BY

s
I)

iE

LOEB CLASSICAL LIBRARY

TT. B. PAGE, cjl. uttm.

PS m.D.. lui>.

BT. u.A.

K.

tW. B. D. ROCHE, B WARMUfGTOlf. ^. M

lttt.d

PHILIPPICS

CICERO
PHILIPPICS
WITH AN ENGLISH TRANSLATION BY
\\

AMI

(".

A.

Kl.K.

MA.

m
CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS

HAHVAHD UNIVERSITY PRESS

DON

WILLIAM HEINEMANN LTD

MCMLVTI

tit* prim* /ft*

1$U. 1M/. /57

Prtmtti

fcl

'.real

MM

CONI'I'.N IS

mm
PHILIPPIC
PHILIPPIC
I

II

...

61

PHILIPPIC

III

186

PHILIPPIC IV PHILIPPIC V PHILIPPIC VI

283

313

philipph- vii
PHILIPPIC VIII

336
861

PHILIPPIC IX PHILIPPIC X
.
.

419
463

pnUPlK

xi

PHILIPPIC XII PHILIPPIC XIII MIILIPPIO XIV

60S
641

605

PAMAOKS WniCH ARK QUOTED BY THE OBAMMABIAH1 PBOH THI PHILIPPICS, BUT WHICH ABB NOT BXTAJTP HKu

647

INI
r!y

KonrCTOKY NOTE

text adopted for the present translati that of the Teubner text of 1910. Hut read that text, and of other texts, have been substituted, where these appear to >rm more closely to th< MSS Thesf MSS are seven in number, 1 of which thr can is the chief. It is off the eighth or ninth
It ceases, however, to be available after centurv middle of the ninth chapter of the eleventh Phil th the exception of fragments of th<

:th
1.

1.

and thirteenth, viz. xii. 5. 12 to 9. to 5. 10. There are also four MSS

23,
.,

and

known

iey arc of different dates, two being of the thirteen of the eleventh ry. hey are all copied from the same older Another lent of one another. Italian MS. of the fifteenth e.-ntury was consulted by Halm, who also, with reference to the fourteenth Philippic, obtained the collation of an Italian M he refers to as v. It is carelessly written, hut is pronounced by Halm as one of the more ancient Italian MSS. The onl\ English commentaries on the Philippics as a whole aj hy George I<ong in the BiblioCUusica (1858), and the edition by the Rev. King (Clar. Press, 2nd ed., 1878), a scholarly

colh

These details are taken from King's useful edition of the

ii

SYNOPSIS OF DATES
work which has been of invaluable assistance
preparation
Philippic
in

the

of

this

translation.

Of
is

the
well

second

Prof.

Mayor's

edition

known.

useful edition of the same speech is by A. G. Peskett (Camb. Univ. Press, 1913). 'ge s translation of the Philij A contained in Bonn's Classir.il Library. work is the translation In K >rntonJ Oxf.,

Another

1878).

Ami

the

first

d
Guthrie.

ed.,

and second speech* 1706; 5th ed., 1806) by William

SYNOPSIS OF HATES
63.

Cicero's consulship. arian conspiracy,

P.

He
and

crushes the Catilinputs the prll

52.

49.

conspirators to death. Clodius, the tribune, is Inn by Mii Cicero defends). Riots at the funeral bel the partisans of God i us and Mil<. Burning of the Senate- house. Jan. The Senate declares the State

'

danger, and calls on Caesar to disband his army. M. Antonius and Q. Casatafj the tribunes, veto the decree, and then on the 6th fly to Caesar, who on the 15th crosses the Rubicon, and begins the civil war.

Pompeius abandons
April.

enters Rome on the 1st; and on the 5tn leaves Ant. in charge of Italian affairs, and Lepidus as praefectus urbi, and proceeds to Spain. At Ilerda Afranius and Petreius, the Pompeian generals, surrender to him.

Caesar

Italy.

viii

SYNOPSIS OF DATES
B.C.

48.

Au.

Caesar defeats Pompeius on the 9th at Pomp, flies to Kgypt, Pharsalia in Thessaly. and is there assassinated. Caesar rWKOM
Massilia.

46.

Caesar defeats the Pompeian forces at Thapsus

in Africa.

45.

44.

March. Caesar on the 17th overthrows the eian forces at Munda in remainin Death ii Spain. md flight of Sextos. Jan. Consuls Caesar and M. Antonius, and la. (after Caesar's death On the lfith. Ant. at the Lupercalia Feh. offers Caesar a diadem March. Assassination of Caesar on the 15th. the 17th the Senate meets in the Temple of Tellus. Cicero supports an amOa the 18th, Caesars "acts" are ratified. Caesar's funeral in the Forum is

afterwards celebrated. followed by riots.

April

Ant's

oration

is

erects an altar the Forum in honour of Caesar. Riots ensue, and the pseudo-Marius is put to death by Ant. Karly in this month Caesar Octavianus lands in Italy. May. -Dolabella levels the site of the altar and column. Ant. proceeds to the south to enlist Caesar's veterans. June. Ant on the 1st summons the Senate to the Temple of Concord, which he surrounds with armed men, and carries out a number of fictitious " acts " of Caesar. Jul the 6th, C. Antonius, as praetor, holds the Apollinarian Games in place of

The

pseudo-Marius
in

and

column

A2

ix

SYNOPSIS OF DATES
B.O.

44.

In the same month S On agrees to lay down his anus. the 17th, Cicero sets out for in tin Aug. On the 1st, Piso atta< iite. Cicero abandons his voyage and S be* Koine on the n Ant. attacks Sept. the del the 1st for his abs<

M.

Brutus.
is

<

-i

in

tin-

the 19th, violent terms. C being abi

Philippic.

On

Ant.

rejoin

Oct

C. retires to

Poteoli,

second Philipfor Brun ons from

and composes Ant set

i

of four bbicheri ns and soldiers at Suessa and

1

to take Macedonia.

He

43.

Brundisium. Nov. Ant returns to Home in battle ei aud Minnnons the Senate for tin- 2 1th and 28th, with a view to the iinpeaehinrnt of On head Caesar Oct. the defection of the Martian and Fourth legions, he hurriedly departs for Alba. to Tihur, where admission, he p he placates the troops by a donation He then sets out for Cisalpine Gmul to encounter 1). Brutus. C. al*>ut this time pub! the second Philippic. Dec. C. returns to Home on the 9th. The tribunes summon the Senate on the 20th to provide for the public safety. C. delivers the third Philippic, and on the same day in the Forum the fourth. Jan. Consuls A. Hirtius and C. Pansa. On the 1st, C. in the fifth Philippic opposes a

SYNOPSIS OF DATES
S.CL

ruled. suggested embassy to Ant., bur On the 4tli he delivers the sixth Philippic in the Forum; and some time in tin- tunc At the end of the month the seventh. in mith the surviving ambassadors (Sulpicius iied) return, bringing Ant's counter-

proposals.
43.

declares "a tumult," and decrees military garb. The pro|>osal of a second embassy to Ant. is defeated. The in the eighth Philippic denext day ates any peace with Ant The day after the Senate awards a public funeral and a C. delivers the ninth statue to Sulpicius. Philippic Antonius is besieged in ApolMarch (?). i by M. Brutus, the rival Governor of In the Senate, C. in the tenth Macedonia. Philippic carries a proposal that M. Brutus should be continued in his command. labella treacherously murders Trebo; The Senate proclaims him I at Smyrna. public enemy. The next day C. in tineleventh Philippic proposes that command in But should be conferred on C. Cassius. the commission is given to the two consuls after the relief of 1). Brutus. Pansa proposes a second embassy to A., to include C. himself, who opposes in the twel fth Philippic, and the prnjiosal is abandoned. At the end of the month Pansa joins Hirtius before Mutina. L. Plancus, Governor of Transalpine Gaul, and M. Lepidus, Governor of Hither Spain, Votes of thanks write advocating peace.

Feb. The Senate

xi

SYNOPSIS OF DATES
B.O.

C. in the thirteenth to both are passed. Philippic deprecates peace. He criticises a letter from A to the consuls.

43.

April.

arrives on the 20th of the first of Mntina, fought on the 15th, in which the Consul Pansa is mortally wounded. On the 21st C. in the fourteenth Philippic delivers a funeral tribute to the fallen A public thanksgiving of fifty soldiers. days is derived. On the 27th in the second battle of Mutina A. is defeated and the
battle

News

Consul

xil

THE

PHILIPPICS OF CICKRO

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
I

The name "Philippics"

given to these (.rations

was borrowed from those delivered by the Athenian

lenes in the fourth century B.C. against the lip, the father of Alexander Macthe Great If the " Epistles to Brol genuine, the name seems to hare been playfully given to the speeches against Antonius by Cicero himself. Thui he writes to Brutus (ad lirul. 2. 4) "I see you are and Unit us referring <*d with my Philippics " to the 5th and 10th orations, \s have 5)
:
;
'

now acknowledge that they may even be called Philippics, as you jestingly wrote of them in some letter." But, however this may be, the name was adopted as early at least as the time of Juvenal, though Aulas Gellius uniformly calls them " Antonian orations," a more appropf name. the future triumvir, and the " Mark A >f Shakespeare and of history, was the grandson oi M Intooin a celebrated orator in his day, whom Cicero had known and courted in his youth. His son Marcus, the triumvir's father, was a man of no capacity or reputation. He was gi in 74 the command of the fleet, and authority on
.

the coasts of the Mediterranean, with the view to the suppression of piracy, a task which he failed to accomplish. After attacking the Cretans without

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

cause, he was defeated, and died in Crete, receh in derision the surname of (

M. Antonius'

His brother Cains, luroamed Hyhrida, uncle, was impeaclied by

tin-

younger
In

J,

Caesar

d a. and in 70 76 for extortion in his province was expelled from the Senate. He was nevertln His Cicero's colleague in the consulship in f>;> patliies were with the Catilina pirators, tioni whom he was detached by a promise on the part of Cicero to resign to him the donia. This province he disgracefully plundered, and was prosecuted, being defended 1> tod island of n conviction he was banished to tin He was afterwards restored by Caesar Cephallenia. about 45. Cicero charges Antonius with his rimination against his uncle when be might used his influence in 49 with Caesar to recall him /. 2. 23 and Juvenal (8. the 38). name of Antonius with IX) label la and Verres as a notorious instance of provincial spoliati The Marcus Antenna whom Cicero attacks in the Philippics was brought up from a very early age in .tlicr .Julia's the household ot P. Leiitulu This man was implicated in second husband. the conspiracy of Catiline, and was put to death by Cicero in the consulship of the latter, a fact which, according to Plutarch (Ant. 2), was the cause In oil of Antonius* bitter hostility to tin orator. youth Antonius attached him the profligate C. Curio, an association which was, even in the Home of those days, a scandal (Phil. 2. 18); and in 58 he allied himself with P. C'lodius, the turbulent tribune of the commons. But a breach occurred between them, as Cicero hints, because of an intrigue
\

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

between him and Clodius' wife Fulvia, who afterTins wards became his own wife: Phil. 2. 19. notorious woman had had two huslmnds before she Antoniu and he irio sad ll.-dius; himself had been married twiee l>efore, to Fadii. tlie daughter ot Q dnian, and to his Pad D cousin Antoniu, whom he divorced to enable him and whom in the Senate, and in tin- pre m father, he accused of unchastitv
I

with Dolabella: Phil. 2.38. 58 to 65 Antonitis was with A. Gabinius in the East, and accompanied the Meg which restored Ptolemy Auletes to the throne of
i

Phil.

mili

-aul,

for a

and in th ayed 53 he was, on Caesar's fleets* d quaestor, and departed to Caesar as Cicero says (Phil. 2. 20), without wai* <, or law of the peofii
*J.
1

'.

ll

In

partition by lot of the provinces.

On

his return

ml he was in 49, by the help of Caesar, elected an augur, and also a tribune of the commons. In tin SUM year he, as tribune with a colleague issius, vetoed the decree of the Senate that Caesar ild, on pain of being declared a public enemy, army, Bl i ith Dg tlin to Caesar. Caesar th n crossed the Kubiron. A :\y Cicero charges it aga that, by his " pest o," he gave Caesar a pretext for civil war (Phit. 2. 22).
|

When,

after the flighl

ot

oso

Italy.

Caesar in 49 was proceeding to Spain to encounter his great rival's lieutenants, lie left Antonios in emnmandoftln- Italian Peninsula Antonius was present in 18 at a, where he commanded the left

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

wing of Caesar's army, and about in the e year, while Caesar was in Egypt ami Dictator for the second time, Antonint, though remaining Italy, was his master of the horse {Phil. 2. 25 and In 41 he 29), and managed the affairs of Italy. held the Consulship with Giesar, though Caesar had promised that ..tfice to Dolabc itooiut, l>< determined to have all power in Ins hands dur
\

Caesar's absence in tin

I'artlnan war.

had induced
1

nil

colleague to January 1 Caesar, by

I

on

way of compromise-, annum

absi this

alalia should be Antonioi threatened as augur to vitiate the election, and on some subsequent day attempt. (1 to do s<> b the omens were uiiprof.itious Phil. 2. 33. of the !>< election was one of the sul> t diteuifed <>n the 15th of March, hut Caesar's deat h rendered tin day, as Cicero says, abort It inav here be added that when tin: honours " more than mortal,'' as Suetom 76) says, decreed to Caesar the Senate gave him tin title of .Inj.it. r Julius (Dio 44. 6), A was appointed Ins Ha men, or special priest, hut bud not, during the period do consecrated by the augtn 19. v asks him whv he does not get himself consecrated, as "divine Julius" should
r

that,

dm

his

own

deputy-consul.

On

'

of the use of a became subsequently

in

literature

title

<

instance inch
;

the

Roman

Kmpcrors.


INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
II
I

of Much, the dictator! Hall of PomptltU at the foot of his brandishing great rival's statue, the r bloody daggers and calling on the name of the Scnr Cicero, passed ded by I of lil>< rt\ faced t the end of a spear. They to all tli.at they had slain I and a tyrant. In tin- meantime If, A ntonius, Caesar's colleague in the consulship, whom TreboniiM Cicei PkU % \\ l>y collusion had prevent from being present in the Senate, escaped to his Dae in the disguise of a slave. The conspirators, being received in silence by the efied populace, and being uncertain of the tude of L pulus, Caesar's master of the horse, #bi n landed a legion outside the walls, and of Caesar's veteran^ in the city, retreated to the Capitol to the D of a troop of gladiators whom I). Brutus bind on the pretence of games. The same afternoon, or the next da d to the in and Brutus harangued the people. He was ilv hut coldly received hut the pi a, and Dolabella, who, to o ppoatttoil to Antoi had so far attached himself to the popular cause, by their intemperat reti rences to Caesar roused the dace to fury, and the crestfallen itors n returned to the Capitol. Towards nightfall ne T> 1 Cicero and other prominent ni< Brutus and his associates, and ( icero advised that the etofa, Brutus and Cassius, one consul being dead, and the other, Antoamna, having disnon the Senate to the Capitoline pie lor the following day, but he was overruled

When, on
dead

the

lfith

fell

in tht*

1 1

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

and he was urged to approach Antonius and to ei hort him to defend the republic. But Cicero reft saying that Anton: u> would, wink* he was in pnmiiM iiiiuluiii:, but. when tlu- fear was r< A would Ik- himself again (PkiL 2. 35). left the Capitol a deputation was sent to Antonius and In reply Antonius agreed to sumand mon the Senate for the 17th, and he named as the place of meeting the Temple of Tellus near his own
fi
I

house.
In the meantime Antonius had on tin- night uf the 15th possessed himself, with the consent ot Calpurnia, the dead man's widow, of 4000 talents of Caesar's treasure, and of his private papers. And on the lith, by the aid of his br aius the praetor and Lucius the tribune, he witln: from the public treasure in the Temple of Ops the sum of 700,000,000 sesterces. About the same time, by pro: in the Pontificate, he came to an agreement with Lepulus, who had on the 10th occupied the I oi um with his troops, with a view to consolidating their mutual interests. On the 17th, in the Temple of Tell; of the !," as he pirators being present. "the foundations of the republic" by proposing, ,r supporting a general amnesty, and the continuation of Caesars acts; and on the 18th the > being overawed by the swordsmen whom Antonius had posted hard by, and many of them being personally interested in Caesar's appointments. Which would be void if the Dictator were declared an usurper, formally confirmed his acts, including his .ruments of provinces, viz. Cisalpine Gaul to D. Brutus, Macedonia to M. Brutes, Syria to C. CasHithynia to Tillius Cimber, and Asia to Trebonius.
I

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
The
from the Capitol,

conspirators were then invited to come down whuh they did on receiving as tges for their safety sons of Antonius and LrpuJus. That same evening, in token of reconcilia >up|>ed with Lepidus and Cassius with

At the same

on the motion of Calpurnius

funeral granted.

session of the Senate it was resolved, Piso, Caesar's father-in

law, that his will should be published

and a public

The will, by which the Roman people was largely benefited, was afterwards read in the Forum Then came the public funeral, a concession fatal to the iots, as Atticus said to Cicero (ad Alt. 14. 10).
The pyre had been constructed in the Field of Mars near the tomb of the Dictator's daughter Julia. In the funeral itself nothing was left undone by WM playing upon the feelings of the populace, and of producing the highest dramatic effect. The body, clad in the gown worn on the 15th, was laid upon couch covered with an embroidered gold and purple pall, which was borne by the noble>' the State. By way of emphasising the dead man's divinity, a cha|>el modelled on that of Venus .tutrix, h Caesar had founded, was erected in front of the Rostra. Appropriate lines from Pacuvius and
(

Attilius
Jul. 84.

were aMnted to solemn music "to ex miseration and hatred of the murder": Suet.

Antonius, as consul, delivered the funeral oration, which be recited Caesar's achievements. He reled the |>eopIe that the Senate had declared his I to be nniolable. Then, by way of contrast, he exhibited the dead man's g< <1 by threeand-twenty dagger wounds. Roused to a pitch of
in
<


INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
frenzy, the
1

mob msJstod that tin body should be horned there end then within the walls, the idea that sedu!"Usl_v fostered by Antonio * the .it y should be hollowed end secured by
i

walls the tomb of tutelar? This was, as Merivale (n. to Abek< di\inity. " it, Caesar's "inchoate Cic. p. 385) p Accordingly the people piled up chi tables and benches on MM uEool was hard by
Ittaing
irithin
its

the Temple ofGsstor and Pollux, and tl the body was plae d. a funeral pile youths*: carrying javelins, whom I words and sup6ed with (*ast.r and Pollux, applied the torch. .bcs, tinM aped on the pii veterans their arms, and the women their Oman* and even tin rena trinkets: Suet. Cars. 84. Then, snatching the burning brands troin the the in. .1) attacked the houses of tin- principal But ( tors, but were held at take tor the poet, a partisan of Caesar, wa Cinna the praetor, torn limb from hml>, and tinwas house of L. Bellienus, a Pec S
I

I)

ii

burned to the ground Phil. 2. 84 outbursts Cic es to the and he goes on t< t Anton duct subsequently, as when he proposed that the dictatorship should be a!>olished, and that att r the loth of March no immunity or grant of Caesar's should be advertised, thus, as it were, "wiping off the soot of the funeral ibid,). At the beginning of April an impostor, calling
:
|

1 The prcten.: <>f the two was no <1< to overcome a superstitious repugnance to cremation within the walls : n. to Mer. Bom. Emp. c. 23.

IO

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
fore of kin to Caesar, Init

himself a descendant of the great Marius. and therewho was, in fact, a horsellus or Ainatius, appeared in

Rome.

He had

pitnriooslj

\ith

the populace during Caesar's absence on his Spanish campaign, and had, on the D return, been r 0J that still lingered round the scene of the cremation as a
nt of and an altar in trout <>t' the column of Nuinidian marble twenty feet high which the people had h the wordi "To th ountry. " At this altar lie persuaded the and make sacrifices to people ko pour Hut Caesar as to a god. quelled the ex'. and put t! ler to death With
h.l\

Unlabel la, in An ton his' absence, the eolama and altar, and lescllcd the site (Phil. 1. 2), which was the object at Anfeonfoi' n, says Cicero (/' the ro dates Uolabella's defec patriotic party. He suggests that Uol abella was intimidated b\ A r to 15) he says that
1

pulled

down

<

>

for I

deserted

it.

republic, he, but. as far as he

bribe he say was carried out by gery of Caesar's order on the Treasury. Aboi riddle <>f April AntonJoj lefi Bone id the execution of a measure for the to si <>f lands assig in Campania and elsewhere unoi ins, and to win them to his cause ad Att. 11. L'l This measure had been prop by his brother Lucius the tribune, and carried by
this
U.

And
14.

18)

II

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
violence, and in
5.
tinit

11. 6),
:

and

midst of thunderstorm (Phil. was afterwards repealed by tin-

Senate Phil. 6. 5. Under it seven co were to be appointed, of which Antoinus and bll brother Lucius were two. During tins progress through Campania he attempted illegally to found colonies at Capua and Casilinum, where eoloi had already in 59 been settled by (Caesar, and was roughly handled l>\ the CapuanSj whe tjeeled tinhim new settlers (Phil. 2.39, 12. 3). ( of dividing the Campanian land and Leontine in Sicily MDOng Ins boon companions and fcl gamblers, and other disreputable persons, among
1

whom his rhetor S jugera, and his doctor 3000

and
in

r<
(

ived
17
L.

exaggerated language speaks of

1

and Anton

the proposer of the agrarian law (Phil. 5. 3), and Nucula and Lento (Phil. 1. 6), two of the sioners, as " parcellers of all It, By the middle of April tie chief cot all left the city. D. Brute* had gone to take up ins government of Cisalpine Gaol, fimhei kq Hithvnia, and Trebonius to Asia (ad Alt. 14. 10 and The chief actors in Caesar's assassination, 13). Brutus and Cassius, had left Rome finally about this time, probably in consecpn-mc of the confusion caused by the pseudo-Marius but they lingered for unabb from peril to months in its vicinit their lives, to perform the duties of the praetorship, and at the same time unable to take up the provim ial governments of Macedonia and Syria which they claimed respectively till the expiration of their term Off office. In the meantime their proceedings were marked by weakness and irresolution. About the 8tt of June Cicero had a conference with them at Antium.
;

-.

12

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

Writing to Atticus (ad Atl. 15. 11), he says "he found the ship broken, or rather shattered to pieces/' and in the proceedings of the two -neither judghey ldt Italy finally ment, system, nor or<!' about August, having first issued a joint edict to the effect that they were willing, if it conduced to the peace of the republic, to live in perpetual exile, and that thev would give no occasion for civil
:

war:

Veil.

same month of April a new actor appeared upon the scene, the young Octavius Caesar, tin great-nephew and adopted son of the Dictator, and the heir under In-, will. At the time of the assassinahe had been pursuing his studies at Apollonit Macedonia hi the receipt of the news of in Caesar's murder he determined to put his fortune to the test, in spite of the warnings of his mother Atia and of his step-father Philippus against his assumption of so dangerous an inheritance. Land tag at Lupia,an obscure town in the neighbourhood of Brundisium, he assumed the name of ( Julius Caesar ()( \ianus, and presented himself,
In the
<

as his adoptive father's heir, to the legions at that place. They received him with acclamation, and him their support. But Octavian as he Id now be called had adopted the role for the present of moderation, and declined their offers. On the 18th he met Cicero at Puteoli, and treated hun with the utmost consideration and respect. As he advanced towards Rome the party of his adherents swelled but he repressed the zeal of tin wterans uho flocked to him offering to avenge the death of their old general. On his arrival at Borne he notified the Senate of his claim as Caesar's hcanvassed the Senators, and harangued the people
!

'3

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
in

to

support of the lex curiata which make his adoption le_

\\

Both to Senate and to people be Caesar's legacies. pleaded only his filial di and his gratitude for the bene d upon him. were carefully (<mcr.il. All ult! from the city, and Antonius was at the t,did oil return to Rome until the middle of M
which he did.
as Cicero lays (PkiL 2. 42) " in battle to bj (>cta\ ian tor the
1

moneys the Dictator had left behind him, to enable him to pay the legacies lie had promised to dis
char returned the insolent reply that moneys, and bad been the moneys wer< fcvet, that Octaviau was ungrateful in asking for them, inasmuch as it was through Antonius himself that the will had been ratified at all. Octavian thereupon, by borrowing money ami by his friends, made good the contribu
obli

ben
h he further

bj

additional

pepnlai

enhanced by agree m- to beet tinthe de cost of the shows to be of the Temple of Venus Genitril which Caesar had Antonius did bowed on the morning of Pharsalia his l>est to ham|>er Octavian by delaying, by means of tribune-, the paflrihg of the Ic.v urmta, and in other ways but. being reminded by his own tro re the MU that hi> cause and thai viz. the avengement of Caesars murder, he made with liis opponent a hollow truce. This was in June

wlm

or July.

Antonius had before this entirely discarded tinit had been at first his policy to assume. On the plea of self-protection he had extorted from the Senate permission to keep a

mask of moderation

14

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

This he raised to the number of 6000 bodyguard. nicked meOj i number which, in ^pite of the protests And by the of the Senate, he would not reduce. s estate and the public treasure he had March 16 out of the Temple of Ops, he had paid his debts, so that, as Cicero says (Phil '2. OB that date 40,000,000 sesHe also te was on the 1st of April solvent. won Dolaln-lla as a supporter by the paynnnt of hi^ <lel>ts. Ami l>v his possession of Caesars papers and B of Caesar's former secretary Faberius gory of " Caesar's he was able to bring within tin acts " proposals that suited his own purj>oses, even And he and his wife it of forgery. Pelvis carried on a lively traffic by the sale of from taxation, even provinces, fran< lT II the LeOSef Armenia, which he sold to K And to the Sicilians he tarus, and Crete. granted the freedom of the city so that, as Cicero says (Phi/. 1. 2), bv the 1st of June Ins conduct had
.

'

illy

cliai

the city with armed For fear of their lives, neither Cicero, nor Brutus, nor Cassias, nor the of the Senators dared to attend : P He instigated Dol ibella to ask the Senate for the Syria, together with the command ofl itended for the Parthian war; and, the Senate being unwilling, as the province had been assign- <1 to Cassius by Caesar, and the assignment rmed on March 18, Ahtoniui procu red it from tin people by a law. 1 On the 5th he obtained from the Senate for himself tin province of Macedonia,
that day.
tilled

On

BMDj he summoned the Senate.

Mayor (Intr. to 2nd Phil. s. 47), however, says that D. had obtained the province aa early aa An
5

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

which had been similarly assigned to M. Br u tot r, was About the same day Brutus, the C and to by a law granted formal leave of absence him and Cassius was given a commission to prot corn, with authority in certain districts on M thdr Mediterranean, a charge meant absence from Italy, and also by way of insult, for, as Cicero writes {ad Ait. 15. 10), " what duty could be meaner ? " Antonius afterwards, perhaps in July, by bribery of the tribunes, and "itli the a of Octavian, obtained from the people 'i their tribes the province of Cisalpine Gaul in flSclMM Macedonia, the Senate having refused to sanction It was the resistance the exchange App. 3. 30.
;
I

D. Brutus to this transfer that btOUghfl lb <""

civil

tli

Antonius on November 28 ol Macedonia from the Senate for his brother Caius
war.
Phil. 3. 10.

The next event

in chronological

sequence wa
I

plays and shows, which began on July 6. was the duty of M. Brutus, as City Praetor, to exhibit Brutus being absent in the island of Nesis off the coast of Campania, they were held under the presidency of Antonius' brother Caius. The play was the Tereus of Accius in which the references to tyranny were received with unbounded aj called by Cicero (Phil. 1. 15) "the jud<: the Roman people." But in a letter to Attn us (16. 2)

"he is all the more indignant that the people were using their h t in defending the State, but in clapping pla In this posture of affairs Cicero, despairing of anything salutary being done, at least until the new consuls, Hirtius and Pansa, entered upon office on January 1 of the next year, 43 b.c, deter16
he
says,

Roman

IMROIHi HON TO PHILIPPIC

d
to

make his long-contemplated voyage to 'where he voold Ml hear sjf the deeds nor the fame of the Pelopidae." With this in Dolahclla had on June 4 appointed him his honorary Ueutfinni, an apjvmntment which entitled without an y duties Cicero to tra\ PkiL 1.2; ad Att. 15. 11. in Pom pen <>n the 16th of July, Cicero and reached Leucosailed do torn there hr petra, a promont<r\ near Rhe^i After a crossed to Syracuse on the 1st of August. I set sail for Greece, but was Here y contrary winds to Leucopetra. 'ceived news of the farew Brutus and them to the conCass us, and of a letter m sulate and ex-praetors begging their attendance at a ,l>er; he meeting of the Senate on tli. 1st also heard there was great hope that Antonius would come to an agreement with them, would resign his in to Cisalpine (iaul, and would submit to the blu-an party would be able to Senate; that return, and that his own absence was regretted and somewhat criticised ad Att. 16. 7. In the meantime Brutus and Cassius had demanded a definite release from their obligations, as praetors, to remain in BoOM during their term of office, and had asked Antonius to summon the Senate with the view of a decree to that cfTect. Antonius named the 1st of August Many of the The consulars who had fled therefore returned Mg was chiefly remarks lie violent attack Hut in a Calpurnius Piso made ujw>n Antonius. ^nate Piso found no supporter: PhU. 1. 6.
.

,,

Brutus nor Cassius ventured to be

1

pre*

Sae anU,

p.

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
On

this occasion Antonius seems to have made a violent speech, to which, on the 4th, Brutus and Cassius reply in a fierce but impot III (ad Fam. 11. 3) saying that " threats had

M
I

fluen^e on free men," and advising An consider, " not how long Caesar lived, but how

a time he reigned*" On hearing what the messengers told him, abandoned his voyage. On the 17th he saw Brutus He at Velia, and heard of Piso's speech on the 1st. rowds. entered Rome on the 31st amid eh But he did not attend the Senate, which had summoned on the 1st of September. pl< fatigues of his journey. He wished, nod u a breach with Antonius until the latter bad Moreover, it was known that Aiitmiius his hand. intended to proj>ose " that on the occasion of every thanksgiving for public successes a special day should be appropriated for offerings to the deified Caesar": Phil. 1. 6; 2. 43. And such a proposal Cicero regarded as impious. In the debate Antonius furiously attar for his absence, and threatened to send breakers to pull down his house as a penalty for his defection. On the next day, Antonius departed to Tibur, his colleague Dolabella moned the Senate. The orator then oi uber2 delivered the first Philippic.
I I i

began by giving the reasons for his departure He had departed becaii preferred rather to hear of what went on at than to see it. What had happened was that. whereas Antonius on the 17th of Man for some time after, had been studiously moderate

He

and

for his return.

I,

iS

INTKOhl
and conciliatory

TO PHILIPPIC

in his policy, had not abused of Caesar's papers, had restored no exiles. abolished the dictatorship, and had np pressed disorder (condut t whieh his colleague Dolabella had i-ntly followed). 1st of June v tiange. was PC had been a cot done through the Senate, but all through the people in tbeftr tnl>es, and even against its will. consuls elect dared not come into ite; the UbermtOfl <t their country were exiles from the and the veterans were incited to hope for He hid r< -turned because he had been SpoiL .1 be com* that an a^ th.it betv tonius ai liberators, and the Senate. reded to protest against the honours to He he paid to Caesar's memory, as l>eing impious. U his speech >n the laj q| An. ll< and regretted that he found no su| that Caesar's acts 1 should be ratified, hut mises or casual memoranda were not " acts "
^
.

least of all should An tonius have upset posr laws. He ends with an These he enumerates.
ap(>eal to

Antonius and Dolabella to line ition over their fellow mself, he had already proved his constancy, ure he would not fail. The speeeli throughout is studiously moderate, runs public actl only to the exand atti< ion of all strictures on his private conduct. The orator had not yet thr the gage of combat. That was reserved for the second spe

Such aa

his edicts,

nomination of magistrates, assign-

of provinces,

and executive acts generally.

9

M.

TULLI CICERONIS IN M

W ionium
\

ORATIO PHIUPPICA PRIM

1
I.

ea,

Antequam de re publica, jwitres conscripti, dicam quae dicenda hoc tempore arbitror, expo

vobis breviter consilium et profectionis et rv

meae.
catam,

Ego cum sperarem aliquando ad

vest

rum

consilium auctoritatemque rem pubhrara esse revo-

quadam

manendum mihi statuebam quasi in vigilia Nee vero usquam consulari ac senatoria.

discedebam nee a re publica deiciebam oculos ex In eo die, quo in aedem Telluris convocati sumus. quo templo, quantum in me fuit, ieci fundaments pacis Atheniensiumque renov.i\i retni cxnnplum Graecum etiam verbum usurpavi, quo turn in sedandis discordiis usa erat civitas ilia, atque oinnem memoriam discordiarum oblivione sempiterna de;

lendam censui. Praeclara turn oratio M Antom. egregia etiam voluntas ; pax denique per earn et per liberos eius cum praestantis-imis civibus confirmata est.

Atque

his principiis reliqua

consentiebant.

Ad

deliberationes eas, quas habebat

principes civitatis adhibebat
;

optimas deferebat
1

nihil turn,

domi de re publica, ad hunc ordinem res nisi quod erat notum

duvTXTTia or &8cia (amnesty).

10

THE

FIRST PHILIPPIC OF M. TULLIUS

I

AGAINST

M.

ANTONIUS

Before I make those remarks, Conscript I. Fathers, on public affairs which I think should be made at tins time, I will explain briefly the reason While I both of my departure and of my return. hoped that the Commonwealth had at length again submitted itself to your judgment and authority, I determined that, as consular and as Senator, I was bound' to remain as it were on guard. Indeed I her departed anywhere nor diverted my eye from public affairs from the day when we were convened in the Temple of Tellus. In that temple laid, to the best of my power, the foundations I neace, and recalled the old precedent of the mans; I even adopted the Greek phras< that State employed in mitigation of discord, and ;>osed that every memory of discord should be led out in everlasting oblivion. The speech Marcus A n ton us made that day was a noble one his good will too was conspicuous ; in a word, it was igh him and his sons that peace was established
i

most

illustrious citizens.

And To the

with these beginnings the sequel agreed. deliberations he held at his house on public affairs he invited the chief men of the State; to our body he made the most favourable reports nothing then but what was known to all men was

21

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

iur; omnibus, in C. Caesaris commentariis r summa constantia ad ea, quae quaesita erant, re3

spondebat.
aiebat,

Num

qui

exules

restitutio

Inum

praeterea
Sulpicio,

neminem.

Num

uninunil

datae.

" Nullae," respondebat.

Adsenti

nos Ser.
aut

d
Martins

ne qua
allim
\

tabula post
beneficii

Idus

decreti

Caesaris
>,

eaque Multa figeretur. ad singulare enim M. Intool factum Dictaturam, quae iam vim regiae festinat oratio. potestatis obsederat, f'unditus ex re publica sustulit
praeclara;
(iixiiii!

de qua re ne sententias quidem

senatus consultum, quod
recitato
fieri

ptom

vellet, attu

auctoritatem

eius

summo

studio fid

sumuseique amplissimis verbis per senatus consul turn

gratias egimus.
i

II.

Lux quaedam videbatur oblata non modo

regno, quod pertuleramus, sed etiam regni timore

magnumque pi gnus ab eo rei publicae datum, se liberam civitatem esse velle, cum dictit nomen, quod saepe iustum fuisset, propter perpetuae dictaturae recentem memoriam funditus ex re
sublato,
5 publica sustulisset.

Liberatus periculo caedis paucis

post diebus
illi,

qui in

uncus inpactus est fug; Mari nomen invaserat. Atque haec

senatus;
quae,
nisi
; alia porro propria collega afuisset, credo

omnia communiter cum collega

Dolabellae,
futura
fuisse

communia.

Nam cum
:

serperet
A.'s h

1 S. Clodius. the brother of the tribune C. in Epp. ad Att. 14. 13.

cf.

22

PHILIPPIC

I.

i.

2-n. 5
;

aj found in Caius Caesar's note-books with the greatest decision he replied to the questions put to Were any exiles recalled ? One, 1 he said; him. Were an\ lodj. He, he n wished us to assent to tli< a man of great distinction, that ice of any decree or grant Much, and that exaesar's should be posted. ere is one particular act pass o\ at once. of Marcus Antonius which I most The dictatorship, which had already usurped the f regal authority, he abolished utt 'ie State; about that we did not even debate. He brought in draft the decree he wished passed, s was read we followed his rccommendaand passed e greatest en' a vote of thanks in the most complimentary terms. II It seemed almost as if light had been shed upon us, now there had been removed rely despotism that we had endured but also the dread and a great assurance had been given wish that it tk Tree, to the Sta in that he had utterly abolished the title of dictator an office often established by law on account of men's recollection of the perpetual A few days after, the Senate was relieved f> peri e slave who had ied the name of Marius was executed. And all these things were done jointly with his colleague; other things afterwards were Dolabclla's own acts, yet I believe tint. bad labclla's colleague been al>sent, they would have been the j<int acts of the two. For when an illimitable evil
, t
1

Mm

*3

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

urbe infinitum

malum idque

miinarct
ct
ini

in

idemque bustum

in foro faccrent, qui

col

illam inscagis

pultam sepulturam effecerant, magisque perditi homines cum

sio

similibus servis

tectis ac templis urbis minitarentur, talis

fuit

animad\

Dolabellae
illius

cum

in

audacis sceleratoaque

servos, turn in

impuros et nefarios liberos, talisque

eversio

execratae columnae, ut mihi minim videatur tam valde reliquuni U-inpus ab illo uno die
dissensisse.

Ecce enim Kalendis Iuniis, quibus ut adesscmus edixerant, mutata omnia nihil persenatmn, inulta et magna per populum et absente populo et in. Consules designati negabant se audere in senatum
;

venire

patriae liberatores urbe carebant ea, cuius

a cervicibus iugum servile dei< ipsi consules in contionibus et in

laudabant.

quo* tamen omni sern

Veterani qui appellabantur, (juilms hie nem ordo diligentissime caverat, non ad cot earum rerum, quas habebant, sed ad spem novarum praedarum incitabantur. Quae cum audire mall cm quam videre haberemque ius legationis liberum, ea

mente
7

discessi, ut

adessem Kalendis Ianuariis, quod

initium senatus cogendi fore videbatur.

III.

Exposui, patres conscripti, profectionis

;

silium

nunc

reversionis,

quae plus

adin

1 An altar fronting a column twenty feet high of Numidian marble, built on the site of Julius Caesar's pyre by the mob, with the inscription, "To the father of his country" cf. Suet. Jul. 85; Dio 44. 51 : and Intr. to this speech. 2 Probably an allusion to the illegality of Caesar's cremation within the walls, and to the riots attending it.
:

24

PHILIPPIC

I.

ii.

5-ui. 7

was creeping into the State, and spreading day by and when the same men were day building an altar in I m who had carried out burial that was no burial, 2 and when daily more and more scoundrels, together with slaves like themselves, were threatening the dwellings and temples ity, so signal was the nth 11 and rascally slaves, hut also on debauched and wicked freemen, and so apt was his upsetting of that accursed column, that it seems ton greatly the time llowed differed from that one look you Kalends of June, on which us to sit, all was changed
.

<

rough the Senate, much and and done through the he absence of the people and against its will. consuls elect said thev dared not cone Into Senate; rators of their country exiles from a whose neck they k off the yoke of slavery, while none the less consuls themselves, l>oth n. mgs and dk, were passing eulogies cm. Those that claimed the name of veterans, for whom
that Im portant

was

were pos sesse d

to

body had been most carefully solicitous, not to preserve what they already hope for new plunder. As 1
i ,
;

hear of these things rather than to see id an honorary commission as legate, I departed with the Intention of being at home Kalends of January, which seemed the first v date for a meeting of the Senate. III. I have set forth, Conscript Fathers, the reason rture: now I will briefly set forth the for n
1

'5

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

habet, breviter exponam. Cum Brun. illud, quod tritum in Graecia vitavissem, Kalendis Sextilibus ven -

ausa
sas,

quod

ab ea urbe transmissio in Graeciam quae tamen urbs mihi coniuncti.s>

laudabn

nocte cupiens retinere non potuit. meus repentinus ad meos necessarios adventus
picionis aliquid adferret,

autem me ex promunturium

Sicilia

si essem commoratus. ad Leucopetram, quod

est

agri

Regini, venti detulissei

lniiltmu

loco conscendi, ut transmitterem, nee ita

provectus reiectus austro

8

esset unde conscenderam. mansissemque in villa P. Valeri, comitis et t mei, postridieque apud eundem ventum ea manerem, municipes Regini com pi u res ad D runt, ex iis quidam Roma recentes aquibui primula accipio M. Antoni contionem, quae mihi it.t ut ea lecta de reversione primum coeperim cogii Nee ita multo post edictum Bruti adfertur et ( quod quidem mihi, foi*tasse quod eos plus
;
i

sum in eum Cumque intempesta nox

i

publicae

quam

familiaritatis

gratia diligo,

pl<

aequitatis videbatur.

Addebant praeterea
qui

(fit CJ

plerumque, ut
laetius)

ii,

boni quid
faciant
;

volunt adferre,

adfingant aliquid, quo

id,

quod nunt
fre-

rem conventuram Kalendis senatum quentem fore Antonium repudiatis malis suasor
;

remissis provinciis Galliis ad auctoritatem sen I esse rediturum.

1

Autouius had four legion there.

26

PHILIPPIC
reason
ri

I.

m. 7-8

for
t.
1

my
end

Having
the

return which has created more not without cause avoided

Hrundisium,

ece,
o(
S
>

DM

<>n

kalmds
..

to Syracuse, since

[passage

from that

est ties,

detn
len

recce was well sp< though allied to mc 1>\ the could not, though it wished to do so, than one night I feared that
I

suspicion had
district of

am. a among my friends might cause some stayed. Now the wind having carried
I

y to Leucopetra, a prom<

the

Rhegtg

rom that place to

hut I had not proceeded so very far was Mowtfl beesi t.. the rerj pin h had embarked It was the dead of (1 1 stayed at the villa of Tuhlms Valerius, an id of mine; end on the next day. while nained in the same friend's house waiting for a several townsn 1. me, among them some recently from Rome I first heard of Marcus A ntonius' ha ran;: so pleased me th.v had reed t began
cross over;

when

ink of

Vnd not so long

after, the e

and Cassius arrived, which per: iuse more on eds than because of private friendshipseemed indeed to me abou messengers added besides for it often happens that those who wish to bring good news invent somewhat to make their message would be re would lie a full

iate

thai
..ces,

advisers,

and return to allegiance to the Sen

*7

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

IV. Turn vero tanta sum cupiditate inccnsus ad reditum, ut mihi nulli neque remi neque \< satis facerent, non quo me ad tempus ocv non putarem, sed ne tardius, quam cupei Atque ego cel< publicae gratularer. devectus Rrutum vidi, quanto meo dolore, non t! Turpe mihi ipsi videbatur in earn urbem me audere reverti, ex qua Brutus cederet, Neque vero il posset. esse, ubi ille non similiter, atque ipse eram, commotum ease Erectus enim maximi ac pulclwrrimi fncti sui conscientia nihil de suo casu, multa de vestr< Exque eo primuin cognovi, quae 10 batur. Sextilibus in senatu fuisset L. Pisonis oral
9
<

quamquam parum

erat (id

enim

11

audieram), a quibus debuerat, adiutus, tamen et Bruti testimonio (quo quid potest esse gravius ?) et omnium praedicatione, quos postea vidi, maj." II mihi videbatur gloriam consecutus. ir ut sequerer, properavi, quern praesentes noi non ut proficerem aliquid (nee enim sperabam Id nee praestare poteram), sed ut, si quid mihi lum tus accidisset (inulta autem inpendere videntur praeter naturam etiam praeterque fatum), bi tamen diei vocem testem rei publicae relfaMRM meae perpetuae erga se voluntatis. Quoniam utriusque consilii causam, patres
1

The
Gell

assassination of Caesar.

(13. 1) takes " praeter naturam " as referring to a and unexpected death, and, with regard to "praeter fatum," suggests that the words are the Homeric !ntp ^6 ? ov
2

violent

(e.g. in II. 2. 155; Od. 1. 34), the idea being that the ordinary course of fate may be influenced by human conduct, or other event see Hay man's n. to Od. 5. 436 ; cf also Suet. Jul. 89
:

28


I'HII.IITK
IV.
I

iv.

(y-ii

Then

truly
i

was

return that
It

that

Mich eagerness to winds were b thought I should not arrive in

fired with
n>

eagerness to congratulate And then, after a rapid passage to Velia, I saw Brutus with what sorrow on my part I do not say. To me personally it seemed disgraceful that 1 should dare to return rue Brutus was departing, and be to that here in safety where he was unable Hut indeed I did not find urbed as to be. was myself. For, uplifted by tin* consciousness I of his supreme and n he made no
that

my

might

suflr

<

yours. And "iso's learned what had been speeeh in the >< the Kalends of Sextilis. ii.i'l Ih supported this very fact I had heard from Brutus by those from whom support was due, yet stimony of Brutus ami what can be more a that? and according to the report of all whom I afterwards saw, he appeared to me to have achieved great glorj i. therefore, to support him whom those that I could do any good: I did not expert that, nor was I able to do hiit order, if anything that may befall tnity had happened to and much seems to be in % even beyond the course of nature and that of destiny * I might leave my voice this day as a witness to the State of my undying good will towards it As I trust I have made good to you, Con
I

first

me

(of

ach of Caeaar'a murderer)

" nse mta morU dtfunchu

e$t,

where #*" maaos ordinary.

MARCUS TULLIUS
scripti,

CI

probatam vobis esse confido, re publica dicere Indpio, pauca querai Antoni iniuria cui sum aiuici;
|

UNI nullo
in

eius officio debere esse prae me sem V. Quid tandem erat causae, car

hesterno die tain acerbe coherer ? an non saepe minus frequentes agebatur, ut etiain aegrotos d< Hannibal, credo, erat ad portas, ai agebatur, ad quam causam etiam

ca res pace

caecum
12 est.

De

et senem delatum esse memoriae supplicationibus referebatui quo

.

honor* a_ triumpho refcrtur. sine curaconsulessunt, ut paene liberun non adesse. Qui cum mihi mos notus esset, e via languerem et mihimet amicitia, qui hoc ei dice ret At ille vobis aud
gratia,

G>'. senatores deesse non solent. pignoribus, sed eorum, de quorum

quod idem

tit,

cum

<!<

Ita

cum

fabris se

domum meam venturum

esse d

Nimis iracuude hoc quidem et valde Intemperaater. Cuius enim maleticii tanta ista poen hoc ordine auderet se publicis opens disturbaturum publice ex senatus sententia aed Quis autem umquam tanto damno senatorem <.>
1

A. had spared C.'s

life

at Brundisiura a

it

tie of

Pharsalia.
8 When a Senator was summoned to the Senate and neglected or refused to attend, something wai taken his house, and retained till he obeyed; or he coul
:

fined.

On C.'s exile his houRe on the Palatine waa d< enemy, the tribune Clodius, and the site dediea Goddess Liberty. On his return the State rebuilt U Epp. ad Alt. 4. 2.
3

his

30

PHILIPPIC

I.

i%.

n-v

12
I

Father-, tbe reason for the

t

two courses

took,

will

now, before I bejjiii to speak on public affairs, make a brief complaint of Jay by Anton us, whose friend I am and, because of certain good offices 1 I owe him, have ever so professed
I

ask you, was the reason why I was In he Senate yesterday? <>r have you not often been m I alone absent less number? or was the point at issue sin h v men should have been carried Ik Hannibal, I fancy, was at the gates, or a peace with Pyrrhus was at issue, and to that debate history
A hat,
I

*t terms

even Appius was carried when The U IIClUon in debate was a ng, and in such a scussion f Senate are is as a r \% < forced to attend, not by securities,towards those whose honours are iscussed, and the same thing happens when a triumph
Bl that
I

blind

and

old.

\.

<

i .

i 1

consuls are so reli a anxiety that it is almost free to a Senator not to attend. As was known to me, and since I was ..!. fatigued after my journey, ar sent
I!>e
I

But he would come to my house >e-breakers a very angry thre.i' and extremely IntempenAi what off' here entailing a punishment so severe that he could dare to say in the presence of this body that he wo demolish by State workmen a house built at public expense by a decree of the Senate ? f Who ever by so great a penalty put force upon a Senator? or what penalty is there beyond forfeiture of secun
in

way

to inforn
said

this faet.

he, in

y<<

_r.

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

quid est ultra pignus aut quam senU-ntiau dicturus ess< 13 aliquid profecto de sevcritate cogendi.
aut
I

scisset,

VI.

An me

censetis, |>atres

inviti secuti estis,

decreturum

fuisse,

talia

cum

supplicationibus miscerentur, ut religiones Id rem publicam indue nerentur supplicationes raortuo? nihil Fuerit ille Brutus, qui et ipse don puidicam liberavit et ad limilem virtu

di0,

duL

factum stirpem iam prope in quingenU propagavit; adduci taiiicii DOO poatesij ut quemq

mortuum coniungerem cum

religione, ut, cuius

deoi
.

Bepulcbmin osqus

ubi

publics snppHcetw sententiam dixisu -m, ut me adversus populum manura, si qui accidisset gravim- rei publwae casus, si bellum, si morbus, si fames, facile po defendere, quae partim inpendeant. Sed hoc ignoscaut di imn et populo Romano, qui id non probat, et liu 14 qui decrevit invitus. Quid? de reliquis rei publicae mal dicere? Mihi vero licet et semj

parentetur,

ei

tatem

tueri,

mortem contemners
|

I'oU-stas

modo

veniendi

non
1

hunc locum sit, dicendJ recuso. Atque utinam,

in

perictllua

Kalendis Sextilibus

adesse

potuissem

non

quo

public festival in honour of dead relatives, whose spirits (Di Manes) needed pro; )fferings were taken to their tombs, and sacrifices made, and the days of the festival were rrligiosi. C's argument is that to contuse such a festival addressed to the dead with a thanksgiving for a general's success addressed directly to the Gods involved impiety.
(

The Parentalia was a

32

PHILIPPIC
or a fine
v
?

I.

v.

12-vi. 14

But had he known what opinion I was he would assuredly have relaxed somewhat of the vigour of his enforcenn
to express
\
I

Do j

think, Conscript Fathers, that I would mi unwillingly passed,

<* dead should be con that religious 1 thanksg ild be introduced into the l>able of ex piState? that thanksgivings should be decreed m >ur of a dead man? 1 say not of whom. Let that man be the Brutus who in his own person crcd the State from regal despotism and who s has left descendants well-nigh for five bun to show similar virtue and to achieve a similar deed ; lid not have been induced to associate any dead man with the religion of the Immortal Gods so that a public thanksgiving should be made fof him while a tomb existed anywhere at which offerings could be made. 1 No I would have given such a vote as would enable me easily to justify myself to e if any more serious calamity had happened to the State, war, pestilence, famine

that a

calamities which already exist in

are,
I

|>art,
I

and
t

in part

pray may grant their paroon, l>oth to the people which disapproves and to this our body that decreed it
fear.

Imp

odinsr.

But

for this

'y-

But to resume. Am I permitted to speak of the remaining ills of the State? permit, and shall always |> f to protect my reputation, to despise death. Only let me have the power of coming c, the peril of speaking i do not shrink And would I had been able, ( Fathers, to be present on the Kalends of S
I

33

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

profici potuerit aliquid,
sularis,

sed

ne unus
dignoi

modo
ill-

con-

quod

turn

tccidit,

magnum
populi

dignus re publica inveniretur. Qua quidem ex re homines ampli^ accipio dolorem,

Romani beneficiis usos L optumae sententiae non secutos.

populus Romanus consules fedt, ut
dignitatis locati
in

Idrircone

nos

altissimogradu

rem puhlicam pro

nihilo

haberemus?
ista

Non modo
15 vultu

voce

nemo

L. Pisoni consularis, sed ne

est.

quidem adsensus
servitus?

Quae, malum, est

voluntaria

Fuerit
iis

quaedam

necessaria

neque ego hoc ab omnibus tiam consulari loco dicunt

desidero, qui sen

Alia causa est eorwin,

quorum

eorum, quorum vocem quidem doleo in suspicionem popul.. Romano venire non modo metus, quod ipsum esset turpe, sed alium alia de causa deesse dign
silentio ignosco, alia

requiro; quos

suae.

VII.

habeo Pisoni,
publica,

Quare primum maximas gratias et ago et qui, non quid efficere posset in re
cogitavit,

sed

quid facere ipse deberet.

I

Deinde a vobis, patres conscripti, pet< sequi minus audebitis rationem atque auctoritatem meam, benigne me tamen, ut ad hue
audiatis.

16

quo probem (quis enim

servanda censeo, non quidem potest?), sed rationem habendam maxime arbitror pacis atque
id

Primum

igitur acta Caesaris

34


PHILIPPIC
%
I.

>

vi.

14-vn. 16

order

could have been effected, lmt in sular only as happened then ight have been (bond worthy <t the honour he held, worthy of the State. Il thll iigs my great grief, tli who the most ample favours of the (toman had ver of a

'

Was it for th t proposal. nan nade us consuls, that we, placed on the iest grade <t rank, iboold regard the State as of Not one single consular seconded no accout us Piso by his voice: do, net tree by a look, lague u|*on it! is the meaning of this I grant it sometimes may be nor am I making this claim on all those that speak as consular*. The case of those whose silence 1 pardon is on those whose
most
'

et

call

for

is at

m<]

do regret that
nan

these last
Id

fall

under the sum

because of fear
l<

be base
ires.

but

which

in

itself

ivc fallen short

for

som<
VII.
<

reason,

some
.

anotherot what
\

ti

A< first of all I express and the deepest gratitud accomplish in the State, bat k of what of what he himself was bound to do. Next I ask of will not pt Fathers, even althure to support what I say and advise, yet to I, as hitherto \.u have done. rst ot all, th 11. think the acts of Caesar sin be rccognis<< them fr who indeed ran c! iee bold that sp< regard should be paid to peace and quiet I would

tain

35

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

otii.

catis.

Vellem adesset M. Antonius, modo sine advoSed, ut opinor, licet ei minus valere, quod
Doceret

mihi heri per ilium non licuit

potius vos, patres conscripti, quern
Caesaris acta defenderet

me vcl urn ipse mod ad

prol.it
lirtis,
is,

An

in commentariolis et

chirographis et libellis se

uno auctorc

ac

ne

prolatis

quidem, sed tantura

;

modo
aes
it

acta

Caesaris firma erunt

quae

ille in

quo
)ul<>

populi iussa perpetuasque leges esse vol

17

habebuntur?
actis Caesaris
ille

Equidera

existimo nihil tarn esse in

quam

leges Caesaris.
fixum,

An,

si

col quid

promisit, id erit

quod idem facere

fecit,

MS
quae

potuit? ut multis multa promissa non

tamen multo plura

illo

mortuo reperta sunt quam a

vivo beneficia per omnis annos tributa et data.

Sed ea non muto, non moveo

praeclara acta defendo.

summo studio

illius
I

Pecunia utinam ad

maneret! cruenta

ilia

quidem, sed his ten

est,

quoniam

iis,

quorum

non redditur,

necessaria.
tint.

Quamquam
18

ea quoque

sit effusa, si

ita in actis

Ecquid

est,

quod tam proprie

dici possit

actum

eius,

qui togatus in re publica

versatus
sit,

cum

potestate imp* -rioque

;

quam

lex?

Quaere acta Gracchi

;

leges

Semproniae proferentur

quaere Sullae

Corneliae.

Quid?
36

Pompei

tertius

consulatus in quibus actis

PHILIPPIC

I.

vii.

16-18

that Marcus Antonius were present, without his B. <>se he is allowed to backers, however. be unwell; a privilege he did not allow me yc^' He would explain to me, or rath* day. Conscript Fathers, how he himself defended Caesar's Is it as in small note- books and acts. memoranda, and papers, produced on his sit authority, and ed, !>ut only quotient tbc acts of Caesar are to be ratified ; and those Caesar engraved on brass h lie wished the commands and fiermanrnt laws of the Rot tig? people to be preserved shall these go As for myselt, think thai ; can be so the acts of Caesar as the laws of If he made a promise to any man, shall Caesar. that be unchangeable which that same Caesar had
1

<

fulfil?

He made many m and

:

promises
\<-t.

now
far

that he

is

d<
>us

nises

have been discovered

than the benefit! conferred and given bj him during all the years he was all Hut I am not changing, these: the greatest eagerness 1 defend his noble acts. the BOnej remained in the Temple of Blood-stained it was, no doubt, but to-day, Ops as it cannot be restored to its owners, absolutely However, let its squandering pass, needed. was prescribed in the acts. Is there anything that can be called so peculiarly the act of the man who, although a civilian in the State, was with I.n power both military and civil, as a law he acts of Gracchus: the S ian laws will be brought forward enquire of the acts of Sulla Again the Cornelian. the third consulship of
!
1
,

37

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

constitit?

Nempe
quidnam

in legibus.

Dc

Caesare ipso
il

si

quaereres,

egissct in urbe ct
t

multas responderet se et praeclaras

grapha vero aut mutaret aut

dedisset,

non daret

aut,

si

19

non istas res in act: quibusdam etiam in rhacc ipsa concedo coniveo; in maximis vero rel> acta Caesaris dissolvi ferendum non puto. VIII. Quae lex mclior, utilior, optima etiam n publica saepius flagitata, quam ne practoriae pro vinciae plus quam annum neve plus qu
;

consulares optinerentur

Hac

lege sublata
?

vi
''

turne vobis posse Caesaris acta servari

quae promulgate est de

Caesaris defenditis, qui
forte, si

tertia

Quid lege, decuria, nonne on

I

iudiciariae leges Caesaris dissolvun

vos acta
Nisi

leges eius evertitis?

i

quid memoriae causa rettulit n

in actis et,
;

libellai
i

numerabitur
sit,

quamvis iniquum
ad

defendetur

quod

comitiis tulit, id in actis

20 inquit.

At quae ista tertia Quid? isti ordini

Pompeia,
Aurelia
inquit.

populum Caesaris non halieln decuria? u Centuriimum,"

iudicatus lege Iulia,
I

ante
solum,

non

patebat

"C<

praefiniebatur,"

Non

centuriodi
itaquc

qoiden
vin
I

sed equiti

etiam

Romano;

1 C. confined the jury -panel to the Senators and hknights. The third panel proposed waa to consist of centurions, and even of privates of the Legio Alauda, Cf. n. 1

on

p. 40.

PHILIPPIC
of his laws.
self

I.

Tii.

18-vui. 20

Pom pe ins of what acts was that made up ? Of course

If you were to enquire of Caesar himwhat were his acts in the city and as a he would reply that he had introduced m but his memoranda he would either excellent laws
;

alter, or wot.
11

roduce, or if he had produced he would not regard thrm as among his acts. Hut these points I concede: at some I even but in respect of the most important things, nive
<

that

is,

his laws,

think

it

intolerable the acts of

Caesar should be rescinded.

VIII.
useful,

What aw was there, what more what more often demand*-, m the best
i

period of the republic, than that the praetorian provinces should not be held longer than a year, consular longer than two years t If this law be done away with, do you imagine that Caesar's acts can be preserved ? Again are not all Caesar s judicature laws l rescinded by the bill touching the third jury-panel which has been advertised? And do you defend the acts of Caesar, you that upset
:

laws? Unless perhaps if he put down antthii. a note-book to assist his memory, that will

be counted among his acts, and however unfair and useless it may be will be defended, but what he ;osed to the people at the Comitia of Centuries ill not be regarded as among the acts of Caesar. Hut whit is tli, third pa )f centurions," he says. What ? were ni to that class by the Julian law, also before that by tin- I'nmpcian, by the Aurelian ? "A property qual was prescribed," he says. But not a centurion alone, also for a Roman knight; accordingly men of the greatest valour and n who

39

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

tissimi

atque honestissimi, qui ordincs duxerunt, res

"

et iudicant et iudicaverunt.

Non quacm.

"

Quicumque ordinem duxit, iudicet." At si ferretis, quicumque equo meruisset, jiuhI est lau nemini probaretis in iudice enim specterii debet et d ignites. " Non quaere, Inqttft, * ista addo
istos.
;
;

etiam iudices manipularis ex legione All aliter enim nostri negant posse se salvos esse." contumeliosum honorem iis, quos ad iodicandam nee opinantis vocatis! Hie enim est legis index, ut ii res in tertia decuria iudicent, qui libere iudicarc non In quo quantus error est, di iinumrteles, audeant. eorum, qui istam legem cxcogita\ quisque sordidissiuius videbitur, ita libentissime

severitate iudicandi sordes suas eluet laborabitque, ut

honestis decuriis

potius

dignus videatur
est,

quam

in

turpem
21

iure coniectus.

IX. Altera promulgate lex

maiestatis damnati ad
dissolutio?

ut et de
si

populum provocent, Haec utrum tandem lex est an legum

relint,

Quis est enin intern legem manere ? Nemo reus est legibus illis, nemo, quern futurum putemus. Armis enim geste numqw.tm
profecto in iudicium vocabuntur.

At

res popularis.

quidem Omnes enim iam

1

Utinam

aliquid
cives

velletis
rei

de

populare publicae salute una et

esse

legion raised in Transalpine Gaul by J. Caesar, and of A lamia (lark) from a plume on the helmet like a lark's crest. 2 The Leges Juliae of the dictator Caesar against riot and treason respectively.
called

by the Gaulish name

40

PHILIPPIC
have been

I.

MU. 2C-XX

command still act as judges and have men I am hitherto act .ose are look he says " let every one that has been and act as judge." you were to <se that every one who had served as should act as judge, jualitication D the case of a judge and wort to am not asking for alifications," he says; even add as judges privates of the legion of Larks l ise our adherents say be safe." What an insulting hoi e whom to their sun n to the
:
;

ic
' -

law

is

s on the third panel who those should And here what dare not judge with imic|M -lulenee. a bl >odt have the devisers of lor the more discreditable omitted 1 man's reputation shall be, so the more readily will he wipe off his discredit by severity of deciand will strive to appear to be worthy of h in honest panels rather than as rightly flung into a
!

raceful oi

\ A second law has been advertised, that persons convicted of riot and treason should appeal to the |" is a law will. k or a rescission of all laws? For who is there to-day that that law should remain? There is no one now accused under those laws,* no one we to be; for things done by men in arms will doubtless never be brought into court. Would to roposal is a popular one." Heaven\ mplatcd something that is popu ns are now agreed in mind and voice
I
I i

4i

MARCUS TULLILS UiT.RO

mente
et voce consentiunt.
legis

Quae
?

e^
I

cupiditas

eius

ferendae, quae

summam
vim,
22

habeat, gratiam nullam

|>opuli

quam, qui maiestatera

Quid hum tin Romani immirrit per

ad
earn

eum damnatum reverti, propter quam sit

plura de lege disputo?

iudicio
lure

ipsam

Hn

damnatus?

Sed

quisquam provocet;

Quasi vero id again id agitur, id fertur, ne

Qt
qui

<

omnino umquam istis legibus reus fiat repen tur. aut accusator tam aniens
condemnato obicere
se multitudin

reo

aut iudex, qui reiim damnare audeat ut ipse ad operas

mercennarias statim protrahat

Non
Quid

igitur provoeatio ista lege datur, sed

duae

uiaxime salutares

leges quaestionesque

tolluntur
turbul'

est aliud hortari adulescentes, ut

ut seditiosi, ut perniciosi cives velint esse?

Quam
?

autem ad pestem furor tribunicius impelli

his

doi

duabus quaestionibus de
qui de

vi

et maiestatis sublatis

23 Quid,
ei,

quod obrogatur legibus Caesaris, quae

vi,

iulx nt
sit,

itemque
?

ei,

qui maiestatis damnatus

aqua et igni interdici

quibus

cum

provoeatio datur,
?

nonne acta Caesaris rescinduntur

ego, patres conscripti, qui
ilia

Quae
probavi,

numquam

tamen

ita

conservanda concordiae causa arbitr

tuli
illas

sum, ut non modo, quas vivus leges Caesar

42

infirmandas hoc tempore non putarem, sed ne


PHILIPPIC
I.

iv.

21-23

about the safety of the State. What means then that eagerness of yours to propose a law wh ves the greatest disgrace and no gratitude? what can be more disgraceful than that a man
iolence committed treason against the nan people, and been convicted, should then iolence ! be wrm resor iu t why do I argue any more law were appeal about the law
i

its

object,
if

and your proposal, is that no one at all For who >e accused under those laws.
:

be found so mad as to n of an accused to expose 1 crowd? or if he be juryman as to dare to convict an accused man at bttefl himself at once haled before a gang of suborned labourers? No! an appeal that is granted by that law: rather are two very salutary laws and courts What else is this than to urge young abolished. I to be turbulent, seditions, pernicious citizens? And to what ruinous 1 ngths may not tin- frensy lbunes be impelled when these two courts as to md treason have been abolished ? And what of that those laws of Caesar's ar t altered li declare that he who is convicted and also he who is convicted of treason, shall !> refused water and fire? when an appeal is given to such men, are not the acts of Caesar annulled ? Those acts indeed, Conscript Fathers, though I never approved them, I have thought should be so carefully ed for the sake of peace that I disagreed with the annulment <>t his laws, not only of those he had proposed in his lifetime, but even of those he be prosecutor

will

be

willin.

43

"

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

quidem, quas post mortem Caesaris prolatas csfixas videtis.

24

X. De exilio reducti a mortuo, solum singulis, sed nationibas et a mortuo, inmunitatibus infinil mortuo. Ergo haec uno, verum <>j prolata defend n mis ; eas leges, quas
|

ci vitas

data
univcrsia

vectigalia a

ips

lit. tantibus recitavit, pronui quibus gloriabatur cisque legibus rem publi putabat, de provimiis. de tudieiis, eat, inquam, Caesaris leges nos, qui defendimus acta Caesaris, 25 evertendas putamus ? Ac de his tamen legi promulgatae sunt, saltern queri possumus; d quae iam latae dicuntur, no Iliad qa illae

enim sine
scriptae.

ulla

promulgatione latae sunt ante qu un

Quaero autem, quid sit, cur aut ego aut vestrum, pa tres conscript i, lwmis ti malas metuat. Paratos habemus, qui in! paratos, qui rem publicani religione defe

metu

w Quas tu milii, esse debemus. cessiones, quas religiones? " Eas scilicet, quihua rei publicae salus continetur. " Neglej: ta et nimis antiqua ac stulta ducimus ; forum I
ita

omnes claudentur
26 locis

aditus, armati in pra< collocabuntur." Quid turn? quod gestum, id lex erit, et in acs incidi tub
1

redo,

name

Persons benefited in this way gained the sai of Orcini (liegemen of Death), or Charonitae (Charon '

crew).
* Proposed legislation can at least be complained of ; not so laws stated by A. to have been already passed by Caesar. 3 Here follows a supposed argument between A., or hit partisans, and the Senate.

44

raiupfic
Caesar's death.
liave

i.

ix.

23-x. 26

which you see brought forward and posted after

been brought back from

ri^lnp ha>
l'-n

dead man;
.

riti/.

exile by a C'.wn. not Only to

!

iduals, but to whole tribes auil provinces dead roan l by boundless exemptions revenues have been done away with by a dead man. So then these rum bis house on the a jsals, prexcellent no doubt of a single man, we del those laws which Caesar himself m our presence read, published and pro|>ofted, and in the proposal of which he exulted, and in which he thought safet 1 State was involved, laws concerning s, concerning courts those laws of Caesar, 1 say, do we, who defend Caesar's acts, think should And yet of those which were published be upset we can at least complain : concerning those that are said to hare been already passed we have not had wer; for they were passed without any on before they were drafted.* 1 ask why should 1 or any of you, Conscript era, fear bad laws while we nave good tribunes We have men ready to interpose fchl people? their veto men ready to defend the State by the sanctity of their office: we ought to be free from fear. 3 " What vetoes," he says, " what sanctities are you telling me of ? " Those of course in which the
;

'

disregard safety of the State is involved that, and think it ijtntr out of date and fool

all

the Forum will be fenced in: all approaches will be closed: armed men will be stationed on guard at many points." What sac ted m this manner will be law, and TO poaa, will order to be engraved on brass those legal formulae
t

45

MARCUS TULLIUS
ilia

CI<

!'.!

legitima: Consules populum iure rooaverunt lus(hocine a maioribus accepimus ius rogain QUE IURE SCIVIT. Qui popllli: est? Quo iure? an eo, quod vi et armis omne quod est sublatum est? Atque haec dico tl< amieorum ante dicere ea, qua. si facta non erunt, refelletur oratio mca. legibus promulgatis, de quibus est denuntio vim, ar, demonstro vitia; feoUftt removett XI. Irasci quidem vos mihi, Dolabelln, pro re 27 publica dicenti non o[ Quamquam te quidem id facturum non arbitror (novi fa< tuain) collegam tuura aiunt in hac sua
I

quae bona

ipsi

viiirtur, (imlii,

ne
cr

jrravius <|iuppiain

dicam, avorum et avunculi sui

retur, fortunatior videretur) sed eon ira. -uiuluin audio esse factum. Video autem, quam sit odiosum habere eundem iratum et armatum. fanta praesertim gladiorum sit impanitas. Sed propoi
ius,

ut opinor,

aequum

quod

arbitror repudiaturum. Ego, si quid aut in mores cum contumelia dixer

non vitam eius mihi

inimicissimus

sit,

meam[quam
est
si

in re publica

libere,

non recusabo m semper habtn quae sentiam de re pul

;

\ero,

deprecor, ne irascatur, deinde, si impetro, peto, ut sic irascatur ut ci\ i. Armis uUtur,

primum

1 C. warns A. and Dol. (though the event may prove his warning unnecessary) against violence and i.

passing future legislation. Antonius.

46

PHILIPPIC

I.

x.

iti

fcx

27
to

people" is thif the right of patting the question and the we have received from our n: What pei That peoj ifully ass< By what right? By that h was shut out' h was wholly abolished by armed violence? here I speak of the future- -it is the part of ds to say beforehand what can be avoi! if tins dors not otvur my speech will be be laws that have been advertised conshow you I these you have a free hand r armed faults: remove them; I
1
;

rightfully

put

the

question

the

<

ibelU, must not be angry \1 Y. a You with me, as I speak on behalf of the State. I know yourself, however, 1 do not think will be so r easy temper league,* but they sa\ with his pr. mtelf tli good (to me not to put it more harshly appear more fortunate if he copied the consulships lis grandfather and of his maternal uncle) he, however, I hear, is angry. And I sec how fortable it is to have a man angry and also am especially when swordsmen enjoy such great will make a proposal, a fan I think I do not imagine Marcus Antonius will n myself, if 1 say anything insulins life or his eharact< r. mil not his
1

no

<

becoming

my

m<>

constant practice, that is, if opinions on public affairs, first of

ang
I

my

fail

by speak freely all I deprecate his here, I beg klm to be

i

Let him angry with mc as with a fel!< Q. ploy an armed guard if it be necessary, as he

47

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

si ita necesse est, ut dicit, sui defei qui pro re piiblica, quae ipsis visa arma ne noceant. Quid hac postu Quodsi, ut mihi a quibusd 28aequius? iainiliaribus dictum est, omnia euro, quae contra voluntatem eius, oratio gra\
.

ista

odit,

etiamsi nulla in>t((i.

:eremusaiiii<
intur: "

natui

Sed idem

ill

ita

mt<

N
et

adversario Caesnris licebit quod Pisoni socero," simul admonent quiddam, quod ca\ bi causa q iustior in senatum no
mortis.

29

nens, XII. Sed per deos immortalis! te Dolabella, [qui es mihi u vot utriusque vestrura errorem rvtu nv. Cr rctantes nobiles homines magna <jii u pecuniam, ut quidam nimis creduli semper ab aroplissimo quoque claris

tempta est, non opes violentas minime ferendam poi ted

cl

carital

gloriam concupi. factorum magnorumque in rem pul 30 quae cum optimi cuiusque, turn etiam multitudinis testimonio comprobatur. Dicerem, Dolabella, qui recte factorum fructus es
paulisper esse expertum vidm-m. Quern potes recordari in vita inluxisse laetiorem, quam cum expiato foro, d
1

til)i

ursu

The bracketed words are added by a second scribe in the Vat. MS.
1 i.e. if C.'s life is threatened he may with good excuse be absent from the Senate. * By the destruction of the column raised to Caesar's

memory.

48

PHILIPPIC L
says, for self-defence
;

xu if-*n. 30

hut do not let that guard hurt those who express their own opinions on behalf \W1.1t can be said fairer than this lie State. ind? But if, as has been told me by some of
nates, every speech
s

made m oontravenl gravely offends him, even tho ben wt ill pot up re is no n the idiosyncrasy of a friend. Hut those same gentlel of his say this to me, " You, as an opponent of Caesar, will not be allowed the same licence as Piso, his father-in-law " ; and at the san ixive h I shall attend to; me a word of cm. will Indlspodtk afford a more legitimate excuse for abs< the Senate than death l \!1 liut in Heaven's name! For as I look at Dolabella, who are my very dear friend, silent as to the mistake you both are making. I believe that you both, men of honour, '<><> credulous with great asj persons suspect, craved for h has always <1 by every man of the highest stal n, not for wealth obtained by violence, lurable by the Roman people, but and pow<
-
1

ir

fellow-citizens

and

for jlory.

Now

glory

is

praise

won by honourable deeds, and

great services towards the State, a thing that is roved alike by the testimony of every honest and also by that of the multitude. I would 1, la, what was the reward of honourable deeds, did I not see that you above all oth r

men had
t

for a

time realized
recall

it.

you

Forum

in life that shone upon yously than that in which, when the had been purged,* the concourse of imp

day can you

49

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

incendio et caedis meta liberate] te

impiorum, principibus sceleris poena adfectis [,urbe domum recep

Cuius ordinis, cuius generis, cuius denique fortunae
studia turn laudi et gratulationl tuae se

non

Oj

lerunt? Quin mihi etiaui, <jm> auctore

uti arbitrabantur, et gratias

rebus

boni

viri

agebai

nomine gratulabantur. liecordare, quaeso, Dolal> consensum ilium tlwatri, can onirics earum
i

obliti,

propter quas fuerant

tu, P. Dolabella,

tibi offensi, sigi

se beneficio
31

novo memoriam veteris doloris abiecisse.

Hanc

(magno loquor cam dolore)

hanc tu, inquam, potuisti aequo animo tan taut d tatcm deponere?
XIII.
appello)

Tu autem, M.
uiujin

Antoni,

ilium

diem, quo

in

(absentem ardc 'IVlluris

fuit, non omnibus his in< juibus te quidam multum a me disscntientes beatun. anteponis ? Quae fuit oratio de concordia qu metu senatus, quanta sollicitudine ci vitas turn a te

senatus

liberata est,

cum collegam tuum

illo

depositis inim;

oblitus auspiciorum a te ipso

nuntiatorum
voluisti, tuus

augure popoH BoOUUll primum die conlegam til>i s

<

parvus
!

filius in

Capitol iuin a te

32 pacis obses fuit

Quo

senatus die laetior, quo populus

in

Romanus?
frequentior
1

qui

quidem nulla

contione
liberati

umq
per

fuit.
17.

Turn denique

On March

By which, as augur, he declared Dolabella's election to the consulship invalid Phil. ii. 32. 8 With Caesar's assassins ; cf. Intr. p. 8.
2
:

PHILIPPIC

I.

xii.

30-xiu. 32

wretches Mattered, tin- ringleaders of the crime shed, the city delivered from banting and the fear of massacre, you betook yourself bomc W 'hat rank was hat famii art what fort;. not thrust itself forward to e and congratulate you ? Nay, more to me too, who had followed in these affairs, good men returned their tli JQu and j rn tula ted me in TOOT name. Recall, I ask J Dolabella, that unanimous applause in the theatre n all mrn. forgetting tBOM tilings fof wlrch
I

had been hostile to you, made it plain because of your late services, they had cast away tinI such a title men, nt pain. to fame, to think that you, P. Dolabella it I sa\ say, had been able to great pain that
.

lay it aside without XIII. And you,

u

Mareus Antonius for I a: are not here do yon not set

the Senate met in the Temple than all these months dun: some much disagreeing with me account fortunate? What a spe< made on ui. what dread of past evils, from what an\ was the Stat cd by you, when, laying animosities, forgetting the auspices 1 announced by self, as augur of the \( first consented that your colleague should be your colleague, when your little son was sei the ;tol as a hostage of peace!* day was the Senate more joyful ? on what day was tic people? which was never at any public assembly gathered in greater numbers. Then at last it did seem we had liberty through most heroic
that one
hiefa
1

5*

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

illi voluemnt, lr tatem pax consequebatur. Proximo, altcro, tcrtio. denique reliquis consecutis diebus non intrnnittebas

fortissimos videbamur, quia, ut

quasi

mum

donum aliquod cotidie adferre ni ptihlicar, autem illud, quod dictaturae nomcn n

Haec inusta est a te, a te, inquam. mortOO Cacsari Ut enin nota ad ignominiam sempiternam. gcntis Manliac W unius M. Manli scelu

inem patricium Manlium Marcum vocari tu propter unius dictatoris odium non
funditus sustulisti.
33 rei

licet,

sic

Num
clarit.it

te,

cum haec
nam
glo

pro

n
Non
I

publicae

tanta

gessisses,
is.

fortunae tuae,

amplitudinis,

num

bat?

Unde

igitur subito tanta ista

mutatio?

possum adduci, ut suspicer te pecunia capt am. quod cuique libet, loquatur, credere non est nccesse. Nihil enim umquam in te sordidum, nihil boi cognovi. Quamquam solent domesti- deprmvan numquam sed novi firmitatem tuam. Atqu
1

ut culpam, sic etiam suspicionem vitare potuisses

XIV.

Illud

magis vereor, ne

ig

gloriae gloriosum putes

plus te

omnes

et metui a civibus tuis. 1

unum Quod

posse
si

<|

ita putas,

totam ignoras viam gloriae. Carum esse civem, bene de re publica mereri, laudari, coli, diligi glori est ; metui vero et in odio esse invidiosum, detestabile, inbecillum, caducum. Quod videmus etiam in
1

Some MSS. add

here

quam

diligi

malisy probably a

copyist's addition.
1

Caesar's assassins.

