0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 1K views40 pagesEnglish B For The Ib Diploma Cambridge Education Cambridge University Press Samples
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Introduction
‘Section 1: Core
Chapter1 Communication and media
‘Unit 1.1 ‘The Internet
‘Unit 12 Gaming
Unit 13 Blog
Unit 14 Assessment: The written assignment (standard level)
Chapter2 Global issues
Unit 2.1 Ending poverty
‘Unit22 Global warming
‘Unit23 Speeches
‘Unit 24 Assessment: The interactive oral activity
Chapter 3 Social relationships
Unit 3.1 “Minorities and education
‘Unit 32 Partners for life
Unit 33 Letter writing
‘Unit 34 Assessment: Paper 1
Section 2: Options
Chapter 4 Cultural diversity
Unit 4.1 ‘Migration
‘Unit4.2 Third culture kids
Unit4.3 Essay writing
‘Chapter Customs and traditions
‘Unit 5.1 Pilgrimage
‘Unit 52 School uniform
Unit 53 Guidelines
‘Unit 54 Assessment: The individual oral
Chapteré Health
“Unit 6.1 Alternative medicine
‘Unit 6.2/7lppeauty and health
‘Unieé3 Whiting ainews report
Uni 64 Assessment: The individual oral
Chapter 7 Leisure
‘Unit 77 Gear hobbies
Unit 72 yFuareme sports
‘Unit7.3 Brochures
‘Unit 74 Assessment: Paper 2 ~ Written productive skills (Section A)
‘Chapter 8 Science and technology
“Unit 8.1 Future humans
‘Unit$2 Animal testing
‘Unit $3 Official report
‘Unit$4 Assessment: Paper 2 - Written productive skills (Sections A and B} (higher level)
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013
18
28
a
56
69
7
81
82
96
107
13,
15
B6
151
163,
170
170
183,
192,
195,
203
203
216
233
237
240
241
252
285
268
zr
278
289
298
302,Section 3: Literature (higher level)
Chapter 9 Building blocks of fiction 310
‘Unit 9.1 Plot and conflict 310
Unit 92 Characters and setting 39
‘Unit 93 Book review a7
Unit $4 Assessment: Written assignment (higher level) 30
Chapter 10 Storytelling ns
‘Unit 10.1 Point of view and narration ns
‘Unit 102 Speech and tense
‘Unit 103 Transcribed interview 9
‘Unit 10.4 Assessment: Written assignment (higher level) 52,
Glossary 357,
Acknowledgments 363,
oS
we carn Uns res 019Global issues
In the four units of this chapter you will:
learn more about efforts to end poverty in the world
understand the problem of global warming and explore solutions to this,
ml explore speech writing. looking ata sample and its use of rhetorical devices
understand what is expected in the interactive oral activity and how you can
bes! prepare for it
Look at the world map below, and
‘you will see very precise borders.
‘Countries are shaded in different,
solours. The world seems neat and
tidy. Each nation state can see where
its boundaries and problems begin
and end.
Now look at the satellite photo
and you will sce the Farth from a
different perspective, as a planet that
consists masily of water, with swirls
of doud and massive continents of
ice, There are no visible borders.
typhoon could roll around the
lobe regardless of national borders.
The ive at the polar caps does not
seem to belong to anyone. The clouds
abave one landmass may drift over
another landmass. It appears to be ane
marvellous ball of natural elements.
ANTARCTICA
© Cambrioge University Press 2013, 43cwaPrER2 ss
‘Some people say that the environmental movement was bom on.
the day that astronauts took the first picture of planet Earth from space.
Word bank Je was the first rime in history that people could stand back and see
spovery + aleviaion that we were unified by one planet and its environments. The study
ie rece + susainable ‘of global issues invites us to think in that way. Wars, natural disasters
smieroeredt © «marginalised © and disease arc problems that knew no borders, They requize international
nuttion capital solutions,
exploit wages ‘In this chapter, we will focus on two global issues: paverty and global
*toan | *comuption warming. Neither of these can be tackled by one nation aloneIm ander
a “plague to understand these issues, we have to stand back and look at the larger
cota) picture, at the world as a whole, as in the satellite image. Concepts such
as fair trade and microcredit are changing the way people do business
crass the globe, as you will sec in Texts 2.1 and 2.2. Global warming, as
‘you will study in Unit 2.2, has literally changed the face of the Earth, as
Extra polar caps melt and deserts grow. The effects of global warming arc felt in
many countries, even those that have not combibuted ta it.
‘The introduction to his chapter ‘in Unit 2.3, you will read a speech about global warraing and analyse
reteset es Sera speech writing in genetal. Understanding this text type better may
you may want ta discuss futher. help you on Paper 2, the written assignment and the interactive oral.
Hore are'some questions foryout® = tn tit 2.4, you will have the chance to Isten toan example of an
Se imteracive oral an globe wating and Show i was asses acconding wo
ee ‘Remember that thishigpier explores only a small sample of many global
+ le everyons on Earth oqually issues, Global warming and payerty are very complicated issues tha, lke so
reeponstie for glabaliesuas? many problems, are the result of agreater process: globalisation.
+ How can pros goto one county, Globalisation describes the way in which people are becoming connected
when the products mad in across national borders, so that our fuel may come from one country but
enor? the pollution fromiltaifecs another. Our telephones may be made in one
‘eountry, but the profits go to a company in another. Part of growing up in
this interconnected world is showing awareness for these international
igsues and seeing the world, and the responsibility for it, as belonging to
everyone equally.
Unit 2.1 Ending poverty
“How do we end poverty?” The question seems so fundamental. It assumes
that poverty can be ended. If it were possible, we would surely have done
this long ago. After all. mam has walked on the Moon, dived to the deepest
depths of the accan and eradicated so many dangerous diseases. So why is
poverty so difficult to end?
‘You may be surprised to learn that the percentage of the world’s
population living on under SUS1.25 a day has, in fact, dropped in the
ppast ten years, However, 80 per cent af those who live on less than $US1.25
2 day live in countries where the gap between rich and poor is growing,
‘These statistics question the definition and nature of ‘poverty’. In this
chapter, you are asked to consider ‘absolute poverty’, which refers to a
lack of basic human needs, such as clean water, proper mutrition, health
‘are, and education. The term ‘absolute poverty’ can be applied
to approximately 1.7 billion people in the world today. How can they
be helped?
“8 (© Carbicge Universty Press 2013Unit 2.1. Ending poverty
How co we tine poverty? De he people shown in hese mags ive avy?
‘There are many ways to help end\poverty, and you will foeus on two of
these in this unit. Text 2.1 introduiees pind to the fair trade label that you
may find on various products such as ¢oliée or tea. This label or ‘mark’
means that the product does not exploit thepeople who make it. Text 2.2
is the story of a woman who recéived microcredit =a small loan to help
start her juice-making businessin Kenyan These two ways of ending
paverty are both different from the traditional understanding that aid is
the solution to poverty. In fact/as Text 2.3 argues, aid may even worsen the
economic situation in developing nations.
‘While peaple may disagree on which ways we should fight poverty, most
agree thavinisa battle worth fighting. What's more, itis a battle that cam be
woneif the world’s seven wealthiest individual people have more money
than the world’s 4D poorestinations, then there are means to stop poverty. If
the world produces enough food to feed everyone, then no-one should have
to go ungry. The only question left to ask is: ‘How do we end poverty Entra
“Te fest activity ofthis unit asks you
i to [st allot the aoutons ‘or ending
Getting started poverty that you cantink of You
4.41. Take just to minutes to think of as many waysas you can af ending eer
werty. The person with the longest Ist of ideas wins. Ready, steady, gal the-causes ol aoverty?" You can
poverty The ps steady sol rainstorm this question by erecting
4.2. Take the list you generated from Activity 1.1 and compare it with a spice eagram oft (see Reacng
classmate’s, AS a class, make one list that includes everyane’ Sratagyon page 47)
You may have to reword any that ate similar,
© Cambrioge University Press 2013, 45“a =~C~C=CS*“‘=~:*:
Locking at your class list cf ideas to
fend poverty find one that you oan
contribute through a CAS project.
(Ona othe main coas of CAS is service
‘psted learning, mesring that you ean
learn tough helping others.
Learner profile
Goring
Yu may be shocked to earn
the answers tothe questions in
‘Actiy 1.5, Howmuch do you care
‘bout and sere fr those who are ls
forunets tran you? Event you cannot
itecty save he aaring oven ct
the word every dey. you can sil as
‘yourseti, ‘Who do | care for, help and
‘pend tra wih regulary?
TOK ?
‘In TOK you may study optical
a
pe ees See
Ses
peel ase
eens eee
by different people. Language
aa
ae tee ie
®
way
approach
strategy (paragraph 1)
idea
lessening
improvement
alleviation (paragraph 1)
aocpaore
13
14
14
Once you havea list that has been compiled by an entire class or
group, try ranking the ideas from most ta least effective. Which would
help most ta end poverty in the world and which would help least?
