ORDER SHEET
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH,
CIRCUIT COURT, HYDERABAD.
C.P No.S-39 of 2019
DATE ORDER WITH SIGNATURE OF JUDGE
For orders on M.A No.111/19.
For orders on M.A No.112/19.
For orders on M.A No.113/19.
For hearing of main case.
17.01.2019
Mr. Pervaiz Iqbal Butt, Advocate for Petitioner.
=
1. Urgent application is granted.
2. Exemption granted subject to all just exceptions.
3&4. This petition challenges the warrant of arrest issued by the Executing Court
in Family Execution Application No.01 of 2018, against the petitioner.
Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the Family Court through its
Judgment dated 28.04.2017, allowed the plaint of respondent No.2, in respect of
the dowry articles except one gold ring of 9 grams and declined Haq Mahar i.e 4
Tola of Gold. Learned counsel states that vide order dated 15.10.2018, the trial
Court valued the dowry articles in the sum of Rs.4,26,000/-. Learned counsel
further states that the petitioner has already made an application before the trial
Court to make the payment of dowry articles through installments. Learned
counsel while referring the Section 13 of Sub-section 5 of West Pakistan Family
Court Ordinance, 1964, states that the Family Courts are empowered that money
payable under the decree could be made payable in installments as the Court deem
fit. Learned counsel states that when the application of the petitioner was pending
before the Family Court for making the payment of dowry articles through the
installments, by the issuance of warrant of arrest, serious injustice is caused to the
petitioner. He states that the petitioner is inclined to make payment of the dowry
amount, however, in installments at the rate of Rs.20,000/- per month and such
request has not been considered by the Family Executing Court. In this regard
reliance on the Provision of Section 51 of CPC is made, where before arrest and
detention of a person, the court has to the first considered that whether the
judgment debtor is given an opportunity of showing cause as to why he should not
be committed to prison by attaching any of his properties, however, such provision
has not been followed by the Executing Court.
Let notice be issued to the respondents, as well as, learned A.A.G for
07.02.2019. However, petitioner is directed to immediately approach the Executing
Court by moving an application for making payment of dowry articles in
installments of Rs.20,000/- per month. Meanwhile, operation of the impugned
order is suspended till the next date of hearing.
JUDGE
Fahad Memon