Macbeth's Descent: Power and Paranoia
Macbeth's Descent: Power and Paranoia
Since Macbeth’s prophecy came true (verities), Banquo hopes that his
would as well and his lineage will continue as kings. He starts believing
the prophecy and drops his wariness a bit. But he does not act upon it and
lets it be.
Macbeth and Lady Macbeth enter. (And Lennox, Ross, Lords, Attendants
etc).
Lady Macbeth’s kind and respectful words for Banquo – if he had been
forgotten…gap in feast…unbecoming (improper) – are false and she does
not feel this love and respect for him. Instead, she is feeling hatred,
wariness etc. Theme of Appearances vs Reality.
Banquo says – Let your highness Command upon me; to the which my
duties Are with a most indissoluble tie for ever knit. This dialogue sounds
forced, as if he was forced to do so. The shift in power dynamics is
significant. From companions, he became bound to Macbeth by the bond
of duty.
Macbeth informs Banquo that he would have liked to hear his advice that
day, suggesting that he sees Banquo as level-headed and trustworthy.
This however, is ironic as Macbeth refused to heed Banquo’s earlier advice
regarding the Witches – “and oftentimes, to win us to our harm, the
instruments of darkness tell us truths.”
While asking questions, it is crucial to note that Macbeth does not jump
into questions directly, but rather provides apt reasonings or fill-ins before
asking, in order to reduce suspicion.
After he is done with extricating information, he also tells him that
Malcolm and Donaldbain are in England and Ireland, possibly running
away after parricide and spreading fabricated lies/rumours to other
people. He ends by saying they will discuss it later together. Then, after
this fill-in, he asks if Fleance is going with Banquo, possibly to plan both of
their murders.
To be thus is nothing,
Mark Antony Allusion - Mark Antony was rival to Julius Caesar's heir,
Octavius. He was told by a prophet that his genius/guiding spirit was not
powerful enough to oppose Octavius Caesar. In the same way, Macbeth’s
genius is not powerful enough to oppose Banquo.
He is brave enough to scold/chid the witches and find out about his own
prophecy which was that his descendants will become king.
Upon Macbeth’s head, they put a fruitless crown – childless crown. Barren
sceptre also indicates that it cannot be passed on to his lineage. This
sceptre will be snatched from Macbeth’s hands and given to those who
are not in his line of descent.
His words suggest that he feels the act of Murder was pointless, as having
the crown is worthless if he cannot have his own children inherit.
He states that he has sold his soul (eternal jewel) to the devil (common
enemy of a man) just to make the seeds of Banquo – his descendants –
kings.
He is angry that he has given his “eternal jewel” by turning his back on
God and committing regicide, only for Banquo’s benefit.
Macbeth ends the soliloquy by saying that he will not let Banquo win. He
will challenge fate into keeping the crown to himself.
Enter Murderers.
He says that the murderers were deceived, misled, and tricked by Banquo
and the only reason why they’re suffering is due to him.
He says, currently, those murderers are at the lowest rank. But, if they are
ready to join Macbeth, and if they’re not cowards, they will rise up and
bring them closer to Macbeth.
Macbeth says that he will feel sick as long as Banquo is alive, but he will
be perfectly fine once he’s dead.
The murderers agree. One says that he is angry of beatings that the world
has given him. Other says that he is tired of bad luck and being at the
mercy of fate. They will risk everything to fix their lives.
Macbeth reiterates that Banquo is the real enemy. He says that every
minute Banquo’s alive, he feels threatened. As king, he could use his
powers to destroy him but they cannot since they have mutual friends
who he needs for his own benefits.
He says he must pretend to grieve and cry over Banquo’s death even if he
was the one who had him killed. He says he has to hide his real plans from
the public eye, EVEN FROM LADY MACBETH.
Directions of Murder: He says that he will tell them where, when (that
night but exact time), who to murder. He said there must be clearness. No
one should suspect Macbeth. The murder must be away from the palace.
No evidence should be left. Fleance must also die.
The scene ends with a rhyming couplet. Banquo thy soul’s flight/If it find
heaven, must it find out tonight. This is similar to the couplet at the end of
the scene of Macbeth’s dagger hallucination where he says “Hear it not
Duncan, for it is a bell/That summons thee to Heaven, or to Hell.” Here,
Macbeth just makes up his mind to kill Banquo.
