Global Desalination Trends and Qatar's Water Challenges
Global Desalination Trends and Qatar's Water Challenges
8%
22%
70%
The Composition of the Planet’s Water
Clean water
available Total water available to us 2.5 percent fresh water
Naturally
2.5; 3%
2%
30%
68%
97.5; 98%
glaciers
ground water
ocean
fresh water lakesand
fresh water rivers
• Potential of desalinated water
Desalination is the answer to global water scarcity with the help of emerging
technology
As earth has enough water in the form of sea which can be made potable using
desalination
NEED FOR
DESALINATION
Technology used for global water desalination
(pie chart )
ED Hybrid
MED 2%
3%
8%
Desalinated water production
world wide MSF
60000000 26%
50000000
40000000
30000000
20000000
RO
10000000 61%
0
Category 1
RO MSF
MED Hybrid and others
•World desalination capacity
Middle East Asia Europe Africa North & South America
WORLD
DESALINATION
7%
INDEX
8%
12%
8%
65%
Gulf Thermal
& RO
Desalination
Capacity
Chart Title
10000000 9855977
9000000
8000000
7000000
6000000
5000000
4000000 1529429
3000000
759785
2000000
1000000
0
Category 1
msf med ro
Thermal desalination uses
Pump is the only component
75kw/h where as the RO
to consume major portion of
uses only 5 kw/h for
electricity.
100m3/h
RECENT
TREND AND Membranes are made up of
RO has a modular plant
BENEFIT OF structure.
polymer/callous material
which are non corrosive
RO OVER
THERMAL
Caribbean 2,466
Asia/Pacific 2,970
Europe 4,741
18
1000
16
Desalination 14
plants and their 12
800
capacities of the
10 600
Arabian gulf
(1970-2012) 8
400
6
4
200
2
0 0
KSA Qatar Bahrain Kuwait UAE Oman KSA Qatar Bahrain Kuwait UAE oman
350
future 14
desalination 12
300
4 4 100
4 100
3 3
63
2 2
50 45 48.952
2
1 1 1 1 1 19.8
0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0
0 0
KSA Qatar Bahrain Kuwait UAE Oman KSA Qatar Bahrain Kuwait UAE Oman
3000 2658
2500
desalination capacity
technologies 1500
1251
1000
558
413
376.5
500
0
Existing plant capacity Future plant capacity
RO MSF MED
First plant was established
using submerged tube Two plants were built in
process having an out put Ras Laffan and one at Ras
of 150040 gallons /day Abu Fantaas
HISTORY OF SEA
WATER
1953 1962 1977 1982
DESALINATION IN
QATAR
First Multi Stage Flash First RO plant at Abu
evaporation process was Samra with a capacity of
installed at Rass Abu 149600
Abood with a capacity of gallons/day(680m3/day)
1.5 MIGD
AVAILABILITY OF WATER
CHALLENGES
FOR QATAR THE POPULATION OF QATAR IS INCREASING FROM 1995 EXPONENTIALLY
3.5
Population 3
and 2.5
Desalinate 2
d Water 1.5
Production 1
2000-2018 0.5
0
2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018
Qatar Population Growth(in millions) Total Production of Desalintion Plants (million cubic meter/day)
Overall capacity of Qatar sea water desalination up to 2010
DESALINATION
CAPACITY OF
QATAR
• Overall capacity MSF MED RO
• Thermal capacity
Expected Qatar sweater desalinati on 2018-2022
MSF
MED
• RO capacity RO
39%
MSF
46%
MED
15%
MSF MED RO
DESALINTI
ON
PLANTS IN
QATAR
Locations of the
4 major Plants
1. Rass Abu Fantas
2. Umm-Halul
3. Rass Laffan
4. Rass Abu Abood
R&D IN THE FIELD OF WATER
DESALINATION AND NEW
POSSIBILITIES
• Hybrid
• Membrane based(nf/uf)
• Solar integration
• Forward osmosis
• Solar powered desalition
OVERVIEW
• Introduction
• Need for desalination
• World Desalination Index
• Gulf thermal and RO desalination capacity and
recent trends
• water challenges for Qatar
• History of seawater desalination in Qatar
• desalination capacity of Qatar ( RO and
Thermal )
• Conclusions
State Of Qatar
Attractive Destinations
[Link]
Global Water Crisis: H2O QUICK FACTS
• Water scarcity will be one of the defining features of the 21st century.
