George Washington Carver's Bachelor's Thesis: "Plants As Modified by Man"
Written by George Washington Carver, Plants as Modified by Man details Carver's views on plant breeding. According to Carver,"Man is simply nature's agent or employee to assist her in her work, hence the more careful and scientific the man is the more valuable his as an aid to nature in carrying out her plans methodically, instead of at random as is the case when left to herself to perform the work." Carver praises the work of noted botanist and horticulturalist Luther Burbank and lists some of his success in the thesis. Carver also expounds upon the plant breeding done at Iowa State College (University), including the work done with plums, geraniums, and the amaryllis.
George Washington Carver received his B.S. in 1894 and his M.S. in 1896 from Iowa State College, now Iowa State University.
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
100%(1)100% found this document useful (1 vote)
1K views7 pages
George Washington Carver's Bachelor's Thesis: "Plants As Modified by Man"
Written by George Washington Carver, Plants as Modified by Man details Carver's views on plant breeding. According to Carver,"Man is simply nature's agent or employee to assist her in her work, hence the more careful and scientific the man is the more valuable his as an aid to nature in carrying out her plans methodically, instead of at random as is the case when left to herself to perform the work." Carver praises the work of noted botanist and horticulturalist Luther Burbank and lists some of his success in the thesis. Carver also expounds upon the plant breeding done at Iowa State College (University), including the work done with plums, geraniums, and the amaryllis.
George Washington Carver received his B.S. in 1894 and his M.S. in 1896 from Iowa State College, now Iowa State University.
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 7
Plants as Modified by Man.Ever since science overthrew the idea of spontane:
generation and established beyond doubt that no organisn
Gould have existence without a parent cell, the sciontific
world received a thundervolt which was to be means of its
first great, awakening. And as the message was heralded fro
one to another it arroused more careful investigation, stimu-
lated advanced thought and opened up a new line of possibil—
ities respecting the whole plant kingdom.
Man aia not grope as hitherto in the dark trusting to
uncertainness but from a m ntific basis. This was
the dawn of a new cra from now henesforth man was not simply
to assist nature in producing endless varitios, but bo the
actual progenitor of new creations.
I need only refer you to the excellent work of L. Burbank
of Santa Rosa,California,to substantiate this statement. It
is a well known fa at plants kept on the same soil
subject to the same environment for ome
in Vitality ana less valuable for eco 3 again, na—
ture did not perfect hor fruits and flowers to stiit the fas—
tddious taste of man but left this for hin to do,and now he
is oxercising that right to a degree that was never dreamed
of a few years ago.
The casual observer regards us as usurping more privi—
leges than belong to ts, but not so, just as the Chemist takes
original elements or compounds, breaks up their combination
or Combines them into various proportions to suit his pur—
pose, so we are at liberty to do the same with our plants and
without violating nature’s laws in the least. However, nature
refuses to indulge man only just so far in his modifications
of both plants and animals a3 we find hyvrids in either case
as a rule are sterile. ‘
While a few have worked only froi anipoint of curi~
osity and the enrichment of seiehco, tho groatest work nas
been called forth from an economic standpoint. Extensive
cultivation has taught to the horticulturist, farmer and flor
ist just how to secure larger returns from a particular soil
and a given surface than heretofore ;4t has done even mor
than this, xy carefully selecting, cross fertilizing and cul-
tivation we have been able to double, triple and even quad—
Tuplo desirable qualities we wish to porpetuate in our choice
fruits and flowers
Man is simply nature’s agent or omployee to assist her
in her work, hence the more careful and scientific the man is
the more valuable he is as an ald to nature in carrying out
her plans methodically, instead of at random as is the case
when left, to herself to perform the work.
Darwin gives a great. many fisting illustrations of howa
does it,a fow of which T will consider br:
tho first, place wo find that nature distributes her plants
ih a way favorable to cross-fortilization” and not only does
this mixing and crowding together of species do this, but it
doubtless encourages tho survival of the fittest.
Nature seldom transplants her trees, rarely grafts and
never buds. Upon examination of the roots of many of our
forest trees we find a long straight tap root, which goes di-
rectly downward which of necessity must be broken if trans-
planted, this gives the plant a shock from which it never
thoroughly revives,and if this be practiced from generation
to generation the result will be a whole race of plants much
lower in vitality than the original unmolested stock. Some
of our most eminent horticulturists deem the art of budding
and grafting a curse rather than a blessing to horticulture,
owing So the use of uncongendal stock ;while many of our
fruits and shrubs will unite with a great variety of stocks
they do not make congenial hosts; Jhence,a weak short-lived
plant is the result,4.c.in commereial circles certain stocks
are used such as the Myrovolan for grafting the whole plum
family upon, now this 16 not a congenial stock for certain
members of this group.
