BFN405 Bank Lending Policies Overview
BFN405 Bank Lending Policies Overview
List and discuss the critical areas relating to lending for which banks normally set policies.
There are critical areas relating to lending that the banks do not normally take for grant in the
formulation of bank policies. Such areas for policy formulation on bank lending are as
identified and discussed below. Loan Limit
Policies are normally set for the granting of loans by the various officers of the bank that are
directing involved in lending. In setting the magnitude of loan that can be approved by the
officers in charge of credits, certain factors are usually taken into consideration.
In terms of policy on loan limit for the officers, the following factors, among others, are taken into
consideration;
The position of the officer, e.g., a branch manager, senior loan officer; The experience of the
officer, e.g., 10 years in loan administration;
The level of expertise in sector of the economy, e.g., estate, agriculture, etc; Performance
of the officer in handling loans in the past; and
Understanding of the customers’ product markets.
In terms of the loan limit for the customers, the following factors, among others, are taken into
consideration;
Creditworthiness of the customer;
Performance on the previous loans, for old customer;
Performance of the business in the last five years, at least, for new customer; His market share in
the industry, e.g., 5%, 10%, 25%, 35%, 45%, 60%; Geographical area of operations, e.g., a town,
city, suburb, village, farm settlement;
His operational capacity, e.g., medium-scale , large-scale operations; Level of demand for his
product or service in the economy; Magnitude of cash inflows on periodic basis; and
Customer’s character and other personal qualities.
Furthermore, grading system can be used for setting the policies on loan limit such as portrayed by
the figure (2.1) below.
Figure 2.1
Categorization of omments oan Limit (N)
Customers for Loan
imit Grade
A lue chip company 0,000,000
B Government Agency 0,000,000
C arge Company ,000,000
D Medium Company ,000,000
mall Company ,000,000
ndividualized Business 00,000
The individualized business refers to business entity such as partnership and sole proprietorship,
having operational capacity that is not comparable with an incorporated company whose asset base
is very reasonable in terms of operational capital.
However, there is no hard and fast rule in the categorization of customers for the purpose of loan
limit. A grading or categorization system being used by any bank for setting loan limits on
customers depends on choice.
In related terms, such categorization of loan limits can be also be used to set loan mandate for the
officers of the bank when it comes to approval of loans for the customers.
In the case of the branch manager, the usual policy on loan limit is for the bank to set the amount of
funds that he or she can lend out to a customer. The limit is regarded as his or her authority in
lending, and any loan request in excess of such lending authority will have to be communicated to
the head office for advice.
A loan request in excess of the branch manager’s authority in lending can as well be communicated
to the area manager who may have the authority to sanction it without recourse to the head office
for the necessary approval
Loan Supervision
It is very important for the bank to set policies on loan supervision. The policies on granting of
loans, their supervision, and recovery drive are normally established taking into consideration the
relevant strategies used in the past and those ones being utilized by other banks.
Bank policies on loan supervision are used to address responsibilities such as: Teams to be
constituted for checks and balances;
Superior officer(s) to be in charge of reports and evaluation, e.g., an Executive
Director at the head office, a Senior Manager at regional office;
Time line for periodic reviews of loan portfolio for compliance on laid down regulations; Number
of loan recovery visits to customers who are loan beneficiaries in a period.
Charting out procedures for compliance with extant banking laws and regulations on loan facilities;
The rate of interest to charge in line with prevailing market rate and bank rate; Spread of available
funds for different sectoral allocations; and Repayment drive to keep pace with liquidity needs.
Credit Risk Management
A policy should usually be established for the management of the credit risk in terms of the
problems that can emanate from loan recovery by the bank.
The policy is on the following areas of responsibilities: Manager’s responsibility in preventing
credit risks; Assistant Manager’s responsibility in credit risk management;
Loan officers’ responsibility in preventing credit risks; Hierarchical authority for handling credit
risks; and
Actions necessary in managing difficult beneficiaries of loans.
There are other areas of responsibilities for the management of credit risks by various bank
officials, which are not covered by above list. Therefore, the list is by no means exhaustive for the
purpose of credit management of credit risks by the banks.
Managing Difficult Loan Beneficiary
There should be policy on how a difficult loan beneficiary can be managed by relevant bank
officials. Such policy should be used to specify the necessary actions to be initiated and taken by
the bank officials to recover the amount of loan involved in the transaction.
The necessary directives in managing difficult account involve the following considerations: The
use of committee for the recovery of the funds; Discussion with the difficult customer by the
bank officials;
Visit to the business premises of the customer for assessment;
The use of subtle pressure on the customer, e.g., threat of legal action; Constant visits for help in
managing the affairs of the customer;
Threat of disposing off the collateral security pledged for the loan; and
Legal letter on the status of the customer and the plan to take action on the business for the recovery
of the outstanding amount of loan.
In addition to the above, there are other areas for policy actions on difficult customers, which
various banks can formulate to manage them. More so, necessary responsibilities for the
management of the difficult customers are formulated and assigned to various bank officials, which
are not covered by above list. Therefore, the list is by no means exhaustive for the purpose of
managing difficult customers by the banks.
What are the considerations for inviting bank customers to make loan request?
In the process of lending of credits, it is the normal practice that a request be put forward by an
applicant who is customer of the bank for a credit facility for the operations of a business entity or
to prosecute a certain project which is expected to be self liquidating.
Nevertheless, some customers of the bank may be approached by the bank managers or credit
officials of the bank to convince them to apply for credit facilities. The bank officials normally take
into consideration certain factors before initiating the move in drawing the attention of some
customers that they are entitled and qualified for credit facilities.
Such move by the bank officials is normally based on the following considerations: performance
of such customers in the operations of their bank accounts;
the size of their business undertakings; the nature of their business operations; their market share in
the industry;
the personal integrity of the customers; level of
liquidity of the bank; business focus of the bank;
and type of banking operations, e.g., investment
banking.