In pairs, take turns to describe a word from the word bank and
‘guess the word heing described. For example: This word is used to
describe countries that are poor but have a growing economey. It also means
‘progressing’ or ‘changing’ ie a good sense. The other person may guess
‘developing’. You may find it helpful to look up the definitions of
these words before describing them,
Here are some questions to make you think abou paveny Compare
‘your answers with those of your elassmates. Your teacher €an. provide
‘you with the answers. Who came closest the zight answer for each
question?
a What percentage of the world’s poptilation lives ann less than
$10a day?
b How many children under the age @bfive digltach day due
to poverty?
© How many people in the world live without electricity?
There are 2.2 billion children in th world. Haw many live
in poverty?
© What percesitage of the world’s resources does the world’s richest
20 per cent consaime?
f Attheturn of the century (2000), how many people could not
read or write their names?
‘9 How maity people in the world have limited access to water?
Exploring texts
16
What do you see whem you look at the Fairtrade logo on the left?
‘Write down the first thing that comes to mind. Then share your
answer with classmates. Does everyone have the same answer? Why
might you see something different?
‘Text 2.1 contains some challenging vocabulary, which it may help you
to study before you read the text. Which one of the four words im
each of the sets 1-12 below does not have the same meaning as the
other words in the set? Which is the ‘odd one out? You may have to
look up the definition of some of the wards. Check your
understanding of these words as you read the text.
a manageable 5a remarkable
'b sustainable (paragraph 1) b normal
adjustable © conventional (paragraph 1)
workable usual
a marginalized (paragraph 1) @ oppressed
bb side-lined bb disadvantaged (paragraph 2)
© included © unfortunate
d excluded d exploited
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013Unit 2.1 Ending poverty NL
7a 8 a standards (paragraph 5) 47 a interest
b b habits b interpretation (paragraph 6)
© guarantee (paragraph 3) ce values © understanding
d code d principles d analysis
8 a founded 40 a consultation (paragraph 5) 2a campaign
b started ‘b agreement b promotional (paragraph 7)
© produced ¢ discussion © marketing
d established (paragraph 3) d rules. d reporting
Text 2.1
eo a hay 7 ene
. == Reading strategy
[The FAIRTRADE Mark a
Background
“Fairtrade is 8 strategy for poverty alleviation and auatanable devclopment.
ts purpose is 1o craate opportunities for producars and warkers whe have bean
‘econorrically cisacvantaged or marginallaed by the conventional tracing system,
If fair access ta markets under better vade conditions mould help them to overcoma
‘sarirsto development, they can jen Farad” thet coms from this tis, using he
Fairrade is & tol for development that ensures disadvantaged farmérs and waters {four main headings. How would you
in developing counties geta better deal through the use ol the intemational branch out further? Spider diagrams
FAIRTRADE Mark. ‘ean give you a views! representation
‘of haw information is organises.
FFaicrade Labaling was crested in the Netneriands in the lala 1980s. The ax Havelaar
Foundation launched the frst Fairtrade consume: querer label fn 198B on cotice
‘courses fram Mexico, Herein the UK, the Fairtrade Founssten wes eetaionee in
‘1982, with the fst produess 9 carry the FAIRTRADE Mark launched in 1894.
The FAIRTRADE Mark
‘The FAIRTRADE Mark ise registered/certfication label for products sourced trom
[producers in davalaping courses.
For a product to display the FAIRTRADE Maric it must meet international Fairtrade:
standards which are sei ky the intemational cetiization body Fairtrade Labeling
(Organisations International (FLO), Thase standards ere agreed through a process:
cof research and consultation with key participants in he Fairtrade scheme,
Including producers themselves, traders, NGOs, academic insitutions and labelling
‘organisations such as tha Fairtrade Foundation
What does'the symbol represent?
The eye-catching blue, greenjwhite and black FAIRTRADE Mark was adopted by
FFLO Intorationslin.2002, Tho symbol open te ntarpretstion ~ sors eae a pare
chats graen test, gore see the black swi ate carte as a reac leading 10 @
brighterfuture. The most popular interpretation is to imagine the blue as sky, the
roan 28 grass, and tne back dot and suit at he esrtr a8 parson helsing one
arm alot. Tatfigure represents the people al ihe heat ofthe Fairvade system =i
could. a farmer holding up thee product shopper reacring t purchase, or a
campaigner fgrting for greater justice inintematonal vade.
How can the Mark be used?
‘Asa registered cenfication mark and trademark, there are stict ras forhow
the FAIRTRADE Mark can be used —bath for product packaging, and for wider
romtional and earrpaigning Use.
rw a erg
(© Carbncge Universty Press 2013 arText and context
* The term i trade’ implies that
‘hare is untae inthe wor, The
faim othe Fartrade organisstion
is to make sure thet farmers and
manuiactrers are paid afar pres
for the pracucts they produce.
* Inmany developing nations,
ei erarenrcoel
conditions ara bad.
paid fair wages and their
18
18
4D imagine someone loaned you $30. Writ
a
Here are some comprehensin questions based on Text 2.1. Answer
them in complete sentences with reference to the text
2 How does Fairtrade helparmers in developing countries?
b What was the dtst Fairtrade product?
© How does a produictreceive the FAIRTRADE Mark?
d What mostipeople see in the FAIRTRADE Mark?
Imagine you aré shopping with a friend or relative. They see the
FAIRTRADE Mark on a chocalate bar, but do not know what it
means, The chocolate bar is 10-per cent more expensive than a
‘comparable chocolate bat. How would you explain the Fairtrade
‘concept to them, and the reason for the price difference? You can take
on these two roles with a friend and act out a discussion.
a paragraph to explain
how you would invest this money in a business idea. Write a second
paragraph to explain how yau would pay it hack. You might consider
ideas involving selling, working or collecting.
Some adjectives go well with certain nouns, Before you read Text 2.2,
mateh the adjectives 1-8 in the box below with the nouns a-h im the list
that follows, Then write briefly what you think Text 2.2 will be about.
1 ema S bese
2 nutritious 6 food
3. increasing 7 ice-making
4 ving 8 poweeres
a loans, e food
b vendors f standards
© profits g needs
d drinks fh equipment
© Cambrioge University Press 2013,Unit 2.1 Ending poverty NL
Text 2.2
Soumu Eneza lives in Dar-es-Salaam, Tanzania, with
hher husband and four children, Before joining a FINCA,
‘Village Banking group, she operated a tiny business
selling juice on the sereet eo help suppore her family.
‘But she had no eapital to improve her business, so
she contemplated closing it and finding anothes, better
source of income, so the family could afford beeter food
and the schoo! fees forall che children.
‘Then one dey, Saurmu meta FINCA loan officer and
earned about FINCA’s financial services and how its
small loans could help her transform her Business and
imnprove her family’s living standards, She soon joined
FINCA’s Mchafukoge Village Banking group and
received afi oun af $30, which she sed to purchase
feuit, sugar and ocher supplies for the juice business.
‘Wichin three FINCA loan cycles, Saumu’s earnings
had grown substantially, becanse she could afford to
buy fruic in bulk at better prices and expand che variety
of jtices she offered for sale, including powdered
drinks. Saumu was able to move toa permanear stall in
‘the marker, upgrade her juice-making equipment, and
hire three neighbors ro help her make her juices and
to the custamers éStinipin cheladjacént food stalls.
Hee success is cantriburing,co the growch of other
businesses ift her community—not only her tenants,
bur also the wholesalers who supply her with fruit
and other goods—and three families benefit from the
‘wages she pays to her workers.
‘Scum is verp happy chat her business has allowed
her to buy better and more nutritious food for her
family and to pay her children's school foes so they
can continue their education. "I love FINCA,” says
Scum, "because I've been able to fulfil and exceed
‘my basic needs. I am proud to own a stable business
and to be an employer”
sell chem to her growing clientele.
‘With increasing profits and FINCA loans
of $1,000, Saumu purchased ber own place of”
business. Today she rents part of her premises to)
other food vendors, which allows her to sell juice
api es
Text and context
1.12 The following questionsiask you to go back through Text 2.2 and look a aa
for specific words. You may give one-word answers, ts on oa
‘Assistanco} ia an organisation that
lends small aroures of money 12
8 What do you call a sum of money that you can use to start a business?
b What word is used to desczibe the money that you pay for schooling?
: poor people in developing nations,
coWhen you haye enough money to buy something, you can eee elena
it, (fil the blank) + The main idea illustrated in this
d What do you call the group of customers who frequent a place? story is that of microcredit.
© This word is used to describe the area that Saumu owns and rents
‘out to others at the market,
F She sells her juices to customers at stands near to her awn stand. Learner profile
What is another word for ‘near to"? isk taker
. “To what degree is FINCA taking 2 rise
‘What do we call people who rent space from someone else?
s me . eh tect bby investing in poor envepreneurs?
fh What do we call the people who supply Saumu with frait and ‘What ig a practar ak lng money
other goods, so that she can make her juices? to those in poverty, or giving it to
them? Why should an IB learner bes
viakttaker? Discuss your answers with
‘asemaies:
| What is another word for the money paid ta employees?
i. This word is used to describe how the loans kelp Saumu go beyond
basic needs and fe. What word is used for “go beyond"?
