0% found this document useful (0 votes)
223 views7 pages

Instrument Cabling Productivity in Morocco

Uploaded by

bishnuphukanwork
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
223 views7 pages

Instrument Cabling Productivity in Morocco

Uploaded by

bishnuphukanwork
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Productivity Rate Analysis for

Instrument Cabling Installation in


Morocco

Executive Summary

No specific productivity data for instrument cabling in Morocco exists in the public domain.
This report establishes a defensible rate of 1,600 man-hours per kilometer (mh/km) by
synthesizing regional benchmarks for core installation tasks and applying a productivity
adjustment.

Recommended Productivity Rate

● Recommended Rate: 1,600 mh/km


● Supporting Range: 1,270 mh/km (min) – 1,900 mh/km (max)
● Basis: Composite average of sub-tasks, adjusted for regional productivity.

Key Evidence

● Cable Pulling (International): An international estimating guide provides rates for


laying single or small bundles of cables in trenches, with an average installation speed of
approximately 4.9 meters per hour.1
● Cable Pulling (Industrial): A benchmark for industrial facilities gives rates of "250
manhours-1000 meters" for small cables and "250 manhours-500 meters" for larger
multi-pair cables, indicating significant variability.2
● Cable Tray Installation: A construction estimating source provides detailed man-hours
for installing ladder-type cable trays, with a rate of 1.19 man-hours per linear meter for
a common 300 mm tray.3
● Regional Productivity Context: An International Labour Organization (ILO) report
notes a decline in labor productivity growth in the Arab States region, justifying an
adjustment to international norms for local application.4

Conversion and Calculations

Methodology

In the absence of a single, verified productivity rate for instrument cabling in Morocco, this
analysis employs a Bottom-Up Composite Rate Synthesis. This method constructs a
comprehensive rate by quantifying the man-hours for the two primary physical installation
tasks defined in the scope: (1) Cable Tray Installation and (2) Cable Pulling. A Regional
Productivity Adjustment Factor (RPAF) is then applied to ground the resulting technical
estimate in the operational context of the MENA region.

Termination labor is explicitly excluded from this per-kilometer rate. The labor for termination
is a function of the number of connection points (cores, terminals), not the distance of the
cable run. Therefore, expressing it in mh/km is dimensionally inconsistent and would produce
a highly inaccurate and indefensible figure. It is recommended that termination man-hours be
estimated separately based on project-specific instrument and junction box counts. Industry
norms suggest a range of 5 to 10 minutes per connector for this purpose.6

Component 1: Cable Tray Installation Rate

The installation of cable trays is a significant labor component. Based on data from
[Link], an average rate was derived using norms for ladder trays with
widths of 150 mm, 200 mm, 300 mm, and 450 mm, as these are most representative for
instrument cabling applications.3
● Data Points (mh/m): 0.90 (150 mm), 1.08 (200 mm), 1.19 (300 mm), 1.26 (450 mm)
● Calculation:

4(0.90+1.08+1.19+1.26) mh/m=1.1075 mh/m


● Normalized Rate:

1.1075 mh/m×1000 m/km=1,107.5 mh/km

Component 2: Cable Pulling Rate

A blended rate for cable pulling was calculated by averaging normalized data from two
distinct, credible sources to mitigate the bias of a single benchmark.
● Source A ([Link]): Rates given in meters per hour (m/hr) were converted to man-
hours per meter (mh/m) by taking the inverse. An average was taken for pulls of 1, 2, and
5 cables.1
○ Example Conversion (1 cable): 6.2 m/hr→(1/6.2) hr/m=0.161 mh/m
○ Average Rate (Source A): 0.191 mh/m
● Source B ([Link]): Rates given in man-hours per length were directly
converted.2
○ Data 1: 250 mh / 1000 m = 0.250 mh/m
○ Data 2: 250 mh / 500 m = 0.500 mh/m
○ Average Rate (Source B): 0.375 mh/m
● Blended Average Pulling Rate:

2(0.191+0.375) mh/m=0.283 mh/m


● Normalized Rate:

0.283 mh/m×1000 m/km=283 mh/km

Final Composite Rate Synthesis

The final rate is the sum of the normalized components for tray installation and cable pulling,
with the regional adjustment applied.
Description Value (mh/km)

Component 1: Cable Tray Installation 1,107.5

Component 2: Cable Pulling 283.0

Baseline Composite Rate 1,390.5

Regional Productivity Adjustment Factor +15.0%


(RPAF)

Final Recommended Rate (Rounded) 1,600

The supporting range was calculated by applying the same methodology to the minimum
(fastest) and maximum (slowest) productivity values found in the source data, resulting in a
low-end estimate of 1,270 mh/km and a high-end estimate of 1,900 mh/km.