In general terms, therefore, the request for loan facility of a customer can be initiated by both the
customer and the bank. This is often based contacts and good banking relationships between the
bank and their customers. Hence, it is not uncommon for the bank's loan officers and the managers
to solicit new accounts from individuals and firms operating in the bank's market area with the idea
of convincing them with offer of loan facilities.
What are the reasons which inform lending and credit administration by the banks?
What are the necessary administrative measures for managing problem loans?
Committee’ s actions for the recovery of difficult loans; Mutual discussion with the beneficiary of
the loan; Planned contact for assessment of beneficiary’s premises;
Threat of legal action against the beneficiaries Offer of restructuring of beneficiaries’ operations;
Threat of sale of securities for the loan; and
Representation to beneficiaries on plan to take over their business operations.
Mention and explain the main objectives of lending and credit administration.
facilities so as to choose those ventures that are capable of generating constant income with which
to service the loan and make repayment on regular basis.
It is the responsibility of the credit officers and the committee to also evaluate new projects using
their technical feasibility and economic viability reports to determine the nature of cash inflows in
terms of their nature of earnings. Such assessment will be used for the selection of the projects that
can generate enough funds for repaying loans and credit facilities.
In the case of existing business, the usual practice is for the bank to request for financial reports of
the business which incorporate relevant data for five years. This will be used in evaluating the
regularity of generation of earnings. And the assessment is used to determine the stability of income
from the business for the repayment of loan facility.
5. Earn Adequate Returns from Lending
An objective of loan and credit administration is to generate adequate earnings from lending and
credits, which are very important to the operations of commercial banks. Loans and advances are
usually granted to customers with the intention of earning some income for the banks. The income
from lending facilities comes mainly from the interest charges being made from loans advances
being granted to customers by the banks.
The rate of interest being charged on loans and advances by the banks is normally determined in
consideration to the prevailing interest rate and the ruling bank rate sanctioned by the apex bank in
the economy. Such bank rate is called the monetary policy rate in the country, as determined by
Central Bank of Nigeria.
The interest rate being charged on loans by the commercial banks is normally determined in relation
to the bank rate being charged by the apex bank, the former being higher than the later. In addition,
the banks incorporate some other charges as may be determined by the lending officers or the credit
committee.
6. Ensure Effective Supervision of Lending
Another objective of loan and credit administration is to ensure effective supervision of lending by
the banks. In order to ensure that lending operations are proper supervised, the banks normally set
administrative policies on loan supervision. In this regards, administrative policies are established
on supervision of credit facilities, their recovery drives, and personal visits by bank officials to the
loan beneficiaries.
The relevant supervision policies are normally established in relation to the past strategies and those
methods being used by the other banks in the industry. In order to ensure effective loan supervision,
these policies are used: supervisory teams, reports and evaluation, time line for periodic reviews of
loan recoveries, loan recovery visits, procedures for compliance with banking regulations,
appropriate pricing of loans and credits, and loan recovery methods.
7. Efficient Management of Credit Risk
An objective of loan and credit administration is to ensure efficient management of risks associated
with loans and advances. In this regard, administrative measures are established by the banks for
management of the credit risk in respect of grave problems which can arise from loan recovery by
the bank.
The banks do formulate administrative measures for the management of credit risks by assigning
responsibilities for; branch managers in preventing credit risks; senior officers in credit risk
management; loan officers in recommending only loans with minimal risks; credit committee
for assessing and handling credit risks; effective supervision to minimize defaults in loan
repayment; managing accounts of loan beneficiaries; constant visits to loan beneficiaries; and
actions necessary in managing difficult loan beneficiaries.
The objective is to eliminate or minimize the hazards and perils that loans and advances can present
to the operations of banks. The measures for controlling loans and advances in order to manage
their risks may differ from one bank to another.
To review major new loans; Review major loan renewals; Ascertain the reasons for renewal;
Assess delinquent loans & determine the cause of delinquency; Ensure compliance with established
lending policy;
Ensure full documentation of loans before disbursement; and Ensure
consistency in the treatment of loan customers.
The responsibilities of a loan committee as stated above may not be exhaustive and therefore,
individual bank may include other duties for the committee to discharge.
Mention the factors that influence the rate interest being charged for bank loan.
The bank’s cost of funds;
The riskiness of the borrower; Compensating balances & fees; Interest rates charged by
competitors;
The ruling bank rate in the economy; and
Other banking relationships with the borrower
Mention and discuss the modalities for lending and credit administration.
Mention and explain the considerations for initial evaluation of loan request
The assessment of the amount in relation to the above issues will make the bank either to grant the
whole amount or decrease it.
3. Reason for the Loan
The banks will also be interested in determining the main reason which informs the customer’s
request for loan. The reason for the loan will enable the bank to classify the request in relation to
broad-based categorization as shown below.
Real estate loans:- short-term loans for construction and land development and longer-term loans
for the purchase of farmland, homes, apartments, commercial structures, and foreign properties.
Financial institution loans:- loans to other banks, insurance companies, finance companies, and
other financial institutions.
Agricultural loans:- loans to finance farm and ranch operations, mainly to assist in planting and
harvesting crops and to support the feeding and care of livestock. Commercial and industrial
loans: to businesses to cover expenditures on inventories, paying taxes, and meeting payrolls.
Loans to individuals:- credit to finance the purchase of automobiles, appliances, and other
consumer goods, equity lines for home improvements, and other personal expenses Lease
financing:- to corporate firms on equipment or vehicles.
The categorization of the loan request will enable the bank to determine the appropriate amount to
grant for the demand. 4. Sources of Payment
The means of repayment will also be considered by the banks in assessing any loan request by the
customer. This consideration is related to the cash inflows from the business, which will be used by
the beneficiary to meet the periodic repayments of the principal amount and the interest charges to
the bank.