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013CHAPTER 2
esearch ane of the micracredt
‘organisations listod below, and
[present your findings to your
Classmates. Explain where the
invasions money gose, what kinds
Coteus the organisation nas
achieved, and why you think its
Wort investing in. If you preter, you
could research an organisation of
your own choice, oF in your own
region, which yeu find particulary
lngeresting or wortharile,
* Microcredit Enterprises
* Grameen Bank
= Pro Mujar:
* SHG-Bank Linkage
41.13 Activity 1.10 asked you how you would invest $30 wisely. Haw did
Saumu spend the $30 that FINCA loaned her to help her make more
money? How was the way she spent her loan different from the
‘way you would have spent yours? How is her context different from
yours?
4114 Where do you think Text 2.2 came from? What might be the purpose
of telling Saumu’s story? What might the author want to achieve?
41.15 If you were promised your money back, would you make a loanito
someone in a developing country for little or sig interest? Give reasbas
for your answer.
Form and meaning
4.18 When should you use a comma in English? Below are twelve
sentences taken from Texts 2.1 and/2.2. Find pairs of sentences that
use commas for similar purposes. Then make a list of six rules for how
‘commas are used.
Example: Commas are used to list items, This rule ie wsed in sentences a and f.
f@ Itcould be a farmer holding up thelt product, a shopper reaching
to purchase, dra campaigner fighting for greater justice in
international trade,
b Before joining aPINCA Village Banking group, she operated a tiny
business selling juice an the stzeet to help support her family.
© These standards are agreed through a pracess of research and
consultation with key participants in the Fairtrade scheme,
including producers themselves.
@ Saumu’s earning had grown substantially, beeause she could affor
to buy fruit in bulk at better prices.
'&, She soon joined FINCA’s Mchafukoge Village Banking group and
eteived a first loan of $30, which she used to purchase fruit.
# Saumu was able to move to a permanent stall in the market,
‘upgrade her juice-making equipment, and hire three neighbors to
help her make her juices.
{8 She could afford to buy fruit in bulk at better prices and expand
the variety of juices she offered for sale, including powdered
drinks.
h She contemplated closing it and finding another, better source of
1 Today she rents part of her premises to other food vendors, which
allows her to sell juice to the customers eating in the adjacent food
scalls.
j. Within three FINCA loan cycles Saumu’s caring had grown
substantially, because she could afford to buy fruit in bulk at better
prices.
k The eye-catching blue, green, white and black Fairtrade Mark was
adopted by FLO International in 2002.
1 Then one day. Saura met a FINCA loan officer and learned about
FINCAS financial serviees.
© Cambrioge University Press 2013,4147 Gould you find all six pairs of sentences in Activity 1.16? In the table
below are six rules for how commas are used. Copy and complete
the table to match each pair of sentences from Activity 1.16 to the
relevant rule.
a Poverty may be worse in countries with a colonial pas
exploitation in the past by colonial powers.
b Fundraising can be hard frustrating yet rewarding
© My grandmother left everything to charity which surp
Ic to buy a piece of land,
‘so much money from charity
the people heavily.
ny that understands the power of microcredit is United
rnetton. This clothing brand ran an ad campaign i
called ‘Africa Works’, which showed pictures of entrepreneurs who
hhad received small loans. Study the image on page 52 carefully and
discuss your answers to the fallowing questions.
carn Uns res 019 ona How does the ad makeijou feel?
b How does the ad useleolour, fonts, body language. icons, lighting
and general layout to make you feel this way?
© What do youthinBof the eampaign title, “Africa Works’? What is
the greater meaning of these two simple words?
The people in this ad arenivt wearing dothing from United Colors
of Benenon. Nevertheless, how docs the ad a its aim of
selling mare Benetion clothing?
1.20 If you Hiad enough moncy to spare, would you give it to the
following people? Which of these causes would you most like to
be able to donate to? Explain why and discuss your answers with
classmates.
& Ablind man, who is begging on the streets
b A young woman standing in a busy shopping street, signing up
donors for Doctors Without Borders, asking for $5 every month
through automatic bank transfer.
© Your neighbour's daughter, asking you te sponsor her for a charity
mun,
dA microcredit organisation that wants you to invest in a small
business in a village in India, advertising an one of your favourite
websites
8 A vocabulary-building website (http:thwww.freerice.com/ricebaw!)
that donates ten grains af rice to the World Food Programme every
time you answer a question correctly.
Your school, which wants to build a health cenire in South
‘Africa, asks you and your parents to donate something of value
{a weekend trip, a piece of art, a set of dinnerware) for an
auction.
9. The Ronald McDonald’s House, which supports families of
ill children all over the world, has placed a box next tothe
rash register at every McDonald's worldwide. for people ta
donate.
(© Carbicge Universty Press 20134.211 There are many different kinds of humour. Which of the following
terms do you think apply to the cartoan below? Explain how and
why they are relevant.
2BENES),
‘Black’ humour - where we are invited to laugh arjtbings that'may
be sad or difficult, and not usually funny
b trony — where there is a mismatch between what is done or said
and what is expected
© Pun a play on words
Satire ~critical humour, where we are invited to laugh at cultural
© Understatement — where lafge idea is reduced to a few words
fF Repartee - a clever reply or response)/usually an insult
9 Parody — when one style imitates another
Writing
41.22 Text 2.2 is atestimonial, meaning itis a short, personal story that
showsithe benefits of a particular praduct or idea. Saumu’s story shows
the value 6f microcredit. Write a similar testimonial for fair rade.
‘Write about Or from the perspective of, a farmer, fruit picker or factory
worker. Rescarth a product that has the Fairtrade logo and find out
‘ore about how it was made, in order to write your testimonial.
4.23 Fairtrade products are known to be slightly more expensive than
“regular! products. Write an essay on whether we should be expected
to pay moze for Fairtrade products, and the reasons why (see Unit 4.3,
page 163 on essay writing)
1.24 imagine the year is 2008 and United Colors af Benetton has just
launched its ‘Africa Works" campaign. Write a short blog with your
response to the campaign (remember that Activity 1.19 presents only.
‘one of many ads from this campaign). Be sure to research the topic
and show evidence of critical thinking.
(© Cartoge University Press 2013 33CHAPTER 2
‘Much controversy has surrounded
(United Colors of Benetton and
[as advertising campaigns. The
companys ads could even be
considered as interesting ‘cultural
artetaots). The ads say a lot
‘about taboo, target audience and
advertising techniques. A good
Category 26 essay might havea
research question that reads, ‘How
‘and why have Benetton ads been
ccontraversial for the past swenay
years?’
Dabise Moyo
Text and context
Moyo gs writen several
‘of aid and
«= She is a highly educated weiter
\who comes from Zambia but works
fe a.columnist for tha New York
Times.
* A clarion call (final paregrenh)
le a requeet for the pubie to a0,
action,
Higher level extension
4.25 Text 2.3 starts with the following question: ‘In the past fifty years,
more than $1 trillion in development-related aid has been transferred
from rich countries to Africa. Has this assistance improved the lives of
‘Africans?’ Discuss your answer to this question with classmates,
4.26 Text 2.3 contains some challenging vocabulary. Several words have
been removed from the text. Decide which word fram the lisebelow
belongs in each gap. You may have to look up their definitions first.
a debunking # rejéeted
b dependent 9 reduce
© desperate fh vicious
d myths i. (escalate
2 optimistic j) reliance
Text 2.3
Why Aid Is Not Working
and How There Is a Better
Way for Africa
assistance improved the lives of Africans? No. In fact, across che
continent, the recipients of chis aid are nor becter off as a result of ic,
bur worse—much worse.
In Dad Aid, Dambisa Moyo describes the state of postwar
development policy in Africa today and unflinchingly confronts one
bof the greatest (1) of our time: that billions of dollars in aid
sent from wealthy countries to developing African nations has helped
ro (2 poverty and increase growth,
In fact, poverty levels continue co (3) and growth
rates have steadily declined—and millions continue to suffer.
Provocatively drawing a sharp contrast between African countries
that have (4) the aid route and prospered and others that have
become aid-(5) and seen poverty increase, Moyo illuminates
the way in which overreliance on aid has trapped developing nations
ine (6) circle of aid dependency, corruption, market
distortion, and further poverty, leaving them with nathing but the
“need” for more a
m7. ‘the current model of international aid, Moyo offers
a bold new road map for financing development of the world’s
Poorest countries that guarantees economic growth and a significant
decline in poverty —wiehout (8) ‘on foreign aid or aid-related
assistance.
© Cambrioge University Press 2013,Dead Aid is an unsertling yee (8) work, a powerful
challenge to the assumptions and arguments that support &
profoundly misguided development policy in Africa. And ic is «
clarion call co a new, more hopeful vision afhow co address the
(10)___ poverty thar pllagues millions.
tan sto sama bo
4.27 What kind of text is Text 2.3? Where might you find this text (apart
fram on Dambisa Moyo’s awn website)? What clues made you think
this? Support your answers with evidence from the text.
4.28 Together with classmates, do more research an Dambisa Moyo and
find out her opinions on the following topies. Why do you agree or
disagree with her apinions on these matters?
‘The solutions to the economic crisis in the West
China's investments in Africa
Celebrities who raise money for Africa
‘The future of Zambia, her home country
‘The book Ending Poverty by Jeffrey Sachs
oS
k
carn Uns res 019 8CHAPTER?
