J ~, •.. ~ I? ~,--c ~L···,·········· . .,. r(~ 'C. II ~ % J l' j' II JI~' / I .... Iwl ~'-' .
' 1~17 Lh7~ J}!If"" ,
. .I!o. _l.;. ... ~ <1M. C1 #<. ~+.
, ~~UI~ilL.J"~,._· ..••
.. " .
~,-
,/t,
d~,
~~zJ
..
J I~ -- ,I'~-j' l,iIVIVI
P-ubUs,itie!!di by
Na,z aril a-I- POllkli,s,"t,a,nl 'Yru s't ,A,iwr!lrrll=!II-Ka ~'kll! na n,-i -'lll;!lh ~e'e,~A,-P',alf()~s'kn!!lj Madal~'·~-:Mlililln!illt. Park! '1 Oi!l·Sllralillr~lh,·i·Ql!iiaiil:ill,-i ·Az,1I filii! LiCiIiiJiOrfiE!:.
Pill" %Ji2WIiI 21:3;·9~(I;1'~~# 1F':l:':. 9!lii1l2~1,$1JI !::.m:! !l:: 't~~~~~Z~ri!:! ~~.tiflir~ 'f,N',g,P:: 'W~W,fi!Jiiii!Uill!J~'ilIl.liiif.O'
!~~lf.t_- j "J ~ - r' rr "'./~ ,,',",;!\- ... JI '~!IoI".JP/ii!...._I~
~-'I'- ',,:- -- .. ' --..-
., ;t ..... :"~,I7'" ifj ... -}1, ,,'~ ~ 1!iiii!iO*'.;! ~'~' Lo.-
- ''!t' ,M-.-
'"
- l\ioo r; jJ-~'
J~./c}~~, ;;',-_- 0"-:'
/"~ - ''1' .... -
~)~1'
Jt~~1'
I~
'"
,_
'.
~,2,O 1 OU.I,)' 11000
'"
Pin!Ifl~i!d I;It: ~IZ,jli!l"II:;!I..;I~P',(IiU:~~91n Prhiilter~.
,t 04l'luilILim 1R.(]\iI,d;, IbliIlhQITe. PIiI~ &-.4:2-a,7,iI~ii;9r7!!)
3
4
5
i'""' d .- ~.,. .,I_
. /" - ~4 . /.,. /" +£' I~;J:' .'. "" ~ ,"". 1";},-'9'
V ~,n '" ( J i> j;!; r c_ tJ.~ ... d{? ~ ~ I" ~ .. V-' +, ;_l ~ _...<' ~ t I,;)'i" .;;...../ ~ r I ;, - L·
~ . . . "-I' .. : .. ,- 'Wi' fi..... '.. . -~ .~ .. _... ._, . ~ +"I' ..... - .: ",' ,.... ~ ~ -. ~_/ ... V' /
6
7
? -" _..., r" / ,p "", ,,;'i,
J r,;)1l} ~ At J ~r c-- L,fy L... I;.tn./J r ~!j J ~ l.A ~,~ (y x:< J ~ Ll; J- ~
.J( LJ -4 d c_, V\frA;:,.JiV"L" u ~7 ;vfi~j X I~ Cf ~ C_, ~t./J/ .JJf ~ ~'
~ I~' 'rr ~r. . . . . .. ~., v
" , J-1" ...... ;i ..... ,,+ ~.']" ,.,. (' • ( ,." '. .~ + (' .) 'P, .-1 r'"'.' "
~ U, I J,? 0 1;:, ,j' ~ ~~ r :i ~~:. \,,(f! -~, 0./J _...~ [}J j_1 U ~r j U L--~ ~,L, L ,U
~
'L-L.-"~ l'-/A"U;c--~1.~r t~,SJ'}
- '.:::,..; ~.
J J: r,JrJ ~f ~ ~, Lx'
,.. ~
_,;\b.
~'
r~
~ +0.,.... "
./ .:,: U 1£,0. J U ~;
( Jj"T r,J If.' ~u j>'" _1
~ /
(V1 Wl·- I ~ U ~
,',', ~.,;'r., " ~ .,;' ./ ~r
U" !".I~l U" -
.. ;1.0 .'
r.,;;...;
, I L;:-'
v,,· ...
L
"
~~ c_,
... ~
t ".'
1I~'
.......