• The U.N. predicts that by 2025 two thirds of the world's population
will suffer water shortages.
• Compared to today, five times as much land is likely to be under
“extreme drought” by 2050.
• By 2050, 1 in 5 developing countries will face water shortages.
Sources: United Nation’s Food and Agriculture Organization; World Health Organization; UNICEF, 2015
Qatar Scenario…
• Water stress is rising due to rapidly growing demands from population growth,
industrialization, urbanization and agriculture
• Qatar Nation Vision 2030:The scarcity of renewable water resources and the
escalating competition for water is a major challenge in the sustainable development
agenda for Qatar
• Innovative desalination technologies that minimize both cost of water production and
the environmental impact should be further investigated
n in the
Domestic usage and Arabian
gulf region
2.5; 3%
glaciers
domestic
ground water
2% 8% industrial
fresh water
30% lakesand rivers agriculture
22%
97.5; 98% 68% 70%
ocean
fresh
water
Desalination is the answer to global water scarcity with the help
of emerging technology As earth has enough water in the form
of sea which can be made potable using desalination
8000
6000 5067.31 7%
4000
1559.18 8% Asia
2000 974.5
0
Europe
RO MSF MED Hybrid & other 12%
8% North &
MED ED Hybrid 65%
South
8% 3% 2% America
MSF
26%
RO
61%
GULF THERMAL & RO DESALINATION
CAPACITY
2500
2168
2000
1500
MIGD
1000
336.43
500
167.14
0 MSF MED RO
82 % 12%
6%
Desalination Capacities of the Arabian Gulf
(1970-2012)
Number of Desalina- Desalination capacity
tion Plants in the Gulf of existing plant
19 1110
16
NUMBER OF PLANTS
12 12
MIGD
647
473
7 7 7
6
5 263
245
3 3 183
2 2 2
1 77
1 65 74.5 52 54 95
70
KSA Qatar Bahrain Kuwait0 UAE Oman 14.5
KSA 0.2
Qatar Bahrain 25
Kuwait0 UAE Oman0
16
369
MIGD
249
9
7 201
157
132.244
4 4 96 100
3 3 70 80
2 1 2 1 63 48.9
1 1 1 19.8 52
KSA Qatar Bahrain
0 Kuwait0 UAE 0 Oman0 KSA Qatar Bahrain
0 Kuwait5 UAE
0 Oman
0 0
3373
3500
• Less power consumption 26 %
3000
2658
2500
• Modular Nature of RO
2000
MIGD
1500
• Membranes 1128
%
1000 175
558
413 376.5
48.2%
• Small footprint 500
77%
12% 11 24% 65% 10.7%
0 %
Existing plant capacity Future plant capacity 2012-
UPTO-2012 2018& BEYOND
3.5
2.64
2.5
& Million
2.3 2.3
2.15
2
1.75
1.65 1.651.7
1.5
M3/day
1.23
1 1
0.9
0.8 0.75
0.7
0.6
2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018
Qatar Population Growth(in millions)
Moving average (Qatar Population Growth(in millions))
Total Production of Desalintion Plants (million cubic meter/day)
Exponential (Total Production of Desalintion Plants (million cubic meter/day))
HISTORY OF SEA WATER
DESALINATION IN QATAR
First plant was Two plants
established were built in
using submerged Ras Laffan RAS ABU
tube process and one at FAONTAS
having an out Ras Abu SWROMPLANT
put of 150040 Faontas 1& with a capacity
gallons /day 2 of 36 MIGD
2016-
1953 1962 1977 1982 2017-2018
2017
Umm Al Houl
First Multi First RO power and
Stage Flash plant at
water project is
evaporation Abu Samra
process was with a 136.5 MIGD
installed at capacity of (621,000 m3/d)
Rass Abu 149600 Using SWRO
Aboud with a gallons/day(
capacity of 1.5 680m3/day)
MIGD
DESALINATION CAPACITY OF QATAR
RO Thermal 333
96
26.6%
263
Million gallons / day
100250 % 128
97%
65
RO Power (RO)
Conclusion
• Water scarcity will be one of the defining features of the 21st century.