Ache in natural conditions tends to weaken our own
plants. Man performs nis work too suddenly,nature builds up
her work slowly,man secks to bring about ‘he same results in
one-half the idine and as a result we invariably
of plants low in vitality, susceptible to the attack of fun—
gus discases and early decay.
er way of reducing vitality is
monstrosities, the highest ultimatum of the
of nature is Lo produce seed,much pulp to her is waste and
nowhore do we find her expending her forces upon waste mate-
rial. Man is just the opposite,he wants much pulp. Nature
ids ready to accomodate him in this but at the exponso of
some other function of the plant,usually the production of
sood.
Scientific research has taught us that everything in
nature tends to strike an equiliurium,henee we are at. liber-
ty to shift certain forces here and there
vine certain forces but at the expense of
these deductions were made.
Experience has also taught us that the removal of trees
from forestry conditions upon high, dry and arja regions is
too sudden a change for shom and honce a weak
plant 4s the result. It will be of interest here
some of the morphological characters of secds and
semmination. Nature calls into service many ai
sist her In scattering her seed ;such as the wind, the waters
and various forma of animal life. Many sceds 11Ke she dan—
deldon, lactuca, cottonwood, ete.have long plumose appende
that fit the seed for bedng buoyed up uy Lhe wind and car-
ried long distano Some are fitted for enduring salt wa
y days,o are provided with hooks and barbs that,
eling to whatever object they may come in contact with and
are in this way scatlered far and near. t411 seem
to require the action of the gastric juices of stomach,
and the only way that man has been in any degree successful
natdng such seed is to imitate
rly as possivie.It 1s also well established that naturo’s plants are
increasea in size ana vigor by varied environments. There
are many other illustrasions of intorest that might be men—
toned, but, I trust these are enough to rertray that thought
in view. Summarizing these fow remarks we might add, “That
naiure’s methods are favorable to natural crossing, natural
selection and exact climatic adaptation.”
In man’s manipulation the one thing sought for is puri—
wy of stook in fruits and flowe Jmormal in size which we
can readily sce is a violation to nature’s laws and hence
must ve done at the expense of vitality ;such plants will
survive and do well for a few years, but finally will succumb
Jo the inevitable,and then are compelled to go back to some
primitive form for a starting point agadr his explains
why the sood and plant catalogues are flooded every year
with now varities of sterling merit.
Every farmer, horticulturist and florist should know the
few simple facts concerning atavism, reversion and sports (no!
a scrious task, however, )then he would not only be able to
work intelligently but greatly prolong the life, size and the
vigor of his choice fruits and flowers and possibly be able
to build them up to a higher degree of perfection.
ir. Burbank, of California, is, doubtless, on the right
wack to the greatest revolutdon that horsiculture has ever
known, he has certainly unearthed many goms from the mysteri~
ous realms of nature, hitherto unknown ;he has rade a great
number of successful crosses,a few of ‘he most remarkable we
append as follows
k Almond. Chickasaw plum X Jap. plum.
Japanese plum. Apricot X Peach.
Chickasaw Plum. dapanose plum X Peach.
Foach X Apricot, dapanese plum X Ghickasaw.
Almond X Peach. Yyrobolan X Japanese plum.
Almoha X Japanese plum. Domestic X Wild goose plum.
Apricot X dapanese Plun Common Appice.
Prunus Japonic wince. X Crab apple.
Chinese quince x common quince. % apple.
Fyrus Japonica x Chinese Quince. Quince X Appie.
Japanese Quince X Apple. Ghinese Quince X Apple.
Potato X Tomato.
omé of these crosses are very remarkaule,as you seo,and are
doubtless new creations.
me need not go to Europe, Asia, California and remote
parts of the earth to find remarkable crosses and astonish
ing results,as our own College grounds furnish some yery
striking examples of what we have done and are doing in th
way of Gyolution. This work has beon in progress for a num
ber of years, bu: owing to the difficulty unaer which much
of the work has veen performed the results are as yet unknow
The work here on the ground has veen promoted by two
main objects, first the developmont of the science from ar
illustrative standpoint and second the possibility of buila—
ing up a class of fruits and shrubs adapted to the sodl and
climate of the whole north and northwest which we are sadly
in need of, owing to ‘he ever increasing population and the
growing demand for superior fruits and flowers. In this
lino of fruits some very intcresting work has been done onplum, of which I shall make @ brief monton.