HEAVEN OR HELL
END OF SCENE
This scene mirrors Act 1, Scene 5. However, in the previous murder, Lady
Macbeth was in charge, now Macbeth is. CHANGE IN GENDER ROLES.
Lady Macbeth says nothing has been gained. We have lost everything
without happiness. This contrasts to Act 2 where the only way they could
have happiness was through murder.
She says that it is better to be the one who is killed rather than the one
who is living in doubt and anxiety. She seems to be disillusioned and
anxious. This highlights the trapping of power and fame.
Macbeth enters.
Macbeth uses snake and animal imagery, talking about the ironical theme
of expectation vs reality (NOT APPEARANCE VS REALITY). He says that
they have merely hurt the snake but not killed it. Here, the snake is a
metaphor for Banquo.
The snake will heal and they will be, once again, threatened by its fangs.
He says that Banquo is dangerous to them.
He says the universe will fall apart, and the heaven and earth will collapse
before he eats his means in fear or spends his nights by the nightmares
he has been having.
He says Duncan has suffered through the worst betrayal ever. He has
nothing to worry about, so he sleeps well (albeit, forever). No steel
(weapons) or poison, rebellion, invasion – NOTHING can touch him further.
Lady Macbeth senses Macbeth’s fear and desperation and pleads him to
wash away or fearful looks and be bright and happy in front of guests.
Macbeth says that he will. He tells Lady Macbeth to pay close attention to
Banquo, speak to him in a way that makes him feel important.
APPEARANCES VS REALITY. He says they are unsafe as long as we have to
flatter Banquo. He tells her to wash away their reputation in these
flattering streams (false insincere compliments) – façade. Disguise true
feelings of guilt, ambition, anxiety, and fear.
Macbeth, discreetly, hints at his plan, without letting Lady Macbeth know
much. He says that Banquo is vulnerable. He uses imagery by saying that
before the bat flies secretively in the darkness and before Hecate
summons beetles that announce the arrival of night, a dreadful deed will
be done.
Macbeth tells her to be innocent and not know what is going on. After the
deed, they can celebrate.
Macbeth calls upon the night to cover the gentle/tender/pitiful eye of day
(LIGHT AND DARK IMAGERY) and with its bloody, invisible hand, put an
end to Banquo and Fleance’s lives.
The word – bond – hints at the cancellation of Macbeth and his humanity’s
bond. Note – a simple legal contract (bond) is being used to describe such
an important connection. His direct connection with the natural world
keeps him fearful.
Things achieved by bad deeds will only grow stronger with more bad
deeds. (Once you tell a lie, you must tell 100 more to protect it).
END OF SCENE
A third murderer is added to the group – maybe Macbeth does not trust
the murderer’s abilities.
Note how there are three murderers – allusion to three witches? Three is
an evil number
First murderer strikes out the light. This causes Fleance’s escape.
END OF SCENE
Macbeth gets to know that Banquo is dead. He is joyous. But he finds out
that Fleance is not dead.
Hearing this, Macbeth is clearly upset. He says that he had been perfect
and safe but now there is fear lurking around. Whole as the
marble/founded as the rock (simile) describes a sense of security in
Macbeth’s position and how it would have been had both Banquo and
Fleance been killed.
In contrast, he is now confined by the knowledge of Fleance’s freedom.
Harsh alliteration complements the sense of the horrific state of fear in
which Macbeth now finds himself.
The first murderer says that the gashes in Banquo’s head were as deep as
trenches, with each sufficient to kill him.
Macbeth blames Banquo for breaking his promise and not coming to the
Banquet (IRONY).
Macbeth is suspicious and familiar with deceit. He believes that one of the
Lords is playing a trick on him – he sees Banquo’s ghost (ONLY ONE TO
SEE).
Lady Macbeth tries to play it safe and take control, cleverly blaming
Macbeth’s outburst on a mental illness from childhood in order to reassure
the Lords. She says to ignore him so that he doesn’t get worse. When she
addresses Macbeth, she uses the same method that she used in precious
scenes: questions his manhood.
Macbeth earlier used to give in but now he is not cowering down. He says
that he is a bold man. He says that what he is seeing (Ghost) is so
terrifying that even the Devil will be scared.
Lady Macbeth ignores him. She says that this is the same hallucination
that you saw – picture of his fear (Dagger, ghost). Lady Macbeth questions
his bravery, claiming that his fears are as pathetic as those found in a
woman’s story that a grandmother would find suitable. This mockery used
to work earlier but now it doesn’t. Their relationship is drifting apart.
