100%(4)100% found this document useful (4 votes) 1K views155 pagesReading Strategies Part 1 & 2
good way to teach reading comprehension in the classroom
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
ce ENSION.
a practical classroom guide
@coralContents
Foreword by Linda Gambrell
‘Acknowledgements
Part One: The Background
Introduction
‘A model for introducing and teaching reading comprehension strategies
Creating a supportive classroom environment for strategy teaching
Getting started - some frequently asked questions answered
Recording the learning process
How to use this book
Part Two: The Key Strategies
Activating prior knowledge
Self-monitoring
Predicting
© Questioning
Making connections
Visualising
Inferring
Summarising
synthesising
Other Useful Strategies
Skimming
Scanning
Building Vocabulary Knowledge
References
Photocopy Masters for Activities
12
16
20
23
25
31
45
53
65
79
87
m1
143
149
155
163
178
183Introduction
Comprehension is one of the most challenging
issues facing teachers of reading today. We know
that although many students are accurate and
fluent decoders, this does not always translate into
having a good understanding of the text. Reading
comprehension is important because without it
the student is not truly reading.
In the past 25 years there has been a growing
body of research on reading comprehension. One
ofthe most significant findings of this research
is that proficient readers are active readers. They
actively engage with the text using anumber of
strategies to gain meaning from it.
So whats it that good readers do? We know that:
Before reading, good readers:
+ activate their prior knowledge
+ areclear about why they are reading a particular text
+ know what type of text theyare about to read
+ preview the text
+ make predictions
+ askquestions.
During reading, good readers:
+ construct and revise meaning
+ monitor their understanding of the text
+ continue revising and adjusting their predictions and questions
+ usea variety of strategies to determine the meaning of
unknown words and concepts
+ make connections with ideas in the text
+ make inferences.
Aen reading, good readers:
evaluate whether the text met their purpose for reading
+ revisit their predictions and questions and adjust and revise
them if necessary
+ areable to summarise what they have read
+ synthesise what they have read.Authors and researchers include from six to 18 strategies as being important for reading
comprehension. For the purpose of clarity, the strategies covered in this book have been organised
into groups.
1 Nine key strategies that appear to come up the most often in research.
2. Two strategies that are also important but tend to be less well documented.
3 Two setsof strategies that are indispensable to readers at any level:
+ word attack strategies to help clarify the meanings of unknown words, and
+ fix-up strategies - what to do if meaning breaks down at word or text level.
Reading comprehension strategies
Group 1: Keystrategies
1._ activating prior knowledge
2. self-monitoring
3. predicting
4 questioning
5 making connections
6 visualising
7 inferring
8 summarising
9 synthesising
Group 2: Other useful strategies
1 skimming
2 scanning
Group 3: Additional strategy sets
1 _word attack strategies
2 fix-up strategies
Is it possible to teach these strategies to students?
There is compelling evidence to say that we can teach these strategies to students. Nell Duke and
David Pearson write in What Research Has to Say about Reading Instruction:
A large volume of work Indicates that we can help students acquire the
strategies and processes used by good readers — and that this improves
‘their overall comprehension of the text, both the texts used to teach
the strategies and texts they read on their own in the future...
There is a large not overwhelming number and range of techniques that
work, yet the use of even one technique alone has been shown to improve
students’ comprehension. Teaching what we call collections or packages
of comprehension strategies can help students becone truly solid
comprehenders of many kinds of text.Explicit teaching is best
Research tells us that explicit teaching techniques are particularly effective for comprehension
strategy instruction. Explicit teaching requires teachers to tell readers what the strategies are, why
and when they should use them, and how to apply them.
Itis important to explicitly teach these strategies individually, However the goal for our students
is that they have a toolbox’ of strategies that can be activated unconsciously and in unison. These
strategies can help them to interact with the text to become more active and engaged readers. The
big picture is not just that we teach the strategies in isolation and hope the students catch on. We
need to encourage them to be using a variety of strategies simultaneously.
A cooperative learning model works well
Cooperative leaming groups — where students work with a buddy or in 2 small group of up to four
students to complete a clearly defined task ~ have been shown to be an effective way to teach
reading comprehension strategies. Cooperative learning groups not only provide opportunities for
peer support but are motivating for students, as they know their work and ideas will be responded.
to.
Teaching reading strategies has cross-curricular benefits
Another important point to note is that these strategies are used not only in reading, but across the
curriculum. We activate prior knowledge, predict, make connections, infer, summarise and question
in many curriculum areas including maths, social studies and science. Teaching these strategies
has cross-curricular benefits. This is particularly true for research projects and studies thet involve
inquiry-based learning, How many times have we asked students to summarise a story or skim or
scan an information text without having actually taught them how to do it?
The importance of building vocabulary knowledge
One area of teaching reading that has taken a low profile for some time is the role vocabulary plays
in reading comprehension.
‘Vocabulary plays a significant role in students’ reading success.
Kithout an understanding of the words ina sentence. paragraph. or
passage, comprehension cannot occur, and without comprehension, one is
‘not truly literate.
= Bleek 8 Wangiert (2000)
Research shows that in most cases, the bigger the student's vocabulary, the better they
comprehend, One vital area we must attend to as teachers is the building of vocabulary knowledge,
particularly in students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, and new learnets of English.Summary
+ Reading comprehension is important because without comprehension the reader is not truly
reading.
= Comprehension strategies are not an end in themselves; they are a means of helping students
understand what they are reading.
* Students who are good comprehenders of text are purposeful and active readers.
Reading comprehension can be developed by:
= explicitly teaching reading comprehension strategies
+ using a cooperative learning model to support leamers
+ encouraging readers to use strategies flexibly and in combination
+ using the strategies across the curriculum as appropriate, and
+ building vocabulary knowledge.
© What do good readers do?
see
ee What do good readers do?
/
EEL wretcotaiendy know about ns topter
— | predict this book will be about... because...
een
een
Peet]
know what thatfeel ike because...
ean make pieces in my ming
Pann)
Ihink what the authors trying to ell me s+
Peet itr
wonder why...
predicted ... would happen, but now Ithink...
Jen ofthe storys.
‘My idoas have changed ater reading this...
ike to find out why...
ound this bookuseful for my report because.
NNB This poster may be downloaded from the support material section of the CD that accompanies
this book.
reeA model for introducing and teaching
reading comprehension strategies
-adapted from Duke & Pearson (2002)
‘What is the most effective way to introduce and teach strategies in the classroom?
Here are the five components.
1 An explicit description of the strategy, which includes when and how it
should be used (no student help)
For example:"Predicting is making sensible guesses about what willhappen
next in the text you are reading. tis a useful strategy because it helps you to
think about what to expect when you read. Predicting gives you a purpose to
keep reading?”
2 Teacher modelling of the strategy in action (think-alouds| (no student help)
For example:"I am going to make some predictions about this book. First ofall
1am going to look at the cover. It's called Evil Weasel and it'sgot a cartoon kind
of picture of a sneaky looking weasel on the front. | can see by the title and
the picture on the front that itis probably fiction book. | predict this story is
going to be about an evil weasel who does mean things to people. lalso think
from the picture on the front that itis going to have some funny parts in it?
&
3. Collaborative use of the strategy in action (now students can start to help!
For example:"My prediction about the weasel book was preity good. Now Id
like you help me make some predictions. fm going to read this page and at the
end ofit I will stop. |want you to think about what will happen next and why
you think that... [read text] Okay, now let's hear what your predictions are..."
4 Guided practice using the strategy with gradual release of responsibility
For example:"We have been talking a lot about making predictions in
reading. Today as you read in your groups, id like you to practise doing this.
While you are reading, Id like youto stop after every two pages and use the
prediction flowchart to record your predictions for the next two pages
‘coming up. Stop after your frst prediction and talk to a buddy about what
your prediction s and why you think that will happen. When you have read
the whole story, discuss your prediction chart with your buddy. Discuss
whether your predictions were correct and whether your ideas changed”
5 Independent use of the strategy
For example:"It’s time for silent reading, As you read today, remember what
we've been talking about - making predictions while we read. Practise this
strategy by making predictions every two or three pages. Ask yourself why
you made the prediction and what made you think that. Check to see if your
predictions were correct!”es een ee
Modelling
Modelling is often the forgotten step of the teaching process. Teachers of younger students tend
tobe very good at supporting their learners by articulating what they do as readers. As a teacher
of mainly 9-11 year olds, I did not feel at all confident about modelling in front of older students.
| assumed the students didn’t need this support. | went straight from telling them what to do, to
asking them to apply the knowledge - and forgot the steps in between. Now, having realised the
Value of modelling and seeing the engagement on my students faces as they recognise that all
readers (even teachers!) have to work at understanding the text, plus some considerable practice, |
feel a lot more comfortable with the process of modelling,
Good modelling is all about preparation. When | first modelled a strategy | assumed that, being
an experienced teacher, | would be able todo it with ease, How wrong | was! The first time did
a modelling session, I decided to model the prediction strategy. | had found a newspaper article
about Matchbox Toys that | thought would be of interest to the class, and off | went. Being the
teacher | am, | started with the best of intentions but found myself being steered in all sorts of
directions, unable to control my excitement at all the different possible teaching points | could
ram into one lesson. The poor students probably had no idea that my modelling lesson was about
prediction - it had becamea hazy mishmash of teaching points that occurred to me as | sat in front
‘of them. So be warned: be prepared and be focused!
Placing sticky notes on a text to provide prompts works a treat. It does take time to prepare
your’script but once you have a modelling session planned, there is no reason why you can't use it
multiple times. For this reason, it is a good idea to choose a text that you have a personal copy of,
or photocopy a part of a text so you will always have it to use. Be on the lookout for texts thatJend
themselves to modelling particular strategies.
Start your own bank of resources by keeping
copies ofthe text complete with sticky notes for
the modelling session ina resealable plastic bag.
Think-alouds
Think-alouds (Davey, 1983) are a simple but powerful technique. The reader literally thinks aloud’
~ articulating their thought processes as they attempt to do something, in this case make meaning
from text. When the teacher thinks aloud, it makes the thought processes ofa good reader
transparent to students. Remind students to take note of the things you do as you work your way
through a text.
!tis also important that students practise think-alouds. They are a valuable tool for listening to
students’ thought processesand assessing how well they are using particular strategies.
13Some pointers
1 Use awide variety of materials to model: stories, textbooks, articles and visual text such as
photographs, graphs, maps and tables. Use think-alouds across the curriculum as appropriate.
Select a text that is genuinely challenging for you as a reader. This will give your students a
sense of yourthinking processes and how you approach difficult texts,
2. Plan your think-alouds. Write prompts on sticky notes and post them at appropriate points in
the text.
3. Read the text aloud, pausing to make comments about what you are thinking in order to
‘comprehend the text. Be careful not to do this too often as it will affect the flow of the text.
4. Unless you are doing a general think-aloud, keep focused on the strategy youare teaching.
Ifappropriate, quick references to other strategies taught in the past will help consolidate
learning.
5 Keep the modelling session short and’punchy’~ don’t bore the students with long drawn-out
| demonstrations.
6 Take a few opportunities to show word attack and fix-up strategies.
7 Remind students thatalll readers get stuck sometimes, but good readers are able to recognise
what word or part of the text is confusing to them and then use a fix-up strategy to clarify the
problem,
Using sticky notes and think-alouds are suitable follow-up,
activities for teaching all reading strategies,
Examples of think-alouds
Here are some examples of think-alouds for a book about the experiences of two men who
compete in a challenge to row across the Atlantic Ocean. You could use a think-aloud to
demonstrate your thinking as you
ovledge and make
Make predictions and confirm or
revise them:
Activate prior kni
connections:
know the Mianric Ocean Is
and America
T predicted tr would be really
Cold in the Atlantic Ocean
but now T know the men aia
‘theie trp
between England
ber I'm not sure how many
iometres that would be. Sou
tee a pretty long way, T think
ere frriartic Ocean te where the
| Franc sunk. It hit an iceberg
as ct mist be pretty cold in the
| Aeantic Ocean.
nds
in summer 50 it was
actually really not!
44Summarise:
Muy summary of what has
ls that the men have had
lots of challenges caising
4the money to build & boat
‘and preparing for tne tip
bot they have overcome
trem and are ceacy 10
stact the race.
Make connections:
T remember going in a cance
when we were on holiday
once. I+ was quite hard to
fow because the cars were.
a BF big fer muy hande. My
hands got really sore. I can’t
imagine how it must feel +o
row for such a long time.
Visualise:
‘of these two men in this
towering above them.
Clarify meaning:
Tm not sure what this word
fartique means -
120] dase cP cong
lack of steep,
the effects o,
te: 6
it says “after
tant rowing any
we were feeling
ontext basa clue. Fangue
must be something to do with
Being ‘ied because that's how
T would be Feeling if T hag
rowed a cance for 12
had not had that mu
ste book
happened so fac in
ZT have a pictere in my mind
aves
fring canoe with hige 0
f fatiqve® I tink
Synthesise:
Now that I have
fead this story, T
think T have a better
understanding of how
some people deal with
feally hard sttuations and
what makes them keep
going
Ask question:
T wander what they ate
on the ‘rip and hoo they,
stored their Food.
Infer:
HF doeant say exactly in
the beak, bet I think tne.
men were finding tt hacd +o
ge along near the end of
HE trip because the book,
says they didnt tak to each
other for three dais,
Evaluate and respond toa oa
“er was a feat teres
story, Tt gave me & ie ses
pictuce of what it woul a
“yo cow attoss the ss =
definitely, dont Rac ail
“r 40 ao ther. Fim going 70.
oe he Internet and see a
ae find ovr what those mer
a
are doing now.
1516
Creating a supportive classroom
environment for strategy teaching
Literally hundreds of correlational studies
find that the best readers read the most and
‘that poor readers read the least. These
correlational studies suggest that the nore
children read, the better their fluency,
vocabulary, and comprehension.
— National Reading Panel (2000)
Getting to be a good reader is all about time on the task - the more you read, the better you get.
So how can we provide the maximum amount of opportunities for students to do this at school?
Independent reading — read, read, read!
itis important that students have daily opportunities to read independently. Ths is sometimes
called SSR (sustained silent reading), USSR (uninterrupted sustained silent reading), DEAR (drop
everything and read) and even DIRT (daily independent reading time)!
This opportunity is particularly important for students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds
as studies show it may be the only opportunity they have to make personal book choices and read
independently.
Studies also show that giving opportunities for students to talk about their reading increases
jon and engagement. Adults often like to do this - many people belong to book clubs and
enjoy sharing opinions and deepening understandings by talking about what they are reading.
In my own classroom, | was sometimes guilty of using SSR asa time to prepare for the next
lesson. knew modelling reading by reading my own book was a good thing to do. | thought it
‘showed students that we value reading — which it does. But we need todo more.
In atotally unstructured independent reading time, many students who are not good readers
‘read’ books that are too hard for them and nobody takes any interest in what they are actually
reading, This can have little benefit for the students ~ in particular the less able ones. There has
been a move towards a more structured or’monitored SSR’ session, where teachers take a more
active interest in what their students read and provide opportunities for students to share and
recommend what they are reading to others.
Some ideas to encourage reading
Independent reading
+ Ensure that students have access toa constantly changing selection of quality books across a
number of genres.
+ Provide a short time (say two minutes each) for students to share their book with a buddy after
the independent reading session.
+ Timetable one day a week (Friday often works) where two or three students are scheduled to
present a review of a book they have read. Students or the teacher could develop a list of review
Prompts, Books can be recommended and reviews filed in a clear file for other students to refer to.Some ideas for book review prompts
1 Title
2. Author
3. Fiction/nonfiction
4 Tell an interesting fact or tell about the
main character/s.
Talk about a part in the book you enjoyed.
Give the book a star rating 1-5
(Sis highest) and say why you gave it
that rating.
Other ideas for creating a supportive classroom context
~ adapted from Duke & Pearson (2002)
Experience reading a range of different text types for authentic purposes:
+ reading lots of examples of different kinds of narrative text, if you want students to write
narrative text
+ reading instructions for how to play a maths game before you play it
+ reading school notices and timetables
Creating a classroom environment rich in meaningful print in context:
+ teacher and students creating labels, signs, lists, timetables, word banks, explanations, writing
examples, instructions and topic displays which include both known words and new words
used in context
Vocabulary building ~ fostering an interest in words and their meanings:
+ Including more sophisticated words in your day-to-day talk with students ~
“Can you articulate exactly how you did that please?”
