Can A 𝐓𝐞𝐧𝐚𝐧𝐭 𝐃𝐞𝐟𝐞𝐧𝐝 𝐄𝐯𝐢𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 By The Landlord?
a-tenant-can-defend-eviction-by-landlord

Can a Tenant Defend Eviction By The Landlord?

Renting a city apartment is convenient and affordable, but there's always the risk of eviction. Scroll down to learn when you can defend an eviction and when a tenant can be legally evicted.

Updated: By: Kanika Arora
Print

Today, a huge percentage of the population is moving to other cities for better employment opportunities. The best way to stay there is to rent a room or a flat. Living as a tenant is affordable, and you also get all the needed comforts. However, tenants are always at risk of receiving an eviction from the landlord. Many times, these are unjustifiable, and this is becoming common today. Many cases have come to light in which landlords have traumatized tenants by sending a legal notice. To help the tenants, the state government has laid down some eviction rules. So, tenants must educate themselves about those rules to counter invalid tenant eviction.

Know Your Rights As A Tenant

Landlords and tenants are legally bound. To ensure you do not become a victim of unjustifiable eviction, you must know your rights as a tenant.

No one can evict you because you are disorganized or not friendly. There are laws set aside by the state government for eviction. If the grounds for eviction are invalid, the tenants can seek protection. The rent laws by the state government have proper sections and sub-sections. These regulate the ground for the protection of the tenant. The tenants can seek protection in case the eviction notice served is unjustifiable.

According to the laws, the landlord cannot evict the tenant for five years if all the rent is paid on time. However, the landlord can ask for eviction if he needs the property for personal use. The ground for eviction should be valid in the eyes of the law.

Educate about tenant rights to prevent tenant eviction How to prevent tenant eviction?

Right to refuse

The government gives the tenant the right to refuse the tenant eviction if he has paid all bills on time and fulfilled all the obligations mentioned in the rent agreement. If the grounds for eviction are unjustifiable, the tenants also have the right to file a police complaint.

Under What Circumstances Can a Landlord Legally Evict a Tenant?

A landlord can legally evict a tenant under certain circumstances, such as:

Nonpayment of rent: If the tenant fails to pay rent as per the rent agreement, the landlord may have the right to evict the tenant.

Lease violations: If the tenant violates the terms of the lease agreement, such as by subletting without permission or causing excessive damage to the property, the landlord may have grounds for eviction.

Illegal activities: If the tenant engages in illegal activities on the rental property, the landlord may be able to pursue eviction.

Property damage: If the tenant causes significant damage to the property beyond normal wear and tear, the landlord may have the right to evict.

End of term: If the renting term has ended and the tenant refuses to vacate the property, the landlord may initiate eviction proceedings.

Ways to Defend Tenant Eviction

Here are the ways a tenant can defend eviction:

Check The Grounds For Eviction

The key grounds for eviction are not paying the rent, property damage, violation of the rent agreement, or illegal activity. Other than these, the landlord cannot evict you. It is better to check out the state Rent Control Act and the specified grounds for eviction. If the grounds for eviction are unjustifiable, the tenant has the right to seek help from enforcement bodies to stop this eviction.

Ask For Adjournment

If the landlord has filed the eviction, you will likely receive a notice from the court to appear on a specific date. Seeking an adjournment is an option if you want to avoid going to court on that specific date. An adjournment is a 14-day postponement. If the landlord has filed the eviction, it does not mean you will have to leave. If the grounds for eviction are nonpayment, you can seek an adjournment and clear your rent. It will prevent eviction.

File An Injunction Suit

There can be many situations where a tenant cannot vacate the house, including a medical emergency or his old parents. If the tenant has a genuine problem, he can file an injunction suit in court to prevent the landlord from evicting him. This is an appropriate step if the landlord is forcing the tenant to leave without notice.

