0 ratings 0% found this document useful (0 votes) 919 views 78 pages Rotker American Chronicles 2000
The American chronicles of Jose Marti: journalism and modernity in Spanish America. Translated from the Spanish by Jennifer French and Katherine Semler. Includes bibliographical references (p. - ) and index.
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here .
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Go to previous items Go to next items
Save Rotker American Chronicles 2000 For Later Reencounters with Colonialism:
New Perspectives on the Americas
Mary. alley, AMERICAN HISTORY, DARTMOUTH COLLEGE
[Agnes Lig-Ori-ATIN AMERICAN STUDTHS, DARTMOUTH COLLEGE
Dian Trl UATINE AMERICAN AND LATINO STUDIES, NEW YORK
ances. Apri Satna Chive-Sveran
open: Towa Reprerenaton of Latina
apy and Sentiment Curl hangs Amarin Lert, 182-15
Aer Ring Pip Wr: Presence an essence non New Bland
(cai nto, ean and tion V. Sales
neq i ary America
Rene L. Degant
‘he Netionl nso dln Gh ond rion Suite
‘ae America Chief lat Mart eral and Moder bx
SpmithAmerce
Core Kitt Wayne: PstodernianandCantempoary Psion of be
rns Pronter
The American Chronicles
of José Marti
Journalism and Modernity in Spanish America
Susana Rotker
Translated from the Spanish by Jennifer French
and Katherine Semler
University Press of New England
anova andsUnive Prot of New Engen, Hanover NEEONTSS With Love
ceeeceeaenend To Solna, in her own language
iy use Spheres deo Mar
by aoa Ce Ami Ou. 2) To Tomds Bloy Martinez, who began it all
Ate remred
sary of Congres Calon Pbiaton Date
ote, Sus, 954-
(Pandan ce nn riers. ag]
"Te Ameria oie of Jone Mit joa and aera Spanish Amst
1 Sana Rte tae orth pny Ser Pac hd Kase See
caesar wi soloiaim now pererteron i Aeris)
Inches bibiogapie reece (=) ne.
ss o-§1451-90-2(lo al yope)—i¥0-F451-go-o al. ape)
1 Mar fo 1859-1895~Ceren cd eration, al a
‘are—Lata Ar. 3 Mar Jos, 1859-19 Heres reese. Tle
Sere
rosigaaz77313, 200
ssideat soraigns
Wid LC
PA
7389
“AZ
2771313 a
2000 JUN 9 > 200
B2722Contents
Preface
Chapter 1. The Lope of Literary Repesentaon
Chapter 2. The Writer Role
Chapter 3, The Emergenseof he Chresicle
Chapter 4, Weg the Present
Chapter 5. ‘The Year ia North America: Creating Local Lore
‘hor Abroad
Chapter 6, Conclusion: Adventure and Transgression in Wing
snd Reading
Note
Index
5
st
6
105
coPreface
‘Most tooks hol oor interest beiy before hey lus go: tis ose has eld
mine fr years without ever loosening its grip. Perhaps this i because Tse
‘Maret wing ras oto be uly ieshansbe, forever suggesting ed de
rmanding new readings Or petaps the proximity of «nw fr de ste invites
te to Jk closely the previous centr. Perhaps te cniele os «teary
tnd journalist sya nt yet fund is du recognition despite the exo
‘inary prdvcton of lasails in Spanish Amerson a aly bass, Pethaps
the vewpoit of en cul nthe Uated Sats challenges us to consider our
(en ieaity, All hese themes a explored his book al ve enveloped
te tT dn’ hin they lever lt go.
"The idea for thi project began in 1983 al the Univer of Maryan while
1 wa taking core taht by Graila Nemes. By pure chance, she assigned
‘nc an anfis of Jue Marts chronicle onthe death of Jesse James. That
‘lose presetton ws exponent amonograh and then ter, nice
to his projet. Tho et age lsed mare tn ve yeurs and nce esearch
in ars, ros arcives, and newspaper les in Washingtoa, Carcts,
fa Boenos Ales, Te second tage comes a end now, sen eas le.
Tome te ies of compariag the North American press, La Opinion No-
clonal of Cassa, 08 La Nacln of Buenos Aises to Jorge Agila Mara. He
“ko showed me that ere to dlsetangle the complex tery web of pe
Tie needed to tk int secant tends of tought, history, and ferent
odes of tera producon. Pat of my research was supported by » grant
{om th Soil Scenee Research Cou thank Joan Das, Francine Ma-
sell, Beatriz Sario, an Josefina Ladner for hi elp in defining w discus
tive geae betwecn Jounal and iterate, Special metion goes to Doris
Somer who gave me nt oly generne torical suggestions from the xt
Set but eo the dps deve farther nto new perspectives on Marts
‘roailes.
"Thanks to Joe Emilio Pacheco forthe thetric ofthe sblime to Sylvia
[Molloy Marfa ise Bases, Jean Franco, and An Masa Amar Since: foe
the mater ley supplied to Ricacd Morse for the etovery of Sousa
‘Andree’ Now York poe o Mateos Rees, Peano DiGiovanni, Marcy
‘Schwarta and nner French for comectons of te vised teat ia Cas
‘ova a Teaifer Ras, who researched inthe ibraris to nd guotaions in
thoi orginal English wording, o Margo Prin fr her readings of my ele
‘elects to Roberto Feeder Remar fr his Maries altho Sergio
‘alba for sharing my intrestin te “cose: and to my pares for geing
‘books and papers fom one ed ofthe coment othe ke forme.x Prfce
Taso thunk Fata Lar for inviting met give seta theehonile
the University of Mar dl Plat; Jalae Allo snd Gabriel Gaea Misgaez
for Ieting me confont ay tories na workshop athe Foundation fr New
Spanish American Journalism in Catigena de Ins: he jury ofthe Casa de
Jas Américas for he 1990 prize awarded tothe Spanish eon ofthis bok;
‘ny colleagues inthe Depart of Spanish and Portugese at Rutgers Uni
‘versity foe hei profesional spt; Donald Pess, Dian Talon, Apres
[Lago-Ortizfr believing tat ts book deserved anlaton; nd Rs Ferd
ez, Jefe Belnsp, an Julio Roigue-Lus fr inching recent frags
‘of my work on Martin ther eons Jo Marts “Our Ameria”: From Na-
final 10 Hemispheric Cultural Studies (Duhass: Duke Univesity Press
1098) and Recreadng Jo Mart (1859-189): One Hundred Years After (Al-
‘any: State Unversity of New York Press 1999),
“To my sweet SolAna, who was brn With ths research projet. and who,
despite having lived since then with my obsessive presence in font of the
‘computer to with many moves and readjosueas, his managed toe the pi
tur of solidarity and cherules. To Tem Eloy, generous companion ene
demanding reader, for “La seganda Vids de Araya” (E1 Nacional 1978) td
his book Lagar com a muerte, which lode to disove tht ving form
‘ofteratre hal fund lace in te daly pages of journalism long bere my
counter with “esse Tames” Hs apron fo iteratre aod joualin hat
‘rated Ife int this project fom begining to ead
‘The American Chronicles of José MartiChapter |
The Logic of Literary Representation
|The Problem of Modernity
‘By 1888, the terms “moder” ond “modem” were so atimilly raed
fot write’ that Rub Dao wat thing te two interchangeably. AL tat ine
in Spnish America, modelty meant he perception of the beplanng of i-
tlstiiaion and the concolion of songs bureaucratic saes—oaly
(Co and Putt Rico rertinod unde Spsnsh agemony—end the ieoepont-
‘Sonof tat hemispere lt th intemllona economic te,
"To be made meant a geacral terms, new stmospiee: sia, sam
engines, face tslegrapte, dally newspaper lephones, seetife dicow-
(Ses aban center that changed the sage of soxety andthe dsbuion
‘tendon socal less, Tp be moder, im Westen terms, mean fit ia
eve ehnologes: mn, at designe, woul! inprove the miei world ando-
‘ety would become «wap thanks wo bis ew efficiency. Te be modem wa
fn the eg, to sujet ener tte Taw ofthe make, o adopt a tanscont-
cata ater han replona ono, ado face man's ew conto senna
Taorans bet of burden
"cccadng to Angel Rama, th eationship of modemism to mode in
Spanish Amerie can be explained tha: “Modernism is but the conjonton of
ray forms which explain the efferet ways in which Lain America was
corpse ito modesty, eoso-slal concept which was peered by
the bourgeois indus vito ofthe aoetcath entry” This socio
tora covept generated Hy th les hove terest it served, was being that
‘ropes would brings bounds fture. According to this log, the con
fitios la the fees aad the real constions of Spanish Amis’ heteo-
fzneous populaon were exacerbated, che social costs incared by growth
‘woul eventually be nualzed, Jee Mat explana
‘As clang rewen, eventing inate ht egal spe ob conta
‘Sey Auto happen ta hs pio pln expansion andor de
‘sical cosas grates men pops themsieto cnt one mothe
‘ings of ings i ne for pc, for st men. Te confixon hth change of
Soto and ovement beige tou aks laine of bea 8 pn2+ The American Chronicles of Jot Mart
ih te re te mon tse ne to
‘to come. (VIL 224° oe
ero of hangs of ota nna a te mio
‘Stkioisg of en pant atin sede ana
felon in dmhseraly joie wn see seen och
Stren of tn Gk Tha in we power ee
Creed gy any svn wa soe change far tte?
Titogh ral nation tne cele! Sp Ane
cay ater ge i mals mk oes ef deme
‘a anise flow fies feng at
fost vit zon ants pth ogee
Epis nd pmertl tesate ce arah tap,
‘ening he te Sts wwe hn a Spee
tStamecen comes vse Cle Unga, Again.” uber,
‘Sor ont as Rama sfoon wey ie Lan Ans
‘epson r tip poplin he ty yu fer
es cnr fp anally ow oft prec was
ovine expr nalts sea
‘ar cool hu 0 ped aon el og
‘Besa seals The ew Sasi man npr
org oC Va, chased wt cle -La ee end
ae weston heya om spas ih
Enea ety Varin ht sp ga ngs Eo
Ppa ts a mate Be
Eas tne wel "Pepe tre ep
‘ging om Pace el Great Sin To oped cp oft
‘Se cc nd ny fat ty mers
Socio td cae eon fo sit ety er wo
oe pea ea 8)
“Paola were raphe’ een cent, he wes
inet get ite inpratie ceae'o ese tne
st real n bopapy of Mr, ag Mach es Cas
theca new" dapyd tt pens pel a oe hs got
feet eo ing ce sl
onsen ty a ting ca nu iy fe
‘on the past and on peasantry.” meet “
Bb nro at epi argebn cner sc Mes-
ic iy and aes Aiea woo spe, lng wt fi ots
Sow pit omer Spenco ss Tt poe
Selo te nna aver eon
“The Logi of Lisary Representation + 3
‘remain immune othe interes information that eve with increasing
regularity, not only ough tavel and boos, bar trough juralsn a well
cart was i i fist tance, x rtm of noon. progress, como
politi, sundance, at an inexhaustbie dese fr nove, Al of these
‘tee derived tom pi ecological advances, new systems of eommanic-
on andthe logic of consmpton wich belonged 1 He laws ofthe new
Imeratonsl arte" Nonetiless, mater the violent tasfomations tha
vets beganingf trode new peveges vo the capita exe na the
“pvcalypic ete ofthe iatinnoe ofthe century’ en can completely eX
plan oe concrete fat oardng te modems the intense mai."
2 Imbalance and the Coesstnee of eterogeneous Elements
‘Thee ae numatonstetinonie of nbalanee la modest poe They ca
be found nN” by in del Casa "Nothing of he tre gas my
‘Satan othing of epee des stage well at a /if oka he hor
on alls ado, if sun owned the eat lis sh” tn"Las Als Hae
{Em (Te Ope Sly Cues Nien dyin of ithe
xpoed sul esting Who bought x? Whee di we come fa? 7
‘Wheres eer home, our ous”
“The poems of Rabla Dao aso sbow signs of his obession wi aot
Arn hte we arguing rem whence eco as in“Lofaa (Te
fh) fin Cantor delay eer Songs fife an hope). Dass
stn we id dion he cnt of ply: “Out paras wee blr han
We a hy hd pase for someting The good oars f te 18308
‘ree oth sows tines nore thn wea, Our own ines eth di
cae of tt moa agnatn: we don ink stot aig with edo
‘Ne epee wiht and soa
“at ad hapene projets ofthe fue, oth power offing Hie he
abode ote it of age Tn 187, Ts Mar posed new
fa win tienen of Pee Leow eting the who gable fr
‘eco “in ert hunt one dy mip ve we i, a ee of
‘ih fey bbored™ en sboutnanerysymes or echamber ahs,
TRtrner the bth of anche dav ofthe debate eign andthe retith
iinun is yg vet in wr sound fe sting sides,
‘earn cies ete sand the enaed sve” CI 140-80
‘Whi one camot comply enfitemedemisn wi Mar, eo
pred hs ext for modem mun wi «sae of dsenchannent wih
ihn fe Ths embrelece vat i aco Verso ies fe
ipl tine modems on be charac yt deseo cee spaces of4+ The American Cronies of José Marti
‘condensation fr contactor clements—a nthe sym othe chonile—
the ssc isinction between coe ad be oes lay in Mart foltion of
‘ce of soliton fer th contacts af i time, othe pardon of ie:
son and hope, For Marthe coaualcons could only be resolved ithe et
sy space of te stage
Not cre the abnor sy of be wontrae mv mote ca sy
(ang wits ease te jas np dos no ind tw he de
Sead ati. Wed tae teeth et ough oad he
felch ta es of mao ord we have ae ne ws ofonoa
nd on ha come fom gay the dn matin. Vo
‘The maize of Mats cotemporuies originated in the contadictions ofr
onatism, hoe, te dislacatlon of man in he face of cheng nd the chim
berneen itue and eck, eviginte, scoring to Ange Rema, inthe eo.
‘nomic displacement of moderits, the rapid incense in readership, the
‘akdown of lngstending utr model, and the intncess of new
standard of values (Rams, “La dala” 190.
For Cas Real de Aa, “th new coneiousiess of inlegratng@ social
‘goup wih amore mtked specicly than bad before ta so sya nel
liens... tare nome" Tis mals alsievaved th fn ager
_eming bade ovored the movers ot bcais othe oct wok in al
‘nef utter hetaose of ir actives wii offical juralam, dp
‘acy, busines high bavesbercy,specch writing, and eer special seve
“This was a pviod of drastic wanston infty; inevity the ps 0
reserve or ingos modes foreach scarf society became more inten. The
Importing bouyeoisi urged constructivist Biber discourse, The educated
lass—withot opposing economic Iberalion —forwanied a conserve die
course more ashore inthe past nd terested in ean nto model,
‘Land and anch owners declared hi ulramontae belts while ne pole
sicongen supported poplin. Peasant groups rebelled ad eganized in
logiily around religion belies, while the wba poet of Burepcan i
Imran ew more and mote pitied” In Ca and Puerto Rica a
tion to the internal conits moog economic sctrs, were the ies ef
Independence trom Spin andthe expansions tet of te United States
vas s conictbeneen old and nov, betmeen heterogenous discourses
‘ramed by a cosnopoian consclousaest dt scented conta. As Mar
wrote in 891: "We wee a vision, retire with the chest of an ate the
hands of dandy andthe forehead ofa sid. We weve masquerade iE
al underwear, a Pasian ves, a Nort American jacket, aed a Spaish
‘mountain hat. We were chariots and ngs incon that came nt tie
‘The Logic of Lieny Representation + 5
‘wold wearing espuis on hei ft nd headandson tired” (VI, 20)
‘Sortre was more thin oe reality ae mere than ooeiesogy Inte of
‘modemity a8 malaise ne can see the poblem 2 moat tastamoual 1 the
fisence of elie whose singularity is part ofthat very malise. Although
these dvsioes in Latin Ametean societies wre not absolute, we cannot i>
nore the fact that the mogemiss perceived themselves oben apoio si
iro that ofthe nneceuh-estary European wes: boated between the
utoducted lasses andthe Bourges, Woe et albough hin po
son was very predoctive many of the most cal medeaist text bea Wit
‘os tee sthon’ frsaton and ui abou serving the importing inter-
‘ts ofthe boupedsic intermediary between iatral power slatons and
‘wold capil ® Modernism was about nintellotl litt lt mari-
‘mized and alionted bythe redjosteat o seca vations.
2m the Crossroads: Man
Maris chronicles offer oe ofthe ys to deciphering th-map of he power
lines runing tough modernist senate. His work gos beyond what is
clit inthe aforementioned discourses “Science ncrestes man's ay 0
Jide ad eds hm with secure ta, but inthe end the problem Will never be
‘solved. Iwi simply be beter led oat Man cannot be God, ince san.
‘We must admit how insertable the mystery is an do ged, since this po-
duces positive plese and Its an ceve sane preston al growth=
‘sch ber ee dt ofireble myeywas mei
‘emologie! lemma crossing of various sensihlies and vaiou modes
Joowldge. Mart combined bea faith in progress, eason, goed deeds, ad
‘hepefectilty of man ("snot enough js tobe bor: one must make one
sel" be wrote ins ots XI, 40-41 wit Kantian discipline of wil wit
fut educag scene meted to ltarznism at Auguste Comte had done.
“The above passage reflects Carl Chistian Fisdich Kraus’ ea that beauty
‘expresses good and tut, a wells the redempJonst bent of Sint Simon end
his disciples, who concivedof the post as» pist in seach of hamnan.
“lowove, be scaowledges at “the problem Will ever be rslved il,
‘simply be beter lid oot” This sa curing theme of his: humanity i 20
Tages the way ised to be sad “ows no ow ix” andthe nvidolBas
ot defined heights, “knowing nether how, nor before whom het vind
‘ate them” (KXI, 26), This dots sii to that of Baudelaire, who, pe
pleted by he cossaictons of onal, social urban hoops, ass," curt,
cher, Que cherche i” sad answers, “il serch quelque chose qu'on
‘nous pers apple moder"6 + The American Chronicles of Jos Mart
‘A Rationale and Remanticem
Accodlng w Max Weber, the proces of modemization was in past propelled
bythe replacment of ore system by anther The ied and ests parm
cess which eadionallyseuctured human life were suddenly removed the
oncopt of detny was decosecrated as human sce was engined aru
‘ane concep: ia thr i sence, no mysterio and unpredictable farce
leering and tht, moreover, al things canbe donated by caleuhtion™=
Weber termed tis proces raianalaton: the mastery of te mati word,
the sysmatizatin ofall mods of Bf the soularzaton of metaphysics >
‘Although itis now common practice apply Weber’ canept tthe nine
‘wax century, the crisnty sounding human cont of space aod ate
began few centuries eat.
Tes posable wo trace secuariaton ck to the Refomtion dees
to saj—to the discovery of America, which caged the coordinate of West
ce imowledge drumacally. The en ofaeity mpi athe very con
pion of Ameria a the "New Ward" *
"Tis dempeicain of he eld trncendent onder ened & return to he
ides hit soil ality san de deter by rain, The ies tok oot
uti he ighteon-ceaury Euopen Eaihenment In Spanish Asi,
reat incamation was perhaps th dona spl of post idependence
‘witing precisely during the stage tha precoles modernism ifone can cee
‘uly laconic history of though
‘Using Weber’ ideas about sodeszation and raonaliation, one could
argue that Spanish Amerie modems wee the writers ofthe post
independence perio, For thnkes lke Domingo F. Sarmiento, fo xaos,
‘wring was the way 1b console widespread tenes snd dives lu
‘ages under 2 cena anor: the void of dicoure let hy te antiquated
Colonial syste aed be files For Stmiesto, isouse was a meas fo
ili Latin Americ’ wilferess. He wie “Wom the ay afte evo.
Jn, ncedd otra ou eyes a all Seton ina effort the voi hat
smust have been left by the destroyed Ingusioe, by vanished absolute
ower, by widespresd religious exlsion™
Tn Mart ani Daco's tine, oa the oter band, modest writers satfeed
from dgplacemeat an vertigo. Pamir orzo were asta in pepe
ual fox If we take it account he fc tht Weber was thearzing fa Ba
ope at the da of hs cnr —hie tes were of he ened vintage and
‘consider te pesod from 1 contemporary vantage poi, We at 20 lager
eine modernity simply rationalization, The rig of method ante will
to systematic began to wane atthe clo ofthe nnstenth ena, a the fll
climax of postive, In Spanish Amica, tha we the beginning of another
“Te Logic of Literary Repesention + 7
peo, hat of the crambling of eran, he age of suspicion. The modernity
‘hat deine and dene te wears wa a confontation beeen ranalza-
thn aad sabjectvam, between the tedious route of dally fe asd mythic
‘comsioses,beteendsappolnzsat nd flint uu: I was dese
‘te consel the eontaditons spd fagmetation of ely desire fr novel.
tnd ines change na commopolitn envionment.
‘The lives and dco ofthe moder 2 ona oie guise the
nist of echnologial age. They incor the sete suggestions and
odes of perception of Gane, de Line, Hugo, Menits, Wide, Huystans,
nd Poe, cle ota fev: They became asortof echo chamber forall of West
{rn cotre combining serch forall ings perso anew with th est
of eadigonal elements.
Tis wot torememiber Octavia Pars observation abot the historical fone
‘on of moderasm a smart the (Baropeae] romantic reacon atthe dawn
of the nintenth ceatry [Gnd ta thelr version was not a repetition bat &
tipo: different omanciem” Iwas loa response o poss an,
farther to the ilitaianism hat impregnate Spanish American seool with
the ideas of Dox Tracy orem Bent. Beathan' das were par-
Tay convenient forthe emerging Wourgecise, sed a hey wer oa te
Principle of maximum plarie forthe masimum sunber of people semanas <
Adept xiteion™ F
Liking Senin Armercan modern to Buropean romani, as Paz,
propose discus hei asa governing ston of ear rodueon Tt
Ibe oer cla implications at well In Europe, conan was a move-
neat of socal pots nd eis, esthete and moral poli. ook place
Garin «period of rach major revision of tought Ha We might, folowing
‘ighe cil ea eolanary pod rater ans roman one ight, 330)
"Ae egarde modernist espzaly 3088 Marthe Hist formulae he
ew poner -Cutirea Gide ssympathet othe Inking of male
‘rit romantic if one considers thse movement revlutonary. He sas,
Aewag oa Heigge: nth one Mar wasn revoltonay"=- fh z-
ltt we mean, ott ‘the ansformaton” seis has seni ut
tha with he eangrmaton be uminaes hat whic decisive Interprets,
\ ponders it considers (Gatenen iret 78 emp ed), Tas defi.
tin exons be velo when considering the role of molest pots.
‘One deisv arpct ofthe desi wa secularization. But twas 23
treme scalars, fr the peoces that had begun several cents before
became, tthe od of Mars rary, the metsphor af the death othe abseace
‘of God, or those art a serch of romance at an andte tthe materi
‘ulgarintion of every if, the abence of God alo meant he end of tine,
the lot ofa meatingfl staal proces in human history a its replace.
teat bythe mre certainty of progres8 + The American Chronicles of José Mart
‘This void was fied by modernists wit a search fer oto enayca-
able of reflecting the absolute, the infite™ The fl of fut and he search
fortuemoai tates were paral, s were the need to ook fr mmanence
In the word andthe Sese that writers bad no place within the ne marke
ivr Socket. Caught buswsen vulgar reality end the dese fer eter the
‘ew man an "the davning of he Birth of newer didnt exaly achieve
the redeoming and “define religion” to which Jexé Mart spied. The now
‘man was mowe akin to the amphitian in Hegel's Aeshetcr an amphibish
forced o move among conditions ater the dente of aren.
5 Subjetvism, Historic, and Leiimiztion
In the prologue to Pérer Boold's“Poema dl Nigra? José Mart sys that
ins tinea persona ie fl of ub, lam, gustion, anxiety, belizasty,
sm inkimate fe ful of fever, isturbance, vigor, ad clamor hus comet be the
Cent sve sad, slog with natu, the only lepimate sve in meer
osty” (VIL, 229). Since they no longer believed ina sacred aio ran b>
folt ew, men wer lft oerpanie theron coexistence. The experience of
sel-umitaton for human beings is ne, in istorcal ters, and even mae 50
in Spanish America, tthe te intoathcotry Span Ama remained
Inerogenous, pt ttally independent fom the Spanish seopols, and in
reed of covering is Own identy. The horizons of the fiir weld
‘hanged veriginosly unde the banner of progress, making i necessary to
tear for gnarl pencplen on which ond wc crde. Al was ebjet to
‘Modernist tlived shat eveything, somehow had o move toward Sl
harmony: But th ery concep of everthing entered nt ie Whspoo of cit
ihn, Modernist suffered or began to perceive—an epistemological rp
ture: thoy no Longer ad before them “established maps tht charted all he
routes snd paths and knowlege sel, reviously an invisible elason-
‘hip between the mowing sot and he object of knowlege" woderwent
tn inoperable aleraion. Fou afin ta athe nineteenth entry the
Westen episime underwen’ a genera estat, whea he writes hat "ihe
‘nowladge of mat should appear ins sian is, as contemporaneous
and ofthe same origin as biology, economics and plogy” 349).