“Please leave the door ajar to let the breeze in”
wed arte prea
re) eh mt en
™,
teeny ; ‘small minuscule,
little of
Word alternative chart
716
Who's used the word
this Week?
“seruae Ml
North Africa
when
oe year ago
oclothin
eburials «food ‘Aenvebes
tt rete ty canter ha tonics
cy ae ee reg
atte sitcingingets -
‘ee ie Topic word bank chart
Encouraging fluency - being able to decode quickly and accurately:
+ shared and independent reading of poetry cards and shared books
+ Readers! Theatre
+ listening and following along to recorded stories
Students writing and reading each other's texts and providing authentic opportunities
for these texts to be read by people in the community and the wider world:
+ writing instructions that will be followed by other students, e.g directions to get from their own
house to school (as part ofa focus on procedural writing)
+ writing a letter to the editor of the local suburban newspaper expressing an opinion
+ peer-editing formats
Creating an environment rich in high-quality talk about books:
taking a genuine interest in the books students read, and talking to them about the books
+ asking, and having students develop, a variety of open and closed questions
+ challenging students to give more information as they answer questions, eg."What makes you
think that?”Regularly reading a variety of text types aloud to students:
Abalanced programme of reading aloud to students every day for 15 minutes has many benefits. It
shows students that we value reading. It exposes them toa variety of authors, text types and new
vocabulary and provides a shared experience that we can use as a platform to discuss concepts and
ideas
Given the constant time pressures of today’s classroom day, reading aloud needs to be planned
for. You could plan a read-aloud session with your students first thing in the morning after roll call.
This is a great way to start the day, prepare for the reading session, connect with students and
know that you have done something worthwhile.
balanced read-aloud programme could include:
+ picture books (sophisticated picture books for older students)
+ novels
+ short stories
+ folk stories or fairy stories
‘+ myths and legends (including some appropriate to the cultures of your students)
+ poetry
+ biographies and autobiographies
+ letters to the editor, magazine articles, etc.
+ excerpts from books for different purposes, @.g, to show how an author engages the reader at
the start of a story or to highlight an author's style.
+ published work written by the students in your class.
1920
Getting started - some frequently asked
questions answered
How does teaching reading strategies fit into my literacy programme?
Reading strategies are a component of reading, nota whole reading programme. Explicit teaching
of reading comprehension strategies gives students information they need to help them to
comprehend. Reading strategy instruction needs allocated teaching time and should be woven
into your literacy programme.
A suggested model could be one reading session a week for explicit instruction. This explicit
instruction session could include:
= _anexplanation of why the strategy is useful and how to use it asa reader
= _amodelling session where you demonstrate how you asa reader think when using the strategy,
and
+ opportunities for students to be involved in having a go themselves in a shared then guided
situation.
This does not mean introducing a new strategy each week. There will be times when you are
working on a strategy long term (summarising, for example) so the weekly session may be used
for practice activities only. Other areas of the curriculum provide opportunities to practise reading
strategies. For example, predictingjis a useful strategy in maths, science or social studies. Once you
have begun to teach the strategy, use the practice activitiesin this book in your guided reading
programme to reinforce them. Be careful not to overdo this and make strategy practice boring or
too repetitive for the students.
Which strategies should I teach first?
There appears to be no research to suggest that there is any particular developmental order
for teaching reading strategies. Stephanie Harvey and Anne Goudvis (2000) suggest that self-
monitoring is a good one to start with. Teaching students to be aware of their own thinking when
they read is a great place to start.
You may want to introduce or reinforce a strategy that is fairly easy for students to come to grips
with, such as predicting, to kickstart their awareness.
The introduction of different strategies will depend on your classroom programme. For instance,
if your writing focus is information reports, you may want to teach your students how to summarise
‘or skim and scan for information, Plan your strategy teaching alongside your classroom focus so the
strategies can be taught ina meaningful context.
How long should | spend teaching each strategy?
There is no required lenath of time to spend teaching each strateay. The important thing is the
explicit explanation of each individual strategy followed by modelling, shared, guided and then
independent practice so the students are clear about what the strategy is and why they are using it.
The length of time you spend teaching each strategy will also depend on the level and
capability of your students, Some students may already understand and be using particular
strategies. There is no point in spending time teaching a strategy they are already using proficiently.
Ifstudents have good comprehension they will require a range of more challenging texts that
extend their reading horizons and allow them to practise strategy use at higher levels.
Some strategies will require less modelling and be easier for kids to pick up. Visualising is anexample of this. Summarising, however, is a much more challenging strategy that requires many
modelling sessions and lots of practice in a variety of contexts to become proficient at.
Should | teach reading strategies to the whole class or in groups?
Introduce and model each strategy to the whole class. As is always the case, there will be a range
of abilities within the group. Some students will understand quicker than others. In fact, there
are likely to be some students who are already using some strategies proficiently. Although it is
important that we don't ask students who are already using a strategy successfully to practise
incessantly, we do want everyone to be’on the same page’ and using a common language.
Students also need to be able to articulate what they are doing and why. No student (or adult for
that matter) ever comes to the point of understanding everything they read instantly ~ think of
what happens when you try to decipher a legal document or usea ‘help’ box when something goes
wrong on your computer! For this reason, there is always a case to be made for strategy teaching
and practice.
After you have modelled a strategy, support your less able students by withdrawing them into in
a small group and working with them. These students will need the whole learning process slowed
down - lots more modelling and scaffolding in a small group situation to help get them started.
How old do the students have to be before I can start teaching reading strategies?»
Research suggests that students are cognitively ready to receive information on reading strategies
when they are around7 years of age. Students younger than this tend to have trouble thinking
multidimensionally and also have difficulty in retaining strategies. Research also strongly suagests
that at this stage the ability to decode the text - to attach phonemes to letters and names to
symbols is critical. A degree of fluency and the ability to reason with others is also required.
This is not to say that we donot include comprehension strategy Instruction as young readers
learn to decode, Comprehension is always a goal in reading, Think-alouds (see pages 13-15 and
49) and the modelling of strategies by the teacher are important at this stage. This can be achieved
through shared reading and read-aloud sessions. Some activities in this book are suitable to use as
follow-up activities after guided reading sessions - the Story map (page 95) is an example.
How do | assess where my students are at?
There are many formal tests available to assess levels of comprehension. It is beyond the scope of
this book to suggest specific tests, as every country has their own test formats.
Formal testing and teacher observations provide data that may show a student's need for
improvement in comprehension levels. This book is designed to support the explicit teaching of
reading comprehension strategies with a view to improved comprehension. The learning goal for
each strategy activity is to practise the strategy purposefully so itcan become assimilated into the
student’s bank of knowledge to help them make meaning from text.
When trialling the ideas in this book, | found that I began to build a picture of which students
were understanding and which ones needed more support, by observing how they coped with
practice activities. | made a point of roving around the students and actively listening to their
conversations. When | noticed students who were not ‘getting it; | withdrew them for more explicit
modelling sessions and support. The products of the activities the students complete provide
evidence of their level of understanding. These products can be used to support formal data and
provide evidence of learning. By listening to students think aloud (see pages 13-15), and reading
their sticky notes and graphic organisers, you can get ‘inside’ the students heads and find out what
is really going on. This, to me, isone of the most interesting and rewarding aspects of teaching
reading comprehension strategies.Some other important points
+ Remember that not all reading strategies work for all types of text,
+ Never ask students to do something you haven't modelled!
+ The activitiesin this book are great classroom tools; but remember, the points the reading!
These activities are intended to focus closely on a particular strategy as part of strategy
teaching. Don't kill the enjoyment of reading with too many practice exercises,Recording the learning process
Ideas for recording teacher demonstrations and student learning
Itis important to keep a record of learning as you teach reading strategies. A record of teacher
demonstrations and student products is a useful way for both students and the teacher to revisit
and revise learning sessions. This way, the learning is available to be referred to again.
Modelling and clemonstrations may be recorded in a number of ways.
Some ideas for doing this are:
+ chart paper - clip together, hang on the wall or make into a book
= electronic whiteboard - record and save demonstrations
+ scrapbook ~ buy a ready-made scrapbook; see ideas laterin this section.
Reading strategy mini posters
The support material for each strategy contains a mini poster. There is also a ‘Strategies we know’
sign included on the CD. These can be printed and laminated. As you teach anew strategy, post the
appropriate mini poster on the whiteboard or make a wall display. Use the display asa reference to
remind the students of the strategies %
Activating
prior knowledg.
‘Synthesising
(=i
BB won
Keep exemplars of student work
‘As you begin to teach the strategies, start to collect examples of work that show how students
are using strategies effectively. These can be invaluable for demonstrating exactly what you are
‘on about. You may want to make a file for each strategy and put exemplars and pre-prepared
modelling session plans (books or photocopied text with sticky notes attached at appropriate
points) into it.
23Some ideas
for recording
learning in a
scrapbook
lens
POE)
Aida Cay
Book
°
Gradually hand over
‘ownership of the book
by having students take
responsibility for writing in it.
‘An explanation of
what a strategy is, and
how reading strategies
can help us to better
understand what we
read.
The starter poster for
the strategy being
taught.
A written recap of what
you did to model the
strategy.
‘An example of the
activity the students did
4o practise the strategy.
Leave space to odd
more practice examples
ata later date,
Some examples of the
| language you might use
wa when using the strategy.
ID voce space forine
students to record when
they use the strategy in
other situations.How to use this book
Read the background information
Itis important to read the introductory sections before you give students the activities in this book.
They contain helpful background information that will support your strategy teaching. Merely
completing practice activities is not an effective way to teach reading comprehension strategies.
The introductory sections are:
+ Introduction
= Amodel for introducing and teaching reading comprehension strategies
+ Geatinga supportive classroom environment for strategy teaching
+ Getting started - some frequently asked questions answered
+ Recording the learning process
Decide which strategy you are going to teach
Self-monitoring is always a good place to start. An awareness of when and what causes meaning to
break down is critical to understanding the text.
However, the strategy you choose may depend on your classroom programme. If your focus
is writing an information report on an animal, you may want your students to learn how to :
summarise the information they have gathered. Teaching the summarising strategy would be a
logical choice as the students will be practising it in a meaningful context.
Use the strategy sections in this book to support your teaching
Each strategy section contains:
: So a strategy starter poster — this can be used to give the students an explicit explanation
of the strategy. There may also be other posters to support the strategy;
these will be listed at the beginning of each strategy.
. a mini poster — this can be used to develop a wall display that can be referred to as a
prompt for both you and the students
(see page 23 in ‘Recording the learning process’ section)
+ anexplanation of the strategy and how it supports comprehension
+ question stems and examples of the language used when using the strategy
+ _aselection of practice activities — the activities are loosely organised by level of difficulty; the
fist activities in the list are the easiest.
. 3° strategy certificates — these can be used to reinforce strategy understanding. Remember
to give specific feedback on what the student has done right. For example: really like
the way you told me what happened in the story to make you revise your prediction”
NB All support material is available on the CD that accompanies this book,
o The CDicon indicates material that may be found on the CD only.
25Suggested session times
The amount of time you spend cn each part of the process will depend on the length of your
teaching blockand the ability and engagement of your students.
Session 1
+ Use the strategy starter poster to introduce the strategy to the whole class.
+ Explain how the strategy supports comprehension.
+ Use the appropriate strategy mini poster and start a ‘reading strateaies we know display
ona whiteboard or wall.
+ Usea suitable text to model how you use the strategy when you read,
Session 2
+ Choose anether piece of text and a different activity from this book and have the
students help you to complete it.
Session 3
+ Revise the strategy. Use a different text and activity to practise it.
+ Think-alouds and using sticky notes are always useful to practise strategy use.
Revisit and revise the strategy
Revisit and revise the strategy during other reading sessions and in other curriculum areas as
appropriate. For example, you may be predicting or summarising in maths or social studies, Make
the connection that this is the same strategy as we use in reading.
As you build students’ knowledge of the strategies, use short pieces of text such as newspaper
articles to revise strategy use. This will help students to see how we use multiple strategies to gain
meaning from text.Student ability will dictate the number of practice sessions you will need for each student,
to assimilate the strategy into their own repertoire of skills. This can be catered for by using the
practice activities as starters or follow-ups in your guided reading programme.
Remember, reading strategies do need to be explicitly taught — but they are just a part of your
reading programme.
The goal is for students to be able to use the
strategies flexibly to help gain meaning from text.
Pat ie top pein
edi Aap the achele wot
fal akout soreane «de ploys
to much video Gawres.
Weve other'se?
carat at
Won af move? 3
What twill hopes “y
Ysualising)
Bae or
+ afer cating
We wrok Tasvetcle
0d wihy only a hae
of deo Gone and g
Gy2.gne9 bg she
chloe tam St
Sabet Gon dons
peek har”
i ase nation oblbaactl ip cats
Sage ed Le Ble} en , ss
aR ities
onde other
veaele
Kate's page
ayPart Two
The Key Strategies
Contents
Activating prior knowledge 31
Self-monitoring 45
Predicting 53
Questioning 65
Making connections 79
Visualising 87
Inferring 99
Summarising 111
Synthesising 143
Skimming 149
Scanning 155
Building vocabulary knowledge 163Activating prior
knowledge
Introduction 32
Practice activities for the activating prior knowledge strategy
Stand and share 34
Before and after web 35
1
2
3 Drawit! 36
4° Brainstorm it- sortit! 37
5
6
KWL 38
Bus-stop 39
7 Last word 40
8 Tabletalk 417
9 Dot-to-dot connections 42
10 Anticipation guide 43
Other activities that use the activating prior knowledge strategy
+ Predict the words 56
+ Walk and talk 57
+ Postcard predictions 60
+ Keyword story strips 63
+ Question web 70
+ Before, during and after (BDA) chart 72
+ Apairof shoes 90
+ Senses chart 94
+ Word sorts 168
+ Possible sentences 171
3132
(8) Introduction
Proficient learners build on and activate their background knowledge
before reading, writing, speaking, or listening: poor learners begin
without thinking.
= Irvin et al. (1996)
What is prior knowledge?
Prior knowledge is the unique set of knowledge each individual student brings to the reading
experience. It is a combination of the student's attitudes, experiences, and knowledge.
By knowledge we mean:
+ what the student already knows about the reading process
+ vocabulary knowledge
+ topicknowledge
+ concept knowledge
+ text types or genres and the language features of these.
How does activating prior knowledge support reading comprehension?
By activating their prior knowledge, students are able to connect with what they already know. This
gives them a base on which to build further knowledge. For new learners of English and struggling
readers, it is especially important to spend time building the students’ prior knowledge to give
them a‘headstart' to comprehending the text. This could be content or vocabulary knowledge, or a
combination of both.
Some students may have prior knowledge but not make connections to the text so it is
important to help students make those links. There may be opportunities for students to build each
other's background knowledge by sharing their own knowledge and experiences. For example, one
member of the group may have visited or come from a country a story is set in.
Language we use when activating prior knowledge
+ What do | already know about this topic?
+ What have lead that seems similar to this text?
+ Dol recognise the author's name?
+ Whattype of text/genre is this text — article, narrative, letter, poem?
+ What sort of language features would | expect to findin this text?
+ Based on my prior knowledge of , My question/s is/are
+ When hear the word (or phrase) , it makes me think about
+ The words and pictures remind me of something else that | have read/seen/experienced
+ The illustrations tell me about the text.@ © Adtivating prior knowledge support material
Activating prior
knowledge
‘Thinking about whot youalready knw is useful
‘cause lt ges you aba to build new knowledge
|
Activating |
prior knowledge
‘Activating prior knowledge
‘mini poster SM2
IMPRESSIVE
| PRIOR KNOWLEDGE!
‘Activating prior knowledge certificate SM3‘es Stand and share
Stand and share is a practical way to engage the whole class in sharing responses ina relatively
short time. It requires that each student listens carefully to the other ideas being shared so they
don’t repeat them.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, sharing information, listening
Materials: none
Student grouping: whole class
Procedure
1 Students all stand.
2. The teacher asks the students what they know abouta particular topic. For example “Does
anybody know anything about planets?"
3 The teacher then picks a student to share their idea. If someone else in the class has the same
idea as the person speaking, they sit down.
4. The student who has shared their idea chooses another student to share their idea until all
ideas are shared and all students are sitting.
5. Ideas could be recorded by the teacher as students share.
34(@) Before and after web
Students enjoy seeing concrete evidence of their own learning as they complete this popular
graphic organiser.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, locating information in a text,
synthesising
Materials:
+ text at students’ instructional level
+ Before and after web PM1 (this can be enlarged to A3 size for group or class work)
‘Student grouping: individuals or buddies then small groups
Procedure
1. Students write up to eight facts on a particular topic in the inner circle spaces.
2. After reading a text or studying a topic they add the new knowledge to the outside circle (itis
not necessary to match the inner circle facts to the outer circle facts).
