Mushroom Farming for Poverty Alleviation
Mushroom Farming for Poverty Alleviation
Agroecosystems 1
Department of Botany, University of Rajshahi, Rajshahi-6205, Bangladesh.
1
Department of Biology, University of Incheon, Incheon 402-749, Korea.
2
Department of Sociology, University of Rajshahi, Rajshahi 6205, Bangladesh.
2
Poverty Environment Network (PEN), Center for International Forestry Research
(CIFIR),Jl Cifor, Situ Gede,Sindangbarang, Bogor Barat 16680, Indonesia.
E-mail: [email protected]
*Corresponding author
SUMMARY RESUMEN
Mushroom is an important vegetable usually grows Los hongos comestibles son un product comestible que
in the forest with its nutritive and medicinal value. generalmente crece en los bisques y cuenta con valor
It can also be cultivated domestically in a small medicinal y nutritive. También pueden ser cultivados
scale by landless people. The climate of Bangladesh domestivamente a pequeña escala por gente sin acceso
is highly favourable for high volume of mushroom a tierras de cultivo. El clima de Bangladesh es favorable
production. The cultivation of mushroom is one of para la producción a escala de hongos. Su cultivo es una
the lucrative agricultural job. In our study the actividad agrícola lucrativa. Este estudio encontró que
profitability of mushroom cultivation was found la rentabilidad del cultivo de hongos es mayor que el
comparatively higher than that of rice and wheat, cultivo de arroz y trigo (cultivos con alta rentabilidad en
the most popular cash earning crops in Bangladesh. Bangladesh). Debido a que los fondos para la
As funding to promote the production and promoción de la producción y consumo de hongos son
consumption of mushrooms is limited, local limitados, la participación de los gobiernos locales y
government and NGOs can play vital role to ONG’s es vital para desarrollar la producción de
develop mushroom agriculture to arise at industrial hongos a escala industrial, lo que crearía mayores
level which can create ample employment oportunidades de empleo tanto en área rurales como
opportunities both in semi-urban and rural areas. peri-urbanas. Los resultados sugieren que el cultivo de
This result suggests that the potential of mushroom hongos es una oferta potencial para reducir la pobreza y
cultivation could be a possible offer to alleviate mejorar el nivel de vida de la población vulnerable en
poverty and develop the life style of the vulnerable Bangladesh.
people in Bangladesh.
Palabras clave: Análisis económico, empleo, valor del
Keywords: Economic analysis, Employment, Food alimento, cultivo de hongos comestibles, pobreza.
value, Mushroom cultivation, Poverty
93
Imtiaj and Rahman, 2008
94
Imtiaj and Rahman, 2008
cultivation include temperature, humidity, light and and actual costs and benefits of mushroom, rice and
ventilation. Optimal levels of them at vegetative stage wheat cultivation. Focus group discussion (FGD) and
differ from those at reproductive stage. Mushroom observation were also carried out in order to determine
mycelia can survive between 5 and 40oC depending on the motivation and capacities of both cultivation
the species. Mushroom mycelia grow well with the practices. Other data were gathered by way of
temperature range between 20 and 30 oC. Substrate interviews with key informants (Government, non-
moisture content should be 60-75% and log moisture government, public organizations, books and daily
content, 35-45%. During fruiting, different relative newspaper) and market prospecting. The secondary
humidity levels, ranging from 80-95%, are needed at the data were used from statistical yearbooks, local
early, mid and latter stage. Though mycelia like dark to administrative and various related sources. For many
grow but some species require light for fruiting body elements of the study (cultivation practices, actual cost
formation. Being aerobic fungi, mushrooms need fresh and benefit etc.), semi-quantitative analysis was carried
air during growing and ventilation is more required for out for mushroom and other crops (rice and wheat)
reproductive stage. In conclusion, among the three cultivation at the household level.
factors, the most important is environmental control. By
maintaining optimal conditions at each growing stage RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
and for each species, growers can produce the desired
yield of quality mushrooms. The economic analysis of mushroom production was
calculated. The production cost of first and second
Mushroom cultivation method in Bangladesh round was tk. 20,000.00 (including house cost) and
tk.10,700.00 (excluding house cost), respectively.
There are many methods of mushroom cultivation but Average net profit of first and second round was
bag cultivation, bottle cultivation, log cultivation and measured tk. 10,000.00 and tk. 19,300.00, respectively.
