Google Cloud Platform Blog: Open

Google Cloud Platform Blog

Product updates, customer stories, and tips and tricks on Google Cloud Platform

Introducing Kayenta: An open automated canary analysis tool from Google and Netflix

Tuesday, April 10, 2018

By Nikhil Kaul, Product Marketing Manager & Andrew Phillips, Product Manager automated canary analysisSpinnaker "Automated canary analysis is an essential part of the production deployment process at Netflix and we are excited to release Kayenta. Our partnership with Google on Kayenta has yielded a flexible architecture that helps perform automated canary analysis on a wide range of deployment scenarios such as application, configuration and data changes. Spinnaker’s integration with Kayenta allows teams to stay close to their pipelines and deployments without having to jump into a different tool for canary analysis. By the end of the year, we expect Kayenta to be making thousands of canary judgments per day. Spinnaker and Kayenta are fast, reliable and easy-to-use tools that minimize deployment risk, while allowing high velocity at scale."

— Greg Burrell, Senior Reliability Engineer at Netflix (read more in Netflix’s blog post)

“Canary analysis along with Spinnaker deployment pipelines enables us to automatically identify bad deployments. With 1000+ pipelines running in production, any form of human intervention as a part of canary analysis can be a huge blocker to our continuous delivery efforts. Automated canary deployment, as enabled by Kayenta, has allowed our team to increase development velocity by detecting anomalies faster. Additionally, being open source, standardizing on Kayenta helps reduce the risk of vendor lock-in. We look forward to working closely with Google and Netflix to further integrate Kayenta into our development cycle and get rid of our self-developed Jenkins job canary”

— Tom Feiner, Systems Operations Engineer at Waze Continuous delivery challenges at scale

Speed and scalability bottlenecks: For organizations like Google and Netflix that run at scale and that want to perform comparisons many times over multiple deployments in a single day, manual canary analysis isn't really an option. Even for other organizations, a manual approach to canary analysis can’t keep up with the speed and shorter delivery time frame of continuous delivery. Configuring dashboards for each canary release can be a significant manual effort, and manually comparing hundreds of different metrics across the canary and baseline is tiresome and laborious.

Accounting for human error: Manual canary analysis requires subjective assessment and is prone to human bias and error. It can be hard for people to separate real issues from noise. Humans often make mistakes while interpreting metrics and logs and deciding whether to promote or fail the canary. Collecting, monitoring and then aggregating multiple canary metrics for analysis in a manual manner further adds to the areas where an error can be made because of human judgement.

Risk of incorrect decisions: Comparing short-term metrics of a new deployment to the long-running production instances in a manual or ad-hoc fashion is an inaccurate way to identify the health of the canary. Mainly because it can be hard to distinguish whether the performance deviations you see in the canary are statistically relevant or simply random. As a result, you may end up pushing bad deployments to production.

Poor support for advanced use cases: To optimize the continuous delivery cycle with canary analysis, you need a high degree of confidence about whether to promote or fail the canary. But gaining the confidence to make go/no-go decisions based on manual or ad-hoc processes is time-consuming, primarily because a manual or ad-hoc canary analysis can’t handle advanced use cases such as adjusting boundaries and parameters in real-time.

The Kayenta approach

Open: Enterprise teams that want to perform automated canary analysis with commercial offerings must provide confidential metrics to the provider, resulting in vendor lock-in.

Built for hybrid and multi-cloud: Kayenta provides a consistent way to detect problems across canaries, irrespective of the target environment. Given its integration to Spinnaker, Kayenta lets teams perform automated canary analysis across multiple environments, including Google Cloud Platform (GCP), Kubernetes, on-premise servers or other cloud providers.

Extensible: Kayenta makes it easy to add new metric sources, judges, and data stores. As a result, you can configure Kayenta to serve more diverse environments as your needs change.

Gives confidence quickly: Kayenta lets you adjust boundaries and parameters while performing automatic canary analysis. This lets you move fast and decide whether to promote or fail the canary as soon as you’ve collected enough data.

Low overhead: It's easy to get started with Kayenta. No need to write custom scripts or manually fetch canary metrics, merge these metrics or perform statistical analysis to decide whether to either deploy or rollback the canary. Deep links are provided by Kayenta within canary analysis results for in-depth diagnostic purposes.

Insight: For advanced use cases, Kayenta can help perform retrospective canary analysis. This gives engineering and operations teams insights into how to refine and improve canary analysis over time.