Osp 14992
Osp 14992
50/4 | 2021
Varia
Édition électronique
URL : https://journals.openedition.org/osp/14992
DOI : 10.4000/osp.14992
ISSN : 2104-3795
Éditeur
Institut national d’étude du travail et d’orientation professionnelle (INETOP)
Édition imprimée
Date de publication : 15 décembre 2021
Pagination : 623-652
ISSN : 0249-6739
Référence électronique
Audrey Imberdis, Marie-Christine Toczek, Marion Dutrévis et Margault Sacré, « Disciplines scolaires et
stéréotypes de genre : perceptions d’élèves et d’enseignant·es », L'orientation scolaire et professionnelle
[En ligne], 50/4 | 2021, mis en ligne le 01 décembre 2023, consulté le 08 janvier 2024. URL : http://
journals.openedition.org/osp/14992 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/osp.14992
Le texte et les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés), sont « Tous droits réservés »,
sauf mention contraire.
Disciplines scolaires et stéréotypes de genre : perceptions d’élèves et d’ens... 1
'LVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVHWVW«U«RW\SHV
GHJHQUHbSHUFHSWLRQVGɛ«OªYHVHW
GɛHQVHLJQDQWyHV
School subjects and gender stereotypes: Pupils’ and teachers’ perceptions
b
1. Introduction
1 4XHFHVRLWDXQLYHDXLQVWLWXWLRQQHORXVFLHQWLILTXHOHV«WXGHVVɛDFFRUGHQWGHSXLVGHV
DQQ«HV VXU OD U«XVVLWH VFRODLUH DFFUXH GHV ILOOHV HJ %DXGHORW (VWDEOHW b
0LQLVWªUH GH OɛGXFDWLRQ QDWLRQDOH HW GH OD -HXQHVVH 0LQLVWªUH GH Oɛ(QVHLJQHPHQW
VXS«ULHXU GH OD 5HFKHUFKH HW GH Oɛ,QQRYDWLRQ 'LUHFWLRQ GH OɛYDOXDWLRQ GH OD
3URVSHFWLYHHWGHOD3HUIRUPDQFH 0(1-0(65,'(33 b9R\HU 9R\HU (Q
HIIHW GªV OɛHQWU«H ¢ Oɛ«FROH «O«PHQWDLUH HW WRXW DX ORQJ GH OHXU SDUFRXUV VFRODLUH
MXVTXɛDXEDFFDODXU«DWOHVILOOHVSU«VHQWHQWGHPHLOOHXUHVSHUIRUPDQFHVVFRODLUHVTXHOHV
JDU©RQV'HVQXDQFHVVRQWFHSHQGDQW¢DSSRUWHUVHORQOHVGLVFLSOLQHVHWVHORQOHQLYHDX
GDQVOHFXUVXVVFRODLUH &KDEDQRQ 6WHLQPHW] &ɛHVWHQIUDQ©DLVHWHQODQJXHV
YLYDQWHVTXHOHVGLII«UHQFHVHQIDYHXUGHVILOOHVDSSDUDLVVHQWOHSOXVW¶WHWUHVWHQWOH
SOXV PDUTX«HV WRXW DX ORQJ GH OD VFRODULW« /HV JDU©RQV REWLHQQHQW TXDQW ¢ HX[ GH
PHLOOHXUV U«VXOWDWV HQ VFLHQFHV KLVWRLUH J«RJUDSKLHHW «GXFDWLRQ FLYLTXH ¢ Oɛ«FROH
SULPDLUH «FDUWIDLEOH HWDXFROOªJH «FDUWXQSHXSOXVPDUTX« &HVGLII«UHQFHVGH
U«XVVLWHVFRODLUHUHOHY«HVHQ)UDQFHOɛRQW«W«GHID©RQVLPLODLUHGDQVGLII«UHQWVSD\V
2&'( /HVVW«U«RW\SHVVHPEOHQWWHQLUXQU¶OHSULPRUGLDOGDQVOɛH[SOLFDWLRQGH
FHV«FDUWVGHU«XVVLWHHQWUHOHVILOOHVHWOHVJDU©RQV
b
2 /HVVW«U«RW\SHVLG«HVLPSOLFLWHPHQWY«KLFXO«HVSDUODVRFL«W«VRQWXQHQVHPEOHGH
UHSU«VHQWDWLRQV GH FDUDFW«ULVWLTXHV TXH OɛRQ DWWULEXH FRPPXQ«PHQW ¢ XQ LQGLYLGX
GɛDSUªV VRQ DSSDUWHQDQFH ¢ XQ JURXSH 0F*DUW\ HW DO /HV FULWªUHV GH
FDW«JRULVDWLRQ SHXYHQW ¬WUH GH QDWXUHV GLII«UHQWHVb LGHQWLW« UHOLJLHXVH SROLWLTXH
HWKQLTXHVH[XHOOHbDSSDUWHQDQFH¢XQHFODVVHVRFLDOHDSSDUHQFHSK\VLTXHɣ/RUVTXH
FHV VW«U«RW\SHV FRQFHUQHQW GHV FUR\DQFHV VXU OHV ILOOHV HW OHV JDU©RQV HQ WDQW