"The eitrnclogel debate hat examined the pivilegs of sacs a well
1s the notion of historicity, lv incorported soch claims as Hegel tht at
Id ceatedto be the frm n wich uth manifested ine tose omtompory
issues ed the modcmis to tke a deeper intrest in philology Ta the efor to
schiove both social leita and reconclition, they esd snd Wrote about
‘Bhllogy becaese it suggested wecking with ngage ina way that was nt
Tee Logic cf Literary Representation = 9
simple signifeaton, Marts comments soggest 2 combination of sate
Haar ister profendty od aesthetic sexsi: "Words ave a ayer tt
Eavelos them, ht is mages aecesary to get down their bodies, Some-
things troken inthis xan, nd depth revealed, Words most be used
ti ey ae sea nts depth, wid tel ral eymlogial and pate i
tian, whic she only ones robe tht assures hat thee tex
presses wil last” (XXL, 164). Piolgits wate language in way tat was
“Etlopou ode work of Boogie or archacoogists, which produced param
‘ies consnat withthe sient thn is vogue. Parhetore,pitolgy wes
dered as Rentn pind out" exact ince of mates ofthe pi
[Phillogy othe humanities what pysis and chemist aet the pil-
‘opel slenve of mater™
iced with tie demise of eveything permanent, tbe modernist writers
found in plllogy & scenic med of approaching knowledge, Yet st he
Same tne they sve away rom sence ecanse they rejected rationalism 8
tring “a mod fo ole probleme [tnt denies] tn Universal applicability of
ae toad ed social tall They hao search for new notion
‘tut inthe intersection of conraictions and opposites, formulating 8
posi sytem hat cold recone eeaigue and emotion the progres of m=
{el soy andthe neo fr wanscensence
“Thiscuage appv onortmed he pate of epeetaon gent athe
‘Smee te gency of repseaon bape an int hr ae ie
eel question te bing et fancanent 9 pokes, dee cold m0
[eine an esas th fom wach al nove coud cnstdbe-
foe wad pone eec foro. cane at wc ows
tuto douball max Inorg (oan 339)
“This oberon wil be eri othe analysis of aos poe. The”
cre ash oly way ache ase, b Da expla in Dio-
Slacenr' the medion he jet execs and ave wed
feck te highest fea expressed wha rts fy Sole x
real an het ed open son of tes and ake nell
Ws teseniveralsol.veinued he yc insrment ity mom
‘ceo tu am mpafia nan fens asoos an vale ject
{he whim of esp ae or etosma
‘an European manic, aw erie dcr te chasis con
ceptaf ares anion of tre Slips served buh asa poof dpa
{ifr ese crenion and ast vay to ctan Kaede ofthe xis of
[isnt wen no mneealaw Tho me erated ken (ras
‘wean Wi he tla sem of represen: the modem id ot
teal wh ima Te" ited so Wo argue he neryoveedscouses10 + The American Chronicles of Jos Marth
of sions, technology, philology, and terry and cosmopait eon a
‘he “organ ofthe inst” To th exteme indvidnlem underscored daring
this pid, the modernise responded by vndaling isa method of Dearing
‘hat whi waste through hat whic was mort athe Inthe ll.
"He, Mart alu ha his ow nt. He claimed «ceatvewbjctviy that
vas united wit story: “Le us make ou on history looking ato ur sl
td that of others looking at herded There wil aways retain, ovr evry
phan th subjective muse andthe historcl one” QOXL, 236). Mast
thus opened anther “space of condestion” thet sony, unkue represen
tation hat inks several asociave cla, and eid a the point of ttre
tion of those eas. The space opened ere is that of he etal net
mantic nor anonymous, 2s Fina Garcia Mari aply observes, bat ae
Collective "that asuned man tobe the “Universe eed, The universe i
ka in is warts” OI, 361."
{6.The Era of Suspicion
Aftiming subjctivism a a sure of subentiiy seted contaicion in
the age of echslogca fervor. The moderate ncoporated nto thle en
age he avarnes of philology atthe scence of language Ele tey bad
Ie off the imation of Nate in favor of the moves of prouction,axording
‘oliteray ete Nos Jk oi thee seach fora new barony, hy incl
1 once ideas taken from Pyhagoreanism the occ, nd Cao eonogr-
sah. They undestod techigue rather tha ioepirtiont be the essence of
‘witing, and practiced sabjectiism as mode of knowledge the es ws 4
raehod tac supassed the Limits of ssenoe and connected sbteraneauny
lth euments of contemporary though. Mati hielf ned: "This sever.
‘wer an epoch of reorerng so remolding The past century blew ou, with
‘nevi and forcefl ir the elements af the ol life mpesed bythe mia nits
uh, which teaten ad excite with galvanic lifes every moment this ex
{try of detail and preparation accurate lasing element of the new Lie
5)
‘The conditions and disorder Mart dssibes here ed oa system frp
_esentaton that created pew spaces of condensation, swe hee sen tnd Wl
discs further. The pst wi lesly inchded inthis excitement fo conse
‘ow ie Uke dhe Wier ofthe Independence ea, wh ejected thei Span
‘shige in favor ofthe French and Eaglishaions, Mat formated he
Iieray osgin by mixing ideas sed tecrigoes om these cules with le
‘nents recovered from the Iteraueof Spits Golden Age
“Anuber characterise ofthe modems ocaon Between two stgesof|
owledge can be described ass lope of teary representation, the acco
‘The Lope of Litrary Representation +H
uburlly and Bstorialy determined stsupsons upon wich any linguistic
eserpin or chuacterztion i based. The logic of erry representation i
In fat any given epochs epistemological system, tbe network of fanart
valves aod Belefetat concion and inform the production of knowledge at
{hut ine The mos of production af given clase, visible in theses
its of is erature, are lntimtey related tote logic of teary representa
ton lathe cae of the moses, he lope of repreecation was based upon
2 willingness fo qooton the dominant vale of the nineteenth ceaty:
[poaress, postvsm, and scenic objec. Certainly, the modernists
Shared moses of ptcepton with Marx and Nictache, by whom the mot fn
menial assumptions of Wester pilosopty were brought ito question.
‘Tei rial methods, together wih he evtaton ofthe interior wal oft
rials, arte constnative elements of eae ceotary thong
Mare peesived a say In fcing the oncoming changes “All xed c-
Iatogsip, frozen rpily, with ther a of preudces and old and ene
thle options, are swept aa all those hat stp evolving become inadequate
fd thy canoe. Al that solid doles itn aly all tats sacred
Inde profane, andi th ed, man are forced to contoat the real conditions
‘thd ives and hl slaonsine with hee companions" In playing With
Jmages this way, Mant gave a new character 1 theo interaction of oppo
ste, persiving that "neu me everything som preguaat Wi Is OPPO
site" (S77.
‘Realy was ironic and comraictory. Man bad constructed wots in
‘order to find his om cones and meaning within them. The ator eased (0
‘es apectator who repeodioed ely by mean of «universal concep Intead
hn tempted to diacover i ough his own bing. and, with Nite, a
‘ised that "rom the sees comes all credibility ll ood conscience, al ev
‘denee of th" Tas aie mas many modernist texts, whee oc nt
[istiche det infuened them.
The relitionhip between moderiam and moderity cannot be taken for
ra sitce the frm “node” bar had various meunings Ugh the age
‘Asa mater of fact, Jurgen Habermas args thatthe erm came int we in
oer to distinguish the advent ofthe Crsan ea he proposes that “ode
rity. always expressed the conscousness ofan epoch hat undesstands
ial in oott a the pant, the eu of tansition fom old to new The
‘modems wnderiod "modern to deny particular quality of those wo
‘were fom a roe epoch, lived inthe present, endow al sv themseves
‘emai ransom into Wat which was nev: Puy defition helps us artc-
Use thelr relationship withthe tweet century locate the eyo of
‘present lemmas in he modemist malaise: "Moder is a decison a dee)
otto be ike those who preceded ws and a wish to be the begining of coher
time” (Posten movie, 8.12+ The American Chronicles of Jos Mart
‘The fn de sic wets tly experienced a cis between two epochs.
Having discussed the ress of ationaization, e will ow tun to amply
‘nd investigate more thoroughly the appearance of doubt or suspicion, which
‘marked the commencerseat of saath
In exploring the mendes chronicle as an element of tanston ito the
resent century, We can we the following puramers: heer of dou—f0
‘ive the contemporary see moi deed ite by Weber's concept
‘atcalizaton or by the hope tht vaca progress and technology wil bing
‘out human happiness. Ou ctentantment st 0 With he oe of tlie:
{ng teleological naratves and eth Inthe fue ts the beakown ofthe
mage of nits he heterogeneity an dives of te cesses mod-
‘riz. In the nincteenh cer, te shred exjerence of ene, mora
J.and modes af erpaniig socal coeistence signed a tension that tained
toward ulkimate hanson whereas athe went centry thi energy i=
ered and dfs, the possibility of imate recon spa ia doubt
“The modomity of our on er ix ote complsted than tht Geseribed by
“Weber”
"Movers tents expres not only bedazsiement in the feof ecology,
‘but also a theme of exrangement, of being ot of pac ad having na hot
lind, ht would ltr be cntal othe theories af red and Heidegger. Here,
aswel was the reltvzation of seen knwledge tat wou lad Berd
Ruse declare, “Mathematics the seience where no one eve Knows What
hfs talking about ori what be issaying tra nt Roan Barthes oak
for amathels singulers, scence bse eniely on rejects Ts the
‘epistemological schism tat began with the Hepes iden tat the gue in
‘which de wah exit ean be nothing bat the sysematelsorton ofthis
‘ruth Today post-sructaraliss ashe question, "What ta sfentife yee”
and ote th espoese that ony system ba notes aero ®
‘An epstnologial pare had beg, inaugrting “moder” knowledge «|
ss prt of “paradoxical uta wit ofthe ist tha “places wx ll wit
‘mackstrom of prpcunl disintegration snd renewal, of bute and cous
an, of ambiguity and amex” Bema, 15).
17.The Space of Condensation The Symbol and the Conic
‘Mart observed hat “we arn tne of station, nt condensin; of ix.
tue of elements of energetic workings of united element." The resoiion
‘of anew order wl Ads Space a writing, a nll pace of ri, Lalas
points ot tate crisis "isuanlated inp ah exacerbation of al he decog
al eontaicons... This ideological eis wil warlte nee ito a,
"identity csi’ of cial agen Each neo he agent cont wil aang
“The Logi of Literary Representation + 13
to seams ideological unl using a ‘sytem of narration’ which isan
tes the Mooogia coarse of oposing forex According to Lael, one
ofthe posible soistons othe css is that social faction may Geel an
Setrpeliton wit all fs impistions and wanafonn its uch ito aceti
‘xm of th exiting ste a pice for etretsing the entire eaog-
caldomain
“Therefore, we must analy how modernists fomalte the “system of|
rato” the way in whic thay arved a ny ater the rope. We bare
‘mentioned tat fr eplzemalopical crack, anagonisi intersections, css,
‘deco, an sytet sytem of aarton Te sytbes es in he ea of
the space of condensation.
Amocative chins were formed from te devices of symbol a analogy
_Mosemist prose and poetry, ot nlite the work of te French symbaiss, de
rived «sytem of symbology inspired bythe eightceathceatury philosopher
Emmanuel Swedeaborg and hie teary of correspondences: I man Were i
‘olvod ia the lnowloge af comespendences, thea, he would understand the
‘Wor in i sputual meaning. In this way ie would be grated him to woder-
_aand arcana of which he ses no taco inthe Iteral meaning. The Word does
‘conan eal meaning and a pica meaning"
"This conception ofthe word was siniar among symboliss aed modern
‘se Symbols lke Banelie thought of synesthesia not asthe contact
‘etwoen itor vision sa the divine, bu mera te eonnetion beeen
the mind and the snes. In he et, he word tok ona power aka 1 that of
‘se I provoked, by simulating en of the senses, a ulsensory plane of
images. Poetry woaldaoqie the exit crete, though the scription
‘ofa sensation, te very seston ise
"This nbn war the point of departure for medemist syncretism, which
Incorporate nto erary expression procedures and echaighes tht persed
ot only fo misc, but leo to pining end supe, Mat mained tat
“the wets mast pis ik the painter" CX, 3), Gutemez Najera looked “10
‘oem with words bd cates fom the Rembrandt cho oppose light with
shade tease black wt brian wie
Post incorporated mulipiciy of arse tecigues and tendencies into
thee wenn to develop 3 peti that woold rect th resent in al is
‘iby, Modeeist txts eplstered cosmopolitan, ant-economistieel-
Ja lien and soil compassion, regis, ispnism and francophili,
Ltn Americans and tyne sentiment, the eal of popula bres, and
‘more. Along vith symbol technigas were mixed nd even
‘atm, The rele wast assoriment hat anformed teary discourse
Sud ereued a space of synhesis”
Rabin Dai's desertion ofthe symbol in “Cologuo de ls eatauros” i
s prft ws to dite space of condensation: "as in th wisdom of Nature,4 + The American Chronicles of Jos Maret
{he symbol join together diverse fom” It was othe proces of wing i-
‘ese element tht modemist stempted—not always sucess em
brace duality 8 «system and to employ wring as v point af eacounter
between sich antgonsic pals a sprvmaer, hertufouraism, pose!
post, oldnew,freignédomestc, "collective, arUeystms of prodasion,
‘ature, mavanimal conformist.
‘Mart himself supported thie thei concersing spaces of condensin, ale
though in diferent teams He considered his epoch to be analytical or it
«cal—dispersing it elements in dale ways opposed to eps of ah,
hich were “capricious syntheses" (XI, 199). Te space of condensation
shouldbe understood nota a sytheds, but ath a4 dlc enouster
neler stati nor ressived, where "dere forms come tgs” Foe Mast
{he movement from rin to syste was succes, spring 1 fin
‘yma: his en was, coicidecally explainable in essa o Marx's
because "the perfect gins the one who withthe sopreme power of oder
sion expsias both nays and sya without daregadag oe i favor of
he other or denying one because of the eter, and ss to te sya by
means of analy" (XH, 296)
‘ost asthe image ofthe centaur was the pottype ofthe maaan dul-
ly the Ghost ook form in a space of condensation pr excellence, is
‘emis condensation beaut it encompassed all mitre, as twae «ae
‘ur ise converted int singular ad atoms iy.
Chapter 2
The Writers’ Role
1h iy
‘The modernists’ envionmeat was the cy, Surrounded by arstortc prov-
ines sil eling ofthe colonial past, an ceters grew as bureau
Ibs where traionalsutbory Jed» sytem of slnccurs and prerogatives.
Civil commercial an legal power was enftcd fom uéua capitals long be-
‘ore indilation had been tngbly consolidated
‘Some Senin American is got tsuch ate, by 1890, Mexico City
‘nd almost at many ababitans as Rome (lose to four hundred thousand) and
‘Boeaoe Ales boned more tan hal millon New York meanwhile, reached
“ion nd wah feel ard cmaial cet eae (Reames
250-59) Clan Vali expla the disproportionate gues ths: “ts evident
thet he inhabits of these ban centers Were nite anes nor peas,
bor wer thy indoor workers... thy served one another, ware employed
‘by the servic artery sector ofthe econo, which incladed domestic tr
‘oer ar wel a ache, lawyers, deat, goverment employes, commer
‘nl dependets,pollcinn, solder, doomen, scout, and cooks
"The devlopnent of the rtan service economy hud is root inthe tension
seen urban gros and ted social sectors, confit tht lasted
‘dough mich ofthe intent eau. The eliza, comnected to huge po-
vil eats know a landing, ited “urban growth, national inege-
tion, andthe ceston of « modem bourgecis sta? Ilso Hime land eon
tool, which is why urban groups inte eighties opened themselves up tthe
Intemational sphere aod pecazed in mercantile commercial cts, f-
‘hots, ad the promotion of ew poods and services
Ta Syenish America wszaion sdvebeed acorn to fternatoal com
merce, Atte apope of indian, Earope ad the United States esb-
lish diet contol overt cousbies in which raw materials sbounde,
syured by the accumuliton of capital, the necessies of unchosked ban
ow, abd manvfuctring’s comin need foe mates. These foreigners
‘tanfooned Spaish America’s economic uctr by investing capital and em
‘plying ntiooal workers to aval eee whore objective wat na
‘ovelop buster tocstrct. Latin Ameren epi is were redesigned and
1B16 + The American Chronicles of José Harts
Peep er
Srpctnas nace oetara Set rie Aer
Paging rite ee nremrrehany
eee a See
ee
Sn eae
Sear ceuencaiae eaieneenrene
Zea eee ese eee
ean pe in
‘chy —t inant class in ‘economic, political, military, and religious
here mean oreo san
Se ee ee
SSieceenes pay sien
ee ee
pillicnies canoe ocisea arrest
eos eet
eae
2. The Redfinition of Discourses
Jn Buope the process by whch wits wore spent fom the scl mi:
seam began tbe easane, sensor fat bp o pedo wl
Iovate markt. Ti dintion beans eaggerd daring be ronan Pe
"id when wes dpsed from poe powcr bogs ike ht eaiy
{rom hat very lpacement They the with te atte of pt fa
sesthticing pate ie aed asin he se pabema sym a ee
Senaon. An anorcy of nlgens ce nto ing," carsnai ep
‘eniaion of the roan sed rcepn of syle wes new el
spree aplenty far ed ar
te sepntion between Sse a erry couse, Hrgen Hames
lied tt the bourgeois adel sic vided wht pected tote es
vate sphere from what pertied ath pl, Aird pba pica and
terest war exalted to mediate beeen he mccies of soi and
thoseof the Sine thse would a pomit "We miata of ber ale
rons ins pica us of eon Wate 8 wel es oral hereore
fecame part of te martet of cll goods For Habermas whowe over
tos ee 0 nineteecentiry Esrope-—powe, inthe fonn of he Ste,
‘ond sharply vided om he Cocmmayofcize Thr Her tees
‘Stuthedtemacves nthe space bees he rae opes ed the sate
Inthe poblicopce of x sn aa. = "
‘The Water’ Rolo + 17
Aroand the sms tine pero in Spanish Amati, the publ sphere exhib-
ited slr habit But i Jon Lai tomo’ view, which is undamental to
Ufestnding the cole tht thé modernist weer wil ater assume, the
Courses wore not soparte. “Their joumalit was a okesperson ofthe
mall community whom eveyone Inew sod from whom eveyone expected.
Arguments and posse in fvor of or against he palptating question of he
ay" Romeo 249.
"When the Belaaing ofthe vost wanizaton ofthis hemisphere in-
itcted the separation of poe! and erry discourses, th ers to the soci
‘ey of aman aitocrts were forced wo serch fra discourse oftheir own
‘Sol teak tesa» Habermus would sy~ith he declining poblcspere of
2. Uteratur as Veatlon In Spanish Ameria
ier’ tbo is weil for unrstaning fr de sete Beat, bt sme
Sinnetions ae neded to locate he social function of the modernist chronicle.
‘ut the hcory of th separation ofthe State ith i vigilant role andthe
timation of social ation a th eoonomai eve hough a ideology of ex.
hang apps only to England rng «bie io ofthe sneteenh cet.
Presa, Habermas fst noe at the te nat of pla life reveal
the pertain of dfrent force in constant ruta, The limits off
‘ll estnons ae aime expe: ter for f soci nracton, soc a
technology, verse boi practioes, and other ttn contrite tthe
‘enon of vloes (ton ecu, bene, growth
If we age Habermas categories tothe specie conditions of tie a
lice, oe that win ops i Spanish Americ at the end ofthe nintenth
ear wat tendency twat piled couse, as lo indicated by Ke
pln, Vale nd Remet, Pedro Hencguez Urea aims tht fi dese o-_
‘ey sav" dvsion of labor Men of tellecual professions tied to remain
‘lowe tothe task they had chosen abd abandoned pits... And since dtera-
face as not ly pofetsion bu voc, mea of ees became oats
[st or teaches if et both” tis inartant ose bere the dscusve separ
tion of profession and vocaon in reladon to Irate: These nations were
Alecsive in sontuting an aesthetic and the soare of more than ane fly
fnterpestion of to characterises of moderism®
‘Aboter point wort highlghiag, which moves away from Habermas's
scheme, tha, in Spanien Ameri, dure ferentiation did ot mean
‘hat wets abuoned poleal temes. We have concrete example in he
texts of Dari, Jose Asucisn Silva, Manvel Diaz Rocfgur, Sosa Joe Ti
‘a, Jot SattosChacao,Leopeo Lagones, Glee Valen and Jali18 + The American Chronicles of Jost Marti
Herrera y Retsig. Many modernists participated filly in pois, frm José
Eng Rods and Babtomero Sane Cano Jos Ingeietos al Alcides Ar
bedi, name ae.
"The diference for tur-f-the-cetury writes and milan autos suchas
Mart snd Goal Prada was tha lierrre,aesch, became disconnected
fram what Haber call the “publi” forthe juclalpeltica operate
sor pnb: el, te wr aa ft com
good. ag] a pablc representation of pomet"® Weng was becoming
1 practice opposed to the deur ofthe State, Evens, my moder x
‘aye mainaned the polieal sho of erry vepreseuto: a good ex:
inp ofthis s Jose Mart -Nacss Amica” Oter tts tat supported
‘State lcoure ted ot tobe effecive more isthe ran of peste han of
real power
ia leer to fellow writer, Rod cares the panorama of spoilizations|
and his commitment to rane a «veaton “Peps you ae not unre
‘of this tagedy in South American Iie tat poses anybody wih a penis is
nnd towed polities. Ad don't consider th tobe an aigeter bd thing. I
‘depends upon oot allowing oerelves to be sipped of eur personality"
He tne deserts as “uapic” the purndoxcal characte of South America i
ary ule, in which the panty or sitredaess of wings valued and yet
‘vere “anybody witha pen in is hand” i called o paricipat in polis
Reds final waming i most important poiical engagement etens stip
te pero ie “fetsonaliy” and he mit defend his restive aaonomy is he
‘moment of writing Kteratr
este dhe evidence of profesional speciation, the modest bad
wool range of osepatlons. Marti was &Jouralt, laws teacher, sory
tel, walt, crate, politcal activist, dtr, const Argentina and Ur=
us and university professor of piloophy, trate and lew. Dario was 2
_graminer profeso, asian, customs agent oor sn foreign comespon-
den, pate secreary othe Nicaraguan prideacy, and consul to Colombia.
Del Casal was a bremvrt,juralsy and studzot of Herat Siva was a
dlplomst and tusnessan. Belonging io Us educated clases was stil uel
inthe joo market an helped the moder to obi their may postions
‘The wer saw these pat as mee obigatons, maging o thet creer ut
neces othe esnomic survival. As Rams expla, “What the poo abun
oned was the mulupliety of fuscuoes that had jstiod and explained, be
Yond the posible artic exelece of his works is place i socal fe and
‘is historeal ole as gen wadionlcommunity"=
Posty did oocipy 8 place of i own, especialy a separate fom com
mec. Porth movers, eo, what was proftble end what was poetic
were separate. When they were forced odoin arly terry sper ey
ound thatthe category of he asta was esseatl ote.
‘Tae Weiter? Role 19
4. Morality, Redemption, and
uty
ban sci revolved around money sod practiaity. Contemp ties,
‘Mat cated ther, bose "tere no primary ast ther than ing the pan-
{is of hvac siting ina golden cbt and Ling agen Uife” (VI, 22).
‘Contemporary cies jodpe atin relation tothe decalence ofthe tines a
yo Ello Wide wrote that at was a ay ofthe inligene, an ab-
‘Tezaro mind that asthe aefuess of xan Literate Was abo
ovurtod at an objet of lear and parr, «oxy forte cuted it,
‘Bn ar was o cay out soil fio of sotber Kind. Sao rare
‘warn longera necessary vebile for national ratealization, is new role wes
Ufatora moaiig instemet wed beauty to couterict—tyough edie
ton, for example the tera, empties, ad amoral that capitalistic
Iie xples brought abot Martin Gare Meron wrote tha the so-called cult of
Teter was «way to sve cols "who, without templet fac the atl re
themselves up lk couresns woth seduce’ caresses There was ley
the fsng that tb moder man, having become an animal aborans ad bee
tiped of something. Habeas developed the concept of “residual need” «o™,
Fer ike untied dss tht were suppressed by the ystems of seeds _)
[plated bythe new pilsoptes of sltsm and sates uti mo
‘aA we discount commercial market vale, fasetoned as vehicle
{Ssseadow scity with Dobe or ranscenent feelings. I provided poitve
‘Siac tt wer otberwise displaced by quolen route: trans, spon
‘yan alam, Art was supposed “elevate thoughts, eanoble the spit
"eted) testis of Bourges ationlization”* José Mat wrote
rei ey a
EEE. seus dss rapa ross dova ssi whee
aie ep nhc mo staal poplin than ny.
Fee Solero prowes nen of ain, wile poe ges ep be -
‘Eos te sang foie 135)
For Mat art was nota means ofesaping fom life's worries, utetber 8 way
{© infect the popelton with esi for knowledge and wanscendeatl
‘Garces, Fr Joe Bago Rod," ene of Beaty, clear vision of whats
[ove in ie least abo nd noble derstanding of i Unlike Mar,
towete, the author of Are fle tt sn astotic vena and the ove of
‘beauty ave “enon value tobe clad for their own sa"
Torte morass. the cla function of at was 1 leva he spits
uc mind by selieing them fom the beating effets of routnize labor,20+ The American Chronicles of Jost Maret
reserving coma plessres and providing mages td ideas 8 compete
igo aad motiation Moves wie agreed on tis peinipe of operating
‘Gonusives fm commeriazaton and monstaisn, They coined with te
aaa German lit at tert was Hike the priest of an interior temple
‘Gatec to he values of art sl easy” In hi search for psi hey 3
oched form of besuy "uncontaminated" by rely. As Fse Asuncion
ihe sot: They eal ely al het meioce, vil. insignis ep
ate Reni! Rea ie Practical met... Horrors. .Tb be pata s
focompit toa nasty and iculousenepis!™*
‘SpurshArmican modernist wee faa withthe works of at beng
grown in Europea tte, Thre, pty was ued by quas-eigiont
‘Planstafn ta concentrated on commositon and poetic syle a higher
Junot th Theories ofthe autonomy of language occupied symbols ike
Saodelae, Malan, and Vay, all of whom infienced moderist txts
‘helt gina cstos was ed the Kalan ble inthe aivrsaity of
‘hele and ths fusion of he tre vce oh ety. nd goodness.