3. Students share their before and after wheels in a small group.
Variation
This activity could be used in any curriculum area when starting anew topic, for example-a unit of
work on statistics in maths or teaching a text type such as report writing.
@ Before and after web mm
eno Brooklyn ~
1 echoes need 40 have | Female Seahorse
a te ron
ok fe Since Shes!
a sheeneta
lwild \to stove feed in. oa
Seen When
ck cea: Seats ecaorses
rms | \ ve’ one en
Fish Frc water. their tai\s|
ete or
soe hey ese
armas” Beougn
ne |
Seahorses!
[The ridle Male Sea-|Seah< |
[estar ieee Sith “hove
e eae fet
Poe sa9s sa so they |
Int fore suck tite
led, age
Pee whole
| ‘Seahorses can [Male Seahorse
blend into ther
one fess
Crate eng)
35(B) Draw it!
an alternative to a written brainstorm. Rather than write words, the students draw
pictures to show what they know about a word, topic or idea. This can also provide the teacher with
information about the level of prior knowledge the students have.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, making connections, summarising,
synthesising and visualising
Materials:
+ text at the students’
+ paper
+ 2different coloured pens
structional level
Student grouping: individuals, buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Introduce a word, phrase or concept to the students.
2 Ask them to draw a picture or pictures to show you all they know about the word, phrase or
‘concept. They may add labels to their drawings ~ but encourage them to draw rather then
write.
3. Students share their drawings with a buddy or a small group.
After teading the text they add to/revise their drawings by using a different coloured pen to
add new information. If thereis a lot of new information, a new picture could be drawn.
5 Students orally summarise what they have learned with a buddy.
Rebecca's before and after pictures for an article about spiders(8) Brainstorm it - sort it!
Brainstorm it - sort itlis a great way to activate prior knowledge. It can also be used to build
vocabulary knowledge or as a quick assessment tool after completing a lesson or study.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, building vocabulary
Materials:
+ Brainstorm it — sort it! PM2:
+ paper or pencils for individual or buddy work, or
+ chart paper and markers for small group or whole class work
Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small groups or whole class
Procedure
1 Toactivate their schema, present students with:
+ aword, eg. space
+ aphrase, eg. leisure activities
+ a question, e.g."How can we be more environmentally friendly in our school?” or
+ aconcrete item, e.g. a plastic insect for a study of i
of clothing fora study of another country.
2 Asindividuals, buddies, small groups or as a whole class, students brainstorm their prior
ects, or a cultural item such as an item
knowledge about the topic. *
3. They thensort their words or phrases into categories and justify why they have organised them
in this way.
Variation
Students write their brainstorm words on strips of paper. The strips are then cut up so there is a
word on each paper piece. The students sort the words into categories and glue them onto a large
sheet of paper.
Brainstorm it — sort it! ae
Sone at en = wh
A
ie So ps tet elk Seagate nn
th seatepoe abten dient fa frat Ty
eg sgh Hay cas mses boc hada aptaon
Sedat Rs Gert a
Fo on maby gs tn)
—————
3738
fe) KWL |
KWL (Ogle, 1986) is a three-column graphic organiser.
Students recort
1 Whatwe think we know ~ our prior knowledge
2. Whatwe want to find out - establishing purpose for reading and asking questions
3. Whatwe have learned ~ summarising and main idea
NB In column 1 What we think we know'is written instead of’ What we know, so as not to confuse
students with potentially wrong information.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, questioning, summarising and
synthesising
Materials:
+ KWLPM3
+ text at students’ instructional level
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small groups or whole class
Procedure
1 Provide a word, phrase or concept and write it in the box provided at the top of the photocopy
master.
2 Students record their prior knowledge in the first column.
3° Students decide what they went to know and fill in the second column with their questions.
4. Students read the text or do research on the topic.
5 Students answer their questions from column two, and add any other information that they
have learned.
6 Revisit the ‘What we think we know’ column to discuss and clarify students’ previous knowledge
if necessary.
; Ses
| ‘@ KWL re
| we Bees seme Tiger om 2/06
1
SE
| What tpe af "Beas ore abled
ye oF Ho
lo ee poles sal | nC tee,
| Bees cllet pollen
“Fallen s the Athy
Stilt on He Flover
‘Bees make hos |s How he bees colbct | |e Bees collect pallen shen]
poten? hey ore inking nesta
Bees can sting you ha
low ‘uch honey
ar a bce mate in | [PH tpn ot hve
ie hanes oH hei
“Bees (re in hives‘e Bus-stop
The bus-stop activity isa great way to activate prior knowledge and get a picture of what students
already know about a topic. It can also be used after a study to check understanding.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge
Materials:
+ chart paper - *sheet per group of students
+ marker pens - 1 per group
Student grouping: groups of three or four students then whole class
Procedure
1 Label each sheet of chart paper with a question appropriate to the topic about to be studied.
For example, if the topic was'The Rainforest; some questions could be:
+ Where do you find rainforests?
+ What animals live in rainforests?
+ Why are they called rainforests? :
2. Place the pieces of chart paper around the room, Each group starts at a different‘bus-stop’ and
records their ideas on a chart
3 After an allocated time the teacher says, Bus-stop”. The groups rotate until all the groups have
responded to each chart. s
4 Each group then presents their chart to the whole class.
at is happening to
Roe aa wh ‘Should we Care!
The Rainforests are bang cat denn,
uc dello tae
3940
ie Last word
Last word takes minimal preparation and provides a platform on which to build knowledge. Itisa
Useful tool to gauge students’ knowledge about a particular topic and can also be used to reinforce
note-taking skills.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, note-taking
Materials:
+ strips of paper
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals then small groups
Procedure
1. Students are given a limited amount of time (say 2 minutes) to write as many words or phrases
as they can about a particular topic. This is done individually.
2. Students then workin small groups and take turns to share one word or phrase from their list.
3. Ifanother student in the group has that word they puta tick beside it. If they don’t have the
word, they add it to their li
4 Students continue to share a word each until they have finished their list.
5 Thelast student to share a word is the winner.() Table talk
This cooperative learning activity encourages both individual thinking and group discussion, and
Tequires all members of the group to participate and share their ideas.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, building background knowledge,
encouraging active listening, and setting a purpose for reading and questioning
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ small sheets of paper
Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small groups, then whole class
Procedure
1 The teacher writes a thought-provoking statement or question relating to the text on the
whiteboard. For example, “Why should we save endangered species?”
2 Each student has 2 minutes to read the statement or question, reflect, and write a response,
3. Each student then has 3 minutes to share their response with a partner. Partners reflect on what
their partner has said then write a response to their partner's statement. °
4 Pairs combine to form small groups of 4-6 students. All responses are shared within the group
and one response is chosen to share with the whole class.
41(8) Dot-to-dot connections
This rich activity has many benefits for students. It can be used to introduce a new topic or ina
guided reading situation. Students are introduced to new vocabulary and then relate the new
words to familiar words. This helps to reinforce the meaning of the new words and put them ina
context.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, building vocabulary knowledge,
making connections, setting a purpose for reading
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ teacher prepared Dot-to-dot connections sheet
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals, buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Choose 6-8 meaningful words from the text, One or two of these words
should be words you would not expect the students to know. In the case of the example
below, the words | chose were biodiversity and census. Spend some time explicitly telling the
students what the words mean. include some words that are similar but others that appear
contradictory or don't seem to fit in, so itis not immediately obvious what the text is about.
Write the words on paper, spacing them apart and drawing a dot beside each word.
2. Photocopy enough pages for each student, set of buddies or small group to have a copy each.
3. With the class: Distribute papers to students and have them make connections between the
words by drawing a line and writing the connections close to the line. If there is more than one
student they may like to write their initials beside their idea.
4 After they have completed their connections the student/s make a prediction as to what the
text will be about and explain their thinking, Remember to revisit the predictions after reading!
@rredicine
Lin,
pated betes and stuff \e
i scientist Se census
Kbit sts May, do a cons TO, 5
Se iF animals are endangft
‘Sophie's connections for an article about discovering a new species of coral2 Anticipation guide
Anticipation guides (.£. Readence, 1986) are a useful graphic organiser to activate students’
Prior knowledge and set a purpose for reading. They are most useful when the text contains
controversial ideas, opinions or problems.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, setting a purpose for reading
Materials:
Student grouping: in
Anticipation guide PM
text at instructional reading level
iduals
Procedure
1
The teacher writes several statements relating to the text in the spaces provided on the
Anticipation guide PM4,
When writing the statements, consider:
+ writing statements that focus on the concepts or ideas in the text that you want your
students to think about
ig statements that students can react to without having read the text
+ writing statements for which information can be identified in the text that supports and/or
opposes each statement. .
Before reading the text, the students read the statements and indicate whether they agree or
disagree with them.
After reading, the students indicate whether they were right or not, and write a short reflection
about their thinking.
| @ Anticipation guide a
| vox How they were built The Colosseum ane David J. Brown
pm Aye om ye
(— some | ax [or Ietcton |
Se | Bs |
' The Colosseum took, J“ = omen ae |
around iO years fo build. | * * ee Te |
| 2 Roman emperors tea teeuldo, Fetes Sat ete the
mney cies | | ey epee eee
ort grandiose Pubic buildings.| tg te hmeart yee the
1 [>the Colosseum is made of | ae Ee
lq limestone bricks. se EF gia nd or
ok = = bE TaagRE ae ane, Ba
[|p Tee Gelogeum i a fioute |. Vat [is natn sb badtag’ a
| [to the architechural skills of epee fo tte the act
| BBE tpt Sr
F [7 The Colosseum was builtso | yes | ory [Ree Mba Teint about “ah
| [people could watch chariot races} ‘
1) Neon
43Self-monitoring
Introduction 46
Practice activities for the self-monitoring strategy
1 Think-alouds 49
2 Idon’tgetit! 50
3° Strategy log 5146
Introduction
Unless students are self-monitoring while they are reading, they
cannot truly comprehend the text. Self-monitoring relates to the
concept of ‘meta-cognitive awareness,’ which is ‘knowing when what
one is reading makes sense by monitoring and controlling one’s own
comprehension’.
= Warrts & Nedges (1995), p. 153
What is self-monitoring?
Self-monitoring plays a crucial part in comprehension. It requires students to be metacognitive - to
be aware of their own thinking as they read, Most importantly, itrequires students to realise when
they have stopped understanding what they are reading.
I think itis news to a lot of students that adult readers get stuck or lose concentration when
they read. | explained to my students how, when | am reading my book in bed at night, | can read
‘a whole page and suddenly realise that Ihave no idea about whet is going on, even though | have
read the words. |asked them who else had had a similar experience. Practically the whole class
agreed they had! | explained to them that this is a common thing that happens to all readers.
Good readers know when this has happened ~ a voice in their heads says, “Uh oh, | don’t get this -
problem! warning bells! lashing lights! time to stop!”
Itis interesting to note that research shows that when students with poor comprehension come
toa word or partin the text they don't understand, they just keep reading because they don’t know
what to do.
Students need to be able to identify exactly where the breakdown in meaning has occurred. This
could Be at word, sentence or paragraph level ~“I don't understand what an estuary is” or" don't
understand the first paragraph on page 14”: Once they can articulate what the problem is, students
can then use a fix-up strategy such as rereading, reading on, stop and think, visualising or adjusting
their reading rate (see Word attack poster (SM6) and bookmark (SMT); Fix-up strategies poster
(SM8) and bookmark (SM9)).
To summarise, self-monitoring is the students’ ability to
+ be avare when meaning breaks down
+ identify what it is they don’t understand (word, sentence, paragraph)
+ use appropriate strategies to restore meaning.
How does self-monitoring support comprehension?
Self-monitoring supports comprehension by giving the reader control over the reading process.
Before reading, they might clarify their purpose for reading and preview the text, During reading,
they monitor their understanding, perhaps adjusting their reading speed to fit the difficulty level of
the text and using ‘fix-up'strategies to deal with any comprehension problems they may have. After
reading, they can monitor their understanding of what they have read,Language we use when self-monitoring,
+ mnot sure what means.
+ Idon't get that paragraph.
+The author mentions John Davies in Chapter Two, but | can't remember much about him. | think
il. go back and reread that chapter to help me understand this part.
+ [don’t understand what that sentence means. | am going to go back and read it aloud slowly
and see if that helps.
+ Ie lost my concentration. Id better go back and reread that page.
+ Im going to try and create a picture in my mind to help me understand that bit.
© Self monitoring support material
Self-monitoring
sng bag er of or om nig
‘einen
ese ppc tae 4
Salleh seen ener
toca ee ees onto
aioe eum cnseoet one
a cents a Leone rotcce
seweyy suche reeoig
Self-monitoring strategy starter chart SM4
Self-monitoring
mini poster SMS
a7EE)
Fe
=
4 Use te content to guns he mao, + cnt aptreny md
6 Wepre hrtasctor de. —
trent rei ti ot Lonerrorreneneery
6 Ueda. eten hana
7 Asef, =
= nator
Word attack poster SM6 Word attack bookmark SM7 Foxup strategies poster SMB
Salmentring ley cha
BERIS 8 SIRI
z
Fic-up strategies bookmark SM9_—__Self-monitoring key chart SM10
SENSATIONAL
SELF-MONITORING!
Adjusting your
Basie
& qa
Self: monitoring certificate SM11 :
‘monitoring te ‘Adjusting your reading rate poster SM12Think-alouds
A think-aloud is when the student literally thinks aloud. They articulate their thoughts as they read.
Itis particularly helpful when students need to identify exactly where meaning has broken down
in the text. Itis also important that students know that they can use fix-up strategies to restore
meaning, More information about think-alouds can be found in the Introduction on page 12,
‘A model for introducing and teaching reading comprehension strategies.
Strategies and skills practised: self-monitoring
Materials:
+ Focup strategies bookmark SM
+ text at the students’ instructional level
Student grouping: individuals and buddies
Procedure
1. Discuss the think-aloud process with the students. Review the fix-up strategies on the
bookmark.
2 Students read the text.
3 When they come to a word, sentence or paragraph they don't understand they stop and tell
either the teacher or a buddy exactly where the problem is.
4 Atthis point they could use the Fix-up strategies bookmark (SM9) to try some different x
strategies.
5. After they have read the text, they discuss where meaning broke down and which fix-up
strategy they tried to help restore meaning.
Variation
When students become more
proficient at identifying and using
strategies, photocopy a newspaper
or magazine article and have them
underline parts of the text and draw
lines to the outside of the page
noting the strategies they areusing
and responses they have to the text.
4950
I don't get it!
‘I don't get it! (adapted from Harvey & Goudvis, 2000) helps students to identify exactly where
meaning breaks down for them during reading.
Strategies and skills practised: self-monitoring
Materials:
+ textat students’ instructional level
+ sticky notes
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals, then buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 The teacher explains that the purpose of the lesson is for the students to identify where
meaning breaks down for them. It could be at word, sentence or paragraph level.
2. Explain that when they come toa word or part of the text they don’t understand, they will stop
and puta sticky note with a question mark at that point. They will then continue to read to
see if their question is clarified by further reading. f the question is clarified, they remove the
sticky note. If not, the sticky note provides a place-holder to remind them where the point of
confusion was.
3. Students read the text.
4. Atthe end of thereading, the students get together with 2 buddy or in a small group to discuss
their clarifications and the sticky notes that still remain, indicating the questions and confusions
they may still have.Strategy log
A strategy log is a useful tool for both student and teacher. Itallows the student to monitor their
‘own reading, For the teacher it provides evidence of which strategies the student is using, whether
they are using them appropriately and whether they fully comprehend the strategy’s use. A
strategy log is also a good discussion tool for conferencing with students about their reading.
Strategies and skills practised: self-monitoring
Materials:
+ text for teacher modelling
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ My reading strategy log PMS
+ enlarged copy of My reading strategy log PMS for modelling
Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
1 the students help, briefly revise and record all the reading strategies you have covered.
2. Introduce the idea of a strategy log. Explain that the purpose of the strategy log is to see what»
strategies the students ate using to gain meaning from the text.
