|
Morton H. Fried is currently Chairman of the Department of
‘anthropology at Columbia University, He received his Bachelor’
Degroe from City Callag, New York, @Certifeats in Chinese
Language and Far Eastern Area trom the Miltary Governmest
School (AS.7.P) at Havara University, and his Ph. from Columbia
University. Professor Frid has been teaching at Columbia since
950 and has served as Visiting Professor atthe Univoriy
of Michigen, National Talwan University, and Yale Unversity. He I
the author of Fabric of Shinesa Society (1952), editor of
Readings in Anthropotogy (1958), and 2 trequer
focia sience journals, symposieon the Far Eas, and anthologies
In variousaieaf the cova eiencos. His area of specialization
in teachin, mnie hina
|
‘an Evolutionary Perspective,
byEimanR. Serves ss 3
“The Nature of Cultural Things,
by Marvin Harris 485
Rethinking Archaeology,
byK.c.Chang. A86
‘Te Evolution of Political Socoty:
‘An Essayin Polieal Anthropology, |
ByMortonH. Fried #37 |
MORTON H. FRIED
The Evolution of
Political Society
An Essay in Political Anthropology
z
3
a
3
2
z
3
a
8
_
a
z
m
m
S
=
=
$
2
=
=
5
wn
o
8.
=
e
ip
Taper226 / nm svoLovioN oF rote soca
to maintain a systems of diferntal ranking, To be sur
many of he speci institns are enentaly olga
toot to lateriistion of nore, hic regles the
eaten of the wmprivoged with such ple slogans
ss "the santly af pate property” or “le god of the
State” Kem be wnrined, despite some recent work by
Tuhavirl pola cients, hat the acceptance of each
slogans and the concurent bea Iindoces inary
backed by a veity of fo of ted power, Iie posbl
for such apileations of power to be made in tho context
of preoiting st of Kt vlatons, but 8 not lily hat
thi wl ong rena the cae. We ae aware that soe
‘tho mest repesive lava ondvdoa relations are to
be ce win the framework of Knee thare tm death
of cae of petal eracky, Yet sch ener exit within
leger fac of referenco which ipl that to survive 3
to assune uttnately the mpererdate rl aber wh a
tin who war ot the original persocutr, In relations
within staifed solic thee can be no mach seston,
tnd thereto thero mnt be edition! Doltering. Usually
that bolstering involve the appeance of eats who
fonotion 10 maintain the economic and. poieal system
tod whose positon Sa tht sytem has wating Yo do with
nti. Inded that poston uly repre the anti
si of ina.
7 should nt be thought that the gonorlly uskeppy
tone ofthe preceding soma inate ay fling on ny
pat thatthe ate a «form of poland como or
{anlzaton woud lave been etter avoid. My vow Is
thar could tbe wold. No individual choke ith
tuatr were ever preeied in any aigniant sens, Just
ts srateton grew within wosetiedscstes without
theeomscousewarene ofthe amber ofthe alec so
late, so the to emerged and was ard st work cone
contating it power on spc cacy Yong befor any re
Setve fv took th effort slate and deat the
ay
\ ena eret reer
cwarren 6
The State
For some tine now thr has been
Irn atin word Sita” at fo the
‘orks of politcal sonst David aston (suo sh
says “The word shld be abandoned arch Bo ae
that the word is seupaloly ava, no cova hak
‘hip in esresion wil ref a act lary of apres
dean this abstinence Cail Alon tad Jane Coe
2a, to ler another lanl exp, ech fd sala
‘pon is pote vow
cal, and politica eden tno eae
isp pa Sots et238 (rams mrowenon oF rou, socueY
lad, vite strstr, and which tends to re
TiS pola pro tone pets perfor
tho spiclzoveure «Indeed thi ame
a te pind si pis ih
fase othe strentypedconcpton of Caditonal an
mio sponse syste sve the pal
Jaane ment iy too ilerentated ae tative
Ilpltive end active sruume, Tho technics
el na toes nel tom
of Irion pola structure, The Tue to flow
Artic we suggest hee i Ifthe fncone are thar
then the srtlres most be, eventhough we sy fed
than tucked away, sot peas in ars and creat
a oler soca ste (amd olan 960,
Pu)
“hisses moat lenght phsing of what the eto
logit I, Adasmon Hosbal ated fly decade err
‘her thre i poles! organ th asta
ole. rpeniaon it wer 20 ten f the st
{Hocico p57)
“Te cutest of th prvius chapters should mak i
clear tat Tcamot agen wits thee dtngthed soil
Sets, Ido agree thatthe lc i not merely a vera
‘qubble” We ans nt he confused by the pristence of
Pole! funcuone in "ooo end cram” of sell
Es that ttn othr aspects or eabeyetame of te lager
socal sytem, even ater the cmeryence of speciale’ ap
Darius Aprecation of the er of modern poltical so.