52

PHILIPPIC
1
1,

I.

xin. 32

even as they had wished, in the train of hi the next day, on the second, finally on all the remaining days you none pass without conferring daily some boon as >tate; and, beyond them all, your abolish ii hat was the mark I say, branded the name of dead Caesar to his everlasting infamy. For, as on account of one Marcus Manlius it is he decree of the Manlian clan unlawful for any patrician Maulius to be called Marcus, so account of It tor one dictator, have
for,

liber

utterly abolished
after these great

the

title

of dictator

> 1

achievements for the safety of the ae, your vour

renown, your glory? Whence therefore came suddenly that great change? I cannot be t to suspect you had been seduced by greed. Ever}* man may say what he likes: we need not be! or him. have never recognised in you an sordid, anything mean. Sometimes nose of his own household 3 corrupt a man hut know your st will. And would h tfuilt, n able also to avoid sum
1 I
\
t

What
y'i
ferae

more

fear

is

this

-that, blind
it

possess in
so,

path ugle self

totally blind

mv

to

think
is.

glorious
If

to

more power than

all, and you think

to the true way of glory. /en dear to all, to deserve well oi State, to be praised, courted, loved, is glorious but to be feared and an object of hat wdious, detestable, a proof of weakness and decay. see
;

you are

We

A oovert allusion

to Folvia, bis wife.

53

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRRO

34 fabula

Oderint, dam met illi ipsi, qui no tuum Utinam, M V perniciosum fuisse. de quo tamen audisti miilta ex meminisses eaque saepissime. Putasne ilium immortalit mereri voluisse, ut propter armorum babendorum secunda Ilia erat licentiam metueretur ? fortuna, libertate esse pa rem ceteris, principem Itaque, ut omittam res avi tui prosperas, dignitate. acerbissimum eius supremum diem malim quam L. Cinnae dominatum, a quo ille crudelissime est
'
.

intcrfectus.

35
C.

Sed quid oratione te flectam ? Caesaris efficere non potest, ut

Si

enim

<

irus ease

quam
oratio.

sunt.

modo

metui, nihil cutatq nlehil Quern qui beatum fuisse putaut, misen Beatus est nemo, qui ea lege non inpune, sed etiam cum gumma Intc
possit.

gloria interfici

Quare

fleet-

t<

quaew

maiores tuos respice atque ita guberna rem publicans, ut natum esse te cives tui gaudeant, sine quo nee beatus nee clarus nee tutus 1 quisquam ease onu
potest.

XV. Populi quidem Romani

36 habetis
;

indicia

multa ambo

quibus vos non satis moveri permoleste fero. Quid enim ? gladiatoribus clamores innumerabilium civium, quid? populi versus, quid? Pompd statuae plausus infiniti, quid? duobus tribonJi pi., qui vobis adversantur, parumne haec si incredibiliter consentientem populi Romani un
1

Unctus (Vat.)

tutus (MuretU8).

The quotation

(a favourite

one of the Emperor Caligula

of Acciua.

Suet. Cat. 30), is

from the Atreus

54

PHILIPPIC
<vcn
fatal.
1

I.

u*

33 -xv. 36

mueh

the v< rv man who said " Let that it was they Would, Marcos Antonius,yoa had remembered though of him \u ha\t- heard l)i you think ffOm tin*, and that wr\ oftrn. (1 have wished to earn imtn r
in

the play
it

to
11

keep an

ar

ird?

prosperous fortune, was equality in lihrrt he rest, the first place in -rand father's Ace. to say nothing good would prefer that last roost bi( I i, day of his life to t: nation of by
1
1

was most cruelly s! shall I turn you by what I say? <>f Caius Caesar cannot induce you to prefer aflec :ear, no words of any mm lu-r ad. TbOM that think he was happy are themselves wretched. No one is happy who terms that he may be si not ut even to the grea
1
1
i

layer.

turn,

pray you,

look back

up

ancestors,

and so direct the

were born withoul whoQy impossible for any man to be happy, or illustrious, or safe. As to the Roman people you both have before many judgments: that you are not suffici<
.

b? them I am much concerned. what mean the shouts of numberless citizens at the gladiatorial shows? what mean the popular broadsheets? what the unbounded applause bestowed on the statue of Pompeius ? on the two tribunes of the who oppose you ? are these only a si ation of the wondrous unanimity of the temper
influenced
I

55

MARCUS TULLIUS
voluntatem?

CICE1

Quid?

Apollinarium Unlnrum plan

vel testimonia potius et iudicia populi

Homani parum
illos,
<j

magna

vobis videbantur?

beatos

com
licebat,

adesse ipsis propter vim annorum POO aderant tamen et in medullis popol
visceribus haerebant
!

Nisi forte Accio turn sexagesimo post anno palmam dari, MM BralO putabatis, qui ludis suis ita caruit, ut m ill" apparatissimo tnbucret spectaculo studium populus absenti, desiderium liberatoris sui perpetuo plausu et clamore leniret Equidem is sum, qui istos plausus, cum populari37 bus civibus tribuercntur, s. idemque, cum a summis, m ab universis hoc idem fit, cumque ii, qui ante m

populi

consensum solebant,

fugiunt,

ilium, sed iudicium

videntur, quae contemnitis, quod sensistis, tarn caram popul vitam A. Hirti fuisse ? Satis erat enim probata in ilium esse j>opulo Romano, ut est, iucundura in quo vincit omnis, caruin suis, quibus est carissimus ; tantam tamen sollicitudinem bonorum,
38 in nullo.
!

puto. Sin haec leviora \ sunt gravissima, nuiii rti.nn hoc

tantum timorem omnium in quo meminimus ? Certe Quid igitur? hoc vos, per deos Immortalis quale sit, non interpretamini ? Quid ? eos de vestra vita cogitare non censetis, quibus eorwm,

1 Yet C. says {Epp. ad AU. xvi. 2) he would have prcf that the Romans used their hands in defending \.\u- * than in applause. 2 Brutus, who as Urban Praetor should hare presided; Cassius, and the other opponents of Ca * The play was the Tereus of Accius Cic. Epp. ad AU. ;

xvi. 2. 3.
4

The consul

elect for the

next year, 43

B.C.

5&

PHILIPPIC

I.

xv.

36-38
:

lie whole Roman people ? Again did the applause bestowed on the Apollinarian games, or rather the testimony and judgment of the Roman people, 1 Hi, how happy appear to yon an insignificant t: were they who,1 unable through force of amis to be present in person, yet were present, seated in the hearts and inmost affections of the Rmmsj people Kut perhaps you thought it was Accius* that was luded and sixty years afterwards awarded the **, and not Brutus not the man to whom, though it the games he himself exhibited, the Roman people in that most elaborate spectacle were yet paying the tribute of their seal in his absence, and soothing tin ir reirn-t tor their liberator with
1
.

laose
I

and shouts.
:

indeed

am one that always despised such applause

when awarded to popularity-hunting citizens at the same time, when it comes from the highest, from the middle, from the lowest grade, when in a word it conies universally, and when those, that before were wont to follow the popular verdict, stand aside, I do not regard it as applause, but as a judgment it is very But if this seem to you trifling importantdo you also count it as petty to have learned how dear to the Roman people was the life <>r it were enough to be, as he of Aulus Hirtius ? 4 to be, beyond is, esteemed by the Roman people

all

others, the delight of his friends ; to be dear, as he is very dear to his kinsfolk; but in tl

of what man do we recall such anxiety among the good, such universal apprehension? Ccrfci in none. What then? By the Immortal Gods! do not decipher the meaning of this? Again: think you they do not reflect on the doings of your
57

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

quos sperant
sit?
rei

publicae consulturos, vita tarn cara

39

Cepi fructum, patres conscript!, reversionis ineae, ct ea dixi, ut, quicumque casus const esset, extaret constantiae meae testimonium, ct sum Quae a vobis benigne ac diligentcr audita* potestas si mihi saepius sine meo \ ctllo fiet, utar; si minus, quantum potem. Don t.un miln me quam rei publicae reservabo. Mihi fere sati quod vixi, vel ad aetatem vel ad gloii.mi hoc il quid accesserit, non tarn mihi quam vobis reique pubJ

quoniam

accesserit

58

PHILIPPIC

I.

x*.

38-39

when lives which they hope will serve the I, State are so dear to them ? I have reaped the reward, Conscript Fathers, of th.it have both made these remarks, lit, whatever might hereafter befall, there might ive some of my constancy, and in that kindly and attentively hear I have been opportunity, if it be further given to me without peril to myself and to you, I will use if not, I f my power, hold myself at call, not so r my own sake as for the State's. For myself, the time past of my life is well-nigh enough, whethi -r !r years or for fame: should that life be lengthened, it will be lengthened not so much myself, but for you* and for the commonwealth.
I ;

59

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

II

After the delivery by Cieero on the 2nd of ius, as Cicero ember of the first Philippi says {Phil. ft. 7), " threatened him with his cm and led htm to be present in the Senate on
-

the

>'s

villa

On

the 19th he

at Tibur came into the

Antonius I] up his reply, Temple of Concord,

'

ruj

as Cicero says (PhiL 5. 7), "in battle array." The orator was himself not present, for, as he declares in his friends had allowed him to the same sj>

would have begun a massacre with attend, A him, far so he had d is' speech was a furious tirade, a speech in which, as Cicero es to Cassius {ad f d to all to be, in his usual fashion, rather spewing than speak rder He charged Cicero with of the Catilmarians, the assassination of Clodius. the rupture between Caesar and Pompey. This ive strove to unite against him every faction in the State; and, above all, it denounn-d him to the veterans as the real contriver of their hero's destmcRom. Rep. c. 15 ; see also the letter to " He poured all his drunken frenzy on my Cassius. single head," writes Cicero to Cornificius (\ 12. 25), " but I cast him, belching and full of nausea, into the toils of Caesar Octavian En October Cicero retired to the country, and composed the famous second Philippic. It purports to be an immediate reply to Antonius on Sept. 19;
-

'

6i

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

II

but it was, in fact, never spoken, being published about the end of November before the 6Y third and fourth Philippics, when Antonius had left had Rome for Cisalpine Gaul. In the mea: \ been submitted in draft to the en' (ad AH. 16. 11), and had been handed round am.
Cicero's friends.

two divisions, one defensor which Cicero replies to Antonius' charges and the other offensive, a scathing den mix Antonius' private and public life since boyhood. the The orator had now flung down before A gage of battle: the issue in future was the lite of Antonius or his own. The Fates decided aga him. On the formation of the Second Triumvirate, "one of the basest compacts was made that was ever entered into by men," when ins were reciprocally surrendered to the enmity of the others, and in accordance therewith Cicero was surrendered to the fury of Antonius by Octavian, the man who had addressed Cicero as "his father." Put ujxm the proscription lists, he was murdered at Caieta on December 7, 43 b.c, by one C. Popilius Laenas, a man whom the great advocate had success) defended on a criminal charge, and who yet,
It consists of
i

17), in

the basest ingratitude, had, according to Valerius Maximus (5. 3. 4), solicited from Antonius the execution of the murder. 1 For this he is said to have received, in addition to the advertised reward,
1 Dio (47. 11) adds a curious detail. "In order to win the credit of the murder, not merely by report, but by visual presentment, he placed his own bust near Cicero's head with

a wreath on it, and an inscription stating his name and his achievement."

62


INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
sum
of
II

drachmas, or, in English icken this mom.: says the historian, "written words are weak." It required, as he says, an era The speech has, in all times and countries, been regarded as a masterpiece of eloquence and m ive. Juvenal's reference to it (10. 120-6) is
250,000
Attic

money, over 8,000.

well

known
tie

hand

of Genius, and the head, was lopped

'

pleader's blood hath e'er besprent The Tribune. Rome, in thy natal date mate when I was Con lad his speech Been all alike to this, he might have scorned

No puny

The swords
That
stir

of Antony.* (Jive me the poems men's laughter rather than thy harm

next
After the
!

first

unrolled!"

he invective is undoubted, but soma readers may think degenerates not seldom into mere scolding. And of aloqaanoa the speech (apart from the peroration) contains no soon ina passages as are found in soma of the other Philip; * Because it bad written the second Philippic An allusioo to the orator's own word* (Phil. ii. 46): "Contetnpsi OatiHnae gladios non pertiroescam tuos."
that
it
:

63

M.

TULLI CICERONIS IN M. WToMUM ORATIO PHILIPPICA SECUNl'A

I

ut

Quona* meo fato, patrescons stis, nemo his annis viginti rei publicae iniln quoque qui non bellum eodem tempore Nee vero necesse est quemquam a me indixerit? nominari; vobiscum ipsirecordniniin. Mihi pdenMUB te miror, Ant illi plus, quam optaram, dederunt
I.
;

quorum facta imitere, eorum exitus non perhorrescere. Atque hoc in aliis minus mirabar. Nemo i-inm illorum inimicus mihi fuit voluntarius, omnes a me
rei

publicae causa lacessiti.

Tu ne

verbo quid
r
<:

violatus, ut audacior

quam

Catilina, furiosi*
la<
<

Clodius viderere, ultro

me

maledictis

que a

me

alienationem commendation

m
?

impios civis fore putavisti.

Quid putem

tumne me ?
2 in

Non

video, nee in vita nc(

tihi ad contempt nee

i

rebus gestis nee in hac

despicere
possit

mea

mediocritat-

quid

Antonius.
rei

An

in

scnatn

facillime

de

me

detrahi posse credidit?

qui ordo

clarissimis civibus

bene gestae

publicae testimo-

nium
tare
est

multis, mihi uni conservatae dedit.

voluit contentione dicendi
?

An

decer-

mecum

Hoc quidem

beneficium.

Quid enim

plenius, quid uberius

quam mihi
1

et pro

me

et contra

Anionium dicere?

i.e.

the Catilinariau conspirators.

64

PHI
CI<
I

PHILIPPIC OF M TULUUB rONiUS IGAINST U

attribute

fate of mine, Conscript Fathers, shall I that no man has these twenty years been the enemy of the State without at the same time irin^ war on me also? There is in truth no need that any man should be named by me: y< iey l have paid me greater selves ha penalties than I wished:
it
1
,

To what

while
I

at

tt

And

thii surprised

me

less in

friendly to of others. ee DMB wai me of his own will it was by me they were all attacked on behalf of the State. You, not inj by even a word, to prove yourself more audacious than Ca Clodius, tb unprovoked, attacked mt with abuse, and thoajfht ent from me would be your that you
:

shudder the case

recommendation to disloyal citizens. What am I to think? That I am scorned ? cannot perceive, whether In mj lit*, or in my popularity, or in ti moderate abilities of mine, anything to be despised by Antonius. Is it in the Senate he believed he could most easily depreciate me, an order that has
I

borne its testimony to illustrious citizens for tin ir administration of the State to many, to me alone ftft reservation ? Or did he wish to strive against me in a match of orator) Thai Indeed is a kindness: for what fuller, more exul>erant subject is there than to speak both for myself and against Antonius?
|

65

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

profecto est: non existimavit sui timOibQI .ilu esiet probari posse se esse hostem patrii Cui priusquam de ceteris rebus respondco, inimicus. 3 de amicitia, quam a me violatam esse criininatus est,
Illud
t

quod ego gravissimum crimen

II.

iudico,

pauca

dicai

Contra rem suara me nescio quando venisse An ego non venirem contra aliei questus est. pro familiari et necessario, non vei gratiam non virtutis spe, sed aetatis flore conlectam, non venirem contra iniuriam, quam iste intercessoris

non tare prart. commcinci.itum i te jnt<, ut te infirmo ordini commendarcs, cum omnes te recordarentur libertini generum et liberos tuoa ncpotes Q. disAt en Fadi, libertini hominis, fuisse.
iniquissimi

beneficio optinuit,

Sed hoc

idcirco

ciplinam

meam

tradideras

(nam

ita dixisti),

meara
melius

ventitaras.

Ne

tu, si id fecisses,

doinuin melius famae,

pudicitiae

tuae

consuluisses.

Sed
t

neque

in faccre per I 4 licuisset. Auguratus petitionem inihi sine dixisti. O incredibilem audaciam, o iripudt-ntiam praedicandam Quo enim tempore me augurem a toto collegio expetitum Cn. Pompeius et (). Hortensius nominaverunt (nee enim licebat a phi ri bus nominari), tu nee solvendo eras nee te ullo n eversa re publica fore incolumem putabas. Poteras

fecisti nee, si

cuperes,

tibi id

1 The allusion is to some suit against a friend of which Cicero appeared for the plaintiff. The details are unknown. 8 Fadia, A.'s first wife, was the daughter of Q. Fadi us, a freed man. Young men used to attach themselves to those eminent in

the State for training in public life Plin. Epp. 4 For his relatioos with Curio, see ch. 18.
:

8. 14.

66


PHILIPPIC
The
fact of course
II.
i.

3-11.4

is this : he did not think he could himself to men like himself as an enen fatherland unless he were unfriendly to me. reply to Inm on other points I will say a lew words as to the friendship which he charges I account that the heaviest of charges. II. He has complained that at s< or other 1 ap|>eared in court against his Was I interests. 1 to appear against a stranger for an intimate acquaintance and friend, not to appear against fa won, not by the hope of <ut by the prostitution of youth } n..t to appear against a wrong h that fellow up ndly vet a most dishonest tribune, not by process of the praetor? But 1 think you have mentioned this for this reason, to commend yourself to the lowest order tixens, since they would all remember that yon had been the son in-law of a freed roan, 1 and children turs had been grandsons of Quintus Fad us, a Oh. hut you had surrendered yourself freedman.
i

to

bj

ion

for this

is

what you

said you

had

house.* Truly, if you had done so, you would have better consulted your rcputat: Hut you m had better your purity. ive allowed you. you wished, would Caius

frequented

my

<

You

said

you waived

your candidature

for

the

irate In

my

favour.

redible audacity!

impudence! For at a time when the whole college wanted me as augur, and Cnaeus Pompeius and Quintus Hortemius nominated me nation by more was not allowed neither were
1

anyhow
save yourself except by the overthrow of the State

67

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

autem eo tempore auguratum petere, cum in C. Curio non esset, aut turn, com factu
tribum sine Curione ferre potuisses? nn familiares de vi condemnati sunt, quod tui
Italia

studiosi fuissent. Ql III. At beneficio sum tuo usus. 5 quam illud ipsura, quod commemoras, semper prae

me

tuli; malui me tibi deberr cuiquam minus prudenti non satis gratus viderl quo beneficio? quod me Brandish* non occidefftt? Quern ipse victor, qui tibi. ut tute gloriari solebas, detulerat ex latronibus suis principatum, salvmn sm-

voluisset, in Italiam ire iussisset,

tu occidercs? patrcs con -npti, beneficium latronum, nisi ut commrmorare possin Quod si se dedisse vitam, quibus non adei esset beneficium, numquam, qui ilium interfeccrunt,

cum

Fac potuisse.

Quod

est aliud,

<

a quo erant conservati, quos tu clarissimos viros sold Quale appellare, tantam essent gloriam consecuti. autem beneficium est, quod te abstinueris net scelere? Qua in re non tam iucundum mini \ 6 debuit non interfectum me a te quam miscrum te id

inpune facere potuisse.

latrone

beneficium, quandoquidem maius acripi | nullum potuit; in quo potcs me di< ingratum ? An de interitu rei publicae qu< n non debui, ne in te ingratus viderer ? At in ilia querella misera quidem et luctuosa, sed mihi pro hoc gr
sit

Sed

The tribes elected one of two nominated by the college note to Phil. xiii. 5. Cf. note to Phil. L 4. 11. 3 Brutus and Cassias, whom Caesar spared after the battle of Pharsalia, would have been regarded as ungrateful, not as saviours of their country.
1

cf.

The

first

Philippic.

68


PHILIPPIC
II.

n. 4-1...

Betides, could you at that time stand for the augurate not in Italy? or, when Bg that Caius Curio elected, could j tribe 1 without the help of Curio, whose fri< were even convicted of riot because they had been behalf? too zealon B .* III. id Bad in you a benefactor.

wm

fact, however, you mention have always kept fared to admit a debt to you rather than seem to any one less informed But how a benefactor? Begrateful enough. cause you did not slay me at Brundisium? 1 W] the very victor, who, as you used to boast, had you the chief place anions fill brigands, bed a man to be safe, and had ordered him

How ? The

very

to

Italy

were

you to slay that man?

I

w*a in your power: how are brigands "benefactors," ei to assert have granted life to those from whom have not taken it ? H were a " benefacti those that assassinated the man by whom they had
Assii
t

been saved D are wont to ble would never have achieved such glory. 8 And what rself sort of "benefaction" is it to km a nefarious crime? In such circumstances DO! to have been seemed to me j on as for bitter regret so much a matter for g l>ower to do so with impunity. But grant u a benefaction, since no greater could he received from a brigand wherein can call me ungr.i not to have complained of the destruction of the State, that might not
i
l

ar ungrateful to

yet in that CODS us and mournful as it was, hut, having

you?

And

69

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

in

quo

me

senatus populusque

Romanus

collor

dictum a me cum contmr quid non moderate, quid non amice? Quod <jn cuius temperantiae fuit, de M. Anton
necessaria, quid est

abstinere maledictis

praesertim

publicae

dissipavisses,

mercatu omnia essent numquam promulgatae essent, et de te et a te

confiterere,
sustulisses,

cum tu reliqul* cum domi tuae tu venal ia, cum leges eas, quae
latas

cum auspicia augur, intercessioncm co cum esses foedissiroe itipatoa arm

impuritates

cum omnis
7

inpudica

in

t!<>m<>

col

susciperes

vino

lustrisquc

confectus.

At
qu
*

ego,

tamquam mihi cum M. Crasso contentio essct, multae et magnae fuerunt, non com uno _
nequissimo, de re publica graviter querc:
nihil
dixi.

Itaque

hodie

rw

it

iutt-llegat,

quantum a me beneficium turn acceperit IV. At etiam litteras, quas n><

recitavit

se diceret,

homo

et

humanitatis

expers

et

vitae

communis ignarus. Quis enim umquam, <jm pan modo bonorum consuetudinem nth-ras ad se ab amico missas offensione aliqua mterpodta in medium protulit palamque recitavit ? Quid est al u<I
i

ex vita vitae societatem, tollere conloquia absentium? Quam multa ioca solent esse
tollere
;

three market days according to law cf. Phil. r. 8. an office or power, the proposer and his kinsmen were hy law excluded from benefits. The allusion is to the Septemvirate (Phil. vi. 5).
:

On

If the lex created

70

PHILIPPIC

II.

in. 6-iv. 7

regard to this position in which the Senate and Roman people have placed me, inrumlunt on what was said by me with taault? U hat will Wli.u m moderation-' me? W <1 of self-control it was, while I was a siL Marcus Antonius, to absta complain abuse all the more when you had scattered abroad the last remnants of the constitution, ulim at your house by the foulest traffic all things were on sale ; when you confessed that those laws that had r been advertised * had been pro)>osed for your own behoof and by yourself; when, s augur, you had abolished the auspices, as consul the tribunes' veto; when you were most shamefully fenced round by armed men ; when, exhausted with wine and debauchery, you were practising in your licent, house all forms of impurity. But for my part, as if the conflict was with Marcus Crassus, with whom 1 have had many great ones, not with a gladiator of all t Inmost villainous, while making great complaint about ng the man. public affairs, I said refore I will make him understand to-day how great was the " benefaction " he then received

<

ed a letter which he said fellow devoid of good For breeding, and ignorant of the usages what man, having only a slight knowledge of the customs of gentlemen, because of son e in the meantime, ever produced in public a letter ten to him by a friend and openly quoted but to eradicate from lite life's social rcourse, to eradicate the con m mm in absence? How many jokes are eommool) found
IV.
I

Hut hi had written

'

him

this

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

in epistulis,

quam multa
Sit

seria

quae prolata si sint, inepta \ulrantur, neque tarn en ullo rot

;

hoc inhumanitatis

stultitiam
mil.

incredibilem

ft*

dete.
diserte,

Quid

habes,

quod

ut Mustelae et Tironi hoc ipso tempore stent cum gladiis

senatus,

cum

In
si *>st
i

egoquoque

tedis. -turn putabo,

1

s defensurus. quo modo sis eos hit Sed <jui<I opponas tandem, si negem me umquam I An chlfO litteras misisse, quo me teste convincas? grapho? in quo habes scientiam quaestuosam possis? sunt enim librarii inarm. Ian stro tuo, qui te tanta mercede, quantam inn pro! nihil sapere doceat. Quid enim est iiium

oratoris,

quod

ille

sed hominis quam si verbo negarit,

Id

obicere advrrsario, longius progredi non

possit, qui obiecerit?

ipso convinco

amentiae.

At ego non nego t< non inhumanitatis solum, sed Quod enim verhum in istis
humanitatis,
officii,
l><

non

plenum

ni\ <>l<ntiae

crimen tuum est, quod de te in his litteris non male existimem, quod sen ad civem, tamquam ad bonum virum, ad sceleratum et latronem. At ego tuas litteras, etsi iure poteram a te lacessitus, tamen non proferam quibus petis, ut tibi per me liceat quendam de exilio reducere, adiurasque id te invito me non esse facturum. Idque a me impetrasti. me interponerem audaciae tuae, quam
;
'

Omne autem

Satellites of A.

The former

is

called (ch.

41,

s.

106)

"gladiatorum princeps."
*

An

under pretence that they were Caesar's

97-100).

allusion to A.'h forgeries of decrees, exemptions, etc., cf. ch. 38. 39 (ss. :

It is given in Epp.
S. Clodiu8.

ad

A tU

14, 13.

The man

referred to

was 72

PHILIPPIC
in letters

II.

,v.

7-9
!

which,

if

published)

seem jejune
s

how many
:

serio

Jits

winch ncvcrthelc

should in no

way be divulged!
incredible folly!

So much

for ill-breeding

mark

man

of eloquence,

and Tiro l and seeing that at they arc standing sword in hai Senate, 1 too will think you clo<ju< u show how you ><se to defend them 00 a charge of assassin' Hut what reply would you make, pray, were I to had that lotto* to you > by what ess would you con By handwriting h you have a profitable knowledge. 1 How lie hand of a secretary. Here envy your teacher who for so great a fee its 1 amount i will reveal presently teaches you to have no sense. For what can be feat proof, 1 do not say of an orator, but of a man, than to make such an objection to an adversary that, on a bare word of ial, the objector can proceed no further? Hut make no denial, and you in this very matter merely of ill-brccdn also of madness. For what word is there in tint U
t
1

What have you in reply |0 as you now appear to Mustela

not full of *i\ ility. of friendliness, of kindThis is the sum of your charge, that in this letter I express no bad opinion of you, that I as if to a fellow citizen, as if to a good m not as if to a criminal and a brigand. But I, although by right lit do so, as having been attacked by you, will not produce your letter,* that in which you ask me to allow you to recall some exile, and assure me that you will not do so without my consent. And that consent you obtained from me. For why should I set myself against your audn
that
is

new?

73

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

auctoritas
10

huius ordinis

nequc CJ
f

populi
\

Romani neque leges ullae possent coercerc

tamen quid
rogabas,
erat,

quod

me

rogares,

si

erat

is,

de IBM

Caesaris

lege

reductus

Sed
i]

vid( !

meam

gratiam voluit esse, in quo ne

lop

ulla esse poterat lege lata.

V. Sed
aliquid

cum
in

mini, patres conscrij)ti, ct

pro m<

et

M.

Antonium

multa

alterum petoa vobis, ut

me pro me dicen
CUB
illud oro,
si

'^ne,
ilicam,

alterum ipse efficiam, ut, contra ilium

attente audiatis.

Simul

meam

(inn in

omni

vita,

turn in dicendo

moderationem mo<l

amque

cognostis, ne

me hodie, cum
Non
tra< :

respondero, oblitum esse putetis mei.

ut consulem
ille
;

ne ille quidem
consul, vel

me ut consularem.
ita vivit vel
;

nullo

modo

quod

quod
ego

ita

rem publicam
11 ulla

gerit vel

quod

ita factus est

controversia consularis.

Ut

ig

qualem ipse se consulem

consulatum

profiteretur, obiccit mihi

meum.

Qui consulatus

verbo meus,

patres conscripti, re vester fuit.

constitui, quid gessi, quid egi nisi

Quid enim ego

ex huius
consilio,

auctoritate, sententia ?

Haec

tu

homo

sapiens,

non

solum eloquens, apud

74

eos,

quorum

consilio sapientia-

PHILIPPIC

II.

iv.

v.

body, nor nor any laws coui after all what reason had you t if the man about whom you made r request had been already restored by a law of Caesar's? But of course he wished the credit to be niiiif m a natter wherein even he himself could in none, as a been passed. V Bat since, Conscript Fa must both say something on my own behalf and much aga while to the one I ask your conration, as 1 speak for myself; as to the other, f take care that while I am speaking against him you shall hear me with atAt lame tune 1 make this request: if you recognise my moderation and restraint in every part of my and m particular as a speaker, not to think liall have made a reply to In in to-day v in accordance with his challenge, I have been will not treat hnn I totally forgetful of myself. as a consul he has not treated me even as a way a consul, whether consular. Though he as regards his life, or his administration of the State, or the manner of his appointment, I without any controversy am a consular. Accordingly, that you might understand what sort of consul he professed to be, he has flung my consulship in teeth. That consulship, in nunc mine, ConFor what did script Fathers, was in fact yours.
this
le,
.

neither

the

authority

of

what policy did

I

adopt,

what did

execute but on the advice, authority, op And have you in your wisdom to say this body? of eloquence dared to vilify those acts in the face of those by whose advice and wisdom they

75

MARCUS TULL1US CICERO

que gesta sunt, ausus es vitupcrare? Quis autnn, raeum consulatum praeter te Publiumque Clodhnn qui vituperaret, inveutus est- cuius qoSdem til>i fatum sicut C. Curioni manet, quoninm id doml est, quod fuit illorum utrique fatale. Non placet M. Antonio consulatus meus. At
placuit P.
illius

12

Servilio, ut

cum

primiiiu

nominem ex

temporis consularibus, qui proiime est mortuus.

Catulo, cuius

placuit Q.

vivet auctoritas, placuit

semper in bmc re publics duobus Luculli M 'rosso,

.
1

Q. Hortensio, C. Curioni, C.
M'. Lepido, L.
Volcatio, C.

Pigulo,

1)

Silan.,

I.

iMurenae, qui turn erant consules dcsignati, plat -nit

idem quod consularibus M. Catoni qui nun multa vita excedens providit, turn quod te consulem non vidit. Maxime vero consulatum meum Cn. Pompeius probavit, qui ut me primum decedens ex S}
;

conplexus et gratulans meo bcneficio patriam se visurum esse dixit. Sed quid singulos comm-n
Frequentissirao senatui sic placuit, ut esset nemo, qui mihi non ut parenti gratias ageret, qui inilii BOO

vitam suam, fortunas, liberos, rem publicam referret

acceptam.
VI.
13 talibus

Sed quoniam
viris

res

illis, quos nominavi, tot et publica orbata est, veniamus ad

vivos, qui

duo de consularium numero

reliqui sunt.

L. Cotta, vir
1

summo

ingenio

summaque

prudentia,

Fulvia,

successively the wife of Clodiua, Curio,

Antonius.
76

and

I'HIUITK
I v

II.

r,

,,-m. ,3
has been fouud
to

transacted?

And who

consulship, save you and P. Clodius, whose fate indeed awaits you, as it does C. Curio ; for you have that l in your house which to each of them

my

was
Hut

fatal.

My consulship
it

pleased

does not please Marcus Antonius. Puhlius MvftlM if among the

consular ion one who has recently died ; it pleased Quintus Catulus, whose au will always sur his commonit wealth pleased the two Luculluses, Marcus Crass us, Quintus Hortcnsius, Caius Curio, Caius I'iso, Mauius dliri... \I MJMJ Lepidus, Lucius itius, Caius us Silanus, and us Murcua. who then were consuls elect; the tame conduct that pleased the consulars pleased Marcus Cato, who, in his departure out of life showed large foresight, and above all in not having a sight of you as consul. But most of all did my consulship gain the approval of Cnaeus Pompc who, the first moment he saw me, on qoiti
;

embraced me, thanked me, and said fi.it it was to my services that he would see his coun again. But why do I individuals? In
t,
t

1;

a very full assembly my consulship so pleased Senate that there was no senator but thanked me as if I were his father, but credited me with the preservation of his life, his fortunes, his children, and the State. \ But seeing that the State has been deprived of the many illustrious men I have named, let us come to the living, of prbom two out of tin ranks of consulars remain. Lucius Cotta, a man of the finest ilect, and of the highest judgment, after the
I

77

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

rebus iis gestis, quas tu reprehendis, supplicate decrevit verbis amplissimis, eique illi ipsi, quot modo adsensus nominavi, consulares senatusque is est est, qui honos post conditain hanc u L. Caesar, avunculus 14 togato ante me nemini.
> i

qua oratione, qua constantia, qua gravitate sen'

tiam dixit in sororis suae v. II unc tu cum auctorera et praeceptorem iHMlfaim consiliorum totiusque vitac debuisses haben Huius ego te similem quam avunculi maluisti. alienus consiliis consul usus sum, tu sororis ecquid ad eum umquam de re publica rcttul At ad quos refert? di iminortales! Ad eos sci! quorum nobis etiam dies natales an Hodie non descendit Antonius. Cur? Dat nataCui ? Neminem nominabo ; putate liciam in hortis. turn Phormioni alicui, turn Gnat "in. ttnn etiam Ballioni. O foeditatem hominis flagitiosam, < imps* dentiam, nequitiam, libidinem non ferendam Tu cum principem senatorem, civem singularem tarn propinquum habeas, ad eum de re publics nihil referas, referas ad eos, qui suam rem nullam habent, tuam exhauriunt ?
i 1
1

15

VII. Tuus videlicet salutaris consulatua, p< osus meus. Adeone pudorem cum pudic-i ut hoc in eo templo dicere ausus sis, in quo ego senatum ilium, qui quondam florens orbi terrarum praesidebat, consulebam, tu homines perditissimos cum
-i

P. Lentulu8 Sura, put to death for hia ahare in Catiline's

conspiracy.

Ph. and Gn. are parasites in the Phormio and Eunuchus of Terence respectively : Ballio is a pimp in the Pstudolus of
1

Plautus.

78

'

PHILIPPIC
uits

II.

vi.

13-vu. 15
in

you censure, moved

ns
I

the most compli-

and to named, an honour since the foundati< paid to no civilian e\< me. Lucius Caesar, your maternal uncle with what hat earnestness, with what gra eloquent
for a

motion and the whole Senate, assented

public thanksgiving, consulars I have just

;

was the man whom you should have had as your adviser and preceptor in all your policy and in your whole course of life yet you preferred to resemble your stepfather rather 'imugh no k His ad than your uncle. his, enjoyed when I was consul ; did you, his sister's Hut son, ever refer to him any matter of State? to whom does he refer such things ? Heavens why, to those whose very birthdays must be announced (lay Antonius does not come down." Why \ He is giving a birthday- feast in his gardens. To whom? I will give no name; imagine it to be given, at one time to some Phormio, at another What to a Gnatho, at another even to a Ballio. 1 outrageous indecency the fellow shows! what impudence, wickedness, lust intolerable When you have a principal senator, an eminent citizen so closely allied to you, would you refer no matt< r of State to him, but refer it to those that possess wn, and drain yours 3 VII. Your consulship we must allow was a salutary one, mine pernicious Have you so lost your of shame with your purity that you DIN have dared to say this in that temple, where I used to consult that Senate which in days of its power was supreme over the world, where you have stationed
1

did he give r stepfather!

against his sister's husband,

He

79

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

16 gladiis conlocavisti
est,
? At etiam ausus es (quid autem quod tu non audeas ?) clivum CapitoMntUB diccrc Ut consule plenum servorum armatorun

me
ilia,

credo, nefaria senatus consulta

fieri ut.

rim adtales

ferebam senatui. O miser, sive sunt (nihil enim boni nosti) sive sunt,
viros

ilia

tibi
<|

nota

tam impudenter loquare

(.

Im eques

ullius

Romanus, quis praeter te adi ordinis, qui se civem esse men

in

senatus in hoc templo esset,

fuit,

cHvo CapitoHno non

I

quis

nomen non dedit? quamquam nee sen me

suflicere

17 runt.

nee tabulae nomina illorum capere potueEtenim, cum homines nefarii de patriae
j

cidio confiterentur consciorum

indiciis,

sua manu,
in Ham n

voce paene litterarum coacti se urbem

cives trucidare, vastare
I tali

consensisse, quis esset,

am, delere rem pobl qui ad salutem communem

defendendam non excitaretur, pra< um senapopulusque Romanus haberet ducem, qualis si qui nunc esset, tibi idem, quod illis accidit,
tus
contigisset
?

Ad
18

sepulturam

corpus

vitrici

sui

negat a
fui,

me

datum.

Hoc
;

vero

ne

P.

quidem Clodius
doleo a

umquam
te
tibi

quem, quia iure ei inimicus omnibus vitiis iam esse superatum.

venit in

Qui autem

mentem

redigere in

memoriam nostram

1 Against the Catilinarian conspirators. * cf. n. Cicero himself. 1, p.

So

PHILIPPIC

II.

vn.

15-18

Hut ites sword in hand. greatest' uld not even dared and what is there dare? to say that, when I was consul, the slope In order, of the Capitol was full of armed slaves.

Sena Sena
or

suppose, that those nefarious resolutions 1 of the t pass I was offering violence to the are wretched fell

for you know nothing i:xd to you they are known, to make such an statement in the face of such an assembly what Roman knight, what youth of good birth saving you, what man of any class, that remembered he was a citizen, when the Senate was si temple, was not on the slope of the Capi' who was there that did not give in his nam ere neither clerks enee For when nefarious ues? registers to take conspirators to destroy their country were confessience of ing, compelled as they were by r accomplices, by their own handwriting* by letters which almost spoke aloud, that they had agreed to burn the city, to massacre the itizens, to lay waste Italy, and to wipe out the State, who there be who would not l>e stirred to defend safety, especially when the Senate and nan people possessed a leader 1 such that, were -, the same fate would have overtaken you as befell tli fused to surrender his stepfather's* body for burial. That charge not even Pubuttfl Clodius ever made ; and, since I was justly that man lament that he has been in every vice already I surpassed by you. But how did it occur to you to recall to our memory your education in the house

unknown
if

fa

<

81

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

te

domi P. Lentuli esse educatum? An vere! ne non putaremus natura te potuisse tain improbum
evadere, nisi accessisset etiam disciplina
?

VIII. Tarn autem eras excors, ut

tua tecum ipse pugnares, non
inter se diceres, sed
traria, ut

toU
ta
tibi

in orati.m-

modo non

cohaer

maxim

atque conteCQBB eatet

non tanta

mecum quanta

contentio.
fatebare,

Vitricum tuum fuisse in tan to scelcre

poena adfectum querebare.

est, laudasti,
;

Ita,

quod

proprie

meum

quod totum

est senatus,

reprehendisti

nam comprehensio sontium mca,

senatus
fuit.

animadversio
intellegit
19

Homo
(licit,

disertvs

non

cum, quern contra

dicit, vituperari.

laudari a se, cos,

apud quos

lam
qua

illtid

cuius est non

dico audaciae (cupit enim se audacem), sed, quod

minime

vult,

stultitiae,

\incit

omni\
inter

elm

Capitolini

mentionem
in

facere,

cum

subsellia

nostra versentur armati,

di

cum

in

hac cella Concordiac,

immortales

qua

dictae sunt, quibus

me consule salutares sententiae ad hanc diem viximus, cum gladiis

homines conlocati stent ? Accusa senatum, a<equestrem ordinem, qui turn cum senatu copulatus
fuit,

accusa omnis ordines, omnis cives,

dum

con-

fiteare

hunc ordinem hoc ipso tempore ab Ityraeis circumsederi. Haec tu non propter auda<
impudenter, sed, qui tantam rerum repugn m-

tarn

tiam non videas, nihil profecto sapis. 82

Quid

est

enim

PHILIPPIC

II.

18-viii. 19

of Publius Lentulus? Were you afraid we might ik that by nature alone you could not have nod out so shameless had training also not come
to your
ai

>o void of sense were you that throughout your speech you were at war with were making not only inconsistent statements, hut ted and contrary to statements so en tin one another that the contest was not so much me as with yourself. You confessed that yon? ited in that great crime, yon paying the penalty. Thus what I is peculiarly my part you praised, what is wholly that of the Senate you blamed for the arrest of guilty men was my duty, their pui that of the Senate. This eloquent it How docs understand that his opponent is being praised l>\ audience abused. Moreover, what a sign it I do not say of audacity for to be audacious is but of desire In! thing he desires, of the wherein he is unrivalled, to allude to the slope of the Capitol when armed men find a place among our benches! when, Good Heavens! to this shrine of Concord, where in my consul salutary votes were given whereby we have survived up me, men stand posted sword in hand. ise the Senate: accuse the equestrian 01 which was then allied with the Senate accuse all if you only confess that classes, all citizens order at this very time is beleaguered by Ituraeans. It is not audacity that causes you to make such impudent statements, but being blind to such self-contracl. ou show yourself a perfect fool. For what is madder, when you your:
,

VIIL And

83

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

dementius quam, cum
rei

publicae perniciosa anna

20 ipse ceperis, obicere alteri salutaria? At etiam quodam loco t'acetus esse voluist
id te, di boni,

non

nulla; aliquid

potuisti.

In quo non decebat enim salis a ml u Cedant arma toga<

!
.

ilpn

ihere

At postea tuisarmis cessit toga. Quaeramus igitur, utrum melius fun it. Mx-rtati popoU Romani sceleratorum anna an libcrtatcm nost Nee vero tibi de \ armis tuis cedere.
cesserunt
?

respondebo; tantum dicam breviter, te neque ilios neque ullas omnino litteras nosse, me nee rei pab nere nee amicis umquam defuisse et tamen

monimentorum meorum perfecisse, tit mea< meaeque litterae et iuventuti utilitatla el Domini Romano laudis aliquid adferrent. Sed haec
huius temporis
;

maiora videamus.

21

Clodium meo consilio interfectum ease dixisti. Quidnam homines putai esset, cum tu ilium in foro spectante populo Komano gladio insecutus es negotiumque transcgisses, nisi se
IX. P.
ille

in

scalas tabernae

librariae

coni

oppilatis

impetum tuum compressisset ?

favisse

Quod
;

qui-

dem ego
dicis.

me tibi

fateor, suasisse

ne tu qu

enim rem

At Miloni ne favere quidem potai prius transegit, quam quisquam eum ta< tiirum
is

1 One Cytheris (the Lycoris of Virg Ed. x. 2), foi the mistress of Volumnius Eutrapelus: cf. ch. 24. " Uxor"

ironical.

Cedant arma togae, concedat laurea laudi : This line and another (0 fortunatam natam me consult Romaml) were two
*

84

IILIIM'IC
self

II.

VIII.

IG-.X. 21

have taken up arms to destroy the State, than

to reproach another for taking tbetn

up

to save

II

Hut you were even pleased on one occasion t<> be facetious. Heavens! how clumsy you were! And here some blame attaches to you, for you n have derived some wit from your actress 1 w " Let arms yield to the gown." Well did they Hut afterwards the gown yie, Let us therefore ask whether it was to your arms. better for lie arms of criminals to yield to the liberty Etonian people, or for our liberty to yield to further reply your arms. However I will make to you on the verses; this much I will say brfc that you neither know them nor any literature at all that I, though never wanting in duty either to State or my friends, have yet by every kind of memorial of myself, secured that my vigils and my to youth something ot writings should i profit, and to the Roman name somethm; ..t bootW, But these are not topics for the present occasi
!
t

let us consider greater matters.

IV IP. Clodius was slain by my a< What would men think if he had been killed at when you, in the Forum, in the

the the

an people, attacked bun with a sword, and would have finished the affair if he ii.nl not thrown himself on to the stairs of a bookshop, and baffled itt.uk by barricading them? In this proceeding
ind<
fete
u
I sup assert even to

-u,

that

inst
I

opportunity

But Milo's action bed no support he finished the

:

unfortunate line* from Cicero's Epio on his own times, which were often emoted against him cf. Quint. xL 1. 24 Juv. x. 123. Ant. nad probably sneered at the hue.
:

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

At ego suasi. S id suspicaretur. erat Milonis, ut prodesse rei poh non posset. At laetatus sum. Quid
laetitia

ergo ? in Unta

cunctae civiUtis me unum tristem esse Quamquam de morte Clodi t'uit quaestio 22 oportebat ? non satis prudenter ilia quidem constitute (quid enim attinebat nova lege quaeri de eo, qui
I

occidisset,

cum
in

esset

ta?),

quaesitum est tamen.

batur,

Quod

Igttnr,

win

res age-

nemo

me

dixit, id tot annis

post tu es

inventus qui diceres ? Quod vero dicere ausus es, idque mult 23 opera mea Pompeium a Cacsaris amicitia e
turn ob eamque esse natum, in eo

causam culj>a mca helium ci non tu quidem tot* re, sed, quod

est, temporihus errasti. X. Ego M. Bibulo, praestantissimo cive, con ul. nihil praetermisi, quantum facere enitique potui, quin Pompeium a Caesaris coniunctione avocarem. In quo Caesar felicior fuit ipse enim Pompeium a mea Postea vero quam se totuni familiaritate diiunxit. Pompeius Caesari tradidit, quid ego ilium ab eo distrahere conarer? Stulti erat sperare, suadere Duo tamen tempora tnckb runt, quibus 24 impudentis. ea aliquid contra Caesarem Pompeio suaserim ; velim reprehendas, si potes. Unum, ne quinqut -nnii -tur imperium Caesari prorogaret, alterum.
;

maximum

1 T. Annius Milo, having accidentally in 52 B.C. met the turbulent tribune P. Clodi ns on the Appian Way, on a quarrel arising between the respective servants, slew the tribune. He was afterwards prosecuted. C, being overawed by armed men, made a weak defence of hia client, who was banished to Massilia. 2 The Lex Pompeia de vi of 52 b.o. It applied only to Milo.

86

PHILIPPIC
II.
ix.

21-x.

before anyone suspected

Hut pro temperai

I

No doubt
I

he would act 1 such was Milo's

lie

could not serve the State with-

But
en
all

rejoiced.''

What then?

the community was so joyful, must I have However, as to the been y one sorrowful? - was an enquiry deaf not indeed (for what was the use of set i.' 8 when il law an enquiry into h e was by the laws a proper court already con* v there was. And so, whereas no one made such a charge against me l

matter was in issue, have you been found to

it

make

years after ? As to your audacious statement, and that in many was words, that it was by my r that reason severed from Caesar's it was by my fault the mil war arose, here you are : ed in the facts as a whole, but mistake what is most im|K>rtant in the dates.
so
i

many

st

eminent

citizen,

undone, to the full extent of my activities and efforts, to win I' alliance with Caesar. Here Caesar was more In- severed Pompeius from intimacy But after Pompeius surrend lly to Caesar, why should attempt to part him from Caesar? To hope it had been folly, to urge it impuricn ie the less
i

e did happm two occasions for me to give Pompeius some advice against Caesar you may at tl u can. One was that he should not extend Caesar's command years; the other that he should not tolerate a proposal that
:
j

*7

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

in si ut absentis eius ratio haber in has miserias numquam Atque idem ego, cum iara opes omuls incidissemus.
ferri,

utrumvis persuasissem,

et suas et populi detulisset seroque

Romani Pompeius ad Caesarem ea sentire coepisset, quae ego

multo ante provideram, inferrique jwitriae b< viderem nefarium, pacis, concordiae, compositionis auctor esse non destiti, meaque ilia vox est mta " Utinam, Pornpei, cum Caesa item multis
:

aut numquam coisses aut nmnqsan iirtinissct! lie." Fuit alterum gravitatis, alterum prod Haec mea, M. Antoni, semper et de Pompeio et de iluissent, res re publica consilia fin runt. publica staret, tu tuis flagitiis, egestatc, infamia
-

concidisses.

26

XI. Sed haec vetera, illud vero recens, Caesarem consilio interfectum. lam vereor, patres conscript], ne, quod turpissimum est, praevaricatorem mihi adposuisse videar, qui me non solum mess laudibus ornaret, sed etiam alienis. Quis enim

meo

meum

in

ista

societate

gloriosissimi

facti

DOOMS
<

audivit?

Cuius autem, qui in eo numero ttiisset, nomen est occultatum? Occultatum dico? non statim divulgatum? Citius dixcrim iactasse se aliquos, ut fuisse in ea societate \ ii -rentur,
ut quisquam celt porro est in obscuris, partim adoletcenl
veri

conscii non fuissent, 26 qui fuisset. Quam

quam

simile

tot

hominibus partim

1 praevaricator was an advocate, who, by collusion with the other side, sets up a sham accusation or defen means that he appears to have set up A. to accuse him of

what were

really

good actions.

88

PHILIPPIC

II.

x.

24-xi. 26

Caesar's Candida old be recognised in his absence. If on either of these points 1 had prevailed we never should have fallen into this unhappy Yes, and I too, after Porapeius had already carri< bo Caesar all his own resources and those of the Roman people, and had too late it 1 had long before foreseen, begun t<> and after 1 saw the unnatural war that was assai my country, it was 1 who never ceased to urge peace, and concord, and reconciliation ; and my saying at would is known to man \ either you had never jomed in partnership with Caesar, or had never dissolved be one course would have shown your steadfastness, the otiw r foresight" These, Marcus Antonius, were always my nil l>oth as concerning Pompeios and the State : had they prevailed, the republic would now be standing ; it is you tha I rimes, your penury,
I

'

your infamy would have been brought to rum. XX Hal tin- 1. old !i:-tory the next accusal new, that Caesar was slain by my advice. And I am afraid, Conscript Fathers, to appear, by the most dishonourable act, to have suborned a mock am. my OV n merits, lor who but also to load me with borrowed ones. 1 ever heard of my name among the partners in that most glorious deed ? And what man's name among
1
!

number was concealed ? Concealed, say 1 ? whose name was not at once made public ? I would sooner assert that some boasted of the deed to win tin reputation of a partner though they were not
that

auv portlier wished his name conMoreover how likely it is that, among so many nn obscure, some young, who were
in that
-(1.

89

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

ncminemoccultantibusnnum nomen
Etenim,
si

latere potuisse?

auctores ad
illis

siderarentur
alter etiam

liberandam actoribus. ego uiu

Bruti

quorum uterque

L.

alienis potius consilium peterent

maioribus ab a suis et Quid ? C. Cassius in ea fan potius quara domo ? natus, quae non modo dominatum, sed quidem cuiusquam ferre pot u it, me nuctorem, credo,

Ahalae?

Hi

Igtttir

his

quam

desideravit; qui

clarissimis

m
id

rem
si

in Cilicia

ad ostium Hum;
appuli
t

ille

ad earn ripam, quam

navis
I

27 contrariam

I'm.

Domitium
nor,

patris interitus,

non

spoliatio dignitatis

\iri, non a\ ad reciperandan)

I

libetta

sed mea auctoritas t\ An C. persuasi? cui ne suadere quidem ausus essem. etiam maiorem ei res publics gratiam debet, libertatem populi Romani unius amicitiae praep depulsorque dominatus quam esse mi

jin

An

L.

Tillius

Cimber

me

est

auctorem seen:

quem ego magis fecisse illam rem sum admif quam facturum putavi, admiratus autt-m <<1> causam, quod immemor beneuVi.irum. memor p
fuisset.

Quid
1

duos Servilios

Cascas

dicam

an

Madvig's suggestion for atixtutibus

of the republic mother of M. Brutus, the assassin of Julius

The founder
Servilia, the

Caesar, claimed descent from C. Servilius Ahala, w b.c slew Sp. Maeliu8 as an alleged conspirator to seize kingly

power. 3 Caesar in 47 through Cilicia. mentioned.

B.C.

marched from Egypt towards But nothing is known of the incident

I

90

PHILIPPIC
suppressing any name,
sers

II.

n. 26-27

my name

could have lain

were wanted

for the liberation

c acton, es, of whom the one saw should v day the bust of Lucius Brutus, 1 the other that of Ahala also ? * Should these men then, with audi a lineage as this, seek counsel from strangers rather abroad rather than at Caius Cnssius, a man born of a family that could not endure, I do not say sovereij: even the superior power of any man, wanted me, I suppose, as an adviser; Cassius who, \Mthout the aid of these most noble men, would have finished la at the mouth of the ri this business Cydnus if Caesar had, as arranged, moored his vessels to one bank instead of the opposite. 8 Cnaeus Domitius too it was not the death of that most illustrious gentleman, his father, not the deati t the deprivation of his rank, that stirn-d him to the recovery of Ins liberty, hut Did 1 convince Caius Trebonius? 1 my i; should not have ventured even to advise h Wherefore the State owes a greater debt of gratis to him who set the liberty of the Roman people above one man's friendship, and preferred to resist a sovereignty rather than to share it. Did Lucius Iillius Cknber follow me as his adviser? I was rather astonished that he performed that deed than thought he would do so astonished for this rea he gotten benefits, but remembered his country. Again the two Serviliuses ? shall I call
I

L. Domitios, slain at Pharsalia, and M. Cato, who committed suicide at Utica, respectively.

9*

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Ahalas?

Kt

lios

soctoriUte

me

censes excitatot

Longum est potius quam caritate rei publieae ? persequi ceteros, idque rei publieae praeclaruin. fuisse tam multos, ipsis gloriosum. XII. At quem ad modum roe coarguerit bono 28 "Caesar acutus, recordamini. "statim cruentum alte extollens Brutus pugiCiceronem nominatim exclamavit atque ei Bf mi! atam libertatem est gratulatus." simum? quia sciebam? Vide, ne ilia cau
(
I

adpellandi mei, quod, cum rem gessisset consimiK in rebus iis, quas ipse gesseram, me potissimum testatus In est se aemulum mcariun laudium extiti -,<.
29

DOB mtellegil, |j autem, omnium sti. quod me arguis, voluisse interfid Caesarein esse morte Caesaris crimen sit, etiam laeUtum esse? Quid enim interest inter suasorem probatorem ? aut quid refert, utrum voluenm an gaudeam factum ? Ecquis est igitur exceptis iis, qui ilium regnare gaudebant, qui illud aut fieri )innes erg noluerit aut factum improbarit } culpa etenim omnes boni, quantum in ipsis tint, Caesarem occiderunt aliis consilium, aliis animus, 30 aliis occasio defuit, voluntas nemini. Sed stuporem hominis vel dicam pecudis attendite. Sic enim dixit: "Brutus, quem ego honoris causa DOB cruentum pugionem tenens Ciceronem ex< ex quo intellegi debet eum conscium fuisse." Ergo ego sceleratus appellor a te, quem tu su
( ;

1 P. and C. Casca, the assassins of Caesar, and Ahala, who slew the traitor Sp. Maelius, were named Servilius. They might almost change names with him. 2 A common formula of politeness in speaking of a living

person.

92

PHIUPWC
them Cascas or Ahalas
were aroused by

II.

xi

27-xii.

30

? * And these men \<.u think advice rather than by affect It would be long to go through Unfor the State ? rest of the names : that they were so many is an Mate, for themselves a title to glory. how this sharp fellow has conJUL Bui " When Caesar had been slain," he victed me. says, " Brutus, at once lifting high his bloody dagger, shouted for Cicero by name, and congratulated him leespeciallv? ry of freedom." v because I was privy to the plot? See whether calling on me was not this, that, as he reas< had done a deed exactly like those deeds I myself had done, he called me especially to witness that he had Hut \ u. most foolish appeared as a rival of of all men, do you not understand th-v be a as you assert against me to have wished

my

Caesar's to have rejoiced at his death is also a crime ? For what difference is there between the adviser and the approver of a deed ? or what does w atter whether lone, or was glad that
I

was done? Is there th in, except those were glad of his reign, who repudiated that deed, or disapproved of it when it was done? All therefore are to blame, for all good men, so far as their own )>ower went, slew Caesar; some lacked
it

plan, others courage, others opportunity: will man lacked. But regard the of the fellow, or should sayof the blockhead. For I is what he said: " Brutus, whom I name with respect,* grasping his bloody dagger, shouted for uld be understood that he was

an a< suspected something,

mm you suspect of
called

ha
.

am

by you a crnnmil

93

MARCUS TULLIUS CICKRO

aliquid
suspicaris
tulit,
;

ille,

qui

stillantem

prac

se

pugionem
Esto,

is

a te

honoris causa

sit In

verbis tuis hie stupor; qunn'.. in rebus

hoc, consul, alimaior! Coi quando, Brutoruru, C. Cassi, Cn. Domiti, C. crareliquorum quam velis esse causam admovendae faces An exhala. et pnlam, inquam, suut, quae te excitent tantae causae in

sententiisque

Numquamne
illi,

intelleges

statuendum

tibi esse, utruiu

qui

istam

rem gesserun'
?

idac

sint

an

vindices libertatis

enim paulisper cogitationnnquc l:>, qui temporis suscipe. punctuui hominis sobrii 31 sum illorum, ut ipse fateor, familiaris, ut a te arg
XIII. Attende
1

socius,

nego quiequam esse medium;

populi R<>

eoa,
rei

nisi liberatores

nservatoresque
l>

quam sicarios, plus quam cidas, plus etiam quam parrieidas esse, siquidem est atrocius patriae parentem quam lomn <>(<>dere. Tu homo sapiens et considerate, quid dicis ? Si
publicae sint, plus
parrieidas, cur honoris causa a te sunt et in

hoc
?

ordine et apud populum Itomanum semper appellatJ cur

M. Brutus referente

te legibus est solutus,

li

urbe plus

quam decern

dies

afuisset.'

cur

ludi

Apollinares incredibili
additi, cur

M. Bruti honore celebrati?

?

cur provinciae Bruto, Cassio datae, cur quaestores

legatorum numerus auctus

Atqui haec

1 Brutus, as Praetor Urbanus, could not by law be absent from the city longer than ten nights.

94

PHILIPPIC
he

II.

xii.

30-xm. 31

before him bit dripping rtaggnrj he is with so: let the be as I say: how much grca ieeds and sentiments! Del ul, what i mine thi^ lome time or <>tl. !d of th -cs, of Caius Cassius, of Cnaeus uis, and of all off, say, and exhale the fume of I debauch. Must torches be brought to rouse you as < an issue you lie as) r understand that yofl must determine whetln r the doers of that deed are murderers or avengers of
roa
1
1

who held up

and assume for a of a sober man. I who am, as est, the friend, and, as you argue, e mm 11. say there is no middle course I confess that tin v, if they are not the liberators e Roman people and the saviours of tl are worse than assassins, worse than murderers, worse even than parricides it be more atrocious to slay the father of 1 ry than one's V own wise and thoughtful fellow, what
for a while,
s
I
I
.

Mil. For attend

If parricides, why have they been alwa d with respect by you both m assembly and before the Roman people? why was Marcus Brutus on your motion exempted from the statutes, though abv longer than days? 1 why were the A|< n Games held with incredible proofi oi honour towards why were provinces given to Brutus, to Cassius ? why were additional quaestors assigned them ? why was the number of legates increased ? And these things were done

you

call

them?

95

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Non igitur homicidas. Seqintur. ut acta per te. liberatores tuo iudicio, quandoquid m tritium nihil
potest esse.
32

Quid est? nura conturbo te?

enim

intellegis.

quae diiunctius dicuntur, satis, Sed tamen haec sum ma est conclai >dem meae, quoniam scelere a te
fortasse
li

amplissimis praemiis dign

iam retexooratiimrm meam. Scribam ad 111 qui forte, quod a te mihi obiectura est, quacn -nt Etenim rereor, W sitne verum, ne cui negent. turn celatum me illis ipsis non hoi Quae enim res refugisse mihi sit turpissimum. umquam, pro sancte Iuppiter! non modo in bmc iirl>e, sed in omnibus terris est gcsta maior, quae gl<i quae commendatior hominum memoriae seni|

huiusme tu consilii soci Troianum cum principibu 33 etiam gratias, quoquo animo
In
est,

unquam
facts.

ago

Tan tit

ut invidiam istam,

quam

tu in

me

vis concitare,

cum

laude non comparem.

Quid enim

beat

quos tu expulsos a te praedicas et relegatos.' qui locus est aut tarn desertus aut tarn inhumanity qui illos, cum accesserint, non adfari atque adp videatur? qui homines tam agrcstes, qu d eos

non maximum cepisse vitae fru< quae vero tam immemor posteritas, quae tam ingratae litterae reperientur, quae eorum gloi
aspexerint,
?

putent

That C. was privy to Caesar's death. A horse of wood in which the Greek chiefs concealed themselves and were stealthily admitted into Troy.
1

96

PHILIPPIC
r

II.

xiii.

31-33

Nt mordci efi therefore. means. It in your judgment they are saviours, since indeed there can be no middle term. W ie matter do I disconcert you ? for jierhaps jrasp what is put as a ie gist of my coadai that, as they have l>ecn absolved by you tr> you too are they adjudged most worthy of the st rewards. Therefore I now recast my speech. m, that if any persons happen to wfl] harge against me 1 is true, ask them wh11

follows that

'

'

it

my

it

any.

F.r

fear that, plot may

be dishonourable to the men themselves, or my refusal of n my own utter disgrace. For what thing, boly Jupiter erei dooet n..t ba it in all the world, was greater? what more glorious? what more to be uded lasting memory? I)o you ad: with its chiet hip oftbis enterprise, horse? 1 I do not decline; 1 even as into a thank yu. wli.it. r be your motive. For the do not account that odium matter is so great th it excite against me as comparable with For vn*4 hnufjlli fortune li there the renown. than that of the men whom fOU proclaim you have expelled and ba what spot is there so deserted, or so savage, as not, as it were, to seem to accost them when they come, and welcome them ? what men so boorish as not to think, when see these men, that they Ives have reaped the fullest harvest that life gives? what future gen< ideed shall be found so unmindful, what literature so ungrateful, as not to enshrine
1
I
:
I

97

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

u memoria prosequnntur? talem in niiim ruin. XIV. Sed un:un rem vereor ne non pfoba 34 enim fuissem, non solum r<i:cm, sed llMCt, meus stil de republics sed ut dicitur, mihi crede, non solum unui

non

inimortalitatis

adscribe

me

totam fabulai Caesarem voluisse crimen est, quid tibi futurum sit. quem el Narbone hoc consii

cum

C. Trel

isse

notissimuin est, et ob eius

consilii societatem,

cum

interficeretur Caetmi
tasti

a Trebonio vidimus sevocan quam tecum again non Inil aliquando, laudo, qu
35

gratias

quod non

Quod si

fecisti, ign co, te in indicium cjuis

a<l

Hud

Cassianum.'-cui bono t haereas. Quamquam illud quidein t'uit. ut tu diccbav bono, qui servire oolebant, til! \imo non modo non scrvis, sed etiara regnav te aere aJieno ad aedera Opis lil>**r:i easdem tabulas innumerabilem pecu ad quem e donio Caesaris tarn multa cuius clomi quaeest falsorum co riorum et chirographorum offieina, agrorum, dorum, immunitatium, vectigalium 36 nundinae. Etenim quae res ege tuo praeter mortem Car

Um

1 The stilus, used for writing upon wax, was a pointed instrument, something like a dagger, and C. think of it here as something which could stab or kill cf. Hor. &" where Horace compares his pen (stilus) to a sword (enris). 2 i.e. A. should have been slain as well as Caesar. * An unjust charge. A. was merely sounded, and did not consent.
;

98

PHILIPPIC
r

II.

xm. 33-x.v. 36

me

in

glory in an immortal record? Aye! enrol the number of such. But one thing I fear you will not an
I
1

had bean one of thrm. would have removed, not a k bat kingship, out of the 11 had been mine, as is said, believe me, 1 would have made an end, 1 not of one of the whole story. And yet, if to act tor Caesar's slaving is a cm have der, pray, Antonius, what wili be your position, who,
'

well
10

known,

enter

>

this

scheme*

at

Cains Trebonius, and, because of partnership in that design, were, we have seen, drawn aside by Trebonius at the time when Caesar was But 1 see how I treat you in no being slain. praise you for having at one time had friendly way a noble thought; tor not bavii mod, I thank ur failure to act I pardon. That ma But if any one were to drag called for a man. adopt that maxim of Cassius, whose advantage was it?" take care, I pray, yon are not embarrassed. Although that deed was in fact, as you said, a gain for all men who
witti

>

diated slavery,

who
1

it was especially so, y< are not a slave, but even a ki have at pie of Ops delivered your a load of debt; who by means of those same
1

documents have squandered moneys innumerable you, to whom so much was brought out of Caesar's house you, at whose house is a most lucrative factory of forged note-books and signatures, a most igeous market for lands, towns, exemptions revenues. For what could have alleviated your need and your debt save the death
;
;
1.

99

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

times, ne ad

Nescio quid conturbatus esse videris numq te hoc crimen perttom vident est Libero te metu ; nemo credet umqu.v |>ulmereri Uab< bene publics re ; tuum de
;
'

cherrimi facti elarissimos viros res

37

ego te tan turn gaudere dico, fecisse non Respondi maximis criminibus nunc el respondendum est XV. Castrainilii Pompej atque illud omne Qu<> quidem tempore m. ut d obiecisti.
;
I

t<

np

consilium auctoritasque

valuisset, tu

hodie

egc'l

nos liberi essemus, res publica non tot duces et Fateor enim me, cum ea, (j exercitus amisisset.
acciderunt,
fuisse,

providerem futura, tanta in maestitla quanta ceteri optimi cives, si Idem pi Dolebam, dolcbam, dissent, fuissent.
(rem
publicam
vestris

scripti,

quondam

consiliis

(conservatam^brevi tempore esse pcntu

Nee

vero erara tarn iudoctus ignarusque rerum, at

conficeret angoribus, dimissa
ni<

frangerer animo propter ritae enpiditateofcj quae

manens

uii-

Illos ego praesta bus liberaret. lumina rei publicae, vivere volebam, tot con tot praetorios, tot honestissimos senatores, onn. praeterea florem nobilitatis ac iuventut optimorum civium exercitus; qui si vivercnt, quamvis iniqua condicione pacis (mihi enimomnis
|

civibus bello civili utilior videbatur)

rem publicam
valuisset ac

38 hodie teneremus.
1

Quae

sententia

si

non

The summer of 49 B.C., when C. joined the other Pompeians in Epirus before the battle of Pharsalia in 48.

IOO

PHILUTIC
of Caesar

II.

xiv.

36-xv. 38
disturbed
:

seem

to

me somewhat

have you some secret fear this charge may seem to 1 free you from apprehension: no attach to you? one will ever believe it it is not your nature to deserve well of the State as authors of that most urns deed the State possesses most illustr men I only say you are glad of it, I do not cont
;

have replied to his greatest charges

also reply to
"i

now

must

W
1

what remains,
icbed
all

me

with

iho

can

time have said, my advice and influence had you would t< day l>e in want, we should be State would not have lost so many leaders and armies. For I confess that, fores* what actually happened, I was filled with the sadness other loyal citizens would have felt, had they foreseen the same. I grieved, I grieved, Conscript Fathers, that the State, saved by vour and my counsels, should shortly perish. Not that I was ed so ignorant and inexperienced as to de^; through desire of life, the continuance of which would overwl h anguish, the loss set me free from all troubles. It was those most esnfc the b< .K -on. lights of the State, I wished to
th.v

Pompeius and with

Indeed, as
:

If at that

so many consular?, so many expraetors, so many most honourable Senators, all the flower too of our nobility and youth, as well as the armies of loyal citizens, since were they alive now,

preserve alive,

wver harsh were the conditions of peace for to me any peace wftl seemed more profitable than civil war we should be holding fast the republic to-day. Had that opinion prevailed, and

101

MARCUS TULLU IS
ei

KO
spe

maxime

mihi,

quorum ego

vitat

victoriae ejaii obstitisscnt, ut alia

omittam, tu

numquara

in

hoc ordine

vel potius

numqoaia

la

urbe mansisses.

At vero Cn.

me

An ille qoemqnai plus tulit aut coi sermones aut cum ullo dilexit, saepius ? Quod quidem erat magnum, de summa re publica dissentientes in eadem consuetudine amici
alienabat oratio raea.

permanere.

Ego, quid

ille,

et contra

ille,

quid

sen ti rem et spectarem,

videbat.
di

Ego inrnlunuHT
ille

civium prituum, ut postea

praesenti dignitati potius consulebat.

Quod
sin:;

an

habebat uterque, quid sequent

39 erat nostra dissensio.

Quid vero

ille

ac paene divinus de
Pharsalia fuga

me

senserit, ciunt, qui

rum de
plena

Paphum

persecuti sunt.
nisi

N
nisi

ab eo mentio de
amicissimi desiderii,
se

me

honorifica,

cum me
Et

vidisse plus fatei

speravisse

meliora.

eius

nomine

me

insectari audes, cuius

me amicum,

tc v

fateare

XVI. Sed omittatur bellum illud, in quo tu nimium felix fuisti. Ne de iocis quidem respondebo, quibus me in castris usum esse dixisti. Erant cju ilia castra plena curae verum tamen horn quamvis in turbidis rebus sint, tamen, si modo 40 homines sunt, interdum animis relaxantur. Quod autem idem maestitiam meam reprehend! t, idem
;

102


PHILIPPIC
had not by the hope
:

xv. 38-xvi.

II.

40

whose lives I was anxious, elated been my principal OpfXMMI then, to say of other results, you at rate would never have remained here in this body, Hut. you say, my of talking alienated Pompeius from me. Was any man with e any man he loved more?
.

his counsels more ed it was a great thing that who were at variance on ters ^tate should retain an unbroken intimacy of
:

saw

v.

feelings
is

were, and on the other hand

rardi think
<t

and objects he saw mine

1

first

tlicir he ral But tin- <: of the tin more aim r side made our disagreement Hut the feelings towards me of that endurable. and almost godlike man are known to time of his flight e that followed him d l'harsalia to Paphos. There was never any honour. BMi he ackn full of the most seen farther, but that he had Kndd ledg'in bi id tlu-n do you dare to att me in the name of that man, whose friend confess 1 was, while you were the buyer of his
;

of dignity

all

that

we

\.

>ated goods? nit let us pass over that war in which yon were unduly lucky. I will not reply even with regard to the jests you 1 ide In the camp. camp was indeed full of care; but men, m however troublous times if on are human sometimes relax their minds. But as the same man
I
'

03

MARCUS TULLIUS
iocum,

magno arguraento
ne<

est

me

in

utroque fuisse

moderatum.
Hereditates mihi

nam
!

hoc
i

tuum

verum crimen
viverent

essct

pi urea

amid
tibi

necessarii

Sed
'

qui

istuc

m< \<mt

|n

mentem?

Ego

enini amplius
t
1

41

Quamquam in hoc acceptum hereditatibus r< Me nemo genere fateor feliciorem esse te. amicus fecit heredem, ut cum illo commodo te is, qu-m tu erat, animi quidam dolor iungeretur vidisti numquam, L. Rubrius Casinas fecit heredem. us atCvM Et quidem vide, quam te am a
;

fuerit

ignoras.

Fratris

filiura

praeterit.

honestissimi equitis

faetitarat, ne non palam heredem uinquidem; te, quern numquam viderat at. Velim mihi dicas, quam salutaverat, fecit heredem qua nisi molestum est, L. Turselius qua fa< statura, quo municipio, qua tribu.

Romani semper

suiqu<

quem

inquies,

"nisi quae praeriia hal fratrem exheredans t< jiraeterea pecunias aliens imorum eiectis veris heredibus, tairiquam heres

42

Quamquam
te

hoc maxime admirati:

hereditatuin

ausum

esse

facere,

cum
iej

hereditatem patris non adi

XVII, Haec ut colligeres, homo am

tot

It

was considered derogatory by the Romans not to be

;

in a friend's will. Proverbial of complete ignorance cf. Cat. 93. Probably there was no estate, but C. mean, either that A. was not mentioned in his father's will, or (so Dr that, the estate being bankrupt, A., though raa<l<
1 8

mentioned

104

PHILIPPIC
critteteM l><th proof that I was
this

II.

XM. 4G-YWI. 4 2

my

sadness and

my

jests, it is

a great

moderate

in both.

in

v said no inheritances come my way 1 your charge were true! more friends and would !>< tiring. Hut how did occur to you ? By inheritances I have entered my accounts as received more than twent\

sesterces. However, in this particular 1 acknowledge your greater good fortune. Me none

million

but

friend

made

hi^

hir,

so

that

with

that

as it was,

some sorrow might be

allied

you

Kubrius Casinas, a man you have never seen, made his heir. And mark too how the man loved you, a man the very colour of whose skin * you do not know. He passes < tinrr's son
1

son us Fufius, a most honourable Roman knight, and his own very dear friend, whom he had always o; claimed his lu-r. be doefl not even namhe had never seen, or at any rate neve made heir. Please tell me, if it is 'rouble, the features of Lucius Turselius hi-, " I know nothing," ire, his township. bfe tribe. will say; "t hat fanns he hat! he made you Mr? And many urns Ixodes belonging to total strangers, when he had ousted the heirs, he seized, as if he were t And yet this is what I have particularly marvelled at, your daring t<> in' i,i you yourself had not entered into your father's inhi ritance.* \ \ II. Was it to rake together these charges,
1

MM

1 to take possession, thu casting on his father the stigma of ban km;

105

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

dies
in

aliena

villa

declamasti?
di

Quamquam
At

tu

quidem, ut tui familiarissitni

tnat,

non

ingenii
ioci

acuendi

causa

declamas.
sutlragio

vcro

adhibes

causa magistrum

potorum tuorum rhetorem, CH quae vellet, diceret, salsum omnino homtaejft, sed
materia
facilis est in te et in

tuos d
III

autem, quid intersit inter te et avum tuum.

sensim dicebat, quod causae prbdesset
43 dicis aliena.

irfim

At quanta merces
Duonti

rhetori data eat

te rei
'it

Audite, audite, patres con

publicae vulnera.

mi

Sex. Clodio rhetori adsignasti, et

ut populi

quidem inm

Romani tanta mercede

hoCj
?

nihil sapere discercs.

Num

etiam

homo

audacissimc, ex Caesaris

commentariis

Sed dicam

alio loco et
iste

de Leontino agro et de
ereptos
pel

Campano,
turpissimis

quos

agros

publicae

possessoribus
eius

inquinavit
satis

lam
di

enim,
ipso

quoniam criminibus
sunt.

resp<

emendatore et correctore nostro quaedam

Nee enim omnia effundam,

sit,

ut,

si

sa

decertandum

ut erit,

semper novus
istius

quam
44

facultatem mihi
largitur.

multitudo

ulinnim

peccatorumque
opinor
1

XVIII. Visne igitur te inspiciamus a puero

;

a principo

ordiamur.

Tenesne

memoria

06

PHILIPPIC

II.

xvii. 42-xvi.i.

44

that you, you utter madman, spent so many days declaiming in another man's villa? And yet in case, as your most familiar friends are always ise declamation to evaporate y sharpen Yet by way of a ta. jest you call in an instructor, a man whom you and boon -com pan ions voted to be a rhetoric r in you allowed to say what he wished against v fellow no doubt but material lies ready to hand for witticisms against you and your Now mark the difference between and your grandfather. He said deliberately what advanced his case: you at haphazard say what is And what a fee was paid the ten, listen, Conscript Fathers, and rhet< Two thousand appreciate the wounds of the State s of Leontine land you assigned to Sextus rician, and that exempt from taxes, a fee paid by tin- Roman people, so tl

Was this too, you most ira to be a fool. audacious fellow, derived from Caesar's note-books? \%ill recall in another place both of the Leontine and the Campanian lands, those lands he the State, and has defih <i with the my of their occupants. For now, since I have >ly answered his charges, our reformer and
I

shall not

elf calls for some few remarks squander mv whole store, so that, if I have to contend with liiin frequently, as I shall, I may still 'nine always with something fresh: the abundance eral opportunity. Of hil vices and n Will. W \.;i have us then examine you from your !>oyhood? Yes, I think: let us set out from the beginning. Do you remember that, while
<
i

107

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

praetextatum te decoxisse?
culpa est."
defensio.

" Patris.
est

"

irujuit-s,
\>

Concede Etenim Illud tamen audaciae

pietatis

tuae,

quod

led

in quattuordecira ordinibus, cum esset lege Roscia decoctoribus certus locus constitutus, quamvis quis

fortunae

vitio,

quam

statim

non suo decoxisset. muliebrem togam

flagitii

Sum
reddidisti.
Pi

vulgare scortum, certa

merces, nee ea parva

!

sed cito Curio intervenit. qui te a men abduxit et, tamquam stolam dedisset, in m.v
45 stabili
et

certo collocavit.

Nem<>
fail

umquam
|x>tesUte
|>ater eius

emptus

libidinis causa

tam

in doiniui

quam
sua

tu in Curionis.
eiecit,

Quotiens te
custodes

domu
limen ante

quotiens
tu

posuit,

ne

tamen nocte so libidine, cogente mercede per tegulas den Quae flagitia domus ilia diutius ferre non
intrares!

cum

p<

Scisne

me de

rebus inihi nol

re?
is

Reia-

cordare tempus illud,

cum

pater Curii

ad pedes meos prosternens lacrimans te mihi commendabat, orabat, ut te c<

cebat in lecto,
filius

se

suum patrem, si sestertium sexagiens pcteret, defenderem tantum enim se pro te intercessisse dicebat Ipse autem amore ardens confirmabat, quod de
;

Se (MSS.)

(Madv.)

1 The law of L. Rosciua Otho, the tribune, paused in 67 b c, and assigning to knights the 14 rows in the theatre behind the orchestra where senators sat. * If "orabat ut se de/enderet peteret" be read, the meaning would be that the younger Curio begged C. to de*

...

108

PHILIPPIC

II.

xMii.

44-45
'

That yet in your boyish gown, you were bankrupt \"ii will say. I grant it, G is nr Bat this touches is a defence full of tilia own native audacity, your sitting in the fourteen rows although by the Koscian law 1 a particular place had been assigned to bankrupts, however much a man his had gone bankrupt by fault of fortum own. You assumed a man's gown, and at once At first yon were a turned it into a harlot's. prostitute, the fee for your infamies was fixed, and that not small; but Curio quickly turned up, who in your meretricious traffic, and, as with u a matron's robe, established you if he bad No boy ever in an enduring and stable wedlock. ous purposes was ever so uracil m bought
:

his

master as you were in Curio's.