‘Thon theories were simuanenusly posttd by both Spanish Krauss
qt the Now EapendTranseendenialst, especially Ralph Waldo Emerson.”
‘Nes sommurienton technology andthe screed ease of ltersonsl
eovel hope Spanish Arereastdersas wel informed abou ne, osmopO
xderdopnens in Hcrtre and cule, ad they too gant propose the
sere etry ncoure. They didnot go tc entene of may ofthe
Hartpanss however (Hanber, for example, Had wished to wit book
‘Showtnuthing” absolutely daconneted from exterior reat bat made mesn
saga th tie fee ts sy) fact, we mat not og that bee
‘te Restagonist of Foss Asuncén Sas De Sobremeso, who repeated
Sn hoor tythng practice, was lo prosperos business wit oli
a tnv ccosomie plans fr national development. Dario Rims sme to r-
Sa see i lation n Canto de i esperanca: “tered by OXY ower,
Tre to ble ep in my mind / and angered for space and fri / rom he
ze shadows of dng” Dar, 245).
hart always dened te exp ormaism ofthe “at for a sak" 0ve-
sent Fos hs the wie had clear socal ison; “He mast web ety
rahi. to pnih hove who try to takeaway human feedom, or who steal
asm the people wit hl lve as, or who wan thei countrymen
ede tem Tk sheep and lick thr ads like dogs. Poetry sould no x
nether ose apy or ata thou be asf tte wor nd
Show that nate besa" (XVI, 349).
arty mle istence on neal ve id not mean thet be renounced
ccedlete th pruitof testis ad orm It was visto hm tht “lan
‘pe bad bs materia, gomatc, and supra, The ies must it
ree te sentence so exaly ts is imposible to tke anything oat of
‘tcce witout sabrcing the same element fom the ides a8 well”
“The Weer’ Role + 20
(904,225). Bry feng shou ave is own color, very thought its peise
Storia, so that "every emotion asi fet». Willows shouldbe pated
‘Wath ga verse sort of slender, nd th wank fan oak wih rough, ised,
{ot profound word’ One of the tats that quaies Mat at & mode
poet was wit Jose Antonio Portondo called “the modemist wil ws
[Tic miseace on firma precision converge wit the estat the sabes
the enence ofl
"Tain he cave of Spanish Americ, poet” andthe amiraton of form,
shoud ot be interpetd ae love fr sesbai hry a the highest form of
‘Som, but rather san empbaseon he estonoay of poe ngunge. By he
Pivse“ttonony of pet language” we eer tothe ext aby elit
‘ones rom sane the prption of beau the pre contemplation of
Tie tex fee fom worl distecton, sd fll an appreciation of is s-
{hand inp costa,
am eer a form? sald Darfo, The madenss believed in posi orm a8
sninsrument of evelaon, an ingortantGxtncton fom the prs of art fr
fees sake. Foe the moderns, the contemplation of betty taught ob 0 ap-
frosts and ere for he cos ttl, neiling sat of profane religiosity
hd daatin into what Dao called the “abythm ofthe immense cele]
‘Sovhuiam’" In Pros profana Dai explins the commen modems elie
‘ahurmoai ew that xpi te word tas a sere of as, separated by
Castes” but er as sing immense act labora by a incest
Inborof anion” |
Rejenng the ultimo tie, moderasts approche society,
tare, and verbal nuances wih diferent sensi. They staged to recover
(Ue harmony ond weaning that had been lot from cual dscouse. Gute
‘Najera wove, "Beany is ncesniy onolglal: itis boa, iis God” IF
beauty was God teat writer was is pret "God reveals himself the sub
Tie creo of poets. Using a mteratica form, we could sy hat
‘muy tote artst what perertion ito asait™
“Tus “verses the scr copa Joss Asucién Si wrote. Te profane
pot grad he resin ofthe dvi, ax Davo suggest in his “Respono” to
eran. As fliers of Fusisr an Sint Simon tbe modernists positioned
therelves outside of commercials, represeating themseves a propbets of
‘he fue, ciel of the vices of BoUrens society and nied toward the
‘Phiovement of eats penne. They of rele othe present but ds-
Sociod thts fom he ent past hey eniced the vital imagination
ith thi att for neue and erences to mythology, al serail by
Ths un abialences as Calais inthe ea of seulrzon and coop
sais (Gali, 165-69.
“Tis was no acne arto art without lection, Rater it was precaog,
pollen both, Beat on harmonising the contradictions ofthe tie, they
‘tors othe sabe wich ‘As Nature new, jis disparate elements22 + The American Chronicles of Jost Martt
“Th dencaion wih hea of gud lye mers o rete
‘ons ofl ple Ty ee angugs tegen eine
Ie rl le Lingo, Koen Dar wrote flowing ns “Cog
As cet” Poss profnay Te esis nde ss ll
tot esp you, nods, plying yon charming e.g ar oat
ede hep hpi Wien
tere you coe your eran iy fra fourier ng
dom" (Dario, 181). * wns
“emit hmv far eon othe “shade
sc fh ought hey che o en heme a har
‘Sein tar mace. Te mot wees gop of Europeans sve
‘ing Sone Mart iad finn 18) ont Arc Sia De eb
tema 87 1899, Mas Ros son mr 90 nd Re
Dur tse Bon El ena Mab fm A
(as,
5. Ambivalence and Contradiction
Rubén Dao cits Leonardo DaVinci: “And if you ae al alone, yu ae al
oer own" Toe wit’ oie canstacts within th text pvt place of ep-
{Rseoaton, a refuge and above al reserve in which to Sectode hs. Ye
‘be clamor simaltancosly, to ope hinsel upto cosmic comprebenson
“Tis contradiction btwoen representing the private spd the cosnic was cae
ofthe die that mot fasinted he modemists. Complicating mater ar
‘er, the spce the post reserved for thselves cussed with he bougeas
Interieurthey 9 eal despa. As Walter Benjamin exces it "The boo.
{oni wo squnes is acco with reali iis ofc demands the ner
fore maietained in his luis... For th private invidoal the priate en
‘vuoemeat preset the wivere Init he galer remote places andthe past.
‘is drting rom ea box athe wold thee In his way the modes,
‘searching forthe subline and uncontaminated, teaded to reproduce Doug
‘bis: hey sought dstaction som ety andthe e-creain of te uaiese
in their individ fant Altbough modernists were opposed (the new
‘opts valbes, they seemed to express themselves, metaphorical, with
‘he same cltrl gods the economic efits imported fom rope o ads
{teichomes and thir bode: nemo, fashon, exasous and exc images,
‘secumulation
"To these preferences the madris aed thee disdsnforvulgasity, ex
rosed tough azeiaenest ofthe senses. This combination of chances
Iwas aly missodersood a kin he ostentatious and speck sintocale
Inclination ofthe bourgeoisie they so despise.
‘The Ween! Role + 23
“This sone ofthe contadcons hat appears in heir wing. AS we uw in
she previous super, the enti period wat characterized by instability, ans
the, an the sensation ha everyting was prepant with i oposite. The
{talon fom arrl soy toan aban oe also implied dart between
gual aadnal ways end the emergece ofthe moder, conicive sad
{ietube ot wan Moderate ocepid soll postion twas stoctuly
‘Sonrsitry. Whether tough fale, or acces to Knowedg hey
longed tbe dominant edaeted cls, but they di not have secure pace
in the mining fasing rind gre. no atthe top ofthe wan 0-
{Sal pyri iby sommes, the Church andthe military. Fin de ice wit
‘Ss nga nero thesligatcy not he popular clases, Tei ck of|
‘Eton was typi lio of the nw urban middle t,o which they wee
Site iscladed(Boudien, 22-73) Bat they were alo instruments, helping to
TEptniz the dominant is though the senso of ielogy ical
‘Seeoue. The wetview ofthe majority af th population was shaped by
{Goa gatarod fom slocaton the pes and atin ther words, tom te
‘work of te intl geatsin Kaplan 196)
"We hae si ha tbe mens eaization ofa developed from se
sigue of contemporary sults; however it cansot be denied that meh of thei
TE ir ft supported the domiast clases, As Calzto Oyusa, on of he
Tasceenowned is ofthe ue wrote, "wong egies a rete eleraon
Stine spit ora more exunte elaement ha the contemplation and jo
‘heat of beau” If cxguieenemen” was a element for understand
‘the beaut ten the world oft and aesthtes was neces nsec
{Blt the unedocred laboring cases, and avin acozs to cule teefor
tmett belonging os cxain elite
The modernists were disgusted to see themselves as producer of commoé-
ston oud gaan thir wil with the als of Daf’ “rey Doge
(Gonipecs king). However, tis rosin oF Ge bourpoi di ot ingly tht
Bey were wetng for tha masses ft wee ot fr their conics, seed
fons pu apace of dally new, be maderists wouk! have reached ely
the mos culualysopbisttd oie
ougsis society rengszed he moraiig fancon of atin principe bat
inet poetry oociyed amines and main pac in Spanish American
‘Sul. Many writers complained about th dicuty of fading someone wilt
{gto polish fcr work, and about the vey Limited edo that were gee
tly peeed nis Aubingraf, Daco remembered is expicce in Boo-
Shou Arex “Whoa lined tere, pabishig book was a tremendous fea only
‘Poulble fr someone ike Ancorena, or Aleaz, or Seatamain, 1 was ike
aying a tfomebile now, ar arace horse... Eos? Not wove
odemist poets were clay excluded fom th book industry. Even
‘tera epptd in fil spheres as Leopoldo Lugons didnot hve much24 + The American Chronicles of Jost Marth ,
ble respons is pblizaons. The snd cones of a guerre sou
‘Esthave ben bought y the Minty of War the Mimsy of Poi aor
ta, nd be Bdcaon Coe.
The hw les of mods poor cate stint ako eer
‘pine more rele o essa vocal wen Spnh Ame
‘eonmrets Miguel Cae sold of thutod cps of lve fn
few dasa orl by Eugenio Cantos to ui eosin eck
Ie gen, Ethrdo Gutter’ ua Mors “hd apse ano
‘wo thous copies of tarts Pry le Heme Pes 9)
‘Slo gues ae sgn not alten iy ae an nen de
set Whats imeesing that hy ee modo wi rapes tee
Idi of wring adsl exgaganeat twee spor ot tine
{thy he become ier ity. Monee and pec a ta
‘em, ele, clio, a Mtl Scien pedal ta of teeny
Sesialottrry quand sci commie
"toner touneatand ter sic of modems pat, we mat
se: workin omer sony which wat ol ta
Europe tends some ery stressed, We tt sh oe
siete panorama of cotengayluty potion Spi As,
‘aah of whit ws marked by a ely feet deny of hy
tor ad funtion. While ode wes wee peal exo e
Seok mete sagopa porte ors wa eng pled
ling wes at showed athor indore madosnr seat
Innovations an eens of tal is, ware onl ot
staoes long wth eal and ati tx tat mere etsing east
‘ndachivng commercial sucess, wos fet om te mae oe
Grinds Mato do Tunes ve snd, vel aoa dpa of
Indgenoor puopls in Peru Other example in’ Gea,
Mae ay Los bones deo Flt Masel Samia’
Zar, Laci Vice Lipe's La les grand, oe Les Porto La pr
el edricoGunbos Sa, Bugeio Camber Ba ange sd it
‘abo, Casas Reyes Beba an a chaca by Mame Zo Gal Those
‘ominperioous works erent ey of etna soley ead
8 ide age of este and clog potions Batted ses
‘city presen in modest wring, ich wy ea cous era
Spottt henry eon a Ge sol tag"
6. Against Mental Cliché
[Modernist pots itrotced a new stan of represeatation ito the soci
‘imaginary, a plete of cosmopotian and spbiststed sensory lage that
‘The Waits Role + 25
sexes tte ten Pe
gettin erence oe
Suianet Bahram
Sites Sta ese
Satincomenieancs
Stee aaa ne eames
ee err
soit oem rece
Speaecetcraicioniarmieaae
Hiei anemia
cae
‘Angel Rana vere the terms of thse efsitons when be gave a posve
einer
sake cores nocache et
eaaeroeareree mens
Sihepet Ranana Sector
See en meme done
Tiny rg temd
eat ese wos cel te ie adhere wee gi ow pons
is itieeitn aires eine
SStriioarohaencsan
fees rae paeerummnrnaae
emit ae ete mee ca ee
Spiros cn eenam os at
ese aeeeecee nant
simimamms corte mee
Soom eacenat enema
cnet etacaniatecaet ee
Seether saenaenmes ere
Fanaa cee touas matress
tones caanaes
See eaeeeerrens
soci gti oeeeciocame
Saino ee erect
tnnlepean cern taa anaes
Sienersmcntaminm meres
Siew tae cariaeearteremtins
Sie aecegenesaors
Sot mreeesore MEE,
sipemrice eee neice eae
featnteerentreeceh eee
heme26 + The American Cronies of José Mari
Both themes’ image ofthe werd andthe ani of tir poetcs were
conned the isa of progres, the dzling new frontiers of knowledge the
‘tue af indastilzed counties, andthe psctelcapaiies of man. Fa
‘armors, modems refed the pain of tansfomaton. and fused de
Seto regain aelng or the soblime slo crest ew spaces of cndensation
Ina world where everthing seemed fps
‘Moh of their weg as confession maced by «touch ofthe Baude-
Taian dandy asin these ies by Casa “I Hove aly wretcd beings, The
Innppy people who ze ssid with hel ives Gn me thy saddened mo
say sgst me.I abominate ter wth aly sul"
Modernism varied according othe ator andthe period Max Heriqae
‘ret commend usefully on he mull le oem trate
Ine scond phase an nese poe uff t “py” of xy
‘mole: ee peso Si ects at toe anion, eee
‘teal mysty ocd ead, wie mame ine anos dei wees
‘enely Amen atc expres praise, Capra li sd nbs
‘tte people of Anco, unssing tar wer, esd pe hse mee oe
{ng the language with ac™ .
‘There were individual difrences and illest pid within modernism.
How, thea, to ascertain that thie groop of cretrs from diferent counties
de up srving the inerets of the Bougeie?
Tn general and not only i the eae of modem, istran hve limited
Ahemselves to analyzing artifacts of “igh culture a iliratons of sociopo-
liteal developmen ra reeconsof dominant iealgy. Butt analyze ey
‘he boupens aspects of ertre isto imposes misleading homoge upco
social discourse and assume tat social cases have “pure” “neces” ot
“paradigmatic” ideologies (Laca, 103). Fredric Jameson a tum engin
thatthe movemest ofthe soa eaexinence of aos ines of pr.
Scns abtsycroonn io eae hiya dle
‘The modems entered the market a produces of keoogy "Teotogiing
fanetion’ ithe exact expression Rama ues o describe thelr sail role in The
Letered Cty (110, bt ch an expesion ca lead to consion especialy If
we tino accoun that a lage portion of the models work was pub
lisbed notin the limited collections of ter poetry but nthe fret ly
res, with al the power tht jouraism bao sbape the sol imaginary,
The confusion epuing produces and wansiterr of Sdeology stems
fromthe iden ectvely refuted by Emesto aca, tt all dolog dom
Int We can also say that al teats area symbole at rprevenig broad,
‘The Waters’ Role + 27
clas basd ole tht he ets someting more tan an individ po
role, Athsser hes ered the tana maest notion that here 0 50-
Slaton tt does not epodice he modes of production, which wool ug
fot ht the moderates were fated to reproduce the ales ft market
fst (Altus, 9), Aloser’ theory doesnot ake int aeount the fat
thet there are sectors of the popalition inspired by sn cology divergent fom
the domant on, and htm every soil astm bere are inividaal whose
tank tis to oppove tat syste. Th, in order to uadertand the ambivalent
sd teterogcneous ideolirng fue” of te modernists itis bet oer
tora definition of Seology such as that proposed by psychologist Jacques
Caan Lsolgy isthe mean by which he subjecatemps to beach the gap
between pits experence and be colective™*
“Alexi can bee asthe wring of pr-eiten ideological Msteal
ber and ab daloque of social aagonions Jameson wes defi
‘Hon extremely enlightening for moderism—ut designates a “cultural ey
‘lon a the moment in which preoalyeoaxstag modes of production
‘bsvome lly opposed or atagonisi. The vision of antagonisms canbe
‘ented wih th nde cle Sponith Amerian soley and with modest,
‘senses: madera cn be sen as sigacant ambivalent moment of
Stance ote Bourgeoisie.
“This is ot what Joan José Hemiadex Arregui though. Toh, modest,
texts were “he lacy tt the oligarchy ads to is upstart caroity for eu
Tore Joo nis Romeo asus them of being pootealy idealized “ass
ares” (290)
"These ideas seem to coinelde with our previo icsson ofthe modem.
is" elton tothe bougeise ad thee epesenaon ofthe inreur, they
‘woud seem to exphin the appacn vaiy of many chronicles produced in
Spanish Amoi by the modems. However, vay and nary wee aio
{be “umasng enelope”—to me Baudlare’s expression —of masgaaized
tectr spite He wat ot for voting tht Grex Girard refered t the
‘modernist at “ecoomic oles” This group, pour ater le bourgeois ap
‘roped elements of boorgois clare pecsly o express opinion agains
the boargciie®
"Tatonal Marte conidr writers as dz produces inthe ieoogial
sabe crestor of ecg taal goods Bat his deat sig, a
Tamesoa ha showa, beets the idea of is tpe of goedsconnins the
‘Sampo of a nivocal nterpreion. Ax Foucmiiomclly commented,
fering those who len or Mack, Hegel, td Feud, “iss Foaishoes is ©
‘aioe that al thought express” the Sasology of ne cls 328). Farther
‘more, ss was dicued in the previous apo, thee vas no hegemonic dis
‘Cousei fndesitte Spal Amaia, trae several verse scouses
‘within he dorian ls(7B + The American Chronicles of José Marth
Inthe case ofthe modernists, itis clear hat they adopted a semi oficial
postr of insulting the process of moneteriaion ad rection” Noose
Jes this is avery ambivalent soe the tray selon they prodced po
founly changed Spanish American cure, which makes untenable the dea
that hey sided with contention. A he same tine it is unerible that they
sang the pales of opulence, eputdly using ajectvs like sees "te"
exguiiey” “eines nd especialy “ante” Today i swell Known
bat tei aristocrat inclinations were 2 way of tacking the valgaiy f the
bourgeoisie, Atte tum of the century, however the bourgeoisie was not Yet
folly recognized = 2 distinct social group. They were frequent conuied
‘with the merchant class ofthe rain ele, ad as a result mch of the
‘modemis”ctique was misunderstood In any event, the stort tobe of
‘auch modems wing tended a look down upon te populrcases aswel,
‘malig the wir sce decidedly eis. y
Asher agpet to consideris the preseceof he sparen moder it-
cerur, used «wy ef overturning the dominant vison af th word But
salu way of evading realy, an interpretation soporte bythe fet that the
majority of modems stepped ove nd beyond the mpoversieg masses.
"Real de Ain also observed ta, with ter passion fr bilan, modea-
{sexed Sgures of real or psential eroes—an these were not aay he
‘expel ear. But his tendency was based on their nee for new men
and went agains he old oliguchy that sapperted the goverment of tei
"in heir umbivlence they both warned agaist the dangers of mpi
sod exalted te Uni Stas a5 podel of progress Inthe spt of wlversa-
Jism and search forthe anoctogoos, they—Marts included found them
sels dealing Spain, “disco know to wate. they were
‘conscious hat with hs position the validated the worst adsione of beta,
atc ged, sed, and sup arog, which thy st able“
mani "pote aod ie” (Real de Aaa, a)
"Anotberof the secusains aginst moderns shat proclivity for oma
‘mentation was a mere exibition crcestted withthe deminds ofthe mart
‘nmin. Worse sll iste suggestion that theve waters finding themsaves
‘overveled by te laws of supply and demand that were imposed on may
‘bythe regular abr of oaaais, wee incapable of cing tht hs aor pox
vided tem With new ier forms and instrumens, ach sth brite
"We cannot engage in achonisns snl expect the writer of the pst 10
‘conceplizegeares the way we do tee. Nelthr can we ak modems not
‘0 vow joumalism as ¢ form of slivers, or—like Geto undead tht
imide them songs.
"What s most puzzling abou modernists objections to jour Ito de
fie situation bey wool ve prefened:
‘The Ween’ Role + 29,
ertapitsthe hatin of the Satllyindpesent nan of ters in te Mile
[Apt Oe Rennie it Slater bec soght Perhaps it was th a of
(SF Brien ce pte he lanor of Gorn at se of Dene
{Sor ies uopal Wear tcoldbave bea te pong of ome gterous Mee
fn fred wino tng ine, lene Das nc smi is siya,
(este az xv.
‘re pea he coms Dep he ly ei
‘Dei Se samp farm, hn oso lee ot
Shas mcp ta mt ssy.Ar a y ol
rancor atu eso ey wee lat
ter de site of tag ny 0 e ein
Tiere
Teter rach wns Hof chon nb id hat ode
wes ames pnt iss at ars pn om epost
suo eay cen te they sug ee re
ergs fain eas wie Seg ee
Spas ote st tent coy Oe
eee nat eee ene spe hr Bere
axa sie on be ly pc oor neni
Satur ft ee nonlonof won e Deanery. Man
‘zh eS Amo mr to pe
See Doc att iu tan Dongs arm
SARE be hastens cnn ett: mot
caste cman, beer cn min Aner ced
Sati
itt lu bose ae i ae oe ae
asia steal eng Sp anne
‘hacen ein pss ane a atl at Be
‘Rebtel hs oper bey pepe ton
ceo
rants o ype sss td an eed exif te
increta canes at nse can oi Do as
‘nrcc s meon os even Te com
seers a eee tirade a
‘Siscinptoc we ofsuntng be apogee a ee
‘Rete of Noo og oe
[Deseltcm oy trem nomen ee dice oe en *
‘Recetas For ron jing Cae
{Sedo ele ning mena an cre i ie
ceric cn So mle weed nh
SSIS peer naey hve on es ened30 + The American Chronicles of José Marté
fnporting and iting Sign ton he ot ind tr wo aid he
fenton of procs hat Ferman Ortir abd Ange Rams tr eid
‘ranculoarin Inet words, odes sstblihe oe of te m0 in
eran sates of Spanish Ameren ieee: tr clei approeaton
{teen rm trent cures, ans, nd gees sober he st
led erry order nd ultly cel anew one”
Chapter 3
The Emergence of the Chronicle
Wt hes yo te on wing?
May Got neve allow ie 1b be hin wood es despa.
"esi Gtnorahieto werk wih one ben,
‘oh tis bononblet week wien arms andes
ati oan
ean Bats Ae aie so
(Etats Nveaber 938)
1h Lies of Spanish American Journalism
From the postindependeace period though the 1880s, Spanish American
owapaper were atinaliig fore in herr publce, Commercial alver-
{iemeats occupied lie space covering onl cross and Ieaving compet
tion op tool aversng Thad coins with Sombars deseion of
Barope ding the sme pesiod: "The didaguished polishers were averse
‘reat the simplest commercial avertsements; publcy washed belnde-
‘Sen Joule discourse ring thi peiog was drt inked othe pub-
Ee cmergenes ofa goupof pve peaons"Inded seat nd emerging cal
tured bougeaisey who cse forward wih conomlsagends and plans for
evelopment. They legtized their aged sing the language of easoa and
freedom of speech, which inter case meas oninervention bythe Ste
‘Their metbod continued though the modernist psd
ori fit ive yrs Argentina's a Nacga, fr example, founded in 1870,
swat a mouthpiece forte Partido Liberal. This party as dominated bythe
‘Mice any wo wer the owners ofthe newspapet Bourges and pole!
publicity di ot efor, ake separate ways Journalism bre the stamp of
{he “pay of moibles" a group of edced and inoental month neloded
‘ergymen, professors, lawyers doco, teachers, pharmacists, manufac,
tnd ndowacrs, Tey fern plea lbs, topical coalitions, and electoral
“socatona The muber of profesional pltisans was rdaced dorng this
332+ The American Chronicles of José Marti
eid: forthe “genemen pales was secondary cceupation,butnonethe-
[es oficial eered Gequnt rept to the mewepepe.