fais to cst broader nets and catch import plea
[rocasesoutie the formal istietons ef modem gov
Eroroent mst ot leon cor imay at he ipl ema
Xion of tho coneptof force sad power he fous
Ina of thos ntti desigsted "he tate”
Turthecnore, to pet the “oaks sn eeics” heory
Into th amy of snple sole, ar euggesed by A
‘mond and Coleman, cat bave the proche rent they do-
‘lr, he olny of th mami of police dovdoy
Inet On the other and espn of th ft at there
The State / 229
as tins, not bo lang ag by autoplay reckoning,
‘en hare reno so Ses at clnure sting ek
{ainlyW door moe necessary courage sae poof
view for empl, the dncon of he tay st
Ted tacely at the end of Chapter § thows how dys
analysis can bo if sched fo Ue monsateste de
Shotony. No dos see of thi ichotony meena pr-
tent broadyauged ayes a fotos, eral,
tion of comomi, Ky ral or ater elatnhi This
‘enckson, too, shold be sue fron te Scion in
sr arr caper
‘Altough the queston goes beyond the simple probe
den of definitions, i ectsy to conn tnt pbs
af the cut, Once aun i ot mater of elening
the “te” mosning of «word Bat of ating lly
that word vw mean in oUF usage and why Bee sda
{agoous ote that ay.
‘Admittedly, eae tendencio obyposasie the sate
“=to asus the state with ome myst concep fp.
‘lof mass wil of of highest gond aid cbs
mage eis ot mening in such age wold png
‘actin. Bat oul ottawa wi ae
ad neoesry cont breast ha been lop
fal and necessary concep nope
‘A stato Dot simply legate, an exctive by,
«foley sem, alee Bea oe
4 govern From the lt of view developed i ect
© chapters, stato better viewed 2s the complex of tna:
tions by means of which the power of the socioty 6 or
{ganized on a basis suporioe to insip, Note at all the
Power available n a society doer not necessary bocome
pre-cmpted ly the state. OF course the state may be i
volved in a numberof eontets for major aad rior sources
(of power and it may even terupoatly Tose some of thse
contests, although t0 Jose too big sone, a too oft, wil
‘avarisly lead to a shi in the de facto power-hlding
group290 /- tun nvoLunoN oF PoLMICAL SocrEY
| When T say dhat the states an organization of the
| power of scity I rfer to snauy diferent things OF groat
importance i the claim ofthe state to paramountey in tho
‘pplication of naked force to socal probleme, Prequcctly
| this meene that warfare and killing become monopolies of
| the state and may only e carried out at tines, i paces,
tnd under the specie conditions act by the sate, Other
epider involving king wil dor the punitive resction
ofthe ongunied sate free, Sometizes ths concern forthe
‘control of violence invades the merowest of Kn groupe snd
ven extends to the individuals rights to his own person a
{nthe frequant prohibition of suede
the Grab unas tho power of «state can be mani
feated in areal pystcal fore, an arty, atl, « police
force, «constabulary, with specialized weaponry, dil, con
scription, a hierarchy of command, and tho other part-
pphemalis of stroetored contol How diferent from what
‘ve encountered in exploring palieal contol iu egalteran
Sod rank society. To the extent that a straifed society
Tacks formal and specialized mnechanims of control i eourt
dlsuster, for in tho face of weakening bonds of kinship, in
face of the commonplace realization tht the web of Kin
‘cannot contain the enlarged. popelation or the locreasing
xumbees of others, of nonkisinen in tho society, it be
‘ames a question of developing forma, specialized instei-
tents of coorion o reverting fo a ote ealy maintained
system of access rights to asic rewurons, ti te tak of
‘maintaining general social order that stands at the Beart
of the development of te slate. Apd at the haart of tho
‘pODle of maltaining general oder i the need to defend
the central onder of statfeaion—the diferentiation of
cilogpres of population in terns of acco to aslo te-
sources. Undoubtedly, ab alkeady inaleatd, ono means of
Ine to stor common atte of states to whic we
shat very sory thy tt or otherwise take Tvs
tpn tle members, far the sein that the sate
‘ts ou ens be sbi
‘Tho sate most deal wil touble cast, Quite early
thse sppets ome snot of norms asclteWit
Sanction Cotonary heing of gts does ot ano.