Unit 2.2 Global warming
In Unit 2.1, you were given a global perspective on poverty, showing how
{individuals from around the world can help by buying Fairtrade products
‘or contributing to microcredit funds. In this unit we will look at another
problem that affects everyone in the world — global warming.
‘Unlike what the cartoon below may suggest, the air we breathe is not
‘contained within any national boundary. The pollutants of one.gountry
‘often harm another, meaning that imtemational coaperation(s needed to
solve environmental problems.
“They have very strict anti-pollution laws in this wate.
‘The Webaic continues whether or nat global warming is caused by
humamactivity, You will address this debate and its place in the media in
Text 2.4. In Text 2.5, you will explore ways to lessen human impact on the
environment, Text 2.6 reports on a village in Bangladesh, where water
levels have risen and created more problems im an area already threatened
bby flooding, disease and poverty. Finally, in the higher level extension, you
awill discuss the effects of global warming.
‘Working through this unit will help to give you a bettcr understanding
of the causes and effects of global warming and to appreciate the kinds of
solutions in which individuals around the world, including you, can play
apart.
Getting started
2.41 What human activities contribute to global warming? Sit in a circle with
several dassmates. Go around the cirde. giving everyone a turn to briefly
sive one cause of global warming, No cause can be used more than once.
‘Record all af the causes mentioned. How many could the group think of?
2.2 Once you have listed the causes of global warming, rank them in the
order in which you think they contzibute to the problem, from ‘greatest’
to “least”. What were the challenges of ranking the items in this way?
56 (© Carbicge Universty Press 2013Ut 2.2 Global warming
2.3 Write a brief explanation of how the greenhouse effect works.
Imagine that you have to explain this concept to sameone who knows
nothing about global warming. Use the diagram below to support
your explanation. You may use some of the wards from the word
bank opposite as well as the words listed below. You may need to look
up the definitions of same af these words.
the sun's rays 6 trap
b gases © escape
© heat f atmosphere
24° The amount of carbon dioxide (CO,) we emit by doing various
activities is measured in tonnes. One tonne {1,000)kilograms or Word bank
approximately 2,205 pounds) would be released into the atmosphere |S greenhouse ellect- polution
if you set fire to 545 litres (120 gallons) of benzengyivis helpful 10 scaren ‘fuel efficent
compare the amount of CO,ceated by different human activities. diowide (CO, » renewable
This puts your carbon footprint into perspective. Below is a list of “carbon footprint energy
human activities. Decide how much catbon dioxide (in tonnes) you ‘toe caps * flooding
think is ereated by cach activity. and complete a copy af the table * seapical
ow. Discuss your anisiwers with dlassmatcs.
Driving the average car nonstop for 2.5 days
A.25-minuté fight ofa Boeing 747
AA2-incHIECD TV used. cominuowsly for 374 days
‘THE lenergy used by an average house in 1 year
A 13ewathlow-energy bulb lit continuously for 61 years .
Energy used to produce 500 ky of bec!
Exploring texts
2.5 The ttle of Text 2.4 is Is Global Warming Real?’ If it is real, how do
‘we know? Discuss this tile with classmates, giving well-informed
arguments, using reference to the TOK box on page 58.
b
a
f
(© Cartoge University Press 2013 7CHAPTER?
In TOK we have several Ways
‘of knowing’ that nelp us understand
what ‘realty'is. These can be used
to aid your discussion on the realty
of global warming. Here are some
‘questions thal you might ask:
© Language — Ta what extent
have the media influenced your
understanding of global warming?
Reading strategy
(One useul reading sirtegy is called
"SOaR— Survey, Question, Read,
Fecal, Review. Try anpiving the
following steps to Text 2.4:
* Survey: Take avery quiet glance
‘trough tt text winaut racing
every word. This is also known
‘skimming (#08 page 18)
+ Question: Before you read
any questions thai coma
ents tone
‘Text 2.4
Is Global Warming Real?
Whar do you think of when you hear the words “global warming?”
‘You might envision melting ioe caps, drowning polar bears and
‘shrinking coastlines. Or perhaps your mind turns to magazi
‘cavers, politicians and celebrity activists. Global warming has
‘become a very divisive term, bur is it real?
‘The shore answer, according co environmental scieatist Da
Keieh, is yes.
“There is no disagreement among really anybody who is
scientific in any way that the world is.a lor warmer than ic was 100
‘years ago,” Keith says. "If there are intéresting disagreements, the
disagreements are about whether this is the warmest it's been since
the ice ages 10,000 years ago.”
‘A recipient of honors that istelude MIT's prize for excellence
in experimental physics, Keith has spoken te governments,
‘corporations and mediautlets ebour climate change. As he points
‘out, scientists use various methods to'measure global warming;
they produce varyingeanswers,
“Ifall the scientists in the whcld believed there was only one
answer, it would be right forall the rest of us to be scepeleal,”
Keith said, "There's nothing in the warld that one ever measures
with perfect accuracy,”
‘Those measurements include thermostatic records and satellite
images thar decument temperature increases over the past century.
“Additionally, paleoclimate databases suggest the current rate of
increase is substantially higher than normal.
Undercutting the Issue
‘While global warming is certainly an important aspect of climate
change, the term's use in mass media may actually serve to distract
‘people from the real issues. Keich uses che example of a human
‘patient hooked up to a mezcury drip to illustrate this point.
‘The hypothetical human will eventually dic from mercury
poisoning — it's the scientific reality of the situation. The media
focus on year-by-year warming or cooling, he argues, is akin
to focusing on the patient's symptoms instead of the proven
‘underlying condition and the cause behind it, In the ease of climate
‘change, elevated carbon dioxide (CO") levels are the deadly mercury
drip.
re care chery says if you double or eriple CO? in the
atmosphere, it's going to get warmer,” Keith said. “This is
something we've known from pretty basic physics and proved with
aloe of good science for more chan 100 years. That's che reason t0
‘worry, nor the warming over the last few decades.”
Scientists firse raised concerns aver the warming effects of CO?
in the atmosphere in the 1960s, when the climate was actually
cooling. While chere’s noching overtly problematic about nacural
‘climate change, it’s the rate of change that worries experts
(© Carcge Universty Press 2013it 2.2 Global warming
Approximately 55 million years ago, che climace was warm
enough to support alligators in the high Arctic. It rook 10 million
years for those CO? levels co decrease to the current level. At
humanity's current rate af CO* production, Keith said, levels
will rise back up co that point in only 100 years: 100,000 times
faster.
“There is no contraversy among anybody, even the sceptics, that
the amount of CO? in the atmosphere is going up ~ unless you pick
ones chat are just nutballs,” Keith said. "We know chat without
any doubr.”
prow. cccenry.com
2.B After reading Text 2.4, go back and find ane word that matches each it and eantex
Sih lowing dcSnitons (the nardsappeasin he cat wihesome _aMLand Context
order as the definitions given below.) Hoan sbirevatn
rete |
to imagine or pretend to see Te
when something gets smaller and smaller
something that divides people into two groups
someone who receives something
a range of differences
exactness
to keep a record af
take someone's attention away from
i
k raised, increased, heighteéhed
1 directly, openly
m pace, tempo, speed.
fn debate, argument
2.1 Consider the followifg, comprchensio# questions on Text 24.
Write a short, complete afiswer to cach question, with reference
to the text,
2 What do Scientists disagiiée on?
by Why do scientists report different results on global warming?
© Analogy ithe Comiparison of two ideas, things or events. How
does David Keith use analogy to describe the media's zeporting an
slobal warming?
d) Why are(scientists alarmed and concerned?
@ What an climate change sceptics and scientists agree an?
2.B Imagine you have to convince a sceptical friend that global warming,
is real. After having read Text 2.4, how might you do this in less than
two minutes? Write a listaf key arguments that you cauld use as
notes for your two-minute presentation.
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013 39cwaPrER2 ss
‘Text 2.5 may give you some ideas for
18 CAS project. How could you help
reduce CO,emissions? You could
| procuee & plants have ear
panels installed on a local bulling
+ Start an awareness campaign
‘about the importance of recycling
in your are
+ help with the improvement of a
local reeyeling faety.
Discuss possinlites witn your CAS
coordinator or advisor.
Text and context
= Carbon footprint (paragraph 1)
Felers to the impact @ person or
person's actions can have on the
environment
* Some products are required by lew
tw have an Energy Saving Trust
Recommended label. Thay tel the
consumer how energy affcient ine
product is. They look ike this:
recommended
er rend
Certification Mark
2.9 Text 2.5 is characteristic of an information website. It has many
bullet-pointed lists with hyperlinks to other webpages. Several
links from this text have been removed and placed below it. a
random order. Where would you insert them in Text 2.5?
Reeyeling at home
Find a bus for your journey
Calculate your carbon footprint
How to offset CO; emissions
Food labels
‘Water: using less at home
Pressures on the environment
Re-using and recycling electrical waste
‘Choose fnel-saving cars
‘Cut your energy bi
ke Food and drink: greener choiges
1 Energy labels
m Find a cycle route
zesoeonoce
‘This article can help you start being greener. with links to more detsiled information
fkyou wantit. You can cut your carbon footprint, help look after nature and save
‘monay wth simple changes. Try making your hams mare energy eficiert, using
‘greener diving tips and wasting less food.
