The Rattrap: A Study of Human Temptation
The Rattrap: A Study of Human Temptation
The Rattrap
(Selma Lagerlöp)
Introduction
The
Flamingo :
had mistaken
this man for his old comrade. Upset by the
he
ironmaster threatened to hand him over to the
that
pretence, the
peddler insisted that he had never claimed to be
peddler's
Sheriff.
However,the
that he was thought to be. On the contrary, it
was the
comrade
the
who had refused to listen to him.
At this point Edla
i r o n m a s t e r
Flamingo : The 81
. crofter
:aperson in Scotlandwho rents or owns a small
farm adjoining ahouse
. bossy
:(here) cow
. creamery : factory producing dairy products
kronor : a unit of money in Sweden
incredulous unbelievable
nodding moving head to express agreement
stuffed : pushed quickly and carelessly
ebliuc
thickets bushes
" peddler a person who sells things moving door to door
impenetrable : that cannot be entered, passed through or sen
through
descending
.
coming down
SOrroW
" gloom
disappointment
. despair
summoned (here) gathered
staggered : walked unsteadily
smelting
. smeltermo; an industrial plant for
sheets
"rolling mill : afactory that produces metal
. forge : ablacksmith's workshop
barges and scows: flat bottomed boats
" sifted separated
Literature eComporiom
How did the ironmaster react on seeing
the furnace?
the stranger
In the uncertain glow of the furnace the 1yingdl
ironmaster(AICBSE21
oel
stranger for Captain Nils Olof, his old
Overwhelmed, he spoke kindly and invited regimental mistookh
house with the intention of him to COTmrade
bringing relief to his matK
companion. his
Q9. Why did the peddler decline ironmaster's
destte
The peddler declined the ironmaster's sinvitation?(Delhi
invitation
of revelation of his true identity as well as due to
20)
the three the feat 10
bills that he had stolen from the crofter.
correct the ironmaster when he first However, he krdiodng no,
mistook
regimental officer, because he thought that hehim for an oG
might e.
get a
couple of kronor in the bargain.
Q10. Having vehemently declined the
ironmaster's invitation. wh
did the peddler accept Edla's invitation? Or
What made the peddler accept Edla Willmansson's
invitation?
The peddler declined the ironmaster's
invitation for fear of
being caught for stealing the old crofter's money. However, he
accepted Edla's invitation as her warmth, friendliness ant
Compassion instilled his confidence in her. He was also touche
by the ring of sincerity in her voice.
Q11. What doubts did Edla have about the I 20159
peddler? (SamplePaper
Or
Though still quite young, Edla Willmansson had a good
of 0r
immediately concluded that he had either
money
stolen some n
hardly
had escaped from the jail. She also observed that he
tobe
looked educated like a Captain that his fatherrthoughthim
87
F l a m i n g o : T h e R a t t r a p
did the
ironmaster realize his mistake of confusing the
When
Q12. p e d d l e r ' s ,
identity with the captain?
i r o n m a s t e r
realised his mistake of confusing the peddler's
The
with hiis old comrade when the peddler was presented
identity
before
himinthe broad day light after having been given a bath,
a. haircut
and fine clothes. He understood that the man
shave,
a
was actually
a tramp.
that he
What did the
peddler say in his defence when it was clear
Q13.
the person the
ironmaster hadthought he was?
was not
Or
cards with
with him. Further, he repOses full faith in him
plays
and histhree ten-kronor bills.
shows s him his
and
How
did the world generally treat the tramp?
H
Q21.
great contempt. He was
The tramp was treated generally with
chased away
from wherever he went. The extent of denial was
such
that when someone granted him a favour, he failed to see
he expected to get afew kronors and shelter ffrom the biting3 cold
under the mistaken identity of Olof.
Flamingo·The,Rattrap
91
What
didthe: ironmaster plan to do for
028.
the
The ironmaster planned to feed his so-called Captain?
get
some flesh on his
body. He alsoemaciated friend well and
something more worthwhile decided
and respectable to help him do
livingthanjustmaking gand for earning
How didIthe ironmaster selingrattraps.
interpret
his
029. the peddler's refusal to accept
hisiinvitation tothe: manor house?