3 Model the use ofa strategy log by doing a think-aloud — read a short piece of text and discuss
and record which strategies you use on the enlarged strategy log. ‘
4 Students read a text at their instructional level, recording which strategies they use on their
strategy log sheet.
i @ My reading strategy log ras
1) oe ‘Your nemels Luke ote
| |
| 1 emacs ae | ewes vera ae
18 [od hn aE [visualising |" Shak the Fe
T
19 | crackle on the er’ reading on i Tea pee eens!
| rs ee
|
51Predicting
Introduction s4
Practice activities for the predicting strategy
Predict the words 56
Walk and talk 57
Y chart predictions 58
Predict the headline 59
Postcard predictions 60
Character crystal ball 61
Prediction flowchart 62
Key word story strips 63
eVaununs
Other activities that use the predicting strategy:
*« Dot-to-dot connections 42
+ Predict and scan 158
+ Possible sentences 171
53o4
3 introduction
Simply stated, good readers predict. When students predict they set a
purpose for reading and anticipate what they will read.
Lubiiner (2001)
Predicting is fundamental to conprehension. Good readers anticipate
meaning. They do this by predicting what they think is going to happen
in the selection and by revising their predictions as they read.
— buffy (2003)
What is predicting?
Predicting is when students use clues such as the title illustrations, blurb, author and text type or
what they have read so far to make smart guesses about what is coming up next in the text.
How does predicting support reading comprehension?
Predictingis a key pre-reading strategy as it helps to set a purpose for reading. Continuing to make
predictions and confirming or revising them throughout the reading process encourages students
to become active readers who have expectations of the text. This also keeps them actively engaged
inthe reading process. This engagement is crucial for comprehension. By thinking about their
predictions and confirming or revising them, students remain motivated and focused.
Language we use when predicting
+ I thinkthe text will be about because
+ predict will happen next.
+ From what | have read so far, | predict that ,
+ From what | already know about Ipredict
+ * The picture makes me think that.
+The style of this author is so think
and revising our predictions
Ithought butthen Iread that so now Ithink
+ I changed my first prediction because it said in the book
+ My prediction was confirmed in the story because
* My prediction was partly right but
+ lassumed but3 3 Predicting support material
Predicting
Predicting wselul odin strategy oti help us
think about what to expect when we red, What we
now otreody (our pir knontedge) help uo pric
‘When me rd Can he
Wecan thik sat the
Predicting strategy starter chart SM13
Predicting mini poster SM14
EXCELLENT
PREDICTING!
Predicting certificate SMI5
55.[C3 Predict the words
This is a quick starter activity to assist students to focus on the types of words they might expect
to see in the text. It also helps orientate students to the text they are about to read and may also
be used by the teacher as a quick assessment tool to establish the degree of prior knowledge each
student has about a particular topic or concept,
Strategies and skills practised: predicting, inferring
Materials:
+ text at the instructional level of the students
+ paper
+ pencils
‘Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
The students read the title of the text and jot down five or six words they predict will be init.
They then discuss the words they have chosen with a buddy, justifying why they chose them.
As the students read, they tick any of their words that appear in the text.
After reading the students discuss the words they chose and revise their predictions.
Itis important to emphasise that the aim of the task is not to get all the words right but the
ability to be able to justify why they thought the words could be in the text.
WS eS
4 Molly’ predictions for an article about the
difference between stars and planetsFe] Walk and talk
This cooperative learning activity engages students and increases motivation to write good
predictions, as students are required to share their predictions ina group situation.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, predicting
Materials:
+ text selection or picture book suitable for using the predicting strategy
+ blank paper about AS size (one per student, plus one per group of four students)
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals, then groups of four students
Procedure
1 Divide the students into groups of four.
2 Show the students the cover of the text or read the title if the text selection is not a book. You
may need to give more clues ifthe title doesn’t give too much away.
3 Individually the students write:
‘+ what type of text they think it is (narrative, newspaper report, article, etc.)
+ their prediction for what the text will be about
+ one sentence they might expect to see in the text.
4. They then circulate around the room and read their predictions to as many other students as
they can. They do not discuss their predictions, just read them aloud at this stage.
5. After about five minutes they return to their groups and jointly writea group prediction.
6 Groups share their predictions, explaining why they came to those conclusions.
7. Teacher or students read the text and confirm or revise predictions.58
FB Y chart predictions
This activity requires students to look at a photograph and make predictions and inferences about
what was happening before, during and after the photograph was taken.
Strategies and skills practised: predicting, inferring
Materials:
‘ uring
+ aselection of newspapers
* chart paper
picture
+ marker pens a
+ scissors
+ glue sticks
. before | afer
Student grouping: buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Students find a suitable picture in a newspaper. Encourage them to choose appropriate
photographs that include some action or emotion or background details that would give clues.
2. Students use a marker pen to draw a large Y and write before, during and after in the spaces as
shown in the diagram above.
3. Students then glue the picture in the middle of the Y shape and use the spaces around it to
write what happened before, during and after the photograph was taken.
4 Students get together and share their responses with another set of buddies, stating the basis
for their predictions, e,"I thinkthe manis going to board the plane because he has a suitcase
in his hand”
Variation
Studerits write what was happening in
the photograph.
They then swap their photo with
another group of buddies. The next
group writes what happened before the
photograph was taken,
They swap again with a different set
‘of buddies who write what they think
will happen after the event in the
photograph.[53 Predict the headline
Predict the headline is a fun, small group activity that could introduce or reinforce the predicting
strategy. It can also be used to introduce the idea of context and how we can use context clues to
make predictions.
Strategies and skills practised: predicting
Materials:
+ newspapers
+ photocopied sheet of headlines - one per group
Student grouping: small groups of four students
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Cut out a number of newspaper headlines. Remove an interesting word
from the headline, e.g." Swamped at Airport”
2. Glue the incomplete headlines onto a sheet of paper and photocopy one sheet per group of
students. Keep 2 copy of the actual missing words to share with the students after they have,
completed the task.
3 With the class: Give each group sheet of headlines and ask them to come up with two
possible answers. First they try to think of the correct word to fitthe headline; and second, the
funniest word/s to fit. 2
4 Discuss the idea of context and how we use it to make predictions.
5 Share the answers. Take a class vote on which is the funniest headline.
Variation
Students could create their own headline sheets to challenge others to predict the headline.
|
a putt world of fun
Toy Zoe built |
_Sap _ goes the power line
| ep
1 “Jove ec mp sca sack |
| Tey i thetelge
Coping wit
mens wath Se
orev
|
Pe Seen eel |gg Postcard predictions
Postcard predictions are a fun way for students of al levels to practise predicting and inferring.
Strategies and skills practised: predicting, inferring
Materials:
+ a selection of postcards or magazine pictures of a variety of different holiday destinations
+ chart paper to answer questions
+ marker pens
Student grouping: individuals, buddies or small groups
Procedure
1. Assign each small group a postcard or magazine picture.
2. Explain that a friend has sent them this postcard.
3 Have them answer the following questions:
+ Inwhat country do you think the picture in this postcard was taken? Why do you think that?
+ Have you ever been to a place like this?
+ What languages might be spoken in this place?
+ What sort of clothes might your friend wear at this place?
+ What food might they be eating?
+ What are some activities your friend might be doing at this place?
60(3 Character crystal ball
This activity requires the students to make predictions and inferences to create an epilogue for a
character or characters.
Strategies and skills practised: predicting, inferring
Materials:
+ narrative text
Procedure
1 Students write bullet-pointed statements of what thay know about a character.
2 They then make predictions about what will happen to characters in the story in the future,
They could decide what they think the character will be doing in six months, two years, five
years and 10 years.
3. The epilogue could be presented as a piece of writing or as a timeline.
Bo yearspSemi-Rebre. Shilhelps ext ot chen
Panning a» righ lass tn mechanics
Head of C-HERU:BHasS bids . fixes
'mobrbikes in spare bine,
Working iin PS. Merricel to Kerrey.» kids)
Shadjing lave and crime br
paws ese
Brigenks me
Ends
characte’ ergsrel all for
jams trom the CnEruw
Books
a[9 Prediction flowchart
The prediction flowchart activity focuses on the process of predicting and revising predictions
throughout a text. It may be helpful to complete this activity with the whole class using a picture
book before students attempt it independently.
Strategies and skills practised: making and revising predictions using new information in the text
Material
+ Prediction flowchart PM6
+ _apicture book; or a sophisticated picture book for older students
‘Student grouping: individuals then small groups or whole class
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Read the picture book or text and use sticky notes to indicate appropriate
stopping points for students to make predictions.
2 With the class: Discuss why predicting is a helpful strategy for comprehension. (it helps to seta
Purpose for reading, orientates the student to the type of text being read and encourages them
to think about what might be coming up next.)
3. Discuss what helps us to predict (see the list on Prediction flowchart PM6)
4 The teacher reads the title, shows the cover and perhaps reads the blurb. The students write
their own predictions for the book in the first prediction box.
5 Read the story, stopping at the predetermined points you have marked with sticky notes. At
each point ask the students to revise their previous predictions and make new ones for the next
part of the story.
6 Share the students’ responses in small groups or as a whole class.
Fd Prediction flowchart for .. BS
Ma Caea, ond the AligtrigmenAnnatelle |
eemaan E fhink Thad gS Stary TE
Filion becarse oF ME) drawings’ on the
The blush tells you Hat Set 90509
ono adnate
Cee think the
jeans
Uae oa
ihgga swtoe
Lee
Rae
beer tag oe
be Lies
pe Bhat
62| Key word story strips
In this activity students are required to use key words to create a story. Although narrative text has
been used in this example, key word story strips would work equally well with factual text.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, predicting
Materials:
+ picture book or factual text
+ _ list of key words for a story (photocopied in strips) - one per individual, or per set of buddies
+ exercise books or paper
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: read the picture book and make allist of about 10 words that are
important to the story. Type these into a text box and duplicate it so you have approximately
four lists per A4 page. Photocopy and cut into strips.
2 With the class: Give each individual or set of buddies one strip of words.
‘Ask them to read the words then construct a possible story from it
4 Students either write the words from the list in their story and highlight them or cut thelist into
strips and glue the words into their books. =
whale
mouse
ocean
boat
hurricane
friends
rescue
mammals
help
aying
grateful
63Questioning
Introduction 66
Practice activities for the questioning strategy
1 Question cardsor dice 69
Question web 70
Hot-seat character interview 71
Before, during and after (BDA) chart 72
Double entry journal for questions 73
Thick and thin questions 74
Radio reading 75
Question-answer relationships (QAR) 76
@eNansun
Other activities that support the questioning strategy
+ KWL 38
+ Table talk 41
* Character inference chart 106,
* Current events summary 123
+ What's the big idea? 124
652
(introduction
Strategic learning during reading is all about monitoring reading and
naking sense. Skilled readers know how to monitor and keep track of
whether the author is making sense by asking questions . . .
= Vatea (2002)
What is questioning?
Questioning is when the student poses questions before, during and after reading a text.
Questioning plays an important part in the process of self-monitoring as students ask themselves,
“Does this make sense?” Encouraging students to become aware of and value the questions they
ask naturally is a way of helping them to engage with the text.
How does questioning support reading comprehension?
Asking and answering questions helps to engage the reader with the teat. It provides a purpose
for reading and gives the student a reason to clarify meaning. This connection helps to deepen
comprehension.
Language we use when asking questions:
+ Iwonder why, where, when, how, if, who, ...?
+ Whatis going to happen next?
+ Whatis the author trying to tell me?
+ Dolalready know something about this topic?
+ What do | think | will learn from this text?
‘See the QAR bookmark SM22 for more examples of question starters.ad o Questioning support material
$9) = Questioning
oot odes ak gueston lr dvingond ater
theyhoveread ott.
Somme te qton anata tet
Sones youre owe yur own pornowladge
ondots ithe po come pit th
Sometimes he uston may tot become y the
texto ena yore nd nates
‘foment yo,
Questioning mini poster SM17
QUESTION!
Questioning certificate SM18
67o Support material for QAR (question-answer relationships)
(Bear - what kina of question is it?
Think and search
phonic emeraay
QAR starter poster SM19
QAR student practice sheet M21(9 Question cards or dice
Question cards or question dice are simple ways to support students to generate questions. Who?
where? and what? are the simplest questions to answer as they are position words that deal with
concrete concepts. When? relates to time. How? and why? questions are more difficult as they
require verbal reasoning.
Set 2 of the question cards can be used in conjunction with set 1 to develop question stems
such as whowill? what might? where could? etc.
Strategies and skills practised: generating questions
Materials:
+ 2blank dice or
* Question cards 1 PM7A
© Question cards 2PM7B
+ cardboard to back question cards
Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small groups or whole class
Procedure
1. Teacher preparation: Use PM8 and PM9 to make question cards (or write the words on the two
blank dice). Laminate the cards and put in a suitable container.
2. With the class: Model how to use the cards or dice by reading a text and using the cards or dice
to generate your own questions.
3. Use the think-aloud strategy to model how to generate a variety of question types, both closed
and open-ended. The QAR bookmark (SM22) will support students to develop a range of
question types.
4. Students work with a buddy or in a small group.
5. Assign each student two question cards that they can use as a question stem to developa
question related to the topic or book they are reading.’Who might...” “Where would ...?”
They choose another member of the group to answer their question.
6 Alternatively students take turns to throw the two dice to make a question stem and answer it.
Where? would
Who? coulda
What? will
When? can
How? should
why? might
69(9) Question web
Question webs are a simple graphic organiser that can be used for many different purposes across
many curriculum areas.
Strategies and skills practised: question generating
Materials:
+ text st instructional level of students
+ Question web PMB
+ QAR bookmark SM22optionel)
+ pencils
‘Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small groups or whole class
Procedure
1 Use the think-aloud strategy to model how to generate a variety of question types both closed
and open ended. (The QAR bookmark SM22 may help students to come up with a range of
question types.)
2. Students develop their own questions and note themon the web organiser.
3. Further reading is undertaken in order to answer questions.
| Question web dn
| {' rene WOrTdS srmolleSt Stake enone Willian , Caleb cow 20/0
|
4 |
j
| TS, the Snot
i, Phatend? How 5 the smelkst Snare?
va |
What county df
Mie
Aretiey 1S thee coy there, 4g |
ted Veg Veneenid IA SO Sera.
William and Calebs question web before reading an article titled The world’ smallest snake’9 Hot-seat character interview
In this activity, one student becomes a character in the text and is interviewed by other students.
Although this activity lends itself to narrative text, it could also be used with factual text. A student
could take the role of a survivor from a story about an earthquake, for example.
Strategies and skills practised: questioning
Materials:
+ text at the instructional level of the students
+ QAR bookmark SM22 (optional)
Student grouping: small groups
Procedure
1 Students read text.
2 One student is chosen to be'in role’ as a character in the story.
3. The other students in the group take turns to ask the character questions relating to events in
the story.
NB The QAR bookmark SM22 provides question stems to encourage students to ask a variety of
different question types.
n72
(@@ Before, during and after (BDA) chart
This graphic organiser helps students understand the idea that good readers ask questions before,
during and after reading. Some of the students’ questions may be answered in the text. They can
record these answers next to the questions they have written.
Strategies and skills practised: questioning, searching for information in a text
Materials:
‘= text at the instructional level of the students
+ Before, during and after chart PM9.
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Introduce the text, looking at the title, text type, illustrations, etc.
2 Have the students fill out any questions they may have in the ‘before reading’ section of the
BDA chart. When introducing the idea of asking questions during reading, it may be helpful to
have prescribed places for the students to stop, think and ask questions during reading. They
record these on the BDA chart.
3. Atthe end of reading the students think about and record any questions they may still have.
@ Before, during and after (BDA) chart = |
|
wie The Fit Olympic. Maratha yarsenn Tonsthon om 15/5 |
Vy.
|
"during wading 2s ater rading
(OP people stil remem) =|
Upson ais “ae RAT
Tie wai the Fist
Pelion fohave a Meco Ow Tl eas noe
Qiwhe Fit Thess OF Gigs
the olympics? -
e Owht wit he do win
TWh KAM OF Sos 7 | | hig mate?
seat
Dill Spitidon Lou's |
evel chatge Jobs?(@ Double entry journal for questions
Students write down their questions before they read the text and note the answers as they
find them in the text. They may keep adding and answering questions as they read. By asking
and answering their own questions, students create a purpose for reading and their level of
engagement is increased.
Strategies and skills practised: asking and answering questions
Materials:
+ text at the instructional level of the students
+ Double entry journal for questions PM10
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals then buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Students use the title, pictures, and their prior knowledge to ask questions about what they are
about to read.
2 Students read the text, noting answers to their questions when and if they find them.
3. After they have read the text, buddies or small groups discuss their questions and answers.
Puno
®@ Double entry journal for questions
ve The worlds smallest Snake =~ Claudia AHicat
‘Yourromens uh vee 28.10.