"Thus the project of “easoa” was not Lied to organising lforation,
pinion played fdas prt these clued papers, wach were wait
tea, in le part, by waters. Sich is the case with an Mae Gasémer,
focder of La Nacin Argentina whch diely preceded La Nocén A ped:
otal spit srfsed these puications, whic found poli education and
‘he consolidation of national deat aman te aon dae
Newsppe e for made pope wha ora ae th Roman The pee at
‘enced he upc and pn wing hs oped the pln wet, an he
ae Abels or, dire vis the maps of gene a aiero move te
sos of sever lon iene romance ay bf ans whose in
Sap sine sae eps he fo hesing Task joa, ge
‘ewe fr ana sna of ced han for wins”
‘As Haber bas expsne, with be conslidatio ofthe bourgeois tte, the
press began to detach itself fom the goveramcat and offical opinions and
epun t ated to pros tke an otier commercial undertaking” BU in the
ccf pn Aen iil tr thei of oer
press dicey related to the “consoldason ofthe boureais Sat” since
fh s consoldation is questionable eves today. Moreover, economies
{nm led to authoritarian regimes many ofthe coanies of hs hemepers,
‘making tfc to detach commercial enerpises fromthe State Whit i
{tue, however, that sound the decade of he eis, the Spanish Ameren
‘retundervent change silo thao writers: Boh cored o set Sate
osogis. Mart wes legato varied he jmped fom advice boat lexp-
hg int wo new types of porcelain frs good ca set to was, the deta of
[ntemtonal pots elacadon attr, fashion, amd expecially scientific
dvences and literary vloes. He never cca to refet upon ccs sd te
man sondon snd he wiote aay wid afl images exhaustive infor
ati, mardve grace, ands apis in wich the smallest etal teed to48 + Tho American Chronicles of José Marth
F Sarmiento for whom wsting wae modemizing, or mediating betwee c=
zation and artis (Ramo 3-57). In order to moderaiz, those wo con
Sicng worlds hed to be bough ino harmony, On one band, ere Was oh =
tempt rationalize society by imposing des “tat were fa fom ping sry
of those instructive and humsaly natural fection of the sal” On the aber
hand it was necesay 1 incorperte te stage Other ino the maton by
transcribing th poten word of tov who wee net pert of ere elie Bt
‘he rnsciber hs gover ben eat and the words of the Other appeared as
if wansforbed by distance and cifercaes saborinated tothe norms of West
ferrule, Once writen, se words enter the game of cal tonal,
{eeogniing te conditions of possbty ned the anipation of another
cde”
ofthe project of subduing he heterogeneity of couse. Inte new ode at
fess the Othe Is subordiaied othe dicourse of evan, othe spaces
‘cpio bylaw This owas in Palma’ tents a wall ae those y Cuban co-
‘tombs wre of the 18808 ecuding Joxé Quintin Suz Jos. Trin,
Franeico Valeo, and Francisco de Paula Gelaber™ Iz Quan Sure "Las
oso the deseo is dawn apres mature, a ft were a pit wth
Sun The theme isthe disappearance of wadioal ral fe in the face of
“alos, eleprapts, telephones, and all te oe dlghs of civilisation”
(Gueno, 45). All ofthese changes ar aro the process af emocatization
nd for hat reason spposely limite acl clases, Bu t Quit Sazarc
Suggests, yin ality only degrade the lower clases by suppig aay tee
‘ail chao th por become merely dmatve nd oe thei beat. Tere
Isastong sese of nasal for he past nd a dese to preserve local wats,
olor, and eas.
a Quan Suzarte's formulation, the atu! man—the creole descended
from European ancestor fl of quaes hat need tobe clio. Thi is
not a mater of imitating appearances or of sing hard werk and educa to
‘The Emergence ofthe Chronicle + $1
tum te soto ving in moral cist no a sigue fail. JB
‘Mays sEl ene” (Tie cache) so wes any descriptive aleve
epic terms bt tren etna “Ls naj” A
‘Guiles woo the pt petal on-xste,bt iose fats
Serene by curt who bob wes sad so knowl
‘once n popu cua nd marci soc is ngnge i ae
om onied road an esine! operas end Weed th sein
od: tool ch elower aes ng supa by the vir
{uesefcomaton si pgrss leo Zanes snouts ese
trun, Te usr peal appease oh reader comment
on th te, adiesngsert'y Ne cw scl las, the acts fea
feces tl ze of forge nto, "Zacks puis e ome
fmoienetn by talting moder" ari of band tame bat
there m oe peer econo eh cso at are cen 8 ipe=
‘rea om pst Tit combed wih an abet rer oi belt in he
‘Pane cblieof ropes” G30). De Pala Gabers "La sla de
‘omboisborm of he ame adonlzing it, bot losr natal ine
‘ow he Ot “he infer, uncatued ting” no ager sage who
thst te vies, bt sees oe whose sydney his of br
‘leionment
‘ter yratsaehe Mexican celles ofthe ine. Gulemo rt
s.rtmascn yankee” (The ice sso, 1875 and “Epa” The scam,
‘Aaya el wih epsenting the Ose bt ine wii In ee
hones he matric sed wien Thee we soa =
Son ceed wi eis sein, Tey peg saan bat conn 4
Star cata mestge ne conden of Inpealin.Theyephaie
{Toller nd epee the pstin toms f he it’s ineecton wih he
‘Senn peopl epeting tant uty 8 ne ain be eto
{frig nunc, Aliogh Polos language oe nate eee
‘Ecce between ir sl oer sobre thos Hn he teed
‘arta he mney and system of repesenttn. Tis i
‘ots inthe cae of gaa Manol Alamitos ‘Una vt a a Cada
Se ts Par (Ast to he Ducks Candely 1859 Altman’ araoe
Shc eran inincy and ren comp) with is eles by essing
fh cpay te cal ap ssl ca The Ote, however etal)
Sec ota rata by Pogson nod of i enistce he en
{tatpopes or molknarein nut connate totais the beef is
Chonie By js ping tel of ine th suroais Meio Cy wih
ur peostatny is sua coodton in Sp, te marr deus he ca
‘Soins sgn ces pf ats ats" forse be foes
Tet ocesioally sarge leant part he cy Avaher contmpony
Mencan chon, Angl de Campo, employs wally erat syste of|) SL + The hmeian Chronicles of Jost Marth
switog His “El fslaniento” (The exeeton, 1894) desis mans dea
Win Eh inpeesoniste plese that the acon seems suspended, in ober
TaRSihe eft is 2 skingly sual that th text seems to Tose narative
‘Moveimes For de Campo the topic fe buts prext his obestive so desrbe
aoremlasy borhan lo sommes The milly i represented,
‘Pe rth gomon people who wines the excin, a hes represen
‘peso he new urban sans ia, solder, and arepster, who pest
Sh Some Thre isa sytboticopeston between the wan andthe wie
veh eucouted man who “eloped desperstely, caring co ber back cid
‘Jno lnghed gg oer aid The engine whl once mor fom the
creams it of ake, afer owing slowly in the a, ll onthe pin
de he ian sigh of happy, be sping y™*
5: Marti and the Press In Spanish America
‘soni so win Mart ine wa aw populate sn cite.
aa tenth coma tadtion vas mach mor compl with he ro
pa econ an snes work ws Atop ot lof be
see shred he for inpatient be ong ad the
aaa Pa in common shold te adn geen ems ha Beir
rane sum skacies were les el ofthe dominant nt
(er ninacent ey soi Bebvers inde and prog ye
a convnng ole tnt oration shou be ered 1 te Othe:
Tere pe cnn Bgeio Maa de Hoon, for whom rai al 0
ats mts ofedunng and mowing, mstaed the cvietionba
ae tony Hs plngopal Reva de Pancico V. Agee” a
Dat anc. Agee pracy spats inte et oft Ea
creer tie cc Ald ocupicd by ¢ defense of rab, Iw he
‘a lect among, abe ooo ain. The bec
so oct rors Ager, epetets te very est fe popace
(ons 36-29.
ee ee nesta appropiate
tea epoaan, bennett deep eognize he eed
sean lel Rermae inca oto" Bu om, abet enon
{G¥or cont of devinghusan types exo S=ney, oleae and Ge
Son Sa my eter Spih Ames woes nether
Sia wees cone ponte pop poi or lis
Ste ey Ene tap ay inbaocetc tems such wt pros
‘Sheen th ciiaed and he bare
ant sew aman pes acoing tnx monlly ins
eae et cne forename na eral chino™ OC, 77-78) ia
“The Emergese ofthe Chonicle + 53"
the mates ported on Brooklyn Bridge, or he series onthe anarchist strikes
bythe "Cataloo del Tabeo”(Ksight of Lab) a 886i which German
migrants ae oot teted Kindy, Bot pejuces sie, th epreseation of
‘anal ype” was aot he obese of hese texts. in gneve touches
te given in pasting, a aoterbrshstoke in an impression pening. I
‘Mac red to detioete a humas “ype” twas one that coud ise up 8 a
‘modem-ay er. To ds end be went beyond geographical iiutions and
‘Gedo uadesfnd fom orton, wales, plisins, pilosophers and all
tary men-the intra ve tat roved thom 0 sac forthe sulie fn he
nit of indian, These "Wes" id not exist solely through thee
‘ros or habits a nthe costombrna txts, nor ace they a mitapbr fo he
‘poop: They ext through ther passion fr whats grea, for Liberty or Ni
{sr forthe sbi to eanscend edocs. Bach ipe" elaborated fom a
‘eal proof, bt oe whore specs biography dos not pater mac; whi
Tater is eeting an example Ae Mar said" don't eae aout the tops
‘ong the human raoad tht se up and deszoy the cmveneaces ofthe i=
ing care abut the stu, wich i changeable but fe, at keep the tain
moving” (CXL, 186), Tot Js why the sccunulaion of concrete referent
Fc oot evenfl eis chonicles, Marts system of rpeseatton dies
tot only fiom the sytem ofthe other chrceizis, bu so fom the ober
lst polite alongside hs ova Ia reviewing Lt Opinién Nacional fom
ro, for example becomes clear ht hs was sl be newspaper of th ie
Instious th dio fora cerning, bea ls © promot is des. Tk
thd ot yt been “profesonalied” at newspaper, a it woud Inter, i the
sense of eling information
“Although is tue di he wircopy in Lat Opin Noclonal consisted of|
ots ee, many fis ets were sll etal. On Jasuary 16,1880, the
‘per reruns plese orginally published in B Hlspanoamericano ented “Ex-
{ehor —Mésio, eb In actin” (nteeatinalnews—Merico toy). The
Dewey is charcezed by short sentences, fe adjecives, anda focus oa
‘Bc ie comtet covers many ofthe obsessive hemes of Mars work the
css of comtemporary lie, Nor American inpealisn, th necessiy of
‘ceting nw and elé-saricig mes. Tae writer invokes the image of Cis,
‘rea tothe point of cling Boia "the Crit ofthe Souter edema” in
‘ede to suggest continental nity. Americas represented as Pardo sai-
fg now Adam This ew Adana ist appears o bea igure for dacation,
tut oth end rpresets instead progress, ciation, aod commerce: a
thre embodied inthe dictator Parti Diz. This wie asin effet reversed
‘Marts srteny: ether thon posting conemporary Sigur o vet 28 4 pe-
text to speak of ales and dea, the writer of México, la actual” ap-
ropes phiowopiel and poi ases a sbetxcl base from which fo
Ianoeh is rapport of D254 + The American Chronicles of José Marth
Cte texts in Za Opin Nacional in Carns, ach athe ections abot
the United Sates published othe fon page on Mach 9 and 1 ae sna.
The mala tris ropes, education in eas of Bropean and Noth Amer
jean cae etson, commerce, sh indasey, andthe teat of imperialism
{fom the northern nego, The language ie fnctional, supported by author
ites soch ss Hogo and Gate, an has the sme objective offer the pop
Tac the nvesay eduction and work o accompany mademization.
“The frontpage ares polished ut 182-~such as “Les partidos poti-
cos Political parties) (August 25, 1881), or "La libertad depress” Freedom
ofthe pes) Febrory 25,1881) are unsigned and take an edie ove, at
lke prosened inthe fat of now, The oven is coasistent ciation
‘Sq well being, and we needa harnoaize social elton, if between 2
Soviats ina mercantile company, Nar mae maa ree node fo ain
that iced, the Stat mist ak ceo hough ews, which ae de ams of
reason and of te malty that chanel he ederwie unconroled masses.
‘efemptonl end porivet spit infuses a of is
"The pepe of he time presented psnorma of rationalizing discourse
whose nistence on edcting for progrese sms ike at impositon af
“oeign nor and «toggle against Soca ely. Mad responds to this o-
fitvist clamor by eding the Revista Yeneolana in Caras, a magazine
(etiatd‘o celbrating Venere ise, praising its hecoes and its ature in
‘Snow language and defining the local no intr of eviizaton, at ether
ts memories ofthe nation ands pa. He posts wadition asa, book, man,
fenascape and eo He declares he iasation fom the psslon of domestic
politics and his dedication to grander things, tthe superative, tothe pot,
ff th new wel, “whose genuine channels and sources, more naturel ad
Drofound than thite of ny poetry now, certainly donc hie in those pale
oaks fehl bots shat come ous fom wvort-out lands (sy ems). He
Isao connected withthe Bolivar tuna, bat his hope so find freedom
fd new divinities in Nature and local istry At fit pace tac ke
a joke of exteme idealism, but is projects 0 radically opposed to thei
tational power thatthe Revista Venezolano bardly makes it i second
{ssc in the fist, Mart had praised the wter Ceo Acosta, who Wasco
fideed an enomy by the dcetc Guana Blanc, The note enough ous
{ty Marts expulsion fom Venersla and inaugurate his long carer 05 &
coespondeat.
“La Opinin Nacional also employed » gest corespondent who signd bis
work “Hortensio” ie "Revista pla earopen san asemblage of ite
Tovmution and tibecl opaions presented without meeto, sin anew re
Physically, is "Revss” esembles Maifv North Amerianscenes—hsving
the form of eters tothe itor ta ar signed aed, nd receded by som
rary—tnt, une most of Maris chronicles, which presented an oulne
"The Emergence of the Chronicle + 55
rade up of subudes, Hortesio offered uve summary, albeit weiten in a
telegraphic syle, Here is oe of Hortenso's samsmais, from Febery 18,
io:
Spin Ines n Cabs — Aan Lasoo rer on te nd — Ren
fe serge members of Congest stato of Spun ae Coba—The
‘epic Oto ecards inte by doctrDalvs so Spin “Te Emp
‘Bigena—Plded stan race~Dewh ules Fore
‘The folowing is by Mac, fr the same newspaper, May 19, 1882:
Death of arson —The eat Anarene is ed —The peso nd
ot, Emons pure fe id, his dene, is fry hose
lec evaay Me sof ie mets Hs tii eo x
‘dnc boos‘ —Whai if? Whar ees —What nr Rare ech
{So Paleo o tempt df henen?Vire el bse of
‘Se Une His wy ofaing Tis wonder ves,
Marts sumsmiry more clotly resembles the kind of beadings tt preceded
novel chaps the slntenth centr, Using the secons that make up he
‘woe rater thn sma he information Infact, hoo fll the
‘ase eguremea of ging ths wes of Emerson's deat, thi sata repeaed,
suggesting tat th summary was ot meat a text wi autonomous vale,
‘5 Horensio’ was, or eps Jouualiste sammy Raber Mat bo:
ely dependent on th exe small index ofits cote
(Coen La Opinion Nacional withthe Boenee ie pape La Neca
yes sila results. Despite La Optnd's commimnnt to becoming com
‘meralized at an informative matin i ong remsnedthe plac wher cele
es voiced hei options. Although La Nacin copseatate on Arent’:
tutional ssves—the probes of immigration sad populating the wits
seaera rst was th same. From the poston of «pieged "we" La Nace
fale for progress, promoting soil equim at wellbeing ond“ ply”
fd suesiag the aoe coatol chaos With elas of coasseace and season
‘Once agin tbe theme isto impart habits of err ad freedom tothe masses.
‘Wi this eatril postion, La Nacin polished a minus of news ade.
tori fteratonal news rie chronicles, store, serialized novels, and et-
sol lets One ofthe tes ll attention titel fortwo reasons: et he
‘be dateof ts publication, and second, the identity fits auto. The place was
fpublad on Ocaber 8, 188, by which ie oul ad supposedly boon
‘modemized and ths, opsonized. The autor is Domingo Samieu56 +The American Cronies of Jost Mart
“The author css himself asthe Sst person protagonist who emerges in all of
Tis colosdl grandeur a edopades is opponent, an exicple wham eas
fer in tis let His eatepy eae: bays te opp of what he means
very tur, with the reader compli He resorts o expression in oer
Sacguages and foreign toms of pase peck [in English), homo, jeanesse
nuit feo, dollars, passe part, genfenan), caons of European 3
thors bn especialy of ins clita, opaions, and statis, He
arte, wie history, ite varios leis e has received, and deseies
‘hurcerunngtheeappenrnce toast thie prsnalityor codon Fe
fern on educating sad izing and stacks the clergy and bart li
namalgar of ses that ship fom corespeadence to omer, the ey,
tnd bck tothe Teter o he anecdoe,
‘Semiento never became prope chronicler during Mart’ tine, though
te ocipied extensive sce onthe fost page of Lz Nalin. One who dié
Share the cinder’ role with Mat, was the Spaniard Emi Costa, x
eign conesponest a era writer a wel. ister practiced the postin
ft new er ro on concades fer glance ata text och as "La eyend
Gz iacienca Ce leped of een), pblsbed in Lt Nac on amoay 20,
Te abounds in apes od omparsons, soc as: Poetry resembles will
(thoi in that tn nly thro cemeteries and is crowned only with
(he willows and eyprestes of dea” He construct naturel atlegies and ate
tacks east ata mantels inorder to defend the conection between
Soy and soul and tsscendence ito the eaves, He works with oppor
‘ons and immediacy, and makes the muse-mueum cbviows, He ouch 0a
‘Chrtan snd pagonsythology, exten, and ilsrons Nor Ames
them He units science wd ne pos, rin “when he tas descended into
feescopes like sbipeo tetas”
“A of everthng cn be found in “La leyenda del lencin”except fora
syste of representation. Ie a Kaleidoscope hat represents absolutely not
{Bg Is preform witht costent, a combiaton of wards i th now tray
fisbion, The more ified the Tanguage, the tore devoid of creativity 1
Svme, Caster wes more ti ry doorand weeds to expres baal. the
thay of tiees end poy arcelito Mentnder Peay stilacd Baio Case
tear dus "2 great metabior-hoter iesbausbe in enumeration, a lve f0
the image who ends i coking he idea inte rings of hs cicamlcaton, a0
‘Gator who wool ave sandlind te supremely austere Demosthenes” Me
endex Ply, 370
"To jogs fom th positon gven to these ates by Castel, ht eto,
_nforianatel fo itety isto nd fo the chronicle, was judged equal oe
Tila innovtions of Mars peose- Many subsequent writers of ik epe-
tilly among Rubén Dario fans, would coalaue to conse te reader ad
ttemelyes wth tama ineideicops of xurous wording and exo imag.
‘The Bmergeee of be Chile + 57
‘Sch witing detracted ran modems reputation for quite some ine batt
‘Sd nlhng to diminish he force of the movement ery insovatins
(6.The Chronicle as Genre
Nowe ms consider why the chronic rary gear in sown ight
‘hough was st pls inthe pres an saied the equiemeats of jou.
lise discourse, The aiteion of utifulness san lement tht leads 0 con-
fsion when sang genres of wong. According to Ais, posts were
Tas parencellence aad should ene th versiaitde of ter invecon. OF
Cou, the vessmitade of «writen word ix «sama element tht sold
‘ov conse with th. Since verhltudeis in etait oly ater ©
Slate effect, ne cannot coe othe conti hat Hsin pertains oer
‘Mie snd tu jours,
‘When jumalis bop fo deine itself san atonomes discourse, t=
‘aise te dosnin rea of he oc, sts ierary scours esta
Iho isl in he elo he sesbe, This dstcton, of course, was a
‘couric of eglimiation and diferettion. The writing sesay We Know
“Shetty dd ot tk bo in journalism ual he coasoiton of interna
tonal es agencies inthe tweed ceotay
Tear cts hus a general perpetated bourgeois atiudes. By oves-
Toon histori dt och those ast mentioned, crism atthe end of the
netenh and bean of th wend untarieformaated a sytem of ge
evi eateprizatin tht ened th chronic because it belonged wo the fae-
ta ai twa if ly heated the rary could se isp or
tlds to emotion. Fi
‘Systems of epresntng realty are med athe public space, nd their de-
loyient has ben determined since the tan ofthe century by the categories
Df trbfalschood that ae inposed upon ours and tert, Creativity
fis been sono the enlsie providence of users that ves and eds in
dof ise and its al nwomayt evan "tecay” vale of text in
Inverse proportion fo it connection to coneret rely. Tis ine of reasoning
hs bts hindered the recognition ofthe crise es terunre aod done iu
‘Sef god journalism
“The eal refseathas been confused withthe sytem of represettion, the
den te ft wi that of te narston, Raymond Willan anges, “The di
Chotomies fctficlon and objoctvefabjecive ae thea the teres and
soil iy to he basi bourgeois thar of iterate, which has contd
td spevolize the atl mpi of wong” CWliams 147-49) Hen
ing te sestede withthe fttous as distanced trary discourse fom he
‘word ffi ang seem a sppemeniary and unecessary acy58 + The American Chronicles of Jost Mart
actualy shoud nots eto, face or exlae the chronicle frm
‘trate o joonalism. Real requirements for to eroncle aris referen
tity—although i maybe expressed by Iie sibjeet—and ts tempor
fi it must be ciegtOregn y Gasset sad at Jouraaism is “tbe ct of
‘reals & AG” The chronicle then, Wasa story about contemporary, ery
{Gy history Wht eoald be tet fora erate such os the one 1 whic
Mart aspired than o “rel uel the multiple and confused conditions of
the tie, condensed, unproei, eet] and informed by great artic gon
fae" XX, 169)"
The texts alana within the asthe erary sphere depends on ster
the refrentliy or topalty of th sje, Weve noted tht many modes
[Stchvonicles detached temscives fro empaal ements and continue to be
‘baable as tre objets in and of tbemsnves, In ober words, having lost
‘over the yeas the pinay sgnicance thatthe cvoncles hd fo their eae
‘Ship of he ine they remaia oar discourses ar excellence.
Leroy discourse f characterized ty the preponderant role hat granted
to contextual meanings." The se occurs in regu to post Inguage, #0
‘Hvoncies cannot be sen oly a8 ouralism, bat most be considered poetic.
‘rove aswel.
"tis offs interes odefie the expesion "poetic pros" which suggests
falas oppostion basween prose and poe. anit ito rescue the notion tt
Chronicles ae also pote Sscouse. They display the relationship beeen
topleal specticiy oF pence ad inraletal resonance. A pai of exan-
ples wil suis
Inve met pat ifs Tony hes ales ch sow a lo
im lory hn ang a wou bi, gases aaa Dresis He es
oon ad ore din sod mune shy of le and evasive Li
‘Great veer ofthe seo he eer ae empha an ed
trons witer duress Then ets te gino if te dunes
‘ena Hs oul wb entered tle
No, ei oof ose who st mite Gt oto tae ad ap slong
verte vise oreo ele cos He oer natin swallows make
lem seem eagle He showers dn expe eery ie opens is hand, Ha wane
shore ars
‘The int pursgeaph is from a port fIhsen by Ron Dario, em is sees
Tos reros 199), The sound ina Bomage to Walt Whan by José Mar, fom
‘sete fom New York (XI, 39). In both cass fhe pape dsbuton
teere broken up andthe prose diated as verse coulda’ they be read as
The Emergence ofthe Conicle + 59
oom? It coud pethas be sida rp dtibutin could wansform ay
ea thu, eve te most baal But what is tue is hat both paragrapti—oe
‘Sanzas, to prolong the festa) the conventions of lye oe ina ma
fre mode: tey a temporal comple cobereston a symbolic evel, nd X=
‘yes anatinide™
The etgorisng of chonilesiecomples an asclating. As he ines
tin fours od rary cncorses, dey preset wo types of meaning:
enfgal and cept, or extemal and tera” This represents the f=
part oonriton tt igus spns ae at he service ofthe eirelaton of
‘emiog within etext, whl the same tne, te coset be anspeat,
rl or strunettl and acquire specific and inerdependent weight
"What sit tt nls tee fora, news tess "works of a? What
istinguishes and coastites thm tems fom the will o create Herre,
surging eopecaly rom he way in which icons is verbalize, how veal
‘xt dominates the taasnisson of referential messope**
‘Defining the chrovile pense st the coming togetier of liery discourse
og jour cea oarinvesigaon of Mara’ week, as is derstand
ing ners’ ole in itrzy bntoey ad th renovation of Spanish Ames
fan pose which de modems sctualied troagh pit juralsm. Gere
ota single agpet ofa work a at butrae “ie whole uternce” because it
‘cries beth he form sod the Nematic reslt of the tat, be ita detective
‘og sceatic ese, or up colum,H eodons what Bakinin called the
‘inonatope, the spec relonship between space and ine in ay ven ext
‘he semantic ar (uc as dea of ex, the extra entation of contions
(of pereption ad ction, nthe imal rcnation of he text, th por
tine of lity of treo hat gee
‘Rears recognized the modes conicle ab a genre inset, distinct
from pre ouralsm There ae abundant neato of isin iterate of he
tn, ncoting the provouly cited example of Bartolomé Mine: a dtr of
is Nac, Mie fel justied in eating s plea ote "Fasastc Nar
tons simply because ts author was Know as a erry wlan therefore
incapable of rproenig reality ffl
“The hone ists pore andthe aterectionof two discoures. tsi
ptt io keep in mind tat the geo fot pote set, and therfore
{be very ete ofthe chronicle wring tool kes the wate forme
seq eos an i
ain Mart fds an appropiate way to speak ofthe chronicler, a
hough his wards refer fo Escron: "He di ot fake revelations. He did oot
‘onntrct meatal ors He didnt pace mental will or effort in what prose
‘Su pouty he wrote All hs roses prety. Andis pocry is prose—they ate
like echors.. He sa bimseiftanspsetpypl that sa tall rected it
alland was ost ppi OL 19)Chapter 4
Writing the Present
{Tie a8 Poster
ase Mats rogue to “Poems del Nigurs”by Joan Antoio Pérez Bonale
(VI, 221-38) i round breaking text becuse its esthetic purpose isthe
‘epson of temporal, anersood athe suareaess of th preseat
time, Wrien in 182, tempts to deine aos sytem of represettion
‘dat expats man modernity in the Americas Ie asym capable ofa
‘tenia apprebeding he preset itis notanatemp to form aman s
‘ove tous erate, bt to cknomedge the ex a ope of the i de
[reac ain to redacor, trough everéay loging, the 2 reltonship
tetween sap, nt bd the interior ofeach, Literate sas be “our Sma,
facing or Nate” (VI. 223).