shelf cultivation are usually common. Rice straw, After 4 months, average net profit was tk. 29,300.00
wheat straw, sugarcane waste, banana leaves, grass where total investment was tk. 20,000.00 because the
and sawdust are the major fibrous residues important income earned from first round can be used to cultivate
for mushroom cultivation substrates. The pasteurized second round (Table 1). The profitability of rice, wheat
substrate is usually spawned and packed into and mushroom was also evaluated and found that
polythene bags of about 30cm wide and 60~90cm mushroom cultivation is the lucrative one. We
long for the bag culture of the oyster mushroom. The considered one acre of land for rice and wheat
growing rooms are maintained at between 18 oC ~ 25 cultivation, and 30′×18′ in size growing house for
o
C, with a relative humidity of about 75%. Although mushroom cultivation. After four months, the net
up to 6 flushes may be obtained from each bag, the income of rice and wheat were tk.12,240.00 and
first three are the most important in commercial tk.24,360.00 where total cost were tk.11,760.00 and
production. For every 10kg of dry substrate used, as tk.7,640.00, respectively. Within the same time the cost
much as 20kg of mushroom can be harvested from the and benefit of mushroom was tk. 30,700.00 and
first 3~4 flushes. At least 2~3kg are usually harvested tk.29,300.00, respectively. Interestingly within this four
per bag. During the cooler winter season, Pleurotus months period mushroom was cultivated two times
ostreatus is cultivated while the more heat tolerant P. where average production cost and benefit was
sajor-caju is produced in summer. The button tk.20,000.00 and tk.10,000.00 for the first round (costs
mushroom, most often grown by well-financed including house), and tk.10,700.00 and tk.19,300.00 for
growers, is the main export mushroom. For button the second round (costs excluding house), respectively
mushroom cultivation, wheat straw and cow manure (Table 1 and 2). The relative profitability of these three
are mixed and used as substrate. Some farmers add crops can be focused as the mushroom cultivation is
inorganic fertilizers and/or peat. Cultivation is carried more profitable. In Zimbabwe farmers have been
out in trays. Lower temperatures of about 18 oC need benefited more by growing mushroom than maize and
to be maintained and diseases and pests must be wheat. The net income of mushroom, maize and wheat
closely monitored. The expenses and requirements for are ZWD 1703000.00, ZWD 518500.00 and ZWD
strict management of the growing room have restricted 1140000.00, respectively (MushWorld, 2004). This
the number of newcomers going into button result is quite similar to our findings. To the aim of
mushroom production. poverty reduction in Bangladesh, mushroom cultivation
could be potential job. Because Bangladesh is located in
Data collection a tropical monsoon climate which is ideally considered
for high elevation of mushroom production. Mushroom
Research methods were used as structured interviews cultivation can be popular to income generation among
of 60 households focused especially on experiences the women in Bangladesh because of its suitability to
95
Imtiaj and Rahman, 2008
their works and life style. As they are especially reduction among the vulnerable groups like women
responsible for household works and taking care of are especially encouraged. In this context, an
their children, thus they can easily accommodate their assistance of the local government is important for the
time for mushroom cultivation. This product is highly development of mushroom industry which can create
nutritious and a good food for their children and the job opportunities both in semi-urban and rural areas.
older as well. They also obtain some money from this Here we assumed a project how farmers will pay their
product because of its high economic value. They can loan. Our findings indicate that the growing set-up,
utilize the agricultural waste, and thus mushroom costs-benefits and space for mushroom cultivation are
cultivation can improve the life of many poor families recommendable as well as pay back of loan is easier
in Bangladesh. Cultivation of mushrooms is labor- than other crops. According to estimate of Table 3, the
intensive for the countries where jobs are rare. In fact, loan tk. 20,000.00 with interest will be fully paid after
some technologies can use family labor thus providing four months which is difficult for other crops. In the
employment for all of the family members. estimated project, one mushroom grower can produce
about 5~6 crops, 3 tons per year on average. Therefore,
Unfortunately, funding to promote the production and he can earn tk. 73,250.00~87,900.00 (USD 1098.70 ~
consumption of mushrooms is limited in Bangladesh. 1318.14) per year.
But the potential of mushroom cultivation to poverty
96
Imtiaj and Rahman, 2008
Table 3. Financial aspect of the project for mushroom cultivation (USD1= BDT 66.67)
Su Decheng, a mushroom scientist, who lived in can therefore make a very important contribution to
poverty during 16 years of his life in China, human nutrition. Based on this theme we presented here
committed to help his countrymen out of poverty trap a comparative chart of nutritional value between shiitake
by studying mushroom. In 1989, he started a project to mushroom (Lentinula edodes) and other foods taken
help people how they grow mushrooms for self– from MushWorld 2005. The caloric value of 100g of
sufficiency in the poverty-stricken areas of China. dried shiitake is higher than 100g of raw potatoes (66
Using his knowledge and experience he involved 20 kcal) and beef loin (224 kcal), but lower than that of
students from mushroom science to train the local whole wheat and brown rice (328 and 350 kcal). The
people how to grow mushroom on sawdust. They protein content of dried shiitake is comparable to that of
established a mushroom farm to demonstrate the local chicken and beef but the fat count is much lower and the
people how mushrooms could be cultivated. In dietary fiber count is considerably higher than those
another location in China there were 70,000 people in meats. It contains enough sugar (59 mg) that is the
14,000 rural families living below the poverty line nearest of rice and wheat. In addition to dietary fiber,
with annual income of less than CNY15300 (USD dried shiitake contains higher contents of calcium (Ca),
36.01). The land here was unfertile, producing only iron (Fe), vitamins B1 (thiamin), B2 (riboflavin) and B3
scrub wood and little grain. In 1989, Su and his (niacin). But it does not contain vitamins A and C
students trained them how to grow mushrooms, (Table 4).
