Difference between Security Group and Network ACL in AWS
Last Updated :
16 May, 2024
In AWS Cloud, Both the security groups and network ACLs play a important roles in managing the network traffic, but they work differently. Understanding the difference of these make us the aware of the security implementation of AWS Setup. In the article, we will disucss in detail about what are Security groups and Network ACL, their differences and troubleshooting issues much more..
What is the difference between Security Group and Network ACL ?
The following are the difference between Security Groups and Network ACLs:
| Security Group | Network Access Control List |
|---|
| In security group, we operate at instance level. | In network ACL, we operate sub net level. |
| It support only allow rules. | It support allow rules and deny rules. |
| It is stateful, when we create an inbound or an outbound rule. | It is stateless, it return traffic must be allowed explicitly. |
| We cannot block specific IP address using SGs. | We can block specific IP Address using NACL. |
| All rules are evaluated before deciding to permit trffic. | Rules are processed in number order when deciding whether allow traffic. |
| It start with instance launch configuration. | In which we assigned to subnet for all instance. |
| It applies when someone specifies security group when launching the instance and it associates with security group. | They do not depend on user it automatically apply all instances with subnet. |
What are AWS Security Groups?
Security group like a virtual firewall. It has inbound and outbound security rules in which all inbound traffic is blocked by default in private on AWS EC2. It does not allow particular protocol no one will able to access our instances using this protocol you can stop traffic by using that rule by default everything that is denied. There are various multiple security groups on EC2 instances. We can not block a specific IP address using that security group but using the network access list. In which we edit any rule a security group with faster effect.Â
What is Network ACL in AWS?
Network ACL is a modifiable default network. It allows all the inbound or outbound IPv4 traffic and here we create a type of custom network all or each custom network ACL denies all inbound and outbound traffic. This network is the stateless and separate inbound and outbound rule with a default limit of 20 for both rules and starting with the lowest numbered rule. In which all subnet in VPC must be combined with network ACL one subnet to other network ACL at a time. It supports rules and deny rules and operate the subnet level.
How does Network ACL ( NACL ) works?
Network ACLs evaluates the traffic that is entering or leaving the subnet in your VPC (Virtual Private Cloud). They process the rules in a sequential order, starting from the lowest numbered rules. When a packet matches the rules then it checks whether it is permitable or denied one. If the rule letting for permitting the packet then only it will be allowed. If they are match rules then the default action deny is applied. This process helps in enforcing the security polices and protect your AWS infrastructure from the unathorized access and potential threats.
What is the difference between Network ACL and Route Table?
The following are the differences between Network ACL and Route Table:
Aspect
| Network ACL
| Route Table
|
|---|
Location
| It operates the subnet level within a VPC
| It operates at the VPC level affecting all subnets
|
|---|
Function
| It controls the traffic that is entering and leaving in subnets.
| It directs the traffic between subnets and internet.
|
|---|
Rules Application
| It processes the rules in sequentially based on the priority.
| It routes the traffic based on the destination IP addresses.
|
|---|
Default Action
| Its default action is to ney all the traffic
| It default action is to route the traffic to the target
|
|---|
Use Cases
| It used for implementing the network level security policies
| It used for defining how traffic is routed within the VPC.
|
|---|
How to control the Traffic to Subnets Using Network ACLs? A Step-By-Step Guide
The following are the steps that guides you in controlling the traffic to subnets using the Network ACLs:
Step 1: Create a Network ACL
Step 2: Associate the Network ACL with Subnets
- Associate the network ACLs with the subnets where you want to control the traffic.
- You can also associate one NACL to mutliple subnets, but each subnet can only have one Network ACL assoicated with it at a time.
Step 3: Define Inbound and Outbound Rules
- Configure the inbound and outbound rules within the network ACL to permit or deny any specific types of traffic. Rules are evaluated in order, starting with the lowest numbered rules.
Step 4: Priortize Rules
- Arrange the rule in the order of priority, with the most specific rules at the top and the more general rules at the bottom facilitating its evaluation against the appropriate rules.
- Specify the action whether to the traffic rule to be allowed or deny for each rule based on your security requirments. Example: you can allows the HTTP and HTTPS traffic while denying the access to specific IP addresses and protocols.
- Apply the changes to the Network ACL. The updated rules will take the effect immediately and start controlling the traffic that is coming to the associated subnets.
Network ACL Basics
Network ACLs (Access Control Lists) in AWS act as a virtual firewall at the subnet level, controlling inbound and outbound traffic. They are stateless and evaluate traffic based on rules defined within them. Each subnet in a VPC can be associated with a Network ACL, allowing you to customize access control for different parts of your network infrastructure.