• The U.N. predicts that by 2025 two thirds of the world's population
will suffer water shortages.
• Compared to today, five times as much land is likely to be under
“extreme drought” by 2050.
• By 2050, 1 in 5 developing countries will face water shortages.
Sources: United Nation’s Food and Agriculture Organization; World Health Organization; UNICEF, 2015
WATER A GRAND CHALLENGE FOR QNV2030
Qatar Seawater Challenges
Temperature
of feed water
Algae boom
& difference
of temperature
GULF DESALINATION CAPACITY
Desalination is the answer to global water scarcity
As earth has enough water in the form of sea which can be made potable using
emerging desalination Technology
MEMBRANE
DISTILLATION
Natural
Desalination:
Water Cycle!
• Major Stages
• 1. Evaporation
• 2. Condensation
• 3. Precipitation
• 4. Collection
Membrane Desalination
• Remove salt ions from water by using membranes that selectively permit or prevent the passage of
certain ions.
• Seawater Reverse Osmosis (SWRO) desalination
• Increasingly popular
• Advances in Technology
Equilibrium
Apply pressure to reveres the osmosis
Semi permeable
membrane
osmotic pressure
Pure salty
Water salty
Water Pure Water
Water
Water molecules Water molecules
Membrane Types
Based on Materials
Cellulose Acetate
One polymer
Tolerate oxidizing agents
Lower salt rejection
Polyamide
Two or three polymers
Less net driving pressure
Based on Configuration
Hollow fine fiber
Spiral wound
Tubular
Plate & Frame
Fabrication methods currently used
in FO membrane
Polyamide 200 nm
Polysulfone support 60 mm
Polyester Reinforcing web 300 mm
Drawbacks:
• Hydrophobic
• Rough
• Not chlorine resistant
• organic solvent
• Thickness
• composition
58
Selection criteria of Membrane
• Sustainable Performance
• Product flow
• Salt rejection
• Performance depends on
• Feed water quality
• Inherent membrane properties
• Chemistry, spacer, membrane area etc.
• Operation conditions
• Flux, recovery etc.
59 59
Spiral Wound Membrane
Product Reject
water Reject
water
water
Reject
water
Product water
Feed
water Feed
water
Feed
Product water
water
Product
Feed
Schematic Diagram of SWRO Desalination Process
High-pressure pump
Intake Reject
61
Major Research Challenges for membrane based desilnation
Major Issues with SWRO Processes Major Issues with Membrane Processes
• Solutions to the Problems • Membrane Fouling
• Undesirable deposition or accumulation of
• Improvement of the Process
solids on the membrane surface
• Preservation of the Environment • Happens when rejected particles are not
transported from the surface of the membrane
back to the bulk stream
Types of Fouling
Reversible
The membrane performance can be restored
by chemical cleaning
Irreversible
The performance cannot be restored at all even by
applying rigorous chemical cleaning
62
Different Types of Foulants
Biofouling
Outcome of Fouling
• Production loss
• Low permeate quality
• Higher pressure demand – Higher energy
• Additional labor
• Chemicals for cleaning
• Lowering of membrane life
Desalination is the answer to global water scarcity with the
help of emerging technology As earth has enough water in
the form of sea which can be made potable using
desalination
Overall increase in
Recent trend and benefit of Desalination capacity
RO over thermal Technologies
Product Virtual-water
content (liters)
1 sheet of paper (80 g/m2) 10
1 tomato (70 g) 13
1 slice of bread (30 g) 40
1 orange (100 g) 50
1 apple (100 g) 70
1 glass of beer (250 ml) 75
1 glass of wine (125 ml) 120
1 egg (40 g) 135
1 glass of orange juice (200 ml) 170
1 bag of potato crisps (200 g) 185
1 glass of milk (200 ml) 200
1 hamburger (150 g) 2,400
1 cotton T-shirt 2,700
1 pair of shoes (bovine leather) 8,000
Virtual water used in six types of fuels, for a
round trip New York City- Washington D.C.