5. Ability of the Beneficiary to Repay
This issue will be assessed in relation to the capital and assets of the business for which the loan is
being requested. This is based on the fact that the capital base of the business determines its ability
to carry out its operations efficiently.
In the case of a new project, the financial projections for a period of five years will be assessed to
determine the ability of the business to generate enough income to meet its cost of operation and
meeting the loan repayment
Mention and discuss the relevant factors to be considered in decision on loan request
Character: – this is a review of the management of the business, the products of the company, and
the past performance of the business for which a loan is being requested.
Ability: – this refers to the ability of the business to generate enough income from cash inflows
with which to repay the loan facility.
Margin: – this refers to the profit or reward of engaging in the lending facility which will determine
the bank’s consideration in committing funds.
Purpose: – this relates to the reason which informs the customer’s request which should not be
connected with abnormal business operations such as speculative business, illegal business
transaction, fruitless venture, self aggrandizement, failed venture, money laundering, dealing in
arms or weapons, etc.
Amount: – this refers to the value or amount of funds that is being requested by the customer,
which will be considered in relations to issues such as available funds for lending, the liquid
position of the bank, regulation of the apex bank, amount of loan already committed to loan, pace
of loan recovery, trend in volume of withdrawals, etc.
Repayment: – this refers to the possibility of the repayment schedule being appropriate to the
bank’s liquidity management plan. More so, the bank will also consider the past performance of the
business in relation of its ability to meet periodic repayments of the funds in relation to the liquidity
plan of the bank.
Insurance: – this refers to the issue of collateral security which is available to secure the loan by the
customer. This is very important to the bank because in the event of defaults or inability to repay
the loan the bank will use the collateral security for generate funds to settle the loan. The analysis
above indicates that it represents a broad-based evaluation of the loan request compared to the
earlier consideration in this unit. These
considerations are important in terms attributes which coalesce to form the basis of the lending
decision.
Among these considerations, there are five attributes that are linked to the accounts and finances of
the prospective borrowers. The remaining two considerations are character and margin, which are
related to the customer and the bank’s profit contemplation.
In the case of character, the issues are management of the business, which represents subjective
assessment, and the others in the areas of the products of the company, and the past performance of
the business, the latter which can be specifically quantified from the balance sheet data.
The banks will therefore, be interested in seeing financial information for the past five years before
lending any money to the customer. These are the balance sheet and the income statement of the
business which incorporates the past data relating to five years consecutively..
What are the characteristics of a term loan that can be granted by banks to business entities?
Available to business entities that are associated with heavy industrial undertakings;
Available to industrial organizations that deal in manufacturing, petroleum refinery, transportation;
Available to business entities that produce durable goods, chemicals, rubber, and public utilities;
Available to firms and trading organizations whose main purpose is for enhancing their working
capital;
Available to large business firms with heavy investments in plants and items of equipment;
It can be used by some small and medium businesses that cannot have access to funds
in capital market;
It can be used by large firms because such firms favour their flexibility for meeting their peculiar
needs compared to bond issue;
It is available to firms that have the ability to renegotiate their terms after being granted; and It
is granted to business entities that have the financial ability to prepay them without issue of
penalty.
What are the major uses to which the term loans are secured by business entities?
Acquisition of operational facilities particularly lands, buildings, equipment and machinery by large
industrial firms;
ii) The term loan can be used as well for enhancing working capital position of the firms in
meeting daily operational commitments;
iii) The loan can be used for financing new projects such as development and financing of
new
products, acquisition of sales outlets, establishing source of raw materials, etc; iv)
It can be used as a means of drawdown of funds for financing fleet of transport
facilities for operational logistics; and
v) The facility can be combined with revolving credit facility for periodic drawdown by business
entities for financing periodic commitments by firms.
Mention the provisions that are associated with the term loans.
. Collateral Security
The term loans, in general terms, require pledging of collateral security by the borrowers. The
collateral security can be for the long-term loans than the short-term one as a result of the
differences in risks associated with the term loans.
The reason is that the long-term loans, in general terms, are associated with much risk compared
with the short-term loans. The collateral security may also be demanded from smaller
enterprises because of the fact that their operations can be much risky as compared to large
industrial undertakings. 2. Interest Charges
The interest charges on term loans are generally higher compared to other forms of credit facilities
from the banks. In comparison to short-term loan, the interest rate on term loan is higher due to the
fact that the latter form of bank lending facility is less liquid and it involves higher risk.
Furthermore, the term loan that involves large amount of funds calls for charges which are higher
than the type that involves a small amount of funds because the cost of
packaging and administration of the facility increases with cost of insurance, administrative and
paper work, and logistics for periodic contacts with the borrowers.
There are other factors that influence that the charges that are associated with the term loans. Such
factors include: the prime rate in the economy; issue of compensating balance, financial position of
the borrower, and cash inflows prospects of the project or the business, among others.
3. Maturity
The term loan normally has duration of about 2 – 6 years or even longer periods. This depends on
purpose of the loan, the agreed term, liquidity position of the bank, status of the business or projects
for which the loan is taken, etc.
In some cases, the term loan can be repaid back before the maturity date but it can attract some
extra charges regarded as penalty particularly if it is discovered by the bank that the borrower is
using a cheaper funds to repay the loan.
4. Repayment
The repayment of term loans involves installment payments quarterly, semi-annually and annually.
The agreed terms may involve a balloon payment at the end of the maturity period in which a new
line of facility may be negotiated by the borrower.
The negotiation of a new line of loan facility at the end of the previous one is desirable particularly
by the lender for borrowers who may need a long-term credit facility. Therefore, the duration and
the whole amount that may be demanded by the borrower can be graduated and granted to him on
periodic basis.
Mention and discuss the factors that the banks consider in granting term loans
Mention the advantages and disadvantages of using working capital loans by firms.