Of the first group,tree No.4 is a cross betwoon tho
besoto and tho Japanese plum ; the Desoto, of course, being
jhe true American type. In leaf we have neither thé Japan
hor the Americana, but a combination of the two, the leaf is
much thicker and Gloser in coll structure with not voining
on the upper surface like the Japan,and the under surfac
like the Americana, serrations like neither. In bud 4b 4!
like both, being double and triple. It evidently endures a
drouth well as 1t has scomeda to thrive during this most ro-
markable season on record during the civilized history of
our country. Yellow leaves begin to show early in September
indicating determinate growih (which 1s an indispensible ro-
quisite of a hardy plant of any description) showing, of
course, that, the elaboration of starch and ripening of the
wood was comple The shape of the tree is all that could
be desired, being rather upright in habit with Lhe limbs suf-
Piciontiy spreading to ariate the fruit. ‘The limbs are very
strong ana capable of supporting as At as can han,
upon them. ‘The color of the bark is. a as, bub
resembles that of the Americana more
free No. 5 of the same cross shows bo x na and
Japan ouds,also the color and peculdar spotting of the bark
is distinctly Japen,tho leaves are fully one-third larger
than those of Americana with serrations 14k Japan
ture, thick and leathery. Yenation same as N
ds good in habit being very large and spreading
gan inmonse quantity of fruit. on “ot
t to the ground by a tornado that
wn dune 17,and notwithstanding this severe injury, f
ly five fect of new growth was made,and the wound showed up—
? dneh of granulation, which goes to show that
remarkable vigor vitality. This t
has frulsed twice, (in 795 and 94) producing a purely sel
colored yollow fruit of a rasher rich purpleish rea on the
sunny side, carries a heavy vloom,and 1s marked with a deep
suture. In size it ds as large as stone, su
perior in flavor,and considered a
The next Go of v Lerestiny
because here we have a crc z of 2 the Desoto
and Maquoketa.
tree No.i, in general appearance she Desoto
double, single and trip] yes snaller than vet
thick and of good substan
broad leaves serrated like
3 triple buds,w
i shows °: wendency to the
early ripening of its wood.
No.3,4n general appearan
has a leaf 14ke nedthe:
of these up more fully.
The unquestionable haradr of Rosa osa in connec—
tion wit beautiful foliage has prompted some very ela~
borate work with it hore upon the College grounds. Pollen
was used from our best cultivated roses in the Bast. The
aim being cure a class of roses equal in form, beaut:
and fragrance to those of our best Eastern varieties in leagcolor of stems, size and vigor. Of Shose that have flowered,
some have come semi-double, delightfully fragrant and of a
pleasing shade of color,among those that have come single,
some are very desirable in colér. A Tow mildew, badly shot
ing thelr weakness of constitution, and inadaptability to this
latitude.
uch careful work has been done with the geranium, of
which I will speak only in a general way as the work is by
no means complete. Of a truth this can bo said that they
are more floriferous, larger flowers,more of them, purer in
color, tints and shades, larger,more robust, and ueautiful fol-
ge, both in the house and in the order. The increase in
or is quite notdceable,even to the easual observer.
and interesting crosses have been made between
Amarylis Johnsonii and A. Defiance,also the beautiful fairy
lily zephyranches atamoska and Johnsonii. These are rare
erosscs and much 4s expe thom. Some promising crosses
have been made between Abut: Golden-vell and A. Belipse
Also much work on She Calla Lily, the adm being So increase
the size of She flowers by 1n and in breeding and selection.
@ also have nine seedling plants produced from a cross
made between our best double white geranium,and one of our
new vrilliant scarlots, but Tor some unaccountable reason
three flowers came on tne same head that were quite rich sal.
mon pink, the cross vas made with the avove results. Some
crosses have veen made between Nicotiana tabaccum and N. a
finis with w 7 results,which I will be pleased to men-
tdon in detail later. One new border plant, has be
to the list of encouraging sports of Mad.Saleori
and carefully selecting the game. Three new chrysant
of merit,have been added to the list,and several others that
show promise. The department has made a groat number of
crosses b. n our, cultivated strawberries and the Manatova
wild o: present an almost endless varicty of modifi
tons, 1 will describe later. Also much systematic work
the apple, pear and grape has been done, but desire to give
n future ooice.
to what has been done, one need only refer to
books and periodicals on this subject. 01
is of much deeper interest to us. ‘ith the
past and present experience has given, the wide
vilities are beginning to dawn upon us. Hort,
ndeed,a broad foundation upon which to build a
6 to add him in his work are, in
and in ureeding and selection.
is by no means of minor importance, since the sclen-
ists have ostablishcd veyond question that hob only such a.
ving exists in the plant kingdom as heredity, but that it is
very characteristic table pathologists recognize the
fact, that, ci can be transmitted from one plant.
to another,as in the casc of the frenching and blea
leaves. Its first appearance, to be sure,is a sport, butand grafting, pe can be fixed so
-self with unerring certainty, and sot
have been so well fixed as to come fairly true fron
this 4 kowise true of all characteristics.
ith these few mile-stones to guide us in our course,
dare we not predict that the day is not far distant when man
workshop need no longer be chaos, but will be able to use th
tools nature has placed before him from a purely scientific
basis, free from all conjectu
‘why should not th sAcul 3 Just how to buila
up size, flavor, vigor and hardiness in his fruits and shrubs,
and the florist know just how to proceed to unite, blende and
pe tthe color of hi erg not only harmony,
but, a glorious symphony
Bh just. as much certainty
14@,and the novice gi
untdl nasure refuses indulge him longer