Rent Payment Notice

If the tenant's rent is due and the landlord uses the nonpayment of rent as grounds for eviction, the tenant can ask the landlord for his bank details via written notice. The landlord has to acknowledge the same and provide the bank details to the tenant within ten days of receiving the notice. The tenant can pay the dues as soon as he receives the bank details. If the landlord does not act on the notice, the tenant can also send a money order amounting to the pending rent amount.

Pay the rent on time to prevent tenant eviction How to prevent tenant eviction?

Visit The Rent Controller

If the tenant has received an eviction notice on false grounds, they can seek the guidance of the rent controller of your jurisdiction. The tenant can ask them to challenge the tenant eviction notice. The tenant will then have to present before the court on the summoned date to present their case. They can also present evidence supporting the case.

Other Possible Defenses

Here are other possible defences the tenant can use if called to court.

  • The landlord did not provide the receipts for the rent payment.

  • The tenant did not pay the rent because the landlord needed to provide maintenance and repair services mentioned in the rent agreement.

  • You have all the rent payment receipts and the false eviction grounds.

Read on: Landlord Tenant Checklist

High Court Judgements on Tenant Rights

According to a recent judgement by the Himachal High Court, a tenant's right to re-enter a property is not absolute and is bound by the law of time.

The court was hearing a case of tenants where building reconstruction is required, and tenants want to re-enter after the repair or reconstruction. The court held that although the tenants have a right to re-enter the premises, it is not absolute. The High Court held that in case the premises, after rebuilding/reconstruction, are to be rented, then tenants will have the right to reentry/re-induction following the law.

As far as the right to re-enter the premises is concerned, it will be subject to the prevailing laws and requirements of the landlord. However, if the tenant has reconstructed the premises for better use, from residential to commercial, the landlord reserves the right to give the renovated space to anyone. The previous tenants do not have an absolute right to reentry into the premises.

Latest Update on Landlord Tenant Relations

When a tenant is evicted on Bonafide grounds, the Court will not prescribe any guideline for the landlord: Delhi High Court

November 2023: In a key judgement, the Delhi High Court has held that courts should refrain from prescribing any guidelines for landlords' choices when a tenant is evicted from the rented premises on bonafide grounds. The Delhi High Court said that it is not within the prerogative of the courts to direct the landlord for his/her choices related to the chosen premises.

In the case under question, the landlord wanted to set up a business for her wife on the rented premises. This indicates a bonafide requirement by the landlord, and he has every right to evict the tenant. The Court held that no directions can be passed to the landlord under the 'Delhi Rent Control Act'. The landlord is free to make decisions in this regard.

Conclusion to Tenant Eviction

Evicting tenants on false grounds is common these days. Most of the time, the landlords are motivated to increase the rent. If you receive a legal notice, there is no need to worry as there are rights to protect you and prevent such false evictions. All you need to do is keep yourself updated about tenants' rights. You can also file a counter and present your case to prevent eviction.

Frequently asked questions
  • How can tenants protect themselves from tenant eviction?

    A Rent Control Act protects tenants from tenant eviction. This act provides rights to the tenants, including the right against unjustifiable eviction. It means the landlord does not have the right to evict the tenant for the wrong reasons.

  • What are the reasons that may lead to tenant eviction?

    Some common reasons that can lead to tenant eviction are not paying the rent, using the space for illegal activities, giving the property to someone else, and damaging the property.

  • What is the notice period for tenant eviction?

    The landlords need to give tenants a notice of 28 days for eviction. The tenant eviction period also depends on the terms of the agreement.

  • What is an injunction suit in case of tenant eviction?

    If the tenant has an emergency and cannot make a move when a tenant eviction notice is served, he can file an injunction suit. It allows the tenant to stay for the emergency period.

  • Can Indian police evict a tenant?

    Police cannot assist in reclaiming the property, even if the tenants' position deteriorates. The only court with the authority to evict tenants is the court of rent controller where the property is located.

Disclaimer: Magicbricks aims to provide accurate and updated information to its readers. However, the information provided is a mix of industry reports, online articles, and in-house Magicbricks data. Since information may change with time, we are striving to keep our data updated. In the meantime, we suggest not to depend on this data solely and verify any critical details independently. Under no circumstances will Magicbricks Realty Services be held liable and responsible towards any party incurring damage or loss of any kind incurred as a result of the use of information.