My question [tate teet tye
unknown-only 3
ee Pe fe are Be pave been fauna |
[wit ever be | Mayoe, because &
Sruongeted? deforestation
|
[Is it venomous? | no
|
| the |The ,endke 1s 4
[Hie og, © the |r es. ong
|What colour. is thel
| Snake?
iSland
where would it ns
normally be founds led “eorcades i
7314
Thick and thin questions
Thick and thin questions (Harvey & Goudyis, 2000) are terms which help students to understand
the difference between open and closed questions.
Thick questions deal with large concepts or the big ideas in a text.
‘Answers to thick questions are open-ended and require complex answers.
Question stems for thick questions could be:
Why? e.g."Whyisit importantto treat your friends well?”
What? —e.9.*What would have happened if plastic hadn't been invented?”
How? _ e.g,"How would you feel if you had been in Toms situation?”
Thin questions deal with specific words or information in the text.
‘Answers to thin questions are closed and can be found in the text.
Question stems for thin questions could be:
When? e.g.“When was this story set?”
Who? eg.“Who is the main character?"
Where? e.9."Where would you go to find manatees?”
Strategies and skills practised: recognising the difference between open-ended and closed
questions, encouraging students to develop deeper level questions, using questioning to facilitate
understanding
Materials:
+ suitable text to model the activity
+ text at the instructional level of the students
+ sticky notes
Procedure oldijocks and the tee bears )
1 Explain the difference THIC THIN questions
between thick and thin SEEN
“ -Shouyu geriesoneones hase “HOW many bears lived
questions Salter aotees “in he houke?
2. Usea think-aloud to model «After gadocks bate baby WE oes Sia
the concept of thick and thin bears inate of going Hace?
questions using a picture dpstaits? “Whose paridge did
book or short piece of text. ‘ewe a Fey saw Gpidilocks eat"?
Record the questions you Goldilocks sepirg in” baby
ask, before, during and after as Pa cir bea hie
reading the text, on a sheet of = What woud ie hadnt
Paper or scrapbook. Indicate Tun anay so quickly?
if your questions are thick by
using a thick marker pen to write a capital'T; or thin by using a thin marker pen and writing a
lower case’:
3. Have students create their own thick and thin questions for the texts they are reading. They
could write their questions on wide sticky notes for thick questions and narrower sticky notes
for thin questions.
4. Share questions and answers in large or small group discussions. This is a good opportunity to
highlight inferential questions.Radio reading
Radio reading (Tierney & Readence, 2000) is a cooperative learning activity that requires the
students to work in small groups and read a short passage and then develop questions about it.
This reinforces comprehension on two levels ~ by requiring the reader to be familiar with the text
in order to develop the questions, and by receiving reinforcement from classmates as they answer
questions.
Strategies and skills practised: close reading, listening, question generating
Material
+ text at instructional level of students
+ QAR bookmarks 5M22 (optional)
+ paper
+ pencils
Student grouping: groups of 6-8 students
Procedure
1 Divide the class into groups.
Provide each group with a piece of text.
Have all the members of the group read the entire selection silently.
Assign a specific paragraph (or paragraphs) to each group member. 7
Have students prepare questions on their piece of the text. They jot these down on a piece of
paper. It may be helpful for students to use the QAR bookmark to support them to develop a
range of different question types
6 Have each student read their assigned section aloud and present their
questions to other members of the group.
7 Ask group members to respond quickly. Once a que:
question,
8 Repeat the process until all the team members have had the opportunity
to ask their questions and have them answered.
wen
in is answered, move on to the next
1816
@ Question-answer relationships (QAR)
QAR — Question-answer relationships (Raphael, 1982) is a great way to teach students how to
recognise and answer different types of questions. Often students think the answer to a question
is always right there in the text and they will find iti they look hard enough. When this is not the
‘ease they become frustrated. QAR teaches students that there are different types of questions and
that sometimes we have to use our prior knowledge and look beyond the text for answers. Another
benefit of using QAR is that it gives you and the students a vocabulary to use when discussing
questions, not only in reading but across the curriculum.
Teaching the four basic question types and how to approach answering them is a valuable skill
that has long-term benefits for students.
The four types of questions are:
Right there
The answer to the question is literally right there in the text. These questions are sometimes called
closed questions or literal questions. The answer to aright there’ question is usually found in one
sentence. Some question stems for right there’ questions could be who? where? when? or what?
Think and search
The answer to a'‘think and search’ question is in the text but may require you to search around. The
answer may use different words from the question or come from different places in the text. You
will need to piece information together.
Author and you
The ansWver is notin the text. It will require you to use your own background knowledge plus what
the author has told you in the text, to come up with the answer. Author and you’ questions require
you to infer.
On your own
The answer is notin the text. Youneed to use your own background knowledge and experience.
You could even answer the question without reading the text.
‘On your own’ questions are big idea questions that must stand alone from the text.
NB: ‘On your own’ questions can be a hard concept for students to come to grips with. | explain‘on
your own’ questions to my class by saying,”If you went up to someone in the playground and asked
an‘on your own’ question, they would be able to answer it. For example if the book you had been
reading was about war you could ask, ‘Are there times when war is a good thing?’ This is an example
of an‘on your own’ question. ‘How were the soldiers feeling after they were dropped off at the base
camp?’is not an‘on your own question, asit requires you to have read the text”
Strategies and skills practised:
+ understanding the concepts of explicit and implicit information
+ locating information in the text
«understanding that there are different question types
+ identifying question types and responding appropriately to the type of question asked
+ developing and answering deeper level questionsMaterials:
* a sophisticated picture book
© QARstarter poster SM16
* QAR teacher modelling sheet SM20 (enlarged to A3 size)
© chart paper
= QAR student practice sheet SM21 (1 perstudent}
= QAR question developing boxes PM11
+ aset of QAR bookmarks SM22 ~ 1 per 2 students (laminate to use as an ongoing resource)
Student grouping: whole class, buddies then individuals
Procedure
An example of how to introduce QAR (NB Its probably best to do this over two sessions)
1 Teacher preparation: The teacher reads the picture book and writes down a question that fits
each question type. (This is to make sure you have an example of each question type in case the
students don't come up with one in each category.)
2. With the class: Read the picture book.
3. After reading the book, ask the class for their questions about the book.
4 List the questions on the chart paper. Add your own questions to the list. Use the QAR starter
poster SM19 to introduce the idea of the four different question types. Depending on the level
of your students you may want to introduce and practise just one type of question at a time. %
5 Leave the students’ questions for the time being.
6 Introduce the QAR teacher modelling chart SM20 about Tutankhamen, enlarged to A3 size.
7 Read the story at the top of the page and model how you would decide where a question fits.
Remember thisis modelling, so you will require no student help at this stage.
8 Have the students work with a buddy to complete the QAR student practice sheet SM21.
9. Go back to the sheet with questions asked by the students.
10 Introduce the QAR bookmarks SM22. The wordsin bold are question stems that the students
may like to use and the rest of the sentence is an example of a question using that stem.
11 Have the students work with a buddy to put the questions they asked about the picture book
(on the chart paper) in to the correct question types using QAR question developing boxes
PM11.
12 Further practice: Have the students develop their own questions that fit the four categories,
using other texts.
Coming to grips with the different question types takes time. It can be difficult for some students
to distinguish between ‘think and search’ and ‘author and you’ questions. Encourage the student
to justify their thinking in a logical way. It is well worth the effort to teach students the different
question types, particularly having students develop their own open-ended, deeper level’on your
own’type questions.
°o NB See page 68 for alist of QAR support material
7Making connections
Introduction 80
Practice activities for the making connections strategy
1 Sticky notes 83
2. Compare and contrast diagram 84
3 Double entry journal for making connections 85
Other activities that use the making connections strategy
= Dot-to-dot connections 42
+ Anticipation guide 43
+ Think-alouds 49
+ Postcard predictions 60
* Senses chart 94
+ Keywords aboutme 117,
+ Saysomething 129
* Personal elines 136
+ Possiblesentences 171
192 Introduction
When children understand how to comect the text they read to their
lives, they begin to make connections between what they read and
the larger world. This nudges then into thinking about bigger,
more expansive issues beyond their universe of home, school and
neighbourhood.
— Harvey & Goudvis, Strategies That Mork (2000). p. 68
When information is read in isolation and not connected to existing
knowledge, it is forgotten and deered unimportant. Calling on existing
knowledge and experiences is crucial if readers are to assimilate new
information.
= Cris Tovant, from 1 Read It, But I Don't Get Tt (2000), p. 64
What is making connections?
Making connections is when students make links or associations between what they read and their
prior knowledge.
There are three kinds of connections students can make when they read:
1 Text to self connection. A text to self connection is when a student relates what they read to
their own personal experiences. An example of this is when a student reads a book about a
family moving house, and relates the text to their own experience of moving to a new home.
This helps to make the story more meaningful.
2. Text to text connection. A text to text connection is when the student relates what they read to
other texts. An example of this could be if a student reads a book about a boy who was always
playing tricks on people, and made a connection to a similar character in another book.
3 Text to world connection. A text to world connection is when a student relates what they
have read to the wider world. Texts could be in book form or a visual text such as a television
documentary or a movie. An example of this might be ifa student saw the movie Whale Rider, in
which whales become stranded on a beach, and made a connection to that happening in real
There are two things to be wary of when teaching making connections. The first is that students,
make connections that are genuinely meaningful to them and don't just make up connections to
try to please the teacher. For this reason itis important to reinforce the idea that sometimes we
don't make connections, and that's okay too.
The second thing is that the connection helps to enhance the students’ understanding. Just
because the story has a dog in it doesn’t mean to say that, ifthe student also has a dog, this
will help them to understand the story better. Asking questions such as, “Does that help you to
understand the story better? Why?" may be helpful. Refer to the list of teacher questions listed
further on in this chapter for ideas.ee
‘Making meaningful connections helps students relate the text to their own prior knowledge. The
more connections, the more likely the student is to comprehend the text. For example, if a student
is reading a book about snorkelling and they have had that experience, they are more likely to
make meaningful connections than.a person who has not had that same experience.
Making connections helps to deepen comprehension and create personal links with what is being
read, These connections impact on a student's motivation to read.
How does making connections support reading comprehension?
Language we use when making connections:
Text to self
+ That part reminds me of
[remember when
‘+ That makes me think about the time when
+ Melt like (character) when 5
+ [hada similar experience
+ That happened to me once
+ This sounds familiar to me s
+ Ithink| would have felt differently from because
+ know aperson like this character
+ That partis similar to in my life because
+ Thisis different from my life beceuse :
Text to text
+ Iread another book like this one
+ This reminds me of another book | read 4
+ Acharacter whois like is from the book.
because
+ Ihave already read about this in :
Text to world
+ Iknow that happens in the real world ‘i
+ Similar things happen in the real world, like when
+ Thisis different from things that happen in the real world because 7
+ Isawa television programme/film about this topic
+ Tread a book/article that talked about this:
Teacher questions
«Does that help us learn more about the story?
+ Can you tell us why you think that is meaningful?
+ What can we understand from that connection?
+ How does the connection help you understand?
81(3e| © Making connections support material
= =
|| S88 making connections
|) ses
Lan ee
|) eens me
|
| |
BF making conne
TB) Making connections
cecceaayterniecntgd on
Ratovalt
Making connections
mini poster SM24
THOUGHTFUL
CONNECTION:
Moking connections certificate SM25BY Sticky notes
Sticky notes are an invaluable resource for teaching reading strategies. They enable students to
make notes and attach them at an appropriate place where they can be referred to easily.
Strategies and skills practised: making connections
Materials:
+ textat the instructional level of the students
* sticky notes
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small groups and whole class
Procedure
1 Students read the text, recording the connections they make on sticky notes. They indicate
‘what kind of connections they have made by writing TS, TT or TW.
2. Thesticky note is attached to the book where the connection was made.
3. After the reading, students may share their connections with a buddy, in small groups or
with the whole class, Be aware that some students may write personal connections they feel
uncomfortable about sharing. The choice to share should be left upto the student.
L remember when
at patie rg horce
vt tarp. ;
t thnk she might &
felé aslwhy her
Pra re ra peel(ee Compare and contrast diagram
This compare and contrast graphic organiser is a useful format for students to record text to text
connections.
Strategies and skills practised: making connections
Materials:
+ 2textselections (books, articles, excerpts) at the instructional level of the students suitable for
making connections
+ Compare and contrast diagram PM12
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure:
1 Teacher or students read both texts.
2 Students use the Compare and contrast diagram PM12 to record the differences and similarities
between the two texts.
3. Itmaybe useful for teachers to provide a framework of ‘things to compare’ such as setting,
characters, style, etc.
| |
|| Compare and contrast diagram for ... a
toe Text 40 text comparison rwarems Taylor a (42.
[ee Satine the wate
They get older im the doryGoth The Snail and the [the Snail doesn) have
The rouse falls into the |mouse are small creatures|q boat
saree Bein of the whales [+ the whale ws a
[TIS a mouse —_|get_ Stranded [Rump back
Ames the mouse as _abaal~ the tog onmals are | 1¥s a shal
f [Bimos ‘gets elephants tohadboth whales, The Shiail gets help
j [Bens gets skonded by |-Boin of the Stones |frem human:
y [The turna ~ [Show that tle Things [+ The whale gets test _|
{ [lus whale is blue [can ete land_gets_Siranded
|) [tney spend time [+ Beth the conate: This whale rey
| [apact, ~Ihelp the Wile things|-“The snail leaves
i rs) messages.
'
|
]
q(@2| Double entry journal for
making connections
‘When you are teaching a new strategy such as text to self connections, itis easier for students to
focus on finding one kind of connection.
‘These graphic organisers allow students to record either textto self, text to text or text to world
connections.
Strategies and skills pra: making text to self, text to text or text to world connections
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ Double entry journal: text to self PM13A or
+ Double entry journal: text to text PM13B or
+ Double entry journal: text to world PM13C
+ pencils
‘Student grouping: individuals then buddies or small groups 4
Procedure
1 Students read the text, noting what it says in the text on the left-hand column and their
connection in the right-hand column. }
2. After they have completed the chart they share their connections with a buddy or in a small
group.
lesen ee
(B® Double entry journal: text to world ™° |
|
aera ese [UP
easels Seat ate [fiat Ee
Rr ie | ei eo
Tr the Shry tne Inthe Bleck house Bog)
Pee PET os «| ROMS. atenome
fetern gd se on a | itary geen
Stee
‘wren Willian are Tos om Hye
‘edevt 19 “Unicorns
WaE_cape B thet | Apshalia wea
he Tow ee” [ioe Tos "aye
lene doarieys are ct [aw Argenta hee
meen Pence.
Fes ame ley Be | da wari wae |
|
nee read.
Te une Gong tee | Teancient Chan oh
Jincon tap Chia Hood ay burnt hangs oF
feopte Gwened Une |e,
ooh.
85Visualising
Introduction 88
Practice activities for the visualising strategy
Apair of shoes 90
Picture quilt 91
Photo album 92
Nogard drawing activity 93
Senses chart 94
Story map 95
Weekend news 96
Other activities that use the visualising strategy
Nausuna
+ Beginning, middle and end flipcharts 140
+ Word map 170
8783
4 Introduction
There is an old saying that a picture is worth a thousand words.
When it comes to comprehension, this saying night he paraphrased,
‘a visual display helps readers understand, organise, and remember
some of those thousand words’.
= Duke & Pearson (2002)
What is visualising?
Visualising is when the reader uses their prior knowledge and experiences to create a mental image
of what is happening in the text. Visualising is also sometimes called sensory imaging, creating
images, pictures in the mind or'the movie in your head. It may be helpful for some students to
actually close their eyes and imagine what is being read.
The reader may use all their five senses to make the story come alive. Reading about a boy
having a picnic at the beach and imagining the taste of the sandwiches, the sound of the waves,
the feeling of the sand and the smell of the salt air connects the reader to the story, if they have had
a similar experience. Visualising helps the reader to connect with and become part of the story -
which creates that special magic of reading.
Itis important that students understand that everyone creates their own unique mental images
in their head, There are no right or wrong images, but students must use the clues in the text to
create their pictures. Ask the students if the characters in the Harry Potter movie were exactly the
way they imagined them, if they had read the books before they saw the movies. The activity on
Page 90 in which the students draw a pair of shoes may help students to understand this concept.
ng models or dioramasis another way to help students use the information in the text to
visualise what they have read.
How does visualising support reading comprehension?