TXɛLQGLYLGXVDSSDUWHQDQW¢XQHGHVGHX[FDW«JRULHVRQSDUOHGHVW«U«RW\SHVGHJHQUH
6LODQRWLRQGHVH[HGLII«UHQFLHOHVKRPPHVHWOHVIHPPHVGɛXQSRLQWGHYXHELRORJLTXH
ODQRWLRQGHJHQUHFRQVWLWXHTXDQW¢HOOHXQV\VWªPHGHQRUPHVVH[X«HVH[FOXVLYHPHQW
FRQVWUXLWSDUOHVUDSSRUWVVRFLDX[TXLG«WHUPLQHQWHWKL«UDUFKLVHQWOHI«PLQLQHWOH
PDVFXOLQ &ROOHW $LQVLGHSXLVODQDLVVDQFHFKDFXQyHDSSUHQG¢WUDYHUVODVSKªUH
IDPLOLDOH OD FUªFKH Oɛ«FROH OHV P«GLDV mbGHV VLJQDX[ TXL DVVRFLHQW GHV WUDLWV GH
FDUDFWªUHGHVFRPS«WHQFHVGHVDWWLWXGHV¢XQVH[HSOXW¶WTXɛ¢XQDXWUHHWTXLIRUJHQW
QRWUHYLVLRQGHODSODFHHWGXU¶OHGHVKRPPHVHWGHVIHPPHVGDQVFHWWHVRFL«W«b}
&RVWHHWDOSb 'HQRPEUHX[DFWHXUyWULFHVHWPLOLHX[ IDPLOOH«FROHWUDYDLO
DPLyHVɣ VRQWLPSOLTX«VGDQVOHG«YHORSSHPHQWGHFKDTXHLQGLYLGXbFɛHVWOHSURFHVVXV
GH VRFLDOLVDWLRQ GH JHQUH &HV LQIOXHQFHV SOXULHOOHV LQGXLVHQW XQH FRQVWUXFWLRQ
LGHQWLWDLUHGLII«UHQFL«HTXLGDQVOHFDGUHVFRODLUHDXQHIIHWGLUHFWVXUOɛRULHQWDWLRQHW
OHV SDUFRXUV VFRODLUHV GHV ILOOHV HW GHV JDU©RQV 0LH\DD HW DO /HV HQIDQWV
DSSUHQQHQWDLQVLWUªVW¶W¢¬WUHFRQIRUPHVDX[QRUPHVVH[X«HVHQXVDJHGDQVODVRFL«W«
HWORUVTXɛLOVHQWUHQW¢Oɛ«FROHLOVHWHOOHVRQWG«M¢ELHQDVVLPLO«OHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGX
V\VWªPHGHJHQUH &ROOHW&RVWHHWDO 6LOɛ«FROHHVWOHOLHXGHWUDQVPLVVLRQ
GHVVDYRLUVFɛHVWDXVVLFHOXLGHOɛDSSUHQWLVVDJH¢¬WUHXQHILOOHXQJDU©RQHW¢GHYHQLU
XQHIHPPHXQKRPPHHQDG«TXDWLRQDYHFOHVUHSU«VHQWDWLRQVILJ«HVTXHQRWUHVRFL«W«
DVVLJQH¢FKDFXQGHVGHX[VH[HV *DXVVHO ,OH[LVWHUDLWXQgenre scolaire TXLVHUDLW
XQH FRQVWUXFWLRQ VS«FLILTXH SOXV RX PRLQV FRQVFLHQWH HQWUHWHQXH DX VHLQ GH
OɛLQVWLWXWLRQVFRODLUHSDUWRXVOHVLQGLYLGXVTXLODFRPSRVHQW DGXOWHVHWHQIDQWV HWTXL
IRUJHUDLW OHV LGHQWLW«V Gɛ«OªYHILOOH RX Gɛ«OªYHJDU©RQ DX[TXHOOHV VRQW DVVRFL«V GHV
PDQLªUHV Gɛ¬WUHHQFODVVH HW GHV FKRL[ SU«I«UHQWLHOV 'H %RLVVLHX 'LII«UHQWV
VW«U«RW\SHV GH JHQUH OL«V DX FRQWH[WH VFRODLUH H[LVWHQW SDUPL OHVTXHOV OHV IDFLOLW«V
VXSSRV«HVGHVJDU©RQVGDQVOHVGRPDLQHVPDWK«PDWLTXHVHWVFLHQWLILTXHVHWFHOOHVGHV
ILOOHVGDQVOHVGRPDLQHVOLWW«UDLUHVHWDUWLVWLTXHV/ɛLQIOXHQFHGHFHVVW«U«RW\SHVQɛDJLW
SDVVHXOHPHQWGHPDQLªUHLQGLYLGXHOOHHQU«SRQVHDX[modèles VRFLDX[&ɛHVW«JDOHPHQW
GDQVODUHODWLRQLQWHU«OªYHVFRQVWLWXWLYHGHOɛH[S«ULHQFHVFRODLUHTXɛHVWHQWUHWHQXFH
SK«QRPªQHbmbODYLHTXRWLGLHQQHGHVFODVVHVIRUJHGHV«OªYHVJDU©RQVRXILOOHVb} 'XUX
%HOODWSb /HVSURJUDPPHVVFRODLUHVRIILFLHOVRQWEHDX¬WUHOHVP¬PHVSRXU
WRXV HW WRXWHV OHV «OªYHV VRQW LPSOLFLWHPHQW VRXPLV ¢ XQ V\VWªPH GH QRUPHV HW GH
YDOHXUV TXL OHV H[SRVH GH ID©RQ GLII«UHQFL«H DX[ VDYRLUVb FɛHVW OH curriculum caché
)RUTXLQFLW«SDU7URWWLHU &HWWHQRWLRQHVWHVVHQWLHOOHSRXUFRPSUHQGUH
FRPPHQWOHVVW«U«RW\SHVGHJHQUHLQWHUYLHQQHQWGHPDQLªUHLPSOLFLWHGDQVOHV\VWªPH
VFRODLUHbILOOHVHWJDU©RQVLQW«ULRULVHQWUDSLGHPHQWFHTXLHVWDWWHQGXGHOHXUSDUWWRXW
DXORQJGHOHXUVFRODULW« *DXVVHO /HVHQVHLJQDQW⋅HVHQHIIHWQɛ«FKDSSHQWSDVDX[
VW«U«RW\SHV TXL LPSUªJQHQW OD VRFL«W«b SDUFH TXɛLOV HW HOOHV VRQW LQFRQVFLHPPHQW
SRUWHXUVHWSRUWHXVHVGHVW«U«RW\SHVTXLLQIOXHQFHQWOHXUFRPSRUWHPHQWYLV¢YLVGHV