How

often did his father eject you from his house, how often did he set watchmen that you might not cross wlnlr you nrvrrthrkws. with night as hold at the bidding of lust, and the compulsion of your pay, were let down through the These infamies that house could bear no tiles. Do you know I am speaking of things well longer. Itccall that time when Curio the his bed : his son, father, sick at heart, was t, with bean commei
!
. 1
.

te

Implored

me

to

defend you*ag.t
i

father in case he should sue you for six

for this, he said, was the amount for w But for himself, in the he had become your surety. ardour of his (Mission he assured me he would go into

million

fend him against his father's anger il he, the son, beggci to repay what the son had been compelled to pay as A. surety.

109

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRRO

rium
46 rum.
tui discidii ferre

non posset,
!

ium
florentiss

itu-

Quo tempore ego quanta mala

filii

familiae sedavi vel potius sustuli

Patri persuasi. ut

aes alienum

dissolveret, redim-

summa
ris

facultatibus

spe et aniini et ingenii pracditum rei fain eumque non modo tua familiaritate,
|

sed etiam congressione patrio iure et potcstatc Haec tu cum per me acta meminisses, hiberet. illis, quos viclnmi , ^ladiis confidcres, maledictis provocare ausus esses ? XIX. Sed iam stupra et flagitia omittau 47 quaedam, quae honeste non possum dicere

me

tu

quod ea in te adm ;ae a verecundo inimico audire non posses. Sed vitae cursum videte quern quidem celeri stringam. Ad haec enim, quae in maximis rei publicae mi it, et ad ea, quae

autem eo

liberior,

cotidie facit, festinat animus.

quam multo
ut
facitis,

notiora vobis

Quae peto quam mihJ

Debet mini

ut,

attente audiatis.

talibus in

rebus excitare animos non cognitio solum n rum, sed etiam recordatio. Etsi incidamus, opmor, media, ne
48

nimis sero ad extrema veniamus. Intimus erat in tribunatu Clodio, qui sua erga
beneficia

me

commemorat; eius omnium tocendforum fax, cuius etiam domi iam turn quiddam molitus est Quid dicam, ipse optime intellegit. Inde iter Alexandriam contra senatus auctoritatem, contra rem
1

'

enemy, and the author of hia exile. Probably an intrigue with Fnlvia, the wife of Clodius.
C.'s bitter

no

PHILIPPIC
exile, as

II.

L 48

el

>

regret of being of a most is family I at tint tune mitigated, or rather I persuaded the father to discharge his sod's redeem by his family resources a young man

he could

no4

low great

wen

tin- ills

rt ami intellect; of Ike greatest promise bo* and bv the rights and authority of a father to keep him. familiarity, hut even from meet 1' >ii* tlm ere not trusting in the swords we see have dared to assail me with abuse ? t us now dismiss his whoredoms and ere are some things I cannot speak of owevcr, have greater freedom nlty are because the acts of which you have such as you would never hear from the lips of a modest c kit regard the rest of his life, wl .1 quickly to* ah upon. For my mind hastens to ts m the civil war aiiml the crowning misery As of the State, and to the acts he is doing daily. hey are much better known to you

th.u:

beg you to
1

listen to

meat t

as

you a ought to be

such matters our stirred, not only by the knowledge of We must, things, bat also by their recollect km, however, I think, cut short the middle of the story not arrive too late at the end. with QodiQS,1 He was intimate in the tn: hough he re he was the firebrand of that man's incendiary acts, and it was at house too that he even then attempted a cert !.What I mean he himself best understa: Then he journeyed to Alexandria, it rd of the regard of the interests of itc's authority
1

1 1 1

MARCUS TULL1US CICERO

publicam et religiones; sed habebat ducen Qui ium, quicum quidvis nrtissime facere posset. Prius m ultimam turn inde reditus aut qualis? lien Galliam ex Aegypto quam domum. <bat, domus? Suam enim quisque domum nee erat usquam tua. Domum dico ? <jui<l rat fen num ponerei terris, ubi in tuo pedem
t

Misenum,
tenebas ?
49

quod cum

sociis

tan.

aponrm

petendam. quam parentem ad me. Acceperam iam ante Caesaris litteras, ut mihi satis fieri paterer a te itaque ne loqol <iui<i< m sum te passusde gratia. Postea sum cultus a te, tn

XX. Venisti Aude dicere te

e Gallia ad quaesturam
I

prius ad

me observatus in petitione quaest

P.

tempore

Clodium adprobante

|<>|>u
|

...

in

foro es conatus oceidere,

conarere, non inpulsu non existimare, nisi ilium interiecisses, hup, In quo pro tuis in me iniuriis satis esse i demiror, cur Milonem inpulsu meo rem ill in -gissc dicas, cum te ultro mihi idem illud deferenten numquam sim adhortatus. Quamqoan, si in eo perseverares, ad tuam gloriam rem Ulan r

cumque earn meo, tamen its praedicaba

50

malebam
factus
;

quam ad mean gratiam QMflt deinde continuo sine senatus oouraltOj

1 The Sibylline books had forbidden the restorn Ptolemy Auletes by force of arms to the throne of Egypt, and the Senate had refused to do so. C. explains the in Epp. ad Fam. 11. 1 and 2.

Before the confiscations. i.e. held in partnership with his creditors. Sisapo was a town in Hispania Baetica where were cinnabar mines worked by a company.
* 3
1

12

PHILIPPIC

II.

xix.

48-xx. 50
;

the State, and the sanctions of relipi >n l but he had as leader Gabinius, with whom whatever he might do How did he return, or in what was entirely right He went from Bgjtf lo furthest Gaul
before going home. But what home ? For every man possessed his own home then, 1 and nowhere was What spot of Home do re one of yours. earth was there where you eoold plant your foot on your own property except Ifisenum alone, and that was a sort of Sisapo which you shared with partners. came out of Gaul to stand for the quae you dare, that you visited J I had previously received a soother before me! letter from Caesar, asking me to admit your 1 MC so I did not allow you even to mention reconciliation. After that I was courted by you, you (led by me in your candidature for the quaestorship. It was just at that time that, with the
;

lie

Roman

you attempted to slay

Clodius in the Forum, and, although J OH d that deed of your own motion, and not at my in fixation, ft professed your belief that, you could never make amends except by sin; iigs 4 against me. As to that indeed I why you say Milo did that deed at my Ration, although, when you voluntarily offered
Pttblfofl
.

MOW

lie same service, I never gave you cm ouragement. ir purpose, I preHowever, should you perv ferred it should go to the credit of your own honour of any gratitude towards myself. You were appointed quaestor; then at once, without of the Senate, without luiuiu urnwiiig decree rcc 01 me ociittii, drawing ui of lots, 5
i

Probably A.'s intimacy with C.'s enemy Clodius. The quaestors divided the provinces by lot

"3

'

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

sorte, sine lege

ad Caesarem
egestatis,

cucurristi.
\k ni.

Id

unum
te

in

terris

aeris

nrquitiac
I

perditis vitae rationibus

perfugimn
I

hi

cum

et illius Urgitionibus et
si

visses,

hoc

est

explore,

quod

statiin

advolasti egens ad tribunatum, ut in eo

si

ma
ipse in

posses, viri tui similis esses.

se atque

XXI. Accipite nunc, quacso, non ea, quae inpure el in domesticum decus
l

peranter, sed quae in nos

in universam

forti;

51

rem publican, impie ac in ab huius enim scelere omnium maloram princi] natum reperietis. Nam, cum L. Lentulo C. M&rcello
consulibus

Kalendis Ianuariis

la!

cadentem rem publicam fulcire cupert Caesari, si sana mcnte esset, consulere venditum atque emancipatum iste
consiliis vestris

ic relletiff,

C.

tutn

tribunatutB opposuit cervicesque suas ei sub

id decrevit
s< :

securi,

qua multi minorib

In

te,

M. Antoni,

incolumis

nondum

tot luminibus

hostem togatum decerni est solitum more D Et tu apud patres conscriptos contra me dicere es, cum ab hoc ordine ego conservator essem, tu
rei

11
li

publicae
1

indicatus

Commemoratio
The

illius

tui

Dedecus (Vat. MS.).

correction in MadvigVi

Curio. In his tribuneship in 60 B.C. he had desei interests of the Senate for those of Caesar, and was also under suspicion of bribery. 1 Dent operam contules ne quid retpublica dctrimenti carnal (let the consuls see to it that the State suffer no harm). This

II 4

PHILIPPIC
without any lepal
:<;ht,

II.

xx. 5C-XV.. 51
;

title, you ran off to Caesar for that, was the one refuge in the world your ices possessed from need, debt, and ;ity. When you had filled yourself up there both with largesses and your own robberies (if one can speak of filling up frith hat you gorge, to disgorge ediately), you fled in jour need to the bib vou might, if you could, be in that magistracy like your husband. \ \ Hear now, I pray you, the record, not of the impurity and intemperance with which he disgraced him elf and his own fin it of his disloyalty and tst us and our fortune this man's misdeeds will find Sprang the beginning of all our ills, is Lentulus and Caius cllus, on the Kalends of January, you were is it was and anxi >|> up the State, t< well nigh falling, and were willing, if he w< sts of Caius senses, to have agreed
1 1
i -,

Caesar himself, then that fellow set the trihunrship, ii he had sold and subjected to a master
opposition to
lie

insels,

and

laid his

own

axe whereby many in less offence have Against you, Marcus An* ie Senate and it was then still intact, its many lights not yet passed the decree* usually made ag.t a civilian enemy by custom of our ancestors. And d to speak against me before the Conhave ;t Fathers, though I was by this body adjudged a saviour, you an enemy of the State? Allusioi

'ency decree gave the consul a Dictator's power ng that of life and death, over an enemy {hottis) citizen
d

the walls {togatui).

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

1 sceleris intermissa est, non memorit del eta, genus hominum, dum populi Romani nomen ex! (quod quidem erit, si per te licebit, sempitenn:
*

52 tua

ilia

pestifera

intercessio

nominmbltur,

Quid

cupide a senatu, quid temere fiebat, cum tu D adulescens universum ordinem decernere dc salutr ic Bemel, sed aac| rei publicae prohibai neque tu tecum de senatus auctoritate agi passus es ?

Quid autem agebatur,

nisi

ne deleri et

ev<

publicam funditus velles? Cum te neque prin< civitatis rogando neque maiores natu monendo n frequens senatus agendo de vendita atqu<
sententia movere potuisset, turn Iliad mall

ante temptatis necessario

tibi

rnlniM

inflict

um

est,

53

quorum incolum turn contra te dedit anna hie ordo consul ib;. liquisque imperils et potestatibus quae non eflugisses, nisi te ad arma Caesaris contulisses. XXII. Tu, tu, inquam, M. Ai inceps C.
quod paucis ante
te,
;

Caesari omnia perturbare cupienti causam belli CO patriam inferendi dedisti. Quid enim aliud
dicebat,

quam causam

sui demei)'

facti adferebat, nisi

quod intercessio neglecta,

ius

tribunicium sublatum, circumscriptus a senatu esset Antonius? Omitto, quam haec falsa, quam levia, praesertim cum omnino nulla causa iusta cuiqoam
esse possit contra patriam

arma capiendL

Sed

nihil

1 A. as tribune vetoed the proceedings of the Senate winch had made a decree that Caesar should disband his army.

To

Caesar.

n6


PHILIPPIC
II.

xxi. 51-xxii.

53

Urn wiped that crime of yours has ceased, '>. while While the BM the out of memory. you name of permit it, it shall be everlasting that deadly veto 1 \N bat jiassionate or rash urs will be spoken of.
I

a single youth forbade the whole order passing a

tv of the State, and that but several times, and refused ill neg ou about the authority of the Senate? what was their aim except to prevent you from seeking the Biter destruction and overthrow of the It was wl State? ther the chief men of the is by ad\ (treaty, nor y. nate by deliberation on the veto which you bad sold and delivered 1 could move you
< . -

action was being taken by

tl

you

raj then, when many efforts had been made, that blow was necessarily dealt you, which had l>cen dealt to few before, of whom not one escaped it was then order put we the hands of the consuls, and the other powers, military and civil, weapons betaken you would not have escaped had J 10 Caesar's camp. I. V.. 11, \,.u, iay, it was, Marcus Antonius, who most of all gave Caius Caesar, aiming as he did at general confusion, a pretext for waging war ag.i what other reason did he allege? what reason for his most crazy policy and actions did

he present but the disregard of the tribune's veto, the destruction of the rights of the tribunes, and the n by the Senate of Antonius's power ; pass over the falsity, the triviality, of these pretexts, all the more because no just cause whatever can exist for any man's taking up arms against his country.
I

ti7

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

de Caesare;
54 miserum
intellegis
te,

tibi

certe

confitcndum

est

causam

perniciosissimi belli in persona tua CO

huius rei

umquam
pulsos

BOB si haec Intelleg hoc litteris mandari, hoc memoriae pa ne posteritatem quidem omnium laeculo immemorem fore, consules ex Italia exiis

cumque

Roraani decus ac lumen

Cn. Pompeium, quod imperii populi fuit, omnes consulares, qui

per valetudinem exequi

cladem

illam

fugan

potuissent, praetores, praetorios, tribunos pi., D

nam partem

senatus, omnem subolem iuven' unoque verbo rem publicam expulsam atque c\
!

65 lninatam suis sedibus

belli

Ut

IgitUT in
sir

M-minibus est

causa arborum et stirpium,

huius lad

semen tu fuisti. Doletis tris ex opoli Romani interfectos interfecit Antonius. Desideratis clarissimos cives eos quoque nobis eripuit An tun ins. Auctoritas huius ordinis adflicta est; adfliut An;
;

tonius.

Omnia denique, quae postea autem mali non vidimus?), si recte n uni accepta referemus Antonio. Ut Ht

quid mur,

sic

iste

atque

exitii fuit.

huic rei publicae belli causa, causa p Reliquae partes tribun.-it us principii

perfecit, quae senatus salva re possent providerat. XXIII. Cuius tamen scelus in scelere cognc 56 Restituebat multos calami tosos. In iis patrui nulla
similes.

Omnia
fieri

publica ne

1 2

At

Pharsalia, Thapsus, and Munda. In recalling condemned exiles and not including hia

own

uncle.

n8

PHILIPPIC
Hut
let

II.

xvii. 53-xxi.i.

56

confess

say nothing of Caesar : you at least must excuse for a most |>< war man it in your rstand these things, O m <i still if
t
.

me

you do

i:

record, this

is

handed down

t<>

memorjj that of
t

this

generation

will

not

ills were d be foi in Italy, and with is Pompeius, he that was the glory and the light of the empire of the all the consular* whose health enabled

to effect that disastrous flight, praetors, expraetors,

ill

the p< ople, a great part of the the breed of our \

jelled

from

its

home.

As thru
ts,

seed.

the principle of trees and there 1so of this most mournful war were you the You grieve, Conscript Fathers, that three ople have been slaught.rrd
j

>nius slat.

You mourn the noblest Antonio* robbed us of them too.

*

lifin.

s our order has been o authorH thrown; overthrew it In a word, all we have seen afterwards and what evil have we not
t

we

shall reason rightly,

we
to
t

shall credit to
ti,
,

so that man has been to this State the cause of ruin and iel of his H<- effi tribuneship was like the beginning. everything that the Senate, while there was still a lered impossible.
i

Anton us

alone.

As Helen
;

raj

<

Will
reinstated
is

Yet mark

h
-is.

many onfbrtaiu
his uncle.
If

1 He Among them
s.

no mention of

he must be severe, why

119

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Si severus, cur non in omi l.u-mium suos? Sed omitto ceteros in non cur mm. Denticulum de alea condemnatum, conl restituit; quasi vero ludere cum condemnato non liceret; sed ut, quod in alea perdiderat, ben<

mentio.

rmtionem populo Romano, cur eum restitui oporteret? Absentem, credo, in reos relatum ; rem indicta causa iudicatam ; nullum fuisse de alea lege iudicim et armis ; postremo, quod de |>atruo tuo diccbatur, Imrum Nihil pecunia iudicium esse corruptum. At vir bonus et re publica dignus. Nihil id qui ad rem; ego tamen, quoniam condemnatam esse Homii pro nihilo est, ita ignoscerem.
legis dissolveret.
attulisti

Quam

nequissimum, qui non dubitarct vel in fOTO alea ludere, lege, quae est de alea, condemn atom <jui in integrum restituit, is non apertissirae stadium swum
57 ipse profitetur? In

eodem vero tribunatu, cum Caesar

in

proficiscens

huic conculcandam Italiajn

tr

quae fuit eius peragratio itinerum, lustratio municipiorum Scio me in rebus celebratissinns omnium sermone versari eaque, quae dico dictunuque notiora esse omnibus, qui in Italia turn fuerunt, (juam
!

mihi, qui nullo

scientiae.

non

fui.

Notabo tamen singulas

res.

modo

poterit oratio

mea

satis

facere vestrae

flagitium extitisse

Etenim quod umquam in terris tantum auditum est, tan tarn turpitudim in,
in essedo tribunus pi.
;
;

58

tantum dedecus ? XXIV. Vehebatur

l

lictores
x. 10).

This assertion

is

false

was at Cumae {ad AU.

120

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxiii.

56-xxiv. 58

not against all? if pitiful, why not towards his own in that of Licinius kin } Hut I pass over other eases ticulus, his fellow-gambler, a man convictei
I

on the plea, no doubt, dicing, he reinstated him but in is illegal to gamble with a convict fact that, thanks to a law, he ini;Iit discharges gaming

debt.

why he

res on did fOO give the Roman people should be reinstated? He was prosecuted, absence the matter was decided rase being heard; tin- proseci he was crushed bling was legally null and void

Win*

of arms
case.

finally, as

was

sa

I is

corrupt.

None of these

uncle's excuses.

Ah, then he was a good man, and a descr ired is nothing to the petal, but, seeing that een convicted goes for nothing, 1 would H it when an e his character, be lenient. tier reprobate, one who would not even shrink from is convicted under the gambling in Gambling law, does not tin- man who reinstates him its most openly nroelsJss Ins own bias? same tribuneship, after Caesar in had surrendered Italy to this setting out fa man to be trampled under foot, what a progress there what a traversing of the was in

know I am dealing with matters boron jh ii discussed in general talk, and that what I say, and shall say, is better known to all then in than to DM who was absent 1 Yet I will notice points, although my account can in no was; your knowledge. For what outrage so to have existed in the :s was ever heard Id? what turpitude? X XIV. A tribune of the people was driven in a
I

,1

121

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

laureati antecedebant, inter quos aperta

portabatur, quam ex oppidis municipalea lion honesti ob viam necessario prodeuntes et mimico nomine, sed Voluraniara const! Sequebatur raeda cum lenonibus. ft .mites nequisreiecta mater amic-ani inpuri tilu tainquani minim
i

sequebatur.

O raiserae mulieris
Baglllof

fecunditatem
tot

<

V
Manic

tosam!

Horum

municipia, praefecturas, Italiam inpressit.

59

colonias,
eius,

Reliquorum factorum
cilis

est sane repreliensio et lubrica.

;

bello est

pa tres conscript i. diffiVei saturavit se sanguine llJMllllflllimilim

I

civium
citas.

felix fuit, si potest ulla in scelere esse

Sed quoniam veteranis cautum esse

volui

quamquam

dissimilis est milituin causa et tun

ducem), tamen, ne apud illos de genere belli dicam. Victor e Thessalia Brundisium cum leg tisti. Ibi me non occidisti. Magnum ben potuisse enim fateor. QuanKj
secuti sunt, tu qmesisti

me

in invidiam voces, nihil

qui turn tecum fuerunt, qui inihi non cense 60 oportere; tanta est enim caritas patriae, ut \< etiam leponibus sanctus essem, quod earn a me servatam esse meminissent. Sed nln, quod non ademisti, meque a te haben non a te sit erepta ; licuitne miln per tu
1

Ace. to Pliny {N.H.

8.

21)

and Plut. (Ant.

0),

drawn by
t

lions.

As for a victory. According to Plut. (Q.R. 81) a could not have lictors, or use a horse or carriage, or wear a praetexta, or indulge in any display. 8 See n. 1, p. 84. 4 C. is afraid of offending Caesar's veterans.
1

122

PHILIPPIC
sh chariot
1
;

II.

xx.v.

58-60

laurel-crowned 2 lictors precc linn in their midst a female mime was carried in an open litter, a woman whom citizens from the is, decent men, coming out perforce to meet i>\ her known professional na her, salu hut as \ There followed a travel! l* le ; a mother coach of pimps, a most us son's mistress p tin- n O wretch law. as though she were a daumother, disastrously fertile! With the imprints of it man set his seal on all the these infamit boroughs, praefeetures, and colonies, in a word 00
;

the w

To

reprobate
is

of his doings, Con

truly a task at once difficult and hazard1 He was oc n warj lie gorged himself he with the blood of citizens most unhk.

Fathers,

there can be any good fortune in as we wish to regard the interests of case of soldiers is different the veterans the h. v followed a leader, you looked out that you may not brfalg me into (kIiuiii with -ne ng as to the character of the then: war. You returned, a conqueror, from Thessaly There you did with your legiona to Hrundisium lint a great "benefaction " ! * for I not slay And yet none of ess you could have done so. those with you then hut thought I ought to be spared; for so great is love of country that even to inhered your legions I was sacred because t But grant you gave that it had been saved by me. me what you did not take away, and that I owe you my life because you did not rob nie of it did your

was

<-,

if

As to

this see ch. 3. ante.

*3

MARCUS TULLIUS
ut tu< melias hoc tuum beneficium praesertim cum te haec auditurum XXV. Venisti Brand isium, In sinum 61 complexum tuae mimulae. Quidest? mini mm n'

Quam miserum est id negare non posse, muni< S turpissimum confiter pudebat, ne veterani quidem exen
miles
fuit,

mm
.

<jmi qui Brandish* Main non vid< nescierit venisse earn tibi tot dierum Her obi gratulatum? quis, qui non indolnerit tin serquam nequam hominem seeutus esset, cognoscere ? 62 Italiae rursus percursatio eadnn oppida militum cradelis et misera dedin-ti-, in auri, argenti maximeque vini foedn sit, ut Caesare ignaro, cum esset ille Alexand beneficio amicorum eius magister equitu

retur.

Turn
et

vivere

se suo lore exi equos vectigales Serpi

cum

II

Turn

sibi non banc, quam nunc male tuetur, sed M. (, ego Pisonis domum, ubi habitaret, legernt istius decreta, quid rapinas, quid hereditatum possesi

siones datas, quid ereptas proferam ? Cogebat egequo se vert ere t, non habebat nondum ; a L. Rubrio, non a L. Turselio bereditas venerat nondum in Cn. Pompei locum multoramdaC ilionnn. qui aberant, repentinus heres successerat
stas
:

vivendum latronum
rapere potuisset.

ritu,

ut tantum haberet, rjuantiun

As being himself 1inrapxos=magistcr equitum. The meaning of equi vectigales is uncertain. may be horaes for public games (Mayor) or horsea delivered by tributary States (Orelli). Hipp, and Serg. were actors. Juv. (6. 82) strangely takes "Hippia" as feminine. 8 The house of Pompeius. This ia " held with difficulty,"
1

as Sext. Pompeius, the son, claims

it.

124

PHILIPPIC
-

If.

xxiv.

60-xxv. 62

to cherish this

your

"

as

>ur
I

insults,

benefaction and that

is

"

though you saw

lap

should

make

tin

to Brundisium, that

to say,

and into the embraces of your d< What? do I lie? How wretched able to deny what it is most disgraceful to confess! If shame before the boroughs, had yon army of veterans? For what ie even b< iier was there that did not see her at Hrundi sium? who that did net know she had come so many days' journey to congratulate you- who did grieve to have been so late in mg how villainous a man he followed ? There was again a progress through Italy with the same mime as compani' wns a cruel and galling
1
1

of soldiers: In the etty a shameful of gold, silver, and especially of wine. To this was added, without the knowledge of Caesar, because he was at Alexandria, his appointment by favour of Caesar's friends as master of the horse. Then he thought h as of right live with Hip) and r the horses the unr he had selected for his redden hut M. Plso's. Why should I b; ml tinfellow's decrees, his robberies, his bestowing, his laying baodi 00 inheritances? Need compelled him; he had nowhere to turn ; not yet had ample inheritance come to him from Lucius Rnbtins, from Lucius had he ife npttsH into the shoes of Cnaeus Pompeius and of many other absent persons He had er the fashion of so that he possessed just so much as he
i

125

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

63

Sed haec, quae robustiori improbiUtis sunt, omittamus; loquamur potius de nequissimo g
i

levitatis.

Tu

istis faucil>

iteribus, ista

diatoria

totius

corj>oris

firmitate

tantum

\ini

In
in

esse esstt Hippiae nuptiis exhauseras, u postridie. O vomere populi Roman eonspectu auci etiam sed foedam, visu modo non
i
I

cenam
populi

in

ipsis

tuis innnanil>us

illis

pocolil boc tibi

accidisset, quis

non turpe ducerct? In coctu vero Romani negotium publicum gerens mngister
<

equitum, cui ructare turpe esset, is vomei esculentis vinum redolentibus grenuuin swum
turn tribunal inplevit!
suis sordibus
;

Sed haec

ipse fatetur

e.s

veniamus ad splendidiora.
<ju

64

XXVI. Caesar Alexandria se recepit fv\ mea autem sentcnt la, quidem videbatur publicae sit hostis, felix esse nemo potest.
;

posita

pro aede

(miserum
infixus

me

haeret
re

Hasta bona Cn. Pm consumptis enim lacrimis ts n. animo dolor), bona, inquam,
Iovis

Statoris

<

Pompei Magni

voci acerbissimae subiecta praeconis

servitutis

Una

in

ilia

oblita

civitas

ingemuit,

servientibusque animis,

cum omnia metu

trnerentur,

gemitus tamen populi Romani liber fuit. Expectantibus omnibus, quisnam esset tarn impius, tam demens tarn dis hominibusque hostis, qui ad illud scelus sectionis auderet accedere, inventus est nemo praeter
1 A spear was a symbol of a public auction, the custom being derived from sales of things captured in war.

126


PHILIPPIC
II.

xxv. 63-xxvi. 64

they are the us speak You with the vilest kind of those lungs, with that that gorge of y<> had gladiatorial strength of your whole body, h wine at Mippias' wedding that swallowed so n vomit in the sunlit of the Human Oh, the hideousness of it, not pie the next day. If during the to see, but even to hear of! banquet, in the very midst of those enormous is had happened to you, who potations of j would not think it disgraceful * Hut at an assembly of the Roman people, while m the conduct of public Mrse, for whom it would be ness,a master lap disgraceful to belch, vomited and Hied and the whole tribunal with fragments of food However these things he reeking of wine.

Hut let us pass over these things: proofs of a more robust improbity
:
:

let

li

mm

ii

more

Igi

let

come

to

more

brilliant ones.

WVI. Caesar came back from Alexandria, happy, as he indeed fancied, hut in m\ man that is an enemy of the State can be happy. The spear 1 was erected in front of the temple of Jopttet Stator, and the goods of Cnaeus Pompeius alas alas for, when tears are spent, yet deep-seated
!

goods,

say, of

eius

itted to the harsh

sanom

In that one ma* etfal oneer. of its slavery, the public groaned, and though their hearts were enslaved since all tilings were possessed by fear groans of the Roman people were While all were waiting to see who could be so free.

ad, so hostile to Gods and men, as boldly to support that criminal auction, not a single

127

MARCUS TULLIUS
illam, qui alia
;

Antonium, praesertim cum tot essent etaOMH 1 omnia audcrent in qui id auderet, quod omnium tugisset ct r< t.nni

'I'autus igitui f nppressit vi-1, 65 dasset audacia. ut verius dicam, tantu% furor, lit primiim, cum s< DOO tfl sis isto loco nntus, deinde cum exsecratum p<>pulo Romano, non detestabilcm, non <s ct esse inimicos omnis tibi deos, non omm

At quam insolcntcr statim h< et futuros scias? invasit in eius viri fortunas, cuius virtutc tcrnhilior
erat

populus

Romanus

cxtcris

gent

canor
sc nblto XXVII. In eius igitur riri copiai ingurgitasset, exsultabat gaudio |>ersona d modo egens, repente dives. Sed, ut est ln66 nescio quern, "Male parta male dilaluintur. "

en

credibile ac simile portenti est,

quonam

multa quam paucis non dico mcnsibus, sed diebus effuderit. Maximus viui iiiiincrus f'uit. pennigUMII optimi pondus argenti, pretiosa vestis, multa et lauta supellex et magnitica multis locis non ilia quid* in luxuriosi hominis, sed tamen abundant: H.nim paucis diebus nihil erat. Quae Cbarjbd 67 Charybdim dico? quae si fuit, animal iiniim fuit Oceanus medius fidius vix videtur tot res tarn
.

dissipatas,

tam distantibus

in locis positas tain cito

absorbere potuisse. Nihil erat clausum, nihil turn, nihil scriptum. Apothecae totae n

1 This is not true, as C. himself shows: cf. (sunt alii plures /ortasse). ' Of confiscated goods at auction. 8 Cn. Naevios ; cf. also Plaut. Poen 843 {male

l'hil.

xiii.

partum malt

disperit).

128

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxvi. 64-xxvii. 67
1

\ that too when n was found save there stood around that spear such a throng of men r anything besides; one were bold ei man was found 1 l>old enough for that from >f all beside had shrunk back h the a ercome you, appalled. such madness, as to leave or to speak more truly ignorant that >eing a purchaser at all * a man of your birth and secondly the purchaser cius" goods, you have become an object of execration, of loathing to the Koman people, that all Gods, all men, are and will remain your enemies ? Hut how insolently did the glutton at once take possession of the fortunes of the man by whose valour the Roman people was more dreaded l>\ foreign

races,
in the

by who
I.

\VI

When be had
kith

ample we

of

more endeared to 1 begun to wallow that great man, be was transas

all

at once

ported with joy, the verv character in a farce, now Hut as some poet* says !y, suddenly rich. ible, It .rains come to an evil end." and almost portentous how in so few days I do not say

months was l

he squandered
DM

so

rty.

There

store of wine, a very great weight of the finest silver, a costly wardrobe, much elegant and magnificent furniture in many places, the I of a man not indeed lavish but fully supplied. What in a few dn ybdis was so voracious? Cbarybdto do I say? ever existed, it was a single animal an Ocean, so help me Heaven scarce seems capable of ha\ swallowed so quickly things so scattered, situated in so many different places. Nothing was locked up, Whole winenothing sealed, nothing catalogued.

129

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRRO

hominibus condonabantur.
;

Alia

miml
i.

alia

mimae domus erat aleatoribus ref< it plena el rum; totos dies potabatur, atque il locii plaril
suggerebantur etiam saepe (non enim
f'elix)

seni|><

damna

aleatoria.

Conch yliatis

ij><

peristromatis servorura in cellis lcctos stratus vidcres.

ob rem desinite mirari haec tarn celeriter esse Non modo unius patrimonunn qtuu am plum, ut illud fuit, sed urbes et regna ceb
consumpta.
tanta nequitia devorare potuisset
68 etiam et hortos.

Quam

At idem aedes
!

audaciam immanent
ausus
es, tu illud

tu

<

ingredi illam

domum

Mnctissimum

limen intrare, tu illarum aedium dis pen.it ft purissimum ostendere? Quam domum aliquaindni

nemo
ire,

adspicere jwterat,

nemo

sine lacr
|

uter-

in

hac te in domo tam diu deversari non qua, quamvis nihil sapias, tamen nihil tihi

esse

iucundum ? XXVIII. An
adspexisti,

tu, ilia in vettibulo rostra [spolia] l

cum
Fieri

domum tuam
tajn. n

itas?

non
sis,

potest.

Quamvis enim

sine mente,
ti.
i

sensu

ut
te

es,

et te et tua et

Nee vero

umquam neque

vigilantem

somnis credo posse mente consistere. Ne< quamvis sis, ut es, vinulentus 2 et furens,
obiecta 69
sit

cum

tibi

species singularis

viri,

perterritura te de

somno
1

excitari, furere

etiam saepe vigilantem.

Spolia
ia

Mr

Rostran spolia (Vat.), rostra (Orelli).

a gloss.
1

prohaMy * J

FioUntus (Vat.).

130

PHILIPPIC
Inns

II

xwu.
bo

67-xxviii. 69

wen- mad- pretea^l

there

wm
all

lucky were of slaves you purple t eease to

:

rown

the rilesl characters. n actresses the nublcrs. full of drunk.t drinking and that in many
;

for tin-

it

How

is

not always

-aming

losses.

would see beds

r

In the garrets covered with the

Wherefore

these tilings were so quickly ever I single patrimony al< tat was, but cities and kingdoms such But he also red What house and the gardens. much as dare to monstrous au you that house; you to pass over tii.it your most 1 most sacred thresho (Jods of iigate face to the household A while past no man could look at, none ?
I

>

tout tears are you not ashamed Bg an inmate in such a house, where, though you have no sense, none the lev \ can
I

have seen

ships'

beaks and
IS?
It

spoils,

forecourt you think you are cannot ever

that
1

on are without
as you are, you

know both your own self, and \nd and your own fi neve that you, whether awake or asle le However drunken easy in mind nay be, as you are, it m and distract the image of that matchless t be that, when start fi man is presented to you y<>
still

-nigs,

slumber

in

terror, often too feel distraught

when
*3>

MARCUS TULLIUS CICBRO

quidem raiseret parietum ipsorum atque tectoram Quid enim umquam domus ilia viderat nisi pudlCQIB, quid nisi ex optimo more et sanctissin Fuit enim ille vir, patres conscript cum foris clams, turn domi admirandus neque rebus
i.

externis magis laudandus

quam

institutes

domest
1

Huiusinsedibusprocul)iculis rtabuU, pro cum n iluis popinaesunt uinegat. Nolite quaer> factus est ; illam mimam suain 1 suas res sibi habere iussit, ex duodecim tabulis clavis adQuam porro spectatus civis, quam probftt omni vita nihil est honestius, quam quod cum mini At quam crebro usur|)at: Kt eon 70 fecit divortium. sul et Antonius"! hoc e et consul t m pudicissimus, et consul et homo ne Quid
.1
'
:

est

enim aliud Antonius?

Nam,

si

dignitas

si

ficaretur in

nomine, dixisset, credo, al tuus se et consulem et Antonium. Numquam Dixisset etiam conlega meus, patruus tuus,
1

dixit

es solus Antonius.

Sed omitto ea peccata, quae non sunt cam in partium propria, quibus tu rem publicam vexa\ ad ipsas tuas partes redeo, id est ad civile bellum. quod natum, conflatum, susceptum open tut 71 XXIX. Cui bello cum propter timiditatt m tu.-mt. turn propter libidines defuisti.
1

Illam suam (Vat. MS.)

illam

mimam

(Halm.).

1 The wurda "keep your owu property," uml the taking away of keys, constituted a divorce. Aa Cy theria was not

uxor, this is of course sarcasm. 1 C. Ant., the colleague of C. in 63 B.C. in the conaulahip. See the Intr. to Phil. i. p. 2.

132

PHILIPPIC
awake.
roof

II.

xxvni. 6y-xxix. 71

e \ -rv walk and that hat had that house ever seen but what was pure hat sprang from the most morals and the holiest il that d r cripi Pa w, alike il abroad, and admirable at home, not more worthy of praise enta than for
1

As

donn

-How's abode brothels take place of bedrooms, taprooms of dining-rooms, now den km't enquire he has become a sober character; that actress of his he has d the Law of the Twelve Tables he has taken away her keys, has turned her
I

forth

how

tried

and tested! a man whose whole

life

shows nothing
!

than his divorce of a female mime does he use the phrase "I' consul as to say, " both consul and lness,"" both consul and very in pi what else is Ai 'h were signified in the name, yo Id, I pose, have sometimes called himself, "both sul and Anton in He never did so. My have done so, unless too, your uncle,1 won hi hance you are the only Anton Hut pass over offences not peculiar t<> Unpolitical role in which you harassed the State: ;rn to your proper n'.le, that is, to the civil war which was born, kindled, begun by your work. XX' varyou took no part in. partly through irdice,* more so through You had ts.

And how

often

i<

C. refutes hi* own charge by saying in the next sentence that A. was in the front rank at Pharsalia. Plutarch (A id. 8) also speaks of A.'s bravery.
*

133

MARCUS TULLIl
sanguinem
Pliarsalica

RO
fueras
in acie

vel

potius exorbueras;
;

antesignanus

L.I

vWBNMH
moltosqoe praeut

et nobilissiniuin virmn, occideras,

terea, qui e proelio eflfugerant,

quos Caesar

nullos

fortasse

servasset,

crudeliasime
tantis

persccutus

trucidaras.

Quibus rebus

ac talibus gestis

quid fuit causae, cur In

sequerere,

Atricam

Caesarem BOB
?

cum

praesertim belli pars tanta restaret

Itaque quern locum apud Ipsum Caesarem post eius

ex Africa reditum obtinuisti? quo iiumcro

Cuius
tu

fa

imperatoris

quaestor

fueras,

magister equitum,

belli princeps,

crudeliUtis an
fi

praedae socius, testamento, ut dicebas ipse,

appellatus es de petunia,
72 pro

quam pro
Primo

doni<>. pro

sectione

debebas.

respo
te,

ferociter et,

dum

ne omnia videar contra aequa et iusta dicebas : " A

?

prope moC.

me
?

Caesar

pecuniam
ille vicit?

cur potius

quam ego ab

illo

an sine

me

At ne

potuit quidem.

Ego ad

ilium belli

causam attuli, ego leges perniciosas ror ego arma contra consules imperatoresque populi Romani, contra senatum populumque Romaiiiim,
civilis

contra deos patrios arasque et focos, contra pa!

tuli.

Num

sibi

soli
sit

vicit?

Quorum

facinus

est

commune, cur non

Ius postulabas,

eorum praeda cominuii sed quid ad rem? Plus ille pott

rat.

1 Ego rogavi are wanting in the quoted by Nonius.

.
.

Vat MS.,

but are

134

PHILIPPIC
tasted, or rmther
l

II.

nix. 71-72
I

brill

li

<<1

mast
thou

hail drank the !>!<<. had been in the lines of Pharsal had slaii: ^untms, a -(I and Doble; and many bethe battle, whom Caesar m have spared, as he did some, you had Alter so many led and l>utlicr. d. son was then wliv you Caesar n illy so great a part of the war rcmaim rdli Caesar himself In what account was con I quaestor, when he was dictator, his of the war, the
I
i

wttt by adopted son.

bis will, as

you yourself

sta
for

moii'

the gardens, hasesat au< ti.-n. At crcd v, and for I would not appear to be

wed

for

|OSl

I-

it

iey

thont

iii-

was even beyond

I

liis

power.
I

war. propose ious laws, I took up arms against the generals of the Roman people, aga the Senate and the Human people, again t my
!

brought

\il

coun
I

Is

and

altars

and

he.i

mv

be conquer for himself alone ? Where H iv are they not also to share in the I-" but Qanded jront rights what has that to do with it? He was the stronger.
I :

35

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

73 Itaque excussis tuis vocibus et ad tc et ad praedes Ub tuos milites misit, eum repeate a te Qui risus lioinimim, tantam ease tabula prolata est.
i

tabulam, tarn
quilnis praeter

varias,

tain multas possesv partem Miseni ml

qui
n

auctionaretur, |K>sset miserabilis adspectus

suum
;

dicere

Anctii
DOfl

vestis

FompeJ

eaque maculosa, eiusdem quaedara argentea vasa |uam conlisa, sordidata mancipia, ui 74 esse ex illis reliquiis, quod videre p<>^ tamen auctionem heredes L. Hubri decreto Caesaris
prohibuerunt. Quin bis ip is temporibui habebat. Caesaris percussor ab isto missus deprehen batur esse cum sica de quo Caesar in senatu aperte Profu iscitur in in te invehens <] >t. niam Caesar paucis tibi ad tolvenduin propter ni<> piam tuam prorogatis die bus. Ne turn qui Tam bonus gladiator rudem sequeris. Hunc igitur quisquatn, qui in soil suis fortunis, tain timidus fuer XXX. Profectus est aliquando tamlt m in H 76 niam; sed tuto, ut ait, pervenire non potoit QuoOMQ modo igitur Dolabella pervenit? Ant n. enda fuit ista causa, Antoni, aut, cur >isses,
I
I

non

defendenda usque ad extremum.

navit

Which was shared with

A. had dissipated
all

A.'t
P<

creditors:

cf.

n.

'A,

p.
*

112
the rest of
his

tj

cf.

ch. 27.
*

Who
:

had made A.
cf.

nephew
136

ch.

16.

The natural

heir to the exclusion of his heirs appear to have

objected to the

sale.

PN1UPPIC

II.

titff.

73-xxx. 75

n off your expostulations, he sent ur ties, and then you and

I -

of a Hidden that wood taloguc of yours How men laughed that tliere duccd. should be such a long catalogue, such various rlcs, so many possessions out <>t which, except a share in the land at Misenum, there was nothing the man who was putting mction could d the auction itself was a miserable ipeius' wardrobe, a scanty one, and that ied some dinted silver vases of his, some sha hat any lined of slaves, so that his for us to see. Vet this was the auct heirs us Htihrius 3 stopped by Caesars dec spendthrift was in a difficulty he had nowhere Moreover at this very time an stssssin to turn. sent by him was said to have been caught at of which Caesar Caesar's house dagger in hand plained and openly attacked you in the Senate. Caesar sets OS you, because our poverty, a few days' groavment n then do you follow him. So stout a gladiator, and so quick a discharge? 4 And when he was so fearful t of his own side - 1 mean tunes is any man to stand in fear of
all
1 ;
t
i

as

Length he did set out after he says, he icfa

all for
it

Spain,
ssi(

in

Hw th Dolabella reach should never have adopted that cause, A or, having adopted it, you should have defendit to the last Three times Caesar fought with
1

his discharge

The rudit waa a wooden word given to a gladiator on from service.

137

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

cum civibus, in Thessalia, Omnibus adfuit his pugnis Dolabel
Caesar
;

Africa,

etiam vulnus accepit. Si de meo iudicio qua sed tamen consilium a primo reprehennollem dendum, laudanda constantia. Tu vcro quid es? Cn. Pompci librri turn primum patriam rej Esto, fuerit haec parti um causa commoi bant praeterea deos patrios, aras, focos, larem smmi
familiarem, in quae tu invaseras. Haec cum pet* ii, quorum erant legibus (etsi in simis quid potest esse aequi?), tamcn qoem erat aequissimum contra Cn. rompei liberal pugnare, Te sectorem. An, cum tu Narbone mensas 76 quem? hospitum convomeres, Dolabella pro te in Htopmnk dimicaret? Qui vero Narbone reditus Etiam quaerebi ego ex ipso cursu tam subito revertiss nuper, patres conscript i, causam reditu! nisi possem, etiam ante Kalendas Ianuarias prodesse rei publicae. Nam quod quaere bas, quo modo redissem :

armis

non tenebris, deinde cum Cfllcelt et nee gallicis nee lacerna. At el adspicis me, et quidem, ut videris, iratus. Ne tu iam mecum in gratiam redeas, si scias, quam me pudeat nequitiae tuae, cuius te Ipsum non pa Ex omnium omnibus flagitiis nullum turpius ridi, nullum audivi. Qui magister equitum EuUMM til>i

primum

luce,

toga,

nullis

1 i.e. of the Caesarean party, and not affecting A. individually. 2 On Sept. 2 ; cf. Phil. i. 1-3. * i.e. in the dress of a dignified Roman. mantle (Suet. Aug. 40) {lacerna), which Aug. prohibited in the forum, was regarded as effeminate and ostentatious (Margnardt 2i. obo).

138

PHILIPPIC
ies

II.

xxx. 75-76

ea, S|>ain. At all these in the Spanish one Dolabella was he also received a wound. If you ask my opinion, In had not been present; yet, though I could wish
;

nay be originally blaraeable,

is

steai

But what are you? The sons of tin- first <-us Pompeius were then seeking in place U Good! let this be their country. ted as your party's common concern. They were
laudable.
1

seeking further to recover besides their country's Gods, altars. fodl of their home, all of which you had seised. When those, whose property they were by law, were seek in reco things by arms, who thou justice can there be in iess should teas most justly have fought against the loi ;rius? who? You. the purchaser, While you at Narbo were vomiting over the tables of j hosts, was Dolabella to be battling for you in Spain ? what a return from Narbo He even asked w tsji return, when actually on my journey, was so have lately,* Conscript Fathers, explained len.

con I<1, of January to be of use to tin State. As for your question how I had returned, first I returned in daylight, not in the dark next in hoots and with a toga, DOt in any Gaulish slippers or in a mantle. 8 And yet you look at I am sure you and, as it seems, in anger. would now be reconciled to DM tf you knew how ashamed I am of your misdoings, of w hi Out of all outrages in the are not ashamed. Id I have seen not ling, heard of nothing, more
reason before tl
Ol
I
.

Is

disgraceful.

You, who imagined you had been a

'3"

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

viderere, in

proximum annum consulate

vcl

potius rogares, per municipia coloniasque Galliae, c

qua nos

turn,

cum

consulatus pctcbatur, non roga-

batur, petere consulatum solebamus,

com

lacerna cucurristi.
77

XXXI. At
diei

videte levitatem hominis.

v :

decima fere ad Saxa rubra

ibi

lit

in

quadam cauponula atque

ad vesperam
;

se occultans perpo*

inde cisio celeriter ad urbem

domum

venit capite obvoluto.

tabellarius."
1

U tutor
cj

"

(,>

"A

Marco

Confestim ad cam,
eique

causa venerat, deducitur

trad id it.
s

Quam cum

ilia

legeret

Mens (erat enim

amatorie; caput autem litterarum

posthac nihil futurum
illim
;

uima

omnem

se ainorem abiecisse

atque in hanc transfudis.se),

cum

mulier fleret
potuit,

uberius,

homo
aliud

misericors ferre

non

caput

aperuit, in

collum invasit

hominem nequ
mini possum
oj

Quid enim
dicere.

dicam

magis

pn>|i x

Ergo, ut te Catamitum, nee

78

spem mulier adspicen-* urbem terrore nocturno, Italiam multorum dierum metu perturbasti ? Et domi quidem causam ai
ostendisses, praeter
habuisti,
foris

etiam

turpiorem,

ne

L.

Plancus
tuac

praedes tuos venderet.

Productus autem in conrespondisses te

tlie

tionem a tribuno
1

pi.

cum

rei

This word

is

found in some of
1

Fulvia.

I40

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxx. 76-xxxi

78

master of the horse, who were a candidate, or rather a beggar, for the next year's coi the boroughs and colonies of Gaul, winch we, when the consulship was canvassed for, not begged for, in a tss, raced in (Jan
Hut regard the levity of the man When nth hour of the day he had reach 1 in a certain petty tavern Saxa Rubra, elf, went on drinking till even v. he anrl ly carried in a gig then< \N ho is head muffled. Door-keeper: 'A courier from Marcus." He is miare r on whose account he med had come, and he handed her a letter. While she was reading it with tears for it was written in amatory but the gist of the letter was that he would style have no! e for the future; do with he had discarded all love in that quarter, and had
I !
< I
I

'

1 the woman was weep soft-hearted fellow could not bem he unveiled his head, and fell on her neck. Oh. For what else can I what an alwmdoned fellow can say nothing more fitting. Was him? lit enjoy the it then in order that the wot

surprise of seeing a catamite

li:

had

show

unexpectedly, that you upset the ror by night, and Italy with a; An within doors, indeed, an v days? sion amour provided you with an excu < outside you
1

had an
selling

<

ucius Pint
0]

sureties.

Hut

brought before a bed replied that you had come on your peoj
141

ron had been l tribune of the

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRRO

causa venisse, populum etiam dicacnn in to r< Sed nimis multa de nugis ; ad maiora disti.

veniamus.

XXXII.
longissime

a Caesari ex
proccssisti.
si

Hispania red.
Celeritcr
isti,

viam
ut

rod

!i.

cognosceret te

Factus

es

ei

rursus

minus fortem, at tamen iMWIMUIl nesoio quo rao<:

:
j

Habebat hoc omnino Caesar quem plane aere alieno egentemque, si eundem neqtuun homii audacemque cognorat, hunc in familiarita
79 libentissime recipiebat.

His igitur rebus prat u

commendatus

iussus es renuntiari consul, et qui

cum

ipso.

Nihil queror

inpulsus, induct us, elusus.

de Dolabella, qui turn est Qua in re quanta

t

uterque
ignorat?

vestrum
ille

perndia
ut

in

Dolabellam,
transtulit
tu

quis ct
eius

induxit,

peterot.

prniuissum
;

receptum intervertit ad seque

perfidiae

voluntatem
;

tuam
cogimur

adsr
in

Kalendae Ianuariae
est copiosius

senatum

invectus
ibelll

multo

in

istum et parat

80

quam nunc ego. Hie autem iratus qua< boni Primum cum Caesar ostendisset se, priusqiunn
!

proficisceretur,

Dolabellam consulem esse iuttomm

et faceret

(quem negant regein, <jui modi aliquid et diceret)

dixisset,

semper eius
Caesar
ita

sed

cum

turn

hie

bonus augur eo se sacerc

ut comitia auspiciis vel inp
1

praeditum esse

dixit,

Antoniua,

142

PHILIPPIC

II.

XXM. /8- VVVM. 80

|>opulace ate affairs, you mac But we speak too much of witty at your expense. come to more weighty topics.

When Caesar was returning from Spain went a long distance to meet him. You made so that he might reco^: vere weak in courage, you were at least You were somehow made again strong in energy This was entirely Caesar's way miliar friend. tnd In n D a man was utterly ruined
l

\\\II

if

he recognised in that
!i

man an

audacious rascal, he
his familiarity.
qi.

most willingly admitted him into

tin
beiiifl

in

nently

recommended by these

ncations, he orders that you should be returned as 1 make no consul, and that together with himself.

complaint on Dolabella's account, who had _ed to stand, brought forward, and fobbed off. In thai mitt r who does not know how great was the treat th of you towards Dolabella ? Caesar brought him forward as a candidate, Caesar intercepted and transferred to himself what he had i.ule yourself the promised and guaranteed willing instrument of his perfidy. l'he Kalends of
1
I

lary

arrive;

we

are forced

into

ate;

bol against that fellow mocfl a fully and elaborately than 1 do now. Good heave a speech this man l made in his anger of all, although Caesar had made it clear that, before he set out, he would order Dolabella's election as say that the roan who was always of that kind was both doing ai well, when Caesar had said this, thoa asserted that he was invested with a priesthood of such a character that he could
t

143

MARCUS TULLIUS
81 In

CIGEIIO

vel vitiare posset, idque se facturum esse adscver tnink quo primuin incredibilrn.

Quid en id, quod te sacerdotn cognoscite. iure facere posse dixisti, si augur non ettei Vide, ne eti MB esses, minus facere potuisses? Nos enim nuntiutionein solum habci: facilius.

consules et reliqui magistratus etiam spectiooem, nee enim est al> hon Esto, hoc imperite; numquam sobrio postulanda prudentia s< Multis ante mensibus in sen inpudentiam. se Dolabellae comitia aut prolubiturum auspiciia aut Quisquainin- di\ id facturum esse, quod fecit. potest, quid vitii in Auspiciia futomm sit, nisi qui d<;

caelo servare constituit? quod neque per leges, et, si qui servavit, non con sed priusquam habeantur, dt b inplicata inscientia inpudentia est; nee
82

\
s<
-

ruin

Itaquc faeit, quod pudentem <1t ex illo die recordamini eius usque ad Idus Martias consulatum. Quis umquam adparitor tarn huo tarn abiectus? Nihil ipse potera abat, caput in aversam lecticam mserens b< venderet, a collega petebat. in dies. XXXIII. Ecce l)olal>ellae Sortitio praerogativae quiescit. U -mint isafcii

augurem, nee

1 An augur, as such, had no right of taking the auspice unless he was called in by a magistrate, to whom he made a report {nuntiatio, or, if unfavourable, obnuntiati< magistrate had the right of observing the heavens {upectio), and also at any rate if he were a superior magistrate, such as a consul the right of obnuntiatio to another magistrate presiding. The obnuntiatio was abolished by the Lex Clodia of 58 B.C., but the law was frequently disregarded and is here ignored by C, who, however, after \ recognises it (ncque licet per leges).

144

!:

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxxii.

80

-xxxiii.

82

by the auspices either hinder or nullify tin- ellilfcHi, II 'of he assured us he would do so. nark the !e stupidity of the man. Tins act. look you! u asserted you were able to do b\ II priesthood, would you have been less able to do if you were not an augur but consul? Surely, even more easily. we augurs have only tin right of report, the consuls and the rest of the magistrates the right also of it be this was observing the heavens. 1 require knowledge Hit in.irk his impudence from a man never sober. Many months before he said in tin Senate he 1 the auspices either forbid Dolabella's Can election, or would do what in fact he did. anyone divine what flaw there will be in the auspices except the man that has determined to he heavens? But it is illegal to do tins during an election; and he who has observed it to make his report, not when the election has made, but before it is begun. But his ignorance and hit impudence arc mixed up, and he does not know v. hat an augur should know, or act as a And so recall his consul lest man should. that day up t< the Ides of March W lackey was ever so humble, so abject? He could do tig was a request; putting e Utter he used to head into the I solicit his colleague 3 for favours whieh he could
at id
I

1.

Now comes
right
.

The
he
r

of
I

iefl

the day of Dolabella's elecvote is determined by lot lie result is announced he is

'

Ok****.

M5

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

nuntiatur suHragia; turn secunda classis vocatur quae omnia sunt citius facta, quam (ii\i. Com eres)"Auo die" negotio bonus au^ leras. 33 inquit O inpudentiam singularei quid senseras, quid audieras? Neque nun \>\ caelo servasse dixisti Dec liodic igtto? obvenit vitimn, quod to iam Kalendis f'ut urn in esse provideras et tan to ante praedixeras. Ergo hercule magna, ut spero, tua potius quam in pubUeae ralamitate emntitui in religione populum Romanum. augur auguri. consul consuli obnuntiasti. Nolo plura, ne acta Dolabellac videar convellere, quae necesse est io ad 84 nostrum collegium deferantur. Sed adrogan hominis in-iuVnti.unque cognoscite. Quaimim tu voles, vitiosus consul Dolabella rursuv emu voles,
adsolet,
;

Prima d

salvis auspiciis creatus.

Si nihil est,

cum augur
i

iis

verbis nuntiat, quibus tu nun' uni " Alio die " dixeris, sobrium non tuisse ; sin est aliqua vis in istis verbis, ea quae sit, augur a collega requiro.

Sed ne
veniamus.
esse

forte ex multis rebus gestis

transiliat oratio,

M. Antoni

nm

unam pulcherrimam

XXXIV. Nondissimulat, patres consrripti commotum; sudat, pallet Quidli

;

adparet

Called Sapiens, or the Wise. He was the younger Scipio, and is an iuterlocutor in C.'s Dc A and De Senectute. * The regular formula for " The omen are unfavourable."
8

i.e.

of augurs.
if

* i.e.

they don't mean what they say,

void.

election
i

was

But now you acknowledge

viz. that D.'s his consulship.

46

PHILIITH
dumb.
1.

II

xxxiii.

82-xxxiv. 84

The

fin! class

is

called

as usual, the votes of the knigktft] tin n the second class is called ; all this is done quicker than D the business is finished the

good augur you would call him Caius Laelius 1 says "On another day." 1 What consummate imw pudence' bi j on seen? what had you perd? what had you heard M you did not assert that you had observed the heavens, nor do y.u the say so to-day. So the flaw interposed 11 Kalends of January you had already foreseen, and so long before predicted. So, by Hercules, you
!

rf

falsified

the auspices as I hope, with great disaster to yourself, not to the State yon bound the Human v a religious liability ; as augur you
;
1

a consul. 1 do say more, or I shall appear to nullity Dolabella's acts which must some time or other be rred to our college.* But mark the arrogance and insolence of the man! So long as you choose, Dolabella is a consul with defective election again, whei <>ose, one appointed withool the ausj> s of there be not an augur's report which you employed, confess that when you said " On another day " you were not sober but it there be some force in those words, I, as an augur of his colleague, ask \ <>u what they mean. 4 Marcus But that amongst the ma speech may not accidentally pass over one act a rest of all, let us come to
to an augur, as consul to
;
:

the Lupercalia.

WXIV. He
Ipt

Fathers
pale.

grows

does not disguise his feelings, Conclear he is moved, he sweats, he Let him do what he pleases, except
;

it is

M7

MARCUS TULL1US CICERO

nauseet, faciat, quod
potest
esse

porticu

His
defensio

Quae
Ctopfo

turpitudinis

tantae

audire, ut videam, ubi rhetoris sit tanta

est ubi

m
toga

campus Leontinus appareat.

in
rostris

85

Sedebat
purpurea

conlega
aurea

tuus

in

sella
(ita

coronatus.
ui

Eso
suit

accedis ad sellam,

eras Lupercus,

esse nieminisse deberes) toto

foro.

sustuleras,

cogitatum

diadema ostcndis. (iemHot Unde diadeina? Non cnim et sed adtuleras domo meditatum scelus. Tu diadema inponebas
ille

plangore populi,
esses

cum

plan
i

ergo
:'i

unus, sceltrute, inventus es, qui

uin

auct.

eumque, quern collegam habehas, quid habere velles, idem temptares,

dom
j<

>;

86

Romanus

ferre

et
;

pati

posset.

At etiam

cordiam captabas

supplex te ad pedes abiciebas.

1

Quid petens? ut

servires

IbJ uni peteres,

t

qu

a puero vixeras, ut omnia patercre, ut

a nobis populoque R<

non praeclaram illam eloquentiam cum es nudus contionatus Quid line turpi us, quid foedius quid suppliciis omnibus di.
habebas.

exspectas,

dum

te stimulis fodiainus?

Haec

te,

si

ullam partem habes sensus, lacerat, haec cruentat oratio. Vereor, ne imminuam summorum
1

cf. uh.

25

ante.

> cf.

ch. 27 ante.
:

8
*

Caesar.

An allusion

to his relations with Curio

cf. ch.

18.

148

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxxiv.

84-86

being sick, as he was in the Portico of Minueius. 1 can there be for such disgraceful conI duct ' long to hear, by way of understanding where In presented, say, where the Leontine land* shows a return. Your colleague* was seated on the rostra, clad in lrple gown, on a golden chair, with a wreath. You mount up, you approach the chair if you were Luprrcus. yet you should have remembered you were consul too you display a diadem. There is a Whence came the groan all over the forum. diadem? For you had not picked up soiiicti. cast away, but had brought it from your house, a crime rehearsed and fully planned. Von persisted ni put tin.: it on his head amid the lamentations of the people; he amid their applause persisted You then, traitor, were disin reje< covered to be the one man who, while establishing a tyranny and willing to have your colleague as r master, were at the same time making trial ian people could bear and end Nay, you even courted compassion you threw yourAsking for what? self as a suppliant at his feet Slavery? Kttld have askod yourself alone, whose life from boy showed you would submit 4 to anything, would lightly be slave; from us and from the Roman people at least you had not Oh. how splendid was that that as a mandate. eloquence of yours when you hanangned naked! What is more disgraceful, more foul than this, what more any punishment Arc \<>u waiting for us to spit you with an ox-goad ? These words of mine, if you have any particle el feel these tear you, cut you to the heart. I fear
'

'

149

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

gloriam;
indiimius

dicam

quam
?

vivere

tamen dolore commotflt: Quid eum, qui inposuerit diad

ini

cum omnes
87 abiecerit

fateantur

At etiam ad

LupercaliaC. Caesari dicta'

M
cmm
in
t

in

ete,
'is

qui

\i

'

ad nunn

consulem populi iussu regnum detulisse; Cacs lam iam minime mi: uti noluisse.
perturbare, non raodo urbera odisse, sed etia

cum

perditissimis latronibus

non solum de
tu
in

die, sed

etiam in diem vivere. 1

sistes?

Ubi
in

jwice

conioatu

qui locus

tibi

legibus et in imluiis esse

potest,

quae

tu,
?

quantum

Ideone L. Tarquinius ex Cassius, Sp. Maelius, M. Manliu

regio sustulisti

it

multifl

post saeculis a

M
ad

Homae
88

constitueretui

XXXV. Sed

auspicia

redeamus,

de

quibus

Idibus Martiis fuit in senatu Caesar acturus.

Qua

Turn tu quid egisses? Audiebam te paratum venisse, quod me de ementitis ausp quibus tamen parere necesse erat, put a res esse dicturum. Sustulit ilium diem fortuna rei publl num etiam tuum de auspiciis judicium Interital
Caesaris sustulit?

Sed
1

incidi in id

tempo

quo

rebus, in quas ingressa erat oratio, praevertendum

Bihtre (Muller).

Brutus and Cassius, and the other conspirators. would A. have opposed Caesar, or would he have declared Dolal>ella duly elected ? 3 i.e., until they had been declared invalid. 4 The death of Caesar prevented discussion.
1

* i.e.,

i5

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxxit. 86-xxxv. 88

lessening the glory <>:" tflastrioaa men; 1 yet I will speak, moved as I am by indignation. What is more shameful than that li g who set on diadem, while all men confess that he was

who

flung

it

away?

But he even

indcr the Lupercalia in the pub; To Caius Caesar, perpetual dictator, Marcus Antonius the consul, by OOOUMad "t he kingship: Caesar was un the willing. " By now I cease wholly to wonder th.it peace discomposes you ; that you hate, not only the hut even the Ugllti that you lhe I
i .

on what the day the day. Fof vJkerC m peace will you plant your foot? What place can tin re I the laws and the courts i, so far as you could, you overthrew by Was it for this Lm the tyranny of a king? is was banished, Spurius Cassius. 9 reus Manlius were put to death, Mae many generations after, by an act of desecration, a should be set up by Marcus Antonius a king

most abandoned brigands,

brings, but also
<

Hut let us return to the au^; subject with which Caesar intended to deal in the Senate on the Ides of March* I ask, what would

WW.

you thru have doner* 1 heard indeed you had come primed, because you thought to speak on the falsification of the auspices, which That day the fornevertheless* we had to obey. tune of the Roman people made abortive. 4 Did the death of Caesar also make abortive your opinion of Bat I have lit U|K>n a time which I allude to before touch upon those matters 1
I
I
I

MARCUS TULUUS CICERO

Quae tua fuga, quae forniido praeclaro ill. <li\ quae propter conscirntiam loelemm dcxpcratio vitae, cum ex ilia fu#a beneficio eorum. qui tc, si sanus domum tc esses, salvum esse voluerunt, clam O mea frustra semper 89 recepisti Dicebam illis in Capitolta rerum futurarum liberatoribus nostris, cum me ad te ire vellcnt nt ad
est.
!
!
.

defendendam rem public-am te adbottarer, simul metueres, omnia te promissunnn

;

<|

;i

Itaque, cum ceteri similem te futumm t ui. consulares irent, redirent cquc te illo die neque postero vidi, neque ullam s< optimis civibus cum inporUmissin foedere tmui ullo confirmari posse credidi. Post d veni in aedem Tclluris, et quidem invitus, 90 omnes aditus armati obsiderent QoJ tibi dies ille, Antoni, fuit? Quamquam naihi InfantaM inbtto extitisti, tamen me tui miseret, quod til rig. XXXVI. Qui tu vir, di itmnortales, et quanta* fuisses, si illius diei mentem scrvare potuisses! Pacem haberemus, quae erat facta per obsidem puertim nobilem, M. Hambalionis ncpot. in Qoaav
desisses,
-

en

quam bonuni te timor faciebat, DOB diuti. magister officii, improbum fecit ea, quae, dum timor abest, a te non discedit, audacia. inm, -urn optimum te putabant me quidem disscutii -nt-, funeri tyranni, si illud funus fuit, scelr:
1

.*

patriotic role he had at firt adopted : Phil. i. 1. * A.'8 son by Fulvia. He and Lepidus sent their sons to the conspirators in the Capitol as pledges for their seci. cf. Intr. to Phil, i., p. 8. Bambalio is described in Phil, nt
* cf.

On March 15. By abandoning the

6 as " hotno nullo numero."

152

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxxv. 88-xxxvi. 90

had begun to discuss. What a flight was yours what a panic on that notable day what despair of life through consciousness of guilt when, att kf
!

t, thanks to those that wished your safety re sane, you secretly found refuge in J Oh, how to no purpose have my auguries of home future been ever unerring told those, our I liber 1 the Capitol, 1 when they widud me to approach you and exhort you to defend the State, that) so long as you were afraid. jpM would promise anything, hut that, as soon as you ceased to
!
!

fear, you would be like yourself. So, when the other consular were going to and fro, I abided by my opii; did 166 ><>u on that day, or on the next 1 believe that any alliance could be /ens established by any treaty between the Two days after and their most savage enemy. indeed, cam seeing that armed beset all the approa< ugh What a day was that for you, An have suddenly stood forward as my enemy, yet I pity you for having been grudging to your own
I
i

mm

-.*
I

i\ Heavens! what a man and bo* great you would have been had you been able to keep We should be en] that day ing the peace that was made through tin hostage, a boy of good birth, the grandson of Marcus Bam3 i] Howevet it was fear no steadfast teacher of duty that made you good: what made you unprincipled was that which, in the absence of fear, never departs from you, And even tl. iry to my belief, thought \<u D loyal, you most criminally presided at the tyrant's
r 1
> 1

153

MARCUS TULI.IUS CICERO

91 praefuisti.

Tua ilia pulchra laudatio, tua raise tua cohortatio; tu, tu, inquam, illas far et eas, quibus semustulatus ille est, et ea hVUieni domus deflagra\it; tu illos incensa L. impetus perditormn hominOB et ei maxima parte servorum, quos nos vi raanuque reppulimus, in Idem tamen quasi ful nostras domos in mi -Mi. abstersa reliquis diebus in Capitol io praeclara senatus consulta feeisti, ne qua post Idus Martias immunitatis tabula neve cuius beneficii figen lUte Meministi ipse, de exulibus, sets, d quid dixeris. Optimum wro, quod dictaturae noraen in perpetuuin de re publica sustul t';icto tantum te cepisse odium rtgnJ \ nl<l> itur, ut eius omne nomen l propter proximum Constituta res publica videbat ur 92 metum tolleres. aliis, mihi vero nullo modo, qui omnia te ffubernante nuufragia metuebam. Sum igitur me fefellit, aut num diutius sui potuit dissimilis esse? In^, bus vobis toto Ca pit olio tabulae figeb.-mtur, neque solum singulis venibant immunitates, sed el populis universis; civitas nor sed I, provinciis totis dabatur. Itaque, si haec mm: quae stante re publica manere non possunt, pro vincias universas, patres conscript i, perdidittit, neque vectigalia solum, sed etiam imp num p<.|)iili BflOMBl huius domesticis nundinis deminutum est. XXXVII. Ubi est septiens miliens, quod l 93
i

1 Omrte nomen (Muretus, followed by (Vat. MS.).

Halm)

omen nomen

ad
ill

sneer, and untrue. C. himself says (Ej>p. that Caesar was *' in foro combustus." The soot of Caesar's cremation, with the second sense of deeds.
Alt. xiv. x. 1)

An unworthy

154

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxxvi. 90-xxxvii. 93

Yours was that beautiful funeral, if a funeral it was. panegyric, yours the commiseration. exhottou, 1 say, kindled those torches, those ation alike by which he was half cremated, 1 and those by 1 the house of Lucius Bellienus was set on fire and burnt down ; you it was who directed aga. <>se assaults of abandoned men, for the most part slaves, which we repelled by force of arms. the less it was you too who, as if you had wiped off the soot,* on the following days in the Capitol carried noble decrees that, after the Ides of March, no placard of I I from taxation or of You yon any privilege should be posted up. remember about the exiles, you know what you said he exemptions. And, best thing of all, you abolished out of the State for ever the title of dictator, and by this action indeed it seemed you had conceived such a hatred of kingship that, on account of our recent fear of a dictator, you were abolishing its very name. The State seemed to others established, but by no means so to me, who feared shipwreck while you were at the wheel. Did character escape me? or could he any longer be unlike bhntcU } In \.ur very faces, all over the Capitol, placards were being posted up, and ex*
.

'

were being sold, not to individuals only, hut to whole States; tin p was no longer ;t to whole provinces. being given Accordingly, if these things remain and State stands they cannot you, Conscript Fathers, have lost whole provinces and not revenues only, bat the very empire of the Homan people has been
1
'

dun

this

man's domestic
tic the seven

\\

II.

Where

hundred millions
151

MARCUS TULLIUS
tabulis,

C\<

'.!
1

quae sunt ad Opis? funestae illius qui. pecuniae, sed tamen quae nos, si ns. quorum erat, Tu autem redderetur, a tributis posset vindicare. quadringentiens sestertium, quod Idibus Ma

modo ante Kalcndas \\ Sunt ea quidem innumerabi a tuis emebantur non insciente te,sed unuroegrede rege Deiotaro populi Roman! amicis&im crat quo pro; turn in Capitolio fix um Qttli 94 qui in ipso dolore ri ram posset continerc. enim cuiquam inimicior quam Deiotaro Caesar? aeque
debuisti,

quonam
?

debere desisti

atque huic ordini, ut omnibus, quibus rem publican) popoll Komani c.iram Igitur, a quo vivo nee praesens esse sentiebat. nee absens rex Deiotarus qnic(|uam aequi boni
impetravit,

apud

mortuum

fact us

est

Compellarat hospitem praesens, conputantt iam imperarat, in eius tetrarchi a amino ei (>raecis comitibus suis collocarat, Armenian) abstulerat a senatu datam. Haec vivus eripuit, reddit rnortuus. 95 At quibus verbis? Modo aeqiumi mIm vi non iniquum. Mira verborum complexio! At ille numquam (semper enim absenti ad: taro) quicquam sibi, quod nos pro illo postularemus, aequum dixit videri. Syngrapha sestertii centiens
:

As representing the blood and the

confiscated property

of citizens, particularly of the Potnpeians. In I'hd. i. 7 calls the money cruenta. 1 King of Galatia, an adherent of Pompeii. Caesar deprived him of part of his dominion, and was pr. to deprive him of the rest on a false charge brought against him by his grandson of plotting Caesar's death. Cicero defended him before Caesar in the speech Pro Rege Deiotaro. A. for a bribe contracted to restore him : see infra.

56

PHILIPPIC

if.

urn

93-95

entered in the account-books at the Temple of Ops ? moneys, ill-omened, 1 it is true, but which, if not owner, might yet set us free from And you, how did you before tin property taxes. Kalends of April cease to owe the forty mil ieed sesterces you owed on the Ides of Mar. iimuiii. r il.l. re the decrees that were being purchased from your partisans, not wi' if knowtit one remarkable decree concerning King 'tarus* a great Mend of Ibc Koman people, was at posted 111 the Capitol it was proposed, - was no man, even in the midst of his gi For who was ever that could restrain his laughter. more hostile to any man than Caesar to Deiotarus ? as hostile as he was to this our order, to the equestrian order, to the Massilians, to all to whom he hit the Koman people was dear. ly, while from tin- living man Kmg Deiotarus, lirr present or absent, never won any just kindness, on death he became the object of his ir. Face to face uitli Ins host, he had called him to account ; had reckoned the sums ; had uided the money ; had settled one of his own bad taken away ek companions in his tArmenia, the gift of the Senate. These things took away m lite, he returns them in death. But in what words?* At one time "it seems fair," at another " not unfair." A wonderful conof words But Caesar never acknowledged always appeared for Deiotarus in his absei 1 and know that any claims we made on his behalf seemed fair. A bond for ten million sesterces was
: ;

C. quote from Caesar's supposed

Lex Julia de Deio57

taro.

MARCUS TULLIUS

CICEI

per legatos, viros bonos, sed timidos et imperitos, sine nostra, sine reliquorum hospitum regis senfc facta in gynaecio est, quo in loco plurimae
venierunt et v.ncinit.
acturus, meditere censeo.
nullis

Qua ex syngrapha quid

Rex enim

sis

ipse sua sponte

comiuenUriis Caesaris, simul atque and suo Marte res sua 96 Sciebat homo sapiens ius semper hoc fuissc tyranni eripuisseut ea tyrann dbos
eius

interitum,

erepta essent, reciperarent.

sultus,

Nemo

igitur

ne iste quidem. <|ui tibi uni est iure consu per quern haec agis, ex ista syngrapha dcberi d pro iis rebus, quae erant ante syi ratae. Non enim a te emit, sed, priusquam tu st
sibi

venderes,

ipse

possedit.

llle

DOS

quidem contemnendi, qui

defendimus.
97 quid

actorem

odimus,

acta

Quid ego de commentariis infi innumerabilibus chirographis loq quorum etiam institores sunt, qui ea tamquam gladiatorum libellos palam venditent. Itaque tanti
de

XXXVIII.

acervi

nummorum apud latum construuntur, ut iam expendantur, non numerentur pecuniae. At quam caeca avaritia est! Nuper fixa tabula est,
locupletissimae
statuiturquc,

civitates

Cretensiura

vectigaHbus

ne post M. Brutum pro consule sit Creta provincia. Tu mentis es cot tu non constringendus? An Caesaris deer
liberantur
1

"omni
1

C. says (ad AU. xiv. 12) that Deiotarus was regno diynus, sed non per Fulviam" Caesar.
Fulvia's.

'S3

PHILIPPIC

II.

xxxw:. 95 xxxwii. 97

signed through the agency of envoys good men, h hut timid inexperienced, and without mv advice <r that ot" the rest of the King's friends: this was m the women's apartment, a place where many On this bood igi have been and are sol<) >e yoa to consider what you are to do. For the iself, of his own motion, apart from Caesar's note-books, as soon as he heard of his death, recovered his own by his own valour. Being a wise man he knew that it had always been held lawful ints had seized, those from whom it was the tyrants had been slain. recover iwycr therefore, not even that one who advises you, his one client, through whom you are now acting, that says there is a debt on that bond for things that had been recovered before tinhe himself was made. For he did not I; took possession before you should sell him Ins own property He was a ndeed are to be - but defend his acts. \\ What am I to say of the endless notebooks, the innumerable autographs? of whieh t are even hawkers to sell them openly as if they were gladiatorial programmes. Thus such huge heaps of coin are bein^ piled up in that house of liit moneys are now being weighed out, not counted. Hut how blind is avarice Irately an advertisement has been posted, whereby the most ununities of the Cretans are l>* from tribute, and it is ordained that 1 the proo Marcus Brutus Cret should be no longer a province. Are you in possession of your wits ? Should you not be put under restraint ? Could Crete by decree of Caesar be exempted after
.

whm

mm

59

MARCUS TULLIUS

CICEI
l

post M. Bruti decessum potait liberal nihil ad Brutum Caesare vivo pertincret venditione decreti, ne nihil actum pot

>eU

At

hi

ciam Cretam perdidistis.

legem, quam insector calamitatem
bus
;

Omnino
Caesar

MM
tu
j

nllM
<!

98 mit emptor, cui defoerit hie veodil

fixisti,
;

<-\ulilllittl

tantum queror, reditus inquinatos, 1 quorum causam Caes deinde nescio cur non reli milera iudicarit neque enim plus quam tres aut idem tribuas 111 calamitate sunt, quattuor reliqui sunt Qu cur tua misericordia non simili fruuutur, cur COS habes in loco patrui ? de quo ferre, com de r-l u| u is
;

ferres, noluisti

quern etiam ad eeiiMiram pet r

aut<

nam
arum

impulisti

99 lisus comitia non hahuisti

eamque prtitionem compar. hominum et querellas m Cur

?

an quia tribunus

pi.

sun

fulmen nuntiabat?
auspicia
sunt,

Cum

tua quid interest, nulla

turn
(is

cum tuorum,
in

reli^x

Quid? eundem
ne^are
onerasti,

septemviratu nonne d<

intervenit enim, cui metuisti, credo,

ne salvo capite

non

poshes.

Omnibus
si

eum
ei<

quem

patris loco,

ulla in te pietas c

colere debebas.
1

Filiam eius sororem tuam

Some

editions road exntquaJoa (equalised).

1 Caesar had nominated B. to Macedonia. Tinlation as to Crete could thus not be a genuine " ac' Caesar's.

8 An impossible conclusion. The lo*s of tribute was not ' Von " is the Senate. the loss of a province. 8 As not being reprobates cf. ch * Because the uncle had been convicted of extortion, and expelled by the censor from the Senate.
:

160

PHILIPPIC
the departure of
(>t!

II.

vuMii. 97-99

Marcus Brutus when Crete had u t us when Caesar was ali\

I

But by the sale of ree lest you sli think nothing has been done you have lost the province <t Crete.1 In fact tlurr never was a but this man was the seller. And as to the law concerning the exiles which adve I rail at no did Caesar pro|>ose that? m u. *in of; first as been cast on the return of those whose case Caesar judged to be distinguishable;' next 1 fail to see why you do not grant the same re than three or lour favour to the rest Why <lo those in the same misfortune nt remain ency ? W also enjoy at your hands the mi whose behalf do you rank
4

in

tkr I

and
<

whom
i

[WOpOl win | urged to stand

for

organised a canvass that moved n. 4 and But why did you ? or was it because a trill thunder on the I. it ) When
i
:

any

are that of your friei you scrupulous. Again, in the case of not leave him in tin* lurch } septemvirs 4 I

when

some one
fear.

in

wh
your

Hlppose-

> u
i

vat the

peril of

life.

with every insult

affection
father.

the

mm

IOU

Ion

whom
to
ha-.

liad

any
as a

m
*

\.u. \<.u

OVjrhl

His daughter,* your cousin, you turned tut

As
9

to this see Phil. vi. 5 Anionis, his second v.

161

MARCUS TULLIUS
alia

CICE1

condicione quaesita et ante perspecU.

Non
DOR

est satis; probri insimulasti

pudicissimam feminam

Quid
fuisti.

est,

quod addi

possit?

G
K
Doiftbella

CO

Frequentissimo senatti
tibi esse

sedente patruo hanc

odii

cum

causam
tuae
in

ausus

es,

quod ab eo
esse

sorori

et

uxori

stuprum oblatum
pretari

comperisses.

Quis

potest,

impudentiorne, qui in senatu, an

inprobior, qui in Dolabellam, an inpurior, qui pa*

audiente, an crudelior, qui in illain

spurce, tarn impie dixeris?
100

miseram

tain

XXXIX. Sed
confirmata
egisset,

ad chirographa redearaus.

Quae
causa

tua fuit cognitio?

