f

,

Difputalio xtt: $1J6Jiflen'fiIlMflltillic':Uitlll' ih perfiYhit.

De hoe: amplins dicCTtlIl5 fo'l.J;ff'. N Ilnc:Cohl.m. dice fLlblhntiam rt.lmi pm rermlno complente.& penOIli1nte naeurarn t &. fie mueniuneur pll1t~$ (ublinenri;e :ttnibl1i perfonij j &, timpHci'u:r fotten plutes eire in Oeo Cubfi.tlcnti:l.!i, vr parer in: epi11:o!a So!,hrcl(1ij ,qlta: leth,& recep!a ~11: in V [. Synodt1 ac1illflt 6. vbi {;:spilh nornlnanmr eres fubtiftc:nri3: in Dee. Cum ergo plut3litarem in fubfi!icmihteneamus. videndum dl quomodo id lIare pollit cum Vl'iiure ipfius uiJtc:mjil: per fe. Ef dic(l fLibJiJtentilm duo polle impOHjre. l'omo exiflentiam pede,v, oPFCinifllt cnli in alio.Ceu accidcnri inh:i:renti;&: patti CublbmJaIi non (ubli(t':~ 'i.SerandMumim, pro rerminc vIti mo incommunk;i!l)ill. vt cxprctR dccee S.Th.fit!. q.i,.II,~, ad ... '" nos di~emu$ [tq.dtjf.Dicit enim defe terminii

. i'i) pertinent-em ad (Ilppoilt~itt'lf(:u ~YPQna'ii,'n , '<;tun. {ubJil1:en~ dl: qu~!i Cub aho h!ie-fiS f ~ (ie -di-ctu~ miourn vkimi (ub alils politi,&: quoci habet ratjo~ nern "lrirni.terminum imporm rc~ed:\i eoru,quz [liper iprum ponumur,vrnon ccmmunicenrur fII.·rcri rerrnino. Primo ergo modo 110n multip·Jjcatut fub!1!lemia in diuinis,qllfil non c1lalilld-qnillfi d:i .. ficnria p~t (e,feu independens ab alio cui inh;l;'reat aut infir. Ec fie datm fublil1enda ab(olut:l in Deo, Vt"diccrnll5 difP.(l!q,Sccuodo vero modo lIOn da-CUr (uhf! rlcnda abCof Ul:!. • &: aarHur ftcs rcllltilllC'; qui:! inCD1"i1mUrlicabilifas tieCdUfio req1!lirit oppoti(ioncm cum vltcripri rermin·o i tiiblara enim oppolirionc , omnia fum vnurn • &. con(cqlfCnrl!t fecO'nlrtiunic~ilf,8.I: idemificant.Ergo (11b hoc ron-. cepru fubfiftc:nria '1I:Ia~iUl dc:bet 1fiulrip!/cui,qui;i debet oppon.tiollcm dicere; & fub o£,pouriont exercere f3ticmem lenninj.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*~~~~~*~

Q V .IE ST.I 0 XXIX~

De P (;jOnil diujni.t~

S Y M MAL ITT E P. ce.

~~ .. 't.::~11Il G 1 T S.Thom.poil: e"plicatas procelliones,. &" relariones , quz fundicut principia ponend;'erConasditlinLlas in Deo 7 dcipfis perionis. Ee primo dehls qua: perrinenr sd omnes petfonas in communi quatllor qlia:t\iolli. ~~~~t!. bus Iequennbus. Deinde de his qua: pereinene ad fingulas Ipeciahrer,

~~. Primum ergo quod occurrit de ip(i§ perfonls in comuni c:ftagerc de p~rfo~

nh fc:cundumfe,. &chi quoc6.tifr<!t,quiduefignilicet:uf hoc nomine: P~rfotJli,Er. 6crratld quatuor. Primo,dennitiOoem pc:r(onz in communi explica, Secnnda.quomodo comparerur ad (ubGllel1ti<l.tn '" dfcndam Be hypoftaGm. T crcio ;i quomodo inur;niatudn diuinis .. Qp.ano , an fignificc:t ibi r~!;uionem vel etfentiam.

Igirur in r.arciculo exphcar defimnonem perfonzaffignar:una Bocrio7 quod eft radonalis namra: indiuidua fpbl1antia: dicirur enim (ubfl:anria indiuidua,qu:ucnus fignificat ilngubre ingenere fubf1:3:ntia:. Dicirur aurem raeionalis naturz.qui~ non quodlibet mditriduum luhQantialt:,fed quod ell natura: inteUeUllalis (cu raeionshs f perfena vadtur.

In art. a, ad. melius explieandcmranonem pc:rfon{l!"j(:ompaut illam cum. aibus,quz:in {ubft';l.Iltiis fingularibus concurrent. Inuenitur enim in ahquo indimduo fubnamiafulJl~ pta pro quidirare, & euncef] idem quod effentia : deinde inuenlrcr fubfiftentia qu~ PC.t~ riner ad rnodum exmendl, CdL quarcmus pet' (0 cxHh., Ee j. refuleae hYpOtl~fi5 feu fup~ pofirum , quo nomine figmlicamr res ilh,fcu indiuiduum,prouc[ubdtj fCllliibfiernicur accidt:ntibu5& przdicans fupcrioribus,[ca accidcntibus fubfrernitur reaheer VI; fOJ"mis inh.a:rentibu5; & ficdi~i[ur res natura: , ((.'"u·hypuHafis, id eil rub aliis pofirurn, quonomine etiam fub(bntia feler Ggnific.ari7vt fit ide quod Iub allislbns.PrzdicaEis aUte fupc. ricribus fuben: t non realit!=[ • (ed logice; & (cl;DnduhI inJ.cmiones ranoms ; & tic di~i~u, fuppofitum.quafi fiJppo6t1oriem faciens. Nunc aurern communircr pro eodem accipitur fuppofitum , hypofra!is t res natura:,(ubii(lens- complete • crt .. Pcrfona aurem dl ide m quod hy?oftafi s vel (ub1iftcns complerum In genere natur.,; inrellcdualis,

In an. ,. ofbcndit Deo conuenire fignificatum huius nominis perrona; quia conuenir ei eKe fubGQens eompletum & perfea-um in natura dtUtna, qu::r ell: natura intcUeCtuahs. Hoc enim, quod cfr(ub6llere in inrelleltuali natura, nullam imperfcd:ionetn irnporrar, fed perfeCtioncm maximarn.id dl com,ret2m &: terminaram. Elfe aurern inaiuidu:un (ubttantiam non conuenir Dee rationcalicuius matcrire,fcd ratione io<.omunicabili(2ris,. vt dicit flltilitJ1U If,/. 4. Er licet conceptusformahs perfonz , VI: relacio cl1: ad :iliba ~ pc: rfe.:.. liioncmnon explicer , explrcat ramen pct'fed:HTimumin natura; Icil, cffe u;rmin.attlnJ itt natura intelIcfruali.& rerminus,feu modus pcrfcClionis in Deo en. Hie ramen abfl:rahit c D. Thom.ab co quod partlcularitcrconO::ituit perfonam in Dco " & (QUun vult fii;hifi ... carum huius. nominis pfyfo'IJA Deo connenire , quia conuc:uit pCt(ctli.ffi"p:la: na~u~z:> qual cft ifUeUcttuaIis.

ill,,{t. 01 ~.ThrffJJ.i~ ,.pArl.D.Th .Tomuuhu. I) i_n

IT.f fJ.!!,4ftio XXX~'

I~ an:. 4.dooet quM perron:!. in diuinis dgni}ic;t rcJatlOflc.'!m ~ formam confHtuenuiTI perfenam , non quatenus relano fignificatur exercendo oppofitume:ru ad aleerum , red q~tatenus fignificatur relatio fub£ifl:ens) ,&_ di(linClionem f~cien~ab .al~o,_ perf on a quip~.e eft indiuidua fubitalllia ~ & ilIud ell; indliuduurn quod dbn (c mddbn6tllm , s: ab allis dHHnfrum in aliqua natura. Hoc aucern facII: relario: nam eft [ubfifrenst fiquidctn I:da~io in Deo non Inheree , &. eft diilingucns quiafola relatioin diuinisdiftinguita correlanuo.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*~

QV kSTIO XXX.

De pluralitRle Perfonllrum. s r M .M ALl T T E R~!

- E c V» 0 "Mquod traaandull1 ell: de perfonis in communi,eRdc:earum plli~

-_ n.hrare I & numero. Inquo quatuor explicae O. Thorn. Primum allli.lt

plures, Sccundurn,quot fine ped~ma:. Tertium,quomodo6gnHicent in Dee termini numerales. Q!;arcum, an pluribus perfonis fit communjii ipfa tatlO prrfonz,

In I. ergo-arriculo ollenditetTc in Deo plures per(onas t quia funt plures relartenes fubfill:c:ntcs: rclancnes cnimdlf1I1l~\lUn[Ur realrer rccundum procefllones. Sum ergcr plurafubfilh::ntia realirer dil1:inlla j &hocin natura intdktl:uali,ergo plures perfone.

In an. s., oflcndtt non efTc plures perfonss qu~m trcs , feil. Parrem , Verbum, &; Spirirum S. quia folum rUnt tres propw:tal;C:s, id ell: relseiones 0PpOU[Z meet fe, fcil. patetnuas 1& filiJtio ~ qua: reciproc:c opponuneur Jpif3tio l.liua, &: paffiua, qua:: eciam 0pp0. nuneur. Sed ex his duabusvna • qua: ell:: fpiratioall:iua .non opponitur paternirad t &£ fi[iatieni , quia necprocedie ab illis t nee ilt:J: ab ipra. Et fie fi non opponitur , identiJi. carur cum eis.Spirarioautem paffiuaopponicurillisduabus;rum quia procedie a fpir3tiono qmt idcnnficatur cum cis. &: fie oppcnieur ill:s Vt fpiranribus , tum quia fi idenrifieaJ'ctllrfpit;ltio p ... ffiua paternirati, &" filiationi, veraqne diceeerur fpir;u;i-, &: procedere pet smorem. Ee rurfus dun idenrificarcnt fibi (pirationem aetiuallJ,procederenr a fc ~ quoc1 cll: ablurdi ffi mum. Re (lac ergo quod ere s relarlones can ll:imant rees relarfones oppour3$". & ccnfequeneer propneeares perfonales : fpirario aurem aCtiua non fit prop;;ictas)quia eft: communis du obus.

In art. ~. docer quid pluraliras , feu mulrimdo in diuinis, qua: per rermines numerales ugnificarur,non impottat niG plures vnieares , & fic6gnificac res Ql1X dicunmr vnt( CUID indiui60nc circa vnarnquamque. Et fic folum eft ibi multimdo rranfceudenralis , qUill: conftat ex ennbus di{lint1:is .non numerus t qui ell (pecics quantitatis.

11\ art. 4. oftendi[ quod hoc nomen perfonll eft commune eribus perfonis communi': ate rationis , feu pr:Edicationis t id dl: tanquam commune przdicabile , non ramen vc genus aut (pedes, fcd tanquam indiuiduum vaguill vi: aliquis horne , eo quod perfona indiuiduam fubftantiamiroportat,&:ficell:: commune tanquam indtuiduurn in communi

COil fider.aNm. .

~*~~~~~~~~*~~~~~~~~~~~~**~~~~~~ Q V JE S T lOX X X J.

D, His qUA "d Vnil4tem , velpiuralilAfempeTlinmt in diuinii; S Y .M MAL I 'l" T E Jl_ ~.

~~iIj;.. i B:l' 1 Y).i quod con6dcI;'aml;' circa perfona5 in comrnuni,eO: modus fign1~ fie-and! &: vEc:ndi nominibus , que velpluI21itau:m fignificanr • vd flxcluuo-nem ptur.alitatis.ln quo quatuor eonfider:u:.Primojde hoc nomine ,-rinir4til. Secundo de hoc DbDliIlUliHS. an fit dicendum in diuinis. tertia de hac ex----".'~,I.- JtIWlN1IJ, &cfilnilia J an at a.dhibcnd.a tennino c:lfentiali. nrolu!> Deus eft

bonus

~£Jli()XXXlJ:· . U f

bonus J en Creator, kc. <lllarto an c co~uerfo poffic adiungi tetmillo pcrrOn:1.li;Vtlph~ Pater eft Deus,

In art. I. docct quod hoc nomen Trinit,u did porell de Dco.non eamende ling-ulis pet. fonis, Itt Pater,&" Triqitas, qUia Qgnihc:l.t pluralitatemdeu:rininarantper[onatum in vna drcntia , (cil. pluraliratem innumero rernario ) sc hrel; verb dicirur de Deo, non de qu~-

Iibee perfona, .. .

In arc. 1..oftcndit quOd rea~didm~FHiusa1ius a Patte, ~ Pater alius a FiJio, non aliud.& allud , quia ly linus 6glliDcar dHtincHonem in perfona , Iy alina rn natura, feU {ubfl:amia. ~t Iimilirer alia nomina c:xcludemia di{hnclioncm perfonarum , vr etfevnicumfelf~ (olirarium,vcl diuilionem poneneie, in natura, y, nomen feparationis, diuiuO+

Dis.di tfercmja vitanda nUlf. .'

Inare, 3. docee quod hccnomen sD11H, Ii Gtidem quod (o!itariu" & excludai con": (onium perfonarum elufdem namr~lnOi1 en apponendum Deo.Sinen exdudat con(or~ dum pe[ronafl1m,(~d ¢onJottfum :lliorum,extra Deurn.porcfl adiungi tcunino elfentia. ..

Ii , vt cum dicimr,Solus Deus eA:: :Etcrnus,Sohuell: imrnorralis, . .

