History ralr,.ing is usuilly tl1e first 2 ....r1d most impo!'ta..'1t part of ch,e 0 5. What was the
family or friends
psychosocial context of
health care process. The physician must know what information to get responded to the illness?
the onset of the
0 4. Employment history/job
and liow to gee it while building a relationship as he proceeds. The symptoms?
satisfaction
· 0 6. What is the patient's
format of the history is outlined in Table l. 0 5. Sexual history/function
understanding of the
0 6. Significant life events;
disease? Especially
deaths; divorce, financial
causes/implication/fears
hardships
0 7. impiJct of the disease c! nd/
or its treatment on the G. FAMILY HISTORY
patient's life, work 0 1. Current health of parents,
relation ships siblings, children
38 39
The l'thpino l-'h .
ys1c1an .1 ooay
H 1s rory T uon g
g 2. History of significant illness
3. Death: dates and..ages at death
/
PSYCHOSOCIAL HISTORY
H. REVIEW OF SYSTEMS I T his incl udes info rm:1rio 11 on the.: c.: duc:n io11 . lifr c.:xoeri c.: ncc•;, 1nLI pe r-
son al relationships of chc pa tic.:11 t. •
I. FUNCTIONAL STATUS
Does your health interfere with:
0 1. Taking care of yourself ( . . SEXUAL, REPRODUCTIVE AND GYNECOLOGIC HISTORY
0 2. Your daily activiti ( e.g. to, 1etmg: bathing, dressing)? Th is embraces inform ation on che pati ent's sex ual activity anJ symp-
es working, shopping, housecleaning, cooking)?
toms related to it such as dyspareunia, discharges. Inquiries about sex ual
Sour-cc: Dcputmcnc oflmcm~l Med icine, UST n cuJry f Mccf .
o • io nc i nd Surgery, reprinted wich pam W:ion. relations should be conducted in a nonjudgm en tal manner. D irect
questions regarding oral and anal sex, sexual contacts, and sexual prob-
CHIEF COMPLAINT
lems are important.
The chief complaint is the reason why th . h . For the reproductive and gynecologic history, one must inqu ire
. . e paaent soug_ t medical at-
tenaon . It establishes the agenda for the incervie 5 · about a woman's age of menarche, regularity of mensuual flow, and
h I w. ome paaents may
av~ a or_ of complaints so that the physician needs to focus on a duration of periods. The date of the last menstrual period and then
parncular Jtem by asking, "Which is your most pressing problem?" past menstrual period should be determ ined . In addition , one must
ask about the number of pregnancies, deliveries, abortions, and compli::-
HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS cations of pregnancies. In the reproductive history of a man·, it is impor~-
An elaboration of the information relevant to the chief complaint, the cant to ask about sexual interest, function , satisfaction, and problems.
history of present illness should answer the questions what, when, how,
where, which, who and why. The use of open-ended questions will help. REVIEW OF SYSTEMS
Ir is important to establish the chronology of the events. This includes the list of possible symptoms that m ay have been over-
looked in the History of Present Illness or additional symptoms which
PAST MEDICAL HISTORY may be unrelated to the patient's illness. A best organized review of
This consists of the overall assessment of the patient's health prior to systems contains questions that start from the head and proceed down
the illness. Ir includes past illnesses, hospitalizations, surgery, allergies, to the extremities. The specific symproms to ask about each organ are
immunizations, lifestyle (diet; exercise, smoking, alcohol use and sub- listed in Table 2 below.
stance abuse) , sleep patterns, and current medications. Head Ask about nausea, vomiting, stress in work, headache, seizures, loss of
consciousness, trauma . Understand the time course of the symptoms.
l
t..·
OCCUPATIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL HISTORY Eyes Ask about visual changes, loss of vision, blurring or double-vision, presence
Occupational hisrory is mainly concerned with exposure to certain of spot!; or flashing lights.
diseases in me place of work and environment. Ir is imporrant ro in- Ears Ask about hearing loss, ringing in the ears, dizziness, vertigo, ear discharge.
quire on the nature arid duration of the job as well as the use of protec- · Nose Ask about nasal catarrh, bleeding, itchiness and i.f this has a seasonal pattern.
tive devices. For the environmental history, one must inquire on the Throat Ask about sore throat, cough, difficulty in swallowing.
location of the residence as well as possible hazards in the environ- Chest, Heart and Lungs Ask about palpitations, skipped beats. chest
[Link] of breathing, difficulty sleeping flat on bed and whether this has
ment. a relationship to activity.
Abdomen Ask ab~ut nausea, vomiting, loss of appetite, urinary symptoms. change
FAMILY HISlORY
in bowel habits and color of the stools, pain.
Paying attention to possible genetic influences on the disease, the phy-
Extremities Ask about joint pains and signs of inflammation such as redness,
sician should inquire about the diseases acquired by the patient's rela- swelling, heat or loss of function .
tives.
Table 2. REVIEW OF SYSTEMS
41
40
E~d~dy patienrs pose special problems and issues. They often face
chr~n1c illnesses and diminishing control over their lives. For geriJtric
p~t1ents., certain symptoms listed in Table 3 should be emphasized.
Revie~ of System Elic_i~ if there ~s weight change, nutritional problems, hearing lI
o~v,sual changes, dent1t1on, continence, falls, bowel dysfunction, musculoskeletal
stiffness, sleep problems and alterations in mood. I
Personal and Past _History Ask about medication use, adverse drug reactions,
past and current tobacco use, alcohol abuse, caffeine intake.
Functional Status Ask about activities of daily living. This includes dressing,
toileting, transferring, feeding, bathing, grooming, communication and mobility.
· Social/Financial Status This includes information on family structure, available
support systems, living arrangements, stressful life events and basic financial •
resources.
Environmental history/ home evaluation This includes physical layout of ~
the home and home safety checklists such as assessment of lighting, flooring,
furniture location, heating, air-conditioning and basic home protection devices....
Ease of access to the home is also assessed.
47
li1story 1aking
~
History Ta1ang
------ -·-
. .
--- -,
Re~fo~v of Systems:
45