Acta enim Caesaris

quae
ista

|>acis

sunt a senatu;
ea,

quae quidera
Caesar-

Caesar
dii

non

egisse

m
si

Antonius.
feruntur
?

Unde
At
actis

erumpunt, quo auctore pro

probantur
}

Si sunt falsa, cur

sic placuerat,

vera,

veneunt?
Caesaris
fuit

ut Kalendis Iimiis de
cognosceretis.

cum

consilio

Quod
quas quas te
rettu-

consilium,

quern

umquam
an

convocasti,
eas,

Kalendas lunias expectasti?

ad

peragratis veteranorum coloniis stipatum

listi ?

arm is

praeclaram illam percursationem tuam D

Aprili atque Maio, turn

1

cum etiam Capuam

is

colon iam

Fulvia.

"You"

here Antonius.

162

PHILIPPIC
!>ors

II.

xxxvi.i. ,,9-xxxix.
first

ioo

when you had

a

sought and provided for

anot!
niscoiuhict
e

woman

not enough; you accused of the greatest punt v.

said

more?

You were not con

f the Senate on of January, in the presence of your uncle, you dared to allege this as vour reason Dolabella -jour discovery of his attempted adul' yur cousin and wife. Who can determine whether you were the more In ie Senate, or more desperate like this charge in to make it against Dolabella, or more indecent to make it in jroof uncle's hearing. >r more cruel to make it in such foul and unnatural fashion against in ? that unh.i Hut let us return to the autographs. What was your enquiry? For the acts of Caesar were, for the sake of peace, confirm. <| by the Senate ; is to say, Caesar's own "acts/* not such as had said were Caesar's. From what source do those acts burst forth? on whose authority are ilse, why are they held val it true, why sold ? But the resolution was in these Kal t, that after the mc too Senator! should enquire into Caesar's "acts" with the Ik What commission was there? *i a commission. you 1 ever summon? what Kalends of June you wait for? or was it those Kalends on wl. you had made a progress through the colonics of veterans, you brought yourself back, surrounded

with

tli.it.

At a crowded

VWIV

by armed
it

men ?
.

a splendid excursion was that of you: months of April and Ma\ at the time en attempted to found a colony at

63

MARCUS TULLIUS CK
deducere
conatus
!

101 abieris vel potius

Quern ad modum illimes paene non abieris, scimus. Cui tu

Utinam conere, ut aliquando lllod At quam nobilis est tua ilia Quid prandiorum adparatus, quid peregrinatio! Tua ista furiosam vinulentiam tuam proferam ? Agrura Camp unim, detrimenta sunt, ilia nostra.
urbi minitaris.

"paene"

tollatur!

qui

cum de

vectigalibus eximebatur,
rei

ut

imlitilnis

daretur,

tamen infligi magnum putabamus, hunc tu compran

soribus

pul
uis

ulnus
et conlu

dividebas.

conscripti, in agro

Mimos dico et mimas, Campano collocates. Q

t

patres

querar de agro

Leon

inn

qoootaa <|uidm hae

i

quondam arationes Camjvma et Leontin in popnlJ Romani patrimonio grand ferae et fructuosae ferei

102

iugcrum quid si 1 te te discrtum facere sanasset? rhetori duo; quid, si potuisset? Sed ad iter Italiamque rcdcamua. XL. Deduxisti coloniam Casilinum, quo Caesar
bantur.

Medico

tria

milia

ante deduxerat. Consuluisti me per litteras de Capua tu quidem, sed idem de Casilino respondisscm,
possesne, ubi colonia esset, eo coloniam

novam

iure

deducere.

Negavi
;

in

earn

coloniam,

quae esset

auspicato deducta,

dum

esset incolura

niam

novam

iure deduci

colonos novos adscribl posse

insolentia elatus

rescripsi.
1

Tu autem

omni auspid-

So the Vat. MS.

The other MSS.

rea/1 quasi.

A. was roughly handled by the Capuans cf. space marked out sub auspiciis a Umj
:

wu

1'hil. xii. 7.

place

Nieb. Hist. Rom.

2. 625.

164

PHILIPPIC
Capua
(1
1
!

II.

XXXIX. IOO-XL. I02

How you

departed thence, or rather aln

That city you 1 to depart, 1 we know. lw>pe you will make an attempt on it so that that (1 "almost" may at last be eliminated Hut
!

what a

ogress of yours followed!

j

Why

should I reveal the win nous ness of those lunches, Those are the madness of your winer losses: these are ours. The m land, whose exemption from tribute in order that it should be given to the soldiers we yet thought was Inflicta great wound on the B u were Of your boon -com Mini cms and fellowMDblen Male and female mimes, I say, Conscript iers, were planted on tl panian land After that why should I complain of the Leontine these arable farms in lend? as I well mlgkl Campanian and land used to be deci vastly productive and fruitful as part of the |> monv of the Roman people. To your doctor three thousand seres : what would he have got if he made you sane? To your rhetorician what it lie had been able to make you eloquent ? But let us return to \ la colony at Casilinum where XL. You Caesar had founded one before. You consulted me by Capua, it is true, but I should n-ply sbcSjf ( isilmum have made could you legally found a new colony where there was one al reach said that where a colony had been under the auspices, while the latter existed a new colony could not legally !>< founded but that new colonists could be added I admitted in my Bat you, insolently elated, and ui all the law of the auspices, founded a colony at
t
1
>

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRRO

iure turbato Casilinum coloniam deduxi lU, quo erat paucis annis ante deducta, ut wxillum ut aratruni circuiiiduceres J cuius quidnn von portam Capuae paene perstrinxisti. ut Ab hac pertur103 coloniae territoriuin miiiucrrtur. bationeroli^ionumadvolasin M. Varronis,aai

orum

atque integerriini viri, t'uiidum Casinatem quo ore? " Eodem," inquies, " qiu m beredin
*

Kubri, quo in heredum L. Turseli praedia, <)u.. al> hasta, reliquas innumerabiles possessiones." Kt valeat hasta, valeant tabulae, modo Caesaris, non tuae non quibus tu te libera quibus debuisti,
i

Varronis quidem Casinatt

dicit, quis

in

tnnilum quia venisse

hastam

istius venditioni! \i<lit, quis

vocem

Misisse te dieis Alex praeconis audivit ? enim qui emeret a Caesare ; ipattm ullius Quis vero audivit urn 104 magnum fuit. autem salus curae pluribus fuit) de fortunis Varr. rem ullam esse detractam? Quid ? si etiam ad te Caesar, ut redderes, quid satis potest Remove gladios parump< tanta impudentia? quos videmus; iam intelleges aliam causam esse hastae Caesaris, aliam confidentiae et temeritatis tuae; non enim te dominus modo ill; qui vis amicus, vicinus, hospes procurator arc XLI. At quam multos dies in ea villa turpi es perbacchatus Ab hora tertia bibebatur, batur, vomebatur. tecta ipsa misera "quam
<
i
|

1 Colonists proceeded to the site of the new colony in military array (sub rexillo), and the boundaries of the new city were marked out by the plough. 2 Tabulae is used in two senses, "auction catalogues," and so "auction," and "accounts" (of the money in the Temple of Ops).

166

PHILIPPIC

II.

XL. I02-XI.I.

I04

Casilinum, where a few years before one had been founded, so that j raised your standard, and marked boundaries by the plough ; yes, and by that ploughshare ym almost gUMM tin- gBM tt" l.ipu.i. colony was so that the t< rr ; nished. From this unset tlement of religious rules you swoop down on to the farm at Casinum of Marcus Varro, a most pious and honest man. By whn' with what fareThe same, you will he farms of the heirs say, with win of Lucius Rubrius, of Lucius Tursellius, innumerable And if you bought at auction, let other posse MJ on the auction stand, let the accounts stand, provided they are Caesar's, not yours ; those by which you were a debtor, not those whereby \<>u Med yurself
l

asserts it

was sold

that sale ? who say you sent an agent to Alexandria to buy it from Caesar; tor it was too much to wait for the man himself! But who ever heard for no man's safety was of more general concern that any thing had been filch d from Varro's property ? Again Caesar even wrote to you to restore it, what adequate description could be given of such impuden for a while those swordsmen we see you will soon understand that Caesar's auction is one thing, r assurance and rashness anot! not the <r himself only, but any friend of his, neighbour, guest, steward, will drive you from that dwel \I.I. Hut how many days did you most disgracefully carouse in that villa! From the third hour 8 was drinking, gaming, v< nehtfTfTJ
1

Varro's farm at ft who the spear that marked heard the voice of the auctioneer ?
?

who saw

>

'

The usual hour

for the etna

waa the

ninth.

167

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

sed
105

dispari

domino
tanien

" (quamquam juo quam ah dispari

imxio iste dominus

?)

9tadi-

orum enini suorum M. V'arro Quae dinum deversorium.

!

voluit
in

Mud,

MB
I

lili

ilia

villa

dicebantur, quae cogitabantur, quae litteris BMU Iura populi Romani, monimeuta maiorum. bantur omnis sapientiae ratio omnisque doctrinae. At
te inquilino (non

enim domino) personabant

01

vocibus ebriorum, natabant pavimenta vino, bant parietes, ingenui pueri eum meritoriis, scorta inter matres familias versabantur. Casino kjiI ut.it um veniebant, Aquino, lntrramna; admissus est lure id quidem in homine enim turpissimo ob

MM

fiebant dignitatis insignia.

106

proccssit, ut est frequens municipium, magna sane multitudo. At iste opcrta lectica latus per oppidum est ut mortuus. Btofa Aquinates; sed tamen in via habitaban Anagnini? Qui cum essent devii, detcenderapf istum, tamquam si esset, consulem aalutn Incredibile dictu f sed turn nimis b stabat neminem esse resalutatum, praesertim um duos secum Anagninos haberet, Mustelam et Laconem, quorum alter gladiorum est princeps, alter poculorum. Quid ego illas istius minas contmne107 basque commemorem, quibus invectus

Cum inde Ruinam accederet, ob viani ti

profiriscens

ad

Aquinum

1 Dictum sed cum uinus (Vat.) dictu est sed sum vicmus (Madvig and Halm) riictu est tamen vicin>* inter omnes (Orelli). The text is Halm's following two M
;

A
Off.

quotation from an
1.139.

unknown poet

C. also quotes it

De

168


PHILIPPIC
how was
II.
xi...

104-107

what an ill-matched owner that fellow an owner ? at any rate For Varro with what an ill-matched tenant! (1 that house to be a retreat for his own studies. What discussions formerly took, place ir that villa, what meditations what thoughts were The laws of the Roman people, Morials of antiqui? system of philosophy and of learning. Hut in \ <ur tenancy tor no owner were you the whole place rang with the
!

drunken men the pavements swam with be walls were wet; boys of free birth were consorting with those let for hire ; harlots with
<s of
;

mothers of families. Men came from Casinum to pay their respects, from Aquinum, from Interamna; That indeed was right for, 'ic |>erson of so vile a man. the insignia of rank becoming rol g out for Rome from that place, he .\<{innum, as the borough is a Ite a large crowd came to meet b he was carried through the town in a closed r like a corpse. The people of Aquinum acted the ttshly, but they lived on the way. igh they lived off the road, e down to greet t: m as consul, as though were really such. The story is past belief". but at that time was fully accepted, that no man was greeted in return, and that though he had with him ignians, Mustela and the one the prune of swordsmen, the other of topers Why reals and insults of that fellow which he Inveighed against the Sidicinians, and harassed the men of Puteoli, for having adopted
;
1
1

169

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

vexavit

patronos
iudicio,
vi et

quod C. Cassium et Magno quidem benivolentia, caritatc, non ut tc et

Puteolanos,

Brutoi
Basil um

adoptassent?

armis et alios vestri similes, quos

habere

velit, non modo Moroni cliens esse. XLII. Interea dum tu abes, qui dies illc conlegac 1, turn in tui fuit, cum illud, quod venerari soleba

foro

evertit!

Qua
;

re

tibi

nuntiata, ut ronstabat

inter eos, qui

ncril una fuerunt, con postea, nescio metum credo valuisse et arm legam quidem de caelo detraxisti eflecistique non tu quidem etiam nunc, ut siinilis tui, sed certe ut
;

dissimilis esset sui.

108

totiusurbis

Qui vero inde reditus Roinam, quae perturbatio Memineramus Cinnam nil Sullam postea dominantem, modo Caesarem reg;
!

tern videramus.

Erant fortasse gladii, sed absconditi quae et quanta barbaria est! Agmine quadrato cum gladiis secuntur, scutorum lecticas portari videmus. Atque his qaftdk in iam inveteratis, patres conscripti, consu tinlnir obduruimus. Kalendis Iimiis cum in senatum, ut
nee
ita multi.

Ista vero

erat constitutum,

venire

vellemus,

metu
potius

pefterrit!

repente diffugimus.
109

At

iste,

qui senatu non eg*

et

neque desideravit
efTecit.

quemquam

discessu

nostra laetatus est statimque

sui causa, is leges Caesaris,

ilia

mirabilia facinora
lucri

Qui chirographa Caesaris defendisset

easque praeclaras, ut rem

Dolabella.

Cf. n. to Phil.

i.

2.

170

'

PHILIPPIC

II.

xli.

107-x.n

109

Caius Cassius and the Brutuses at patrons ? This did with great seal and jfl m kindness rcc of am s. the way in wlm-h and affct you and Basilus, and others like whoa no man would wish to have as clients,
1

much
\I
over'

leSS a> patrons.

11.

In
'

the

what a day

absence, r colleague that was when he fonnn the altar 1 you were wont to was reported to you as was
in
l

evident to those with you

fear
linn,

io

you not

colla|*ed.

What
suppose

know

prevailed

and colleague, it is dragged down from heaven, and made not ew n now indeed like you, but at least
himself.
!

Hut what a return was there then to Rome what inhered of the whoh a's excessive power, Sulla's domination afterward ; lately we had seen the reign of Caesar. n possibly there were swords, hut they were hidden, and n..t very many. Hut what a barbaric display is this of yours Sword in hand they follow
!

him

in

battalions;

of shields
this,

we

see

litterloads

carried.
iers,

And
has

to
it

all

so

habitual,

Const

1 us of June, although we wished to attend the Senate, as had been arranged, yet overcome by fear we of a sudden fled in all s. But he, having no need of a Senate, missed no man's presence he rather rejoiced at our departure, and at once carried out those a
.

become, custom has

ilends

;gh

signatures for his

own

profit,

he had defended Caesar's yet he upset Caesar's

III

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

publicam
concutere
posset,
evertit.

annorum provinces prorogavit, idemque cum actoruin

Caesaris defensor esse deberet, et in publi In privatis rebus acta Caesaris rescidit.
nihil

pobl
est
raft

est lege gravius, in

privatis finnisslmum

testamentum.
tulit,

Leges
quod

alias sine proini

alias ut tollent.
fecit,

promulgarit
intimis

Tcstainrntum
civibus

irritum

etiain

sen

110

obtentum est. Si una, tabulas, quas populo Caesar una cum hortis legavit, eas hk pirtmi in horto Pompei deportavit, partim in viilai .ilium XLIII. Ettu in Caesaris memoriadil amas mortuum? Quern is bonorein
i

secutus erat,

quam

ut baberet pulvinar, simula

?

fastigium, flaminem

Est ergo flamen, ut

I<>\i,

ut

Marti, ut Quirino, sic divo Iulio M. Antonini

igitur

Quid
;

cur non inaugural um< n< inauguret; conlegae sumus negabit. O detestabilem liominrui, sive quod Caesaris 1 sacerdos es sive quod inortui Quaero deinceps, num, hodiernus dies (jui sit, ignores. Nescis heri quartum in Circo diem ludorum Knin.mcessas?
te
vide,

qui

orum

fuisse? te

autem ipsum ad populuin

toll

M,

lit

quintus praeterea dies Caesari tribueretur?

Cur non

sumus praetextati? cur honorem Caesaris tua lege

1

Some MSS. have

tyranni, probably a gloss.

On three market-days, as required by law. Pulvinar = a couch at the IctisUrnium (feast of couches), on which the image of a God was set with sacrificial viands placed before it fastigium a pediment resembling that of a temple ; flamen = a special priest all signs of divine honours paid to Caesar.
1 *
;

172

PfilUPPIC
laws,

II

Mil. IOQ-XLIII.

HO

even when they were excellent, that he might be able to shake the State. He extended the tenure of provinces; and at the same time, though he was (1 to be defender of Caesar's acts, he rescinded Caesar's acts both in public and in private matters. In p tters nothing is more im|x>rtant than a law; iti private the most unchangeable thing is a laws of Caesar's he abolished by laws will. S ler to al hers he never advertised lie nullified a will, a thing advertised new laws, that has always been held valid even in the case of wl Statues, pictures, the lowest citizens. Caesar bequeathed to the people together with gardens, he carried off, partly to the gardens of
^

pio.

are you zealous in respecting Caesar's ' do you love him in death? What greater honour had In- obtained than to have a couch, an _re, a pediment As to Ins house, a flamen?* as Mars, as (Jmrinus has a flamen, so tlamen to divine Julius is Marcus A Whv then delay Why not be inaugurated? Sel day; look out fr yof in I we are detestable man, colleagues ; no one w ill say no. as priest of Caesar or of a dead man ask you next whether you are ignorant what esterday was the is. Do li day of the Roman Games in the Circus? and also that you yourself proposed to the people a (itth Id be assigned to Caesar } Why day* in a Whv do we permit are we not in holiday garb? an honour granted to Caesar under your law to be

.1 1 1.

And

'

'

* Which would bo Sept. purported to be delivered.

19,

tho day 00 which this peach

73

MARCUS TULLIUS

(1

datum deseri patimur? an supplirationes addendo diem contaminari passus es, pulvinaria Aut undique religioncm tollc aut m noluisti?

mm

111

quaque conserva. Quaeris, placcatnc mini |>m Mihi vero nihil istorum esse, fastigiuin, Haminem. iotes placet; sed tu, qui actaCaesaris defend
dicere, cur alia defendas, alia noo
vis fateri te

metiri.

omnia quaestu tuo, non illius d Quid ad haec tandem? expecto

tuam.
Disertissimum cognovi

ei

eloquentiam

avnm
nuiii-

tuum, at te etiam apertiomn

d iccndo.

II!-

quam nudus

est eontionatus,

tuum

pectus vidimus.
hiscere audebis?

Respondebisne ad haec aut omntlMl Ecquid reperies ex tam longa

oratione mea, cui te respondere posse confidas?

112

XLIV. Sed

praeterita

omittamus
<i

hsae Ca

HUB

diem, unum, inquam, hodiernum

pancttun

temporis, quo loquor, defende, si potes. torum corona senatus saeptus est, cur me

tui satel

cum

gladiis

audiunt,

cur valvae Concordiae

omnium gentium max baros, Ityraeos, cum sagittis deducis In Praesidii sui causa se facere dicit. Non igitar mi liens
patent, cur homines
1 A. on Sept. 1 proposed that in all public thanks. (supplicatioTws) to the Gods a special day should be adaed for offerings to the deified Caesar (Dio xliii. 44 ; Phil. i. 5, 6).

He had thus allowed the impiety of blending honour to the Gods with honour paid to a mortal. Yet, although he was Caesar's priest, he shrank from placing his bust on a couch at the lectiaternium.
174

PHILIPPIC
I

II.

xi.lll.

IIO-XLIV. 112

u!- you allowed the disregarded? or public thanksgiving to be polluted by the add of a da\ ttMntg the couches should tier abolish altogether religious scruples, be at hem on all occasions. You ask whether I am pleased there should be a couch, a pc a fUni'-n. indeed am pleased with none of those you who defend the acts of Caesar, what excuse can you give for defending some, disregarding others ? unless perliaps you wish to confess that you measure all things by your own profr Caesar's honour. ray, can you for I am looking forward to your closay r grandfather was, I know, a very ready speaker, but I know that you in speaking unbosom rself more freely.* He never made an harangue naked; your breast, simple man, we have s<Will yon dare to open your mouth Will you find in so long a speech of at all? something to which you may with confidence rep M.iV Hut let us disregard what is past and gone ; the doings one day, this very present day, I repeat, this point of tim<- in wh I am speaking defend them if you can. Why is Senate hedged in by a cordon of armed n>-

Why
open

an
?

men

listening to

me

sword

m
lie

do the doors of

Com

leans, of all tribe

most barbarous, down into the forum with tin ir arrows? It is for his own j> he says he does this. Are not tin na thousand deaths better than
>

C. plays
i

on the meaning of "aperttts" i. v." A. harangued nudus at the Lupercalia

5.

75

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

perire est melius quarn in sua ci Sed nullum est praesidio non jwsse vivere ? mihi crede, praesidimn caritate te et ben
I i

tul

113

piet et civium saeptum oportet esse, non arnu extorquebit tibi ista popufal Etomanos, utinara salvis nobis! sed quoquo modo nobiscura egeris, dum ease potet, mill istis consiliis uteris, non Etenim ista tua miniine avara diuturnus.

nimium ego sine contumrlia descrilx), debet populo Romano tertiam pension*. Habet populus Romanus, ad quos gulxrnacula rei publicae deferat; qui ubicumque terrarum sunt omne est rei publicae praesidium vel pot us ipse res publica, quae seadhuc tantum m< !< ulta est, nondum

quam
diu

Habet quidem certe res publica acb centes nobilissimos paratos defensores quam vulrnt illi cedant otio consulentes, tamen a re publica revocabuntur. Et nomen pacis dulce est et ipsa res salutaris, sed inter pacem et servitutnn plurimum interest Pax est tranquilla libertas, servitus p< mum malorum omnium non modo bcllo, sed morte 114 etiam repellendum. Quodsi se ipsos illi nostri liberatores e conspectu nostro abstulerunt, at excmreciperavit.
;

plum

facti reliquerunt. Illi, quod nemo fe< fecerunt. Tarquinium Brutus bello est percent us, qui turn rex fuit, cum esse Romae Lieebai; Cassius, Sp. Maelius, M. Manlius proptei mem regni adpetendi sunt necati ; hi priraum cum g]
-

non
1

in

regnum adpetentem,

sed

in

regnantcm

sarcastic use of the polite formula

living

person

is

ceremoniously

customary \\ mentioned: cf. Pht,

12 30.
1

The death

By

of a third husband, i.e. Antonius. * Brutus and Cassius, etc. Caesar's death.

176


PHILIPPIC
II

x.iv.

112-114

not to be able to live in one's own community with Hut that "protection," out a guard of armed men r it is by the affection and good l>elievc me, is none of your fell* na you should be hedged, not by arms. The Roman people will wrest those ip arms from you, and wremh mem out <.. may it be while we are still safe! hut in whatever way you deal with us, while you pursue \u: For v you cannot, believe me, live long. that consort of yours of all wives the least illiberal, whom portray without irreverence 1 has been too long a debtor to the l;.- man people for her third The Roman people still has men to instalment.* in to commit the helm of state: wherever they are, there is the State's every defence, or rather, the State itself, which so far has only avenged It has, I say, itself,* and not restored its strength. hest birth ready assuredly young men 4 ot e its defenders: let them stay apart regardful ot r case as they choose, yet they will be recalled he State. And the name of peace is sweet, the elf wholesome, but between peace and difference is great. Peace is tranquil sen: liberty, servitude the last of all evils, one to be Hut repelled, not only by war but even by death. it those our liberators have withdrawn themselves out of o they have left the example I. Thev did what no man had of what Hrutus waged war aga nin who was a king when to be a king was lawful at Home Cassius, Spurius Maelius, Marcus Manlius, because of the suspicion that they aimed at k. the men of to-day power, were put to death were the first to attack with swords one not aiming
;

77

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

impetum
fecerunt.
est

Quod cum ipsum factum per

divinum,
turn
illi

se

praeclarum

atque

exposi
earn

ad imitandum

est,

praesertim

cum

consecuti sint, quae vix

Etsi eniin sit
is

caelo capi posse videaini.

facti

in

ipsa

consruntia piiK-lirrrimi
i

115

tamen mortalt immort non arbitror esse contemnendam. XLV. Recordare igitur ilium, M. Antnni. diem, quo dictaturam sustulisti pone ante oculos
fructus
erat,
;
I

senatus populique Romani, confer

nundinatione
turn inter

tua tuorumque
in>

turn intelleges,

<|

lucrum etlaudem

Inlmirun

quidam morbo aliquo et sensus stupore suavitatcm cibi non sentiunt, sic libidinosi, avari, facinerosi verae laud is gustatum non hahent. Sed si te laus allicere ad recte faciendum non potest, ne metus quidem a
foedissimis factis potest avocare
?

Iudicia

non met
,

Si propter innocentiam, laudo, sin proj

intellegis, qui isto

non
quid

modo

iudicia

non timeat,

ei
I

116

timendum

sit? Quodsi non metuis viros egregiosque cives, quod a corpore tuo prohfbentQT armis, tui te, mihi crede, diutius non ferent. <,

est

autem

vita dies

et noctes timere a

si.

vero aut maioribus habes beneficiis obligatos,

ille

quam
in illo

quosdam habuit ex
ratio,
1

iis,

a quibus est inter tectus,

aut tu es ulla re

ingenium,

cum eo comparandus. Fuit memoria, litterae, cura,

Cum

hoc

immanum

latione

Vat.).

78

PHILIPPIC
at kingly

II.

XLIV. II4-XLV.

116

power, but who was a king. That deed is not only in itself illustrious and godlike, but also set before us for our imitation, all the more because d such a glory as seems scarce to*be bounded by hcavi -although in Unconsciousness of a splendid deed there was sufficient reward, yet by ;i mortal immortality should not, think, l>e despised. I \ V. Recall therefore, Marcus i, that day on * abolished the dictatorship; set before r eyes the joy of the Senate and of tin peo| para it with this monstrous marketing d by you and your friends: then will understand how great the difference between gain and glory. But assuredly, even as some, through a kind of disease and numbness of perception, do not pen flavour of food, so the lustful, the avaricious, linal, have no estimation of genuine glory. But If tflory cannot allure you to right doing, caneven fear call you away from the f< edt? law-courts you do not fear. If because of your praise you ; but if because of your violence, do you not understand what he must be afraid of mho m such fashion is not afraid of the law-courts? \ou have no fear of brave m< n itizens because they are kept from row an armed guard, \ followers, be! not endure you any longer. And what a life is it, day and night to dread your own followers? unless indeed you have men l>ound to you by greater favours than Caesar had in some of those by whom he was slain, or yourself are in any respect to be comjwired with h in. In Inm there was genius, calculation, memory, letters, industry, thovj
I
!

MARCUS TULLIUS
diligentia;
res bello gesserat

CICEI

calamitosas, at
meo'itatus

quamvis n i publicae tamen niagnas multos annos regnare magno labore, magnis periculis, qmod
;
;

cogitarat, effecerat
ariis,

epulis

multit

imIiik-iii

muneribus, in imprriUni

dr
.

suos praemiis, adversarios cl vinxerat; quid multa? attulerat iam liberae

partiin nit tu, partiin

.1.

ci\

patieutia coiisuetudinnn scr-

viendi.
117

XLVI. Cum

illo

ego

te

dominandi

vero rebus nullo modo comparandus es. Sed ex plurimis in ilis, quae ab Ilk) juod rei publicae sunt inusta, hoc tain, n boni Homanus, quantum CB didicit iam populus
conferre possum, ceteris
crederet, quibus se committeret, a quibus caveret

Haec non

cogitas,

neque

intellegis satis esse

fortibus didicisse,

quam

sit

re pulclinim,

beneftcio

gratum, fama gloriosum tyrannum occidere? An, Certa118 cum ilium homines non tulerint, te ferent? tim posthac, mihi crede, ad hoc opus curretur, neque
occasionis tarditas expectabitur. Resipisce, quaeso, aliquando;
1

qniboi

<>rtus

sis,

non quibuscum
redi

vivas, considera;

mecum,

ut voles,

ego de

Sed de te tu videris, Defendi rem publicam adulescens, non deseram senex ; contempsi Catilinae gladios, non pertimescam tuos. Quin etiam corpofl libenter optulerim, si repraesentari morte mea libcrpublica in gratiam.
ipse profitebor.
1

cum re me

Respice, quaeso, ali

add remjncblicam.
Kay8er.

The text

quibus (Vat. MS.). Oti is Jeep's amendment

foil

180

PHILIPPIC
;

II.

viv

iit-ouvi

n8

gence he had done in war things, however calamitous to the State, yet at least great; ha many years aimed at a throne, he had by great labour, great dangers, achieved his by shows, buildings, largesses, banquets he had conciliated the ignorant crowd ; his own followers he had bourn! to kaioa by rewards, his adversaries by a show of elenn n< \ m !>n -f. he had already brought partly by fear, partly by to a free community ranee a habit of servitude. \l.\ With Imn I can coin|>are you in lust of domination, hut in other things you ar wise out of very many evils which he has nwealth, there has emerged this much good the Roman people has now learned how much to trust each man, on whom to rely, of w Think you not of these things? and do to beware. not understand that it is enough for hrave men to have learned how beautiful m act, how grateful
:

in

hem
.

fit.

tyrant?

how glorious in report, it is to slay a Or will men, when they did not endure
In rivalry hereafter, believe

endure you?
will

me,

hurry to do this work, and no slow-coming -rtunity will l>e waited for. Recover your senses, at length, I beseech you sprung, not those consider those from whom yosj with whom you live; treat me as you will; be reHut TOO must look to your conciled to tin State.

they

own conduct
fession.
I

for myself I will make my own defended the State in youth, I will not desert it in old age I despised the swordsmen of Catiline, I will not dread yours. Ave, and even mv body will I gladly offer if the liberty of the State can be realised by my death, so that the anguish
;
;

181

MARCUS TULLIUS
pariat,

CICFJ

119 tas civitatis potest, ut aliquando d<

quod iam diu parturit

riginti hoc
[|

Ktrnim,

si

tbhinc
|>osse

annos prop**

mortem iinmat uram esse consular), Milnvero, pat nuncnegaboseni

!

qtuuil

etiam optanda mors est |>ex; adeptus sum quasque gessi. Duo inodo haec unum, ut moriens populum Roman um quam (hoc mihi inaius ah dis imroo nihil potest), alterum, ut ita cuique evciiiat, ut de re publica quitque mereatur.
1

82

PHILIPPIC

II.

xlvi.

118-119

of the Roman people may some time bring to birth that with which it has so long travailed. For it

nearly twenty years ago in this very tt -tuple 1 said that death could lv to a consular, 1 greater truth shall I say it in old age! By me indeed, Conscript lathers, death is even to be wished for, now that the honours 1 have won and the deeds I have performed are past, e two things only I pray for ; one, that in my death I may leave the Roman people free - than this no greater gift can be given me by the mortal Gods the other, that each man's fortune may be according to his deserts toward the State.
:

Neque turpi mora foiti viro potest aecidere, neqne immature conaulari, nee niiaere taptrnti " 1 Cat.
'

,8,

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

III

Hrundi ium to take command of the four le^: from Macedonia which against the will Senate had been assigned to him by the people

in

intended, says Cicero {Phil. to march them to Rome for the purpose of a general massacre. On his way lie put to death some soldiers At Brundisium he tttem] at Sucssa (Phil 3. 4). cause, and offered them a to win t! don.. money 100 denarii a man, b bout 3 6*. Sd. But the legions, who had expected OIB him than Octavian was offering them, laughed at his stinginess (Dio 45. 13 43), and raised a tumult. According to Cicero, he slaughtered picked centurions of the n in the presence of his wife and himself. 1 In the meantime Octavian went on levying troops. He won over to his side, by a promise of 500 denarii a head
their tribes.
_'
'
i

He

1 Phil. A] t>ian (I.e.) gives a more detailed 18 B. account. This was that Antonius called for the roll-call of the legion, in which was entered each man's military record chose bv lot "according to military law" every U of the disaffected, and put to death tome of them. Dio, who confirms Cicero sa to the slaughter being in the presence atria, says that "he commanded amongst others the centurions to be slaughtered." Cicero say (Phil. 3. 4) that A. slaughtered " up to 300 of the bravest of men and the best of citizens." As no legion had 300 centurions, the number mentioned most have included either civilians or common soldiers.

i8 5

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

III

(about 17), the veterans at Casilinum and Calatia (ad Alt. 16. 8), and at the beginning of November, before the Martian and the Fourth leu over to liim, was at the head of 3,000 D his object is," writes Cicero to Atticus conduct a war against Antonius ; so that I see With these trooj>s a f< \\ days we shall be in arms." Octavian, by Cicero's advice, man led to Rome, and in a popular assembly convened by the tribune Canutius delivered a violent attack upon
|

Dio 45. 12.

at Tibur,
left the bulk of his army entered Rome frith an armed He summoned the force. threatening death against absentees, but was him-

In

November Antonius
and
illegally

says Cicero, too drunk to attend. He summoned again for the 28th, forbidding three of the tribunes Although his object was to have Caesar to attend. Octavianus declared a -public enemy, be made no proposal to that effect, but me In the public thanksgiving Ko honour of Lepidus. midst of the debate news arrived that tin and the Fourth legions had declared for Octaviai had taken up a post at Alba. Thoroughly frightened, he cut short the proceedings by calling for an immediate division, a most unusual course in tin<1 his case of a motion for a thanksgiving dress for military garb, and harried off to Alba to quell the mutiny. It was at this juncture that Cicero published the second Philippic. Antonius, not being able to reconcile the 1 at Alba, proceeded to Tibur, and kept his troops there in good humour by a donation of 500 denarii a head, the same sum as Caesar had promised his
self,
it

186

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
own
troops.

III

And

at

the end of the month

he

marched against D. Brutus.

inber the tribunes convened Senate, the object being the protection of the new consuls on the 1st of January by means of an armed guard. Cicero had not intended to be present (ad Fam. 11. 6), but, having received an edict of
1)

BnrtM

in

which

he warned Antonius

off

his

province of Cisalpine Gaul, and expressed his determination to k e to the Senate, he made up his miod to attend the debate, ami Cicero opened the a full house. presence debate with the third Philip] He regretted the delay in taking action till the Had it not bc< >ctavian 1st of January. Antonius would have inaugurated a general massacre tian and the State would have per and the Fourth U-^ions had acted with loyal tv in attaching themselves to Caesar, and his ad should be confirmed by public authority and both he and the veterans be honoured and rewarded. Renj to the edict of D. Brutus, the orator stid Brutus was a worthy descendant of his ancestors who had expelled Tarquin, and Antonius was worse tli hi T injuin. The Senate should therefore confirm what D. Brutus had done on his own initiative. Antonius' conduct was such that he should not be regarded as a consul ; otherwise the legions, Caesar, Brutus were all criminals for hav >scd him.
I

He referred to Autumns' conduct on Nov 24 and 28, on the latter of which dates he admitted himself to be a public enemy by not daring to move the Senate on the conduct of Octavian. One of the
i8 7

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
He
criticised the allotment of the

III

two must be, but Caesar had been their salvation

the

same date and enumerated Antonius' crimes ml and he regarded the brother Lucius as illegalities no better. Having I). Brutus and Caesar as their
;

champions, they should seize the opportunity and The Roman people was Mill SO act with vigour. be free, and freedom now could be achieved. Alluding to this speech, Cicero writes (ad 10. 28) to Trebonius: "This day, and my exert and pleadings, for the first time brought to the Roman people the hope of the r heir
i

liberty."

z88

M.

TULLI CICEROMS IN M. ANTONItM OBATIO PHIJ IPPICA TERTLA

Serius omninOj j>atres conscript!, onion too

1.

rei

publicae postulabat, aliquandu

i

tamen

sumus, quod fl-igiubam equidem

no

bellum ncfarium contra aras et focos, contra \r

fortunasque nostras ab hominc proHigato ac perdito

BopOOtontOf non conparari, sed geri lam Kalendae Ianuariae; quas non expectat Anton
1

qui in provincial D. Bruti,

summi

ct singularis

cum

exercitu

impctum

faccrc conatur;

instructum et paratum ad
2 minitatur.

ex qua sc urbem venturum esse

Quae

est igitur expectatio aut

?

quae vel

minimi

dilatio temporis

Quaraquam enim adsunt

Kalendae Ianuariae, tamen breve tempi

inparatis
;

dies
est,

provisum
dies

enim adfert vel hora p<>' magnas saepe clades certus an

;

non ut sacrifices, sic consiliis expectari solet. Qaodsi aut Kalendae Ianuariae fuissent eo die, quo

primum ex urbe
ritate

fugit Antonius, aut eae

non essent
AuctoI

expectatae, bellum iam nullum haberemus.

enim senatus consensuque populi Romani

hominis amentis fregissemus audaciam.

fido

Quod

stratum inierint, esse facturos

190

equidem consules designatos, simul ut m sunt enim optimo

;

IHK THIRD PHILIPPIC OF M. TULLIUS CICERO AGAINST M. ANTONIUS

necting, Conscript Fathers, is altogether than the public emergency deman at length we have been called together; a step for my part urged daily, seeing as I did that is war against our altars and hearths, aga lines, was no longer being prepai but was already being waged by a profligate and abandoned man. We are waiting for the Kalends of January but Antonius does no* he is attempting with an army to attack tin j.r.>> nice of that nentand remarkable man Decimus Brains; and from it, when he has completed his equipment and he threatens a descent upon the it then means this waiting and delay even for the though the Kalends of January are at hand, yet a short time is long if men be unr a day, or rather an hour, unless there has been forethought, often brings great disasters and an day is not, as a rule, waited he taking of counsel as it is in sacrifices. Hut if either the Kalends of January had fallen on the day when Antonius first fled from the city, or we had not waited for it, we should not now be ha any war, for by the authority of the Senate and the us support of the Roman people we should y have broken the audacity of a madman. Iced trust the consuls elect, as soon as they enter upon their office, will do for they are men of
later
1

191

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Mca animo, sumino consilio, singulari concordia. autem frstinatio doo i ktoriae solum avida dt, sed um, Quo enim usque Ul 3 etiam celeritatis.
tarn crudele,

bitur? cur
ritas
?

tam nefariuin privatis consiliiN propulsanon quam primum publica accedit an<
p
a*

II.

C.

Caesar adulescens,
lie

purr.
tute,

iiuTC(iil)ili

divlna

quadam mente
furor

arderet Antoni, can eius a Bruudisio crudelis ct pestifer redll retur, nee postulant i!)iis nee CO bus quidem nobis, quia non posse fieri vidt batur, firmissimum exercitum t enore vet. norum milituni comparavit patrimoaiomque laon ecfudit; quamquam non sum usus eo verbo, quo non enim ecfudit; In rcl pabUcM lalute debui 4 conlocavit Cui quamquam gratia referri tanta non potest, quanta debctur, babenda tamen est tanta quantam maxiraam animi nostri capcre possuuL Quis enim est tam ignarus rerum, tun nihil d publica cogitans, qui boc non intellegat, si M. Antonius a Brundisio cum iis copiis, quas se habit urum putabat, Romam, ut minabatur, vei
tuin,
;

cum maxime

nullum genus eum crudelitatis practt rituruin fai quippe qui in hospitis tectis Brundisi foi viros optimosque cives iugulari iaaaerit quorum ante pedes eius morientium sanguine os uxoris respersum esse constabat. Hac ille crudelitate imbutus cum multo nobis omnibus 1 venire t iratior,
;

Bonis omnibus (Vat. MS.).

Of Caesar Octavianus and D. Brutus.

192

PHILIPPIC

III.

i.

2-11.

is, of the highest judgment, and of the best remarkable agreement. Hut my eagerness covets, not merely victory, but also speedy decisis

how long

will a

war, so serious, so cruel, so nefarious,

be averted by private fdH why are they not supported at the earliest possible moment by
of the State? a young man, or rather almost a bov. hut one of tncreaibto, and, as it w god-lik Mce and courage, at the very time when An frenzy was at its greatest heat, and when his cruel and deadly return from Brundisium was dreaded, while we were not asking for, or thinking of, assistance, nor even it, for it seemed impossible, collected a very stout U of the class of veterans, and liviv though I have not used the proper bis patrimony phrase; for he did not lavish it, he Invested it in the salvation of the State. And although we cannot recompense him to the extent our debt to him requires, yet we should feel a gratitude the For greatest our hearts can conceive. blind to events, so thoughtless for the State, as not to understand this, that, if Marcus Antonius had been able to reach Rome, as he threatened, with forces he had thought to have, he would have omitted no kind of cruelty, seeing that, under host's roof at Brand manded the hery of the bravest of men and the best of whose blood, as they were dying at tret, it was well known his wife's face was besprinkled? Steeped as he was in such cruelty, since he was becoming much more enraged against us all than he had been against those whom he had
the
1

C'aius Caesar,

*93

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

quam
illis

fuerat,

quos

trucidarat,

cui

tarn:

nostrum aut cui omnino bono pepercisset ? Qua peste privato consillo rem pub 6 enim fieri potuit aliter) Caesar liberarit
in liac re publica

Qol
,

natus esset, rem publicum scclere

sic

Antoni nullam haberemus. Sic en iudico, nisi unus adulesc crudelissimosque conatus cohibuiss Cui quid funditus interituram fuisse.
die,

bodlerno
ita

patres

conscripti,
ill
i

(nunc

enim

pfftaram

convenimus, ut

us beneficio j>osseiiius ea,

quae

scntiremus, libere dicere) tribuenda est auctoritas, ut rem publicam non modo a se susccptam, sed

etiam a nobis commendatam possit defend-: III. Nee vero de legione Martia, quoninm
intervallo
potest.

loqui

nobis de

re

public

Quis enim unus

fortior, quis

amicior nmrsa?

quam rei publicae fuit quam legio Mai Quae cum hostem populi Re
casset,
;

m
em

>>i<]i

imt comes esse eius amci relftqoH consulem quod profecto non fecisset, m sulem iudicasset, quern nihil aliud agere, nihil molhi nisi caedem civium atque iuteritum civitatil videret
;

Atque ea legio consedit Albae. urbem eligere aut opportuniorem a<

I

Quam

potuit
l

fideliorem aut fortiorum virorum aut amiciorum

7

rei

publicae civium?
1

Iluius legionis virtutcm itnitata

(Vat.).

Fortium

vir.

descriptive of

aut amicorum "urbem."

The

genitive

is

194


PHILIPPIC
III.
ii.

4-ii. 7

murdered, which of us, 1 ask, or what honest roan tever, would he have 9\ aesar on his own initiative
(

otherwise has freed the State. Had he not been born in this common wealth, we should, by the crime of Antonius, now possess no
Ik-

commonwealth
judgm< nt
:

at all. For this is my belief, tin had not a single youth withstood thai madman's attack and most cruel attempts, commonwealth would have utterly perished. indeed to-day, Conscript Fathers, for we are now for the first time assembled with power, thanks freely to utter our sentiments we must 'T authority to enable him to defend the common wealth, as a charge not merely undertaken ut entrusted to him by us.

111. And indeed, now we are |>crmitted, after a long interval, to speak on State affairs, we cannot Martian legion For what be silent regard has ever been braver, who more n ate than the whole of the Martian Having decided* as it did, that legion? >nius was an enemy <t the Roman people refused to be an ally of his madness; it aband<< a consul it certainly would not have done that had it Judged him to be a real consul whom it saw to be aiming at, and striving hut the slaughter of citizens and the d< of the And then that legion took up its Stat Slate. W at All. lid it have chosen either more conveniently placed for action, or more loyal, or g of braver men, or of citizens more tie State? Copying the courage of legion, the fourth legion, under the command of
i:

Mm

'95

: ;

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

duce L. Egnatulcio quaes Optimo et fortissimo, C. Cacsaris auctoritatrm *tq-C Faciundum est igitur exercitum persecuta est pti, ut eft, quae sua sp< nobis, patrt clarissimus adulescens atque omnium prarstm simus gessit et gerit, haec auctoritate nostra corowin. probentur veteranorumque fortissimo! turn legion is Martiae quartaeque mirabilis consensus ad rem public-am reciperandam laude et testim
quart* legio
nostro confirmetur, eorumque commodi, honores, praemia,cum consulesdesignati magistratum imrnnt, curae nobis fore hodierno die spondramus. IV. Atque ea quidem, quae dixi de Caesarc deque 8 eius exercitu, iam diu nots sun enim admirabili Caesaris constantiaque nulitum veteranorum legionumque emrttm, quae optitno vestram, libertatem populi iudicio auctoritatem Homani, virtutem Caesaris secutae sunt, a ee nostris est depulsus Antonius. Sed haec, ut dm, superiora; hoc vero recens edictum D. Hruti, quod paulo ante propositum est, certe silentio non potest
Pollicetur enim se provinciam Gal retenturum in senatus popuiique K nun pott O civem natum rei publieae, memorem sui non imitatoremque maiorum Neque enim Tarqi
praeteriri.
!

expulso maioribus nostris tam fuit optata libcrtas, quani est depulso iam Antonio retinenda nobn 9 illi regibus parere iam a condita urbe didicerant nos post reges exaetos servitutis oblivio Atque ille Tarquinius, quern maiores nostri DOB

It

wa3
xi. 6.

this that

induced C. to attend on Jan.

Epp. ad

Fum.
I

96

PHILIPPIC
brave

III.

in. 7-iv.

9
loyal

U Egnatuleius the quaestor, a most

If

and

of Caius Caesar. We Father see that what a most noble < and is doing shoul man has of his own m be r a authority and that the wonderful unan heroic \md especially of for the the and of establishment of the State may be sanctioned 1>\ praise and warrant ; and we must engage to-day when the consuls elect enter upon thee, interests, honours, and rewards shall be 0O1 r
;
I

id and to the therefore, Coi

care.

IV

And what

army has long been known

admirable
ran soldiers, the finest jud

have said of Caesar and of Ins to us. For by Caesar's courage, and the st.-nim iiness of tin
I

those legions whirl with e aid of your ii authont people, and of Caesar's courageous action, A has been cast ofF from our necks. These things however are, as I have said, earlier; but the recent edict 1 of Decimus Hiatus issued a short time since certainly cannot be passed over in sil>r he promises to keep tin of Gaul wit In ii the jurisdiction of the Senate people. Truly a citizen born to * and the State, mindful of the name he bears, and an itor of his ancestors For our ancestors' Ion p for liberty when Tarquin was expelled was no' great as ours should l>e to retain it now Ant<" has been driven off; they had learned ever since on of the city to obey kings; we aJ the ngi had forgotten our servitude. And that Tarquin whom our ancestors would not
I

197

; ;

MARCUS TULL1US CICERO

tulerunt,

non

habitus et dictus
tulimus, id

est non tannine, scd quod nos vitium in privntis saepe maiores nostri ne in rege quidnn
crudelis,
;

fi

potuerunt.
L. Brutus

regem superbum non

talc, qualia

tulit; a

I).

Brutus

sceleratumatqiu- bnpium n

Antoninm?

Quid Tarquinius
et fecit

imiuinrrabilia et

Antonius? Senatum ctiam rege hnbcbant nee tamen ut Antonio senatum haben Servabant au^ regis versabantur barbari arniati.
|

reges;

quae hie consul augurque neglexit, neque

10

solum legibus contra auspicia ferendis, sed el conlega una ferente eo, quern ipse vitiosum fecerat. Quis autem rex uun; tarn insignite inpudens, ut haberet omnia commoda, beneficia, iura regni venalia ? quam hie immunital
i

quam

civitatem,

quod praemium non

civitatibus
vel

vel
|

singulis

hominibus vel

universis

vendidit ? Nihil humile de Tarquinio, nihil sordidum accepimus; at vero huius domi inter quasilla p batur aurum, numerabatur pecunia una In d omnes, quorum intererat, totum imperiuin popnli
;

Romani nundinabantur. Supplicia vero Romanos nulla Tarquini accepimus at

;

in

hie

et

Suessae iugulavit eos, quos in custodiam dederat, et Brundisi ad trecentos fortissimos viros civisque
11

optimos trucidavit.

Postremo Tarquinius pro populo

turn,

Romano bellum gerebat

Antonius contra populum
198

cum Romanum

est expulsus exercitum ad-

PHILIPPIC

III

iv.

9-1!

brook was not considered and called cruel, not <us, hut "The Proud," a fault wlmli we have often brooked in private indi\ totals, but whieh mir ancestors could not brook even in a k us Brutus did not brook a proud king shall Decimus Brutus endure the reign of the accursed juin and impious An toni us? What single a< do of the ini le acts Ar ii both doing and has don d the kings had a Senate no armed barbarians were present in the king's council as when An toni us holds a Senate. s observed the auspices, which this consul and augur has negleeted, not only by proposing la* defiance of the ropietl, but also with that very in the proposal whose election he colleague had annulled by falsifying the auspices. Again, what king was so signally Timeless ss to regard all the rests, the grants, the laws of the kingdom as objects of sale? what what reward, has not this man sold, either to indi;
'

WY whole pro\ u< Tarquin nothing mean, >ut at this man's house amid the won work-baskets gold used to be weighed, moneys m one man's house all those whose concount was used to traffic with the whole empire We certainly have heard of no |>unis!,miiN inflicted by Tarquin on <ns; but this man l>oth at Suessa butchered M he had captured, and at Brundisium murdered as many as three hundred of the bravest men and best of citizens. Lastly, Tarquin was carrying on war on behalf of the Roman people at the time he was expelled ; Antonius was leading an army ag
viduals, or to States, or to
-

have

heard

of

199

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

relictus DOB ducebat turn, cum a 1< Caesaris exercitumque pertimuit ficiis solh-mnibus ante lucem vota solverct, nuncupavit, et hoc tempo M populi Roman! conatur invadere. D. Bruto beoefidam |>opulus Romanus et expectat, quam maiores nostri acceperunt a
i

I.

Bruto, principe huius

maxime

conservai
est misern.
sobri.

noun
12

V.

Cum autem omnis servitus

sen
ire

intolerabilis est

inpuro, inp

numquam ne

in

metu quidem

Hui
V

qui Gallia prohibet, privato praesertim iudicat verissimeque iudicat non esse const) Faciendum est igitur nobis, patres eon oripti D. Bruti privatum consilium auctoiitate

comprobemus

Nee vero M. Ant -in in eonsulem

Quo cniiu ille die post Lupercalia debuistis putare. populo Romano inspectante nudi est contionatus et id egit, ut collegae diaderoa imponeret, eo die se non modo consulatu, sed el libertate abdicavit ; esset enim ti station
serviendum,
voluisset.
si

Caesar ab eo
igitur

r
< I

ego banc Romanum, hunc liberum, hunc denique Inmiiiinii putem, qui foedo illo et flagitioso die, et quid pati C. Caesare vivo posset, et quid eo niortuo
ipse cuperet, ostendit
?

Hunc

Consuls and praetors, on departing to their pro vcrvs Livy, xci. 10. C. means that A. never be called upon to fulfil his vows, as the Gods would not grant his prayers.
1

made solemn

too


PHILIPPIC
the
his
III
v

,,-v. 12

Roman people

his legions,

at the time when, deserted l>\ he quailed at the name of Caesar and
I

lie usual sacrifices, uttered army, and, nvi: ht those solemn vows 1 he was never be for fated to fulfil and at this time tog t.. invade a province of the Human people. Greater then is benefit the Roman people both has and expects from Decimus Hmtus than <>ur ancestors received lirutus. ?. r of a race and name that should be, above everything, preserved. V. H all slavery is wretched, it is especially intolerable to be slaves of a man debauched, immodest, tfeminate, even when in fear never sober. He then who debars this man from the province ndi of Gaul, especially when he does so
;

vidual

judgment, decides, and most truly decides, he is no consul. We must see then. Cons. l>y our general authority the era, that
id ua I

judgment ot Decimal Hrutus. And of a you ought not to have thought Ma Antonius a consul after the Lu|>ercalia. For on the day when, before the eyes of the Roman people, he harangued while naked, anointed, and drunk, and aimed at placing a diadem on his colleague's head that day itcd, not his consulship CM hut also his freedom for he himself would certainly have been at once a slave had Caesar been willing Am then to to accept the tokens of royalty. man a consul, this man a Roman citizen, con man a free man, in a word, this man a human being, who on that foul and iniquitous day showed what he could endure while Caius Caesar was alive, and what elf wished to gain for himself when he was dead?
.

truth

201

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRRO

13

Nee vero de

virtute, eonstantia, gravitate provincial

Galliae taceri potest

14

Est enim ille flos Italiac, ilhwl illud CM firmamentum imperii populi mentum dignitatis. Tantus autem est munu-ipinrum i-oloniarumque provinciae Galliae, ut omncs ad auctont it. in hums ordinis inaiestatenijii populi Hoin.mi detendrudam conspiraase videantm. Quam ob rem, tribuni pi., quamquam VM mini aliud nisi de praesidio, ut senatum tuto consoles Ianuariis habere possent, rettulisti% tamen mihl videmini magno consilio atque optima roente potestatem nobis de tota re publica fecisse dicen enim tuto haberi sen Be praesidio MM potte iudicavistis, turn statuistis etiam intra muros Antom scelus audaciamque versari. VI. Quam ob rem omnia mea st: omplectar vobis, ut intellego, nun invitis, ut et praettai
<
f

ducibus a nobis detur auctoritas et

tibus spes ostendatur

fof

mili-

praemiorum et iudicetur verbo, sed re non modo non consul, sed etiam h Antonius. Nam, si ille consul, fustuarium merucrunt legiones, quae consulem reliquerunt, sceh Caesar, Brutus nefarius, qui contra consulem pr consilio exercitus conparaverunt. Si autem milr exquirendi sunt honores novi propter eorum divimim atque immortale meritum, ducibus autem ne r quidem potest gratia, quis est, qui eum non
i

existimet,
toires rei

quem

qui armis persequantur, conserva-

publicae iudicentur?

to?

PHILIPPIC
tancy of tin

III.

3 -ti. 14

Nor indeed can the courage, the staunchness, the

j

t.iul

be passed <>wr

in

ver ol Italy, that the mainstay be Roman people, that the ornaAnd so great is the unanimity of y. the boroughs and colonies of the PflDtteee of Gaul, that all seem to have united to defend the mtho of this our order and the majesty (1 tin* Unman "'. tnltiiiif .<: tii- commons, though people. W
(1 merely for a guard that the consu K ilcnds of January be able in safety to car to me to have, with great a Senate, yet >t and with the best design, enabled us to speak generally on State affairs; for when you decided that a Senate could not safely be held Kthoot a guard, you ned that even within the walls the ud audat <>nius were at work. re I shall summarise the whole quesVI tion by recording my vote not, I perceive, against wishes that authority be given by us to I most eminent generals, and hope of reward held out to most gallant soldiers, and that Antonius, not by words, but by deeds, may be adjudged to be not For if but also a public enemy. man is a consul the legions that have desc the consul have deserved death by the cudgel, Caesar is a criminal, Brutus is a villain, ho of their own have levied armies to oppose a coi But if n in for the soldiers are to be devised 'quite their god-like and immortal service, and it it be not even possible adequately t<> requite our generals, who is there but must count en ncmy those who are in arms against him are adjudged saviours of the State?
I
-

Mm

11

203

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

\6

quam

in edictis, qn Primura in Caesarem nialedicU congessit deprompta ex recordation- inpudicHiae et prorum suorum. Qms enim lioc adulescente cas: quis modestior? quod in iuventute lml>emus

At quam contumeliosus
rudis
!

ll

exeniphnn veteris sanctitatis male duit, impurior?

'.

qui

tat

em

t>

Caesaris film, eolui etiara natura pater, si vita peditasset, consul factus esset Trallianam aut Ephesiam putes dicere. quam despiciamur omnes, qui imnai e munieipiis, id quotus enim quisquc nost est omnes plane
;

non est? (^u<<1 aatem municipiam m Aricinum Unto opere <i is, qui
antiquisshnuin. iure foederatum, pr
-

unit

state

iene

splendore municipum hoi 16 Hinc Voconiuc, hine Atiniae leges, bin sellae curules et jmtrum memoria et nosti
finitiinuni,

i.

tunc

Romani lautissimi et pltirimi. Sr<i Aricinam uxorem non probas, cur prob.i lanam ? Quamquam huius sanctissimae feminae atque optimae pater, M. Atius Halbus, in primis honestus, praetorius fuit tuae coniugis, bonae feminae, locuplctis quidem certe, Bambalio (juidam
equites
;

pater,
1

homo

nullo numero.

Nihil

i)l<>

ptius,

praetor, a fact which in itself made Oct. the head of the Octavian house, and had married Atia, the niece of Julius Caesar. inger Octavius, the grand-nephew of the Dictator, was adopted by the latter's will. 1 The Lex Voconia of 169 B.C. (inter alia) deprived in certain cases of inheritance by will. The Lex Atinia of 197 B.C. prevented the ownership of stolen property being acquired by long possession (usueapio). Another of 130 B.C. (a plebucitum) gave a tribune the rank of 8enator.
nobihs.

He had been He was

204

PHILIPPIC
ulting

III.

m. 15-16
edicts
!

he
!

i^

how

boorish

how ignorant

First of all

he has heaped

on Caesar abuse culled from the recol! Mi indecency and isness. For who is ter than toil young man? who more modest? r example among youth have we of Who, on the contrary, is more world poriti haste than the calumniator? He taunts the son aius Caesar with the meanness of his birth, is actual father too would have been a " His mother was from consul 1 had his life lasted. ta " you nigwt think he was speaking of a woman from Trades or Ephesos Mark how all of us who come from country boroughs are looked w few of down upon 1 mean absolutely all us do not so come ? And wliat lx>rough does he despise when he so utterly looks down upon the <>f Aricia, one in antiquity the most ami
.'
1

1 1

by treaty allied to us, in situation almost <,ur neigh_'h repute of its burghers most arable ? Hence were derived the Voconian, hence the Atinian laws ; * hence came many curule magistrates within the memory of our fathers and oar own; hence have sprung Roman knlghta of great wealth, and many in nmnkr. Hut it you disapprove of a wife from Aricia, why do you approve of one from Tusculum ? And yet the one was a most pure and excellent woman, whose father Marcus Atius Halbus, 3 an especially worthy man, was an expraetor ; your wife, a good enough woman, at any rate <>nc, had for father a certain Bamhalio, a person of no account. He was the most contemptible fellow
bour,
1

* The hubanrl of Julia, J. Caesar's sitter, Alia, mother of the younger Caesar.

and father of

205

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

qui

propter

haesitantiam

linguae

cordis

cognomen ex contumelia traxen Tuditamis m-mpe ille, nobilis."

.

avus
palln et

17

nummos populo de rostris spargcre solebat. Vellem banc contempt ionem pecuniae suis relisam. Habetis nobilitatcn quisset! !>ilis Qui autem evenit, at til>i f [alia nat videatur, cum tu eodem materno genere soleas Quae porro amentia est eon licere gloriari? aliquid de uxoruni ignobilitate, cuius pater Nmuiproditorii BUam, babuerit toriam Fregellanam,
cothurnis
uxorc-m.
ipafl

ex

LiberttaJ

tilia

susce)

ros?
(jtii

Sed boc clarissimi \in \idrrint. L PhiUppQt, babet Aricinam uxorem, C. Marccllus, qatf
filiam
;

quos certo scio dignitatis

fratris

narum non paenitere. VII. Idem etiam Q. Ciceronem,

mei

filimn,

compellat edicto nee sentit aniens com: Quid enim accidere esse conpellationem suam. buic adulescenti potuit optatius quam cognosci ab
18 furoris

omnibus Caesaris consiliorum esse socium, Antmn inimicum? At etiam gladiator ausus est isse. scribere hunc de patris et patrui parrb O admirabilem impudeutiam, audaciam, temeriti in eum adulescentem boc scribere audere, q ego et frater meus propter eius suavissimos atcjmoptimos mores praestantissimumque ingenium
:i

So the Vat. MS., ncUus being

= prognattts.
;

Bambalio (from BanBaiva)

air'

Stammerer
:

rhv

/Ja/t/3aA Ivpcl,

rbv
*

outt)? ttjs 4xwyvfjdas 4irtfi6riToy

Dion Ca&S. XL.

p. 205.

47.

Caesar Octavianus.

See

n. 3

on

206

PHILIPPIC

III.

vi.

16-vn. 18

in the world, who, by the hesitancy of his speech, and the dullness of his mind, got a name by way Hut his grandfather was noble." That jibe itanus you mean, of course, who in tragic robe and buskins used from the Rostra to scatter e wish he had bequeat I among the people. his family such scorn of bmm m possess a
!

'

.! r.ue cpnte gloHooal Hut how does it happeo that one descended from a Julia* seems to you, when you are wont to exult in your vcr, descent from the same maternal stock what madness it is that a man should allude to the ignoble birth of wives, when his father had to ria of Fregellae, the daughter of a r. and he himself has recognised his -hildren But let this ma by the daughter of a freed man be settled by such eminent men a> Philippus who has a wife Ida, and Caius Marcel us who married the daughter of one from Aricia; t! know well, are not dissatisfied with the rank of I

DObil ty

<

these excellent women. VII. He also abuses Quintus Cicero, my brother son, in his edict, and the madman does rive ira is a recommendation. that or what
1

more desirable

tl-

rid

happen to
tl

this

young
r

man than

to be recognised by all as

of

Caesar's counsels and the enemy of Antonius' frenzy ? Bat the gladiator has even dared to sa\ in \w that Quintus had plotted the murder of his father uncle. What marvellous impudence, auda< recklessness! to dare to make the charge in ng against a young man who, by the sweetness and excellence of his character, and eminent abilities, arouses in me and my brother a rivalry of affect
1

207

MARCUS TULL1US
tatim

CICE1

>

amamus omnibusque horis oculis, aun ictcit complexu tenemus! Nam me isdcm Cum idem tappllcitm) aria laedat an laudet. is ac optimis civibus, quod ego de scclt
-

pessimis nunpserinij laudare videtur, qua*

velit;

cum

auteui

illain

pulchcrrimi far
u

refricat, turn
<

a sui Bimilibui invidiam a quid

fecit

me

oinmoveri putat.
VIII.

19

Sed
1

ipse?

Cum

tot

<

j)roposuisset,
a.

edixit,

ut

adesset senatus

frequens
Mint, ut

d.

VIII Kalendas Decembres; eo die Iptc HOD

adfuit.

At quo modo edixit?

extremo
:

Haec

opinor, verba in

'

Si

quis non adfucrit,

et intrritus m<

hunc existimare omnes poterunt

perditissiraorum OMMJHortMM auctorem fuisse.'

Qliae sunt perdita consilia? an ea, quae ad libertatem populi Romani reciperandam ? quorum iiortatorem et consiliorum Caesari me aucton m

esse

et fuisse fateor.

Quamquam

ille

non

<

consilio cuiusquam, sed

incitavi.

Nam

tamen currentem. interitus quidem tui qi;

ut di<

MM

esset auctor,

cum

in eo salus et vita optimi cuiu

libertas populi

20

Romani dignitasque consisteret ? Sed cum tam atroci edicto nos concitavissct, cur Num putatis aliqua re tristi ac ipse non adfuit?
si

severa? vino atque epulis retentus,

potius

illae

epulae
edicli

quam popinae nominandae

1

sunt,

diem

Posuis8et(MSS.).
of Catiline's conspiracy.

The suppression

208

PHILIPPIC
and

III.

MI.

uS-vm. 20

with eyes and ears and enfolding arms hour For. as to myself, he does not know whether he is wounding or praising me by these same edicts. When he threatens the most loyal citi the same punishment as 1 exacted it criminals he appears to be praising me, as though he wished to imitate me of that most km be evokes afresh the igines that some odium is
!
1

whom

If on to i) lers. Bat what did he do himself r' Winn he had issued all these edicts he gave notice that there should be a full meeting of the Senate on the 24th ibrr. On that day was ah*-' what was the character of his notice? These are, I think, the words at the end: " If anyone is

VIII

li

f'

not present,

all

men

will

be able to regard him as

one who advocates both my destruction and the most abandoned counsels." 'landoned counsels"? are as aim at the recovery of the liberty of the lioman people? of which counsels 1 confess I am and have to Caesar the supporter and the advocate. He, need any man's counsel nr as the 1;. willing horse. For of your dest: unuld not be the 1 seeing that in that consisted the safety and the life of every loyal man and the liberty and dignity of Roman people? after calling us together by so violent an why was he himsrlt not pmoafcJ Do \<u think it was because of some sad and serious matter ? He was detained by a drinking-bout and a feast if that should be called a feast rather than a tavern blowI

209

MARCUS TULLIUS CICKRO

obire
neglexit, in

ante

dim

Adesse in Capitolio mssit; Decembres distulit quod in templum ipse nescio qua per Gall
cuniculum aseendit Convent-runt oorrognh dem ampli quidani homines, sed humeniin erat dies, ea fama, tat is suae is
;

is,

senatura timere.

verbum

nihil ut turpe senatori ess. t Ad eos tainen ipsos. quidem ausus est facere de Caesarc, nun

voearat,

de eo constituisset ad senatum
21 attulerat consularis quidani

sentmhim.

i sc de eo referre non audere, q' consulem exereitum duc< iudicare? Necesse erat enim alttruti um esse hottem, nee poterat aliter de adversariis lod

aliud

ducibus.
referat

Si igitur Caesar hostis,

nihil

a senatu notan<iu> non fuit, quid potest dicere, quin, cum de illo tacuerit, se hostem confessus Spartacum appcllat, hunc in senatu Be buprol quidem dicere audt-t. IX. At in rebus tristissimis quantos excitat risus Sententiolas edicti cuiusdam memoi HModai i, quas videtur ille peracutas putare ego autcm. qui into geret, quid dicere vellet, adhuc neinm in in " Nulla contumelia est, quam facit dign 22 Primum quid est "dignus"? nam etiam main

ad

senatum?

sin

llle

1 C. in Caec. 30 speaks of a mine through which in 390 B.C. the Gauls attacked the Capitol. But Livy's account (v. 47) does not support this. 1 i.e. not afraid to attend. C. teems to be excusing the * i.e. the younger Caesar. absent. 4 A Thracian gladiator who led a revolt of runaway slaves against Rome, 73-71 B.c. Cicero himself (Phil. iv. 6) calls Antonius a Spartacus.

2IO

PHILIPPIC
out

III.

Mil. 70-I.X. 22

cd day; and failed to come up to the he postponed the Senate till the 28th of November. He ordered us to meet in the Capitol and came nd passage of op to the Temple by some un Gauls. 1 Thus summoned, the assembly was held, and some indeed were men of note, luit
;

mm.

for,

considering the

is convened the and * Senate, the Senator was dishonoured who was * fear.* Vet to that assembly, such as it was, he ture to say even a word concen make a Caesar,' although he had detenu

common

talk,

the Senate; a ccr' ular terms of m in draft When he does not venture to make a motion about the man who was marching against him with an army, though he was consul, what else is this than to a< mself a public enemy ? For necessi one or the other was an enemy no other judgment lie opposing leaders was possible. It m n ( aesar was an enemy, why was the consul not to move the Senate? hut if Caesar was not so to be stigmatised 1)\ the Senate, what can Antonius say but th.v ice about Caesar, he confessed himself keep to be n: his edicts he calls Spartacus * in the Senate he does not dare til dishonest IV Bui on the saddest topics what laughter does ive committed to memory some phrases of a certain edict these he ap|>arently icute; but I have so far not found anyone that understood what he meant. "No insult is that which the worthy makes," First of all, what is "worthy"? for many are

on about liim

in

ii

21!

MARCUS TULLIUS

CI

An "quai. multi digni, sicut ipse. Quae atitetn potest ess< dignitate est"? (till sic Quid est porro "facere loquitur? Deinde "nee timor, quern denuntiat iniinicus." Quid ergo? ab an iiorum similia deinceps. Nonne satius est mutum
i

esse

quam, quod nemo

intcllegat, dic<

<

ur

magister eius ex oratore arator fa In agro publico campi Leontini duo n

nnimiiiia, ut

erum

hominem stupidum magis

;

etiain iufutiiet

23

mercede publica. Sed iiaec leviora fortasse illud quacro, cur mansuetus in senatu merit, com In tan ferus fuisset. Quid enim attinuerat L Caaai o pi
.,

fortissimo et constant si in senatum venisset, D. (Jarful

dcnuutiare,
lc

re

senatu vi et minis mortis expellere, Ti. Cannutium, a quo erat honestis contentionibus et saepe et iure vexatus, uon t< solum, verum etiam aditu probibere C CttJ senatus consul to ne intercedDe supplicatione, credo, M. Lepidi, clarissimi rill At quod erat periculum, de cuius honore extr.t cotidie aliquid cogitabamus, ne ei 24 impediretur? Ac ne sine causa viderctur edi
1 C.'s criticism is very obscure. According to the meaning given to " contu meliam facere "(" inflict insu Plautus, Ann. ii. 4. 82 or "suffer insult"; C. seems to ask "What greater insult can there be than on suffered) by a man of real worth?" Quintilian, / 13 takes cont. facere as meaning (as in jacturamfi suffer insult" ; a sense which, he says, was not Latin in C.'s time.
;

publica sentientem

212

PHILIPPIC
.

III

ix

2:24
Is
it

like himself.

the insult

a
ill

man

of worth:
}

ran there be?

But what greater Again, what is the meaning

to

make
v

insult "

Who
it

talks like that

'

made by an a charge of Similar express fear usually made by a friend? Id it not be better to be dumb than to lerstands? Mark the reason say wha! why his master 1 has a ban trades for tillage, possesses of public land two thousand acres of territory free from taxes: it was to make a ore fatuous still, and at the public cost Hut these matters are perhaps too trivial what why he was so tame in the Senate, I ask is this although in his edicts he had been so wild. Fot asion was there to threaten with death, it the Senate, Lucius Cassius, tribune of mons, a very brave and steadfast tod: hreats of i the Senate death Decimus Carfulcnus, a man well-affected towards the State ? to debar, not only Iron Temple, but also from the approaches to the Capitol, Id.. Cannutius, by whoa he had l>een often !itlv a hat assailed with the most boned decree of the Senate did he fear they would put their veto? On thit, I suppose, concern in ; public ks to that most illustrious n mnt Marcus Lepidus. Hut what risk was there that, while we were every day thinking how we could confer up some extraordinary honour, he might he preiry? ed from receiving that which wa that he might not appear to have given notice
Seeot

ge of

fear'
is

.invthu

then?

1 1

<

lodius, A.'s tutor in rhetoric

cf.

Phil.

ii.

17

II

2'3

MARCUS TULLIUS

ftO

ut senatus adesset, cum dc re puhlica reUturus fuisset, adlato nuntio de legione quarta mconcidit et fugere festinans senatus consultum dsupplicatione per dfteesfonem fecit, eon i<l factum
esset antea

numquam.
:

palml.tti. X. Quae vero profectio postca, quam n quae vitatio oculorum, luci>. m fuga, quani foeda, quam turp senatus consulta illo ipso die vespcrtm.i, ptWUV ciarum religiosa I'rae25 quae cuique apta esset, ea cuique obv< clare igitur facitis, tribuni pi., qui de prar consulum senatusque referatis, maximas vobis gratias onines et agere et habere debemus. Qui enim periculo carere possumus in tanta hominum cupiditate et audaciar ille autcin homo adflictus et perditus quae de se expectat
}
i

iudicia graviora

quam amieorum suonim

I

}
I
<

miiliaris*

simus eius, mihi homo coniim utulus, et P. Naso omni carens cupiditate nullam se ha provinciam, nullam Antoni soi
verunt.
fuit

Quod idem

fecit

L.
;

Philippos, vir
in

j.

avo, maioribus suis di^nissimus

eadem
qui

homo summa

integritate atquc
fecit

Turranius; idem

Sp.

<>p|>i

1 Which had refused to reoogniae A. as its commander, and had joined the Martian Legion in revolt sea Phtl. * i.e. by a silent vote, there thus being no opportunity for panegyric, which on such an occasion would be exp< Ordinarily individual Senators were called upon separately. 3 The paludamentum, being assumed aft had a certain sanctity (in Verr. v. 13). C. may mean that A.'s conduct was almost sacrilege. * An illegal time: Varro apud Gdl. 14. 7
:
\

214

PHILIPPIC

III.

ix.

24-x. 25

mse, he was of a meeting of the Senate about to make a motion on State affaire, when, on receiving the news about the fourth legion, 1 lie was dumbfounded, and, in his haste to fly, caused tiuite's decree on the pobli og to be passed by a division, 1 although that had been done
before on no single o< re was afterwards! X- But what a s< what a journey, and n. litary cloak !* what an avoidance of men's eyes, of the light of day, of the he forum how sorry was his flight, how scandalous, how disgraceful Vet splendid were the decrees of the Senate made on that very day after nightfall 4 ; scrupulously exact was the allotment of the provinces; truly Heaven din fitness whereby what suited each individual should come You do splendidly therefore, to that individual tribunes of the people, in moving the question of consuls iate, and the prut B your service all of us ought to express and to feel the greatest gratitude to Of how can we be free from danger amid such cupidity and audi w li r< does that ruined and abandoned man expect heavier judgments on himself than fi friend of his own friends? His closest Intimate, LentolUf, and Puhlius Naso, a man devoid of all covetousness, have decided that they have no province, that the allotment made by Marcus Antonius was invalid. Lucius Plnlippus, a man nently worthy of his father, bifl grandfatlw r, and his ancestors, has done the same thing of the same was Caius Turranius, a man of the greatest integrity and purity of life; Spurius Oppius has done the same ; the very men too who, out of re.
!

215

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

juam amicitiam M. Aritoni veriti pltU ri tn! fortasse vellent, M. IV". et civis egregius, parique innooentia M. Wlnlius senatus auctoritati se optrmperaturos esse dUefnnt
26

uius p Quid ego de L. Cinna multis magnisque rebus lingularis int< admirabUem tacit buius honest issimi item magno qui uninino proMiHiain in animo et constant] C. Ccstius rcpu Qui sunt igitur reliqui, quos 10
I<
I

que Annios, M. Antoniu enim maluerant. C. Anton ibebat sempef Hunc quoque felicem hi C. Calvisius Africam. Nihil in on provinciam. felicius! modo enim ex Africa decesserat divinans se rediturum duos b-gatos I'ticae reliquerat Dcindc M. f Ciisim Q. Cassi Hispania. Non habeo, quid suspicer ; duaruin credo ciarmn sortes minus divinas fuisse. XI. O C. Caesar (adulescentem appello), quam tu 27 isani, sal utem rei publicae adtuli (piam repentinam Qui enim b m quid faceret insequens ? Etenim in coi \erat se custodem tore urbis seque usque ad K laias () ad urbein exercitum babiturum. praeclarum custodem ovium, ut aiunt, lupum Custosne in bis an direptor et vcj t Antonius? I't qaidem se introiturum in urbem dixit exiturumqiif-, rum
j-

L.

nihil

<

!i

*"

1 So the Vat. MS. Cusinus is unknown. M. Icciiis Siriliam Q. Cassias Hispaniam."

;

Orelli

si

1 C. probably means that these two men were opponents, not partisans, of A., there being thus less suspicion of

favouritism. Ocem lupo commisisti; Ter. Eun,

5. 1. 16.

2l6

PHII.llTK
to their friendship

Hi

x.

_>

5 -xi.

27

with Marcus Antomus. have paid him more respect than perhaps the

connexion, excellent as a man and as a one of equal t slated th v will bow to the authority of the Senate. What shall I say of Lucius Cinna ? whose singular integrity, prated Ifl u rtant affairs,
Piso,
:

my

Me has altogether of wonder. nee; and Caius Cestius also has -s repudiated his. the Heaven-sent allotment then ar< to d Annius and Marcus A A wished more. Caius s gets Macedonia. He also is happy for he had always in his eye. Caius Nothing could be happier; for he had ji. lea and laming, as it return, had left two legates at Utica. us belongs Sicily, to Quintus t<> M.u have no ground for suspicion
tter

garded

the allotment <: the work of Heaven \I. () Caius Caesar!

.

ices

was

less

call
I

on
I

tin

what safety have you brought

unlooked for! ho

how

he man did as a fugitive, what would he do if he were m pursuit ? Pot he had declared m harangue that he would l>e the city's guard would keephif amy by tl dends of Whit an excellent guardian o! May. they, is a wolf!* Would Antonius he the gOafd of the city, or rather its plunderer and hara And he said indeed that he would enter and go out
217

MARCUS TULL1US CICBRO

vellet.

Quid?

illud

nonnc

audit-

ilo

sedeiis

pro aede Castoris dixit,

nisi

qui

rum
longu

neminem ?
28

Hodierno die primum, patres con

intervallo in possessione lil>ertatis ped<

cuius quidem ego, quoad pot; Cum aut sed etiam conservator fui. non possem, qu dignitate casum ilium t< Hanc vero taeterrimam beluam qui

rem
I

tub.

aut

quo modo? Quid est in Anton nem, crudelitatera, petulantiai.

totus conglut hiatus est
iiiiuin, nihil

un

Ex

29 Quapropter,
est,

adducta id pocnas rei puhlicae luat, an DOS serviamus, aliquando, per deos immnrtales, patres conscripti, natrium animum virtutemque ut aut libertatem pn.priam Romani et generis et nominis reciperemus aut mortem at ponamus! Multa, quae in libera civitate fernon essent, tulimus et perpessi sun spe forsitan reciperandae libertatis, alii cupiditate sed, si ilia tulimus, quae nos nccessitas ferre coegit, quae vis quaedam |>acne fatalis, (quae tamen ipsa non tulimus) etiamne huius impun latronis feremus taeterrimum crudelissimuinqin-

moderatum, nihil quoniam res in

ille

utrum

30

minatum? XII. Quid

hie faciet, si poterit. iratus, qui cum suscensere nemini posset, omoibua !>nis fUerit inimicus? quid hie victor non audebit, qui nullam
1

This was

illegal

cf. n. 3, p.

Julius Caesar's.

218

PHILIPPIC

III.

x.