In 3rt.4.docct quod hzc diaio So/m propde non ell: adiutlgcn4:i tetfQino p!='r(on~li, vt G dicarur, Solus Pater en Deus; quia excludie alta! perfonss 1 conforrro pfzdica~i. Si autem pona.t\lr~duerbium,vr,Patc:rfol~m c~ D¢us,dJ: vera,quia. cxdudit ~i~g ~ no.tl .lium a diuiniutis f;:onr~,m:iQ. " , '.

~~~~~~~~~~~~*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Q V 1£ S T I O' X X X I I·

De diuin.flm...peifi;1Jarum, (ognjtionf~ S P.M MALI 'TT E~v9J.

m~~~ V A l. ~ \1 lot quod in 4iuinis perfonis con Gdcrafurio communi;etl de ct~ rum cognofcibtlirate,m quo eriam includunmr . n 0[2: .feu nodones ,. qui" bus petrO~ difcernulltur. rum inter fc? rum ab dfcmia. Ee inquidt quatuor.Prime,gencraHu:r, an T f1mtatis myficrium fit naturali ratIon,," _ _ _ - _-. : illuen:igabil~. Secundt},an demur nerienes fcu nOt% a}iquz,qnibu s 1ing!1-

1<& per{pnOE dlfccrnamur. T cnio, qJlot fin:c i~ no~ione~.' 9,)!an9,an lij:e:Jt eire" ~ 4i~

uerfimode aUt conttarre: opinarj. ,

Igitur in l.aniculo docer Ulyfierium Trinitatis non po{fc vUa,ratione natura-Ii m.;; udligari, qUia nullus c(.c:tl:us naturalis ,8£ qui naturali ratione a.ttingi pm:c:ft, mani .. feA:are pordi Deum , niG lit capi"am talis dfclhls. Ell:: 3\1~e m Deus catifa cre#[urarum rsrione fila:' \Tinutis, ~ potcntiz. &" . :1-His.quz omnia fum :Dei ~n q~aijtum vn!lS~n.op v~

1" rinus • T ):ip.!r3s ergo ratione naturali inud}"igabilis non cit _

In an.~ .. docet effe pcnendasnctiones in d!pinis.,id ell,formas,r~u nota!! quibllS dj{eemanrur ca 'lux penona lia (unt ab c(fcmialibus, Vt diQinguafilUs in quo pcrfOIJ% djpj .. n:J! unt vnum • &. in quolintplurcs. ~I" v.1" irerum in perfona.qne eft VDllj" vtParujdjfcernatur id quod en proprium , feilieee parcrnieas, & id ql:'o~ commune; (cflicct: (pit~~ Jio adi ua.Ec bas no~jon,esJ prop rieJate5,~ npw t:»1'l uam qua(dlJ.m for1l}lIs "d~,m j;lubfrr:~ ..

ao figni1icamus. , , _

In art. j. docee has noricnes rerum per-(onaU.um dl"e quinque. ~ia norlones funt form:t > feu norz , qUlbu~ P«{OD;E innotefcuot ,& .dl(cernumur- lnnotcfcir aurem p~t~ rona Parris dllpJicirct .,& pcr neganonem cxiftendi ab_aHo; & fie eft Inna_fcibiIicas, &. pcr prindpium originandi aJiudi& fie vtdl prio~ipi\lrn FiJiJ;.c:4t parerniras, vt p~incipium Spiritus S-.efl: {pirat~oatblla, q~ .cria~ eft coa"nlunis FII~o.Filill5 aueem inne-, refcirnonone propna, quz di F11iario , in qU2nrum geoitUs ; V1: autem (piraQlf innate-fcit noeione communi cum Pattc:.(cilicet (piratione aa:iua.D~niql.1c Spiritlls S.innotefciE' notione procedendl per modumamoris.quz eft fpirado paBiua.

In art'4.doc~t quod circa norienes licirum eft conttane opinari • in hi~iftqllibu~ non. fequiter aliquid f;onttariutn .fidei,&" detct~inati$ per E,(:lc:fu.~ S~c4s V¢J;~.ip ~m 'lui~ }"us [e..quit~.

;

lDAn. A~. rhD,". in pliTt .1J/lh. T omus alter.

-DISP;,tT .K

.all' ~ifl.XXIX.'XXx..XXX1Xr~ll.. fire lPeifonb,diur.ni}:

~ ~is ~di~«'f1tibU's \lltin\:i)firation~ fubleCij -c'Ul

" - _ '_&_'b_ -11_., inhlH!:anq Be tic-de:bet Cub iIlis poni. &: rub il-

tWt#''''hu4\A\'''~:~~'''J'IV1m~m lis tire: tanlj,Il,Jm (ubieGtilm, & futtc:mariuum eo-

" " -' rum. lit quia h%l;: due -o8icia .(c:u mum:ra f~ci~.

DIS P V l' A T lOX I V. (cdicet in [e IHtete conupunic-;ltionc:m. q uatct]ll~ non (o!Ilfu!lt)I~atur alteri "ne,; vlEerilPi"i lili)iecttl ;lpplic~rur • red in (e ranquam in vltirilo fiLlit. & ful;i alils fotrni5 roni unquam (uilieClulD eatum. rcfulcaui£ hoc nomen fubli!h:ntia. quali Cub:illiJ 1ia~ntia. ita quod Ilflgularc,(eu indiuiduultJ,'1i1mi in (I: {j(lir (;omtTiunh:a!lonem • & .:lre" De vlmi COti)Dlunicet'Jr, & (lib alils ponitur , & (ubiic:itur, VI alia libi communlcenr, dicitUt (cbli'lc:ns, ~ fllppollrum • '" fl:l natura. Ik prima! fllt;fiantia, & hrpolbli~ , i::di fidll natut'a ratiolJali j dlcitul pedQJia. 0 III nia. millen jfta idem lignific;;tlc, &: eotdem dT~aU5 fadunr, (cIHcct illo, dllll~, ~luud ell noil commuiliClti ali, (iibied:" ~ Ieu tcrmino,8t t'tclperc in Ie ll1iarum fortnarum cemmuniearlone!u,E.( ideO, lUattd:t. dicirut in rebus campoli'; tis principil:tl11 indiuiduationis (ubfi~ntjiili5 , quii etl: vldmlll1l (ubic:.!I:um omnium forli1afUID ."hill quod aIred Cubicao non communkanrur. In ri~ bus aurcm (pirit\l~libus founa ve Inecmmunka-

bilis , en principium indiuiduationls. "

Sic ergo dLflillgu~nd.? filnr nomina omni Iingl1-- , !ad conueniemu line lit accidens • ul1e (uo[hnti~,r.lle pm,uu:= mtum,l nominib<lS peculiaribu, f\lbtbllf.i~, 9.U:i! nc.n ell parS, fed t?tum. No-miDI' commwlIa fimt • Smguhrc, Partieulare , lndtulJllum:ha.~enim eriam acciderni adaprantllr. liellt' b;E'c !I1btdo,h:u qtl~ndr:u,&'e. & adapt.:lnmr c:dalP pdrri • VI hzc manus. hie oCLlluJ,ift.uuris.Et hnmanitas ChrilH finglll.uis.& indiuidu:l cR:,{ ed non fuppD!iWtn. NomlUa vera Cpe:cl:di.1 lignificantja indlUir!uum.qllod in g<=nere (uh'bnti:E eft tl;ltum~ & comph:ltJnr ftu Icrminatllm,non vero par5. M. c.:m(l!quemtr non ell: communicabile. fed inCDm ... mllni';lbil~ • qUia hoc irro quod en reiIl1in .. turn t &: cbu(um in [c,inCQmmllnicabilc cn. «gn! .. fi~mr nominibu~ ddignannblls ulbil;tlutn • fun-. d~ml!mum.& yhimum. jl;u' tmninatmn in fill;;<. fb,nri~ VI [ublill:enc.fuppoumm • prima fnbJUnriliJ &e,qnz ["P,.J numerate Cunt.Et qUQ" illa nomina fignitiCM1tilJ, 6ngularetcompletum .& towe in g¢'o" nere {ubll:lnd:r: jmpQrt:Cnt incommunieabiliratrnl, ram obuium c:l1: apud Allthorcs,vt rnirsndum lir polle aliquem dehocdilbir~rc. pili qui:tb eOrllln libri~ a(pe{tllm aucnat !t~ affirmal S.Thom.in he ~.1?lIrt. J.4d 4'& ad id addllcit dc6nitio!J~m Rf:o ch;udi de perlon;!.. ybi clJ:plicatur in~mmunicabJ--" lit .1.$.hcCt in definitionc Boedj non cxplic~llr. it SC[ltu5 in s.tlifl.1 j<'f' r.hane deflnithmcm Richardi mulnim commcnd.tr,~ pr:l!fm cam ddinido~ oi Boetij. quia vtitur nomine incQmmllnicabil~ potitl$ qll.J1ll indiuidllre.Eadl:mqu~ definition!: Ri .. c;~rdi de ineoru-mil ni':Jbilitatc vfll$ ell: Ieannes Theol~us CODtra Motrr;um Ephefium in Condlin Florcn'inor.ffiM~ " Vidcatllt Su:nc~ lib .•. J. T ri"it,C.I. V ilfqut;:t. [UjUT bll.t1& qli.1.!} • .zr,: s. il1t_ metllAril1l1T,icul, Caie~:{urer IlInJflll 'I".ltt" 1. T or~ re~ ibi • tJc commnnit~t Ol'I1nc:s in r«prirc~ , S. Thorn. [upct E:unaemloeum nplicnntt'5.& de .. fendentcs dc6nirioDctn l3oihij.qu3m mox u:plica.bjmu5.

. Il.t ra!io f:la~ iJ,~roblt. qUillingtlhrc (ubllah- 4 tlZ Ggnlfieat ilhq~ldcomrlctl1n'. ~ totc;n,o\cqulI adeMn re thulul'n.& !lu!l. ciflllmunk;,bih: aheri.

V ndt; in vfu communi nan vocamm panes> 1'*rOllas,aUt fuppolita,licur oculum.aut mJnum nOll dicimU$ elf.: per(onam ~ qui a partes coml1lunkabi~

. 1~ lUnhtlOll. pQ'fonaj~ ,Jc:IU ~Jt d; aJlim;11Cp3~

, _. PU

De perfonis diuinis ,~ nononibus in commum-

AR.iICVLVS

1.

• 0 N ell: snimus dc lingulis ilHs dir·

K (erl:lc. ~ dilli!:ultne; vadas. qua: circa fubfi~elJtia,m feu perC?n~lil:l.tern. &. cx!llCilU3iTI excmn (olcnt

- "hie explicate. Prz!1itum id lno~is

ell pr!tud.tomQ difp'4'&; w Ph,fieiJ q. 7. Nune 10- 1\UlI hzc b!cu,itcr d~lib.1t'1lt1~'\lll'lren?S ,con,dll,um ~ll eXpliC~ridalD ranonern perlon:!:: dlullllt m quo ,onlilt.Jt)& ql!id ad e~m rtqllir,uuc.

I

Ell: <=rgo not:mdl1:Tl apuil. omnes pro certo.& cornperre ha.bcri • rasienem ptr!(,oz • hypolb.us, (uppo(lti • [nbfiltcnli:t. & primz fublbnli2:. ad Jillgnbr~ ill genal: fublbmiz pertincrc. Vndc &. d<=tinitio Boed; de p~rrDDl pt't indiuidll.1tionc:m procc-dit. dum in~lit Allod PU'f~lIlf eft ralitl1fdlis T1 .. rll~~ iIlJir#iJH.c ji1rjJdltlitl. EI dcfiniIio R ichardi dcS.VIQotclib.J.a~Trjnit.~lIf· 13.& 1~. '!Ii us menricncm fcdt S.Thom.birl]-19.atl.;.aJ 4. vbi deliniuie perCon,lIn dillitl31n • quod sft dir.i'11. llii'liT;' i11l:~1111nHl1kAbi{iJ e"iflt'~tjtt • "bi quod Bo~tius t'o(;aiilt indiuiduam • Riclurdus vocat Incommani~ilt:1\'I • qui:l, non poteft indilli.lul[io inrelligi (inc !I1iqu:l incommeuicebilitate, fiqUidem vaiUerlaliw tommunic.lbilit:Utm dkir j &; fic cius n,r P'11.i, IUm, quod cll,linglllarc • Ceu indiniduuu\ :tIiquam incolPlf,l1nicabliit.l,t~m dcbe[ habere , & id qu.od pcrfcd:c. & comrlete indillidLltlm dl, tiCUt fupPolttUm , vel p~r!ona. tomple!t incl;lln~ rnunic.lbllc: dl. vt ~m I;'xplicJmus.

2. E:I: hut ergo pfinti~io. 6( pcrfuppolito, 3pud

emnes eeno • quod luppofilUDJ. vel (ubfilb:m pcnincnt ad l'ationem lingill:!ris. fcd indillidl:li. ,,!tenus nafdtUr dilfmnri3 v.1lde conIiJct3.nd;) inter fi'ns:ub.rc accidenfis , & fubfianti~ ~ quud tnJiuidl.lOlU qllid~1l1 ;lccidt:'ntis h2bet t1n~uuri~lre.& d.etull'Iinarc pt;rdic;lt~ quidilatill31upcriou tan~ll1!U vltittla determinario. & innmns gradus in b=ri~ przdic;I[O!Unt • qUia indiuiduano eft ld; quod omnibus gudibus fubiidtur in bac feric; ~~d umen quh pet fe non pOl:e.fi: el:iQere. [cd mCllg~ alteri inhit~e • ('wus adminiculD. &. ben~ fi~o futltTiienn- .. idc& non pardi we accidens cUll.m pIOvt'ibdiuiduutU • 'ell'e ohuUfto inc:ommlini':l~ile, fed indign a1icui fubiet}t; ,('oinmunic3ri~ \'c ib. (ufl:en\et'lir. At VClO (mgul.nc (Ub(l;ilUiz DUn follliJ'! ciJcir ulionem infinli .. radu:; in (eric

~ ·Iing, pr~di~~totUfil ~ ~gtadlt.i:n comtit\l~n~ -I:!U~ • fed m~m. djdt. nn~~ ~fteriris pet' fe, & In (c fine IIldlgtnna adlllUllC~ altc=tius In qllo

• • .. {U~tlUUUf. Vlldc don debet vlrt:PUJ communict1.ri ~ QpC}1Wn temtino ... d Cubit'll-o. (cd llJ\cte in ~~~ p~ ho~ pr;;bcIc lu::ddcmihllS ~ & fo.~

.. - ... i' Ij. __ .1 ~

ni!)f~'itJ;o x JP.

'h·t;'t; 'qu:ia et:fi fie (ubhflens, id ell:; pCtfe~:ulI:e'fi"~ ~on ramen perrona ~ & {lIfpolirum, qllia communi cabills,& vnibilis eft. Vt f(ltlna,fcu pus.

4 OJ:!od Ii peru .. quam sommunicabilitatcm cx-

dudat (uppofi,urn .. (ell perrOn;!. quando ~icifUf incomml1nicabilis!N::im lireddir natuum incommunicabllem , (equiCUt fubfill:~dotS rclatiu<u in Deo non elfc perfonas,qllia nattln diuinz pcr pe,fonam l)arris incommuniC2hili~ nOD ell pt:don~

'ilir· . . .

lteCp.ex n.Thorn. in pol A"ibllid.dijfinQ'ftf.

fiflilJll MM.i" filii. qllOd perf ana , feu indiuid~llJm in 'ilbtlamia ududit rriplium commLinicabiliu~ Icru. Ptirn~; vnillcn2lis ad inferior a , quia irrdilli.dl1urn ( pr;:eCuti III dcfign;ullm ; . non lC'qmmdo de iildiuiduo vago) non poreft elfe vniliq(alc, nee h~bcre inferiora. S cCllndo. paitl I ~~ EOfjlm • qi1l~ '11 compla;l ~ ~ terminau (ublt'lnria. T cuio j af~ fumptibilu ad ali'quid di~itl!. {CU termmabih, 1Ilctt:iQri terminG ~ qllia etli n~Curil ponic dli.lrni. ramen p~r!on,;l, alrl1mi non purdt H'ne: d\l;;itu~ ~d. inllanrjam de p~rh::misdiuinis; qu,e rdm'l,.untn~6 rur!comuUI(ab.!i: • .x ramen {jm pcrllm.l::dil;unu:1 en im 'l!I()J rehnquunr nil[IJr.il1ll 'D[j~m un1cabile 'It nlltll'~m,non Vt f'1..1'onarammam lpl~ pc-trona I'atril nan eft com'llum.abdiJ , (IIJfi.u: ,lUcem ad [1. riOtil:ffi p"rfQII~ 1 ~uOd ipf.i! r~rt()n.l. (ell. limlra yt ptr(onar.i! non li~ COIHUhI(Abilis.licch ve natura t:Omunicabihs fir. Et hoc idl:o lit in djQim~. non in pcr{onis ertarif.q,uiI PI:[(ono;litatc· drulIIz lilne re b.riuz; non abiolu:z. De ra[WIlC all"rn fd~riui cftquod h~bC::2[ ccrrelanuum , licl!{ dilhnaulU 1 fe in qlllllltllm oppotimm ubi. nun r~m~n d.llillaUn! i narura , quia non 0pPQulum ilh. V ude quiacortel~rii1llm ttIminutn baht!" illlfa e~ndcm t1amram , non potell qu.dibet rdado elf: re~miDIU lId>tqllarll5 £Iarurz. (cd illadarquatufj q,lia deb« d3re con{ortium ~Irerl correlanuc. Vndc mio per(on:.: r~litiu<e • Mil ell: reddere lurllum incornnllUlkabilem • qllau:nus IUtur.l ell, ted IpCun p~Col1alIl tewilWn {cddit inC"ommurliclIbdcm. &:: 12:uuram • quatmu, pcdon~ta ell. non .. bl(_,IUtf. ~Uill iil;uLr:qlUtus tcrminuJ Cills eft. vtpote r .:J~ nuus. Terminus alltcm feu r.a-foll:ilita5 ct(!olI:a, qUia ~bfol..Iuca, .. d:cqll:mu;!. Vnde rc:ddltlla· turasn .JbCobre incolJ1IDllfllc.llbilem i & lie qll:tnw do atrtlmpr;l ell namr,l hllrnan3. 1. V c:obo. qC.lU. pcr(Q~ah[;H in,ptdit~ c:Jl.~.tr" ~omcn iilppotiti. &: prnon~. &. :Ilia qq~ prim3.111 'UbJtalltiillmdeti~ g'lant incommlln ie., bilit:i1rcm in ipCue ~ fc:u Cubftilmi. lingularl important.

S Dcnomin~ hypoft~li5,~ {ublbntiz.maloupod

.:mdqllo, cOnltollerfiil fuit J ~rdQct:t S. Thorn. ill bJf& '1.if1'1.:z..R4 a,IX .. ,q-"~. Vidc-tIlI' "niln direGte (;ofrdp()Ildere nomilli bypolhfis hac DI1IDI:"B (ubfhnti:l.~[) quod .plld Grzem hoc namen r Ji;. tignHj~n dlcnriam. feu quiddibtcm.mr Datunm. &. hypo;J:;'di, dic:i£urquafir._p. .fC12f,J~ffiI11ilt~ &: idemli~!Jific.lre vidcrur flloJi:mtu • quia t:Jl ql:laU Cub ;lii" Ibns • if( vidmn ¢l;phc:ate ofiiciUID inblbndi. El ali:!. '11('[0 pancQPPQnihtt :u:cidcnti. &0 6gnifiClt id qllod intiinum.& fubJl:mriaJe ell iii aliqiio. :ad dUfae-ntiam ilccidC'rmllm quz Cl:fetioritamn f.tcil.mr. Vndc f.aUla eft quOd plum ~ nomine bypollam,li:u {ubfb£lf!Z olim 4ccipeen, fur. -qwa plmes IUcndcm~$' ad r:niooeM 'qbtl:andi, &. non adr:l;tiol!em ,,&. feu cffi:nriz. tiatplici=radminebmt £reS hypo-flares.vel rrcs. fQbl~ntiu. De:indc: 'Vera in yj GgnfficuiollH v6~ • 4c {Ilbftan~ tialifuts cogtbantur fatcrl aU dfentiu in Dco,&: hocet.2t ~eti'lI.m_ Pol'hll04IJIUV(U Ca{bOllco~ Pauum. ftDoaoolWfttmla <;;;.~,i}u-

ArfiC'. ·l-

·extra lis ifta ~ompoitta ~ft • n nom'tn hy'fio'lbliil pgrCotuIi'tinihus ~ (eu fubfilh:llrii~ deplitetur aw~ men rnb1lamiz. vfi:c,fcu (''{fentia!) 'l.uU. virum e~ in nomine (ubAiniJ~ magis d"ilm: aitem!j ad ~omrapo6rionem cum accid'Cllribus cu~i·o'tibU~ ·qlla~ a~ odisf~m(ubll:.lt:di feli fll~entandi ac.cideona : III nomanc ve~3 h.YPQtlalis, l£i!.lm (Ilbdf~

feu fubl1an: magis espiicari. .

DefttJitiuFtr:fol1~ ex/liC'll;";& ilifenfo. .

Ell: hi! I:xplicari ro~1l defillirio F{on~foprA , rr~dir3 .:i Bueno. quod Ptrfottll ~fl tA/jOnil/J· t141""

r,. il1liillidull [UbjlSfiIJ4' Dh;iu1i lndluidu;I {u&a~

cia. hoc ell prima (ublhmtia , ira qLIOd I)' (Ubj1iill-

ti« frgnlfi!:.:It conccpeum[uh!1;melz.vrde (eCOIDmunem ~d pri m<lln , & fe-cundam fiibll.1G darn •. &;

per Iy indi'uial1.ltfj rr .. hfmr ad(landum pfopritna fubftJiltja i vtdoc~tS.7h6m,in h.t& qk",jl. 19'''~ i.ad 1.& if:l,~o.~m.l,ad·1 dicit, quodp.bjlll'lli_m 4eJi,mtmll Pt~J~~tI.~o,! jignift~4itJi.rltit!lm: foJ. fop~ P"/tlU m. Er It31ndnlldua fu.bflannl-ligI11tic.at Cilb.;. fimtT>lm lirig!!lar~m compkram. & qu~ ea CQfUnl

& ~onl~quclltcr qu:t' in'm'tlmllnic"bliirer i feu (0'" uHfI:!' (qblillir. Dicttur auU:m rtllfi~"itl;1 nlil_"e" qUl~ non qucdiib(:r fuppolimm eft pm(:ma J fed

ill genere illtdkatlah.Et hoc idea. quiz n S. Th. aducrtic j;j hat: qJt;e[1.11.lirt.~. Ad 1..& if] ,.Jijl. it.

IJH. '.Art. I. 'f] Jittt tQrp. idem "dducit 1:1 Bocdo li;~

at d"ltbm 1f"'H'rU • nomen pctfon:r pnmo impou.. tum ell 1 ptrfOll.llldo , quia in tr;lg~dii$ • 'cu. ~O" m~djji tC'citatore;, qui r"mo(oJ vlro$ Icprfc1cn,.. tdb.lnr qUlIlc1am fibi iJrtf3m impDueb1J1t 10 Be w: r'·rr~(~mabm(. (eu p~f(on~blH' illolum d.tta • &: gc:I~;!1 Sic: rc:prl:(l;nranm diccbi'lni:uf ptrfOM:. (~il aHCUIII! JigiJ,od; viri perfOl'llm gtrere. llid~ Cr~ dum e!l.rtomm.;td lignincandum digni~;ltem aliqnam corurn qui pc:rlOII::t" dicuDJur. Et quia lnte! omnes (ubltanrloU.quz imclleallalel (unt d"ign!q-

res tilnt.ad conun d,guicac~ c:)!:plkan~m~ Puwp

nz di4i LUnc.

Ex duplici ramen p.m e h%c: dcfitlitw impugna- 1 t~ eft a S.:(){o,l It ichJfdo de S. Vi{t(,I(::.a UUfrn-

tio Vall3. S!:QtU$ ~ RicbOltdUI J abilc!Uilr !;01'irr, Illam P:i[til;uum ,udirtidf#tIIN alb t;OJlaa ilJam par~ tkulam fllbjtil1J~iJf. Obikit St"OfIJS d·, {MprA, quia d~6nitio ilia (onue:oit alllrnz raEionaii {cp:lr;az,,¥ amen nb~ ell pcr(ona: ergo non eft bona. M.!iot prob. quir anima fcparara eli !ublbnria. vt dc: lC liqrn:t : ,ft indi uldu:1 • quia dI: .lingubii!; dlta~ tionali~ .II .. ~u[z, IJuia eft imd1etJ:i~ Obiicic RJ.. c:b~rdus t quia ilia d~ !initio c(lmpmr Dami. {cd. diuin:t' n:Ulll'zo. IX htl [C Dco: n .. m cliilimtu ~3 {ubfianri.a." ell indiuldll ... quia tiDgubt~. & elt talionalb narUf::t. quia inrellcailia, ~ E.amcn noli

elf pcr(ona, {f'd tdbUf p~tlollil: communis : .·tgo~ Obikir Vall:!lib.fi. Ehg,,",.ellp. H.qui3.'in~.« ead(;QI p;s> feu fubllmria plines dicirur gctcrc p~r(ollas • quia flutes rcpr:zftnut. au[ vIce carU,n1 fungifur.P~dona ergo ad qu~iWtm !ped:.1t) lC!1

ad officium ,non ad !ubtbmiam. & ~~ lfica!lgr~ t.ic6nirlJr per (ublbmiam.Er bU'I1:" fatlum eli qll~ SabeHiu~ Mil umhUm CUf,Uct Dco amihu~ plures pCrfolU5, Iil:l!r {ohim fare-ram YIlU_IU {II~ pofilum oinUmqgc: (ublillms. q:uia pluteS IlIth~

bat p"folUJ (~Il pluduiD !UlllJUC fn.qgebarur eadem Oct fubJilla1tia apl.ld ipfum. v.pqe &. plum anrlillorum'''t t&m S. GregoriilS N~~z .. ,""1_

2.IJ" .Atb4l1",rIH1/J t:~rtll jll~TTS. ,fC'c;&,IIabarit .{ohim .-

CDIlCcd~fC DC:(J plllles pa((IQ:Q, Jlc: in Sabdhj .. r~

rorcm yidnm~Dr dC(limrc>qul rllJrium inULlCJ:U~

r d! ~ ,. f._n' - .. .-.1-- llwmdk

.cv. a __ .amlQ$ --r~ - .. cc~

~£ft. XXIX. fic. Ve 'Perfonu tjiuinil.

vo~ 'l't D:Thom. tkeet in J~Jifl·l~.q.I.(l1't.l,iTJ ftM t:"tp~ril,dc[illatUr,fic\lt pet (of\a 3. facie lanla[a;q\;~ tepr:J:(ent;lbantl~r pedooz in coma:dHs. ~adf,jtn voce 'i'cuntur TemdliafillS conlJ'll Prllxe.m, Hiia§ rius lib.de Slnod".Hkiolly['il.Epi~. ~7 • .Aug,Ub .... d~ TTinit.f.3.& 9. Leo Papaftrm.2.. d, P~'mcoJle. Damaf us irt 1;(Jl1ftffio71t fidei ad PIUllim~m. Concil. T olersnum 1l.il1 '''l1feffwl1t jiJei , L;u:cunCnk: in '"

Firrnil'7 & c. Dam!WnllJ vbi fupta. . .

Concludlmus ergo de 6de effe dati in De0l'cr- 11 {enas. MC Gneiplis flare myllmill'li Trinitatis.c:}('que rectA adaptari dc:linitionetn Bocci;. quil funt {uppofit:J., Ceu prim;l: fubltaJltiZ' in n~tura intdlcduaH diuina, Solum ;idumcndUIn I:ft ne Dimi. [CIupulo Yocum hzr~3m\ls, cum dicitUf fubGfl*

ti a! fup. politilm. hypo ~aGsj quod tomm fOlut aliqllld [lib/tans, & hlbU'~aum I [ultentans f(]fjllU fupctuenitntChqilz atddc:nuici {I.ln~; quod tame

in Dec non illuCnitur.quia accidcntium ~pax: DO.

en-. non ob hoc. Ligmlicatum inorllm nominum dc:dt~ Dco, Dicimus enim ex D. Thorn. ;" hA& '1. 19,arf.~,~d J.t!( in t. diflil1El. q. '1. I. arM .• J4 'iI~immn, quod hypo(bli,,& (uppolitutn non fum III Dee quantum:ld mumn fu!tentandi ac;:idcmia,1

quI' nomen illud imeoJimm , & origin2tUm til,

fed qllamurn ad rem lIg_nificatam. fc:iliC'et comple •.

IUm (ublitl:cns in noltllt2 r.1tionali. E, ob id R.i-,hlrdu5 in (lin. d~pfljtID"" 10'0 indll.lidll:li: (ublhn ..

ti~. pofllit inc:nmmunica hi lern e;rillcDtiam ad ac.. lignlndum fubllanti;om in Deo, non vrfublhtm:m

:11iis. fed tl cx.iftc:mern in fe, &: per fc: incommuni'~bil~[c:r • e.: cotnph:[~. Dilhll.s.ullnulf autem Ula normna hypolh(j~. fubG!L:nu2.. rUFpofi[um.re$~ noltUr:z:, tli~m in creatis non <:1 p;mG rei 6gnifica~

fa: • II~C 13Tl1tn [uln [Yl1ornma. quia lubellt Qfigi-:-

nem ex diucrns pdnqipiis, &; po aunt in veulU .Iignifi':,ationCin'lUC= illorum venire, fi ali'luiS yc:&

fie applica,,) &. vri illis pro 6gni6,~riori~ talillill furm3Jj[~tum reu munerum, [;:lliccrTub{bndJ aut

pet fe c~ndii &.1'1, non bili.:nt v(cm{Yllony" mum, lice' eal1q~m tern lignifi~t.

Ctb3t; ~ lk:'plures fulliner; perfon1~. E:(illi~:I,~ bal1.rergQ IlftfottaJ1i, qualit.'lu:tn feu rt:pr"l¢ntallo~

nem impottat:e.non Cllbflantl:lm., .'_

8. .. Ad Scotum RcCp. quOd Boenus nomme indi'UiJIl~ (ub£bntj~ inrellcxir (Ilbaantiam prlruam, 1J1I.!E ClttetiS omnibus (ubfl~t, [CII Cub aliig omni- 1I~5 el\;· Ih ita 111 If il1ajllidu4 "'fnitimelligendum indlllid~uiJl compictl.lID) k;U tOt. de , quod ell: indi;. WdUl1ffi (tn1pmitct in'gcnerc: f~bfuDtht, ve S.Th. c:~pUC3t jff' J. diJl;ntl.1J. ,.1. art.:,.. ~ #t. h~c,.2.J. Art. ~.lId4.tk q.;o.lttf.l.ad l·Rt lie Inrc1!lgendo 11

~, ituulliaull17J pro indiuiduo complc[o.~ hnnin,uo. fru, quad idem ell. incommUllicabili. non conuenit~nim;e rcpar.u:r dclinitic pa:fQIl£, quia (Jon ell ilidillr&Ul1tu complc:nim, /':{. incomrnunicabilieee [uhliftcns • (ea. .... nibills , &: COJTImuniCllbilis ve fOrma.

, Ad Ri,hatduin didrnuf ecdem roodo. quo d

Dei~ (~ hie Deus ; cfta\iquid GJlgiJlar~ , ~ per {c,jmoa feCl:i!l:ens I'" ipGmct dfc:lltialis exiilcnd~,(~d ramen non eft ul1guI3.l'ncrmiD3UlID, &in~ c:on'llnunic~bile intra Ce, I.!( ita non c:1l: indiuiduum per modurn (uppoliti , &: P[~ (ubl'bl'lliz > Ctd ptr modum eRi=mi:t. &: lutu~%; atqueadc\l non

, (Ilnllcnit d dcfinido pcr(on~ tra.dit:£ ~ Boedo, qui (limit indiuidl1lm (ubibrnialu pro indjllidua compl~rc > & [orailrct. (eu pc:r modum fllppo6ti. G_!!od amptiu~ ded;u'auit Ric'llarQus. loco inJiuidU;l;, poncJ'l.s incommuDlcabilcln J & S. Thorn. bj(& '1.~9.arl+.td .pdducit,

. Ad V ;dl~m Refp. ipfam in hoc pdlime lemire, 10 qllQd p~dona fol:un qualituem lignlfictf. (eu re-

. pt:t(el1rarionem. & olhdum. N~m vr (~aC obfc-r.

U.3.t S.Thom. ID~Dcir.m l.dJjb.;.q.l.411.1.d I, iuclicillm de nomine non debtt dl~ fccllndum hoc. a quo imponitur, fed (c:cundUm id :llt quod ftgnioondurtJ illl1:ituitur. V nde lici!t DolUCD perCorut' titlmpofiwm 0. rept:r:(enutioJ1e:. t:ni'lcn cllimpoiitum ~d 6gnifiea~cbmfQbfr;tfiti;m:l compleram ill natura Intc:Uethtali fubliikntcm • & hoc Den conuenit. Qy3propter gt;lUiter j1\ hoe repr~hcnditur VaUa,quOd db:criI non m.1gis in Oro cile perfona~, q~hn ~l hru~s aninumibus~ e:l hlc PUll; 1;1'5. r1iauc:~1izqu.!llocwone dcCCptllh cUm clI:pEcfsii fides docut)& EcdcliadcfinhE ill Dee dflluesper~ (on:l5. & Vl1;j_M elfcntiam in &.FII'(lfjr~t.& ,,!D"'TlIlIiJ1Ilf4/. th filmm,. Trinit: 6( in ClJl1cilio Flortminll. ,;- J~ _fli" litis. Nee bmit 8o,oum hoc ill. quo a Valla tc:ptchc:ndintr. qu04«il. pl:tlOn.l non ~ {ubllantia. (cd a leprzreDtaOODC leu munere , & officio impoo2tw', cUm bee i pfurn diU( .BoetiU5 in lib."t JiUhw ""r~ fillilli 41ite 1lUdi"m, quOd N ~nun ptrfoh~intp'filtml 'fig F"fonblth• 9";a;" cmllZJiii f'n;t.'#r~ .. tl J'lpr~fom ~U'" lliiiH~",~ tai~ g41"Y«il~. LrrIl4If~ f4&imJ ~~~ b.nr; &" fie ru;t~ fHIIID p~rfo1t4h"71t.ld ergo dl. iquQ nOWeD etymologi~E. ft'a non 3d. id fignificandum eft impo6tuID. fed 2d GgnU1caJl-. cos ipros homines [oblbntialitc:t in fe ) &: hoc modo ftt-qUt1lS eft Yr~ huius vocU in iute ciuili, cUm agitttt de:: aaione. [Cll inill~b pcdolUtUm;& in Sttipntra, 'It cUm dicinu' S;picni.6. Zijfl f;;b"UtI ppfo1U1fj 'f4i.[,x.nt DnM, vbi nomm Ftfonz;ld (lmnn utml:liwr. & P~iitcr.10.J)'Ul flllj ftl'[m"'1lJ 1WJ IfUipil., JJ4fJUUltr/l; All. Ie. N~n t n Irr[~M",14r.D~iU. EtiD.~~lfib~j lu:c V01- ,"{l11II profublbntlab fubfilknu.a. finnllur, &: in Do:o ?cr~'tOpitllr. ft contbt a Symbolo AtNr nalij: .A1iAt1lrf1'frm/lPlUriJ~~ FiUJ.&:·Et Na- ., 'Zian~td>i {""." eandctn VOCCID Atbau3fillm apFtClbalfe..-efert. Et vbi babcrnr. in Symbolo. ,,,,IIi

f:-r.".. ,r-i<G .l..J:~ ,

~·I·. . .fnl"'~ ~1Ii~ ~~.~

.!JgiJ. fit per{olMlito in ctl71um,ni, tJ1iiJ pt'~ flcll/ilM d.illifJ/J,& quomodo "i!nH pcr{orJiI Jit (0711111lmilf

{lcrfon3Iius. c;um (it id qllo fornullrer conlii- 1 i mitut pcr[ona, nihil aliud irtJpon~l in natUIa$~ lionali.qll3m fubGftcmia, & fLlppofitaliusin Q1Ucumqne fublbntia. Elt enim r~ttninns) ku compkmenrum fublhnti:r; qua redditUr vldmo ~t'P= pleta , &. tetmina~a, licu! quantir:ls tcrminatuI rli~ pcrlidc,lincOl, pllnai$. Er 'lLlidqllid iUud tir. con~

ftat tc:[lIlinum hunt. [eu Cubll!b=ntiam nOll per-

tin ere .ad pr.r;dicatum cOllfiitutiuurn D3tur~, led conllinlta: rerminatiuum.Conllar: hoc maniftll~;

n.;Itn in Cbrifto Domino tft: inte:gn. buman;. na-

tura in ratione natUrz; nam eft vt:re • &" .integrA homo,nD elfet autern fialiqllcd CilftitUtllllltl1 pr~ .. diCllEUn'l illi &t: (lit: vari;u>t!n1r ep.im eSClltia ; &: umen Cuppo{itwute!'D [eu [ubij:am~ CIc:ltam

non ~bet. Ergo Don p~tinct [ubfitl:c:ntia ad confiiu.ltiDncm o:ltUt~. (ca 3d ,~inariQncm IUt\UZ

ell nftit Iltz. .

Qyid aurem lit hoc qnod p'~tJ:r natUra illlpon:n I J' fub.ijltcntia,& [lIppo!iuihas • aut pcrfonalitas. an

ut .aliquid reale, an aliqllid rarioni~. an modus,

vd qltid tandem li~ c.liximus fr-«~J. t011lD "'[p. + arr.t.duA :..J.ijfifxlt.Jum. Ex hoc ~im 4epc:nd~ tCite qllid lignilic:a.& prQ qllo CUPPODat Iy I mliH(..

- rlf~./Ilt111ur itt d.din,il:ione f. q[9I_1z. Nam qui~.

JlQ~

itJJijp¥itlffio K]P. ;!frjJr~,1.". '. Ilj···

'(tbminc inJjujdli •• intelligunt rcI;,.riol1eln TlttiOnir. 'lii1 pimit:liI4rihilJ. (;q.ll1pe!i~ .:lUfe·m (uhtlandij: (cHicet (lJbiidbili~:l.tem ad prdicara fuperiora .pulii:ularfbU!i inqillidilari pr:r f; ~ ilon ticui: ac~

'quod tribuitur Durande iii i.dijl.tJ.q.l.num.1.4. '~ldetltia qll.:i: IndiC(iduaml'u't peH.fiud:. illqlf~

Itaquc Cumid ylnaiuidu" I Qgid tOM phyliie. In- 'CaM/cil. perfu~ic;,hjm j vr di"erad1Horp .• rt , E.~

diuiduultlautem logicc fumprum eontrapOniUl't parrcsindluiduamur, non per fllbi<:lGlum in '4ue.

vl1iuc~(;ili logi~e (UlflpEO" Vrliuerfa!c autem Iogi. funrJ~d p~'l rerum qaod C(lInPOtHltit., ..

Cilm dicit rclatlonem ad inferiau per modurn Et Ii inql:!iratur,qllcm dfd.hi f~ciilt modus fJr~

fupc:dor.is,> 8& pu~dicabilis. Indiuidnur» e(g(l 10.. f:u realitas quam.add't pCI1DIlalir.ls t'cu ~UppOlitl.

giCLlnl dieer rd~tionctr:l pet modum ilifcriorj~, & Ims [up'~r naturamlRefpondco dllOs dic"pu for ..

(ubiidbilisi~ lie in delinimmc: perfona:: incliuidtla males p ra:lh[c,quorurtJvnu5 aliqLlandu (cp~ratu~

~, fublland.1 ell:: fublwniavt [ubiieibilis pr;;tdic~Ei; ab alia; «toralircr,& Iid;t'Ciulr~ non iit complet~

(upcrioribus.. . . illdiuidt.um : di enrm ntO'dus CXiflChdi per fi= •. ac:

I . A Iii ~ic unt. non. film; 11 iIt4i~idH .. logic:~p .• o en !ti" ,dus citi fic-ndi inc onJmuntc~ bili eer aJr~ri fi.IP;"

4 k;cl1ndl intentione:, (m prO. rdauoocr3tlorllsj(~d poiictl quarenus habet fh.tUID roeius.vr dilbngui:"

pta prim3. inlcmionc, (eu pro eo quod h~bcdn te tud p~m!:,'qLjlt' commlJliicabiliEcrfe hab"t ad ~o"

indiuldnum fubll:anriald:r dicunrqnod in tt: non eli m. lit anima mion.li5 {cparara, Iketjl'er Ie exi-

addit(uPT~ ,latUfJm ol!iquid pol!tltium,fed :lJi'1~id lbe,ncllt f;im"l1 ve eotum incommunicabilc;·& Iii;:

:acgai'iuum • (cilif;.Ct il1communicabIIlrat<.:m, i.u non dt pcr(on2jld autem qllO'd dlperfona, &; tilp;.

Dltgacionem eommnnicanonis , non Collim per poliunn incommllm,~bihu:r fc hJDet.& ranqu~fll

mcdum vniuertalis • ;ld inferiora. [.d pet mcdum quod,uTI rerum in {c elaulum t & lompfet!l'nt. Ei

parris incompl~ta::Old (O(Um; debet ramen ronno- vocarur (ubfilh:mi=l, qmm:nus per {e e"illit:. hr-

ure aliq1lid pofiduum lupra quod flmdetut .(ta PO[Ll'i~ vero,feu (uppo(j[jlJil'~ qum:nUf :tHis :u:40

negacio. (i,u~ in diuinis conn ow relarionem in ditibu!, ;'IUt pr:tdkaris lilpponiruf".& (uft(;mac'~a,

qu:l. fund.leur ilb ncg~tio jjjcommunic,.bihwj~. Vt JOI:l!t 5.Thom.ltlh,u'f.l!i."rl.~.il1~I1Yp. £t 6.-

Er b~c ~aopinio Scot! 1ft 1.dlfl·1.f.q J .Alij dicunr milltcr declMar lao' dU~l eifet1:us modi '"bGa~n;.

ly i"aillidlltf .in defiJ1itionc pcrCnll~ , arquc ~dl!o ti~ • [cu· fupfotitaliratis complc;r& in alii! loels .Di;.

fpfam pa(Dn,tlira~cm leu (lIppo~r.ilit~~"m irnpor- 'it cnim i,i 'f.g.dqotmfi,urt.,. (judd PU}1IfT1f P-

ure ilIiqLlld pofirluum [up,,:rlddlwm Ipli natllfZ. g"Jjit:llt t14iHram I;wn '1l1u4at11 muM IxiRtmli • qtii

ilIamque rerminans • :5i; complens , qu~;:1I. com- tflQdHUjl tjfo pel' fo lXI/1m;. ld(m!lll~ b~bec ill ,.

munier [~nn'!nda • & inter Thomiflas fund.oltiffi. d,P.1.,.q, 1.117t.T.o2d 1-.At vc:ro il1 hilt: q. Jo.Rrr'lf.il

mOl • vu-ir .lo~o oflendimus. R ell(:ra cnil1':ap~,f ona 1.dicic .quod Li,;' p~TftJfllJ fit rfJ'ltmmsnf(ab,IUj t it.~

feu filppo(irum dl olliqllid pofitiuum V'T~,& rea- me« iplt t,.~dHr t:xij/tnd# iri,u7iJntuni,,,/Ji/ittr pmfl

liter inueneum :l pam: rei. Non potdt ~urcm :lh- effi ~fittmll4nil mu/ru; Q!!a!f Cubfil1:cntia. feu rup§

quid a parte rei t:epl:rtLl!1l formdlitc:r • &. per (0:: roiit~ljta~3da::qu~te (umpra hos dUOJ df'cCtUj im~

primo con Rirui ente rationis qllod ell ncg·uio,allt ponar. fcil.f~tcrc, per {e eXillttc. IX vlrimQ I:om~

intentione {ceunda ,q',z.t: (ohim conUcnrE rc-i in I:(~ plerum. &. incommunic;tbilc rG"ddl:" fubicdu·m·;

.G: cogni(o • IiquiJcm eonuenle elf.: pt:rfonam 1 quia 1fte fCC-llndus cffc:Cl-us ne,eJf~rio pe~l' 3.: {u,-

pme cei,& Chri.'o conuenir 1 p.1f{e rei non ha- rClJjit prilflullHncc enim pou:!! intomrnuniCilbde

b ere per(onam ere,nan!. ,non [olum in eJfe I;Ogh i- elfC', quod' pcr (e non c:xifiir. fed in ~Iio : Ii~t .aIi.

Co. V nde S. Thom.ht,; if/U.P· ~o .",rl'4' docer nomen quando iouett j~rur aliq uid inad~'lu3[~ habere.

pt:t{OllZ , nOll dfc: ncmen Intcnnonis • (,d rei. Er iltum modum 1Ubflllendi. (olum quoad ptitnlllli

id=m aBirmat I/J l.dzjl.l;.& J;jl.l. S. Bene verum efF"tium c.lIaficndi perle. non quoad fecundum

eft quOd in aliqllo COIl!htUtt,l reah inuenitur ali- exHhlldi illcommunu;:~bi!it"r • VE mim;t fcparara

quando :lliqu;tR~glti(l • feu pri!];lrio , vel ahqllid per fc l::lIitlir, & non ~ft fllppofinlm feu ptrfon~;

ndoni, includi r"nquOUll connoratum , feu mo- quia communkabiliHft. Ex; eo aUEem qllod w-

QUill. Cuppollendo um~n fo,m~m raliter, (ell flit per te..c~uitur quod pollit (ullcnt~EC a(:cideli.

i pane rd conlliruentl!m. lit lle cUm pcrrona 1 tia in dfe. & (llbQarc: iIlis Cglilinend~ in dfc;.

poll(e t~i conUicl1lmr ~ aliquidrcale aJIigllari debet ~ti:zmli incomlllunicabi[e {uppo6Iumnon'ht.lkUL

pro formali eoaflitumretflcct fllndetiJIam ncga- aninufull:c:nt;l.t fila accidentl", quia 1'1;( (c e%dlir,

fionem .comnmnicabiliud, • IX iIlam k,uncbm licer l1em fie fuppolirum-

ilUentioncm fnbikibilirads. Non pordi autem Hh aU£C"n:t c)(Cplicaris clrta rarionem pCrfonz: rt

ilIud formale cCllulimCDJ (uppo{irum .fc:u rl:r(o- feu {UPPQbl .. litaris~& fubfilh:mi\ 111 comlJlIlni,re-

l1am elf~no1el1ra Cub cenc-eptu narurz • cum lit fiJt v.d,n. qUid in Dro pcdollaliras. (~ r'l.:it;i

rota. & integra nanm .• quoad przdi{atoJ conRitll' perfonr fotl,DiJliEer. I!<. diI~d:~ jmpoItct~rdal'll;j';'

'.iua in humam(ue Cbiilli. t.c nOli lit peIfolJa ocm an dfenn3m lloqll~nd(l de lubl.fir:nria j (ell

C!:c;at:l ~ crgo aliqu~d poCitiuum , & reak dl id modo petfonaliraris .nt:Jn fDlumjn.~!lale • Ik

quod per[on.aaddlt (upcr nawf2tQ. . quoaddfcdum cxiUtndi p~r Cc,[ed .aclzqllau~i

1 $ ~ vr=;Q iII~ po~tiua .r~!aS Ii~ moduS', feu aI~- & quoad dfedam triam incolUmunic:abilit~m..

qUid falum moihlita:dilhnltum a natUra. an ah- N~m vrrum imlJ:rnatur in bOI; Deo.ccu in Dl;it<lre

quid diliinClum unqtwn res ii re, in dtzttJ II!~ fcrundlitn [I; ;!nu;ced;:;mcr ad p~fronils rcLuiuu

iil.".ollet!dim\u ex meme D.Tbom,& Caie[.& Cub6i1:enria abfolma q~£lfcdllm e:zptcndi per:

a!iofum Thomilbntm. & n f2rjl)nc. eflc ma- f~ .ft'lIlt:t11i pt_difquil'CEur. ~ . . e

d,ull fi.lbt1:antUlcm fupeuddimm nanuz 1 re-dll- in hoe ergo punao J!imifeRi~ en fentq1- 1.7

aiuiqul: patinenlem ild· pt3!=dicamemum (ub- lia D.ThQm. ill hitt 9H·~9 •• m. <to vbi C'oodudir S.

A:anriz. tanCJCIID modlU teml.inan.~ • &. comple- D. quod P,rfm. JJ1n1t1i jif.mfi~lII.t '~!4'tur1t'lij"" mcru;um JW.ur~ ~ (KUt puntiu! eft (caudiui:' in fllbf1/1tl1umF& hoc d1 tignilicarc rda:iolldn pu

przdiamento quantitiltls yt (exminas lina:. &: modum fubll.mt~ • qu~ e4 by~jj5 wpiiflfllJ

inodwinttrlGoni1 k rcmiffionis redna-inc in ptz- in na[ura diuina J licetfubJin~ns'in nJ1lutz diuifll.

dicamento q~iraris pw fotmis inceniionis c;;tpa- non fit :Jlind. quhn Jlut:lili dil1ill~~& fc:c:unduBi