«OªYHVFHVGHUQLHUVYRQWHX[P¬PHVHQU«DFWLRQDSSRUWHUXQHU«SRQVH HQWHUPHVGH
FRPSRUWHPHQWRXP¬PHGHU«XVVLWH FRQIRUPH¢FHVDWWHQWHV 7URXLOORXG 6DUUD]LQ
6 6LGHQRPEUHXVHV«WXGHVRQWUHOHY«ODPHLOOHXUHU«XVVLWHVFRODLUHGHVILOOHVGɛDXWUHVRQW
PLVHQ«YLGHQFHODPHLOOHXUHU«XVVLWHSURIHVVLRQQHOOHGHVKRPPHV (XURSHDQ,QVWLWXWH
IRU *HQGHU (TXDOLW\ b 8QLWHG 1DWLRQV b :RUOG (FRQRPLF )RUXP ,O
H[LVWHUDLWGRQFXQSK«QRPªQHGHmbUHQYHUVHPHQWGHVLQ«JDOLW«VGHJHQUHb}HQWUHOHV
FRQWH[WHVVFRODLUHHWSURIHVVLRQQHOLQWHUYHQDQWDXFROOªJH ¢SDUWLUGHODFODVVHGHH
6LFDUG Sb Oɛ«FROH SULPDLUH OHV «OªYHV SUHQGUDLHQW FRQVFLHQFH GHV
G\QDPLTXHV GH VWDWXW GDQV OH GRPDLQH VFRODLUH TXɛLOV FRQQDLVVHQW ELHQ DYDQW GH
FRPSUHQGUHSOXVWDUGTXHOVVRQWOHVSURFHVVXVHQMHXGDQVOHPRQGHSURIHVVLRQQHO/HV
«OªYHV DWWULEXHUDLHQW XQ VWDWXW VXS«ULHXU DX[ SURIHVVLRQV VW«U«RW\SLTXHPHQW
ɢ/HV HQVHLJQDQW⋅HV SHQVHQWHOOHVyLOV TXH OHV GLVFLSOLQHV VFRODLUHV VRQW SOXV RX PRLQV
LPSRUWDQWHVSRXUOɛDYHQLUGHV«OªYHVVHORQTXɛLOVVRLHQWJDU©RQVRXILOOHVb"&HWWHSHUFHSWLRQ
YDULHWHOOHHQIRQFWLRQGXVH[HGHOɛHQVHLJQDQW⋅Hb"
ɢ2EVHUYHWRQXQH«YROXWLRQGHFHVSHUFHSWLRQVDQVDSUªVOɛ«WXGHGHb"
b
2. Étude 1 : Perception des élèves
2.1. Méthode
2.1.1. Échantillon, matériel et procédure
15 /ɛ«FKDQWLOORQGHFHWWH«WXGHHVWFRPSRV«GH«OªYHVLQVFULWVHQ&0GRQWILOOHVHW
JDU©RQVRULJLQDLUHVGHQHXIFODVVHVGHFLQT«FROHVSULPDLUHVGX3X\GH'¶PH
16 /ɛ«WXGHVɛHVWG«URXO«H¢OɛDLGHGɛXQTXHVWLRQQDLUHHQOLJQHFRQWHQDQWOɛHQVHPEOHGHV
FRQVLJQHV«JDOHPHQWG«FULWHVRUDOHPHQWDX[«OªYHV/HTXHVWLRQQDLUHHVWVLPLODLUH¢
FHOXLXWLOLV«SDU'XWU«YLVHW7RF]HNHQ6XUODSUHPLªUHSDJHGXTXHVWLRQQDLUH
ILJXUDLHQWOHVFRQVLJQHVGHSDVVDWLRQDLQVLTXHOHVFRRUGRQQ«HVGHOɛH[S«ULPHQWDWULFH
/HV«OªYHVDSSUHQDLHQWTXɛLOVDOODLHQWU«SRQGUH¢GHVTXHVWLRQVFRQFHUQDQWOHXURSLQLRQ
VXUGLII«UHQWHVPDWLªUHVTXɛLOVWUDYDLOODLHQW¢Oɛ«FROH8QH[HPSOHGɛLWHPDLQVLTXHOHV
PRGDOLW«V GH U«SRQVH OHXU «WDLHQW HQVXLWH SU«VHQW«V /ɛDQRQ\PDW OHXU «WDLW JDUDQWL
$YDQWGHSRXUVXLYUHOɛH[S«ULPHQWDWULFHVɛDVVXUDLWTXHFKDTXH«OªYHDYDLWELHQFRPSULV
WRXWHVOHVFRQVLJQHV
17 'DQV FH TXHVWLRQQDLUH OD SHUFHSWLRQ GHV GLVFLSOLQHV VFRODLUHV SDU OHV «OªYHV D «W«
PHVXU«H¢OɛDLGHGHWURLVFRQFHSWV 'XWU«YLV 7RF]HN b
ɢ/DYDOHXUVXEMHFWLYHDFFRUG«H¢FKDTXHGLVFLSOLQHSDUOHV«OªYHVb
ɢ/ɛHQMHX «YDOXDWLI DFFRUG« ¢ FKDTXH GLVFLSOLQH VHORQ OHV «OªYHV SDU HX[P¬PHV OHXU
HQVHLJQDQW⋅HHWOHXUVSDUHQWVb
ɢ/ɛLPSRUWDQFHDFFRUG«H¢FKDTXHGLVFLSOLQHFRPSDUDWLYHPHQWDX[DXWUHV
18 1RXVUHWURXYRQVGDQVOHWDEOHDXOHVGLII«UHQWVLWHPVTXLRQWSHUPLVGHPHVXUHUFHV
FRQFHSWVSRXUOHGRPDLQHGHVPDWK«PDWLTXHV/HV«OªYHVGHYDLHQWU«SRQGUHHQXWLOLVDQW
XQH«FKHOOHHQFLQTSRLQWVDOODQWGHmbSDVGXWRXWb}¢mbWRXW¢IDLWb}&KDFXQGHFHV
LWHPVD«W«DGDSW«¢WRXWHVOHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHV«WXGL«HVbOHVPDWK«PDWLTXHVOH
IUDQ©DLVOɛ(36OɛRUWKRJUDSKHODJ«RP«WULHOHVDUWVSODVWLTXHVODOHFWXUHOHVVFLHQFHVOD
PXVLTXHODU«VROXWLRQGHSUREOªPHVOɛKLVWRLUHHWODJ«RJUDSKLH
b
Tableau 1 - Concepts étudiés et items proposés aux élèves.