wally bppens but costmay ruler and procedures
tre renfrsed by formal eration end appcaton. Balos
tht might ave tgplicdbnéneen En groupe se now ep
Ded whi kn Zoups by a eaten force Wh tho
Bute comes the pasty tht rember of a common Ein
{up tan accuse one anthers one ater, tod by
See othr fo lager scely ta sande beyond Kin
Te Site / a7
the net edn he ts of intespral ney
nd aggreion, i alo is soon reqled to Fond dopey
owe hg an ovr aprons ona ea
intro, ate ths nee owe eae
of court othr ejunlns of kay oc Pee
otro pts end hoger Sas
ted vated of firs de Sa me
pak
The aa mur etal main srg,
whch maybe oid te Veter nd ee
2 pra oto ver appellee
hese dled win tap oko ee
‘cure mt fe eat ade Ss
‘ary of int ands of concn eee et
Pons ig ned tions Ga sae a
Koel, with rye sees gett th
Nejerols Repl of cone Se a
Ine funy sa Hs gop om cal oe
otis ban, hdd ge ad yal
ine of the sna ape fd he
Ito singe ol pes es
E Gaye en enditrd gray eat hee
ted cts inlet oe te ee
Stina pry sete te tae ne
sovergiy Te i nett aa Sekt
dt poi ny ence Ratan ee
suc it mary meg sce Sy
erie eat asia
xrily ote maltese of oct han
hugh st of istry rested tho Bal amy
tyme ht
rng myers st ta epg at A
milly esabishnen always dependent upon the gon
Sal oy th ate wh pera ee
tte rman on te maa ae
Inger pet A th oy Ws cet ha238 /- i EvoUPnON oF Foun, soc
tas Known many smal sates, maitary weak that ave en
Arad for ete log. pevods amidst ae. powerful
Sedplbors. Thus weak soveteigtes may be pote by
concatenations having Ite Yo do with the sal sat
Geedn, as when Thala’ romalied sree between
French snl Bech clonal expesocs Sul ho fact at
‘ben tat even the sls tte have ad some airy
finger ths hoy fequety mimi igh combi
Senet hy ese hat rain ane
ile promising broader milly suppor.
inthe amteance of tral overegay, tow.
cer that some of the most fasnuing quony about
ie eat. A acl Chae sme
‘ony ie to legitinacy an that fn tr roger mare
than naked powers No iio now has ever been devld
Of an dsogy tat conecrated ts power and sneioned
tee, Many state however, hve undergone stations fn
hic, toto the fomfar Chinese pis, the rand of
Teeven has boon ft by a suing group’ Where thi has
Tapper win soe sat, of eve arth rs of
leet overt stent opon Invasion, the bese pin
[is ofthe previo order of fticaton verry be
Tenouly aired. Instead,» new portion of the population
termes the vacfed roles end sates, and th old ordot
‘erermed with minor aeratos
Tat anlye of the coneep of legacy san ue
sate problem forthe sul seat peta fom the
ttre ofthe hesomenon As inated nou et chapter,
tren such a cuny proponent of postive polly at John
‘Kon rcopaleed Gat pysal per alone ws ot sa
Clot to tatgate 4st Set growing sophistication tags
the vealation tat power es not erly in Ua sty
Act ples er oer military force at a specie soil ob
fet, bat soc thingy at costal of wore of information
Sha the menos of cttenmiato. rem what we now of
the anciont pitino states te were mals of ges
lance fom the outst That eal ruling ets sometines
The Ste / 299
‘sppesred in priestly gut, making the specail busiest