ciblu. Vndc dicit S. ThJ~ h~ 1].1.9',:1· t.fU! f.quDd noe velum dt. quOd Iic, D9.men p~ljlm4 Iig.fllfi,

ll1JilliJUIDJI P~'1itil'ill dtji1li,iJJ"e ptifgl1l. .d tUft- CitE rwtiollem in r«10 ~ ~ eff~iam in oblIque.

'''1''141114 m~J.m f~bfijll",li t '1lJi t_P"1I fHbj~ .nOll lamlfll i4uio.Qrol ill 1iIIt.QJ1lm dt u4!ip, {,d

in

in quantuin 6gnitic~tilr per maJuro bYPQ!la.6 •• Hoc ell: non in qunntum excrcetue [dado circa tcrminurnlcd vt ~e!1ct [c eX patte ~e(pidends., fe.1i Cubitai • vel ipfa potiuf rdario {ubiec:to non mdi~

gct,qlJia {ubfiO:cns e{l;. .' ..•

Ratio ell; quia fola rclado In diuinis mcom~~nicabiliratem funaatc porell ad fuum correbt!yu, co quod cum ipCo oppofirionclll hsbet •. rdlqua pra::tcr tdadu<\! oppoIstiones. Vl}llm (unt In Deo. Similit~r eft rerrmnus fublhntialis • iprllnquc natuum diujoaTII fubl1:anti:lliter reddit terrninatam, qUia rcbtio iliac accidens non eft, nee: edam cli natuta aut pta:dica[UITI co)\I'titUtiullm. & dlenrialc::

Jlltl:r~>'i\m rota natl1r:1(ccundurn conccptum na!ur~comrnuniccrl1r Fille, non commQllic1ra relarione P~!ri5 : eq;o dl. t~rminu5,Ccu modus na~Ura: fublhnriali.tcr • ql1ia prxiet acci<1en~ ,& pra;dic::ata iI.1tUf:l':,(~u ql1idit;l.t~1U n3turtt,aliud non rcfrat. Et hoc ipfnIU ex (uis vi(c~ribus e:w.igit relatio qll~ndo nQn cit ac::ddenra.le aliquid. fcd [ubll;;lI1li~h:, qni<i. t.'Ili~ fubltaRtialitas non impouat (lib(1;;lL\tlam ptO

·'cil'Clltia. (lui~ (ubl\.inria pro c:iTcmi;l ecrnmurucarur pctfOni5, &. t.:ll: vn~in uibm. non autem rela-

'. tio,r~d imporear, fub!hntiam pto c:xillel'ltia per fe.

Ilquidem non cll: accidens , & cenuenir 1111 rerrninatio f quia incoffimunic;lbiliras ad v\teriorcm rermlnl1m,~ cUm {it 1I1communieabili(35 fl1b[hmialis, til terminatlo (ubllandalis: lillit enim in [lib· fhlltia.cp.1idql1id fublh[l[hlirer incommunicabilitatcm ponit. Ergo hlbet tc::biQ lublitlell~ quidqUid requiritur .... t fit renninus Cub!1:.lnti~lis incomlnuni~<\bilite( rc(pcCtu eius cUi opponirur.

18 Ex Q\lC) colligitur tres relariones pcr[ol)a\cs. (ell

propri~r~tC5.fcil.paterni[atcm,fili.tioncm, .:t (plu[ionem paffiu~1TI, QU:1: illcommllllicabil~$, & oppolitte h.lilt,Cl1::' tres [ubliac~tias>& tres p~donalitares; Sene enim c01\flimtiu~ (dum petfonltUm diftind::arum in effe pctiottali ~ funr ~rg? rres perfonalirucs:n;lm pct(ortalir3s eft form. confbrut iua pdQn~ in dIe, & mionc p trfonali : r unr c=rgo in D~Q rres pctfonaliutcs,fiCl.It Cunt I;l'CS perron:. Per{onalitas aurem , (eu fuppoliu.lit$ ell fuhlillcntia in natUra ratioll31i:ctgo 11 Cunt rres perfon;Llitate~. (unt tres fubli!l;enti~. Nee nomen [ubli!1:c[uia; ell nomen :l,b[Qhuz pcrfca:ionis. fed terminationis nartm:,qu% terffii~ildo ill Dec rcbtiU<:l eft:. Littr enim {'ilb!lll:ElmI3 vid~.nur inuoluere c:':iIlcmiam. qui~ [ubGltemia dicitlJfexilkntia per fl!, & Cubfi. I!:c:ns per (c ex.il'itm.tamlln non eli filbfiltcntia ipti cxill:entia di(cCl:e, Ted mo4us CiU5. id cli per(e·jrls exi !ltoriz: per (c :l\UCIT1 dicit modum q 110 habet Ut mot exHlenri:l,(cil.nQn in alio)nec. del'cndcntCln ab "lie .... t l {libicClo [ullent:mre, fed (ullcnm:l1T1 in fdpfo! (eu termiD<ltaITI jn (e,&' il1communic.abilcm. {i comp1cla. & (O(alis fit. <l!p.tr.: fubliilentil modum dicit tetminadonis • :ltque a.dcd magis ad inl:olnmunicabiliratem peninet. qllia vbi eft inc:ommllnicabilius, ell: rC£mln;l.tio. &: perr e'it:l5: C tim ctgotehuiQn~ &ci3m: incQInmuniC3bilitatcm (abihntialc:m. qllil0ppolidonelll fubfrandalem dil:uf1t.'Qnrc:qIlCnt~~ fubfill:enti:tS Illllltiplicanr,quitum 3-d ltIodos pet(c·itaris ) &: v:rm.iIutionis, lieet ncque c~d(ltntiatn, neque {ub{bnriam muhipH~ cent, '1u;r funt modilkau p.:r mQdum, &: pet Icdtalem (ublillendi. lit P:aUr.:I comimmitet fubfiftcn. rU5 pluuli. nOinill~ Iigni6c~nl : przfrnim po Il: fcd..u(J1 :r.nuquarn lllc:n1 de diiff;'(cJ\tb. hypolbfis, &. ",fiz)!([2n4:m hypolblispfo fuh_fillentia.ft=u fu1'.po fi~Q. di3 pto ~ Ifcntia. lieut & lub(t:l.nlia ptO efCm~ CQ~Ull1l~f 2cc,c:plala cft. ~ Me in cpill:ob. ~g:lthom$ paf:t II! Y l.s,JfQtU 4fU'~tje 4.dicituUffi ,11 'Dufri-f,J,frjlflllWumy{", pvf~-1l11_

§}g_gfl. XXIX. fiG:- fj)e Perfonit diuinil;

[ubIMntiMl. vel. vr~ntiqua cdirio habet VitAm r,J, .. ftPel11iam; & in epil191a Sophronij, qU;1! ilJtlldtrJj S)'fI~O aa/one (i, recirata , & accepma fuit (:;epiu; plures Iilbfil1:cntiz Deo a(ctib\:U1tUr. Et MminUJ I. in Concilio Lareranenf CQn{tlftilti~;T' f .&IIl1ol1! h explicauie D~lIm 'ffi 'UnUm j,t "ibm !nbfiftmtiil. Q9:1rC rctl:e lutHnianuslmperator in edmu fidei Ad bltnhfm II. dit..ir,Omrm!anUip"t,ucDl1fonalJur 110J J.octl1t,4liuJejfo lJAmram fin {nftjlamitlmj&!urmam,allUd fl,bjijitn:illm jiue perfollAm. Subfi{lcntia. ergo per[on,diter, & complere fumpra multiplicarutin Dco,licer aliqui id ncgaut .. rinr, fed male. An vcro pra:rcr pr:r(onalcs, &. complef~s fublitl:cntias rclariuas , derur aliqua abColuta in 0 .~o communicabilis tribus pcr[onis,/L'q .. <lrt. dicetur,

Sed obiicics primo)qui:l relario non porell eonl1itllcrt in Deo emnes pc:r(ollas,pr",fertim ptimam pet(onlln Parris , ql1ia dl!bcr perfona przfupponi g~neratiofii. feu origini. dIm ab ilb. prodc>::u genc~ rstio.vt 1I principio gencrsme. Relauo aucem p~ rcrnitatis (uppollit originem.&: gelicutioncm,quia filpcr iII:l.m fUn darur:crgo ance rciationcm ell: pcc~

Iona, liem ante origin em.. .

Stc::undo,quia pe(Coll:l debet conftitui fotmalifer periJ1cotn1Dunic~bilil;ltcmf vel per relarlonem vt excrcirem ad tcrminum f non ve rubliacnfcm: !:rgo male c(in(brajtut per aliquid po!itiuum • vel pet relationcm vr [ublillemern. Amc!:ea probarur, runi q1lia pcrfona iii talnum f;onl1imitllt relatione, in qU,lnmm cl1:0ppOlif.l, ell: autern oppolita provc clcrccn!:',.:c(pc:';hllT1 ad alterum, non proV( in fe (ublil1ens,am Vt hYrol1a{i5:c~go vt rclatio excrch1 c.oI1IHtu.ir per(ol1J.m: V c11i 1'1011 con!liluir , Vr exercens rerpiciemiam, fed VI (ubliR:ens: ergo ratione ipfi~15 /J~ i;:onltituit. I10li rationf: ipliu5 Ad.quia, fublil1cnria ccnuenit relationi diuin%, ptOVt corl·tfpondcr inh:tremia: in relatione creataJinbalr~ntia autem ~rtinet ad ipfun1 I r1,in relatione crearae ergo, & [\lbfith:lllb in diuin~. In autem magi; pl;t!inet ad (;11;;',& ad ab«JI urum eonc:c:prnm dIen5 W:.quatn:td rel:uiuum. Tum quia iUnd formalirct .::on(l:iulit perfonamjquod formalitcr conftirnit in~ diuidLlum,dim in definition!.: pet(onl!.: ponaturindJf4jd,~a [flbjJJtnri4. Forrnale autem confliturillum indiuidui cit; incommunicabiliras, vel (daeio fl1biicibilitads:videffill5 enim quod p~~ im:ommunic::ahilitatcITI pti1\~D, &: pt:r [c dilfen prima [ubllanti~ a (~C\Jnd~.(eu .b vniuctfali:Vid~mu5 c:tiam.,quOd in ~iLlcdis nat.uris pef d.i~erf<J. principia fit in~~iduauo, lieU( In (u blbl\l1 a corpotea per !IU[Cfl;lm 6- gnJ.talU)&:: diui[3lU qllamit;l[c) in Angclis pa im~~ ecptibiHra[cm forma: • in D~o p~t rel3fioncs;formale vero in om!1ibu~ ifri$ ell clfc incommurtic:a. bil~m infc:rioriDw,quia non hab~nt ilb, 8<. fubiicibi1em fupetiotibu5,qllia p,;eJ.ic;ntuf dc::ilb. Eigo id fot"lpalitcr edt per 10112.

Temo ; [lcI[onJ. pote[!accipi vr communis ad rres per(oulS _communitate pr:tdicationis, vt S. Thom.docCt: 'lf4.f(1.;o.ATt.4' Si aurcm eifet allquid rcale, ... e1 iltud elfer primo diucrfum in quolibct indiuiduQ; & fie non datetur vnus conceprm comm,mis clfentUliter pr;rdicabilis de ttibus petrollis; vel non d{'c:t primo di~cr(um in quolibct indiuiduo, fed in aliquo cortut:nifcnt,& iIlud cum lir rea.· le I .:rit prl.'lCdic;l.cllm elfc:ntialc pc:rfon;t. &: con(e .. qumu:r fe habcbit Vt gcnu$Ve\ rp~cie5 u£pcau p~rron;c,qllod tepugnat. qui:!. lic pcrlon.a mbetet alind gcnris aUf CpcGiem quam natura, & habe~el:. fll:!. ,onllitlltiua. & fcricm pr:J:dicatotllm fc..orfuw. quod dl duo p~a:dicamc11fa ponc:re in indiuid\l.i~ filblhmialibus. :l.l[c:r~m Q;l.t1.U1: J .altmlm pc::r~

fQmt:. .. .'

Adpri

no

.:.

10, . Ad I. Re{pondcbitllril1f. ·ai[p.J6. agc:ndo de c:6IHtllduopcr(QIla: Pmis.Er fUmlna folmionis ell quod rclatio non lndiget fllflJ~menro ad cxiltt:n~ dum,Ccd:'ld rdpick"ndum:ln fe enirn [ubliHeils ell linc alio fundamcmo.Ad refpidtndunuutetrJ fubfequirur gc:ntf~ti{jnern.:!d fubli[lc;ndum vcro prz;.. ced ir.De quo ibi latius dic:clTll!S.

Ad 1.dlcirurqllod.vr done S. Tho. tJ. 30.AYQ; pcr(ona in communi non foli'lm dicit, aut de formali inccmmunicabiliratem ptO ncgationc,aue ih~ tenricncm rationis,quz dl rclauo jilbiicibilit~d5~ qUi'l hoc: nom efiptrJiJflI$ .ncqllc ell nomen negafiolli~,lit'q\tc: intcmionis. {cd nomen rei, Nihil au. rem abfurdfus qulm dicere pcrfonas eJ1i: nihil,& ens r.:ttionis. aur non ens> cum ocnlis & {cmGbus ~pmc viul'oImus :tliqmd dr~ped(mjm non ranquam carcnnam aliquarll,licut c:rdtatcm, ftel VI aliquid mregrum, & plenum. Et pra-rete;!. ilh neg~tio debcr dfa fUlld~ra ill, alrquo polidno. alii, eifer putum nrhil , & non fllnd.llUf immc(li;!re: in natutOl,fiquidcm porilisnamrz communr..lbilis ell de f~,& fine ilia illUC:niruf n;'I!Uf~ in ChrH!:oj-flldafUI ergo in ~Jiquo (uptmddi·w nlwr:t pofithto, ilIud ergo, &: non Jllif;Z negario ~ri! fiJrifi~le contlilutiu(i rcrloil~; lli:'tnc:g.uio in~oltlmlini'Jbili[jtiJ comifemr. Ncgitmus ergo ameccd.argumenrl,

: Ad prim.1m pro b.t1idt ur qll ad relario conlHruic per{onam pro'lfoppofir;l,dil1lJ1guo,Pfovt oppolira ~pccificarillcj& h:cundl'u\l fe,'OIl,c~lo ; !V"0vt op~ pefita rc<l!~rli~,1dtl~ 1 & in c:~c:rdrio.neg~. h~'l[Je forma dc II: dicens OrpOlitl0ncm, &. jllmpt~ ve Ungir CubicCtIllTl confticult rcrfonam. (juia lie: (llblilllr.fion anecm rarione (;:t~rtitij oppnlirionls, ve ung;t rerminum. Ip{a quippe 0ppolilio,qll;t erga t:-rmillum UCJCm1r ,lrCdnlt! I,n (~bi~ao fllbfilht. &. ve renet II: ex PJ{t~ tuhll:lh enam oppofiu. & dill-lnlla e{U fllo corrda!iuo.(cd noll conlidcramribi cins excrdtium in oppofitioDC ad rerminurn , Ii:d in aff"dione. Ii-:n adha:llllne lid rubicallm.R~lDanc:~ ~U[e dif!ind:io in ilia forrna rc:iarilla hoc ipto quod in tc b~bct oppofirionem ,fiue confidererur vcaffid<:m {Ubicctum, vd fl.lblilleIl~ • liu~ vr cx·"rc:c~ ilbm ag3 rerminurn, Et:;d inlhmiiquod [t1b{j[l~tc:,61IC'nitutiLl!;le /71.

. difHl1guo,fi.:bIiHnc vr dr(lr .;unceptum lncommnili,abllis,Tlego; &. licpc:ninet 3d pcrfon3m.& teo! U[jonclD,!llbJiflcrc, vr (liCit pu [e et"itlcre przeis~. fI;m("~r ; IX lie cmlm conu:=-nir Cubllllrn£iz ab(oh,[2'. C otr~{pondct JI)t(!!n inhzn:nti:e ac:eidc:mis, non io\t\m ratione: uitl;~nti5, qua infutrenria d't ill alio • fed c:tiJm r;lIiconc rn,;-emmtmiCJbiliutis. (11Ii:l Il1hxr~nu" dl communic~bili'.

Ad 1, prob, conllJt e:t dklis p=r[oo;trn & indi\Jldutlm non dkfie f.,lam !ubiicibilit'lrcm rarionis ad (up~riora. :iile negaeiollr:m Im:ommunicabiJit.:ltis",kd edam funl.bmcntnm cias pofiriuum. Nee prima fllbllantlOl ditf~rt a (rcun&h fob. flcgaticnt: c:ommunicabilitaos , {cd eti.m pDiirio:J. dilf.:rmtia indIUidu:ttionis a qlla :lbfh'al!it • & fubliElc:mi% qua terminatur; imo potii» prima {ubUmri;& non [olum opponiIUIVniu({(ali, (eu fl;'cund~ {uhilllltiz • red ctiam polIti, quia c:omphO:f3 Ulbibntiol ell.· vnde eilu conltiUllio p~t' [abm nrgJtioncm aut ronrrapofiriolltJIl3d vniucfulcnon !if. Ad ft',un~ dam vero pmbldoncm didtllr quod fOfrn.l.11: m,liuidI!i. non ell Cob fubiidbilitu Olllt ncgatio. fed ttiilm po Gdua ilia dilf'e-renria. q'la lingol.lfe conft~hit fpecii:.& (cdditUf fingulate Ventm .. & tc:alc. &. Ilia t~imdoqua rcrldltur Cublillcm adaoqq;. rc,&totollirer, vndc- i1:I[,.itur m(;IJl'Ilmunjc:obihtilJ, qUQd cft ~Llb[ilter,: ftlpp,!6tQr~f~r (l;"U p~rlo)Uhrcr.

Ad tt;lIurn. Rt~Fon: valdt Ultcr . t~ pll~n.iIc In :. I!~. AS.Thmi.," l'fI411.D.Th. TQmllS O!l!"a',

tit

hac pm'c Vlfque!l:. &. ·Su:it'"et; iJ!c ~rihn contciti;, die pcr(oIl3m, leu fnbfi~cJlwun nori dIe con:" ccprt1m communem ad ped~Ilas diuinas , I:jui aD iplis abl1r~hat ;. sc de cis qlli4imit1~ pr:tcllci:!ut:

Ita docee li;ttdi[p •• ;o.clip.2..& Ii,!!; J! 8;",1'. 7.5uarer, vcrbiib •• ode T rtnir.c, ~, {ctititd~ti ~o'fii:~ptum communern perfone lid p.don.l·s diuinas , itllll]:l;' que eJ1e VnidOCLi"fil. 110n ramen . vnill(!t(;.ie generfs 1 am (pcciti • (cd qua" t[,;IIJ!~I;I:kn( ~ ~u~ni feqllirur Ruiz djfpIII.;! pU, 1.I1I/m.S. V.denna~ & alij.AL!tcan f1'flfi. f. dtJPllt.J" "If. 1. dlflinguffd~ rerfo!l:l in communi quando pr;r.dic,lnadc rtr:. Ionis pmic!JI.1riblli lub he, nemine p~rfOha.vr dj..: cendo b;e~ ~cdond cll pcrCo()~,vlZl (ub ahis fHlmF mbus , ve F i!!ll~ ell pcrron~,P~rcr tft p,r(otJa ; &c: •

E~!xirrmj1 ,,"dr71l~ pr;t:'.~ic:aliofl~n_j dLnrialtm; nee I negar! l V;!lqucz • camqu~ db meneem S. Tho,in 17M q. ~o.art.:;. & eorum s= Joct=i1t re~ r~ nam ctfe comrnunern per rncdnn, vlTiEfcn~li~ qui .. dit;itiuc de rribus ptr!ollis. Addit taIl'!~n·hdnc F~7 ~. dicationclllllee ,,"Ill! rr{Jpn~ Vlln.!O~:ilm, nee .111;110;' s~m ,j~d quail a Il,'llog;lfil ,!c-utll!"~jn hoc curn Kufi flb,jil/"it/itJ.J. . , . . ." .

5e-C1Ind~m vero prorditaiiom:m diCit cri3m, dfci facmialcm,~ non dC{loruillariuamJell acdt!cIHa':' [ern.in quo conrra VaCq.((; ((;ntir" J~dr .nen t~mc:n elfc vElh~oI:am rr:t',lic~tiOllCI"ll,fcd quafi amJog3m;

Nos tc!uludoncm lnrius babanus 3pud D; :t i Thom.ht hit,q.~o.lI.r·4.vbi inquit. qucd pe,(onl! t(hl()tn~11 commune communit.m: rarionis , non r.CUt gO:llus • aut fpc(in • fC"d lh:m indiuiduum va. gum ve l1.licpis heme, Adll«tir r;:mCfi CaieC~JJ; .'1t:ormntntJti" til ilii .trt.~ bene- quUd co m d itiml' Parer c:Jt pctfon3. Ii~h Iy ftYjQ)111 'Qi1lp~utjue

ad nil[ur~m P~Hi~ • &. ad Dt'~lm fr: h~~n 'It modus > &: 'It indiuiduuPl v;lgum j f:!n1m re .. Cpc:tru iJjiu~ (tlbi~dj.(dl.relpe"u Patris.drcmi~JiI pra:dictnjo dt,tum ratione commtllli t. qll"i~ modtli {ub6ll:ellcli dlcmiali!>d~ fi!lgulaubu~{llbl1:tlitiz;ia rarione fpedilli.quia perfollA dUliIu lignificat td~ {ioncm,&: hec prlt"dic~tu[ dle-nrliUitcr de: pata-nirare.Sed hec z.rsuo non multum vrW·t, quiJ tcla-

rio pra:dic:,u ipfmn g~ll~lHdatillllm ,quod de 1d~ rionibus p:j[c=~ni(alls,& fiHarillni! pr~dic~~llr>quan

de fpecie diuCifi~ .m3gifque pr~dk:lt n~mr"ITl;(<:u formalem q11iair;:l!CTfI rd;:ltiolJi~.qllhn modQm fin...

guladtads vel pcr(ona:-; . ... .

Q!.:apropu:r reiicicnda dI: (utili, .. ilIa difiitl~o i. i' dt' pr;-rdlC;itIOIlC: pnfon;l;",vdic de a'lbus per(om.

fub Il()mine pCr!Qnarum, vel l'Ub nomine PlItris. &. Filij,&: Spitillls S.Q_!Ji,l dilm m~gi! ,nrc-cd!: nomi-

ne l'atri~ n(llniii;'lfl~ lubl~lhfl'h i1IillJ ptopotinonls ~lllam nomine prh'llll pcrfimo:.vtl huiuJ i'~iJont.Hi~

em itIC ell dietlf'· Pt1.r1I, vel hune homin~ dcfrsna:;.

to P~tro:Petr1u enim,& Ilk homo :!equipollent; &

pro cortt'PJ {ul'ponllnt.& q~idquid t8ccta!i[~t pri"" dic~t Lll de h(>(; homfn~ .. dh!"nti:dir~r ,heirur de Pc:~ uo.Ergo Ii pe.rfona e~!:mi~1if~r dicifur de:: hac rc:tfOI1~ (ub nomlOt; pcdon~, vr J.C( Itdo. H:e-c per{om' ellpcr!on~,p{ima penona eft perfon;l,aiam dI~n6 ti;llh pt<t"4ic;1lio (til, Parer <"11: pedon;! ,filil15 eft" pcr(olll.quia Pa~er dE:nriallrer pro !:odtm filppo.

nir arquc p:dma pcrron:!, vd h~c ptdona.· £E'

hoC" fohim ::Il- v;ltlarc- notniTl;); dil;cnda Parrcm vd primam pcr(onanl~quoad rc:m c:ninl idem fum.

pc pr~dicil(ic~1Z .... e::ro iFC~>2n~t vn~~o~a vel i j an3Iog~;,"mllC[f.'lhs,vd p~mcttlatlf. drcRuaiI!. vel :lccidel!nlj~.dicimI15 dlrcccc.& pt"oprit nuH;:;m be. rum elre-ied r~dlld:ju~ prtrim!"rc ad- fp«icm.li:u;l4 vnillfffak IrPiIlOI;llIll,:d!llllid Um!!"u pmicipa,~ de u~n!Ccndmf:!li. &. modo ;w;dogo • &. timpl!circr ellcJJtia.lQn die:-. 1-Ioc tlmun inc:ludieur in ilia.

. , dolLlriont

,

~41io XXIX.e1c.

fcforlltion~ n. Thom. qllod non rr:t'd.i~a!u~. ranqLli\ln genus.vel (pc'i~s, (~d vC mdl\lliiuultl V4' ~LlI11.Et pt~ cius ~xplkaliol1c ad.u~rre: ql!?U p~r~ Iona !i:1.I (dulifremia IIOn'ell: per {e [II pr:l,:dIC~mcn. Eo,r:d r~dLlcHlIc,vt complcmcnnln1! ~ [:tmjn~~ cillsisicqlJl:!p(..,dicalio elus ~~ te:~\laIU~ "Illue~(al~~ dc ilIo pr:edu;;;un ~lHO. SrJIlllmr l~ ngu lat~'(<\Lllndl. uidllum perriner ld (ericm Pfa:~fC~Ill(:II.(1 pee [e,y~ (ubiicibilc,non vr p'rl'l=djca~lic!ndi ~a~ltlln1?' vnoSi crgoip(,J t.lfi~ lJlIgular.lr~tIS t1,cl),laulc '" CO~Dlllrtr e:c:trahi,UI a red-a kue, &; linea (Ill pf$d\. ~amc;Jti,(ctl 1 10::0 qlle[l\ in illo (urdrur;&: Jic noll mlrum quod non pr;ediccnJr vr gCJHI~,v;1 (r.ede!, ~lll ticur commune, ~ vniLlcr{al;; dlrdt/: j Icd redllaiu~. E;;:. hoe ergo probreur hinc proru1(3rio. n~rll, (111;\ indinidnurn , vel p~crona pra!dicamr de; hac v-d ilb perCona,l1011 ta~dirc:ac~& pcr (to: pr~~ i!icarionc:m gtneri~,vd Cpeeilti ,;lm vnhloc~m.vel vllill¢rr;llcm • {cd jol~m rcdutl;illc, qtlia iltc 1110~ dliSindhlidUalioni5, & pcrl<maHtads non pcrtin~t dirctU:ad pfa:dic.·mleJmilll,l1(~ iUud rcr fe ,ollllimim~rgl,.i no porea 11tfi r~duaiuc ililpOIme tJtiQn'lll cornrnuuem • & vniucrf.llc-m, Ii:d (ohIm redur!i:illt i (i.;1It edam d;lf~rcnd~ polf\llU concipi in communi • Vt rseionale in COl'llllluni ad hoc ~ illud raflollal~. &. (~ll!itlUUm Old ho~ vel illull (enlicill.uln, uec r:II11"fl hJbciH raeionern g.'n~ri$.auC {pccid. qlla:: per ~ha5diff..:rrntj ... s cOIHfdhititJ'; fie enim clll:t abire in infinitum. eUln Illz ditf~rC:lltia: rontrahClHes rurfm conrraherenruc per all~s; '" il1:£ ali.1: per :lIiJs; &(ic in infillitum; (cd Ilu:tlibcc dllf~re:ntl .. cll r::ollccpms lilnpl<:~ ,'111.1 non rc(ohlitur III genus & drfi'crtllli;lln. Iudunduatic aurcrn dj~rC-lltillquJ!d~m ~n. & pr;~fQnalita.s > (eu fublj· ficmi3 cit tctmin~tio huil.ls illdiuidll31iollis. &; lit! Iinearn in.til.lidtl~tkmis p!:rcillc=t. Non ergo c:tit per fe vrliucr(,llc aut vnino(:um Ullqllatn genus 'lid [pC:<.:i<;~ abar.th~n$ a dilfc=rC'.ltH$ &. '0f!tr.lbibilis per ilbs: ~oc enim coda: modo replIgn;l.[ ill indiuidLl4riol1l:!,hC:lIt in alri5diff~tcndis.quia &: i1"(.1 !ndillidl1atio dilft'rcnli:\ qu;d 1m jndil1idullis ell.

14 Ql!~rnodo ergo. c?ndpitUf. ceneepru ,o.mmilni, & qu!dc:11 rcdua:tuc r:lle ~nluer(:dc: , dh g~lIlh aut (pr:r:icm 2

Rc=rpnndco tolf'>! commune ~d modUln U3n(cendentis , feJ non pc&tl~ .tl1ol!(JgIIl\l > ncque pctfcdc vniuer(.Ilc vniUDCUI'I1 : .bplidtcr enim olliqllid condpiruc conccptu COtnllluni. VIlO roodo per toulcm (tp~r~tioll('rn ~binfeIioribll~. &. .1b corum dilfc:rcntiis. u;m gen~; & (pcdes pr;tic:indund. dilhcntiis; quib!ls conU'~bI1mu~ ad.. (0.1 infcdo~. Alia modD cOrlcipitllr ;\liquid COl\4;Cpm eommuni.nr;1Il per [oralcm fi:plf.tDonern. & przdli.oncm ab infcdotibu.i , (<:d indu den do. & rcdMIld.o ilb ;lau , non Umen e.lprimcndo~ a.: cxplic:wda alJllli.1,quz ibi in illo obieao [llnr. qUiu;ui5 4;onccpms nan omnia poren- compleai. atl.tllOIl vult >.ted contidtrat r~ 2.liqllam Cub aliqua confu!i.one • &. nOll [lib oJnnimod~ ~.:tprdlio.. IIC, ~o pr;J:(.:indtn!i. modo vii iunms up!icalldo atmbutotuDl dilliof!:ioncm in Dec (matd. ,,",Ii dife"'· .oj. Brielll, 6. & nplicandD CO,r~eptum ,.ommunotJn mrii in l~f.icA tJlujl. I J. Er (u~ milur IIlc madUI pra:(cindmdi pr:na cor.fllCum. lit. t::ltplic:itum , nOll PCI'l" dilltrf,ullm rCl'um. (eLl gllietlorum . ((par~ionr:m ~ turn ex hi! qn~ :lCC'dUl'lt in f!:ofu • tum in intclldtu. tn fep(d quidan,: Dam vidrnll!$ aliqlUI!do aliquid a tOl'lg~. rub q~ a;mf~dione • ~ non dirc:etneqdo .Q~.dilb.l1cU: 4;um vtroaC«tlir prgpc. dlain-

. ~"Pl\I1$. & diftr:tni n-nlS e;mQCf.ol rem; Ik quando ~ «J1lMd:.co~D.p(sr;b.qnUl I l"CS llb. noll. in ~

. -

..

"

D e P er(onis diIJintJ.

Rullo t &. in potentia continelm itt quod pode;). .cum cxprtffione cogl1Q(cltur t f<:d ~D[Ltm illud in adu fbi bab batur t fed DOll OlI)rli modO&. dHHndc eXpri!l.eb.ltlll· attingendD & ecmpledcndo {jgj]~ulm omnia ql1a:: ibi (Ull£. Similltrit tfanCcmdel](j,\ non poffi'nt pra:(cilldcre:!b inferioribus remanendo in perentia ad inferior:l. Ii qui~ J~m. edarn illdu~l1ntur ~nHlis • t: ita nunqu.1.m l'Oflllll[ pCI fea.c:: ab ill IS [egrcgatJ j (cod folfun alcimt pr:t'ti(io. q!lia ert confufacognitioornIlium in ilia r~dOlle (:ornmun(iii:n:i entis ; quz pollea cllp,icauu IX clprimitur in infc:rioriblu, linguJo\ cognoCcendo. Et amibuta diu ina cum /illr a&us p,j~US , vnum non ell: in pot¢nria ad a~ liud , fed aClu cn vnum quodquc: • quia ramen conceprus nollcr non valr.:t [O~Um qllcd ell: in ill., obiell.o peno:rrare • fc:p;lrat vnum anribunUD ab alio t id eft j c:xpnmit vnillt formlliuEcm E~IIU'lilJ, rdinquendo ~Iteum ibi aclll Indu[;l.m. fed ill conf~l[o ;uu«am ~ de fie ab a(luali ('IItpticarionc pr~:i[.il\l • non ab aClu31i Inelu. none.

19itur lingularc , .cell indiuiduum t feu diff't- S S ren!ia indluldu3li~ I & fimilirCf p:nona • (ell (llbliacnli", qU;J: dl inconlmuniC<lbili$ !ctminnio indiuidui nol~ co~'ipjl.l!r in c(l!nm~n;. per con .. eeptum lottlhu~r priCcllum ab mf~LlDnb1l5 , k

qui IfIJoc;tr. in potentia. vt pet add;donem differenda: .,fcriori$ ,0J1lr3hamr , fed {olum pr::r conceprum iplillfmct finglllilfis i [eu !illgulari"~ falis in lOllfl1li:. I qlli tamen dcrmninanlt ft'r c:~pt'cITiono::m iplius lingularh VE O. ligll:ui &:" dererminari , 6cltt. tilde i.l. Thorn, ill b.Jc IJIIIli1-.

~o, Imi&ll/" 4' qlloJ Indinidfjif7jJ ift climmHnj fitl indiuidlill711 'V4gllm dicit m~Juf1J p!1(,lIi4T#6tis , foil. quad fit [HbfifhTll dij1in£JIITIJ lib ii/iii , fod il1l1li~ millt P'Jglltllril dpl.""ri fil/tiji'IIIIO' Jmrmil'lAt147l1 diPil1gH~iu. fit '" nQ!Rin~ Sqt:1'.zJM b~ ClI.rIJ, & h7C~S. CQllcc-pruJ ergo lillgubri~ ill comll\lJni,

IX in pilrric:ulari eli p~nC:j confu(um • & ell? rermlnaum , ';;iI. t~prz(enratc: rationem linguJaos fublilte'ltil ; fed nondum uplicit!! cl=li~ gn:ltc • it~qllod in conccpm fiugnlaris in ~ muni indlJdifl.l.r aclu hOI: &: mud Jingilb.re. fc=d l'Iondum nplicJ.mr delign:J.te ~ llCllt quod videtur Honge vidctur in cl)nfu.Co • fcd l10ndllm aplidr~ d~tenniI;lJ(Ur , Ii~at ",au indudu iIlud. St hoc ob JupticttrJ {"tion:m. tom ql1ia indillidU;Jtio feu 6ngl11irlras babet (e vt d!ifcrelltil vltima:conCeplU$ al.ltcm dlffr:ecntl~ non contrahitur per aliill1l rlilf~rcnri;uu.nec en- tcfolubilis il'l dLlo; ,on«"prlb~ altetllm genc:ricum I illW\lIl\ dijf~rellti~le. ne lif proc:dlusin infinlmm,vt aiximus.Non porc1t erg" Jingulolrit.u abltrabcte:ab hac Be ill.! Iingul3titatl~~ quafi ~oncc:ptus contr;lbibilis pc:r 3~ditiDncm dif~ fuen[J;u'um , fcd Vt conceptus magis confiJfw, vel Jlugis cxptdl"llsciu(dml fimpl1 cis dllfc:rcnn..=. Tu!D. qllia quando concipirur fillgulltir<Hin communi. mm reQ:llu ali a principia indiuiduationi.t ad deJignandum Be 'Ontrahendlltll mud fmgu!are, & ad linguhriz:mdum amplilJs : ergo ~rn in illo COn~ cepm fingularitatiS indlldeb.1tur a~u hoc hnguhrc. quia prined' ia indillidlurionis dlls ibiin· dudeb:anUlr. fc nondum dcligDatiQ ¢;:pIime~

bllUI. ~

Qllm~ coneeprw iIle communis rc lubet n rr3nfcendem .. [ell PCf lUodum conceptus d,jtfc;. ~cnti:l: • qui ngn eli cdQJubilis in dU05 con::cpt"$ • al[crull'I g:lI.C'ricum • "Itetllm dlif;rcmialem:. r~d c:od.r;m CODCCptll c:oncipitllf in communi pe~ ncs cQncqttllm r;:onfLI[Llm,&: in parti(;uhci PCIle$ ~~i1 d;tCt"minawm a( o:plir;itllm.

Di1Jtllalio XlP.

~6 Q!!Od 11 ~utl:r,u~r • an lir ~nllo~~~ 'Re,,!

lp()ndeo non c{f:;qIU .. anl!ogum rcqutut Uj~qtU~

h'~f~m in.p~r:icip~ntib~s ill~d.'iU. '1.r ill vrloftr d~pJ.'~ter • m~ho fecllI~du~ qUid. !1I vno pet ~tt~lbUtlOI1CIl'l & denominauonem > 111 aha clf'c:mla. liter. Singui=lre :u:ltE:m {eu. Jingqiarit.!.5 in communi j non n:rpicidnfcdor~, fdl. hoc ~ illnd fingul.ue Je{jgn~tum vr inil:(lllali.l , qlli3 omni;l tin~ gUlatia a:qualia runt ; non (alumm natUra. fed ~i:lm iii Hngularirare t nan vuurn iC-i::lilldtim qnid, & aJilid 6mplidtet. Habet t~lT'icn rnedum analogi , quantum ad hoc: quod ell includi ill jnferio, ibus , &; p=r lfiadliltllr,ii1i<:end~li!i$ Ie b~bW::ld nmnes rnodes infcriorcs : (ed quu ilia infcriora non (um in;tqualia, non peruc:nir a4 f:ldonem an,t1ogi JimplicitC"t'. Q.!.!"d anrern dlxJ. mus de fingubritllrc, eodcm !trod" dicimus de' rcr[on.\ ,qa;e dt tenniflali~ {illguJJ~it.ttis. Be a forriori dtcunus dt:' p~rlonjJ dilfiniJ. qnil pee· (00;£ diuin.e funt omn!llo ~qu~lc5 • & ira lich per(oll::l dillil1l1 ill communi iridiHhtil!: intime in ipfa d~tennin~tione &. diff~rC:lJtj::l inr~d~i. qllia eamen ill:tqI1Jlir~tern non habene , nee ip(2. coldo communis inzq:lillim"m fj(ir > an.do&um nOI) ea.

Nee obtlar q'lod m,e pCrfOlp! d,ctermir)arz. (cu lillgld~ri:l {im primo ~iueda. quia flInt p"mc diuerfa vr om nino zqJ;dia in elfc. «(oJ':Jm in "p' po(ition~ ,orrd.lti1.b ptimo dmc!fa , & i[::l r~tlQ cnmraunis iIl,Z(PI;i!it..Ecm non qU&t~ quod (;11: non eITe:: an:llog,llu. JiCl.It ens r:(pc<!J:u PCEti & PJuli • (1:\1 d"'J=lJlU inJniiduonlrTl eiil(dem (p~. c!ei non cit an .. loguffi in elf~ ,qll.ia. infc:cior,l in tlfe: (unt omnmo .eq lJillia; & i~I:Q I Itc l;onC"cpm~ communi! fingniariuui baber :diqLlid de an;llogQ in q ll~ nrum (Ii! h~b.:t taIlQl1.JJ1\ traIJ~c~ndelu ,. «aliquid de vrnuoco. lit dkk ;rqu,dit.ltcllJ lorerio{Urn , ~ ir.J. rcduajLl.i:,~11: vlliu':lfaIe v~iuO(:um,

noD' firnplidtt:r. '

Q_u)d IICtQ fit "OIlCCp.cIl~ eJf~niali$ per(ona in comniuni , & lndlllidULtnl m ccmmuni rdp{:.!ll,l. AUTL;I$ & iJlills • I:X dldi~ lU-lilef prob~;ulTI , qlJi;t di prJ::dic~tLln;J quiditaOllum p::rtOIl;l in .c:omm9;ni,rclpclht buiw os.: jllius PCdQ~lZ • II quidem ell formalc conll:itntiuum ehis. is:: p~.t'4ic~tum .iD.uillfed: & newll:trio canncxilm : lice I:oim potel1: de~ finitJ; aUt condpi con fHt UL;!. ha=cpet((Jn~ • & ~Q~ fingulate • Ill.fi irtdudcllrlo pet(onam ~ C"919- mUl,li.

ARTICVLVS II.

YmJm ,Jetll, ill DfD fohfif/mlillll/,ft;Istltpr,dtr Ir~ueiJllitlsHl

N E qll~~iQ ,i~;l fohlm re~datur de: ?~ine.

1 an vu\c:hC"ct !!Iud. quod tobM ttwmu pet-

{oni! & fubfill.entiis C()l'I1mUlle eft in De-o,liivo.candumfllblilbntil, an non. Snppllnimu5 • circa ip(am rem iignifit~t:lm nomifle {ub6I1en[ia:: quamot CCinlidctarifell in!leniri.

Primnm ell tingulariru. quia res in vniucrftlli "tin (ubliilunr, thl (c(1.u'ulz lubl1:antiz roC:dils primil filbG(hlnt &: (ublbnr.

. Se:~Ulld!1mdl inC"ommunicabilir:u • vrin (up,pOGIO , fcn pcr(i;J!la • qll~ dl t~t;dite{ • & com~ plctetuhfilhn' , vbiinucniulr hI; IUmram .{ubliHere in lupp .. iito. quod \ilraiori tctmino in q!J~'nlUffi fie fuppolima a: tctmin;lt.t. , cO!:jlt1nlnicabuit nOll ell.

- l'~II.JsS.ThQm.ifll_p"tf.D.Tb. Tomu~aln:r.

'Artie. If.

Tertium ell: modus exi!l'etldr per Cc: ; qUi etiafn folet .,acari lilb1ilblti~ • dil):.ngurrurcpe ab Ipf& fl1ppouralitate ve incommllnicablJi, fiLur viJemu~ in anima r,iUion::lli,qu;e dl per rc filt-iiJh:l1s (~pllrat'" a corpore, nee ramen eft (llppOfir<lIU > aut p'~c-fona Incernmunicabilis • fed dl: furma vnibdh.

Q.!!,:iHUm ell ipfum concreru-n !l;\tur~ pet mcdum h ... benris ip(Jm. quod dl: clpl!~~I~ IUCliram non fohler. pcr modum principIi '11ff', &; per rnDdnrn forma:, qua, ll.!iq\!id conillruirur , n <kIt,., • hllm,lni(.:i.~. fccl ,! lam per m(l~ dum ,{lIqd, (1:'11 Il.lb~nm naturarn , vt D~lJs .ho. mo; nam bom~ {lImplns in communi & fine (uppolitis euam ell: in concrw,) hsbens '1II1na/li;a-o rem.

rgitur apllJ omnes prime. cerunn ell ; quod re- ~ rncus lilbJij!~nliis (cladu;!, &. c(lnfidGr~fa fOPl1:l ddt~ti5 fccllndum fe , d} ~Hq!lid fingulate-. quia non el1.1liquid vniucr{alc. bl p",pet Ynit~tcm Ill;" gularcm a pmc: rei, fiqulcLm ~ Pilftc: HO'; eft ynlJ!:

Deus ill Eribtl~ pc:t(oniJ, vr d~,~( lidc$, V fli'iI~e'1l ergo lil'lgnlan:m:l mbtl~ p~Elonis non ~bc~ t !i:J1 c;tlc vnus Deus lirtg\jl~ns e{l: t licltt 1:% (c f" po~ a pcrfonii ling\!latc & dcrcrmioamm dIe h~btf.

SeeLI1iaJ (c'nurn ell quOdil!..: namra ftcundum (c ",11; !;xdlcns c:liftc-miil Indcpctld. nrl OJP oml1i alia exrr .. fe , lm.) ell; ipfum eilr: a (c • &: peI f:, cum tit a.:lns PtI[IU • de cnius (Otrlf*!iijamq CCi~~ ,ccptU l:Il c:xilleml:l & d1(: l,{e.

TI:HiQ dl CCfEllm.IMtUr<1 q:jllil/~~ , feu bJj~ Deum (~(Und"flJ (I: , & rc:motl' F"r"Qn<lh'a'l~g ,L'clalilli! non dl;: (LJppofimm ~ fCI~ per!op..m ilJ,ft CDml'lltlni~,lb~lC:iU, alils dkm qU<1llllor PC[(QnlfJO lrno cl1~lICi~ ipf.l Ii c:act pCf(qD!l ipcplPmuJji:cabilii • non communicalc:lUr tribtu rd;'ltiuiJ ptrfonis • fcd e(f~E o,l;'poli!a 'j1111 j & ti~ ~p(:,: pct(onz tehtiu~ non efleoe Dell$ ,neque dmmz• quod ·eft h:neticilm. Vnslc:: r.c:ll:C £y.m~iO;:,llS~. pAYle di7fa~YiJ qll. z-.lf7f.,. & u· crro.ri~ #a~n .. ~ aJlcrtum illud quod m~lbllitu, Rilypmlldo I..Ii[- 1io. ~"mr~q\l(1d pi, De,:s, (c:'11 Dtiras ~t.qu(.lddam fLjpp~fitum vel peTh;ml ('Ornmunu m!;lu§ per(t1lliJ. Et D.Thom. ifljJat:'1""f/. JO,ATf • ..,. infl':rr pro ro .. gno jncoil1.l(;.niCl:nI 'l"od I~ Dco ,fl.c "na. pedolla triUID ptlfQJ1atu!p • ~t ,{I: ;v~ cJfd!:ti~. £t IJH.tft. '10. 41'tit;MIIl ~. ~oett flllW", femoris prnprierltlbus pl;ff(ln;ol,ihD~ , .,,-011 f.e:~ m3na: hypoildi~ .(eu ptdun,l in Jit,lin<l n~tU"r;z.

His erg .. ranqu:iro CcHi~ lhnliQut t ~em:lnt' J ditli,ulra1 ~n id qLwd <lcdpitut rqnori$ pc~{oo~llr.mbm in De-a , (ell itt qU,(Jd ell: ,c:ommllJu: iflhll~ pl:do~a1imi~U! t'X v~ I~i f(lrfJl4fis '~jj'~Pt~.f ddrauf. & e1ff;llU oJ! nOll I (llup:l lit ,eHl:J\t11 JiglUJic~ra p~,~odmn ll:I~m~ ~ o,'ll .fo~a::. fCIl. Vt prindpium lJf4i1 IpOUl Del , {ed eEl~m tiE (H~n-

tia iigni6c.ata pcr lllodnm 'llJfld. &: V,t COllcrertlm lub!lllells quanwm ad r:l~ione,m p,tt (e ,e.ti- 4~ndi, ila quod h;("cpcrf.:aio pet fe tJdllcndi Ilon lit fohim t:u!ica:ir(! in el1;mia & formatirct ,p~' fu,bkquentcm tonC'~pt!ln,J rd;tEio!J\.J co!ulelliar. fed formaliter in ip(o conC'f'pm ~tk.ui' indlld~rur • ira quod hoC" {q.fficiat vt f~b(ia-c:nll {"cma!itet dimudik Den" &: .h%~ ,dc:irlLs , 'ic~t non lit fllblifkns inC"ommnnil;abilitCr , iieut (uPPQGrutl1 & pet rona : tiCUt erlam datur (ub-. liGcm quod non fit pt'rfona • (dl. anima rario-.~ nali.~. 'lili.l 'I).mmllnic~bilil ,eft • lid, fiE v.aJd¢ .diffirnilc: c~c::mplu~. quia ¥1\ma JlO~ [ub£Hlit complete·. 'lui<l. fanna ~rtc~mplC:E~ cd io k· indigct c(lmp0!lU{: vc pan (U,m w~lma' y~ ((Jtn.~ pofitUIn rc:fuJlC:C~ & (l,ppotirum,fe&btui.At V~(O

_- . . '-. 't'-'j • ..Ji1riPa

/

.1t.f., §.e.tI. XXI x~ FJr:: .~

diuina natura non e1: flItlonc fOftn:l: incorJlplct~ . ailt patti! ton:pcmends(:olll mnni.ca.bilircr . r~bUlli[, rcd c:l r urnrna petfeG!:ionc , qUl~ ul!:luJlt .m~.1fe fprm1lircf gcnu$[elatilJ1l1u • quoJ fine: plurl~u~ tdadonibus Hare non p(ncl~. &. eaf~ll1 orpoJit~o.~ -ne iilte~ (e debet y-ltim.:lm rcnDlnanOn~n1 (ortlrl, ipfiUlllcln rdatiollibus clc.bct ip(a ~lfellda idt?d~ beari ;trquc ;Ideo tefpcll:u J!la~um mcommunrcabilis ~cre non debcr,f.d per illas inccmmunicabili-

rarem (onid. .

III hac C'~go diRlcliltatc duple,;: ell ~ntCnll~.

4 Pr{milalfirmat hunc Deurn toUlinull.:;m uibus pctrOllaH[~dbu5 rclati u i s,illi (qll e i denri nc:atlllU, fe-

, (undllm fe, (eu in gcncre abfoluti cUe Indiuiduum (Ilbfiilens, IX cencrerum DCi[atis. ve ql.od. liccr (uhliil"ntia ilb fi~ communicab.lis, Hanc (ellttn~ IL1m renet Caiet.irt few l.p.l/. ~9' "1'1'4'& q. J9·11rI• ".& ill ~.p. 'l.1.art.dk '1+'" t.&' J.Eum ~cquulltUt C:1b~(:[~ 3'P''1.1.a.1.d;[P.1..j, f .Aiuarez ;. p', q. ,.Jirt+Na:t~rju~ I ,p.q. ~9.!lTt'4·colf1rfff~rjid 1.1"\01- uanere hic tD!trrlm.1-1..& Sual~z~f.J'!P.II.ftfl.~. ~d;b'4.dG 1'1';tI;I.(.II. Gr~l!ados h'~ dlJf + fl a. ~. 'lui cit;r Ranei'.. 6c ZlIIJlcl,.'!:' ~lIi.os.' id~rnllLlc I~\tt (onfirm:ant~& reaenr Cermelnani h,c u4£f. (0. di[p.

