Graphene defies 200-year-old physics law, reveals quantum secrets

Graphene Just Broke a 200-Year-Old Law of Physics In a groundbreaking discovery, physicists in India have observed something previously thought impossible: electrons in graphene defying the Wiedemann–Franz law, a cornerstone of physics for nearly two centuries. This law holds that in metals, electrical and thermal conductivity are linked—when one increases, so does the other. But in ultraclean graphene, researchers saw the exact opposite. At a unique state known as the Dirac point—where graphene exists in a quantum limbo between metal and insulator—electrons began behaving like a Dirac fluid, flowing collectively like a near-perfect liquid. In this state, as electrical conductivity increased, thermal conductivity dropped, a phenomenon never before observed. What makes this discovery extraordinary isn’t just the violation of a textbook rule, but what it reveals about the nature of quantum matter under extreme conditions. The Dirac fluid in graphene mirrors the behavior of quark-gluon plasma, an ultra-hot, high-energy state of matter believed to have existed moments after the Big Bang. In essence, this experiment brings black hole physics into a lab setting—allowing scientists to probe quantum entanglement, thermal transport, and critical phenomena on a tabletop. Beyond the fundamental science, this breakthrough could pave the way for next-generation quantum sensors and ultra-sensitive electronics, reaffirming graphene’s status as one of the most extraordinary materials discovered in modern times. Source: Universality in quantum critical flow of charge and heat in ultraclean graphene*, Nature Physics (August 13, 2025).

  • No alternative text description for this image

You know, I really expect more from scientists in your country than this clickbait nonsense. “Just broke” 🙄 good grief.

Physics is solid and remains physics, what changes is our ignorance.

The more we learn, the more ignorant we are. We will come to know how much we didn't know. The movement of free Electrons from one Atom to the next Atom is electric conductivity. Vibration of Atoms and the transfer of these Vibrations to the next Atom is thermal conductivity. They may not be proportional in all materials. Looks like Graphene is being mechanically rigid ( due to its Hexagonal structure), and cannot transfer mechanical vibration from one atom to the next properly, and it drops its conductivity. Did I crack the answer to this new Graphene phenomenon?

Exciting headline, but I’d be careful calling it a “broke” of a fundamental law. The Wiedemann–Franz law holds under specific assumptions (like elastic scattering and Fermi-liquid behavior). Near the Dirac point in ultraclean graphene, those assumptions fail ,so it’s more a fascinating exception than a true violation.

I said that soon we will have to throw traditional physics in the trash. Similar reports about breaking the spell of physics come every day.

Wiedmann-Franz law is not a universal law, so there is nothing surprising in it. This law says that the ratio of thermal conductivity to the electrical conductivity is equal to a constant(Lorenz number) times the absolute temperature.

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore content categories