‘Conventions ofthe pst are hollow and frig mass: “This century bas
worm eaten waly ike «kel in which metal his ben gue” he yn
"Tis grandes hnelges en Estados Unidos” (The great ster inthe United
Stas) O41). now sun mst be conrad, at Spanish Ameria cxmnot
be rsted wo doit, even in it “gut confsed bug instiuons (VI. 29)
Everything tat bs relearod and rediscovered. This epoch he ass
pio ofthe "dismembering of he hamas mind. Other wee mes of esced
fences. This isthe ie o broken foes" (VI, 226) The chrnile "Cone Is
land” express th amstemen\ Mar fet before te whan multitudes and con
stent social wanton whet mazes teri the ithe quant, the sudden
fev of baron stv. those roads da rom wo ales of re nt roads
‘ut long carpets of heads That mobili, tat pk for advancing, that atack,
that hmnge of format crashing abd urconuolableexpesivesess
‘td eet and hat saraloes bout the fantasti. 1X, 12.
Tor Mri is wis 4 moment of constant development. The dil dame
‘nas toch man went tobe with one fen tnd awoke wih ancher ery
thing wae fre snd rgmenary,vrpinous snd imperfect. Speed, sila
‘iad the launedacy of what shaman aethe central ius. As Mar sate,
Ignorance shamefl nd new answers ar egused "Today no on as cue
faith.» [The ntvioe af ren conceals) Angst, nsecaiy, Vague Hope, See
Vision. What aight othe ear! T ak for whatnot coming! Nott
Waing he Present + 64
ow what we tie! T fel ight nd nasi ou oust once: muse at
the dyng day and ett inte daw” (VL, 225.
Fea delight imply tat oo, tras, ad amazement ral part of
this perception of the Word, Isitudonlzed tadions are nt eaovgh t0
‘derstand fe ne ml, Science amines only partly the pys-
‘al dimension, Metaphyis, expecially onaogy i the branch of knowledge
‘nos bruised by moder. One of hemos trupaent images isthe rp
‘eotton of te lone indivi snang the muludes of New Yorke epic
‘eof the ner un ely fghered ty the monetczation of ie and the
Joss ote meaning of existence
‘ew fons had to secompany the new processes of production. There wee
longer ts Bke temper. Some patiss generated eters. Tere was 20
‘penny to understand present to which anew pice was added vey do. Tis
[sty Jose Mar concen his prologue o “Poema del Nigar” tht the
lc for ea noua the space of whats nom peanent of comm
caon,ofzew fact, ofa pble mijn, place lnue and aon esbish.
‘The newsper ithe sign of te new times. To a prid of such mobili,
conespoods &Sintaly mob wring. Only jumals permits th invasive
tnt of ie, and fe the only legimate topic ofthe fr de siele clo
Souaim wat one ofthe tral fonnative sources forts new sensibility,
‘wich had wo find pot in an invasive dyes. In te prologue wo Pérez Bo
"de, Mar explains the sem of representation trough the symbol and
fnlogy, ab well the concer work wi Wlga and common mate:
“inthe universal factory thre no sage ie hing that does not eosin
alle seeds of big dings” (VI, 224) He wes:
Alls exenson,conmsioicn, Saran, conbigon, and sad. The aewpae
“owes nds eto oar fom al a aoe ous
Tingle Ty av tna shore om + Upting ba dh wings They ot
‘Sele ina sige dat ye corn al of Bo Rae ha ang ng in
‘outing sl umber fas rater ar hy bento ea.
nw a ued eid on agh wens ore, ped rected mH. ove
fumed ued at. (VIL 337)
“Tae modernist chronicle a cla practice vel a dep epistemological
‘ise, Not only did doubt ooepy the center oF toot bat temperality i
‘ade everthing lik zr pel Bverying wssfeeng changing ab im
‘evfoet Iewas the begining of democratization and miss ult “Ths ike
2 decenvalization of inelience. Beaty has become eveyooe's domain
Gens is moving fom the inividul tothe cllecve™ (VU, 238)
‘The fnces of prt and pre Raphaelite exqistenes,Pamassan perfection,
romanic reeig, pole, and natal elim were al a work. In he+ 62» The American Chronicles of José Mart
ist of tos, Mart proposed either exape to naira sco
‘pte by mtv vor nor the reproduction of prestgoes arts canons
Instead he sought to fcamate ine In eden, ung ad combining
whatever he cout nd the most sincere expressive form give an acct
tf the sot and vertigo of big cies. sents ad expecially in is eon
fies and poems, be est the customs imposed by urouszation andthe bout
froise. Avs poston, however, dnl tat poet might have ool-
[epic along with auditions eis. Pety—be exclans-—isin the melings
and in searengine fare; iis the eadsh and Danteaghe aight of the
modern Babylon Tatras: isin weekshope" (XII, 421.
2. Marts Chronicles vie 3 vie the North American Press
Arona 1890, the objetivo the bast Now York press was—asPulier do
‘manded-—to avestigte tothe boom of things and fo we naativetchniqae
‘ocaprr steton Nowa oe vivid. Baomous space could be dedised
to aseenngly nino em ht was ftresting ote man onthe es. North
“American oor comseedthemssves to be wien or rast sts,
They undersood histo be pt ely te mimetic fanction of xs, bt teen
ticton of reality” with exer phenomena Jot Maron he ober band
dizer ofthe Herald, moved ava from the “extemal” ofdscipions a
bis chronicles to defend the" ofthe trary subject ad the right subjec:
Avy. According to Gara Mare, Mart learned is imaginative Hight fom
Spanish Americans, the ies of «serio stand the gravity ofthe pst fom
hropeun, bt he efcacy of fact ad the in of Ie fom United States
journalism?
“Compariag Marts conics fom 18 to 1852, whe he was ome
spandet in New Yor, fo America textstha appearein the pes att ine
ops us understand his writng? Mart was a great rade af the New Yor
ress. He mized the Hera oc example which hid begun doing big overs
Sd special dion dedicat to single ae of intrest half-century eave.
“He contd tothe Hour, tod especially to Charles Dana's Sm, Da even
tually woot Mars obituary
“The Sun was "ie bridge betwees the olds pres st the new joursisa
that was to develop before the ead ofthe century Like the biggest aces:
apes ofthe cit aimed its editorials and writing style at worker, sal
businessmen, and inumigrans. The lesson ofthe Su Was very important for
“Mart he cronicler Dana's stated objective was to present as cea as pos
sible daly photograph of the elements of the world. He crete his es
ape vith his writer inspec pages, 0 tat would lio repre
feat the people of New York, He showed interest in police, economics, end
‘Writing the Present + 68
ovement, bathe mantsined that es came “the peoples One of his bog-
‘apers writes that "be had he indefnable newspaper instinct at knows
‘ens tomcat onthe tp of Cy Halls more imporac thn ris in the
alkane”™
"Tis was the time of great eri erases, of wa correspondents eos
of seosaonalist pres, Mart, in Now York, rad and sdmired writer
journals such e Mark Twain sod Walt Whitman. He was sep off hi fst
bythe delete reporter of is vo fevoritenewspupes, te NewYork Tribune
tnd the Evening Sin, Jeo Ris. This Danish ee ofthe capitalist sem
‘wrote sandlows chronicles aot te poor neighborods of New York. His
(sfc ft Lowe clases enjoyed uch suoes that hey Iter eappeared in
is book ow the Other Half Lives (1890)?
‘Whit could be beter tinng for s Hurt soch as modernism than tobe
“ere tings bape"? Modems wasted to be capable of following the
yh of change oft intel he mull ad confused condtans of
‘is ine, condensed, not rsa, courageous, ap nfemed by supreme ats
te pits" XI, 163) Ae Ans! Gomes put it "The chronicle pt he
odemity of modem wring the testa ook iterate othe it of ts
Abts in order to inser the present moment” (6)
Een though the one of he best Nort Americ Jouraalism id not em-
pai the sare’ poniion, ar mederitehvorces did, “objetivny” in
The nietcth entry was ata pat of he spe of acouse. Journal
ism had to ae asd, coulé not be natal, vee i he selection of nes.
‘The interest of local readers ruled. The Associated Press news agency found
the need for objectivity Ir got watt ell news tothe whole country, and
Thee it wanted o pest inthe moet “objective” (Sand) ght possibe,
in order interest a wider ple Jot at thotalend of the cerry the New
rk Tes became feces by lnosing a more "normative del un
bd been wed this fa model for marating sols or eprs.
In ender to broaden the count ofthe Spanish American conc, we
shold wot thet Europe tendo to etoile oe, wheseas the United Sees
fe preference to ew. Ba these ae only pat endencies. The moet med-
fm press produced in the West war docomtsry journals understood as
‘Shratcn,beease “he facts would be here, butter point was 8 fen 1 ea
Teran af for Whats more, the taser of iafonmation was not the
only tent of jomalss, Both nthe new profession of reporting and in the
sine for ling sais, thefts were of ls intrest han popes wit
{ng and personal se
Mart pricy sited resi in st because “it dos Umi itself to
copying whats bat exepgerstes and ovens restr evil It does at preset
‘long wth evi, te lmmedite remedy i falls fax Oinkog hat ev wil be
‘aod by presenting aa exgpertod image oft” As amodemi his goss were(64 + The American Chronicles of José Mardi
to achieve besuy snd armowy ad 0 Sind whats prasewoiy in te han
‘being: yt he conceded th ele thatrshing i abelutly good or had.
‘he eal sohoo fill recerded sek st would be tonal and jst and
would accompli its good den However, dis reaed shuld not be used ©
jy wrongs oo make a spectacle of open wosds, but oils and crete
{py toward the wrongs tha ccc ao escoer how the led tht com
nly Rows rom wretched bigs can Be stances (VIL, 26)
3: Introspection
a Mart’ ie th anarenes of modernity safes everthing As estaisbed
ystems of prcepson begat fall the forms of expression wil change 1s
‘wel oaralism becomes the idea! medium tizcugh wich to conte, da 0
fay, te flow of ev soe. Ives o now men, The writer questions the
lmedite a is xtc the sre time. The and personal exper>
‘ence in some way replcesicce- Only what subjectively lived seam se
ue, As Mart ites, “And where ae we obgin staying, it wih our
elves? We mat sn our hands ito our naa ad 10K tthe bod inthe
‘unlig. Otherwise, we cannot arance" (KX, 372-73)
ts preciely ins mmedlay apd i his pecular way of understanding
sabjectvsm thatthe gn Betwen Mar’ poets and romantic poetics cou.
Romantic sko cemeatad in the the senses, and ther etcnsip to
[Nature, Mart was romantic his yersing for absolutes ad his ath in the
fate bate was more ocr nthe sonpe of his tocil an pial be
Hef: Furthermore, twas exe ohi w Sart om hs ova expesieace:
“These re slates a my om ents warins—, Not one has ome out
of my mind e-eated, artificial, composed. Rather they ae Uke tars tht
‘pring from my ejet and blood hat bales et ofa wound He ais the
‘ale of subjectivity none of is eter about is book omeei,
‘Do not dhs es wl een fon ge. Re tc otha Yon wll
fEegne mI een te wings he kas, deep ass ose es
‘My minha ee ge andl hs isos he Ben 2 upon it yo as
etatcipy. Thus doe'Thnve sng ine oftaagt So hoa tbe bald espn
ttl fr ge tome tome ost my lg the T have dane oing nose
‘hen pt eyes nt te These see ave wounded me so aly hat
osned by hm af halt ea rk pe wih rt Whi
ini. 27)
‘The that Met introduces the answer to oder and tothe fn de scle
sisi not confessional or ptsnalized Iti an “7 tht sess to include the
Wiking te Preseat + 65
universe olectve “that expresses not nkivionity, bat te soul of he
Srv. This ane ox Bore sud "tha tty fo exes oneself and ox
res life elf areone and the same thing”
“The rpiethe ths conoepon asus is of spreme importance, Marts
oct, whether posry ori ourmalin,i not mimes, or aha, ot
‘eng raoaalton, sane he thi aly that ofthe interior. Reality
nso wl be is posi, Seclaszation bas broken dows ays,
Tat now te tnscondett fede on everyday materia. The “I” oganizes and
soca hese concrete images in a way tht sete the laws of Nase
(vier what seems contradictory and antagonistic realy ao snc it bas
‘umaooy-—eleviing every) saris ad jours news t anon
{ea densa, "We lend a ear to everyting, Thoughts no sooner gemioat
tha they ae lode with owes and fut, umping off he poe, ike ube
thsi all minds. Raoads overcome the jong; newspopers te aman
jmle" (VL 229
4.The Rhetoric ofthe Subllne: Whitman and the Greats
Mart wasted to account fr modernity, He maintain vat wrters arin the
rl of he new ime, hat heir gation i to inecogat these and
etre, become pt of it cycles aod laws. They must abaken elevated
‘hgh in other well the serch for meang thas usifes cach person,
‘pera “amen fe would bes igusing and bart invention, i were
limited wife on ea” (VI. 230).
"Bot Mart ues not only what sn. He waned “to make people ry, 2b,
rebuke, punish, make tongoes crackle, possessed by thought tke a sade
‘sen arider mounts it. "Thats wha ues by wating, Noto srk one
‘hod, bt elf the, Not xcs the printing of an emoon,butin the at
‘ot evakening alo tem (pin, LXXHL 193-34).
hore to achieve this Mar resis a device wed by Spanish American
roms and costonrise water alt: the beoic of oratory." His wait
{ng bears at once his paston for the sublime and the mark ofthe oratoicl
testtion In fat, nemspaper>—and many popular poeme—were read slond
tothe trate for uch ofthe nnsteeth century. practice hat writers ad
‘Stor doves took into consideration. Whether recovering older state
Ses of representing the sublime or coating the Spanish American tai-
Ea. Mart wan clesry a active un orloras be was journals. Subjectivity.
‘nmediay, aonogy, comatsm, and synesthesia allowed among pote
scoure,chroneles, nd poems in which each influenced, carched, and
{afecad th ober wi the new poes. Brique José Varna describes the
‘wearer66 + The American Chronicles of fst Marth
1 wil neve fre ny ih wile Mar po The aden of i senor, Wh
Ine nly sym oe psy racked my acl isu se an i epee
fects ef mun esti te poe fore hehe am glen tea,
‘pats unions week Bower of re fig inthe hens, bane of
{i sp, nd cre soos word a wat of sacng mages Oat
‘Seed tosio fn hemi spe an pace wie hot of he
orator seems more pesnet toe intent contr than tothe twentieth,
‘Mart tured i nto ferent prods with hi yeast ste. So much so
that is constacion ca be compued—as Was noted eaten many eases,
tthe work ofthe gute modem Wak Wetman, who also discoveted the
‘lime in he secre iterations ang the Tving. Few chris osed =
‘on inallis cnet; many Hed hemslves adssing the reader oto
‘hing maxi and exclamation. Mart enriches the teva ttm wih is
“mint of ural, Here, an ener. Furthermore, be gears oly
Inia wefl fem each ecalgu, “acai before reters oppesiod tent
{alent rested sete” Tropico, L, 50).
Marts prison in anlingorary eas histo eet that eae such an
pres of leliaese tt the character inluding the narator—want to
Tee the page, As Mie de Unarnuo id, Marts verses are ie-giving apd
Iie Mares worked ith » strange ie of Images and techniques tbat
‘woul form ane ad agen prose made of seasons selected and o-
ered by the mamaie “I” In tat moment of deiaing dscusive spaces
‘Marts work presets anew understanding ofthe creative poten of he st
fof eading. The mora charter that Mar assigns wring diferentes him
fiom the aestees and eves fom other moder, wil is impression
his symbol, his Parsesinion, ond his use of snesthsi distance him also
fiom the mantis. AX the ame lne, his perception of meer ed him to
inclide the ragmeatrioess, impressionism and peed that marked the er
ture ofthe early twentieth cet. Yethis wer fers frm ll these move
Ines becase Kr denonstates 2 vigor that most be called oral: Mat
tgs tend to break te balance of fila searching for new harmonies 0
Clements tat sem advert, His practice coincides wih tho philosophies of
SGuyau, Tarde, aod Foul, who Belved the power of visual segeesion on
thooght wo be away of aveiding determinism nd elnming fre hoe for
‘man! Sine “inteligence th power both wo der an to uns, then
think about exenor hinge eo emwine tem, and scence consists ofthis en
fining» Within tit Hit we cans, lie he God of Boden, don't
‘hnk boot hing o come only because tay wil ocr, bat they wll ocean
at becaas think them Foil, 277).
‘Mart beloved in he improvement fan, He fought achieve his by in
‘ecg ie fellow man with images to break te mol ia wich is peception
SS
Weidagtbe Present © 61°
tad Sates ep, Along wih White, a: He wo shows ir chest
Pease nee shows th wes: fy on ct XI 140) Fo
[Riri orm, esinl vite was enoogh to ovecoe defects Mac's
ToRE ach for beauy sae rw dio moral He eld:
ree foe sb earoy fe good pesto he ba of he
hance shoul rey the god als Tipe, 99). Tis where
She pnerl lanes lt Eres novcomerians which 0 ise
SESE three, He expen in sth of Genel rt By
wey ePae pt desu ines wih nr ad sven yale:
Sey bey be en: tea sin wil vay be mach al han
bis rennet" 3)
‘Fir wed commie othe ater te could ind ps ad
shy na logue wih Nae He wanted ofc he ede ith he
Say tePhn scot in Phd pay plese alas wigs ote
{kV tty bony sd remanence Ks what Longin elle the s+
ii pneuroned dapper te vba of ems, the dig, hat
‘eicaonctcins od eas static asses te dty of poding
TES of impepanng sus od ppg thm flr able esis
“fa Neth Ameren coils con devics of th ol tae of
sctoe Tis eMart peal move f coax dpa mes, making he
“Spe otrewatom ef Longa Foul or Whitan Bo ino apt of
‘ibcee: To cet hears reorder logis in cose
‘attend obey thera of ry the asee oper or of theo
{arma Te deseopos oie pe of expen “Enron” fore
pied ot ste Bon bt hein nan ob we of th mpeenl
aetac ic ncvcs be parr a sess deed gat
eet etek ofthe sl of unas sth ere msdn nor
Tinie betome anter popes f eso: “lags reat af mast log,
‘howe: Petr Cope Gent What eave behing i popes of
ilu Toor ott of ts anand beverinew aboutne—an Love
fGmars fuer Hat {rested i path I would ve sedis bao XU,
wi Randy doe Mart eee 2 wise cra o a ings, when
elnissmlytotoor and compre ports get people who hie st
EE Tate eee uel pour plop erties, opie
‘Cavin crn toe wie, Man goes aro i is
ois pel ine pices about Langflow tesa, and Whitman, The
SUS SPikdheuisetnaue become conte wih tat of the poe, 0
{Goma uagle vce witout anymore aanon a a quotation mak,
‘Sooner sal Tis ir ciigobomomed fm cry whee
‘Sener odraly asus he et eon ain wee he charac
‘Mar ao vcs mins, OF Bese he sas Whee eon wander,
snhe hamony ofthe Univer loons” OI, 33) is gues ae bse(68 + The American Chronicles of Jos Marth
‘collective myths: the pris of Weael Philips and Peter Cooper ae con-
‘Sct onthe images of Christ Emerson and Whitman resemble piss ot
‘lial prophets and policians are epic heroes. Rhythmic cadence, so ital
for orsey, iv also cuca t the seal ofthe new petc prose it con
bce passion and serenity, silences, successions of exclamations or gues
fio transposons, and onmatopela."Whitnan” fer example, festues
‘nape: the soond paragraph alone repeats the word “nan eight ies
(fll, 13) Iconic apaalepis: "sacred is sweat andthe sou ssa
od” (AI, 134). He includes silences inated by blank spaces and puncto-
‘ton, a well parallel consructons sch es beponing sentences with only
Sieh diferent variations: be make hmtl, be ads, he doesnt ive, be
‘Say, be is GIL, 132-33). Another spical device in his etconils is antin-
‘omy. itis not. bat”
"Te ichaes of Spanish asorance and literati sand out: “waking
Jn the fertile forests ofthe shore those faded lowers andthe nests. Polen
fies beaks pos Keser branches ato" CRI, 133) The succession of su
{sted images bold ogetierby the association of comiguous ideas: fowers
‘es yingfallen bea ee i aster sample,
‘Shih he "0" n=" and "sounds reat a sense of Sow in conection
(th teeth of ponetiton and groups of consonans and weed epedon.
terete the impression ofa seam tough itis cesrbing a cemetery a
bone isa ower Suffer thse souls whom Tove possesses: fe
as no pal for those who kits naning in ime” CRI. 124)
“Accumulstios loo appear, as well nea consonance,
phon sequences, and especialy changing caesus and enjarbed fal para
raphe
bare nga i pi eno Tei npn ome
‘ies ita dai gern es, fe ere
‘tote he tnard neat hive fen soc drab ees of wa
Iiery witht bee's wig, nth Areca balls an peaks. They sherbet
‘ly ene ward he peace fc elm, hie tei ods eve hae
finn of ie png ed wi charpagne on coma lt GIT, 143-43).
“Marti waned to crest dere pases inthe sth ofthe reading, whichis
‘why le eco to nonacadenc punctuation. Hs texts often ncade des as
{sortoflong cotta ey indo a arester pause lathe eaing hana ego-
Jar cota Colons reappear several tines win he ae exten, nt in
{ate simantes or deraons, but asa way of slowing the hy of reading.”
"The following se examples of Mars retrial sates, n accordance
sa at: Mt eh og ea ome Lata tee," ge aT
Wong the Present + 69
wits an ortry that parses the sublime. This paragraph, exprssonntc in
fomulation, question and response, the change of persons, abundant mee
hos, nd perphass: "Do we sl aot now what his vere are? They are
‘Sometimes ike bearded oman wth snake bear, orton itd e
eight gaze, leaning on an ok stick, ike a pgane angel with olden wings
“escended into the abs from the green mountains o hgh, Marvelous old
‘am, [eve at your et my bea af ght rm fish pls, and my ver
sora Go).
"The chronicle onthe deh of President Gari ie rich in eto de-
ies. presents ramatizatos, with dialogues of pst action rated inthe
rset, These represcatations ae 50 Vv that tbe tart sees ke ape
‘agonist or dre wines. Belen, spostophied fury intrpeied With
Pi scfeaces tht never each ter ed, and the iuppearance of onjune
ons and verbs a all hee
‘Teas doesnot ete deere fre pce of te rine oe ned ni, Nol
Forage bso Fim, whe sess Hom hs tab a ptr ee, us ay
{ene Wisi bed nd np? The ei jl one rsa cave sk
‘es, cv! Mayr und en scompat tl eal sage fs dtd
es hat ek adel Ma wo ve crate emits sd deve tht
Jes don ae ine lan ev ene! (20)
‘lr espe ken bd led, enh clot pte This eat
‘man har rte he coat 0 pt mi fore, og ne nd wale ng
[Povrteromde Har soe ough mong en, aps fetons, cee
[itl He ba be feted by sve ul ve yt pop eau eer
{np Hens vee on plows of unde gids of stags halloas of
ble! Om 207),
Exaltaton singed by verb sucessons such a “he loved founded, coa-
soled” (XI, 4) als is cousunicted though esd socomlatin: "be
‘himed his cme, begged his fear, the bates raged and his victors spread.
‘thei wings” QC, 34) the reader wih unl adjectives achat
‘the moseegoe ange of Emerson, and of unusual images such she dst that
‘becomes snow a fl. Lanpelow'scotin II, 230).
5, Roots: “Calderén's Centennial”
‘Od an new come together ina conscious way in Marts prose. This cont
gi of and by deren ines accords with his dualistic aking repuding
Inside and outside, up and down, ancient and contemporary.+ The American Chronicles of Jost Marth
(One ofthe tools valued by writers in he nineteenth cota ws ioe,
ad the romaics Had tis very much in mind. Mart sys inthe prologue ©
"Poca de Nps that there ino pear please haa hat of Knowing te
gino every word hat eed and wht sope i” (XI, 234). Bue Mart
‘wero plac is ov pi. language, dint evn fm Ens’ del.