!).dub+

Secunda (emcntia n~gar aliq1lid dfc in Deo fetundulI1 abfoluram dii:lUiam (umpt:l, IX rr:rci~e A tribus PCrlOll3.litatibus ftbuuis, qUDd null1cn aUt munus fubfiClcntilt mercatur , (~d (olUIn dIe tees (ublill:clltias relasiuas , ficllt trcs hypolhfcs. eO quod l\lblilil:Ptil, &: hypolhGs idem (um. lu 1'.V~(ql!e~ hied,[p"1f.C".J.AHubald,;,p. 10,. ".l.1kellnns t. J.q.,.,jllm.G.j\bro::ontr"a.f .d.[p+". 04. Rnit dijP·H·/lfl. f·Lol,a ~'f,dl[p.14.ArauIQ J. :~11I0 1'IJtlllpb.llb''7.q.1.lfj·t.~.ml1ll.11'

,

Stlltemj~ D. ThD. eft,dari in boc Deo commuIIi lribu5 perlctnis {ing\llarirat~m. & (ubfillcilliam :Jb(ohU:lrn. qua: ramen ccmu-umeabllls til rnbus pcr((lni~ rdatilli~. Sum piura IllCl_ • vbi Id ~pmjrfirn~ doce:, S.D .... ccsns ipfam cRcntii,& diniP3m f~cun,durn fe. &:: fl:motis tribu< pr;:rlQDi11ital1bu5 fublificntem.lra docer ;1/1.J.iP.11.q.l.4rt.l.vbiin. 'luil, qui.lIl1 fle ttrmilllfl Deus prul,cllr nalIltli1n dill;nl1.rn de tT/it,. ,"[ani., q"'£ Ulilm J11 fi tIl h". blnl'1ft [lfbftflml,n,,/f.t inttUt(l" ptrfolll1rUm «1ft;"" lliMt.Et jPl 4_"lIl1Ir4 Qt1ttil. '4piu. J+ 4d f. ibquir. EJfo",i4 dillinll. t:.tji JifbJijltns fil , ItDIl t4111CfJ poujl ~ r,{mimt ftplfrlf1i : IUlllt!mqdi "'Hum rtlllt;D1UJ 11Df'1 font "~d;'nti,, in ]JeD. fod "Ttl ftlbft}hnt(4: Dca tnim l1ihil IKciJm pmJ1 , III {Np1'J Qj1,nfom tjl: runt t:.'t!.(J plnra TU fobfin~l11tj.ft 1'lldlj~lItJ Clilf~ jdtrt11tIl.F. ,ft aHttm 'V1t1l rtJ fobJitltnl .j CIl1/idrrttH~ 'j[Vfliit. El FI'~ftd' b~c Jidmfl1 'Vl1r111J D(u'I1 fifo. 911U ~fl 'Un,. ~frnfi4 fllbfl}1~lIs, & pluTu ptTfomu p'~plcr difti"fIi~l1tm fobfllttlltiflm I'tl.:tliot/flm. Et copd~it : Nan "1/1 Jicc/lda tft 11114 ["[om' prop.. trr 'lJ';"41hJJr.j[etlfilt [lIlfjijlffllil • foil pltlr~s PDF'" nl~l~no.E.t in ~.dip.6'1.1.-rr. 1. d.J. :.. fie iDquit~ ~/1f,J 41. tI, D~D , ?' dt omnihs "I;u nbili. qUi4 '" D" Ipfo tJIfnl ... rl4b~~~I1S tn.fF lIJI jibi ft(1ft1~ Jllm {t afbltlll' IJfo. ~-~ Iffll tn filII,,! rifo f"bfi~ flt"J.~~ lot;!. m.:tt\lfc:ni: Itibuunr dminot t;llcn\'i~ fllbr.n,nri;lm.criam indtpmdcmtc:t & t~iblu pet[on..linribds.

. tucutuU'Cf~ (em hane pfor~qQiturD. s. m 1fJU/l'9'tU pfJUmlA ;nl. f. lid l J. tic inquims:11I fib., Q't!fis prn:ripilr. inJi.llit!-.4tUiil JIl~ hu~. '1"a- n- ~~. fJi ,.OJ fil'ft prlllttp'"11J fl/rjiH~7U/';lI"'Ur~ IIIJRJ, cnmnw, h Ii . ~n. fob[tjlil 1IIJi in fUir

tJJt~Pt1OnM Jiflini/~

!fll,,;-ibul: hl;I1j e{l tJllod pty prioztiplii i"dlU;J~ilft.. ·';It,{"fpnjiran/lt"rll ~ommlllliJ lib iliHke Jifting~lm" 1I1t.lftdj,,;n~ dIlttm pr~pri~t!l.tu ptrfol1af'J hoc fo/1111 hab~tIt. IJltUd jf~ppofila dtuitl.e nIlIH~i. ab ;l1ui .. eem diflittgUHi1iUr • nOlI "Hum runt prmrip'il.m . fjt;4 jiilmJi JIHidd. tJftmil.: ipfo enim diuii18 tJfomi4 til [icHlldu7/1 fo fobjiilenJ • [td ; '~n""fo Ft~prj"'lftll pe'[ol101leJ habttlt '1i1~t1 !ubjiflarlf ab tJfomill: ex ,. ehim pntmm,u baku qNed fit Yes JubJifltnlo 'I_i. fifomilt ditlil1;r "Ii ~n iJ~m JtCfll1Jhm rein ~en rl, j,.bjifltl1,.Et condudit: L;ctt tlkit#> dilliM tffn1<i lIafic1J;IIJn," [df/am, 'tit irR a'e4m, iI.'tiiHiJtmm IJrt(trJtnm ad hOi: I/,,~d tE ptrft fftbjifltTl,tarntrr ip{if 'Un" t:rijlmt( foCll11diml nUmmim .fum pluM fop .. fojie., in dlllinis frtbJifltntiA jicHmlilm ""mlnlfIJ. 11:' D.Th~mas. ~i iocus m,lIlifellitIiwul ell:.

OCCITrrir ilute!'fi Va(q.omriibmHlislods,vnico 7 veibo.dicens di[p.c;,. c. I. qllc,d ~ongt;tuntaliqlli Innumera Iota S. Thome pre :, fl;t1u:ntia t qulC' confilltD,pr;1'ml1liuo, qui~-m lbiquC! lq,9uiUJrde: ;ehl (xill< ncii, quem ar i~t cltinenrlam fell c.l'fe. AJd!l quod Ii hi!: lees D.Thom.prcbam de {uba .. ncntin IH uillil1glljtul' 1b !:lI:llI:cnua I aut probmt

in Dec tllepcr(fin~m ablo!m.m aut nihil prob;tnt. P~rct hoc. nam '11l3ncio D. Thorn. !Ot:UUii ettdli lilblhmia ptoptic,& rigurost dlJ.iE,qU~ (i in Dca (hIm lilblillt'mia :lbfhatlis p~dohaliraribu~, lUi-

crit prr(ona: ergo quando negar yuanl die petfonam ~b(olllrllnl in Deo , & ponit dl~ljnanll: if~i' tiam (ubflf,,,l'c , loquirur non de [ubGIh:ntiuig"rose t ltd proexllltntia. Minor Pt( ootU1' a~ prdlo tdHmomo D. Thom.itl.;.p<frl. '11lifj7.Jd.rt. ~.ad.l.'vbi mquirl.Qflldl}lf,d ~O~;"'l IJfitf, ~lIribllllll"

tftr VtP in tibjlT.t£to fi(tlCdittn f~ m1iamttlT'" ..I,;' cir(fI!'IJfCJ'jfd~"tit ffli9Uid jl,ErjiptIlJ,& F"'&O"" frqil~tl' ptrjDl'I1I ·d/1l1 {Ii in mWl1'a IiluHt/Jilla. Src •• iXitur ,,*11~ pofill~ 1" D~b prop,ie'ltl,b#ls F"joll4i,blf' Jmmt,. ITtI, prrjittl""; fIR e;I;&I1iJi~ per mullc0i4t11 pro .. pric,alfbtl4 fcrfol1 .. ;.DIU ,TttTlimtbi, ;fJ rot'l_ilti~

r.~ II~jI~fI dlUitt~ r,,,/~ya 'lit fllbjiJlelt1 • fIT 'fit pV{Olld. Cl!!i locus (atis manifdills eft ,&:VrgltllEior czrc:riJ. qui~ ell ex fumlll~ Theologia=. vade po(h~1D

D.ThQnt .. cl!'lerminarmncm ;Ctipimus. .

Ad Va[qUt7, Rdp.td'pcnfioncm illim it.:! gcpe.; 8 rslem minus accuraram ",re pro tor lods D. Tho .

in quibus ita exprcfsc loquitur de natura diuina fubfiftt:IIIC indrrc:ndclltc{ i fI,I:l.Iionibus.n minim

fit vdleV"rqllcz nobis obtnulere ,J(in.t'nti~JII profubfiJlcn[la in tam dafis, & uptcllis vc:rbis D~ Tho. N:"1 exrrelr~ didrqt.ocl .:Imina dlclltia e~. fuuIn rtle (ubfillc:ns, vel habeE dfc ulbtillclU.VDl

Ii Iy fi,bfiflt11J c:tl: idem 9uod cxillens. (enrus ~rit CjUQU Dens etl (uum cUe: C:liiHtcns, yel cxillcnti:t uia~n~,q\1od ccrti': dl inmilis [C'pcliriQ. Przu:n:a dotel quod rd:ttiOilfS funt treS reS fuhGlIfnres. & eJIi:ll[ia eft vna res (ub611en5 ~ qUQd prindpillm (ublin ~ndi ipfis tel;ttionibU5 dt: C'!Iemi3, ip{;c verA utariolles runr p[indpi~ dillinguelld:l (uppolit.. ~od non pOtell: accommodari uitl:cn~~, dlin ItlqLl~tur de 1.'(1 quod proprium dl rel~tio!l~vtr~ brio di,& vt conltituit [upPQlitii.cl!illc:mi;l autetn non CMIHIUit in [dation&: fuppoJiuUIl. ne:, fpe("i31iutt pcrtipet ad rclati"ne$j& perfon:uic:dacl <1E!oo uibul:lt& ad operationcs.&- ad omnia quz in Deo (1I1l1,ntC :ui fxlllcmii ptrtinct rOn Ililllc:rc rdado-ne5(ubfinc'nt~5,r~d exiftcrcs ,feu eXIra nihil: quomodo ergo de elillitia loquitur.qu~do dicirquOd

ex drc:ntia redquntUl fllbfiftctttes rclationes~~omodo ai3m d,cit ,quod lietE dfenria lir (ubGfiem. non t3m~cfr ,vna per[ona.licutrtC$ rc:Iationes,li d. (entiam fubfiHetuem aCcipc:ret pro e:dllcnrein t'O Jt'~Un pm:cise quod CJ.itlUli lit) nulla inuolwnIt

.' . Q~bj~o

10 Qgod eire di!linnm. LIe diuina elfc:ntiacxftu abfCllura ra~DC:: • ok pe[feaion~ fir fubliitmi. ok indep4!lld~ in ratiQn~ eulh:ndi pet (e: ~ tdatiQnib% PtQbatW', I}.tJil diuiaa nanna c:X k.& inde:~

D!JpMidtti; JtlP •. '1 7A;iiit~·'I!!. h.t

dubit:lti<Hllt6dperrona'Mfe pome,magis qn&n'nie pendttitb'l'rir.:l}ionlbos eihdu$'purils " Be 'con';;.

'qllo.:umque'iUCf,bllto • quod eeiam exiJlenHIl'. 1tituitur p~r ipCum eH"e ranquam pC'r przdica"tu'in,

Sen Ius ergo cit quod D.Thoitl.loqnirur de fl.lb(i-dfc:lJci:dc-.&: inmnfccum:t:rgo h.:lbl·! dl:per {e.&:

i1:cntia.; VE dmingl~tUt contra r;xi~~miam: de hac ,jndcpcndiln!; feu .:tbfohlturtJ lib ornni exiJienda in

CI,in'l dlil;Jitatio e!f:: poto:rar; an lit pcrfofu Ii dl: :i1i(l,Ii.I'HanquJ.n1 pai'sin roro, fiue tanqua;n ~,d.

fubliflcn5, ~uod de cxilic:ntill. non potem allbirari. 'd~tlS ill fi.lbrcCl-o ; Pater ,onfequ~ntiat quia nantU

Ac deI1iq ue intoletabile inconucmens dt dicere, dtuinanullquam pord! concipi v, rar~1 6.: mulw

'IlIlld D. T hom, 'lui ram form:l!itcr,& ~d normam 'mirlUs Vt acC'idcns neccife illiLu vrp:trri31e,aur'de:.

t?~.I1alli';:al rcgub: loqurtllf,i[;1 ab'lfi'l~ , & jmpro~ 'pendens ~ relationtDu5:, vr per iHas, IX t:itroile iI1;r-

prie lo(jllanlr, vt (i.JblirtendlM (umai proexilten- rum cae n~lL1r~ n:ddafllt pt"rfecblttJ, & indcpcw.

til,pnrrcrdm dIm S. Thom.dr:dmre velit non fo- den~,& ptr fe. fcd (ot3m peJfcdioncm ell:m~i1fi:t.

Jilm q_[fod cllentia fit cxifiem, (cd modum pro- & {ubfbmi~ h,Joct l fe, & ex rrzdic.aris ctrcmiafi-

pri'.lm ~,,1i5 c:xiltentiz.nempe quorllir perfe.quod bu§,& quidjratlui!' Ergo tiel' (e. & c:t vi genetH'

, til Ii.lb611entia propri~. , ':obfoilld ailft''1uam lnrelligaflir gcnl15 u:l:niuamiii

.Ad in qnod 2t!Ji,,1.. fX (<<9 ~,;. dicirnus S:~how . Dco h<ibef elf.: p~f~Cliffill1!1m.&: infiniwm. &. iii. flll!n fbi loqlli de conlideratione n~tura: diuin:e "ttll rlUO; 6< indt'pcndcn,c( a rclaeienibus, r1i01l

'ircnmferiprh pei'(on:l.lilatibll~ n~garill%, qllb 10- h.ibc:t illlld ,ranqn~m prxdicarum efi"e-nriaIe Si:

qoirur de ea p.xdfionc: • 'luHcmanl=(ct d rl.linl er~ cmnc t'1I~fial e dlantcrius ad ?otiollali~, & rela-.

fC:fifia;lic\tr Iud,d illam inrdligunt. & 'lui non h:l.~ tilla;conr"qncmer mud ell!: abfolutum :mtt.'cedell~'

bmt fidem Trjnit3tis,y.~ did~ Ibip/1ft.ad 1 ,6( idc:m ret ad ornnem com:cp~um t~laduum,. ~ tlf~ non

ttjfinnltt ill J.dijl."tjll.t ... rt.J' vbi ~andem Pfl>,[U:> jn alio , nee: un'ql1am p.IU, nee uoqtlam aC~iden$f

difficulcaccm Ir~chr. NOll aurcm lnquitur de ~f· qlli:l vnllmqllc ~'hmJc~fHU$ impC'lf,di cJ1e'.&rc.o

{i:ntj~ dillin.t conlider~ta fohim pnJ;"lliue • & Ce- pugl1o'1r cum ~ai: per m04thn .iI.'ttl~ p',fri, &. p~rfc:-

cnndtllllid quod hlbetex (e, cum in ~lii~ innllme~ chlIimi,& 1 te. Arm~C'dcm5 :lU!r:mjitpr" pOllrum

ti, J,oQ$ a/linMt ll~fUf;'lm fie confldt'tltilm dl"c cll pet Ie noeum ,Itil. qm;d oimn" clh'tlria p~t fe-

{ublillcmcm. !~no Ii pe;r(pk:lcite~ ,collli,dcr:ttlr D. j~r.1m fir athl~,pnr~;. &:' :pCum dl~. cilm pC'~ hlle

Thom~ mens tJJ ,Uri latlj 3.P. rOnin ell' illo cenfir- difccmanu elk dnlllUlm :I CrC:1rO quod dllimulIl

nu",~ (mt<:niia did",. quod in D~() (.:c'ln(h)m fe eft ipfum dh l t~. & amm pC)rtnti;}lir~re cjlrl!'nS ..

ciullt Cubli(!C'nril ablohJ[ J, IUm q1fi1 non lolilm de nee dblhui ,liuina C'tr~'I1 n:1,q"~m ipfLUn df.: • nee

elfcntiil, (cd de qtiOcumque arrnbuto, a?dl! q\J~~ p,r aill1m 'I;nc"pwm, (c~1 p:~ fdp!am r:!f'mtaHtCf.

eumqnerc , qli;& artriblllnlt' Deo , dicit. ql10d eft & imrinfecihll clli; a.:lu< purl: n;:c mim p~ reb,..

fLlblilt~I1', & lilppollmm • & pciJon:z. 'lUI:! ill D~o [ilJlu:J dlenti.l <liuina b~ber d1e ,fcd p~llp(.mUc.

idem dl: 111I1t/1,& q .. ~d eft, Et t.1mc" conJl'lrquCd IJdo:!c::; dr, habenr. '

~t[tibuta fignili&:nt>l. vr proprii1: q.la::dlrll p.llliont:S E ~ IllC llUtCm conr"'lllcnciily qll:H1mnillo jmJ!.I~ :t 1

Vt mi(cric:ordi:l,lultiri.11 immcnneas, pO'~lltl.'l:. &e. bic;'Ifli dl. rc:qllilllt alia non mioorh '~rr!(udinis!

Don fignr6c:antnr 'It perrona'incolllmunic,lbiic!. Ergo efii::nda dillllU!.'lt vi (iii formaliflirtti eonce-

& totahrt:{ complc::t~. lkct lim (.lbliftC1l~c::1 cOm- pm5. & anreeonccpeum ,d~~illulP cll tllbli1!co,.

munkabiliter vt'l:tid. Non ergo filmic ibi r~rfo- t1~fcfiaHon[eqllenria,<fltiaconceptUs.. qui C1: 'Ii

nam pro (l.lbliJtmtC itlCOdlmUliic;)bJli t fed pm {Ita p~ri[, ~ & b"bcr "Jd(\cmio!m cum ddlifiom:

(ubtiJ1C=l1te raflooalis n.tmra'. {iuc=: COm!l1tlll>l;.,hdi- crnnis modi impe, fed:i n:lfl,cmliin .tlio. lille t;1ill-

tee (c hsbeae , fiue non: dicit enirn tbi D . Thorn, 'l!lilm pars; fiuc ullquilm ;lccidc:n~.n C'cdrm (On-

'11104 ~id'1"kl ilItTibuit:l~ Dttvft f-"bJifl~'u.& per C,PIU bother modum c:xi l\~ndi P('I!Cd::C • I>: pct' (~

,~nfoqIlMs perfomt.t]lti4 eft j'/uU&lbfolfu flarm'". So- & i:aoqll~m qlflld.quj dl modu> lublificmi.e.qu~

lura figO (umir p~[(onam pro ulb.ill enre rI~mr:!! r(!'nll~ (ubfilbnri:a didr medum e,..ifi~di pCT rC' ex-

intc!1e:dIl3Iis ,&:: non amplius. Tum «lam qUi,l D. clufiuum modi c:xifrenru in aliI): IJ~~ ilIlpoffibilt

Thom.loquttur dC'fubfin'mi1dllli!):el1amr~ (jaa.- cit ilium con~~lUm qui indudlt dJc cum t:uu:&

lireJ; manet'et ,Ii circnmCCIib'rentllr pt;'riQn~lilnt1' pcddlionc qm;.:! cxdl'ldir 'omncm modllm eti""

rcIiltilU'.Etdlcir,quOd iIIis e:jrcllml,npds (Cd!. ne~ ftcndj in alio, non mcludere rnodul» uiilmdi

g~riuc)m:znctctn~rlir" diuiw VtfilbfittCl15, & pcr- P""r (e, qCli~ m'ldll~ cxill~ndi in alio adudullr:i

lona • quia viddicc:t mne non h.Jberc=:r rd~r~onCl' modQ e:nlh:ndl per (t'. fed I;OIJl;rpIUS elicnria: ;ziltc

QtlihU5 iln:ommunkabilis fem.lllertt. nec oppali. ,.darionts indud~r cite ''1uia til: :tdus plfruf.1k ~:i-

liOll1ml inre{ Ie habi:rtnt U'CJ p;[(on~ dilliru:1:a:J c1udir OmlieID modum c::dfienri:t in aUa; ergo

6; fic perfeipCam dlh inc:ommunit;tbili~, & ;tf1u. jdcmm~t COI1('~I"lli jndudit rnodilfn cl'ilh'ndi

.men-polTer old fC:l1.nutam hum~DlIm. Ergomodll pet' (c I '" rlllwlicmli : Jilbfitbre ~nim di: dr~

ilia nafilr.l. habet 1£1:$ ptrfonali~afc, .Ik roJ!l:in Clib. per fe. , ..

lifteoti:un.qu;c= ftlne t=:mo(is iIlis drn pafollz. k Dices ~ Concepturn ilium dfrnti% non indtl' i i

pro iIIo cafu quo tolle~mtur pc;[omhr,u« \I'(lC1- d= filQdum. cxiftclldc per rc formahru, fed fo!tun

tud. D.ThollJ.p~fon:&: E(gG pm "l!"C fubtiflC'n~ p{lio;~dkct. &. pro ~lio policriDfi ('on~&::pnl fotllla-

tilm vcnm.-" propri~:n habtr. non loltiru exiHen- lit~<: pIO ilia alltem conctptn n(lnJun} fDfm;dm:r

fiam. qllia. iIlam m~do hlbc:t. qUol: Ulne: c:ITct pl:J:~ expt~rur, liequ:: mod[J~ nillcndi in alio. ntcjll't

fOll4, fiquidl:m ipl.l p~nu~ Il:u;ulo PQr [drCam eft pcr (~.!Cd f"rrll.:llir~r.& qU;'ifi in qll~rco modo pa

fJft() /j&. 'III"", U( ibi dicit{olflli()1ll'.cd 1.& n hoc Ita- (e IleDUUm txplk.n pro ill 0 !isno .1ic:hr.uJlcaljtli

bet c:if~ [libliacn~. Modo ergll h;lbet, elfe. fl.lbfi- i;rm indut:br modum c:tift~nci pcr fl;'~ & t;Jdic.:;aJj.

flell' .quod tullt((.;:ilicct rcmo,js rc!adonibw:)cJfct tCf c1chuhr modum exilh:ndi in ali(>: fed formm-

pcricmz. r~f mum modum fuhfifiendi ~bcbit per conce. ptum rdariontlM: I1.l1n tdarionn '~i3m ~d petf~ tlionem Dei peuiw=nt~& fic non dl illcotlIlCllimj quod (lib OIliqtl:J rrzci60ric noncum inrdligamr dfcmiil cum il13 p~ffelli(lDc Qledi d:ili~ndi per fe~ f"d fohim' cum cOllctpm ipuus df;:. IX clli-ntiz: upiicctUI aumn modus itte Cublit'tcndi in ,~iC C'oru;ep~Il.1ian opliawt mod~ p«lCnaliraril iQ.;

l' ~ ~omtnif

~4flio XKIX. f5o~. ·I1I,"JOnn diutnil.

cDmmlloicabilis,& "Cllt in ~nceptl1 natu~~,& ifip illtclligi oili vt per (c:,n<:4 'indiS;t rC"cmino inCo~

telieaLl~liratis dilljn~ nondurn jntcl[[gitUf a~11$ munic~bili Vt pede lie, fcd ipta rumma indcpcD:"

. VQlcll,ji;lkCt ticpctfedio ~ntellca:.u.1!il~ti~,cG~~uf. denlia, & ejf.:l1tiali~ connexio eJ;illend;E cum ef-

li:it quod radicali'ct'eo,ul~ur rn IPCO IfIr~Jjgc- tenda reddie iIlart! per fc; ql\i~ ad pef Ceo forl"oalj(tl'j

ce.Et.ll.u:: (olu£lonc: enetu.n op~otica (:n,lc:o_tl2 om- (lIfficit non peH.llIul, nee in alia; elTe: aurem cum

ni.urgumc:nt.t qU:l: c,: pl:£~c:c:tione d"l~n~ e{fe~- (umma Iml~pcndcntia , fuml110 m~o;& fo~~na~it:

ria!dedu.cunrllr: fatcttJr emrn (ub-liU:cmEllln pc:nl~ iirnc,cxc\ud1[ affine quod 0::1l: pet aliud, vdln.alIP •

. nere ad perfc:tlio,wn/td ne~3c dcb:l:e f~rmalite, qniaill:i Cl.ln~ modi dCl'cndcnriz, 03C infc:riodutis ill

!:Kplicari bane: p:rf:d:,"n~m !Il OIUI'II 7on~c,pc~. & elfe: perCe aU!CII1, &; fine depenJemia ab alio [!lb~

prZ!cifione, fcd 1ldti~IH~J.i~~htct'on~'JlC~1 Ul COI1- iei!\:o .... eI compofiro , am rerrnino pcttinct ad pef~

ecpnl dfcntiz. exp~~rt VCtO fa[lJl.aliter Jll eonce- fe-CliQncm ip:fiu~ clTc,qllla pcrunet ad exdnfiom:i'I)

pttl polleriori pcrlonz. 'modi impcrfell:i,qlli e(l; in alio.Rdatiua amcm in:-

J J Scd conrra hane Colutionetn inftauro argumen~ cOlilmunil:abilitas, ~ d,itlinCljo non pe-ninet at;!

rum , ~ conficmo (eft enim in hoc ronls(:J(do,&; exclufioncm imperfeltionis, (eu modi impc:tfeil,i

p'LlI1Cl~l ditii'~'llr~lis) C[ltia ill fotlnali conccp[u cC- c:"ia~lldi.qlli ell in illia. vel pcr aliud. (ed ad mul~

fenda:!t01l COlllllH~dicaliccr) (cd formalitcr cxpli- ripJic~ciolll!m fllppofitorl1m,&: pcrColi~mm. Mql •.

'11,[Ut ipfa ~xifi:entia.&c i rl!lII~ t',lT'c aClus p~ri : ergo tip licaEio autem p~tron:i,um pettinet qllidem ~d

enam explll::atut modus c:Il"C,ndl pc:r, f~; qUI~1l Cuo- fc=,Llmliutcm,& abundsntiam p~tfc:tlionil inipfa

li!1:enti:ol. P,obQ confcqtlc=nrlam,qllil In 1110 conee- d~iUle, fell non ad primum fnndamemum petCe-.

'-IU clI:plii:.!;tur cITe, {cl1cxilhntia <lr c:Ri:ntialo: pr:e- ~qioni5 , q\lJ: ell p~r "ldnli.oom1 impcrfl:'&ioni!.

d!tatum dillinlt.1Cu: ergo explic:U:Uf modus elri:n- E.t ideo til~gi5 imime pminc:t modus p~~fdradl iQ

(iJlircr con Ul:nielldi,quia coouenit in prlmo modo ('lI.il1endo,quod elUn bfiilerc: ,quam modus ineom.

perle,S< explicatur moduslingul:lfitalii , qui.dlle municabiiit'lriJ (lippofiti,(CII per(on;e • qnod elllic: .

.:onCeprUi diuilla: c/l'inti:t non ell commllnis, fcJ rcl~r:ue rcrrninarl.E.t ideo (uliliftentiapminet (Q1'.,.

indiuidua.!is •. & lillgllhri~= ergo ctjam C::l:pli,cat me- IJ1;)lilc:r t &, non r~dicali~er [olum ltd pfi~rhlllJ

dum non c:ullendl In ~ho • fcd f ubuftendl per (Cji flmJamentum clfc:mi~ diuina:) & ad ip(lilii inu6

qlli inrer modes per Ie a rhiiofophQ C:llumCf;iros mam rarionern clI:itlcntia:. Yf (ulllllle imkpendcn-

clhc:ttius, Patct htc conf(()ucntia,quia exillentu rls in clf~)& 'If o14u$ plitUS eft) quia el1i: pede di-

conCepta in Ii.~glliari.rcucum modo fmgu\;uitari5, rc4-c. & ~lJrm~littt non Cohim radk:dirercxdudi~

lk cum conncxione dfl::nriali. I$.: pct Ie. cum ipr~ ilnpcrf&lionclD C'~iJlcndi in alio,& per aliud; dr~

dilliniutt.. hno qtJ~ crt ipia dilliniras,c:( 'Ii taiis c:6- veto incomlmmk~bilitcr in pluribus rei.1tioni bus

o=ptUl, ~ lilll; adJitionc: alt~ius.habct Cummam pmim:t 3d pUrlln r~tion~m tl:"nninandi, & mulri-

indcp~ndcnd3m .1b alio c:onccptu pa!lariori • nee plkmdi pet[onJ5. in qUibu5 c:11: ipr:l nlfU~ quod

per ilhnn elrllC~tllr aliq,ua eius maior indcpeu- p~dncr ~J abLindJ.1i[i~l1\. &" fo:cunditOitem. Pdll$

Mnfia.v(!~l't'l'cC:Jtllr.qi1ia bocip(oqucd.exifi"tD~i. eft autcm in re pl.'!rCetb cxduderc omncm 100-

pcr (c, &. cnendali!(~r conucnir etfcl1ti:t, indepc:n- ,;111m impc:n..:ctionjs.qu:lm ext~nd~c > &; mukjp1i~

dens rc-ddirllr sb emni alio,lIt conllenUt ,l( e;;cr- e~e fa:cllnJiure m, '

ccatur ill ipf:!. elff'mia, & limilireI expJicatur in il_ 10 conCl::pttl • non (olu~lI u.di~i[erlcd. criam fccjlulic~c quod ille C;Qncq[Us 6f af1;QS pUfUS. LIe inilnlfum tlr.:. Ergo non dependc:r ab ~Ii(l eonccptl1 potleciori. !It forlU~littt fit (ubl'lkrI~, &: es:plit:c=iU~ 1Il0dU5 (libli Ilenti!;:. Nam Ulodu! [Ilblilic::nrior. 'It dicit hoc q'lod ~Il aiftere ptdc:. nOll elplicac ~1lIU CDlI~Ptum.q 111m mod-um GoguU.nt.1dJ CI1It1 .i!ld~p"nd!!mia;tb alia in ell-i!lend!) ,& in ezercendo ip(um r:fic ~ nam ilk modus c:11 modus e"mc::n.. di.non in ;.:Iio. fed pl:t (cJboc ::I.lJte[D.lub~[lir fOf~ mali[cr P" fortnllan conccptum iplius elf!: ... t indepmdtnus.vt alltcm iIlud c:l1"e fotmalirn- c::.:plicciUf VI i ndc::ptmdms • lion debc:r c::tpechrc: v lrl;tio~ «I'd coru:tptllm,Cc:d futlidr c::tfentialis connelio.&" perre (um clfcnt4, reu pothhquQdip(Uln ctf; lir tfft'nlia.

l4 ~od Ii inllerur in ipc.. per(onalit:ue 'It rel:niua.&: HlcotI'lmunic.hili:nam r=.ci.1111 bzc pt:niner ad pttfedionem ex.ill:cndi. nee ramcII c:oouenit c:t: vi cont~tut etr~rialis.Cc:d ex voi rCUfiui.

Rd'POIl.~{fe di[p~rem rationcm. &. vallie noundam ciiifQ'mmm • qt:li.1 dfentia ex relationibtu "DOn ~~ ~c:rtfiil:ltemt& indt:pc:ndcmi~m in ¢lfe. led dillwaiQnetn,!!.:: oppolirio~rn inc:ornrn!lni.:~ biliut:is ~~~inam. Non ;UtCffi eft conditio, aut purequlh~urn ad h;tbCl!d~m. c:lI'c per {c • &: ind.ependc:ntc:r IpCa telmo,&- I:tU5 tDc(ll"Qmunic:;iliili,ss. Vntlc el incornmltnlcabilitlte non ponilur ratio enflc:ndi. flee: ~jus prnc:aio. :1111 in.dtpmdmria ·ctC"li:it. fed ipfc modW lubcneli c:'xiA.C1ltiM'Q per fe. &: 1\011 in ali(; ~ ad modwn pc:ri'c:&iaDU .. & iD.d~pcndeQtilr inmas iplins ajft~ • quia. DOD po~ft Intfilligi « pIClU.&: pafc:tb G din :alio.&:

_ Ii ell: (~fndefcnd=s.·" pctklb, D~{Iotcft.

116

corollAris ex diflit.

Vnde deducunmr tria v;l.lde notmda,quz m~ gis explicant vim folidam huiIU do&in:a: D.

Thom. .

Primllnl ell qllod dre~ (ell ex.illmtia. '1'( fll'piiH. I f diCit D. Them, ell: pr8p~i~ fl!ppofiri. fi:u fubfiJl-en-~is.qltod ~dco verum ell: <Jluxl elI"c dilliDQIn Ifuod

dl: in Dee pu:dicamm ea~Dtiale J & conuenir ipJi n.1l;ln~ dium:\: quidit~du~ , n':cclfJrio fUppDnit r::a.~ (ianem [ubliftendi in ipra !=tTclltia. nee j;onucnirct illi,nili Cub Gllerct. h:lqllc CUtu narll-ra,fCII dfenria diuina G~ iJ qlla Deus cfr > &: id qllod eft p~r r"" ipr~m~ & .. b inirin[~co , t.\1l1cn ipCllm drc:,{c\! ipt'a exillmtia i 1(: non cottelporuJct rliuin~ c:lfcllri,e qu.mn1l5 c:oa/ideramr ... t principillm qllil dlcnili.

{cd qllltcnui I;olifidl:ratur Vt pti~(lpiulJllJIIIIJ fublillens. E[ it:!. in dO.:mlll S, Thomz eft (o]id;t Ct;Jn~ fequenria.C1U t:onucnit dl'e limplidrer. pr:di,pponitut conucllitc lub1itt:erc > feu eire prlncipillm qll~J. &:: babc=ns modlllD per fe cxHlencli,arque ita fub6!b:nda lll;Jn pOICIt cITe conceptus eon[cclltll~.

IS! po!ic:rior irfo dfc. fcd anreccdcl15.& prn:fuppolitlu, &. Ik Ii conceptui diuinz c:ITcnria: C(lIlUC:-

nit forma.lher.& noll radicaliJerip(u!U ~ll"::.(CII cxi~ fh:Dda. ru:q,ue (ublinclI~ia conucnit ra.di~alirer • lie:

pro alio poftcriori concepn!. (I:J antccedcnter, &; pt::t:requi lite:; atquc: adto l foniori <:oJluCllif for-

malitc:r. .

R.uio dt. quia elf!! eft pr%dicatnm clfenri:lle .;IilIiniuris.ttoo quomOOocumqllc,fcd Vf p.crfetlllm. & indepmdcEU.& in a«\1 pUlO. ita qu"di1h: conditioncs p«f;d-i ~ tk iodtpcndcntis e(fe.non t~.4i~cr rQ~fcd CouP,Wt!:1' AAbr~nw • '" t~.Q,c;Q":

mU~llrUl

'Dijputitli!J' x IPo

mitennlf iprurii em:. qlli.l formalker;& non udi .. ~.:\1itl:r ~(l:;l.:t'15 putus.1nter iflo; aurem duos con'!:CPW5. feil. f"'l1u: vt qUI) aHquid ef], & formte vt 'Iliad ell. p:rf.;;!titu, &: indep::nd:;ruins, &: fotma. llus eft habete!:lf~ 'It '1lloJ> qllam Vt l'lfo,lilluidem ·elfc Vt qH~ ordjn~rur ad ell'c: 'Ir qlluJ ; ho~,.!:njm fimplidt.:tel1. Vnde ... t dfe intellig~mr limpli'itcrt& perfed:~,~tql1e lndependenrer ,d~b(!t conueDirc alicu i vr '1"44,&; non prz::-ist rc:'pondcrt: con· t~pruifo rmx vr '1"1'. Vcraelt ig'tl.lr h;ec propbJi. rio quod. !:/ft:,C~u el;illc:nlia,vtpc&aa lir! &: 6m~ PI_icitr:_UC: i~df;pl;'lid:n.cr .licatur a!iq>1id elf.: • debet CUppO.ilI']!iod. _Cc h.1h::u u!l~'um cITe if""J. nen vt rulO h~be-lidl V' '1"n. Er lie modus fubu~ !lend.i,feu: hlbmdi Cc yt 1f"~Jj pr~c"d~r~.~ pr.-cr¢quid dc-ber vr aliquid h,t bc~t ('((I: G,llplu::iti:l, &: petfl;"t'ie. ita V! lit lei quod ell. nOil id quod! ranrum ~ Ell'c 3UtCm (ubGIl:me,.& dfc vr qu,d idem elt, qUia id qllod til yt 'IlIlIi • ell per fe.& lion Iii illio,i Ii aurcm '1uad r31'11iim Ce lwb;:! 'It prindplum '1JiIl cxi(tendi, (:2: Vi t:disconceptliJ non ('x('luciit ea"c in alia, vel tanql1;ztIi pars compOllcns, vell.lIIquam i1eddens ill b:n'em • '1 LIla umnia i 'b lu bene eJfc 'It IIJlIt. [ncipir 3Ulem dlli:-~rnj id quod limpl.'i~r eft. ab eo qnod imr~rfe'U eli, p~r hoc quod ell h;Jbcre elfe ill ,,,af. C\im ergo in formal. eGOupro c:ll~Qli;t:'djujn;ll: jorrct cO.., limplkitet',& PCffeCllim. ~ quod ell iI'!l15 pnnn,i.Il il/o cDn,:r:p£t1 prZfilppO?lrtlr JnPJUJ 'pCe , & rano lub,:ndt fi:: ve

1i1IjJ,!~u tubli !lend.. _ _ ~ _

I' $c:clindulll quod colligimus til. quod in diuini~

ui:ltioncsrcrmin.lntcs,& incommunic:!btlcs.'Juod pcainet:ld ratjonem pC:'(Dn~.non (unrmedlUm. & pr~requiG[um ;'ld habendum l::"Jl'e. Ih:ut in rebus cre~li$ fllppolimm prttG.:dic ipfum dfc.nt::c eli· citut ;tliqllid bmplicirer elf!:,&: cxiltcrc: Iliu CUPPO'litum quod dar perfC"if:ltcm; & cemplernm mQe dum e~ifl:('ndj ip" {ilblbndz. E. hQC ideo,q!lia ui!tr:tc: umpJicitct.k perfca~ non inuenitur in rebll5 creaels , nin fmqilam przdk4tum cl)mingcll.~, " dc:pcndms,ac deriuJtum ab ag!.'lItc. V nde rom 19m1i nOD prOdliG~t rem in fa.:tu cl1i:.,~ 11'( '111'111 produltuJU lIili ip(um (uppo'im n • hnic (!tiotll). commUIJie"ac p('(' ((!, & dJt~it~ df.:. IX non dlClmr 1Iliquid cUe oili przrUppon.1~uttroni,,;uiu~ Cup. polimuw. At '1ceo in D~<J ci\:m ip!u.Il cOl:: fit i k, & rndependeas, ae limplicifCf,&: pa:fechlliru t. uia~s.n(Jn dCfCDd('t a rerminationc:- td:!rill<lo&: (lJpp(JUtali quod iIIud de lubcat pcrfcdum mcJ~ dwn elfc:ndi. &: t~nqwm qll4J .qlli.ll coX" fe ell ipl;.lni dre: pco,fel!iillimum. arqllc :Ideo Cdm modo perfe(hJlUno. qlli eJ1 P('t fer It. da,i II": ugo Icrmin.tlio. tics ~ Ik pct(OlialCS modi CcmlCqlllll1l11f io Deo, ad ipr"m dl~ • 110n pr~C"cdQm. fcU. ex IlbWidmtia.&(acundifarc iplid5 ilitinidc:-ffl.':; qifilt~j'j1l5 .Clmrioct nOD lahlm gt:nus ~brnltulilD prtfedionwD ~ {cd etiam ,.d,1tiuulDi&: ftc OplJllct. quad cfli:nti.1 iden-tineaur ijJ(IS,eiCque dtt elfe pa- rumm~m idc:ruifiacioll(m ~ iplZ '1eli; {datio~ inlet ie opponJ.Q~ [IIi"&: dillingl:lantur. quoaell: incornmlJDlabilltc:r fc habc[c- V 0& hoc c~ confatumri ii: haba: iii di~ ulna (ubltanria. ~ Ik ell: abundanu. ipum efi'e. non. "I p~uiJlU1tn.vf c!l'cdiumum mci'feindepen-

GUtS ex k.& v-t fUlf4. ' .

11 . Teniurn quod c:olliginnlS ell. Iloneif: in DeQ qualUQf ddlintl:u fub6Umnu , lie':l dnUf _iubli.;. QalDa abfol1!~. quia ilia idmtincatlll:: CUm ttibus: relatiuif,DCC opponifur iilisl& fie n(ln fedt HilmI:rum cum illil J Gl;Utdknria,,& rebtion« non lUll' quaruQt fd • fed {fa res, & vnot lnm~ !es qu,.;: idc:nrifiatur CUIll iliu i quod ptOUmitC1 appc:tLltion~ iUillS termini numuoJis 1II1II1_. qlti !lffdb,

A'I1ib. /].; i-11.

(upra (iiGinaiorrem, 8& rrttidnell'l toln'l.~emdiarn", gucndi • qtneA: oppofido •. &: vbi nulla.el1oppo!i .. tio,nulla ell numc:ratlo.SubnA:~mia am em dillina. ficnr &. >e«~mia nullo modo npronj~u, t[lbu) fLlbliJl('nriis; & fie non facitnumerum (:.tUD iIliS'. SeCI.Hell 'dercbtiO'niDUS, quit' runt quarucr , licet non ql1:ituorperfon~ • quia (unt quatuoroppofIt:e tlirrtlln~tione • &: mde dencmicsrur nl.ltnc.us.:c'" larionum, lic.:tfpif'lfio dtiiua~· qua: tpir.m-oni aai .. iJ~ opp::;nimr.idcnri6ccrur cum p:,1ttrnitat~; '" Ii· liadonc; j Bi 6c pon EA ~x omnipanc incomtnutil* cabills, (cd [alum (pindani paffiuz. &. bee (ultil:llt v, relarjil~ multipJic!:cUf caUOIIC ,umin.uioms dl,,;

uc:r(z. ,

SOlllHlItHT IJr!JImmf ...

ObiiciJ primo,ex v.trquez! Sl.ibGllclltia Cc:eun.. 11 clam communem vCl.lm loqu~ndi E,do;!i~t &: is.

pp ,til idc:rn quod hypolta6s,f(,d in Dee, Vf COiUmUni tribllf pet(oniftrJon Ja!lJrYnahypoihfi.s 1Ib{uInta: ergo nt-que (ublill-emia. Minor ea D. T h.

; .... fr.i QU'4o.ATt .~.vbi aoc:cr qlIod femod! proprir:'" taribu! pc:r(otl~lIb 1I.s nOli remall':f illtClJcllu5 by .. pol1a.G~ : bypo ltaGs enim Ggni6at ~liquid dill:il1- dum in di lIinis.ctlm fit fi.bftamia indiuidua; & ftc idl:f!J dt conc:c:prds _ hypofiah! arquc pn(Dn~. at tic-ut non d:Utl~ in DeD vn3 pet(ona.lic n~'luc da-

tur lIn2 hypoA-afu. Maior :lurcm prob~tur U commnni lIftl Ij.'ltturn. Nam in epill:ol;l AgacboDil pz.. pz.qlt:t h.ibctllr in V I. 5, nodo "llrllM 4. ind.ifCa.. mlJiarim hyponalis vO('atur .pctrOnaJifa quod C"Orr~rr!Jnd~1 hvpt.JioliJ pet(ol:laJirai ku (ubiiftenti:z.

EI M2nrmld. in C(m~ili(l Lat«~tufi ,;mill/fA,ti'iff f. (q!1(1"f ,. explic;Jf q'loniodo G, vnit~f ill Trinif;J,.!.!.dicm~ quod 1ft DfJ(4i,orillljJfobftlm.~ ,iU,gUAji Gr6t; JiwliY hJpaJlllfiblll.Et IIttJifili jIJ,1 lufl:ini~ni hnperatotis 64 / 1Ji171llfm II. didiur QllOd Omn(.J SS.P P. (tmfotlllmlr nlll J~rml , Mi"J ~Jfo ~ t'IY<Jm, jiae fobjf.ttlliAm, ". fo7m_~ "liHd {lIbfijltll-

li a 111,fillt p"fo""m.Sr;:mp~ "80 fumimr fllb6Jl~o...

ti;l ex pane hypolbliJ bue pt[rCin~; non Clt pamt d{~"ri~ tilll:' fubltanrb: quz rdhm perroW, ,ommlloi5 eft.! dc:m dOl=l:t O<llnaG:.lilt.Jc J;~ttth rim,; injlitflt.t.t.YI'l1I(qIli[IJ"' h~11J(lfjl h:!plffl-fi~.itl ejJ,.. prr fo txijlt;ts. S! d;Jrim S. ArMnatilH firmlitil'tt £lfil'lgeliflm lit fonUifJi1!l. /)n_PATtI i H7,ujl4it~ inquit.fll~ inwpm;lfJ(Jn~figr1ifi~41id IJlllldfl;/tJijlir.

SIC ugo cum MID clcbe~mllJ in alia ugnHicationt;' I1ccipcr_ c' fub/Hkol_i21il • 'ltlam in e.a '}!lz ell in v{tI Patrmn ;.& Conti!ionup. & Eccldi;t, pr2f~rjtil poll: . compofiram liTem. quz oum in Ealcfi<l O· rit:n;.dj·fdir ck hoc nomine: bypolb6~ non poJra.nmUJ05 ad libitum vri nomine: flJbJillcQii;a .. at e'~m pon~l'~ ;abfo)m3m in Dco, tVllInon POMmU. h1PQlblirn.nt"C p~flon~m ;tbColuEalJ1:.

. Acrpon. ncg,mdo ~jorem t nl~iuJ di4in.. I, g_u~J1:d() :: 6 fllb61lC'ntia lIun:llur pro !ubJiIl~tt: incommu l1icabili, & tennin:1to •. ,it- dHdc:-m qaOil p'u(oo<l,feu ~ypoaafi, j & lic CUDt lO!um tns rubnlt~ntiz rt::l;:uiua: in Deo.sifumarut (ub6lkre prO'

to quod eft przcis.e niilere per (c • (eu e:tiftnc Vi qHIRi., & independe1ltet vt (ontnlponlturriquod eth:d!len: in a1io; 14:u per aliud;hC Don dietinE PaUC'l qllild (ubGl1enria eft id~m quod. hypofiafu. quin li!lrius Oi!"po6tlliD iIJ6nu:mr: • pFol:fcnim Hic:4> r:onymlu, Hib.mI5, AuguR.&- D. Tbnm. Nun $. H,crvnymus in ef1ft. ftA DRm4fom • hY'p'otbliltt 1100 die!, dIe idem qllod (ubliftenp~ • J~d idml qllod {ublbuti<lm , 11;11 vfi~m,iu:u.lllt-~lati!un Ii,," ccrratum doqurnr iam. TQI",.inqair, f"fd~1Iim M~ rtri6'litJI 1'-'. film' "III,. b)!,ji-jintPifi"'[liIJlJll6tli,.

.se

" s.~ cert~ interpruU,tio atic~ ill! e LatillO ci;rit> {pondc:ns magi, fublbntiaRl (Ollllt. quam fU,bfi, ftcntianl. DlcitnrenilTi tl1ni~ul,.CelJ thrvilot., W~. _ quod c(l(ub.&: .J;I",qLlod ell elfcntia. q!lali ~ubl1~

I _ Jia. vel Cubcfi'enria,'qllod dlre¢l:c~ dl f~bfbnna. ~c : c He D. TbBm. in hile '1HI.P.1-9.I#'''C.1.~i. t: &II~W:. ~~ ... d 3. doect qllod [ub!talltia fCI;Undum pr,?pttam ~,Jignificationern C(lt'rerponJe~ h1PO~?-g.t quia no.

· : mine .o{ublhnri% nos Iigni6camlU C'.aennamj COI1- ~'tcndcb;int olim Arriani (lib hoc vocab~lo bypo, ,ll;:i.Jis 1l'CS {ublb,,~ia5, Ceu Vfid. &. etT:ntlu in Dee ~ inHoduotere;proytcrqllod dicit Hje(o,J1~rn.~bid.plb -1m /JQtJJinl hypojt4jil1wIlmun lilt", , qU.HI. Vldc:hcet

iIIo direQe fignific~b3tllr (ubll:anth. & non ita clafHllbfafl;cnti.a.Loqllcndo 'Ierode (ublilknti3. 'It 1 nobi~ a,dpiw.t.Cubdit Hier(lll.l~~ dr. Ylla eft Dti, & flliS r14ttlr~, q""' 1m'; til; id 'him qlloi. fllbfiftit.

[ , ,"Dli alilllla. hllb,l ,ftJ. ["llm eft •. Ybi,ly 11<1,,,'1"11 ffl. · '1mJ eft, idem ell aG n~tllfil qua:: perfecta cit, 'Ina: .,fimplidter dicitur ea'e, & noh in ,dio elf:. Et cum .'liddil: ~ i4 ,,,tld fobfiflii. Mil aiiW7Jk bJm ~ Iy 111m · 'il/iIlIlJt, inrdligirut 11011 eX alio concepm, Ced c~ , proprio t:t.lis n:lturQ:, Fan:tur ergo in Dee abfolu, tam fitbliA:entiam , feu in cffi: n.UUfZ. quidquid Ii~ - de lignilic:atiol'lc hypolbfis. qu;e tunc ambi{l;ull ~ erllt,neC (umcbatllr crmm;r.b iUit ami9uis pro 'ub: liJl:entia, qllz ell c!&,pcrCc. (cd pro Cubflinda.vel • pcr(ol1a. Bt dh:ebanc Catholici, 'It ibi Icfctt Hiero.. ";aym. Si hyppaJiI ~fI fobften,i4/()'1 [fi1ft irQ h.lplJ·fttifu.flptrfon4 !Hbjiftllti. {"lIlfr" bJpl!flll{ti. Do:: '(ublillcl"lti.:l. vero non pe,ron;di. Ccd pro f!u fc exi,1I:cnrc,Sc 'It '1j,~J • non fllit cont1'OU~Jia,If:J aileaa ,fllita P~ribus.vr pute in Hici"oll.cit.

~o ' , Idrol dicieur u Hilario 7. at T ,.1";,. tired ji'1P11 vbi loquens de Patre,&' FiliI) diCit, intffi Jibi. inHirem fit fobftflmli;r, ntl.rur" b.b~ .. "t pnfttllf'il 'f/lZ;ltII~