27-xn. 30

1 And what of this too? the hea the people, say, while fitting in front of the temple of Castor, that, except of the victors, no man should be left alive? To-day for the first time, Conscript Fathers, after a long interval we set our feet in possession of I. so far as 1 could, have been, but even the saviour. When hat, I remained quiet, and I could - bore those abjectly or without a measure < cs ami my own sorrow. Hut chances most savage beast who can bear him, and how ? t is there in Antonius save lust, cruelty, inso, audacity? Of these qualities he is wholly compacted ; nothing shows in him of good feel Where! deration, of modesty, of chastity. since matters have I ght to the |x>int that we must decide whether he should pay penalties to the State, or we be slaves, by Heaven 1 Const

hen he chose.

he not,

in

on our fathers' f] and courage, so that cither we may rec\-r tin ilxjrty of the race and name, or n prefer death to slavery. Many things unendurable in a free community we have borne and endured, some of us perhaps in the hope of recovering lib*
iffc excessive desire of life; but if we borne gi which eeceesUy, which a force, almost that of fate, 1 has compelled us to bear and yet bear them we did not shall we also bear the most savage and cruel tyrani tnd? XII W hat will this man do, if he once be al> his anger, when, with no ability to show wrath ag.-i anyone, he has become the enemy of all good n what will he not dare to do as a victor when, with-

219

MARCUS TULMUS

<

adeptus victoriam tan turn fecerit, refertam tins domain cxhauserit. conpilaverit, ad se ex iis omnia ornament* tf tulerit, caedis el Incendiorum causam quaesien
Ii

ultis funere, duobus aut tr e re publica factis reliquaa res ad lucrun revocaverit, vendideril unmunitatt verit, provincial universas ex ii

bene et

mquc
l>era-

ui.mi

iure

sustulerit,

exules

reduxerit,

falsas

leges
ii

C.

Caesaris

Bominc

et falsa deereta in aes

et in

Capitolio
r

Agenda curaverit

unnqM

rcrnm
pulo

omnium domesticum Romano lc<_ 's impofaerit, am

31

lum

et magistratui foro excluserit, sen armatis, arr.iatos in cella Concord iae, cum I T UltlfH haberet, incluserit, ad legiones Hruudisium <u ur
rerit,

ex

iis

optime sen ti en tea eentu

l

exercitu Romam sit ad interitum n <*t ad dispertitionem urbis venire con at Atque is ab hoc impetu abstract lio et cm copiis Caesaris, veteranoi legionum ne fortuna quidrm fi nn nee mere demens nee furere detinit. tlii.im In mutilatum ducit exercitum. cum un e, et ea vacillante, L. fratrem expectat, qui iiciniunn reperire potest sui ^imiliorem. autem ex myrmillone dux, ex gladiatore im|>erator qu

cum

Me

M rages,
apotheens, 2
1
2

ubicumque
caedit

j>osuit

v<

Ftmdk
reliqolqac

greges

armentorura

Bisptrsionem (Vat. MS.).

<;

These words are not found in the MSS., but are from Servius on Virg. Acn. 6. 55.
1

Julius Caesar.

220

PHILIPPIC
gaming
ai

HI.

vn.

30-31

1I<1

tesar's death, has has gutted Caesar's

house; pillaged his gardens; from Ted to himself all their appointments sought in his funeral an exeuse for massacre and arson after Rood decrees of rests of the State has reduced :it and u ise to a cji. immunities from tribute; sold exc; taken 1 b iices out of the juris*! f the oople ; recalled exiles caused false laws and fa In the name of Caius Caesar 1 to be engraved on brass and posted in tin and of all those things has constituted a in his boa rnark< ini|>osed laws on the RoDMI with armed guards shut the people and the pie the forum; surrounded the Senate
;
|

>

armed
>rd

when he

but armed men in the sh run off to held a Senate

;

number butchered attempted to march on Rome

rir

and portion out the has l>een dragged off from this assault by Caesar's skill and forces, by the unanimity >t ii- legions, even be veterans and tl
t<

with an army

<:

ifl

<

And though he

or cease

\\r
r

is

leading a

mutilated arn
u

ingle legion, and

for Ins
lie

brother Ln
find.

once

Imseff

can

a
,

matador, now a commander once now a general what havoc has he cai<

That man
a

ted his foot Urs, slaughters herds of cattle

!

He emj and of other

221

MARCUS TULLIUS
pecoris,

CICEIU

>

ipse

quodcumque nactusest; epulantur militcs autem se, ut fratrem imitetur. .bruit ri

villae,

vastantur agri, diripiuntur

virgines,

matrcs
militibus
tra-

pueri

ingenui abripiuntur,

duntur.
fecit

Haec eadem, quacumque exercitum

Aiitonius.

M.

32

XIII. His vos taeterrimis fratribus portas aperietis,

hos timquam in urbem recipietisr non tempore

oblato, ducibus paratis,

an i mil militutn inciUti

pulo

Romano

conspirante, Italia tota ad libertatem

reciperandam excitata deorum immortalium hcneficio

utemini?
fronte,

Nullum

erit tern pus

si

hoc amisso.
in

Ate
veii

lateribus tenebitur,

Galliam

Nee

ille

armis solum, sed etiam decret

ur-

guendus est. Magna vis est, magnum iniim-n uiiuui Videtisne reft et idem sentientis senatus. forum populumque Romanum ad spem reef] longo intervallo cum erectum ? qui libertatis
i

frequentes hie videt nos, turn sperat etiam liberos

convenisse.
33

vitavi, turn

Hunc ego diem expectans M. Antoni scelerata anna cum ille in me absentem invehens noi
ad quod
Si
i

tempus me et meas vires enim turn ill caedis a me initium quaerenti respondere voluissem, nunc rei publicae consulere non possem. Hanc vero nactus facultatem nullum tempus, patres conscripti, dimittam neque diurnum neque nocturnum, quin de libertate populi
intellcgebat,

reservarem.

222

PHILIPPIC

III

x.i

33
his soldiers

beasts whatever he got hold of; and he n imitation d

ii

ther,
;

banquet drowns
plunof good

himself

in

wine

fields

are devastated

villas

><>ys

birth are carried off* and given to the soldiers. These same things, wherever he led his army, were done

larcus Anton; XIII. Is it to these most noisome brothers that r gates? these that you will at any jroicwill o Miall we D time admit into the the occasion is offered, our leaders ready,
i
I

soldiers
es of the
will

s'

man
the recover

people one Inspirit,

iqi
:

Italy roused for

There
into

be no opport you lose this. Hanks he will be held it

In rear, in

arms only that he mast be

harassed, but also by decrees, (ircat is the force, great the divine majesty of a Senate u and the same mind. Do JOQ not see the packed for and how the Roman people is eneour ope he recovery of their liberty it after a long interval it has seen us assembled here in numbers, pes we have also met together as free in is for this day I was waiting when I avoided the accursed arms of Mar. iicn, itflung against me in my absence, be did not was reserving understand thr occasion elf and my strength. For it I had been willing to him n ben he was looking for me as fruit of a massacre, I should not now have been able to espouse the cause of the Hut,
I
I
i

J-

now I have gained this opportun let no moment pass, by day or night, without thought for
11

"3

MAKCUS TULL1US
Romani
^
1

CI

et

dignitate vestra, qucxl

I

tin.

quod agendum
.

'<"

modo

nnii
I

sed

el
llcuil
;

pctara
infc
I

nt

-esse non solum licet, scd est, nisi servirr male 34 animisque decemerr. pracsidia dedmint. url>i Caesarem, Br Si enim ille opprimere urben .<lum Galliam tenerr. pauln |n>st opt. erat, rdiijuis st-r\ irndum. XIV. (lane Igituf occssionem oblatam tenet

deposcam. non limit.

!<><

Peel,

dum

Iain

deos
orbis

innnortales,

patres
prii

con

ainpli

terrae
!

consilii

esse mliquando
Hie Nihil

recordamini Signum date silium vestrum noil <l< a rel pub virtutem suam non defuturam esse profitetur.

est,

quod moneam
intellegat,
si

vos.

Nemo

est
h

ittot,

qui
not)

non

indormierimus

modo erudelem superbamqm-

tionem

n<

esse. sed iirnoininiosam etiam etfla^ 35 Nostis insolentiam Antoni, nos! totam domum. Libidinosis, petu uiiiiiii impudu-is, aleatoribus, ebriis servire, ca nriseria est summo dedecorecoiiiun Q nftdti iaui. quod di omen avertant fatui publlcae venit, quod gladiatores nobiles fariunt. ut honeste decumbant, faciamus n< terrarum gentiumque omnium, ut cum digi potius cadamus quam cum ignominia serviamus. 36 Nihil est detestabilius dedecore, nihil fa servitute. Ad decus et ad libertatem nati lumus;
!

224

I'HII.II'I'Ii

III

.36

the
I

the

Uu
I

>u and deeds, not only not will even seek and ind to act and do. This I did while I was allowed ; 1 desisted so long as I was not allowed. it is also impera' t allowed, but Now refer to be slaves rati. gainst slavery. The weapon and with inn (Is have given us these safeguards for the city, Caesar, Brut q for if that man had n able to overpo*< then t once, or, if
trill
1

soon after, every loyal d, and the rest ben tal Gods, this XIV. Seise then, bj tin ocea rs, and at length remember you are the leaders of th< proodet! council Koman |ieople a sign that in the i the State, for that people jnscl docs urea that its courage will not fail.
aul,
!

for

my wan
ir

but

No man is so foolish as 'and that, it" we sleep we a tyranny, not merely cruel and arroj: You know and infamous.
,

Is,

you know
1

Slavery un
is

lustful,

this
tin
if
"

already may the Gods avert the om latest pa te has been I>: the leaders of the world and of all nations, do what stout with honour, let us ity rather thai

Hut

misery

.1

ice.

servitude.

It is to

glory and to hlxrty

we

Mi

MARCUS TULLIUS CK KRO

aut haec teneamus aut

com

dignitate

moriamur.
nun

Nimium

diu teximus, quid sentiremusj

apertum est; uiunes pateim-iunt, in Sui partem quid sentiant, quid vein,'
sed pro caritate rei publicae

utramque

bene sentkntium quorum opprimendorum di immortally Incredib

multitudinem
rei

publicae potestatem et fort u nam dedcrunt.

pniesidia,

Ad

ea enim
consules

quae

habemus, iam
concord
libertate
<iu

gumma
de

prudent i>

menses

populi

Romani

atque meditati.

His auctoribus et

iuvantibus, nobis vigilantibus et multuin in post<

providentibus, |x>pulo

Romano
;

consent unte en

profecto liberi brevi tempore

iucundiorem autem

faciet libertatem servitutis recorda

37

XV. Quas ob
uti

res,

quod

tribuni

pL verba
tuto
hal

feet-runt.

senatus

Kalendis

Ianuariis

tentiaeque de

summa

re publica lil>erc dici [>oesint,

de ea re
operam,
possit

ita

censeo
senatus Kalendis Ianuariis tato liaberi

Uti C. Pansa A. Hirtius, consules designati, dent

uti

Quodque

edictum

D.
sit,

Bruti

imperai

consulis designati, propositum

D. Brutum imperatorem, optime de re publica mereri, cum senatus auctoritatem populique Romani libertatem imperinmqoe
38 defendat; quodque provinciam Galliam citeriorem

senatum existimare consulem designatum,

226

PHILIPPIC
I
;

III.

xiv.

36-xv. 38

let

Too long have we

tier is clear; all feel

us either hold fast to these <r Hie with veiled our feelings ; now

mak< either side and what they wish Disloyal ens there are, gauged by our love of our country too many, yet, as against a multitude of the wn >sed, very few; to crush them the immortal Gods have given the State a marvellous power and opportunity. For to the safeguards we have will presently be added consuls of the highest judgm r.ige, and ty, men that have these many taken thought and consideration for the liberty of the Roman people. With these as our Mscllors and leaders, with the help of the Gods, h ourselves alert and exercising full forethought for the future, with the Roman people in agreem we shall surely be free in a short time and our remembrance of servitude will lend an added charm

what they

these accounts, as the tribunes of the spoken to ensure the Senate's assembling in safety in the Kalends of January, and the free expression of opinion on the highest matters te, on that matter I move That Caius Pansa and Aulus Hirtius, the reelect, see to it that the Senate can be held in safety on the Kalends of January. And, whereas an edict of mus Brutus, general and consul elect, has been issued, the Senate is of opinion that Decimus Brutus, general and consul elect, has deserved 'Iftriiding the authority of exc< the Senate and the liberty and empire of the Roman pie; and whereas he is keeping th< e of 1 ither Gaul, one inhabited by citizens of the gre.i

commons

have

227

MARCUS TULLIUS
optimoniin et fortissimorum
publicac civiuin.

CI

uorumqw
in sen.-r tate

exerritumque

retineat. id earn exercitumqu<

nias pro\ inciar (Jail: W
publii-a

,e re

fecisse

et

facere.

Senatam ad room
ah
1>

rrin publirain

pert Inert arbitrari

Planco iinperatoribus, consulib

a ceteris, qui provincial optinent optineri ex
Iulia.

nque

quoad ex senat
sit,

uin

eosque dare

at eae

atque exercitus in senati popultque Romani

praesidioque
rei

publicac sint.
I

Cumque opera, virt summoque consensu militum

auctori totem
secuti
rei

am, qui
t

publ
ericolifl

et

fuerunt,

a gravi
sit

populoa

39 defensus
legio

et hoc

tempon
in

cumque
manic

Martia Albae conatfterit,

lissimo et fortissimo,

populique

Romani libertatem contulerit;

et
.

pHri consilio

eademque
eivi

virtu'

L.

Egnatuleio duce,

egregio,

populique Romani libertatem defendat

senatui

magnae curae

esse ac fore, ut pf
lion

eorum
228

in

rem publicam mentis

tntur

PHILIPPIC
loyalty

HI. xf. 38-39

and courage and friendliness to the State,

e to the Senate, that Inarmy, and the boroughs and colonies of the iitlv province of Gaul have acted and are and in order Mid in the interests of tin- State. - the t the Senate is of opn rices should be held by Decimal e that tli Brutus and Lucius Plancus, generals and consuls elect, 1 and also by the others who held provinces, according to the Julian law, until a successor to each of these be ap|>ointed by senatorial decree
his

and and

hat tlu y

ihottld see to

it

that those provinces

t*

and armies be under the a the Senate and and a protection of the State. And where* bj the li -.p. courage, and judgment of Caius Caesar, and by the supreme jiarmoiiy of the veteran soldiers, who, by following his lei guard, and have guarded the State, tin Roman phas leen defended, and is at the present time b defended, from the gravest |>crils and whereas the
.

legion has stationed itself at Alba, in a the greatest fidelity and court l>or<> has devoted itself to safeguard the authority of the

Senate and the liberty of the Beeou people; and -cas. with equal ju and the M
the fourth legion ui command oi n. Egnatuleius, an eminent it ling and has defended the authority of the Senate and tinliberty of the Roman people that the Senate does and 11 take care that, in return for such service part to the State, honours be conferred upon
I

They had been nominated by J. Caeaar in succession to Pansa and Hirtius.

as consul* for

22()

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

jratiaeque referaiitur.

Senmtui plac
(!

Pans*
magisl
uti c re

A.

Hirtius,
si

consules

inissent,

eis \i<lrntu'

ad hunc ordinem rcferrcnt, iU publica tidc-(]ue sum videretur.

his rebus

230

PHILIPPIC
resolves

III.

xv.

39

them, and thanks be returned. That the Senate that Caius Pansa and Aulus Hit consuls elect, when they have entered upon office, should, if it seem good to them, on the car r these matters to this body as it shall occa appear to them consonant with the interest of the
t

State and their

own

loyalty.

*3'

'

!\

RODU<

HON TO
i

PHILIPPIC IV

of the debate in the Senate on In>er, Cicero proceeded to here harangued the people. He showed had not been .ally applied t< A that in effect he tiiat the honours paid to been so de the a the Martian and of thr tli legions, and the Senate's comm Of of I) Bratc fend the province of Gaul, by implied is to be an enemy of declared the State; that with Antoniui (with whom no ) was litions of peace wcr to de. whether nans should be permitted to live And he urged then to display the valour at all. it hers which had made the Romans the of th juerors of the world. m, his harangue to the j of this the sixth Philippic he s n if that day had been o be the end of my life, on it I had reaped an abundant est when you all with one mind and voice shouted that the State had been a second time preserved by The Mess of this sj>eech has been, with what ran only be regarded as craziness of scepticism, Impugned by Krau Bn< King shows that arguments, mostly a priori, are singularly un nents are based on a passage cited by Nonius which does not occur in the s|>eech
t t
. i

At

<

2 33

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
as

IV

it, to which the answer i* that it may have dropped out; on the alwence topics which Cicero might have been expected to touch on, such as the details of the senatorial decree, the flight of Antonius from th< Ity, the defcnct iesar, and abuse of Antonius' 1> the j But, as King shows, it was not necessary for Cicero

we have

very well

to allude to these topics.

Another

arjjt.

be

similarity of the subject-matter of the that of the third Philippic, and often tl.

speech with
not

of the same expressions. unnatural feature.

It

But

this

would be a

may be mentioned
is

that the end of the third

(9.

chapter
I

quoted
2.

idorus (Orig.

by Quint ilian 21. 11), and three

3.

86),

and
tilth

the

chapter by Arusianus Messius. Bui in fact the eloquence and force of the whole speech mark it beyond question as Cicero's.

234

M.

TULLI CICEHONIS IN M. ANTON1UM ORATIO PHILIPPICA QUART

I. Freqaentia restrain IncredibUis, Quirites, con< tioque tanta, qunntam meminisse non

il.K

rit.itrm inihi suininani

dcfcndendac

rei

pat

adfert et

spem recuperandae. Quam mini qnidem nomquam defuit, tempora

lueis
ie

deftierunt,
t'ui.

quae simul ac priinum nliquid

sunt, prince]

ostenderc visa

libertatis

def

Quodsi id ante facere eonatus essem. ne non possem. Hodierno enim die, mediocrem rem actain arbitrru.ini, fundainenta iaeta sunt reliquarum actionum. Nam est hostis a aei nondum verbo adpellatus, sed re Kan lodl Antonius. Nunc vero multo sum ere*' quoque ilium hostem esse tanto consensu tan toque clamore adprobavistU. Neque enim, Quirites, fieri potest, ut non aut ii sint inipii, qui contra consulem exercKtU COnparsI

verunt,

aut
sunt.
erat,

ille

bostis,

contra

qaena

hire

sumpta
nulla

Hanc
tamen

igitur dubitatinncm.

qnamqaani
ten

ne

qua posset

esse,

hodierno die sustulit. C. Caesar, qui rem pobl libertatemque vestram suo studio, con rfmonio denique tutatus est et tutatur, maximil lenatof laudibus ornatus est. Laudo, laudo vos, Quirites,

1 Here evidently followed applause. ng his speech, C. picks up laudibus with laudo, and praises the people.

236

THE lolKHI PHILIPPIC

ftO
I.

oi

If.

IULLIUS
and
the
this

AGAINST
I

M. A

i:

in<

numbers,
aeein
t.

sise

U the greatest eager

d the State
g
s
it.

and with hope of

re-estab-

Yd

it

doI that the ipirll ever tailed

seemed
I

to shed

and as soon some gleam of

ns ever the
light,
I

the

do
it

to d so before,
first

should not be able to do so

t\

not

now for deem

;

been accomplished
!

of

wha

ns to
|

be aeronipliv
so called, has in Senate to be a public h more encoi
i

in

fa.

adjudged by the

am
title,

ise,

have confirmed tint

the J. her those are tint havi than armies against a consul, or that man is an enemy agah m arms have rightly been tak n up, then ibt on ti though there wa iht v of d doubt Caius Caesar, rll htfl

policy,

and

tribution

<>!'

his

patri-

mony
liberty, has

been honoured by the

I

with
I

highest commendation. 1

commend,

com
237

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

quod
gratissimis animis prosecjumnni
;

DOOMS d
<

simi adulescentis vcl pucri potius

cius immortal tatis,
i

sunt

-nim facta

nomcn
legi,

aetatis.
;

Multa mrinun.
nihil

multa audivi, multa

Quirites
i

ex

omnium
nihil

saeculorum memoria tale cogn<>>

qui, mm servitutc

premeremur,

in dies

malum

haberemus, capitalem et pestiferum

iB
hoc

turn

M. Antoni omnibus consilium, incognitum

redituin

timeremus,

insperatum

rrrte

cepm?
itum

exercitum invictum ex paternis militibus

Antonique furorem crudclissimil const

a pernicie
4
II.

rei

publicae averteret.
nisi

Quis est enim, qui hoc non intellegat,

Ita
sat

Caesar exereitum paravisset, non sine exitio nostra

futurum Antoni redituin fuisse?

piebat ardens odio vestri, erucntus

enim

se

mm

Romanorum, quos Suessae, quos Brundisii Occident, ut nihil nisi de pernicie populi Romani cogitaret. Quod autem praesidium erat salutis libei
vestrae,
si

C.

Caesaris

fort

militum exercitus non fuisset:

et

Cuius de Uodibui
et immortalibus

honoribus, qui

ei

pro divinis

meritis divini immortalesque debentur, milii scnatus

adsensus

paulo

ante

decrevit

ut

primo

quoque

tempore

referretur.

Quo decreto quis non perspieit hostem esse Antenium iudicatum? Quern enim possumus appellare eum, contra quern qui exercitus ducunt, iis senatus
3

PHALIFPK

IV.

i.
|

:..

[tomans, for greeting with the warn gratitude tiie name of a most no! man, or for though his deeds belong rather boy c name of boy belongs to his age. n remember, much have I heard, n Romans, have I read; no such act have I ever km amid the records of all the ages. When we were when, day by day, the og opprev was growing, when we had no protection, when we were then fearing the deadly and paitiluiil
* ;

Marcus Antonius from Bmndisiom, he me unhoj>ed for, at any rate unknown to all, of raising an unbeaten ami father's and turning aside the fren Ant< the most cruel designs, from the d< State, II es not understand this, thai Caesar had not levied his army, the return of \ntonius would have entailed our ruin? Fbl was he coming back, burning with hatred of you, red Kith the blood of Roman citizens whom he had slain at Suessa, at Bmnditium, that he had do thought hut for the destruction of the Roman people. And what safeguard was there lives and lil>ertv, if Caesar's army of his father's stoutest soldiers had not existed ? And with re| to the praises and honours due t< him and d\ and immortal honours are due for his div immortal services the Senate now decreed on my motion th.it they be taken into consideration at the earliest poss. does not perceive that by that decree Antonius has been adjudged an enemy? for what can we call the man, when the Senate decrees that

adopted

39

MARCUS TULLIUS
legio Martia,
traxisse

C1CBI
In

arbitratur singulares exquirendos

mores?

Quid

quae dco nomen, a quo populum Komanum genera

milii videtor divinil
1 1
*

acct-piiiiu-.

11

Ipsa rais deeretii prius

quam
si

lenatqi

hostem iudicavit
hostis, hos, qui

Antomum ?
reli<j

Nam,

illr

consulem

cesse
(

est iudicemus.

Praeclare et loco,

tione vestra factum pulcl

probavistis
;

qui

se

ad
ad
i

senatus

item,

ad

libertatem

vestrani,

univcrsam
et latroi

rem
i<l

publ
lam

contulerunt, ho it
6 patriae
fortiter,

reliquerunt.

Nee solum

animosc

et

sed considerate etiam

sapienterque fece-

runt; Albae constiterunt,

urbe opportmia,
virorum,

mm
leg!

propinqua,

fortissiinormn

fidclissimnrum

civium atqur optimorum.

legio quarta

Muius Martiae
duce
la

imitata

irirtutem

Egnatul
Caesaris

quern senatus merito paulo ante

exercitum persecuta
III.

est.

Quae

expectas, M. Antoni. indicia gravi

Caesar fertur in caelum, qui contra te exercitum conparavit;

laudantur exquisitissimis verl

quae te reliquerunt, quae a te arcessitae sunt, quae essent, si te consulem quam hostem maluisses,
tuae
;

quarum legionum fortissimum verissimumque

confirmat
senatus,

iudicium

conprol>at

universus

populus Romanus;

nisi forte vos, Quirites,

consulem,

240

PHILIPPIC
special honours should
ies
In*

IV.

n.

5-mi. 6

devised tor thoat that lead did not the M legio h appears to ine to have derived its at from that God from whom e has sprung), by its bj tradition resolution before tbc Senate, adjudge it lie is not an enemy liat have deserted the
again

What?

'

ul

to

be

onalj

and

in

se.i

repeated shouts approved most honourable action of the Martians, who have come to the authority of tin- Senate, and the mtire State, who have and brigand and parricide of Ami it is not only with spirit and age, but also with d -liberation and wisdom they have done so they stationed themselves at Alba, in
.

I.

d,

fortified,

close

to
'

ni

and

foil

loyal

and of the im eiti/.ens. Copying the good COndtt km, the fourth legion under the
I
.

whom t'<r I of Luciu the Senate has just now commended, has followed the army of Caius Caesar. III. verer judgments, MarCQJ Antonius, are \ Caesar is exalted to the skies for? ha- levied an army against you; legions are ed in the most generous terms that have aban.'ik.iiciI by you, hat it (1 you, that have . be a consul rather than an enemy. you had Id have been yours; and the judgm< nt of those .the Senate ooi and unless the whole Roman people approve* you, Romans, adjudge Antonius to be a
command
ices
I

<

241

MARCUS TULLIUS
7

CICBftO
Sic
I

non hostcm
cipia,

iudicatis

Antonium.

arbitrabar.
miir

Quirites, vos iudicare, ut ostenditis.

colonias,

pracfecturas

num

alit.

tod

censetis?

Omnes mortalcs una mente con.srntiunt omnia arraa corum, qui haec salva D Bratl illain pestem esse capienda Q fedlcto II judicium, Quirites, quod ex li-<: dtua perspicere potuistis, num cui tandem coi
l

videtur?
quasi

Hecte et vere uegatis, Quintet.

l>

Et

e
:i

netioioet muttered deorum iinmnrt.-ilium rei publicae Hrutorum genus el populi Romani vel const it uendam vel Quid igitur D. Brutus tie M. A

Excludit provincia, exercitu obsiM

hortatur ad helium ipsam sua sponte
excitatam.
St
rei

dicio
si

consul

Antonius, Hrtitus hostis;

Brutus,
hostis

conservator

publicae

Am>i

Num
IV.

igitur,

utrum horum sit, dubitare possumus? Atque ut vos una mente unaqtte voce dubitare

vos negatis, sic

modo

decrevit set

I)

Hnituin

optime de re publiea mereri, cum senatus aur' tatem populique Romani libertatem imp
defenderet.
9

quo defender
alia

tpe

ab hoste

quae est enim

laudanda defensio?

Deinceps

laudatur provincia Gallia meritoque ornatur verbis

amplissimis ah senatu, quod resistat Antonio.
si

Quern

consulem

ilia

provincia putaret neque

eum

re-

ciperet,

magno

scelere se adstring

nes enim

242

PHILIPPIC

IV. hi. 6-iv.

consul, not an enemy. I thought jour judgment, it ' do you tins, was at you show it to be. think the boroughs, the colonies, the prae: All living men agree with rmine ol

Wh

that every weapon those who our to be saved possess must be grasped to oppose s the judgment, Romans, of 11 could gauge by his edict !>car now one to be despised ? Rightly say No. For it is by the k ness and bounty of the immortal Gods, as it were, that the race and name of BrattM has been bestowed on her to establish or to recover the liberty
I

What then
is
I

is

the judgn.

on Marcus Antonius? He shuts him out of uc; with an army he resists he exhorts to war all Gaul, already itself 'd of its own accord, and by its own judgment. If Antonius is a consul, Brutus is an enemy
;

Brutal

is

the saviour of

us

is

its

enemy.
IV.

Can we then douht which of these

alterna-

And

Si

loobt, so has the

one voice say Senate just decreed,

rutus deserves excellently of g the authority of the Senate, and and empire of the Roman people. Defending from whom? from an enemy of cou what other defence is worthy of praise? N the province of Gaul is commended and ji

honoured by the Senate

tor

in the
If

most generous terms

that province deemed him i coriMil, and yrt would not receive him, it would involve itself in a great crime; for all pro
resisting

Antonius.

*43

M UlCUS TULLIl
in consulis iurc et

imperio debent es
in
.

Ne<;at

hoc

1).

Brutus

natus rd pul
Italia,

:iuta

negat senatus, negx

nisi
[pai,

ilium

CMVRMddm

tatrone*

Quamqa
hint,

quidrm
rodicio
sint,
si

quod lncuntur,

Dec
iique

omnium mortalium, qc
>

rapit-ndi atque quos non bonorum

noii ilia infinita

Sed spcs sunt obcaecat animos c<>

;

d<
<|

hasta satiavit
uin ad

bona et
10 sibi
di

fori

praedam propoanenmt

qui, (luin bic

nihil sit, quod rai defaturum arbitrantur; quibus M. Antonius ( innnortales, avertite et detesta aeso, hoc
!)

omen
Ita
liuius

urbem

se divisurum esse
ut

j>i

vero, Quirites,

precaminij even

amentiae poena in ipsum faroiliai] Quod ita futurum esse enim non solum homines, sed etiani deos immortales ad rem publicam conservandain arbitroi
recidat
!
<

Sive enim prodi

nobis futura praedicunt, ita sunt apert

ut et
illi

poena
:

<-t

nobis lihertas adpr< inpulsu

tantus

<-ons

deorum esse

11

non potuit, quid est, quod de voluntate caelestiam dubitare possimus? V. Reliquum est, Quirites, ut vo

quam

prae vobis
1

fertis,

persevereti

Jtur,

Of the property of the Pompeian par*

244

PHILIPPIC

IV.

iv.

v-v

it

uiaiitl

\inces ought to l>e within the jurisdiction and Dsolsbin Decimal of the niiisul. Hrut uander, consul elect, a citizen bora to
i

let; Gaul denies it; all Italy you deny it. \\ bo the Senate deafel it deem him Not that consul hut brigands? these very men think as they say; though uitl criminal. tlwv are, yet they cannot Hut dissent from the judgment of all living men. of ropinc and plunder blind the minds of men :n do jifl issignments of lands, that neve has sated men have set before themselves for plunder the city and the goods and fortunes of its citizens; men that think nothing will fail them provided tin re be here

'

some tnbjod

for

njune,

for

robbery
.

men

immortal
t
i

pray,

and make

harmless COS Antnnius has ptomi be division of the Yes, Romans, may le be according to prayers, and may the penalty ft this man's madness am confident on himself and on Ins family I it will, tor only, but also the think that, not lmmort.i ivc agreed together fur tlx Fee whether the immortal of the State, is foretell for us the future by prodigies and tve been declared so openly that lioth his punishment and our freedom are con near; or whether such unanimity of all men eould not l>e without the impulse of Is, what 10 have we for doubt as to the will of Heaven ? V. It remains for you, Romans, to persevere in the sentiments which you openly display. I shall therefore act as command Oil commonly act when
I

mm

'

245

MARCUS TULLIUS CICE&O

ut

imperatores

instructs

acic

solenl

[QSin
tit

paratissimos milites ad proeliandum \idcant. tamen adhortentur, sic ego vos ardentes ct

en

Non est ad libertatem reciperandam cohortal>or. vobis, Quirites, cum eo hoste eertann -n. eon quo
aliqua pacis condicio esse jwssit.

Neque

enini Ule

servitutem vestram ut antea, sed iam iratus sannullus vi Indus \idrtur esse guinem concupivit
;

iucundior
12 oculos
rites,

quam

cruor,

trueidatio civium.

quam caedes, qu Non est vobis

cum
in

cum

sceler.it>

bomine ac nefm

inimani taetraque belua.

incidit,

Quae quoitiam
recusanda.
iis

foveam
Dnllitll
t.

obruatur
crudelitas
erit

supplicii

Sed
quas
I

premitur, urguctur nunc

copiis,

consules bemus, mox iis, quas paucis diel Incumbite in causam, Qafrites, ut comparabunt. Numquam maior consensus vestcr in ulli facitis.

causa

fuit,

numquam tam
fuistis.

ve!
;

consociati

Nee mirum

agitur ennn,

non
etttt

qua condicione victuri, sed victurine simus an supplicio ignominiaque perituri.

13

Quamquam mortem quidem

posuit, crudelitatem mortis et

natura omti
d
pro-

pulsare solet, quae propria

t.nnseminis. Hanc retinete, quaeso, qua] quam hereditatem maiores vestri litnii mil Nam cum alia omnia falsa, incerta sint, caduca, mobilia,
1
1

virtus est

una

altissimis defixa radici!>iis

quae nutn-

quam
246

vi ulla labefactari potest,

numquam dem

PHILIPPIC
the line
is

IV.

v.

11-13

although they may see absolutely prepared for battle, they yet so will I exhort you, though you are You have, ardent ami eager to recover your liberty. Romans, no contest with an enemy with whom any terms of peace are possible. For it is not, as
in battle array;
;

torn r enslavement, it is for your blood he has in his wrath now become athiiM no s: seems to him more joyful than bloodshed, thin tore hi^ massacre, than the Imteherv You have not now to deal, Romans, with a eyes. guilty ami villainous, hut with a man he has fallen monstrous and savage beast 9 bin DC overwhelmed; for, 1; escape out of it, there is no torture, however cruel, we shall be able to evade. But he is being held fast, pressed, harassed, now by the forces we already have tlv he will DO so by those the new Put your shoulders, consuls will in a few days levy. Romans, to the cause as you are doing. Never has your unanimity been greater in any cause, never have you been so earnestly associated with And no wonder; tor the issue is, not pa Senate. what terms we shall live, but whether we are to
;
1

and Igl Nature has indeed ap|>ointed death for all men, yet against a death of cruelty and dishonour, valour, the native possession of the Roman race and lineage,
live at all, or perish in torture

ever affords a defence. Hold fast, I bese< to that which vour ancestors have bequeathed \ For while all things else as it were an heirloom. are false and uncertain, perishable and ir alone is planted with the deepest roots ; by no force can it be shaken or removed from its

*47

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

loco.

Hac

virtute maiores vestri priiuum

nunc:

rant, Italiam devicerunt, (hinde Karthaginei Numantiam evertcrunt, potetttisshnoi regcs, belli

cosissimas gentes

in

dicionem

huius

In

degerunt. VI. Ac maioribu quidein vestris, Quirites, cum 00 14 hoste res erat, qui haberet rem publican, em et concordiam di nun, ratkmem aerarium, fiffff"

aliquam,

si

ita

res tulisset,

|>acts

et foederis;

bk
ipse

vester hostis vestram

rem publicam OppQgnftt,

id

habet nullani

senatum.

is terrae consil
t
;

delere gestit, ipse consilium publicum nullum hah< aerarium vestrum cxhausit, suum non hal

15

concordiam civium qui habere potest, nullam cum habet civitatem ? pacis vero quae potest esse cum eo ratio, in quo est incredibilis crudelitas, fides nulla? Est igitur, Quirites, populo Romano victor! omniurn gentium oinne certamen cum percussore, latrone, cum Spartaco. Nam quod se si mil -m esse

mm

Catilinae gloriari solet, scelere |>ar est

inferior.
Ille

illi,

imlu

rej)ente
amisit.

cum exereitum nullum habuisset, conflavit; hie eum exereitum, quem ac<
Lt
igitur Catilinam diligentia

mea, scnatus
,

auctoritate,

vestro

studio

et

virtute

sic

nefarium latrocinium vestra cum sen it concordia tanta, quanta numquam fuit, felicitate et virtute exercituum ducumque vestrorum

Antoni

16

tempore

oppressum

audietis.

Equidem quantum

cura, labore, vigiliis, auctoritate, consilio eniti atqoe

1

/..

as being host in.

Of. n. 4, p. 210.

248

PHILIPPIC
place.

IV;

v.

;,-vi.

l6

By this valour your ancestors first conquered rased Carthage, overthrew whole of Itai i, and reduced to allegiance to this empire knifes the most powerful, and nations the most
ike.
\
I

And your ancestors, Romans, had to deal with an vim inv that possessed a State, a Senate, a treasury, unanimity and concord among its citizens, le on which, if the occasion admitted, som
iiil peace and a of } attacking your State while he hfmtftf (>ossesses none; he longs to obliterate the Senate, that is to say, the council of the world, hut he himself possesses no public council ; he has drained your As to " treasury, he has none of his own.

MMM

is

<

cord
i

among

how can he have

it

who

has

But as to peace, what reckoning no can there be with a man whose cruelty is incredible, his good faith Ootid therefore, K-inans, s wholly between the Coiuan people, t) over all nations, and an assassin, a brigand, a Spartacus.* For, as for his usual boast that he is like Catiline, he is equal to him in wickedness, but inferior in energy. The one, v. h.n lie had no army, hurriedly collected one; fcBM other has lost the army he received. As then by my exertions, by the authority of the Senate, n seal and courage, you broke Catiline, and so will you hear that the criminal brigandage of Antonius has been in a short time crushed by your unprecedented harmony with the Senate, and by the good fortune and valour of your armies and rals. As for me, so far as by thought, labour, watching, influence, and advice I shall be able to
I
-

249

MARCUS TULLIUS
etficere potero, nihil

CICEItO

praetermittam, qtod ad libertattm vestram pertinere arbitrator; neque enim id pro vestris amplissimis in me beneficiis sine M Hodierno autein die primum rcfVfacere possum. rente viro fortissimo vobisque amicissimo, hoc M.
Servilio, collegisque eius, ornatissimis viris, opt

civilms, longo intervallo

me

auctore

ct

um pnmipe ad

pen

libcrtatis exarsimus.

250

PHILIPPIC
undone that

IV.

vi.

16

ct anything, I will have nothing think concerns your liberty having regard to your most generous kindnesses towards myself, it is impossible to do so without a Hut to-day, on the motion of Marcus Sercrime, courageous man and your very good dished n ad, and his colleagues, mo and most loyal citizens, we have, But time after a long interval, with ray counsel and at my instance, been tired by the hone of liber
I
j I

*5

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC V
the 1st of January, 43 b.c, the [* Antonius had shut Dp I). Brutu, in and was closely besieging him, and that
tli.it
.

;tina

Caesar On l.mus was mart! attack Antonius. that dav the ne* Consuls, Hirtius and Pansa, in the pie of Jupiter Caj consulted the Senate in on the state of public affairs. After rs spoken, as Cicero says, in a manly strain, the] pinion first, HI called upon Calenus to dc! because he was Pansa's father-in-law, hut potalbl) because, being a strong partisan of Antonius. be would propose moderate counsels in contradistinction to those of Cicero, whose views were well known. II tli it. before proceeding to the extremity of war, an emltassy should be Antonius to command him to raise the siege and nit to the authority of the Senate. was supported by L. Piso and some others. Cicero then delivered the fifth Philip; rle s lid it was madness to send envoys to a man whom the Senate had on the 20th of December in effect declared an enemy by on that <lav commending the generals and the veterans who bad taken uj arms against him: that the question was whether Antonius should l>e permitted to crush the State. He alluded to the laws Antonius had illegally passed the armed men with whom he had blocked the lorum; his squandering of publir moneys his forged itizendecrees; the sale of grants of kin.
i

*53

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
ship,

and of exemptions from taxation; the false records of such transactions; his constitution of tin courts of law and the Introduction of b oi the introduction into the Templ< re of the eettdoii bands of brigands; hi
;

at Brundisium; and ln^ threats of dcjit Now, Cicero argued. \ beaten party.
'

ll

*ai malt Mutina.a colony of the \l<> war, and to send an embassy I and weaken the universal indignati tate Accordingly he prop l of of commotion should be proclaimed, th< the courts suspended; military garb be assumed, a \a\ and levy held throughout Italy without benefit of furlough, and that the well md of the State should be entru ted to they be enjoined " to see that the Stat harm." 2 1>< He also proposed that a vote of than! passed in honour of D. Brutus and Lepidus,* and thai be a gilt equestrian statue to As to tin erected on the rostra or ti young Caesar, he proposed that he should lould be given the imperium or military a have the rank of propraetor, with a seat in the
i I

For the meaning of

It was M. Aemilius

this

term see

n.

p. 288.

The decree investing the consuls with extraordinary

powers.
*

like a proclamation of martial law. L., the future triumvir, now Governor of Narbonese Gaul. In 49, on Caesar's departure for Spain, he was left as Praefectus Urbis. He had been thrice Caesar's master of the horse, and in 46 his colleague as consul. The honours now decreed (for which he gave no thanks : ad Fam. x. 27) were for persuading Sext. Pompeius in 63 (of. n. 2. p. 542) t o lay down his arms,

254

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC V
Senate; and should be allowed to stand, notwithAnd Inding his age, for the higbcf oAee*, pledged himself, on Caesar's behalf a pledge at uhu-h tin Fates, as they spun tin-threads of the m holy drain have "somewhat urriinlv Bailed " that he " would always sen a- tin y ought nosl to with and pro

it'-

n to be."

proposal n the quest:

00 his

sid-

uied till tin- 4th of January, and _ ard t<> honours were lassy Cicero had a n >i >i it \ - .Uius tin !>\

ented a vote being taken, and C 'altThe envoys motion for an embassy was carried. were charged to command Antonius to submit to the Senate and people to abandon the siege of and to withdraw his troops out of Gaul to the Italian side of the Huhn >n. l>ut not nearer to
;

Ih v were also instructed XX) miles. Brutus, and to assure him and his army of the Senate's approval of their zeal. that on the fourth day of tin under the influence of some hope deb or other, was more lenient. Hut Appian tells us wife, that, during the adjourn (3. 61 moth r, and young son, and his frn nds, in black garments beset the Senators with cries and supplica-

to see

I).

'

tions,

and succeeded

in ptei ailing

upon them.
L. Piso, and
L.

The ambaaeadors were

3. Sulpicios, pus, the stepfather of Oct. Caesar.

'55

\I.

TULLI CICRRONIS IN

M.

ANTON

I'M

ORATIO PHILIPPICA QUINTA

1

umquam longius his Kalendis lain. I. Nihil 'i mihi visum est, pfttrc quod idem int Qui gebam per hos dies urn cuiquc vestrum mini helium cum re puhlica gemot, hill tlOn exspectabant nos autem tun: fcfQ Mibvcuirc cniiiiiiiiin saluti oporterct turn non vocabamur. Sed querel nun
;

dierum sustulit oratio ut magis exoptatae

coi
K.il<

ui

ita lot

mlae

videantur. A tque ut oratio c<> erexit spemque attulit non inodo sal litis conservandae, verum etiam dignitat |>erturbasset eius sentt-ntia. qui j> 11 est, nisi vestrae virtuti constat 2 Hie enim dies vobis, patres conscript i, in! potestas data est, ut, quantum virtutb, qoan constantiae, quantum gravitatis in huius ordinis
esset, populo Romano declarare possetis. Recordamini, qui dies nudius tcrtius d< quantus consensus vestrum, quanta virtus, qooota constantia, quantam sitis a populo Romano land- m, quantam gloriam, quantam gratiam consecuti. Atque illo die, patres conscripti, ea con ut robJi

quam serae esse iBOmomn

consilio

A. Hirtius and C. Pansa, the consuls for 43 B.C. Quintus Fufius Calenus, consul 47 B.C., a partisan of Julius Caesar. He afterwards joined Anton ius.
1

256

in-

ii

in PHILIPPIC OP M.
M.

TULUUS

CICERO AGAINST
I.
i

ANTON1US

N Conscript Fathers, has ever seemed than these Kalends of lie longer in coining fiat during these last un<l. Janu days it has also seemed so to each one of you. For those who wage war against the State did not wait lut we, at a time when it espet behoved us to come to the rescue of the common safct;. <>unsel, were not summon <1 t tinHut any complaints as to the past have Senate. been removed by the speeches of the tlu\ h.i\.j., kn in such terms tl.it tin- K >1< rids L so much to come late as in fulfilment is the speeches of th< have urhl b >pe, not merely >ut also of restoring our
i

member who
poo
I

not

tr
lias

enable you degree of courage, of firmness, of importance, resides in the

i

would have disturbed me were :r courage and firmness. ript dawned upon yo iity has been given you, to to the Roman people what
ooi orbV
r.

Recall

t<

mind what a day that was thirteen days ago, Imw great was your unanimity, your courage, your firmness,

how much praise you won from the Rotnmn And on people, how much glory and gratitude. th.it day, Conscript Fathers, your resolutions were
257

MARCUS TULLIUS CU BRO

iam nihil sit integrum nisi aut honest* pax aut bellum neccssarium. Pacem vult M. Antonio*? anna do ponot, inc. Neminem aequiorem repcr deprecetur.
i

Miinirus quain dum se Oiviboi ImpMfl COmi amicus esse maluit. Nihil est pvofecto, quod possit erit fortasse aliquid, quod dari bellum gerenti concedi possit roganti ; legatos vero ad eum mitl de quo gravissimum et severissimum indicium undid tertius decimus feceritis, non iam lcvitatis est, sed, ut, quod sentio, dicam, dementiae. mtra ilium II. IViinum duces eos laudavi.st bellum privato consilio suscepissent, deinde mil veteranos, qui cum ab Antonio In ooloalM I
cui,
;

deducti,

illius

beneficio libertatem

populi

ftOMBfl

4 anteposuerunt.

cur laudatur?
laudantur.

Quid? legio Martia, quid? quart* Si enim consulem suum n liqu. runt,
rti

vituperandae sunt, si iniiniruin Atqui, cum consules

publicac, iurr

nondum

habei

decrevistis, ut et

de praemiis railitum et de hpnoribus imperatorum primo quoque tempore referretur Placet eodem tempore praemia constituere eis, qui contra Antonium arma ceperint, et legatos ad Antonium mittere? ut iam pudendum sit hone decreta esse legionum quam senatus, siquidem legiones decreverunt senatum defendere contra Antonium, senatus decernit legatos ad Antonium.
1 Dola Delia had gone to Asia Minor on his way to and Ant. to Cisalpine Gaul, and the consuls for 43 B.C. had not yet assumed their office.

*5"

PHILIPPIC

V.

i.

2-11.

but such that you now have no course opei -ran honourable peace or a necessary war. Does Marcus Antonius desire peace? Let him lay (i arms; let him ask roc lei him al to our mercy. He will find no man fairer than I. he preferred, while commending is, to be my enemy rather himself to di ling at all can be granted to a hatant; possibly there will be something to be iter; but to send envoys to a <n days ago you passed the man heaviest and severest judgment is not now a sign must give my real opinion one I of 1.

II.

First of all

had
agait

nes,

you praised those commanders who ate judgment undertaken war m the next place the veteran soldiers, h they had been planted by An to: set the liberty ot the Itonian people What of the Martian legion fits.
.'

praised If it hey deserted they are to be blamed ; was tlu i! the State, they are rightly praised. And yet, although you had as yet no consuls, 1 you decreed that a motion should be submitted at
is

Why

it

moment for rewarding tin soldiers and Is it your pleasure at og their generals. the same time to appoint rewards for those that have taken up arms against Antonius, and also to envoys to Antonius ? so that now one must feel heme that the resolutions of the legions are more honourable than the Senate's, since the legions have resolved to defend the Senate again-t Antonlm m<l the Senate resolves to send envoys to Anton
earliest
!

259

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Utrum hoc
6 tare
ut,

aminos an di-lnli duodecim profeccrunt quern nemo praeter Cotylam iincntus sit jm
est confirmarc militum
?

virtutem

Hoc

dies

defenderet,

is

habeat inn p itronos etiaui consult

Qui utinain mnnes ante

me

sentet

_.

irrntur
co:

(quamquam
qui post

BUSpioOTj cjunl (iicturi sint

quidam

me

rogabuntur) facilius conti

(juid videretur.

Est enim opinio decreturum aliquem Aptoolo illam ultimam Galliam, quam Plancus obtinet. Quid est aliud omnia ad bellum civile hosti anna lar

primum nervos
dico?

belli,

|>ccuniam infmitnm,

eget, deinde equitatum,

dubitabit,

quantum
gentis
\

velit?

credo,
qui

barbarms

sc

idct, excors, qui. cum HOC videt, decernit, impius est. Tu civem s< !< -ratum et perditum Gallurum et (Jcnnanoruin pecunit,

adducere.

Hoc

|>editatu,

equitatu,

istrues?

Nullae

istac

excusationcs sunt: "

prius.

Meus amicus est"

Sit pa'

"Meus

cognatus."

An
in

propior ulla

esse

quam
id

patriae,

qua
tril>u

etiam
agatur,

contiiientur?

u Milii

pccuniain

it

Cupio videre, qui

audeat dicere.
erit

Quid

cum

aperuero, facile

statuerc,

quam

sententiam dicatis aut

III.

quam sequamini

Agitur, utrum M. Antonio facuitai d tur oprei

primendae

publicae, caedis faciendae bonorum,

1 Lucius Varius, a friend and emissary of Ai. Cotyla appears to be a nickname taken from kotCk-tj pint). He was an envoy of A. {Phil. viii. 8).

(half-

260

PHILIPPIC
Is this

V.

..

a bracing <>t the soldiers' spirits or a weak 1 Has this been the result of ieir courage. that the man for whom no defender twel was discovered hut Cotyla l has now as patrons e\cn I wish all of them were asked t: eonsulars? r me. though I suspect what some of u called upon after me will say I should more easily say in opposition whatever seemed appropriate. r there is a belief abroad that some one "ill :><*c to decree Antonius that further Gaul wl. What is this hut to lavish on Plancus holds. enemy all the weapons for civil war? first of all, the smews of war, infinite treasure, which he now needs; in the next place, cavalry, as many as Cavalry, do I say? He will shrink. wishes. og with him whole barbarous He that does not see this is a fool ; he ns! Will you that sees it, and pn|Kses it, is disloyal. nial and abandoned c,*i/. n \nth the try, the cavalry, all the resources .nils and (irnnans? Your excuses * are no use : let him l>c his country's first; He is my friend relationship be closer )i that fatherland wherein even parents " He has given me money." 1 long are included ? But when to see the man who dares to say that I have revealed what is the issue, it will be easy for to determine what opinion to pronounce or

'

'

hi< -h

to follow.
is ,
i

HI. The issue is whether Marcus Antonius be given an opportunity of ci massacring loyal men, of portioning out the
*

to of

those of yours ") C. addresses Caleoua aad the other partisans of Ant.

By

i**e

26l

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

urbis

dividundae^agrorum

suis latronibus

com!

hi.iimI

populi Romani servitute opprimendi, an horum ci Dubitatc, quid ag;< MM) facere nihil liceat. Hoc nc Cotyla cadunt haec in Antoniuni

Quid enim in cum non ci dicere auderet. Mi leges perv cuius acta se defendere di> Ule paludes quas inaxime laudare poteramus ? siccare voluit, hit- omnero Italiam moderate limnim. Quid ? han L. Antonio, dividendam dedit. populus Komanus accepit. qoid ? per ausp de potuit? Silet augur verecundus sine inauspiciis. Quamquam ilia auspicia n agi terpretatione ; love mini ton ante eun
i
i

non esse fas quis ignorat? Tribuni p de provinciis contra acta C. Caesar i. Ule bieni hi 2 sexennium. Etiain hanc legem populus Komanus ante lata accepit? quid? promulgate fuit. qu quam scripta est, quid? non ante factum ridi quam futurum quisquam est suspicatus ? Ubi lex Caecilia et Didia, ubi pron rintun miiulmum, ubi poena recenti lege Iunia et Licinia? Po hae leges esse ratae sine tnteritn legom reJi Eccui potestas in forum insJnuandi fbH? Quae porro ilia tonitrua, quae tempestas! ut, si aus| M. Antonium non moverent, tamen eum
1 The Vat. MS. reads (under a later hand) urbis erutndorwn ; other MS. bonorum eripiendorum, urbis, agrorum. The text is Halm's. So Zumpt hie (Halm).
;

1 A thunderstorm during an election was a be<> rendered the proceedings illegal. * The Lex Caecilis Didia (98 B.C.) and the Lex Junia (62b.c.) provided for the publication of all proposed lav
!

three market days.

262

PHILIPPIC
of

V.

in.

6-8

to his brigands, and of the Roman people with slavery. of whether be allowed to do none of these things, Hut these things, you will say, hesitate what to do. do not not even Cotyla would dare to say. For what does not apply to the man who he says he is defending the acts of Caesar, overturns those of his laws which we were able especially to commend ? Caesar wished to drain the marshes ; this roan has given that moderate person, Lucius Antonio*, the whole of Italy for dw \uian people accepted sion. Who! bi law? What ; could it be proposed In the face of the auspices? Our augur is too bashful to interauspices his colleagues. for who does those auspices need BO know that, when Jupiter is th 00 transaction with the people can legally be carried <ut >u ncs made a pro|>osal to the commons t of the ! contrary to the acts of Caius Caesar ; Caesar fixed a two years' tenure, Did the Roman people accept this law too? Again, was notice given of it? Again, was did it not proposed before it was drafted: \_ ah we not see tl done be cted ould be o the Caei law? where the notice on three market days? where lie penalty according to the recent .lunian and law ? * Can these laws of yours b< without the destruction of all other laws? Was any man able to steal into the forum ' And what a thunderstorm there was besides! what a temp so that, if the an InOffcC* Antuuius, it seemed wonderful he could put up with and
3
i

making presents of land

'

263

MARCUS TULLIUS ClCEHO

ferre po6se UnUm vim tempestatis imbris ac turbinum minim videretur. Quam legem igitur se augur dicit tiiltwf non modo tonante 1 caelesti clamore prohibente, hanc <lui I? quod on 9 auspicia latam ooofiteri )

ac

collega
vitioMim.

tulit,

quern

ipse

fecit

sun

mintiat

iiiliiliic
-

ad impicfai bonus augur pertinere

fortasse
;

arbitratus est

IV. Sed atiNpicioruin nos

pretes, qui

erimus
CTgO

inter
<

sumus
ita

eius collcgae

nun

armorum
fori

interpretes
saepti,

quaerimus?
ut,
el

Priunai

on
obstaret

aditus

armatus, tamen n
nullo
ut,
;

isrevolsi
<i

rmn
urlxi

modo posset sic vero erant quo modo hostium adituplebi

n!il>riitur

tellis

et oj>eribus, ita ab ingress

propulsarl

10

tribunosque

videres.

popalom Quibus de
itur,

causis eas leges, qn.i

tonius

omnes censeo per vim legibus populum non

et contra auspicia latas iisque

teneri.
Si

quam legem de
in p-

actis Caesaris confirmandis

deve dictatura
in

tuum
tulisse

tollenda deve

coloniis

agros dedu<

M. Antonius dicitur, easdein leges de integro, populum teneant, salvis ausjn Quamvis enim res bonas vitiose per vimquc tulcrit, tamen eae leges non sunt habendae, oinn
ut

audacia gladiatoris amentis auctoritate nostra repudianda est.

1

Dolabella:

cf. Phil. ii. 33.

264

PHILIPPIC

v.

s-iv. io

endure such violence of storm, rain, and tornado. When, therefore, the augur says he proposed this law,
not only while Jujut almost ij, but the face of the uproar of Heavenly prohibition, ill will he hesitate to confess it was proposed in e of the Again, did our good augur l? res that he think it was m concern of propdied tin- la* jointly with a colleague * whose appointment he himself bad rendered defective by

rej>ort

of the auspices we shall possibly be interpreters, who are his colleagues. Are we on that account Firstly, also to search for interpreters of bis arms ? all the approaches of tin Jtram were so barred up
IV.
liu t

th it, even it no man-at-arms stopped the way, t! was no getting anyhow into the forum except by pulling down the barriers in fact the guards were city is so placed that as an enemy's en? rve prevented by forts and works so you m the people and the tribunes of the commons thrust back from entering the forum. Tor these reasons I am of opinion that those laws which Antonius is said to have carried were all eatlitd by violence and t<> the auspices, and that by those laws the Marcus Antonius is said to
;

my
>.

law for the confirmation of Caesar's

acts, or for the perpetual abolition of the dictatoe-

or for founding colonies on lands, the Senate 'used that those same laws should be carried afresh subject to the auspices, so as to bind the people, for, although he carried irregularly and by nce good laws, yet they should not be regarded as laws, and all the audacity of a frenzied gladiator must be repudiated by our authority.

265

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

11
Ilia

vero di^qiatio pecuniae publicae fercuda nullo

est, per quam testertium septieos milkftl falsis perscriptionibus donationibusque av tit, ut purtniti

modo

simile videatur tantam

pecuniam populi Romaal tain illi nn manes brevi tempore perire potuissc quaestus ferendine, quos M. Antoni tot* 1 exhausit tates, doiiius? Decreta falsa vendebat, reg
iinmunitates in aes aootpta pecunia iubelmt

i<h

Haec

se ex commentariis C. Caesaris,

quorum
Kb
;

Pe

auctor erat, agere dice bat

Calebaol

aedium parte
sibi felicior

totius rei publicae

viris aucti

nundinae

mulier
quasi
re-

quam
;

gnorumque

faciebat;

restituebantur

exules

quae nisi auctoriUte senatus scinduntur, quoniam ingress! in spem rei pnbl recuperandae sumus, imago nulla liberae
lege sine lege
relinquetur.
12

Neque solum commentariis commentioii^ graphisque venalibus innnmerabiUi pe

in illam

qhfcOr
ijesta

domum

est,

cum, quae vendebat Antoi

ea se ex actis Caesaris agere diceret, sed seii etiam consulta pecunia aeccpta falsa referch.it syngraphae obsignabantur, senatus consulta tram-

quam

facta ad aerarium deferebantur.

Htiius tur-

pitudinis

etiam exterae nationes. Foedera interea facta, regna data, populi provinciaeque liberatae, ipsarumque rerum falsae tabulae
testes

erant

v.

sola

cf .

una below.
P. Clod i us

Each

of her

two previous husbands,

violent end.

and

C. Curio,

came to a

266

PHILIPPIC
Bir

v.

iv.

n-!2
iiynometni

he embezzled seven hundred to be bon million sesterces by means of false entries and by donations, so that it seems like a miracle that so ti treasure of the Roman people could 'in so Again, are those short a time have disappeared. up with which the whole

swallowed
sold forged decrees,

He

led that and for a bribe grants of kingdoms, states, and immunities from These things taxation should be inscril>ed on brass. he asserted he was doing according to the D ;s Caesar, of which he was himself the book rest re was a lively traffic in auth'
<

of

taner pert of the house; 1 inert- lut ky for herself than for her husbands, ip to auction provinces nd kingdoms; was of law but withrestored exiles wei law; and if these things are not rescinded by
t!

the

the
i

now we have entered

the State, no the hope of re-es g lance of a free community will be left to us. And not by falsified notebooks alone, and by the lias a countless sum of money sale nee Antoi been accumulated in thai ales he was acting according assei to Caesar's " acts " hut he even recorded for a bribe ed decrees of the Senate; contracts were being sealed ; decrees of the Senate never made were entered at the Tree ury. Of this villainy even Trestles were in the ere wftneee. meantime made k Ingd one were bestowed ; peoples tribute ; and of these very and provinces frt things false memorials were posted all over the
;

267

MAIUl'S

III. I. II >
toto
(

(UKRO
a|

gemente populo Romano

est, ut, si

''tin.

Quibus rebus tanta pri-unii una non

sit

in

don

rvata

hoc geiiu^ pecuniae in terariuni redflfri petunia rei poblicM drt'utura. V. Legem etiam indiciariam tulit homo In quo atque integer iudiriorum el lurl mdas nosfeieUft Antesignanoset mnnipulai
<

indices se consti'
legit exules,
legit Graecos.

at ille legit aleatfl

consesMim iudicum dignitatem <nsilii admirandam 13 Avet animus apud consilium lllud pro r< Cydain ( retcnst in, jx.rt.-nt um insulac, lioiniiirni audacissimum ct perditisftimum. Scd fac non -,-,; nmn Latino bcH? num est ex iudicum genere et nostra! forma? mini, quod \tgfit inoresve novit, nuin denJque homines? -st Creta vobis notior quam Roma Cydae J dil antem el notatio iudicum etiam in n riboa
praeclarunnj

'

<

habcri solet; Gortyuium ven nidi' quis nosse potuit? Nam J plerique novimus ; est cnnn I'hardri,
nobilis,
filius,

H ant

14

philotophi praeterea festivus, ut ci emn Curio consessore eodemque conlusore facillumc possit convenire. Quaero igitur Si ludei non respondent excuseturque Areopagites ease debere eodem tempore Romae el At

homo

Hoc genus pent in unum redigatur (Vat. MS.) MSS. omit pent. Conington suggest* hoc gen. omru in
1

red. (in

unum

to one

denomination of coin).

i.e.

As

lias

raised by the methods above described. to these, cf. n. 1, p. 38. C. goes on to show that A. not only appointed jurymen who afford no guarantee

268

PHIUPNN
itol

[i

v.

14

these

amid the groans of tl |>le. means such an amount of money was Ilea
_:le

H\

up

i;

house

tli.it.

brought

into the

if this sort 1 of nu Treasury, the State would

never lack money. V. He also proposed a judicature law, this and upright fellow and supporter of the courtiw It this he deceived us. He said be had ap|M>iuted as jury rgeunt, and ites, and soldiers Larks * but he has appointed gamblers, appointed exiles, apjwunted kv What ai bench of jurymei a wonderfully dignified court My he ul for a defendant in tli.it eeori re is island's prodigy, a most las from Crete, the audacious and abandoned fellow. Hut assume litis not so does he know he of the type and fashion of our jurymen ? what is m< does he know our laws or eool D ibort, does tor Crete is better known to he ne to Cydas; and even among our own /ens some selection and enquiry as USUallv in ad ; but * lio knows, or could know, a j twia? Now Lysiades of Athens most s know; for he is the son of Phaedrus, a no philosopher; he is besides a cheerful man, so that he can very easily coi h Curius, his assessor
;

Y.

and fellow-gambler. I ask then, if Lysiades, when uioned as juryman, does not answer to bJl name, and e\ nnself as being a member of the Areopagus, and not bound to acta n at the same time at Rome and at Athens, will the
j

of integrity, but also actual reprobates proceed! to criticise them individually.

and

foreigner*.

He
269

MARCUS IT LI. US CICERO

I

iudicare, accipietne excusation

praeerit, Graeculi iudicis

|ui

qu*tt

modo

pal!

an Atheniensium aotiquissimas leges negleget?

porro
ille

Qui

consessus, di boni

'rrtmsis index, isque

nequissimus.

Quem ad modum
Dura natio
fortunae

id banc reus alleget,

est.

quo modo accedat ?

misericordes.

At Athenb
cr
facit
;

Puto ne Curium quidem esse

cotidie

lem, qui

periculura

Sunt

item

lecti indices, qui fortasse

excusabantuT
exilii

habent

enim legitimam excusationem

16 vertisse

causa
ille d<

nee esse

j>ostea restitutes.

Hoe

iudices legisset,
lisset, his

horum nomina ad aerarium

rei

d
si

magnam partem
rei

publicae credidisset,

ullam speciem
VI.

publicae cogitavisset ?
notis
;

Atque ego de
nostis, nolui

lodicfbufl

<li\i

(jtios

minus

nominare

saltatores, citharistas,
in

totum denique comissationis Antoniani. chorum

tertiam decuriam iudicum scitote
esse

conieehnn.

Em
bus,

causara, cur lex tarn egregia

tamque praeclara
ferrctur,

maximo
iudices
velit.

imbri, tempestate, ventis, proeellis, turbini-

inter

fulmina

et

tonitrua

ut

eos

haberemus,

quos

hospites

habere

nemo
male-

Scelerum

magnitudo,

conscientia

ficiorum, direptio eius pecuniae, cuius ratio in

aede

Opis confecta
nee
ante

est,

hanc tertiam decuriam excogitavit

iudices
quaesiti,

turpes

quam hon

270

PHIUITh

,-%..

,5

dent of the Court accept the excuse of a Greekltng juryman, wearing now a Greek blanket and now a toga? or will lie disregard the most laws Moreover, what a bench Good ? Heavens! a Cretan juryman, and he the worst of Cretans! How is a defendant to choose counsel to It address this man? how is he to approach him? is a hard nation. Oh, but the Athenians are in* n it ul ink that not even Curius, who every day risks

'

>rtune,

is

cruel.
will

There are also jur

>sen

be excused; for they have the lawful excuse that they changed their domi because of exile, and have not since been recalled. Are these the jurymen that madman would have chosen, and entered their names at the Treasury the men to whom he would have entrusted a great portion of the State if he had thought that any semblance of the State remained ? VI. And I have spoken of jurymen that are known; I was unwilling to mention those you know leas; dancers, harp-players, in a word the whole gang of the Antonian revel, you must know, have the third panel of jorya been a the reason why a law so excellent and so splendid was proposed in the midst of a dot pour of rain, in a tempest of wind, storm, and tornadoes, amid lightning and thunder: it was that we should have men as jurymen whom no one would willingly have as guests. It was the greatness of s consciousness of ill deeds, the plunder of that money the account of which wi the Temple of Ops, that has invented this third jwmel base jurymen were not sought f<r till the exculpation of the guilty at the hands of honest jurymen was
iiaps
;

271

MABCUS TULLIUS CICERO

16 iudicibus
os,

nocentium salus desperata est

fuissej

Sed

ilhxi

illam impuritatem caeni

ut

hos iod

legere

auderet!
rei

quorum
esscnt,

lectione

meretur
turpes

publicae

dedecus,
alteriun,

iudices

duplet impn unom, quod tan quod petenettun

in
civitat

cognitumque
haberenius.
I

esset,

quam multoi

lane ergo et reliquas

-s, etiatn

abrogandas;
17

tamen nunc rero cur abrogandas cense. mi. quas iudico non rogatas? An ilia non gi ignomin mentiaqne
vi

salvis auspiciis essent

rogatae, cense rem

huius ordinis ad posteritatis

memoriam sunt notanda.

quod unus M Autooioi in hac urbe poat fiWHJitam urbem palam seeum Iiabuerit annates ? quod ncque reges nostri fecerunt neque ii, qui regibus ex

regnum occupare

volueruut.
;

'inn ran

m mini,

tidi

Sullam, inodo Caesarem

hi

enim

tres pott Civil

a L. Bruto liberatam plus potaerunt quam uui versa res publica. Non possum adfinnare nullis tclis eos
18 stipatos fuisse,

hoc dico nee multis et occultis. At banc pestem agmen armatorum sequel .at ur; Cassius,
:

Mustela, Tiro gladios ostentantes sui similes gn

ducebant per forum; certum agminis loeutt tenebant barbari sagittarii. Cum autem erat ventum ad

aedem Concordiae, gradus conplebantur,

conlocabantur, non quo
ille

lecticae

scuta occulta esse vellet,

sed ne familiares,
1

si

scuta ipsi ferrent, laborarent.

Who expelled

King Tarquin and founded the Republic.

272

PHILIPPIC

v.

vi.

15-18

But to think or the impudence, the despaired of. foul scandal of his daring to choose theee men as jtirn d by whose selection a double disgrace was branded on the State; one, that such bate men were jurymen the other, that it was revealed became known bow many base scoundrels we had in
;

nunitv.

stamp

and the remaining laws of that they had been passed without \ lolence to the an -hould vote should 1 lid I vote it, U the cisc stands, W for the repeal of laws which decide were not passed
law, thni.
11
it'
I

m
I

at all

As a memorial too for posterity, must \t e not stamp v this order with a record of the de< can Inflict the fact thai hit tin- founding of the eftj had oprnh in t! him an armed guard ; a thing neither our ever did, nor those that after the expulsion of the
i
1

I remember gi fought to seize kin er? have seen Sulla, and but lately Caesar; China; for these three possessed more power since the was made free by Brotot 1 than tin- whole State. cannot affirm they were rounded by no weapons this I assert those weapons t many, and were concealed. But an array d this pest ; Cas tela, Tiro, displaying their swords, led through the forum gangs like themselves; barbarian art; marched in regular column. And when they reached the the Temple of Concord the steps were In d the shields litters were set down not that he should be hidden; but that Ml (Honda should not be fatigued by carrying them themselves.
I

273

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

VII. Illud vero

Ueterrimom Don modo

In

as|
I

sed

etiam

auditu.

cella

Concordiae

armatos, latrones, sicarios, de tcmj

opertis valvis Concordiae,

ran
.

fcwij

versarentur latrones, pati

19 dicere.

Hoc

nisi

vcnircm Kalendis Septembnbus.

etiam fabros se missurum et

domum mean

disti
|

turum esse dixit

venit.

Magna

res, credo,

agebatur

1.

supplicatione referebat

Veni

jmstridie, ipse

Ml

lihere, qtuun

Locutus sum de re pub1i< mea consuetudo, liberius tamen, qi mens postulabant At ille h; ininae periculi et violentus, qui banc corisuetudinnu Ubere di<
excluderet (fecerat enini
laude
1

hoc

hi
nalhi

iginta diebus ante

in

denuntiavit, adesse

senatum

iussit

a.

1.

Mil

Ipse interea Beptemdi Kalendas Octobres. de me in Tiburtino Scipionis decl.v quaerens haec enim ei causa esse dcclamandi solet. 20 Cum is dies, quo me adesse iusserat, venisset, turn vero agmine quadrato in aedem Concordiae atque in me apsentem orationem ex ore impurissimo
; I

evomuit.

Quo

die

si

per amicos

inihi

rupirnti in

senatum venire licuisset, caedis initium fecisset a me semel gladium (sic enim statuerat), cum autem
scelere imbuisset, nulla res ei finem caedf
ridi

defatigatio

et

satietas

attulisset.

Etenim aderat
qui

Lucius
1

frater,
first

gladiator

Asiaticus,

myrmillo
of Sept.

The

Philippic, delivered on the

2nd

274

PHILIPPIC
VII.
nlv to see,
,

V.

vii.

i8-2o

thing of all, not that armed n assassins, were stationed in the shrine of ame a prison the the t< ! doors of Concord were closed Conscript Fathers gave

And the most infamous

but even to hear

of, is

tin

1:

mds were moving about amid

I

the benches. And if did not come here on the Kalends of September, he even said he would tend work An imid would break mv house up. portant debate was towar pose; he moved the day after: for a public than he himself did not I spoke 1 on thecondif doubt leal fnrly than m\ wont, Of the Statr. but more freely th-m In threats of danger warranted. Hut c and violence meant to -ludeour present habit of free speech a freed bad used with the utmost credit th days before- threatened me with ind Senate on the nineteenth \lt> r in the meantime for seventeen da a good deal against me

i'f

villa at

Tiber

K
in

provoke a

thirst

for

this

is
i

his usual reason for declamation.

it

When

the

me to attend had battle-array into the of Concord, and in my absetn d a '\\r Speech I from that foulest of mouths. On that day. it my tr;< nds had allowed me to come to the Senate, as I wished, he would have begun
day
he had ordered
arrived,

massacre with me for so he had resolved. And, he had once fleshed his sword in crime, not would have made an end ing hot weariness and sal r his brother Lodui was that Asiatic gladiator, who had fought at
;

if

I.

75

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Myiasis depugnarat; sanguinem

nostrum

sitiebat,

suum

in ilia gladiatoria

pugua multum profuderat.

Hie pecuniasvestrasaestimabat, possession <s imtabat

Indus mendidtM a\ idiUte coniuneta in fortunas nostras immii hat dividebat nulla* aditus crat agrotj quilms et quos volcbat tintuni q privato, nulla aequitatis deprerati"
et urbanas et rusticas;
;

que habebat possessor! quantum

21

reli(|iieni

Autonius.
rata esse

Quae quamquam,

si

leges irrita
nullos septemviros

non possunt, tainen separatim suo mummiudii nndumqur

notanda censeo
diceretur.

fuisse, nihil placere

ratum

esse,

quod ab

iis

actum

VIII. M. vero
iudicare potius

Antonium quis

est qui civem possit

quam taeterrimum

et crudelissimum

hostem, qui pro aede Castoris sedens audiente populo Romano dixerit nisi victorem \i< tuium m -mi

nem?
in

Num

putatis, jmtres conscript!, dixisse urn

ininacius

quam facturum

folate?

Quid vero? quod

contionc dicere ausus est sc, cum magistratu abisset, ad urbem futurum cum exercitu. lutroMtinm

quotienscumque vellrt, quid erat aliud nisi denim tiare populo Romano ter vltutem? Quod totem 22 eius iter Brundisium, quae festinatio, quae spe ad urbem 1 vel in urbem potius exercitum maximum
1 So the Vat. MS. construction after apes. 1

Some MSS. have

nisi iU,

an unusual

like a Gaul, with a helmet having a usually fought with a Thracian (eo called), or with the net caster (retiaritu). See PA a As to this, see n. 1, p. 328 and Phil. xi. 6. 11

gladiator

armed

fish

for a crest.

He

276

PHILIPPIC
MyUsa
;

V.

VI..

20-V.M. 22

as a mvrmillo; 1 he was thirsting for our modi of his own he had pour d forth in that d gladiatorial man was estim r
i

te

was making a note of possessions,

;

tunes; he was di\iding uptaodSytowhomand where lie pleased there were no means of access to him for a private citizen plea for equity was possible so much only each owner possessed as Antonius had left him In the Although these things cannot stai *j make laws, yet I think they should l><- Individually hat we should d< and spec that the septemvirate* is null and that it is your |>l< a mi re that nothing should stand that was leen done by those mm. said VIII Hut as to Marcus Antonius, who can consider him i it i/. -ii, rather than a most savage and cruel enemy, when he,* n front ofthe Temple of Castor, in the hear man people, said that, except of the victors, no man should be left air Da you think, Conscript Fathers, that his words were more threa* d have been his deed what of the fact that he dared to say at a public meeting that, ulan lie had laid down In, office, he would be present close to the city with an s What y, and would enter it asoften as he pleased ? did this mean bat threat to the Koman people And what meant his journey to Hrundiof slavery ? sium, that haste of his ? what was be did not bring to, or rather into, the city a huge army?
; ;
1 I
.

urban and rural greed, was threat

l>oth

this

man's

be;:

\sitli

* It wan illegal for a commander at the head of an army, unless he surrendered his imprrium, or military Jafieil to enter Rome, except on the day of his triumph.

77

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

adduceret? Qui autem dilectus renturionum, quae Cum eius prom effrenatio impotentis animi legiones fortissimae reclamasscnt, domum ad se
!

venire iussit centuriones, quos b<

publica cognoverat, eosque ante |>edes suos ux

que suae, quam secum gravis imperator ad e\<-n itmn Quo animo hunc futurum fuisse censetis in nos, quos odrrat, com in eos,
duxerat, iugulari coegit.

quos

numquam

viderat, tarn crudelis fuisset, et

quam

avidum in pecuniis locupletium, qui pauperum sanguinem concupisset ? quorum ipsorum bona, quanta-

cumque
23

erant, statim suis comitibus compotoribusque

discripsit

Atque

ille

furens infesta

iam patriae

si^

Brundisio inferebat,
tudinc,

cum

Caesar deorutn immori

talium beneficio, divina animi, ingemi,

quamquam

sua sponte eximiaque

mi

tamen adprobatione
adiit,

auctoritatis ineae colonial pa

<lu l>us
r<

veteranos militesconvocavit, paucis

fecit, incitatos

exer-

citum

latronum impetus

Postea vero

quam

legio Martia

ducem

praestantissililxri

mum
IX.

vidit, nihil egit aliud, nisi ut

;

aliquando

essemus

quam est imitata quarta legio. Quo ille nuntio audito cum senatum
consularem,
sacrifices

vocasset
C.

adhibuissetque

qui

sua

sententia

24 Caesarem hostem iudicaret, repente concidit.

autem neque
votis
1

sollemnibus
est,

factis

nunoupatis

non profectus
*

sed profugit
200.

Octavianus Caesar.

Cf. n.

1, p.

278

PHILIPPIC
:

V.

VIII.

22-IX. 2 4

what a Gathering was that of the centuri> what an unbridled, unconquerable teni|>er! When
id with great bravery repudiated his the promises with shouts, he ordered those centurions to attend at his house wlmm he had recognized were well affected to the State, and canted them to be us feet, and those of his wife whom murdere-: the august general had bfonghl with him to the army. What do you think would have been hitemper towards us whom he hated, when toward those he had never seen he had been so en and what would l>c his greediness for y of en he coveted the blood of the poor; whose goods, sueh as they were, he at once di fellows and Iwon eomp anions? And that in id man was already advancing from Brundisium hostile standards against his country win -n l uu Caesar, by the favour of the immortal Gods, with a heaven-given greatness of spirit, of is own accord no doubt intellect, and of judgm* rare virtue, yet with the warranty and l>\ of my authority, entered the clonics founded In er, called together the veteran soldiers, in a few days founded an army, and stayed the headlong rush of the brigand And after the Martian legion saw tin- most excellent commander, it had no other object than that we should at length be free ; and Mirth followed its example. IX U<-n he had heard the news, although he had summoned the Senate, and put up a oonmUff to declare on that Caius Caesar 1 was a public enemy, he suddenly Mieeunibed. Hut afterwards, wit' making the accustomed sacrifices, with no solemn vows, 2 he did not set out, he fled away in his general's
t

279

MARCUS TULLIUS
l

CI

At quo? In provinciam firmissininrnn. paludatus. et fortissimormn civumi, qui illuin, ne si iU quidem venisset, ut nullum bellum intrrrrt, ferrc potuissent impotentem, iracundunt. cCMiUimfHowiWj MHjHf

bum, semper poscentem, sem|K r rapicntera,

a

seinpi

At ille, cuius ne pacatam quidem nequiebrium. tiam quisquam ferre posset, bcllum IntalM provindae
Galliae, circumsedet Mut didissimam (>opuli Huinani colon Br u turn imperatorem, consulem <!
I)

ivem

25

non sibi, sed nobis et rei publicae natum Quid Hannibal hostis, civis A hosti liter, quod hie non aut fecerit aut faciat aut
pud moliatur et cogitet? Totum iter Ant. habuit nisi dcpopulationes, vastationes, caedes, rapinas? quas non faciebat Hannibal, quia multa reservabat, at In. qui in horara ad usuiii rfverent, non modo de fortunis et da booai dfiofla, sed ne de utilitate quidem sua cogitavemnt. Ad liunc, di boni legatos nntti placet? Nnrunt

nun

homines formam rei publicae, iura belli, exempla maiorum, cogitant, quid populi RomaoJ maiestas, quid senatus severitas postulet? Legatos decern Si, ut deprecere, contemnet, si, ut imjares, non audiet denique, quamvis severa mandata dederimus, nomen ipsum legstoran liunc, <pini videmus, populi Komani restinguet ardorefla, iminiisti
i

cipiorum atque Italiae franget animos.

1 These two words are added by a MS. and may be a gloss.
,

Ut omi:
in

later

hand

the Vat.

See n. 3, p. 214. C. here addresses Calenus.