For the advantages of using the working capital loan, considerations are as follows: The working
capital loan is a source of quick funding;
It helps a business entity to sustain their operations until it is profitable enough;
Such a loan could be used to refinance cash flow for meeting the short-term financial obligations to
workers and suppliers;
Working capital loan provides funds to a business entity it needs to keep growing until the business
can cover all operating expenses out of revenue.
The working capital loan also enables businesses to generate enough revenue from additional sales
to stay afloat.
The loan also makes a firm the access to cash which can be used to make payment for rents,
mortgage payments, utilities, marketing expenses, inventory, and remuneration for employees, etc.
For the disadvantages of using the working capital loan, considerations are as follows: The funding
is only intended for short-term solutions;
These loans will not be relevant to long-term business goals or business projects that
will need higher investments;
The firm needs to make regularly payment on the loan;
This also calls for ensuring timely payments to avoid being considered as a high- risk or a
delinquent customer.
Another disadvantage is that obtaining capital through this method can be difficult for many
businesses, particularly the small and medium enterprises.
Mention and explain the two basic types of working capital loan.
1. Line of Credit
This is any credit facility that is extended to business entities by a bank for use in enhancing their
working capital position. The line of credit from the bank comes in form of a cash credit, overdraft
facility, a demand loan, an export packing credit, term loan, or discounting facility.
The lines of credit are very flexible for business use. Nevertheless, they are only made available to
the business entities that have meaningful way of repaying them. The consideration is defined cash
inflows from the operations of the firm.
The availability of credit is a key determinant in the ability of particularly small and medium firms
to expand and grow. In order to lessen the perennial problems of meeting the demands of operations
of growing number of small and medium enterprises, working capital loans are normally made
available to them by the banks. In fact some of these loans do not need collateral securities but offer
of mere promise of repayment from the business entities in need of such loans to back up their
working capital. 2. Short term loan
The short-term loan is another form of working capital loan that is available for the use of business
entities. The short-term loans are usually seasonal loans, but their maturity does not always go
beyond a period of one year. The thriving and well established business entities are nearly
guaranteed automatic access to short term loans, which in most cases do not require collateral
securities.
Since the working capital of a company reflects its ability to meet its obligations as they fall due,
the short term loans are necessary in avoiding a run towards a position of bankruptcy. Thus, some
amount of working capital loans in form of short-term loans are needed more often to direct the
character and scope of a business operation. Working capital loans or short-term financing
constitute the funds usually required by the firms to finance working capital short-falls.
Mention and explain the factors responsible for the risky nature of agricultural loans.
In the case of the other aspect of weather, too much sunshine can spell drought with consequence of
poor harvest of agricultural produce. In extreme cases, the drought can lead to famine in some areas
to the extent that the farmers themselves would not be able to obtain any produce to feed their
families.
In the event that there is no farm produce or limited quantity of farm produce, the farmers would
not be able to generate any income with which to meet the demands of the so-called agricultural
loans. Therefore, the banks would incur loss in their investments in loans.
4. Difficulty in Assessing Framers Creditworthiness
It is always very difficult for the banks to assess the creditworthiness of the farmers because some
important pieces of information relevant for such analysis are not just available. Granting of loans
by commercial banks is based on the assessment of the customers’ creditworthiness using relevant
information and data from past performance of their undertakings. This is not possible in the case of
the farmers who operate in precarious environment.
Farming in the less advanced countries such as Nigeria is characterized by small holdings whose
owners engage in agriculture for the purpose is mainly for subsistence operations. They would sell
only surplus quantity to the public. Therefore, the farmers do not keep records which can be used to
evaluate their creditworthiness by the banks for the purpose of granting agricultural loans to them.
5. Diversion of Agricultural Loans
Farmers in the country are fond of diverting funds from agricultural loans to meeting family
commitments which cannot in way distinguished from the expenses being incurred on farm
operations. This is because borrowed funds may be utilized for both productive and or consumption
purposes which in many cases could not be distinguished from each other.
Furthermore, farming operations in the country are mostly carried out on the basis of family
holdings. This implies that it is difficult to separate expenses on family commitments from costs of
running farming operations. The income being generated on periodic basis is being expended on
family commitments as well as the farming operations.
Mention and discuss the main types of agricultural loans available from commercial banks.
livestock; vehicles;
and durable
implements.
All these farm requirements are normally meant for enhancing the production of agricultural
products.
Part of the money from the term loan can also be utilized by the beneficiaries in:
acquiring farmland; construction of farm house; fish pond; piggery; and pen
house for goats; etc.
The commercial banks normally ensure that the farmers are encouraged to utilize the funds from the
term loan to enhance the mechanization of the farm operations.
Therefore, the funds can be utilized by some farmers for the:
purchase of tractors; and acquisition of modern agricultural
implements.
These operational assets are meant to encourage the farmers towards the mechanization and
improvement of their agricultural production. The commercial banks would be interested in such
assets being purchased by the beneficiaries so that they are easily secured as collateral for the loan.
In terms of collateral security, a large percentage of the intermediate loans for agricultural
production are secured. Therefore, it is only a small percentage of such loans that is unsecured by
the farmers when they are granted by the banks. The reason is the risky nature of farm operations
and the fact that the loan is repayable over several years.
The extended length of maturities of this type of agricultural loan increases the riskiness in the loan.
This informs the need for collateral security for this form of loan for agricultural production. The
items that are purchased with the funds from the loan are normally mortgaged or secured by the
banks as the collateral security for such loans.
The real estate for which the loan can be utilized, for the farm operations, can always be accepted
by the commercial banks as collateral securities. This is in the event that
the funds from the intermediate term loan are utilized by the beneficiaries to improve farm land and
buildings.
The maturity period of intermediate term loan for the farm operations varies in accordance with the
purpose of the facility. In the case of the loan being granted for the purpose of livestock the
maturity would be for a relatively short term. The maturity becomes a relatively long term if the
purpose of the loan is for the acquisition of vehicles and durable farm implements.
Current Expense Loan
This type of loan is normally granted by the commercial banks to farmers for the financing of
frequent seasonal expenses for the production of crops and livestock.