· ttm,'1ll'I, vulij I egune, fobftflil1llu ff4Ilir.:idem c'nim :(enru~ ell: QltOd fit natura: Cub6tb:ntit ynira~ • vel fubtittcnti;t: natut:.= 6. enim n;(tUf.1 eft (Ilbfi(t~!. &ttUt fubJiilcntia U:lmtz. Er: Cubiieit Hilmu$ de natura muina. ita eft If. fubji/tm. 'V, in fi,bJij1tm, ·irzfit f;l .. lIer~ il1'ifo • VI c!r ip[1I. {flb[ti1l1r. Item Au~ &1111'7' k Tr;I1i1.f4p.+ Ot/JI1U ~ 44. fiip!"'" {"bjillit ffl411t, tilllgU 'Dttu; ,~ pmpolirio atl'inwt.illa nail. lollit quod etiml telanut; fubfillar. {cd afiirnwtqqOdaf.tm abfohU:~fvtomirum di&um Ag .. - (honis P~p:c: iI. 'tjfl.qlf-. bIJim1l7' in 6. SyfIQ,h jI# .... y'?i diCit tf'~ !"1!'n.u,g; 'Eln~", DC"'IJ~rI~ !,;"m n,.; mmlWJ ftJ,jiJltl1'" ; fiJ. m_ {lIbjijll1lll4rotR foil p,'[mt..rum 'fJ11_ fobftjlmtid.rn. Sk ellim babet anoqua IcCQo, nou:l verb qUZ' lubc:Clli in Coodliis C;olooile Ul06.legit Iri_ pe"fott~",. - r.bJl6iJ,i_.(cd nOD prziudiut h..:c Icd:io pfiori:qua~ Ie mim condcmDabimus »lI'iquam lc4ioncll1 fl)~ aooonun ,,[u6nnat1mlDc Cenfu O.Thom.oiamfa .. tis di'xin"fus. - Q_u:ne .:onIla[ Panes H quando vfJ dQllDl! ncg.ue in Deu (nbfiH:endam Y'Q1tIt .1oqUi de (ubfiikritia. pcd"omli. &: rompktainon de [u~ .6nmti~ ~otilt1lanic;abili paConi$o Nomen .:I.Ufetn by~ poOd e~ commllDi v(u f.cdel1e prO' pQ(onalifuppomo.(eu (uhliflmria I,:omplcr~ liUnprum e-Il: ~ &. in hoe (eneu' l0'l\lIlntur autboritat~ ~dueta: 1 y ~que:t,Dl;qul: fubibmi!l= nomen pro :flia '11 cGc:nua,byp0&(1I plO pufona ill Ec:dtfl3. ,eUaumeft. .

QaOd veto quidatn nfpondent ad nob :aUrhoti{;\le! (umcrc Pants illiquando fuhfillcQtiam pro (llbil.2Q.rili. vd(uhlillctC~ cxillerc .. & (~ 't'1Ulm in Deo &lemur. cmninofurile dl::mr cniffi. Patlf:snoD loquentu£ edam proprii: !'umeud. Cubfill~. & liJblillcre. pro. per fe I:lIiftere.quod ~,ond\~~c~, (111 mo8us mftendi; {gL.

...

,§};fi4fl.XXlr. e1t~ t.l!tPerflni1 Jjfljn;j~ , ,

pet (C'.necdHub1hnda(oh\m~ fed cilln modo,cd!. per Ie t licct l;oJtlmllnicabilitCr ! Hoc enim negsre Parrihu$.cll negare I:is ptoptietatcm l"cutionjs.

&: ad:improprh ~jucrf('re. • _ '. , . r

-SeJ:u(ldo "rgUlt.pro fenrcntla Varq ql!l:i efi"enna " diuijj~ (cc:unduan fe,&: pia:ci(i: reillriombU5 poull: q~j~m conlidc,rari 'It exill:Ctif s " q!l!~'g~ aCtus pa. ·fLl5':4I€. non ell In !t.m! pora:: poffiblh~atl •• {~d ta.men iII;l clr~nti;l. fie confide(3ra non porL:ll: eonlidcrari vrpcr (e. fed vtcommunj~~biHs rribu5 per[onis, in quibu$ eire &ica.tut: eigo pro ... r lie noll eondpimr cum mode cliftenJi per re, arqllcadco

. n!!qllc cmn CnbfiCtcmia ab(olllra, cuius mueus ell c:onfHmerc: ens pct (e. Con(cqu.prob3.U1r.qui:r. iUa natura ex yj t.:l.lis concapnu fie p~cili con6det:lmt

'Vt terminabllls alle termino , (,tI.t'e1.1tiolle: ergo,

. nendum per ie.Nce (ulBeit dicere: 'llJod eonlideraa

-eur per (Ii: (ecundum quod I)' per fl oppoilitur hllic~ quod ell: ctre in ",Ho. 'It in Cubic:ao,non ei quod eft clle In alio, vr in (uppoIitCJ t vel. vr aliI dieunr,c:Jl

pc' fc communic.abiJjtCfJ non incommunicabilitcr:

Contra hoc enim ell. rum qUia hoc non CuBi'it ad rationt:tn [ubliftenriz • alias humanitas in Cbriltb diccri:tur habere (ublillenriam crc3tam. quod eft h.£'retictlm.ec (eqm:1a patet.qula ill. n~tW'a hUlllan;l. cxdndit hoe quod ell: cjfein a!io,vt in fubied-o: !lce enim cO: accidens/cd non cxcludit elfe: in alioj. ,Vt in lilppolito.quiatcrminara non eft. necincommunieabilig ~ ergo non (ufficlt Iub~re aiflenriani non in (Iio, v t aie2mc habere (ubliftenti:un : TUIll etiam quia in hoc conlill:k implic(uio , quOd dic;!~ tnE ;lliqUld habere fublill:entiam, & ramen manat communicablle. NiUD id quod eft communiabil, alred.habet elfe: 'It f"".non v£ 'I"I1A, nee h:lber exiJlenw.m aut fubfiO:entiam petfede,. & compt.:ta-~ fed incomplct~, hent :!nilna rarionaIi5.qu~ (ub(dli, communiC:lbilitcr; (cd hoc idea ell: qub fubfutit p~rti:l.1itcr.ft::u Y'r pm ordimta ad return. Noun!. rem non concedimus djuin~ n;uura: rllblin~nria!D pmial.m. & illc~mpl«aln t Ced pctfc:llifJim:l.m~ ergo implic.amos i (I di ais,es: vna pane ponendo in diulna elf entia filbfiftenri.tm abColuCl.m. eamqnc p~rfc~am.&. non parrialem,. b~ incolDfl~~; q: alta du:endo elfe commuiUeaLde:m., Cw.:!! m Jplil viCccribus communicabili5 (ublificoo:t:' imbiinml' eire: unpctfcll:am, & pauWem.' &; inccmplc-i:

1lUU.

Et c'onl'inn. amp1il!$ ifr.a ~rio , quia vet e4"entIa dillioa, quando ;ltndtllr pcrConalibU5 rdationibqs .. fcdclirur pcr iIIu Cubfil1ens, 'I'd non ~ Ii non ceddi. mrCubtillens: ergo tcbdoRes iIIaJfub611:entiOl= non flint. qllod oQganiml1J fop;-". & 'lac licgmdum eft,cnm HOt perlooalir;!tcs. COO(cqll.pattt,quia ti {ubfill:C'nli~ r;lrent • reddercnt natur;ml quam afli.: aunt Cubfia-e:ntcm = Ii ergo Cubfillerncm non re-d-dlintrCu'bliilend~ non {lint: ,Si Veto redduntfllbfill:~em natllram ~ ergo riidunt ipf$ Cubfilkn .. aim :ilifalutain; jps~mque (oblillcntem reddunr,; Gqoidc1ll naruWll aAidunt kcundll.m omnia qu:z: ~et, &: confequenrct fublillmtialn ip{am ahfa-: lut:lm afficftmt.Subfillmda I!utem. non PQEeft :.1&";

, ci vlrc::riori Cubfillentia. Dili fit in fe incoml-Icra,&l irnpcdctl:a. feu pamalis. quia. Cllbfillc::te p~ :Uia!lt fub6R:cnri3m,cll rc::ddi fubfillentem per iliantj&' tic non clilWe-pct fe. fcdab.vltetimitc:rminodcpen .. '~j detC~ I cui communi Cl1ri POten. quod eft ~ntr.l ra.'"' rioncm cail1fc1lmqlIc fOlffiZ ""lQ;I; non potetl pu

ali am fiiDilem focQlati,nili in (e impml:;!ta fir,licut

vm 6gora non p_ordl: vlrcriils figurari • vna aaio: aliaattione proiluei. vna VIIi!) ;Ilia VniODI!'Vniri .. ' ~na (pc:.;ies illlptc:lfa~ vel apreCfi ;dfa. CpC'clc-~di IIIle!ligibw.k rl:£I'~fc:nwiua. _. ' , ~ .• ,; COIlJir.

Di1Jtlt4iio XlP.

';C-unA'~m':lcc1Tfld(Yj qltii ilia ab(olutil fublillciiria h~~~r (cvt :II tribntiim terrettu e!Tcritill: ~. ergo potcll'c:e~dri t1re'~tia c~~ pra:cifiofle 3 i:lli • ami;. bum, {jellt ~ quohhet :1"0' fad'j ergo tab f'r3;'Cilione, iIIJ clf':fltia nl.iiJel ensincreannn, &':itl:UJ PUtLiS ; & cOIl(d]uctner vrexil1~ntia, & err" 'ip~ [um,;i (i!:', &: un1cn noli cohdpitur fi.ibJiJleli;:ergo porel~dJdeonc~pm$ tncnti~,& iplius dfe in De. line' f(t"fiJl~nd;i : &:·t~incn JIIe conceprus d1 due pern;,tliffima , fdlic« de 'eire diulno, 5icnr c=rgD mle clfe perell:· ~I)m:!f'i lille f!,bfifreiuia (tI;! ab{o_lur~ '.it:!. quod fubJlflelHi~~ h;l.~~:ir per ari~ ~~~? ;m~lbLlE~I_n.' _ mr non, pOlem C'~~Cl~ c{· fi:nna, &; loemmef e:lTe conl:'p, vr pcrfel1um .. & tamen ql10d non habeac ,uvi' miuJ fomulis con~ c-eptti$ [ubfillenti;am • f~d n rdarlonibl15,licut hi noara [entemia h.tb~t e:\ anriilulo :idiunaoj linC' quo cOl1cipi potdl-. Ik idem argnmcnttlmJitde conc:eptlf Jlat!lrz 4i1.i;n~;quZ!' concipi pordl ve pcinc:ipium q fIV,& in r:i(jomfna,ur.t', & non cand" pi V[ qf/oJ. ~ t tine cOI1l;ipittlr vt eft ip(uln drc~& nendum Vt fub6aens: crgoll,blillc"cia fubiiqni pot!!l! ad cenceprum pcrfeclutn ipliu5 ellt:;& confequcntet non repngna{ ilIi eeauenire pei" rela-

eione5. . " '

~ Re(pon.ad prindp~lc: argummtnm,quod elfmda dinin2. eX: (uo fOHD.di t"onC'cpm non falum habet elfc,provt opponitur Jl:u:ui POffitJl!irdtis.& ipll nihil~ pr.ecisJ , {Cd eeiam 'It opponimr c:a~ imp:rfedo : U depen d.,nri, (",t1 habenti mud, ~ in alia, lin..: vr' accidens fllbicdo.(iIJC vr p.:U'~ coti : fed pet {c babet dIe 'It qll~l. t"ommunicabile ramen filppolilij relatiuis, vr n:rminllntibus, 1St in.:ommuni-' cabilem Ieddcnribus naturam tic pcr!6n;itam.'S::d f"men ,non'cll comml111icabilis dfcDtlJ. diuinare .. 1atlomb1l5; Il[ pet illas raniac ur cae: timpJjcittr~ quau pet (dpr~m foh'uD ell'tilci~f 'iilli, rl:l~[ionlbIl5. rmninata "litem per tel.1tioncs non {olilm ;. jnfir~ fed limpiiciur fir.&: habear prt:f~ dfc• Non fie ea:. {~d ll.1~ora d~uin.1l (I; h.lbens pllrIJmj &: ili6~lujm :!tqnc indep.:ndeoJ C:lfc.commUDkat illud reJatio'nibus vt hilt, & .:W ipfi. (alulll act"ipit rcrrnib:;ltio-' nem.~ dulindtollem fuppofiralcm, in quibus VIIil fir, ,Cuill!) lignum ell quia natU{;1 6e t"ommouiara nOll mulriplicatllr. flce in fC,il~~ill fllo dTe. fed imelle r=CinC't in rribu~ pl::rfonis.Non ergo commuuint ilIis clli: (olum vt ijflll, (ed ~am VI '1I1IiJ~ quia rcciner vnj[atfm fuam inttibusillis pcr[o.bis~ &: vnum ctfe. . , "

Z. ~E:t quo p~tCt ad probationes (1:11 rc:pIiQ.l • q~

lillDt cOntfiJ. boc., '

Ad primam ditinJlu ,foflicerc hoc: ;ld rarioucm filbGflcnda: quando (uRicit:;1d riltiotltln mde4. pendentis c:xiltc:ntia:, '" p~fca. iffi~. qP~ nOn po~ell: coneipi fine exduJJonc: modi dfrndi ,in' alia • & per aUud. Et 3d inlbnriml . de hullWii-c (~[c:' Cbnl1i,dicimus ipfalD omni artte fgb6Htntia • quia nOD ct:dudiI omncm r:l(ionan exilhadi in alio ~ lic~( e:oim eJ.dlld.:u: aillentiam in a1ftJ. yt ae:cideru in (llbieClo non bmc:o aiilrn-' riam in alio,vt fonna,&. pars in fuppofu:od"oJthn_ enim c:s:pliCltUr nomIDe: bummir.ms prlncipiurn' quo homo conltinzitllt VI forma .touli • &. Bilmra.. Vndc: neqne ~ fc dicit t:lfdimplidta; & pet fe, Ut"M Id quod ell tf~ (JCUf idquo aliqnid 'cftl, mt'dianfc au[t:m foppolito' (lillie vt i]I1lla" &: G, non habet et: fc: elTh :omilino' indtpI:Qd::n. i' tup- ~ polito.imo in fentcntia S. Tbom:!: nul!um etT'e haber, iUG mediame: -fuppolim : Qalora aUfmf'di~uim indqiendellfu HuppoJiro eft ipfWD efi"e nfe omnillO irukpende~ & pc:rfedllm • &; per fet

lUll .• S.TIm..is".p.,.D·rh., .TmDll$.JJ~,_,;

& lie 'eli:; vi (ul C'onc:epHl! nee h;bei: clfdriair6; Vi: in ri1oic:CtQ. nee depcrlden!c:r ab aile 'vd. {up:. poliro,Jicct ccmmuuicentr illppolim • non vi:' Mpendens ab i1loiri clfe, (d 'l't lpli commtlnIC:ill$;

err,:: t"x(c,& perfe.' . , " , '

, ~d f~~ti~dam repJicatrt dicirhr D0':l implkart", 1 j 'Iuod ahqurd habea. (1IbfiUcnr;all1 • &. fit ctIm;' nJunrcabHiJ; non foltim lictrt :rbfma fJ[,cm:dis i qu~ Illbfit1:ir vt (orma incompkca ~ [!, informacilia rnared:!;' , fed cd.1.1t1 'Ir forma perf,,~aa j &::

in (e b;-ibcns elli: petf"AiffinJlIlJ!, & ii1ch'p~l!densl dnpli'iter enirn pou:U ~lig!f1 fcnnl t (eu dIll c(iltIlJlunicari. V no modo \l~ indigellti.an lid.

8& . ordll'~m ,~d :I!lqnid perfec1JII~. ad quod lIe! '

fe ordilUfUrt ';Jlio rnedo ex abundanria (Iii ~ & perFdWlima fc::cllndil:tC.:" infinitate .~u!~ b6~ num de Ic ell communu:ammm • ficudu&hlten~

ria. & exHtemi<l dhlina cO!nmlinil:.mcur bbm<%;; nirad, &. elfenria rliuin:l' in urionc fotm% iri:.. relligihilis inrcJlectni ,rcJto; non ex lndigemH

fiti • led ex abUlld:llltiot ptrfc.'i!bonjs (U%' ; nolt acdpic:mlo ab jllis dIe. lcd d,mao j1l1$ p.trflt~ lI:ionem. Didmll~ Ingo quod Ii nanlf;1 iliuIIl# cH':;r cOIlln1unkilbilis Pl.'tCo"i~, VE 'jrnpufeituiH r~rfe4ioH • vr P,lfS ,oli , & fUriiiaJC:u pnm;rpil1m

{I'flj pr~,;i,5e ipli COfllPOhto ,&. lubfill~lln t bene prob~,el 3tgum.:nruril dfl: iltlpoffib,;e"quod cf~

fer commlirlkJbihs, Ik, & qUtld dr~c (ublillt~fJ!'

Si aurem ell I:.;inlrllllllk~blli~ per lonif V{ h;z;. hem in (e omncm pl.'rfdtiQ"1:1II 1 .),:: eam illif comnl1lni';ifJ~ per '''knc'lk:ldoncm • t~li5 cornn1unicabilit,n non tollk fllbLin~nEjjm • in I:~ '1uod commtinic~tnr, {ca ("lum CJnod lilbfift~fi(i'

ilia nOli h~bC'.n oppo Ii! !{;nem. e, III COErm!lmi,a~ biIJ,:lIcmcl1m.:o,ui cmnmunic;m!r.Argumemlllli vcro pHlCt·di[ in hf! qll;t communicanuu t.ln~ quam res .lInpc',fl:t\;r,& ordinariiii.' ad V lr«ilu elfcoi

feu' :ab :lhqllo, In quo, vel per qllod habcnr dre~

- Ad plimam Confltm. Re::pond. dkndam di '-4 ujn~m per. t'tiatiohl:S: rrod. lubilllcnlcm rmmnafitte • &; incQfIlllllIQj,abilitct • Don quia ip(~ ~(fciuia in tatione n.IUIlZ nan mant:~t comlDunjeabilis alted p4:lfonz fetuioz ~ clim iiI! communkllbilis uibus pnfoniso , at non flo-ffie habcte vnUm tc:nninum tdarill~m, nlli biJbC'at a1illm ,0rrelariulIm, (td qnia df"nOa diuina vt pC'rfon:u:1, &. ilJo £crmino rebtiuo atfcCb • non

til a]l«i c(lmJllwUc3bili$. kd oppofiu. k(d~ ditur ergo n~tura tx fe abfolute • & coinmu":; nicabili[cr fubfificlJ5 • rcl.uiu~ '1ml. & incbm';' mnni.c:abilitcr pa rdarilllm hlblitleotuli! t nori abflllll~~ {ub1iI~cru: • & qU;llImm ad ilfoie:pen; denliam in clle,ftll modum ("lKud;. & c:.dltmdi

p« rl:,& non in a1io,& yt Ifllad; hoc mim e% (.bl<> bet., {cd COinmunl~;lUltrda,illa;· fi.bliltemiz. 9t ramino dinjngu~nti, & in,omrnUIlif:abilirattm f.tclenti imer tem'llnO$ rcbduos. qUia oppoh£io":;

Jf~1D h.2bc:t Imq ifJo;. Et qDolndo dirirlJr quOd (ub.: liltenti:l fcu JJ;uura lubfillcDS non potelt 3J1fd

alia [ubfiltenm, dHIingllo • alia ciul(lCJD ordi-

ni$ • k llne;r. & (cClIntltlm cafdc:m dftCha f(Jrnules • conado; ali;; ditlC!r~ f;l(ionij • ._,. lioc%' , Be fc:condiun dillcc(os c:ifcaus formalt'f; nll'go. SubGfttmia :llIrt'm 4bfolora habet: in (~ UIiC~ t & ratione redd~'tc: diuinulD dfe per fe {&I'

non- In ;aHo cxiJlens. non umm oppofrric:illdif faene • &: ddl:inaionc:m t 6( inw1nmlUlkabiIi...; tatem. quia hoc: p_'rri.n« ad linc:am rdatiu#qt:

Et Jicit fublilltnti~ abfoluIa r.:lre:lln ~tii[& " fnb611emj~ {ufficicJlltm diflintliolJem. & ~ ~mmUniCilbiliIafcJll habe,lf, nOD tamen inttz

. q_ diW.

J~" §2.!J.41.xxrX. elr:~ Ve Ptrfonu tli"!ni/~ ,,'

tliuii1am nnuram h:l.betiacominunicabllit~rem.niG ftiuanquam pdncipium fll~J ill e~efidD; ergel

mediante oppo6tionc:, qulf Colilm parin~' ad ~. tIl:, ill operBndo I ~tirDpaatiO {eqUltur effe , ~&

ncam tcladuatti. NCqilc ob bot ipla Cubh_lllllitl:l eae: Vt 1"~a,orcr~t1o. v~ 'f(lud. A?;ccc:d. ~efclp't~.

ablOhua ell incolllpleu, & imp!:tfi:Q~. q~lIB vlee- bstur, qUia ell ;::nrll1 dlUl1U {cmotU pcr(onls ~ela~

riori (ublill:entia. {,W!:tt f~1atiu.l t¢!mtnan P?te!l:, UIS nDll gCIlc:ur. neque gellc:~a~ur. _YE dditutur In

qUia hoc Co!um bab~t locum ,.'lIl<1?do(ub'lll:en. C411.DAliJl1am~f,dtfummA !'omt. MqUC: creat: tet

,ia ~lt rali terminatlone p~rliclUJr l.n. ctr~! Ii ail- ad. excra , qu~pcd(m% crl:~mes fUliq!.at~ .' 0%:

tern el uli retrulnationc: non acqulr~t c~~ ,fed Flt.,us; U ~PlntU.S (analli. V nde de fib" dteltu.~~

tOl1hn diltinClionc:m; & jncom~umcab'lltatc~ qUl1d Or/llll.- pey Ip[l/.ttJ_ fila" [lint. N ~iI ~rgo Del?',

~ oppoli,ioJ].cm in ctfc quod III f~ pra:babe't t;1s Cubccm~cptu przc:do 1. f,r(o;,:lhCJubtu ~p~

plt:/l~ ,& l?c~f~ac ! . vrpolC:, atluln . purum r n~n t~tu{ Vt '1l1g4 • & con(e({l1~n~Cr l1~qu.:; CXlJUt 'IE

quod vlrc:p~. acqLilnl • tslis :rlte,]O! tC~lnatll) 'l,,,a. . .. . '

non CIlPPOl1l£ Jrriperf:aiollcm In (ub!illenrl~ corn- Con,fit~.l "mIl! • qllli Geut hi?, D. e'1lI ~gni.:

nlunicabili • fed Calum quod non habee mcem- fica.ur In ecncreeo vc hab~1l$ OC:WltCm. Ita.hi~

niullieabilit;uClJ\. & oppofitioncm. V Ddt conft.1t (pir.ro~ Vt hOlben, .,.im fpjr.tndi , ~cd 11 Jplytllw

quOd fub(iIli::ntiOl :1b(olut~ c:1l p::tfefu; lidt fit non ~ffm propter hoc lub61lentlam fcorGun •

comitll.lIlicabilis;C}llia incommuniOlbilim (olum fubfillclltiardlthw. t red fubfi!l.it in {ub6!lentia

addit tccmioatiollctn, & dillina::ione:I11, qU:i: a Pattls& Filij:crgo nequc hie Deul,

oppolidollc r!:ladll:l ditn~nat. ~on aaualit:l.uan, Connrm.fccnndo ~ nam D. ThQm'J;r'.~'1.m.

& clre;& fico :Ib(o~ura fubfillcnna omnem perf~- "I 2.. p(obat nltU~am bum~na~ c1c:bt't~ ... tlm III ~er-

t(Jollcm (ubhllcnn~ habet , non cmnem UWUl- fOIll! ,& non til natuI'a~ qltlil non datUi' medium

mtilmem. ElI~mpb :illr~m qua: in argumento illr~ nanlnm • 8; pcr(onam t & Ge (i limo DOQ

~Jdllcuntur de fiiura. & atlinn;:, '" fpC~IC~, non ell fJtt;& in nalUfa diuina ; quod en folCta in pet-

vrgcnc, C)lIi~ ~bi hmt forma: ciu(dcm .prorfus.li- ~I)na •. At" toian" f.ubfin~nua, ~b(~lutll. ~e ra.

nc;t, at DtdlliIS.& fie pofita yna. them UlcaplCltU tlO ell InelJic;lx J qLllol potr:llfl en ymo.n~c In perw

ad 3h~r~m. ton a ; nee in O;lUl(oI • li:d in ilia abroluta Cubli.

:J' Ad f~C:i1n.damConf.Rcrp.qIlM [ub6ftentia ;lb~ llc~tia: ¢ril;0 .yd, raticD. TholD. qU;& proba!

foluu non k habet vr atmbutum. fl:d ve moJus vefltarern CalhoJ,,;amJcll "'ana, vel dl:~t negan

indcpendcnd:t, &: pcr(e·iratis in ipfo dfc diuino. [ubii{b:luia ab(ohlt~. Et~" I.J,pmU. 16. '1"~JI. ,.

(econdum quod rale cUi: tit a&s pu.t\1~.& Ht:.& Rt.~.diait~ quod 'R..,t11lilfA reI4f1_ ftll'''''al1tt fofJ-

in (uo pc:rf.;cl:HIimo ~Oll'cptll ex.dudit omnem fij1l1f1tt{IIII11m.Et jkeoncl~lI:1itilJ 4· q11ld}lmH,.

motlulU c:x.illerldi in alio, vel pet alhld. Er hee ex- ,.doi/iIJ1Jt Ilfi/Ut P .rln' IP qUid, tltq14t Fil:I'J ~II qlli6.

duGo ncn tit per attribumm (uperOlddil\uu, Ccd Si il.U~CIll Do:tturadiuino:t CctunduPl (e eft:t fubJi..

ptripfummct conCepnlnl perf<;di cITe. ~ :ldU$ nens. ytique Cubfillc:rtt fclationi ; non amma

pllri\pr~(errim qui;umibut,11C: habem "tproprie- rclatioprimo. & pet rt Wbfi1I:c:t:CG. CCQ adncnkl:t

'~rcS.qLl;C: confequuumr naniram L1nqualll perre- ('ublifiCl'lti.

Aion~ (uperMldit:t. ~m principi1 opa~ndi : =e a.crp.nc:ga8do anltce:d.. Et;1d prohalioncnl di-

)lUtem (ub!ia~ntia ~b(olllta pctrine~ ad ipfuJtl eil"e atuc.quOd dluit&' cll"~lllia ptll!:imclledjl pnfoni$

qL1~tC~~5 perfcd:uOl c~ ill ipla line~ exHl~ndi,. ~ non g~ne:rat nee opl!'ratUt .n. quod nO~OJ:l~t~.

eacndl,ua qaod fit:ut Iplum effe rauoM CUteR: JO- fed opaatur: 'Ii qllM ell~ntlali[cr. licut liJldlipf.

dl!p&:lldms, cll pcrfQ!tulll. dl nea in alio.nee ta- alUac t ~te3t • prouidec J &,.quia ae! iftas affio-

men ind~'PC1ldCmi:l. Jk:rf«lio. aut r;:xclu Go dfcll- DCS BOP "'luituPtU~ pet fc: pu[onz rdatiU:. {cd

di in alio non lum :lttrlbut;t. fed ciufdcitl ecnee- ~'Deus vt Cu.bfiftens 0Pet:atllI • 6£ 'It vnu$,

prlU ex:plic;uio!lcs,& modi ~ iu f~fillel1li.ubfo~' f;oru:um,iunm auwn ... t T rinu$. Non dt autem

Wt;l, qu~ in his 'ollullif; ~ltributum aon ell: • fed l1eceJl'c ad hoc vt hie DI:U5lic (ublitl:ell$ ,quOd

chlldc:m eoncc:pcu5 diuini ell rnodlls.l!.: explicatlo. opaCtl1t y~ '1t4~il t ctia;m notionalitet • fullice

FlItCmllf WIlell quM el nolho raedo diu@ fl.. qOOd op!:rc:t:uc c:Qi:ntiali~~r. Nam ~d opemio-

gniliQtldi. & 110n ratione: diuerfz rei (ignilica[. oem llodoDalem requiritllr lIOU iolUnt yirtUI

potell ilte canc:.e:ptll5 e{fcllIia::. feu c:{fc diuinl a. operandi. nee fohllll principium IJHld qUOil\O-

gni6cati in COIlattO, &: in :tbllracb) , per modum doeumquc • fed oppplitdm corrdariui! fuo rct·

ro«n~lcl.1 pri~piI1"oJJ ~ per modum priQ!':ipij mino p,o,~denti, tiquidc,n debet pr('iducetuli-

f." Sc4 hoc totUm nOll en per modam anributi. qUid dillinaum ad inrra J nCC pau:1i diftiDal1nl

ULl 1'" UiodlUll dillindz rci lignilic:l.r~ • {cd pet clfe nili per oppoliuoncn1 ~Iariuam.

1IIOdum din=tCz Ggni6'lItiollis eiurdan pror[us . Ad primam Cont Rcfp. flon elfc GmiJJ::, qllia

td.ql,lod Cc~l.~~Jll clfil; (eu dren~ia diuina Ggni- 11 H i& {pirllllJT n0!l impomr i,pfalll na(Uf;3m • &:

~. yt diunutu qlU tit Deu S In :ahllndo. k c::de o:tbfoturum Det • fed potrnuamlcu pdncipillU1

'It id. q!uxl cO:: Dan. & babcns elfc diuinllIn in Cpir.tndi , quod pettiner ad allionem DOriOmdem. Cl)nCtt~. q\1~d nop :uldit dintt£m miont:rn a Vode: nonpClteit Cnbli.tkrt: nift ootion;Wrcr • noD.

t:c t~ 6gwlic;uz • fed diu«rum madum ugniw ab[ohn~.Sublia~r'ltia autero Dotianam non da~

candi u. p3ttc= UQ(h'a, qllatCllllS fub Ulodo ahltrot- tJlt. oili Ot perron:! ; at Gdy hir.n17Y nOn po.ell:

tbt.~ COnl!r~o idem tigni6camus. Et fie pater ad pCt' fc h:!beIl: (ubJillennam (eor[um a. Pane. &;

alStunc:nW1J\ de dirunltione: eon,cptus I\\tll~ VI FiliI) • quia oO,n ell perrolla. tdad~ per Cr:,. ~

,.,,& yc 1J~.d: ~utlH:nim diuedi conceptus n conli:quentCl' n~ {ubGllemi:l ,tWUUJl;. AdrCa.

fane ~I. IignI6t~lIdi. non rei figl1i&C:-~t;E. V ~ DanlU. &: ~lI't. pCf re.& ratiOne flli dicit elfc in de~

au~em aliquld lit :lEmbutum. ~:h« dicere aliquam pendensj&: non ina.lio; &: 6.c potcft. fubGftcre rub.. '

t;1non~ noll~ modo .coIIC!pirndi. diuO'tam (~ liIlc:nlia non rd:)ti!'!a.n~ue ootlon31i. kd ab((ll~,

Earte rt:1. 6gnI6~~~qqja concipinu: 'it proptieca uJicet commolli';lbili,vt ditlum crt

UP~1la ~~. '" . .. Ad Cecunda.m COQ6nn. llefpond. 0.. Tbnoo

2.' - ~~o argllitur. EIf~Dtla .dll;lIna (iftnOtlS peTro- IIWi1 non £aC!;Ie illam coJ:lrequentiam • fcd. b31tc;.

~wib: ?on potefl congpi YE prindpium ope- Natuh.1wmma 1Itffa. 'eft Vctbo ferunt!WD fidem

t'i . 4'~ .• ,I;[$:O n~ue VI • fubliltem. Para lO:on- Gathvli~ t fcd. non ea ,nita V crbo ill nacun:, c!l' 'J,1Ila Cub~ ~~ llatlUaID qua:&bJi. "p iA.p~ • Ci~ ill ,V~O tIClD. dl aliud

quam

7Jijpi414rio XlV.

~Illm pcrCortaliras,& natura j & ita G iii natll.fa ci nOI1 VnitUf,dmct vniri in p~ ona .Qgue D. ThQ. non proc.:df£ abiolure eX m:g.uione Vllionis in natJjra djllina,qu~d vnie deb¢.lc Ii~ri in perCoIJ;;i,fed (upponendo ex fide vliionem f~itatli Verbo. di(currie. & prob3l ;;ilidenf,;r quod, Ii nOD dt fjd;t in natura V erbi , elt faQa in pe;(olf.1. quia in Verbo non {unr nili ilia "ilO' pcr(Do;J!n.lS, & n;,lEUtll,. Nee dicie S. Thorn. non dJri medium inter naturarn abftr;1cre (umpt.tm, feu ve ljll#. &: pcdonlm, &: quando il! diceru, & inrelJigc:remr de m.:dio fccllndum rem ; & I~nqt;am

l- ~ii~ di~~nClum: .n~m (uol'illentia ablahira non IIhngUllura rd~rume.

Ad f~c:nndllm la(um Rerp.qllOd remOEa reJ.uianl!' , DUll (1;1'11,1111:[ IIlblillC"1l5 rd~doni ; id cit, flibfillens furpolira.liter. & per modum hypol1atis • vdbi dicit: miG e:nim hypofl.1lis difit ;ncommunicjbilit~tcm , JJCt1t perrona; fine,. ~C':'boone aurem non dafll! iliCommunieilbllit;hJ~c remora ,dation!,>. Psrer non ell: quis • neq,;,e Filiu! • qlli:ullllcnon maner pe£(on~ P,nca,3ue fili;, 'l"it rd.l.Eione cDnl!iruitor, (cd manet hi; D~lls t ~ iUe eelt C).llb t:inquam fubfill.lu fublifi.:nri2, "bfoluf;;!. ncn quiHaD'1Uam petfon.l. & vi P~,er.

AR TIC VL V SIll;

Ytrll1l1 jiM FDnnsJ.t itl D~D (1',i11'1I"n#lionu,lJttAI~r 7'dAtifJnU, 6' trU!7'b-

!rie/lltts.

NOlioncs fnnt quz pertinenr ad dignofcemL1, &: dHlinguenda C\1 !.fila:' tebEiu.a.& pcrfon111fa. (um in 01:'0. V nde: DpOrter vid~c: qu~. '* qUid tint iltz notionO'. &. quomodo d~eilloqu~n~lIm. pr:t:lib:lndo EaMtTI pri~. quomodo :iJlobis Trini~ ~.'lti~ myftcriulU polht. cogna(d.

Ex IlJJtf(rlllj!J/~J cffiOibllJ ljI i1J&(Jgll(Jfli~ hili! 'Irinit.u.

.1 ' VUE'.taetD.Tb"'1' J~AC notioniblU,quibu5 diflinguimus ,S!: dd~nimus in Deo rciariu;!. ab cf(tnt1alihus,&: ptrfonas intet {e.protmiltil.qllomodo wylh:dum Trinimis 1 nobis cogno(cibile 1k pa na[urale.~ rariones. Dicunmr aUEem D2Ulr.Uc:.f radopes il1z qu~ dcduciimr ex dfcdiblls ordinis JJar17- r~lis.Ex dfcltibm aurem (upc:rnoullnlibus dedll~i polfUnE (.triODes aidorc5 • quz ii .ti((:udu n~llro ;I.(quilirz finrtPe.rinelJE ad ThcologimJ.5oltr antern agir.ld ilb qu:cftio agenda de mylkrio Incarnadoni! lid '111,1.in ~.p.tc quz ,bi dicuDtur procedunr communirc:r tdpcau omnilmrii fuptm:tfUr.;Jlis.Spel;i~ljrer autml in pr~lnJli quia hoc my-

l ll~llrQ non eft illiquid &dum. {a:d inITdtUrti• & intra Dc:um;efi difficuh;u.an paaJiquem di'callm D'lanifcliari polIir, line natilralcPl.fiuc: fll~na[lIralem .Et qlJidcm de dfeau (upc:rnaturali. Jicur eli: viii., Dei "ails fidei qllo creditor T rinituu mytltriumt& alUs !imilibu$ • foict ii dirpiI[;l(i ,.,.q. II· vbi agifUr, an Chriftus per fcienriam in(QC.m i;Qgnouem cuiMm"ef myllerium Trilliraru quoad an dl·Nc:c :aliud in pr.t'[en,Ei mtlati pote:ft ~ quam

. dccognilionc hrdlU-myllmj CJu04d an c:11:qmditaliue t:"j~ euidenru non patelC ~ningi~ nifi pa yjtioncm cIanm Dei.

3 . Spppotita dillinaione data quAd 3)i,lJi dtc:au, (untlwUf:ales. :tIi; fllpffilall1nl~ • adhllc iffi' lMfeausfllpnnilrurale:s poa-unt confideRli dupliillllll. as.Thmt.iu J .p,m.D.Th.1'omuuJr«.

Arlie.

1/1.

1'31 , ,iter. Primo ve rr2ci;~ Lim! e1t'o::aUI, &. refpic:il1nr oitifiipott:titiam Dei vt caura!l1 eHicknum, (:illnque ferminant. SccuildJ. ilt rdpidunt DculU unqu3rn obic:aum. 6r. c;!uidm forin~lelJ1, fp~ci .. Hcantem, fiCl1t vilio beau re(piciE Dcum vt obie''lurn ipcdfi(;,:uiuJlm fiillifi.tlon f"lull! vr efl viJu~~ fcd eti:irtl 1ft ell trinus , & fides refp,dr jd~m 0(,.,. JeCl:um vr pmprioin,& imrncrli.tUffit & villo hy~ poflalic;t,qu1e fileh eR, rcfpim pc:r{oIlOlm n:llltiuam V (fbi 1ft (Ctrniilum VllifUm.

Dico ergo pullum .:fled urn ... neqlll.' l'IatllraJc~ n('que Ii'p"tnatnraicm in vi. "tfCCtus.& fCcllndum fc:{r~q,um ad Deum, Vt ad 'au(;'Im c:flicielJrem. poa~ 1Il3nifdlarc fil;l!m! nee c:urCCllrcr nee probabllim my Il~rjllm Trlnila(i$.ctl:lm qnoad an dtAr vero aHql11 i:lfe{tus fup:rnawrale1 PQJliIfU manifdbrc: euidc:m"f myJtcrium 1 "nil~ti~ qmJ~d an ell pcr connC~ignCfil 1l~c:eJr:i{illm ulm !plo C.in" quam "lin cbii:do, am (')IU"crno "nira, h(ut.Yin(J bcarj6c;l,qil~ (efpiei' Tnmtarcm 'It obiedumJ 'Inil) bYPlJlh[k~jqlJ:t"tefpfclr pctlon.1m vr n.Ct"crmum vmeum Filch! aurern r¢lIdildalichl1ius mJ~ lhmj, ~ tOllgrll.'ntljs illill~ mgnl,j$. b"nc pon·1f aliqllts ~ m'l(ino n:tturdit telJl:tlJ lupctnaruraJi~ eire.! h(lc:myft~tium dU'I,{itUt drCil aHa £iil'h·n~flltalia.

1·r,,~ pane$. b~b(,t hxe com:lnlio.

1:( plIJna, '1HkrrCl;t Imlillitl df,;tlum in vi cl- t fcltlJ$ pull!; m .• tnf~ibr~ hm: mrtll."illm~ [lJmilu(

f::C D.Th"m.!J;: q p.>lrr.l. '

'!it probarur, quia nulhu· dfcllus h.~mt tonneiiionemjtl vi dftcIII~ (11m pedc,.m~ ,tlllinh provt dilii.lal; inter Ii: rcl~tillC: , 'col pw ... , Jum vn!1f Deus abrolure~ c:tgo ""111 ro!:cit I"lmf(:~,;\;rl:" ho, myJle:tium ', Con(tq.~lUb.Jmr ,tJt!i~ ,,"lhf~ ~ff e 4Q$ pou:1l manlfefbre fijum prmtll'II'lIl, & ,;oufa~ II iii tuioM afic:uii15 eonnn."ntJ '1m. 1110, quia t'f~ fc:tluf. eiu! ell ; lit ab ;;1) protc.!it ,ldlqU.l. omnia ~oll1~lIibus cOlJnex[an~m lion !",b~r.lfrni pou:Jl P1;!nifdbu qU;tntumcumque all<b (" connexnm cumeua (IIU{.:a. i1lique 'cntlcni~m • fi'(:ur~tf;.:'h~, pro"drns ab :.niti~",v. g. do mil:> ab :rdjfi~;lH}rc. porc:1t quidt'ID llI~nlrdl;lfe altern 1 qu~ l'r()(cdiv "" bOl1lil'lcm IP qlliinlUID afli6c~i'D,ltd nDD porc:tl iD~nifefl.uc :.Huccid4!lUia ip"UJ !WI) ptlnllemi~ .:ad t.lem arrem.'U' g.;1R fuew ,.Ji~ arljfcx a:bm • .,cI fulCus .paIU:;!: ;vcl m;l.gnz JbturOl:', pingui5 tan gracilis, iodurU5 vdlc J:Jlbd.vd vitidi • ()wmhoc p::r ralem effi:crum non dl milnifdlabile t qui3 Jid·r proccfic.rit ~b .:anin!:c h~be:r.re ta:};:s ,ondiri~ nes,& ;lccidc:nria~ '1ui~ remen 01,111 pnJc:~i!' ab iUfi ntiollc uJinm ;:tccldrnriam • JltC COIUlu":mcm. b~brt,um illis, nOll m.1nif;:fl:lf ilb. Api'ectd.'1Uo prob. ')lIia nuihu dfl:'~tQS proccclir ad aml, ,!iti per poraltiam n", c:uiliiuam • & .:auem Ddf Jell Idcas: crgo {oliim 'CQl!.c:aitttr. k rd9Jtii' Dcnm vr crC:illor~. &. :miriccm; c:fk :Ju'em Oeum 'r~ f(lft::m. &. arti6cc:rn oliul'o:UiniJuC df~a:1.i$ ttiam {upc:rmnlrali" dt- commtJne omnibus pc:dona dininls •. qlJi:a proc:cdit per :.ruibnmm c:",nlmun",. q?~ !:II c!Dnlpo(rmi~.& :IrS, r~;mdktlllm Vt d1flgmlt'lIl. &: porcnfum vi' ncqilcntnn: qgo tlnn pOlel\: mllnifellare ;lI!~1tlid in qll~tltum o:lfC:r 'dus , (tU in QUalltlll1l proccden$ a Uco , lir otb ,flicit'llle:, oi6 commllne: rribus pafonis, quia CoJum pfoemi[ ;)b eG quod commune dl;" 11'"& <Juz funr dillincb.& propria in perron;, f maniic.:

It~n: non pouR.. lraquc pu{cQZ Vf dillind.:t:. &:: corrcbrillit inEet fe nun induum in crratllfaJ. quia non VI c:oErc:laduz , te:d Vf atatilliit' ",fpic-iUllt (Je,um;u ~ Yl ccttc:ladur mi~ {olEim ad il1llicem fe I'efpic:illhi ~ t¥WCJlW VDa dl prinap_ium , ,.

, q_ ~ aiia

alia ellJrindpio. ~od "~tO tefpic:iant maturas. & qna inHtlJnt in crearuras , noll holbent p:r re{pectlls vt oppo(hos; & dHHngm:nrcs illtcr fe, {cd Vt fllilt vnum in creando , &; opcr~t1do ad extr,,~ N on ~I'go ctfcthlS ad extra l'rocc~¢ns hsbee eonncxtonem cum [cI~fionil>us pcr[onahbm,V[ ad inc~a. oPPl)fitiS • & ciil1illdis, quia dIe dilHndos nihil conducit ad infhitmlum ad ell:r~.

6 Dices: Eei:lm Spiritus S.proccdit a Patre, & Fi-

lio ) Vt fllm vnum princlpiLlln fpir;!ndi • &: tamcn qni cagllo[cera vim fpiradu:lIll. deberer cogno{c~t~ cI(\~5 perfoll:t~ • in qurbus vis fpirJtlua ell:: ~rg? ~llIlilitcr li,h crca~ur~ pro~c:dallt ~ cibus per/oms, 'It (um vnurn prmclplum e:canciJ,tamc:n qui cognofl;:tt Hbm viJlI creandi , c.ogl~o~c:r p~r. !OM~ in quib us ea. S,l:d centra ; qUI-l VIS Iplrauua IIcet lit V[lJ in P;!.Era &. Fillo • ramen ex 11I~ formalit:nione,& proprio d,auaerc r~qllirir JilHnw {Honeln pC,rOIl~I'um ,tjllb proccdir Spiritus S. ex pcrCollis,"r (c mUfuo llillalltiblls.li'~t vnico amorc, quiaproccdit ex smore ~nlicabdi • qUi rcquirie r]UL'CS pcr(onaJl redpl'Oce Ie amances- M 'IC£_O vir[Us creatil1;1 non cn uoelonalis ,fc:d pure ~b!oll.lr:'l, uec requidl pluraliuu:m pl:1'fomrLlln • tdam ve eenduicnem inrriJ\(ccalll ad creandum , Heel concOLuital'ltCf fc habcant It~S r~(onil: ; (ed non influ~iue t aue cum conlln:iont' per fc cum crcamris procedcnnbus • quia pra:cis~ prtlccdullr sb co

quod ablolutum cll. .

7 . IhIH'bis:111 (cntCllri3 corum qui dicunt i[l Dca nallcl1"cotliq\l.ml [ub (I !h ,II iam abfolumnl,lIifi rres rd~tliJ~s. &. JO:lt,'ltcm ft',und,"m f.ltiuncl1l3bfolutam talum (Il habere VI rrindpillm '1m. non vr lJ"ud , Cf(!.ltllrX non prot,,;JUIlr l mmrailiuina f:in~ tum , (c(l etiam j pcrfoni~, qui~ precedunt 1 Dca, Mil roli'itn vr pm\dpio qUD , led t::lillm Vt ~ prindpiO '111;',1, E~(!f.llls ~UU!," non ro~u~ ~cCl: rnsnifdhllt cautam (UJItl. t'x rJrte pnllt'p'l qti~ •. ftel e[j~i!1 tX paree principij quod. Ergo ft III Dt'Q ptin. tiphlm qfll,d 11011 ell: 'Ina tol\lm p::riou,'l communii,qma. nun d.:it\lr , (,d tria (uppofitll • & nes p~r· fOJl:t,:rdatnl~. df~dLl~ procedcntes a Dee t:Llc~ p(rlolJas tnanifclhbllnt , qUantUm cadI; fc,licct nos de f,l.Clo non cogllo(c;Llnus bane manifdl::ltionem , 111M quia v~ldt: o'ttllra ell: ,111m qui:! ex; :l:qllo conutnit UibllS p~r!(mis • tll!:C VOam frod"ulll &. dl(tinll:l: ab ali 3 manifclht: licut etiam mll!t:\QIi~ occult'!' Dei iud,cia. illlo & taUraruln CJ"c;'It:!film rottione§, Vt cogirJtiont$ cordis, lit alia IImilia non cognolc.imu$ > lii:Cf Rer c!fe-aus nl:1nifctbbiliii lint.

Rcrp. ~u&d quidqLlid lit de ilia fentcntia ncgantc (ubliitt'llti~m ~b(ol"f;lm. tam en cI!:niffimum ell quod iJl Deo Wlltllf "'etz & rC'ale~ opnillioncs. fcu :lans 1u.bcnrcs htftlde:mcr ptin(ipiurn q,,~tl,& '1'16 , indc:pcndcnlcr J. Irib~ pt!rConis • licu( hie Deus amal. &. intelligit. Patc:~ gcncJ;at, Filius. & P:u:~r fpir.mt, nee tall\C:D illa' ad:iones proceount :i. ,tnbus pafonis. Similiter eft cernlm qQOd in 0[dille ad cr~:mdnm UhtUm vitrutis. &: potentia= habeT 'Vn:! paJolJ;l > Q'lll1tum ornncs ttC$ timull vnde:. :tdconllittll~l\dum pripdpitnn qll~dcte;mdh fufli~l[ \'~>I pcUQDa. nee m~gi5 confert concgmi~ un!!a Ulum. Conc~di~~5 ergo quod dfcfhlS JI\:1n!fdl.mt de: Ie pnllclP.lum tjllad a prtlcednm. fat lub 1:0 moJo, quo conilueit I & (onfttf ad tot. 1ern procc:ffioiic:m • &:.11011 amp\ius. Data ~go quOd non (it [ubJifienna 3bfohna • t~m~ qnb. 'It opcrarionl:s. & prttCcllil)nr:s dtnrUf l Dco nOll rc:qul~rur concut(us. Hium pc:t[onatlul'l. frd ldf_ fiat hie Deus. vehhqna perfon;l, qQi~ '1tu (03. habet rDtl.m vim p~I1'mdi ~ & (ulBcic;Du~m

~£flio XXIX.5c. 'De Ptrflnu JiuJnis.

r~tionem {ilbJiftcnriz j& ptitK:ipii_qlloa ; &; lie rdiqux ex vi t;lli$ pto,effioni$ non· mani felhn ElItI , ficut Ii cgo euidenrer (,item aliquern e!feaum procedere ab homme, ~t. \lidente, rCL! aud/ell[e. non ramen eX hoc pr~'I$C porero eolllgcre quod videt d uobus 0 culis, v el au die duabus aUriblls, qui:i eriamu \Inurn clandst , reqnc bene vider. .

Et quo fequlmr Inalc V.a(Q\1ez ill pr~folll' 8 difp. 1 p. (llp.To ;JJlirm~re contra D. Thornam i11.

hA~ '1'1.tfi.p .. art; f. aliquo$Pb1Io(ophos cognouHr~ hoc ltlfllcrium : Et omnia f~!timani:l .quilii addueie , nihil :aliud Iig'1ificant, qll:i.Jn quod D. Tholn,cx Arill:o!elc. Plarone , & Trilintgi!lo