Table 1 - Items submitted to pupils
3RXUWRLELHQU«XVVLUHQPDWK«PDWLTXHVHVWLPSRUWDQW
9DOHXU VXEMHFWLYH DFFRUG«H DX[ (Q J«Q«UDO WX WURXYHV TXH IDLUH GHV H[HUFLFHV GH
PDWK«PDWLTXHV PDWK«PDWLTXHVHVWLQW«UHVVDQW
7XDLPHVOHVPDWK«PDWLTXHV
&HTXHWXDSSUHQGVHQPDWK«PDWLTXHVHVWXWLOHSRXUWRL
(QMHX «YDOXDWLI DFFRUG« SDU OHV 3RXU WRL DYRLU XQH PDXYDLVH «YDOXDWLRQ HQ PDWK«PDWLTXHV
«OªYHV FɛHVWJUDYH
(QMHX «YDOXDWLI DFFRUG« SDU 3RXU WRQ PD°WUH RX WD PD°WUHVVH VL WX DV XQH PDXYDLVH
OɛHQVHLJQDQWyH «YDOXDWLRQHQPDWK«PDWLTXHVFɛHVWJUDYH
(QMHX «YDOXDWLI DFFRUG« SDU OHV 3RXU WHV SDUHQWV VL WX DV XQH PDXYDLVH «YDOXDWLRQ HQ
SDUHQWV PDWK«PDWLTXHVFɛHVWJUDYH
19 /DGHUQLªUHSDUWLHGXTXHVWLRQQDLUH«WDLWFRQVDFU«H¢Oɛ«WDEOLVVHPHQWGɛXQFODVVHPHQW
GHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVSDURUGUHGɛLPSRUWDQFH8QHOLVWHGHGRX]HGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHV
«WDLW SU«VHQW«H DX[ «OªYHV HW LOV GHYDLHQW OHV FODVVHU SDU RUGUH GɛLPSRUWDQFH HQ
LQGLTXDQWmbb}GHYDQWODGLVFLSOLQHODSOXVLPSRUWDQWHHWHQG«FOLQDQWOHFODVVHPHQW
MXVTXɛ¢mbb}TXɛLOVGHYDLHQWDQQRWHUGHYDQWODGLVFLSOLQHTXLOHXUVHPEODLWODPRLQV
LPSRUWDQWH/HFKRL[GHFHVGRX]HGLVFLSOLQHVD«W«PRWLY«SDUODQ«FHVVDLUHFRQIRUPLW«
GHQRVLWHPVDYHFFHX[FKRLVLVGDQVOɛ«WXGHVLPLODLUHPHQ«HLO\DDQVDILQGHQRXV
SHUPHWWUHGHPHQHUXQHDQDO\VHFRPSDUDWLYHGHVU«VXOWDWVREWHQXV&HWWHFODVVLILFDWLRQ
SHUPHW HQ RXWUH Gɛ«WXGLHU VL ¢ OɛLQW«ULHXU GɛXQ GRPDLQH GLVFLSOLQDLUH OHV
PDWK«PDWLTXHVRXOHIUDQ©DLV LO\DYDLWGHVGLII«UHQFHVGHU«VXOWDWVVHORQOHVVRXV
GRPDLQHVFRQVLG«U«V ODJ«RP«WULHHWODU«VROXWLRQGHSUREOªPHVOɛRUWKRJUDSKHHWOD
OHFWXUH
b
2.1.2. Stratégies d’analyses
20 7RXWHVOHVDQDO\VHVRQW«W«U«DOLV«HV¢OɛDLGHGXORJLFLHO6366p3RXUFKDTXHFRQFHSW
«WXGL« YDOHXU VXEMHFWLYH DFFRUG«H DX[ GLVFLSOLQHV HQMHX «YDOXDWLI HW KL«UDUFKLH GHV
GLVFLSOLQHV GHVDQDO\VHVGHODYDULDQFHRQW«W«U«DOLV«HVHQSUHQDQWOHVH[HGHV«OªYHV
FRPPHYDULDEOHLQWHUVXMHWV$ILQGHGRFXPHQWHUODWDLOOHGHVHIIHWVREVHUY«VOɛ«WDFDUU«
η D«JDOHPHQW«W«FDOFXO«SRXUFKDTXHGLVFLSOLQHDXVHLQGHFKDTXHFRQFHSW
b
2.2. Résultats
2.2.1. Valeur subjective accordée aux disciplines
21 3RXU FKDFXQH GHV GLVFLSOLQHV VFRODLUHV FRQVLG«U«HV GHV DOSKDV GH &URQEDFK RQW «W«
FDOFXO«VVXUOHVTXDWUHLWHPVGHOɛ«FKHOOHDILQGHVɛDVVXUHUGHODFRQVLVWDQFHLQWHUQHGH
FHWWHPHVXUH (FFOHVHWDOb(FFOHVHWDOb-DFREVHWDO /HVLQGLFHV
«WDQWVDWLVIDLVDQWV 7DEOHDX XQVFRUHPR\HQD«W«FDOFXO«SRXUFKDTXHGLVFLSOLQH
b
Tableau 2 - Valeur subjective moyenne accordée aux disciplines scolaires par les élèves
Table 2 - Average subjective value of school subjects according to pupils
M ET M ET M ET ddl F η2
0DWK«PDWLTXHV
)UDQ©DLV
(36
2UWKRJUDSKH
*«RP«WULH
$UWVSODVWLTXHV
/HFWXUH
6FLHQFHV
0XVLTXH
5«VROXWLRQGHSUREOªPHV
+LVWRLUH
*«RJUDSKLH
Notes. * p < .10, ** p < .05, M : moyenne, ET : écart-type, EPS : éducation physique et sportive.
Lecture : La valeur subjective moyenne accordée aux mathématiques est de 4,20 pour tous les élèves,
de 4,32 pour les garçons et de 4,07 pour les filles. Le test F de comparaison des moyennes entre les
filles et les garçons est significatif, bien que la taille de cet effet ( ²) est faible.
22 /H WDEOHDX LQGLTXH TXH OHV JDU©RQV DFFRUGHQW XQH SOXV JUDQGH YDOHXU DX[
PDWK«PDWLTXHVHW¢Oɛ(36/HVILOOHVTXDQW¢HOOHVDWWULEXHQWXQHYDOHXUSOXVLPSRUWDQWH
DXIUDQ©DLV¢ODOHFWXUH¢OɛRUWKRJUDSKHHWDX[DUWVSODVWLTXHV
23 &RQFHUQDQWOHVDXWUHVGLVFLSOLQHVDXFXQHGLII«UHQFHGHYDOHXUVXEMHFWLYHHQIRQFWLRQGX
VH[HQɛHVWVLJQLILFDWLYH
b
2.2.2. Enjeu évaluatif accordé aux disciplines
24 /ɛHQMHX«YDOXDWLID«W«PHVXU«¢OɛDLGHGHWURLVLWHPVSRXUFKDTXHGLVFLSOLQH'HV$129$
RQW«W«U«DOLV«HVVXUFKDFXQGHFHVLWHPVHQSUHQDQWOHVH[HFRPPHYDULDEOHLQWHU
VXMHWV
25 /ɛHQMHX«YDOXDWLIDFFRUG«SDUOHV«OªYHVHQRUWKRJUDSKH F b bp HWHQ
DUWVSODVWLTXHV F b bp HVWSOXV«OHY«FKH]OHVILOOHV,OQɛ\DSDVGH
GLII«UHQFHVLJQLILFDWLYHGDQVOHVDXWUHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHV
26 &RQFHUQDQW OɛHQMHX «YDOXDWLI DFFRUG« DX[ GLII«UHQWHV GLVFLSOLQHV SDU OɛHQVHLJQDQW⋅H
DXFXQH GLII«UHQFH QɛHVW REVHUY«H HQ IRQFWLRQ GX VH[H GHV «OªYHV GDQV DXFXQH GHV
GLVFLSOLQHV
27 (QFHTXLFRQFHUQHOɛHQMHX«YDOXDWLIDFFRUG«SDUOHVSDUHQWVXQHPDXYDLVH«YDOXDWLRQ
HQPXVLTXHVHUDFRQVLG«U«HFRPPHSOXVJUDYHSDUOHVSDUHQWVSRXUOHVILOOHVTXHSRXU
OHVJDU©RQV F b bp $XFXQHDXWUHGLII«UHQFHQɛHVWVLJQLILFDWLYH
b
0DWK«PDWLTXHV
)UDQ©DLV
2UWKRJUDSKH
+LVWRLUH
/HFWXUH
6FLHQFHV
*«RJUDSKLH
5«VROXWLRQ GH
SUREOªPHV
(36
*«RP«WULH
$UWVSODVWLTXHV
0XVLTXH
Notes. * p < .10, ** p < .05, M : moyenne, ET : écart-type, EPS : éducation physique et sportive.
