self-care practices as related to
assessment of
chronic illness care among people with
diabetes
consulting in a family physician-led
hospital-based
first line health service and local
government
health unit-based health centers in the
Philippines
AUTHORS: GRACE MARIE V. KU AND GUY
KEGELS
A JOURNAL REPORT BY DR. ALIMYON
[Link]
BACKGROUND
The
purpose of this study was to investigate
differences in diabetes knowledge, attitudes
and perceptions (KAP), self-care practices as
related to assessment of chronic illness care
among people with diabetes consulting in a
family physician-led tertiary hospital-based
out-patient clinic versus local government
health unit-based health centers in the
Philippines.
Introduction
People with chronic conditions encounter many day to-day situations where
they have to make decisions on their own
self-care plays an important role and collaboration rather than a health
provider-directed care may be a more effective care model .
Such may involve self-management education and skills development.
However, the provision of self-management education and support is not
simple.
It does not only involve the development of selfmanagement skills but
barriers should also be addressed
These barriers include personal, social and environmental barriers
Introduction
Personal
barriers include disease-related beliefs,
emotions, knowledge and experiences ;
Sociocultural
barriers take account of the differences
in language,and in cultural and ethnic beliefs and
perceptions of health and illness between the
providers and the recipients of self-management
development; and
Environmental
barriers refer to the immediate
environment of family and friends and the wider
environment of the health care system and the
community in supporting adoption of proper self-care
behavior.
Introduction
Studies
have demonstrated that culturally
competent self-management education
improved diabetes care, self-awareness and
understanding of diabetes
Patient-centered,
biopsychosocial approaches
as practiced in the family medicine paradigm
address personal barriers and improved
diabetes knowledge, patient perceived
selfefficacy and glycemia
It
should be noted that self-management skills
METHODS
This
was a cross-sectional study conducted from
October 2010 to September 2011 involving
people with diabetes consulting at the
purposively selected sites VMMC and LGHU of
Batac City and Pagudpud.
The main outcomes of interest were: diabetes
knowledge, attitudes, perceptions, Self-care
practices and patients assessment of chronic
illness care (PACIC) of the people with diabetes in
the two study settings.
METHOD
People
with diabetes consulting in the said primary care
services were interviewed making use of questionnaires
adapted from previously tested and validated KAP
questionnaires and the patients assessment of chronic
illness care (PACIC) questionnaire.
Adherence
to medications, diabetes diet, and exercise and
the number of diabetes consultations were asked.
Analysis
of variance was used to determine differences in
KAP, self-care practices, and PACIC and regression analysis
was used to determine any associations of the
abovementioned variables to the PACIC ratings.
RESULTS
A total of 549 respondents were included in the
study. Differences in knowledge, attitudes,
perceptions, PACIC, utilization of health services,
and adherence to medications and exercise were
all statistically significant.
able 2 Age- and gender-adjusted mean (95% confidence intervals) KAP and PACIC, and p values of the differences in
KAP and PACIC of people with diabetes consulting at the family physician-led hospital-based (VMMC) vs. local
factor
VMMC
LGHU
P value
Diabetes knowledge
70.7
58.7
<0.001
Positive attitude
3.7
3.3
0.002
Negative attitude
2.2
3.1
0.001
Fear
2.6
3.5
0.076
Perceived support
needs
2.7
4.3
<0.001
Perceived support
received
3.5
4.4
<0.001
Perceived support
attitudes
5.0
4.6
<0.001
Perceived ability to
perform self-care
3.7
3.2
<0.001
Patients assessment
of chronic illness care
2.6
3.2
0.016
DISCUSSION
It
seems that the patient-centered, active listeningbased, biopsychosocial approaches practiced by family
physicians at the VMMC contribute to better
knowledge, attitudes and perceptions among people
with diabetes as was corroborated by this research.
Adopting
self-care entails changes in behavior. Such
behaviour change should be understood as part of an
interpersonal process that may be enhanced by a
collaborative, patient-centered approach and an
effective and clear communication process between
the health care provider and the person with chronic
condition.
DISCUSSION
Patients
assessment of chronic illness care (PACIC)
ratings were higher among those consulting at The
LGHU.
It
may be that respondents from the LGHUbased
health services do not have high expectations or
may not be knowledgeable enough to have such
expectations from their health service, thus their
higher PACIC ratings.
More
than that, the socio-cultural homogeneity of
the health care workers serving people with diabetes
within their own communities in the LGHU-based
health service may have played a role especially
DISCUSSION
Socio-cultural barriers exist in the family physician-led health service as
patients come from all over the country and, as is typical in group practices,
may be seen by a different health care worker each time they consult.
Problem solving may be viewed to be better if the person with diabetes
collaborates with a health care worker without any socio-cultural barriers ,
which is the case in the LGHUs.
The perception of better follow-up and coordination may be enhanced by the
home visits done by the BHW.
DISCUSSION
Combining family medicine principles
and cultural
competence
DISCUSSION
Ideally,
self-management education and
skills development should be carried out by
a team of professionals, which include
primary care physicians, specialists, nurses,
nutritionist/dietitians, psychologists [35].
However,
such professional composition
and creation of teams concentrating solely
on chronic care delivery are not possible
across all areas in low- and middle-income
countries.
DISCUSSION
In
a wider portion of these countries, professional
health care providers are limited to nonspecialist
physicians or nurses. Considering this context,a
collaborative biopsychosocial approach practiced
by a care provider having a similar socio-cultural
background would be preferred to engage the
person with chronic conditions to adopt and
adhere to self-care behavior
DISCUSSION
This
may be addressed by training LGHU
staff on family medicine-based care such as
patient-centered, biopsychosocial
approaches and the use of the CEA
methods and active listening skills.
CONCLUSION
Culturally
appropriate diabetes care that extends
from the clinics to the community provided by
health care personnel with similar socio-cultural
backgrounds may bring about better
collaborative care with people with diabetes.
On
the other hand, family medicine-based
approaches may contribute to improved
knowledge, attitudes, perceptions, and self-care
practices of people with diabetes.
RECOMMENDATION
Mutual enhancement of both family
medicineprofessionalism and cultural
competence is instrumental in
promoting self-efficacy and adoption of
adequate selfcare behavior in people
with diabetes.