ill p'i711'tII.'''Ummfl1j~Ttitl$111 primll. addncii'; is( (al ..

uit , oll~nd~ns nou,fuiltl: PbiJu(ophos iIIos I~c~~

eos de IpCls perfonis , &. procdI1onlbus d1U1Dif.

(cd <II: quibu!a:lm amibutrs • qU3! pcrConis ap~ propri~ntut i & fere Il;:mp~ locuel fnnt de pro-.· cclliombus ad ~lI:ru; &. Clre:l ereanms , non ad intra. & circa l'cr(ool' , nee VJ1'lllllin al1i:cud Iune eX n:uurali dif,utlu vnam eflennam In tri· bus diftino!tis pcr(oni~. fcd Ii plum p"ron~, dlll"inXetlmt, crillm &; naturns. Vndc:non.tam cognQue:runt t quam crr~ucrnntcitc,l hoc mynerium dillin~ gcnc:.r:Ltionis, erraUl:fUm ab nerot leeuri funt f.dI1. Si quid vera cognOLlcmnt CJ; S~cra Scdpmr.1 • qUlin ~Iiqui eorum legcrtUJr., 3CCepr,l flll::re. Cew!:i'auitu 1. 44C,ri""b.l.diCit

fo 1'111i {llpiel1lill.m "I myjletil1 • quam ttemQ Pri",ipt:t/J b/li(;r foCI'U c~gnoflit ; nee v iderur aliquoJ efle 3uguJ'l:ius, & occnltiu5 myftaium.qn~m hee, arqnc ~d~Q nUn\1s cognitul1l e.ft l Ptincipibus huius (a:GIIJj, qui,vt inqllit Glo!h. fum Pbilo[ophi, princlpcs vtique ra:culati$ dodril1%, aUf Ii (,'1:~ culi Priucipcs runt d:cmonc5. & ipli ell: haumdi lumine mylletinm hoc non cagnolle:mnt muleo minus PhiloCopbi.

De pollibilitatc huius my!h:rij ptlfitiua, idem , dicendum ell: quod de ip!:! cxill"enriol. (c=u de :Ill dHllius.Nam Ii hoc my{~erillrn poffibile dlDeo. vriquc de falla ell:. quia quidquid Dee ell poffi~ bih:.dc fJdo ei conllcnif,li intra ipCum e(fe debet.

De poffib[Jime m:gatiu;l. , Ccil. quod nan implicet conmdUl:ionc:m hoc myll~riutn. idem dicimus quod non pateR: n:ltnr~1i ratione demollllr:!ri,quia hoc fupponir Doriti;1m iplius myll~rij ~ quomotlo coim oll:~ndi pote!!: ntln implicarc,ltHi cognoCccn-

do prius f3mam e:iU5,&: an dl ipfiu5! Hoc vcra ~ nullis cffelliblls per namralelll t~tjonem babc:ri por~Il.Etquidquid non jmplic~f in Dco. pcrfc:c!lio

d~ her ~a~i3r9.\Ie: adc:o ci ctlnuenite. Et Ii, pJ:tind~

(e hab~1 paOlbiliras negatiua.& pofitiua.

Sc:cund:l pars ,:ollclutionis,fcil.qu OJ per dfeal1S 10 LUpcrnatnr:alcs habentes conne.linncm !;:um pcrfo-

Ilis, vel cllm :lliqna perrum Ttinit;lr.is,quarlmuH~ {piciunt iIIam pro obicCl:o, vel pro CXt{c:mD vniro imdligitur. quando ipG. elfeClus Cupl:matllrJI~ c:uidentcrcogno(cl.lnruf in [e, VI; I'i vidC3.mr.Gm co~ gnokatUt in fe qlliditatil1c! ipra vilio beat;l .. qua viderUl hoc myficriom. Et it3. in lue parte d1: duplex Itntcnria. Airel'! ul=g:lt edam pet ifios c:ff~a115 polle c:ognoCd euidl:nU~t myfrctium Triniuris ~ r:ti.un quoad an ea. co quod non h:l.bct c:onnc:sionem per fe cum Trinir3[c: tlllquam e:f(r:4I1s vel Cl1ula "illS. Q!1am Ll:ntentiam fcqllr~

tur Tortc::s 1. ~. Ji{pHt. g.duh.I.1. f!! J. Et idcm viderur [emire P. V ~(quc::t hit:di[p.l-H "lfp. 4'& jlJ

;. p. JiliN'. n. ,~pire 1.1I11m. f. 6' 6, Sed r:\met'l cius me:ns lie expliearllf l P. Almon bie IT.'JEI •.

f' ai/p"r. I. capire f .11(017)'1, !). quod lion abfotu-

le I!.cg~E w.yl1:cdum Triniratls nonpolfe cogllOt~i 1:1 i::llidcnd at cbt;t DQrjcill 'liliollis bcat:t')

, .. "aut

,

Vil/mfatio -XlV.

:un . rcuel:idonis my Ilcrij Trinit;lnJ, [cod negat dad poae euldentem noridam hulus Viffoiil,.aur 11lminis glori:r:. & fimilem ~cd::l1u~.qujbu5 qllidir;uj. ui ar~ipgrtur D!:lli TrinU$ in fc: • niU Oem ipf!: vi_ deaeur in (c: coo quod non patell: '1uiditatiue"o~

,gnorer ilh vilio. nili i~di,etlif elfe conformis lifO ob ieao : . ergo Ii irf,) vid em! Vt quidit~tlllC: ;ittjn~ gCI'l5 Delllll in (c • 6c viderur Vt (:ollformis (1i0 obic:d::o • nccc:Jf~ eft [ale (lbic:GlI1m quidimiuc vidfri. 'IlIi;l illi \1'£ qllidkaril.e elt in (e. 1;.0 nformatUt ralls !ifiQ. '~od [ecwell de: :tau fidei. quo crcdimug -Dcum eRe: ninurn • qUl<l licc£ emns fie it:. qnod ci non pardt ClIbea': f~l(um J ramen non ft-ptafcllu£ Deum Vf in (c elh& tic vt indicc:tllr cOfiformbtilo .obic:llo,IiOIl ellnl!cdtt' videre iIIlld inmirille ill fc. ftd fullidt alillnde: conR.ln' 'Iliad Deus {r'nllS ea. Alreril (emenril affirmar per has effcdm rolfe- eo·gnot'; cllidultcr myll .. rium Trimr:nis 'llJoad:;i1t eli ~ & de fJeto habudlc ChtillUm C\lid~llEi.am de ilio (juoa,l an ell: pet (ot'llii;!.m infn(am. ~od cOlUmunirer te-ncnrThmllilb: ild ~'ftU.qii.r I. ibi 'l':ater Su1tez dY;'~7.jeU,j. & f. Artub~1 bkdl[P. 116.c.J.& 4.

XI Nos 01: h,lC diffi,ulure It1 c lathi5 rralbnd.1 (U-

pct fedc:mlls, hH~ I~(~ f.P""'/, lie e.a :.l\uti. 50hlm adliertimu~ pro el£pH.::~~nll= hll!ll~ (cculld~ pUEl? coltl;:luli.miJ. 'lund '!bh;itlff it:",gari non patdl.eli: uliblls ~·ff::d:;b"j eu: dc:ntcr coguim, ipfnm mylb:. num T,initdtis, qClo.ld an cll. euid.nrcr dc.iud. <l.!!od p.uer f It'JI~ ell ncctlIlrh conne:tittinrer 11- JulU ad-ulll vifioni; Dd ; & myllcrium Tdl).r.n'~j quod ell e:ius pn'prillm,& immtdiatum obil:dum; ago non rotell i;Jh13ri r<ltio formtllts. &: fpeciric;1 ,.alis ~au, ) nifi detur [.tIe .obiedum : ugo qui c:ognofd( euidc:nt&:r, & quiditolliue wem ildnm. cogno(clr euidenr:r dari ~lc obicaum, quia ad 1I~ Iud obieallm tendir, &: .lib ilIo fpecific.lImr, ficut -cri:un qUi eognofcit a!iqu;JIU fp~drnl vd rcpr%~ ·Unr~tionem.cognorc-ir: ihi conrineri rem upt:dm~ fatam. qu~ ell objeltum r:iU5;& fi~ euidenrer cogno(cit d:Iri tale obic:llum. Ii vid~t ccprJ:li:nruio. nan alIt fpwfiC:lrionem f .. dOlm i tali obicdo in ipfo :ian. Nee ell needf;:: ad hoc: quod l:ogDorearUt" aliq!lid c:uidmEc:r ,I}t1oad ;n en • quod cognof(;mlf pet" medium quOd lie C'a1If;& vd dfc:CltlScilts. fullicit . quOd inn:rucniaE necdt:nia connnio. ira quod hoc line ill(_! cUrl non poffi~;Ii, enim cuidctU ell illud dari,lich non cogno(carllf 'luidimiue.f~ {olum quoad .m elL V nde in m~thc:marid$ fiulJt uudrz dClllonfl:r~rin;lc~ ctlidenrt!! per mt'dia, qU;1' non funt C:lUfol ~ 1I'd I.'lfccbJ5. hCOt probafur {npcc 'lll.lmlibc{ line:uu ret-hm poJle: Ii!:ri «fangulum _q.ui b.fcmrn • qui:! p"ffilnt ll~ cl:rrmlit;tfibus Clliuleumqm: 11111:% ft"~te dcduci dtlo ciredti (co conringrnu:s. & 'inl:;t ilb ~orum (cnrm t1uit;t: crunT a:qualcs intt'r fe. ConcLfrfUI :intern dnofDm ~;rcd.JOtllln cirn .aliqlum IiD~~m lJeqtlC elt i:.lfl;alH,n~ que I;aof~ ciq" vd tt'iangnlr. Cene: Ii tOl;lVis dcmonftuEionis nirittJr in 'OIlDe%fo:l~ IIccc.ffuia exrrellll;1tJ:l m • qdomoooC'lImqilC' inumi.uu.t ilia eon~ ntxio,demonl1:nno ncr. qui,l. cogetur irncll::dus vno d.no.alrcri .aJfenriri. Vbi aurcm ilJrc:!I~lhu: cogimr • ibi ell nc.::c:illt;lJ ~ &; contlcxio vt'r1Ii1mm. Pr:etetqu.lIn quod o~ic:Al1m rcfrean aalls hIb« vim caufot, 'lllia (c babet vr (pccifieariuum ciuJ. q'tod pcrdf!~ ad eaulam form31cQl CXUin(l;cam.

11. An vera poBit dari eIIidtm, & 'Juiditarillil Co-

gnirio ilbmun dft!tiuOin fupemmU:llium.v,gJumillis gl~. vilionis bndfic2. vnioniJ hypoJbdt~ fine ".jHonc ebra ipbta Pei. & in bominl: pure Vlatorc f Cert~ in boc ego nuU;uu video inlpb("a-

'_

Artie. ll/.

rienem :nuU4, ~ili1 Cfe~furad:ltlJt; qore firilpfiul copiam intelJelhll faeerc no'.' potlir , & lit intltnet & quidicadu! cogno(cibi!b, vt ell in j~ ptr ahqu~m fpeciem,& hUnco propriUJil J falu:m lliperl1atul41e. extra vilionem Dei. $J c:rgo rarione Iue cteaiZ!cn. tir:'ltis • imelligibili$ c:l1:per propnam {pc:tiem. If( ilKdhglbilirjfem.luam. atque ad~o quidlt~tilJe .:& euidcnEer: Et hanc ennrarem h.lbef diltincbm aD ipfo Deo ill (c. cur non porctif ~ogTllJf" III Ie- qllidilariuc}$l1on vifo D~o ill (~,I(d pr~lvtcomin~Ulrin tali etrt"tlll, {eilil:c, in ipGmcr vllioiH'. aUf rcueJa(ione?

Q!lc}d V(r& dlcilul' neceir9 ctrc v"iderc mud c:x. J 3 t"mllm cui coofurmlifur '1ilio.vt iunicetur ilh tile cenformem , flillolum dt. Ad iudk:indIJrn enim '1uod dewr tale obi.;o!lllm) &: CJi13d ilIad iiiobill" ~tum r:llis vifiMi/, (iI!lidE videle- obit:ttUin. hon (t:'orIiJm in le,f&:d .... e ceneenrem iluaJi zaU.Jell c:fw fectll; n l1o~ enim rbn~ t(}iilht dp~i:Jfc;obkaDm.&: dcbere Jan r;I!C: obicch:srn. Vt '1Cf~)& non

li ae vati:wr drc;t ilJlld. fcd rilme-n ji(lD cft necc:lT~ "iclere obi,t}lJm jplilm in (c , led luaicit ;djWld~ c:ognolccrc quod 11Ic: ilaU, vUiolJh: ell1hrrln(e,a vt-ms ; & CeliO ;lrqlle ~lIidentcrlJol:I tide: ""Wllil drcil filum C1bi~tlum ; 8c lie '1idcndo 'IliAd ahiedum iIIud vr come-mum, (c:u ~uf:!4Ilml rali ;lafh Jkef non In Ie • plcne jIJt!icauu talc obi~alfm dlid

in re , lieut. ibi cominc:ruf • nrc Oporfll"E obiellll'm

. iplilln in (c lIidt'n:, ftd eolligrrc per difcu,(um dolEi

ill fe.quia (OllUllttllr,lh, :luingltuf ll~Ji aau, & :lall~ dIe VUdJ eft, qUlld totum fine vilione: rei in

(e pordl <'lHingl: lietiE Angehn clJgnofcc:re poreR: vimm:n) S(lh, ad pnHlllcc:noum aUrum I ttl<'lIl1U nullum aurum VldcQ, ill ,e- • & Ylnurl.'tfJ o,uli ad coJOrt~S vidcruio§. &" JUCtltJ , uiam anlt"qmm fit prodllGla Jus. vel coJor, (luia yider ilia obic:tla "t' conrmra,(eu anatb ilb iliif puwum.& in proporl done carllm ad ilia.

Dices: In Deo dfe ip(um cR quid~r8, ergou J 4 ~lIjdem:cr (ogl.o(dmr dIe: Trlmuw. ku Ti:mird" 'llload an eft> cognoicitIlt quicbtuTrinitatu cui· dC:lltcr. eo vdque modo 'luo cognol~itul" du.,

Ii abl1c"aill~.abllr;jaju~;ti illtuiuu':,inUJiriu':.

RcipOIl.'JuM U ngUJJlfnrllrn .,Jiquid problRt. etiam pta baret qllod ex cffc:lhbuJ naruraJibti.~ ex quibu$ e(lgno(dmQ$ eJii:nri'!rn Dei vt vnam. ~ cognofccrl$\Js Dc:um '.luidif .. tiu~. quia riu, db: ell: dill quidka~. Eodcll:> ergo modo pO$ tdpolJ~ d:mm quod ell\-: D_ci. c=lt ~;u~ quidiru provt eli fn fl'. Vt aUlrnl manlfdbrur in dftllil:iu.f CiuHfi~. tic manifell:num qu(),ui anefl".& impl'tfcd': arqur; connol~riu~ non ell qlli~jtaj l)ei.JfolC)lIt ~ m.:ltJ,f~* ntlr(tIIrdfc: Dei pufed" • IIHf! Ink,tu.:t.m ntmtfdlar~ hlr qtli.fiCJJ Dd.&: qlliditarill~ manifdbrctIIr: Ar vera dJf: Dd m~()lidl:tlllm impcffeltl, & provE in df"aib~s. nDn lII,tn;fdbt jp~amquid~ta~ rem diuinam in If'. I!c:n~ famnl el". .£'Iii dlc he JIDpa(e-el f: m:mifdbto, PC?,rdl qUldiu5 ~~ qllo3d carotiam vc:l quoad pt'r.toIlas- J1np~:ffcdc:. & pc-r !dic:li;u fpfcics. & c(limomiut manifefl:lii, fiILut no~ r'!Elone 1t3t!1f31i diCcu!riJlllls circOl atmbura )Ic 'luidimcm Dei, 6i; qQ! 'ognnf~tn:t Tfinita£CJD (lIidcnrcr qnold an dr, crllil1.) .:ilea qnidimtC1b 1;(:f:!liq ... u~<. ~ PT~CffiOl'lllm rorlCt dlli::IlffCTC' ~ ted

holl qllldll:ItIUj} In fe cognofecn. .

Te«ia pan (on~ufionis.rcil.quOd fatla rcucla- J f tione poreli. ::lliquis nltur.ui dilCluru probabdna

de iJlo my fte-rio cognofcae .1 IJCDlUIC vldetUf nG:6 gari paa~. Tum qllia Oa:mones end!:!ll • &; ~o.~n~'nnrcunr.qnia "("ilonon U lifO :df~all.rl=d mdn;us.

& jjgni~ quoad ercLiulilartIJl ,~ai.ql!di ff:mell-

res nedgnt ~ Don IJl!Iidan .6de: jl,lpern;'ltUiali. {cd

Q.. J llalU

§J.g,£jlio XXIX.fffi:. ,

Ji.1turali. Tum quia MtclkU$non.q~~s aliosar~ riculos IX crcdem Tritliratis mrllenuJl'I>IJOIl credit fidc:'(upernaultali.U tllo.!1lf!1 alf.:-ntjrur huic my:

· flerio. T Lim quia pot~lt abqulf pagallu~ !cgen5 v~l

· audicns hoc myitcril1J'll t ,/$I. ~~~mQdo m Ecd~lia renetur & .::xplicaftlr, :ill~nurt Jpfi, duCtus COI1-

· grut:ntits.& e"pHcadonibLl~ • q~:J:: deip(o ~:iI1[ur. & ramen non illl~ndrj Cit fide [ll~rna~lltah. nee irf~m fjdl:m, &rcligj()nc:m.C~!lh:!lam att~praIre [lb ~Hos finc:!. Sed ile hislatlU! Ill. muerla de

nde.

Diffie/liMitS tirell nOliOlJfllfI,& rtiRti(IIIIt'" 'Ill/tlleT.IIl.

. Cir~:1 numerurn notienum • tc:bdonum,& propricr~tum ~lIZ (iUH dIfE,\11ta.te$.

Pnma circa numennn nonouUJn ~ G Gnt folum

~uillquc.. '

Secunda c:irc:l. relaciolles:m Gnt ver~ , Be in re , qU~tuor relation C$ reales.

l' Circ:l prirnam,eQll'Imunirer ddignanrur a Tb«:()o.

'logis quinqu!: ru),iancs>qu3fuor pofidu~) lk Vn.:l , D"g~ril!,1. Po~ti~z funt P;ftt'nit~.Fi/j.'i~,Sp;:~t~1I ,atflllll,&_ Spmmo ~lIffiuil. N~sat'lla ell: ~ n"ilf!,hfl~~ , till , (eu dfu ingclIItum. Du:tlmur nonones. qUIa illis qninquc nomil)lbus. (til ilEItis fpeeialiter d;ileernimus , & digno[dmllS petIOlUS. I'atanit:ll eonuenie (oli Paui , lk FiIi~ti!J fc)li Filio : (pind!) atl:iua vrrique pet[on~.Pln-i.& Filio,qUi3 yuaquc (pirat SpirirumS. Spiralio paffiuafoli Spiritlli S. lnna(cibilitas conul:llit Coli Va!ri » feu cll'c: lll~coitum ,quia hoc nomine non fohl11l Ggoi6'::11(118 c,:dll fioncm gcn~mionis. Be n~Eiuit~ri$ , fed omnis proceffioni$ ab alio Bt h~ modo ell propriuscbataller,s.: none Patris.r~u prbn2 pe,tCon~.

17 Hi~c OHUsen: (etllpulu~ Sc:oti in 1.Jijl.18.qf,.r.

lid 3 .cur edam i nrpir~b[hm,qu;t figDilicatncvtionem pree I.':dcndi t:t1i rno do t kll p~ 'i?i~tioncm

"nou fit netic, qua: connepi;n duablb prlillis pctCoSlis.qll% non p[oce:dumptI 'Pir:.rionc:m:6cut C:WIll

· pcninct ad dignit3.u:m pthn~ pMfl)Q%. quOd nul- 10 modo procedu ab a1iquo t ita pc:ninct ad digni-

· t:ltem prim:l:.& rccunilz ,quOd non prat:cdant ta~ Ii modo.(cil pc~ fpirariotlcm : cur c:fgo non mt nocia infpirabi!iw.6cut innafcibilitu. ~od Ii mnaC,ibili(~! (umatur pta (ol~ ~u~g.l(ione ge:nl=r3tioni$~ k na.tiuitatis. vlique: non erit p[opJia folios P3trls. fcd edam Spiritus S.q\\ja nop COllucnit ci gCDcrari,& ft,ard •. Ad h;l:c. ucur tll: dignius p~ tiM proc:cd':fe ab aliquo. it,!. ell dignit;l$ Spirlnu.S;nOIl .I'roduccrc; :lliqu;un pet(Qll3m; ergo clle improd!l-

tliUU!ll,¢rir norio SpiriulS S. T c:nio phlr:. alia nonUna (unt &lign2liull ptt(ODat:um. tum qnoad

I oiigincs.rum Qllo1d pccronas. N;a.m g~nHario .. &.

, natiuit:LS Cignifk;mt origincm. & pollilnt delignait;: Patt~ gcnaantern. & Filium n:arcc:ntem: cur ergo non trunt nociones'? Sindlita nomc:n V f,'[hi, IX nOIl'lf:n Dnagill~ in Filio,nolnctJ doni,& nomen amoris Cpir:a.ti in Spirim S.funt nomil)a notionali3., & ddign~nl perfona$.. CUt ergo non efllilt DodoI!t$l Demque opomt ¢lplil;;ttl; in ipl2 ~otionc ne,~riu~ innafcibiliUlis qqid fl.lmllllitc:t 6glli6cC't, aD

· po6(i~um,a~ ntg*d\lllln. Namb eft fola ntgado, non dir~nlt. a~c !nnotd'c«e faciE ;diqujd &: per{ona. Si ell polimll!ftl,OpOIl:a. npli,;.te quid lit ,311 a1iqUid ah(Qhnum • &. tUDC nfm eft nociQ. fed a1iqUid omnibus commune. :an aliqujd tc'Luiuum.&: tuncaitidem QUOd patcrnifu.

1& eiJa (1;(!1Daaro difticulfatern I illud e:ommune acc:unic.quoI1'lodo lint qU1l1l0t rwnoncs Ie:dn..fi lion liuu: qUalUot ffa rebti_! Plwurll£atO ctJiDl

De Per(oni,diuinu.

iiif~riori ; necefl'e eft. multiplic:ui rupel'ius, {jellt mulriplic.lto hornine , Be. eqtto j multipli'01tur anim~I;(ed fe, eft {itpetior:!d relarionem, Ii cut ensecrgo multipiic:l.fa relaelone, ira quod finr qUiituor reIaticnes, multipli,amur qu~tuor res rdatiul£. Hoc aLlr~m dl falfullI. quia (,e dfcnt qUII[\lorper(on%. ulilllt ql1.:Jcuor res 0I'P(1Iitz:qu:eiibet I;nim res.eeJarilla diftfnCta ell lubfill.~ns ind;'ntilfiicabllf[C'f t ~ res n3mrz, quod ell: elfe pc(lonam. Et'pr2rCre~ quia Ipirado .acHu3. non c;!l res dHlitJeb .. i patCflli.tare. & filiatiotJt! ; ergo non Ctl nt qii4tUoJ; tc~. quia non eft ali ... re~ fpirario :lCllua 3. p:lt~tDi~ tart.

Hiae onus ell alree {erupulus Be Durando. & f, ScOto. Nam Durandus in l.dij1.I;. q--ft.t. Villi: {pimionem aifliuam djJ1ingui realifcr i patemif~ cet&' fiiiatione ~ &: fie o:lfe: quamor fl:S re:iaciuasJl. ddinr folum tre$ pcr(on3l'. SCotl.lS vctoqliaJ/rp.f'

firr .a..in fiT/t, vult dillingui has rd~ti{Jne5 U lWura

rei: diftinguit enhn Durandus quod aliud dBn diuinb diJfme rcatittt Ic:lntiua.,aiiud dilf~"e realitn perfooali~er. feu [.1nqllal1l nu D (uppolita. Relatioo-

nes eniln teales, vtip(c putat,difUirunt re;alj{er fC:6 ipG!. (cd non cQnllimllm diUCiW PUfOD;1S • nib diffcrant incomrnunk .. bilircr, Be fecund,un 0PPo.. titionem. cum au ram [pir.uio II.tijua non lit appo-

fira p~rernitati. & fili.1tioniJ nee eis incommumcahills, lic:ct diffctu r~~liler , non conlUtli!:[ ptrlOnam. Et dl fun.jo1m~ntum pro (.:nreutia Dilrandit

& Scot (licet Durandu! pIma cong~rat ;ugulI1en-

fa pto illa p:tne) quid non ell id~nlil.ls illr", part:tm nimcm. lie {plrationtl1l. inter gene .. "I:'. & (pjr.1fC:~ ergo ell:: diucrGtas. ConC"quenri:l p:!tet.Anu:'cc:d. probatur ~ 113m ill:! ptzdicado ell faIra • VatriDitaa

eft fpi(atio.6quidem h;i:c ell: falt:.,gdimre cAl: {pi_' un:.gcnetui ell; fpit:lri:nam Filiu; gmerMu. t nOD fpiramr ~ &. SpiricU$ S.c contra: ergo non habent illcntirau:m:v&i enim eft identitz,i6i eLl: vaa prp dicario vniUS' de :ilio.Er fie ge:nqate eft i Patre [eliiJliDatum ad Filiunl. fpitarc vero. rerminatllm ad Spiritul1l S.diffm: ergo vnum ab ali •. Adb:c PattInius, (en gencratio t &:: fpiflflo habent inter,G: 'atdincm orlginis • quia gcpetatio eA: per intellethlm t fpitario per volunrarem,&:: voluoras fuppo-

nit inrelle:c.hllfl : ~rgo ell dillindio,qnia vbi ell ra-

rio originis. eft [·atio dHUIlClionis. T emo, Rcbti06

nes illlt p2fc;mitads • .filiationis • &; fpiradonis funt fpcci(l dillinelz, quia habent fllndamenta.&aetminos dillinCtos; liquidem parcmit3S fund;a.ludn gcnemioae ~ & ttrminauu ad. Filillm. fpir-.mo iu amotc~ &. rermin~tlJr ad Spiritum S. ~z aueem .c1ilHnguuntur (ptcificc, diltillguUntut r~aJjtC:IJ &

. (ie non requ iritur oppolitio rdariuA vr dift.inguan. tUl,1i ex fc hahenr diftindioncm rpedfigrn.~M ergo Cufficit lld difl:illCl:ioncm {pc:d6c21ll. {uffiCit ad difijnaioncm realcm in rd:Jtioniblis. Deniqul: pro fententia Scod vtger , quia a1iqua przdicar:a conucnium Pltftnirati. qu~'non rpitationi 2.CtiU~. &: .; conua(o : ergo dillinguu ntJlf e:lI: n:u:ut:lrci. (;onfcqu. parer,quia dilHnaio ex Il3lu:a rei fohll'D ob hoc ponitur> quia :InrI: omne: opus inrelleeills v(!fihcatur vnum prltdic<ltllm de: VIlO • quod noll de: alio. ficut (:oJl\munic:abile veri BeatUr de dr;:ll. tia,& non de: patemitBfc; & fie: dilliDguunrur ex n~tUra rei ~plld Stotum •. Antcced. vero C:Qnltll(: nam p;a.!er~it;l$ conll:ituir p«:t(Qllmu I non rpiratio :l.ltill.\,cpirario form~litcr,&: circ8c 0rPQnitur (pi~ rationi paffiu;r;pate:.mitls auri!m~&fibariD,non ui~ 'udicalitu. > &: quarcnus. cQntitle:n~ ~n fe: fpir:l.ti~ nem:etgo :diquod ptlCdicatllUl CODUcniI: vni in ,1:'. ,,!loci. non a!t;ri.

; ~~ ... ',

· bifPU141iti ·XIP'".

prJ,,;. eliffttliitali r~fponJtllir.

i.e Dieo primo t NUlilcnt5 notiontlm rcahonl'U-

tLlinu. (ei!, quod rUnf rantli'm qUinqltc nOrlQfieS [uprj, nllm:rat;t -. Pro_ imelllgenria bntus ccnclun:;mis [uppt:H\cnd" en plOpIili rario. & defillirip notionis in t"mtnuni. ~t ex eius vi(ceribus ,oUi~ garnus • q uibus conueaire pOmt rali5 rado nctienis. De Jill imr crgo nOlio i D. Thorn. qHt.JI.~ t.lfrl. J.quod eft. propr'iJ r4riHu,(ilo[ul'ld; d,lwrltm prrfo""1Ii.Pou~!l: ~urcrncogno[ci diltiii:i perron;. &, die. cerni. vel a ,reaUlfa,vcU diuin" n~mfll, fcu ab eo quod cJli:nri3lc dl in Deo. vel vn.a per(ona diuina ab alia pt:r[oJl~. Oiftmio. Ceil filJtIO d!lli~glicnj perConam dllilnarn a ereasa non ell allquld ptoprhlm p~rrQniC aliatiu5 J fcd !:Ommllne omnibll"; fo:il.ipCaeJl.~miJ dluina. '" elfe il11:,eamn'l. ret hoc chilli d,llinguimr 1 qu"lib:t i:fe.itUra. Odlindj(j edam pcrron:mun ab etli:nti~ dioina fllffi,i~nle, fit per gC'n~ralelJi, &; eernmunem rat/anem p .. rioliZ.&: rdationi5. cum dfentia in Dec die:!t id quod prninet ad ge:nnJ ~bfolulUm. qUidquid v~o ad gcnunr::!;l.tiuulil.& p(:flonal¢= pt:(!illtr.fcJc:rnk. & difiinguic a ranene abfolura. Q!.HItC ad hoc non c~igi(llr alijll:1lloca.feu I:huaaer. aut ncrio fpe~ialis qua: ill1l1!1uat pcdonalia ab elfc:nEialibu~. dm a!Jquld com mr.mc omniblls pccfonis in gmere relanuc, &: p c[fon~ Ii Ul flidemc:( hOG dlfcc:mar. fiau hoc nomen rtlatio.ptr{oitil.lJYigl1.[lIppujltffm. Bee. Nodo ~rgo deber efle aHqlla "pel:jali~ota.ccu cb.uaClc:r di fcernens int~ pC:r!Oii3f, P" quam fcil. aliquid Ipcci ~I~ in p~t(()nI5Iignilj"lur! qllod (,jim cll: pfin~lpillm. feu (alr~ inoot~f,c:ndj , :aliquid (PC'ci:Ilec:tfc debet. vr 5.Tbom. dicit Jlih,,; tJlI&ji.p • • ,1 +" f. Ellie videmu5 quOd emnes notif.ll1t' dilH ngnunt: vnam pl:ffonam vclab alii!!" emnibus, vc:l faltc:m d IIU "b VI'I;1. \It lpiralio :;Iaiu;! diJtjngui~ Pauem~1Jt Filinm 2. Spldill s.

2.l Sc:,und& aducrrendum en quod notio rumde

{r: diut zliqllid pe'lincns ad cognorccndam. dit:' (;C'mendwq IIC p~r(QJiam in (oa pIopeta ratione, DOn (umi[llf me Ilo~io P'" ,pC! fOImali =goi[lon~. 'loa. fit ilb difnctio a ,ognorCCOt~ .Ied pw ip(;t formali ratione:: obicttiua; rd !:II. qu~ ex paftl; obicCli ~ tencr , (ell ex Falte irftll~ pClfonz fc:cundum quod impOitlt ahqnam fp::-cia1em notam.& c:ha~ ucccrc:m di(cemclldi vn~nJ pet{oll:QIJ) 'I'd plurcs ;l,b :l.lli$. ~;t nOla. fCIl dl.l(adu. aur forma p':l:: quam Ii,. innotdCII • ik dc!igoatur vna ptffoO;l. ab alia 0011 ell nt.c:diC qnod lit alia dillinCb 1 rd:l.~ lione,vel_ prop'kt~le. qua eonRifUitlJf • fcd eulem eire: POW'It.licet (Db dillerfo rc:fpdlu dlC3tUf rcbfio.pr(lpria~,aur notio.qllia. n dicit S Thom.in J .d;jl.J.G.'tIf.t._,. J.P4urniIM dUil1P' Ydsllil1 flltllrtJ»m '1",4 lid Fd'llm t;fattl,..Ji~lf1Y 4111'"' pupd~'M;1I IJII"m~m folf Pillri ~1I1mV1i1; dl'$I,;F' nllifll i" Ijllilm_,ft prilldpiff1JJ fll71l1.d~ ilPJIltefimdi P.n~/m. 19ituf iplilan« [;lO!). (i:n forma aut c:hatailerillic~ proptic:(;u .. nius pc:rfoD~ crit: norio. qu;arcnus in rc: impDtU[ fotmalc: prim:ipium innou=«:,nm u!cm perfonam.

Quid aUtem tequir.1tUt • 'It ~Iqua n!)fa {~U forma JK pr_incipium innOtdCCndi ~ l{ di(l;Cmtndi rall!m pa(on:un. D.Thom. itllWt cit. p"ntqp(ljI ilLl ""til fie npJicanA d hl1~ qnaJ .IIIlitf_iJ d"'"tn nIJ1i1l pnjimllJ I,i. WlilhiilltT.PrimD ,tlDd ~dnril.ini !I'ni",,n.,.i,. rd"timibw ,7igil1B f~fo1l4djjl#lgf4l1tnIlY. S~IfJ; 'JIM pmi1UAt .J, Jigniwmz • in/II pCffon. ,p bJF.PIljU,dsjlinEJiI proprtlfMl1Ui dJgmf4lt1Jl 1'7'rineme. T nfi~.qll~ dicII' illiqMiJ [Pt'i.:lf~7"i.;: ClJfIj~ t1l1l~ _,ft {ujdml prillrifiillll immljHn.dt. Q_u;e ~rion. vaJde utionabditct pongntlU',&:' eon~

Artie. .tn. 2}J

.fonniret ad l'nunUJ) &oliidurnqbtioni;,quia C~i'ri popantur notioilJ:$_r:.nqnam.propri:lt: r:llion<:s to;. gl1u(ccndi feu jnnolef!:todi perfonam.Per[OUil:: ;lli~ tem diCUllt :!li~uid dininClum '.datione originiJ, & iter 11m ; rar.lo per(on;r: addic [llper bypollaiim, feu [uppolitum :oliquid ad dignitatem (pCCU~7 .::lim. dic~r (lIbllftf;n~ ill natura digniffi'ma" CdJ. jnrdle~ ai:l~li: ideo iJlntl deber 'uoli tanql1am prDpria taw tio innofc(,endi per[otJaffi j . ~tl0d dfgllil~{c:m f 0- nc:t,&' lid f.uiOIiCjfi originis (p,Clet;8(: dmiqllc debet !:Ill:: aliqilid Cpcdalc ill tali. per(ona.id dl'luotl nc.'que 6~ 'ommUilC omnibu}. cum notio lh pr~ prj., tario cognnfcc:ndi perlimam , neque {ohlm pc::ninc~t Iflari:t'ql!af.t.& mlll~f p,jn'irll]~i'tr ad rlV" J.em ilotJom:m;Cjula. !lhld malllfe.ibf, & liinote('e~ : rc facir qnod magb ('mint[ aur a,,,die in aliqlloJ non quod minlis,&; '1110111 in'ld"quatc in "lio imfo" luimr;& fm;llldiUJd";ontlat coim q;uf)d eadem .c.Jarlo Parrj$.& habet ,eferri ad liiium ,& t"onaltU~. re pe,foifatn. 8c pcninete ad pot~'iam getlctat(. uam , ip!amqtlc' gcnctatiOnl'f!J di~re. fed noll qtlodJibe:t munUi (;1 ifiiS. f.acetc: dc::bc( ddlinaam notionc:mlcd omnia ilia (Q.nAuunf in .. "~m nOllO" Ilem jnr~gram P.IIH is. Similiu:r tiliu~ &' b.d,.cu·~~ fe'Eri ~d Patrem.& pr",'"l(;rC'~& c:onllitUtu."KI:UIldam p~rf"'IJam • & in radou~ filij includer!:: 'Iliad »~:mago,& intcJIC'auak v~Jbu",.A;. ~~tiolic~ g~~ mn , fi:d In:& oBmU non al;;unt fpc'lafcs t~'I(JBGci innof!&C':ldi Ji~nc pctfun<im,. fed iDadOiqll"riU,~ omnes pettincnl ad Vilam adil'qu:mun notionc:ni fili; qn~ follionrm (Jrigin~Ej. & proced(lifilli. (1:1.;0 fTe pl<nv PCidnur. Ula C:~ glJ fflfio qll~ in relatione aut ordllie origrniJ aliquul Cpedale; bt. pdncip;tl« rrpr.a::ltJ)J;1t. IlL mlloiie'lbt. \I'd eX pam: ptindpij orjgh);tnr~!. vel ex ~if~e ,~ml~i Ofigioa!i; DOtiO'" nem ljIeaalc:m (on ffinllf 7 lieer In (ab tanOb!:' plurCJ ali..: jll,d~qnarz f(l:JIl~lilafl:'!~ur rcfpc:'dlJ~~.,d offid3 cQo(unalU • qtl:1fUm fillgua DflEjQncm IiQG f,lI:illm.(td ad nouonem ,,,nJueuIJr.

T euio d~nique (lIppoJl~ndum dl dad ill;15 no- :l J tidI1C'~. 6.!qm: ~a~ n~,drari:l!Ji ad upljl:ationm:J~ ddignalioncDl'lnc: p~ffo!l~wm. at i1lis d)moBi(ct Patrcs clfl;'v(o,.Ne-cdlitas qnid;m p "nendi norio~ ncs <>ptimc c::splk~tUf 1 D,Tbom. hkut.1.e.nl.,;i Pr4pti[s:iN_. qllia inl1~nitur in Deo VIU eJkmn rum uibll~ per(onil;. Be irerlllJ:l v~ petfana ,om pluribus rd.nionibu~ • ICD r<lrlonibu5 rrillcipij od~ ginamis. :lilt (;;(milli o.rigllla[j; & p(01;td'ntl$. Opone! ~rgo in d!i.:mia. ~ perfoni~ ddign.ue. k difimguete id q~lo "fle:nti .. ell VIl3 ~ r,il.ipU diuinf- . rne::.& radoBes qUjbll~ pl'~(Unz tum ltC'~. IX inca

{e difcemunnJf,'" dillillguuflfur,:c:il.rcluionc: fa,ri$.& filij. qu~ vnic'o !Iolliine Jicinlt P~'C'Jnj:a; ..

& IiJi3HO. Similiter dun in nn pc:r(on:2 If\uelJJ~

(In diu"~ rdadon~J ptilldpij , :Iut td~j(lplI!!ll principii, 6:. tctmi~i originali."yornt dilc(tnuc qua fiI(iODI; dl VJium priu'ip~un,.~ qua ~li,u.d.q,iJj. ratione ell pro,te'den~. 'l\kJ PUD('lpJo'Ins: lil:c:r "nub

vnl :datio PQllit r~fpk~r(: Flllr~ 't:fltli~ in~ qP:lfOi ,& paniak,. c:riOim f~ r;ltt~~ltcr • & inad.l:qpalc diif;:ram fpl;'l;i~, nmCIirohtcr ,6; p;miilliE~r)''''' mt:n pillus [l1rmino~ alb:qltatol. & fp:cle adz. «oara cliuc:f.fo! • non po'dl ;,nk<l tdoliUO rcfpknel

Jic: mim biuticnl!m[ ad al~ud Yin rdltio, quod ne(;at Philof. f.mtt..pb.c.Jt AaAli'lNid f '.lll~'om ellnnia Idation.is eft ad alilld G: hlIbc.t\~i& GI: G di,irut b~.et1: dupla::ad aliud. Cum egg Patn fit prlticipill.M fili;. & SpitiJD1 S. &: filius lit EU~

111» Parris. &: principium tum Paae- Spiritln.S.«

jlia: rd~ioilcs adtquiZ(z fun Qlm (gJnc:wiuu ~ '" IIIJ1J felpimr vp~ [amjnos .p#ualcI2 OpdRtl.<ltt9 .ouibuJ wiombu. f.u IlQflI. ~Ul' ~~UJ

-~ , -- " .. lIifea

I:; 6

ui(cerflere ill.a~,;pe~(odaHIi tluiape fiiliulllpriDCjo. piorllm. tIC' rolatiullum,[eU olJiciorllm~ Ee Patrc~ {un:,~Ji In:is nodonibus, vP/idcri potclbpl1d.$. ,BaCtlillltl Ub.z,. ~iI;rfl4 Eutillr;jiflm., & lpifl it7,"'ji ,Gregoyjillh frdlr!;~ ! Plfter, inql1it; flli /lIf'y il11!l1I;j 'DtlU efl-~, ptcflliii_rernhyp~ft~fwl flU lIDfI(J~em filtH .hi,(fit; qf/iliJ PI/.tenp • & ~flO~~:X TlUIU_Ommll' c~~;flt i"bfljlie,dl'lfleij/o imUm mdmo. & 'P~'fI'DPrl' '!t: fep"wj;P.ign"fci~/tr: AL1g~R:.pl~ Tm",:c.6·11tif, 'Porib eft 'Iliff i1lfell'f,lttlr gellltu;:'; ~,,, 'JllA mg6l1lt1fl. ,DiUlla(c.lib. j.de jiJe~. f.& tlEatnt i Q;Thom .. Mil 'art. 1. Dif[utnliAm hypDftAfliJrl, id tp perfoflarfl1iJ in trlbHl,prt),"iti~~ibHl,idefl pattrn"ti)& filiali,r!r pyo-

'~tJliollllli ft!fi:Jgi1Qfo'irJim.' " , ,

"4'. His fuppoliti~-~oJlcJulio polita., qll=e elt~ O.

Thorn';" pr.efoMi "ti';' t1 .. 'Ir/;~.' & in J.di{li16.qli;1.. Ifrt.~.& .,li;' m1t[tu (oc~,lic ab iplO ,co\ligimr; p~;t:r {eitHn i{f:js diiobuslocis.; PeJ:fortz diuioa: dilbn'gJiillllut;&: multiplicantut fccunduinori ginem • (,(. 'proceffionem voiu! c:'IC alio. Ad:l'roceffioncm autern,&: o~igincm duo·pcrtincnt j a\rcrum c..: pure f!rindpij a 'lIlO elhUu5. Ilkcrum ex p.tttc: termini -qlii ab ~Iio.· Et-"uumquc: pateR innote[tac:, vel IIl1irm~title, vel nc:gadue. A Rirmaduclecundum influJillln.ik: proc:cmon~m ipram~ntgatiue per nc:ga:. tionem pfocedendi ab alio ;' vel ptoducc:nlii; vd 'otJg;i'landialiud, 'quod e~ vel ncg.t1'1: [ariOnCDl :prin.ci~ij; vd r~!jontm procc:dc~ti.s. 5i crgo affitm~EJuc.6c politillc (umamus ongmem, &: pcoceC. fionc:m. canthr in Dee elf>: [ohim dw.s ptocdlioltcs.3Irtr.anl jntdle&us ,alrcram voluntad5. Etgo 'fohim ponendum.c~ duplex prindpium, & duplelt terminus; & tDIIICqllcmer ,dupkx. relatio p~Jnc!pii ~ri&inantis,& duplex rdano tl;jmin! o~gIDau;& fie hUnt QIl3ttl0t flOt:!!, (tU form:!! d"llll~ guentes ilbs reb,tiones • &: pctfonu fec:undiun rl· tionem principij. & rerrninl , (cil.paterniw ranqllam principiun'I Filij , & filiMio· tanqU31'D tcrmiIlU5 p.3tl!toitaris ~ limilitet fpirni() =-tlilU. ve principium Spiritus S. & Ipitatio paffilU 'It terminus tius. Et i~ Dotiones fwu ttlatiuz !CU reb-riones; Noo tarnen emnes quatUOE runt plopricotcs • quia· fpitatio aaiu:! ell CDmtnUDi5 P:un • &: FiJio, ciim eis non 0ppoD;1tur. Nee iIC:r1lDl omnes illz CUDt Rationes per(onalcs, id ell c:onftituriu~ pcr(onarurn.lic£t; pctfonis conueni.ulf.quia wmJUtlnis !pitario nonpareil c<lnllituc:rc pct(Qnam fcorfum i Patre.& Filio'. cum cis non OpPOtl:ltur,& confcqutnr~ eis ick:ntificctut.

2. ; Si aut'r;:m Ca 'l~ ad originem pertinent (ununrur ncg;ariue, lrel n~gJriones inuc:nic:mus ad 1"ro-

eeffionetn pcnincnrc5 in diu in is. . .

Prima ell negado principij.fcil.quM aliqlta per(ona (It nihil prodno:~.ficUt cit in Spitim S.

Secunda ntgatio eft ptocedendi • fc:U. quOd lit alil}lU perfon~ non p[o~edens. Er boc: dupJjcit~rJ "Iclqni:t.fimpliclt~rnonprQ~t vllo modo; lieut P~t~. ~~ quia no ptoc:edit uli (pedali dlDdo.fu:nr Fi1i.a nop proccdit (piratille, ~ iiI: eO; non (pit:J.tnt,.&: infpirabilitilS. illl CODUenit. &: a fomori (;011- n~t_ P,:Uri:fIl!IE enim fpiratoI,m:m tpirari, &, in gener.m i:QllllenU Spi.ritui S. &: a foniori Pani. qui eciam non gc:neUtUf. Pdm;1 negatio;rcil.nQO eil'c pfod1u::ciJtc:m pttrOIWD.non pc:ninet a.d notio. nm1) qnia ex ... ua ~e ilb. ntg~ (olUm de:c:brat !onmUter quid nOD fit,non VCfO quid lit: virtualiter autem.& per circumloquhun non eJpnmit ;ill. (}wd nou,biIe.&' 3d digniratc:m pc:mnClU,quia non ftodu'~.vt Gc.nibildignimis fpccialis:aftm. Vt atem rtf notio)bbeE I!'el formaluc:r. vel impljcitt:. -&."¥lrtualitcrclI:plic:u:e quid a1iqUid fit,oop pura ~_D bE} idea~m~ &nwmina~~u-:

dUnnlr hati~nc:Aomini~, 'quia nop fuoi:: nptam eli reimec enim dcligil;ltlt am noranr aliquid in rei (ed (blam-'qUid nun' lj t dicll,I1t •.. Eadem aUrepl mOQ" :::, negltlio'prodliccn?~ .non ab(olll~e ~ -'f,:. limplieilcc.~

(ea no prodnccl1dl 111'0 'iUOlto; \I, g. gcm:r;tnl1e,ficut Filius non g~oerat',licet ~io mo'do-prod!lcat;(dL (pir.ftiil~. nihi laue hOritllti5 <lut· dignirati!r 'in: hac" pra:ci(anegariolle cxplicM. T 4'nia ncg:ltio.Cci1.no~; proccdcndi ab aiiqiio,oonlimplicircr,rt;:d ali fpe~; ciali modo.fciLnol'l (pir.trine,non didt"aliquam gc~ ~utrlrem d:gllimcin,' qni;l formaErer foluiD ~xpli"

.:at qUid non fir il b.perlon.ddl. non li'lima,liittu~

liter autem , & pet circumlQquium nen explii:atu~, aliquiddignifl1[is fpeciali1,quia fuppofico quail a·.

h perfona procedit ,. :eque dignum ellnon-peoee.

dete pcr volunratem ae ptOi:CdCfC per intclleth.m. Se(:unda denique nt-garlo; Cc:i1.nuJIo modo pro.:c .. dcrcjnotio eil: pfopria Pattis , Ii' nomine iDgeniri~

(eft inna{cibilis delignnt:t , quia lieat de fonnali.fo.

lum cxplicd qUid non fir Pilt!l![ 1 illXf~ C}liod did, Aug.r.d, Tril1ji.c.~. quod C8m ;l1gmttluJititfl,. Pdttl'.nll1l 'Iuid fit ,[cd 'JIIM 11M jiJ,J.i'illlrj tmlCP elt

!Iolia pme pcc bane neg~donc:m cit('umtoquiIUQ( nugnarn qjgnit.u~m. &: autheriearem principii pa

mo dum c:lpitj~. & fontis omnium proccflionum ~ ninuum null.dU aliam h~bi:ntis origincm ab alia; fcmpcr c:nim qnod elt caput,&: qllali primum, nC· gationCll1 emannndi l1h alio debi:t habere.a.= ta1is ~cga~io d~cumloqlli~ur magnam .d!gni[,at~.~rut in1inu:u'r, U\.cre:u:um,lOdfabllc. Iicer ncgatlollibus e~1"Ii~enmr,magnam ramen pCIfcliioncn'l per ilbs ncgariont$ circumloquimur, OJ!a: dignit:Js,no ell

in filio 1;0 rna do quo in P3tti: t k" til mnt:l. digm..

us .tlio modo,(dl.pcr. modum gcniti,& c:xprimeu:

tis tomm quod eft· in IJ3m:. Ita colligit S. Thorn.