Such recurrent expenses in farm operations for which the loan is granted include: seedlings;
hybrid seeds; fertilizers; fuels; and hired labour.
Since this type of agricultural loan is for current farm operations in terms of utilization for current
farm expenses, it is normally granted by the commercial banks for a short- term basis. The loan
facility is repayable within a period of twelve months.
The loan is usually regarded as current operating facility for expenses such as feeder;
livestock; and other recurrent expenditures.
These expenditures are normally incurred in the process of farm operations by the beneficiaries.
Some farmers have the penchant for spending part of the funds from the current expense loan for
the upkeep of the family. The loan of this nature that is usually secured is of relative small
percentage.
The commercial banks normally ensure a security interest, for the purpose of collateral security, in
articles such as:
The benefits of installment loans include the following considerations inherent in the facility.
It gives a borrower the freedom to make payments for an extended period of time.
It allows the customer the chance to make a purchase that he may not otherwise be able to make
upfront, e.g., a car or house.
Each payment is due at the same time each month and for the same amount. Installment loans are
useful for those who do not have a lot of money in savings. It is useful for consumers for avoid
putting high-ticket items on a credit card. Installment loans offer the ease and convenience of
structured, monthly payments.
Short-term installment loans only require a verifiable income.
Installment loans can even be obtained over the Internet in some states of the US,
depending on state regulations.
What are the factors that influence the interest charges on installment loans?
The borrower's credit history with the bank. Means of repayment of the amount granted.
Length of time the customer has account with the bank. Performance of the customer’s account in
he past.
The length of the repayment period.
The total amount of the loan being granted to the customer. The contribution of the customer or
down payment.
The state or performance of the economy.
In some instances, short-term loan interest rates are much higher, especially those for some days,
since they do not require a collateral security. This is particularly applicable to consumers who use
such loans to acquire assets for household use.
Ensure regular repayment of loans and advances; Generate enough funds to meet depositors’
demands; Prevent loan defaults from the customers;
Ensure liquidity for the banks’ operations;
Generate reasonable amount of returns on operations; Protect depositors’ interest; Guide
against financial distress in operations;
Ensure regularity of cash inflows from investment in loans; Minimize risks inherent in loans and
advances;
Ensure safety of the funds committed into loans
Mention and discuss the various modalities that can used for loan monitoring and supervision.
Collection Procedure
It is always necessary for the banks to institute relevant measures for the collection of funds
involved in loans and advances which are granted to the customers. The
collection procedure is normally determined at the stage of granting the loans and credits to
customers of the bank.
The collection procedure involves the use of the following administrative measures.
1. Schedule of Repayment
In most cases the repayment for any loan by the customer is normally effected with a prepared
schedule showing the frequency and amount of principal and interest involved. The schedule is
prepared to show the number of repayment installments, the magnitude of principal repayment, and
the interest charges to be met by the customer on periodic basis.
2. Reminders and Circulars
Another important responsibility of the credit officers of the bank is the preparation of the periodic
reminders and circular letters which are normally sent out to the loan beneficiaries. The reminders
and circular letters are normally prepared to incorporate the total loan commitment of the customer,
the repayment that has been made, the outstanding payments and their due dates.
3. Personal Visits
Personal visits are very imperative for effective supervision of the repayment of loans and advances
by the banks. The visits may be scheduled or on the basis of surprise contacts by the relevant bank
officers.
The personal visits by bank officers to loan beneficiaries are normally facilitated by the evaluation
visit which is made during the assessment of the loan request from the customers. In the process of
loan evaluation, the premises of the customers’ business would be visited, and this eliminates
problem of difficulty in accessing the loan beneficiaries.
The personal contacts by the bank officers to the customers are on periodic basis and therefore, not
reserved for solving problem loan accounts when the beneficiaries might not be forthcoming in
terms of meeting regular loan repayment. It implies that the personal visit to customers who are
holding the funds of the bank is a regular action, which can be used to forestall repayment defaults.
4. Mode of Collection of Funds
The mode of collection of funds from the loan beneficiaries is normally determined and made
known to them at the instance of granting the facilities. The mode of collection can either be cash
payment or payment by cheques by the loan beneficiaries. The collection of repayments in cash by
the bank officials is not normally encouraged
The non-repayment of loans and advances by the customers in cash to bank officials is to prevent
frauds and fraudulent practices by the staff when handling cash outside the premises of the bank.
Therefore, the customers are encouraged to make repayments in cheques directly to the bank and
not to the bank officials unless they are crossed cheques.
Repayment Evaluation
In most cases the repayment schedule for any loan by the customer is normally used to assess the
progress of repayment based prepared schedule. The evaluation is based on the frequency and
amount of principal and interest being repaid by the customers.
It is normally easier for the bank officials to use the repayment schedule for evaluating customers’
performance since it is prepared to show the number of repayment installments, the magnitude of
principal repayment, and the interest charges to be met by the customer on periodic basis. Hence,
the details of the repayment schedule would be compared with the records of the actual repayment
of the funds involved in the loan in order to assess any discrepancies which may require actions on
the part of the bank.
Another important aid to evaluation of loan repayment is the appropriate accounting records
maintained by the bank on the release of funds to the loan beneficiaries and the repayments of the
funds to the bank. This is important for the bank because such accounting record will be used in
evaluating the performance of the loan repayment by the customers.
The evaluation of repayment of loans process also affects the assessment of the entries in the
separate loan accounts that have been created for large of amount of loans. The customers’ existing
accounts used for accounting records of release of funds and the repayments on the facilities would
also be evaluated to determine the performance.
Mention and discuss the various forms of property that can be pledged as collateral security.
Real Estate
A real property is acceptable in the consideration for a collateral security on a loan facility. Once
the property is accepted by the bank, the bank can put public notice of a mortgage against a real
estate. The bank then takes action to file with the relevant authority the pledge of the property for a
loan facility from the beneficiary.