resulting average annual income per capita increased
CNY 1800.00 (USD 216.09) in 1993, six times higher Mushroom is used as delicious item of our food menu
than 1989 when the project was first started. Three containing both nutritive and medicinal values (Agrahar-
quarters of their income came from mushroom Murugkar et al., 2005; Cheung and Cheung, 2005).
cultivation. This interesting report demonstrates the Shiitake contains almost all the essential amino acids,
incredible impact of mushroom cultivation may have with lysine and arginine being particularly abundant
in China. More than a dozen such successful story of (Liu and Bau, 1980), and methionine and
mushroom cultivation in China are quoted by Wu phenylalanine less abundant (Lasota and Sylwestrzak,
(2000). 1989). In laboratory analysis it was found that amino
acids, protein, glycogen, lipids, ascorbic acid, and
Mushrooms have long been favored by Asian people as total ash contents increased as the fruiting body
food stuff in soup. Now a day mushrooms are found in developed. Based on these findings, it may be
markets throughout America, Europe, Asia as well as desirable to consume fully mature fruiting bodies for
Africa. Popularity of mushrooms is ever increasing maximum nutritional value. Shiitake contains dietary
throughout every part of the world because of its exotic fiber in the ratio of 6.7g per 100g of dried shiitake,
flavor and their culinary properties whether eaten alone which is a figure much higher than that for brown rice
or in combination with other foods. But until now, it is (0.2g), and sweet potatoes (0.9g).
not well known that mushrooms are full of nutrients and
97
Imtiaj and Rahman, 2008
Table 4. Constituents of shiitake mushroom (Oak) and other food sources (*Dry, **Fresh).
98
Imtiaj and Rahman, 2008
cholesterol levels in serum lipoproteins and Liu, B. and Bau, Y.S. 1980. Fungi Pharmacopoeia.
liver of rat. Hypocholesterolemic and anti- Kinoko Press, CA, Oakland.
atherogenic effect of oyster mushroom
(Pleurotus ostreatus) in rabbit. Nahrung 39: MushWorld 2004. Oyster Mushroom Cultivation:
98–99. Mushroom Grower’s Handbook-1., Korea, pp.
20-23. (http://www.MushWorld.com).
Chang, S.T. and Miles, P.G. 1992. Mushroom
biology–a new discipline. Mycologist 6: 64– MushWorld 2005. Shiitake Cultivation: Mushroom
65. Grower’s Handbook-2., Korea, pp. 18-20.
(http://www.MushWorld.com).
Cheung, L.M. and Cheung, P.C.K. 2005. Mushroom
extracts with antioxidant activity against Ngai, P.H. and Ng, T.B. 2003. Lentin, a novel and
lipid peroxidation. Food Chemistry 89: 403– potent antifungal protein from shitake
409. mushroom with inhibitory effects on activity
of human immunodeficiency virus-1 reverse
ESCAP (Economic and Social Commission for Asia transcriptase and proliferation of leukemia
and the Pacific) 2007. ESCAP Population cells. Life Sciences 73: 3363-3374.
Data Sheet 2007. United Nations, New
York. Ngai, P.H., Zhao, Z. and Ng, T.B. 2005. Agrocybin,
an antifungal peptide from the edible
GOB (Government of the Peoples Republic of mushroom Agrocybe cylindracea. Peptides
Bangladesh) 2007. Ministry of Agriculture, 26: 191–196.
Bangladesh.
(http://www.bangladeshgov.org/moa/moa.ht Ooi, V.E.C. 2000. Medicinally important fungi. In:
ml). Van, G. (Edt). Science and cultivation of
edible fungi, Balkema 41–51.
Gunde-Cimerman, N. 1999. Medicinal value of the
genus pleurotus (Fr) P. Karst. (Agaricles S. UNDP (United Nations Development Programme)
R., Basidiomycetes). International Journal 2006. Human Development Report 2006.
of Medicinal Mushrooms 1: 69–70. UNDP, New York.
Hawksworth, D.L. 2001. Mushrooms: the extent of the Wasser, S.P. and Weis, A.L. 1999a. Medicinal
unexplored potential. International Journal properties of substances occurring in higher
of Medicinal Mushrooms 3: 333–340. basidiomycete mushrooms: Current
perspective. International Journal of
Kiribuchi, T. 1991. Effective uses of fungi by UV Medicinal Mushrooms 1: 31–62.
irradiation. 3. Change of free amino acid
composition in fungi by suli or ultraviolet Wasser, S.P. and Weis, A.L. 1999b. Therapeutic
light irradiation. Nippon Kasei Gakkaishl properties of substances occurring in higher
42: 415-421. basidiomycete mushrooms: a modern
perspective. Critical Review of Immunology
Lasota, W. and Sylwestrzak, J. 1989. Chemical 19: 65–96.
composition of cultivated mushrooms. Part.
shiitake Lentinus edodes (Berk.) Sing. Wu, J.L. 2000. Shiitake Production in China.
Bromatologia i Chemia Toksykologiczna Agricultural press in Chinese, Beijing,
22: 167-171. China.
99