has notiones > pr:J:fenim qn:e ad negation~ p~

nmt fOCD cir.tx 1.{tntf7it .a,jI.J.6 .Er Gc hultquinquc umum ncriones , V na ncgmua,.& propria PauU~

non ramen p;I(on~ljs,(cil.il1na(dbilit:l5: Q_ll.uuot politiu;!;. (dt. patcrnit3s.quz edam eli: propria PaltiS.&: pnfollaJis,filiatio propril,61ij., &.~: {pirario afrill3. pan p~opria, ted communis Patti.lIe r:i1io,&: non pCI(tIll3li5:fpjrati~ paaiua prop~a ree-

EI:r pC:ECOII;l!~& pcr{onalI5. V"J[llI pcrlOuahs. q~

conlUmit pctfonam., '-

Fuit prn:rac:a neceffiu"iu:m affigl".arc Parri nori~ 16 nemillalnneg.uitlamirtn;l(cibilis prOptCT Arrianolo

"_ni contl:.ndeb3nt P~trem dilliO~l1i a filio.non ~ohim rdatlont, [c:d c:t1:lot (u bltmnOl I co quod Jy 111- KIn/trim cum nOn fignific:et IclaEioncm~ infetebant

ipli CQncerncrc fubOamiam, fil:ur ly i"~c.41Hm; &

ftc djJfene Pattern 1 filio In fllblt1miil. quia diffeR

in r.ltiunt: ingc:nld.Sc:d tcfponder Aug.f.4t.TritJit.

c:~. ingenirum non dice,c Cllbllanriam. (cd,nc:garc relationcm proccdentinb alio.Vnde conduditc'7'

N ~n rmdi"I' .2 prairlitIJen" "ulillo cion ingwillll dit;itm-; vi delicct.quia ctIC: ingenitum in Parrc: fu.

him ncgat telarioncm:,b alio ~ & it:i ly itJl.tmlllm

ell: ootio rd:ttiua negaEiue.non poutine.. ::

All fundamenr;t,lio: ob~cltiones cantU hmc pri. mam diflic:ulr.ucm ex diClis conlbr.

Ad prinuun de; infpit;lhilitate dicimus ham: ne- '1-7 g:uil)Jlcm non import;z,c fped:lolem maDifc:ll:arione IIlicuius dignitatis in p(tfonis prQcCdmtibus : non tnim 6gnifiru quOd nullo modo proccdanr. (11:11 t ingcniulIll in Palf(:,r~d [anrUm quOd wi modo no, prDl:echnt. rUta per (pintioncm. vel peI'nat~lliratern. Negate aUEem n.lelil modum proec~di tm':' tiim. Galias procc=dunr pctloJl:e,non en c:rpJicare

in cis aliquid fpecialis authoritatis, kdpUtc.quid non 6nt. Hoc autem non fuffitit ad nOtWRCI1h"t\· dc:dar:uum ell. Nee innafcibiliw. quile.' eft. ;wxiQ

V.uris

Patri~ IiglliGcaf iohlm,neg:ltionem. ~:iEinitaiii;: fie., CliiM e,ri,lIn.COIiUtnit ,Splrimi S •. led I'H:gj.d(lil~ittJ omnis procem lui, ab llio:Gc mini: ligoilicatcapllt &.. ronrem amnis originis • ac. pcocdlioflif iii Deo, &; dl: IlOtio prima!' per(un;t,vt prima eft., . . .'

:18 :Ad 1.eria~ d ditl:if.p:ltet quod non prorllKercJ pet (c: non ell dignir;ls aHqll3 • fed tit g.uiQ fcccflndjt:ld&~'1tdo(er s. TnD,hi& • .t.l,sd ,,;ncgatio 4llt,m ellimdil;ib alio de fc: cxpUc.u digniurel'fj primi .quia Parer eO: prima perCon;'! in di tlini!. V idl:! ctl.lIn .qLtal didirnu ;fljr'li ciru folurio:lem vlrimi argummti in filie bullU difficul~adJ.N~c a hoc iofcr.i.tqliod 06 ptoducer.: in SpiricuS.ei impc:rfeaiD. ("11 j~di. gnirasiaurquad aliqlla digniru ci dcc:tl.fcil.ilIa qu~ ell; in Patte.&: non inip(o.R.eJp.enim quod in SPIric" S.non·el1 impc:rfeaio.atj~ indignim non pro~ ducer;:: j qUia non (peefa' ad iplom rdado prodil-o" ~entj$.(C'd ,dado, (eu concl.ulo termini produeii; Ad relaricnem sueem tetmini non pcujll~t: rdario principij.ticut ad rd:uiontm principii Don {p=tlilf .,ti:ltio:cc:rmini.Nec dlindjgnirM,am impnfc:tlio ellC: teranin~m principij diuini.qu3do ttimiDII5 ci~ oem n:l~Ilr.tm,& ;tq'.ul!l';t(cm h.zbctcUID principio: cVnde 'non ncc(t iIIi d!glJiP' Pmi"ICd lub~t ~ ... clem dignimi P,mi> fub alio modo~ld cnim quod

. in Parle ell dlglli~u principiJ i in SpiritU S.c:lt dj:" gtlita5 tc:nnini,qnia porc:fi ulltiim prindpium ter+ mlDare • ~ ci ad :eqUate 'otrerpol1d~rt. C~~t=mm b%c djgni(a~ non e.lplll:arilr pa non produ(;lirc:.Ctd per (pirad ~ ~ procc:dtn. DigQiE~ aUlc"p:rimz per((:m~.vr priin:t',txpiicamr per no procedcrt:.(cu per ingenitum,lft ncgat omne procrilione ab alio.

19· Ad J .Rerp.illa omnia non p.;:nlncn:.ad oOrionu. nee in vim notionum a 55. p~ .elre 3C1:Cpr:&. Nam Domina tignificamiaociginc$ qualijn ficri.&rcn. dcnria non Ilotilicam perrollU~ Lcd !lam earum, !lans autem lilppOl1llDr per(otw • & confcquemer (upponunr diitin¢liu:& C;UU1n • &: ea per quz inno • .rCfcCfc::polfunf:in {",plifo Vnde origin=s ipf~ .lignifiar: per modllm actionis.& nl!~j,&:" Kndmtil< no lUnr ppmO-.& per {cdiJ11na~ pertolUmm.qula nee conflim,iuziglm hgoilicl:l1tUt V[ in vi~&: renden.. ria,non 'Itt in (eo&,:: per fetLma: Ergo neque (unt JwtiOIie5 primo,&: per {I;' • fi:d iupponunt alias for- 111:11,& noW. dillinguentC5,& 'o!lfHtUt'Du.~s. Et lie {al:im reduatoe.ptninerc pOMUf ad nencnes rm~ quam quid conCi~utnpS.&'·ori:um 1 perfona,vd ad ilJ.un n:ndeos.~ fie aa:clTorie fllJ1t nOliones • non ptlmo,&: per fe.Idem qnoo diamus de ,adihut 6- gtli~caEis~u modl!~ (ltjgUJ!s.~ (mded~7diciPlIU d~ pOtCDllii gcnetanua.& {puauua. qUIa hzc pon figoilkanlt yt pafoltaled vr vitau petfonz j&; lie (uppom, aliqllfd aliud • quo innordc:ir perfona ; & qu;c ell: nodo principaliuir~ k timpliarer. Ea yeu\ ftomma quz aefign.1nr per(olJlls , & non {Dnt DDtionel,v, im3gD,Vctbum. fplendQr.& fimili3Jdc:d nDtion~$.non fllnt.qnia in.1dzqQl1lc penint:Dt ad vnalll,Be ('andew prop(icraUM,iQlblbunnirqilt:~ &: includunnu: in tlomine Filii. {eu filiationb. qQ:l: omnia iIIud.2quate indodil;& ideo non (unt DOdones dillintht,(cd codiriaocs.aut jnad:t'qu;l.t~ f;'Inones eillfdem propricutis.Sumimr hoc I:X D. Tb. i1If.,.,.".ATt. .1.M~. v .. bi in~W(. 'I. lIed. . Ip[''''lZtittillU Fi/~ .f"'~ 'il pupic,,. ,1f/imIlIM ritn J'"l'fo nlllliItjDIIS ftgmflwIIY lid IX~_ Jitltrjim,JJ pnj'h lIinum ';;u.N!I'M 'fit tijltllUtIi,.tmmlfl,.mJu Pt61'~ Jidl1n' FiIitu.flIIlIlmJA'II'"UMtr"lII. JirilJh fpt,n,lqto. 'fit IIft_f,." rmtlliltll Jimi1M ~ diei,., iPu1.Q ~ 'fit dI~ il#nwmillitl7ft."';t,u ~ Ji""w Y "hm.

. Nm ""l'pml fllIi'lI_' ,,,_in pir f-u. _"i_ iIIlf tkJlgil4,_t.QJ.!att: illa nomina Verbi. im3gi.

• ·,ni$.amoriJ,,&C.III::ellpccialibus ~nis toQUC1ll~ Iu_ . .is. ThmI.ill l.p"n.D. TJa. 'l'omus ;dIU.

tJ7··

non t~m~rt dicunmrCpeciale. n.otioll.r~;<1ltin om_ nes in~lu,htnIQdn 'Ina proptierate,& neuene fili;\~ dOliis aile (piracionj';qu.e Cecul1dihn diner(Q!I,& in:l.dltqn,uas condltiones Ceu fotm:alitate. omnia ilIa incilldic. ' "

. Ad '1ltirnum in quo inquirlmr quid de format~ I) dicat ingc:nicum.reu mn;d"ibilitJs,:m negarjon~m~ ; an :ili']uid po!itiuum ~ quia Creciille difli~ ul.rate,IN':' b~t.ptttjnttqllC: (~tcialiH;' ad p,edon,,?, Pa~~isJi~~ diJP.4rt~ 1,traaabltlir.Nunc (olUIH d"lmU!i IIJgfln~

tilm Impom'~ de formali ncg~tioi1em ptD'cfii~!'iij

;ib :diqljD plincifio,f10ii UrnC:Il banC" lJegariDnem nuda irnpomre,ft'd 'It fUlid,ua • & P,II.',/UpP(lhCnt' r.1tiom:m peE(oDZ.& principij,qiiod r~m:en ,,6 p.e:,;nnee ad ra[iOnCi1l f«fI'I:d~m ing_thiti, qll;lli ,ouR(~ . nuiilltm cillf. (¢d 'luaJi pra;(uppolil<im, .... l1. Th9, docCf in ~.·J.JI.1.S.'1' t, 11. 1 ... d.I.Del;, ncgac.C"d po,:

tiu; COnliJ~i' i;if. IH ; .•. -t. 111 mp. Itt ad primnm~

dUIll ponicj;gnlfkllti pet I,. ilJgtrtl~tlm punGipin u6'

de. principu). ,Jura c:nim nl:'g;mo tIT"om i1n. ;llio j'j;~' p"Qtcll olgnifalem Hprunctlt. dim hoc c'J~m Uiii~ ni.uur in b;Sql';f !JIh,) ~lm".1i! "c.ab aliI) tl9D fnnr,

(~d tlegJtl9 td~,d, <It., ali., in Ito qlloa dlpn(on~ au~principlil.d,gDh"lC: dll, dc:lign;uC%pJi('~ndo.l-4 qUD? prim~lJn ;:~l p~r~eg,IEi\lntm alt~riu5. P?orlI! ~od" v.:ro ~y ml.:mlu ImpOntf de m.Ifi;"Juh pert

. foli<lm Ilia) vel ynnciyiu I Ill:! pmi,"J~ti conc:epm

P .trit If.e! piincipJj Ii..: velli~ inauc:nu~. & pr~nrcl' J.,l:i ;,,1 r:lliis pcr{on<u. hoc alii! ')Ilitllit' cl1. de' C)uo dill:mktut 'ltot/Ii IV'Ii)flf.4if,!lrq.~" I. .:

. Q,god Ii dcmi:iJn jnq\lifa.~.qll()'1!.od", rplrario aa,~ " u.a dl"arurnolio l)"Erj5,~ F.hj.com n6 fil pt\)rrie~ (is.n 0 Th,d."t:E ~fI h." q.;z.,,,.~. & ,,,men no(iq diciEIJr:_ quod <:Ii ptl}pri~ r~u" dignl'(u'JIdi P" roni~

fi ;mum III fficic eire: propdC:fafem dnorum. lie nOil vnilll fiUlu\m.j fimm r,nlo!1c non ~iriiu'm 'il fUn~ d~tUt,6; lilppt;Jnird!lu pc:tlomls~I"'I. Parnm ~.,~ Filium,ql1iblll tanqllillD {uppoGlJst;onaenit. di~

Ell! nodo Pan:is,& filij. . ~." . . .

Refp. non rC:'lliiti ad dOlioJjml quOd lit pro~ ratio dlglloli:endi pet(onam ~:QHum vnam. r~d • .,(i. tid: quOd hr t.ltia propria dig!lok;enJtp\.'1~onii..jjue vnam.hllC p!urchpl(Jv,aba~iqlUaJia dilcemii;o tnt,Gent bip~$ ell prortium.bomini~."d n6 (oliu, homini5.Cc:d e~ia aois pcoyr tam homoquam :IuD; • qnadmpc:dc d!&tont.~o clI::tEpio ydiUr S.Tb. ad clI::plic;tndui'il h(Jc ill IIpflj&.:t..,. S9' Addo 'Iliad ipi~ ratio 'ommuni~ ell propriil noriu dU;lIU P((Collo:iiii~ n6 qlla{CmU5 1"lu"1 perlona:: (unEled '1"~rc""D~ to.. ucmlJl'.I~& hInt IISlumin r:niun'-prJlIcipIJ (plf:UiW; lie cnim ell no ti~ P,mis,& Fih;. "on vl P:*t. " filiuslcd vr vnlls Cpir.nor. Dt' ration.:- auccltl *lOll {pimi pilUiui.i:un diximllf,qllOd IIce( dUilbilJ pCTJonilcOQllmW.uihiJ UQ)m qicniriltl51111i prindpij ..,.c:l,crmini (lfilPniJ ('"lI::plk.1r;~ .G, ooliopc: non ~e-. , ligMt<1 ill!} oOP (puaEcun IllduJirtlr in i('{it raEic~

{pi .. atori$.& {pi(.Itiolli5_atliu,1:"llo'.a hoc: Ipf0'lu!ld.

1=1l fpir.J'or~t)pponi,ur JpitoUo pal~dtl,& fie, non·cit fpirinumpJffiue.qili;J oPPI1.nW{ ,IIi. Infrinbilir3s ergo.feu nOD (piratum non ell norio !corsii. ~.~ fe,quia dl illciulit.& inuolurn in (piraEione ~aju~ 6"lt non gc:nillim , (tU non 6lio5 inciuditU,r in p~ rernihtc,nC'c ell n(uio dillincra. Q,!o~Jh'w; eft de ingeni.to :lb{o1ut~;ni in ipf.4 ~tiom: frincipij qupd Labci m quamum Pliler ,non lDuohutur qncld non

(I[ ab :ilio ,.110 modo.(ed (alum quOd no·fu gmi- ~ ti1S Gcur; PiJim cuioppcnhur.EI id~odebn.jrdiru .... 43 nouonl:c~pJi,an quod fir onmino mna{dlri,a.

id ell inuUo atio pnKcdmlY( ~fic~rcrm IlIJ4ld dr~1 plim;a pcr{qnit in ration,~ prim;&'. q_uod tJbm opona IWliltc prodffaimine interiJmalclbdbncm Pouili,&. mfpinbilital:Ea9uMiIJa lit lJotJo~ncn ilb.

II $1"*114

§l.!!,41io XXIX. dc. t» Fer[oiJildiuiniJ.

Secfmrllf difji(jlll~ti folifjit. fe habetlf;quia no ell: aliaoppDuti6,ealfs iJ.,~; qu~nt cdati!lil. ltl,irfus , iloll fe(pl,iunr reaiicerS:pi(itum

S.patctnii.ltc, at 6ii.ltiohj: ~. ilta:: cnim rcl,ci9l:l¢' (11lupl inter fe opp~unt!lt. ~rcfctunulr·: F~t;1. cnim,vr pari:r,fohi~ Ce habet a~ 6HultI,&, Glillud patreJti.E.rgojSpirim~ S.rc(pidunt VI ip,it:t"leS.(el1 i ~t (pir~tor : etgo tel atio Ipiratoris re:ilis ~f1:~y~p.Qt q JD rellh ppjfe lllODe fundat", qua proccdlt ,Spu'&W$ S.a rpirarore, qui ell-Pater, & FiliuS!~ illa,reiail!) {plratCr;s n011 mulriplic;uuc in du~bullo'pCl{9'l1iJ~ clim 'Itr:lquc: lit vnkum priiicipi~m SpiiilusS-.ei .. go ell'V!la relarlo rcalis in Patte;&: Fillo:ad Spitffii 5.quz Mn ell telatiop:itcn'litaris. & SliatiOPIs. Ec fI, oponer ponue in,Patte',&: Filio prlttCi'I;;llitiQ8 nero patc::rnimis. lit filiationis,aJi;am r~lllioilli fpiA rariolli!.qliz lit alia.non per fcpa(atjo~nnieu noli identilic:~tionem CntitltiU:lln. & f~c:mc:um iRiI d\l4buS;fiq~idi I:is no bpponrtur,fcd pu tennijjaElone ad· alium ti:rminii.lId quem n~uttl am ruminanlr formalirer, qUia p:m:rnitaf ttfmilllltur ad (olii. E'i1iu.liliario :ad (alii,Pane.Sic ergo qll:u;uonebtio-nes reales dm. conll:aE.~on plurl's,qui:lDOD sUI

, plura fund,JllIetlt.t quam du:r proceffiom;s ~ealei. quz nccc:if.uio inrC;tquatUo~ 'erminos 1;'4e dcbmf. nee: pIUt,cs. c(Jrrd~p'one., & (~in;ltionc:s CJ.igl,lnr:. Non pauclorc:f!qUianccpdllclorc. proec:Jlio.nC1 difur.qu~ (unt ilb1'1lm rel.uienu fund:lme,.il.&: qUI:~ libct procc:ffio iDtc:~ duos terminos vclf~ dl:bef:

. Sed;quia.foi~m tres ex ill:isrdationibu5 funtpc&;- 14 fea:o~o~Bc.vlld~qllaque inter Ce oppoG~; V n* Ya'o,fcd.fpiratio c:ommunb innetl;lUt 1100 opponi parernit:lti.& filiationi;& fie ab i11i5 ft1n diJlingui~ r~d idenEi6cari~mcrito.jnquirimr quomodo jlti "w l:ttion~s vnnm Gnr cum' iDOl (piCildoJ!~ tOW uili;ir& quod muIdplicC1:ur rel.nio , &. nop inilJl:iplicmtur

res ve lint q~tnQt fubfill:cntiz, fcu res rdariuz. E~ eomuniEcr did Colct quuq dHlinguiirur formlilita 'rcaliter in dferclafioiW,funt ~ute YDurnin dfc{c:i.

~n 9.uo inuenit. dift!.cnhar.eUl Va!q: hit: ~ifN ~1I~e.!. .nftn.& t.l..qll1;\ Ji tl1it~flonC:$ ddlingulltur formao. litl:t in dre rc:i.uionis, etHi i.lillinguepulr in efe, til

ob 3fgumc:ntllm ["pit faltii,quia maitipliC2tO . iDfcriod,4illidirllrquoque,&muitiplic;uurin,eilp dus fupenor. Alij dic';Int mulriplicari qUfEllonela,. liont:s in cfie .Aa.no jp efl'e '",fed in hoc in.a$· duu rc:lationes patmlitatis,& fplmion,is idc:miJk.ui,Ant fendun, tpit;JEi(J1trnl.& p;lternif;ltem iQcnrinl1afi ill

. \lnO tertio rc(pca:iuo.quod:td vtrumque termina (chabet.qllia ,cil.non dl VDa rclatio renia,Led Vp!& ·cC$ fC(pcaiua,k duplex r:ttionc tc:t'l\Uno[ii. ~od -aliqlli CJplic\lltt c:xemplo c:iufdE ;llbi,quod eLl ti,mi ..

i.: tefpcC!:u atf."ril15 albi, & diffimilc cefpc:au ni-< gri.&: C;lmen ilLt relatio Iimilimdin!S s & di""lli~

mdinis idc::mifiC:lntut in ;JIbe in cae rei. ,

C:¥ttnlm ilhz: czplic:ltiones conantllr pUIl¢liutingcte vcrit.1tis,& no peru~niit,.dlUrnedo abillo. J f. '& dirninute tan upliando. Conftdm.ndu.n c:ft: ~im quod in rwu5 treads reladoQts dillingulm':' tur re"liter • tum ratione' oppoGtionis ad c:orrelarluum.rum ratione limitationlst quia vn:I.rclado no habet niG 'loam fpc:dem,& pcrfed:ionem adiUam

p. millcntem.qui.:!. cum limitata.& Clean 6t.no. ~ {cll: pluElum pctfctliODCS in fe Ildunare. 'Eteum 'tot, r.uio • &: perfeaiG relationis iif ~ a(,«um ~ , non folufI\ non. poteR: vn~ rdatio cre.an. habe.

,e . rpCC:imJ fui 1 tmnini . c:otrl'iadul, kd. ntq,iC= fpecicm aliOlfumrelarionum • It;" quM, terminol di!pararDs rcr?ici;u v~a & e~cm,,~rel ,relat1113,

&: hmgatLlr 'lIte plUflUqt' rclauODul11. obJillcnt= 'ad bo~ Ipfa limitationec:rcat!ll:rcalifalis lc:latiuz;_At vcroin' diuinis nOll ell, ratio :difiingnendi ~'.dariQ.., DCS" limitaticmc ,outatilla'. &: in· atiOlU::: Rl". fed

, ... '" ,_" ". ' . :~""' ,'. ':; {ol4m

1;.8

! 1. Dice l. Rea.:; ponuntUr qll.ttUDt r~lado,n~s tea~

lesin Dc::o.r1QO tame emnes fum reahret ,hlbndi.

. & itt n5 (uPt c6c~dend~ quatuot tC~ rdarillz in DIG.C6c1uUo quoad cernes parces ell D. T. Nail! qltod relariones rdeslinr '1u~m?rjaHir.mat fgpr~ '1;i8."'i.& '1.JO,drt.1..~J ' ..... b~ enarn :t~!ma.t vna jlb.tUIlI tdariDnum. (cll, fPlfatlOnel11 adli1~111 non (ep:lrari ~ perrOn;! Patrl$ ~ filij. ~ fimiH~~r quod fintt(:Jatlone; t'ealc5.tcl~tlo Pams ad:Fillun:;; &. ad SpirinJln 5.do~~t ~It bAG q. p,. ArM.&' qu~~ i~~ri' liCCiitUI,docet ~!1frA'qll .. ~o.liTt.l."4 r , A,; denlque qilod IiOIl lintdll~ reS p~tcrnir~.&dpirlltio atriu;!, !ieee {ipt dua: rcl:mones,docct In 1.J1ft.l1·'1·r. 11.. f. vbllm,ll1it.qllOd PA!~rn;f4l~& ftl;4';' liJ;dll~ T{4,r/!' jimili"r l'Alert& Filiul,{td P"'ff"iIM, G' nm,,,,JIIi4 /iirliti' HDs F"ntd.lil. 1II;I1"ill"; DpPl'n,,,,tflrul«;i,,J. ft~ t4tl,~m @~ t'eia,iU/lel. ifiii" J.iRingfHII'lIrJiJ!ia ,.'iltii! r~l«ti"rl4 iii '1111111111", rft rll.,jD~ Et idem fu-

i 1l\itur ex & ;.g'Alflffll,11 dt %'1'1" . T yinit.,,; vbi ddini~ I' cur,rjfolJ#nmer rm ptrfoP4I n6 t:Jfo '11l"'IIMr~!$"i#jn tlluil1it1 CIlIlCtallld"mtjfo l/'ttflt:YIlif<ltllJf. Eade aud~ t~do ell de cll~nri:l,& rribus per(oni s, 2t9IlC deipi~ ratIone: aaiU3; &: de rerCollis~G coiro tllct di!\intl'l res nb iIIis.clt1:nr qU:l.fllurrcs in Dee.Nee fcfpolio. Dur~ndj v;l,~ct.qllod loqu;uur Concil. de qUatUOr rebu~q(j:e nnr quamor pct(ont.'1el [res ~lonlt.'" vna eJl~nti.1mam li Cllllcitium dall1n~[ c:1f!:ntia,8c tres pCf(OO:U dfc qu:ltuor ra,cadent ratione debet negare quod (pitoltioc6I'1lunis,& tees perrona: fint quamortes; eadem cnim I;Un1ttatio, Pt:t:terquam quad nfpir,nio ai!liu.t ell: rCS dillintla a uibus pcrfanis.erit iIli$inc(jmun!l~bilis in rt:;&'c6lequenrct perfQlla qUiitta.quia diO inda.tIc incommunicO\bi(if. it antcced~ns prob~tur.qui1 t~latio ilia fie: dllliofril d,ber eJfe fublillC'Ds, Sub.fillcns ;nncmdilHnltum ell: incomlloicabilc his') quibus dil1l"gui~lIr. quia alitc:t non poreft dillingui fubGllau. pili incolDunicabile lit. imo Ii t:)liJ res eLl difi:intb ~ P.a.trc • &; FiIiQ;& tnmen cQanmunkatutillis te;tlittl; ergo vnitur ilIis:ergo f.ac;it ;a!lqualll coropolidonl;lU (1)111 illis, quia d1ial: dillinll::;t; res non ell intdligihilc: quod vnianrur, lie communiccnlllr tine aliqna copolitione. Hz.:: :luccmoblbr (urom;i: umplit::itOlri Dci:«gQ vndiquc: vrgl:cur DUt;U1dus,vc:i ponendg fpiradunem dill:infr.tm commonic:ari P.lni & Filioi & lie po net i:ompofitionl!m, &: toUCt limpliciutc. vel nen conttnllnic.ui;1k lit em fub611:ens illCOfl\. municabile.& con(cqucmcr pcrfQP;t ; &: fit: ewol' 'ImInO! pmou:rjEt jrcrum Don proc:edct SJliriul$ S,l P~ci &; Filio." cis nQP commllnic.atur (Pirat!o llaiU:l.qU:C d~ prlncipium prodllB:ionis Spiritus S. Q,_ua:. QJl\n~ confequtJlci~ (unt Contra fidem.

, j ,Ha:c aduafus OunttldulD prob;uJr non elfe qualllor ces rcluin:u in diuinis • nl:(: diftingui tulirer fpiraJtonctn affiumll Patre.& Fi1io. quia cis rda'UUCUQP opponitUr; &.lic dcbe~ e«e 9nUln c:ii ~i~ • . ~Olltn.SCGtum auletn ptobatW IIOB dillingui ex ~ td atuc: opus inteUe.:ms.ca generali ruiOllc q,ua ulprob.mir lie: e!ftllti.lo &. tdationibll5. vel atp'ib~:c:adctn C'niQl mi1im ratiQ de fpiooonc. &: patcrlUtUc , cUID nOR minis vnum Jinr I qulm c:::(~ itnri~ lie p2terniru.

Sed refta(modr). oll~di;r!:tquoinodo CJ, vna fIlrte Jinr qdaroOrrcbtlOIli:S rW~1 , &: ex di3.no!1 fint qu.uot ra,fecl rpir.nio a~UU41 vnit fiat cum duabns cxillis,(c:i1:Cllm p:uernjt~~c>~ tdationt.N:l1'Q quOd ~es tcl.anones 611r,c!libtUD DOn POtell;qni3. Pat« " Filiul rc:di (eLui!)Q!: lc(picillDi'Spiritllm S. &: acurthtiQne ~ionis>di.Dl rC'llircnl;i eodiftinguiNf-ctgQ Gc ~EuoppOnUIl(1It' :agQ cI;Jtreiatilla

_ D!lPlJtd~io XIP'.

r olum exoppolitionc cotfebdua (i1Mara Cuper od-: gbicMiquia videlicet in origme'.&: pfocemO~Ii non porell: eadem res procedete re:t1iE" a fc,pr~ kd Ii aliquid r('aliter procedit.debct ~a~ reliliradillin.d:uqI.& cum nOD poait res ab(olut.l procedcre.

· k,dillinguiOib aliaJolum ra reiatiuatlnelzJibne petfedioni, abfolurz dillinguitut (ectlndi'lm op~ poJidofi!:fi1. relariu:urt pro.:c'!IQois.R.c:mo,a •. ~U(enl oppoiiriQne corrcladua • ipfa in6nitas. &: amml li9 miratiQoi, negado adUn:lf;& idenE,neat.in cJfe lei roeum quod ad e:ntiratc:m.&: rc:alicarem perlin« ill reja:ioni~u! ; Be ~c vnilmet cndc4I p(ltelbjimne~ (pecuiim rebt!Onl! aduilare,dunirnodo opp06(1. ubI DOD 6t; & lie v;rim i:erm!i1M rc(picere: p~dl dilPa~, (arc;non corrdatiue f,d1ft€'u.& plurium i'cLuio-: ~um vice fungi,q~od tocUm ad eminc:ndam fnti"!' nit~ti$ (pcltat z qua: mam Jn: genefC: felati~o m Deo e:ll-lit hze dotlrina vaMc obfCfUanda clt.c~ Era.eo) qui pur~nt poJI'e ipdhtinn ,dalionQ' f~pft.! di{tingu'i.mam.inc oppofluonc.& proufficme vnius ab.alia;coQEu '1110$ agcmus Jiji.Ji'.,W.B:Ui-

, do dtdiltind:ion.: .spiritUS S.li;\ fiho -MQ~prot'('derct.R.adir C:him.& pdn.:ipi~m ':onfo cos. ~(u-. rnilUf ex ,eminentia ,& intinit3t(' diuiD:J t edam in. genae: rC"litiua.qllz polluut adunare. & idl:DIica~ re omncmipcdem.&: pcrf"aton¢m iUiu$ geQ~is. in .emiqtc,& (talirace ~ dummodo oppoftdo non i1netUc:niar,quiaiD6niD5 vnitan:m (2eiE,.~ poilu. 'ar,(i, c:iin6nir.u limplicira.

· Ex quibllsliquid& colligitut quomodo 'Prado

J'; ;u·.l:iu;:p;,& paE(;mlfa51intvoa res rd,ariua,4:: dll~rcrationes reales,lIon ita quOd ., all. ~at fupa 11 ,.nrltl.id eft,quod i'calicer hm dd!t', {cd Iya"" adit fltp" Iy tl/If"IiR",id eft quOd iila miius rcali.r;qu~ refpicitrealircHi:rminos. ddpliciHcbdonis, teah, vim babc:~ & muDIu.& reali," 1 p.atfC rei l'c(pjd~ ilIos cerminos,(ed quia inter (c: no flint oppolilit& rdado iUl4 non dl cinrius 6ni{a. ~ limi(ara • paleR:

Cilcile-m eiuiu.ndariuOl. duplids rdationis ~~i yi!n mbere~ Dicuorur tamen qwtUm ~dationcs rctlc:s ahfoJut~.~ uplplimt'r.quia I y .,tl41W fcpa appc:1- .lar (dim) ~,lItdt'm conccp[am (UP" terminu.noD {up!=."fu.b~c:alJ~,co q~od pr?pri~."': fOttJi;llis~rio i"cb#ODl5111 COlO quo a (~tCI;i$ gCllCnblU dill'at,C'~ lubere (I; ad terminii;&: quia ngni6Qdo iI,lios E~-: minj.R.datio(l;mpe:r in'fCllisimr in foimali{~ &:

Co~tpm~ideo clhB rc:lado Ilnmenwi.fub appella_tione ad tc.nninum nuni"atur~quidqujd lir.an eann.rille lit VM teS,vd plures.QyooeOnD pro prz.. di(:arionibDs rc:urionum obfC'ruandii dhdi: enim iIb pr;cdicaio.Parerniw eft (pi(;lri~ ticw: ~ atuiblltiml fapicnri:a= ell: ilnribut~ iuftiriz:iaaquc cnIlU for:malelnfC:Q(U~& "'ppdJa1ionem foldH in (cprll IUleJD limp lid vel idtnrig) "pi.moa ell iull:icia,nl. til res quz c:ltJuftiWj!pillllio dt'[« qnz di

pacmnas • va}enr.. '

· CoUigitw: i... eadem JDodo loqumdum c:4"c: de

J 7 mllftiplii:aril;tnc: rc:buonu.,at'll1e ckmnltipJicariOJllI: anributon(m;liaumim dicilnus iullhlzm.&: mifi.. ~diam effe dUQ ~tlriJ?Uta reili1 ~ aut viBurC'$ ,cales in Deo.non ramcelfe: duastca.'ifUC:S. quia If J. ~pp~Uat fU~ formaliucc:m atuiburi.ok fIJP~ :nit: ra.li~rare,irolc.}m dieo 'l~uo~ rcladon~ECaks~ vel (pinlio.9E.& patcmilllll:m dUB rchticma: t:n.]~)ll ~"fl2. 2p pella~fupR rc,"nalir:l~pn (e:Iar:i .. ·onit,vl: cxc:rc:e;t~ ~"umlhum • Jf .t'ttUu , (cu ~tu,nog

'~ niultip,Jiwudcu lounaliz;uuribi. fed fll(lP.DDiiur. ,qqi.\ illC:l'r:(p~allS qlu CJ:1:(CCEQf: ad dil!~o$~t~i-. .IIQS r~.is ,dilcd eJ.~~ rcaliw:c.n"Qdiue:rf~ ~u~ _ dE diuinitate dininu$. c:ll.&·eodi dre: inaeauu dr.

.;8 ' 'ColIigitUrtcnio)o~umosQlodPs4iccndi.& expliciDtI!,hanc .!niWC(D rei tcWiDZ.~ 4illcdit~ J_~G. tiI$,rhms.;~ 1.,qr.D.Tb. TOlUlaaha.

I

/\

Arlic~ ,'Ill. 139"

rem 'l1.form~hppeJlationefe.ladoniJ!u; patte cottrinere vtritilremJ8c ex pmc delkcre. . ~

Nam primus modus qui dicit rclationes Ili3s .in, drc re.i.eHe 'Inurn.&: in clfc: teladonis fOfmalirer~ dimllgui il:~lit".qualltUtn lid hoc V.~l! dicir.q~ijl fclnioric:s ,ilfz cmitaciue non dilf'e(IUlt.fe4 ~e,,~i:'!. naCilJc unmm. quia excrc,cnt IC(pcQusclid ~~~(9$ tcrminos rcalitct. Sed in hoc. dc;~ck quod ~F~' Jiratem ilbm . ~ .& nlUDDU;d:uiol)!s . VuIf ~iftlngR' fealitc:r, ira Ql10d ecHi rC:lIfiras.~3t rup~ Pl\lkieJi-o cacionEre:ladODUM.cUm umentc_"Ji(;Q,!i9Ii(im~I#" pli,c:ncur,(ed viia m~ne';i'~"',if.ili re.diur,l!Io,ll JJ)1J1~f~ pJi,"uridqnod formale ell iii tc:lad(iM;Jic;i~~~l~ tCr eJtcrceaEllt 3d mlllripJic3tDS;kpiilrn tC(~~iro,~"

, Sl:culid1.1nero ·1J10dlif dicll:iJdi.'llljJOcum adJiol'l' .~ ~ ,uod rclationu iJItt" mllbip'ir:(ii.~~ i? Ii'tf7 44,Qfiif < III eire i",GfllmlltUrc!lClfI' prO;f;lU(ln~ Ip(~ ~o~ mlliJi telationil in rariUiJifa'll(diliUis ,~J~riq,.~~~

pro tlldone:p:lniclli:zd iclati~"i;,.&;qua~ fp~~f d~.6cjt,qui;j. nOD folum (pifado.~~~llirlU idm":" dJiQi!tur Lec:undllm rationcnJ ,communem,.(,;::d «14 {tcunillimpmscularcs, Ik pfOPIiA?;llIdOil~ ~ 'iu!a edam in quantum raJa (pccili~c. ,k ill ip(afp,'!~Ji !lIdO~cAd non oppOnUDrdr, ~f'',', {unt ~J,II~~~ ~ ,d1:nuficablur.qullu:IIUJ flll~J n;IO!;(JoPcs {lInf.~ f,~

rr~ aUfem Ii dic:a(llt cITe plutes rt'wd~f (q:lr.-

do 4J2b 1n,"2 qllod non lint plqrc3i,iJ);c r~lati~ nes,e:rii reriQmdQ. c:c:idiEa.cmj~ui.mis. C:OD!lf.~~ ex rOicioneln.lii:ct non mnJEipbcmtjDilm~faJflJlI),!i=Jl', qllod,nOP (iUt qualUOt ,eJarlonC:$r~C'5.cEiam f~ tincudo J 11 rCQlJe~&: .non rcp;lr~.,do. 'luili.p"nqlM~

. tJTenria,~o& Gat mionc:m J" rlila,doJlI.fc:pmf!iI ia . re ; lic&. lion .rnulfiplkctUt,. rcdnmdo tameD ip~il In ea'enfblc:.EIi zlUem yera ilia {l:mcDri~1i ImcJlf:r gatut quod illli rd.arioneHamquo~d ralioneml:¥; muneriJ~q.mm lIuoad panicubrcm in PriODe: talit; .Ad,fum Vnllln cnd,,,dutt Be P':0vt allicium (ubi~ allm~riquc uibutlntcfittium f!;lOD2!m cmaminarum.& {p~dficum : fUnE au[c:tn plu~c$ tCljiJi~ riue pJOVE ad, diuer(ouetmiftoJ rtalila. ft'fminan.'ur,~ appt'ltiut .::oncc:ptum {Ullfn "SO iUO$.

Demqae [c:muJ QlodlUdi'l:J)di io hee deficit 'lnod vidc:tur iJla$ duas teJ:uiODet. ~ iiJ Y~iii (onfundttc:.ciun ramC-Q inconfo(:dit rdaiio.flI~<~ niracis.&, fpimionis 3t!liwr.~vlr\tqnc aplicit~,k ineonfu5C tmdiud (Dum ,e(J~inii,ncc datllr all'}ua n:ialio communis. feu IInliUQ)~qu2 neeli, fOfllJalitc:t' patcmila.!. nee formalitC:f (piratio, {cd Poiiq formalitu_eft- patcr.&:' prow para formalitu dici~ tur foh1m :ld Fjljli.& Palnfo(malice{ eft (pJr3r«.k (ub bac relarlene di(irnr folmn :ld SpiriUlm S,Non vcro chulr VR.1 r"Jario m~ia in '1113 JRII: du~., "011- fund:lntur.qll~ limu)' rc:fpfcjar~(~que/dl·fd!'u~ " Spiritdm S.VI tU'minum adotquanuu!cd ra:* ,lJUS !ld~'lu.uus p"ttlniraris C;1t Filius. &. Iqm~~ ;icUquan1$ (phadonis ell Spirims S.Similira delicir cle:mpJuPi de albo ill quo i~llriJiatitU,p:~tio IimilirudiDis.& diffimililudin~.C)ui;l. .aJbum eft all- . qUid abColulum. lkperma9u {nndame:nti rcmoti. nOli pmrlmi,iJI quo nOD ~Jl miril 'luad eoneGRe:-te pq@tt plures. rehtioPc$ , . fiCQt nnD e:ft qIlidu9 qaudin .edUitia diu!l)a ; ((U in ipro Dca ab(olu,~ ~f'~ id~c~ ~cbtiQp'a~e"'.itatiJ~ ok .CpimiO,DJs.lmo & fiJwloms. C2«llUDm hoc 'Jidcmud

ve:riw6 !Kctdae ille modus dk~di. qucld f~O {pimion~&. p:!ttmiurls mUca,riue m.iin geJ}C'R relarluo (onc, vpica IC5 rd:itiu~qui:l. 1I~,~ppO~ . iAIU {~fC'dJum: plUfIl$ ,elaCiODeli (~a 2. &. fcamdUm quodrd,mo ~FdI.3(Ua ~~cprii(~ 'pa t"lDinu.rum:pl!lrC$uladonu.~ ~t fpoll iClDlinos diftmI!los ~'1U."c.espJlclte 8f ,~.

Q,yuc R~~~~~SOP",! CJ.I!.04 '~ad'~

, '.A. . ~ .DnaAUIf

l+~O\ ~~fli{J XXIX.f5c~,

;tdunantl1dn vne /u:rrio tefpeaiuo.,. 'qwa net 'in wrm:l,litatc fcrpicicndi; &, re1adonis :lduruntur,' led . impcrmixt;£ 1 & incDnf[JC~ . p(!fma~cot (I~b, ~ppdbttoric rcladonis ;,~CUt, ~JmfcrnUXtllS. eertIIinatibnes h:lb~n:q lice III vno rerno datllr.ad~~ nado', q~i~ hoc quod el~ CCtCi?ID, fanat a,~q~lIt quod ti:ec{it. fo'm;ilHc~ .P~t:r~tas ~ nee !plraElO~ fed; aliud 'tCl'titlm' cl1ll0crlter eonnnens Ilia duor 4ilod; ell fallbrn j~dia ilia eadem '(C5, r:lat~ua ~or~ tt\ilUe't 'eft partrtnras, ~ fo~~alitCf (p~3tJ~,hc~t erititatiuetlt vbu~ktermlll:ltJue plutts relauones. -i!,lt Q!dbu5 parct'turn ad cationem. dubitandi {u-. p~a prcpolita.m.in, initio' ~Ilios diffieulraris, ~un1-ad aiodua Datandl. &Scotl. .' , "",

9 'J\d tatioben'l' dUbita.ndi dieimr quod multi-

3 plic~to i,rife~6tirti~ldflic~tur Fu~e:ju!, fi m~ld? p~crtut. infet'~5 teal,iter; IlC cntl~IU~. ~olke~o; ti rilllidphct:'"t Inferius (olllrnttrmln:l.tluc;& no end~at~ue ~,rlego':~!lati~tJC5 aUtCra fpir:tioniS,& pa· ~emita[ls rliultlplll:~nmt rub :lppc:llatlo~1: fo,ml!inJtenriinos-.non (ecnndulll oppoJitlonem re;l~ Um;aut limitldO!icm. v nde nOn entir4tiue, fed l6rJl1ln~title J\\ultiplicA!'ltur.Ex boc :ttttem non (0'qUi!ur qt10d lint pilites res ,fed quod ... na resrelilchia in cnetci hnbcat ykCIJ\ ph.riuro J & lit relatiil~ multiplex ad diuet(os tctminosproptct infinif:!tcrn .: litiu.li~ (ua!, \It eiplicafuin cft. '

, " Sec in tl.at 0 [JUttdIU fqU~ fi he drcr,C;ldem relatiClalcc:rctltt bif. 8c 'habcret in teplur~: tctmilids Bd:i!QL1.itQ; • quod tepugnat,quia rdario'c(fa\H:t1itei: Ie habi!r ad tctmimlltl : ergo varialo h:rmi..; no' fpccilke ) va'riatut' relado. Non ergo r.-u:c:t~ ni[ds ~ qu.t tcfpicit Filim1'l ad:tquare; ~ rpir~..; lio ., q u~ r'tfpiciE S ptrltUln S. pot[unt ctIt vna.rcs

l'iI3rili~. feu vilHelatio. ,

, ~ Sed mellc Rl!fp. ex dUlls, qu ad eadern re .. liirio fub appdbtioric. lk formalir:ue relationis -qllit ell: :u1 ierminUI1l t nee dicimt his t tiCc habet plures ttrrtlinos ;l.da:qll:uos, f~d diRingllitln: tet'~ mlri:uili~ iuxr:t dillerfos rerminos ad qo.os tendit! Eadem Qtn~n rts relatiu;i. • fa limirata. non fits nee oppc(itioncm realem habc2t, bene: poten: diuct(os tettbin05 inter fc: nen QPpofitos t nee mri'datiiios ,re(picerc'. qu~ ob (iii c:minenriam emnem it)ius gCl\cris ~ebrluj pc~feaionc:m. &. (pttilicmonem in \ina ~hritJtt habet. EE fie ~d argttmmfUIn; Rdj(jo clfemialitct fc habet ~ remtinlilll , ceneedc ! Ergo v;l1'ia[o termino fpcalice. v4tlatur rd~rio, -dillinguo i vari:uo tl:[millO {pedBeo ... ~ianit !."c4tio fir tit liJIlitara ad j]IOm ternlinum in fUl tIItjtarc. u:mf~at ; 6 lit in~ iblra" 6! iIlilhiuta, nego.H~cenim non diua:'n6catmdtatCrn; ni li in vi oppoCiiionis • q,Uil in vi lilllirarionis,non potcll Vndc cetnl'lte oppofitil)llc . lic~r fermini lIaridltUfi emita$ J;'c:li.tiu;L non multiplicttur.

Ad IDouuaDutandi.

40 Ad prlmlUn neg~ur antec.;:dens. Aa prob:uio- 1J.etnRdp.a1iquos adl1lina-e ilbsn pr~diC3rioncm. P~ttmiE:b ell fpiratio > propter idcptit3tctn in elfe let , UCi1t propter eandan idcntitatcm ldmimtgt 'quOd ~tdia. ell Sapienti:l ~ vd elt: iullitia. Sed mclj~\~/~hom' camncgllt i;,bil~'1'J2,.iift't. J,oul.~.qu~nubl feC}~!t~!~ C:liet,'& In{c~fm:s.Si'' it!t ~U1JJ>ln~itit ; "ftI~ln,!"" tJ~d .u ,ri/1111_ P""1tt1~ If mnb1Jt~ {nflf',f" ~od C:lI:cmplum non Ft~Scoto lJa,u".,.otl'I.:I..qQIa 1,. "',trib"f.m eli: "1IOnlm f~ inu:ntioni$,1k 3fpelLir: Cuprn. cbn~~ nofuu~ ! quo dillin~~ cODclpiliWs ~.D!Dh peife~tlem dlWD3m ',3b ~!:I,:A~ vera parCnlit~ •. ~ bOn {UIlt!lO!nl~."umuoni5 ~ I1ec' apFlJw COIlCq!nIS nofuos dillin.ao~~ f~d fiJqt UomiJt!

, DiPirfon;s;dJl;tniJ:

rellfit~ b'"nic\lgltpi€ria;&"c;Ergo ncue ill:! :tel iit-~ uieem pi'zdiantur. ita&illi propter id!:,ntitatcl'n1' rei v:miuiql:lC l'cpc:nam;S e4 ntrn:J eft fDlutio,Cl[elll~ pl{lIllqric: D. Tho,Lice-t mim''Fi:jtio fit nomen rd. {!(, non iE:cundz :lntenEioni,;tameD ~ propria i at fo{m~1i tatiol1(: faa :alfmkcultl appellationcm(u,; pt~ termini'l, ee qu-oarcIatio in hoe propric clilFet~ a reHquis geMrlbu5 • qui1 n~n DidCdr sd (e-,fe.t adtcimilUj,,?,Q~ate dun~gnilie<ttlb t~nlJi~i (t:~Pi!~ funmur In (00 fotnuU knfu, ligndicarlo ctlaill termini retariul (umitltrfub formalS. fctnfu~ &~p-'! pcU3doilC ;;drenninlllfl;&c:um rub iIla:ippellao; done'n'on: dcrut idendtas, fed diucr6raidnt~r ,(e" Jatltine-!h plternltatIs f 8G (piradonis, corv(eqUl!l1tetl fub hac 'appcJl:uione no'ti.:{it ptltdiario 1 proptd! eandem t3tioDcltl, qua !ton BE imer'antlbuIum i1J.!. tlitj~i~ mirerk'(ltdi:e,prOVE tignlncmtlir (LIb nbil mille iitEributl , oem quOd l'elationcs ill:2: unr no. m{nii.fecundadntenddnis, [cd qlliaimpottan' ap.;! pcll:moflem [llam , & fo[tna!cnl (C:I1Cum [L1per ree.l. minos dU\in&s) fi(ut iI1a IlmibUtll CUpet co!iceptui diftiitll:as, Si amem' termini ~:r;ttahantur 'lIbil!a appell~fione;' & lignifii:arion~ formali , ttinanrnr:' Lllle ad CenTum emnino idcnticuiti , ptttdiclldd eritveta,vt fi dic:asPatemirutelt: reS 'lItE eft(plt'l~ ri(1.CUtn lIt1tcm volumlis predlcare a,itllmtlll nod .poret!: ~c fignilic.;lr~ idl:nrit~ri:mtdican~~jBOi1ld!i cil res qUal ell r.~pllEua.(cil l:[l1mli Jimphc:uer prlj. fer~tur • Bonita; en fapicntia , pr:rdibrio ell·vera; qUIll. Cl\i1t lint mhjiii111 'abColuta. tanmin pr;tdiant pcrfi:l!I:ioccm Cui. \It eft in {e &:: ad (t,tion Vt (t hal. her: ad 1Iliud in quo apptlbtur diilinaio.Et idtd r.t_.: none fui: fighificationis:, null,l. ell: ttplign5da quod pr:tdicentut ad inui~knj q_lla: tamen ell in ~elado.: nlbus ptopIC:r ;!.ppctl~~ioncll'f filpta,: diJtirlli:os ~ct.; Ittinos;& i'dc:'o ,"agi~ affimilatul' ilia pri:dlcatio JUi. propo!iticnib1l5. AttrlbutIJltlbpiC:Pti:2 eft ;lntibu~ tUffiiilil:iriz,&: liiniliblls~\'blimpomtut app,:UOIrio :td dill:indos conc:epnu:.

Ad Iecundurn nl:g~l[ur qllOd P;ltt91itA5'.& fpi,:" 41 ratio .h3beant inter f¢ ordiliclh originis,& proccf~ fionis fl:alis.c.lun vna no prot~d;..t lib aliajllcet eniIU arnot (piUtU$procl!d~ icognitione,~u vctbo~~;;' men volunw non pro'cellit,ab intcllcGl:u,fcd id~ flini:,&,co(cqumter neque (pitaao ad:ida a gate,:il!.: none :l&iU=l.qUll ilb duo vt tdiua,l.lo haherit intci'