Please feel free to share your feedback by clicking on this form.
Show More
Tags
India Property News Rent agreement Rent Rental
Tags
India Property News Rent agreement Rent Rental
Comments
ROHIT
22 Aug 2024 01:14 PM
mere ko makan malik makan khali karne ke lea dhamka rha h.jab ki me samay par har mahene kiraya de raha hun.me kya karu .kripya rasta btaene.
1 Response
MB Editor
05 Dec 2024 05:22 PM
According to the laws, the landlord cannot evict the tenant for five years if all the rent is paid on time. However, the landlord can ask for eviction if he needs the property for personal use. The ground for eviction should be valid in the eyes of the law. If the tenant has paid all the bills on time, then the tenant also have the right to file a police complaint.
prakash
25 May 2024 03:27 PM
without challenging the eviction notice can tenant seek for injunction and if seeks for whether is it maintainable
Surjanil
06 Dec 2020 07:01 PM
How our law siding Tenants, is something that never happens in any other country..Argument should be made on grounds of law.. The west and in any democratic country you will see the law is protecting mainly the landlord and giving some basic rights to the tennant, so that landlord can not misuse his position to harass the tennant unjustly. Still they treat us like savages way behind from the developed countries. They have a valid point for example a tennant staying in a house for more than 10 years our law gives him certain rights, he can not be evicted just like that. Nowhere in the world tenants enjoy this right, a landlord rather gets protection because he has bought this place and if he can not use it the way he wants then his basic civic rights gets crushed. Practicality in our country a tenant is given almost the equal right of a landlord., meaning owning the property does not matter, practically the status of a landlord who owns the place and a tennant who just came to stay temporarily paying rent enjoys the same benefit and share equal status. So the rights of a landlord is equal of a tennant. In India for political reasons due to over population and a huge part of your population are below the poverty level, who has no home to stay or the means to build a house for himself. So the easiest option to provide them with a roof is to make them a tennant and empower there position by giving tenants undue advantage legally. This is done to give tenants rights legally so that they can not be evicted easily. Nowhere in the world tenants are protected like this. Any civilised country landlord being the owner of the property enjoys rights and his interest is always protected, tenancy is just a temporary way to allow a person to stay in the property for some time in exchange of money. He becomes a tennant & get certain basic rights. He can be evicted legally whenever the landlord initiate the eviction proceedings as per the law of the state. In India our Govt. has failed to provide basic amenities for the people so instead providing them with home & shelter, they have devised a plan to provide them with some alternative plan. Mostly people who can not afford to make a house they naturally will look for a place on rent. If the law remains at par like any other modern country then landlord will always be able to evict tenants easily like these countries. In india if the law is like abroad then more people will loose their accomodation and would be homeless. More they become homeless higher the level of discontent will be seen among them. Easiest way is to give tenants undue, unheard legal rights to make eviction almost impossible. The legal procedure became complex, troublesome and time consuming. It becomes beneficial for the people who are associated with the legal profession. So many years it takes and during that period status quo should be maintained. In other words tenants will enjoy their tenancy while the case is running for 30 years or more. This is a dubious way of keeping people entangled in legal battle. Mostly state in power enjoys the vote share of this bonafide tenants for making the tenancy law of that particular place Unduly siding the tenants from eviction. Nowhere in the world people have seen such type of malpractices just to safeguard the tenant whereas in reality landlord always gets protection in a civilised democratic country. In India for political mileage and vote bank politics they target the community of tenants who are 10 times more in number in comparison with the community of landlords. These evil ways have crippled our judicial system and a travesty of justice is going on and on. Rights of landlords are trampled here, just for the sake of vote bank politics great injustice is going on, such a shame. Justice delayed and denied, here average court cases carry on for not less then 25 years and after so many years also justice remains untouched. We often claim that we are the largest democracy where we run the court room play year after year characters in this play, the plaintiff and the defendant cease to exist and leave this world but as Shakespeare told once, "The show must go on". So taking cue from his words, the court room play continues but characters exiting from the play while the show is going on and on and on...