Environmental problems: where can you start?
“The biggostettocts most people have on climate change come trom:
Most other enviranmecial problems, lke pollutlom or loss cf rare animals, are also a
result of everyday demands for food, products and energy,
Find out what your earton footprint i, and how to redue it, using the link below.
1).
@
(Climate change: a quick guida
Greener home
‘Saving energy at home is ene of the most important things you ean co to fight
climate change and can save you money.
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013Energy saving help
‘You could be eligible for money off insulation or ther energy saving home
improvements, Call tha Energy Saving Trusts free helpline a find oul more or completa
{heir ndne Roms erargy check Thi advos could save you around £200 a yar
Tum down your heating
“Tum your thermostat down one dagree te cut your heating bis by up to 10 per cent
‘and reduca carbon emissions.
8)
Buy energy saving products
Fra the most energy efi elactical procucts by ooking forthe Enargy Saving Trust
Recommended label and European energy label (rating of A or higher). The European
‘nergy label also gives information to help you choose Rerns that use lass Water.
(9)
6)-___
‘Home and Shopoing
Greener travel choices
‘Amore fuel effcient car could save you tee months worth of fuel year
Personal travel causes around a quartar fal the damage inaviduals do to the
eironment and most of ti stom cars.
(6)
| youre buying a car, use the fuel economy label to choose one that wills las
‘uo. The mors fuel efit your ca, she lcs tax you pay
‘Buy a fuel aficient new or used car [ink]
Drive less
Use your ea ass fr short tips Waking, eyeing, or tating te cas lho recuce
‘ocal air pollution and carbon emissions. Wakkingand cycling can also help keep you fit.
7)
(6)-__
‘Keeping ft for young people
Fly less and offset CO, emissions
“Think about how you sul get what younesd witrout yng, For example, ty
‘holidaying closer tp/homna and travelling by rail or sea. It you hawe to fly, think about
cffseting your C0; emissions. This means paying money to projects thal reduce COs
emissions other ways, ke cating up renewable energy p12j=c=.
seGiteenar travel ened Joist
19):
Greener food choices
Food counts forneerly a thc a mast peoples etfect on climate change,
Waste less food
“The average UK hausshals spans £420 a yaer on food that eould have been eaten
‘ut is thronn away. Wasting food wasies all he energy needed to make i Viet the
“Love Food, Hate Waste website for recipes and tins to help you wasie less food and
eave monay.
* ‘Love Food Hate Waste
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013
Unit 2.2 Global warming
rner profile
Principled
‘What isthe main principle being
‘explored in Text 2.5? Ietlls us how
to neduce emissions ang our impact
‘on the envionment, but for what
vesson? As an IB learner, tis good
to think about the i
that dive your
Wat kt ae
yyounave a
‘eewironment?CHAPTER?
Buy climate friendly foods
‘The following pa can help you choose food wih alower catbonfootpint:
"+ meat and dairy foods have a much bigger effect on climate change and the
femireement Pan mast grains, pulses fruit and vegetables
+ buying ech and unprocessed foods can mean fen carbon emissions, because
proceseing ood and lrezing o enigerating fuses alt of srersy
+ buying food grown outdoors in season can Pelp reduce CO, emissions, because #
oesnit need hested greeahouses.
Buy wildlife friendly foods
‘Some food ic mage ways tat are mere wie fend. far e@xamete wl using
pesticides Other load supports the countrysice arc local communes for Example by
‘creating local jobs. Find these by looking for labels like LEAF, organic and tha Marine
‘Stavareship Councl, oF enacsing retails na! ae trying to Sock graener food
(10),
(tape
‘Organic labelo
Recycle and waste less
Reusing and recyling instead hrveing tems sway will mean lass wate ent less
‘energy needed to make new tems,
Reuse and repair
Avo waste in the ffs ples, By raUing, urgrasing and repairing. Try saving money
bby upgracing computers and hanging on 1o mobila phones, rather than replacing
them. Avoid disposable items and pass things an when you've finished with them.
(12)-_(
Reducing waste, reusing and repairing
Recycle more:
[Naar two Wits ofall ouscholdrubbien can be ragyied and mast counei run
‘doorstep recycling collections for paper, class and plastics. Waste and recycling
‘centres often accept many other things, from wood to textiles and TVs.
123)
SS
tom dock gore
2.10 Here are several questions on Text 2.5. Answer them in short,
‘complete sentences, with reference to the text.
@ What are the three main ways in which individuals affect the
environment?
b What are two ways of reducing your environmental impact in and
around the home?
© Ofall the damage individuals cause to the environment, how
much of this is caused by travel?
‘Whar does it mean to ‘offset’ CO, emissions?
‘What kinds of food require a lot of energy to produce and keep?
‘Whar should you do with an old mobile phone?
How do many local authorities in the UK support recyeling?
62 (© Carbicge Universty Press 2013How cn wereaine ou ingact one seca?
How are you trying to reduce your carbon footprint? What kinds of
measures do you take around théhouse. inlysur travels and at school.
to help the environment? Use Text 2.5 and other sources to create a
list of habits that yau would like to change, Compare your list with
a classmate’s, Whieh list might Relp most to reduce damage to the
envionment? Isthere ofe habit that you could change for 31 days? Try
it and see what happens! Start your discussion with phrases such as:
ag Weare going to
b “We conlditry to)
© ‘Inthe next'31 days we will.”
Form and meaning
Text 2.4 is based on an interview with David Keith. Much of what he says
is directly quoted, Other staternents are indirectly reported by the writer.
Depending on the cantext, you may also need to report what someone else
has said. How should you do this? Compare the following two sentences:
Direct speech: David Keith said, ‘There is no disagreement among
scientists.”
Reported speech: David Keith said that there was no disagreement
among seientists,
© Carbaoge Unwersty Press 2013, 63cwaPrER2 ss
‘Notice that reported speech does not use quotation marks and the verbs
are all in the past tense. The word ‘that’ naw appears after ‘said’ (even
though this is not necessary). Reported speech is useful for writing about
past discussions. Note what happens to questions when reported speech
is used:
Direet speech: She asked, “What can Ida to help?’
Reported speech: She asked what she could do-to help.
2.12 Change the following sentences about environmental awareness from
direct speech into reported speech.
18 Five years ago he predicted, ‘The planet willbe warmeriin 100)
‘years than it was 10 million years ago.’
b Why do Thave ta take the glass and paper.out every week, she
asked.
© David Keith said, ‘There is no eontréversy amongianybody.”
d_ “The Barth does not belong tous. We belong to the Earth,’ Chief
Seattle once said.
© When will we run out ofoil?”, my fauryearbld daughter asked.
Ff ‘How-do we know whére “green energy" comes from”, I asked at
the meeting last night,
Try using a carbon footprint calculator online,” he suggested.
2.13 Here até thitce discussiom questions that are often debated by
politidans, Whavis your opinion on these issues? Discuss with
classmates.
‘2 As strarigeds ft may sound, emissions can be traded. Governments
often limit the amount a company may pollute. This is known as a
‘cap’. a company wants to break this limit or cap, they must buy
‘a permit from another company that has not reached its limit or
‘ap. Companies can buy and sell the zight to pollute, What do you
think of this ‘cap and trade’ idea?
'b Many politicians believe there would be less war if each country
awere less dependent on other countries for their energy. Da you
think more solar. wind and thermal energy would lead to a more
peaceful planet? How are current wars really all about non-
renewable resources?
© Should your local council collect paper, plastic and recyclables from
‘your house, making it easier for everyone to recycle? Or should
people be responsible for taking recyclables to a centre? Keep in.
mind that there are energy costs for both solutions. Also keep in
mind that many counizies have no recycling solutions at all and
scavengers (often children) sort through dump sites to find any
items of value,
oa (© Carbicge Universty Press 2013Explain how each of the four images ad below illustrates the
effects of glabal warmin,
o
The purpose of the two ads below is to spread awareness about global
warming.
How do these acs manipiilate phidtographs to make us more aware
of reality?
Which do you find more effective in warning against the dangers
of global warming: the ads in this activity, or the pictures in
Activity 2.14? Explatfi your answer.
If you were an advertiser, how world you manipulate the images
from Activity.2.14 and add text.to turn them into effective
awareness €ampaigns?
© Carbaoge Unwersty Press 2013, 65CHAPTER 2
Your Category | extended essay:
chould be a study of language
related tots cuturel context or
‘pectic tert, Language is used 2s
2 too! for persuading peopie tare
more or fess about global wating.
Find a langthy text that cisgsees,
Global warming and analysers dee
cflanguage. Remeriper. a tex may
be anything that canvays meaning
including fimpgrap nia novels,
sdverising campaigns, ofmegezine
ticles, A good example mighi be
thasilm An Inconvenient Truth by Al
Gare good extended essay would
explore haw Al Goto uses language
‘a convinee| pede to care more
‘bout the eisenment.