Tho seach forthe oot of language led Emerson tigi the ancient S00 for
uel terms in over to dsc the Latins of is ona lngusge. Mar,
(Be other hand, esuscinte the technique of coneeptalsn rom Spain's
Golden Ape He id ot limit himself to 8 few achat, but inclade the
(Géogora-shle hyperbnon andthe Caer broqpe sl ht stemmed si
Ian rom every age sth naogy ofa universal category. Mart abo
bortowed Bultsar Grcin'y conceal and leis! sharpness, icing bi
‘Seas othe dey of each word's meaning, as well ae tendency toward
‘soi centenss cr hose bepnning withthe imperonal elev pronoun
"fe" He emecillydovloped ste fr ceating ne words based on existing
oes, Mart eclogite are many: ios, ropa, steal, snooper
Marts aneation to Renaissance conceplism may have ght hm some
ofthe tecnigtes oe bythe symbolise at welsh ste sud compar
fon of elements that veo reson, Als inthis ctogory isthe joining of
{etemal an exter iar, te wansforacion of ope age io anther th
the of contrast and prado, ets, nd the lexicon of sabimation. He ao
‘red the Quevedian device of wing common word in anew senso—such 0
“elon” (to comb) nsead of “pasar pass) ho creating anew gus
stem based onthe foun on
"Thece are some ares by Marl, sich a8 “El cenensio de Caixa”
(Caldera's Centennial, in which this apropition of Reaissance devices
takes sbape ina obvions zane, since Wits te abject tbe sje of each of
Marts cronies varies accord to te intemal demands ofthe topic at
‘nd, “Caen Centennial” begs with an apotheg “Toone the ead
tolnvigorate the ving” QV, 109. There are hyperbales sah 5 “the mest el-
trated post who has thymed in tbe veacult” (100) Antitheses abound:
‘bel phiosophergcal Sr, king of his ownislie of Kings (41; pompous
procesionhumble pat, graying menlly servants (112). Series of wicolor
{adsion alo pear. Concepts dition abounds: “esd of perfumed
tov” ebel maces” (209), caages tha do ot ll bat nan” (11),
"oxo ewes" “human oses"(112)- Thi txt aso conan hyperbolic trans
formations such a "Night ofthe ope, eat of sar, bougues of ight”
(0) 8 well a tems tht refer to Spun at that ine Gageaousness, ape
‘issn, fame, Mooth ss), Some constructions open with retapor ad
Taodulste lt the veal image: "hea come waves of gauze, with Bowery
foan.—and they ae he schoolgs of Mad. Inumerable winged worst
Teliw-and they are the bight peonans cared by inmamerbleyoungste,
Wing the Preseot + 71
‘the schoolboys of Mii (122). When Mart seems aboot t reuse a ied
[Sshe ti oul to unser the expresaon Ino something new and sar
fini diferent: the let remains tht were nce» prison to that elogueat
El” (110), Mar wes asec a top He invents Latina words ely
nd ales roquent eeroce to gues oat of Golden Age drama, especialy
‘Don Tom, Mat eso spikls th ext with ines tht mime the ryt of
the endecafab,eadtonsl Spanish vers form whic hs elven syllables
line “indo cs Madrid enrol mes de mayo” Covey is Maid in all
the month of May, 109), “alombra de cabezr son as calles” (a carpet of
beads ar the tees), an veo luego ls aborts calls” (ed then hey
‘orth suet bsobed 1). Ad of cose, Mart uses hypetblon: “tose
‘ibd mes in whic ns the hair of hia the gallant made Bai fr
thee ats”
(6. The Univeraity of Lael Lore
“The bsesion with modmy aft tho poets ofboth Europe sad the Amer
{Eu Inrcopone ta seve of esto sd genesis in heir immediate nv
Touments, both groupe opted fora pootics of univers andthe conseqbet
thea with regionalism The web of borowings,concomianes, bd wan
‘rmatons tnt coment the new povis becomes fc wase bees
ecumtextiing and ising fecrsques sls in a posi whose itera
{Yum of laws i dsioct and anteaorogs Mart ared eveything he cul,
Aros tente fo any inaortion and cual novel, but vay preached that
Spank Americ ust bem “vith esc wank ofall pics, a wel 5
fhe wonderful branches of ew pines: That's What we ae! New pins!”
(oot in Vite, 88.
"Th difereat esta cast produces increas when hy tute
_pulogy in onder len ont hei language ental: Emeron reachod sy
‘ss and Marthe bres Desering Marts wok as baroque may Seem
otrdtor, nce Mart repeatedly claimed: “The art of wing 10
Soloe? Verboity cerily fll eloquence. There is so macht Sy ta i
Thus be sid inthe lest number of wonds posible. Of couse, every word
“stbvewlags and cole” XI, 196) Although capable of describing com-
‘lex susdons in ery ile space, Mat rometines launches into lorescest
Pots hat can sexi overdone, perl Kost e read carly i ordr'©
ee that he docs ot nde, sol that here are no vacuous pases His expat
‘Noa ea o ead opredson, andthe teak inthe syn also break the me
‘Sic of wading tnd heer of peception His baroquam x matra there
‘Sho place for bejoweled wrt in i ines, becese, he si in Versa
dre, Sy verses re erable sod ignite ike my bear.”72 + The American Chronicles of Jost Maret
Sanio Cano, whose univeslism and awareness of modemity tink him to
te modernists, rained that Stat MU slogan, nemeso apteln (sue
to doa, ougit reign in is tine, “which exn aio be tht of Renn and
“Tain:”” ‘This generalized doub, the essence ofthe symbols, may help to
xpi the rep poplin and wide fans of pressions ice lane
ng to se reaiy with critica r skeptical eyes would soggst that he aot,
oven deploymént of colo in rational pein dd a comespond tthe pro.
‘oses Of nature. Mat found afin between hs own at and impressionist
priming, 10 which he dodiated qute a bit of accion as at cic forthe
Noch American pes. Sain Cano alo dismissed the ida that each attic
‘movereat mast Ye iselsted and autonomous. He claimed that he himania-
Hon of lndscae ws not exclave to the impressionists, since the madera
tense of mate cou already be detected i Rousseau, Thao, Fray Las Je
‘Lee, ot Vig mang tis kin of ttc genealogy 0 more than a st
Jet exercise” (anfa Cano, 20
‘The challenge is oid fem of one's own, sy that is not mece int
‘io. The modems" ebsessin is tha ofthe new maa, of eicersing “he new
alts, big and open ie foes (KIT, 29), Thetefee, just as important as
the bodes berveenIerary discourse and Sue or ouralistie discourse,
‘he arareaes of enpvaly The development of moderinm's new ses x.
presses the excitement of ne blood "Sil, more tas frm, inthe personal
enon ht have to express tanseles tough it. He who ads it
thoagbt to hs frm, ikea sword tothe seabard, has spe. He who covers
‘he seabbard with paper oe gldea sing wil nat prove the temper ofthe
‘blade (¥, 128)
‘Writing as tobe like themes: though everything logical appear tobe
coas,since “to reproduce snot o creat” (XI, 360-61. The problem that
‘Stadaa shelzed himself inte inditfernceof asthe, while Howells
took on scil cases sila to thos of Mart, sah as ening the eee
‘dn ofthe Chicago anarchists. Mar, writing fom “ino bowels of tbe moa-
se” wants neither evasion no mimesis nor file tepareney. For Maes,
‘Waing shoul be toa for human improvement, a space of condensation is
‘which o reconcile the trnscendent and miter asp of sci] existence
“Theroisnot tena ruth tht en preted to be homogenous and ualveesal-
‘ning, Theres alysinterspio, alvaye 3 "et
In “Bl centensio american" (The American centennial) (18), Mart
makes the elitist parse async deve: each person becomes hse he a
‘hats, be ica union, clone othe “brs” of sn Ustsons fly ae.
Tithe midst ofa the pomp, Mart inuoduces insta dsrpt the order: there
"an eeristed git covered with laos” the pice are ced wo remove
‘he presien from the dance by lobbing him, misshapen ffeon tel fey
stoi, and tere ae men in che desing rooms “ling on tei face from
‘omach dink (Crdneas,300- Marts values are eves i tis assemblage:
‘he military uniform is hideous, excep when it feds apuinst tyranny 33),
spat glory doesnot ese "in stocks, bonds, or sumptuous oases but
fn bares, i he ag, and in pase eniment 390)
"The gas is lvays heterogeneous andthe reprecetton carefully balanced
"Como se ere un pueblo nie en los Estados ridas (How a new town is
‘ceatd in the United Stats) (18), bins by telling what "El cetenio104 + The American Chronicles of José Moti
Americano” lars out: ote gbben elector coraptos, the utes il:
‘onde that il New Yrk wid "yoke and ph” the xonding of fags ed op
nde beam fer the celebs, and hed crond tat gather to se he
mains ofthe tribe Cental Railway warebouse fie “senting las with
tobsceo stained ips, young abriag women dese in ity ik tnd ee,
tarefot boys with ter fates” overcoat, black-aoeed vagabonds >
(Cronica, 381,
‘he gate of locaton nthe Escenas noreomerianasis complex. Ibe
is with the difculy of cnstcting a Ieeston from the maga, These
‘usa construct a discourse that canbe andertod by Spanish America,
hich tin tum modes a his lace of feongng José Mart is wt ely to
sewing seteics, togeter with other thers weer he also wan 1
change the ways of ning realty. He write om he maging o the uae
‘ot wih the atitdeof inferiority expect ofthe eae conomed ty En
‘ie, bt wit wansfoing wl. He doesnot sek to sbjct rb steed,
butt create. “Darwin ye Talnud” he writer: "The hun journey eons
‘of reching the coy that is deseribed within ws" (XY, 4), His Bae Ib
fille wit wlfuness, witha diferet fom of owe, ibe were epee
{ng agin and again Fouile’spurspase of Bolen quoted previous" do
‘not hin about things to come simply because they willbe; athe hoe ia
wil be in par bectse I tink them’ Thus Marts ocr nein ee
chronicles that refer to North Amica iss perpetulsefeton on being, af
having the duty of being, Spanish Areca
Marts system of epresnttion seems to dsplice ret outside or be-
‘ond his ents, his echniq in ft mansged reach and spre hat rey
‘wl it was il alive Mir achieved hs with rangurng language, ope
(0 are, and capable of coovertig that sane reality int the soues of oa
stufonomeas fiery discourse
[Mart developed his eave in a ine of lspeion and dtc sce,
pollal cultural. and economic shits. thet ofthe eau, he Spnish
‘Ametica of the independence cenemials no longer resembled the village
based Ameren ofthe civil wars and th atonal pot independeac oganes-
ions, Mart was the fst to captre the modesty that ha scm ae lace,
resbe. He was also aoe of the fis to undesand-along with Maal
Gigmez Nijera~thac tat percepon dd Gt belong in books alone. This
‘esting and constantly developing realty con only be cpared with at
guage that shared the sume tythm, the same feting mare, matty, and
Immediay. A the stme tine, this language had expres te peor of se
anges with an equally iveatve poets that wes teas nad conaly de,
Saused wih telé This lngunge found its ew epi inte ura hon
ele and tamed it ike he alent sagas, ino a spac of be snd ction,
‘stewn wth ictoes and detent
Chapter 6
Conclusion
Adventure and Transgression in Writing and Reading
‘This peo tthe ant be aes reer:
anar oie pres te United Stor or of Spat Aes or eons
‘Mir ec fret nn ire the ere ine Nob
{the plc rca theo oft exile gaze nts wea. Wt
Sproat yf st on thd race te moet
Seni ts aoe mye ee prt at
tusfrme Spt Ansan rte ab ete
ys et ach soon oso caval ends
Sent doe.
Redacovering the oil io est than ant fangs, aeanse
iiss een sod sn advent see tae ere an Ng
‘om ai, ai what» pn noe een woe wha ee a
hy te tt irc ol scr ce Th cia gh a
{nex len soo by easton of erate oun
fem since too deftly one he tir The cet ake 0
ct eave seed oly prompt oe re nso iin
"cn be cme tan wn ea
‘nasa courses was jt begin. Policies ate
ome, bested a sem ila he ssc sr,
Salama ening me out reat oe te ose wit
es of sien comet eens is ips ut wth eae aa
‘ooh wht ld my sou nei iene el.
te coy wit dyer nny aso ano a ads
ite ecsed cose he str negation.
wt coil tte foc on det of dls on ura. It
Andes ineiales at ra te les oration ch steep,
fee, Chroicles do sept onli oder, ey.
State ac fovea he ay awe th ix as Que:
{one wt, when where bo sd hy
“rece dace norm e, Dtfer fom jol
sunintb way ites ray. Th ex Mart wes coed in
10s,106+ The American Chronicles of Joes Marti
New York do not adhere ro th conventions of mimetic repcesentation, this
‘hjetvam does not betray reality. On th contrary, subjects allows Matt
{0 sppact realy in another way, inode to edncover i essence jet
‘sm allows Mart overcome hit en's exhausted cothence inthe appa
ans of things.
Mart decides event though mechani sacha analogy, symbol,
Jmpresdonism expressionism, and musicality. He podces abana imager
that re constrectons of his own doaght sd do nt ene ouide the spot af
‘he fent. The result i chr hat does not remove the reader fom the de
mension ofthe reali of events rls i een lance bit anetess
nrodces mode of percepsion that mybologies ar tanscenenties aly,
Rereading the modest chronicles, a we bave ne, contuts tothe
sly of his teary pte, especialy iit azages to eval lee Mart cle
asthe founder ofa new way of wang. But sother objective of thi dy bas
bea to question the conventions of eding ise or what they revel aot tie
reins between a and society By considering the cronlcle sn infltion
point between joumaism sn lira, we dscove that our way of ntepe
Ing or consisting the atone af course has deformed ut Consideration
ofthe teary” npateulr Pass ve bee eto ther dsiplioe, a5 wht
|i ses ad trary cout allude aly emotion or imaging 8 fhe
“Terarness” of text diminished with an increaee a een. Othe We
ten discourses thn seem exe fom the quai ta inform Mestre sf
they were not also developed representations, congursions ofthe wed re
Sionalizations an elsboratons, which id certain for according tthe
‘Therel referent hasbeen confuse with hess of preset, tf he
objective parts of text were "tt nd ota native state.
“This dissociation Dewees he werd of eleven ad tht OF arise cre
tio cannot be dieganed as «sore af the Scesitions of elit and aes
thetic spsnst modernist writers. As we havo seen, its one thing to snlyze
‘the realization ofthe poetic act at 2 dfston ofthe eeparate donno ee
‘ay discourse and another to eto tat this redlization i eesti a
‘sjeratv sense hat it dors realy, gnores oven and only beatific he
satus quo. The posi at instead permits te formation of codes tt atm
enerate the capi to perceive reality na new way
‘This now way of undersnding weting is aleady very cle in Marts
hroniles, It doesnot mute that hs cathe tte were also prodoced with
&moralizing ination; ht intention sof another order. Mats words have
two meanings: the transparat and cea meaning te pertains 1 jour
‘aim, a well 8 the poetic meaning assigned by the writing isl and the
wor” elationship tach ocer
Literary autonomy represented a eak wth the atonl wating system,
"This ofcouse, is uue nat only in Spanish America. Bu the chronile els
Consision + 107
an oven stronger break, bocase frm he sat it both questions and pate-
cs in Unt auionomy. I contdits and reinforces i bringing in tee
that wring spans have jst Bogan fo explain a centr Ine, Modernist
rose and poty wee the itt onderetand and develop this change in this
"Marts iris got only pacpte in the eolation of word bans,
‘ny also show how sereoypcal th understanding of pete Ingssge WES
fl li To hs ay poetry ie hacen by sponta fr removing
‘oe om tee soa eaings ia ode f reveal mulple meanings, accord
Ing tothe wit echneal bit, Notwe things re ore opposed nthe,
than a poem and a joralite chronicle. Marts ehnicles were produced
‘der all the condidon tha supposedly core journalist tet, ineluding
the need to chose cert and pica sjets, and to write exremely ques.
‘The chronicles cannot be called “disiested” texts, since Mat eared iv-
ing ava oar, Wort oa thy wer writen fra specific, masiv rea
{ship wih eran demand ad expectations, Dept al of this, sere,
‘Marts choos, tat we fd what today quale es poe language.
"These capo of the Herrysutound x power distribution mehstism.
‘Acie ation rss ouside ofthe prodetv, uel word nd scares
the alco inlet or pri pleasure. The mage ofthe word i ordered
thom deren eeu fwitendicoure: hese include history academia, jour
‘msm, and science, But the ighty ofthese eategovies hes the reality of
‘ering: ll texts respond oa process of Seletn, ofan ordsing principe.
“This does aot mean that any writen dscorse is erat, since he Bes
onsructed on tear use of ngage a pinry value; bt it does mean
tbat he redaiantdeinon of ouraisa prevents people fom realizing
that eveything they read i guesonable hat weg is ot reality” batraher
representation.
"The poocion of the vals part of what a moves cron The
ow poste pode new Berar geare. Tis means ew method of con
Cepuaizing reality, of internal and eter composition and orientation
‘hich in ths cave fom its own space by oseilating between the erry ad
dssoures
"The modernist chronicle include some ational elemeats, It eects cu
‘ret theme and end toward he fagrentary,cvard visions of matic,
‘but without loin the comprebensvenss and coherence th ae atractive 0
tha The cri fon fe ye e-
ti toogh images tha express ns, and wide range split devices
‘Refer nal feet ee apes, with equentrefetons o it
‘tar ef onthe city as seting, and on cule as nate atiibt.
"ora text to bo Ira tui have an index of rghit the oposite of
the cic al its way of saying something. Rubén Dato, perhaps the108 + The American Chronicles of Jord Mart
‘modemist mos accused of ets, expres this iden clearly: cds in ox-
pression scompany spent ches. Ths x why moras was so sigicont
forthe ear and socal transformation ofthe in de i: althoagh modert-
Is poetry reached only 2 Ute aucence, tir journalism enjoyed a vast.
‘sere of inurace.
“Asan cforms iterature cant be sees a category spurt rm the 0-
in proces that eta it san ato storia solidity and patiptes
inthe muldpiity of cult pres, as Barthes a Willams led. Ths
‘males the eeading of José Mars croncles so fasinalng, Thi “impur
lity" within the division o iscouses—tat i, their margnli with respect
{0 established categois—cnatates what Mat apced to in his eng
they bea away from ices and allow fo ae forms of perepion. By isis
‘on originality and posepttion, the chromite find te way of teal rp
‘uz: to contoat wih nes own sxpeiace what i ered isto question =
vis ian leave ten wht i has prover meaning or tested into
‘mer form of uth,
Marts chronicles ara product of hi rocess. They ncade any systems
cf epesattion andthe elt of confontaon ad penal mix cone
{ees his nowely and original. The setts he propos ot Intaton
‘of myhing I surpasses the mode of what came before, ths founding In
‘Spanish Americas new way of relating the element of fnguage sad aly
‘Oxginiy, fo Mar, was equivalent thn hat why he insted
so mich that each period has its own language doe each ces, And its
tro, as many hve sid tat modem poetics pve Spanish America ere
tue ts own voice forthe fit me But what interesting ste fore this
unigue voice projets hough he chronicles, Perbap ivaleIs to be found,
‘ven more than ints break wit eos, ins foundition of sae wey of
Writing. Sees tus, te chaise’ hybrid rate isnot dtstion, bt rahe
{he mas appropriate expresion of new pote coneepon. Inthe pole fo
“Powra del Nigaa” Mart eonclaes thatthe pac or ss in ouraisn.
‘tis the pce ofthe impecrsnent of communication nd of major eae
ship tis the only space ta allows the enrance of ie, which is peetey the
ony egtint sein in de fe eat,
Ina tine of eistemolopeal rors, when dscanivebeterogencty wae &
eta dos nia eo mach rier
“he dan iva perme eng aorry ithe pce of ison
sod conngin of sea ay of wnstnding be ray ine
‘Sheree concious esi of lngsage athe eon of ey
noes and symbol acoder ame ign adel dent, of
Someta emer, snp Nees en nae
{dhe Sroentpin of Panne symbols cx alongs fh
inte rere hn, Mu, sd the strate doch it a
‘Rady enous eal of spins mode an
“Thu crn srt by fe eh, onto of
ipetesion,s mobiy ll nso questing, sya
tm and mein. Met got th yr sew Ge development of»
{poe it emt) Spor Asan. The meas cence con
[Sse fa eine en nly enn wii
‘Spon eytcne Frm hee fee andes oar ownfn deste
‘ite mov oped amongst nfs ad sent
Tow ef infrmaton ie theme ow get alton is wes
Ingen we sek dso beany andirmon nha of ou eersy
heeNotes
1. The Lagi of Leary Reprseneation
|. infamtion ieountnMix Henge Ue Bre hori del mor
na Oe Ci: Fonds de Cur Bonny 195) 18 Heerioes Ueta
(he Dao aul “Later on Centon wich be es the
Masicnwrtr Reo Contes
2. Toe en -tinabora” Dlg nua Arent snl cd by Rail Go-
tinea Gina in Menino neon Monee, 959) 88. Comeing
{ie stonhipWeween modern and modernists ncey 10 ce te
‘epson of Rater Gunde: Ecbvur, fer whom nodes wets alae
[Bola Bao, and ban Ecbevena CB tate”) In “Mode ose
timo er urate less 8 mad” ner meicon Rei of Bi
Tegraphy 90.802 (980 157-38.
1 Ags ame “Ladle eo ier ox rt Eni martian:
Menor del Serio ot Mart (Rio Pane: Unvrty ofPure Rca,
tec Ui 199) 125
4 Dale ove nad, quo of Marte am Obras compen ans:
‘Bora acon de Ca, 965-1975), The volume and age amber wl bein
‘Sst int et apres vse sterile ie nro amr
for diy. il anion a ales rine nies eri bate.
‘CF Cela Tt ei, Was, Ee hing Gear Teholoy
"Ltr Cale Moder Aeron (Chaps Hl dL: Uae) of
Noth Carina Pest. 1987. 411-38.
6 do grap expe wl foe to our he soil iy:
‘al Cual wer mon fara and sae plinaton oer who ck inet
‘nen te pon ar i eng epi reser se Jove Asancn Sa
‘ane de aor al, tt ine ws echt post
ion as een toon th dean andes ly snes ues
‘Duan Jo Hereray Rein eccvd wry pores neranes. 2
ti ot hd ot Mart on fo words nicl ber of evel
‘every degen, wa the sono an etduested Spal who worked for he
(tun polis Ato xen le Leola Lagos wo ele he pe
teen fhe Cole Ineage and doveoed st ctnene atonal roe
‘eet forties fuel, Mart resided oti New
“on aed Eup, De, et deste Spam and Pi meta
se Ps war inot regent or wees often alone es
rey Rein ln et Cs fer re.
4. hati Vel La radcion celia de America Lana Bens: vi,UD + Note to pages ang
1984) 247, 213. 230. Engl eon: The Contra Td of Latin Aner=
4 rms, Mara nel Cas Incl Meo (Pact, Pine
University Pes, 1980)
8 Jot Lis Romer, Ltn La doe a des (Mena Cp
‘Silo XXL. 1980, 25. nga ete: ae merc: hes andes, a
‘avi Wii Fost (Bodo: Unwin yma, 5)
lg Mafia, Mare apse Bucnos Aires Exp. 1543) 14,
10. am Butte Aber seve “Toe ha compe he ew pt eal he kt
spi Latin Ameri, siapleaienaon wold Ia ie oacon at
‘iene Europe wat othe cul evince ad pts a
‘seca was inthe ie. Tica ans ec le
‘dung Ia “srs quien” Obras completa, vg (Baens Al a
eta La Tb Nall 1880.69.
11, So Mal Berman, A That Sod Mel no ir: The Experience of Mader
iy ew Yek: Sinon Sete. 198), 36 Change in he mado po
‘ico well a Bia and rnd of he fsa of wedge
‘ae ier mks on ye of tng. In Lar comrades del modern
(exo Cy: Cae de Mic 78, Not las me est
"semi maces” elogos wo te ew seems of profuton. Pract se
munud salad pes eon les of pion Die sada
‘emp. Capal and ein sce. Teholoy aes itn
‘au ofsionalzaon Ve asane ough ps ates Ther na
sul for concamesi in the mt and paces fren. Pa epee
‘vue Lrewoot we ape andrei eign sbstios a wold
fas purl agin proscar sags the ate fm 8
‘em of ritag ama of econ tak place tnt ng inom
Chronic wl ten srepoed ob ade enency eee pee
condo ert tomes nani 610 94-99),
1. Forth pag a pati eso Ret 173.
1a" Boy” La rae, ew nel, san: Cas Bt. Manel
on.