J
8
;.--'C / a, f? r :=' ...... "" ./ - / .' "
':I .. ,l~{) j~WJ;yL,lr;J LJYi;:£(-:.!J(.':JL uiZ.J'jr; Ii., ~J c..JJ; JWi l.-A
'1- , .•
~ -~"' ...... -","" r ~ '"', [.r ", $'" - r (.'"'" r:r r (') ",,~ " »". J" ('
~I;~L I;~I (J..Jr.,.: Jl-'./.b .... a.: - , .. ' Lf. ./J. ~r.r' ./- r' _,. (J~' ~ i,J ~~ ,U~' 0.
~
"i fL(J:j:'I,."·"'-1 iJL(" I. ~ (j -L'''' f .. , rEi- -r:
~7-,j~, !;?r-~'li ./5 ' "'" L-~:./ ~ :.t'./,~""~ '1.»./- v'" ~'~~...I-;
J'i..1. -(il r; .J ~,~ ¥U,~,'" ~I._l-I--v" ~;
.... " ,_ ,
~ + - /.
,(/" ,V~'P..!.1,.b r: ~ ; L ~./r t ~ ,5; ~ (. i I) d:,.,p-L I f_l.:i-! ~ - J~ ~ ,,,!
~ ~ '" I ~ T .I. ,..... _...r. ~ _. J' .I ~; w-- --, ~ ~"'1Iof' ~ +4~
~lf~~)J~7"'-./Jr~,,:,,-./V'~(Self-esteem)~~/'t_.C;~r
+ ~ ~ .' .
J ;:h5 ~~, J ~ f J' }tJ§f. t.)uf -J' fi' vi~~,~£, JrL J ;J\~~.1, r
JJVJj~r l·(human development) J';j Ct ~r L~J~~:,(
.. .. .. ~ .... ~, .•.. +.illl
S ~ .. )~1 ~i.r!..~1 t5:qHuman Resources Development) J;
",---- +/ ~.' ~J
,cz:. .~ - ~J "O/!",- .. ~ ~~'I r .r.L ~ [" .• Ii.? - rl . _ - - r-.-
U +"",i~' ~r.;;, li);. ~r )( a.: ~{I./Jr l J r: 0'.:..-! j (J l,..Jr u +~ '"'" t~r.~ ~ .. ' ~ (..¥j ~
U~.1Jr Y'~,f ~-7-' ,V-~jhJ~\.,.f(-.~"r J~ f/~~t/lj--,; ~r
9
~ ~
J .. li£ J~J Jr 1960 ,{tp; JJ w$'r V~}ljr, L..n·_/~c--I .. h.~'I.IJj- L~ V--t~·
~ .V/tf~J'{~ l::J:~,J/~v :':::-.f.nrrJ i?.:-~ (' fJJvC W;~·
'. II' 'r.
~ ,\~ i":./ .J ~.h (: ~ Ib~ ( j.J ~'; r /' : ~~;!; 11 1~, R' .,A', (r"? n£
1,,;1 "~ r\")_.,,, ¥.<' 'v'~ ~-:;-,!;.; . ~ v ~ ~.I.... 'i.;' !r,,;(' ""
~ ~
J.JI(#"J.J,?/:' (Pri vati sati 0 n) J.J( & ~:J It.' J \,.;;'n ~'~.Iy?·/";·lvJ;
./ ~ '.
~ M w;~ ~if£Su;"i~J ;:"f( de re gul ati on )J' f; fc-- W.(,v..~
, '.
10
11
12
-: L1t J; J ij • ./ ./}~f~,J j :";)_;:~
-q .. ~ . ..~.
f 8
: l),S)f;,J,Y - 1
~r.n,~'~~:~./,-t,U~ l~l::~Lf 1904 4.r;rf ~,,~
: /tiJlff~,/~,~, - 2
,r-, ,r ....... ~ ,_ .r-
; 7'-L - .:.f~'6 ~r r"/"- 1 901 .;,.
-,~ .. ') v;.',Z'..I1.) b "'"' .~,. 1, .. 1 v;.'f~.~ ~
J~i~'U:LJ~£ LJ.l~,j!~;J~~JJu.!~(~v'J~:1911 -3
:~.J::J J
., '~,'
_£j~~~£Y~crJv= Jj~f~W~~f 1 930./,ff 1927
. - .. ~, . ..