JJReddy
23 Jun 2020 09:38 PM
If tenant is bad, ill treating the owner, claiming the property was promised to him and drags the owner to court without vacating even after the lease period, the owner has to pathetically wait in courts for years in different levels and executive petition till his end. God only save owner as he will loose his peace, money , time in the process.
Nandan R.
23 Jun 2020 05:56 PM
What about a tenant living more that forty years! Is there any law in favour of landlords?
Ambrish Johri
02 Jun 2020 11:19 PM
Kindly update us with the law favoring land/ house owner. If the tenant is not vacating the house from long period.
Swapnil
12 May 2020 05:49 PM
Kuch nahi hota. Don't waste your money on legal proceeding. Court simply gives answer as landlords has bonafide rights and due to that tenants has to vacate the property. I have been evicted like that few yeara back from a prime location in Mumbai. I had 3 senior citizens, one mentally challenged lady aged 50 years,my child 3 years old and my wife with me, all these things doesn't matter for court. I am telling you guys, don't get fooled by any lawyers advise, they just wanna make money by advising you to take legal action.
kaushim
05 May 2020 05:26 PM
Hi Sir, I am it professional working in bangalore and i was residing as tenant. My agreement was getting over on 31 March 2020 and i was serving advance 2 month notice which started in the Month of 1 Feb 2020. Because of the lockdown my brother could not give the key to my owner as i left for my home town on 21 march because of work from home. I have already informed her that i will vacate the house before two month even before lockdown was not emposed and as per the deals mentioned in the agreement. When i informed her that i sent the key via dunzo on 12 April and i arranged to shift few of my cloth and items that belonged to me, then she called me said i could not arrange the tenant so you can't vacate the house and there is karnataka government rule you cannot vacate the house during lockdown. Hence she said she will deduct the half of the rent (14k) for each month till the time this lockdown is imposed from my security deposit as this is the only source of income for her. I have already mentioned this to the owner that you take your time to return the deposit till the time i am there in my home town but she said she will deduct half rent for each month. Please help me to take appropriate measures to save my deposit as this was conveyed before two months.
1 Response
Nihala
23 Jun 2020 10:07 PM
Did u find a solution? If yes please share.
Rashmi
12 Apr 2020 04:46 PM
I live in a rented house, I was to leave this house on 30 th March but due to the Lock down could not evacuate it. Regarding this I had informed my Land lord in advance and had transferred the rent upto the end of March. Now, due to the lick down I have to stay in this house for the whole April, this will amount me double rent for this month as I have already paid the rent for the house I am going to shift in. May I ask for some concession in the rent from my landlord of the house which I was supposed to leave.
1 Response
Jinkal Realtors
26 Apr 2020 04:12 PM
Since due to lockdown many families has stuck. You can ask for time fram to extend but relief in rent amount will not be working. So legally, its No that tou can not ask for concession on rent. But yes, because its on individual basis. If you have good relations with the lanlord a d he/she agrees to it, then nothing like to it. You can have that advantage.
Nikhil Bhanushali
01 Apr 2020 06:15 PM
Me and my wife recently moved to Gurugram from Mumbai and rented a place but before moving in the flat, lockdown occurred and society denied owner for letting us move into flat initially stating till 31st March and then now till lockdown is over. This is causing me to stay in company accommodation which was earlier till 26th April but on request they have extended till 15th April (Lockdown is till 14th April). I’m not sure for how long this lockdown will last and for how long I’will be able to stay in company accommodation as it’s very costly. Can anyone help me whome should I reach out to help me to move into my rented place. Me and my wife are in Gurugram since 13th April and are perfect health condition.