b
3. Étude 2 : perceptions des enseignant·es
3.1. Méthode
3.1.1. Échantillon, matériel et procédure
,WHPVVS«FLILTXHVDX[PDWK«PDWLTXHV FHVLWHPVRQW
&RQFHSWV
«W«DGDSW«VSRXUFKDTXHGLVFLSOLQH«WXGL«H
6HORQYRXVles élèvesDFFRUGHQWGHOɛLPSRUWDQFHDX[
PDWK«PDWLTXHV
6HORQYRXVles garçonsDFFRUGHQWGHOɛLPSRUWDQFH
DX[PDWK«PDWLTXHV
35 7RXWHVOHVDQDO\VHVRQW«W«U«DOLV«HV¢OɛDLGHGXORJLFLHO6366p3RXUFKDTXHFRQFHSW
«WXGL« LPSRUWDQFHGHVGLVFLSOLQHVSRXUOɛDYHQLUGHV«OªYHVHQJ«Q«UDOLPSRUWDQFHGHV
GLVFLSOLQHVSRXUOɛDYHQLUSURIHVVLRQQHOGHV«OªYHVLPSRUWDQFHDFFRUG«HSDUOHV«OªYHV
DX[GLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVVHORQOHVHQVHLJQDQWyHVHWKL«UDUFKLHGHVGLVFLSOLQHV GHVWHVWV
8GH0DQQ:KLWQH\RQW«W«U«DOLV«VGHPDQLªUH¢REVHUYHUVLOHVU«SRQVHVYDULHQWVHORQ
TXH FH VRQW GHV HQVHLJQDQWV RX GHV HQVHLJQDQWHV TXL U«SRQGHQW &H WHVW QRQ
SDUDP«WULTXH D «W« FKRLVL FDU Oɛ«FKDQWLOORQ FRPSUHQG SUªV GH TXDWUH IRLV SOXV GH
IHPPHVTXHGɛKRPPHV(QVXLWHGHVWHVWVGH6WXGHQWDSSDUL«VRQW«W«HIIHFWX«VSRXU
«YDOXHUFHVFRQFHSWVVHORQOHVH[HGHV«OªYHV
b
3.2. Résultats
3.2.1. Importance des disciplines pour l’avenir des élèves en général
36 &RQFHUQDQWOɛDYHQLUGHV«OªYHVHQJ«Q«UDOOHVWHVWV8GH0DQQ:KLWQH\QHU«YªOHQW
DXFXQHGLII«UHQFHVLJQLILFDWLYHGɛRSLQLRQHQIRQFWLRQGXVH[HGXU«SRQGDQW
37 (Q FH TXL FRQFHUQH OɛDYHQLU GHV ILOOHV HW GHV JDU©RQV OHV WHVWV GH 6WXGHQW DSSDUL«V
PRQWUHQWTXHGHVGLII«UHQFHVDSSDUDLVVHQWSRXUFLQTGLVFLSOLQHVbOHVPDWK«PDWLTXHVOH
IUDQ©DLVOɛRUWKRJUDSKHOHVDUWVSODVWLTXHVHWODPXVLTXH&HSHQGDQWVHXOHVOHVGRQQ«HV
FRQFHUQDQWOHIUDQ©DLVVRQWVLJQLILFDWLYHV t b bp &HODVLJQLILHTXH
VHORQOHVHQVHLJQDQWyHVOHIUDQ©DLVHVWSOXVLPSRUWDQWSRXUOɛDYHQLUJ«Q«UDOGHVILOOHV
TXHSRXUFHOXLGHVJDU©RQV$XFXQHGLII«UHQFHVLJQLILFDWLYHQɛHVWUHOHY«HSRXUOHVDXWUHV
PDWLªUHV
b
3.2.2. Importance des disciplines pour l’avenir professionnel des élèves
38 &RQFHUQDQWOɛDYHQLUSURIHVVLRQQHOGHV«OªYHVOHVWHVWV8GH0DQQ:KLWQH\QHU«YªOHQW
DXFXQHGLII«UHQFHVLJQLILFDWLYHGɛRSLQLRQHQIRQFWLRQGXVH[HGXU«SRQGDQW
39 (QFHTXLFRQFHUQHOɛDYHQLUGHVILOOHVHWGHVJDU©RQVVHXOVOHVU«VXOWDWVFRQFHUQDQWOɛ(36
VRQWVLJQLILFDWLIV t b bp /HVHQVHLJQDQWyHVSHQVHQWTXHOɛ(36HVWSOXV
LPSRUWDQWHSRXUOɛDYHQLUSURIHVVLRQQHOGHVJDU©RQVTXHGHVILOOHV
b
3.2.3. Importance accordée par les élèves aux disciplines scolaires selon les
enseignant·es
40 &RQFHUQDQW OɛLPSRUWDQFH DFFRUG«H SDU OHV «OªYHV DX[ GLVFLSOLQHV VFRODLUHV VHORQ OHV
HQVHLJQDQWyHVOHVWHVWV8GH0DQQ:KLWQH\QHU«YªOHQWDXFXQHGLII«UHQFHVLJQLILFDWLYH
GɛRSLQLRQHQIRQFWLRQGXVH[HGXU«SRQGDQW
41 /HV WHVWV GH 6WXGHQW DSSDUL«V PRQWUHQW TXH OHV HQVHLJQDQWyHV SHQVHQW TXH OHV ILOOHV
DFFRUGHQW SOXV GɛLPSRUWDQFH DX IUDQ©DLV t b b p ¢ OɛRUWKRJUDSKH
t b bp DX[DUWVSODVWLTXHV t b bp ¢ODOHFWXUH t b
bp HW¢ODPXVLTXH t b bp TXHOHVJDU©RQV,OVSHQVHQW
«JDOHPHQW TXH OHV JDU©RQV DFFRUGHQW SOXV GɛLPSRUWDQFH TXH OHV ILOOHV DX[
PDWK«PDWLTXHV t b b p ¢ Oɛ(36 t b b p ¢ OD
U«VROXWLRQ GH SUREOªPHV t b b p HW GH ID©RQ PDUJLQDOHPHQW
VLJQLILFDWLYHDX[VFLHQFHV t b bp
b
3.2.4. Classement des disciplines scolaires selon leur ordre d’importance
+RPPHV )HPPHV
7HVW8GH0DQQ:KLWQH\
'LVFLSOLQHV Nb b Nb
5 M ET 5 M ET U Z p
([SUHVVLRQ«FULWH
Notes. R : rang, * p < .05, ** p < .01, M : moyenne, ET : écart-type, EPS : éducation physique et sportive.