- ~I • 1,11
-f 1930) l, i,jr ~-;>'
~ II
( Lf)i(r,l..·'+1~r ~j f)f 1 932 jJ1.' ,u~
-/ .~..J ~ .. W./,-t,Ur..tr9.Jv./L f 1 936 ~}
~J-"t- +.!' /. . ./~.
-4
-5
-6
13
14
v cz: LJi' L ~.i;;_j; ~f i':j' ~ ~I.fl L w ~~ a.: ~;'~jJ f ui,~ J' ~ r ~,~ ~ JJ L f./~ ~ !;}1./' f ~'fi ii, l' U , ... (,J,'
-a. ~ .. po f AI.
~LrpL ~J)L ~'j U Cf~. (~~ is' ~)i J.'jJ' Jt~: ulf-:'i~~;'
~Vc~Vn_~.~J./J)£,.··L;;jJ~./Jr~ .J~;J(;;)r~~·rflV-~J~
~ I ~ -~ ~
U JJ
«~vnJ./rJ~jJ...JlvC'i.;/~;,£~r_T·JJf~L5 '. ~,(~r}J)i'J~;~
W.r~./J r W ~ ._)~,j~~ .. c. - ~ . r~'~, L! ~'¥' k; ~1L61./Jr .lr~.... ~ ...... " .. .d) r: . ~ .. .{ if.>: .
. ~ T ..) _.-; • '. '-':
(; r:, 0.;-:;:"' ..... r l::" • ~).
!;,;f""'.1~ L· ....... ,L! .:
15
~ z lb~~~ ~~ui(,:) l.5ri:.~~E~,L ~r jiJi:.' rL vn ~J
· J~~,/r,! nL,r,L' t., )!~rjJ ~f", ~~-Llt' ~~Jr J~J0~d.lL;r
'wf.~ ~ .! / .. Ii ./ _ <F.ofi ~r. W"~ r-- ""!II'
L Q~; r ~ ,~WL~ vC: J~'~,fo - L_, ~~! Ww'L ~ ~ J(" .tk" i:. J:~r ~.i-
•• 1'1' ~'I- ~. . . . l!-~' " ~ .. '!I~ ~
I Jl~r ~ i (.Jf;; .~
~ 1;.0" ... ~ ,,;,;{' ;t...._.
• ~ i _ ,;,~.~ t"'" ...." ,
....... "".1 L ~d
'FI-
) 'L/' (' (.../
;Ii . ;.Ii .....
,; t); -' \.;1..1.,.,
.. ~ . ll .. 'o!'
J+ e: .
, )!o ,
) ~ r V
16
17
'.' r~r _-.<' i r;l.o - ,...... ;1.0 ,,3 ( -'"If i' -.. ~ .. ~,
= L~.J r'lfLf./'C vr..:~./ !.,L_C;,if~: U 1./!J~..c .. ~ ••• ul~';-~J ~/.:. L,-)1.';,»
=-": ,!J./')~~ .{1,.;/1 L ~j~;f-,,: ,~~,;; ~~,:~.r(", ~i:. vC ~l~\.JLVr
!Jl - " !Jl
I ~'Ivf./ i~./ ,_'(.if_e-L r,~Li"i~;"L;::"\~.pr .~.i"~ J !'Ivr ~ ;.r;l~
v.';..' ~/-/. t.- ~ w-- . r oM' we ...... ~i." "",. .. l' - ~,." - .!!+_/ ..E w.: .
fL/.'L d~'l.- ,u,uYIL~;';~J:vrr l.- ~)~C_~~J.~J~'¥~' fl~£d~
.. --r:-"I; ~ 'r •• ' ~:II
L ~J ~,f.lJ r ~id. ;'f,;) f }:_ ~ ~ Q;;£: J ~L(r ~ ,t: ~ VJ',LVr ~;I; ./}( 1+,
- 1""1 ~:,~ ~ -) f i!> rf .;1.0 f ~ ," (' f; j f4; ,. I ,o;.~ I i~ ... f,~ , i. (J- ~r :~ ~ I;;"j',~;!. ~) C- ~'~-I;..i;! ~ v ~ v1L- ~¢Y"",,,"y-j'.<fl,;nJ _ .,_j ~"
~J1~'.{ j}j(.{~ ~,j1?JJ~:/(L ~J ~~,r~ ~'"Jt1~W}L)~l~
'-I '-.