Macbeth says – to the ghost – that if graves and buildings send the bodies
back, then monuments for the dead will be nothing more than the
stomachs of those birds that feed of the dead. He is haunted by the dead
not staying dead.
The ghost, so hideous that it would "appal the devil," appears to have
risen from a grave or a "charnel-house." Macbeth cannot understand why
what is dead should "be alive again," when its bones should "be
marrowless" and its blood "cold."
He says that in ancient times, before thee was law and order, a lot of
blood was shed. Murders had been committed. He is saying that the dead
are rising again, with twenty mortal murders (parallel to twenty trenched
gashes) on their heads. This returning of the dead is stranger than the
original murder.
Notice how whenever Banquo’s topic is brought up, the ghost is there.
When Macbeth sees the ghost again, he panics and tells the ghost to go
away. He says that its bones are “marrowless” and its blood is “cold”. It
cannot see with those eyes which it is glaring with. He is scared.
Macbeth starts by saying that he dares as much as any other man (similar
to Act 1 Scene 7). Macbeth claims that no enemy would make him afraid:
bear, rhino, tiger, or a living man. But this unreal man cannot be fought.
If anyone approaches him in the form of a rugged Russian bear, an armed
rhino, or a Hyrcan (near Caspian Sea) tiger (they were large and fierce),
he would be able to take them on.
But he says that this shapeless form of a ghost is something that he fears.
He says that if the ghost comes alive with a proper form, he will be ready
to duel it in a deserted place. If he trembles at that time, he tells it to
mock him like a little girl’s doll.
After the ghost leaves, he is back to normal. But Lady Macbeth is upset
and mad. She says that he has displaced the mirth/joy and destroyed
everyone’s cheerful mood with his behaviour.
Macbeth, trying to justify himself, asks the guests whether such things
exist (ghosts) and overcome a person suddenly like a summer storm
(strangeness and brevity of the ghostly vision) without special wonder
(without making everyone astonished).
He says that the guests make him feel as if he doesn’t know his own
character and courage. He questions his own character when he believes
that these guests and lady Macbeth can see the ghost. He asks how can
they see such gruesome sights and still manage to keep the ruby of their
cheeks/not turn pale while he is white with fear.
When Ross tries to question, Lady Macbeth shuts him up, takes control,
and tells all to leave. She says that he is getting worse. She tells them to
just leave without worrying about their ranks and the order with which
they leave (weirdly enough, they started the scene by telling the guests to
sit according to their social status).
When they’re alone (Macbeth and Lady Macbeth), Macbeth states that
“blood will have blood”. This is an allusion to “We but teach bloody
instructions…return to plague the inventor – Act 1 Scene 7). It is as if the
ghost has come to seek Macbeth’s blood. (NOTE PARANOIA). Macbeth is
worried that his secret will be disclosed by nature.
He says that he has come so far and sank into the river of blood that even
if he stopped now, it would be very hard and troublesome to go back as
compared to continue forward. He says he has some plans that he wishes
to act upon and not reflect.
In the end, they go to sleep. He says that his delusions and fears come
from inexperience. He says he is not that experienced in evilness and both
of them are just beginners when It comes to bad and evil deeds.
END OF SCENE
She says that she has reason to be angry. She asks them how dare they
trick Macbeth with riddles and prophecies without including her, the
source of their powers/creator of evil things/greatest practitioner of magic.
She says that what is worse is that they’ve done all this for an unreliable,
wayward, angry, spiteful, and wrathful person. He only cares for himself
and his wants, not for others. She tells them to make amends.
She tells them to meet her at the pit of Acheron (Underworld River), where
Macbeth will go to learn his destiny. Bring your
caludrons/spells/charms/etc.
She says that she will spend the night working to make a terrible/deadly
outcome for him and she must accomplish all of this before noon. It was
believed that witches could invoke the moon to shed a malign influence
on herbs and other objects.
She says that he may think that he can control fate, can mock death and
he may think he doesn’t need wisdom, grace, or fear and he is above
them but he is not. Security is mortals’ chiefest enemy means that
overconfidence will cause his downfall (overconfidence is mortal’s worst
enemy)
END OF SCENE
The scene marks the turning point and we notice a shift from Macbeth’s
inner world to external threat.
What Lennox has said before shows the similarity and the parallelism of
his and the Lord’s thoughts. He says that they can draw further (their
own) conclusions. All he is saying that strange things have been
happening.