Tin some instances, the bank may have to take out title insurance and equally insists that the
borrower purchases insurance policy to cover any future damage from environmental hazards and
perils. The bank receives a first claim on any insurance settlement that is made on the policy.
The bank will initiate action to determine the real value of the property once it accepts to advance
some funds on loan facility to a borrower. The basic approaches to the valuation of real estate
include the
Cost approach:- this involves considering the reproduction cost of the building and improvements,
deducts estimated depreciation, and adds the value of the land.
Market Data or direct sales comparison approach:- this involves estimating the value of the subject
property based on the comparable properties’ current selling prices.
The income approach:- this involves the use of discounted value of the future net operating income
streams from the property.
The direct capitalization approach:- this involves the calculation of the value by dividing an
estimate of its average annual income by a factor called capitalization rate.
2. Personal Property:
The practice is for the banks to accept and take a security interest in items of property such as motor
vehicles, machinery, equipment, furniture, securities, and other forms of personal property owned
by a borrower.
Mention and discuss the various forms of valuable that can be pledged as collateral security.
1. Personal Guarantees
The banks may also accept the pledge of the stock, deposits, or other personal assets held by the
major stockholders or owners of a company. The borrower will be required to provide agreement
on such pledge and acceptance between the representative of the borrower and the bank as may be
required for the collateral to secure a business loan for the entity.
The practice is that guarantees are often requested for by the banks in the cases of lending funds to
smaller businesses. This is also required from corporate entities that have fallen on difficult times.
The simple reason is that the arrangement will give the owners the prod or considered reason to
strive harder so that their firm will prosper and repay their loan.
2. Accounts Receivable
Another practice is that the banks can accept and take a security interest in the form of a stated
percentage of the face value of accounts receivable, which involves value of sales on credit, as
shown on a business borrower's balance sheet.
Whenever the borrower's credit customers send in cash to settle their outstanding debts, such funds
or cash payments are applied for the settlement of the outstanding balance of the borrower's loan.
This may to take the form of mortgaging the receipts of the accounts receivable so that the payment
would be made to the account opened for such money in the bank’s domain.
The banks often take the necessary measures to evaluate accounts receivable pledged for the loan
facility by the borrower. The main types of method of evaluation of
accounts receivable are accounting receivable aging and accounting receivable turnover.
3. Factoring
The banks can also purchase the borrowers’ accounts receivable. The arrangement is that the
agreement will be based upon some percentage of the book value of such debtors. The factoring
interest is the difference between the book value and the discounted value of the accounts
receivable.
The borrower's customers who are the debtors would be required to make payments direct to the
purchasing bank, which happens to the lender of funds to the firm whose debts the bank has
acquired. The agreement will incorporate the consideration that the borrower promises to set aside
some funds with which to cover some or all of the losses that the bank may suffer from any
unpaid receivables. 4. Inventory
In this consideration, a bank will lend only a percentage of the estimated market value of the
borrower's inventory, which serves as the collateral security for the loan facility. The bank could
have a floating lien in the sense that the inventory pledged may be controlled completely by the
borrower.
In the case of the floor planning, the lender takes temporary ownership of any goods placed in
inventory and the borrower sends payments or sales contracts to the lender as the goods are sold.
This arrangement ensures that the bank as the lender is rest assured that he has a proper lien on the
inventory.
The practice requires that the bank evaluate the inventory. The basic ways to evaluate the inventory
include resale of inventory, inventory turnover, and inventory converted to accounts receivable.
Differentiate between small company whole turnover policy and single risk policy.
Mention and explain the various credit policies that can be taken by banks to protect the
funds being committed to loans and advances.
What are forms of risks that can make banks to lose their funds on export credit?
Explain comprehensive short term policy in relation to variation of claims in export credit
To review major new loans; Review major loan renewals; Ascertain the reasons for renewal;
Assess delinquent loans & determine the cause of delinquency;
Ensure compliance with established lending policy; Ensure
full documentation of loans before disbursement; and
Ensure consistency in the treatment of loan customers.
Mention the necessary considerations normally taken into cognizance towards final decision
on loan request.
What are the necessary administrative measures for managing problem credit facilities
Committee’s actions for the recovery of difficult loans; Mutual discussion with the beneficiary of
the loan; Planned contact for assessment of beneficiary’s premises;
Threat of legal action against the beneficiaries Offer of restructuring of beneficiaries’ operations;
Threat of sale of securities for the loan; and
Representation to beneficiaries on plan to take over their business operations.
Mention and explain the factors influencing credit administration by commercial banks
Mention and explain the considerations for initial analysis of loan request
Identify and discuss the relevant technique for assessing the creditworthiness of customers
requesting for credit facilities.
The use of the data in the income statement and the balance sheet is not considered weighty enough
to assess the creditworthiness of the customer. Therefore, the commercial banks normally make use
of an assessment technique called CAMPARI, an acronym from other relevant considerations in
loan assessment.
Such considerations for assessing the creditworthiness of customers seeking for loan facilities are as
follows.
Character: – this is a review of the management of the business, the products of the company, and
the past performance of the business for which a loan is being requested.
Ability: – this refers to the ability of the business to generate enough income from cash inflows
with which to repay the loan facility.
Margin: – this refers to the profit or reward of engaging in the lending facility which will determine
the bank’s consideration in committing funds.
Purpose: – this relates to the reason which informs the customer’s request which should not be
connected with abnormal business operations such as speculative business, illegal business
transaction, fruitless venture, self aggrandizement, failed venture, money laundering, dealing in
arms or weapons, etc.
Amount: – this refers to the value or amount of funds that is being requested by the customer,
which will be considered in relations to issues such as available funds for lending, the liquid
position of the bank, regulation of the apex bank, amount of loan already committed to loan, pace
of loan recovery, trend in volume of withdrawals, etc.