Amount of water needed in the
Type of fuel extraction/production of 2 Million
BTUs of energy
The average person living in the US consumes about 2220 gallons of water a day: That’s 44
bathtubs each day. Diet makes a big difference: a vegetarian’ water footprint can be less than
50% of a meat eater’s footprint.
Two people, one land, one aquifer:
Water and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict
Addressing Water Shortages
Increasing water supply?
•Dams (dramatic ecological and social consequences).
•Pumping aquifers (20% aquifers are already being mined beyond their rate of
recharge, including the Upper Ganges Valley in India and Pakistan, the Nile Delta
Region in Egypt, and the Central Valley in California).
•Desalination: energy-intensive and costly.
Dealination in California: $1800-$2800 per AF
Groundwater: $375-$1100 per AF
Surface water: $400-$800 per AF
•Water Conservation
Micro-irrigation – reuse and recycle wastewater
Cost of conservation (San Diego county): $150-$1000 per AF
Price
A
Supply (MC)
P*
B C
PE
PS
Demand
Q* QE QS Quantity of Water
Major Stages
1. Evaporation
2. Condensation
3. Precipitation
4. Collection
© Brain Wrinkles
Introduction
Human Drinking water requirement: It has a pH close to 7. This differs from the pH levels of fresh water
which depends on the geology of the topographical surface containing it "ground/surface" and the intake
feed (rain, stream discharge, agricultural / industrial drainage, etc) which end up affecting the suspended
dissolved particles within the water that may affect the pH of it and could lead to increasing its hardness if
Calcium ion concentrations increased. This pH could fluctuates within permissible limits (the Egyptian Code
allows it to reach a range of 6.5 to 8.5.
It needs to be safe for consumption from toxicity / hazard (an excerpt from the Egyptian Code, the list is
much more extensive though):
Mineral / Maximum Mineral / Contaminant Maximum Concentration /
Contaminant Concentration / Exposure
Exposure
Lead 1 mg/L SO4 250 mg/L
Selenium 0.05 mg/L CL (all CL compounds) 250 mg/L
Arsenic 0.2 mg/L Fe 00.3 mg/L
Hexavalent 0.01-0.05 mg/L Mn 0.4 mg/L
Chromium
Wastewater production in
the GCC countries in billion
cubic meters per year
Source: [Link]
GCC COUNTRIES WASTEWATER PRODUCTION
Source: [Link]
WASTEWATER TREATMENT
BAHRAIN
• Authorized a lot of legislation to control water use and regulate groundwater
but is yet to consolidate it into comprehensive law
• with their management as a common good. By that rationale, groundwater is
public/state property. Bahrain has 11 wastewater treatment plants, most of
which use aeration technology with 150 Mm 3/year capacity
KUWAIT
• The Kuwaiti Government has a commitment to protect the public by
enacting new measures and laws to help safeguard water usage
• Kuwait has put in place wastewater quality control regulations in order
to protect public health and supply clean water for drinking and other
purposes
WASTEWATER REUSE IN QATAR
Water requirements in Doha are continuously growing and the
capital has very low rainfall levels.
By using additionally treated wastewater,
which is of very high quality and contains
Through advanced technologies, such as ultrafiltration membranes, nutrients, crop growers have produced
the Doha West plant can reuse 100% of treated wastewater. better yields and reduced their use of
artificial fertilizers.