fe ordinclll origiuis.ncc oppo(u:ionem. QyOd vera vohuuas Pl':£[llpponat ;nt~ilcel:il, hoc no e(l (~eljn';' dum 6rigin~ te:i.lem,Ccd {ecuud\\m otditJe r.trionis.

Ad tcnium Keep. in dil1ini~ non cffe pro}lriz di· 4l.' ffinltione fpecificam,nec inter rclationes.nce infet ar[l:ibDra,quia vbi non ell gl::mis.nec\:.!l diffnmtia;

ju;c (pedes.fed diciitut aliqua fpec:ics.vel {pc:d6ce

fe ha!;ere,quia ad modli diucrfnllffi (peciC:riicoli.;. cipiuIltUr~ vt m;(critordlii.. & inllitia,boniEas~&: (a .. pi~ntia;Ccd in Dt!Q ifta non (I': ~abenr v[ (pedes di~ ucr(ot,quia nop (Ilndimii:atz)[cd vt aaus: pilms v- . i1ic.us.& fimplicillimlts oroni f~cici fuperelnines.

& infinite omIi~ perfcdione codnnells.'CUib ;tUte dicihlr quod e:! ql1re" {pede dHlinguuntur. tC:itirct diffemm,dillinguo,quz (p'tde diQinguunrut for':' maliter.& Iimitir~EflUl(c:J,nqli~ fpecic d.iA:inguiit\ir Coli! cminttcr.& viriuaUter.teuer:i ~Ute,.& entrr;l.~ dLia fuo', VIlUS :l.thiJ p~*&:'in6niEa cn'rit:l.$,no df~ fiinguii~k "aliter .~ifi ~erlleniar r~iS 0rpo6~o.

. Ad vltun~ quod pro (cntentiaScoi:1 Vi'get,uf,kpe 4" re(pon(umeftq~odfrzdi~~'~!iqU?d ~icidc: ~~~) ) quod non dellio.nollrgnltdllhtJ~honei pmerd; &~tit~. (cdfoh)tn virmalcm,'& ~~talE:fliffii:it enim quOdmm f~tb omni rcnfu.& 'fo't'* malirate n6 identifketllt,lici!t 'crtdrlrln,iHini orlmi- ~~ nO. Vnutil. • lSI: idem;'&'uc bon difiinguailtm (itma--

, 'llitt

\

!jt«inhi.Cunt cnUD 'przdiucia6ar Ccculldii'(erts(i f('lfm~lq'iJ quem {ignifican~;Ec:rmil'!i. non {c,udi\m idcmit;ztem entiC;tiiliarn quam hlibenHn~e;luJji~j~ ~ pr£dic~ndllm de: :diCJ.uo 'Inurn przdiarum.&: non 3liud"lifi:illdio iJliI \"irtualif. fcu non i d.C:il[ifi:~ i:atio Cub ill3: ratione .1ict1t in r,= CU!irilliU;l idcmifi~ Qlltio 6t;6cllt edam dic'imus.ql:ldd, C'lfemia non g':': nera.q&: p~'er genc:n[.li~£ eadem enriras fiE parCl"} '" clfcmi1l1id enlm qUod.de HHs dkimU$; ~ ["pr;1I diximof.dicc:ndum ell ~ tclationilM fpimionis, at pacc:m itatis qlilllltUPl ;111 Cmit3lem Cuam.

44 ExdiCi:'is r.2£et latin; patere: not/one's, 'lUam re-

JlIt!one'j& reiltriollc$ qlJ~m PfiJptiewu::. in,dillinb. Qmriej c!hiiri ptopric:utcs fUnt' rc:lariones,ftqutdem propricratc9 (unr fotmz conlliruc:ntc:s petfonas; & Ul~ pc:ttonaic:s £riflli~ rclariones fUIl~ quia rcluiu! eppo{ir<tivtpou: diftinGh'IJ.Sed.non emnes reb,tit,. nes I:OnltiEUunE pc:,fonas j. IX; ita non (unt propric::~ Utes i ih::u£ {pi.ariO' a.!tiua. en i'eJ;nio (pir,uaris ad SpirUbm S.fcd non eonll:iEiiir puConam, '1uia non eft ii1commlinicabiJis parn •. lk Filio,fi:'d vUUin ell ellln lllis j Be ft~ lion Iu~ pn(onam ftotfum ~b il~ lifo ,Drones t~~rn rdmond Hint notiones .• f:jllia ' pceIlUllntc:! notilic;mt peno~; !elation~s,quldciii fcrConal"i~(uas proprias pctfoniH_qual conlHtuullu Spituio 'Ufcm;~i~.~d.c~g1U,p~~Ji.uGm Pct'A {ooam , (cd PCCUbll(eprmapuJIIl.nOtlODale. quod ell ill d ua~uf p~rtonis.~ illli etiamnorifieat vt op". (Jo{iw:.&: difCioh a 5piEim S.lie!t nOli VII' oppO" ntas infer fc.Non. tamm (lmnes notioncs CUBE Eda~ &iones. 'It PlltCt de: innaU:ibllitue,quz nod"at pri~ mam pctfonam 'It pritmm;{eu in quantum non:dl: 2 principio. ,Nee 0portcr pilltes holionn ;ld4ae~ quil! Ii qu:c: funt ;dia nomina noriomlia. in iais in·

. dliduritllI.&rd illa. 'It ad principalia redueumur. PctfCm.llilrdn. vd t:el2no i:liuinain COlDlUMi nen dl norio ~_ fed przdicamm '.!l'mmuu(: indll(um in panicl1bribu$ notionibu5,non aurem cxplicaE prepriam ,anaiJem iimOEcfcendi pCffDlUf .IiC1l' dicit ddiDido nouolli!"fed (olnJJlUnCIQ.

.: J!~ .. r .

-·r ,.

J

-A R. TIC V L V SlY; £itwliiiIJa jitv;n,ili'm itDiBinilnM Jignijicni/ili/Jfis 'viJifi;~em,irtl p!JlTli/~ '. . 'tlf/eW}fom;l'eifl1lJ,;lIlt R{,~ '".

. ft~nllin iTl4;'ainill

ETiaui -ad 'uononum explicatio-orm pmiPrt dif~ cernqe:sq Domod" nOJninibUt iRis vtmdumut in diuinis. 'N~m ex jndcbiro yfu raliom nominum~ contingir CfI;ire aljqlU)~ ,CifU diuin.u Rodoncs. &. Domina. qu~ tmnu:n!lll vd vnitatcm dc:Ggnmt in

diuinis. "

19itut nominj1. qUibos in itm myfterlo ~ti~nr. alia funt fpe.::i:1.ltJ ipf!!!: no~ionu. !lu~. vt dfllimlU. funt quinqne • .znk.p"o«t4. ftabilit;e. Alia qllZ, ipiis norioniblls fcu perfoni~.aUt idarionlbas adinoguu-. rur, ~ .Gg,oiD';lI(C p<llfunt :vcl ... niEat~ in D"co.vd pluraljflltcQb, ttl jjngularit.:ltc:m~ au~fQlitu~~

aut exJ4nliuatn.Ycl ali!1limilia. ,

Cira nomina ddig~nda jpw norioliClj {ol~m vna difficulru ClCcllnir. 'qp-omodo kil. pontndz lint il(lrion~ in l!blhla:o~"ilH::ollaeto lP dJuinis; ~ quid,pomt 411: illls ptwdinri in abR~tl:o ~ qltid III (onacto.NoriollU cmlD funt fiomm:J in ilIbfiu-. ¢to fump~a.(cil.iJla fo~ {en nota., qua \'t ratione f~nn~i jnn~tI:rcit lIobis. 8c dillinguiEur propria aliqua tariop"(cJD~. vf:patenli~4iliario.~c. Pct:fe~ YuoiDe~"ilo DQIl'-flUlulOnones. CCQ rC$

" ;

ilia: 'qltz' notionibu; innatefcnnt., Hine Otta, eft

dHTcnlioJn duebus. ' , ,. , ",,,;;

P~lnl.lIn;M{int diLHnglic:nda ilb Goncrc;a. :BF

1I~;i!r3ctHndiLlini,. """"" i; ~ I '"

SCCtinoom q~id poait,:zppllcari. &.przdi~id"C

abJitlia-i$~&;'qnid de (:onttct!s., . .,,'. t.: ~ <:: -r.

. . G;itca; ~mumtP0nimp\.vnam regllJam:Danqlt :1 in diuinif abtl:raa:1~ k;concreCll ,(010 Dofito modo Ggn!lk~~di diue~' j n~n .aurem dium.Eiltcm ·.ali", qllllmr,~*'m.reu.i paJ:re lei ~pa~Eerci 6gnlfi~~,fC indli¢Untl , . , . , . 'fi" ~ ,',

Priorem parurD huiu$ "gld~ tltgauit Przpo(itiuQs,iJi: itl:a dillin!tio abtlratli,Bc cdm:ceti.diuinz ft~pli'irari pra:iudicarer" COIlCtil 'luciD agit: S. "fh! hlc fj1l. , 1."7'1.2,. , ' , ' .. - : e, . '."'!' ~fl , pgJlc~orelJt pancm neganir ,A'lfc:oJIIJ .pud Gaprcoilim in ,.a;p.lfi. '& apild ~aieEi in h;t_l/rh 1. cliltimaD5:diRinelioficmabllratU. ~ c(inilr~i ali'lU,am:dillerfua.,u:m induterp,es, pam: fci 6gn~ £icat~; &' nonfO'hlro eX'ParfC modi figllilk~ildi,. qUi;l alias 6. (olum eX pam: mo~i fi8nifi:G;in.dh9.Ct lIinsueJ:cfi£UI; j 'luidquid YC:ijlicirp~ de vJle .. 'ferm~ caIctnrd(:lIlio., :;,,:,' " ,";' ~:;.~

Sa! ,Yfflunque eft flllfumdii pdmgm",.-:qitj PrZpoGtiuum,co"tlat. !qllia·iIi 'Pe'optot'cdinul' iw:la, l1011nlm, modum iOl.cUiS,odi pri£'{ciode(j~ &. diuidelli:!oj& i:ompQn,ndo~q'Jla'vnko 6mplid intuitU neon p,;dJ'lImUs ~m.;~ca~ OJ:mpreb~~"!I;~ Cumautem In Deo IIlUJ:Dlatll( _& umpJIc;J!1im. forma.quianibH eompofilJQPis, babel, &: "'ompkri~;I. , Ik I1bfoiuliffima .iubfuloti;t in {c jndt~ dens, &; incornJ:nunicabi)i .. hllbet: & p~tMiOJi£m luppoliii 'ompJc:te {ublill:auis, & 6mpHciwi:tiJ formz:.Ergo pofi"umin iftOl conC:Cft1l1.dmiduc." inrclligc:t£ ill diuiQltllrC id '1l1od eft forID2 ad m~ dum fOrIDa'.& fuppofimm ad modlSm ha;beiliis II!J'I1n t & Iii:: fOfmUn ad modum (OJmz (cGundlJm fc conli.:icriltam vocaJn1H'aQl1fa!!lUfJI • (oppolie:unJ vcro .. (cuid quod eft 'It (ubUHetli • k Pc:'t m(ld»m qIlq4.6gniliC:fElIr.vG.clnn~~ COnCiCiUIIl. ~~e: Nf; IiOIl nugis dcrog:lr limpli'lt.lti d'uin:. qu1m ipla dillindiO anrlpmotllln • qua: diilinguilnUS- ob impc:rfc:aionclD noltiOWItt conccfI!lnm non valenrium ilb,m c:inipcntiffimarn p«IctlipnCIP vnico modo.6cut ibfcctftaaingere. _' ~,.','c: •

, E:t hoc anEtm deduciuli: per emdem C(in{~ ,. riam,'lau\d liellt ill ptJrdiCdiis :ibfQhni$ , &' IwUt • t!juinadillinguinlriU:e concepeus qua,&. t]flfa·. a,.

tie fornu: co-nili[UCluis.&:: nrin-habrntl$ fDtJIlllllJ,

ita in I;onecpm pnfonz .lFi,IA!:'9,quod p«(oAitlt:

&: nononaie dh, v(C'tquc c:oncepnls diiiingui:}'O;'

teR: I;om:mi) :& .ibfiralti. ,~jJ(,"HJ~uj.,crWD pc:tfooa ipCa rcbriUll~& fubfiftms peironaliru.co. fiiluiturinratione ralls pet{on~ i '" idcO;jliueuitut ibi}& ratio~e9ntli,u~&::rcH~onlliturai ~ in qui.lUID'I!oncipirut Vt eontlituta p.t:f(ODa. & vt: Iffl6Ji dicatli( {e~:Jiglli6cefllf pet mooum, .con"cti •. in quanrul'llve,;-ocondpimt VU4tio.,&::; fCifDlU'(l;Gili" menS pc_rfQniUb in elfc fcbcilJo f~tfQJJ;Z' • rCj~ di

ip(a p~tfoJJl"lius.lignifi«(ur in abat~q • .s;"V(.,.~

fell vt fODm pcrlODalis.G~ .. pa~~tgs'.lili~tio,&c. Sp~, c~ir,ef vcro. !tiIlq, ~i£,. D:.J.~., i~ ".rt:t,'1'~,1.~

~ f~t .. pe:e«,!,lIm,ddl~~ m,. diUlnlJ.p~G~ IDs.tUm qunfult nccciIiWUfD!C:Spliw¢sli' 1i~~ care idin quo perron%: (ulltvllii;i%;id.iD 'quu (rulE: plurCJ:dic:im~ ~i~'pcr(~n~ !D d~raEc.&, ea:qnti~ " dfc vnunt. & m ~(f!,naJ.rllilbu$ 'eu tdauonihtn~ IfC$. B.ede ~t,o tignificanl.urpomina iftzrdatiua

in &ban.!to ~ 'It JigoiDrmiur ,(o'tmz.ICuIiUionf. m~jup'J1a~i pedoDas ;' AUIl quia !DlllEoiwi vita pmona. v. g.p,"cr rc!pica'c dUlli pcrfoJW, WI.,ftJiIlID~&; SpiEiwIIlS.& di~~~ ~b"vua'iuc:"~j ngo

R J ~CJl'~

§2}£4ft.%X IX, ei c ~ rJ)'H'rjtmu. djllj~;i.

{ubfitlcntia. [eu per(onaliw fumpra in ablltaEto: " neque ell:: principiull1 ~gendi vt fJu,a,& in COO(:1'C:4 to,quia (igni6carudnab/fraa-o,nc:que ve qUtJ,& vr forrn;Lleprincipi?lII,quia no~ c:ll: vjrtU5~&iaiuiras natUr;e 1 fc:d Colulii ell tenmnus, {ell mcdas com. " plens p~turam,vt ag~t, tJDqU.1m (uhfille~:ergo ipn (i~ in abR:r;u,:to non poteA: tribal adio ,ne figni6c"," tu~I:'le.principillm 'JIW agc:ndi,feu fotMa.&vinui qua agens agit:id enirn figlli6cattir per princlpium '1"/1 attionis,&' illud quodiil abftra&o {i"gnificaEUI: agc:re,6gnHkatur vr forma,& principiulil 'JillI age4 di, Vndc)i concederetudfta p~(1pOfilio. Patemitas gc:neot,df« Cenfus quOd p3ternita_~ til Jd quo Parer gCI1 erat,(cu ell: rado gcncrandi,q';lod ell: falfulSl. Edi, Iicer pater,& p:m::rnit.l5 fint idem ex p2nq lcoi tignilicllr..e,c:x. patu: camen modi lignilicmfii intcruenie ulis f~rmaliru (eu appdlatio, quod &Uilica,. (ur, ~ropo6riOf in c:i~f i:lli~ ve~ilicationc: ttiam n .. r;ndiu,r modus ligntlicandl. 51 aUttm rcmouOltUt modus ~bl1raa:iu ni5~& fnllilaliras !ignificandi. Coh'lInque in ftoru idClllic:o dicatutt Res quz: eft p~ tcrnirai gcnerat,vetl dl; propolitio.

, itatio vera fc:cublb! regulz ell:; quia pr:t:dic2tio 'J ilb furubUJr in idlmtitatciWnt anum ornniee idtsn

in diuinis abftr~aum. Be GontrCtum • dl"tnd2lia,&: pcrro~aJj.a:ergo r.a'!~nc: talis idcntiu.rls .p~tCrit ft~d pr;cdlc:mo,cUtn Ibl non obtl~t appdb~o illa atHoni5.qul'.c:i: fonnau modo lignilicandi, quando attrib1.*nr form:.: in abllna?lignt6c,uut ilI:un dre principiuIU'IHD agcndi,[cu id '1110 :i.gens agit.quod

de fllbl(!h:ntia (en perf(Jn;llita~e 'Il'Critic:ari non p.,. teJl~qlli.1 follim c:1l con dido rc:qui6E.l ad agendum.

(ell modus , aut rerminus ~ DQIl forrmlis ,~o. lie: ~tlilljE35 CC:1l .... ittUf.

~inrcttog~mu, ,quo diffect Pater 1 FiJi!). & quo a ,Spiritu5;qao rc!picic Filium,& qll~ Spifjtllm ~.,,~ :ponc~ allignate formdicate$ (cu ilO'IOne!~. qUlb~s id "gnifjc:crur~ /3( C:lIprimatUr.oC:l1Ipc.~uodp~tcnu:weditTett 1 Filio~&; fpiruione a. Spmtu 5.

4 Sel:undllJ1\ "ero probarut contra~ Aureoilim. " ~!lia iliuina founa ita ell petCe.&. in (~CJCj!l:e$,'luOJ I!ftrcddatur conc:rcta,&.vt qUITJ,non mdlgetahquo He diltind:o,Ced Ccipfairruncdi~c ell: qil~; & 1"IT1. quia in Ie cit omni1.l~pe,fctla,~ In !tdu PUlO {ccudum ~ffc. Be {cC:l1ndum modum (UUIn. Ergo vt 11- glJifi~c[ar in abll:raCl:o,& ip c:o?cretO ~ vt '111~, s: ve '1M~ non indigeE diuedi~tc: allq?l a p~ .c:1 ~gi1i1h:at~.(cd c.1_dCln emnmo res 111 {~, &: 10 fua h~ nea verumque ob fUlm perf,;dilIilnaltl radonem includens,nolho modo ,ondpic:ndi.6C ligllific;tn~i p(.rci$~ dilJiditur ,. &: diLU:rCO ilIodo concipitUE ill ilbllraao,& in Concreto, Nee oblb.t,qubualiquid atwbuimtlSiftil forrnis in concrete, quod non in ahlhaao ; id enim non ~!tproprc:t diucrtitatem rei flgni6c:atot ,(cd ell: pme modi tigfiili'andi~qui edam: attetlditur in ve'riJicatione pt.opolitionLlnt:lit enim \fcrifiutio. &. pra:dic~tio iusta nollnuJl modum toilciplcndi.Et [uffidt· cmtnentia \'nius "I, quIZ ~quillaletmultis ld form~nda$iJlu diuedasprzdica.rione5 in (con(u fonnall ,Iid:t VilUIn.& idem Gnt In idcntic:o • Vt fzpc di',l:imul.~gendQ de dHliila:ionc::

IInributorum,&: perfol'urum abttfc:ntia.Et fi qU:E'tas,quid ~lprifl1at nomen ab[tQtht{l\".quid concretum ~ Rt:(p.quod abCl:r~allm in ill:1 ftlrm~ diuil1a• qua in (c ob tuam peifClctione inliniEain dl Q140Jt &:'III~.rolltl'l!' c:w:primh munlls forll1~' & ratiorum nU\i~,oll1itrenao modlim Cuppo1it!.fcu {ubtii1:en· tis • &: habcntis illam vt ,1t~J. Conctttlim autcrn cxprimir e~ndcm ~a(Ui~m cum mo~o fubli!lcmdi.

&: hlbenchlc:u clnllendl vt qJllld: ' '"" .

1 " Relbt (c:cundUltl,qllodc:itea hanc diaiculratem propofuhnns.clIplicatc. videlicet quid veri6cari.& pr~ca1'i po IIit de ifti5 nominibll$ ill ablh.1Clo. quid in C()OCtctol Circ.l quod dllZ.tcgulz: a«ignart fol~nt. " " , .

Pl"iitla~Ad:iones.vel prodl1aiones lignilic.atle pet modum adionis nOn polfunt pt%bi .n: rd;ttlQnibu! ,& notiOllibui in :lbfuatl:o t bene tamen ia ccncrere ; hent ilb nlln ell: bona pr:tdiatio PatcrnitQgc:nmt; filiar:io fpir •• 6liatio gc:n~aEur ~ ilb autcm przdicuio eli bona.Pi!t~r gC::QCtac. filius ge~ nemal.

. Secund;l, regulaJP(opo6tiones Ggni6nncesnon atltonan in vi at!liollis/e:d conuenitnUam.&: idcdtatem Y"niU$ id altenl.iU.~quc pr;edicanturde abRraClli,2cdc concrtlis. Jli(i pt.eili<:i:t'lr Vna rclado de Mter".: talis c:nim prOC"dicatio . (~iUpct" eft fal(a. EI~ pritni:P;arernilas ell: pner. vel dlDcus, 'I'd elt dc:itu,& fil'llile5,ompc$ funt VoelZ. ElIcmplii fecundi: PaEccnias dl: fpintio a8:iua •. ell: falr~, Vt fopr;' dix:iInus F«,hnti 471.Mnlto magis f;d(a ell. 1.i:V1ill. reIario przdicetur de: Cua oppo6ta. • 'Il't pata~ dl: 6liano ~ ba::c: tnim non (ol~m c:JI: fal(a,Ced ~'1l1ia deftrui.t my!leriu!l1. Vuaquc rc:gula fumltu~ns.TLomainhMIJ·Jz..Mt.tM1.Ybineg:tt ~dionanlbui notionibus in :lblUaOo. 'ft p.a~ 'fcm~ gl:l~. tttcrDitaS qcn:polfc ralncn pro'~cr ~~ndm~rl\bl\aDtil1l perton~lia.& cJf~nda-

'm. dla de noponi'bu" .

,. Rario prim"! r~~ I~~A: • quia. aQionu non po!f~c Yer~ atuUiuI t nt~ ftlnC:ipiil "pc:rariais. . Pnnapium autcm opCC:md1 m CQflqetO &: Y('1I1•d dHp(umfupF~m (eu fubfilkns.1>rin::.piu ope_ , ~i Vt 9W~dl forma~qu;t eft ratio. a&cndi.~ po:"uneudnatUt,l.m.1ett vlftUlcm op~,IiCUt ioCC':I'ltau dicimll1' intc1ligcte)vol~evell~. At Veto.

r", '

, "

bid ,it llliil nDminibll4 ftgn;.ft&~"'ihu

plllr IIMAt em vei''lm#lJte,,?

. Ciru [ccllndum puntlum huius anicl1li, 'on~ , d~ui debene ali~ nomina, ,qll~ notionwul folent" ac:liungi,Cc:u pcrCQIIis.& pertinent ad vnirar:em,plu4 r~litz[em~ vel folitudinem.aut exclulionear , lieu!:

Pattc:rn, e(fe aUum i~i\iq. I?~um ~1I'c: fulp~t dIC Tonum.&c:. de qUibll$ agit S. Thorn.;,,- '1., c. S!lIlt auEem quatUDi:" ordines (en c:iaJft5" homtil rerminorum. Q!!idam pC:E(inent ad. idcntitatc:m,vd :Weta.. tclll ei oppDfitam • Vt hoc nonien r atm. i1mu.hoc:. nomen .d'kJ.lI~i"J.&c. Ali;. pc:rti.~ent ad liugulariratem) 'It ly <fJI1fCItl,fIll/,.i'illl'14. AbJ alIc:xcluliOncm. VI Iy SaJlI4,'OInt;Jm, Ike. Ali; ",d mnltiplidtatem,{k dill(:ffiEuem ,'Vt dilln{lIm,djjfoTlnl .IFinlil.'riflt~~ mH1Jiplf:c~l5c.1imilia.Fiunt ergo qUatlloucgula::.

Prjriu. regula dl: Nomen .!Jm marC-Dline ad- , iungitur per(onis, IIQtl vero aliud nc:uU'aJirrr (eu (ubltirillil. E conrra Vera Iyvnllmrublbntiu~ cetta dic:irut de pcdonis) non 'tim" maCculinc,nifi adiungatut tr~inus t{ahe:ns ad naturam diUin:!:, 'It cum dicitur Pater, &. Filius runt ... nUS Deus: lignili(:ltllr enim Vnit:ls in diuin;tnamra. Eadem modD 10tJ.uE~ durn c:ft"de hoc;: nomine: /Jnn.qlloo. maftUline non amib!titur pnfQnis", nifi adiungatur illc: ti:lruinQJ 'Dnp • vt cum didtUf (unt idem Deusjnc:urralirer tUEem attribUitur iIIis abCohml. CautJtlf timen YcE-

dii c:1l bo, nomine itkm~ qulm hoc nomine ,",UtIl: tum quia ~dcm \lcx:e,.&: rcnninnione "pronuncia-

lIlf n1a{culin~ • & ncuU!ilittt : rum qllia c:ft nomen teh.rilllim.& refert fuum antecedcn$, &. poted ali~ quando referre idem in pllr(ona, & ell (,Ilfum , vd

ill n~tun.& ell ver\lm~, Ike ttgu Ia dcCumiun ex D:Thom.b1f q.JI.m.l.~amque de[uillpfir es Aug.

de foI~ d PtITll1/f r.z.Et in SI;nprura didtur de boe DOm1nc: .Aliw,RDgllw PIUTII1HlIl1'm.'; idillm fM~"

dillim

\

Dilfflt41io XIV-

di,,,m .lAhit 'II~bl!j loan. 14.& icerom Ioafl.f. Aliifl 1ft '1l1i t~flil1Jmitl ptrhjbl~ M me.at de nomine vnim <dkilU~ 10.;1.11.10. Egu, & P"w' flfium {l4mIU • & f~ loan. f. £1 hi trf41JIlJIr1J {11m. EdlOC ideo eft. quia nomln. neueo fignHicamr aJiq\lld magis cOllfu. fum.&' Ilondum formi!.mrn .nomine aurem m~fculino :lliquid Itugis fortn~tllm.& dillin[tum. Bt quia ptoprium ell:. CLlrpo{hi~ felt perCon:t difringm::re.& tlEinl(, complere J ncrnina maCculin;.& 1?3gis am-ibuuneur Pccrioni'l,neurraTiu:~ aueem n:ttUCIr. ve non ;;~pli'liC (ilppOIiC .• rlenem. Ad d~llgmmdl1m ergo dill:inGlione: in perronis Vtimilt hoc nomine: A/jill mafculin~,&: non aJhibemus hoc nomen IT 11111. ~ Gontra VetO ad fignil:kandufu vnit.atem naturz di~ c:imU$ elI'e filum, & ad euitandam diftjnd:ionem

in narU.iJ neglmus etfe aJind. . ..:

. H ic v er9. (~ olf:rc:bat OC'i_alio difpnbndi an vnitas. leu utio vl'li~ ~i'~t d~ form~li :!liquid poii~ riuum, vel =tliq.u:II~. neg"ri,0D:m.collnoratldo fliGmlum.qltod al!qm In prZICDrI dlfpmant,(JccaUuD; cills~i.lOd rr:a.t£ D.Th"m.i1i f40.",r'{.~.~n (crmini Dllrncrales p()naDf aliqllid in Deo polirillum. ali nl:§adUllm ,.an ;lliqllid (IImptl.lill llpcci.: numC:l.t, qUi ell 'l1J<lmit;u.:ln a ~ul(l,uJIIl~ qu.t: dl r\.lnf,r;. dl:n1~ScJ Ilui de bee cglmnf pr.wld./I'mu tlrc .. fl. H. difP. H.tVt. h vbi I,IIi ol1cr.dimus u O. Th.qllC)d licet VIJLlm Illin Cuper' ~dd.lr chti,hili n:g.uiol1cm. carnc:n fOflmllU:r non conliftir IIl.CO folo quod [11- peraddit: • (cd .in ipll r !)litiu:J ratione emu Vt con-

aeeanee negniollcm diui (ionls. •

It" S()ium pone, en;; diffi~ulms circa pluuJir2t~m vnk1fum in perfon/so quid ifil£ vllit.lrc~ multipliciHI. in' dluillis • fi'lilidc!n efl de lidt: dl~ in Dee m:~ pctfon:li, 1.1tt;ln.vlrimo; Et him:; 'VnH'IJ [Hnt :j1LlI~ ~iplic~rp aDtCln ;liqllo num.:ro.vc1 pli1riBl;at1'tl1i~ t;tc ~ vidttur dan in il1i~ flUi. & mimu. qlJ!~ plus Cunt ~.rC:J.qual\l '1DUm,VC duo,ralu:m enllnl1uc.~ ,on(('l~t:o~cr J;fit ali.qua ,.om.polirio. non per mo~hll~.'fIl.'OlfliilUtCQD1I1DGlil;JiUS,(c:d per lIlodUni 111,,m!:ri.q ... iaille(~mariU$ nUrnCtIJ5 pedonarum (;001- po~iRlr e;r pluribusY;nimlbus ~. nee enim eft lim,.. fl~ vniras : c:(go ell: numerus ex vnit.ldbus reful .. [a~. !\Iiguid .cr&~ compolit u.m.1iilt .. m PC! m.,.ltuu ng:qu:ri in Dco.po,nliUII.!LE~ quo vlu;m'u _(equimt d.u:i ihi r9tU~.« panc:.o;, quia.dltUrcompOhtio ex plu.ribu$.~ e["go d;l.tdr (QUlip,quod eft cumpo(iturn. & p~e$.!init (Ullt pilltcs ynirate1;omli~ autcm totumdi maillS f"~,pan=, &:rutfil~omnis nUmcnl$ ~n(umA' pet vuj~tc:m (~llqlUm p:r aliquid limplici.lU.E.r(c frgo in diuinis maillS. &: minu$'(;dtcnt cX(CnJiLl~.rn~"CllraHlIJ1.& met1fura;qu~ omnlub. furd;t Cupt.&: h;i:jl.liquando SS.P P .rciiciunt munc:'" rum a Jiuh,lls''''t ip. .CoDQlip TO!j!t.ll.i» ~OIlPffilP1' fill" dir.iUl~:Ji~c [A>1lffJ Tri!!irM,lttt rtwlillilllJ1JllI'f,JUC t:3pill~r ~H1.IItf".l~(a,bo~ ergo fJ.~~,jlllt.qlJ~ impcrfetlio iIPP9rtttur in ,puma-o> i qLJ~ dC;P.ClC ~uriliclri Vt pODilJU. ill diuinj,f, ~ .~Q"ibl4t1tr p~. 100;5. ,.

RJp. qqOd flUID '~paJo~ulll in diuin,s (0- l.u.~ da~E peqn vn2~ rmi!~t~. feu QIIi.:ium nom.cri/;il~F-n6di.ui,l. ~re;aljta{emfcb-iU3m.& plu~~lir,l~p)J~t;~c. Pm" ;tI~. iW~Cfn olli,ja qllZ. djq~iod impcffc"dionil imppmnt.vt c:1l cmnp~me(c: YQU ~~ plllribas,3Qdl:r¢ ali'lllid pe~ 3ggtcS";Uionem ill vno. nwncto (upC:,taiJwl ~ mcnfunre qtllha ptr 'fnum.tanquam p~ :a]iquid.limplicilH ~ Iwc ibi Dim inuenicllr. Mult_o p)ill~ a qua: {UlJt prol'da DIlmeriqUillltiutilli~ qu,o~.dl_ 'iu;mtita~isdifac:~ tZ in»~gjll1\!l!r in DlIrri«'",~i:umm,m Fcrro~nnlJ. .. "hluOP .:oil: 4i»jjj.D}l.1: .cfu4«. quOd pel IPtlllipli-:,arion~" 41,11Jlli~ti.aam :.C{e_1~t., ~ qlblUlUflll.P modo -menCII{cnlr,&'c. Qgi er&o fcn;iun~ rc1.nio-

Atlic. JP. t+J

nes in diliiiJis non folum dinngui CC:C"tlfidum rd.~ !i!Oit~s;fcd etiain i rilportate diuerfaJ pcrfc:dioncs,1f(:: di!ler(as cxillemia~ rcl:uiuas. vi:.:: l'oili.mr Ce e~pe~ -aire,qllin in numere (rium.relarionwn • Ceu perColimlm lit ;jgg~egatia. & ,ompobdo pef rnodum roeius , & puris ~ iCi quod !altern e%telJtilJ~ t::refcilt p~rfcd-io rdariua. (fC lion {alum fir plus realiWis • relatill~ in rribus.parDfiis,qll~min du~bus 1 vel in Vila, Ied.etiam pillS pcrfe.ctionis tebtiu:e. faltc:m qlload Iti:renftQnem.qlli.1!uc ;iddu~{up,t i1Jam ali~ 'l'uamptrfC"mo~cm fc:l.Uiuam .• q~z in alia_noll eft. {c:d dn;:t pcrfc:cc.oncs (um. ~ Vbl.d.ltur plus ~.:. tiionis. datnr :ag.gn:gario, Sf. .compoHiio;&: roralt;. EIU j.& pamaliw ~ quia hoc: aggrcgi1Eum uium,dl" qlioddam .forum. at. fingulot vniEat~~ (um: fin.-; gula:.panes milU;lggtc:garl."'qll:Eli~ minot (Ull

ilggtC'gato.quia~~fiJjjH:~.. '. . _. ._ ., H

. Nos ergo. qUI/JO .,mlil· ~lgQf~ Jfitdhg1ffi\B ,!lUG .

[rmboli Athanillij.'jn hllc T,mitlll, n,hil1haiU!jllfll mif1W, edam rdaritH!,.diciroWl.numc-nlmin diuiniS f;!l;cre Jiucdil;irem t~lrnI tela~itliUb • 8& plut~Jiu.,. rem in rtaUutt::. fcd non mailU IIlifjDinUt i nC4!l' addirionem .;ult ;iggccg.nionem·, aut ,oml'0Ji'ia~ ll:rrI. fl'tum ant pOl~~cm • n~Ilt.f'l~alit;lt;m meQoo

fU~;Jbilem per vnum. . . . .... . ..

Karle) ell, ~liia. facae pluralfutem rulcm ell de: coneepm ell"elltiali mlmC"ri.fcU muhhudinu~ptoYi opronitn, vPltad ~ dicit enim ... ni~as indiuiul1Qem in re:l.lirate • kU CD(It.m:. mIlPCU15 ~:m.&: mold. [udo muh::iplicat;&: diuedilkat.Scd (amm quod jl1 hac pluulkl1re • & Jiuedilarc: fcaJi,VIJPIU addu ad alrcmm.& f.u;illt tn:lill~ • & (.c H~. ;iggrcgatio." compoGtiQ,& crm(c:ql1l:ntet J(:fu)," toulm e:\ P4'~ tibu5 , feu pardalibus vnir~tibus depend" n alio ptilll;.ipio,nempe qlloJ dinilio~ &:: milldplkatio M (oJUm fiat in .I"caliute: • led I:Eiam.in ip' c::g'I:iItU,~ 'llt:JjliUC.& pcrfctlionc ~ Ii enim. pci6;tlio dhddi.tur.& ipfum drc, &. namr;b d •• um . .efl:: '1l1ed M&! adilmfu ;dwri facit maius in p~deruotl"'., &: addi~ fup~{ a]i31Jl. ~ 'illia non ell: idl:lll CUm ill~~eti;Jm hi t=() in quo,mcnaimr,maius. &: mihus, KII. penCJ pc:rfeAionc:m.& efiemi;un. .At; vtf"~f,;:b,ioncs; diui_na-: in omni eire.; il1 omni pQ:fetiionc:. in omllJ virmu: ~ &: namra irlemiliC"antur~ & (IInt' 'lnU1U.De~ vDa adciitillteri. Non ergoa mufripJiC:l.rionc:.st ntlm~l;atiol\e tOfUJD rcl"ultat tOtjJnt. & pats;paillft & rninl1S:, m:c . .:!liqQ:1 aggrcgado vdcomP'"ofi'loi quafi addiEione vniamur.& (;rc1canrt quia in nuUu C(c:{cuflt.1i iei QlllJc:I ~ffer. vnum corUIli dl in ak~:"" to. per idcntitoltcm omrlirrto~zm pf~cr oppoli~jonem rdaciuitm inratlolle '~fpeallf: hoe cmm (c:r~ ~lit 014 f~(iend;).m plurali~tCIII in r:alionc:.I"~.lIiRr.is1 fUJI) ,ompolltionilm. & addiriolJC'm in rnion~ ma~ ioris.au~ il) r.atioue pcr.fcllioni5 (J~ ... nJiIl£.& mulw

" tiplicar;J:.;'luaG villi!» U~Ic..i Cupcr affud.& QUIne.:IUS ill~ aggtc:g~'ilm$ jit .. & E:on'poliliUlJ$ .ui,uilJl (O(ius ex pauibU5.Q9arl; ,urn l:ili~do a.due-nit Pa";' tdnir~ri, 6~ pluuJit3S rel:uiI)Pum, & nibil crcri:ig &, i!.ducnicme~pitltU S.nibUJll;1iusclt.quu rOEilm qllQU pqfl.ldioDi5~&: c::Ili;: cd: in yno • c:1I: in dUt;lbas. ~Ut cuibuhqllU in.pcrfcGlione itlcmjlican.pt. .~ hoc dl dfe numc:tum in 4luinis; line illi$ imperfe:. ttionibu5;JleC mrnlimui millritudinc:m per vnlllD; '.IuiHlm timplcxj& iriconfuii:un ell vDUm •. qnl~ plucej t & pli1tcs. q. Il~m vnum .. '. '~fp. id~itI dJ~_~ bc:aor.tIC. pctfedioncm.&1; aUkm ~Piri~,&.;IU'"

mmratio ill ~ IlUmCEo • &. ~¢:tnf~Jyp~ ~~ UI~ eft {olum in nlimcro·~I;I.c:"P~tefliP~

l'c elTe' tl:flml n9IfLCtiUaml1l~, •.• ;;1.' ... ,., .

Q!l:r: J~ari~ dl_eli:ft~ $.I,ho!l1,qpi C,Q~ -11 l"Uunit~. bune numcmm Ii!: poqit ~i1linalmJ ~ ~ dill~(.iia(~ ,~km fxiqlf"41 ; fiuod n~~ additi~

\ nCIIi

Ilem)ncc !:ompolitionern fa,i,,, nee n:i~iil$.allt m~nus (quod ~d muttip.ll~ationem pcrfea:~oDIS pe~tlnellied folulll plilrahur~m''lU4iell:rCllilt.acUn1 multiplicatio. Videti potell qIl4l.,.tk plitt",i .. tlYI'_f. Ita If .... hi ponens :lrgunll:n(utJJ • quoanon porell lbd pluraliras t'ettl~ ~n~ compotitiDne., quod repugll.ar di~inz {j~pllclu~l,rcr~ondet quod 1'1111'4- IiI iii rt""11J Sri J,'HlltU tft plur,dJ1iu rtlAndl1W1J r"bjijltn#sm ~fPlJftlarU11l, t~ Ifrl~ n~rI fiqllitSlf t:'mpoJititJ in !lilli/til. N 11m rtl"do compariJI,s ad ejfintidm di. "i!ulm,M!1 J4fi1" re,{td- Wid"t: fllilm.'!Iflllt lion faci, ttJlflf~Jitiol1f;lII ,~~ ipfa;/kllr lIt:c_bl1llifJII.tIeC ~lilld effinlill/ism 4ur,butarum. Std per r;fJ1I1pilrtttlOflem.-J. IPf6jiW,! rtt._ti(JlI~m .eft plurMitM.Ttrllm. Jt#flllJr:m1- mfll'ojillll, f/mt 1'1!/""MA Dppllfoil.'l1 f"llfltllm hUlu{mudi ab inuictm tliPiJtX14"mfll'. Cvmp,foil trtrd mm 1ft t~ ,diq"ilitu JjflMli4 jri "''''',tum Jijlif/!lIt. fom. It hoe lca_e J.iC:itur.qllia compofilio 6tquidem elt diu"Hs.(cd Vt vnibilia,non pra:ciia 'It dillinfh.Et iill.d;fl.t4' iJ. (.art.1. Sei,"ilHin e/l.inqllit, 'Iu~ilJ Jiljil1u flDIt IjlllHmmli fimplt;l:,qra ~ft ptr Jjljifolltl'll 'Jilltl, tlil q-.mtUlllu;{td tj/ 1J1milT1II 9uitJAi11. fed. ;,ul1lmll rd~ti""um., Cb!od luc:ulentitu el!primit I" J.lla ,Anib"IJuJl1Ilij1.i4''1.I •• rt., .~.d"II)inq~it, flint '1H' ai"id,m'IIr fitf1p{i~ilfr • ,1I;a {tculldHm rnllf(l'I,,",,& ,IIiJ1ttUlltlm, PJI' fiCMndiim"jforuiam. (/;' fli'1JJA11I. El ;Jt~;rI ;flu eft IIH10",14 (impli&j",.. 1'!.!! ... Il.m IfHttm fNII' q"t fft:HJtd~,jj. quiJ djJ.iJ"III~r.lJgi'" fl'~',JHm p"()prutllt~ "ccidtTIIlflu.'Utl ft.t:lIl'1dH,!, F,'1- prJIIIIUJ Ibfolfif.tJ, jfNt Sm~ .. Iblll MtlJT ,,{nu aft I'lii.ro: 'fJtl f!CliI1dJj~ rt!Jfth,M. PC1U SOttA deJ:ler .,ft ,,(,su .~rlnjpr(J,&fI1 hu eft "'''''trlll {ttlltlJUri1 9111J. SIC ~"1:0 "."l'1kr~ fi1hp/lcirtT imp!1"": fiP"~lIt~dlln". & di/hrt!J,oJt,m .fid mldlJltI9 {tOl1ldlltil '1u,d fmptd~ '1# f~/1I1/I aJjlIA£1ill.:nn. Cit1l1 t~1.tJ;n Jillinil {It pt7foI'llfl'Jil1l iijlin(l,,, per prDprit/AUI rellllif(IiI, 6' 111i1 ftp.r.u;D fl~lfnditm tJ{mi,tm. in Jiu;rtj"ft rlH1rJmU l1tffo,,~m flt:UlIdHm 'lAid. rlO7l tllIJntrllf [tmplicim-. jiil.tjfo"liar"7ill!J' '1f1;J/t""lIm.ldctn [umilur I;X iprl) D .ThO_rJ1.in h.u: '1' ,OAft.l ,/Ill ",.licet ibi numeeurn timrliccm , k abloluturn (umn pro numero nuJIli:f;lmc.qui eft in imcllcClu; numerum nUmCrll· rum pro co qui e It in rebus. & in cis (.lcir aggreg3tionem.& compoliliol1etn , &: maillS aUt mInus. It iie ai:nn Patrcl)qui aliquando aRirmanr d.,IinllImtllln in Deo, IOqllllillll1' de numere qUotJ dirund:ionem n:htiQilUrn pt:Ccise.~i;lliqll;llldo nc: .. gmt nUlllerum.intdligllllt cum ca impttfeflioue. ~ compofirionc,qllz en: in crC.1d~.

,lj Secund~egul:a.:Noll1ina ,.lfi;~nWltl ,Jillltf_,txf'lAltnPn.Ji,glTenJ,"'tmll1$ t 0& _ mi la. DOn funt iQ ptopri~ :lUfib!lmd~ petfonis.lu. el£. P. Thorn. II' '1 •• ,1.;1" .1..

Ihli., ell,"1uU UlaJigni6aut :JiqUid diaerfum in n1tUta. Q!l.~re non poll'iJllt lib {lOmin;l 3pplic:ni petfonis. nifi ~dd:l.tur f(·[h-lltio uahros ad rdationes,vt Ii dicatur. perfQII:J: funt ditfcrcnrcs > allt diactkncxionalirerlcurclariu?, '1n;lc=fl ~tt:lneaalrni tehtiue • DOn tamen G abfoJlltc pon:mtur,qui;l jlla nOll:li~ ahrolu~c prol;1f2. illdiL:.tnr diliindioni cum ~iq\la d\lUntp.& dilCnnuetliC'Qtil in cl1'e. vd J~ ~u~{jc:Ut.'J.dtn'.nJ .-I,,,.,,,,, propriHigni ficaf GiftindlOUtIU ~n 'llUliulC. qu~ alu:rurn,fl:u ahetaCQ!D ~~c folet. Eot 61: ne det\K errandi oc:calio, Authllis vtmdum cll,& liquando inueniunnuin Autlcmblis prab.ui •• in bono {ell(u nptkic4 Cunt. '.(Oprl! "'ero Pl:.~~ dicc:ndJ: .Glnt Qjrun~ yet dif~.quMl'ltbil ~e natu.-, diqrrli~tc:de6gnat.

14 _ T ~ Regula CIf!:a nOJiuna GgndiQDna mUle ~QmJ.lI!(I~ tri,'at3ut1hlii,~~non ponitUr :ll~lOlut~ In.dlwnb , (ta cum .addiro. fc:il.adhi. ~ tGminSUIl rc4tillii;U1t ~orionalc.lWc tamE

De Ptrfoniidiuinit.

nomen Trimis. &- TrinitaJ ab[!JILlt~,& line aJiqul reftrittionc Jicitll!. Sumunr ba:c regula ex D. 'lh. h1c'1.p.a.J.lld !.&: ... z.idquc docet ex Hilario •.

E.t rario eft. quia Iy m1llfipll;': aut triplex alit tiNplex QPponumur fimplicitati, quod enim til lim-. plexnonc!bbplclt aUtmultipl~iI:; & it3.illanomlna aliquid c:ompofirlr>Dis importaDt. _vc_I,vr:dicit S. Thom.in~qualitllt~m proporrioni;: affittnare aute de Dee aliquid qued opponitut liinplicit:ni-, vel inducit imtqua!itatc:m. error eft. At vero boc DO. men TriDUJ (eu T riniras dicit abfdut~ fiumentnt trium,Jine aJditione in2ql1alitatis.vcl dimitiutiono thnrlidt~ti, t &. 6.:: abrohm~ Deo ttibuitul'.quAte-DIlS Deus fubfill-it in tribus per(onil~ non llImeoqu:eliber perron:). v.g. PatJ:r ~ aUt Filiul dicirllr m .. nus,qllia rrinius~lIdllquh S. Th.h1t ..,.J •• lffM.d J. kClind,)m proprictatcm voabuli m~gis lignme;l.t numerum pedonarum vnius dJ'entiz. EtpIopter hoc no pOnbJ~ni5 dicere quod Pater en: uiniw. EI: hzc: differentia inredy ,ripltx, & Iy - TrimI' vel T.,ini,." fumiru! ex Aug.6,d, Trinit.c'7.vbi inquil! PiC qllMhfm Tr;'litllJ ell, tr;plu PUlIUJ4m,p,#Ilio. ifNi" mj;;or tril Pllttr [oIIll,If"' Fi/,;" /QIUI • 'I1I6m fo mAl Pattr,r!/ Fllilll. Et (.8. ob eandem ration!: in .. quif,q_uQd TtI";I," P#jjHHjI,QIl_ttipltK. Br lilt. J r .c. ~.Elilf7lJ ill hue Ilbt~ .ppllrIlIlTrinitll'j, .'111",/i- 1M,&' 1ID" DUll fl'fplrx.{td TrinitllJ.Er Contil.Tolocan\1 U.in confetlionc 6dei.H~t,inquir.tftfhEi. Trin;,,,,u rdllill nJilmllj~,qH" 111m tTiplix,{td T rimtlU,& J~~i.& &rau dLbu. AI' quando ramen nomine duplids vlitur D.Th.vt cum info so.dt FIII~nt.lItf. 1.COIlWHt dfcduplice(:mlInarionein Deo, & Pll* rres ;'Iliqll3ndo code rennino vtuntur.lIllt uiplicem pi!tfoni ~ppdbj1t. fumcndQ triplc); vel duph::I,pro timpli ci nemine duoru vel tritt. idque appbcat poll ipfi Dee immediate afietedo Deil. dTc triplicc, 6cut di,imr Ttil'lu~.(ed pcrfonis rtll rub6neti~rc:latiujs.

O!!ma Rc:gub.:T crmini (ignilicantes udlifio· I J pc, \'t I)' fllu., Iy TarttJim, & Jimile,;poff'um did de terminisl!Rentillibu5 in Dee (yn~.lt.gorem;ltic~ oQn caregorem.1tice.De pctfonabbus vc:i'~n6 poC(unt dici,6ly flllU ponatur cl! parte Cubic-tli ~ fS' c.I: pane pr=dic;ni .aliqllid comunc:.Tupe Iy P''''' dici-

III' carl.'gotc:matice quando pO!lirll( n_ pane ptzdieari Vt 1I0mct'.&: impoHu (tliirudillc.vt dir:c:ndo PUet' ell: lOIus. Deus ell fohn, id ..n fine comiDtU. SYllcuegoreD1:l(ice I:"R: cUm ponirot a parte rubie-. tli,per modum adlltrbij, &. 6 gnili'cat a1i"1t1id aliclli

fQ Ii. cOIlUenire .Yt cum didtur toms Dms cftillcoprehenlibilis. V nde ell f.ll( 11m dkere Pater ell: folus:6gnincat cl'lim eire: (oliuriLlm)nec habere confonium. Et Cbrillus Dominus dixit"loan.8. ~lIi .. follll nDIJ [Hm. Et Ii przdkantur termini eO"l:nlilles

d, pc:rroni •• 11 011 patdl pom 1)' flluJ Cl pane (~ ietl:i fyncaregorc:m~th:e,vtdicendo>Solu$ Parl!l'eR:

Deus.quia fic![ c¢neurn pulill$ alius ell Deus.quod cll f.illum.Et hoc pr~cipnt intendit S.Th.lf. 31.41't. 4.vrpatt:ftx jnj,iM7t.~dem ntioQe_ eft falra propolino in qu:taliqllid norionale commune pra;dk:ltot' d~ perfoJU, pom:ndo Iy fll1i1 ex parte fubielli.-on fi dic2!,Solus Pliter Ipir;n:.dl fzl(a.quu etiaJD Filius.fpirat. S~ 6~diccn~r a1iquidnotionaIc p~oprium, v[,Solus Patc:t generat. OJ!oll'lodo '1CiO inuiUigatUl' jUdd lo;au.17'·Y' tagn~J,pnt" fll,,7IJ D'Hm~If'H7II')di:dmi'$ tlit;.prlm1,tI'tl+ ' ..

Deboe nomine pt1t_.'pio* viderllr fiDe peIicl1lo polfe de Den did,qllia ex communi v(o fotilm lignificar indh1iduationem • qua: eri:irtl namra: conucnit •. Si tam~ 11 Jinl,sl.tru , I'J 'f.m'$i ~duderct PlD(tiEudinem pcrtonar!l~ncg~ndllm dt.quo,paao multi P.:I.tIU diC1ifU: in - 01;0 nc:1: ~U"e GngtJlarl.. ~~ a:c diua:fiwcm.' ,-, 1; : ~ _',

\