28o

PHII.IrTU
cloak. 1

is,

24 - 25

But whither? Into a province inh.-dutcd by most steadfast and brave citizens, who could not have \en it he had not come with the Btkm of waging war, ungovernable as he was,
I

always grasping, drunk. But he, whose even in |>eace no man could bear, has made war on the province of Gaul ; he is besieging ina, a most steadfast and t\ olony ot Roman people; he is attacking Decimiis Brutus, a e-ral, a consul elect, a citizen born to serve, not Is Hannibal then himself, but us and the State. Wli.it did he do as an enemy, Antonius a citizen ? an enemy that this man has off is The whole | for and designing niuses what did it consist of journey of tl devastation, massacre, rapine? hut depo Hannilml was not guilty of tlirse : he kept n hut these men, who lived only for the his own use hour, ha thought, I do not say to the ines and the goods of citizens, but even to their own advanta. we are pleased Is it to this man, good Heavens e friends of yours 1 know to send envoys ? the constitution of the State, the laws of war, the precedents of our ancestors? do they consider what majesty of the Homan people, the gravity of the Senate calls for? Do you propose an embassy? If if to comlead to him, he will despise you mand linn, he will not listen; in a word, however stern the mandates we give the envoys, the very name of envoys will qucm h this ardour we now perceive in the Roman people, and will break the it of the boroughs and of Italy. To pass over
passional
|

arrogant,

always

always

.'

281

MARCUS TULUUS CICERO

haec, quae
26 tarditatem

magna

sunt, certc ista legatio

bello.
:

moram

al

adferet

Quamvis

Iw.-mt.

quod
itur;

" Leg.t quosdam audio dicturos belluin niliilo minus p.mtur," tamen men ipsum et animus hominum et
morabitur.

legator.:

n<.

X. Minimis momentis, patres conacnpti.

inclinationes

ws&mm
Nemo
esse

publicae,

temporum Rant can In oami COM ivili, turn in bello, et maxime quod

opinione

plerumque et fama gubernatur.

quaeret, quibus

cum mandatis

legatos miserimui
timoris

nomen ipsum

legationis ultro missae

dgnmn
pugnare
27 verbis

videbitur.

Recedat a Mi
decedat
ex
Gallia
;

Brutum,

non

est

rogandus, cogendus est armis.

miserat olim

Kon

ad Hannibalem mittimus, ut
quern

SagontO ret -rdat, ad Valerium PhcoM et Q. Baebium Tampilum (qui, li Hannibal non pareret, Karthaginera ire inssi sunt quo iubemus ire, si non paruerit Antouius ?) ad nostrum civem mittimus, ne imperatorem, ne eoloniani populi Romani oppugnet. Itane vero? hoc per
senatus P.
;

legatos

immortal es

rogandum est? Quid interest, per deos utrum hanc urbem oppugnet an huius urbis propugnaculum, coloniam populi Romani praesidii causa conlocatam ? Belli I'unici secundi, quod
!

contra maiores nostros Hannibal gessit, causa fuit

Sagunti oppugnatio.

Recte ad

eum

legati missi

282

PHILIPPIC
embassy

V.

ix.

a 5 -x. 27

these considerations, which are grave, assuredly that will bring delay and a prolongation of the iimh they say, as I hear certain II war. none the persons will say: " Let the envoys start less the war may be prepared for," \< t the rcfj name of envoys will damp both the spirits of D and the swift conduct of the war. impulses, Conscri il times the scale is turned most eotnplt not oii!\ in all lents of public affairs, but principally in war, and most of all in civil war. which
;
1 I

as a rule is governed by will ask with what mandates

1

ind rumour.

No
:

we
tin

ys

the

that one sent

Let him n treat from Mii' inm cease to attack Brutus, let him rt <>ut of Gaul: be should not be requested by words, he should For we ed by arms. are not sending to Hannibal to command him to r retreat from iagimhim. as the Senate sent to bim m (K1 tunes Pabtim Valerias Flaccus and (Jumtus !>ilus (who were ordered, it Hannibal Bael' did not obey, to proceed to Carthage where shall we order our ambassadors to go If Antonfoi does not ft How-citizen to hid obey ?) we are H him not to attack a general and a colony of the Is that in truth so? is this what Roman people we must ask through envoys? What difference is e,ye immortal Gods! whether he is attacking this
will

seem a token of

fear.

r an outer bastion ot this city, a colony pla: Ik the protection of the Roman people r cause of the second Punic war which Hannibal ir ancestors was the blockade of waged a Saguntum. Rightly were ambassadors sent to him

for

83

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

mittebantur ad Poenum,
hostibus nostris
s<<ii<.

niittr!

mtur

pro Hannibalis

(Juul simile

tandem? Nos ad

civem mittimus, ne imperatorem populi It<m.mi. tie exereitum, ne coloniam circumsedeat, nr oppognet,

ne agros depopult-tur, ne sit hostia? XI. Age, si paruerit, hoc cive uti aut volumus aut 28 possumus? Ante diem XIII Kalendas lanuarias decretis vestris euro concidistis,

con

ad vos Kalendii [anuariis referrentur, quae n videtis, de honoribus et praemiis bene de r

meritorum et merentium
castis

qUl

principcm

iudi-

eum, qui

fuit, C.

Caesarem, qui M. Antooi

impetus nefarios ab
atque

url>e in

Galliam avert it

tum
Ml
t

milites veteranos, qui primi

illas

Caesarem

se<
I

caelestes divinasque leu

quartam, comprobastis, quibus.

cum consulem suum

pcrseque;

non modo
die

reliquissent, sed

bello etJam

rentur, honores et praemia spopondistis

eoden

D.

Bruti,

praestantissimi

cjvia,

edieto adlato

atque proposito factum eius conlaudastis, quodque

ille

bellum

private

consilio

su

id

tos

auctoritate

publica comprobastis

Quid

igitur illo

die aliud egistis, nisi ut hostem iudicaretis Antenl

29

His

vestris decretis aut ille vos

aequo animo

poterit, aut vos ilium sine dolore

sammo

ridefa

Exclusit ilium a re publica, distraxit, segregavit non

1

When
As

the third Philippic was spoken.

iii.

set out in Phil.

15.

284

PHILIPPIC

V.

x.

27-xi. 29

they were sent to a Carthaginian, they were sent in What rice of Hannibal's enemies, our allies. analogy is there, pray? Are we sending to a fellow-citizen to bid bin eeiM from l>< from attacking a general, an army, a colony of tbc Kmnan people, from wasting its territory, from being our
XI me, suppose he obeys: have we the wish <r On the 20th the power to treat him as a citizen ? of December 1 by your decrees you cut him to pieces; you resolved that tins motion you see made ends of January, Mould be made on concerning the rewards to be paid to those that have deserved, and to-day deserve, well of the State, of whom you adjudged him the foremost who was indeed so Caius Caesar, who diverted the nefarious nil. attacks of Marcus Antonius from t. In the next place you commended the veteran soldiers who had been the first to follow Caesar, and especially those Heaven-sent and God in |>n (1 legions, the and the Fourth, to u Ixun. !>ecause they had, 11 r< 1\ deserted their consul, but wereevenattackliim in war. you promised honours and rewards. Ami on the same day, when an edict of that most mis Brutus had been brought and set before you, you praised what he had done and the war he had undertaken on his private judgment you approved with your public authority. What other object then had you on that day but to adjudge Antonius a public enemy After these your decrees 2 will either he be able to look you him in the bet with equanimity, or you to see without the greatest Indignation? He has been shut out, dragged, dissociated from the State, not
1
.

'

85

MARCUS TULLIUS QIGSBO

solum scelus
fortuna
ipsius,

sed etiam, ut

nufii

videtur,

quaedam
si

rei publicae.

Qui

legatis paruerit

Koinamque n-dirnt. mini

dviboi vesttJunij <i uo ooacmn defuturum putatis? Sed hoc mlnai rerMTJ sunt Numquam alia, quae magis timeam et cogitem. Novi bo parebit ille legatis.
uiiKjuain

peiditif

30 est dttiitus.

gantiam, novi pn-dita consilia amuwum, qoibu ille qui Lucius qaidem fratereh SM I peregre depugnarit. fatuili un (hint per hos esse ei fett sanus, quod numquam rnt Terctur intcrea tempus, belli apparatus lion licebit. refrigescent. Unde est adhuc bellum tractum ra? Ut priiiiuin |>ost discessum ex r latronis vel potius desperatam fugam libere senatus baborl potuit, semper flagitavi, ut convocareniur. Quo die primum convocati sumus, cum desit: consules non adessent. ieci sententia mea nii\im> vestro consensu fundament* rei publicae serius omiiino, quam decuit (nee enim ante |>otui); sed tamen, si ex eo tempore dies null us intermissus esset, bellum profecto nullum haberemus. Omne malum 31 nascens facile opprimitur, inveteratum lit plrrumque robustius. Sed turn expectabantur Kalcndae lanui

ariae, fortasse

non

recte.

XII.

moram
;

praeterita omittarnus ; etiamne banc adferemus, 1 dum proficiscantur legati, dum

Verum

adfert bello dilectus ?

1 This word Vat. MS. It

revertantur? quorum expectatio dobil belli autem dubio quod potest studium esse
written by a later hand in the margin of the adopted by Kayser, but, as Halm shows, is

is

is

not wanted.
1

On

the 20th Dec, the date of the third Philippic.

286

PHILIPPIC
only by his

V.

xi.

29-xn. 31

own crime, but also, as it seems to me, by some good fortune of the State. If lie shall obey the ambassadors and return to ;ie, do you think reprobate citizens will ever lack

Hut this I fear lets: a standard they can rally to? there are other things I dread and consider more. He will never obey the envoys. I know the fellow's

and arrogance; 1 know the profligate nds to whom he is devo of .is brother, as being one that fought abroad, heads the gang. Grant that Autonius is himself sane an yet these men will ef will be Tmir m the meantime ill be allow him to be so. wasted the pre [Mirations for war will cool. How has the war so far been protracted but by slowness and delay? From the first moment after the brigand's defection, or rather desperate flight, when a free Senate could be held, I have always demanded we should be called together. On the day we were first assembled, 1 as the consuls elect were Ml present, 1 by my opinion, and with the fullest assent >ns of the State, nltoon your part, laid the than should have been I could not do so before but if from tint time no lav had l>een lost we should now be having no war at all. Every

madness
tisels

'

birth; become inv< But then the Kalends as a rule gathers strength.
is

en

hed at

its

of January were being waited for: perhaps not wisely XII But let us leave out the past. Shall we add ill the envoys set out } till return } l for them will bring doubt regardhe war; and it war be doubtful, what zeal can be in a levy ?
*
'

287

MARCUS TULLIUS CUKHO

Quam
oh rem, patres conscript
OCH
wto

MM
I

onem nullam

.uimistran

arbitror sine ulla

mora

ci

tn

u'erendam

seo; tumult um deoerni, iu titium rdui, saga iumi dico oportt re. ddectum haberi sublatis vill artonHw
32 in urbe et in Italia practt-r (ialli.m. erunt facta, opinio ipsa et faroa nostrae
uie
s si

obruet scelerati gladiatoris an bellum cum re publics esse SOSCCpta m, rxperictur consentientis senatus nervos atque vires; nam nun. quidem partium cnut< ntu mem esse dictitat. Quarum partium ? Alteri victi sunt, alteri sunt e medl Caesaris partihus nisi forte Caesaris partes a I'ansa et Hirtio consulibus et a filio C. Caesaris oppugnari putainus. Hoc vero bellum mm partium, sed ex nefaria spe perditissinmrum shrfam excitatum, quibus bona fortunaeque nostrae notatae nlmtae. sunt et iam ad cuiusque Oj Legi cpistulam Antoni, quam ad quendam septem33 virum, capitalem huminem, collegam suum. m "Quid coucupiscas, tu videris; quod cimrupr. certe haliebis." Em, ad quern legatos mitl bellum morcmur infrrre qui ne sorti quidem fortunas nostras destinavit, sed libidini cuiusque nos ita addixit, ut ne sibi quidem quictjuam Integrum,
;

A tumult was a sudden and dangerous war

ami
1.

Italy,
viii. 1.

in

Roman

Cisalpine Gauls.

in or near history specially meant an irrupt 8ee Cicero's explanation of the term in
i

* C. seems to mean by the first alteri the adherent* of Ant. in the Senate, who were crushed by the decrees of Dec. 20 by the second alltri the partisans of the dictator, whom A. might have expected to support him, but who were attacking him.
:

288

PHILIPPIC

V.

xii.

31-33

When fore, Conscript Fathers, I propose that no mention should be made of envoys ; I think the ided to without any delay, and mattI say propose it should be carried out at OBCC that a state of tumult l should be declared, a vacation of the Courts proclaimed, military garb assumed, a lew held, all exemptions from service he m tlu* whole of Italy <1 m th. suspen il It these measures shall be taken, the of our stern action will rt overwhelm tin- madness of an accursed gladiator. He will feel that he has begun a war against the he will experience the energy and the strength lor now of a Senate with one mind hfl stantlv says there- is but I quarrel between partus sin \N hat parties? One side is conquered, 1 1 unless perhaps the midst of Caius Caesar's party we think that Caesar's party is being attacked l>\ the consuls Hirtius and Pansa and by Caius Caesar's Hut this war has not been stirred up cut of son! the strife of parties, but out ot the nefarious hopes ot mot profligate citizens, for whom our goods and ines have been marked down and already huted according to each man's notions. have read a letter of Antonius. which he had I written to a certain septemvir,1 a jail bird, and If what you covet: colleague: "Sett covet you shall certainly have.' is the man to whom we arc to send envoys, against whom we are to delay war, a man who has not even inittcd our fortunes to a lottery, but has assigned us to every man's lust so thoroughly that he has ntact not left even for himself a
I
; 1

' ;

As

to the

emptemv irate,

aee n.

I, p.

888.

289

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

quod non
alicui

pronrissum iam
;

sit,

rdiqatlit

hoc, patres coaacriptij bello, bellOj Lnquaa,

I

to

lcgatoruin tanhtas tanduni est, idque D repudianda est. multa rNtad) Qiiapropfeer, 34 sint, coiisiilihus totam inn publican commend MM lain pobtJ censeo iisque permittrnduin. at rein defendant provideantque, ne quid res publica d< menti aeeipiat, censeoque, ut lit, qui In eitciU If. ndas Antoni sunt, ne sit ea res traudi, si ant< K Haec s Februarias ab eo discesserint. patres eonscripti, breM tempore lil>Mtatrm populi Roman! anctoritatemqne vestram recupetml

<

lenius agetis, tainen eadein, sed fortasse De re publica quoad rett uli^tis satis deeernetis. decrevisse videor. XIII. Altera res est dchonoribus; de qui bus date 36 ceps intellego esse dicendum. Sed qui ordo in sn tiis rogandk servari solet, eundem tenebo in A. Bruto igitur, consule desigfortibus bonorandis.

autem

nate,

more maiorum capiamus exordium

Cuius ut superiora omittam, quae sunt maxima ilia quidem, sed adhuc hominum magis iudic -iis BJQMI publice laudata, quibusnam verbis eius laudes liuius ipsius temporis consequi possumus? Neque enim ullam raercedem tanta virtus praeter banc la gloriaeque desiderat; qua etiam si careat, tamen sit se ipsa contenta, quamquam in memoria gratormai civium tamquam in luce posita laetetur. LaOJ igitur
1

1 i.e.

For the meaning of this see n. 2, p. 114. by the new consuls, Hirtius and Pansa, who had

consulted the Senate on the general state of public afl.i 8 i.e. when the consul called upon each senator for his opinion. The usual practice was to begin with the consuls elect.

290

PHILIPPIC
without

V.

xii.

33-xm. 35

dread y promised it to some one. man, Conscript Father*, the issue must be decided by war, by war, I gay, and that at once

With

this

ris- with halting envoys. to avoid the necessity of daily d I propose that all the fortunes of tin- State should be entrusted to the cumuli, and that they be Urged to defend the State, and see to it that tin-

Wherefore

;* and I propose that those Antonius DC not prej ndtci <1 leave him before the Kalends of February Ifroa ed e proposals, Conscript Fathers, yoa will in a short time recover the the Roman Hut if VOH act more pic and your own authority mildly, you will nom h< less issue the same decrees, hut perhaps too late. So far as your 2 mot SUte, I think what I have proposed is

State receive no in the array

I

damage
-

Fit.

second question concerns the honours, and is, understand, the next subject for discussion. will (n honouring brare men order usa
I I
i.

Mil The

inions are solicited ;* let us therefore, by immemorial custom begin with lirutus the consul
.: h are indeed his former ser\ but so far approved rathe* by the general judgment than by any public tribute, in w hat terms can we e mmendatioil of s at this time? For there is no reward which such eminent merit lookl for save this one of praise and fame; even if it were to lack that, still would it be >ness of itself, and \et it

it,

I.

would rejoice

to stand

in

the

memory
Such

of m-.itelul

citizens, as in the light of day.

praise, there-

291

MARCUS TULLIUS
iudicii

CI

testimoniique
retn

nostri

tribucnda

Bruto est

36

Quara ob

his verbis, patres conscript!, wmi

consul turn faciendum ccnsco. "Cum D. Brutus imperator

potestate teneat,
brevi tempore

designat

provinciam Galliam in senatus populous

Komam
tam

cumquc exercUum

rsohpTB

summo

studio muni* ipiomiB ooln

re

rumque provinciae Galliae optime de

publica

meritaemerentisqueconscripscnt. eompsiivft, id eutt recte et ordine exque re publica fccisse, idque D.

Bruti praestantissimuin lucritum
in

rem

publi
I

senatui

populoque

Romano gratum
consults

esse et
v\
it i,

Itaque seiiatuin

popalumque

Komanum
design

D.

Bruti

impcratoris,
virtute

9\

consilio.

incredibilique studio

et consensu

provinciae Galliae rei publicae difticillumo tempore

esse subventuui."
37

Huic tanto merito Bruto, patres conscripti, tantoque in rem publican benencio quis est tantus Nam, si M. Antonio pati. qui non debcatur?
fa

Gallia,

si

oppressis municipiis et coloniis imparat

illam ultiniam Galliam penetrare potlrisset, quantus

rei

publicae terror impenderet?

Dubitaret, credo,

homo

amentissimus alque in omnibus eonsfliifl praeceps et devius non solum cum exercitu suo. etiam cum omni immanitate barbariae bcllum inferre nobis, ut eius furorem ne Alpium quidem muro cohiHaec igitur habenda gratia est D. bere possemus. Bruto, qui ilium nonduni interposita auctoritate vestra
292

PHILIPPIC
fore, as

V.

xiii.

35-37

our judgment tad

iould

our testimony to his be awarded to Brutus.

I

Win

r>,

propose a Senatorial

\\ Iwre nnus Brutu>, general, consul el Gaul in allegiance to the ke Senate and liomau people J and whereas he has, in SO short a time, amid tin utmost seal of tlx boroughs
1

is

of tina ptoi that has deserved and deserves well of the State, >o great an army, tint he has levied and go and in the interests done SO rightly and of the State, and such pre-eminent service to the e is, and will be, grateful to the Senate and the Senate and Roman people. Ace Houian people are ot opinion that by the help, |>rud< nee, and valour of Decimus Brutus.
I
i

and

Consul

elect,

and
tin-

unanimity ol
i

DJ the marvellous z il and Province of Gaul, the State has

i

at a most difficult For such a service as this by Brutus, Con I'ati a benefit towards the State, what honour is too great to be due r Fot it iaul had lain rudi.-d Vntoniu D lie had the boroughs and unprepared colonies lie had been able to penetrate into Further Goal, what a p. ild now he liDi He would the S in. -f of mad ] en, headlong and erratic in all In- judgments, to bring war on us, not only with lis army, hut also with all the sa\a_ of barbarism, so that we could not check his f'ren/y I: even by the harrier of "the A gratitude then who. without waiting for is due to Dec Iran your authority, hut by his <>w n decision and judgment,
i

<

293

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

8UO consilio atque iudicio non ut consulem recrpit, fianc sed ut hostem arcuit Gallia sequc obsidurbem inaluit. Habeatcr^. hums tint W h t.imquc praeclari decreto nostro testimonium IMpitei nimi, Galliaque, quae semper praesidet atju- praeaedti eque huic imperio libertatique com muni, m< laudetur, quod sc suasque vires non tradidit, sed opposuit Antonio XIV. Atque etiam M. Lepido pro eius egrvn 38
i I

rem publicam mentis decernendot honores quam amplissimoscenseo. Semper ille populum Romnnum liberum voluit maximumque sign u in lUo dir drdit voluntatis et iudicii sui, cum Antonio diadema Caesari iinponenteseavertit^ nut iKjur etmaest quantum hal>eret odium servitutis, quam populum Itomanum librrum cuprret, quam ilia, quae tulerat, temporum magis necessitate quam iudicio tulisset.
(Quanta vero
(

ivitatis,

is moderatione usus sit in illo tempore quod post mortem Caesaris consecutum est,
i

19

quis nostrum oblivisc potest? Magna haec, s< maiora properat oratio. Quid eniin. <!i nmirtales admirabilius omnibus gentibus, quid op opulo Romano accidere potuit, quam, cum bellam civil* maximum esset, cuius belli exitum omm si timn.
!

sapientia et dementia id potitti extingul q et ferro rem in discrimen adducere ? Quodsi eadeu ratio Caesaris fuisset in illo taetro miseroque bello, ut

1 He had not joined from Rome.

in A.'s illegalities,

but had

witi

R. Pompeius in Spain. Lep. eftVcted a rec and was decreed a puhlic thanksgiving (sup/ See below and Phil, ill. 9., and as to P. cf. Phil. xiii. Intr.

With

tion,

294

PHILIPPIC
>ed to receive that

V.

xiii.

37-xiv. 39
.

man

as a consul

but

k< pt

dim out of Gaul, as being an enemy, and d

rather to be besieged himself than to sec tinv our decree besieged. Let him therefore an everlasting ted :<ed so great and so noble ; and let Gaul, which always protects and has protected this empire, and the liberty of all, be in justice and truth commended for not baring HUN irred, but for having opposed, to A; tself
i

\ Marcus Lepidus too, in return for eminent services to t! pruj>ose the most n. should be decreed. He has always wished tin- Roman people to be free, and he gave the greatest proof of nil im -li nation and opinion on the day when, while Antonius was setting a diadem on Caesar's head, he turned away, and bj groans and sadness showed how great was his hatred

XI

his

-;. BOW he longed that the Human people should be free, and how it was from the necessity ice he had borne of the t im- rather than A what he bod borne. And who of us can forget how great was his moderation in the crisis of the State it followed Caesar's death? 1 These are great merit-, but batten to speak of greater. or whflftj ye immortal Gods! could have happened IB admirable In the eyes of all nations, what mure welcome to the Roman people, than that, when the civil war,* whose issue we all were dreading, was at height, it should be extinguished by wisdom and clem' of bringing matters to an issue by arms and the sword ? But if Caesar's policy had been the same in that savage and mis rable war, then to say nothing of the father the two sons
;

li

295

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

omittam pat rem, duos Cn. Pompei, summi et singularis viri, filios incolumes habcremus, quibus a I'tinam nMlif M. pietas fraudi esse non dclmit. Lepidus servare |K>tuisset facto rora tuisse.i in eo, quod potuit, cum Sex. Pompdam restitatl
!

civitati,

maximum ornamentum

rei

publicac

mum monumentum
patre,

clementiae suae. fortuna popoli Romani, grave fatum.

Gravis
ium D

ilia

rain
hit,
films

quod
omnia

imperii

|x>puli

extineto
40

interfectus
milii

est

patris

Minilliinus

Sed

iudicio expiata Sex.

XV. Quam

videutur deormn immortaliuin publieae conservato. Pompeio ob rauum mstam atque IMgl

quod periculosissimum

civile

bell urn

maximummir

humanitate et sapientia sua M. Lepidus ad pacem concordiamque convertit, senatus consilium Ins verbis censeo pcrscri bend urn "Cum a M. Lepido imperatore, pontificc maximo, saepe numero res publica et bene et feliciter gesta sit, populusque Romanus intellexerit ei dominatum regium maxime displicere, cumque eius opera,
:

consilio singularique dementia et man suetudine bellum acerbissimum civile sit restim -turn, 41 Sextusque Pompeius Cn. f. Magnus huius on in is auctoritate ab armis discesserit et a M. Lepido imperatore, pontifice maximo, summa senatu populique
virtute,
1

Lep. could not tave Pompeius' other son Cna m when in flight after Caesar's victory at Mumla in 4 This "patris ximdlimus filius " Cassias describes toC. as " one who, as you know, regards cruelty as a virtue" : ad Fnm.
slain

xv. 19.

296

MM IPPfC
I'

XIV.

39-XT. 4 !

hat most eminent and remarkable man, Cnaeus

should iiave unharmed among at for it certainly not to have prejuWould that Marcus Lcpidus had diced them that he would have done been able to save all so he showed where he had the power, when he eius to his felloe restored Sex: l, to be the greatest ornament to the State, the most illustrious memorial of his ewi Heavy was that inc, heavy the lot of the Unman peop the father the very Hghf npirr of the Roman people was extinct, and then a son most like Ins father was slain. Hut all things were, as it seems to me, atoned for by the ion of tin- Immortal lods when Sextus Poiii|mmus
in iiis,
|

we

<

was preser

lie

State.

because Marcus

reason, a just and important one, by his humanity and

I

has changed a most dangerous and mi h ty g civil war to peace and eoncordj propose that a Senatorial decree should be registered in these ns:
I

on

Whereas the State has been often well and prosperously administered by Marcus general, and Pontifex Maximus, and the Ii<>m m people has understood that kingly power is especially
'

pliant to him and whereas l>y his help, valour, prudence, and singular clemency and mildness, a most bitter etrll war has been extinguished, and Sextus Pompeius Magnus, the son of Cnaeus, has, iiently to the authority of this order, laid down his arms, and has been restored to his fellow citizens by Marcus Lepidus, general and Pontifex Maxin with the utmost good-will of the Senate and Roman
;

297

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

itum jx.pu * Romani voluntatecivitnti restitutio s lomque Romanum pro maximis plurimisque in rem

publicum M.
virtute,

I.rpidi

mentis

magnam spem
reponere
ot'

in

cius

tjictoritate,

felicitate

concordiae, libertatis, eiusque in

rem

publican) meri-

torum senatum populumque Romanum m.nmrcm fore, eique statuam equestretn inauratam aut quo alio loco in foro vellet, ex huius or
ii

sententia statui placere."

Qui

honos,

patres

conscripti.

mihi

maximum
<

vidctur; primuui quia iustus est; not) enim solum

pr<> datur propter spem temporum reliquomm, amplissimis meritis redditur ; nee vero cuiquani
1

possumus
42

commemorare hunc honorem a sen

it

tributum iudicio senatus soluto et libero.

XVI. Venio ad C. Caesarem, patres conscripti, qnl nostrum esse potuisset ? Advolabat ad urbem a Brundisio homo impntmtissimus an odio, animo hostili in omnes bonos cum exer Antonius. Quid huius audaciae et sceleri |>oterat opponi? Nondum ullos duces habebam mm copias nullum erat consilium publicum, nulla libertas; dandae cervices erant crmb-litati nefariae fugam quaerebamus omnes, quae ipsa exitum non
nisi fuisset, quis
.

43 habebat.
optulit

Quis turn nobis, quis populo hunc divinum adulescentem deus ? omnia ad perniciem nostram pestifero

Romano
qui.
illi

civi

paterent, subito praeter

spem omnium exortus

prius

confecit exercitum, quern furori M. Antoui opponeret,

298

PHILIPPIC
people, be
it

V. xv. 41-xvi. 43
in regard of

the eminent State of Marcus lus. the Smate and the Roman people repose in his valour, influence, and good fortune a great hope of ease, peace, concord, and liberty, and that is services to the State the Senate and K<-m m le will be mindful, and that it is by its decree the pleasure of this order that a gilt equestrian statue to him should be erected on the rostra, or in ai. the forum be may wish This honour, Conscript Fathers, seems to me to at, first because it is just, for it is be \ en for expectations of the future, but is paid tor the most ample services rendered ; and we cannot recall that this honour has been bestowed ne by the Senate by the Senate's free and d j ud gin MI. I come to Caius Caesar, Conscript Fat and it lie had not lived, who of us could have been alive now ? There was Hying to the city fi Brui a man of most ui burning with hatred, with a mind hostile to all loyal 1. a man with an army in short, Ante* it could have been opposed to this man's audacity and iniquity? As yet we had no coin mar forces ; there was no council of State, no liberty our necks were at the mercy of his lawless cruelty we were all looking to flight, and flight itself afforded no escape. Whit God at thai time presented to us, to the Roman people, this Heaven-sent young man, who, when every avenue to our destruction lay (.pen for that pesti en, suddenly, beyond the hope of all, arose and got together an army to oppose to the frenzy of Marcus Antonius before anyone sus-

decreed that,
services

and

numerous

to the

299

MARCUS TULLIUS CICRHO

quam quisquam
Magni
honores
et

hoc
habit i

eum
Co.

cogitare

ausi

Pun

etset

adulescens,
publicae,

quitlem

lure;

tubvenH

sed aetatc

multo robustior et militum

ratior et in a!

ducem quaerentium
belli
;

non

enim

omnibus

Sullae
t>t

causa

grata

declarat multitudo proscriptorum.

44

iminlcipiorum

maximae

calamitates.

Caesar autcm annis

iara requiescere

mult

is

minor veteranos cupientes

populo,
(ju.ic

armavit

earn complexus est causam, quae esset senatui, quae

cunctae

Italiae,

quae dis homtnibv

L.

gratissuma.

Et Pompcius ad
;

Sullae

maximum
;

imperium victoremque exercitum access it Caesar ipse princepa exer se ad neminem adiunxit
faciendi

et praesidii comparand!

t'u

it

lilt-

id

sariorum partibus agrum Piceuuin habuit inim

hie

ex Antoui

amicis,

sed amicioribus

libci

contra Antonlum confecit exercitum.

Sulla
regnavit, huius praesidio
est.

Illius opitras

Antom dmninatus
siu-

oppressus
45

Demus

igitur

Imperium Caesari,

quo
tin
i

res

militaris administrari, tcneri exercitus, bell

.

non potest; sit pro praetore eo iur quo qvi o| Qui honos quamquam est inagnus illi aetati, t;tn.< n ad necessitatem rerum gerendarum. non solum ad
dignitatem valet.
Itaque
ilia

quaeramus, quae vix

huius adule^

hodierno die consequemur.

XVII. Sed saepe spero fore

300

PHILIPPIC

V. xvi. 43-xvii. 45

pected any such intention of his* GfMfl honours were paid to Cnaeus Pomj>eius though he was a Dg man. ami indeed rightly; for In- came to the assistance of the State, but at a much more robust age, and better equipped because of the zeal of .its looking for a commander, and in a war of a rent kind for the cause of Sulla was not the multitude of those proscribed, grateful to all serious calamities of so many boroughs lint Caesar, though many years younger, shou has armed veterans now desirous of rest; he has embraced the cause that would be most grateful to the Senate, to the people, to all Italy, and to Gods and men. Ami Pompeius attached himself to the
;

I.WrlUS

lesar has not joined anyone;

>

he himself

has been tin an army, and to initiate Pompeius held the territory of Picenum defence. whirl) hostile to the adversaries' party; Caesar, .in those who were the friends of Antonius, but were more friendly to lilx-rty, has made an army to oppose A By the help of Pompeius Sulla reiL Caesars protection the tyranny of Antontoi has been crushed. Let us therefore give Caesar the command, without which n<> military affairs can be administer 1, no army held together, no war waged; let him be praetor with the fullest power of a regular That honour is a great one at his age, but it serves to assist the measures necessary l>e taken, not merely to enhance Ins dignity. Therefore let us ask for that, wlmh is as much as we shall rain to-day. XVII. But I do hope that both we and the Roman

wm

3i

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

omandi honorandique et nobis et populo Romano potestatem; hoc autem tempore ita censeo decer-

nundum
46

"Quod C. Caesar C f., pontifex, summo rei publicae tempore milites

libertatem
populi

pro praetore,
veteranos ad
ait

Rumani cohortatos
j

eosque

conscripserit,quodque legio Martia quartaquc

studio optimoque in rem

summo

>u li ram consensu C.Caesare duce et auctore rem publicum, lilxrtatem populi Romani defendant, defcnderint, et quod C. Caesar pro praetore Galliae provinciae cum excrcitu sub

pro feet us

sit,

equites, sagittarios, elephantos in

suam

populique Romani potestatem redegirit

ditrwillu-

publicae tempore saluti dij: rei Romani subvenerit, ob eas eausas sm placere C. Caesarem C. f., pontifieem, pro praetore, cere, senatorem esse sententiamque loco pn
populi

moque

eiusque rationem,
ita

quemeumque

magistr.itum petet,
I

haberi,

ut

haberi

per leges

w tret,

si

superiore quaestor fuisset"

47

Quid

est enim, patres conscript), cur

eum DOB

qu.-un

primum amplissimos honores capere cupUmos? Legibus enim annalibus cum grandiorem aetatem ad consulatum
constituebant, adulescentiae
;

ten

verebantur
excellenti

C.

Caesar ineunte aetate docuit ab

virtute

eximiaque

expectari
1

non

oportere.

Itaque

progressum aetatis maiorea n

Villia
<

The
31.

first

and principal Lex Annalis waa the Lex

of 180

B.a

The age

for the quaeatorship (the lowest

was 302

PHILIPPIC

V. xv.i.

45-47

people shall often be enabled to distinguish and young man. However, at this time I xir t h se that the following should be <mr drcree "Whereas Calm Caesar, the son of Caius, Pontifex, pro- praetor, at a serious crisis of the State has veteran soldiers to defend the lil>erty exho >t the Human people, and has enrolled them; and whereas the Martian legion and the Fourth, with tinutmost seal, and the most admirable unanimity in serving the State, under the command and autli of Caius Caesar, are d( have defended, tc and the lil 3 people; and whereas Caius Caesar, propraetor, has with an army set out far tin- relief of tin province of Gaul, has brought within his own obedience and that of the Roman people cavalry, archers, and elephants, and has, at a most difficult rrisis of the Stat he assistance of the lives and dignity of the K-.in.ii, pt oplc therefore for these reasons it is the pleasure of the Senate that Caius Caesar, the son of Caius, Pontifex, pro-praetor, be a senator, and exi

->

praetorian benches; and whatever be the office he shall serk. the same account be taken of his candidature as would be legally permissive if he had been quaestor the preceding year." For what reason is there, Conscript Fathers, why we should not wish him to attain as soon as possible fullest honours ? For when by the Offices laws men appointed a later age for the consulship they feared the rashness ot youth; Caius Caesar has, in opening manhood, shown that excellent and remarkable merit should not vail the advance of age. Accordingly our ancestors,
press his opt]
.

303

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

veteres
ill i

admodum

antiqui

leges annales
atttilit

habebant, quas multis post ami is

unbitfo, ut
Ita

gradus esset petitionis inter acquales.

saepe

magna

indoles

\irtutis,

priusquam

rci

publicae
a

48 prodesse potuisset, extincta est

At vero
alii,

pud

antiquos Rulli, Decii, Corvini multique

recen'

autem memoria superior Africanus, T

mu
tantas
res

admodum
gesserunt,

adulescentes
ut

consoles

facti

populi

Romani imperilUB
?

auxrrint,
<

nomen
tertio

ornarint.

ineunte aetate res

et

Macedo Alexander inn a!> maximas gerere coepiss tricesimo anno mortem obiit? quae est
Quid

aetas nostris legibus decern aim is

SularU.
aetatis
\\\

nm

con-

quo

iudicari potest virtutis esse tpiain

cursum celeriorem.
ii,

Will. Nam quod

se timere,
possit,

qui Caesari

m\

idrnt, simulant

ne verendum quidem

est, ut

tcnere se
elatus

ut moderari, ne

honoribui

nostris

49 iiiUinjK rantius suis opibus utatur.

est, patres conscripti, ut, qui

Ba natura renun
gloriae

sensum verae

ceperit, quique se

ab senatu, ab equitibai Ron

rei

populoque Romano universo senserit civein canmi

haberi
gloria

salutaremque
coinj>arandum

publicae,

nihil C.

cum hac

putet

Utinam

Gm

patri dico, contigisset adulescenti, ut esset senatu

atque optimo cuique carissimus

sequi neglexisset,

omnem vim

Quod cum on ingenii, quae summa

!

304

PHILIPPIC

V. xvii. 47-xviu. 49

those old ancestors of a long past age, had no res Qualification laws: it was the ri candidates that many years afterwards introduced these laws that the successive candidatures be between men of the same age. And thus a great endowment of virtue was often lost before it could be of service to the State. But among the ancients the Kulli, the Deeii, the (Wvini, and many others, and within more recent memory the elder anus and Titus Flamininus were made when very young, and achieved things to great that tended the empire of the R^nnati people and made its name illustrious. Again, did n<>t Alexander of Macedon, when he had begun the greatest exploits in opening manhood, die m his rtieth year, an age by our laws ten years younger than a consular age? From this it can be concluded that manly spirit advances on a swifter course than that of age. XVIII. For as to the pretended fears of those uho envy Caesar, there is no reason to apprehend that he may be unable to hold Inmselt in eheck or show moderation, that, elated by our honours, he may employ his powers mt< apt -ratelv. It is natural, Conscript Fathers, that one who has grasped t inmeaning of true glory, one who fe regarded by the Senate, by the Roman knights, and by the entire Roman people as a loved citizen and the salvation of the State, should derm nothing comparable with this glory. Would it had been the fortune of Caius Caesar the father I mean when a young man to be very dear to the Senate and every loyal citizen Because he neglected to secure this, he wasted all the power of hi intellect and in him

305

>

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

It consum; it. ad bonos Don hal>. earn sibi viain ipse pate fecit ad opes suas ampliticandas, quan virtus librri populi tcrrc BOO posset crsa ratio est Eius autem filii longis ue caiissimus. In cum omnibus est. turn opi hoc spcs libertatis posita est, ab hoc accepta iruntiu salus, huic siimmi hoi 60 sunt. Cuius igitursinjrulareni prudentiam dmlraaof,

fuit in illo, in jiopulari

levitate

cum respectum ad sen

i

it

um

el

eiusstultiti.ini tinicuuis

'

Quid rnim

stultiu

<|u.mi
<

it m opes, dominandi praccipitem et lubricam anteferre verae, gravi, solidae gloriae? An hoc vidit peer si aetate processerit, non videbit? " At est quibusdam li Nullu cus clarissimis atque optinu rmbus." timor esse debet; omnes Caesar inimi publicae condonavit, hanc sibi iudiccm OOWtitult,

inutilem

|x>tentiam.

invidiosas

hanc moderatricem omnium consili- tiiiii ttqvc rum. Ita enim ad rem publicam accessit, ut earn confirmaret, non ut everteret. Omnes habe< sensus adulescentis. Nihil est ilia re publica can us, nihil vestra auctoritate gravius, nihil DOUUnuM virorum iudicio optatius, nihil vera gloria du! 51 Quam ob rem ab eo non nndo nihil timers, maiora et meliora exspectare debetis neq
' t

qui

adD. Brutum obsidione liheranduni prof< timere ne memoria maneat domestic dok)
i

plus

apud eum

possit

quam

salus

civit.it is

An
i.

etiam obligare fidem meani, patres conscript

1

rotrfl
is

The Vat. MS. omits

;

this wonl.

The conjecture
eonaxlia
is

Faernus
facta.

cf.

Phil.

x.

10,

where

joined

hy with

1 The death of his adoptive father, Julius Caesar. Brutus was one of the conspirators.

D.

306

PHILIPPIC
it

V. xtiii.

49- 5 i

in pandering to popular having no regard to the Senate and to good men, he opened for himself that p huh the manly spirit to the e\ of a free people could not endure. ii< method of his son is the very opposite: he is very dear to all, and especially to every man. On bin our hope of liberty rests from liim our safety has been already recovered; for him the urs are being sought out and are ready. When therefore we admire his singular prudence,

was of the highest

1

iMOMMm

fear hi r what is more foolish unprofitable power, in\ tiHoOJ wraith, the lust tor in, rash and hazardous as it is, to

we

[H efcl
le
it

and
he

solid
1. 1

glory?

Has he seen
In-

nice in age, will

not see it?

this as a bow, " Hut

he

is

hostile

to

some most

illnstriooi

and

That should cause no fear: Caesar has made the State a gift of his personal ennui her hi^ ler of all he has a; liis pi an be has entered the service -ate only to strengthen, not to overturn h< r. I have within my knowledge all the feelings of the young man. Nothing is dean r to Imn than the te, nothing more Important than your authority, more desirable than the opinion of good men, nothing sweeter than genuine glory. W herefore, so far from feel m him, you should rather expect greater and better things, and not fear, in a man who has set forth to free Dec blockade, that the memory of domestic Bret grief should be so abiding as to prevail with him over the safety of the St hall even venture v word, Conscript Fathers, to you and to p
i

307

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

populoque Homniio reiqoe pablkae; quod pr.decto,

cum me

nulla

vis in

cogeret,

pertimesceremque
iinu triiH-ntatis.
conscripti, C.

Pr

faccre DOB aud< ixiaM re |)criculosaui Of) cipio, spondeo, patres

-

qualis

iioclie

Caesarem talem s sit, qualemque cum maxim.ita sint,

tin,

vcllc esse
satis

et optare ciebemus.

62

XIX. Quae cum

de Caeaare
L.

hoc

trm|)rc du-tuiM habebo.

Necverode

E^

issimoque rei fortissimo et constat i" publicae, silendum arbitmr. ied tribm n.ltim inonmin virtutis egregiae. legionem quariam quae pr.i wsulibus, ad Caesarem ad
senatui populoque Romano reique publicaeesset <>1> earn causam place re, uti L. Egnatuleio tltfinaiw |cre, ante legitiinuin tempos magistratus p< gerere liceat. In quo, patres conscript i, nun tantum
;

commodum
in tali

tribuitur

I..

r n atuleio, u

quantos honos

enim
:

re satis est

DOminari
ita

53

De exercitu nunduiii

autem C. Caesaris

censeo decer-

" Senatui placere militibus veteranis, qui Caesaris

pontiticis auctoritalem secuti Uberlatem jxtjmii jRoOMMI

auctoritatemque huius ordinis defend Tint -it u<* defendant, iis liberisque eorum militiae vacationem esse utique C. Pansa A. Hirtius consules, ambove, si eis videretur, cognoscerent, qui ag
j

coloniis esset,
1

quo milites veterani

<

qui

The words

of GaratoniuB.
1

in italics are added by Halm Cf. the decree fan ni. 1".

on a suggestion

C. in Epp.

ad BnU.

1.

18 regret* this engageinei

adulescente ac paene puero" miseram praestare posse"

and adds, "rtx vUUbar quod proBut these letters are probably

spurious.

308

PHILIPPIC
ild

V. xvin. 51-xix. 53

>man people, and to the State a venture I assuredly not undertake were there no n mint upon me, and should shrink in so supreme a matter from the perilous reputation of prosnux .1 undertake,! solemnly engage, Caesar will aU such a citizen as lie is to-day, and as we should and pray he should be. 1 espe< XIX. In tin* circumstances 1 shall regard what I have said of Caius Caesar as sufficient at pres Hut concerni ng Lucius Egnatuleius, a most brave and one most well-affected and steadfast towards the State, 1 think we should not be sil but should bear our testimony to his en rtue in bringing osrr to Caesar the fourth legion to be a prnt tli.- consuls, the Senate, and the Roman the State. On that account I move thit it he our pleasure that Lucius Egnatuleius may be allowed to seek, to hold, and to administer offices thre years before the legitimate time. In this Egnatuleius not motion is bestowed on advantage so much as honour lor in such a matter
I
1

it is sufficient

to be
1

named,
:

the army of Caius Caesar, i proAi pose our decree should l>e " It is the pleasure of the Senate that the vete soldiers who, attaching themselves to the leader of Caesar tetor, have defended and are defending the liberty of the Roman people and the authority of this our order, together with their children, have WOU from service; and that Caius Pansa and Aulus ilirtius, one or both of them, it it seem good to them, enquire what land there is in those colonies in which the veteran soldiers have

309

MARCUS TULLIUS
ranis divideretur
;

CICSftO
is

contra legem luliani possidrrctur. ut

miHtibttf

dc agroCampanoscpar scerent inirentque rationem de commodil militum veteranorum augendis legionique Martiae et triquartae et iis inilitibus. qui dc legione m A Hirtiuni cesinia quinta ad C. Pans venissent suaque nominaedidissent,quod iis auct< tas senatus popoliqiM Knmani lilx-rUs carissimn MOTHI et merit, vacationem militiac ipsis
;
: :

esse placere extra tumultuni Gallictim Italicumque,

easque legiones bello confecto miasms fieri j>!a< quantamque |>ecuniam milit ihus carum legionmii in ro praetore, p<>lli< singulos C. Caesar po: ii tins sit, tantam dari placere utique C. Pansa A.
;
1

consules, alter ambove,

si

eis videretur,

rattonen agri

privatonun dividi pot Martiae et legioni quai ita darent, adsignarent, ut quibus militibus am dati, adsignati essent" Dixi ad ea omnia, consules, de quibus rettw quae si erunt sine mora matureque decreta, facilius
iniuri.i

haberent, qui sine

iisque inilitibus, legioni

adparabitis ea, quae

Celeritate

tempus autem opus est

et nccessitas

fla<:<

qua

si
i

essemus

usi,

bellum, ut saepe dixi, nullum habert

1 The agrarian law of J. Caesar in hi* consulship (59 B.C.). This was For the division among the Pompeian veterans ami the poorer citizens of State lands in Campania, etc. These were the lands Ant. had divided "amongst his boon companions and fellow -gamblers" ; thil. ii.

3io

PHILIPPIC

V. xix. 53

been settled, which is held in violation of the Julian law, 1 with a view to its division amongst the veteran soldiers: and concerning the Campanian land, that
they

make

separate- enquiry,
tin!><

hurtling
to

with regard to t: those soldiers of the second and thirtj fifth legions who joined the consuls Caius Pansa and Aulas Hirtm and gsve in their names because the authority of the Senate and the liberty of tin people is and has been most dear to them, that pleasure of the Senate that they and Ik ir have exemption from service, saving a ic and Italian state of tumult; and that it is Senate's pleasure that these legions at the end !ie war be discharged ; and that it is its plei that whatever sum of money Caius Caesar, Pout pro pnu tor, has promised individually to the soldiers of those should be given them ; and that C. Pansa and A. Hirtius, the Contois, either or both ot tin-in, if it seem good to tin in, make an estimate of the Hid that can, without private injury, be divided ; and that to those soldiers, that is, to the Martian and fourth legions, they give and assign lands in the fullest measure ever adopted in any gift and
.

and devise a method of the veteran soldiers; and m and fourth legion, and

assignment to soldiers." I have spoken, consuls, to all proposals you have put before us; if they are ratified without delay and in good tinn, you will the more easily make t! preparations which time and necessity demand. Hut prompt action is necessary: had we adopted it, we should, as I have often said, be having no war.

3i

l\

ftODUCI ION

ro PHILIPPIC VI

the conclusion of the debate in the Sena* had gathered in the Forum, cmBed u an account of what had ng introdm. d l>\ D drtrnii Philippic the tribune, <>n tlie last day <>! tin- debate, the tli of Janu He told th. in how he had proposed that a state of siege should lie proclaimed, the law courts closed, and the garb of war assumed. For tl hree all the Senators, days, he aid, it was appen exc port him; but at the last weak, r an embassy was decreed With regard to this, he prophesied that it S as Antonius would not lay down Senate. his i Nevertheless lie people to await with patience the return of tin- envoys. He himself promised to And in a >ts of the State. ration he exhorted them t<> 1>< iji tli.ir exertions to recover their liberty. "Otlwr nations can endure slavery the Roman people' I peculiar
I

On

possession

is liberty.

33

M.

TULLI CICERONIS IN M. ANTONIUM ORATIO PHIUPP1CA SEX A

I

I.

Audita vobis esse arbitror, Quirites, quae

set,
I

sint

acta in senatu, quae fuerit cuiusque

Res

eniin ex Kalendis Iauuariis agitata jwiulo ante

,

fecta est minus quidem ilia severe, quam d < nit pon tamen omnino dissolute. Mora est adlata bello, oon causa sublata. Quam ob rem, quod quaesivit e\
P. Apuleius,

homo
ea,

et multis

oftieiis

mibi

et
is,
is,

Mnm
ita re-

familiaritate coniunctus et vobis an

spondebo,
pos^;

ut

quibus

non

nosse

Causa fortissimis optimisque consulibus Ka!

de re publica primum ret -rendi fuit ex quod XIII Kalendas Ian. senatus me auctore deci Eo die primum, Quirites, fundamenta sunt iacta
Ianuariis

eo,

rei

publicae

fuit eniin

longo intervallo

ita liber

sen

ut vos aliquando liberi essetis.

etiamsi
satis
ille

Quo quid m

tempore,

dies vitae finem mibi adlaturus esset,

magnum ceperam fructum, cum vos universi una mente atque voce iterum a me conservatam esse

rem publicam conclamastis. Hoc vestro iudicio tanto tamque praeclaro excitatus ita Kalendis Ianuariis veni
1

The date

of the third Philippic.

3*4

THE SIXTH
CM
I

PHILIPPIC OF M. TULLIUS
ST M.

ANTON1US
have reached you of

tii nk. I. omi what has been transacted

l:

irs

in the Senate,

and what

each Individual opinion was: for the matter discussed alends of January has just been concluded with less severity than should have been, yet not altogether remissly. War has been postponed, but its cause not removed. Whe refore in regard to the question which PubHoi Apuleius, a allied to me by many kindly offices and the closest intimacy, and your very good friend, has enable addressed to me, I will make a r<-|> you to understand those matters at which you were present our most gallant The reason that first and excellent consuls on tin- Kalends of Jai submit a motion on the general aspect of State affairs was the decree the Senate made on the 20th of December 1 at my instigation On that day, Roman, the foundations of the commonwealth were for the Senate, after a long interval, became so en' e that you were at length free. At that time, indeed, even had that day been filled to bring an end to my life, 1 had earned a recomutly great when you all with one mind pen^ and voice shouted that the State had been a second time saved by me. Encouraged by this weighty and remarkable judgment of yours, 1 cam into the Senate on the Kalends of January bearing in mind
1

3'5

MARCUS TULXJUS CICERO

in

tam a

quam personam imposiItnque 1>< Hum nefarium rem. inlatum rei publicae cum viderem, nullam moram interponendaiu
senatum, ut meminissem,
vobis
in
iin|

hominemque audacissimum. qui ante commissi Koc tempore

Roman] <>ppugnaret,
fort
.

opal!

m
bello

vestron

dum

tumuftum

SUmi dixi incumberent ad

3

esse decrevi; iustitium ed placere, quo omnes acrius graviu

is,

si

omnia gravissimi
viderent triduum

insignia susrepta a Itaque haec scntentia, Quiritc

belli

s-

esset,

valuit, ut, quamquai tamen praetcr pauoos omnes mlfii adst Hodlerno autem die sj>c nrscio qua viderentur.

Nam pi eis obiecta 1 reraissior senatus fuit. earn sententiam secuti sunt, ut, quantum sen vesterque consensus apud A auctoritas valiturus esset, per legatos experiremur. II Intellego, Quirites, a vobis banc sen to Ad quem cnim lega repudiari, neque iniuria. ad eumne, qui pecunia publica dissipataatque effusa, per vim et contra auspicia implegibus, fugata continue, obsesso senatu ad opprimendam rem publican Brundisio legiones a< ab iis relictus cum latronum manu in (ialliam
>

pads

Bucheler, amending the unintelligible Vat. MS., reads Halm suggests dit % ntscxo qua objec' obj.

1 Appian {B.C. 3. 51) states that the Senate was influenced by pity see the Intr. to Phil, v.
:

3'6

"

PHILIPPIC
to sustain. against tl

VI.

i.

2 -i.

character imposed on me by you, which I had Seeing, as I did, a wicked war w.i thought tl: I ne should DC
j)ro|H>sed

with the utmost commission of many previous attacking a general of at tl

that the
I

man who,

acts,

was

Itesieging your most loyal and brave bould l> in war voted for .1 .mult being d I said the Senate should decree that a do* that he courts l>e <1 military garb be assumed, so that all saw all the symbols of a very serious war adopted l>\ the Senate, might with greater seal address themselves U> the injuries of the State. for Acc< Romans, so fully although there was three d ng a few, all appeared likely to assen l>ccausc of some exp ther presented to it, tin- Senate was more iew that for the maj lenient we should ascertain through envoys how far the authority of the Senate and your unanimous rapport would prevail with Antonius. II. 1 gather, Romans, that this view is repudiated by you; and not without reason. I<r urboci dd we send envoys? To that man who, si ng and ring public moneys, after s on the State by violent and in the face of the auspices, after dispersing a public meettig the Senate, summoned leg ium to oppose the commonwealth, and, when he had been deserted by those legions, boisl into Gaul with a band of brigands, is attacking
I

3*7

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

inruperit,

Brutum oppugnet, Mutinam circumsedeat

Quae

vobis potest

cum hoc

gladiatore condicionis,
?

4 aequitatis, legationis

esse COOMBOBltaf
est

Qtti
belli,

Quirites,
nisi

non est
;

ilia legatio,

sed denuntiatin
ut
si

paruerit

ita

enim

dem-tum.

legatJ id

Hannibalem
nuntient,
dilectus

Mittuntur enim, qui mittercntur. ne oppugnet consulem designatum, ne Mutinam obsideat, ne provinciam depo|Mlletar, DC
habeat, sit in senatus Facile vero h

popnliqut
itionJ

potestate.

nerebit,

ut in patrum conscriptorum atque in vestra potestate

sit,

qui

in

sua

nmnqtMin

fueril

Qlc

umquam
quo

arbitrio suo

libido
;

vimilentia

temper eo tractus est, levitas, quo furor, raj> qoQ semper eum duo dissimilia genera tenm latronum
;

runt, lenonura et

ita

forensibus
avarissiinae

parricidiis

delectatur,

domesticis itU] ut mulieri cl

|><>]>tiloque

paruerit

quam

senatui

Romano.
5
III. Itaque, quod paulo ante feci in senatu, (m apud vos. Testificor, drnuutio, ante p nihil M. Antonium eorum, quae sunt legatis man data,

ssuruin. facturum, vastaturum agros, Mu qua possit, habiturum. Is est enim ille, qui semper senatus Judicium et auctoritatem, senip

dilectus,

voluntatera

vestram potestatemque oontemp An ille id faciat, quod paulo ante decretttm est, ut exercitum citra flumen Rubicom-m, qui finis est
Galliae, educeret,
1

dum ne

propius url>e!n Romano

His wife Fulvia.

318

PHILIPPIC

VI.

11.

3-.I1. 5

What communion Brutus and besieging Mutina ? can you have with this gladiator, either as regards is of |>eace, or r any embassy at all ? this is not an embassy, but a \n<i vithreat of war if he does not obey; for such is the issadors were being sent to a ree, just I lor they are sent to Ultimate to him Han! to blockade a consul elect, not to besiege Mui not to lay waste the province. nt to hold levies, but to iti tit of the Senate and the Roman people. He will readily no doubt obey submit to the Conscript this ten and yon? government a man who has never I<.r \\ hat has that man ever done governed hmwlt ii He has always been dragged bis own Initiative?
.
i

'

where

lust,

where humour, where frenzy, where

In-

has dragged him two different classes of men have always held him in their grip, pimps and >r lt.itk s he so enjoys lecheries at home and murders in the forum that he would sooner obey a most avaricious woman l than the Senate and the Roman p III. Acco what I did just now in the I l><Senate I will do give l>eforehand that Marcus Anton his will perform none of the commands the envoys bring, that he will devastate the land, besiege Mutina. hold 1. vies in what way he can. For he is a man that has always held in contempt the opinion and the authority of the Senate, and always your ies and power. Or is he the man to carry out reeent decree that he should draw off his army to side of the l>oundary of Gaul, the river Rubicon, provided he did not march it nearer the city than
toxication,
1 1

'

3*9

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Huic denuntiatiom' Uk ducenta milia admoveret r pareat, ille se Huviu Kuhicone ft ducentis mililm i> est Antoi circuiu>iri|)tuin esse patiatur ? N iinisissft nan
<

1 1

lannibali

in

nici

denuntiaret,

n. net

Saguntum.
t

ut ab nrbe

Quod vero ita avocatur uuquam jiestifera Mamma at

Mul juam
]

habet 111 m, quod quod a senatu dantur mandata

militesque eius adeant iisque demon in rem publicam merita benefici <juesse senatui populoque Hon

Bid

HttflM

eonMH grata

me cam
.

magnae

laudj

magnoque

passurumne
I

f( \1 tit main legates, cen ftoiri Indc tut,.- Numqoam patietur, mini 7 violentiam, vero de illo bomioe aliquo deUtOUtt, scd ut de Importunissima belua cogitare. -.quod Quae cum ita decrevit senatus ; habet atrocitatis aliquid lega utinam nihil haberet morae Nam ram pleri que in rebus gerendis tarditas et procras turn hoc Ixllinn indiget celen odum est D. Bruto, omn ic copiae colligendae; horam eximere ullam 1 in tali ci uklo sine 8 scelere non possumus. An ille non potuit, si Antonium consulem, si Galliam Antoni pr iudicasset, legiones Antonio et provmriam tra<: domum redire, triumphare, primus in hoc or;
I

Horam

cxhibcre
;

nullam (MSS.

Horam

exeubare nullum

(Lambinus)

cf. c. 7,

of this speech (excubabo).

1 river N. of Ariminum, dividing Cis. Gaul from Italia proper.

320

PHILIPPIC
two hundred miles?
warning
?

VI. in. 5-8

He the man to obey this he to allow himself to be circumscribed by tin nv<r Rubicon 1 and two hundred miles? a man; for if he were, he D have compelled the 3ofl to warn him, as if he were a Hannibal at tinbeginning of the Punic war, not to blockade a And Ins being called off from Mul drumonly to be kept away from the what a disgrace, what an opinion of the Striate, fire
)
i

olve does And again, as to the Senate's charge to the envoys to go to Decimus Brutus and
t

services

and to assure them that their emu and good-will towards the State are pleasing to the Senate and to the Roman people, and that their actions will redound to their glory and great do you think Antonius will poffev the
his soldiers,

to cut na? to depart in safety? He never suffer it, l>elieve me; I know his viola know his impudence, I know his I I In truth we ought not to think of him as of a human ost outrageous beast. In the the Senate's decree is not altogether remiss; the embassy has some elen of m d that it involved no delay! For as in the cmiduet of most things slowness and proeras t. o this war especially asks for speed. We must relieve Decimus Brutus all our s must be collected from all quarters; we can>ut crime lose a single hour in the rescue of It" he had so good a citi/t ii red Au tonloi to be a consul, and Gaul An ould be not have handed over the legions and the province to Antonius, have returned home, triumphed, and
>vs

will

<

3"

MARCUS TULLJUS CICERO

quoad
magistr.it tun iniret,

Scd cum se Brut urn esse 9 negotii fuit? vestraeque libertati natum, nun ot
aliud, nisi

sententiam dicere ? meminisset

<

Antoniuin?
o|K>rtebat
?

ut |>aene corpore suo Ad hunc utrum legatos an lrgiones ire

legati,
<|u-<l

Sed praeterita omitUmus properent

;

vos saga parate. Eat enim ita decrrtum, ut, si Ule auctoritatJ senatus noo piruisset, Ibitur; non jwirebit ; noa amtssos ad saga iretur. tot dies rei gerendae quereinur. (Juirites, ne, cum audierit AnIV. tonius me hoc et in senatu et In nasse, iiumquam ilium futurum in senatus potentate, reiellendi mei causa, ut ego nihil vidisse videar, n<>n vertat se et senatui pan-at Numquam faci. mvidebit huic ineae gloriae ; malet n <m a 10 vobis (|uam se modestum existimari. Quid r ipte si velit, nuin etiam Lucium fratrem passu rum arbitramur? Nuper quidem dicitur ad Tibur, ut op cum ei labare M. Antonius videretur, mortal fi esse minitatus. Etiamne ab hoc myrmillone Alii senatus mandata, legatorum verba audicntur I enim secerni a fratre poterit, tanta praesertmi auctoritate. Nam hie inter illos Africanus est video esse facturos
;
t
j

pluris habetur

quam

L. Trebellius, pluris

quam

Plancus 1 *** adulescens nobilis.

Plain -urn, qui omniaft-

1 The Vat. MS. is a mass of confusion name. Then come the words "cum extbwr reading is hopelessly lost.

true

See

n.

1,

p. 276.

* i.e.

a great man.

P. Scipio Africanus
is

was the conqueror

of Hanniluil.

The reading here

hopelessly lost.

322

PHILIPPIC
h

VI.

in. 8-iv.

10

I the first to give his vote in this our body until took up his office.' WhtA difficulty was there? Hut as he remembered he was a Brutus, and one born to the service of your liberty, not of his own almost l>\ his own ease, what else did he do but Should envoys body bar Antonius from Gaul ? or rather legions have been sent this man } Hut let us wa, .ist; let the envoys hasten, as I sec they will do uet ready the gar! For it has been so decreed that, if he does not war. bow to the aul the Senate, we must come to the garb of war. We shall; he will not bow, and we shall lament the loss of so many days for action. IV. 1 am not afraid, Romans, when Antonius hears that I have m the Senate and at a public meeting given my assurance that he will never put r the government of the Senate, that, himin order to refute me, and convict me of want of foresight, he will change his ways and obey the Senate. He will never do it ; he will not grudge me this honour he will prefer that you should deem me wise than that you should think him modest. Besides, even if he were willing himself, do we think his brother Lucius would ever suffer it ? Recently indeed he is said at Tibur, I think when Antonius appeared to him to be weakening, to have threatened his brother with death. Will the commands of the Senate and the words of the envoys be really listened 'V this myrmillo l from Asia ? For he cannot be separated from his brother, especially as he carries such weight. For he is an Africanus 2 among them ; he is held of more account than Lucius Trcbellius, of more account than Titus Plancus. ... a noble youth.* As to Plancus, who, after being condemned

>t"

3*3

MARCUS TULLIUS CICEKO

bus sententiis maxiuio vestro plausu con<l nescio quo modo se coniecit in turban atque ita maestus rediit, ut retractus. non re versus vil t sic contemnit, tainquam si illi aqua et igni int sit; aliquandonegat ci locum e opoftCJt m -un .1, Nam Trebellium valde qui incenderit curiam. diligit ; oderat turn, cum illc tabulis novis adversaiam it in ipsum batur oculis, posteaquam Trehcllium vidit sine tabulis novis salvum esse mm Audisse enim vos arbitror, Quirites, quod posse. etiam videre potmstis, cotidfe sponsoreset credi tores <) i<le (hoc enim opinor L. Trebelli convenire. Trebellium sumpsisse cognomen) quae potest ease maior fides quam fraudare creditores, dom< propter aes alienuin ire ad ami a ? Ubi DMOtOI illc in triumplio est, saepe ludis, ubi acdilitas delata summo studio bonorum ? Quis est, qui hum non
< l

11

l *

>

12

casu existimet recte fecisse, nequitia sceleste ? l V. Sed redeo ad amores deliciasque vestras, L. Anton ium, qui vos omnes in tidem suam re< Negatis? Numquisnam est vestrum, qui trilmm non habeat? Certe nemo. Atqui ilium qun et triginta tribus patronum adoptarunt. ELo reclamatis? Aspicite illam a sinistra eq
<

So Halm

follg.

Nipperdey

acderaU (Klotz)

nequitia

est scelere

(Vat. MS.).

Of recalled

exiles.

The

severest form of banishment,

making a man an

outlaw.
P. had been convicted of complicity in the riot that followed the funeral of Cicero's enemy, P. Clodius, in which the Senate-house was burnt. He had been recalled from banishment by J. Caesar.
3

324


PHILIPPIC
VI.
IV.

IO-V. 12

unanimously and with your loudest applause, somehow or other threw himself ftmoog the and returned so sorrowful that he seemed to have been tugged back, and not to have returned Antonius so despises him as if he had been interdicted water and fire ;* sometimes he says that a man who set fire to the Senate house 3 should have no place For as to Trebellius. he now loves him in the Senate. well he hated him when he opposed the cancellation of debts; but now he is the i||le of his eye ever since he has seen that Trebellius himself cannot without cancellation of debts save himself. For I think, Romans, you have heard you might even have seen that Trebellius' sureties and ereditors () Faithful !* for arc holding meetings every day. this surname Trebellius has, 1 think, assumed what greater proof of faith can there be than in (fatal your ng from your house, because of debt resorting to arms ? Where is the praise he won at a triumph and often at the Games?* where is the aedileship conferred with the greatest enthusiasm of good men? Who is there that does not think tins man acted well by chance, wickedly by his own depravity ? V. But retain to your love and your darling, us Antonius. who has taken all of you under his charge. Do you is there any of you that Assuredly no one. And yet the fivethirty tribes have adopted him as their patron. Do you again shout " No " ? Look at that gilt
:

xiii.

12,

where T.

is

called FitUi

fxitronu*.

cognomen is a name added to mark tome personal quality. * Because he had opposed the ca presence during some other man's triumph, or at the Games, seems to have been applauded.

3*5

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

statuam
inauratam, in qua quid inscriptum
Popllli

"QuiNQUE ET THIOINTA TKIUUS PATRONO."

Romani quidem
velit,

igitur
illi

nus

L.

Anton;

Malara
i

pestem
hie latro,

cUunori enim vestro adsenti

Non modo

sed quis

quem elicntCM habere nemo umquam tantis opihus, tantis rebus

RomuiJ
rfotoril

gestis fuit, qui se jmpuli

13

dominique
In
(,>.

omnium gentium patmnuin

L.

dieere auderet?
ill

Antoni statuam videmus, sieut qui Hernieos devicit, ante Castoris.

incredihilt-m
!

nn

Tremuli,

Impudenl

Tantumne sit>i rampslt, quia Myiasis myrmillo Thraecem iugulavit familiarcin swum }

Quonam

modi istum fcrrr pnssrmus,

?

si

in lio<

spectantibus vobis depugnassct

;

Sed haec una statua altera ab equitilms Romaali equo publico, qui item ascribuut " patrono." Quem umquam iste ordo patronum adoptavit Si quemquam, debuit me. Sed me omitto qu< m an,
:

quem
14

iraperatorem

"Agrum

iis

<li\.

()

snrdidos, qui acceperint,

improhum, qui ded

i

Statuerunt etiam tribuni militant, qui

Caesaris bis fuerunt.

Quis est iste ordo? Multi fuerunt multis in legionibus per tot annos. lis quoquedivisit Semurium. Campus Martius restabat, nisi prius cum fratre iugisset. Sed haec agrorum
adsignatio paulo ante, Quirites, L. Caesaris, clari
viri et
1

praestantissimi senatoris, sententia dissoluta

See

Phil.

iii.

* i.e.

The subject 1, p. 276. 12 and vii. 6. furnished by the State.

n.

is

also

mentioned

in

32O

PHILIPPIC

VI.
:

v.

12-14
is its

equestrian statue on the left

what

inscript

.'" he five-and-thirty tribes to tin The !>eople's patron then is Lucius Antonius. for I agree with your .rues fall on him To say nothing of this brigand whom no shoots. one would choose as a client, who at any time has been so powerful, so illustrious in nt as to dare to call himself the patron of the Roman
1
!

.1

the (<n<jiiror and lord of all nations? In the forum we see the statue of Lucius Antonius, as we see that of (, Dolus who conquered the rferntauu In front of the Temple of Castor. What men lias he taken so much on himself because at Mylasa as a myrmillo he rut tinthroat of a Thracian gladiator, his own comrade? How could we have borne with him it he had fou in this forum before your eyes? Hut this is one statue; a second has been << by the knights with public horses-': they also add
'

the m "To our patron." Whom has that order ever adopted as its patron? if anyone, tin y should have me Hut I say nothing of myself; what what general has it m II'' divided lands Wiomj tin in.'' How mean the uers! how unscrupulous the gi\* xse who had been military tribunes twice in tin- army of Caesar erected another. What class of m. n is that? There were many in many le^i during so many years. Amongst them he has The Plain of M led the Semurian land. i. but he fled with his brother too soon. Hut this assignment of lands, Romans, has been abrogated on the proposal of Lucitl a most illustrious man and distinguished for, Senator
:

327

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

est
;

huicenim adsensi

sept< -iimnim actasustulin

iacent benct
re

us

Anton
;

discedent

nnpennMn
quia
15

fnoermnt,

noodnn

\<rant,

Dallam pnrtun

noi
ilia

DOO
:

hftbl

Sed

de qua, si " L. Am essent, Don possem sine Hsu dicere Itane? Ianus medius in a Iano medio patro.no." Quis umquam in illo Ian<> L. AotOttJ clientela est? inventus est qui L. Antonio niille nuinmum ferret
statu a pal maris,

incumw
VI.
S

'

ad eausain bellumI multa de nugis que redeamus quamquam noO ulii-num tint personas quasdam a vobis recognosci, tit. jmlmscum bellutn
;
;

gereretur, possetis ta< tit, etiamsi melius Ego autem vos h<aliud fait, tainen legatorum r ditum expectetis amnio im n Celcritas detracta de causa e^' aequo. 16 aliquid idcausam ti renuntia-

non

quodcerte renuntiabunt, Don In wstra |><testate, Antonium, quis erit tarn Impi civis, qui ilium eivem habendum putrt ? Nunc -nim sunt pauei illi quidem, sed tainen plui quam M
rint,

In senatus esse

dignnn est, qui ita loquantur " Ne lega" quidem expectabirous ? simulationemque clementiae extorqm -l>it
publica
tes
:

ipsa.

Quo

etiani, ut conlitear vobis. Qwirites, n

hodierno die contendi, minus laboravi, ut mihi senatus adsentiens tumultum decerneret, saga sunn
1 commission for the division of lands in territory and in Campania among the veterans. Their acts were annulled, their appointment having been procured by violence : cf Phil. xi. 6. 13.
I

A
A

septemvir:

cf.

Phil.

viii.

9 26.

328

PHILIPPIC
agreeing with of the septeimirs
unt
;

VI.

v.

14-V!. 16

we have annulled the

l
;

acts
at a

the

btoursef Nucula* are

patronage market is flat. For the trill depart with equanimity; they have gone to no expense have not yet stocked the land had no confidence, some beta had no in. my But one statue takes >uld not Cf had Ik without a laugh have quoted: " From tin Exchange
Ai
; -

it

its patron.**

So?

The Exchange

irf

of the clientele of Lucius Antonius?

Who in
to d<

that

Kxchange has ever been discovered

i

thousand sesterces? But have pokes enough on trifles: let us return to our subject and to the war; though it was
\ 1.
I

te
-

that you shoul certain enable you in your minds to consider

i
I

irboao
1

imp

you,

you were at war. Romans, even though a different

t

to wait with

for the return of the envoys.

Our cause

has lost

promptitude of action, yet some good has accrued For when the envoys report as they certainly will report- that Antonius is net under your ^0 and that of the Senate, who will be so ini" think that man should be regarded as a fellow-citizen For now there are he State, some, few indeed, \et more than 1>< that speak thus: "Shall we not even wait for the envoys r" Assuredly events themselves will from them that catchword and pretence of clemency. On that account to confess it to you, Romans was less earnest, k-s insistent to-day, that the Senate dd agree with me and decree a state of tumult,

329

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

iuberet; malui vipnti diebus post sententiam
laudari
17 perari.

meim
vitu-

ab

omnibus

quam

paucis

hodie

Quaproptcr. Quiritet, exspectate legatorum

redierint,

reditum et paucuruiii dicrum molestiam d

Qui cum
si

si

paccm

BOpidim

bellum,

providum

indicatote.

An ego

MM

de de rei publicae salute c Quid enim non debeo vobis, Qui rites, quern vos a se ortum bominiboi oobilissimis omnibus prai-tulistis ? An ingratus sum ? Quis minus? end partis honoribus eosdem in foro gessi labores quos Rmlis in re publica ? Quis ex< petendis. qui viginti iam annos bellum geram rum impiis
provideam meis
vestra
civibus,
libcrtate,
fa
t

non dies noctesque

civibus.
18

VII.

Quam ob

rem, Quirites, consilio, quantum

potero, labore plus paene,

quam

potero, excubabo
est civis, prae-

:ilaboque pro vobis.

Etenim quis

sertim hoc gradu, quo

oblitus beneficii vestri,

me

vos esse voluistis, tam

inimicus

dignitatis

suae,

tam immemor patr quern non excitt, non

iste

inflammet tantus vester

consensus?

M
intcrfui

magnasque habui consul contiones, multis nullam umquam vidi tantam, quanta nunc
est.

vest ruin
ti B,

Unum

sentitis

omnes, unuui
a
re

stud

Antoni
ordines,

conatus

avertere

publica,

furor in

extinguere, opprimereaudaciam.

Idem volunt omnes eodem incumbunt municipia, coloniae, cuncta

33

PHILIPPIC

VI.

vi.

16-vn. 18

and order the assumption of military garb; I preferred that twenty days hence my opinion should be commended by all rather than abused to-day by Wherefore, Komans, await the return of the a few. envoys and swallow down your annoyance of a \\ ben they return, it they shall brine; peace, days. then you may consider me to have been a partial not be witness; if war, foreseeing. Should not day seeing for my fellow -citizens? should and nig! fan liberty, and the safety of the what do I not owe I, a r all man of no lineage. N
1
t

men? h grateful? than I, who, after mv honours have been won, have spent the same labour in the forma Inexperienced in as when I was seeking them? Who is more versed than I ? who State affairs ? now for the twentieth year an g war against
urs before the noblest
is

Who

less so

disloyal

Romans, with advice to the extent power, with toil almost beyond my power, I will stand sentry and keep watch on your behalf, who is the citizen, and that too of such position as it has been your pleasure that I should hold, so forgetful of your kindness, so unmindful of his e-uritr so unfriendly to his own dignity, as not to be stirred, not to l>e fired by sueli unanimity on your pari Many great public meetings have I held none so as consul, at many have I been present You all have great have I ever seen as yours to-day. one opinion, one object, to avert from the State Antonius, to quench Uf the attacks of M frenzy, to crush his audacity. All orders wish the same to the same object are bent the boroughs,
VII. Wherefore,

of

my

33'

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

Italia.

Itaque senatum
serins
fait,

bene sua sponte (irmum

Venit tcmpus,

19 firmiorem vestra auotoritate fecistis.

Qnirites,

omnino,
ta

Blommn

led

di^num populo matoram, ut difl

quam

Fuit aliquis fatalis casus, ut hora non possit dicani, quem tulimus, quoquo modo fere

nunc

si

c]>

luin

Rnmanum
omnibus

servire fas
goottti

non

est,

qoen

<ii

imtnortales

extremum

<! libertate est add u eta discriraen; dectrnitur. Aut vincatis oportct, Qoftfftet, quod profecto et pictate vestra et tanta con cord ia Aliae sequemini, aut <|uulvis pottos quam srrviatis. nationes servitutem pati possunt, pujuih Komaiii est

propria libertas.

332

PHILIPPIC
made the Senate, already
,

VI.

vii.

18-19

the colonics, the whole of Italy. Thus you have firm in its own determinaThe time has come, firmer by your rapport later altogether than befitted the Roman people, yet one so ripe that t now be delayed an hour. There has befallen a calam ned, so to speak, by Fate, wrhieh wt bare borne as we come now it will be of our own eouU ill the Roman people should be slaves iw is contrary t> the Immortal ( Jods have willed it to rule all nations. Matters have been brought to the utmost crisis; the issue is liberty. must it her win victory, Romans, which assuredly you will achieve by your loyalty and such or do anything rather than be slaves. Other nations can endure slavery; the assured possession of the Roman people is tJbertT.
I

333

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
tinued
to
j.re-s

VII

Durino the absence of the envoys Antonius conmeant in.In the on the siege of Mutina. ^ans, headed by Calenus, attem ->al l>\ to ol Inrenting on his behalf answers to the demands of the Senate by :ig his moderation and so forcing a comway And Calenus showed letters the terms of likely to bring about that result and to irage the Antonian p So! January the <nvened tinr certain trivial matters. Senate t< On this taking advantage of the rules of occasion debate which did !>eakers to the matter eventh Philippic. before the House, deli v< He referred t the embassy which was quenching the public enthusiasm, and res of Antonius' friends. Though he himself was a lover of peace, he protested that there could be no peace with Antonius. Peace would be dishonourable, dangerous, and in fact impossible. It was dishonourable, as showing Inconsistency and want of firmness on Senate when they had In effect by the part their decrees declared Antonius to be an enemy dangerous that Antonius should, after all his crimes, sit as a consul ir in that House; impossible bees there could be no real peace between Antonius and the boroughs, and Caesar, and Brutus, and the people rally. Antonius must yield if not, he had declared war on th people Their liberty was at stake. And, appealing to 'ansa, be said that he had now an opportunity of freeing the State from danger.
<
*

mom

335

M.

TULLI CICRRONIS IN M. ANTONIUM

UK) PHILIPP
1

MA
necessariis coi
la

I.

Parvis

de rebus, sed forUsse

conscripti.
It-

limiir,

patrcs

De A
tnUnnis

et

de

Mood
Quarum rcrum
bus.

Uapercil

pi

refert
niini

etsi facilis cx\

mis aberrat a sententia suspcnsus curis

Adducta est enim, patres conscript

periculum et in cxtremuin pactie d
sine causa legatorum

maximum
men.

Non
sit

istam mission em

semper
quid

tinmi,

numquam

prolwivi.

Quorum

adlaturus, ignoro, exspectatm

quiden quan-

tum .nltri.it languoris animis, quis t? Non enim se tenent ii, qui senatum dolent ad am torit.it is pristinae spem revirescere, D rdlni populum Romanum, conspirantem Italian, |>aratos exercitus, expeditos duces. lam nunc fmgunt responsa
ilium,

Antoni eaque
ut

defendunt.

Alii

pottalare
Scilicet

omnes

exercitus

dimittantur.

legatos ad

eum

misimus, non ut pareret et dicto

audiens esset huic ordini, sed ut condiciones ferret,

leges imponeret, reserare nos exteris gentibus Italian
iuberet, se praesertim incolumi, a

quo main,

prriest.

culum quam ab
336

ullis

nationibus extimescendum

THE SEVENTH
I.