43 6HORQFHVFODVVHPHQWVODOHFWXUHOHIUDQ©DLVOHVPDWK«PDWLTXHVHWOɛH[SUHVVLRQ«FULWH
VRQWHQW¬WHGHFODVVHPHQWDXWDQWVHORQOHVKRPPHVTXHVHORQOHVIHPPHV
44 6HXOHVGHX[GLVFLSOLQHVVRQWFODVV«HVGLII«UHPPHQWVHORQTXHOHVHQVHLJQDQWyHVVRLHQW
GHVKRPPHVRXGHVIHPPHVbOɛRUWKRJUDSKHFODVV«HHQSRVLWLRQSDUOHVIHPPHVHW
HQHSRVLWLRQSDUOHVKRPPHVHWODPXVLTXHFODVV«HHQHSRVLWLRQSDUOHVKRPPHVHW
HQHSRVLWLRQSDUOHVIHPPHV
b
4. Discussion
45 /HVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVVRQWDXFüXUGHOɛDUWLFXODWLRQHQWUHU«XVVLWHGHV«OªYHVFKRL[
GɛRULHQWDWLRQ VFRODLUH HW LQVHUWLRQ SURIHVVLRQQHOOH HW OHXU SHUFHSWLRQ SDU OHV «OªYHV
FRPPH SDU OHV HQVHLJQDQWyHV DSSDUD°W FRPPH XQ «O«PHQW G«WHUPLQDQW 1RXV QRXV
VRPPHV DLQVL DSSX\«HV VXU Oɛ«WXGH GH 'XWU«YLV HW 7RF]HN TXL HQ RQW
UHSU«VHQWDWLRQV TXɛRQW OHV HQVHLJQDQWyHV GH OHXUV «OªYHV QɛRQW SDV QRQ SOXV «YROX«
GHSXLV 'XWU«YLV 7RF]HN HW VRQW G«WHUPLQDQWHV GDQV OHV «FDUWV GH
SHUIRUPDQFHFRQVWDW«V/HVHIIHWVGɛDWWHQWHSURYRTX«VFKH]OHXUV«OªYHVDPªQHQWFHV
GHUQLHUyªUHV¢\U«SRQGUHGHID©RQFRQIRUPHHWGRQFVW«U«RW\S«H
54 3RXU WHUPLQHU OHV HQVHLJQDQWyHV RQW «JDOHPHQW FODVV« OHV GLVFLSOLQHV SDU RUGUH
GɛLPSRUWDQFH6LSHXGHU«VXOWDWVU«SRQGHQWDX[FULWªUHVGHVLJQLILFDWLYLW«LPSRV«VSDU
OHVFDOFXOVVWDWLVWLTXHVXQHOHFWXUHGHVFULSWLYHSHUPHWGHFRQVWDWHUTXHODOHFWXUHOH
IUDQ©DLV HW OHV PDWK«PDWLTXHV VRQW HQ W¬WH GH FODVVHPHQW FRQIRUP«PHQW DX[
LQVWUXFWLRQVRIILFLHOOHV/HVDUWVSODVWLTXHVHWODPXVLTXHVRQWTXDQW¢HOOHVUHO«JX«HV
DX[ GHX[ GHUQLHUV UDQJV 6L QRXV SRXYRQV UHOHYHU TXH OɛRUWKRJUDSKH HVW
VLJQLILFDWLYHPHQW PLHX[ FODVV«H SDU OHV HQVHLJQDQWHV TXH SDU OHV HQVHLJQDQWV OH
FODVVHPHQWGHOɛHQVHPEOHGHVGLVFLSOLQHVVHPEOHGLFW«SDUODSUHVFULSWLRQRIILFLHOOHSOXV
TXH SDU OHV UHSU«VHQWDWLRQV GHV HQVHLJQDQWyHV ,O QRXV HVW ELHQ GLIILFLOH LFL GH WLUHU
GɛDXWUHV FRQFOXVLRQV WDQW QRXV SRXYRQV SHQVHU ¢ OɛLQIOXHQFH SRVVLEOH GX ELDLV GH
G«VLUDELOLW«VRFLDOH6LOɛRQFRPSDUHFHFODVVHPHQWDYHFFHOXLHIIHFWX«SDUOHV«OªYHVFH
VRQW OHV P¬PHV FRXSOHV GH PDWLªUHV TXL VH UHWURXYHQW HQ W¬WH IUDQ©DLV HW
PDWK«PDWLTXHV HWDX[GHUQLHUVUDQJV PXVLTXHHWDUWVSODVWLTXHV QRXYHDXIRUFHHVW
GHFRQVWDWHUTXHFHFODVVHPHQWQɛDSDV«YROX«GHSXLVOɛ«WXGHPHQ«HHQ 'XWU«YLV
7RF]HN
55 4XHOTXHVOLPLWHV¢FHVGHX[«WXGHVGRLYHQW¬WUHVRXOLJQ«HV(QHIIHWOHV«FKDQWLOORQV
«WXGL«VVRQWUHODWLYHPHQWPRGHVWHV «OªYHVHWHQVHLJQDQWV HWOHVSDUWLFLSDQWyHV
SURYLHQQHQWGɛXQP¬PHG«SDUWHPHQW3DUDLOOHXUVOHWDX[GɛDWWULWLRQGHODVHFRQGH
«WXGH Vɛ«OªYH ¢ b HW OɛRQ UHPDUTXH XQ IRUW G«V«TXLOLEUH HQWUH OHV VH[HV GHV
HQVHLJQDQWyHV ELHQTXHFHOXLFLUHVWHUHSU«VHQWDWLIGHVVWDWLVWLTXHVQDWLRQDOHVSRXUOD
SURIHVVLRQ (QILQOHVU«VXOWDWVGLII«UHQFL«VHQWUHOHVHQVHLJQDQWVHWOHVHQVHLJQDQWHVQH
VɛH[SOLTXHQWSHXW¬WUHSDVXQLTXHPHQWSDUOHVH[HPDLVSHXW¬WUHDXVVLSDUOɛDQFLHQQHW«
GDQVODSURIHVVLRQ/HVU«VXOWDWVGRLYHQWGRQF¬WUHLQWHUSU«W«VDYHFSU«FDXWLRQ
56 3RXUWDQWGɛXQHPDQLªUHJ«Q«UDOHFHVGHUQLHUVQRXVSHUPHWWHQWGHFRQVWDWHUTXɛHQ
ODSHUFHSWLRQGHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVSDUOHV«OªYHVFRPPHSDUOHVHQVHLJQDQWyHV
UHVWHFRQIRUPHDX[VW«U«RW\SHVGHJHQUHY«KLFXO«VSDUODVRFL«W«'HSOXV¢OɛLVVXHGH