SKR
18 Mar 2020 09:35 PM
I stay in Navi Mumbai rental, the agents are demanding comission of 1.5 times the rent but there is no such rule and every year also they are asking for comission as such rule is not defined by the government. How can we tackle this situation. Pls advice for the tenants like us.
1 Response
Jinkal Realtors
26 Apr 2020 04:18 PM
Being a broker it is difficult to meet client's expectations. Brokers do their work. They have shown many properties and then you might have finalised. In such case understand the situation if broker haven't been involved with you, then how would have ended up looking for property? Will you take off to search property from your work? How would you finalise without your family's concern? It is difficult looking for property in an unknown location that to with family. Its tiresome. Broker works hard and they know how to deal with landlords. They give you best options, so that you can leave peacefully to that time decided in the agreement. There are no rules relating to brokerage part in rental. You have to keep it clear before signing rental agreement with landlord and broker. If you don't ask for it they'll demand it. Make sure you take everything on paper. Thank you.
Rajesh
10 Mar 2020 04:21 PM
Really it is valueable ....want to know one more thing for suit premises I have file RAD suit ..can other legal heir claim for joint tenancy
Rajdeep
09 Mar 2020 07:10 PM
My PG landlord has fined me an amount to Rs. 500 for keeping the bathroom light on while not using the bathroom. And now he has denied my 3 time meals per day until I pay the fine amount. Nothing of that sort was mentioned in the agreement which is why I do not want to pay up the fine. What should I do?
Kamlesh
11 Dec 2019 06:22 PM
Hi , we stay in mumbai , our home comes in pagdi system i put my home for rent so I am getting some amount my land lord is asking for 30% of rent amount .. is this lagal to ask for 30% .. kindly advise ..
KingMan_11
04 Dec 2019 04:54 PM
So we live in Bangalore in one of the gated communities in Whitefield. We are about to vacate house by mid of this month. The owner is claiming that the deductions from the sec deposit will be the rent of 1 month and 15 days of maintenance charges that I pay separately to the society. The rent deduction was agreed and part of our initial agreement but maintenance charges were never discussed or agreed upon. Also there will be charges on top of that for the damages as well. Not how can I know of the bills are not blown out just to extract more money out of my pocket. My agreement had expired last April and currently there is no legal binding of terms and conditions. Kindly suggest.
Mirza Mohamed Aslam
17 Nov 2019 08:58 PM
Very useful information
Neelam
23 Oct 2019 09:22 PM
Hi, look for me 1bhk, finished or non furnished any floor with lift ,near by market .or airport .I feed up to searching there is broker ,or if luckily you got owner ,,then they ll tell unmatched rent of flat.what they writen on magicbriks app. Help me out
rajeev
09 Oct 2019 04:14 PM
i want a question that if lease has expired and Tenant could not vacate the flat than wt is the procedure to vacate the flat from the Tenant.
1 Response
Ryan mathias
23 Jun 2020 10:41 PM
Hi, You have to issue him a first warning letter in order to probe legal notice.
Jitendra
08 Oct 2019 11:00 AM
I m a tenant in SPS Residency and my landlord has kept a duplicate key with him from day one. And he often comes to my room in my absence and after complaining for so many times, he still do the same. At any point of time he increases power charges and he keep on invading my privacy. What can I do as he is quite old and I don't want to cross my line of respect.
1 Response
Aditya Srivastava
04 Mar 2020 05:04 PM
He is committing, trespass on property as it is under your possession and he can come only on reasonable hours and by giving you a notice prior to his arrival. A civil suit in a local district court would do.
Mohsin
02 Oct 2019 05:21 PM
My tenant is not Vacating flat and making demand of Money for Daily 120/- from Me stating he have purchased Mineral Water and Consumed whom should I approach I have already sent him agreement termination notice. And also not paid rent
1 Response
Swati Sinha
30 Oct 2019 04:58 PM
You may file a case against him to vacate the premises.
Write Comment
Please answer this simple math question.
Want to Sell / Rent out your property for free?
Post Property
Looking for the Correct Property Price?
Check PropWorth Predicted by MB Artificial Intelligence