Network ACL Rules
Network ACL rules define the permissions for traffic entering and leaving a subnet. Rules are processed in order, from the lowest to highest rule number, and the first rule that matches the traffic criteria is applied. Rules can permit or deny traffic based on IP addresses, protocols, and port numbers, providing granular control over network communication.
Network ACLs and Other AWS Services
Network ACLs work in conjunction with other AWS services to enhance security and network management. They complement security groups by providing an additional layer of defense at the subnet level. Network ACLs also integrate with AWS CloudFormation and AWS CLI, allowing you to automate the deployment and management of network access controls within your infrastructure.
Work With Network ACLS
To effectively work with Network ACLs, start by understanding your network traffic requirements and security policies. Create Network ACLs and associate them with the appropriate subnets in your VPC. Define and prioritize inbound and outbound rules based on your security needs, regularly reviewing and updating them as necessary. Monitor network traffic and performance to ensure that your Network ACL configurations are effectively controlling access and meeting your security objectives.
Troubleshooting of Security Groups And Network ACLs
The following are the some of the troubleshootings of Security Groups and Network ACLs:
- Review Rules Configuration: Try on reviewing the rules that are configured in both the security groups and network ACLs. Check for any misconfigurations or conflicting rules that causing the issues.
- Check Logging and Monitoring: Look on utilizing of AWS CloudWatch Logs and VPC Flow Logs to monitor and analyze the network traffic. It looks for any denied or dropped connections that could indicates the issues with the security groups or Network ACLs.
- Check Associated Resources: Confirmation of the security groups and network ACLs are correctly associated with the intended resources such as EC2 instances or subnets for ensuring the changes that made for security groups or NACLs that are properly appling to associated resources.
Similar Reads
Difference Between Security and Protection
An operating system provides a method to prevent tampering with both logical and physical resources. Security and protection rank among them as two. Protection and security are distinct concepts, even though they are frequently used synonymously. To protect user applications and data, unauthorized u
5 min read
Difference Between Network Security and Network Administration
In the world of information technology, there are two important and distinct roles that are often confused: network security and network administration. While these two jobs may be closely related, they require different sets of skills and responsibilities. It’s significant to understand the differe
5 min read
Difference between Application Security and Network Security
The two important and overlapping areas of cybersecurity are application security and network security which aims at securing data and other systematic structures. Even though both are entities with a strong focus on security they are not the same thing and address different aspects of it. Applicati
6 min read
Difference between AS Override and Allowas In
1. AS Override : Its feature allows a provider edge (PE) router to change private autonomous system used by customer edge (CE) device on an external BGP session running on a VPN routing and forwarding access link. The private AS number is changed to PEAS number. 2. Allowas In : This feature allows f
2 min read
Difference Between A Snapshot And AMI In AWS
Snapshots and AMIs are the techniques used to create backups and templates to easily create copies of EBS. AMI has revolutionized cloud computing by encapsulating the configuration, underlying operating system, and software packages that are required to launch an instance in AWS. Snapshots, on the o
5 min read
Difference between AWS and Heroku
1. Amazon Web Services (AWS): Amazon Web Services are the cloud platform services that offer Infrastructure as a service (IaaS) products. It offers many services to its users which incorporates management, and analytics with data. It is an immense collection of cloud services for all needs. It is te
3 min read
Difference between Grant and Revoke
Data Controlling Language (DCL) helps users to retrieve and modify the data stored in the database with some specified queries. Grant and Revoke belong to these types of commands of the Data controlling Language. DCL is a component of SQL commands. 1. Grant : SQL Grant command is specifically used t
2 min read
Difference between Amazon Drive and Tresorit
1. Amazon Drive: Amazon Drive is a file hosting service and cloud storage provided by Amazon. It allows cloud storage, file hosting, file sharing, and file backup. Files and folders on this drive can be transferred from multiple devices like desktops, mobile, and tablets. Amazon Drive was initially
2 min read
Difference between Amazon Drive and SecureSafe
1. Amazon Drive : Amazon Drive is a file hosting service and cloud storage provided by Amazon. It allows cloud storage, file hosting, file sharing and file backup. File and folders on this drive can be transferred from multiple devices like desktop, mobile and tablets. Amazon Drive was initially kno
2 min read
Difference between Access Point and Router
As we consider setting up a wireless network it will be important to understand the functions of various items such as the access point and router. Although both of them are useful in providing wireless connectivity, they have a role in the network and cannot perform the other’s function. In this ar
6 min read