Macbeth pitied (said nice words about Duncan) Duncan (gracious – KEY
WORD) only after Duncan was dead.
He said that the valiant/brave Banquo walked outside too late. Fleance
killed Banquo since he fled from the scene. Just like how Malcolm and
Donaldbain fled after murdering Duncan, Fleance did as well. (STRANGE
DEATHS/DÉJÀ VU)
Who will disagree that it was monstrous of Malcolm and Donaldbain to kill
their gracious father (Duncan). They committed such a damned
act/gruesome/cruel act.
He said that it was done nobly and wisely. (WISELY IS SARCASM) It would
anger those who would hear the servants deny their guilt.
He says that Macduff lives in disgrace (doesn’t favour the king). He did not
appear at the feast as well.
Note the use of tyrant. Macbeth has turned from Bellona’s bridegroom to a
tyrant.
After this the Lord says that Malcolm (whose birthright was stolen by
Macbeth), lives in England where King Edward treats him respect despite
the wrongness of destiny.
Macduff has gone there to beg Kind Edward to call Northumberland and
warrior Siward to help overthrow Macbeth.
The messenger bearing the news turned his back on Macduff and
hummed as if to say that he will regret the day he gave the messenger
the denial. Maybe, the messenger is aware of Macbeth’s treatment of
those who bring bad news.
Lennox, to this information says that this should be warning enough for
Macduff to continue cautiously and stay away from Scotland and Macbeth.
He says that some holy angel should fly to the court of England and
inform Macduff to return quickly to help their country and save them from
the torture Macbeth is putting them under. CURSED TYRANT.
NOTE – This shows the kind of mindset people have of Macbeth. Dramatic
Irony, Theatrical tension, not seen as a rightful ruler.
END OF SCENE
CHARACTERISATION:
BANQUO
Notice how Banquo’s death was somewhat noble. The reason for death
was his virtues were too strong to be overcome by Macbeth.
Banquo’s death marks not only a plot shift but also a breakdown in
Macbeth’s marriage. They begin to distance from one another. Lady
Macbeth is not involved in this murder. Independence from wife.
MACBETH
We see Macbeth persuading others to commit crimes with the same key
argument by which he himself was tempted: namely, to prove their
manhood.
LADY MACBETH
Lady Macbeth is not part of Banquo’s murder. She is antagonistic but she
is slowly becoming more and more weak (SHIFT IN GENDER ROLES).
She cannot understand why Macbeth is behaving in this way and she is
mocking and chastising him for displaying weakness. She is desperate to
stay in control but Macbeth keeps spinning out of control, away from Lady
Macbeth’s grasp.
When she says Nought’s had, all’s spent…doubtful joy, she implies that
she is worried. She is thinking in black-and-white. One extreme to the
other. From nought to all. We can detect fear in her character. We can see
uncertainty and hesitancy.
THEMES
Scene 1: Banquo’s Suspicion & Macbeth’s Fear
Ambition & Power: Macbeth, now king, realizes that his position is
insecure because Banquo’s descendants are prophesied to inherit
the throne.
Fate vs. Free Will: Macbeth tries to defy fate by ordering Banquo’s
murder.
"Come, fate, into the list, and champion me to th’ utterance!" (3.1.71-72)
Fate vs. Free Will: Fleance escapes, proving that Macbeth cannot
fully control fate.
"Thou canst not say I did it; never shake thy gory locks at me!" (3.4.50-
51)
Fate vs. Free Will: Hecate scolds the witches for meddling with
Macbeth without her guidance.
"We may again give to our tables meat, sleep to our nights." (3.6.33-34)
MOTIFS/SYMBOLS
Motifs are recurring elements that help develop the themes of the play.
"Thou canst not say I did it; never shake thy gory locks at me!" (3.4.50-
51)
2. Blood
"It will have blood, they say: blood will have blood." (3.4.122)
"Come, seeling night, scarf up the tender eye of pitiful day." (3.2.46-47)
Lady Macbeth warns him to act normal at the banquet, but his
disturbed mind betrays him.
Symbols in Act 3
1. Banquo’s Ghost
2. The Crown
3. The Witches
Unlike in Act 2, where Lady Macbeth had to push him into action,
Macbeth now takes matters into his own hands.
2. Embracing Tyranny and Ruthlessness
"Thou canst not say I did it; never shake thy gory locks at me!" (3.4.50-
51)
His erratic behavior alarms his guests, marking the beginning of his
downfall.