Repayment: – this refers to the possibility of the repayment schedule being appropriate to the
bank’s liquidity management plan. More so, the bank will also consider the past performance of the
business in relation of its ability to meet periodic repayments of the funds in relation to the liquidity
plan of the bank.
Insurance: – this refers to the issue of collateral security which is available to secure the loan by the
customer. This is very important to the bank because in the event of defaults or inability to repay
the loan the bank will use the collateral security for generate funds to settle the loan. The analysis
above indicates that it represents a broad-based evaluation of the loan request compared to the
earlier consideration in this unit. These considerations are important in terms attributes which
coalesce to form the basis of the lending decision.
Among these considerations, there are five attributes that are linked to the accounts and finances of
the prospective borrowers. The remaining two considerations are character and margin, which are
related to the customer and the bank’s profit contemplation.
In the case of character, the issues are management of the business, which represents subjective
assessment, and the others in the areas of the products of the company, and the past performance of
the business, the latter which can be specifically quantified from the balance sheet data.
Mention the essential elements of a workout plan that a bank normally adopts
i) updated and comprehensive financial information on the borrower, the project for the funds, and
any guarantor;
ii) current valuations of the collateral supporting the loan and the workout plan;
iii) analysis and determination of appropriate loan structure (e.g., term and amortization
schedule), curtailment, covenants, or re-margining requirements; iv) appropriate legal
documentation for any changes to loan terms;
v) an analysis of the borrower’s debt service that reflects a realistic projection of the
borrower’s and guarantor’s expenses;
vi) the ability to monitor the ongoing performance of the borrower and guarantor under the
terms of the workout;
vii) an internal loan grading system that accurately and consistently reflects the risk in the
workout arrangement; and viii) it covers estimated credit losses in the restructured loan.
Mention and explain the various options available for loan workout by the banks.
1. Loan Restructuring
A restructuring or renewal of loan is normally designed to improve the borrower’s prospects for
repayment of principal and interest and be consistent with sound banking, supervisory, and
accounting practices.
A restructuring of loan is, in most cases, made for borrowers who have the ability to repay their
debts under reasonable modified terms.
The option is normally granted by the bank on the basis of the likelihood that the credit will be
repaid in full under the modified terms in accordance with a reasonable repayment schedule.
2. Forbearance Plan
This is a forbearance plan that occurs when the bank agrees to suspend all or part of a monthly
payment for a specified time period. The repayment automatically resumes immediately after the
lull period.
3. Repayment Plan
The repayment plan is the plan that is designed to take care of accumulated payments. Therefore,
the borrower is under obligation to be making payment more than one full payment per month until
the account is brought to current position.
4. Loan Modification
The loan modification arises when the original terms of the promissory note are changed. The loan
modification may be arranged to include an adjustment of the interest rate, a capitalization of the
past due amount, and some combination of all of these.
5. Sale of Property
This implies that the property may be sold prior to foreclosure sale and the proceeds used to pay off
the delinquent loan. In some cases, the sale price or the amount realized may not be enough to pay
off all of the debt. If the sale is approved and carried out it becomes a “Short Sale”. This implies
that a short sale arises when the net proceeds from the sale of the property are less than the payoff
of the required amount of the mortgage.
6. Deed-in-Lieu of Foreclosure
In some circumstances the bank may allow the borrower to transfer the property to the lender
without going through the foreclosure process. This is usually regarded as a “last resort” option, and
this may follow other options such as an attempt to sell the property.
7. Loan Extension
In a maturing loan situation, when no other financing seems to be available, it may be possible for
the borrower to negotiate for extension of the existing loan normally for a fee. The fee is normally
paid on the basis of the period of extension.
In relation to the extension quest, the borrower would take steps to approach the bank some months
before the loan matures, with evidence of the borrower’s unsuccessful refinance efforts and a
specific proposal for the extension. As part of the proposed extension, the borrower might also
request other modifications such as an interest rate reduction, if appropriate.
1. Liquidity Management
The main concern in liquidity management as regards the asset and liability management is the
funding liquidity risk embedded in operations of the banks. The funding of long-term loans and
other securitised assets with short term liabilities possesses a grave challenge to the banks. Banks
are in the business of ensuring that funds involved in the lending facilities are available with which
to meet their customers’ requirements. Poor management of these loan facilities and other
investments result in liquidity, interest rate and currency mismatches which is the concerned of the
bank operators.
In general terms, failure to manage asset and liability of banks effectively can have dire
consequences on the liquidity of any bank. In recognition of this grave implication, it is necessary
for the banks to put a workable framework in place to manage liquidity risk. This involves two
critical aspects:
Managing liquidity in the recognition that all the operations of any bank; and Managing liquidity as
the panacea of resolving the usual crisis that confronts the commercial banks.
There are appropriate guidelines that banks need to consider in effective liquidity management.
Such principles are as identifies below.
Diversify sources and term of funding – concentration and contagion were the killers in the recent
crisis.
Identify, measure, monitor and control – it is still surprising that many banks do not fully
understand the composition of their balance sheet to a sufficient level of detail to allow for
management of the risks.
Understand the interaction between liquidity and other risks – e.g. basis risk – the
flow on impact of an event in one area can be devastating to others.
Establish both tactical and strategic liquidity management platforms – keep a focus on both the
forest and the trees.
Establish detailed contingency plans and stress test under multiple scenarios regularly.
2. Mismatch Management and Performance Measurement
For practical purposes, a bank needs to decide whether it wants to take a relatively cursory approach
to asset and liability management risks. The other consideration is 10 6
whether a bank is prepared to take a more definite approach and target higher long - term earnings
which translates into profitable operations.