PHILIPPIC OF M. TULLIUS CICERO AGAINST M. ANTONIUS

are

Wi;
l>ut

consulted,

Conscript

Fathers, on

tin perhaps an imperative, makes a motion about the Appian Way and The the tribune about the l.up.rei arrai of such matters seems an easy out), ii suspense because of greater cares, wanders from tin- pn stkMi la del*ate. things have been brought, Conscript Fathers, into the greatest peril, and almost into an extreme eri boot cause that I have always feared, the envoys. and never approved, that ser to bring us I do not know; but who does not uh.it l fineness of mood the waiting tor them induces Of there holding !>>< g those who lament that, in of recovering its ancient authority, s youth, that the Roman the Senate people is in alliance with this our ofdl r. that Italy that our armies at and POT

small, consul

.'

>

inlanders ready.

Even now

tn<

replies

from Antonius, and defend them. Some allege that he demands the dismissal of all armies. Of a surety we have sent envoys to him, not that lie should obey and give ear to the commands of this body, lM odTef term-, impose laws, and and bid us throw Italy open to foreign nations in whom greater that too while he danger is to be dreaded than from any nati
!

337

MARCUS TULXJUS CICERO

I

AHI remitteee earn Mbit Gelhai ultimam poatuUre. PrarrUr solum, ted etiam aatieaei ad a
lurrrr
>

Alii nihil

COO

U DM
Sad

frater eat lade revoeatus.

ei

qua

Ilia

U\ rintare

lUqae

Utum
llle

pan* patroeiaaMe Antoalaai noa apart u it

tqae
se

mt amlti

pearl

quidrm a

loeuntur); eat \g\tur in aefarHa

eat?
II

\tijur

bare

li

loraatar. 9a!

levitate

popalares fcebehsfitur.
ilka

potest

m mo
idem

ti tatu,neji

enim

erenit, at, qui la

la

eolentate feuae popular**. Qui rebas iaipeoias popalores

ftirrint,

re

ana aitiian pemlari, quod

eadem salutaris rei fiublieae it, impcoboi at quaro popaUHs ease malmt? Me qaiden temper
scitis, anvrrsarium multitudinis tenierltatl haee feett 6 praeelariisinui cans* popolarem. Rt geld dkaatai

Caio. had baa* illogallj allotlad Mat, a Hot. fa, 44 m.c ( and racaiM 1a efn^ of iba daoraaof Dac(iMaM5V Tba iatifiaat to Marsat oa Jooa I was t borafocs ciaistd as baviag agate tsaoass falfet mas that, in tba aaas of traitors, r.lliwml it bat tar than precaution*. c popularity huntara, tba cttm *ajr/*raf of PkiL i. 15. C. u alio "oding to tba f rioads of A. at tbTSaoata.
.

'

338

HHUPm

VII.

t.

3-il

Others oDeae be resigns to us Hither Gaol, and Very fine! to for hinnrlf the Farther. it he mar attempt to march to the city, not Other that hit egiojM, bat even naUona.
mrr

now wholly

nnJr%t.

,l..,,i*

ha rsIU

since hia brother Galas baa

been

But hat province

i

is

there oat

and

ad vocatcs. In the role of foreatfhted diligent Senators, any that 1 bare

e/ pence.

*r : they take on thtamslvaa Don't they argue thus?

it

ia

against

them
i

Which

that they warn na to take precaution*. coarse then, ban yea are dealing with a Ulaiaa, ahowa the eaore prudent caution ? b the when yon can, or to be afraid of

II. And those who aay thia are men who, on account of their levity, were formed v called democrat* Prom thto K can be understood that in their bearta thee abhorred the aoand constitution of the State, ami arcre not democrata from inclination. For bow does it happen that men who were democrat* in the caaeof wrong mem urea, in a m especial I v democratic, as tending also to the safety of the State, yet prefer to be enerrupeloas m' than democr atic? Aa for myaelf, though I have always been, as von know opposed to the of the crowd, thia moat excellent cause fa me a democrat And indeed they an

339

MARCUS TULLIUS

iiu.'T.-

Fvm to
f uft

botti?

lite

Htten

.!

a de

tpr rrrutn

icfuiMUmm?

cos tu Urttts

prufenu, recites,

dftftc ribendfts

etias deft

impfobU

debiliUs et
deni<|ur

U
>

rurm

p,tr>

ArHp..

PftJttft,

fortiMimut consul fttque

Hunc intern n>

to
6 drfigcrrt,
ftb
i

rei

eftbllm ssJete

urn u lew nan

Illius ftetatc

peUrem.

Quasnqeam no

inrunte

asas, CWMftitiKJO. ttodlon

vinxit,
belli

liusdessgeft

em
dm,

li

wred

M
dtalis

to

drills

pericftlu

petepect

sslutts, sed

etiam dignitatis meae fulsse fautorem,

ut
nisi

tainen

cundcra,

esset

consul,

negare esse coosulem auderrtu.

Idem
Noci quia
set)

tque opttmsa ceeeelein

pari

virtute et voluntatr
in
;

alii

furnnt,

tantam

causam non hsbuerunt,

qua et vol on tat em suam et virtutetn declararent huius magnitudini an gravitati, sapientiae trmpestas est obUU formilatus,

dolosissimi temporis.

cum gubernat rem

Turn aotem mlostratur consopublican si non optabiH,

340

maim*
nwe

...

5-7

rather they call themselves, coneuUrs; a name of bo man it worthy thai cannot by hit conduct a title Arc yoo, Sir, to I* he to trod too letter J" .vlul lull y to hto hopesof Mcceaa? Are yoe joy them to to copy; are roo t the bopea and the virtue of loyal men, yet deem yourself a consular, or a Sen* nana a rltiaea f Calaa Pane, oor moat jralUnt -trellmt consul, will take in good part what For with the moat friendly feeling I shall iy tab: Even hit case, deapite oar close br ere aaeh a cons u l aa devoted all hit vigilance, bit caret, hi thought to the .,

of the Sutr. Although from hit too and amnity with

I

me

in

the

fully

r,

war, baa thown bim to not only of my life, bat alto of

civil

a consul,

m I hare mid, If be were not uch would venture to my he It BO consul. Bat I my he it not merely t consul, bat auII thoae I remember, the moat illustrious and loyal consul. Not that others hare not been of the
I

like virtue and Inclination, bat groat opening lor showing their virtue; upon bim, with hi* greatnem of n strength of character and wisdom, bat been brought And t consulthe storm of a most perilous crisis. is then ennobled w hen it is taking the helm of yet the State, if not t a time to be wi

34

II!!!
at

niusesrln tempore

Marts

patres conscript*, nullum III Itaqoe ego illc. qui

cutque pai, pretserthn ci*ih%. quasnqa Umen in pnasie foil optabtlii (< curriculum Indostriee nostra* in fore, in curia. In amlcorum periculb prepolwuidis el shors t ani est; Line honorcs amnlitsi os, bine ms di o cr ss opes, bine
bonis,

ego
cirili

a,

lumnus, qui qnaatos

eefte non fuiatcm (peneulose dieo accept uri, patres ronecripti, siti*, pre mes perpetoa copfclitate e ti a ti dignitatis reti(IUAT V Itf'lHIAC C" lUtfrtlflAr aBavsaanpspsF a* ww v^^uwn Bsapsmmmr epesuis^asPiaFa ^ pvaaKvjepjpaspea rrbum a conscripti, ut primo, etai rhilr a Cicerone ewe dictum, s*cipiatis sine offenskme, quod ditere. neve id, ndusquam, quale tit, explicaro, repodictie) e go ille (dicam aacpius)

modum

t.

nolo. Magna ape ingredior in liquam orationem, patres conscn culosissimum locum silentio sm Cur ijritur pacem nolo? Quia tnrpie est, aula periculo*a, quia esse non potest Quae trio dum co, peto a volris, patres eoascrij.ti, ut ^uitatr, qua soletis, mea verba rrU audiat audiatta.

M. Antonio esse

levitate, mobilit Q> singulis hominibus, turn vcro univeno senat

mow on

This paaaags waa quoted by Pitt in tha Hoaaa of CowFeb 3. 1800. with tha suhatitaUon of "aa/las" for

turpi ": Cobbetl'a Pari.

HuL

34. 1349.

34

riiii.iiTic
it

\n
urgent, Conscript
pro-

rural time.

And more

ers,
111.
1,

m
therefore,

ho have always been *

peore, above all to all loral men, whole course of or activity bat bee sprat la the forum, in the repelling danger from my friends; last source I hate von the fullest honour, rank aa I postrm I then, the nursling, so to speak, o:
iter
I

of peace, ami to

whom

Hl^^^ f^^Kif^ I peak at my

>Jfc

^^^m^M t
:

MJlKimt iLmiUiI Ll'

MMiM

shrink from the thought how yon will take it. Conscript Fathers, but. sidering my unfaltering desire to maintain and to I n t rs sss your dignity. I a*k, I beseeeh yon, Conscript Fathers, however bitter or incredible it amy be to hoar it said by Marcus Qcero, first to take without what I shall ssy, and not to reject it before
peril
1

|4ain

who bass

iU meaning-!-! will my it again I, been the panegyrist, always the of peace, refuse to support s pence with kntonioft. I eater with great hope upon
si ways
I-

the rest of my speech, Conscript titers, as I bare psssed by amid your silence the most dangerous
\\
it is

bi then do I refuse to support peace? Because disgraceful, because it is dangerous, because it is

I

And while I explain these three proask yon, Conscript Fathers, to hear my with your u%ual kindness >at is more disgraceful, not only in individuals, but especially >enatc as a body, tlmn an
isspossible. 1

343

MARCUS TULUU8
pins
f

quid porro
roultis decretis iodtcarUb,

bostcm noo rerbo, ted re

10

cum

boc subito

paccm rclle conluagt f NW rero. CMttri mcriU illi qtaidea bonorr

bos,

quod

ilium,

qui

r.^v>w,

esset bostis, rcliquiiaetit. racatkme*, pecunlas, grot

qmpoadittlft
II

IV

generis et

Quid? cum ttrutum nominal Dutum ad

it

dam
bellum gcrcntcm
liasimam atque
shuis adfecistis, turn

pro llbriiate popull

fide*

cum

Antonio, provtneiamque

Quid? cum
ad bellum
IS bottis

decrevistis, ut eoolri, Iter

ambove,
si

profidsccrrntur, quod

erat

bellum,

Antonius Don erat?

fortissimua,

Quid

igitur pn>

est

vir

mens

collcg* ct (amiliaris, A.
inbectllitate,

qua macie! Sed animi vires corporis infirmitas non retardavit aequum, credo, putavit vitam, quam popull Romani
Hirtius

consul?

at qua

votis

rctinui&set,

pro libcrtate

popuU Romai.

344

mu.iiTn
-.

vii

in

Whet, more ^consistent than suddenly to wish for the iikkig of peace with a bid whom too have just now it many decrees, not in word onfy, but in fact, adjudged an roriujr > But perhaps, when job decreed bonou n to Cam* Career, bonoBrt that were indeed hit deaert and hit doe, hot none the lew were estraordiuary aad ever memorable, for the ingle rcoaoB that he hat got together an array Marcus Antootus, you did not then adjudge aad Aatoaias wra not then adjudged aa
is
I
.*

by tear authority the veteran aoldiera

aad yoa did not then adjudge Aatoaiat aa enemy when to gallant legions, because they had deserted a man who waa called a consul though he waa an
' f
i

at

iit#fi*ii-

'

r* #*

if

aad lead*?
\aia. In the oaae of Brutu. a man bom of hit race and name for the afjIiHlni of the State, aad of bit with Antonius for the liberty of the Roman people, aad of the moat faithful aad loral province of Gaul, hrn you honoured them with the most generous
1\

then adiodgc AntooJus an enemy ? you decreed that the consols, on* both of them, should set out to war, what wat thr \\\\\ the* baa f Antonius was not an asjtswj that bravest of men, my colleague aad friend, Aulut aa, the consul, set out * and in spite of what weakness, what waste of body! But the infir. of bis body did not tlaeken the vigour of hit mind ; be thought it right, I suppose, to risk on behxi the liberty of the Roman people the life that had
praise, did yon not

Agair

'

345

MARCUS TILL! US

in

pridic

d
porn Irgioue ad

ad

Antootum
paratum
ret'
i

ilrnuntiatio est

Juul

MUsos enim legatee omnn non omnc verb* novcr

V.

vide

Retincnda est

ijritur

nobii comUntta, gravitas,

ilia

perse verantia, repetcnda vettti

(1*

severitai,

nonrstaUm, laudem tUtemqur detidcrat, quibos rebut bic ordocarmt iiiiniun) din. Scd rrmt torn escusaUo npprcasla misers ilia quidem, scd tamen iusU; nunc nulla est
in

auctoritas senates decut,

was

Jaa. 4. the U*t <Ur of ibe dabsu. urban lbs fid. Phil delivered. Tbe Beast* Bssst* bad previously supported
>g ia

(/>A.7. ri. J).

knows

of tbfa nbaaey frota

546

PHIUmC

vii.

ii

v.

through their prayers. Again, hrn to be held throughout all when you withdrew all exemptions from service, wot be not adjudged m Yon ecin tl.r -,ty forges of arm*; soldiers sword in hand follow the consul ther arr a guard in appearanre for the omul. In Cart and 'truth far at ; all men, without any excuses, with the giving In their namea; they submit -.int been adjudgr But we hare tent envoy*.' Alas, ivoys/'

whv am 1 forced to chide alwavs praised. What? do 1 Fathers, you have made thr jceaptsbli) to the people? do roe do von not beer, that it it my policy thai to demanded? The day before yoa accepted it in a crowded session, the nest day * it was to an empty Moreover, how hope Of peace yoe were cast down It is that legions* should send envoys to the Senate, and the Senate to AntonJosI Ami that is not an * embassy''; it is a solemn warning that his doom to determined if he shall fail to obey tint body. What does It matter? What the ae think* i pel the more serious thing ; for that envoys rmsofoordchave been sent all men se it to not all ho know. V. We mut therefore maintain our consistct meet again assume sternness, if, that is, the authority of the feels the lack of honour, of good name, of reputation and dignity, things this body has been without too long. But then in our oppression we had an excuse, a poor one indeed, yet adequate ; now we
I

347

MARCUS Til:
I.il>rmti

rcfio

jrraviai

ulimuj not quidctn ; eitorqacnda font Quod non possaMM) Ucrrr, (dinun, quod dignaM est 15 senatore el Bonn hoMiae)
si

eoiro

UU

crtt

iltuv in

jii

J-

pubUcam
restituit,

mnimeM

dissipavit,

nules

fine
|*

vcctipdia dit rndidii, pruviaciat de

iroperio

rcgna addiait pc leges ciritati per eta topoaaJt, nab Mil apsndit ut I base, iaqeasn, omitutn, mi hoc qoldem cogi talis, ems, qui Muti nam, eolonUm popuii Roman! BnaiasanaM, oppugn* rit, imprrstorem popuii Komani. console design* turn, opse drpopuUtus agros sit, hone In cum ordincM recipi, a quo tot tens ob bat ipsa* ran it bostis todkatm tit,
Muiulit,

Romani

ncMMMlnii

16

IHcmb demceps, ut quod etsJ Minus est fu fiend um quin turpitudo, tamen offendit animos maioris partis
Satis
i!

Mnlu

propoiui, de pcriculo

bominum

magis.
ritk igitur csplorataoi habere

in civiUtc

Antonium

rtdebttis eel pottos

Nisi

forte
1

contemnitis

Laeian
i

pacem, earn Antonio* ? ego ne Gaium

Bt fM a^mth of

By Aatossas*

348

IMI I II I'l-H

VII

,4-n. .6
to

From kinglv tyranny we teemed 1 afterwards we were till b*

we

by the capons of domestic nr.i have, a U true, parried the v mutt now be from the grasp I! canoot do this

die.

For what s da*rsce will that be to the ml a dt%honoor. what a stain, that Marcus should In this bode give hit vote on eonbenches ! To my nothing of the innumerable

dissipated

illegally restored

on immense sum of public moneys, eailcs. has baaked up and

a ^^^^^^

4onn> *^*

law by

ol tJic |*-"| lr l, *< swJtfsma *": Lao iw*|m^pww smasmmm la una J w^ost aam lK A n ,, ,^w^^^aa^ w a wos^es wwsmoouow** violence, has either beet aged or shot out the
.
,

mmmw

armed men to my nothing of these mv. do you not even consider this } What a f.ul and outrageous crime it would be that the man who has attacked Mo Una, a most staunch colony
Son*
thing*,
I

of too

Roman people; has besieged s general of the Roman people, s consul elect has devastated lands that kt should be received into that body
;
1

bo bos been

for these very reasons so often

igh of disgfci. I will speak next, as I have proposed, of the danger. Though wc should shrink from it less than from disgr it affect* the minds of the majority of men more. VI Will you then be able to possess assured peace when you see m the community Antonius or rather Antoniuses * But perhaps you despise Lucius ; I do not despise even Gains. But, as I

349

<

MARCUS

TL'I.LIUS

CICEIO

Scd. Ut patronot quinqoc

sua Irgr, qu
est*

cum
tu%t
,

tolVagiam

turn
17

Buhmim

o
(

go

patronot corutn, qui tribonl

Qoit not Unl mrdli. HMt inrrr, praraertim ub detl

orbitr bti, fotura sit ^ que jrtadlatorrm not. An ton it appellai i. ot mtrrdom ettam pi>cllari uil* t. ted ot appellant it, qoi Utmc locuntur. Myrmtllo in Asia Cub ornattet throecidictt coanttem I fmmillorcm tuum. ilium miaerom fajricotem rajruU*it, loculettUm tatnen tp*e plogtOJ ocrrj.it, ut dcrlarat etc a 18 Qoi faroiliarcm iujrulant, quid it of option e data
jrladiotorit

Mm*

Unci jojlia? n ,,u. lllud onimi eoott fa hunr pmedoe coom qoid (octoroon poUtit? Noo nirtut itnprouot drrortaliit, non tollicitautt rur%u ajrrarioa, noo que ret ur etpolaot ? M. veto An too rat non is rnt.td aucm omni moto eoocortot not ciirioro per It nctno tit alius nti n, qui una sant, nunc a|crte favrnt, |*rari
multi,

pmocrtim com booorom

practidia ditcea*<

ivmg J. Caatnr
Irtttt.
1

Um

right of nominating Use magi

For thw rfoarription of L ef Pkl. ei. 5. A rtcur was a k mU of light-arosed gladiator generally matched *ilh a mwrm- lm (mm to bom cf. o. I. p 276) ef. Aim. Idtf. 12: Quw tyrmOUmA C9mu*UiMmr mifuimmmmtt

flan*

350

philippic mi
perceive, Iajcius will be the

...

,6-18

dominant partner ; for the |atron of the d tribes, whose votes be took away by that law > of In umi he *harcd the office* with Gains Caesar; the patron of t! riet of Roman knight, whom alw wished to be without votes the natron of those that had been military tnbanr the patron of the ill be able to DCS up gainst Rschang

be

is

this

man's power, above

all

when he
00 the

shall

also planted these

V the tribes? the Roman v tribunes? knights? th< Do you imagine the power of the Gracchi was greater than gladiators will be? whom I 1*1*1 railed a glrwhetor, not in the sense to which Marcus A is often so called, but in the sense of those that* speak plain Latin. He fought in Asia as a myro ing dressed up a comrade and friend in the trappings of a Tbrseisi it th*t retrhed man's t at he as flying, but received htsasrlf, a tidy wound, as a scar shows. If he cut a throat, ht will btj do. hen he gets the chance, to an enemy ? If he did that for sport, what do yon Will he not think he will do for the sake of loot? * 11 place rascal on thr jury-panels? ill he not again canvass those hungry lot land; ill he not ul those evicted? But as to Marcus Antotiius, ill he not be the man to whom in every commotion rushes a throng of profligate dtixens? it u no one else but those now bt granted ith him, and those that here openly support will these not be numerous enough, especially heen upporters among hour dispersed, while hit ill be in attendance on his
clients
land.
all

same

Ham

35t

M\l<t
illi

UUS
tie

ti

paraU tint ad notam futuri ? Bf hoe tempore ronsilio Upd ertmot,

:>

mult* nobis ease vidrantur.

Kee ego
brllum

(wrrtn nolo, ted pacts nomine brllum iu%>lutum re-

Quarc,
eat
;

pare

frul

volumnt,

si

be 1 1 am omtttimaa, pace

nomquam

Nil
in

Ral aotem tc atrl enoaJHl, patrea conac H pti,

longtsaimc provftdcee.
Ideirco In
sti>

pottenm qoam

hae custodia et ta
uti

mqua m

specula coolocaU

vacuum metu popnlum Kumanum nuatr loapkkn tla reddercmua. Turpe

orbs terrae, praeaartaaj
itasn.

rifflla

&

luliae, eoa duces, eo* eseteitaa, ut nullam eal

Utnn

ret publlea aeelprre poaalt tine culpa srnatut.

Kquidcm non deero ; moncbo, pracdiean>

c|uul

cntum, nee

and in principe ehrl non eat

aatfo.

mras,

rigiUntiamque praestabo.
21

VIII.

DM

c!r

|>rricu)o?
;

qutticm poase

parem de hoc extrcmum est.

ie potest

tribns enim,

doeebo ne coafpenUri quae proposal,

Antonio primam cam qui bus ricimim eoa
ille

pax eaae
juts

II.

senatu

quo ore eoa

ille poterit,

ilium oculis

vest rum ilium, quern 10

vestrum non oderit?

35*

Age, rot

solum et vos

rmumc n
\

%i

is-....

For my part. I am afraid that, if today there be a j iui%ukr in oar counsels, in a short time they ill appear too many for us. I do not h the name of refute peace, but jijov pence I drrad mu h war we shall pence we matt wage ar enjoy peace. -or task, Cnnacrlpt Fathers, sitting hem in council to provide for the future nt far head at poaaiblc. It ia for that rraaon we have bens potted on guard here in t' that by our vigilance and fore di%Km.rful that peopfc the world's supreme deliberative liody thou Id, e| N ally in to patent a ease, be understood to ha%c U.lci nod
?

haJI

the Roman people, tueh agreement of Italy, tnch h aiinlit, that coalman* offer any cal thnnt the fault of tl II warn, predict, For my part, I aliall not denounce, call e*er 01 '.ueaa my II not only guarantee my good faith, l.i. prrluipa may teem enougl, hut in a leading citisua It not enough 1 will guarantee my
I I
I

i.

ountel,

and

rigilaaoa.
;

VIII

(nan

spoken of the danger

will

how
the

that |eace cannot f my three prop"

for this it
m

What peace can

linoi hfarcmt

th-

the

firtt

place, be-

A ah Antoniut ami what a%pect can he regard you? With hat eye can yon in your turn regard him ? Who of you not hate him? whom of you will *te ? Come, it it only he who hates y ou, and you him ?
I.

353

IfP.QAQY

U
>

II

l.UVS
qui
VCStrss

quid

ii.

qui MttUottB rircemsedeat, qui la

Gallia

dilcctu

lukt.l,

te

fortune
tl

voUt runt aut %m ii< nt, mtci amqiuun ..cculta cnim .HUM amp! Qvi Antonio. ludiciumquc dc volunta* coram Uutmi Id jrraditxu Coororduc fttctcrant, qui DOi d l.lK-rUlr reraperandamemeiUverant. anna, saga, bcllum fUgttarerant, mr una com popolo Romai

rontkmem
urro
i|ui

vocairerant, hi
%rt

An toot am

diligent et

Mi

took?

quid ego dc onlvcrto popolo Romano dioaui ? pinto ac refcrto for bis mc una mente atquc voce in contiaocm rocsvit drcUratitqae mtiiimi

l.'crUU rccupcrandae ceptdiUtem.

opUbilc ante*, ut popolom haberemos, none habemus duccm. ipct , qui Mutuum circutmcdcnt, imprratorcm populi
inqoc oppugnant,
lis

Km

lUqoc fat sis comltem Quae ctt %

paccm

popolo Romano esse posse t An com osonicipiit pax erit, quorum UnU ttudia cognoecuiitur m
ctis (aciendis, militibe* dandia,
.

singulis oppidis curiam

>

pecom popoH Roman!

non drsidercti*

Laudandi sunt ci huios ordinis

sentcntia Firmani, qui principes pecuniae pollicen-

dae fur runt ; respondendum honorioce est Marrucinls, qui ignominia notandos censocrant cos, si tani subtcrfugisscnL liaec iam tota Italia neat in cum ilia Magna pax Antonio cum Quae
i

i.e.

taers iti

Pari is sisa l

m Try

354

PHILIPPIC
tie

rra.

ji- J3

levies in (iaul,th'

knights ? for their frrlmgs and opinion the of Antonio* have been unrepealed ! The men who in denaeat rank took their aUnd on the atepa of Concord ; who called on as to recover our liberty ; who r tary en who
i

m Roman
il* t

beaiegers of Mutina, those Out held your fortunca,ever be jour

.
I

or

>r

ill tir

uke

to his

arms

people to a public meeting will tlteae Men love Antonios, and ill Antoniut keep a |caec with these ? *t am I to say of the entire Roman pe. who a full and a packed forum with one mind and voice txr tutmnoncd me to eddrc*% them, and !.!* rty > displayed the utmost desire to red So, whereas aforetime to have the Roman people on our aide was the object of our prayers, we now What hope then U thorn have them aa leaders. of any possible pence between the Roman people and the besiegers of Mutina, the men who attack a general and army of the Itoman people" Will the boroughs, whose great re be peace with isiaam it recognised in the making of decrees, the supply of soldiers, and the promises of m so that in each several town you do not to find a Senate of the Roman pcopl* people of Finnium should be commended by resolutions of this our body they led the way in promising money ; we ought to acknowledge a honour the conduct of the Man-unmans, who tcrminrd that those should be branded with ignominy

the

Boman

'

who evaded

military

service.

These things

rill

soon be dnr all over Italy. Great will be pence between Antomus and these men, bet

355

MARCUS TULUU8 CICEtO

MM

nullo parte

point

et

mm**
ubi

uli rim,

conaulto cohUimUtc

d t bcaeaa, poterUnc
>

om

Antoniu%>

Quid r^

Caceari, qui illue* erbe. wild?

15 D. Brute, qui Gallia probibeit

plarabtt et Icniet

lam

wo

ipee et

proWncia* Galilee, a qua capeloca

rtdebiU.

repudiates
cripti,

4? Ownlt

pttm
plena

coo*
die-

nU

pfocptdllt, plena odtocum,

cocdurutn. et qulbua oduntur belU driile.

r,

Nellie

.{uod fieri
*

hoq

potest, et eevete, per

deot immocUles
peris

patrce eooatnpU, oe ape praaecatto

26

perpetuam pace amitUUe IX Quo-sum baec eeanie epeetat oratlo? quid enim Irgali rerrtnt, rxmdutnacimoa. At veto exdtati, erecti, purati, armati animb late eaae debemut, ne blanda aut tepplici oraUooe ant aequitatis ahnalatione fallamur. Omnia fecerit oportet, quae mtertli denentiata sunt, prieequam aJiqoid postulet, Brutum excrcitumgue ciusoppognere, eriea et agroa prn rineiaa Galliae popuUrt deititerit, ad Brutum adeundl legatis potcstatem frcerit, eiercitum eitra flu men Rubiconem eduxerit nee propius urbcm milta pussuum duccuta
-

J56

mnimc
!

mi vm

.-3

t6

do ad Anton? What greater discord can bo? and In discord peace between citisens cannot an? bow exist. To tar nothing of the man?,
there

there

it

Lucius Visidius, a

Roman

knight, a

man

and honourably and as a bote wntrh and ward

>

m;

lie consulship hours to become

:

Bated

them with
say.

hit

ova

man,

whom we

should

by decree of the Senate, can A e?er be reconciled i or to Cams Caeaar who kepi * or to Decimal Brutus who V him from him oat of Gael? Ob. bet will be himself the** bit anger, and show mere? to the province of Gaul U be has been cast out and repudiated ? fathers, ill see, scr. unless unlr** you sboi how You, Conscript Fathers, foresight, a world fall of hatreds, full of discords, not thru and worn these spring civil war-. sh for what cannot be, and Laic care in Heal name, Conscript Fathers, that you do not, in the hope of present peace, lose the peace that wi! i\ What is the object of my whole sp here ? for we do not yet know what the envoys have effected. But by now we ought to be aroused, alert, read?, armed in spirit, so as not to be beg bland or submissive reply, or by a pre forbidden mist concede all before be makes any demand ; cease to and bis army and to waste give kbi and tci i ttory of the Province of OasJ ajuoy t means of access to Brutus ; draw off army to this side of the river Rubicon, and not the city than two hundred

357

MARCUS TULLIUS CICERO

admovriit, fuerU rt in senatni at la papal*
potest* r
II.-.
,

-r* potrtaa aobts

senatu. nun parocrit. noa
111!

dr !.Ikt ^iidi
led
17
file

ri

tcnatat,

papain Roam no bellum ladUcnt

:

e r tp tl Sed vat rnoofo, patret tant

populi

liberta* ajritur

Roman i, quae

cat

commend* U

vobta, ?H
Infii

fortunac option ruioaqut, quo rupullUtcm

nw

rmmrfrt crodeliUtc lam pt ldtai Inteadtt

auctoctta*
vestra,

An-

toniut,

quam nullam

habebiUt,

obi nunc tcnueriU

el

quo aid plunmuto,

in

Umrn etiaav

magnh)

tasapesUtibut

anient),

hunc

tantum

pcaeelarum ne ad nJhllnm reeidere patiare. habea

talc,

quale

Tempaa nemo hahnU umquam.

rem p Qui but dc rebut

gravitate senatut, hoe itadk iqaunliai ordlnla, hoc

ardore |*>puli Roman! note In pcrpetuum

cam
refert, P.

'

(K-nculo liberate.

ScnriUo

35


philippic
If

vii

,6-27

of the Senate and he thai) do thU wr shall be natter afresh ; If hr shall prove to the Sonata, the Senate will not have he ill have declared it

the Roman people. Bat voo, Conscript Fathers,

it

remind of

this

what

thr librrtv of the Roman people, Inch been entrusted to your charfe ; the life and of against ! n hot long aimed an infinite avarice combined with montUoua cruelty ; your own authority which you will find destroyed unless yon maintain it now ; take heed yon do not let loose a savage and pestilent beast now you have him confined and chained. Yon personally, Pansa, I remind though voo need no counsel, for you are the surest of
at stake
is

mm,
often do receive advice in grent storms from passengers do not allow those resources, those magnifi resources that yon possess, to fall away to You have urh an opportunity as no one has had at thr anytime I p of thn firm at! Senate, this seal of the equestrian order, this eagerness of the Roman people, you ha% to free the State for all time from fear and' from peril, the motion submitted 1 agree with Publius Ser-

359

IsTHODUCnoS TO PHILIPPIC
TottAMIM thr rad of
!

VIII

JMMMiy III fjrnTOTI, PhillpfiM (S. SwiOlM having died), returned from their mission The latter, hating by the Senate*! complaisance to lending an embaatr net been treated as what he in fact was, a rebel, took advantage of this and prowiandi. These ere that lands be gi*en to ht troop, and that previously made by him nd H..UU II* be eoninned ; that all Um deereca baaed on Caaaar's parw-r %hoold ttand ; that there %hould be no enq uiry aa to Inn treasure tnkca from th< of ()pa. nor Into the eondoet of tl trim or divide landi between the that bit judicature law* shouhl | and that hit follower* should be granted In return he agreed to y iaalpinc Gaul In exchange for the Transalpine terni of ire jean, hla army being made op to six legiona oat of the troopa of l> Brutus In the meantlnni be refnaed to allow thr envoys to ei Mctina, and went on in their preaence to pre* the naeator Cot y la he sent to Rome to look afer

IWiod L

after In interests.

Cletro describe* theae term*

(est fas*.

in a letter to Caatlos

11

4) aj

he

stigmatises

at

"disgraceful

The Senate was convened by the Consul Pansa

3>

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC Mil

(Hirtius having to consider the

proceeded to
report.

In spite of which, Cicero tin la the

.

him M popW In a salutary of Antonlus were strong Too

be declared.
I*(i
i

L. of-ttto c*lln! 1. vl.,r

ii

iff

1)

rather then

W-j. en one*.

Thki

proposal wee supported by

by the eoNNl But a proposal of * Cicero teems not to hove taken a prominent m the drUte Hot on the ortt day he d
finally

Puu

|*rt

the eighth

fh.l., M

that there could not a tumult without a war, that cert thing sheared that a %Utc of war What waa too 000101 of too levies of existed the blockade of D. Brutut ? of the siege of Mutiua } of the operations of llirtius against A o too i us > of the garb of war to be asaomed on the morro os the filth civil war In hit time, but the first took place, not amid the quarrels of c it mem, but amid their unanimity. I le went on to speak of the thrr its ,,;' Antooim gainst the public safety, and expostulates with CaJenus for his obstinate adher to the cause of A n Ion i us under a specious plea for peace and the preservation of the lives of citisens. How long would he say he desired peace? As to the other consular* it was disgraceful in them to wish for a second em bossy. What would be toe ose of that when Antonius went on battering II The consular* had betrayed them. He proceeded to
1

He mid

8aa

a. I, p.

AM.

36a

ItODUCTJON TO

I'iHI II'IMC

VIII

diecaaa Aalooioi' arrogant dcmandi, and chided the or ooaac ottnf to report them, though

Btl ml ut by propotinjt an amnestr for all with Antooiut bo should lay down their arms before the 1Mb of March, and moved that anr bo after thia decree joined A ntoniu, except Lodoa Lid Varies CatjW, bit agent, should be deemed a
i

363

M.

TULLI ClCEROM>

is

M AN
CX
I

OBATlo nill.llTICA

lUtut tat

hm

mihi ritat at eat, qattrnt eedere on totca,

.m.

T .'.l,....,..r.r

arbitrarr nt or. tua voluntas la diiectaloae

fuit

ad lcniUtrm prape atmr.

ii|i1lilil
fuit
rtrt ,

Wueat igitur propter

rerbl atprrt Utem to auctoce noetra teateati*

,

qui rerbt alroettttt detapta

quam

aeateatia lealor.

Qatmqaaai

It

Idem feeerat me roaeele la sororit rlro, quod hoc tempore la tarorlt film writ, ut ororit moreretar et mJati popali Romaal ptorlderet. 1 Atque ipse

iU dixit, aliam rntrntiam

te ec re publics
tur.

Krpi

ille

se dictaram fuisee, eemqoi digaam, nbi propinquitatr in avunculus nam etiam rot araaeali
,

qui illiestUadiensi?

teootrorenU?
1

Belli

>

TbamoUMrof Aatoaia vae ato P. Unlulo. (Ufta aceond hutUnH

who

pot to death for kit bar* la fetilwanaaooaapiraoys el Pkd. u 7

Antonio),

wm

of Julia.

Um

mother of

Um

364

UK UGHTH I'HIUPPIC OF
CICERO A
iuii

M.

TULUUS

VNTONIUS

>>* ram Puin, than the purpose of jour eaUod far; yoo seemed torn to make little to whom you do ooi usually yield For when the Senate IukI showed iU acrostomed courage, and when all Mf there as, in (art, a state of ww, war" should certain persons thought thr word

nm

he withdrawn, in thr ditukm )<ur inclination as towards leniency So our notion was defeated at y our motanco because of the harshness of a word ; that of Lucius (arwar.a oat honourable man, pceva and yet, though the seventy of the expression was take bo woe more lenient in what he said than in hie vote. 1 before he gave bis ed himself by hi. relationship. 1 H had done in my consulship in the ease of hu sister s he same thing that he did now in the of hit sister's eon : he was moved by grief for at by core for the safety of the even Caesar himself in a way <1 yoo not to agree with him, in saying that he would have given a different vote, and one worthy of himself ami of the Stele, were In being hampered by his relationship. an uncle; are yoo also uncles who agreed with
1

him?
But in what did the controversy consist ? Some were urn tiling the word "war" should be inserted
36s

MARCUS TULUUS
ap|ir lUrc

" dum qutdam in aententia non puUbent, M tumultum

male bent
;

ijrnari oott

modo rental, ted etiam

est

vcrborum
3 sit.

rnim ease bellum, at tun tumullus ease tine bell noa potest Quid
potest

imultus ntti perturbetk Unta, ut major

timor malar? undc etiam t>omcn doctum cat tumul
tot.

lieque maiorcs aoatri tumultum ItaUcam,qoud IcratltaUac

tcm tumultum esee quern bellum hlne Intellect potest, quod bello vacations* talent, turoultu non ft lU fit, que ad modum dm. ut bellum tine tan Etcnim 4 pottit, tumultua tine bello caw non poariL

rum
eat

inter belluin

tumultum, si belli noa tit, tbturdittt din ut mulu de verb tmpti, quam qaidem intcllcyo verbo
d

fieri

interdam

NOlumut hoe belloro vidert Qaam Ik eicludendnm Antonium auctontatcm damus, quam, ui tine mulu, studio, volunUte, |uam, ut pecuniaa la rem publteam polliceantar ? Si enim be
II

munirtpits et eoloniit ad

tollrtur,

municipiorum stadia tollentur

ti

popoli Komant, qui iam descend it in eausam,

not

languetcimus, debilitetur neeette eat

1

Cf.

Th u
3 66

the definition of " tumult derivation (rosafiaMou

(well).

"

I'Hil
to Use

IPPH

Hi

I install ua ; they preferred the term "tumult. being ignorant, not merely of event*, but even of meaning of word for there can be war * oat a tumult : there can be do tumult without a war. 1 For hat else it a tumult than a confusion to great that grc* rises from it ? from which the wry word - tumult Accord.. to derived.* oar ancestor ealled a tumult that waa a doracetie tumult that waa on the borders of Italy "Gallic"; and gave the name to no ot that a tumult to More serious than a war can be understood from thto, that in a war coemptions from service art valid, in a tumult are invalid. Whence it comes, as 1 have said, that there can be a war without a tumult, bat no tumult withoat a war. For since betas ta war and peace there to no arnJdle term, a tumult to, if not part of war, nc i t ma nly part of peace; and what can be said or thooght of snore abaard than that I But I have about the phrase; let ui rather look he fact, Conscript Fathers, though I recognise that it to sometimes made worse by the ase of s
;
'

to be accoonted "a authority we are gn the colonics and boroaghs to shut oat Anton the authority to enrol soldiers without compulsion, fine, of thnr .n enthusiasm and goodwas? the aathority to promise contributions to the State? For if the name of war be done away
II

vT

do not wish

this

war "

What then

to this

the eathaatoam of the boroughs will be done away with the unanimity of the Roman people which now rected to your side must, if we falter, necessarily be weakened.
;

367

MAft

bcllum

II

IUS

Sed quid plurm

;

1).

Brutus oppo gnat

ctus I ttrma,
;

Mut.na,

wlonU

He hoc quidcm brllum

pax potest ran* ccrtk*
bcllum sssr

eat

Gallia vastatur

quae

lllud

veto quli potest

MH
am
voc

.}- re,

.um

<!

rn

psjfcH *r

c*\
esset

qukJrm Caesar xestrs drcreta, pf aimrts cos irUtii brllum contm Aotooiom mm
;
I

nun

PJSSooJI
belli

)r, r

]..

nij rtntn

!. |...i

BSOjfoSj erat
I

sutnn gcrrndi tempos si prsftinwlsssii

publico oppeessm nihil posse decern.

Erg

hostia

is,

cuius ptsBQifiliBi Uotssssi deicctt Htrtlus,

bos) est hostts, qol coosolt

orssotw nhstiHt, designs,

His hostilis vert) I

tum contolem oppognst, nee

belli, quae peulo ante ex collegac

Dried pracsidium, CUtcrna pot it u* ion commissam, ocdsJ aliquot." Quae pax potest esse major > u lulu D
fugati cquitea, pcoeliuSB

decreti sublatis vacationftms

saga eras

consul se
7

cum pracsidio desccnsunim

esse d

It rum hoc bcllum non est an est tantom helium, quantum numquam fuit > Ceteris enim be II is, max* meque civi li but .con tent ioncm rr\ publicae causa farfchat
a

cum Sulpiciodc

iurc legum, quas per

vim Sulla

368

PHILIPPIC
to my there old and steadfast colony,
is

vill.

it.

5-7

being attacked

more? Decimus Brutus to 00 war; Mutiua, an

to being besieged: not even t tint war. Gen) u being smstedi uh.it pence can be More assured? Who can call that a war to which we have sent a consul, the bravest Mr though sick of a of men, with an arm?

when he was bring summoned to In the Stole. Cairn Caesar indeed did not for your decrees, es at that age he might have : he undertook war of his own motion against the time for decree had 1* arrived; but he saw that if he had let ilip the for weeing war, when the State was crushed 80 then they arid in pear || not tins has driven out of Qaterna ; he to not an enemy who to opposing in arms a consul, attacking a consul elect; nor are those words of hostility or war that Panes read from I hto colleague \ Icttrr': bet* driven out the gamton I hold Qaterna ; the cavalry have put to flight, a battle has taken place, some few |eace can be grea* nave be* '-motions Levies all over Italy have been dc< from service being withdrawn; military garb will be assumed to-morrow; the consul has said he will come down to the forum with a bodyguard. Is this not a war, or rather a war such as hss never l>een l>c!orr f lor in ot her wars, and es|ecijilly is some political question gave rise In civil to the quarrel. Sulla was at issue with Sulpicius on the validity of the laws which Sulla asserted
;
I I

Mm

369

\!..

US III

III ^

l<

KIIO

Uus

esse dicebat,

Qmm

cum Oct* dc

im Mifm^iit, runut cum Mario

miUU.

Quae ml

ijritur is

damkilta
sepulrhra
ltbrrua,

patriem drfendtmus;
id

mui
pu'

id

molitur.

pujroat,

ut

li

perturbel, evertat, praedem re* publics*

uu

pertiat (Mmcidis.

In hac
est,

Um

dttpari ration? belli

quod

tile

Utronibus

domoa (urbcro enim dieisurum se confirmat) omnibus portis, quo veliot, deducti ties, omnes Sesae ceterueque pe*tc, quae
Thena are iacideota in tba firat oril wee batweae anna end and Carbo, Um tea popalar leaders, aed 8o!la. Tba lav allodad I to tu 00a proposed in 88 Mi by ftulpieis*
Marios,
tba tribona for tba inelneiow (in tee interseta of tba popular party of ihc now iw Italian voters voun in tba old en "unwortby" wars tea leadera of the popalar party ; Um
,

"eminent men" wera Boast ori irrad by Mar. and Cm., and afterwards avenged by Salle.

37

mum

\i:

:i.

bad been carried by violence; Clnn* with OeUvius on the rote of the new eitisens; SulU a K *m with Marios and Cart against the tyranny <>! worthy, and to manish the moat ernel death of The casaes of all these wars sprang eminent men from a political qaarr do not care to apeak : I do not know Ha cau&<
detest

Mi

result.
is

the fifth ajrfl war that is hare fallen on oar own tunes first that has arisen, not amid civic variance and discord, bat amid the sjtmoat aniaon and marvellous All man bate the same wishes, the same concord. When I my thing to daft mi, the same feeling*. "all |* those whom no one deems worthy of eitiienship What then is the issue at stak * r l^tween us? We are defending the temples lie immortal Gods, our wall, our homes, and Use abodes of the Roman people, the altars, hearths, and the senaicbres of oar ancestors ; we ar m* oar laws, law-court, liberty, wives, child fatherland ; on the other side Mareu* is is striving and fighting to perturb and upset all ngs; that be may regard the plumi* State a reason for war; that he may partly
This
all

and partly disperse

In a war with tueh disparity of objects the most lamentable thing ts that he first prom ise s to his brigands oar bouses in Rome (for he assure them he ^hat he will U f*rrcl out tliv will. All the Cafos, from all the gates wl. all the Sasas, and the rest ei the pests that follow

Bai wsaa

J. Gwassr

aad Pompaias.

371

MARCUS TULUUS CICRBO

\.
|

^rlr,
ill.

riM

-T'1-.mv

**>

deianmt

AUivr cUam bomlm

pciadr pottos, tnaal

turn

trolo provebont

Mid

Mil pollkmtur.
EM

Quid o'
Id

>btm

nHaml
*-l

dm

pemM

Amfi
i

Cvltai dfao,

H**u

*r^m, palm

ctmicrtptt.

malt
rn.tn
hai

\ ul. rut.t

ItMMr temper
10 poJlicetor AatoaJaa.
hi

Quid ikm

meltor
r\
11%.
*

tque
<|tii

pPHMHll
***

maiocm. ni|ifi' ml

mrt libertatem to, itMi.cia.' Imperial orbit terrac, digntmlcm, pa mm, utlm poffi8tmr. Antoni
ct

aai Dromitiant

nottrts milKib*, Irgct.

ijritur

|.rnintma
invita,

crumU,

Uctra. rrlrr.U, du

bot..

ncc diutarn nee

nluUm,

itm
II

IV.

Ilicmil.1

arnicas vero, si

meui

Uudanda pax
?

non poatcin temper otlo ttudui

faccre
esset, turn praeci;

quod

dustria

met
D

tenerc potnime

C.
*

in

Of. 3.

%,mXk cb artioni - lattoraai

rfifflw

be daseribai elavvher* {md An. sir. 0) inimicimxmm" H U U Calaaaf axoUooed m a

Whom

".-*<

12.

37

raiuPHc

in

hi.

9 -i>

and pleasure grounds, eststes and All

are specifying for themselves the finest at Tusculun

they ere, and not miner b easts are borne alone by empty hopes as far as watering-places and Pnteoli. So Antonio* has something to promise his What have we? have we anything Heaven fbrfend 1 for our object is that be able to promise anything o/ the kind. 1 tpeak unwillingly, but 1 mi muit speak. Caesars au cti ons, Conscript 1 it hers, inspire many smrinclplsd men with FWpcet scions and auda for they hae seen mem become from beggars suddenlv rich ; and so those who threaten our goods, to whom Antooius promises everything, are always U liat have we? what are its to our soldiers? Much better and For the promise of what is criminal to those that espect and to promise; dertake to secure to liberty, law, rights, courts, the empire of the world, dignity, peace, quiet The promises there fore of Antooius are bloody, savage, criminal, hateful to gods and men, not lasting or salutary; ours, on the contrary, arc honesty upright, noble,

lull

of toy,

and

full 'of

patriotism.

IV At this point too Quintus Fufius, my brave and energetic friend, 1 reminds me of the advantages of peace. Just as though, if peace needed a panegyric, 1 could not compose one with equal propriety it but once I have defended peace ? h always aimed at quirt? which, useful as it is to all good men, is especially so to me. For what course without causes in the could my industry ha
!

373

rundura la regno petal

IS

temper
aoftebot;

prt*

quid le

Son, wk nn eUem de ill fcetanim de beluo poto%

I

toad em Intermit

(rorchuin InterfeeJt, cUre tolebot eomilio, mignitiulinr tumi ltberatom

eitis \irtutr,

rem po bit cam

8m b,
Tat

WCM^ink C mod. bhn eoaoml

older of the

2,

p 1.

in

re form*, Tbejr wore eeooeowreij trtbeattof too Coouoooo. P Scspto Kooico lod the ottock on too popalor portj in tat Cope 133 n-c., during which Tib. woo lUm, bat not by Noekoo

two Urootei. bote being m fovoer of ad remrdoH by tat Btntlirml port y ot oodillooo.

&&

bond.

374

raiuppif

mi

Mhuat
if I

Iswa, without la* -courts, things that

ukr sjsjnn pc* ask too, Calcnut.' what do you mean ? do 700 call eleven peace * Oar anccst or* indeed took op arm* not only to win freedom, but also emj you think our anna should be thrown away to make What jotter reason la there for tisfl a* slaves. waging of war than to repel slavery r a condition 1 filch, t hough yoor matter mar not be oppressi ve, ret It Is a wretrhrd thins; be should ha to be so If he wtlL Nay, other esoses are jutt, but
yoo
this la

But perhaps too think this does not apply to too be the partner of A n ton us' tyranny I Hasjsj too make s double mistake first, in preferring your own interests to thus
i ;

seeoodlr, in thinking thrre is anykingship. If it nroited you once. 1 it ill not al wars profit you. What k more, too osed to complain of Caesar, who

do you think you will do in wss s ass ease of s ts lid beast r And yon asy you are one who has always longed for peace, always wished Fine sentithst all citisens should live in safety. ments ! hot only if too mean good and useful and loyal citisens if yon wish for the ssfety of those that are by nature citisens, but by choice enemies,
i

wha'

cen you and

aa an old man lit in mr youth, a man of au t, was wont to assign to Publius Sasica, who slew lil nut Gracchus, 1 the primacy of all hit w-citisens; he thought that by Nasica s courage and prudence and greatness of mind the State had

them?

Your father indeed,

whom

375

MARCUS TUIXIUS
1

CICftftO

QottJ? 00tapatrtbatHMBal.tr U Ub4 rtr*. *i tawportbot Don prouorvtOT, qoia son owiiwt tslvM ntrrr at Ortmt emmvL On* 10 11 ir %m di

arbitraUtur

pin

<wL

rnwwi,
Num

mu

iacc

verbu,

lajtur

com.

temccwkMi craw

Ml ewd rl wi Hrtvn
P

ant Q. lie-

C Mario
eat
lit

Mm it 1 I miM iroa B*o CatUmam perire woloi. omnea aim rfa, Catilinan aUum Hoc intcreat, Caleoe, lot team: Ego oolo
1

ant

|Hjtat?

Nam
eaae

tu.

volufcati?

Tbaaa art laa tanoa of tba aawalorial dacraa favaaUog Opfamiaa, tba ooaaal of 121 it, fth dictatorial powtra ' araa coaoad by tba partiaam of of tba Tib Graocfcaa above aaa> Tba otbar paraooa rafarrad to vara aopportart of
Tbeae two lad a revolt
la

100 .&.
vaa,

aafaari

tba Capitol, and,

wara baaiagad

tbamok
376

PHILIPPIC
Liberated.

VIII.

rv.

13-v. 15

Well

uic we
So

received anr
that

pU from oar

father*.'

would

sve bees Approved In voer eyes, If you had \m those times, because he had 'not desired the of all thc citis e nsl Whereas Lucius Opi mi us al has spoken mi s matter touching the Senate mi that matter bu decreed that ptmms the consul should defend the Opimios supportf I Senate in words; Would eon then, if you had lived at . t, mice regarded him as a rash or cruel if Quints* hlctellus, whose four tons * or PubJins Lentulus, the lender ot Senate, and many other most distinguished who took op arma with Opimiut the consul and pi ma il Gracchus to the Aventine, an encount which Lentulot roceh ed a severe wound, and slain, and Marcus Fulvios the consular, Gracehns and his two young sons } Thoso men ore therefore to be abused, for they did not desire the aafcty of alleitmens. \ come to more recent exam plea. The Lot the defence of Urn State to Valerius the conauU Lucius of too commons, and Caius lie praetor were lain. On that day all the ft and, M. iii. 1 Uu.li.. Cot**, gomnlsi, and CraosJ Do you think that cither those took op arms. consult or thoso Illustrious men should be abused ? Did you who wish 1 desired the death of Catiline. for the safety of all wish that Catiliue should be There is this difference, Calenut, unpunished? OOtvossj your creed and mine: I am unwilling that any citisen should act so as to incur the penalty of
.

wm

Qmn

377

MARCUS TULUUS CICRRO

In eorpoce atrvandum potM quod rrlk}ito corporl noceat. Id
ut
ti

quid

eitts

modi

cat,

uri accariqor

mrmbrum
ik
;

aJiquod
is

potto*

qoam

totaun

tntrrcat;

uUum
16

tit,

nl publicae corpora ut q ukqnai eat p tot Ififoj, amputetur.

ilia

Dura voi
acelcrat

multo

durtor

Salet

tbv

Iclcantur inmiccntea, horu

toU

rrs

p*Uk*

Uao

lr *d use plot

ijOMimf.
i,

boa E40 P. Oodfcun

to

fatcur

arbitral r

ralum,
*\r

H
|

to contra
|

fjfi'.rtn,

If.r'- ru'.rttx,

fix

r i

rr

jr i.Ju Ml

ct

optandum.

In hoc uno to pi ortmo

tidiasc,

mc

quod mc tecum imrunde ajrrr. ita. Vcbemcntcr mc agerc fatcor, Ira Dcfo. Omnino Iraaci atnici* non tcmcrc aoleo, nc ti rocrrntur quidem. I taquc ainc verbuntm contumel
non eat
im.

Panra cot cnim mihi tecum ant parra dc re

go hole fare, tu
D. Bruto favco, tu

illi>

!mmo

vrro ego

M. Antonio; ego conaenrart eoloniam populi Roman cupio, to cxpugnari studca.

i

ponas, quibot innrmetor Brutus, melior

fiat

Qoousque cnlm dices pacem rdle

1

te

Antonius? Ret ger

Tab

ia,

of courw, bittar

37

rmi.iiTH
;

vim
even

if he has to acted, he be in the body am such to injure the rest of the body we suffer it to be n ot uhuJ sad cut out. that mom member, ra than the whole body, shook) perish ; to in the body State* to ensure the health of the whole it noxious be amputated. A harsh sa\ ra is harsher: the reprobate, the the disloyal, be saved ; let the inm* rent, the

m
i

joe think be spared.

that,

If there

the

com

thejrood.alltbcSute.be wiped ou: In of owe moo. Quint u r ufius, 1 con fern you
than
I.

him

1 deemed Publius Clodiu's a cnminaJ. lascivious, dialog 1. ilUtnoua; you, mi the contrary, thoi sot ie pt, reasonable, hmoeeot, modest, one to

dmm,

bo hoot and desired os o citlsen. That >n the of this mm moo you were very clear-sighted and

moeh

in error

allow
t

it that I am in the hah not so: 1 conic* I argue with ny the anger ; 1 am not at all wont be wroth lightly with frteods oven whea they So I coo dissent from you without without the greatest pain I with you a small one Do I merely favour this man, io favour Decimus Brutus, [ desire the preservation of a of the Roman people, you are anxious it should be reduced by storm. VI. Coo you deny this charge, who are interposing every delay whereby Brutus is weakened, Antooius made stronger > For how long, pray, will you my you wish peace ? War is being carried on is
;

379

MARCUS TUIXIUS
,1

art

E*oate*
J<i..fr

un**
cirttati

Atntiti

tatarftm

ok

arbrtror, qot ami

dvftetf.

Escogitara, que to* ratio ait, Ante* deterrrre te, oe r*rc nunc, at sis

la

All too MS& aara mm* 9 % word of unknown meaning naaaamlna with war. Editor prrvioaa to Balai road

(4mUia ia 48

a.c.

dadorod

(or

Poaipaim, aad was

radaoodby 3 So

PHILIPPIC

VIII. V i

7 -, 9

he

le

brought op face to face ; heavy We have sent three chief of Antonius has rejected ipt jet you remain thr of Antonio*. And indeed, the More Impartial Senator, he to be hit friend that Antonius, to him, appeared in court Mark hat love he ha for hi coon angry with the man, and jet, for hit country'
g.
;
;
I

w h en you ere to bitter against thr Qosnlsji ruies, I cannot listen to you with patience. How long will yon attack Mav U not war 1 ended even by a triumph in wln.li that city, without whoae help our ancestors Ae
far ear,

trium phed over the Transalpine tribes, was bon. csmgy On thet ocmainn the Roman people yroai although all seen had their private griefs for their as not a cititen that ries of this most faithful Sute no of his. Caesar himself, who had been very angry with them, ret because of the steadfastness and good faith of that community daily abated somewhat of hie anger ; to there no calamity by which so faithful a community can satiate yon ? Perhaps you ill say lam angry with you again ? But all I am tying to without anger, but not without pain of mind ; I think that no men to an enemy to that I cannot State who to e friend to this one of ours. discover, Calenos, what is your point of view. Formerly we could not deter rou from being a we cannot prevail on you by prayer to be e democrat

3i

MARc

it

MIS CICUO

Safe nolu cam Kufio c me Credo eatem. qui

feral eeOjOo

Ml

urn

ad relkjaae coaauUrc*.
dleo). qutn
alt

r%t (lure

hoc

meo

memm

babe*'

ronionetkmem

gratiac,

ipuhmm, alii r
aobK
coosuUnl*

nemo natU

Quam
i

hctcrttai

die
urn

inlut

legato*.*

"Quid.

rt

nulurtaa?"

at omlutqae

Uflatoraa

torment*

Mi
mfat*,
it

Ad bane
Sl mCfttias

legato
>

prrtimnrvtlt
tilt

a at coram reditu eehoaate legato* Eqaidcm

mm

decern! nor fiiaaitaatui, hoe

me Umen
*enatu.

conaolatiar,
el

quod, eaai
ilium dr
4
1)

el

Antonio contempt!

>nttrtiaenU|ac

aoo modo

Gaiba aoo dtarcaaaae. uti Mututa quid cm rcrcmima,

liruU conveoJeodi

aoa

futaae, foret

M An tool
dam
-

et areloa aed etiam maolentftam

aonerbUmque

peximua.

Utinam

Caesar valcrct, Scrviui

8oH*JmlnlUV4tUit

<

/m/^

OtaerMK. Ian

Who

had died oa taa ambaafe to A.

Fkii. ix. to

faaeral oration.

38

PH1UPPH

Mil.

19-vit.

>

enough with Fufius, and all wii bat DO word without pain. Hut I think that he, bo bat calmly borne the complaint of his sonill bear that of a friend. Ml 1 come to the rr he consular*, of wh am there la none I have the right to say this that a not bound to me by some tie of gratitude, soma by the err teat, others by slighter ties, no man
.

hat d iahoojQPf did yesterdav dawn upon us us consular Knvova a second t. "Oh. bat what if be were to make a In the presence, before the very eyes, of the envoys be n o ow d iiJ Motina with his engines he showed bis works and siege-train to >ys; not for a ai oau a t , although the envoys were there, did the siege find a breathing space. Envoys to this man.1 Why? that on the envoys* return vou may be in greater panic? As for me, although 1 had voted againat an embassy before, vet I consoled nrv this reflection, that, whan thou after being rejected by Antonius with scorn, had rr turned, and reported to the Senate, not only that he bad not departed from Gaul in accordance with our decree, bat bad not even withdrawn from Mutina, and that they bad no opportunity ot approaching Brutus, we all of us would be inflamed hatred, and stirred with indignation, and would to the assistance of Dccimus Brutus with arms, and men. But we have become even more Iter realising, not only the audarity and villainy of Marcus Aboi his insolence and
h
i

mean on

Would that Lucius Caesar wer< pride as well health, and that Servius Sulpicius * were alive this
!

5*S

MAIUVs
I

detent, detect*,
priocipibe*.

Initiate

Sed (aarpe Urn

deftllo,ad

Qttp

etiam ato adat a aaeapi nmL

Mil

lr.^mu^urUln
}

.UrttiUlMi
aa*ta no*

C. Pufaboa ap4 eaBtai at !

ilr

HtM

rr*

r .iwl.%%cl.

qim! Urtri

lIlllMlllltptll

utcaaqoe popoH H i; cJ qai nan perrt, mo ab co tuandaU mrlnlimti wilt, ted ipte est potiae 24 rrpodiaodaa. A ego ab co

popali

Romaoi tcneta probibente opaidr

!

At quae meodata! qua adrugantia, quo ftupore, quo tpiriu Cor autem cm legat ooatrfa d

latpaaaoa, King of 8yna,

who Had
Pop.

EfjT*.
>

1 no
tory to tao last
/***.

tot C.

to bid ai* tout

. a.

IN

PHILIPPIC

VIII

14

woo Id be dieted much

.t
I

better bj three

is

enndectcd by one.
it

.11

mt

ith grief rather than with insult:

we ere denied, deserted, Conscript Fathers, by 1 hare often said it in such an hour of leaders. Bet iN-nl all who shell record a just and courageous

The envoys should have they here brought fear though I me nonehowever good is the thee esprees of the sees to whom they were ems from whom they hare received eren wnnni Mil Yr .mmortal Gods! where Is the oldworld spirit of ear ancestors f When in the days of oer ancestors Cains Pontile! had been sent as envoy to King Aiitieehtts, 1 sad had in the words ot Alexandria the king began to waste time, and htm es he stood, and said lid report htm to the Senate if the km* did % intentions were before he stepped not rc|U% oet of that dreie. A noble action ! lor he had breeght wtth him the niiiossanotiiin of the Senate and the authority of the Roman people if a man does not obey that, we should not receive commands from him; rather should we reject trim, Wea I to receive commands from the man who was despising the command of the Senate ? or was I to nmsidir he had anything in common with the Senate forbade it, was Senate who, I besieging a general of the Roman people r
sneat will be consolers,

brought es conndeace

Bet what command*!

what

arrogance,

what

why iiMqpiiihw, what insolence, they sho did he give those rtmr**-** to oer envoys when he was sending os Cotyla, the ornament and bulwark
35

MAHCL.s
vero turn
foil

Ml

IIU8 CICERO
imam Antoni
At
to

aedUta,

U convtrio

cm
lorfta

tenri pabik-i

crddcrutit

quam

* rattan
**
I

'juw|

lilUt>:t
at

aCJvHlDoa,

COliOft

Addit

p tow

t,

DnUbrlU
2

Hie est

tomai H, qtiiboa daii Gubbhhm if* et LrooUnoa, quae

dcdcrtt ajroa,

atol

dao

n 8mm ret, quo* ccoturkma

intrr

piflMBU

rt

mtmonitn

Porta 1 t
rant.

et prmcterra, I

Qajid labocat, it htbttl qood eeepH, habet, qui tendtdit ? Id est, ne ai)itlMM tmgtiw rationea ad retur, ne fraud* fit aeptecnvtru, quod ucola hoc, credo, admonoit; vcrchatur
eat,

<

OpK

ne

amittrret

unUi

cilanttlai

Qa*erl

j.

m
4

%*J F

me Caul m1
Vi
5.

JaaotdooJa.

Aa to ito

lattar cf

i.

Pkti.
il

To wboaa

Im

had aariguad
,

feu*!*.

K. waa aa of

tfca

I. /*/. ti. 6

11.6.

jW

miumc
of bis friend, a

Mir

>

.-4

. t6
aedilr

man who had been an

at

he vat an acdile

the time when by ordernebtic slaves lashed turn nHfc tiionga But how mudeat are the commands
.'

made of iron, Consenpt Father "1 gur up both prodeny lino man anvth.ng he an, resign my army I 1 do not O toaonu a pen te station." These sn
BMitt be
1 !

We

bo teems to be coming to hit sense Hut forget everything: I desire reconciliation what docs be ad<! <*i give rewards and land to my oil legions, to my cat airy, and to the praetorian cohort He r\m demand rr*anls r turn for whom it woo Id be excessive impudence demand a pardon He adds besides : ** That the doner* Ol thr Umi. ulnrh he hm>%< ll and l>..UI N -lla gave should eooUnoe in possession' ; that If to say, the Campaniao and Leontine Undo, both of which our anroston deemed oor store-booses of corn. I\ \ Me provides lor mimes, gamblers, and pimps he prov ides even for Cafo and Sasa, pugnacious snd
! I

b iwnv coutuilona whom he has posted amid Ins Innal. He demands herd rA of mimes, male and female. besides that his own and his colleagues d< so contained to writings and note-books should e anxious that each purchaser should retain what he bought if he the seller " And that the accounts in si the price ? that nJe of Ops shall not be Interfered with to, that seven hundred million of sesterces should not sentemvirs shall not be .rula, I fancv, was the he was perhaps afraid of losing so inspire r of tin He also wishes to provide many eJseeis1
;
:

37

"

MARCUS TULUU8
volt
lit,

oi

Mem

eiat,

17 lliwllllllll

Mustctae et Tlroni

iUm>
?

Sed quid

est. q.

iwMlst eokm, a*

ma

lodieian*

le

(>U,

Ljstads,

Cori

et

ea D. Bmti

_M
(tat est ut

rim

qiMMMlM

mm)

iMi M).nlsssi tulit M Ipse M inqsit, " nyllntMl l

kind vrut
X.

lei Caesaria, et ta

tcU

Hwc

Gmvm

rl

in mandate, L. Po, et to, L. Philippe,

Sed, ut MUpieor, terror

rrmt quwiam, nee rot at legst!

apod ilium

foietto

nee

I MM

re rei poblieoe diirni-

Cf /TW.U.4; *.e.
li to these,
cf.

Whch w Ml by L MuaaUoi Reams /ML e. 2. <U>U.ntd.ml with hikheu C. eaea that A. wy levying " net ion* - (/* / .. AatonJe*. by peaking of Brutus and Ceeaiee aa

/til.

no

MM

ci

ssa l i. admit* that his brother would be detested in

3M

run
1

iiTH

xiii.

16-X.18

illegal acts they have taking care of Mustela and Tiro; 1 be does not trouble about himself; for what illegal art ha* hr ever committed ? has he rr handled public money, or killed a man, or kepi an armed guard ? Bet why should he be anxious about them? for he demand, 'that hit judicature law ahoold not be repealed It secure that, what hat he to apprehend ? is it the condsmealliiii of any one of his followers by Cydas,

Mt

train,

wlutnrr

He b

Lysssdes.orCuriusM H o u o ror , he dees not press us with be saak as a few abatements and
he ay, "Cisalpine Gaul, 1 demand her Gaul" 1 that b to say, be prefers to be undisturbed- with els legions," he says, "and those made op to strength out of Decimus Brutus' army " and wot only from hb own levies "and that be should bold the province so long as Marcus Brutes and Cains Caasaus bold provinces as consuls or prucomuls. By this man's style of election hb brother Cains for it year has already been defeated led that I myself shall hold my for 6ve years." But that the law of Caesar

md
.

bll acta.

X. Are these the commands to which you, I Pis, and yon, Lucius Phihppus,* as leading men could, I will not say reconcile your But, as I suspect, hearts, but evm lend your ears? there was a sort of panic, and you in hb presence were not like envoys or consular, and were unable to maintain your own dignity or that of the State. And yet somehow influenced, I imagine, by a certain
ivoys, mrisssias having died.

389

m
MBit
1
1

\i

ruixtus

cj<

no
j

ji.iiui, Tr}. (ju.i r^v

!:

.f

ti<m

ntmt*
qu.d

if

rtwtii.

Vobb M. A
*atfa popoll

tffbttt rlarUalmt

Romani. not

mm
i

leeat

M
Mia

turn

Cot/lee

wciiwui?
fait,

Cui oortae bates artaa naiim lot not rat. kale hoc
te

mpi

pats*

adttee la etnateta

Mr

hotel aa die
contra saam
t*

trntefitlat reatrat la eedieilloa et

Mil,
dl|c>

omnia

hale at etiam

O di

aaaaartalea, quae bmj

publiee tee* prtoctf

reeipe re legatem hottium, la eebtcalum *

da perieaia

ragllaalitb

Qaad

aaleai eat

ut Itbertas parata rleteri ett aut

mon
altrrum

propmita
rff

irto, quorum Jtrrum opUbite

ett.

nejao potest.
SO etorte prior.

Turpi* aateai fuga mortis omni ett

Nam Med
qu nodosa,

quidcat aoa eddoeor et

qui tuetdeant allealat eomtautiae, qui taborl eiu, qui eioi perpetuam
ease
public* adiuvanda

credam,

volonUtcm
l

et ten

pulo
id quideat

Roma no probari
(acerc

mo este

fcrant.

Omnes

debebames,

eaque

ma

ore

nostra*, ted etiam

erat ooo aoada apod noper tumrna \nu<

solarium, vigil are, adesse animo, temper aliquid

1

Sea

a. 1, p. 280.

390

PHILIPPIC

\lll

i.

tft-30

osophy, yms though It would be beyond kind of phil my power tat omul without bring unduly irate. To you Marco Antonius yielded nothing, tho yoo were mco of mark and envoys of toe Kotnan people ; but we what concession have we not made .ugh to Cotrta, 1 the envoy of Marcu by n gates of ibould not have been opened to him. yri tawi feMBpH v*.t* ojm-h to him; he bod a right of entrar. day be waa entering In Ma note- book your votes and e* crythinj yoo said ; even those who' bad tilled the highest oafcea were corrying lavour * ith him to the detriment of their d.*, immortal Ciodi wht a task it u to maintain part of a leader in public affairs! of one who should linga alone, but the \erv looks of stodr. n.
I

e at hot.

of enetntec. to admit
to

a private

rI

draw hhn

the mark of a man a his honour, but too moeh of hi dnnger. For, it we come ss the danger? awaiting for the it is either liberty death appointed for the \ajiqui*hcd x It to be prayed for, the other no man can But >sc Hight from death is worse than li For tin, indeed, I cannot 1* induced
aside,
Is

n vho

begrudge
;

so)

cad fastness, his exertions who take goodwill in asaMin^ the it ill that hi* r. tnoa State to approved by the Senate Mad <nly people. All of us ought to do that, has with our ancestors, but alto in n -lieat praise of contulars Uiat they M boon nt, showed presence of mind, and were always

one else*

his

.-.

39

MARCUS TfU.IL-S CICERO

tml.lir* ant coffiUre aat

patrea

common.

Q
rotidle.

bcllo Mr*co, letodioc.

Ulo bcllo rldit la lecto.

vaielt

la

curiam,
ut
loco,

nsH|N del Hum imJuttmrn

uniUrratttf

14.

quo.

aJtorioa

UboH
tpeai

JUL fUrtiim.

palm

eoaarrtpU,

can
1

la

liberUtu tetrooio pail aiaiin

taffreaal

aolettt. qua* rtfrttfcaft, qua eol quo* laborea liberaadi pop deli r mat f Equtdeai, hoc boaore uai togaU la* tutui taoM-n a tola catartaaae civibua la UnU atrocitale triupur b tanUqoe pertarbatiotv

publics* aoo diferre %r%tito

Noa eaa iu jfcriaN

boaurlt laalgnia,

bob hoc bcllo comuUrra, at aequo aotmo popolos

Romaoat visum *H
partial

ocotri

cum

e 110U1 Ita tinndi tint, ut omnem populi Roaiani bencBciorum aicaiofiaai abie ita a re publica avrr%i, ut tc boati f*cre |rac te frrant, lc-sto noatro ab A dcaprctot et iarkoi fa* tlr ajtiaataf, Irgatum Antnai tablevataa velinL Uunc eaim reditu ad Antoniuni proaiberi
in

cWic

PHILIPPIC

VIII.

x.

3 o-*i. 32

working tome how

of the State. I, Conscript Fathers, recall that Quintal Scaevola, toe augur during 'hough in extreme old age ami health, very day by sunrise gave an to ell that came to him ; nor did any man that war see him in bis bed ; and the feeble -mate-bouse. old soft was toe first to come That bis arti itv might be imitated by those whom It befttted would be my chief wbh. but next to it that they might not be jealous of another man's exertions. XI. For. Conscript Fathers, seeing that after six have catered upon toe hope of freedom, slavery longer than good and Uvea taken in war are wont to endurr it, fens rigtsB, what ansiclies, what labours for sake of the ItberatJosi of the Homan people should > As for myself, Conscript Fathers, led the omce 1 have filled MS) who bote nlled are eaueJIy in civil dress when the community is in military garb, 1 yet I hate determined at such s stem Use, and in the midst of such confusion of the State, not to differ in attire fmm you and the rest of * citiscnt. For we consular* have not liorne ourselves so well in this war that the Roman people will look with equanimity on the badges of our stat km, teeing that some of os are so timid as to have cost away all recollection of the Roman paOfaVf favours tow ards them; some are so disaffected towards the State as openly to display their partiality to the enemy, lightly to put up with the scorn and ridicule nlos has cast upon our envoys, and to wish For they said lie voy to be supported. not be prevented from returning to Antonius,
f
1

393

MARCUS TU.LIL'S CICEIO

uum

Variu,

wd ra I***.
pUx

(^obmiUrfMio: qui rum M \ni..i...

i

Mint. S ui ab *ut a pimm * J aut ad D. Bn aut ad >rtuu prtmaa adiertnt, it

c C

cm

M- Anfcowo nMftot
ni

9
tl
*i

cmmi

wwni,

<jaoa ri

C
**-

Pantm

Hirttet
-i

* *
-

;04

PHILIPPIC

VIII

xi

31-33

to receive him they

I

amended my
1
1

thnr VaHus to bit general, but 00 condition that he Hot to the rest, if they abandon to Borne. think their error aod are r econciled to the State, that a pardon sod an amnesty should be granted. For these reasons I propose as follow* 'hose ho are with Marcus Antonius, and who lay down their anna, and join before the Ides Cains Pans* or Aulas I ItrUtis, of March no
til aaent to
v 1
:

onsuls, or

Ifecimos
I -

Brutus, general, consal

elect, or Cains Caesar, propraetor,

by their having of those that are

be not preju-i Marcns Antonius. If sny wtt Marcus Antonius shall have performed any deed that seems worth? of honour or f' dm Pansa and Aulu% Hirtiui, the il. one or both o( them, if it shall teem good to ard the question of such honor If anv one the irst possible day. aAer this decree should set out to join Marcus

Antonim Lueim Variot excepted the Be nuts will regard bun a having aeted cootrary to the interests of the Su

Ooiy la.

'

strvoy.

395

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC
St'LTicit
least

IX

Rirrvs "the Roman friend of mortal mind/' a* Byron calls him 1 untimely death gave occasion t wing one of the most celebrated jurisU of antiquity, and in oratory inferior only to Cicero, whom, at a fellow pupil, be bad been trained Curnlc acdile in 69 and praetor in 65, in rhetoric. he held the comuUhij in 51 with ftlarccUttS, one of Caeaar bitterest opponents, whoae propoaal to deprive Caesar of bis command before his term was Having esbe successfully defeated. Caesar's cause in the civil war, he was 46, after the battle of Phanalia, Of Achaia. tu the first who handled Uw in As s a a scientific manner, and hit methodical treatment of It was followed by subsequent jurists, thong! the ttngs is to be actual ei Digest He is said to have led behind him as many as 180 treat. le was the writer of a well-known letter of eoninlinn I Cicero (sW /am 4. ft) on the death of the orator's daughter Tullia, the wife of Dolabella. m {Li/9, vol. II. p. 168) describes it "as s and, if due pee of the consolatory be made for the point of view, >t is worthy to be ranked with Cromwell's similar letter to Col. Walton on the death of his son st Marston

vu

Ck%id4

Ifaram

iv. 44.

397

INTI:

ION

TO PHIMPPI*

oeoaie In we debate in wojcb \ after the day arier the oar On me Un the eighth rnnllppie. the Conanl Panaa
ltd to the mewiorr at &%a)r*r.os (w*bo had embassy), and proposed for hkn a public Ad a fti'lt Oatue on the rostra. P. Senrltlus a tatue on the ground that for a tUtue to an embassador who had it not been killed while on an emhass* argued tnenintl -r an cat on was, not that Ut wa* rrKn! thr nifT of death, hot nether death had brought about bj the embassy. And be sh
'
i

~ picius t rrgfd to thr he: cspectation he had of smell the time he started, and at had been brought bv the embassy no leai than ambassadors who had Mr aid, nmraorer, that I --'.n tin* I la old would stand at a memorial to II tunc d lUtue He proceeded to utt n/ of Antonius. eologj on hb friend, and propo*ed a bronae pedestrian lie simplicity of Sulpictot would bare preferred, a public funeral, and the assignment of These a place of burial for him and his posterity proposals were carried*

39

M TULU CtCKRONIS
ORATIO PHI!
WIIUM, VI VIVO

IN U.

Ill

ANTON m
\

It

Nee

H
omotortl foUro*. aut

obit grata*

loom

rt

MS QOO 1

flfltrajO r-

WWi OVWDD
'.,

0* QOOmI
r*

WCW IWMI

m*W

toftUfti

od
tpifita,

s"

!"

Ir jttuone

mortem obmroot,

Qui com

ftto

adfecioa omet, ut,

rocoAAvit, c|oo

minos vol wtfcmo

opcni rn poblkae ferro potort, cijieriretur.

itincria,

luqoc

DOS

*n* 41) mp-k of mi momooo kaovUdga of toa Jm OMte mmIJm HmomW oThto cImcmm of Mpraaaioo aod
(oa*
:

Botes, oaa of Um and Janata of aattqait j. 8m Um I nir. to

this

mono. Cm.

Mi Of hi. MJ

PPIC

OF v
Gods,

iJUS
Conscript

CBBO

A
the
"

AMoMUS

immortal

ttt

now
I

to be returning thanks rather than devising

la

death

Nor do

doubt

that, if

for that grrat

man

to report on

nis return
PIsitfayaia
-nee

would nave been welcome

beneficial to the

State not that Lucius

failed in either

charge

teal or in so important a duty, so important a but, as Sereins Snlpicios was superior to

and Lacias r\so

and to all men in wisdom, his sudden removal from the mission left the whole embassy destitute and weakened. Bat if honour has been justly paid In death to any envov. In no man's case will it prove more just than Others who have died to that of Scrvias Salpietas. on an e m bassy have set out to confront the uncertain risks of life, bat without any fear of death ; Servios Solpicms set oat with some hope of reaching Marcus Although he Antonio*, srith none of returning. was in saeh a cooditkm as to distrust his strength on were added to ill health, he did shrink from trying even with his latest breath what Accordingly re be could render to the State. nor snow, nor lc neither the violence > of journey, nor roughness of the way, nor ggrava-

them

in age,

forgvte

tat be had said about

than in oh. 10 of the

401

IS TULLIUS CICERO
rrUnUiii,

cumqoe

ium

ad ed

uc hoc,
"
-

Pn*. prarrUrr. quod rt 'Milpu-ium rvliorUtui to et dc illiuft Uudc tli\UtL (Juibua

cu. nihil pmetrr too ton lie ilUmnm, nui P. Scnrilk>,cUriM4Muif 0v rcmpimdcmlam potnre

fu%*ct,

em*

belt pcriculoeto oUrrot

ted coueibum cl rorum. e quo ipm exempt*

4
II.

Ur Talemniut,

legato populi

res VcicoUnm, qoetteor Human* Fidcaia toUrcnut, quorum

ru.tru lotto* boaot; lit enim nutncet noU/ ob rem rmMtcom mortem obiernnt, pro brr%. iiutumam wnoriim reiki Co. OcUti,

cUn
*

vin et manj, qui

pnmtu

in

com

fomilinm,

Ftootea,

Toe foor
*

iiUiiion
of

colour. h/| m<Atr.\ to aval from put to aottk by lb* owo of Fiotoae

Roma

Tolamwos-i L< Consul 116 ml !U wa

It.u
Mfot to I6i a

M 434i.a

" by

to

AoOucat

kit* of 8rha. the grtamon of AotJotbo the OwK, tobaiieeetbyU king to * traaljr amda vita the

mii.iN'H
stayed hun. and when lie had got to and have perch with the man to boo be was sent, in the \cry inuKt of hit caret and thought* for the performance of hit charge he petted aAt then in other Instances, Gtlot Panta, to in this bare acted nobly both to exhorting ut to honour ind in having saul much and to bat praite. To bat you liave I ould mereW add my rote. did 1 not think 1 mr rote, ought to reply to to illustrious illu a man at Publius who bat giren bit opinion that this honour be owa ft nijd on no man that hat not been tlain by the sword on an embassy. Hut I, tether, interpret the feelings of our Cotstcrlnt tttttrt to tbc tente that they thought it was the cause of death, not it* particular character, that should be etamined For when the actual embatty had brought death to any man, they wished that a monument to him should be raited, that in art men might undertake the office of We should not, with greater boldnett. therefore, search for (weetdentt among our ancestort, but father examine what was that policy of theirs to which the actual precedents owe their Ml II Lot lolumnius, the king of the Veientines, nut to death at ridenae four ambattadora of the oman people, whose statues stood down to the It was a time of ror recollection on the rostra. 1 deterred honour; for to those that died in serrice of the State our ancestors, at a return tbortneta of life, gare an everlasting memorial, re on the rostra the statue of Cnaeus Octavius,* nan, who wat the fir
far at to

met

403

MARCUS TULUU8
vim
utaaai rid
ttirtimimk
I

aaraU.

alt.,

fww

taatm.