Writing
2.16
247
218
Write letter to your future grandchild about the problems of climate
change and CO; emissions. What do you want to say? How will you
describe the current concerns of politicians and activists? How wi
you explain your own lifestyle and habits? Think carefully about what
you want to write in this letter, and then write a draft,
Research one issue in the world today that is directly caused by global
‘warming. It could be abaut flooding in Bangladesh (Text 2.6), hungry
polar bears, or the frequency of hurricanes ané.typhoons. Wite a
news article in which you neport on this issue. Support your article
with evidence and facis.
‘There are several films and documentariegaboul global Warming and
its effects. Am inconvenient Truth is oftenvcited as a landmark film in the
genre. Try to watch this film, ar one of the following films:
A Sea Change
The 10 Hour
The Age of Stupia
After viewing one of these films, write a journalistic review for a
popular magazine, For more support on review writing, see Unit 9.3
{page 327)
Higher level extension
219
Carry dill Some research to find oat what would happen if the oceans
rose by 58cm (23 inches). How might that directly affect your life
and the place where you live? If possible, discuss this question with
someone who comes from a different part of the world. Compare
your answers to this question.
Inthe following sentences, the underlined words are synonyms for
words used in Text 2.6. Substitute the underlined wards with the
‘appropriate words from the text. The words appear in the same order
as the synonyms in the text.
After swimming he had a salty taste in his mouth.
Beads of sweat famed om his forehead,
‘Due to heavier rains, the sandbanks have disappeared,
The waves came rushing up our driveway.
After the spill. oil was soaking into the ground.
‘After the ship ran aground, it began to sink unavoidably.
He had a diary outlook on the future.
The chemicals have spread, polluting the water supply.
The hedges form a wall between the two farms.
‘Opening the gates will set off an alarm,
kc They had lost all thetr possessions, and were now in a wretched
situation,
resteonoge
© Cambrioge University Press 2013,Text 2.6
Unit 2.2 Global warming
BHAMIA, Bangladesh - Global
warming has a taste in this
village. It is the taste of salt.
Only 2 few years ago, water from the local pond
vwas fresh and sweet on Samit Biswas’s tongue. Ic
Bur drinking a cupful now leaves 2 briny flavor
in his mouth. Tiny whice crystals sprout on Biswas's
skin after he bathes and in his cloches after his wife
washes them.
‘The change, international scientists say, is che
result of intensified fooding caused by shifting
climate patterns, Warmer weather and rising oceans
are sending seawater suzging up Bangladesh's rivers
in greater volume and frequency than ever before,
specialists say, overflowing and seeping into the soil
and the water supplies of thousands of people.
‘Their lives arc being squeezed by distant lands
they have seen only on television — the United,
Scates, China, and Russia at the top of the heap —
whose carbon emissions are pushing temperatures
and sea levels inexorably upward. Barlicr this month
a long-awaited report by the(United Nations said
global warming fueled by humasi activity could raise
‘temperatures by @ degrees and fhejoccan's Surface by
23 inches by 2100.
In southwest Bangladesh, the bleak future
forecast by the report is already Becoming a reality,
bringing misery along with ie.
‘Heavier-than-usual floods have wiped out homes
and paddies. They have increased the salinity of
thegrater, which i eoncaminating wells, killing
fees, and slowly poisoning the mighty mangrove
jungle that forms a natural barrier against the Bay of
Bengall
Af sea levels continue to rise at their present
rage, by the time Biswas, 35, retires from his jab
5 a teacher, the only home he has known will be
swamped, overrun by the ocean with the force of
‘an unstoppable army. That, in turn, will erigger
another kind of flocd: millions of displaced residents
desperate for a place to live.
“Ie will be a disaster,” Biswas said.
Bangladesh, a densely crowded and painfully
poor nation, contributes only a minuscule amount to
the greenhouse gases slowly smothering the planer.
Bur acombination of geography and demography
pats ic among the countries that specialists predict
‘will be handest hit as the Earth heats up.
ATinas
2.21 In antics toi¢heck your understanding of the text, explain what is,
meant by the following phrases:
“their lives are being squeezed by distant lands’
‘an unstoppable army!
‘that, in turn, will trigger another kind of flood’
© Cambrioge University Press 2013,
“the United States, China, and Russia at the top of the heap”
“the bleak future forecast by the report is already becoming a reality’2.22 How does Text 2.6 use language to make you care more about the
Text and context threat of global warming? Find five adjectives, five verbs and five
nouns from the text that encourage you to think about the threat of
global warming, Complete a copy of the table below. Compare your
table with a classmate’s.
2.28 Activity 2.19 asked you how
levels. How was your answer
‘Text 2.6? Who is affected
oS
ae eros inverse 209Unit 2.3. Speeches
Unit 2.3 Speeches
Have you ever listened to a speech and felt shivers run dawn your spine?
‘The power of language can be at its strongest in speeches. What is it about
good speeches that make people excited, scared or motivated?
In this unit you will explore speech writing by analysing a speech
(ext 2.7) given by Senator Dianne Feinstein in 2006 in the Town Hall in
Las Angeles, USA. Her speech on global warming builds on ideas that were
introduced in the previous unit, Studying her speech is not only helpful
for extending your knowledge on the topic of global warming, italso
allows you to analyse some of the defining characteristics of good speech
swriting in action. You may decide to write part of a speech for your written
assignment or in your Paper 2 exam. You also might refer to a speech as
a stimulus for your interactive oral (see Unit 2.4 page 73). Not only is
useful to study speech writing for your IB assessment, it will also help you
to develop your own ability to communicate clearly and effectively.
‘The following activities will help you to engage with speech writing,
Aker reading Text 2.7, say whether the following statements are true
or false. Justify your answers with evidence from the text.
a4
Good speeches answer their ewn questions.
Speeches are like essays read out loud.
Persuasive speeches refer ta facts ar real events.
audience haw smar: the speaker is.
Text 2.7
Taday, I am heze to discus global warming — the
single greatest environmental challenge facing this
planet. So let me explain the gravity of the problem.
Bottom line: che fuel we use to power our homes, our
cars, and our businesses is causing the earth to warm
faster than adjonc expected.
‘The first seven months of this year, and the last
‘three decades, were the warmest in the United Seares
since national record-keeping began in 1895. And
the Earth's cempersture has climbed to the highest
point ic has been in che past 12,000 years.
‘A scientific consensus has been forged. There is
broad agreement that the Earth will only get hocter.
‘The question is how hor and why?
First, how hot?
‘if we act nowr and further temperature increases
are kepe to 1 10 2 degrees Fahrenheit by the end of
Bifective speeches avoid starting a sentence with ‘and’ or “BOY.
Itis common to start a speech by explaining why yoo are speaking.
‘A good speech refers to both the present and the futur,
Effective speeches paint images in the minds ofthelt audience.
Good speeches must have very difficult vacabulary 19 show the
this century, the damages — though significant —
be manageable. But if we don't act, and warming
increases by 5 to'9-degrees by the end of this century,
the damage will be catastrophic and irreversible.
‘So we must act now,
Each of us is confronted with a choice: a choice
that will impact not only our future, bue the furures
of our children and grandchildren. Do we continue
‘with a business-as-usual attitude? Or do we make the
changes necessary to prevent catastrophe?
Now for the question, why?
Quice simply, because we are addicted to fossil
fuels. And ir is the burning of these fuels — coal, oil,
{gasoline and natural gas and che greenhouse gases chey
produce ~ that is the primary cause of global warming.
cars, manufacturing, and co power residential and
© Cambrioge University Press 2013,cwaPrER2 ss
commercial buildings. And here is the key: Carbon
dioxide doesn't dissipate. It stays in the atmosphere
for five decades or more — causing the Earch’s
temperature to rise.
‘That means that the carbon dioxide produced in
the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s is sell in che
atmosphere today. And the carbon dioxide produced
today will still be in the atmosphere in 2050 and
beyond.
“And chere will be serious consequences for our
planet unless we make major changes. Leading
scicntists say that to stabilize the planet's climate
by the end of the century, we need a 70 percent
reduction in carbon dioxide emissions below 1990
levels by 2050.
Sa the goal should be to stabilize carbon dioxide
at 450 parts per million by 2050. This could contain
further warming to 1 to 2 degrees Fahrenheit.
‘The Earth has warmed 1 degree in the past
century, and we are now secing the dramatic effects:
‘Oceans are rising; coral reefs are dying; species are
disappearing; glaciers are melting.
‘We learned just last week that Greenland is naw
losing 20% more mass than it receives from new
snowfall each year And it will shrink further as the:
planet warms.
Extreme weather patterns have emerged — heat
‘waves, droughts, hurricanes, floods — and they
are occurring with greater frequency and greater
tensity.
In 2003, heat waves caused 20,000 deaths in.
‘Europe and 1,500 deaths in India
‘And the number of Category 4 and 5 hurricanes
has doubled since the 1970's. Katrina slonéi
testament to that.
‘And things will only get woiie as Earth's
remperacure rises. The question ist how much willl
the increase be?
Tf nothing isdone ... if eh®/Barth watins 5 co 9
degeees Fahrenbeit, the face of our planet will change
forever,
‘And heze'sswhat I'd like te askeyou to do. Please
support these Bills,
‘Lee the members ofthe House and the Senate
[know] you suppore them.