Visualising supports comprehension as students create their own mental images of what they are
reading. By doing this, they feel more connected to the story, enjoy the story more and understand
it more deeply. Visualising is also useful for self-monitoring. f the ‘movie in yourhead’ stops,
meaning has broken down and you will need to use astrategy to regain understanding.
Language we use when visual
+ Inmy mind I can see
+ [can imagine
+ The movie in my head shows
+ The image | see in my head is
+ I can just taste the
+ Icanfeel the
+ can hear the
+ Icansmell thera 36 Visualising support material
When authon write, they use words to describe
‘hing. The words make a pctare in your mind.
‘retin a piu n your mind oF droing the pte
‘on poper con help you understand whet you ore
‘moding. This trtegy i caledvsulishg.
VIVID |
VISUALISING!
Visualising strategy starter chart SM26
Visualising mini poster SM27
Visualising certificate SM28
89M2] A pair of shoes
‘One concept students need to understand is that we all create our own unique mental images.
‘These are influenced by our own prior knowledge and experiences.
NB Itis important to note that when we are visualising from a text, we need to use the clues given
bythe author to help us, as well as our own prior knowledge.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, visualising
Materials:
+ AS sheet of paper
+ pencil
Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
1 Ask the students to create a picture in their minds of a pair of shoes, and draw them. Do not
give them any further information
2 When they have completed their drawings, share them, discussing the differences and
similarities between their drawings. Hopefully, there will be a range of different types of shoes.
3. Ask the students why they have drawn their shoes in that way ~ is ita pair of shoes they own?
A pair of shoes they would like toown?
4 Discuss how we all interpret the same information in different ways. If we are given limited
information, we fill the gaps with our own experience and prior knowledge.
Variation: This activity would work equally well with a phrase or sentence froma book.
For example: “The dancer smiled gratefully as the audience applauded loudly.’
\
)
KAlute eee ee Se
J Picture quilt
Picture quilts create an attractive display and provide a basis to compare and discuss the similarities
and differences between students’ visuelisations.
Strategies and skills practised: visualising
Materials:
+ picture book or text selection suitable for visualisation
+ Picture quilt PM14
+ scissors
+ coloured pencils and/or markers
+ glue stick
+ heavy backing paper
Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
1 Revisit the visualisation strategy and discuss what it means.
2 Askthe students to listen carefully and note the images the book brings up for them. Tell them.
to pay particular attention to the way the author describes things in the story. They could do a
preparatory sketch as you read.
3 Read the book or text selection.
4. Students choose a part to illustrate and draw a detailed picture of the images that were created
intheir minds, inside the template of a quilt piece.
5 Inthe outside border they can write their name and a phrase to describe which part they have
illustrated.
6 Cut out quilt pieces and glue together on heavy paper.
7 Write (or have a student write) an explanation of what the activity was about.
Visualising quilt for ‘The Best Thief’ by Joe Hayes
1Photo album
Reinforce the visualisation strategy by creating a class or group album of students’ visualisations.
These could be limited to a drawing of a character or a'setting sketch’ of where apart of the story
took place, or a more general drawing that includes both. Mount the pictures in a scrapbook or
create a wall display.
Strategies and skills practised: visualising, listening
Mate
+ picture book or a section of text suitable for creating images
+ Photo album PM15
+ scissors
+ markers or coloured pencils
+ gluestick
Student grouping: individual
Procedure
1 Before reading the book or text selection, discuss the idea of creating pictures in your mind.
Ifyouare reading aloud, it may be helpful to have the students close their eyes to help them
visualise as you read.
2 Read the book or text selection.
3. Students choose a part to illustrate and draw a detailed picture of the images that were created
in their minds.
4 Whenthe students are familiar with this idea, have them write their own descriptive passages
for other students to create visualisations for.
‘Our visualisations of Mary’s garden in The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett.is: Nogard drawing activity
Thisis a simple to follow visualisation activity which requires students to listen to a description of
an animal and draw it. They may realise after they have finished that they have drawn a dragon -
which is nogard spelled backwards!
Strategies and skills practised: visualising, listening
Materials:
+ Nogard drawing activity PM16
+ pencils
+ paper
Student grouping: individual
Procedure
1 _ Explain to the students that they are going to be listening to instructions to draw an animal. Tell
them to visualise what you are saying and draw it as accurately as they can.
2 Slowly read the description of the nogard to the students, giving them time to draw.
3. Ask the students what they have drawn and have them compare their drawings in small groups.
4 Points could also be given out for every detail recorded correctly. Have the students swap
pictures and mark each other's work.
934
5) Senses chart
A senses chart isa graphic organiser that encourages students to think about how text can
stimulate all the five senses. It could also be a way of activating prior knowledge for a topic.
Strategies and skills practised: visualising, listening, activating prior knowledge
Materials:
«suitable picture book or section of text
+ Senses chart PM17
© pencils
+ markers or coloured pencils (optional)
Student grou ividuals, small groups then whole class
Procedure
1 Revisit the visualisation strategy. Discuss how we can make pictures in our mind from the words
in the text. We can also go even further than that and use all our five senses. Ask the students to
think about al their five senses as you read the text.
Read the picture book or text.
‘The students write the title of the topic in the squarein the centre. They then complete their
senses chart and share their ideas in a small group, and finally each group chooses their best
ideas to share with the whole class.
©) Senses chart oan
sorsoman fr at if om 13.05
Tek ke
20 prota
+ felanng
Sriag
+ Splashy
‘People dancing
+ Slow mation
‘oe ==
Sent nae ana “seq
Bos “be ng
ehiben
Poteet tthvng
sfeodte bing these
food 9
li
“ae
cen
“eats
“chocolatenn na =
Story map
A story map is a bird's-eye view of where a story takes place. Rather than answer questions in
written or oral form, students record what they know by drawing it.
Strategies and skills practised: visualising, inferring
Materials:
+ narrative text suitable for visualising
+ paper
+ pencil
Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
1 Teacheror students read the text selection.
2. Students draw an overview of the setting of the story. Place the emphasis on ‘recording'rather
than drawing, Tell students that the activity is not about being a’good drawer; itis about being
able to record all they know by using their pencil.
3 Astory map can also be used to retell a story by writing about events that took place at the
different places on a story map.
Mitchell's visualisation of the setting for Deltora Quest by Emily Roddick
9596
fe Weekend news
Weekend news is an activity that uses all the modes of language, gives maximum opportunity for
student participation and isa welcome change from the usual news-sharing format!
Strategies and skills practised: listening, speaking, visualising, drawing, writing, reading
Materials:
+ Weekend news PM18
+ pencils
Student grouping: partners, individuals and small groups of 4 students
Procedure
1. Students wor
weekend,
2 After both partners have shared their news, they visualise their partner’s news and draw a
picture of it. They are allowed to continue questioning their partner for details if necessary.
3. When they have finished drawing they write a passage describing their partner's news in the
space provided
4 Twosets of partners get together and share their partners'news.
pairs and take turns to describe one event that happened to them over the
eno vas Caving a Soe tore He we cooing
nthe Chl Sie 05 Sot OF He. Con.ther he Keked
‘Me bill “09 Hivh ose could ond all the
‘Bape. all ff
he left Side oF he Goel, Goal tt! ene Body
Shessed then the Game ended:Inferring
Introduction 100
Practice activities for the inferring strategy
Character clue bag 102
Inference jigsaw 103
Ithink...Tchart 104
Character quote 105
Character inference chart 106
Real estate inferences 107
Sociogram 108
Nauswne
Other activities that use the inferring strategy:
+ Anticipation guide 43
+ Y chart predictions 58
+ Guess the headline 59
+ Postcard predictions 60
+ Character crystal ball 61
+ Hot-seat character interview 70
+ Question-answer relationships (QAR) 75-77
+ Story map 95
+ Keywords about me 117
+ Point of view chart 146
+ Possible sentences 171
+ Word investigation chart 172
+ Spot the clues! 173100
Introduction
When we read, we stretch the linits of the literal text by folding our
experience and belief into the literal meanings in the text, creating
a new interpretation, an inference.
— Keene & Zimsernann, Mosaic of Thought (1997), p. 147
What is inferring?
Inferring is being able to’read between the lines’ when the author implies something but doesn't
exactly state it. To infer, we need to use both the clues in the text (context, illustrations, etc.) and our
own prior knowledge, By using the text and our own prior knowledge, we can interpret what we
think the author is really trying to say.
We can make inferencesat word level too, by using the context of the text and our own prior
knowledge to inferthe meaning of the word.
Inferring is closely related to predicting.
How does inferring support reading comprehension?
Students develop deeper understandings of the text when they ‘read between the lines’ to draw
their own conclusions by using prior experience. They create their own unique meaning of the text.
As they read, these understandings may be revised as the reader is exposed to new information
and confirms or adjusts their thinking.
Language we use when inferring
+ Reading between the lines, I think...
+ [would expect that...
+ lalready know that...sol think...
+ Inmy experience...
+ [think the author is really saying
‘+ Myconclusion is... because in the text itsays...
+ The author's clues were...
+ I think what's really going on is...
+ Iwonder why...
+ Iwonder ifA © Inferring support material
a Inferring
Iafersing is beng abe to sod between the ines’
hes the attr implies something but doesnt exacly
Hotei. You ned to we the ese the tert end your
Inferring strategy starter chart S29
Inferring mini poster SM30
TE tiem dren
A Modetting chart
1 Jack's new labrador puppy,
Patch, never left his side.
2 Jan flew into the room with
‘@ huge smile on her face.
3 The old lady's mouth
uivered os she slowly got
‘up and left the room.
4 “Get me the chief of police
immediately!” shouted the
president, as he put the
phone down.
|
|
|
|
|
|
J}
Teacher modelling chart SM31 Inference detectives:Looking for
clues SM31
INFERENCE
DETECTIVE!
Inferring certificate SM32
Th tim digicam =
Inference detectives: Looking for
clues $M31B
101A Character clue bag
Students use their imagination to create or collect a selection of items appropriate toa particular
character. These are put in a paper bag. Making an inference bag could also be part of a book
assignment for independent readers.
Strategies and skills practised: inferring, synthesising
Materials:
+ novel or picture book
+ paper bag
Student grouping: individuals or buddies then small groups or whole class
Procedure
1. Students collect or create items that relate to a particular character. Some examples could be:
+ photographs of the place the character comes from
+ items that give clues as to what they like to do: e.g. a movie timetable if they like going to
the movies or a pencil and paper if they like to draw
+ abaseball capif they wear one
+ amagnifying glass - if they have detective tendencies!
2. The students then share their inference bag and other students either guess who the character
or the creator explains why each item is important to the character.
Variation: Students could create inference bags for themselves as a way of getting to know each
other at the beginning of the year.
Character clue bag for the character of Jan in The Silver Sword by lan Servailier7 Inference jigsaw
This activity is designed to support younger students to make inferences.
Strategies and skills practised: inferring
Materials:
+ text suitable for inferring, at the instructional level of the students
= Inference jigsaw PM19
+ Inference jigsaw PM19 enlarged to A3 size
+ text for teacher modelling
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Modelling — Find a quote appropriate for inferring. Write it into the first
jigsaw piece of the enlarged A3 Inference jigsaw PM.
2. Photocopy one inference jigsaw PM per student or set of buddies.
3. With the class: Use a’think-aloud’to articulate to students what you have inferred from the text
and why.
4 Students read the text selection at their instructional level and record their inferences on the
Inference jigsaw PM as shown below.
| Inference jigsaw a)
| ven litle 2d ciding feed rnanes Lauren cw WS
| eee
tne book on revo tea no any
“Grade mouth | *Geandma was” suegSed
Dropped Ope | _
| ae P «Little tea riding
ed “What rood thisks grandma
a ars you~ have Joes normal.
{ pie Took _ -
j
| OO
|
1034 | think... T chart
This T chart graphic organiser supports students to make inferences, and to gather evidence from
the text to explain why they made them
Strategies and skills practised: inferring, note-taking
Materials:
‘+ text at the instructional level of the students (suitable for making inferences)
+ Ithink...T chart PM20
Student groupin:
individuals or buddies then a small group or whole class
Procedure
1 Students read the text, recording the inferences they make on the | think. ..T chart. They must
justify their inference with evidence from the text. Page numbers could also be added to show
where information was found to make evidence more explicit. The students write their answers
in note form. Full sentences are not necessary.
2. After reading they share their inferences and the reasons why they made them witha buddy, in
small groups or with the whole class.
@ Ithink ... T chart rica
res The en, the wth ood the wachnbe muir (5, Lew:s
Ses fiat ee
Po ees
The one Tey She ala a
Etna could ke sastai be bles tes ea
nes
[Shere Ben doa teak Deby |
EAnwd end ole Magyar Me uae ape Te
oC he ate wh Desi |
ey an fo ay |
Fhe viwich t2.phak bet mts] |
The Waven were HA They nae the etl food |
feepie nd were enemdes of
They ld hire Re Wt vnc
The ue witeh
Pepe to stone
| hey aude a plea to aka4 Character quote
This activity requires students to find a quote in the text and explain what can be inferred about
the character by the quote.
Strategies and skills practised: inferring
Materials:
narrative text
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1
2
3
Model this activity using suitable quotes, and give the students an opportunity to practise
Using quotes that you provide before asking them to doit independently. Characters from
traditional tales are suitable for this task.
For example:
Quote
Student responses! think this quote shows that Aniel is quite cunning as he
doesn't really like William and he only wants him in the club because he has
some walkie-talkies Aniel would like to use.
“Why don't we ask William to join our club?” said Aniel suddenly.
Ask the students to find a quote in the story that typifies a particular character.
Students write down the quote and then their explanation of what it means.
Bock: The Bact Beginning
By Lemony Snicket
quete:"L Guess youve found me out'Olaf said
simply:
os Fos this quote shows thet Olof,
Sd he Knows he is sneal
*GOUNE found ime Ut”
is a sneak
Ky because he eek
Cathy
105106
Character inference chart
In this activity, students collect a range of information about a character. This information is then
used to discuss whether the information they have collected can be found in the text or whether
they have inferred it.
Strategies and skills practised: inferring, note-taking
Materials:
+ text at the instructional level of the students
«Character inference chart PM21
Student grouping: individuals, then buddies or small group
Procedure
1. Students read the text selection in its entirety.
2. Students then read the text for a second time using the prompts — facts, quotes, actions
and getting inside the character's head — on the Character inference chart PM to gather
information. Remind the students that they do not have to write full sentences; rather, just jot
down appropriate information in note form.
3 Students then share the information collected and the inferences they have made with a buddy
or ina small group.
ER Character inference chart st
sors Raja = (108
Tacs-wamyornarmomnen? | Qu mts some
paviel
moved fron Pennsylvania “leis do itl
to Anzona JT named cyself
eee, Ree ae ie
Mee ound ee See
“eting inde the
‘hares bead =
leap whe vkelele [ESP
Jem@qyrares duryng, Rice:
Oy [aig
Tides bie everyunerd
Taelpe ‘others Oe pfeagntere
supports. peeple nen Cinnamen went ss
ts Caanarnceion ner laexastated
‘Shouvder me
‘nm there
| Star gut iS a confident and brave
chacacter. She deesm't juhe other people
god accepts tr for who they are.FA Real estate inferences
Real estate advertisements often include some great examples of inference. Have fun deciphering
what the advertisements really mean!
Strategies and skills practised: inferring
Materials:
= examples of real estate advertisements that use inference (for modelling)
+ selection of real estate pages from magazines or newspapers
+ chart paper
+ markers
+ scissors
+ glue sticks
+ pencils
Student groupin:
Procedure
1 Use examples of real estate advertisements to
show how advertisers use inference to influence
prospective buyers. Discuss what statements
such as ‘handyman’s dream; ‘lifestyle starter’ or
‘entertainers’ delight’ really mean? Explore the
idea of a positive spin.
2. Individually or working with a buddy, students
take a page of real estate advertisements and find
examples of inferring.
3. They then cut them out and glue them onto chart paper and explain what the advertisement is
inferring.
4 Asanextension, students could choose one picture of a house and make up their own
advertiser's slogan that uses inference. This could then be made into a class real estate page.
. There 1s O sROre
TA ona TOS Foe grand chularen
nei
lob A com
3: a
ser NN : hose,
Peace ful
Shade ——
ee | \ No bard work,
Nok too Cosy.
107| Sociogram —— — ——
A sociogram is a graphic organiser that investigates the relationships between people. It may be
Used to focus on what can be inferred about characters. Sociograms are suitable for both narrative
and factual text.