OɛDQDO\VH FRPSDUDWLYH PHQ«H GDQV FHWWH GLVFXVVLRQ QRXV FRQVWDWRQV TXɛHQ DQV
DXFXQH «YROXWLRQ VLJQLILFDWLYH QɛHVW UHS«U«H /HV PDWLªUHV OLWW«UDLUHV HW DUWLVWLTXHV
«WDLHQWHWUHVWHQWSULYLO«JL«HVSDUOHVILOOHVOHVPDWK«PDWLTXHVHWOHVDFWLYLW«VSK\VLTXHV
HWVSRUWLYHVSDUOHVJDU©RQV
b
5. Conclusion
57 'HQRPEUHXVHVUHFKHUFKHVVHVRQWLQW«UHVV«HV¢ODU«XVVLWHHW¢OɛRULHQWDWLRQGHVILOOHVHW
GHVJDU©RQVHQOLHQDYHFOHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHV&HUWDLQHVRQWSOXVSDUWLFXOLªUHPHQW
«WXGL«OɛLPSDFWGHVSHUIRUPDQFHVHWGHODPRWLYDWLRQGHV«OªYHVVXUOHXUVSHUFHSWLRQVHW
DVSLUDWLRQV ¢ GHV «WXGHV HW FDUULªUHV VW«U«RW\SLTXHPHQW PDUTX«HV -DHJHUV
/DIRQWDLQH &ɛHVWGDQVFHFDGUHO¢TXHQRWUH«WXGHDYDLWSRXUEXWGHYRLUGDQV
TXHOOH PHVXUH OD SHUFHSWLRQ GHV GLVFLSOLQHV SDU OHV «OªYHV HW SDU OHV HQVHLJQDQWyHV
SHUPHWWDLWGHFRPSUHQGUHHWGɛH[SOLTXHUOHVSK«QRPªQHVGHU«XVVLWHHWGɛRULHQWDWLRQ
GLII«UHQFL«HVFKH]OHVILOOHVHWOHVJDU©RQV
58 (QVRPPHLQVFULWHGDQVXQHSHUVSHFWLYHWK«RULTXHSV\FKRVRFLDOHFHWWH«WXGHIRXUQLW
GHV GRQQ«HV HPSLULTXHV LPSRUWDQWHV SRXU PLHX[ FRPSUHQGUH OHV G\QDPLTXHV
SV\FKRVRFLDOHV FDUDFW«ULVDQW OHV VLWXDWLRQV GɛHQVHLJQHPHQW 7UªV PRGHVWHPHQW HOOH
DOLPHQWHOHVWUDYDX[TXLU«YªOHQWTXHODPRELOLVDWLRQGHQRUPHVHWYDOHXUVLQWHUQDOLV«HV
SDUOHV«OªYHVHWSDUOHVHQVHLJQDQWHVDXILOGHOHXUKLVWRLUHLQWHUIªUHDYHFOHWUDLWHPHQW
FRJQLWLIGHODVLWXDWLRQGɛHQVHLJQHPHQWGDQVODTXHOOHLOVVRQWLQV«U«V 'XWU«YLV7RF]HN
%XFKV
59 6LGHQRPEUHX[HIIRUWVHWSURJUªVRQW«W«U«DOLV«VGHSXLVDQVHWSOXVODUJHPHQW
GHSXLVGHVG«FHQQLHVHQ)UDQFHHQPDWLªUHGɛ«JDOLW«HQWUHOHVILOOHVHWOHVJDU©RQVOHV
KRPPHVHWOHVIHPPHVIRUFHHVWGHFRQVWDWHUTXHOHVVW«U«RW\SHVGHJHQUHRQWODYLH
GXUHHWTXHODURXWHHVWHQFRUHORQJXH(QHIIHWPDOJU«ODPXOWLSOLFDWLRQGHVORLVHWGHV
DFWLRQVGHSHUVRQQHVHQJDJ«HVVXUOHWHUUDLQOHVSUDWLTXHVSHLQHQW¢VHJ«Q«UDOLVHU
3DUFHTXHFHUWDLQVGLVSRVLWLIVS«GDJRJLTXHVSHXYHQWFU«HUDXJPHQWHURXU«GXLUHOHV
GLII«UHQFHV HQWUH OHV «OªYHV OH VRXFL Gɛ«TXLW« HQ PDWLªUH Gɛ«GXFDWLRQ GRLW ¬WUH
SHUPDQHQWDILQGɛHVS«UHUDUULYHUXQMRXUHQILQ¢XQHU«HOOH«JDOLW«GHVFKDQFHVPLVVLRQ
IRQGDPHQWDOHGHOɛFROHGHOD5«SXEOLTXH
BIBLIOGRAPHIE
$EDVVL( %UXJHLOOHV& /HVPDQXHOVVFRODLUHVGHPDWK«PDWLTXHVDXSULVPHGHV
UHSU«VHQWDWLRQVVH[X«HVMixité et éducation, Pratiques sociales et dimensions culturelles. 3UHVVHV
XQLYHUVLWDLUHVGH/LPRJHV
$ODOXI0,PDWRXFKDQ10DUDJH33DKDXW66DQYXUD59DONHQHHUV$
9DQKHHUVZ\QJKHOV$ Les filles face aux études scientifiques – Réussite scolaire et inégalités
d’orientation. GLWLRQVGHOɛ8QLYHUVLW«GH%UX[HOOHV
-DHJHUV' Les aspirations aux études et carrières à forte composante mathématique : quels leviers
motivationnels et pédagogiques pour les filles et les garçons ? Étude menée auprès d’élèves de 5e et 6e
années de l’enseignement secondaire de transition en fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles>7KªVHGHGRFWRUDW
8QLYHUVLW«GH/LªJH@KWWSKGOKDQGOHQHW
-DPDLQ/ Biais d’auto-évaluation de compétence en français et en mathématiques chez les élèves
de primaire : évolution et implications pour l’adaptation psychosociale et la réussite scolaire des élèves ?