I t , j _, )'~) '. ~ , ... ~ dfr ,>, _.7_ r[' c (.~~~', ( ,J~r '~" i~ >:~ -'~ "(> 1 j;" ::( ~~ c> ~_::: -fo ~I v"" v/i.JU...:- V -L- U~I ~""'i..! !~I;".i~;
j' >;!; ~c_ (j' «, ~"IIf i",,-, ~'i,:;. r. "ivf 'N' ",j'/"';c_(--~r ~ d """_;,,q;.c_
~I L1 !;.;.." ...... ,-.- . iJ&"-~- ~', ;;.",.'" - "'1' L- .d.,!J l,),_,- - ~ '-. ' /"', U'-';'I'" . 1;,' '-.- •
~ ~ ~
L,ifT,~./,/~J~'Jx~~-4ri:~~?~~JuLvr~ .. ~'~:._JdJ·~ i
18
·n
-I .. ~
·r" ,i -:.>"
• ..Iv"
~,rf.~t
.j:. . i ~.
19
20
21
d'i ,,.. ; r, .,'. ~ . I.J,tJ ( ... , ' .J!,. .•• (':1'1 ,;,>.
V~~ r - c_, I.) ~,)./J./_.j' '" ll,#f'/J r ~ /J »: 0 U :''.Iilf;~' ';,.tr;., :;, I.ru V ~~!
•. !II' ~ I~' ~ T .Il I 0::, '1- ~.,. ~,~, '!II'
_.- .,
~.//~<L !;,.; • .n=L-'~ t1-z')J.Jj"J~rj Jr~, ~)~LJJ UJ)?,r;;.: J~,L
. . - ''::-1; ~iII' ~ ~ / ../. . • • I!_"it'
./,f U}r>~ C-- L.lfy..d.~, . ~, J u:'.I/r--0-~, ~,.J,~ je! ~f.t~,~../V
~ .. '
22
23
24
~/~;r::: [ .... 1;. ,,J j~ ......
"'~ i_ ~; ? ,/,i ~ ~.(:. r "( j~.1 r .1'· ..... .1·, J r ~ j' ,K _, l ~ s: i .. ' L- _ f /{.. .::i. L::: i I 11 L'·'L·
~J ]rJ' v.~ ~'" _. - -;. 'W'''' . '~,ili . ~.!." ~.;.{ LI ~ ~~. ~ .. iJ'v.' _". ~!&) ~.+~
25
26
27
,4 (", ,:., .," .' 1.. .. I ~ .' ,e: (' ,:., ..... -/ -".., ::.. r'/
c:....- ~;/. 0 ...;r j i.JJ L ~ 1.;;, U- ~~ Ji ~ I.;;.i: q., (.)..,/1 " ~ VJ.~ ,,_p ~ r
if".,,~ i;; ( '" e;.~ - ~;-Ji P-l, ,- "if" ~ ,<;~ ~ '_ ,~ r I:: i r 71;i/ 1 947 z, I.
10:' {~ If U -:;,'"., '-"f1 ........ ,Ir s y r ~,,", ~.I{ ~/ C-- - \.iU " L,-""," .' of \So_;"
( ~ ~- J ' ,i .<' - - ~/ 6 ,/- ,.." .. + (' + ('
uUf',/;C:_.f~\) -~, rj·_i: t-/i../T.JJf L~ ,~r ~I{r/f-'i' i,e; uY··:J Li-;:,1?)u..! /'
_ ¥~ j 1- $~ • L ,'" if,. i i·' (i, "-" ~ i""->< .. ( _.~, ;; i _ i r r.;;.~ ;'-" ]'.I,J~. J ...... _"'" j i ~
~'J' ~v ~ [ .. ." ~ W'" ~ Iii .L _. V~ W' _. ---or......_~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ V-fift ~'~
,Ii . ~ ~ '. . ~: ,~, ", ," ~, '.... .' t.";!
((P/,~~ .. ,;J.r r!.r ~J,~L~: fi~L~ LJ..;:/,c:....-r_~ ,( 1 960-1 955)
4.-~j(J}kJ,~L J!'Jk.~~~yh/v=of 1 944 J(r-"·~~-~d~ J.'
28
.to. i y~.
+
29
dA~;~-P .~ r'
,M I '~I_~ -11'": .. ,
...... "11;1'" IIi1I'""" 1110 11;(' ./.~,.J&!