Rightnow, the mentality of the congress is do-
Sothing, and ie won't work,
‘The choice)is clear. It is time to stop talking and
ro begin acting.
“Thank you.
‘anne Fines
2.2. The study of speeches goes back to the time of the Ancient Greeks,
‘who belicved that strong speeches had three basic ingredients: ethos,
‘pathos and logos.
Ethos refers to the credibility of the speaker: ‘What gives him or her
the right to speak before the audience?’ This is the kind of question
‘a good speaker will try to answer, when appealing to an audience's
sense of ethos.
Pathos zefers to an appeal to the emotions: “How docs the speaker stir
‘an emotional response from the audience?’ This is another question on.
the speaker's mind when irying to convince the audience of a cause.
Logos is an appeal to the audience's logic. A good speaker will want
to include valid arguments and reasoning.
Here are several statements taken from Text 2.7. Which are examples
‘of ethos, pathos and logos? Complete a copy of the table below, by
‘writing the letter for each statement in the appropriate column.
2 Tam here to discuss global warming.
b Sa we must act now.
70 (© Carbicge Universty Press 2013re)
Unit 2.3 Speeches
©. Each of usis confronted with a choice: a choice that will
impact not only our future, but the futures of our children and
grandchildren.
Leading scientists say that to stabilize the planet's climate by the
end of the century, we need a 70 percent reduction in carbon
dioxide emissions below 1990 levels by 2050.
©. So the goal shauld be to stabilize carbon dioxide at 450 parts per
million by 2050. This could contain further warming to 1 to2
degrees Fahrenheit.
f Oceans are rising: coral reefs are dying: species are disappearing:
glaciers are melting.
9 lfnothing is done ... if the Earth warms 5 10 9 degrees Fahrenheit,
the face of aur planet will change forever.
fh And here’s what I'd like to ask you ta do.
i Itistime to stop talking and to begin acting
i Thank you.
3.3 Great speeches tend to describe the present and shaw you the futures
‘You can continue to analyse Dianne Feinstcin’s speech in the following
way. On a copy of the text, highlight language about the present in
one colour, and language about the future in another colour. Do ya
notice a pattern? What effect does this have on the targevaudience?
3.4 The study of shetoric is the study of how speakers use language tol
inform, persuade or entertain. There are many rhetorical ‘devices’, ana
Dianne Feinstein uses several of these effectivelyiher speech. You
may decide to use some of these devices in a Speech that you write.
Look at the table below. Match each rhewrical device on the left with
the correct example from the 1éxt given on the rights
ihatoriea! devies
ww.
4 Imagery ~ when language paints a pictiafé in the
mind of the audience
2 Parallelism — when selene structures are
repeated inlists of ideas
3 Hypophéita — when a speaker asks a question and
thenanswersit
4 Contrast = when a speaker points to two opposite
points of view
5 Authority — when a speaker refers to.an expert or
someone with authority
G Aphorism —a short statement that captures a
feeling
7 Logical reasoning ~ showing cause and effec,
evidence and principles
Example trom Text 2.7
2 Oceans are rising: coral reefs are dying: species
are disappearing: glaciers are melting.
b Botlom line: now is the time to act.
© If nothing is done ... if the Barth warms 5 t0 9
degrees Fahrenheit, the face of our planet will
change forever,
Do we continue with a business-as-usual
attitude? Or do we make the changes necessary
wo prevent catastrophe?
@ A scientific consensus has been forged.
£ There is broad agreement that the Earth will only
get hotter. The question is how hot and why?
g It is time to stop talking and to begin acting,
© Cambrioge University Press 2013, n3"
oS
‘Are you ready to write your own speech? Here are two ideas for
speeches on global warming that you might develop. Remember to
include ethos, pathos and logos in your speech. Include several
‘rhetorical devices and discuss both the present and the future
8 Pretend you are David Keith and have to give a persuasive speech
‘on global warming to a group of sceptics. Re-read Text 2.4 and
indude the arguments in your speech.
bb Imagine you are a global warming expert, and have
speech on individual actions that can be taken to
dioxide emissions, Refer to Text 2.5 and other t
seseatched. In your speech, try to convince to
their daily habits.
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013Unit 2.4 Assessment: The interactive oral activity wo
Unit 2.4 Assessment: The interactive
oral activity
During your English B course you will be required to take partin at least
three interactive oral activities that are based on the ‘core’ topics in your
S communication and media
IN global issues
IN social relationships.
‘There is no specific time limit and recordings are not made, One of
these activities has to be based on a listening activity. Although you will
swork in groups, your teacher will give you an individual mark for your
performance. The best mark will be sent to the IB and account for 10 per
cent of your final mark for the course.
‘The interactive oral activity can take many forms. Your teacher may
provide you with one or more texts and ask that you participate in a formal
debate, interview or discussion. Alternatively, you may ask your teacher
for guidance in planning your own interactive oral activity. Either way) as
the title of the activity suggests, there will need to be a level of interaction,
meaning you cannot work alone, One of the intcractive oral activities
hasto be based on an audio stimulus (you may do more than onc}, amd
‘your teacher may help you in finding material for this, suck as song lytiés,
speeches, announcements or film. ¥ou should spend time preparing this
activity with one or more classmates,
‘The following activities offer a step-by-step approach teypreparing an
imeractive oral activity.
Preparation
4A. What have you learned from your coursewvark? Try writing a lst of
points that show your knovlclghand unte@tanding of a particular Learner profile
text or unt. You will uséthis as a starting point to plan your eee
interactive oral activity. Groups 1 and? of he 8 Diploma
Programme aimito develop the
Here is an example of a list of ideas that a student generated while
[powers of communication. The
taking notes.om the film 4” Ingorventent Trai by Al Gore. Two reread ty lentes
students decided to use thisas the basis for their interactive oral. ‘of how you are asked to demonstrate
that you can communicate effectively
An incomventert Tratie in diferent stuations. You should
Earths warming up because sunrays are trapped in the atmosphere. (SE
made the.atmosphere too thick for sun energy to escape. ae Pauper
the (of Earth go up and down when CO, levels ga.up ard down, ed
0, | never been so high Temperatures have never been so high,
SE AlGore almost lost his sen in an accident. He says, You never know wht
‘you take for granted until ts almost lost
Mi He lost the election to George Bush It made him go back to spreading the
meseage ot global warming awareness,
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013 73“our opponents are cating youa
me carte Us res 019
Ice caps are melting and that's worrying because it warms up the water
ard causes more stormslike hurricanes ana typhoons.
IS Feople are confused about the issues because popular media lead us to
believe that global warming isa theory and not a fact, Sciertiste all agree
that its real
IB Making paople choose betuten the economy and the ettvinonment iS a
false dilemena,
IM Individual action ea reduce CO, exrissions to
I Gore says that people have solved big problems
eee
bbe able-to solve this one too,
4.2 Now that you have alist of what to inc! yeractive oral
activity, you can ask yourself tit. There are
many formats that your activi all os
may be suitable for what For example, you
may have read a story da microloan
(lext 2.2). This would ind itself to a debate. A role-
playing activity:
A role-playing activity based on a text or other stimulus
Ik show
I debate between two political ca
A ‘pitch’, where one or two students present an advertising
‘campaign, followed by discussion
‘When was the last time you watched or listened to a talk show? What
do you know about debates? Be sure to look at real-life examples
of these before you plan your own, As you watch or listen to an
example, make a note of the kinds of language used in the type of
activity you want to-do, whether it is a debate, a talk show-or a sales
pitch. Try to imitate this language in your activity.
Here is some of the language used by interviewers and interviewees,
as noted by a student who was preparing her interactive oral aciivity.
Good interviewers tend te co the Following
IB They give background information for the listening audience even though
the interviewee may already krow this information, such ae Recently you
wona prize for...
IB They ask questions onbehalf of many people. They may say things like,
what. do you say to them?(They re-state and question what: they have just heard from the
Interviewee, For example, Chey might say, That's interesting, so |
understand you correctly, youare Saying that...’ or you say this,
‘then doeeeit that aloo mean that? This ay alee reat interrupting the
Interviewor when something interesting is said.
Good interviewees tend tado the following:
I They re-state the question in the answer. For example. they might start:
by saying, That's a good question, mary of my opponents are calling me:
that because ...'.
Ei They stay on topic ard do not steer the discussion in.a completely new
direction.
ee aR
‘them say, ‘Here is a ttle story to prove that point; or The other day l met
someone who ....
SS They close each answer toa question with an explanation, using phrat
such as, And that is why ~ or Solbelleve that...
44 You may decide to write a proposal for your teacher. This
formal requirement, but it ensures that your activity
and be relevant to, your coursework. What should
Classmates incinde in your propasal? Here are a few q
you will need to answer:
8 Whatis the coursework that you will refér toi tivity?
(Activity 4.1)
© What do you want 10
d Writea few sentences happen during the activity
Here is a sample proposal ba: Inconvenient Truth.