WHO >7KªVHGHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLW«GH*UHQREOH$OSHV@+$/KWWSVWHODUFKLYHV
RXYHUWHVIUWHO
0LQLVWªUHGHOɛGXFDWLRQQDWLRQDOHHWGHOD-HXQHVVH0LQLVWªUHGHOɛ(QVHLJQHPHQWVXS«ULHXUGHOD
5HFKHUFKHHWGHOɛ,QQRYDWLRQ'LUHFWLRQGHOɛYDOXDWLRQGHOD3URVSHFWLYHHWGHOD3HUIRUPDQFH
Filles et Garçons sur le chemin de l’égalité de l’école à l’enseignement supérieurKWWSV
ZZZHGXFDWLRQJRXYIUILOOHVHWJDUFRQVVXUOHFKHPLQGHOHJDOLWHGHOHFROHOHQVHLJQHPHQW
VXSHULHXUHGLWLRQ
2&'( Are boys and girls equally prepared for life?
2(&' PISA 2015 Results (Volume I): Excellence and Equity in EducationKWWSVGRLRUJ
HQ
6LFDUG$ Les garçons face à la meilleure réussite des filles : étude des conséquences du contexte
scolaire actuel sur les relations de genre WHO >7KªVHGHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLW«&OHUPRQW
$XYHUJQH@+$/KWWSVWHODUFKLYHVRXYHUWHVIUWHO
81(6&2 Déchiffrer le code : l’éducation des filles et des femmes aux sciences, technologie,
ingénierie et mathématiques (STEM)
:RUOG(FRQRPLF)RUXP The Global Gender Gap Report 2018. :RUOG(FRQRPLF)RUXP 9RO
:LJILHOG$(FFOHV-66XN<RRQ.+DUROG5'$UEUHWRQ$-$)UHHGPDQ'RDQ&
%OXPHQIHOG3& &KDQJHLQFKLOGUHQɛVFRPSHWHQFHEHOLHIVDQGVXEMHFWLYHWDVNYDOXHV
DFURVVWKHHOHPHQWDU\VFKRRO\HDUV$\HDUVWXG\Journal of Educational Psychology, 89
KWWSVGRLRUJ
RÉSUMÉS
6LWRXVOHVHQIDQWVVFRODULV«VHQ)UDQFHUH©RLYHQWXQHQVHLJQHPHQWFRQVLG«U«FRPPHLGHQWLTXH
GH QRPEUHXVHV «WXGHV RQW SRXUWDQW PRQWU« GHV GLII«UHQFHV QRWDEOHV HQ WHUPHV GH U«XVVLWH
VFRODLUHGHGXU«HGHV«WXGHVGHFKRL[GɛRULHQWDWLRQRXHQFRUHGHQLYHDXGHGLSO¶PHVHQWUHOHV
ILOOHVHWOHVJDU©RQV'DQVFHWWHSHUVSHFWLYHOɛREMHFWLIGHFHWUDYDLOHVWGHFKHUFKHU¢«YDOXHU¢
Oɛ«FROH«O«PHQWDLUHIUDQ©DLVHHQVLODYDOHXUVXEMHFWLYHDFFRUG«HDX[GLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHV
FRUUHVSRQGWRXMRXUVDX[VW«U«RW\SHVGHJHQUH'HX[«WXGHVRQW«W«PHQ«HVbOɛXQHDXSUªVGɛ«OªYHV
GH&0HWOɛDXWUHDXSUªVGɛHQVHLJQDQWyHVGɛ«FROH«O«PHQWDLUH/HVU«VXOWDWVREWHQXVU«YªOHQWXQ
FRQVWDWFODLUbODSHUFHSWLRQGHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVFRQFRUGHDYHFOHVVW«U«RW\SHVGHJHQUHHW
FRPSDUDWLYHPHQW¢XQH«WXGHPHQ«HHQDXFXQH«YROXWLRQVLJQLILFDWLYHQɛD«W«REVHUY«H
$OWKRXJK DOO FKLOGUHQ DWWHQGLQJ VFKRRO LQ )UDQFH UHFHLYH DQ HGXFDWLRQ WKDW LV FRQVLGHUHG
LGHQWLFDOQXPHURXVVWXGLHVKDYHVKRZQVLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJLUOVDQGER\VLQWHUPV
RIDFDGHPLFVXFFHVVOHQJWKRIVWXG\FKRLFHRIFDUHHUSDWKDQGOHYHORITXDOLILFDWLRQV,QWKLV
SHUVSHFWLYHWKHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUWKHVXEMHFWLYHYDOXHJLYHQWRVFKRRO
VXEMHFWVVWLOOFRUUHVSRQGVWRJHQGHUVWHUHRW\SHVLQ)UHQFKHOHPHQWDU\VFKRROLQ7ZRVWXGLHV
ZHUHFDUULHGRXWRQHZLWKVL[\HDUVROGSXSLOVDQGWKHRWKHUZLWKHOHPHQWDU\VFKRROWHDFKHUV
7KHUHVXOWVUHYHDODFOHDUFRQFOXVLRQWKHSHUFHSWLRQRIVFKRROVXEMHFWVLVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKJHQGHU
VWHUHRW\SHV DQG FRPSDUHG WR D VWXG\ FRQGXFWHG LQ QR VLJQLILFDQW FKDQJH KDV EHHQ
REVHUYHG
INDEX
Keywords : SHUFHSWLRQRIVFKRROVXEMHFWVVH[JHQGHUSXSLOVWHDFKHUV
Mots-clés : SHUFHSWLRQGHVGLVFLSOLQHVVFRODLUHVVH[HJHQUH«OªYHVHQVHLJQDQWyHV
AUTEURS
AUDREY IMBERDIS
3URIHVVHXUHGHVFROHV0D°WUHVVH)RUPDWULFH0HPEUHDVVRFL«HDX/DERUDWRLUH$FWLYLW«
&RQQDLVVDQFH7UDQVPLVVLRQGXFDWLRQ $&7 8QLYHUVLW«&OHUPRQW$XYHUJQH)UDQFH
7KªPHVGHUHFKHUFKHb«JDOLW«ILOOHVJDU©RQV¢Oɛ«FROHSULPDLUHDXGUH\LPEHUGLV#DFFOHUPRQWIU
MARIE-CHRISTINE TOCZEK
3URIHVVHXUHGHV8QLYHUVLW«V/DERUDWRLUH$FWLYLW«&RQQDLVVDQFH7UDQVPLVVLRQGXFDWLRQ $&7
8QLYHUVLW«&OHUPRQW$XYHUJQH)UDQFH
7KªPHVGHUHFKHUFKHbVLWXDWLRQVGɛ«YDOXDWLRQVLWXDWLRQVGɛDSSUHQWLVVDJHFDW«JRULHV
VRFLRSURIHVVLRQQHOOHVPFKULVWLQHWRF]HNBFDSHOOH#XFDIU
MARION DUTRÉVIS
MARGAULT SACRÉ