14. Pete Leo, De la i coming ane duis a isp,
"Ree Encylopedia, 57 (March 1832), 40-81 Ti eto of Lar
‘wl ode ke Marte ropeed oak ke cae
Son nd atten ats of epee Prenat lf hi eects
‘ont ahovetn do wh ca te fate, symbol, psi ato eh
‘ae cla aspects of madras pone. Seo Past Béic, Les tombe der
Prophecies de Ve romance Pais: Clliars, 177). Spanish
‘i emp de los pfs: Doin ee pes rm oA
Camino exo Cy Fon de Cars Bota, 198) 305 9,
135 Ste ao Osa Aching The Pics of Span American Moderna: By Ee
ute Design Ne Yt an Londo: Carp Unity Pres 9) Ona
Novesto pages 4-6 + 113
Monts Ermey presenta idl Casal (Ansa: Ro-
‘os, Gra Mont,“ eno tad whee moses lio
‘askan” Revit de Cron Lauria Lenoamericona 2, 0.40 (S80
ee
recat tat emai at
Sel ane anes
{Be ow cps and oficency of eect eal 134-35)
scutes arpa ey cern
eae aaa ee ee
eee
ee
Perera reat)
es
ee eureae
ae eae emi
Sree
1 2 enaene meting ni
ert ee ag nee
cane cere Nat
parr
aes
Se erties
See
eect aoa
SyictmanemogmcanMA + Nowe to pages 6-9
odes “An Bung Repth the Thay af he vet Gar: Mode
sd Modes in Lat Aneel be tem Reins Mor Language
‘Quarry 57, 00.2, pc ine et by Das Somer ue 960. 22738,
295 Ida Sctinun and veya Pe Garel, Lar noir dl oc: Enso abe
‘te moderna Mpancamericon (Meso Cty: Caner Arian, 1984)
148 See ln Seman, "La modes dl adrian tgpoaescna
Jn Cones: Lert» sce ltnoamericoar del eig Xo en
‘sn Pin Cartel (Utena: Unies of ins Pes, 990) 91-08
26 Recnerdr de province 184: Butane Ale Sope, 1966) 2. S>-
dei was at ence a a etc andor. On te poe of geet
‘ion Ste relectons of Ans Belin ion ong oreo
‘See spec is Ci hil el Repl de Chie in Obras campy,
32 (Caren: 1950. The Bell and Samim ees bewn early eid
ty uo Ramosin"Cosnacines demas Mater Amis Lat
i: oot Mit a cic moe? FD. i, Princeton ves, 386
bse the intent Devencens det moma ex hnren Latins
(Oexio Cig: Fond de Cus Benne, 1989) Al the quan fom
Rao a ths ok comespod to te vga sn of i war, wae hit
tai seta. amor as wre hr exelent tds eld op
[nsdn Parada de er (Caco eXel, 950.
(On te ystenation a it of ew om te fps, esa
1s Eads, poder soli, was. Cstin (Meio Ca, Siglo XX, 1979)
{41nd fred. nL Aner Ange! Ra Le cial Pane Ea
‘ones Det Nar, 1984); oe Lune, Quis eda” in lla (Bees
Aes: Santi, 98), 293-30. On te slant etree pole it
‘ee, ete pri” st compiled by Peto Rene Ue ns hit)
‘etentcenmy tes who te sat fei comie aL cor
ees errs ols dria pea, ene. J, Die Creta vce Cry
Fn de Cola Eset, 1999) 299
2 Octavio Pz Posen mine (exo Cy: ula Mar, 1986 19399
(emp aa,
2, Menoes Ply, Hitaia de ls hetero eae, 7 (Boas Ais
ipasyCape, 95111825
29, Octo Pi. Cannio (Meio Cy: aaa Mat 196),
30. Pythagai, Cable, and the sce were all deve fcr inte
ees Ss Ri Gallin, “Pagosa y modern are eed a
modem, Scum ri: Ta, 8). 86-107
Mel Foucan The One of Tange: Ax Aro of he Haman Scones
(New Yor: Reno Hote, 1952810,
srt Henan, Zoe de osc: Pees de 1998 Pate: Catan
"90, 9 The retain teers poten ai Rem’ pots gr
oust by Aba Goatees Gl ep eran
WNotestopagerg-1a +
sara can rss oder” PD, Yale Une, 183). Tit
‘wo le spend a8 La cdce moderne hpencaerisane Oa.
Por Tareas 182), Gear mots oe ofthe an ie
rece tons on eau in Spanish Anarene, Joa and he
Doiopmot of Spach Amensas Nabe (Camige: Canoe Use
Pres 199)
3. Ferge Auli Mor," elcome mia” La dina par: Hiri y
tmto or Ososo Pa Qeico Ci: Bi, 1978, 96-97. Alo lg Zeta,
eto y wort soils (Boros Ais: AEE 1970, 33 ed By
Agua Mera
{34 Ruben Das, camo ena, in Pos, 0, reso Mea Since (Cas
Bbc Aas, 17)
5 Phu Gace Mar evga ia bose tea and coective *P
ja"Los ven de Mari ena maine, woes coaonin vite Cao
Vier Pot eo: us, 98), 258
6 The Aare ngl Reader. c. Robe: C. Tasker New Yok: Nar, 197,
15-96
Pic Net, Md Bo yl ml a. A Stabe Pale.
(Maina, 1979), 10
1. Jen lke, “Late cuca” Yea 54 ey 19824.
28 Nilas Lahn sugests a denon of tea Oc frente move
cue "We vein ot Wit a sat nd vitou aot, The nt) of
feck n logs comes out in this sce. Tat sn ym cn lepate
‘oer Ia "Repeseton of Solty wii Sul” Gren Seco 35.0.
2 Goh tos The mcealing coos shied, But the ec of isi
ay ef epresetig uty an aay bo founda modes as, Wh ha
‘ali hal ein teeth oem.
4p. Cae by Comeine Catia in Lex corer de labyrinth Pa: Le Ses,
97,1; tame ino Baglsh as Coston i he Labrie. Kat
Soper an Mart ye Canbedg MIT Pes, 98).
‘Rel Barthes, Za chambre are Psi Le Sui, 1980), Engh eon,
Comer Lai: Refecns or Ptr, ws. Ris Howatd New Yor
ian Wane. 198,
“2: th bones on th odenismtondenylentnpority lac, 1
‘ote eb Jcques Leek fori ale La Quer do Moderne
‘des Ponvnadkrae” nthe Coed Estos Avananon fhe Univeray of
‘Bacos Aires (98), Although te tpi the was the postmodern of he
‘Surat and uo Cara was uefa tts ffs
‘sil the“perio of spice” dese by Nate Sarat in 1098 Also
[Nove Lester's “Un dees ead poole” Puno de se 1,
no. 33(Sep-Dec. 183): 26, and Mael Grcht, Le décenlanonet di
monde Ps alia 1985).M6 + Nowesto pages 12-17
1a compos, 9 6 Oi ph, 1965 9h Ine ste
‘se benders patron Man et yw bs
‘ae eet inset ge
{4 Bu La, ten sp ne rs marion Oi: Seo XX
‘8 Te opi cn ir tn er Tey Ca
‘Sin cae Ppt Gnd NL, 97 nd
45 etc econ ein ler tify by
* Se centnte ids ajo tng oe i te eo oe sch
Scaife vce totem deren 1)
6 Sima Seen Hoes nd ee Pani rain
to.
«Tyo oak wih cc egw, ic a he dicompowe
{rot Goon) Syosset! vce rah
‘te woke je ee, er rep fe
Snes durch Ta re aa
‘eso tac es mig ol pnw ota nr leat
‘Spemes ton foxes of ap peti
4 Meme Gite ijen, Orr ete UNAM, 99 37.
{B Miemmder ordered ast fl far
‘cas face deste oo ee
atin of seteatocy Bugs mis wan” Fi
Eni “es Camila oc San mons en
srtiremercns Abr sy fw Ms ran 95)
2.The Wer Rae
1. Se To Halperin Dang Historia comenpordna de Ames Latina, hed
(Mot: EL eB 97) 85-355
2 Vélz, 230. On he vir Sse, see Richard M Mowe “Recent Research c=
‘ats Ameria Utaiaon A Selective Sane nis Consent LARR il
1969:38
‘5 Mico Kapa, Formac et cad nacional ex mes Latina (ens Ake
‘Ane 196), 13.
4 Pome Bouron Can dl pode camp inlecual,ann.5.Da ané MT
‘Gang Boers As: Fos, 1989 1
‘5: Ien Vabeoas pce pb Arh del publ come dineson
ve dela oie boo, as. MB Lamy Pas: Pe 1985,
my
6 Donisick Lica, Relig Inca! Histor: Txt, Cane, Language
(inca an Londen: Cra airs Pres, 1983) 155.
1. Peo Henne Use Las corns ear en América pn,
Noes o pages 17-20 = 117
enue Cao ei Ci Fonds de Cals Ezine. 19), 16-45.
Epa aied
On to tinsp betwen moderna mary et pale “Pre
os sgl de Jou Mar” Cane de lar Adria 35 0198 at Meh 1955)
‘ily sis by vn Schulman dP Palos,
9 Dn seme, ori rede oop pbc: La enomacin
truce el apis, an. Domenech (aces, Gusev Cl, 1981),
20. Eg se: Th Scoala of the Pb Sphere: A Ie
uy into Carry of Borgo Scie, ae. Tas Bg md deck
ayrese (Cant, Mas: MOT Pres, 198). On te ference beers he
sate npn pail pacts ele oe ces Poatne
Power ple ease wile, v1 Pa Mage 1968), Eagle
ae: Pica ower and Soll Case. ancy O aga Lando: Von,
178.
"0. Lee fo Ras Baldomo Sula Cao, Ora comple (Md Agi,
‘ssn.t375.
"1. Ths dats perspective tas yt wb note was speiato, veto
{be dene of Dao’ sting pasion, nd smn geal pape
‘te pub from, where ons pn deny was aaa age
Rana, Le dd tea ator Bhs del Net 1984, 120
"2. See Ran, Rabin Dart y motrimo (Cans: bees Nato, 77,
45 Se ho Slo Romeo, Latnoamé:Lascadates laser dhe Sex,
{80 Ci Silo XXL, 198), Eglsh ein Lai merc: Cs nd eas
‘rns. Dovid Wis Foster (Bax: Uavia Hyman, 1985); al Bextor) le
‘nda cara camino hia projesoatelin oa Riera Be
tos Aes Cento Este de Aes Laan 96)
"5: Edsro Wile, “Sbre po (187), compl ia Tango pre (Buenos
‘Airs: fcaeasnd)
"4. "Lancs oe grinds dios in Rawr learis Bacon Ae: La
Catar Popi, 37a Rive 7,
15 Hakemas, Prolmer de leptinacn eno caplet tno Buco Ass
‘Amonort 1975.91. Engh dion: The Fey of Commi hein
tam. Thomas McCurdy Boxe: Bex Pres, 1984),
"Roh lin Oa cmps Er ote Mn Ma: Apia,
‘959,13
27 Max Harteine, ite! Theon Seed Fee, wa Mater JO'Coat
al. (New Yr Heder Here 197) 5,
1 at Ase S, Obra compete Mes: dow 1970) 237
'9- One that snes new as Aso Gace Moros 7 tain Zor
Iman del hum ola ide mera n fra de catenin
ra, por. Walon pfs dela Uneridd Lib de Ba, ach
‘sus: Arr wok pint Sai at flow he uefa TisM8 + Notes wo pages 20-28
tected by Jos A. Porton i Maré Rr motown Caro
4: Broiler taney Eira Plc, 198) 15. Sethe rove a
‘elas Peo Alin de Haro, "La consi el peasant rio le
‘medi cin lcd rari cl Gain: Payer, 8,
19-83 Jot Las Ge Marte, “Kris, modes 9 eso" ne
es asd maria, 21026; Po A. de Alc, “Disco Soe la
moran el Oba completa SMa Fo, 1959 Urbana Comin Se.
‘im, "Cnracons soe se Sela pont a Kraus: Bc Mer
‘ara cop sn Lip Mar (Barclns Lab, 73) 207
20. Gustave Fae, Correpondane leer Lous Colt Fan 16 1852 (ted
‘nBousiey 9) On ancpurian (sity ofa), Cie Git sini tat,
‘5 popnlaty Wid may tes bao do wih el placements ete
In new ci er nding aires tween cern pose 2 Eo
an nd Spanish Anca Hee, any css ove input fer
ews. Thy genealie about te fncton of he fn de ce “nelca™ bo
‘ie and ela his uf pesto wii be hos en: bat my Spash
“Aen wer ft efron! mall fancies. ning pba oes
‘tee camo ied ea hat adn acne anes we i
{e aoary of tiie ony poy ar a pofction in and of ite, and ee
asin hr pry ae os urn pipe. Ths dacsion co
fies usher te char (Rael Cane Cran, Moderne Bare:
‘eat Montes, 1963.
21, "Unpoet Poss de racic Sla"(¥, 199-90.
22 Pertaced, 15. Te fence betwee Maren ta moras at in i
‘illo eps btn be ethan ett ty ot it”
2 Mant Pao Cones nd vn Sein Jn Mar ae ico
‘Olea Ci Calas, 198,313
4, Our Nera, “Ela intialsmn” In modelo vo por vmod
“aso. ier Glen Breon: Ouran, 180,16,
2g Armodest insane, hi cs the dy bewee pe wor ad
{eins han Ros” ine ea oa eongtarifolmch ne
‘romtzetin or ha be itor fia an (Fina Gari Mamie
‘Narr dese Mat 9-25 Das-Dec. 95 5) Te weal see
‘sh nin Sehr on he af ye oth aly Spit snd the Con ie
‘Sinblo color en a obra de Je Mar sid ess, 1570.
"hein of Catan on Maran ter men andeite,
‘However th tide asin base, ese worn cea fom
"New Yor for a Nc and Poe iba in 66. "wh erasing soak
(Caoicam be abuse of abut fe ade of chr nl a”
Mars wre i bt eit fcr: "Ths st dean ect
of man at in lion Bs ach Rinse (2X. Tis pe of foulon
Noes to pages 21-26 + 119
i i ptt of pin enact a
‘Scene Pt at
15S, "nti old Dts nd
Um 9 (ae 09 Sa Ono es Caos sa
Joaquin Moti, 1965), or
2 et ier“ Cpe inet Cty Rein
‘etn St Bo 0
24 Tie a ein pe of don pi
‘Lis er iene Pa
{Gm St hese we pa
2» enn em eintn eany one
‘eoiey.ntar rs tac AR Lara Da
Ae Gc oe edn ata
2 Cay nate a ema de Agena
‘arn a eS se
1G one a er nyt etn
tentn tg no ds oe woe
it dat ey apa rmeenes ee
‘epee adenredonormaasycociaasse ea
range ef sng nse hap
thie ten ena nasa Ne
‘aa Dao tan” 0 Sens Uaen g
Iie Te nw fon ae te Dk
‘nnn on aig be a ex Lng
2: Pe Pete aya ies es ot nadie lee
Sitesi vee
ss siete Bea mo a il ea a i
ie
SP ta es igen en
‘in cn cis td ports,
det Comes a Cie ttn Pe oa
2 enter Ame eh i
‘hthn stan trasoptts ifs iopes eee
mince sf
imi un a el ae
‘tn ong 9
2 ir es Oi 919, Po Coen Cos ia ae
epee
ite d,s dl mane Oi Rd
* Shimane
eden hr i! hela: rte a
‘Act (ithaca, N.¥.; Comell University Pres, 1981), 94-95. aaann120 + Notesto pages 27-29
“4 Snses Lacan, Le Sire Lee Berit ebgus de Ped (Pas: Le
‘Seal 1979) Fede anon “gia ad Sybil La" Yale Pech
“Sie $556 (i979) 38-98 One cone nerpelirice ndesoy. 2
lh: Cane Bos, Cra Prac (non al New Yok: Roles,
1) Bret ac, Emancipainydferecia Beton Ae Al, 1990)
2
i
i
i
i
F
i
:
;
i
i
I
[palo rl “Tid Wo Lert in th Es of Metin Capi
Use Soial etr5 Fa 1986 6-88; or Barbar Sate in The tr of
opie Colonial Dour i Soran, Del Wen. nding Ada
trac Dei pasha tn Lond: Dake Uni Pres 1933) 6,
See ao Waler Basan, amanadons Eure and Refecton, 8 Haw
‘cod ins. Hey Zh (New Ys: Schocken Bot 969)
4 Dum Jost Hennes Atop berm yea (emo Ales: Amecins,
s9snerien
45 See abr int, Modernoms Aso Gono Soba, “Eps Bos
ris Is Epa er dl 900" in Forma Ura ysemiid social
(iii Grose, 1-1
Tete! Lowy’ ation om Pare settle dere réo-
tele (ae. res Universtaies Je Pre 1978.17
45, Rettig the ocx represen y which he eso
aman acon apenas wncngeabe Ths po
tes ecln iapnandhe rces cous sow tm asa en fe
yor proces sien fo saw pel te asec of proves es See
‘Gene Las "Resco and th Conscious ofthe Pretest” in History
nd Cr Concours, ras. RodaeyLivingsioa Cantige: MIT Fes,
‘op Roan Bren Milas, rs Her Schack exc Ci: Sivo
3, 10).
«6: Te ett soon of The Aeron Chromeo Jose Mat i ind te
wd of Coe Read Ai
«a: Ses for eranple Nol, Este aden 0 ahedarinn Yevor
treo emer ore Sean (Mae Tas, 198755.
“f Deola"Disstacon prologue Econo eran, Sélaing sao
ch as thea fedora lr was. Hola Calis nis he
Towing in Tera marsig dl ata, as. Raza Aled Burns Aes
‘Silo XXL. 973
Teheran bower he mergence of hs et om and
tetas of tweenes of he sie wich ey arse? re moins
recor sages inte procs of eaten of te frms—e iste eo
es hain ly determined by he sate of awareness of las (of
the ents Ct Delong, bat by Saas rae independ’ oily
ck asthe sae of ocnigus of reproduction and communicate, ond te
‘ange pry acme ty nth sce and ese of thle?
Notes topages 29-33. + 121
Furth tl can hese new forms be separ fom he rl arate of
hic hay ae par oe iy Seemed by ha sete and fr eae
fon denies? 7)
4p Feed Or, Contaputncaban dl aac y del carvan eis
Mooi 1540, Ange! Kans, Taselnrcio mara on ri ana
(arco Cis Silo, 1983.
3.The Emargnce ofthe Chonice
We Samba, Der Bure quate y Hatem in The Sacre Tanéma-
io the Pb Sphere: Igy noo Cato of Bure Sete 207.
2. Sumien, "La clr el cb: Edna” Naina palin
rt, May 15 sd 39,140. Reproduced in Palma Mears (Boats Aer:
argo 1933) 13 The falc nthe igi ex.
4 -Fovasinr ani of te uci of he ren 1 A. Sn, La agence
Cab Bia Candee Cli, 3949), 5-87,
41a Nai tary 2, 188) 1 ae his Aen eager he ea
‘sof my mays of ous ean as nc fr egret oder
‘ices 8 wel aan a te newspapers of ret fence md ini ve
‘a Spuih Aaron Toe rerio sos he ont age wee espe ating
1 sy of he gil mati (pune eos 175 sod 1898), cared
ere mont in th archiver of Za Nan nth Heer de iin
te Nace Boon A.
1 eas lope he ot pat of th capt as aed hf
lowing reece: Jue Act Mote, Prodan Haratara, vl x a
‘Guudarams 1973: Beuis Ale tl, Arey Liason “La Nata” de
‘Boros Aes (1870-189) (Boos Aira: Foado Nacional de Are, 968,
seer Be, Hori del perodimo arene Gans Ais: Petia, 43%
Cn Hero Uris et a, BT perodie ev Jd Mart avaa: Oe,
1977) Obsoa Marine,“ ereca moderne sini: oe Mary
Manel Gates Nea in Endo eicor obra pros modernist ip
soamericn, sé Ove Snore Qo Yoo Tae Sen, 979
onal de Que y Mand, ar perdi (Hea our Cl 539)
Fryin Weber, "Mar en Lp Nactn de Besos Alex” Arco fot Mart
[Nimero del Content (sane: Minter de Bosnia, 2959, 458-2. The
‘os one modes chronic already ed were alo of great se, pecially
(toe by lio armor and Aaa Gosa, ele ce wr By Pte
sede.
45 Gntions ira, Reroredor(Caambin: Ube of Miss Ps,
onhss.
(6 Tsien ws reser by Aled Wav, "Curt dn locWa + Notes to pages 33-37
se meor 29t7) Bl aiotnin de lamas. Lo ati y ain Aron
doner rai Quiroga Angel Pas (Canc Mote Avis 196) 20914
2. Examples of weld ton. La rade de Ergo Ecsite ats
(Alert bythe Baron A de Rabe, Ps, 67 Jaaay 29, 18."Den Jn
Sol” by Oneps Manila Getaaey 1881), “BY Bawess. Coo de oe
sellsico by Hugo Coney Only 2518); "Coat yes” by Wie
Colin epember ts) Even Abn Xow, he most consnon sg of he
‘rovion prod fe connie conversely doped
Beeps
1. Theory“ io ard" fr enone, rely inal IP as sgn,
‘asec te love use of eet page ional diced
tod words, btaer spe he unas ke eto emai =
fray 20180. “L leyenda len a news tyne by mio Cos
‘la, bt sly! fence tench nou fe ext an “Bl
trie egth fhe aera ace
9: Tsay war arid ot by consign cllston of he Hemet
afte ites Nill de Canc
10. Tis sexes wa so extenie hi somes cose the ete ft ap fo
seve so, This hapered, os ermple, than hoe pce on Gee
Sent Anton Sce in 181,
11. The adveremen suo came he comopsiane ht ws ord in Canes
‘etn ine aay 37,18, wore he te elsif Gul”
‘ete company tht ls "agus ic, ld evs by be fanoas
‘Anema el foo, anes pepe cle, nd pn Srp
forthe noma, Nat mentor Doctur Rady’ ened "marvels of moder
‘Sey ie fae fe Ray Ray respi. Regain Ra
Fle” Alo ham asa sugson, iin Laroche hos fers -
‘ei Cult inetons hs, Renter sep, yng lng fom Man, "Te Rig
Perfume” ewate xp fom Reset, Bay Ie fr tet, gis ae,
en an Wien chm prs, an Ora apf Pu
12. Ser Raimsdo Udy acto, “Lar cate de Rabie Daa” Rabin
ari: Cuno comple, resto Maj Sace eso Cly Foo &
CCalra Ecos, 190), Rama a “Theme fg crest be
‘woe fr BY Heals of aparaso coats te bes pags of prose at Dao
‘roe dg Ciean pa. The ce pubis on Mach 01858 on oe
{tah oft Geran mpercanoty became toot faa 84“ velo
(deanna "Ee tpi oa cnc ela” Raa, abl Dato
yl motes (Case: Uapenind Cent de Yen 1979).79.
15, mown, "Nous Mais: proc ys leas” La Nace November 3,
185) 1. Tet nt ae ist ive,
14 Cain Gono de Qusaay Mtn, Mara peredi, 97. The quostion a
{ation we om pugs 8 ard 9.
Noes to pages sas + 123,
15, Loner fo Min Mit (ed in Quy Mia 10,
'6, Arai Cat Ll. "lpn t Las Uian, Chelios y eds
shade exo Cy Port 191)
"Se Rpm Wii, Comins Omen: Fen Est
1969.
"8 Enso Qn “pion ante hs mite ae A) 3
1, ni del Cs, Cnc Babe, cup, A. Apr Las Va nied
“Cenc Las Vis, 969, 27-85
120. Der in "La ented del aro” Eso ins, BK. Mapes New
‘Yc Intute de Lar pts, 195, 3. phd
21 Mase Guine Nien, Criss de “Puck” Obrar no, EK Mages
(New You na ea Ease acon Une, 199.7
2D dag Bote Ae: Maya 1978) €3,
23. Quota in Cio Vier sd Finn Gas Mas Tas marta Pt Rio:
ata, 1981). 217-18
24 Theisen sf Jo alo Paco, "Plog estoy Pee
moder, Pacheco (Mase: SEPUNAD, 19) He sy in alin at
“pet tn ating tig a
se by cts pares”
295 Thotexs ced tote Wo sus ofthe Revit nolan th Mar eed ae
ah cies of eel wish ae eroded ex irl bythe Hace
‘eof te Bibles Ncionl de Caen Te ia ee
ote uence foun wee not ala wi
‘pu spl The nex quae are fom cate dela Rave Vel”
dy 15185,
26, "Propet" Rv Yeon, ay 88
27. She obi. The nt te coq ne 1 ieee
tte themes fom de “cmon pore” Ee he os Kind of
ei wit “oti chars, Pech ye ade moet aude”
Insta of onenttag on neato “dea neta sean, Ame
stl sine at een formed mle sector” Te se ebecvaon i at
"be cgertenilizton of exch cian ech dep neve at
lean we mast ett i pes athe woe of iit eo
‘ine of cern Dui” a Prose Pes, Lert y ida en Aron
atin Bl modeono Oe Siglo XI, 97) 8-88.
2, Gis Pi Lint, Moe io del debe Bos Ale: Loa, 190),
=
2, JuguaV: Goose,“ pro ya" Oar compe, vo 18
‘CUnveriad Nacional da Pas, 1939), 344,
2 Mae Gomes Pa ‘Nes pti a Hr de ek (Co Ln
rou).a03124 + Notes pages 4-45
41 The eapton satin Vale pein 1p ail gate by Acts Mon
wo.
"Beigua wid peso vrai ==
ogi myer ora dct eee! a he oui muse ae
‘tof decreed cae What ct journalist agar fom ay ter wee
‘eer eothing odo wih Kern The sac th ie in sown
(Suess depeode tera Lita who ere Early even
np foams th ae spud atong epee, sometine by te tds of
‘douse called joualis.
sa Rolnd Bubs, Paar eric, ans, Cs aol alos Six Bara,
Tons 8 $5 Sagi edn: Ciel Boys, ane Rid Howard int,
1. Nordestr Universty rs 172)
sp Wr Benunn, The Anbar as Pde inRefecon, Peer Dene,
ts Edad epee Yor: Sos Book, 1988)
‘3 Peer Be, Theory of fe fant Gade, wns, M, Saw Ming Uae
‘iy of Minit Pres 1984) 55.