We wat to base our' Truthand discuss
global warming, as One of us (speaker B) is gaing to
(epeaer A) will be an interviewer:
‘that he hls just won the Nobel Feaze Prize. By doing
AlGores a great man for making so many people
ers going to be from MIV.So she is
br a younger aucletca, Shela ging to ask some cfc:
disasters to prove himself right. She's going to.ask him
should do to help stop globalwarming, He willbe very
positive and optimistic, even though heis aserious and concemed man,
4.5. Once you have studied the coursework, diseussed the farmat of your
activity and written a proposal, you will be ready to write an autline. in
the interactive oral activity you should not read from a sheet of paper or
‘memoxise a great deal of text. By writing am outline you will have a rough
structure in your mind and a few key phrases that you can return to,
© caren urny res 019 8cwaPrER2 ss
IE you decide to conduct an interview, you may find it helpful to
model your outline on the following example. Listen to the recording
of the interactive oral that developed from this outline, available on.
the coursebook website, and discuss the following questions:
Were the students too dependent on the autline? Did it sound as if
they were reading from a script?
b Did the outline help the students to structure their ideas and
improve their results?
© What kinds of phrases did the students use but notincludein their
outline?
Sample out
Interviewer (MTV)
+ Welcome!
+ Congratulations on your Peace Prize.
(Critice say the mvie is too much about Gore.
When did you become interested in the environment?
Why do you think you've been met with such resistance?
(Can we go green and support the economy?
Areyouanté-Arierican?
Doss the movie scare too mary able?
Whoshould change First: indies or @Macritmertts aed
corporations?
ist tao late?
+ (ng ot OBhitirud CBiepread awareness and make a
erence.
" Gorgratulstionsap the Peace Prize.
Interviewee(AlGore) QS
Environmentis importamt tc Mie
+ Movie is are reife,
and theitfronment
+ Myollege PrBfiessor and OD.
yNe-ore cared abjut his research in Congress.
"Politicians an@n denial.
+ Edenomyve enwironment = alee dilersma,
S@B, compare Japanese and US car makers
“Nb. just tell Americana they eit the moat O0..
Wi vas Vice President for eight years.
+ The message is serious,
+ But the movie s optimistic toa
+ Ine not either one arthe other:
+ Ite both
Big probleris wee tackled before: searagation, the hale
intheazone layer: We put a man on the Moan!
+ Iwas my pleasure.
+ Let's take action together to beat global warming,
4.8 Before you read the teacher's marks and comments for this interactive
oral activity, study carefully the assessment criteria from the Language
B guide. What marks would you award the candidates? After you
have discussed your marks in groups or in class, compare your marks
with the teacher’s marks and comments on page 79. Were you stricter
or more let
the marks you awarded? Justify your comments
with reference ta the transcript.
76 © Cambrioge University Press 2013,Sample interactive oral transcript
Speaker A takes the role of the MTV interviewer, and speaker B takes the
role of Al Gore.
Speaiier A: Wel, belo, in Grace. Welcome to MIV and hereon the show tadoy
wae going fo ineview Al Gore. Ard hare he is. Helo, Al Gave. We're going re tak
cebout your new move, An Inconvenient Truth Ad | heced you won the Nobel Peace
Prze. Congendtons
Spear B: Thork you
Speaiter A: You're popu: You must be so proud.
Speaier B: Yes, it means 0 ott me. Butt means mare io he ewroenert,
Speaker A: Oh OX, well many cries say you're aut for eli gromation, The movie, An
Inconvenient Th, pes us! bout he environment. fs ebout yay, vigh®
Spear B: Well acnay rot. | think ifs about he environment. use excmaies fom ry
‘pesond life. Far enamee, my son almost died in a car accident, And my sister ded
from .. flung cancer. So | resed that you herve t eve things you take for granted.
Spealer A: Ch, OK. And you fy 12 many ploces total people about he environment,
bat fying 's very bad for he environment
Speaier B: Well | dart know ary ather wy to tall poople. I can comines
roremit less CO>, hen | thine its weit,
Speaker A: Oh OX. Thats a.goad reason. And when did you sort ering a
ernitonment?
Speoler B: Well, hats 0 very good quesion
Speoier A: Thark you.
Spealte B: Ihad 9 profesor in unversy who was the fist person ta
[thought everyone would care about it. So |100k the research from
Congress. Bul shangely enough noone enced about
Spealer A: Oh, that mus be s0 disappointing for you.
‘when you look this mater to Congyess. And wity do you ah
such resistance?
Speer B: Will, hats w hard question
Alm
‘re afraid you hove to choose
They thing sis false diemma,
sae bod Sa the environment and they
‘what many people say: Your Fim is
carn Uns res 019 omSpeaker A: OK, sary!
Speaker B: hope it's o wokeup call ta Americans. We emit ibe most CO. Doss that
ee ee
couse rat.
SSS octonmnpe | served ths country 0s @ stotesman for years.
Speaker A: Yeah, thas right. Thats @ good pein.
‘Speaker B: | hough so too.
Speaker A: Do yau irk your maw scares 0 lot of peaple? And whor do you soy
Speaker B: But he movie is vey ontimisic to. eve
changes, we coud reduce CO;, Then twer't be:
‘A: Can i ealy@ itdoes't seer that
Especioly compared tothe habits of big Shoxde’ they
change fis
B: Wel, every indivicval a6 re foeomow, tat
would have 0 big impoct. Is no eer nd Srmenis: We reed bath to
ay 0 those wiho say that i's 00
ay thot we've possed the point of no
big problems below. For example:
“we puto man on the Mon
very postive way to end this interview. | hope you
sii spread awareness, convince people and make a difeence. And
the Peace Prize,
KS Be Thank you was my pleasure. | hope we con werk iogeher to overcome
‘warring
ae scotersUnit 2.4 Assessment: The interactive oral activity NL
Teachers comments
Generally speaking the interview was very appropriate as an interactive
oral. The candidates had prepared their roles well and they worked from a
good ouiline. At times, however, they were too dependent on their notes,
which is reflected in the low marks that they have been given.
‘Criterion A: Productive skills
Speaker A (in the role of the MTV interviewer): 3 out of 5
‘The candidate has a fairly good command of the spoken language. Same
phrases are inaccurate, such as ‘Congratulations to the Peace Prize’. witich
shauld read ‘Congratulations on (winning) the Peace Prize’. Her questions
are generally comprehensible. At times, however, it is not dear what she
means. Far example, she says: ‘And you fly to many places to tell people
about the environment, but flying fs very bad for the environment. There
is no real question here. Rather she implies that speaker B (as Al Gore) is
being hypocritical. Nevertheless, she is fluent in her use of English and her
intonation does not interfere with communication.
‘Speaker B (in the role of Al Gore): 2 out of 5
‘The candidate's command of the spoken language is rather limited. He!
is hesitant to speak frcely and sounds dependent on his notes. His usc of
English is at times incorrect. For example, he says that politicians ‘are afraid
‘yau have to choose between saving the economy and saving the world’.
‘Then he adds, ‘they think this is false dilemma,’ which docs not make
sense, They create a false dilemma,
‘Criterion B: Interactive and receptive skills
Speaker A (in the role of the MTV interviewer): 1G008F5 Extra
‘Overall the candidate shows an adequate ability o interaébin this ECE
interview. She uses many shart phrases, such as‘oh, Bow disappointing’ to yoycan see that there room
indicate that she has understood what speaker B (in thexole@f Al Gorey arene tel
has said. The conversation flows quite euherently, though there are times ‘you improve on the eanddates’
when her questions present a sudden shifty such as when she asks about performance? Together with 2
why he flies so often. ‘lasemale, watch the fim An
Speaker B (in the role of Al Gore)i3 out oP) Ineamvenient Tran anc! take notes
‘The candidaic’s ability to canyerse is generally adequate. His ideas are in preparation for aninervien.
understood fairly well. Fotexample, he explains quite nicely that bath ‘What questions would you ask that
individuals and corporations have a tesponsibility to change their habits. the cancldatas ck nt ask? What
However, the point chat he raakes about the importance of his personal life ‘Nou yousd toh inservew io
‘he fla clear save itrmare depth? Perform an
to the film is not very clearly presented. interview in front of your classmates
and practise using the criteria for
the interactive ora
(© Carbicge Universty Press 2013 3You started this chapter by looking at twa images: a political map of the world
and a picture of Earth from space. In order totackle some of the world's
larger problems, such as poverty and global warming, it helps to take a
global perspective and see the world fram space.
Microcredit and Fairads were presented in Unit 2.1 as two solutions to
overly that extend across political borders and take a global perspective.
In Unit 2.2, you learned about global warming and measures thatipeople
can take to reduce energy consumption You alse learned that in/places iké
Bangladesh the likely consequences of global warming)jare dira it nokting is
done about it
‘This message was stated clearly and persuasively in Diane Fekasteing
speech betore the US Congress, which you studiedieatefully I Unit 2.3.
identifying defining characteristics of speeches add typicalrhetorical
devices.
In the last unit, you were intreduced to the interatuive oral tivity, with
ori now fo prepare your own activity" Unit2 4 yoUlareiaiven a sample
activity with teacher's comments, This sample aSsessmantbrings together
many of the skills and contert (rorathes ehaptor. GlaBal issues, as acore
topic, snould extend iio your studies of Other ‘options’ in this course and
affer you a broader perspective on your IB studies in general
© Carbaoge Unwersty Press 2013,