Strategies and skills practised: inferring
Materials:
+ text to summarise
= paper
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1. After the students have read the text, ask them to think about the different characters or people
in thetext.
2. Students then record the characters or people in circles and draw arrows to show the
relationships they have with one another. This can be as simple as mother, friend, teacher, etc,
or more complex relationships where inferred information is used,
afar For Tournes to Tangi wos
Lawrence and Reny
108Summarising
Introduction 112
Practice activities for the
summarising strategy
Learning about key words
1 Keywords about me 117
2 Keyword notes 118
3. Selective underlining 119
4 Keyword hunt 120
Note-taking
1 About/point chart 121
2. Tictac-toe note-taking 122
3 Currentevents summary 123
4 What’ the big idea? 124
Summary frames for writing
1 Three-word summary 125
2 One-sentence summary frames 126
3. Summary frames 127-128
Oral summaries
Say something 129
Story sticks 130
Jigsaw 132
Text clues 133
Save the last word for me 134
3,2,1 135
Other graphic organisers for
summarising
Filmstrip summary boxes and strips 131
Personal timelines 136
Story pyramid 137
Bio poems 138
Animal data gathering chart 139
Beginning, middle and end flipchart 140
OuAWNa
AuAWNo
Other activities that use the
summarising strategy:
+ Key word story strips 63
+ Character inference chart 106
+ Scanning grid 160
a1Introduction
- research suggests instruction and practice in summarising not only
improves students’ ability to summarise text, but alse their overall
comprehension of text content. . .
~ Duke & Pearson (2002)
What is summarising?
Asummary is a shortened version of the original text which includes all the main ideas and
important detailsand is structurally similar to the original text.
Itis one of the most difficult strategies for students to master and one of the hardest to teach.
Effective teaching of summarising requires multiple modelling sessions and many opportunities
for students to practise. However, itis worth persisting with, as itis an extremely useful strategy for
students to master as they go on to study at higher levels.
When we ask students to summarise, we often find that they copy out big chunks of text, include
unimportant details, or write too much or too little. Students need explicit teaching in order to
become proficient at summarising. They need to be able to:
+ identify the main idea/s
+ use key information - words, facts and phrases
+ takenotes
‘+ retell a shortened version of the text in their own words.
What's the difference between retelling and summarising?
Retelling and summarising are related but not exactly the same.
Retelling is orally restating what the student remembers of the text. Itis the beginning stage
of summarising and is an important informal assessment tool, particularly for younger students, It
requires that students reprocess the text, thinking about the sequence of ideas/events and their
importance.
Retelling has many benefits for both the student and the teacher.
For the student,
+ provides an opportunity to share what they have read
+ reinforces the structure of the text type or genre that
+ provides practice in sequencing the text
+ develops oral language skills
+ provides variety from being asked questions.
For the teacher, i
+ isa valuable informal assessment tool that requires little preperation.
being retold
Here are some examples of different ways to retell:
Oral to oral: student listens to a selection and retells it orally
Oral to written: student listens toa selection and retells itin writing
Reading to oral: student reads a selection and retells it orally
Reading to written: student reads a selection and retells it in writing
Viewing to oral: student views a visual text (e.g. amovie or TV programme) and retells it orally
Vie
1g to written: student views a visual text (e.g. a movie or TV programme) and retellsit in writing.How does summarising support reading comprehension?
In order to summarise, the students must attend closely to the text and be able to include
information that gives the essence of the text. Summarising also playsa part in the ability to
synthesise — if the students are able to articulate the main points and ideas of a text, they are more
ready to synthesise.
Language we use when summarising
+ The most important thing to know about is
+ The main point the author is making is
+ Inmy own words, the story/article is about
+ The most important idea in this article/story is
+ Another name for this story/article could be
+ The main idea of this textis
«The article/story is mostly about
+ The whole point of this story/article is 4
+ If had to explain this to someone else, | would say
+ Sofarl have learned
Other helpful questions to ask when summarising are
Who? When? Where? What? How?
Teaching summarising
Before you start...
Two of the most helpful skills for students to acquire in order to be able to summarise are:
1 the ability to recognise key words, facts and phrases, and
2 the ability to take notes.
Learning about key word facts and phrases
The Key word starter chart (SM36) may be used to explicitly model or revise what a key word is.
Also see the ‘Learning about keywords summarising activities later in the chapter for ideas.
Learning about note-taking
Use the note-taking starter chart
to introduce or revise note-taking,
Encourage students to understand
that it’s okay to personalise
their notes; ie. have your own
abbreviations, symbols; etc. This is
where text messaging type language
can actually be useful! Note-taking
requires lots of practice and specific
feedback as the students develop.
113114
Modelling summarising
When you feel confident the students have some understanding of what a key word isand have
had some experience at taking notes, it’s time to start teaching summarising.
Read the Summarising starter poster SM33 and discuss with the students.
Read a selection of examples of summaries to the students.
‘Some ides are:
* abook blurb
‘+ ‘about the author’ information in a book
+ _afilm/television programme blurb from a newspaper
+ part ofa curriculum vitae.
Using a short piece of photocopied text enlarged to A3 size, model how you would summarise a
text. Use a highlighter pen to identify key words, phrases and inform. Link the highlighted
information together to make a summary.
Use the Student checklist for summarising SM35 for students to self-assess their work. Review
the checklist with them before they start to write their summaries, to clarify what a good summary
contains.
Teaching younger students to summarise
Itis important for students to know there are different levels of summarisation. Younger students.
can be introduced to summarising through retellings, three-word summary (page 125), one-
sentence summary (page 126) and summary frames (page 127).—
SS Summarising support material
Summarising
‘mini poster SM34
SUMMARISING
SUPER STAR!
EE EE SS = a ee eS ES lClUrcrerhlCUrcaer lca ll eer hl lca el Elot eat anmaing i word
Eh suse det te snr El What is a key word? kaye
‘Atay scmaing tat
‘ay worden werd thot
tn the mening of
tence tp yout
ron expla.
EB sient ko onmarting react tena
SMBS
‘Stroman Sec eestor ore 2 eter ev Oh Gomes
2 fayette i ed eee Sa,
ees ed he key mers a these entenes
1 chickens ge os maton op
2 Wight mene ithe
4 Inca tes ima ftw ud
Good readers notice kay word at snares rn ey or
1 le fork spo0n impliment eat
Student checklist forsummarising Key word sterter chart SM36 Key word practice chart SM37
. G Topic sentence
What is a topic sentence
The top enc stefani paragraph
What does it do?
Riteduce the main ia ofthe poarch
How do I write a topic sentence?
Sumaisehe man de of your paragraph tet he reader
now whatyour peragraph il be about
‘Show me an
The chee the Worlds eee land nil Ii pecaod
for sped though many adaptations. Cheers bods are
rarow an lighweght They have log lendet legs and semi-
Teves on the feet that ate gripe on rmning
‘hoes. The cher head is mall ndaerodynamicly shaped
toallow frit wind esiance Final the cheetah hasan
enlarged lier heart lng and vaca system tall ext
caygen to Sow through body when traveling a high speeds
Note-taking
‘Note-tohing sa fast writing technique. Instead of
‘iting fall setonces you only write key words and
information,
"Notes con include:
‘grophie orgorisers
What really matters is that
your notes make sense to you!
116
Topic sentence starter chart SM38 ‘Note-taking starter chart SM39Key words about me
Key words about me is a child-centred activity that Introduces the idea of key words. It can also be
usedat the beginning of the year to promote self-esteem and develop a positive classroom culture.
Strategies and skills practised: developing key words and phrases, promoting positive self-esteem
Materials:
+ photo of child (or a self-drawn portrait)
+ scissors
+ markers
= paper and pencil
Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
1. Take photographs of students individually and print.
2 Have students cut out their photo (or their self-drawn portrait) and stick ontoa sheet of paper.
3. They then write eight key words or phrases about themselves, e.g. boy, French, 8 years, blue
eyes, blond hair, soccer player.
4 Other students in the class may add positive comments to their key word list. For example:
good friend, best goal kicker, tells funny jokes, etc.
Key Words abort
17118
Key word notes
Key word notes Is a group activity that develops a range of skills necessary for summarising.
Strategies and skills practised:
summarising
‘ening, visualising, retelling, note-taking, identifying key words,
Materials:
+ text selection
+ paper and pencil
+ highlighter pens
Student grouping: individuals then small groups
Procedure
1. First reading: the teacher reads the text to the students, asking them to close their eyes and
visualise the story as itis read.
2. Retelling: the students then take turns orally retelling the text to a buddy.
3. Second reading; the teacher reads the text to the students again. This time they take notes
Notes can use symbols, pictures, words or a combination of these. Discuss the idea of
abbreviations, e.g. one letter to describe a character: instead of writing Pheidippides, just write
eS
4 After the second reading, the students get together in groups of 4-6 and look for words they
have all written in their notes. They highlight, underline or circle these words. If they have no
words that are exactly the same they look for similar words that are most common in all their
sets of notes, e.g. one student may have wide wing span in their notes and another student
may have huge wing span. They can be counted as the same.
5 Ask the students what they could call the group of words they have all highlighted. Hopefully
they recognise that these are key words and phrases.
Optional: All student groups bring their notes to the floor and the teacher and class jointly
construct a summary of common key words and phrases.
the Legend of the Marathon
emerson Kino, worked 10 eweioemainens
wy = aOOowSolders
ee ravmmawonkme 10 ask sSpartans 40 help
@ con ack
eKtheniang Sua Pecsians alone at marathone
\
| 4
phgiiGASemvoitalantt{e
(Goacasolders
esait ©) nck 1 Atheis with news of viclory
After the ri ©) coltapsedamandeedvedt
Lana's key word notes for Legend of the MarathonSelective underlining
Selective underlining is an activity that explicitly teaches students how to underline important
information such as the topic sentence or key words.
After they have underlined the words they can use them to summarise the text.
NB Underlining can be either underlining the text or using a highlighter pen.
Strategies and skills practised: determining importance, identifying key information, summarising
Materials:
+ photocopies of a text appropriate to theinstructional level of the students
= overhead transparency or enlarged photocopy of a different piece of text to model the task
+ pen or pencil or highlighters
Student grouping: individuals
Procedure
1 Explain that underlining text and writing notes in the margin are useful ways to highlight and
organise information.
2. Use an overhead transparency or an enlarged photocopy of a text selection to model
underlining key information (or whatever your focus is). You could also use a highlighter pen to
highlight words and phrases, rather than underlining.
3 When main points are not explicit, create your own and jot them in the margins.
Variation: Underline the main ideas in one colour highlighter and the details in another colour.
Different colours could also be used to distinguish between different viewpoints in a text.
Your Brain — how does it work?
ia ttc birds, reptiles, fish, and amphibians Wave'a f
int But the human) 7. erent from other animals. It is able to
thinikjplan, speak and . It is truly an incredible ovgant
‘The human brain is able to fete an astonishing number of tasks at
once. a HieatPPte and
breathilly. It a huge at of pom ins the world
around you from your wi (3 sitiélling, tasting,
steht, etc). It controls Ditiioy when you are walking, talking,
standing or sitting. It lets you thittk dream, fea8On-and experience
emotions.
All of these fa8ks are a fd, cbiitfbllett and wegulated by an organ
that is about the s ead of cauliflower: Sur brain. The
scientifié Stidy of the brait’ and GEREN i is called rieuboscience oy
neurobiology!
119Key word hunt
‘The key word hunt graphic organiser is a flowchart that takes the student explicitly through the
process of searching for key words, identifying them and then using them to write a summary. It
can also be used as an assessment tool to see how well students are grasping the idea of note-
taking, finding key words and phrases and writing a summary.
Strategies and skills practised: locating key words and phrases, note-taking, summarising
Materials:
+ suitable text to summarise
+ Key word hunt PM22
© pencils
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Students read the text selection in its entirety to get an overall sense of what the text is about.
2. Students read the text again, noting important details, possible key words, etc, in the boxes on
the left-hand side of the graphic organiser.
3. They then write the key words and phrases in the top box on the right.
4 Finally they write their summary using the key words and phrases in the box below that.
Key word hunt ares
Find the key words And unlock the meaning of the text!
re [ending on moon ote 157,
( Vanda on Toly Disk 14GH.
Described Surface, being paudered chareal.
SieSecepens ort con ty tooreAbout/point chart
‘The ‘about/point chart’ (Morgan, Meeks, Schollaert & Paul, 1986) is a graphic organiser that provides
a structure for students to record both the main idea of a text and the supporting details.
Strategies and skills practised: recording main ideas and supporting details
Materials:
+ 2short pieces of factual or persuasive text at the students’ instructional level (one for modelling
the procedure)
+ About/point PM23 (1 per student)
«© 2copies of About/point PM23, enlarged to A3 (one for modelling and one to summarise
student ideas with the whole class)
Student grouping: whole class then buddies or individuals
Procedure
Modelling
1. The teacher reads a short piece of factual or persuasive text to the students using a think-aloud
tomodel finding and recording the main points. These are recorded in the The text is ABOUT’
section of the chart.
2 Usea think aloud to model how to find the supporting details in’ The authors POINTS are”
section of the chart.
Guided practice
1 Give the students a different piece of text at their instructional level.
Have them fill out the chart with a buddy.
Come together as a class and share answers.
Record group consensus on the second enlarged About/point PM.
Repeat the procedure with increasingly complex texts.
wan
ote 15.5, |
Tetons Road Safely
ABOUT: = €085ing & Coad
re 6055 at @ CroSSing if you can
POINTS ore: siook both ways befare you crass
swalk quickly a¢ross the road
«don't run
124Tic-tac-toe note-taking chart
Taking notes in a grid form is an easy structure that students can replicate independently. It also
gives them an opportunity to decide what headings they will collect information under.
Strategies and skills practised: note-taking
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ Tic-tac-toe note-taking chart PM24
‘Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Depending on the reading purpose, students decide or teacher directs what the headings will
be forcollecting notes.
2. Students read the text, stopping to note information under appropriate headings. Remind the
students that they don't have to write full sentences, and that they can personalise their notes
using pictures and abbreviations to save time (see Note-taking starter chart).
r a el rt
|B Tictacctoe note-taking
| w Koala Facts mete Ree |
| veeromes Yoshie, ate 15-12,
Scientific Sie: comes,
Name : up to Free
Paascolarcterd 35cm long | Easten
cinereus | Tg .n,| Australia
seigh 6-91 kgs
| one of eats leaves] sleeps Cor
Australias J of gum »Jup to te |
| Farncus trees hours a
| ammals [gers water | day
Kom its fe
Oe on its
food!
nas sharp
Claws
a
marsypial
uses iF claws
fo chm
trees.Current events summary
‘Students use a newspaper article to practise creating a summary. Collect copies of your local
suburban newspaper for students to use - local newspapers are easy for students to handle and are
more likely to contain news about their own community that they can connect with.
Strategies and skills practised: locating explicit information in a text, close reading, summarising
Materials:
‘+ newspaper article (factual report) ~ 1 per student
+ highlighter pen (optional)
= Current events summary PM25
‘Student grouping: individuals, buddies, then groups of 4 students.
Procedure
1 Students select a newspaper article thatis of interest to them.
2. They read it and then briefly discuss the article with a buddy.
3. Students use the event map PM as a structure to record information. They may want to use a
highlighter pen to highlight information in the article that is relevant.
Students share their event map with a buddy.
They then rewrite a summary of the newspaper article in their own words,
Students share and evaluate each other's summaries in a small group.
Each group chooses their best summary to share with the whole class.
Depending on the level of the students, this activity may be best done over two sessions - the
first to collect information on the event map and the second to write a summary.
eNVauasn
roe Summarising, sees nas OMIOC ow 20.05
f —
Current events summary PM2s
|
|
i s oe Gs
| Wher oi ithoppen?
| Yoruory ea
Whos per eed ow three?
Dr Cucks A skorm tnt the
ceca vi) eae
curre because A \ off the boat.
hit the ShiP-
423194
What's the big idea?
What's the big idea? is best introduced in a whole class setting, As students become more proficient
in summarising the text, they can complete the activity independently.
Strategies and skills practised: locating key words, phrases and information, note-taking,
determining importance, summarising
Materials:
+ anewspaper article or similar text
+ What’ the big idea? P26
+ pencils
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Students read through the text once to get the gist of it.
2 They then read it through a second time, noting down information in the appropriate boxes on
the What's the big idea? PM.