270 K m3 of TTE is used daily for landscape irrigation and to produce fodder
but not edible production
Inappropriate infrastructure
Environmental Footprint
Water production and re-use
Considering that Qatar depends entirely on water desalination processes supporting a capacity of 1.2 Mm3/d,
at the expense of 101.52 GW h/d [68], solar thermal collectors could beneficially operate in favour of water
21
desalting [68]. Taking advantage from the regional high temperature, their operation could enable the direct
power supply of both heat and electricity-driven desalination units. Furthermore, the incorporation of solar
energy on water recovery processes, through desalination, is in line with the nation’s intention of
decarbonising this energy expensive sector, moving towards a more sustainable and renewable-based system
and economy
Increasing water demand
• ➢ It is strongly suggested that Kahrama costumer’s database linked with the National Address initiative which controlled by the Minister of Interior, to limit the water overconsumption and strictly
implement the conversation law. Additionally, this can lead to further collaborations from the side of central municipal council to control the consumptions by their area.
• ➢ An automated report should be issued along with bill that guide the consumers on how they be can reduce their water consumption. Such reports can explain where most of the water overconsume,
dates and times.
• ➢ Improving Public Engagement: After examining the current responding to Tarsheed campaign it is suggested to set a partnership with the Ministry of Education and Higher Education for social inclusion
goals as well as demonstration the importance of water conversation for household. Policy makers and media can have significant impact to promote such partnership.
• ➢ Accessibility: Initiatives and awareness campaigns website should be more accessible and publicized among additional age categories.
• ➢ It is proposed to create a Demand-side management plan to highlight current and post FIFA World Cup needs.
• ➢ Improving Legal Frameworks: Detailed laws on water conversation should be adopted and adequately enforced. Increasing number of capacity building particularly in a technical way specialised in green
growth and sustainability along-side with Shura Council, Central Municipal Council. Water overconsumption prevention polices should be disseminated more widely at all levels.
• ➢ Improving Technology Transfer: Water infrastructure, including efficient irrigation systems and a wide distribution of recycled treaded water for agricultural purposes bring undoubted benefits. These
technologies include nature-based as well as engineering based. Global partnerships is a good platform to exchange scientific information (Table 1), this can be done with the foreign ministers.
• ➢ Improving Economic and Fiscal Tools: Improved tools for understanding the true costs of water production and the burden that the country holds and provide a simulated scenario for alternative options
when everyone shows responsibilities.
• future technology
• TSE has been used in landscaping and irrigation applications for
• many years. This effluent is now considered for use in Qatar’s district cooling systems
in 1990 to 841 Mm in 201473 Mm3 of TSE which represents 17 % of total TSE demand
3
by 2020
• (Jasim et al., 2016). Using TSE as an alternative to potable water in district cooling plants (DCP) will
serve
• nearly 39 Mm3/y of potable water by 2023 (Jasim et al., 2016).
• DCPs in Lusail city have been designed to use TSE water and potable water. Lusail is a city of 38 km2,
and is
• able to accommodate 200,000 residents, 170,000 employees and 80,000 visitors
Qatar is ther most water stressed country In the world as per research sdtuides
full railing on the desalinated top closed to 80 % water needs leads toi very high carbon foot rpitn
generating approx. 4,66 million ton of co2 each year
the bosst on self relince has increased the agricultuiral consumption to 41 % of Qatar total water
ocncsumptioni and duree to covid lock down housr hold uses also saw an increase and rose to 35 %
The high energy consumption has led to the
net increase in Qatar’s energy intensity between 2009 and 2015. Ideally, energy intensity
should be decreasing year on year when a country is becoming energy efficient. Decreasing
energy intensity means that more economic output is generated with less energy, as seen in the
USA, UK, Turkey, China, and the world average,
The tarsheed invitiate
• In 2012 Kahramaa
• launched a 5-year National Conservation Campaign (Tarsheed) under the banner “Keep
Qatar
• Pulsing, Consume Wisely”. The campaign hinges on the drive to preserving the
environment
• and natural resources through three main objectives; (1) increasing the efficiency in the
• electricity and water sectors, (2) stopping waste and mindless consumption, and (3)
reducing
• the consumption of electricity by 20% and water by 35% over the 5-year period
Toliet flus use should be piped
separately with treated water
Production capacity of potable desalinated water in Qatar until the end of 2019 was 476
Million Imperial Gallons per Day (MIGD) and is expected to reach 536 MIGD by April 2021
with the commissioning of additional production capacity in Umm Al Houl and 636 MIGD by
April 2023 with the commissioning of a new desalination plant (Facility E).