~ '-'- ~ ~
30
'~ [' - J( ,.~. ,~ ,,/_.F' e!', ~f - ,,; -~ - L40 -~ j,
s ~/_,< ~~~ ~f~t~ l,rLtf,./,J L..tt.J"",.,·U+~ ~'J~f ~.fl~-· !w!.-{
_Cr. (",-l/~~Lu'?'llfit..ld.~~, ~" (J:~rj~r>fl;d L ~ il;'./· r!L;'
~ ~ ~ +I_ . r· ~ ":' .... W r ...... L;, w.: . .;.{.1 ~~, .I -r.i' iii. ~ ~..r"~ T~'
t7' ., r' ",j ~ '7-41'b~' .;~ L-,' (';;OJ;' j~/l
=!",.i~~~'-~-~\,,;.o"~, .-1-.. ..,- Vi;;. V
.a; J -1= ~
L, ~n L ~ ~lt~ J,b~'./~ ~ .J.lf )4' .{ ~; ~U;-~ J:'lt~J' y..~;r
-~ ,J.J~' J~f).J ... -;:, ./,f J h:~.Jlj. Jf~' J :tJV;J:,f ~~J JJ{Jf L ~ ./,f Lit' e_, ~,~ L, I~ J ~ /./" ~t~·ij~u1·O~~L./' ~ l/l,r Jk~'./
II - of:-IJ ~. ~. ~ ~ . . ..... ~. T +I_ Ir-II'
~ _r _.1 /. /.. _
L.A,CIr~, 1~ l?,Jv'%C ul;..#i1L~ I/.;JJL!~}!JtG' ~~.~y
[!~, ~ r. .. ~I:JI ~, I'~. 'r.II' ~. 'r-r I!~. - .r: .. ; .::
L "J'I '>+./ r J~- --- - -.<' - i (", •• ..... - -/ f (' t , .' - -
'vL~f,J c.:; j,,-~ lr ~ ~..,.,..1 L ~,V l5,fC.J ~"!',;); ~ I,»)!j ~ l .. A./,r fJ.·t:',;.'~'~f
•• 1'1' ~ ~'i.II ~,,",~ ll~.~' ••
Jf~-l2J)J LJJIJ'" L-.r~C:'f~.J (:tJ ~:~V~~f.J,r~J ~G~,J::: ~.
_(" -,~ - ,,~ ../ I ~ r" -};, 'i-'" .• ".... -
7-'';r;.... W.t .. .J}'U.J,r j,1/' ~;J~~jrJ ~b'("L... ~~~ l,ru,b,j ./J 7-' ~},
= l2u ~fJ [~1.t'L l.¥-\.;;'rT ~~l.¥-(~.uL J~;I ~J Ji~iJ~~r~'~l d,LV,r ~ij • .l~ J~'l,r ./,f(Globalisati on) ~;~.If ~ vC J{ ~J J ~i-
L u.rJJ ._.v~." Lit i).J L-f;: ~;"r..t'Z'.£~"J (Economi c Regi onali sm)
- .r:-+ .. .
31
This article is a revised version of the paperfust published in The Pakistan Developmet Review 41:4 Part II (VVinter 2002) pp.937-966
32
~. Cf_l.-} .. ~ :_;.t't,U ~ (Lkf Lt, -! .Af;/J! ~j~~r(f 1 986)J?f~: __ Jr d? jir;
(".,.., _/ ..... __ .;t, JI ,~. _)
:,.r:..-,..c;~ r /'"f _ r-'- ~'JjrJj;,;"",.o' l,~
_/ a. ~
Dr. Taseer) -J~!r(:t :./fi',U _~-~.:'hJr u~J~;r(f 1 988)~~.IfJ;:~
Iqbal; Modern Problems) ( ~I~~ r (:r~ J~; r~..+t ,u~ ~ l!v Jr/~r_, ~,ur (~ (f 1 989) ~J ~.J~ ~v ;ir ; 81-97 j~~_Jf~~~ - ~ 1:~ r :_;fi',1~ - ( ?~.IJ r J~; r( f 1 970) L. r_;~jP:.l·
-J' loll -t .•. ; ,.I- - - W ( -!i (;.~I 'I Ir:" "(' ) - ~ + I~ ~
-~. _; _; ~':.I:.t"Z' Jj - v j'~ ~~.IJ r v ~~ f, f 1 977 ," -1"~--~~A'