3 Finally, they summarise their information in 25 wordsin the boxes provided.
NB Students don't have to use exactly 25 words, but should aim for a maximum of 25.
| @ What's the big idea? nes
| Golden. guts de momen ana
‘he et on car hy erase at nent he ution
indell twind- Carohine and
or Evers-
Georgia
war Win a god medal wm rowing,
| weer The Olympic Gomes In Beynd.
wer August 1" 2005 407 Pea
wp Becase they bel German and came]
First.
von They could oot ath tre oh —
"eleemitolan any each otner.
Een Sui hove
| won their saedor
| beat) (te _) oerman}( oy)
ine} fundreit) CoP) (Co) econ)Three-word summary
Three-word summaries are a simple way to introduce the concept of summarising. They require
deeper level thinkingas students select and justify why they have chosen the three words that are
the most important in the story.
Strategies and skills practised: summarising, determining the main idea, just
ng a point of view
Materials:
+ story or piece of text to read aloud
Student grouping: individuals, buddies, small group then whole class
Procedure
1. The teacher readsa story aloud to the students.
2. Individually, the students write down the three words that they think are most important in the
story. The words don't have to appear in the story, but must be about ideas of themes that the
story or text brings up. For example, for the story’The Ugly Duckling; possible words could be
‘tejectiony‘acceptance, beauty’ Students must be able to justify why they have chosen those
words.
3. Allocate some time for students to get together with a buddy to discuss and justify why they
have chosen those words.
‘One set of buddies joins another set of buddies and they share their words.
5. Students share their summaries and then come to a consensus about which three words are the
most important.
6 Finally the whole class discusses which words were the most popular choices and why.
" prejudi
+ Friendship
ammystical
‘Ana and Blake's three-word summary for The Silent One by Joy Cowley
125126
One-sentence summary frames
‘One-sentence summary frames provide a simple structure to support students to summarise
t
Prefix card check sheet SM48 Suffix card check sheet SM49
| Ecorse
Context clues bookmark SM51
WORD |
WIZARD! |
|
Vocabulary certificate SM52Rivet
Rivet (Cunningham, 1992) is similar to the guessing game, hangman. This activity may be used to
introduce new or key vocabulary and is also helpful as a spelling support.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, building vocabulary
Materials:
* narrative or informational text
+ highlighter
+ paper and pen
Student grouping: individuals or buddies
Procedure
1 Choose a selection of key words from the text or appropriate to the topic you are introducing.
2. For each word, the teacher draws a line to represent each letter of the word.
Forexample
3. The teacher slowly writes the letters of the word in the spaces.
For example: ¢ @ © The students are encouraged to guess the
word at any time.
4 When someone guesses the correct word they must complete the word by calling out the
remaining letters.
You can also play this game like the Wheel of Fortune television show. Divide the class into teams.
Each team has a tur to call out a letter. The teacher fils in all of the blanks corresponding to this
letter. The teams keep guessing until one team guesses the word.
167=| Word sorts
Word sorts are a great way to introduce new vocabulary and prepare the students for reading.
Students literally sort words into different categories and justify their choices.
Three types of word sorts are:
Open word sorts: The students decide what criteria they will use to categorise the words,
Closed word sorts: The teacher decides on the criteria for categorising the words.
Writing word sorts: The students have categories on a worksheet. As the teacher calls out words,
the students write them in the appropriate category.
Strategies and skills practised: activating prior knowledge, setting a purpose for reading, building
vocabulary knowledge
Materials:
+ Text at the students'instructional level
+ small pieces of paperor light card to write words on
‘Student grouping: buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Decide whether the word sort will be open or closed. Select 10-20 words.
Choose key words that are importantto the topic or reading selection, Include around 3 words
that you would not expect the students to know. Write all the words in a list on the computer
and duplicate the list so you have 3 on an A4 page. Photocopy the page and cut into strips so
each group can cut their words up to sort them,
2 With the class: Hand out the word strips.
3. Spend some time explaining what the new words mean.
4 Students work with a buddy or in a small group assigning the words to the appropriate
categories. They must come to a consensus.
5. Each group shares their word sort, justifying how they have sorted the words and how each
word meets the criteria.
Word sorts can be used to: a
+ activate priorknowledge 2
to introduce a new topic or
reading selection
‘+ practise alphabetical order —
useful for dictionary skills
+ identify and classify parts
of speech, e.g, nouns,
adjectives, adverbs, etc.
+ introduce and consolidate
new vocabulary.
168=| Word of the week chart
Introducing a word of the week chart helps to raise word consciousness. initially the teacher takes
responsibility for choosing a new word each week and models how to present the new word. The
class then tries to use the word of the week (or WoW word!) in context during that week. Students
can then take turns to be responsible for choosing a word of the week.
Strategies and skills practised: building vocabulary knowledge, raising word consciousness
Materials:
= Word map PM45A & 458
+ Word of the week chart PM46
+ laminator
+ Kraft knife
+ ruler
Student grouping: individuals then whole class
Procedure
Teacher preparation:
1 Print the Word of the week chart PM46 onto light
card - photographic paper will give a better result.
Laminate.
2 Cutaround the edges of the chart using a Kraft
knife anda ruler.
3. Cut the blank rectangular spaces in the centre of
the chart and attach it to the whiteboard ormake a
vaall display.
4. Decide on a word for the week. Try to introduce
aword that the students will come across again, this Weel
like ‘arbitrary; rather than an unusual word they
will never use in the future. It may be fun touse Jackson
these words occasionally but it is more valuable es)
to introduce words that students will come across “™)
again.
5 Complete a Word map PM.
With the class:
6 Introduce the new word. Use the word mapas a structure to do this. Give lots of examples of
the word's usage. Have the students try to use it in a sentence that helps to understand its
meaning.
7 Explain to the students that the class is going to try to use the word in context during the week,
in their writing or in general class talk. People who use the word appropriately will have their
names written underneath the chart - they could be called ‘Word Wizards’ or something similar.
Asa reward, word wizards could leave right on the bell at the end of the day; and the rest of the
class leaves after they have gone.
8 After you have modelled the Word of the week chart a few times, assign the students a week to
be responsible for finding a new word and introducing it.
169170
Word map
This graphic organiser requires students to look at an unknown word in a broader context than just
writing a dictionary meaning. The unknown word could be chosen by the teacher as a key word for
comprehending the text, or identified by the studentas a word they are unsure of.
Strategies and skills practised: building vocabulary knowledge by exploring word meanings
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ Word map 1 (with explanation) PM45A
+ Word map 2 (blank copies of word map) PM45B
Student grouping: individuals then small groups
Procedure
1. The first time students complete this activity, have them use word map 1 (with the explanation
and single word map graphic).
2. Discuss the instructions with the students. Have each student choose an unknown word from
their instructional text to complete the word map.
3. After they have completed their word map, students get together with others in their reading
group and share their word maps.
Variation:
Jigsaw word maps: Assign each student in the same reading group a different key word to develop
a word map for. When the students have completed their own word map, they share with the
group before reading the text.
The plashe peace on |
hod oi
sed So ated, | Tieabahon
qo eee
Somnple
4 helmet te protect] -geqgies
your fase Safely glasbes
Social
I Sawa maa on
Js maheceyele with
ls viter fo protect
nis tree
|
|
The opprestin of
a tok acc
at Mel vag?
vary ba==| Possible sentences
Possible sentences (Stahl & Kapinus, 1991) isa cooperative learning activity that builds vocabulary
knowledge in a meaningful context and creates a purpose for reading.
Strategies and skills practised: predicting, building vocabulary knowledge
Materials:
+ _ information text at the students’ instructional level
+ paper
+ pencils
Student grouping: buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Read the text and make a list of about 10 key words. Choose 2-3 words
you do not expect the students to know;and the remaining words should be familiar to the
students.
2. With class: Write the words on the whiteboard.
Take some time to tease out the meanings of the new words.
4 With a buddy or in small groups, ask the students to find possible pairs of words - words that
are somehow related. They then create sentences they might expect to see in the text. They
must use two of the words in the list in each sentence. They can use more but the idea isto
keep the sentences meaningful.
5 Inaclass group, share some of the sentences the students have written.
6 _IFsome of the words are not used correctly or haven't been used at all, build the students’
knowledge by explaining the meaning of the word. Call for volunteers to help generate anew
sentence using the word correctly.
7 Allthe key words must be used before the students start to read.
8 During reading the students keep track of the sentences and confirm whether they are true or
not.
9. After reading the text, students revise their incorrect sentences.
Lor Foseibie sentences: =a
a Va My mam WiReS making & nice cheese cae
x a |
[eee K.Some pad bacteria sticks on plastic wrappings.
3 ay
= R.A creamy liquid is feaped in a large vol
: vy K- Seraleleing Solid ground tuilds up Strong
Sy masules:
= of KR. When Selb and water are mixed together it
= MORES a transformation inty brine a
wnWord investigation chart
Completing a word investigation chart helps students to notice words they don’t know the
meaning of. Rather than continuing to read, it requires them to stop and investigate the word
more closely.
Strategies and skills practised: building vocabulary knowledge
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ Word investigation chart PM47
+ Context clues bookmark (optional) SMS1
Student grouping: individuals, then small groups
Procedure
1. Students read text. When they come to a word they are unsure of they note it on their word
investigation chart.
2 Theythen complete the graphic organiser, noting whether they have seen the word before,
making a prediction about what it means (the Context clues bookmark SMS1 could be used
here) and finally finding the word in the dictionary.
3. Students share their charts ina group, discussing which words they were unsure of and how
they investigated them.
| Word investigation chart ree
i eri Sasstving, pre Nibe. winsome. Tiger owe 28/6.
(a iremee) te.) em epertin
Tigh mon a5) Haan
jan 7 | bebe tone whe
S| hate get es
Rowghy sting wild Fearsome frightening.
Goonsdable | fo ele
i “Formidable white water
i 1 ceald mean oy
P| dtace /— |dhtterent or shange,
| 5 A plant that tres in| A gucet aneling
inl waters “s
Fo | Agacinth che oe the phate has [Slvr ohich com
| Pree ee ese ihSpot the clues!
Research shows that using the context to predict the meaning of a word is the most effective way
of finding outits meaning, This activity explicitly tells students what those clues might be.
Strategies and skills practised: building vocabulary knowledge
Materials:
+ text at the students’ instructional level
+ Context clues bookmark SM51
Student grouping: individuals, then groups
Procedure
1. Discuss the idea of using context clues to work out word meanings. Model some of your own
examples and then go through the examples on the Context clues bookmark.
2. Students read the text. When they come to a word they are unsure of they use the context clues
bookmark o try to work it out.
3. When the students have completed the reading, discuss which words they had difficulty with,
and how they worked out what the word meant.
173174
=| Dictionary activities
Alphabetical line-up
For younger students: Make a set of about 30 word cards (1 per student). Write a basic word that
you would expect all your students to know on each card. Ensure each word starts with a different
letter of the alphabet, e.g. apple, boy. cat, day, eat, frog, etc. Give each student a word card then ask
them to line up in alphabetical order.
For older students: Make a set of about 30 word cards (1 per student). Write a different word on
each card, using words that start with a variety of different letters. Choose some words that start
the same letter so that the students will have to look more closely at how to put them in
alphabetical order, e.g. character, chase, chocolate, chuckle. Students then line up in alphabetical
order.
Variation: Play silent alphabetical line-up- the same format as above but with no talking,
Dictionary word hunt
Students work in their spelling groups. They take turns at being the leader and calling out one word
from thei weekly spelling list. The other members of the group try to find the word as quickly as
they can. The first person to find it and read the meaning gets one point.
Variation: Dictionary guide word hunt
Use the same format as above but the students have to find the quide word at the top of the page
that their spelling word is on, not the actual word,
What's the meaning of this?
The students work with a buddy. Each pair of students is given two pieces of card about the same
size as a postcard. They find a difficult word in the dictionary. One student writes the word on one
piece of card and the other student writes its meaning on the other card. Collect all the cards and
redistribute them so that each student has one card. Students then walk around the room reading
their cards to other students until they find the person who has the corresponding card that
‘matches theirs. They sit down, When everybody has found their partner, they take turns to stand
and share the word and its meaning.Word bluff
The teacher divides the class into groups of 3~4 students. Each group chooses 3 words to define.
The words should be words they think other students in the class will not know. Each group
prepares one true definition of each word they have chosen and two false definitions. Set atime
timit.
Here is an example:
Confluence
A. aplace where two rivers meet (true)
8 to influence someone in a negative way
Ca flower native to Spain
‘Ask the groups to take turns reading their definitions aloud once only. Other groups choose which
of the 3 definitions is the correct one. Each group that chooses the right answer gets a point. The
group with the most points wins.
Make your own class dictionary
Each child makes a page for the class dictionary using their name as the dictionary word.
Include the features of the dictionary such as parts of speech, pronunciation (this could be done
phonetically) and other dictionary features.
Downey, Sam (noun) an 11-year-old who has brown hair and blue eyes. Commonly found
playing soccer and riding bikes. Has a good sense of humour (sometimes). (verb) sam; to tell a
corny joke, e.g. Enough of the samming, we need to get on with our work.
wW5176
Affix cards
Explicitly learning common prefixes and suffixes gives students a great headstart for working out
the meanings of unknown words, and is a helpful spelling support. Rather than learning these in a
list they can invent their own card games ~ perhaps adapting the game’Memory’
Strategies and skills practised: building vocabulary knowledge
Materials:
+ Prefix card check sheet SM48
+ Suffix card check sheet SM49
+ Affix card templates SMSOA to 501
+ scissors
+ laminator
Student grouping: buddies or small groups
Procedure
1 Teacher preparation: Photocopy the cards onto light card. Cut the cards and fold in half.
You could photocopy the prefix cards in one colour and the suffix cards in another to avoid
confusion. Laminate the cards and store in two strong resealable plastic bags.
2. With the students: Students take turns to test each other. The student being tested keeps the
card if they get it right. They count their cards at the end then swap and the other buddy is the
caller. The person who gets the most cards wins.Photocopy Masters
for Activities
Ose er eerie
Activating prior knowledge
1 Before and after webs
2 Brainstorm it — sort it!
3 KWL
4 Anticipation guide
Self-monitoring
5 Myreading strategy log
Predicting
6 Prediction flowchart
Questioning
7 Question cards
8 Question web
9 Before, during and after (BDA) chart
10 Double entry journal for questions
11 QAR Question developing boxes
Making connections
12 Compare and contrast diagram
13A Double entry journal: text to self
13B Double entry journal: text to text
13C Double entry journal: text to world
Visualising
14 Picture quilt
15 Photo album
16 Nogard visualising activity
17 Senses chart
18 Weekend news
Inferring
19 Inference jigsaw
20 Ithink...T chart
21. Character inference chart
Summarising
22 Key word hunt
23 About/point chart
24 Tic-tac-toe note-taking chart
25 Current events summary
26 What's the big idea?
27 Character trait summary frame
28 Compare-contrast summary frame
29 Procedural writing summary frame
30. Main idea summary frame
31 Problem-solution summary frame ,
32. Filmstrip summary boxes
33. Filmstrip summary strips
34 Text clues
35 Personal timeline
36 Story pyramid
37 Bio poem
38 Animal data gathering chart
39 Beginning, middle and end flipcharts
Synthesising
40 Point of view chert
41 Synthesis eggs
Skimming
42 Information text skim
Scanning
43 Newspaper scavenger hunt
44 Scanning grid
Building vocabulary knowledge
45 Word maps
46 Word of the week chart
47 Word investigation chart
183Aen eric ein Cnr ener eaitd
Peer eCnt cadet eee ites
Teaching Reading Comprehension Strategies is a step-by-step guide based on the latest reading
IEC eu on ee a ea ae Un ao a he
practice and her experiences teaching in areal classroom.
Basan aOR e rR eC Oe UM ACR US Bilao}
aro ce Ic ue en
eeu u ei eC aa tet ed
SPA UII tel MURMURS acl
ee RR ue ran eens gece RS coon
REE Se uN ACI Ree ene Ce tg ac |
BCE eee eed ee ue Ut ken eC
Teaching Reading Comprehension Strategies comes with a CD that provides all
photocopy masters and support material in digital format.
BUG eete ee 7 CAC ea ee WR eu aule era cram
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Sheena Cameron is an experienced classroom teacher who has taught
CO eR Ur RRO Poe eu ALE
teacher professional development in New Zealand schools and at Kohia
Beem Ca ae lel mee cee a UR cis meee a Cue
er CUC Euroa nS a ke Seco CAS aD
order to trial ideas and keep in touch with the reality of classroom life.
Seen tere sa Ra ka
The Reading Activity Handbook and
Mea Ee agg
a ee ee ee ee ee a re ee ee a ee ee a ee ee ee