The ironmaster interpreted the
invitation to the manor house
peddler's refusal to accept
as his
miserable appearance. In spite of embarrassment about his
denials from the stranger made the
assurance, the repeated
ironmaster believe that his
comrade's current dilapidated state prevented him from
acepting the invitation.
030. Edla sat and hung her head even more
Which twO reasons forced her to behave in
dejectedly than usual.
that manner?
(Foreign 2010)
The first reason was that Edla had learnt at
church that one of the
old crofters of the ironworks had been
robbed. The second and
more important reason was that she had learnt the
robbery was
committed by a man who went around selling rattraps. This
dejected her as she had served acheat thinking him to be amere
unfortunate soul.
Q31. What brought about
ta change in thelife of the peddler?
Or (Outside 2015C)
What made the
epeddler finally change his ways? (Al CBSE 2010)
The humane treatment meted out to the peddler by Edla
brought aboutachange
a in his life. Her compassion touched him
deeply and revived hissconscience. He finally changed his ways
by leaving behind the stolen money with a note requesting it to
bereturned to the crofter.
Literature Companion 1
ONGANSWER QUESTIONS
(o be answered in about 150 words each)
93
His daughter Edla, on the other hand, has positive values and a
strong sense of observation. She brings the peddler home
despite judging her guest to be a tramp. Her sympathetic
attitude makes her persuade her father to let the guest stay
because they had promised him "Christmas cheer". Itis because of
her concern and
compassionthat the peddler redeems himself
from dishonesty and undergoes a thoroughnttransformation.
03. The
story has many instances of unexpected reactions from
the
characters to others' behaviour. Pick out instances of thes.
Surprises. (Textual)
94 Literature Companion 12
the tramp's request for
The old crofter's reaction to
shelter at
night is an unexpected one. Usedtto being greeted by sour
faces,
the peddler himself is surprised by this hospitality.
The
peddler's act of stealing the crofter's money is also
This breach of trust is more of a
shock because ethe surprising
philosophical
inclination of the peddler portrays him more as a victimf
fortune than of ill values. The ironmaster's sudden invitation to
the tramp comes as the next surprise. The peddler'ss vehement
refusal to accompany him earlier and Jater accepting the
invitation at Edla's request is also a surprise. The ironmaster's
hostile reaction on knowingthe true identity of the peddler and
Edla's intercession are also unexpected reactions. The most
unlikely gesture is when the peddler leaves a Christmas gift for
Edla along with aletter of thanks and the stolen money to be
returned to the old crofter.
Q4. For years together, why did the vagabond stick to a life or
dishonesty and a total disregard for his conscience? What brought
about a sudden and total transformation in his life? (Value Based)
Or
What made the peddler finally change his ways? (Textual)
Or
95
Sympathize him
love and guide him until he met Edla.
hospitality nor the That is why
n
the crofter's
herth
e i t h e r
ironmaster's friendliness
any.
impact t on him.
made
H o w e v e r ,
Edla's warmth,
total
understarnding and genuineness
brought a
sudden
and total transformation in his life, When
she
like atrue Captain, he
treated
Heredeemed
him
humanp r e d i c a m e n t ?
highlight the
s (Textual)
r
The metaphor offrattrap revealsr man's helplessness, restlessness
andpowerlessness in the face of difficult pursuit situations that
tinrs and luxuries land him in. All aims and
ambitions of
attaining great heights remain unfulfilled and one finds oneself
incapable of wriggling out of pettiness and trivialities. Many
times, one is not even aware of having been trapped
and thus
goes on receding deeper and deeper into the trap losing all
chances of deliverance.
Just as the bait of cheese and pork tempt
and trap a rat, the
peddler yields to his temptations at the crofter's
cottage and
then runs helter-skelter to escape
being caught. The only
difference is that for the peddler the world itself
is a big rattrap.