3 Obras compearI Haan: es, 1948825
36 Cine ier nd Fan Guia Mara Tar marian 194-88.
sms
Wale Bejan, “The Att Produce" 25,
[Bois Ato, Arte y psc EI pregrama del proce, wats. ose
Fence ncn Mi Comms, See B 1973)
«gs Jn Dene. Arr as Esper Ne Yor: Caicos Bons, Pua. 1958
‘Tarn 16-17. In Sein bs thatthe Spsish Anson ery
‘rt bens wi te pot of Foxe Mr snd one Gales Nie, wh,
eveen 175 and 8, clits very eve movie ors of expen,
"Rent pone we of atet Foch ease revenge sence of yb
‘inv Funanionon,inpesioion, sd expeaonieas Mts nea he
Sone atnece int ceo pane rin. Coney, is in 20
Ajty tral prose a the omit see es for." Ree-
test enrol defn dl mods” Ems erties bre l madr
toma ef Homer Cilla Mii Gris. 965,329
|g The information fn fan Bese, "Mos Caicos” Un param
Ue tormesias de normain en a stidad madera Nes: nse st
‘dor Potiens, 1957.5.
On sf Bagh holes, Asn and Sta, see George Wel ror
sora y ncn de la poms perodsice (xc: Fondo de Cais
Exons, 19) 1, 3. On Fence whan ae of be Bet a ue
Sentey ale, 0 Magtite Usa & Cl Lor eps pa 70 of
mimo 49-18) Bri dew gar conambrine Meio Ci: Coe-
ode tse, 1930, 16-46.
“44 "Tift i gst operons of dctpie en, te cones of teak
[Notes topagesay-s7 + 125
‘va hat afr cof ees dungeon des edd
‘mullce” He gw 0 sy tht pit olen, nh ihe
ory faces 8 tnigae of omer nd proce owed Ils ¢
qe fxg wi small of bang irenentn dome
(Aner be peed, Michel Feral Vary eater Macnee
‘apt, ve. (7a A. Gran del Caio (Mex Cy Sip XL,
1963) 192 Engi edo: Dine nd Pah The Birth rs,
_Ala Shr Now Yo Viste Boks, 1977.
4 Hci: ener cde prs raise, v2 Pas: Prete Unversaes de
"anes, 96), 298-303, Ags Vileoat lo give an excl! defini in
{Pipa 945 “Une ezalqe ant éxgesion dea sos ous oye
kes eoestqpences. Dans ce ice qe pls esate ue ina
Se Tsp cet bon ape nn sees tes ses 00 es, ee
‘can inion doce qe laa de msn, na roi eat gt
rel ded eres es chose ss bese homme Ger, non land)
pera td epaier le mouvement de coceorin oe J
tts, pour en dante eapesion nun ot” Ce by Anibal Gone Pee,
{are mo hier SPs etc),
46. Ged by Boyd GCap Diagn falar
rile de Mae ure Nae Oe iy SepSeeas, 1979) 1
4 Tenet chp of bookie deed © edative wy O28 Marts
‘Aedes nth tern modes Henly pt os eps
‘alte we™
4% Cts Mem, A wands coe: Anal del rina on Misc, 208
eee Ci 198, 21-28.
4 Ries aims, Cian malo peruse, Jost Miguel Oviedo Cmca.
‘Bibioues Ayacucho, 97). All quan coe ow ec ad we ad
eae et in pees.
50 Sumien, Hje por Europa, Ais y Are (ep). n Vg Alter Pal
os Boats les crt) 1
51 Comba nbs de il XD comp. Svar Bato (Carcass
‘ymca, 198), Qin unre cso wed ga” fr goin
53 Moms, 108 Alte Mea ols mentoed ee matin is nl
oy.
53 In Amica nha ore bern ed Manuel Maldonado Deis Mexico Cy
Sigh XX 98) 6-35.
‘The ogporinsetcen olan eta commen ia ena ere,
{example "Every anton shoal be is own Speci har hare nto
‘ie witot alan? Way shoal we let ld Bpece ee he
ew nero land” 237)
(55 Seo Leoni" Socal Mistry fast and Feo: Asha Distowat126 + Noses pages 57-60
inh Ely gh Novia Lier and Seca ed W Si Bali
ew: ee opti Unerty Pe, 980334
{$6 Chad Assn Gémer Af: “Comune, erry” Gast
‘den pose 126 (at 96 8. Cates Dans hgh ora can
do: "Toei hing whch an edi mst ok fr By ne
‘mca cverying at cer eveything whichis of ama est The avy
{tht wntoe Gis Poin permite tox wa to rod
‘ep? tein Sey Kae, Deepen of America oan we. We
H.C.Brown Cempay 196), 368
‘51. .Tnianw fl prabiena de lengua ce (Benos Aes: Sig XXL, 1972 08
als Doct and Trea Toor, Bnet Dicnary of he Sine of
Language ta. Caberine Por (lime oe Hops Unveriy Pr
979)
‘5% Johan Caley, posto etcetera ing eh
‘ri de la Terre, ns. Cass Maza (Barone: Anagram 1940)
10. Helad wor it Engh: Siaenol Pte: Sacral. Ligue
and he Sud of Litera aca NY: Call Unser Pres 1973)
59 Ho I ollow be sugars of Nec Pye, The Ano of rc: Bear
say (New York: Abeer, 965,
(6 Ie ke Ike's el egerng language, we cane 1 te oovig
sonsions toute mode canis: ti fats fhe gnc
‘cave, message and conc wih he respec eed ncn
‘ote, conoatve Pat, meting, eral and poet) present
‘Sars of liner ad onsite wert poe con (etl eos
ann ices npr ha he frei fone wea ee
‘ing eine he Paenemene sd a of pete pose ati to
abn Sos pont the he port nce peje he Regina of
‘une ofthe tis af seer ae sa of pmbinion Se Row kb
son, On Langage Lind R. Wah aod Monigoe Moai Burson (Can-
eae Mas: aver Ute Pa 190)
GL RN Medvese or MM Balin, “To Blane of th Aric Conaaton
‘The Foma Method Litrar Scholrtips A Cra nodcton wo Seco
al Pots, tas. Albert J. Weblo: Jos Hoplins Utes res,
178) 20-35.
(Richard Ota, "ois and Ger Noon Prose New Lea Hor)
0-2 (Wie 19205264
| Wt he Preset
|. Tempo sou ot understood in he acral sete ftp nd
‘pal ard Bo es re ele common senoy with elon
Notes o pages 6o-6s + 127
1 Gece eetet ate ta he lle of he fen per
(Getelsionstip with ie as erent fist epee nd he fiat
‘i eng andl) spt hat which erin frees a dae
Sind pce: apo ou. come), Fore seta dein
‘Orval Das ad Teena Teer Encl Dconary ofthe Sines of
“Langue, tan. Cathie Pree (Baines Hoptas Unies Pes
1990.
‘Conca he nese pops of Marts chronic, spain fad
‘eesti fis arora i tease of Cab eto nh tx
"This coemlnent ws 5 cel Mart a evo at nie i
‘yim ofrepresertne. Tae quale aden th fe he nang
‘ject in iss ia os cod whiners ro he Epon alight
eres as wi te cae stom of Cu nd Pu Rin stepped ia hel
str proeses copra thet of he nat Matte wter whe
Sender ofan et at witot dou changed yt of penn
‘lhe Lan American od bt hi lea oof Caan independence Bs
‘hus ite magne of Mar cotton oer, This ook bere
ne eer considerations of Marts leader nnd: to inst ca
noon hi ets 5 aly. Fri ra, gs by of sii
ne poli gre cfs Marae not cd ar, tpg tos dt
‘ys pt on is ierae, What is gtr comprzon of Mac wk
wid dat fer cestenperatou er sesso he ing betogee
‘nyo mays in wich wag nd conto Nation
2 Chto Vier nd Fas Guta Mea, Taner maronor ro Ris: Hari,
1981196
45 Mir North American execs ale cu eh fog cates
4 Bava Ey, The Pres and Arc’ epee ory of se ae Med
‘Eaglevod Cit NJ: Pesce Hal, 197), 37
{5 "Theres ena gay of ws who cul exes dramatic age
‘neous an abel uma cence rm ave. Te Sun ing
Sei el te rin te wring of oes nd ply nd fale or age
tls” Sidney Kone, Deeopmen of dnarcan Journal (owas W. HC.
Brown Company 1965), 38
6. Punk ME O'sien, Th Soy of The Sa (Sew YtkD, Appice Coo
any 1928) 10
1 Jab Rs How the Oe lf ves (89: eit, New Yrs Han Wing,
1057 Joe Rs Rested 0 Fran Cora New Yrs Donley. 19658),
4 Ml! Schaison, Dering the Nee: A Soll History of Amerie Newt
apes (New Yok: Base Boas 197864,
9 From nS’ cog, mt era rs, eile Me
bi Cnt, 198). 55.
30. Tis sete by Jog Las Rope i tom an any of he poy of Wa8 + Notes to pages 65-66
‘ims whore ses efit Ata who ee wis a sage
‘co he wo eo is shale” inguin [Bustos A: Pro. 525,99
‘hat sient Begs eo aig he igi of Leave of Gras be
ete erin as podce in 185), assertion at he eal
ered be posi ten of epson,
"AE we wl sei chap te agoaioes hat Mir ndes i i
cei ad poy ae chron with thse of ober cars, wo tem
Sete as ow mena ope of molarity. Tle makes e deter
‘ne wo we tly We rt formate ach et propor. Wao
‘oie salen to Mar Hower ould are ea Whitan|
Incas vrns een hosgh be ier wasnt yet wel ko poet
emake at ac cent ewe oth conces bel wit th
‘deal onop of wigan href, wih sce ysl pacing =
ali ise
1, Ls Lanz R, nis ara y Sarno Matt: Cutarans, 1968) ls
‘tral oie in ote of ie wo anor, whom conse witout 8
date oe in Spans Ametcan neoprene He ob
re he fooving tot Lara “Te ple ead npn acs ch
Js Figaro ws reste wth eat oe of hse le ees But De
suey write a hy wer oe of ama be were algo em
‘Sele lower rift reece fede, alesing pba if
‘na spec’ roping foil, ranenting hs ents a quis nd ec
ions, onatd by puson nineties”). He i hat both
{ere goons an exlcos a devises wll a cab popes
‘omer, ad ich emai vs despa of te chancew more
‘oe and cote "at the ear nee snaton of mesg the ao"
(Gra See Las Ale. Eri imager, fin La rr de Tn Mart
(Gian: Cun do le AnarcanCxatom 199). Ti ay ced he Pro
"Exar Sor cht on fox Mart oe Can is Adis tt ya.
12 Oe have of Marts wing ss also Robro Fender Retna, Nara
‘Anriee Cin oor yor aeeeaneno a Mar (Haan: SM, 1995
1, eed de Mar” Resta Cubna29 ly 195)-De. 195348. Th
iin f ipso ete tno 6 pope wake Mi
Insloes point veal cot than ren ary a
ring 8 Mrs ext suchas hse by Decsego Esta (112-13) ae ins
(Zain 1) Tiree of Revise Cube an abe meas ne
‘oe pac Marts work 0 coopera, a base ebro fan
‘rin paging te aso ase ofan aoe
14. Man prin cot ride ost Mart Ma Po Gone,
exo Gry Cats, 1960) 538,
15. Fethre ses, hele contained one, ahogh hws ein to,
"ich had hs own vo the oul of wang wih power eso anges
[Notes topages 66-70 + 129
{hc coud pene crak pool telson ier wy.
“Tey would hen bse eho betwee ous opne wits casey
‘epg comerons. “Te gener of ne wos rng On este of
‘ans wt Aled Fall ia Libera y daerinamo, tune. Lt Al
ances y Casio (Besos Aes: La Esta Noes, 98 fF cols
ethene on hi pit tho mde sped
“Apis licen kaow where Mar ahr he sx ois en, Wis
te Ansan Renaance— Strona Weta among tl ee
‘peda i whi he Unite Sees war sve arpa, een gl Pu
"Se ear ofthe gift of man, “Tot to a ee ot els
‘ors, br hy can he. They ware weten by Een te “Ts ome
‘he mage Roose he pon Nae (Ged in F ©. Maen The
Amerion Reason: Art and Exrstin ithe Ag of Emerton and Whi
[New Yan: Ono Unters Pres, 148,242) Tay al weed with rae,
convinced hoe, dof med to wck me Be sw lion But o>
eis the queso Cldea and be push Ares sane canbe
sd ertb Grek sho sachs Longin, whee rats wo eset
‘eBay creiln
16 "A at beast, ond, ed posts aaogos ques is Diving as
‘ta wich eds an fresh wind foe Pit, "Fedo a ea"
Didoes (Meio Ci: Po, 1385), 657. Os enn, een, ceca
‘pd bye din, and ar se 67-38 Egle: “Pacts” in Di
‘Alga ts Bejan owe (Oxf: Claredon Pres, 1989),
17. Lois, De ablineeees Aes: Ap, 380 2,6:
‘One Sune tas DA. Rael (fot Clarendon Pry, £965. Mart ad-
‘ict ras sed nmr sd oxi poston esi eter
{0 fase Meads; "Beron has alow dec tt gales, how my
ne those? X39) For Mar sor oan be nati eon of
rien ech wa limporaa.
‘On ajo seal Joe Piper, Earaom and Divine Made (New
Yai our race & Wot, 1960, nd Loe and peson A Say of
laos Phas (Lento: Faber an ater 196); Geng Key The rt of
‘Romason in Greece (ince, NJ: Petes Uae Pr, 1969; Alone)
‘Reyes: "La mga ed” ear comply, ob 13 Meio Ci onde de
Cals Become 1961), 249-387: ak of co. Acade, late de lo
tre CBee ire: Es, 179) The rt of Whore, a. HC aca.
“unedCLanicn an New Yar Pega Boots, 991)
18. Se ost Bl, Anam ala america Beran y Mat a: Pos
1986,
49, Pusuaion mas deus neasion in Marts tx He wate to ree -
‘irl nes, sch he mine coms, the ang scr and te nor dh
(00%, 320, On asap ce Alan M, Gorn iy, Verb Cratio ate130 + Notesto pages 70-73,
‘Was of Jot Nari” PAD. ds, Hare Unies 956; io Mase Pao
Grecte, “Feo Mart: Jerrad mona n iselnen de ets de
‘nial Dacor Fron Or or rz ipl, cla ang han
1958).140-42 On he pintin common beeen Mar ad lea Cc 2
‘Man! Pir Gz ad vin Sa, tar Dare el moderne
roma mer gl sunset eo Jan Mola, Ste Mart ir
Lats era ot Mar” In sy pene de Mort (evan:
Mn La Hh, 92) 19-25. Ti nn of rte ces
‘ns ee pod o OC, NIL To sold epee pgiation wile wit
thetetnprresesat heend ef ch quate
20 Onde eral inguin poy se Has Mags Each, De-
tales Barcelo: Anagrams 198). Angel Ra chine dat Mt “ley
‘avert tat ean ha en pti these bat gtr fhe it
"ine inte ity ote let nla he expanse ders oft ace.
cad ctl clon thot cet mae ings ny
tempat sede or sega” alse de aera en Ja Ms
[atemari steel Serio de ot Ma, 9), iar mara Ro Pe
‘river de Posro Rico, torial Utes 97a
21, Acseting to Manoel Peo Gonz, Mat we to sine vices: ie
request and th pote ale Joé Mar on ot enero de
Intocin modernin, 1585-196 (Caras Bes Weert dea Cam,
yet
23 Vier a Gua Maar Ea “cel Brg Mats wt "Tete
Mart ot Yros s:davoes nd Bene, oan one mt, be apt
tng iting, gh enema an fay al seg in ttt of nye
ster aed bases fhe sl, forthe punt wy of ein" (Co Vie
Fin Gurca Mira, emer moranr [Pata Ris Huei 198] 162),
2 Baomer Sunn Can, oft de! cre. an Gut Cob Boa (Cas
‘as Bocca Aacto 4,97, 26
24 itty ot ink Enwtsonan arscandeae, Mars analy of
‘hima es is ci eseace dacvey, bt an adingcneain of
what he eee soo he em pn A cleft engi Ws
‘mas om th tscondetaist, Marne: Wan age resets
‘cota tetween emer andthe el ins pots Sys leapt
‘exceasngle dese On he ote hand, Marsa and oe estas
‘revert im fom tings loon. He deat very few Es in “Whi
‘hu the otic Leave of razr Mario otros ine =
beat Wren who a snogpal opeteed a ter ove gh
‘iis work On Wa Whine Maen, 1 8-fny A eagle
‘ening teh anor is Svs Malloy, "Ha Ame, Ow Ameo Mart
Reals Whitman" Mader Language Quarter A Jounal of Ler itor 7,
0 2 Vane 1990) 360-79.
Nowsto pages 16-79 + 131
25 ln "Nae proin "13,
26. "Les dents nots voyage de Jot Mar, Queg ergs ule se?
es Langer Nolin 8,96 Ver od Cale Mat, 13223)
‘Some fhe Met develo ee bated on Vi nd Ca Mars wor
2. Onspectic symbols ia Mars we, Ine Slt “Est dod
Mar Ter y lenge ni: Revi declare Hip et Lae Pra
(apres.
98. Ched in vin Schism, Gn del madera ar, Neer Sth Casal
(tec CyB Cale de Mio, Wht Unverty Pes, 1965, 3.
29, Baldo Sain Cana, laf decor Care Bina Acar vl 8
as
{8 See Ga Gace Mares, “El exes ero de ot Mar te
as reo sar la prota modems spencer fat Ov Jie
‘be (New Yd: Be Tener Son 97943955,
231 Th ute nd und inion, bore sao cps of ing il
‘arigmous cies in which heath guage nes ech word
nest Mags vid conn of Ciao sacs
°Men md Woten of my beled Ameren” Panos bp oy Aga
‘is a te ltrs wa. Te four bs lin if ie,
‘pining sd ning ac ce Pasons har don tmp, tr, stops
Se avlys, tebe, wns cat te root fam i whl neck cena
‘ect hea ad ir: Engel ek ne Sings, h Set sie ed
{seth ide ade suente Spies na est dance tangs peng he
2 ago ime, clk pes soy, i nes pass rc rs
se eet es thy ses isms, ps oly expec
ean famed Bowing his head wt teeta XL 355)
5s sy Rat hs hat Mar an Rimbaud “ar hh iter fd
emg ofe on eth si of the Adi. They pray pire te Sue
hts hist eat comengreaoa cerns fecal lcs of ape
and Aree’ (Angel Ram, "Ls alse dee mode en Jove Mate Be
‘ios maranes (Rio Fests: Vives de Past Rc, El ales
‘ai 197.
58. Samet “La cities earl? Obra comply, vl 1 eno Ales: La et
Dia 154,11,
14 Las Mongi, Eto ore estes Mipanmerisna y eat (Mexico
iy: Sim 195), 20-21
.35-Tove information Gomes Seba, Mart Dart el madeniome
nga.
6 Sou astern Po of Jn Mart (take Cy: Dai Pes 1973.34
37, Wher Ong, A Date of Aun and Objects Caran erect
on Poy 1.1 Clderwed and ELE Tale (Now York: Oxford ery
Pes 1968132+ Nowsso pages 79-63
{38 Hild Room, The aie of fence Theory of Poy New Yorks Oso
sir Ps 1697, 2,
29. These denon cerespont othe en by Macs Mote in be Dinar
dea del expail Mad Gros, 1980) The "syria wa act
ty he Spanish Royal Academy as pose erm in 34 a1 Comat
And. Pasa stein Be Dicom ete lin esl Hip
rico Mar: Gren, 198) Thee da conor orb ts de ws
Seep ented ino tai tne
‘40. Mart adtocaed the Beteot of skid trough wlingness sd soe
ery a rapes rma th He adres ts in ioc! gor oe
cording nee or bier condone emprans. t e o
igdin impesonat sors, hich were poo wna yes" id
Inde bate tat sets have “parr ave chaste, esta ai,
‘expunio and agin, vany aed avarice (i Mera Amarca (Cae
Bisea Ayscuho, 197], 2) ut he doe not an tht be bleed i
sepaoe groups eri aca et Uae Eas, who bleed inh sper
Jen ofthe vias te cold pons, Mart ene the very execs of
sateen 15S Mar wrt,“ ot alanine en ao
toewistoraerheesieac oft saure ly sa pyaly Bec cae
they wed omen grow a any eda aly egal sd tei n=
ies, wih al people ad ahr bd and asd, cee and sles, ede and
crane” 45
4 Lao V. Maal Bure Nb, Cause del ees ass Aes: Hash,
163) 200.
|#2.0n Mar’ os, see Angel Ess, La moderna Ira: De Béqur @
Mara Gran: get, 692).
4 Mart cover wrote fein inbances or ger the cles of oar
‘xan: on he coer sprog rents rsa bee
intone mast be knob nero case what ef wee
‘ove om ams, oa oft etal rom of Nest Anca (88), The
‘incon fast eer est oxen mail nt een
ny sors sn! He eres me" Tenporiy san set pre Marien
the pstand he frat ove, iting hl oe in coma cet, ce
Ingen nile nd pte nee
|, Accrington Gossnas, omic hte cased emer ilar
(odie eves of tr tex then, ey parce in heey of he ine
cated to changing a aborsing,eleaing thy srculaing vison
hier desi: In “ry ax Deipheroen: Romane History md
he Discover fh then. 4, Peto Univer. 2)
45 Wempst nt gt tf de ce ait wat ero ron fe engence
of cera aici aor ve oo a et yi, Oh
ery of Chis as nage a te eatin ret nd poll lon oe
Notes to pages 2-83 + 139
‘ein me ay Hn Hse Ppl Away
mito, tans. Maris Terese Martinez (Madrid: Taurus, 1977) “
+4 Gi Hanan Go. eo t epen epeay
‘iy tie toa cone ne phe see es
St geo et vue) man ens So
‘ers eRe tO eo ae
Cpls Metsmgry rv Seeman sera sea
vient vend ref oncay ces oe
25: iter pa ene ve
tat reunite duals, such 2 the contr aa ‘ae
+9 Lisle pnt ty Pr Mees Dai The oma
Me omy Sti Ace at ged ee,
‘At Whe Chie Une hoe
Ein a he gt ensnar fh em pn a
‘Si opiltomeftorme aor veabeuee Pattee oe
Semon tale smc hcg eo) Tee,
hese cease hy ae ey anes ey
storms sch waomera those sapere
Mure ny beph ay ea ese
‘ena ay pis gr cs te pee a
sn art te ont two ay a
‘ero elo cg ne wae of tds rine ee a
ty st fy nec fe chen ed a
‘ttt isons me en ae eS pe
a Sn th vm ne ay tok fa
ics pheno ber Sen
{02a en can ofa a engl noe
spa wing On Ogi The Wr ee
49-The mscun coc ya of xing a. a nso hat
iin a daine cose of wold ted onset of hegpe,
{ies The macamcae sees stemitoa udev, tered
‘0 te moana of fy The“ sins own a, td fathom194 + Noes to page 83-85
temo ne et the eck fqucons writers a aye at veson
fi mean wit ti work of fe pat ery memory The dt
‘pote game Sowig the oak of Cua dh conan sac pe
‘Thre a a hemes he hry fate wach hy hve
teen ormsond This fe ose ly ofc, ese Nate sues
resnng onl one cla ume, te nese of he orn "UA
‘ough asoing Svs aot cole wi ti in every fins ar
‘hd, 19ingzon nao,
‘pr osutesaiason oe ode
is
aco, lag, 14036
are La ah 338
anton 7.19 48565
ow 35
eae Aan Cat, 28
Rese we aon n New Yr 8,
"op. Mato 6) nodes ace
bccn wi 1 ppl
Redason $3
Rego, 72.80
etcton 8 es
enn, Bc 9,85 1g
eyes 38
Res ce. 19
Resp” S25
Reade Fanaa Agen” oe.
bo.
‘ejte Cone sie), a3
ove eso pas 44154
Raj Calon 24
in lcch 6p
‘Rid, Ar 7, 3833|
ev efehin os. 08-9 of,
{5.8.03 1 ad mao,
yf Reba, 7s, 3
‘wine irs rea teen ae
‘srs so)Ts egeee dicount Faq? sd
‘wae of a7
Serotec masa, 88
omnia
Spot 3-667)
“Juno 9
ae sn 0
‘decal 66
‘hess
Tempe 60-6, 72.74 8s
“farce fe Che ey 3
“78.97, 3899.1 Seo
Giese eae
“aan 3e030|
“Tamcneton 3879
‘prey ao 13
Tiay. Jo 5058
‘an sigs
‘Vmsne Miele 66
ares. 78 120.20
iano 5,47. 82
Drspuy.2
atin, 5.7.21
‘Wes. atten,
Wes em 103
Wes Pasco, 50
‘in Eigse 6-66
Voix Ca» 117
ec Cana 3 Rv eran
“eva Seana > See ako
‘Spat hata de Coes Ea
(ceospe)
‘esi 8, 8
eran, 7
Viste. 28
Virasoro
Mic 20
ions Ange, as
"totaal es Pb ta”
‘Asch st
etna
‘Wham Wi: Beso, 2722; Maré
(h -67.08 70-747), ona
ut eing 6 ats“ pce
‘Wir Via” 96M oxay
ape wi ha oo
nied tess pln apes
Wile, Edo,
iin, Raa 5,108
‘Worn tnea®
Wate See ee
Pac” es 5
Zee Gs, ul 3
Za E705