• Development of Water Network
• The transmission water network at KAHRAMAA is now reaching a total length of 1,440
Kilometers with the beginning of the functionality of Mega Reservoirs. The distribution
networks are reaching 8,380 kilometers and it is planned to be increased to reach 10,000
kilometers by the end of 2022.
•
Water Reservoirs and Pumping Stations
At the same time, other water projects are being planned to include the
construction of reservoirs in many existing stations, in addition to current
plans for the construction of more reservoir and pumping stations to meet
the growing demand. In addition to it, in the last 10 years, the number of
reservoir and pumping stations had increased from 22 to 37 and water
storage capacity increased almost 6 times from 290 MIG to 1648 MIGD.
Mega Reservoirs commissioned in 2019 and total storage capacity will
increase further to 2392 MIGD.
• National Water Control Center (NWCC)
The National Water Control Center is operated as a centralized water control and monitoring center with a state-of-the-art Water SCADA
system to efficiently and effectively control and monitor the water system and guarantee a high performance of KAHRAMAA water
pumping, storage, transmission and distribution with addition to other vital activities within water strategic management.
• It also has a system that detects and warns of radioactive contaminants in water. An online Seawater Radiation monitoring system was
commissioned in April 2015. Buoys has been installed in the sea and sampler in the onshore to monitor radioactive material presence in
the seawater. The radiation level (Beta, Alpha, Gamma) is monitored at all entrances of desalination plants. In addition to it, KAHRAMAA
had recently commissioned a Real Time System, Acute Toxicity Monitoring of Drinking Water for Chemical, Biological and Radiation
Monitoring at some pumping stations. This system will be implemented at all pumping stations and expected to be fully accomplished
by 2022. KAHRAMAA coordinates to deal with emergencies cases concerning increased radiation and toxic level in water facilities.
•
Water Quality (WLab)
Water quality laboratory monitors quality of drinking water supplied through KAHRAMAA distribution network and ensures that safe
drinking water is being served to the whole nation of Qatar. Water quality laboratory is well equipped with state-of-the-art analytical
equipment in the field of Physical, Chemical and Microbiological analysis. Being accredited to the most prestigious international
standard “ISO - 17025", water quality laboratory ensures the quality of drinking water through accurate, reliable and systemic water
testing services under the umbrella of “WHO guidelines for drinking water quality" and “KAHRAMAA drinking water quality requirement".
•
Water Demand
Statistical data in the water sector shows a remarkable growth in the water demand. To give a comparative trend, the increase has
amounted to 197 MIGD in September 2008, from 138 MIGD in 2007, and less than 61 MIGD in 1997. Water demand is continuously
rising and reached to 420 MIGD in 2019. This number is expected to go up to 487 MIGD in 2022.
• pollution caused by oil spills, red tides, or other factors;
nuclear contamination; power outages or hackers
disabling desalination plants; natural disasters such as
hurricanes or earthquakes; and acts of war.
Solar Energy Distillation
• This distillation system uniqueness is in the utilization of concentrated solar energy which is a
clean source to heat seawater. The design challenge is in the wasted heat that get reflected off
the large scale solar collectors / concentrators dishes / systems. Accordingly, the thermal
solution is to use heat recovery systems in addition to pairing the system with lower pressure
vacuum pumps of the seawater tanks as this would lead to lower boiling / evaporation point
( at 0.1 atmospheric pressure, water would boil at 50 °C).
• Another challenge is the large land area needed to collect enough energy for commercially
viable desalination; due to this, such projects could pair up with other energy sources like wind
power. However, both are dependent on natural local weather patterns and hence require
careful planning for the site based on wind speed/direction and volume and solar illumination.
An MSF solar Distillation plant could generate up to 60 liters of fresh water per utilized m2 per
day.