Ihough one cannot see the bars and wires,
this rattrap ensnares
individuals like him so
Thus the securely that they cannot escape at all.
metaphor of the rattrap poignantly highlights the
numan predicamentof survival
The amidst odds.
peddler
How does thiscomes out as a person with asubtle sense of humour.
the story? serve in!lightening the seriousness of thetheme of
Does
us? Why/VWhynot?this quality of his make him more acceptable to
(Textual)
96 Literature Companion 1)
than comical humour
Ifind more of irony and satire in the
peddler. However, the foolish way in which he acts
humorous. That beinga rattrap peddler he eshould consider is
whole world a trap is entertaining. Equally funny is the
dramatic way in which he getsinvited to the ironmaster's house
his s
and the way his reality is exposed. Later, ability to regain his
equilibrium makes him comical | but I wonder if he is humorous
likeacircus clown.
His temptation followed by repentance is the main focus of the
story. His philosophy, his guilt-conscience and his evenh..
reformation make him more human than Comical which iis what
makes us empathize with him. We willingly accept him as a
victim of the ways of the world. Still, with his pessimism and
irresponsible actions he does manage to lighten the serious
of the story.
Q7. The story "The Rattrap" focuses on human loneliness and the nee
to bond with others. Comment. (Textual; Value Based; Delhi 2010)
The theme of loneliness runs throughout the story. All the
characters suffer from loneliness and desperately seek salvage
from it.
The peddler has only met sour faces, cold words and unkind
treatment. He has trudged along the path of life with no one to
share with either his depressing or his amusing thoughts. Lite
has been kinder to the crofter but in the absence of a wife and
children, the old man yearns for company. Similarly, e
ironmaster and his daughter too miss company which ggnaws
their hearts, especially on the occasion ofChristmas when the
wish to practice their Christian values.
All these characters display a strong desire for bonding
his
Bonding with the peddler givesjoy tothe crofter whoserves
Rattray
97
The
g u e
t with
sw
t i t h
generosity.
ironmaster and his daughter
bond
with and play hosts to too are
to thepeddler. Bonding
ns thetramp too andaawakens the goodness
excited
of his
the
focus on human
loneliness and the need to heart.
othersunderscoressth
Thus
the story. bond with
O8 Thestoryis both entertaining ; and philosophical. Discuss.
(Textual; Foreign 2011)
Rattrap" is indeed both entertaining and philosophical.
The
paced third person narrative with
with
Is fast
of dialogues make it entertaining. In addition, thesprinkling
generous
graphic
description of theecharacters and scenes together with elements
ofdrama anddirony make it interesting.
The crofter's invitation to the rattrap peddler is surprising for
kim but the reader is as much surprised as the crofter when
the
neddler steals his thirty kronor. The unexpected incidents in the
forge also enhance the reader's interest. The dramatic turn of
events resulting in the reformation of the peddler make the
narrative gripping and thus entertaining. One feels as light
hearted as Edla on reading the letter left behind by the tramp.
The narrative is underscored by the philosophy that this world
is full of traps and
everybody, sOoner or later, falls into one.
DOme people fall into the abyss and get stuck forever while
SOme, like the
peddler, fight temptation and discover their
inherent goodness. Thus, besides entertaining the story also
teaches us the philosophy of
98. What life.
made the peddler think that he had indeed fallen into a
ratrap? Or (Textual)
How did the
Teaction reveal?peddler feel after r robbing the crofter? What does his
(Delhi 2013)
Atfirst the
rattrap peddler was quite pleased with hissmartness
98 Literature Companion 1)
How did the peddler betray the confidence reposed in him by the
crofter in "The Rattrap"? (AICBSE 2008C)
fallen into
into the rattrap of
realized
to
he
had greed with no escape in
that
sight.
peddler
declined the invitation of the ironmaster but accepted
The
Q11. from EEdla. Why? Or
(Delhi 2015)
e one
the
Edla proved to be much more persuasive than her father while
dealing
peddler. Comment.
tthe
with1 (Delhi2015)
The peddler declined the invitation of the ironmaster for fear of
revelation of Ihis true identity. He knew that the ironmaster was
extendingall the warmth because he had mistaken him to be his
ld friend, Nils Olof. Further proximity with the ironmaster
ould have certainly unveiled the error. As a consequence, the
peddler could have been denied the comfort of spending the
night closeto the furnace at the ironmaster's mill.