Credibility Assessment and Regional Justification

The data sources used—Methvin, [Link], and [Link]—are


established online estimating guides and industry knowledge bases, providing credible
benchmarks for construction activities.1 The use of an International Labour Organization
report provides an authoritative macroeconomic basis for the regional productivity
adjustment.4

An extensive search yielded no public, credible productivity data specific to Morocco.


Therefore, the use of MENA/GCC regional data as a proxy is necessary and defensible. This
approach is justified by the following logic:
1. Instrument cabling is predominantly installed in large-scale industrial, energy, and
infrastructure projects.
2. Major projects in Morocco within these sectors frequently involve international
Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) contractors who operate across the
entire MENA region.
3. These firms apply standardized construction methodologies, safety protocols, and
quality standards (e.g., IEC) across their regional projects.
4. Consequently, the fundamental work process for installing cable trays and pulling
instrument cables in a Moroccan industrial facility is highly analogous to that in a
comparable facility in the GCC. The use of man-hours as the unit of measure focuses on
labor effort, making the comparison more direct than a cost-based analysis. The
application of the RPAF further refines this proxy to account for documented regional
differences in labor productivity.

Comparison to Industry Benchmark (0.35 h/meter)

The recommended rate is compared to the industry benchmark to provide context and
validate the analysis.
● Industry Benchmark: 0.35 h/m = 350 mh/km
● Recommended Rate: 1,600 mh/km
● Result: The recommended rate is 1,250 mh/km, or approximately 357%, higher than the
benchmark.

This significant variance does not indicate an error but rather reflects a more comprehensive
and accurate interpretation of the user-defined scope. Standard industry benchmarks like
0.35 h/m typically account only for the core activity of pulling cable, often assuming pre-
installed and easily accessible raceways.

The methodology used in this report, however, strictly adheres to the user's scope, which
explicitly includes the installation of trays. The analysis shows that cable tray installation
constitutes most of the labour effort (1,107.5 mh/km, or ~69% of the final rate). The
recommended rate is substantially higher because it correctly incorporates the significant
man-hours required for this prerequisite activity, providing a more realistic and complete
estimate for the entire scope of work.

Sources

● 3
[Link].
"Cable Tray Installation Man Hours." Accessed at:
[Link]
● 1
Methvin.
"Mechanical & Electrical - Cable Laying." Accessed at: [Link]
production-rates/mechanical-electrical/cable-laying
● 2
[Link].
"PROJECT PLANNING AND MANHOUR, COST CALCULATION IN INDUSTRIAL FACILITIES."
Accessed at: [Link]
calculation-in-industrial-facilities
● 4
International Labour Organization.
"Alarming decline in labour productivity growth in Arab States – but policy reforms can
fuel recovery." Accessed at: [Link]
productivity-growth-arab-states-%E2%80%93-policy-reforms
● 5
International Labour Organization.
"Productivity growth, diversification and structural change in the Arab States." Accessed
at: [Link]
@act_emp/documents/publication/wcms_840588.pdf
● 6
Belden.
"Achieving Labor Savings During Cable Termination." Accessed at:
[Link]
● 3
[Link].
"Cable Tray Installation Man Hours." Accessed at:
[Link]

Works cited

1. Mechanical & Electrical - Methvin, accessed August 19, 2025,


[Link]
laying
2. PROJECT PLANNING AND MANHOUR, COST CALCULATION IN ..., accessed
August 19, 2025, [Link]
manhour_-cost-calculation-in-industrial-facilities
3. Cable Tray Installation Man Hours - [Link], accessed August
19, 2025, [Link]
hours/
4. Alarming decline in labour productivity growth in Arab States – but policy
reforms can fuel recovery, accessed August 19, 2025,
[Link]
growth-arab-states-%E2%80%93-policy-reforms
5. Productivity growth, diversification and structural change in the Arab States -
International Labour Organization, accessed August 19, 2025,
[Link]
@act_emp/documents/publication/wcms_840588.pdf
6. Achieving Labor Savings During Cable Termination - Belden, accessed August 19,
2025, [Link]
termination

You might also like