While the choice is that of the banks a bank normally realise that there is the need for right level of
skills and resources to be instituted and committed to support the function. In the face of dynamic
nature of banking industry, failure to do this can result in a poorly managed operation which can
arise from volatility in core earnings, economic instability, and unpredictable business cycle. The
mismatch position of the asset and liabilities normally results in the interest rate and liquidity risk
for the banks. There are various techniques that banks can use to examine the mismatch in a bank’s
balance sheet and it can be a difficult process if not supported with adequate systems. Depending
on systems and analytical support that a bank uses in the asset and liability management process,
the usual analysis is designed to identify:
static and dynamic mismatch; sensitivity of net interest
income; and market value under multiple scenarios such
as high stress.
The general practice is that majority of the banks normally set net interest income limits as a main
measure of performance while the more advanced banks also use market or economic value as a
secondary measure.
The use of interest income limits has become the industry benchmark simulation tool because;
it is relatively easy to understand and implement; it’s a single period measure that does not
require many assumptions, and it is easy for investors to understand because it is linked to
reported financial results.
Nevertheless, the approach is limited as it does not provide a full view of the risks of operations of a
bank or reflect fully the economic impact of interest rate movements. Market value or economic
value simulations on the other hand, offer a more complete assessment of the risk confronting
banks in their operations. 3. Funds Transfer Pricing
The funds transfer pricing system is a fundamental asset and liability management tool in the
banking system. The system creates the ability of the bank to immunize its operations from risk.
Therefore, it provides the basis for operational transparency and profitability. The process of funds
transfer pricing is normally designed to identify interest margins and remove interest rate and
funding or liquidity risk.
The system of funds transfer pricing, from operational perspective, effectively locks in the margin
on loans and deposits by assigning a transfer rate that reflects the repricing and cash flow profile of
each balance sheet item. This is because it is applied to both assets and liabilities.
The system in the asset and liability management is used to isolate the bank’s business performance
into discrete portfolios that can be assigned individualized metrics. Therefore, it facilitates the
centralization and management of interest rate mismatches. In addition, it also effectively allocates
responsibilities between the bank’s business units and the treasury department.
In a sophisticated banking system, the funds transfer pricing mechanism can also be used as a tool
to assist with management of the balance sheet structure with its rates adjusted to either encourage
or discourage product and customer flows. The inherent advantage is that it can lead to greater
understanding of a bank’s competitive advantage and assisting with asset allocation.
The funds transfer pricing rates are normally structured to include both interest rate and funding
liquidity risks with the derived transfer yield curve constructed to include appropriate premiums.
List and explain the forms of marketable securities in which commercial banks can invest.
1. Bill Of Exchange
Bill of Exchange is a financial contract acknowledging a debt which is separate and distinct from
the transaction going rise to the debt.
The seller of the products who holds the bill can negotiate it before maturity date usually to a bank
for a discounted value which is lower than the face value of the bill. This is also known as trade
bill. The Bill is therefore held by the bank for only a short time for about ninety days before
recovering the funds invested in it from the designated bank.
2. Letter Of Credit
This is a form of bill of exchange known as bank bill which is issued by a bank as an interaction on
the bill of exchange. The letter of credit is issued by the financial institution in place of the bill of
exchange indicating its wiliness to accept the bill of exchange up to a certain amount of a specific
period of time on behalf give buyer.
It is a form of lending because which is based on the fact that it may mature and the bank is
expected to pay for the importer for payment to the exporter. The payment is therefore paid by the
bank within a short time before recovering the funds invested in it from the designated bank.
3. Promissory Note
It is a negotiable instrument acknowledging a debt obligation in trade transaction. It is normally
issued by the debtor to a creditor indicating announcement to pay the amount involved at a
specified date. This can be issued by the acceptance house guarantying payment at a specified date.
This can also be negotiated by the seller to a commercial bank for a discounted value for cash
before the maturity date. The Note is therefore held by the bank for only a short time for about
ninety days before recovering the funds invested in it from the designated bank.
4. Factoring
It involves the selling of debts to a factor which can be a bank such as an investment banker for
immediate cash. This usage depends on the continued widespread use of trade credit.
Mention and explain the main types of loans and credits in which the banks invest their funds.
MORTGAGE LOAN
Mortgage is a kind of loan for which land or any other specific asset is offered as collateral security
for the repayment of the funds involved in the credit facility. This is also applicable to real estate
loans for which the building structures put up by the beneficiaries are automatically pledged as their
collateral securities.
Therefore, it is a kind of loan stock that has a fixed charge on the company’s specific assets.
Document of title to the assets, which usually consist of land and trading, will be in the hands of the
mortgage holders or their representative
BOND INSTRUMENT
This instrument is issued and held by the firm for over a long period of time, the repayment of
which is after a maturity period. The whole amount will be held until after maturity when it is
repayable. The bank that subscribes to bond will only be receiving the interest charges on periodic
basis.
In essence, bond is a loan instrument issued by a company with promise to pay back the fund
borrowed after a specific number of years. The interest accruing on bond is normally paid to the
holder at regular basis, say, semi-annually over the life of the debt
It is normally due for payment after 10 to 20 years when the face value (principal amount
borrowed) is paid back to the holder. The bond can be sold before the maturity date of the holder at
the prevailing market price determined by the forces of demand of supply.
INSTALLMENT LOANS
The installment loan involves a sum of money advanced by a bank to a customer for repayment
over a fixed time period in equal amounts. In return for the loan, the borrower agrees on a
repayment plan, which involves an amount that typically remains the same throughout the life of
the loan. The interest charges on an installment loan are normally factored into future repayments.
In another perspective, installment loan can be described as the type of loan that is granted on the
understanding that there will be periodic payments. Such amount of payment is based on a specified
period of time which can be longer or shorter depending on the term of agreement between the bank
and the customer. The cost of the installment loan depends on the interest rate and the terms
involved generally.
The terms of repayment of installment loans are normally expressed in months. The common
periods of repayment include 36, 48, 60 or 72 months. There are a wide variety of terms, ranging
from short term, medium term to long term. For instance, mortgages are installment loans with
longer terms such as 180 or 360 months of repayment. It implies that some installment loans may
be structured for payment over a period of years.