However, the peddler accepted the same invitation from Edla
because her convincing persuasive skills belied his
apprehensions. Unlike her father, she assured the peddler that
he wouldbe allowwed to leave just as freely as he had come. She
won his trust by showing compassion and regards towards him
which was different from the compelling action of her father.
She extended the invitation in such a friendly manner that the
peddler mustthave felt confidence in her.
q2. Why did the
invite the peddler home? Why did the
latter decline it?ironmaster (Foreign 2015)
The ironmaster
inyited the peddler home because,
in the
uncertain glow of the he mistook him to
be his old
furnace, Nils Olof. His pitiable condition
regimental comrade, Captain
100
Literature Companion 12
aroused sympathy in him. He thought of helping him to
his lost status. Thus he invited him in order to
bring relief to his
companionin distress. But the latter declined Such a
warm and
honourable invitation because he did not want his
true identity
to be revealed under any circumstances. InIn such
such a case he would
have hadto face harsh punishmenttffor being an imposter: as well
as for having stolen the crofter's money. The peddler's only
intention of coming to the iron mill was to seek shelter from
the
cold night. He had to keep himself in oblivion, for he knew
that
his crime would not go unpunished. To achieve this end, he
refused the ironmaster's invitation lest the proximity lead s
revelation of the truth.
r s p e e c h
y o O u
s h o u l d
,say
what
everyone
iss prone to these vices
Showhow
i n c u l C a t e e
good values to overcomethese vices
to
ways
sUggest
GrodMorningEveryone.
and today I would like to express my
Mname
is,
with1
rreference to thestory"The
human
n vices Rattrap".
iews
on
fthe protagonist in nthe story"The Rattrap" is hís
of
vice
The
chief
temptation,
which he finds hard to resist because of
tot
gto
sells rattraps for,
for aliving but instead of working
yrelding
greed.
He
shis Loter his lot, he resorts to stealing, lying and cheatine. In
hardtob
he deceivesthe people who trust him.
process,
the
who is smitten with greed and
character
Buti is he a stray
temptation? No. I am afraid, everyone in this world gets to
experience these
vices but people of strong characters resist
hem with their strong willand deep-rooted faith in good values.
And it is these qualities that distinguish people of character
from weaklingsand the extraordinary from the ordinary.
The question now arises is how to inculcate these values in our
characters? Well, Iwould say here that strong family values,
together with sound education and good friends can help us
lkam to resist and beat all temptation and greed. When even
these fail,remember God is always there to helpus.
Thank you!
05. What message do you draw from thesstory ofthe rattrap peddler?
The story of the rattrap peddler delivers the message that an
inherent goodness is present in each one of us. The latent spark
of human values can be inflamed back into life through love,
c r e a t e d
hy the style of the narrative followed in
effect
is
Nhat
TheKattrap"?
it
cof fiction,
-it
it believable. The emphasis on revival of
work
tisa make
m e s s a g e
noble
goodness throughitrust and love may seem afar fetched
human
n o r m a l
the narrative here successfully
routine but
in
jdea
theereaders
ofsuch a possibility. The usage of words like
'stagger' highlightthe wearinesssand monotony
assures
'trudge'
plod,
hunger and
starvation causein life. Also words like
that want,
gray' sour', 'dreary' bring out the gloom of life and 'confusing
paths' and
underscore
'impenetrable prison'
forest, twisted
helplessness of life. The writer does not employ anything
the of
unnecessary to dramatize the events. The use
unwanted or
with the setting to give the
language too synchronizes perfectly
reader acredible experience.
is like a punishment? Comment
Ql8. Do you think a sense of guilt (Value Based)
with reference to the story "The Rattrap".
protagonist in the story "The Rattrap'
15
V3. Ihe chief vice of the
Would the peddler have committd
temptation. Do you agree?
impersonation, if he was
not led to
Or stealing and
emptation? Give reasons in support of your ans Wel (ValueBased)