Nemo

trai

toriUU

In

lectio Octori, la qu* perirall upioio aaa ai beaut

Nam

laMMi
left profit (<

**M U

iatcrfecta*.

RrtldiU
nti^**

eK

d In

two viLa

t*^ tM* |^

Mid UnUr
Ckvio
et
I

ramfHae

totdo at

Sfv

AoUo

et

Folcteio,

la

morU,
I'uit.

md

p son MBfuU, qui est kpm son ob pabl icaa

m
S

obit* hotH>n
Ill

Itaaae,

\mtrrt

ceaarrlptJ,

.eio

caaas

mortem

ftttulU**t,

dolerem etjuidem Unt.

pis dabiut, quia ei

lejrtk>?

Secan eaim aie awrtem et tulit,

rrwiailiitt. aaa

qoain,

tl

aobtecaai

cum, orXimi
aoa

Alii

ide-

liariawque eaoJagto dtfigeatia riUre potaaaat

illr

can

vidcrrt, a) vaataat aaetarttaU

parafcatt,

" (M88). ahnftad K*yaar.

*aM

Ta*aarrwUoBii

PHILIPPIC
rich la gallant

IX.

it

.4 -hi. 6

bring a consuUhip into a family that was

mm.

No

m.x

grudged the

new saw

where the Senate to observe the feelings of been kings and free popalalioaa, and in particnlar to forbid the grandson of King Anttochus, the king who had waged war nth our ancestors, to maintain a icet and to rrar elephants, he was slain at Laodieea he gymnasium by a certain LcptJaea A statue wsa g silted him then lv our ancestors in return for the loss of hss life, to ennoble his descendant many years, and it remains now the sole record of so great a family. And yet in his case, and m those of Tullsa Clutius, and Lucius Rosctus, and gpertas Antios, and Cains Puleinius, who were slain by the kiag of the Veienttnes. it was not that death was accompanied by bloodshed, but the simple (art of death ia the public service that brought them
i
I

hie honour; none failed to pay homage But the embassy of Octaviut was one ae. larked no sus picion of danger; for having

honou r.
III.

Therefore, Conscript Fathers,

If

some

acci.i

I should indeed grieve that the State bed suffered so great a ound. but should bold that his death deserved the honour, not of a monument, hut of public mourning Hut as it is, who doubts that it was the embassy, and g else, that robbed him of For he took death out with him tad thin, hid he remained with as, he might have avoided bv his own care, and by the attention o( his excellent son and most faithful wife, Hut seeing as be did that, if be did not obey your commission, he would be unlike himself, bat that, if he obeyed, the coro-

bad caused the death

us Sulpieius,

4S

MARCUS TULLIUS CICUO

la
7

hae

advcnante peramrartt.

Cetatcaai

\..v

l^i'ur fn^i%

I.#-|i'.JMr'.

(><t*>iutn tire

rtmSer.

Hum

re*

eo,

qnos

modo nominal,
;

quant

Solpiciuro

orcidit

Antonfta*

It

calm

profecto

Unlit, qui

cans* mortis fuiL

QuoHrca

DOfltcrlUtk trmirrfci
estare,

pertioere arbitror

quod fnerit d hoc bello iedicieai senatns; rnim sUtna Ipsa testis be! urn 1MB grre futon,
I

Mti mirritus hooori ut lr k

I

memoeiam eonsecatas
Ser.
Sulpici,

tit

IV. Quodsi
eonscripti,

etcajationem
reltnquetur,

patres

obcundac rccocdari voJueritiftj quin bonore Mortal, quam vito iniuriam feci m us, sarciatnot. Vol enim,
legstioots

nulla dubiUtio

patres eonscripti (grave

dido

est,

sed d trend urn

406

PHILIPPIC

IX.

in. 6-ir.

behalf of the State would be he ehose at an important crisis of the State to die rather than to seem not t assisted the Suic to the utmost of hit power. Ii many dtic* on hi journey he had the opportunit of recruiting and caring for his health. There werl were of hospitality, at benttu- the dignity a/ to eminent a man, and the solicitation of those sent with him that he should take rest and cumult hu health But he, burning, hast. in hit desire to fulfil yonr romm severed, while thwarted by disease, in tin* iteadlatt purpose. On kit arrival Antoniot was much disturbed that laid upon him by your command had ti the instance and on the opinion of Serrius !*lp*rias. and he displayed his hatred of too Senate by insolent delight at the death of the
fatal to hit Ufa,

MB 00

adttscr of I-rptinrv therefore, did nut king of thr \ eientines the

kill

Octatius, nor the

mentioned, more
;

mlr than Antonius

the

killed Serrios Sulpieius

for

that was the cause of death also Wherefore I think it alto concerns the it of posterity that it should be clearly manifested what as the judgmo Senate be a witness on this war; for the statu that the war was so serious that the death of an eovoT won a memorial of honour. IV. But if yon are willing to call to mind, ( lot made Fathers, the etcuv >t lor declining the embassy no doubt will be left that we should repair by honour to the dead the injury on the living. For you, CoBtcript it a heavy charge to make, yet I must Fall

man

407

MARCUS TULLIUS CICEIO

Ml *
la

qnKlrm cradetc' fu*tU (qukl baac octltncm anavealt >). ted.

t gwliuli

VCf#

mi ladkaraart , de eotetitu diliritMa Ut CCfMlt COaOTtatlO |fT**lof InMMBC

MMMI

ire
ftlittm

dldieft*

mrtjuc cdoilt

atqi.

est,

tttSC MttC at

%!

u'.Ttjur liottrutti rrJrrr rojjr lut u r

wgnltadhri aatai ortkbqur grstttaU, com quidei

111

ma&taM Uade

rt grBtuUtJone otar.

If
f|ui

IU locatas
ormtio
10

est,

ut

omen
;

fsti viderctur.

V. Rcddite igitur, patres conscript!, el

drmistit

vita

eaim mortooran
Pcrncite, ot
if iiriii >r ?
1 1

in

viUm, memoria
insctf
i

cui

est

potiU vtrorom.
Mi'rt'" r

is,
it

quern vas
li*lx*%t

ad
li

tTiiM%t*N

rui

Col

si

sUtusm

la rostris decreto vestro sUtucntis,

PHII IPPH

IV

iv.

S-v. io

repeat, deprived Senilis Sulpiclus too saw him urging the excuse of illness rather be hie looks then be his words, though you ere not cruelfor what charge is less |
1

make it you,
life.

of

When

cable to this body. vrt. in r-. U r execution that there wea nothing impossible of accomplishment by d isdocn, you the more urgently sit eseoscs and compelled the man who lOfarded your unanimous opinion at of Hues* weight to aire hit decision. But when there wee added an rshorUtion of the Consul Panea, than Scrvios Solpicius could list then at last be took roe and hU son sulc. words which told us that red to aothort!? before hie own life. We, in i o< hts virtue, did not venture to op|ioee his reaolution on, a man of singular filial rifti ejection, wee moved ; ami nr sorrow did not fall onset of his sni ul l on : but each of oe wee forced to yield to bit greatneee of mind end to his impressive words, when amidst the fullest praises and congratolatiooe of all of promised to peri your wishes, and not to rim Use danger attaching to the proposal of which he had been the aol On toe nest morning we cecorted him on his departore as be hastened to fulfil your t ommands and when be parted from us he spoke to me in words that sc mt d ominous of his fate. naetore to him, therefore, Conscript Fathers, the dead the life you have taken away ; for t sure that the U set tn'the memory of tl> man whom ignomntlv sou sent to his death shall win immortality at soar hands If by your decree yon erect bis statue on the rostra, no forgetfulnem
i

409

m %m

m
cd

if

in

en

ho
crlt prarrlari-

Ser. SvlptH

viu multU

atqoc

it

me

ic

clot to legitjot tnteqirrtcj

fK

ttc

em, qoar

pro-

e lr*ibu rt b lure drill, temp*

laciuUlcm aoqoHatemqoc referchct oeooc inrtituerc

Ergo hoc stetoec moolmcato noo eget, habet

maiora.
ertt,
I

alia

calm stale* mortis honcctcc tncUi 01c mgmnrlc vitee glorioeee, ct hoc magic
lace
grali cite oe

qeam cUn >m futumoi

patri

IS

Multom etiam

raliiiese

cd

booorcn

ptctae

MM

rklebitar; qui

quemqoem cdmctac

loetc
si

noo
EBt

adect, tcaccii

dc coimcU

cccc dtbrtit, at

adrssct

nemo umquam umoi tihi mortem magic dolucnt, qucm illc macret patric Et qunJcm etiam cd femam Ser. Sulpid
Est utcm iu d fret us, at

410

PHILIPPIC

IX.

v.

io-ia

of posterity will cloud the memory of his embassy, n all other respects the life of Serviiu Sulj have been commended to the recollection of II own by many splendid memorials. Ever will the ennoble his dignity, stead riniiinit care |r. and honour, and bfts ami Mi pre-eminent eOTC and urodeaee in the safeguarding of oof Sutr. Nor ill there be anreeorded an an admirable and marvel-

ChI

like

knowledge

in

the

intcr-

%, and the development of the of equity. All men of every age who in

U*\c onderstood jurisprudence, were Into one place, would not be comparable Sulpicios. For be was no greater as a ami thus master of jurisprudence than of juti bo always referred |* or boons derived from statutes and from the civil law to a standard of lenic and equity ; nor did he seek to set actions rather than to do away with controversy.
ly
i

be requires not this memorial of a stat For this statue w>: other greater ones sss to his honourable death, those will recall
.

so that this

monument

will rather

the gratitude of the Senate than to the celebrity of the man. It will appear, too, that in honouring the fat In r r | n much influenced by the affectionate devotion of the son, for although." broken down by grief, he is not present, yon ought to be in the But he is so Some mind as If be were present
It more grief for an ove rcooi r only son's death than he shows for a father's. And Indeed it Is also a matter. I think, that concerns the reputation of the son of Servius Sulpicius that 4i

TUU.

eUrin* See. StlpieMi re I toouere pots*

*rtut...

romUntUe, plcUUt, IngenM

vestro ut mill-

future, rt

em

I
civiimi
1

ooloeein

et

4 moniroenti

minuet et

lenlet.

At que tunc

mram
piliNti
lion

teatoatUa, litres con*<

mmm
Ml

at,

yd

nyilifcfMi
irf,
.it,

!''

lii\ti

Smm
epulturae.

*
f

mor

lejreti

rise cmede fttqur

qui matinot haberi potest mortoo? Sin id trite See. Sulpicio, quod noo est datura Co. OcUeio, cur, quod 11 datum est, huic danduui
moltis drereverunt, sepulchre paueit.
intcrcunt

Sed

tempestnte,
1

vi,

eetuttate tepuletiroruai

Sm

n.2.

p. 408.

4ii

PHILIPPIC

IX. v

,,-v

be shoa ld be seen to have secured for hit father his doe honour. And yet no brighter mon ument could
Servias Sulpicius ha likeness of his own character, hi virtues, steadfastness, affection, ami Kn,Ju% -than that *n. *li.sc tfrirt' '*' be alleviated ly this honour as by no console

\l I., at I recall the many eonversatiom had itf Scnrios Sulpicius in thr course of our friendship, it seem* that a bronse statue, and one on mot, ill. if therr Ik- any consciousness in death, be more pleasing to him than a gilt and equestrian mm Mil as was flrst vet up for Loch Sulla Serriua bad a wonderful liking for the modemof our ancestors and censured the indulgence of lrraent agr A if, therefore, I were consulting him as to hit wish, I propose, following as it were his authority and wishes, a bronse statue on foot, which Indeed, as being a memorial of honour, will lessen and assuage the great grief and regret of
I
.

And this proposal of mine, Conscript nere**arilv endorsed by the proposal of Puliliu* Bill All, h^r opinion has Ihtii tliat nilpicius. funeral shu Id br d-ereed to all

citmeoa.
era,
Is

not a statue. For if the death of an ambassador os)t bloodshed and violence call for no uooonr, does he propose the honour of a public funeral, our that can be paid to a dead 3 slpicins what was man ? But if hr grant to ot given to Pnacas Octavius' why does he disagree that what was given to him should also be given indeed decreed statues Our ar Jpicius * But statues perish iic funerals to few. to 11 her, violence, and age ; of sepulchres the
it

4t3

MARCUS TU1X1U8 CICERO

to
tll<>\rr.

Imo
\

tolo
.?,

est.

Mod null*
lit

wi

Hr.ji.r

*\r >c

jt

Al<|l|r

jpjuntur, tk*

u palcbra miibIIhh
Igitar
tsto

font
It

\ur*ior
nulla

bonor eti*ai

Hi

Ml QuuobrtttUcfMco: -Co Sot. Mpteiai Q. LeionU Rata

f.

dMfeO-

Ibno rti pabhcac trtnpore grsvl

dfrcU riUe
M.

Urn

viUm
Id

Wmkmw hunmbdmrgiic qui ncpe mgao nwi rvi pMkM %iuc fucnt
ct privatos r 16

Ult*%irobrcnjpobUowninlr K tionf roorUmobierit,

>

As burta*

km

mm mtnUA by

riu.

rite*

vera performs! a eorow

wu i wrrfy 1.
ift

sot wputau.
of
life,

ot iiiJmhHiii. bt

tm

migrtcoo

tall

44

PHILIPPIC
it

IX.
toil, 1
;

,6

which cannot be moved and to, while other come to mi end, aepoicbrcs become more sanctified
id

the very

bv violence

Therefore let him alto, to whom do tribute can be paid that is undeacrved, be dignified by this honour; let us show oar gratitudV the death of the man to whom we now pay no other tribute of gratitude. Let there be also branded with shame the accursed of Marcos Antonius, now waging a wicked If these honours are conferred on Servius %ipsrsm, the record of the embassy that has been repudiated and rejected by Antonius will remain
o? these reasons
I

propose as follows

Where* Serving Sulpicius Rufus, the son of Quintu. of the I cmomaii tiil>c, in a most dif!
of the State, although suffering from a serious malady, preferred the authority of ami the safety of the State to his own Mb, and struggled with the violence and sev ramp of of his malady in order to rea< Marcus Antonius wluthrr the Senate had sent him, and when he had very nearly reached vt his life overcome by the violence of his malady at a most serious crisis of the State, and his death has been in accordance with a life passed in the greatest purity and honour, in winch Servins Sulpicius was, both in a private sfci' and In office, often of great service to the State whereas so good a man met with death le ambassador in the service of the State U the pleasure of the Senate that, by the vote
crisis

415

MARCUS TULUU8 CICRIO

qae

lit

qolf>qu<- tubrre, qud it

owertt. caa|t

ob ft public* OK>r ImrHbi; utiq. Pk%*. A I lifting comikl, her ambotr, u tfaWur qoilnrlbm orb im|^ oHca4acttar**4r<

(Mm

to b**i

it

MM

HHWRHN

OTDW1HW

i4k Haft* IU A menu*. it. ut lit oroomentis drrocori debet, ttnttaiii ccmcre tlqut c rt public* tibthmrc tadl ltt cianilc* adlrtJ, qaod dr funenba* hibcaat,

1 onU

HP

CHS VOTfTl.

CUIu g|it

dCPum
;!.

v#-u

i|u

in

IpH wlrln(ijr. |*nlrt tni*inta quo Ser. Salpiciaa faifrr

ri 'i*

%\r!

u'> JUm1

iurr |n;lill<c

(UtM
Tkk iImmtci Mill oUadmc I Um urn* of m tmrim (jwy, Hodrm. lopii oalinu * Tao rootr* *u a nMd platform ooinf Um Foma at Um foot of Um Capiinuao biQ. from wkka ibihbm to Um poopU *od to bo modo. Th pmUorm vmo kMonUotl with Um .hip.' \w+k ibofKo Um umbo) osaUrod from Annuo) io Um Uuo Wot ol
i

4*0

PHILIPPIC

IX. fft ,6-17

of their body, a bronse statue > on foot be erected to Servius Solpicins 00 the rostra, and that round that statue there be a sparr of five feet on all side reserved for hit children and descendants to view the fames and gladiatorial shows, because he has met hit death in the service of the State, and thai the reason thereof be inscribed upon pedestal; and that Cains Panta and Aulu* Hirtius, the consuls one or both, do, if it seem good to tl> order the city quaestors to let out the construe of the pedestal and fUtue, and n on the rostra and do sec that the contract -prio
*

|>|.n>|.r:A*rl

Md

|*ul

tlir

cut r.irti-r

And

whereat the Senate has ere now ihown iu auth in the public funeral of, and Ion conf on, brave men. it U the Senates pleasure the* Suliaeius 00 the day of his funeral be carried out with the most ample ceremony. And whereat
Servius Selpicius Rufus, the son of Quintus, the LtmonUn tnU-. has deserved to well of the Slate that he ought to be honoured with these distinctions, the Senate decreet, and cor. in the interest* of the State, that the curule acdiles to funerals * as regards tnspend their edict ap Rufus, the son of the funeral of and that I Quintus, o! the LemonUn tribe st, the consul, assign for the burin I a space of II the Campus fret in d rrctiont In thirty place at seems good to fa lilinos, or to receive the body of Senrios Sulpicius; and that be aim for his children and this burial- pUee desc endant* with the roundest title conferred by the

&

>

I for

a burial-plar.
Rsgalaiiag ths aspaoasa,

417

HTIODI

It)

PHILIPPIC

t* date of the tenth Philippic the position regard to the province* or Cisalpine Gaol, complies end Syria was eon plicated these prov-

had rwinectiveli aa^ped i. v J Caesar for tne Tear 43 to D. bVutui. M. Brutus, and C. Cassius, and bis disposition had been ratified by tl on March 18; but It was afterward repeat changed, whether by the Senate or by the their tribe*. The legal title was further confused by the senatorial decree on December 20, 44 ax., rcby the Senate annulled, or attempted to annul, previous appointments, and (with regard to Macedonia) by the fact that its assignment to C. Antonius repudiate /'*/. 10. 5), being made after (which nightfall, was actually illegal, Moreov* for the purpose* of hit argument, acknowledges {Phil IS) that Brutus had no legal right to Macedonia, nor It it, however, sufficient to say Cassias to Syria. ay hare been the strict rights here that
:

km

at the date o( the present

three of the | ri\al claimants: in Cisalpine provinces th Antonius, in Macedonia D. Brutus and Antonius, and in Syria C. Cassius M. Brutus and
I

and

U
^

Dolabella.

probably about the beginning of f Brutu had v'rnt to the Senate a dispAtch iiich he informed them of the state of affairs in Macedonia and Greece. "There the former proHortcnsius, bad acknowledged the

Some thne

March.

49

INTBODUCTION TO
brr Caiee

PI!

II

vat

cl os ely

Cicero' gall,

wee abet op in Apnllaeas, mmI the Legion after lagton Ul t tod Ma, and one of them went over to young Marcus who waa serving

For

p.lW-

When

thisdtt|>

the Conanl Panaa iauncdiatr Senate. The q ecaUoo be nropotr to them araa whether Brutus aboald be formally given the command in the provinces whi fact beld bl the ...ml Paaaa la his speech highlv praised tbe action of Hr utu%. bat, in bit aanal fashion, jecsa hit opinion int. and called apon Cain Calenaa advised lUt Brutes aboald be i ccanmand Qcero followed with the tenth After praising Panaa for his sf asks Calenaa why be araa perpetually dceUr. . *wj against the Hrutuses, and twtta him for never being Mr proceeded to pri able to tecare a support r the characterofM Brutus, and sai.1 bad Antooiu*. they .ould been for bis oppoaition to
I

*-

bare

loat

Macedonia and

would be either a retreat for M. Antonioa, or a tarting-groond for an invasion of Italy; that Antonioa march waa one of plunder and devastation, whereas Brains brought with htm security that the legums bad seen this; and that it was a vain fear that the rterans would be offended nothing could be done for fear of often rans, then it waa high time to eboose death ad of slavery. That M. Brutus with his arm? was a bulwark against the two Antoniosca, AccoroV *tc ought to confirm by a public decree wliat Brutus was doing by his private counsel.

INTBODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC X
Bfl therefore moved that M. Brutui should be toswntnd cd ; that he should retain his command, and be ordered to protect Macedonia, IlUrirum, and Greecr, vtth authority to levy public moneys and to make requiattioos ; sad that Hortensius should

of Macedonia until hit successor by the Senate, These proposals were

491

M
I

M
Ol^
\

W
ct tr

HrX'IMA

a^rrr dcbcmo, qui.

eivia, litterae

Mtm%itAy, PaMe, alalia* oaftoctet habere rum bodicmo dtr art-turn mm artatrareaaar. at M.

rt

qai

mm

BMJdmt.

rirtati

Iwridm.

ItMjM

nibl',

t antale CMjhlllCtM, Malta qaae cnia ipar aami part*

MM

de flip dldfdl Mint

oratiotaa.

Scdmihi,patr

; a qao ita aaepr diueti Uo, at Mt id quad Mffl MJMMB I vtdeatur perjietua lata loa ratio, Cmlent, qw t Quae Ml at numqiMtn post Kaiendaa Unuarias idem quod b, qui tr m

Ml ante mc

HMtW

MM

Q. Fata Calaaaa. taa fetaar to lav of taa Ooaaal Paaaa. Far tab r P"**P* at eallad aaaa ant. ti* chafe* baioc taa dfecrrUoa of ta conaal Tka aaaal

?Taa7!aaael

PiT

*"*

4>J

NIB TENTH PHILIPPIC OF

91

M.

TULUUS

INTONIU8

ought, P*naa, to feel and to express the gratitodc to too ; for. Although we did not bold a meeting of the Senate too received the letter of that citiaen, Marcus Brutus, too have a moment's delay to prevent too earliest opportunity of to great a oaoae of delight and OOPtiiUUtlun, This action of yours should be welcome to all, and eapecisilv the apoech too made when too had for too showed it to be true, road tbr so I have always felt, that no man grudges another's Accordingly I, It rooacloos of bit own. with Brutoa springs from very the closet friendship, need not say much of him ; for the part I had assumed Hut I lor myself row speech has anticipated. am compelled, Conscript Fathers, by the optl of the senator 1 who was called on before me to soy somewhat more; I dissent so often from him that I am already apprehensive that though notl my continual dissent of the kind nig! diminish our friend) "7., "or oo what principle, Calenos, with what purls it, that never since the Kalends of January fwossod oo opinion in agreement with bias who calls upon vou first? that the Senate bos never been so full that a single Senator
I

423

MAECUS Tt'UJUS CICRIO

sestot tttr
.

Cmw

cw te et *tta rt

ir U
foft una

tns ad

niihl

Qm)

est Ubi

en BrsUt bellum? nr
let,
14*

eos, ones

sllrntm to*
lll^ -

nnjULt

MMA

Ut rt M t
re*

KnO et

ft

tu*.

psblkse Qasern IgriUar. ena se pern it to, at de tribes Antenna digit " Di meliorm f " inqeiee. On Igitor no
ele? teal
till

Ut favca, eos UucU, qooran wmtlcra toum filium

oh

propones

coin et rei pobtlcae consnlr exempts sd tmiundum. Hoe rero Q. Kufi, eopio sine o great urn nostrse
Tss
fti

steam

tiiMiJ

sps isssseUwaijr Dss. sad U.

Brats*.

RmoLIFHC
yonr opi n ion
?

X.

i.

j-41.5

are you always win, win n your life ml tnrite yon to the enjoyment of ease end dignity, do yon Approve, propose, and sympathise nUil iBf sn ris inimical to genera) tranquillity and to roar own dijp>>' Forto aay'notlring of former matters this one thtng at leant, which causes me the greatest wonder, I will not pass over. What war is this yon wage agates! toe nVntonas > why do yon alone attonk those whom we all ought almost to re\ That one of tnem to bring besieged causes yon no trouble; the other too mrt bv vour proposal robbing of those foreea wbieh be of his own motion and at hie own risk, and with no asatoUnce, has got together lor toe protec tion of the State, not for his *W t i% >Hjr feeling, njfcnj vour moaj tool Own yon think til of the Brut use, well of the Ant. that t hose whom we all hold most dear yon hate r the rest hate most Utterly yon lover You have a most ample wnk of honour, a son who 1 hear ana hope to born to win emi> sham I wtoh well for the sake of the State, eenecssllr for roars. I ask then, would you r hira to be like Bn Brutus or like an Antonius ? lirce I allow yon to choose nnyou wtoh. "lira* en forbid !" you will say. v then do yon not support, not eulogise those will whom yon wtoh your son to resemble I then at the same time consult the interest of the State and %r\ before him examples for imitst But there to one point, Quintnt Fufius, on a without injury to our friendship, but as a Senator

Why

dosnndtng

Mm

nrn

unlike

loarwi

4^5

MABCUS TULUUS

HI

lUnc

tlbi

collijge

tc

\ikmcmtnm

mnkmum tetan

mitig, MMli

HroibaMt, qvlbat

Hm otertt, loqa

llhimiltn

Ao

veto hoc pro

<IUI

Quod

pClflMW MBDSflBSMflB OtScfWp OQDSMBi hoate nrttfn arbitror. uto. oeatpe

dim

MKMVB

cm, (^u> tedrre vertit et id re Rami igitur vu tradttzit

TU onfc to fan*** fond hi mm MHL

r7
forced

eritkMM.

"rifbtly and properly*;

flcismy

"At* H Wi<m Um k4 eh. 'rU * onKm

QU.

referred do

doabtooJ/tolh* toe c4lhlur.

4*6

Hill IITIC X.
nth you,
yon.
I

ii.

5-iu. 6

with to expostulate with

and that from a written draft elm I should imagine 70 bad made a slip for want of a word did I not know your readiness of speech) you said the letter of Brutus seemed !! and regularh What U this but the Brutus* secretary, not of Brutus? You hove by now, Calenus as you well may SSTBSCUu la State affairs. When have such a decree* or in wha rial
said,
1

You

of this kind they have been innumerable the Senate that letters have been inn > The phrase did not escape you, as by accident ; you brought it m it out and pondered. would purge you of this habit of carping at good men on most occasions, will you

* by

MM

^^^^.le* .*.,,...: Wh
for himr.*
-

gether,

and

at

ere fore pull yourse* length pecifv and compose your

of

mind

listen to

good men,

whom you

associate

with many ; converse with that wisest of men, your son In-Uw. oftener than with yourself then at length will you win a name of the' fullest distinction. Do yon really think it nothing here indeed, en grieve on having regard to our friends! your account that it should be wafted abroad, and h the ears of the Roman people, that the Senator who first gave his vote found no supporter ? k this ill also be the case to-day. Yon wish to withdraw the legions from Brutus. What legions? those, of course, ffhkfa lie H from aiding the crimes of Antonius, and on his You own authority transferred to the State.

4*7

MARCUS TULUUS
a re pabltra rrlrgataai
rtdert
,1,. ]r\
.

Vot trn, patrr* cntwrrtpU,

- r!
j -.

.., ,,,i. rurr :.

.->_< *_ _ - : tjc r:
.

M. Br
_,i_ ...

ijijrjn

g luxl'lt)

ijvrm

oraabtUa, cai farebUk? aarf focU

Am 6*
diriaa

km

li

!ni.

Ti UtiUin modrmtiooetn, UnUm la

et

iaJaria

tratM|uil!iUtrm

modnlUm
ten

aoa
ad
deft

malutt quaa praeaeaa

quuictn lode* pro

biai

qui

ae Apolliaarea
|>*

ma
qui

popoliqoc Bomaai digi

apparatus
IV.

priMWi

fecit,

ac quam rbua

QaMana

laetiorea

forrunt, qaaai

aaaqmn *ut lu<Ji cam te atogottt

aut dies

ee ral baa

popalat Romano aiaihao clamocr et plausa Bniti mctnoriam praaequebatur ? Corpus abcrat lil>er*tortt, UbcrUUs meaioria aderat ; la qua Bruii Uaago cera
1

Rata

prril of ihrtr lira*, to tear

Brataa ad taadat b*d baaa compcll* Ron fiaaUr. proU.

4*

riill.UTir X

in. 6-iv.

wish then that a second time be should appear a l if aw and sootar from the Sute. Bat yon* Crmscript Fathersif you abandon and betray Marcos Brutus, hat citiaen, 1 ask, will you whom will you countenn you think that those who set ma >>ead should be upheld, but aboltshed the title of king should be And here of the god-like and imespJoit of Brutus' I will my nothing in the grateful reinembranee of all, though not yet attested by public Good Heaven! what patience be showed, what
i

mmh

face of
left

wrong!

Mm

Though he was urban praetor he city; he held no courts, though he had and though for the SUtc all law
.

re been surrounded day by day by a of all good menand a wonderful thi

ml li\ the smlffnmrd ot followed him tlm wnole of Italy, he chose rather to be' defended by the opinion of good men in his absence than by their swords in his prrsen< Hd not even person the Apnllinarian games, which ualsbmts had been planned in a style befitting his own dignity and that a( the Roman people, lest he should open a way to the audacious attempts of the most atrocious criminals. what games or festivals were ever more joyous than when, in anawer to individual verses,4 the Roman people with the loudest shouts and he memory of Brutus? The of the liberator was absent, of the liberty was there ; and therein the very
r

4*9

MARCt
At

MJ
Coo

cUi pM*

Sedoao
nam auoad tot ornate hi lilNll 1MB patient
At mi
prati

pati vldit,

MM
m

ft

Ipae

Ij HI.
miiHihiih

mUUt!

eatm

l<tlW
*el rerepUctilum

tHlUIHBl

M
Italiaettrareia; qt

Brut,

pobo Antonio

M.
lUliae

BmU

Impetio.
el

a areata

auctoHtofce trndtt
;

mumqoc
abducit

ptarakHai polbceior

quod qoi

illo

ciemtum.

ct reapccta polcJv

16
>

S'. 1-4.

UtwaM

PuUott aad Noiaolk

Clc.

aW. mi

AIL

H h*.i. boM um oad of No*. 44 ic Ml Room to guioj .!. at Morodonfc, kka a*, bm Ukt ap um uk Um aovomaMot of ironna

In xhm ftrat Philtppk.

ollottod to

him

in

to. " r
tftla

W y< rU
to tab, aad

of

Nov.:

ef.

10.94.

TVt

li>U. to

tbu

I'HII.tl'PIC

iv.

8-^

of Brutes teemed to be visible. Bat during very days of the games I mw him on the of that most noble young man, Lucullut, bit mejrtintr, thinking of nothing but of peace ad of the concord of bit fcllow-citisens. I mw at Vd.a when be was departing luU that no oernatoa for civil war should trite on bit ecconnL Oh, what a sight was that, for men merely, but for the very >at from bit country her saviour be departing, that in bit country btt should remain! The Beet of Cassias days after, so that 1 was ashamed,
Fathers, to return to that city

whence

they were departing. But my purpose In foteiulng yon have heard at the beginning,1 and nave eJ wards learnt by tips Hence. Brutes, therefore, has bided bit time; for so long as he mw you put ep with every thing be maintained a man el lout vou alert to win year ilw be he has mode ready a safeguard for your

mw

And what t monstrous

pest he eitattoodl

Antonios could have earned out his intention be might have done to bed not the courage of Brutus opposed bis crime we thould have lllvricum, and Greece; Greece lllvric l would have been either a refuge for Antoniut if defatted, or a rampart from which to attack Italy bet now in fart, being, by the military command, the authority, and the forces of Marcut Brutus, net merely reedy, but even fully furnished for wsr, the stretches oat her hand to Italy, tad promises bet protection; and he who withdraw! from Brutus his

43

hunc rctioento* f InMJiwM At >rmc luo. quid com cum quid Apolkmio, emm Sid rrieo, mild com P. VoUoo impemtorts eiemUi ?
ci
I

Lopim (iUcsx. ood

FOmi Ck
UL
10) to

TWolloUMOiol MookJaa*
proT.nM on Dm.

oa Nor. I

(/>*</.

(MA.

to.

.MO Oo toocd. too* roObioff tOoo logftllj ontuWd * C goo* oo to orguo hat, to if C Antoniu hod * eUfao to Moecdoofc. ret ho hod ooo# to lb* othor proriaooa, or to toologftomof foUmo, too proomoul ia Illjrrfomo. And If

43

PHILIPPIC

X.

iv.

o-v. ii

army rob* the State of a most favourable refuge and of the strongest bulwark. As lor myself to boor of this as toon as possible, so ss to that it U Dot DeeJrous Brutus his palisade, but thst he himself U
i

holds just three towns 1 in the whole be bos Gaol Utterly hostile, and those too on whom be tr ostid much alien* ranspadanes II Italy to unfriend: :n nations, from of Greece as fsr a Rgvpt, are held by the cum nrl of the most loyal ml single hone was in Cains who, coming in age between his two thrm both and was in tint li- ajigbl ha\r been ,% (iu ran ?! thrust by the Senate mto Macedonia 09 contrary, forbidden* to k-1 out. Hea\rns! what O storm, what a bUxe. what a Irvastation, what a would there have been m incredible d-like valour bad not crushed the madman's How qutrk Hrutut was tli entrrprtoe!

world

eful'

bow hoi

valiant!

Howr
:

in

Cains Antoniu* quickness to not to be despued had not some Ispsod inheritance* delayed him on the u would have said be new rather than V\ hen c wi%h other men to procet bed. ? public businew we as a rule thrust then blf man we thrust out by trying to Hut what had he to do with A p him hack with the Ionia' with Oyrrachium ? with 111 army of the general Puhlius Vatinius? He suc|

bad aoae aHbae, vat ba bad a moral

claim, aa he

laaSuu
433

MARCUS TULUU8
i

ty*M dtoetit Hortenaio

rt

Certi

mi

trti mdks, Ctrl*,

lias,

estrrta

cm

Illrrkv eero et

Mode er com Vsttat I

gkmlbw qrfd erst AnUmk) >

II
tl

* At nr Bruto qaldei
lurrtt

mm

f.trtA.%r

|MpM

MMfOMM

rrm fniUkMB

IS

Com
toniom.
^^ ^

VII cobortibos esse Apollotiiae

acribit

An

^^pjp^p'

Qui iajn ant eafrtiu est (quod di duint *v*vvhww ^WPMr^pwMp^aMaaauav KM^V ^^'Vp^pvJBWyj
fcciasc videatur.

ne contra senatos consul turn

Di-

454

PHILIPPIC X

,,-vi

13

as be himself snxrrtrd, Hnrtcnolui. There oundaries to Macedonia fixed conditions of tenure, a fixed army, if it bad am Illvricum and with th< what had
.

"Brututnti hat some unfriendly person will perhaps say. All the legions, all the fore* anywhere belong to the State for not even those legions that deserted Marcos Antoniosean be said to bare to A n ton t us rathrr than t the N te. For sll iui army
1

and to military command to lost usee that wwiiinanil and that arun
VI

man who

attnrk

flse

itself pass judgment, or rtrrtinnrd bv its decrees, is it to Antonios or to Brutus tt would assign the legions iirutus it of the Roman proplr > The one had suddenly tak<n

Bat should the Sute

4%bt

to plunder and destroy the allies, so that, be >e devastated, plundered, and robbed every thing, and employed an army ot Rosusu people again%t the Roman people itself; .thcr bad Uid down this law for himself that, be oatnr, light, as it wrrr. and hope ot In should seem to bare eomr uith Imu. the the one looked for supports to bt other to preserve it. Nor indeed was this plainer to us than to the soldiers themselves, from whom no such clearness of judgment was to

bum iui

be looked

He
.

writes that
legions.

Antonios
1

is

at

Apollonia with

nther already a prisoner which Heaven grant! -or at least, being a modest man, so as to avoid be does not venture to enter M
ppearance of acting against the Senate's decree.

He

435

MAR(
et

TL-LUUS

que ipso ct malucibss eios as Bnrtl

potuUtis.

Itttcflt

Le*K qoam U

PW

docchat, tc*tu

Ansona CScwobI sa awo saeo trndidli

9! ta

ISHtAtut,

>yriam docebatur

trtpstsjjat

ad

Rnttom eontuht, sitrrom

In

Macedonia Cm
con

Posatttaa idslssces

win

%irtutr. K

tUntu

lr (to

Srriaco abdailt

P. aatasn Vatiaiaa.

oai ri antra

mtt ludi faw A

eobis #1 hoc

Tenet

Ijfitor res

poblicn Macedonian, tenet Illrn

eirtate rci

pablkae natut, turn fato qaodam paterni

\b hoe iyitor vfeo qslsqsisi

qai.

ball

timet,

sntcqaam not

Id

coacti sas e i piss at , In pace

qaam In bello eiger* malalt > Qoamqoaro quulrm numquam iacoit, neque hoc ea eerbum in UnUm % irtuti praestantiam potest. Erst eni In deslderio ciritatis, in ore, in sermone omnhim Unturo sutem aberat a bello, ot, cum
Sacere

Ule

coptdttate hbrrtatU
ttudii*

Italia ardcrrt. drfurrit

civiam

pottos

qoam

cos

in

armorum discrimen

430

PHILIPPIC

X.

,4

55?

levy hat been be Id in Macedonia through the ii ti seal and atauJuiU <>i Ql i rtcna man whose cstraordiuar\ If and of hu ancestors, yon have been enabled to fro of Brutes. The legion Plan, thr Irgate of Antonius, waa commanding ttrlf to my eon Cicero. Of the which wa being marched into Syria in two i one division bat left ita commander, the rami/, and baa joined Brutus; Dm

Macedonia Cnaeua Domitins, a young man of the highest valour, resolution, and steadiness, hat *u the legate of Syria. And Pnl nina, who baa been beforr rightly commended by yon, and la at tins Uuv- rightly worthy ot niimmgnrlitliiii, baa opened to Brutus the gates of Uy fracninm end handed over his army. The Slate therefore U in poanilnn of Macedonia, of lllyrtcum, and is guarding Greece ; ours are the legions, ours the light-armed troops, ours the cavalry and above all Brutus i and always will be ours, born as be b to serve the State, not only by his precnmiriit rsrtne last bt *.inr densjp <i mta sttgeffcsj to bit father s and to bis mother's race and name. \ 1 1 1% it from this man then that anyone fears war, a man who, before we were forced to take up war, pred obscurity in peace to success in war ? Not that indeed he was ever obscure; such a phrase rot litcesinnt attach to such eminence of virtue. he was on eyerj lip, and theme of all men's talk; but be was so averse U war that, although Italy was afire with longing for libertv he failed to second the seal of his fel lowrather than bnug them into the risk of

437

ti

us

land

ret

lUqueUliftfuu.siqei Mot, qui

urn video. quoe

occulta

loq.

ndnl

Tunc re
tnlrf
r'-

te dicunt ,
\
I

quo bmmIo feruot

(

r r

|'

4Mufi

I)

IMM

rtrrr.tum

llrul..

quid

ct,

cur hie

wnonutar At t M. Brutt
ct Uudti

b ro ret ilium
f

dftrefaunt eerl

M unt nunc tot ctcrcitu*. old at auluote infiUndacn Caeaurfa mU ercrti. qa redo, qui C Cmwv
face

roteruoorufli pcodi rolunt Mil SI ipee rlreret

16

Cueter, mHm, credo, defendcret. quum etr fortitttmaf defend!! I trtlttS, UUt CMMUv CJuvMMul MfBRn pOCCSK At horun titer nondun ei lonrtnqui t at -n,id grmviMimi morbi recreate*, o^icqaid hai la eorum libcrUtem dcfendeoduai con* rott* iudienrit te mortc rerocutum, Iter t.rtuU*

trU mm

MMOr

Ttoararuurof

Ouul

Teurmn.

of Julia*, u*d rueuiroJ Cfaalpiu* froui Urn. ued burn UMotiaued in hi. Tufa fa. of 09UTM. troukuL lb* G'i uiauiil fa tluU '

IUu*db**u * U^oonu

cmoi dfatru*i thoM who Art defanding J.

U

OoUrfaoU*,

43

PHILIPPIC X
h who

tii.

14-H11. ,6

Therefore the very persons if any such censure the slowness of Brutus, yet *t the seme Usoe admire his moderation and patience. But I see no what the? say; for they make no They say they are afraid bow ake Brute* rnwrssluii of the army. As If there were any ds feience between the army of Aulas Hirties, of Cains Pansa, of Dectmus Brutus, and of Cains Caesar, and this amy of Marcos Bru For if those four armies I ham mentioned are commended lor takinjc up arms on behalf of the liberty of the toma n people, whet reason it there whv It not pl a ced in the seme Oh, but the name of Marcos Brutus U by the veterans! More than that Imrtelf think not; for though the deed to both the Brutusea, and they have an hi its renown, yet those who lore angry with Decimus, just boos use It was, they said, less fitting lor him 1 to N hat then are so man/ armies now take part In it XHP* in hot the liberation of Brutus from the siege ? And who are the leaders of these armies? Those, I seppoae, who wish Cams Caesar's acts to be upset and the eanae of the veteran* betrayed VIII. If Cains Caesar were himself alive he would, I suppose, defend more keenly his own acts than or somethat !. rtins it defending them one can be found snore friendly to Caesar's cause than bis son * But of these men one, though not yet recov ered from a lingering and most serious malady, ha* devoted what strength he had to the ~ sset of the liberty of those by whose prayers he regarded himself as rescued from death ; the
1

439

MARCUS TULL1U8

(treat

pro

I)

Hruii Milutr drlluin grrunl

quo trterani

1Mb 0odto i
i*ttur.

wh d

ic

anaandi
tt

nr

In, <prf

conaervatun
17

anapeeta eaer.

An

vcro,

aft

quid eaact, quod a U. BruU

tidcrrtur. Panaa id

ami victor!

ant,

ai

ildaaut,

Uborarrt>
dUijpntiorr*
|uc

Quia nut
Atqul bolua

aniam ergs

Br

tidmia

Pracccful oration* ana, quid

Bruto. quid aentiru oportcret,

tHdcM.

|ac afutt, ut pe*teutauajaa rei publicae

BruU
ircar
t

puUrrt eaerrttum, ut in co liajilaalajian et gratUaimum poocrrt

hoc

ridet (hebeti rnioa tngcnio cai

dc quibua cr nturUUa ex auetoritate nostra latunsa eat. IX. Deafoant igitur ut ii. qui nan timent, ainoUre ae btnrre rt prmjuccrr rei publicae a omnia verentur, niaaiuaa eaae titnkJi, Ae illorum Quae, alum eat I a nmnlatio, horeaa obaat arnaria.
;
f

TIm two

a]tu.led

to %rr UxtXium, lot

PHILIPPIC

X. tm. 16-11. 18

other,1 more t- igoroua in the strength of virtue than of age, hot set forth with those very veterans to i>eHmu% Brutus. Therefore those most tain sod Most active supporters of the aeU of Caesar are aging war on behalf of the safety of Decimus Brutes; the veterans follow Uu the liberty of the Roman people, not for their own advantage, they tee they mut struggle in arms. Whet reason is there then why, whrn these men wish to use all their forces for the preservation of Be els as Brutus, the army of Marcus Brutus should be su spe cted by them r

Was mjat .nr cmuee for spprchciisioo from Marcus Brutua woo id not Panes see it? or, if he did see it, would he not beansious? Who is * to gauge future c%ents, or more active to ward off s danger And yet yoa hers *r n oil foetfng tow. mis Marcus Brutu*. and his seal to assist him. He hss inttruetrij BUM I* *|w-crh what r sJsOwld <lt rrrr. Hid hot are should feel concerning Marcus Brutus; and so for was he from deeming the army of Marcus a danger to the State that ... it hfl seen! bbc important bulwark of the State. Oh, wither docs not see this(or h<ksregards it, for he does not care arts be ratified and yet he intends, our authority, to propose s law at the Con Centuriata for their confirmation and rati fun'
J

ither. then, let tho*c who sre not afraid l\ cense to pretend they are afraid and are provi<! for the safety of the' State, or let those who arc prwebenerve of everything cease to be over-tit c of thr pre te nces of one part\ other, stand in our way. ' Wliat the plague is
)

441

MARCUS TULUUS C1CMO

ucnnUqoa ad corum votunUtctn opUnda aocB eat, driboa BominB temper fuit atrvttaU
(ful>rrn*ntur

dkte, (mcU rcferuntor,

atd

foerit

ervire

rolunUrium > ToU lulU desiderio libcrUtb eaaraH, dioUoa bob potaat civitas ; lerios popolo Boanano hone vestitum atque ma dadhnos, quam

20

b co Aajptati somaa X. Magna bob quidem spe et prope eiplorata libcrUtis caoaam sBfceaBBoa; acd at ooacedasi

Under J allot Gm-*t Tba , or military drom

wfw

PHILIPPIC X.
of cau*c. .th the

it.

8-1. 20

of this constantly opposing the best name o! the veterans? Dcarlv as I night cherish their valouras I do jv they were ngiit, I would not pot up with their
caprices Weak r arc striving to burst the shackles of slavery, avail tome man's tUtemrnt that tin veterans do not wish it hamper as.here I as ijihImi aseaes M#hl enanenmewuaam l^^ai . %IJI*I* ^*^, a*^eae%.ft liilwIC |K SOf N Jafw* N Ol tm^a*^a*feam^
1
.

to take

there is hot the veteran soldiers to be roused by a Can, then, s indignation to ward off slavery State stand, in reliance on the veterans, *
liberty
!
!
1

up

am

common

supportofthe young men? Astothe yoo ought to welcome them as aids to liberty, as abettors of slavery yoo ought not to follow ihrm.
ally

It mo

give utterance at last to a w<

and worthy of myself if the purposes of this oar order are gove rned by the nod of the veterans, and ail oar sayings and doings are regulated accordtroe

shoald choose death, which to has always been preferable to slavery. All slatrry is wretched; but grant there was a slavery tlis! wa% m voidable ;> do yon contemplate vl beginning the reco ve ry of yoor liberty ? that unavoidable and almost ould not designed calamity, shall we endure this voluntary one I f Italy is aflame with thr longing for liberty ; the community can no longer iaves; r have given the Human people this garb and these arms, but long after they have
ing to their
ill.
I

Roman eitiaens

been demanded by
X.
It is

it

indeed with a great and well-nigh assured hope that we have taken up the cause of libel

443

mm:. US

nil Ms mr.iu)

cirrtitmtrnt.

mi
tl

non est % >ri intmme<jur traiUum. <jem natu r*e drbeat, pal rtse redder*,

CoooorrHorondiquead

MB,
ir

C. tmecuti sunt, poet Pansac dilectus orbcro luliaa* reifrt omnium cat hostL,
lli'rti.

Umm

cJvcui, cuius desk)*

1 MirMii iimiti tast it la tab passsfo Urinktng of Serpsdoa's sposea to Ulaaoat la Horn. / they two could atspt iae war aad > woan says thst, if tmmoruU neither woaM be himeel/ fight, nor re* < Uonu * tar* "Bat/* C, tuuaortality it too doar a tbs p.ioe of

PHILIPPIC
bet though
I

Mow that the issues of war are onMart Inconstant, yet must we struggle
the risk of
life

liberty at

For

life

does not

In breath: It does not esist at all in the All other notions can bear slavery; our and for no other reason than that oil and pain, and, to be M .e all thing* but we have been so trained and our minds so imbued br our ancestors as to refer all oar thought* and acts to the standard of honour and virtue. So glorious is the recovery
;

But seeing that days of oHanccs surround ns on | It Is not the part of a man, least of all of to hesitate to surrender the breath he owes

to his fatherland. Men throng Irons all sides to quench the general conflagration. The veterans who were the first to follow Caesar's lead have replied the attempts of AntonJos ; afterward the Martian legion has broken his frensv, and the fourth crushed it to the earth. So, cond emned br bis own legions, he burst Win Gaul, which he knew to l>e unfriendly and it both in action and in !'<-r lings. The host armies of Aulas Hirtius and of Caius Caesar have foOontd him op ; afterwards Pansa's levy has roused He is the one this the whole of Italv. tammy of all men; though he has with him his brother Lucius, a citiseo most dear to the Roman people* the loss of whom the community can bca
i

445

UAftcus

it

ii

ii

icno

Id

mint,

ui

cootto

rm

El Colo. ip4 nmUci

OVOrtftopI
;

ctihit

rot

potieoto); otot to Ulfto rtrt wwoJltoi lop*

Juntos M. Bmtt.
tote
toeri

new ooctoritotooi
Topuit.
ooid

volt
:il

am

pcooccret, vl

cooUo von

Coi qoftdcai, potm conocript> >ucr* debclU, quod o. I Mil loo. D. Brut, Goeotft a privatum cic rr | iliit< *

Om MS. Km mimiwm ool, MataMm. TWVil hmm

oodttlof jnom.

OlWr

Mm

Xrihmt ot *. vt

ft.

hod.M UftoSOOf

tfa

nor
Phu. Ti
4.

cWbu. ood hod

446

run in
more hideous more savage to have been born for this reason, that the basest of all living men might W not be seen in Marcos Antonius. is
long'
bet can be
?

than loot beast

who teems

a ledger clean ot debts, Is reconciled to Mm; 1 Plancut and others like him; hose straggle and aim is to make t r esto ratio n from die bo teen to be pernicious to the Slate. And Sesa and Cafo are tampering with ignorant on, being clowns and rustics themselves, who here never seen, tad do not wish to see. e established, men who defend the acts, not of but of Antonius, whom the unlimited of CampanUn land has seduced, though under that they are not ashamed of it they tee User have mimes, male and female,
ellioa.
is

who, now there

For the cru%hmg of these pests, why should be displeased that the army of Marcus Brutus It added to et? an intemperate man, I suppose, is not and a tart** too patient, though he is a man in whom, thought or deed, there has never been Kvcrv wish anything r.-.hrr fete ranch ..r U> little of Marcus Brutus, Conscript Fathers, every thou hole of his mind, looks to the authority ot these ty of the Roman people Senate and ti He he sets before him. these he desires to r could effect since it effected he deemed he should essay force against To him, Conscript Fathers, your duty is st this crisis to pay the same tribute as on the twent of December you paid at my instance to 1 Cains Caesar, whose private undertaking
:
j

XL

447

M AIICL'S TULUIM nrp.RO

14 Qttod

Nm de

If

ApulHo

eal testis est per Utters*

Brutus,

rum

faker ad cooitem r irrcit u coaaparandl

litteris,

ilUue et

quae a Q. Cirpsosn Brutu pro la boc erdlne recrtatae aunt, de

raretu

ciaseo:

Cum Q. Caepsools Brail pro console opers,

prosiocia

Macedooia

et lllrrirom et euoeta
us,

Graeeia et lffgiimn

eearitatus

la

coo-

p.!-

jr

in tn

r>i

j-ir

wrutfi Ji^ruf *tr

<

<r

soetudmeqoe reJ public** bane gerendae fcrime, earn rem senstui popoloque Romano gratam erne
26 et fore; utique Q. Carpio Brutus pro consul c provin

ciam Macedonian, lltjrncum runctamque Graeeftam tueatur, defendat, emrtodtat Ujcotajncaagoe appears tt,
>

8tth third

Hfaasssaeaiilppin'abjq

44^

PHILIPPIC
led. 1

X. u.

3 -a6

was by your authority approved and Your duty b to do the same tin ol Marco* Brutus, by whom an uneip and hasty mi forcemeat for the Sute, in the shape of a groat aad strong force of legions, cavalry, and ssttllsarr troops, has been got together. bsm should be associated Quintus Hortensius, who, when ho held Macedonia, allied himself to Bmtns as a saost trosty and steadfast coadjutor in the raising of has army. For concerning Marcos A pole mm I propose a separate motion: Marcos Breton It a witness by Ins letter to his being the tret to ntge him to the endeavour of raising an
>

whereas Cains Panes, the the letter received from Quintet Caepio Brutes the proconsul which has been read hi this assembly, on that matter I propose as

Mtws
Whereas by the exertions, strategy, energy, and taloor ol Quintus Carpi. Hrutu* pnon ul, at a must duncult craws lor the Sute the province of Macedonia,
the whole of Greece, and the legions, the jurisdiction of the mite, and the Roman people, Quintus Caepio Brutus, proconsul, has acted well and in itjttnatt of the Sute, and to accordance with hit own honour and that of his ancestors, and the preccdenU oi good administration of the Sute; and such action is and will be welcome to the Senate and to the Roman people moreover, Quintus Caepio Brutus, proconsul, should protect, defend, guard, and keep safr the province of Macedonia, UUricum, and the whole of Greece; and should
I

kvalry, are in

449

mm.,

i.

i.u-s

Eono
4

^qwe
del, t

a rap

OfMM

|bhc

rit

I emifi

Omqm
rtrtute

ei

littrrit

mIc

hHilliHn

mi Q. HovtaMl pro vehement

450

PHILIPPIC

)L

it.

t6

the army which be himself has established

Ami
It sf

and levy, if nr prion any public moneys that it borrow from whomsoever for military operations and see to it that he be as possible to Italy. And whereas the setter of Quintus Caepio Brutus, procx understood that by the exertions and vn
has

of Qttiatos Horteaatas, proconsul, the State

boast greatly ssolsted, and that all his counsels hare been hi aeca with the counsels of Quintus that that circumstance of greet service to the SU decreed
in
1, has acted rightly, order, and in the interest of tl.< State is the Senate's pleasure that Quintus il, shoo with a quaestor or r, and with his own legates, hold the proof Macedonia until bis ssjCCOMOT be appointed

by

45'

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

\I

Tu i close of the year 44 Dolabella, in anticipation of the expiration of hit consulship, had left Rome to Ukr op the government of Syria, an
appointment which the tribes, on the procure of Antonius, had gives bin oo Jane 5, in spite of fact that this province had been assigned to Cassias by J. Caesar, whose sets on by thr Senate on the !7th of March. On his way to w ards Syria Dolabella passed through the pro\ of Asia, then under the gorrmment of C. Trebon and, being refosed by Trebon us admission racberously surprised it and put to death in the roost brutal manner. involving, at cording to Cicero, torture. This crime, ay% illddhbwi, "had ben projected sHthoai tat*, with Antony to make the revenge of Caesar's death the avowed cause arms, in to draw the veterans to th On the news of this strot ^ received at about the middle of Man I. the Consul Pansa the ired, on Senate, whi of Cairn us, that Dolabella was a public and decreed that his property should be The question then arose, who should Conduct the war against Dolabella? Two proposals wrrr lw-f,,rr the Hoove one that P. Serv fliul si. be given sn eitraordinsry command the second that should l>c instructed the consuls of the present to carry on the war, with the provinces of Asia and
I
i
1

yw

453

INTRODUCTION TO

PI III

This Syria allotted between them vti sgrecable I Pant*, ad to the partisans of Anlonios. these Utter supporting It as having the elect of diverting the ttmt.oo of the consols from the war In Italy. No conclusion wo* come to the first day, and the debate was adjourned. On the
>u hirh he proposed (aofsr one) that Casaius should he recogn ised oa governor of Syria with the fullest title should attack Dolabrlia by land ... \ .. BHsynln, mi bi wmammm Pontoa to nuke rcqotsitiooa lor munitions of ejej Of the other two proposals made he rogsrded the
,
i
! I

first,

U.

that for an eatraordtaory

mow Hid,
.

oa

iaid that

of what

what DolahctU hod done was hot an Antes* would do that Ok

pair.

of the ore a

After rUscrlbing

AntosoW

atonrlsUs, he eoogratuUtod C aleuoa on hit rigorooa udr .ih regard to Dolabclla crinse. With regard to the tccund point, the election of a general to act againat DoUbelU, he aid that eatranrdinary ad never been given to a private person

nuoand given to the voting Caesar had rlrrusMtnax absolutely neccsoarv to roojwlsoinnlng the two consols, ho argued that this would bo against too interests of the public service: the two consul* err already waging o dangerous war in protection of the lives of all ; and, even although the proposal was that they should 6rst relieve D. Brutus, vet their sttmtion would be of the task they had in hand. Moreover, a commission would cause jealous?. The
In the
I

454

INTRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC

XI

war against Dolabella required a general already "ruUw and Caseins fulfilled the requirebat the former could not be spared from rbere be was opposing C. Antoniut. And though ogh (aa he hints) both BruU Brutus and Cass us held no legal command, yet the eiigcncv of the rules should be disBoth should be allowr.l. , tlir public And he to be each his own Senate. by snaking the motion above meni

motion would, so be informs Caorius (ad prevailed " had not Pansa ttfwuosli opposed It And the Senate agreed to Cslsauss* ftotion that the two consols should undertake Use war when they bad ended their campaign ajoiMl Antoiuu*. But rsosiiii took Use matter into his own hands. Hi tsj x ady, as he informed Cicero by a lc dated March 7, but which mutt U*\c been rrcn\ed
's

Fobs. 19.

7% bovo - easily

err of the eleventh Philippic (aa* fast. the bond of a considerable army. With this be red need Laodicea, where Dolabella was, who committed suicide rather than mil into the power of
II), at

flamJn

455

U TULLI C1CRBONIS
OtATK)
I

IN I'lllUFPICA

M
I

am
M)K( IMA

n dolare, patm con*-njX r rt poMus, quern e% Treboai, opOmi eirit

Ml

:.

el purrtarJm. l)oU

brlU et AntooJut, quorum Iter euVeit, quod optarat, dc hero patefartaai est, quid co hum erodeli, Marias la irsrundta penererani

la celere par,

Itaque, qi

bellumqi iugulan inter te romenee el deriniit itnprobitstmae naturae et turpitftimae *itae timilitudo. Ergo id, quod fecit DolabeJU, in quo potuit, roulUt idea minatur Autoniut. Sed ille

45

Ml

VENTH PHILIPPIC OF
I
I

If.

TUL-

Ul
||

\M()N

great sorrow. Conscript Father, or rather which the cruel and wretched death of fttfcta to lojrml and * man to temperate aa Cains Tts liu i ii ae * has canted oa, them U jet something which I think will benefit the State For we have realised what a degree of savagery there was in those men who have taken up their accursed arms against their country Por here we hare two creature, the molest and filthiest since the creation of human bthsgra, Uolahella and Antoniu, of whom one has ejected what he wtthed, while what the other proLnciua Cinna was cr p o d stands revealed Gains Harms In his anger persistent Lucius Sulla violent; but in revenge the bitterness of none of ! tended beyond infliction of death aj was held a penalty too cruel to be Indicted on
laansiitelloa,

UN

Mere yon And a pair of twins in wickedness, unprecedented, unheard of, fierce, barbarous. And so the very men bet re n whom, you remember, there was the utmost hatred and dissension formerly have been since bound together by a singular unanimity and election springing from the similarity of their most reprobate nature and infamous Uvea. Ac where he had the ingly. what fmlabclla ha power Anton ins also threatens to do to many. But
457

HA*

nil

101

CKXBO

ImI
obit

Qoid ergo bene

eiied

ojotlH,

rid optere
belli
>

qoi libere de re pebtke wnolniot, out teotenUe* dill, qui pot

In bo Inn,
If!
II

atd
"
.

kmtw,

Motor*
HOflltOl

Umcm
.f
,

la not
I

job
*
i

*"" 111

" "f'f II:

r %

tit.

In

belle,

in Itenoei Oterqoe Brotos obie ett impetanqtie

ftaitt a

reditu

i olinqoe parte moot rlo ill

Alter in

Amin

inrupit.

Cor?

ft, ol in Syriorn,

Aua

Cbeotr bed aojigned Obolptet Cool to D. to t TrebooiM.

-.

If

prowodief to 8yrie, why did fee not loke th Huoot wmy by mo? if to Tkitiiioloi, ty did

ottered

45

PHILIPPIC

XI.

i.

2-11.4

Dolabtlk, being Gar from our consuls and armies, and not ret luting perceived that the Senate has i:<*nan people relied on the forces of Antoniu*, and committed those crimes which he had already been committed st Rome by the
of hit frensy.

What other

bat other

mppoae Antonius has ? or what do y is our reason for wr ? All of us whose OB State sJairs are those of free men, who bate ei pre ssed opinions tliat become us, who
bare wished the Roman people to be free, he has t his to be, not merely u Bat be contemplates greater ut than against an enemy ; death he regards due to nature, hut that to anger belong then What sort ot rturea. sbouid we see in him. at whose hands, if victorious, death, if not accompanied by tortures, is counted in kindness? II Wherefore, Conscript Fathers, tbo need no prompter for you yourselves of your own longing to regain your liberty accord arr 6 tend yoor liberty >th the greater spirit asiassn inasmuch as you see the greater
.

Boft

that in slavery await the vanquished. baa invaded Gaul, Dolabella, AsU, each of The <>w Brutus has them SSOt bet man'% province confronted, and has, at the risk of his own life, checked thr oa ei of the madman who longs t< milage everything; he has stayed his b) he has put a curb on his he has bound lie besieged
i

.e

us fast on both sides. other has burst into Asia.

Why?*

If,

to

459

MARCUS TL'LLIUS CICERO

ptebat
efta
I

ei

crrta

MfM

loajm.;

a,

mi

md

Hmno

oeacio qao (Mario, arelcrato Utrone atque

egeati. qui pnpuUrrtur ajrrua, vraarct urbea

Mm

ad

qaam
m.l..

r.,.m

tmi),

acd ad
Id

MM. CMMtMtM
belli (quit

twn to

momm
NulU

mm

Oft Dolabclla.

poUrct >)

atamtato; dritcrae, quae

Wei

Miot perftdU

anbq
I
i

Ot

ab CO,
eo, qai

Qtti

ut

*b

Bi qao
tolmt,

quid

Mtt

rlrtk
c

A tern
on,

nmnMM

mm mm

cmtiaontcm KamJark

mmm!

credo, ia victoria liberate eideretar.

Cam

vcrbcribaa ac tormeotia
bttt fracti
1

qaaeJtkmem babaH

IHiWicae, idooe per bid num.

Post cenricicapat abaodit idqaa adfixam gestari laan

by
'

Th iubciMtl worde ara aamjetMre of LaaibiaM laQd. Halm. OraUi omiu ih+m, aad peoatoatee dowa to mam " ia Um Uxt, and ran* oo after

460

PHILIPPIC

Xf. n

4-5
I

paas on into 8?r4a, there was * war open to one defined and not long ; bat if to jo here was toe nec essity of ending forward with tome Martian or other railed Octavius, an and needy brigand, to drtast nul, the cities, not with the hope of est hit private fortune those that loMOJ him ur he can-

not pi

wiu that, for to me Hut Senator

to reach
nuiiirloii

it

unknown

tome readv pasture for hit mendicant UoUbelU followed him There being
<

of war for who could think followed otoat intimate conversations mbrace*. faUe indicatkmt of the highest good will amid the |>retenee of lore ; pledges by right band*, the nana! witneteea to good faith, were ptridioatly and criminally violated; there wat mn entry by night into Smyrna, as into a city of enemies, not of our most trusty and longallies Trebomus was crushed ; if as by an from lack cf caution if as by one who the guiae of i i rabJy. example no doubt Fortune wished us to receive a proof of what the vanquished hn A consular holding the province of Asia liar eommand Dolabella handed over to an exile; he was unwilling to slay his in order. I %up|>osr. not to appcar After scarifying that In hit victory with abuse from he noblrtt of then under the lash and the rack held an inquest Afterat to public money*,' and that for two clays. warda, when he had broken bit neck he cut of! heady and ordered it to be carried about fixed on a
; ;

mm

'

Aooaraall/ as ehargsd T. with oononaling them.

461

ejj

gu,i

QeJi

e*

,,.,

pn rMBAftrodtata *

Aata taeatur. oltut ot rr *. not alio bello disttne*

III.

iMgtooi M. Antnnl
j

et brlU DoUbrllac acoJe

hoc

mi

mi
in

crwdeliUUs In DuUcftcU I, ab hoc pvnerepu aunt trdit*. Sum

UU

Ami DoUbclU
uatam?

full, la

Italia, ai

Mi hi qutdrm et

Ulc pcnrcnlnu" rtdetn r, quoad prog mil pot oerl t feri

nmUa, neooe Antonlua ull..*% anpplku ti poteeUte habrat, ulUm eo

7
I'
.

tgitur nte

nun

lllam

quldee*

ei

InriUndof nottfoa
In Treboni nUdio.

aoduoet, furri nun atquc oa illud tnCamr , vincla, verb tortorrm carniacemqoe Siaurium ; quae telinag Magna lee* ilium fortiter et patenter fcrent

Bet

Tkw two words mo addad

In tee Vat, If

&

b/ a

lata

61

PHII-IITIspear; the rest of his body, after it had been dragged boat and mangled, be cut Into the tea. This It the enemy with whom we must war, one age cruelty all barbarism has been surWby should I speak of the slaughter of Utena? of the plunder of befitting the atrocity of the facts could teeh calamities? And now he wanders
all

Asia,

be

Hits

about like a
;

Um

},<

re

are hampered by another war as if the this be fa oot pair were not one and the

V ... Dolabclla the image of the in of Marcus Antonlut; on him it hat been It from him Dolabella's schooling in tat been received. Ik> you think Antonius, f be be allowed will be more lenient iu Italy than DoiabelU MM >n Asia? To me indeed it seems, both that Dolabclla hat advanced at far at the madneat of a savage could go, and that, given the power, tus wilt forgo there It no punishment ofwbi the exaction of even t fragment. Set thtrefuru before your eyes, Conscript Fathers, that picture, wretched and tearful at it i yet one necessary to stir our feelings the night attack on nof armed men the 6neat city of Asia 1 Into Trebonitts' bouse, when that wretched man saw the brigands' twordi before he heard what the matter was; the entry oi the raging Dolabclla. the bonds, foul speech and his infamous month the stripes, the rack, the torturer and ex< as bore all of wlncli they say Samiarius That it great praise, with fortitude and pat dgincnt the greatest praise. For it is and
III
I

463

mm,

ii

ns

QCUO
kl

MM|
re,
'.

at

Ct Client.
<u*d talc

MMOrit

aeekUt, niral non

t

m ewer
1

lll

(lill

tlklll

I .

.'

il

'.

I"

In vivo, rd

paverit

malto anterior DoUbelU qaa

to ndacrrtomni

cMt

toJttMi!

Dulorca

fait

dolor btdui
;

at coniplvriboa

tnoltnrojn

rrociamcitU

ncc rero jrrarlora twit quam totmlutn tormenU

Alia Mint, alia, toqiiam,

p*

ea,

qoae eonciptuntur ammo, qaam

qui macipit to ae
cogftnr.

Ilia,

quae cor pore.

If iaertor ijritur,

aeeitts,

quam

ai

qoi

altrrim

Carinua tutarc
;

DoUbelU Trebonins
lentlbna
at!

et

CrurUtut eat qukletn a K*rtln

Regains

qua

tint to bo.tr.

ludirandam oat?
1

An

re, cum crudchasJmi Poeni quid to rire de DoUbelU veto boc eonfc
aft,

duluUndu, aler misrrior

This

lane,
afolvi* raadt

b Halm*

poactaaliia*

" Lmrnm

fd

/ai/'tnaspa.iJnf afeOatoprt "aUor,-

PIIII.II'I'K

7 -rv.

the part of s wise man to resolve beforehand that a hat at if an happen to a man should be borne earn (all him It needs altog* judgment to provide against | tig. and no less courage to bear it with
.t

ruinflm

of

shall befall. And Dolabclla was human feeling though in that

so

never had any partas to practise his insatiable cruelty not only on the living, but even on the dead, and to the mangling and molestation of the bodr. as he could not glut his soul, he fed his eves. IV <> DoUbells, much more miseral.lr thai.

whom yon wished to be meat miserable Anguish TrebonJns endured to the full ; but many from thipa. do not ef disease endure great. nnssflili, bet afticted. Two days' was long ; vet many have felt it for many rtu res of esecnttoners are indeed not snore severe than are sometimes the torments of disease. There are other tortures, others, I say, yon most abandoned and insensate wretches! and ne misers hie. For in proportion as the of the mind la greater than that of the i those ilia are more severe that are conin the mind than those contracted in the body. More wretched then is be who incurs the guilt of a crime than be who is compelled to undergo the nnedeed of another. Trebonios wss tortured by DolshaJla and Kegulus too by the Carthaginians and since on that account the Carthaginians hsre boon sdjodged moat cruel in the esse of an em in the case of a citisen what should be our judgn. of Dolabella? Can we really make here Si or doubt which is the more wretched
!

465

MARCUS TULUU8 CICEIO

10

ilu rnim tartmmt

oI*m ob co com.

|t rtme, nte* bote orbi, arte ct forte too rt hoooaaitoti liftetli

Mi

loteolroo.

V yt_>lm

%--.- -

|_
I

to

(Junl ^ftwu

run wmmM *>mv i^w^ jvw coffiUbooe, rum oonffuioeai not bibci

qui to vcrbo pcottocxi

cm orboooni cope re diccbot,

M&.

voro* (a* U> ) *r amuud t tb V*A. too oopjtet Having apoorcotl/ oiionil o line
1

By

D. had boao C.a m-m-Uw. lcaviog too citv for too

466

PHILIPPIC XL

ir.

9-t. io

tenth the Senate and the Roman people long or be who by all the votes of the Senate tytdgcd aa enemy > For, indeed, in all ratures of their tires who could, without insult to rrhonius, compare the life of
|

DolabrlU's ' Who does not k I of the one, his genius, his humar t, his strength of mind displayed in Ms country? To the other from boyo sport ; then oame such baseness himself has always exult. m Ins Isssng men as he could not be reproached
1th
i

Wis man, Heaven*! was

'.

for bis rices

at one time my were hidden from one who

no enquiry. And perhsps now 1 be eUeneted from him, had be not been proved hostile Io von, to the walls of Ins coontrr, to this etty. to the Hoosehold Gods, to the aiurs and of all of us, in a w.nl. to nature and to all Tied by hfai example, let us more diligently and more watchfully beware of A n ton us. or Dolabella bad not with him to many not prions and manifest brigands bat you see whom Antonsnt bos, and how many they are. First, his Heavens what a firebrand what brother Loeies. what a sink, what an o beep of crime and h W hot is there, do you suppose, abyss of prodigal it y that he is not mentally absorbing, is not gulping down in imagination.' whose blood is he not drmk on whose |iusscssinni and fortunes does he not hope and fa ney i his most shame ess eyes ? What of Cenaorinus? who in words stated his desire to be but was, in fact,* certainly unwilling.
i

467

MAftCUfl

it

i.i

it

>

HO

II

Ncque hoc In hue no coolm honeUe coouemiioU.

rat; Mat olM to Qood torpiter rtoUluU. mm boo hoot** tost, ArcrdH S** neorio i?

nm

qfc>

q**oi
pi*

bomb

Cmmt

ultima

inoonQM

ovoiCf cionioB ontco motor, nunc, ttt tpcrot, urbta; qua cum ut lirno, capttJ mKii nobuominetur Con hoc veteran** Co/o, quo

MO

8oeb porto* b.n g by

U Um

ioelieibfe.

C. .lolm. aoov (wing coral* aoffll* in fO ft C. only. Mood far Anoalio mohoii, OMitrary lotlM wco-M by Thoi ilirtfcw trOwoi *Obi)m ! tii trtaJ hm oa* aonrktod of bribery. r confirming Ciwif'i net*. bod rorollod Botti* among lb* other citl. -. cosmoo orbtoao moor tb* ornor* of con boot doxy it tii to Uy oot toe

Jit

wm

Um

La

Um

46

miuiM'u

V.

IO-II

W hat of Bestia, who proclaims his candidature fof the consulship tn the place of Brutus ? May .1 1 And how absurd rl this detestable omen for a man bo coold not become praetor to seek consul* hip ! unless perhaps he considers a convi. * as a pete tort? I that second Caesar Vopiscus a man of highest intellect, of who alter the aedileship stands lor the consulship, be tie sited from the laws, though the laws do bind him by reason, I imagine, of bis extraordinary distincOoo' But this man 1 being defending counsel was five times acquitted; it is hard, even far a gladiator a sixth triumph in Rome.* But for this the blame Is with the not with me. I dufcndid him in the best of fs their doty it was to keep within the community this moat noble and most illustrious Senator. And now be seems to hate no other object than to make os anderstand that those whose verdict we annulled * State. decided well and in thr And this does not apply to this man alone there are others In the same camp honest!* condemned, What do you think will llasgiaiofnll; restored. be the design of thou men, the enemies of all good There is in addition * most cruel one ? whom Caesar gave us out of the tileria as tribune of the common, to be, as s measurer of camps before, now hut, since he hopes a measurer out o( the citv to it, may the omen fall on is a stranger With this man is bit own head without harm to us ! -an Cafo, than whom the veterans hate no
!
I

Of

imsaValliin of
t

bad

wrongfully bestowed on him

s. 10.

in

at

/ML vm.9;

469

MAtCUS TULIJUS CICERO

II
*

OuUte mcrri

hftl nUxilo*, ut cat Ur. Quttm* uUimud )ooran nuirwuU pfMcdlonim conlrott imiMlf fcrrooMU, Ut InUuldlu MM MM| ad qu*d*t* |iHIimiImi fuit, Ml hoc Ueterrimum
.

M
13 iiMMM t Mf ocmIcm pt upogJIk ?

\ntonl

lumtf

FMmum iImmm CoUcgMt

tOMdOTWM *t DoUbcIl

Quid

cUmmmj

de
ridi;

Apulo

unu

aoa prodife rlvrre, cfMOfUat mum. \ uli tumm

rfari,

At hie nuprr tororU dedtt Scd nan p*> qui nostra Uoom spcfMOt, cum
P.

Ucci auctlonem, cUri

qui

in em aurtkme inventus llominem hdiculum, qui te emcrg err Ik-no pfjtet pome, com reudat lie? quid ego de Trebellio dicMin ? quern ulUe rldrr
I

'iirnr i!rlMt..ruin

Mri <lirrinrminiio%ruiii

Uhularuin

Tl rv* Uuda

of Cfcmpaoift

OtlMC

mum
1

xi.

* u-vi.

one. men, at a tort of addition the dowry they had reeeired during our cml Antonlns has lavished Campanian lands they might have foster mothers * for their ether aid they bad been content with that we with it. though it was intolerable; hut is to be endured to free us from this
<>n these
!

* Whet more ? do you not set before your eyes those usnssnaries of Marcus An ton tut' camp? First of all toe two colleagues* of the Antonii and DoUbelU. NucuU and Lento, the parcellers of Italy under the law which the Senate has declared carried by violence, of whom the one has composed mimes, the other bos acted in a tragrdr " hat shall I my of Domitios, the Apulian ? whom goods lately I have up for mle each is the negligence of * But the man recently lavished poison But men cannot s son, not a more dose, extravagantly who are hoping as they do for our goods while they lavish their own.* I have also seen the auction of that eminent man ho, following the precedents of his ancestors, has devoted himself as a victim for Vrt at that auction not a single Swjfef mid debt. he can SO \ idly fellow to think be fouiwl debts to others by selling what belongs to others what shall I ay of Irclx-llim, on whom the Furies its seem to have taken vengeance? of t Duosaos . tWyara sjswpsriag vwb of sasir poisons. ssjfjsata (and the aswteat supports ana) that a is pUying 00
1
!

taTwuri *i
P.

drosm. dorotad hiowelf srssy to dastreotloa. ai so ssoarsd a Rossaa victory.

soma warswd by

war of 340 IMu Mas, too oooml, hi ths Utin with the ooemy'i
B.C.,

isi

i.r,

m ssnaistlna wKh in/uda.

47

nihil

potato* (qJd

mi

tU l litl

potarit,

qid

two word*
1

m pnhmUf *
I

Hi tW>okWn<wntWwldbto;
el

A pkj

am

Um

whig
4.

bus

oL

Jfctl

*L

a bOmiLmi

ha.

St4
r

bw

orsoi

WJUn iiilf of U

47t

PH1UPPU
for
1

\!

,6
1

we see a new lull avenging the clean bill. What of .lua Plancus, whom that most eminent
Aqutla drove oat of Poll en tie, with a broken
too.>

dttom
leg

would

it

liad

happened to him before

here!* One si. of that army I nearly passed of Lysidicus, <treck phrase, for he has the dissolution of all laws;' but perhaps a had a right to slay one germanclv related. 4 that Antonius has this lot with him, and of the same kidney, what crime will lie Uolabella has involved himself in so though he has with him a troop of mean* equal ? Wherefore, as 1 often an willingly dhwented from Quintus Fulius, so tllinjcly ajajajl to his proposal; from this you should judge lhat I do not usually disagree with the man. bet with the use. Accordingly 1 net only assent, but 1 also thank Fones; for he has made a motion, severe and dtgnliad in terms, and one worthy of thi State luts declared that Dolabella is an enemy, and thai est estate should be confiscated by public order, nothing could be added to this for what could be made in stronger and so till he said that if any of the Senators railed upon were to pm|>ose a heavier Who can fail to praiae such severity \ Now, as Isabella has been adjudged an
i 1

'

alls

where C. brother t et Him rVMaiahaa. "On.Ur also aieaos a Cimbrian, anaof et~rnvuitnW. Heoce C. pun.
Ctavbar killae hi
'

HA

473

MARCUS TULUU8 CICERO

belU, belle eet bebet

dffrrrrt,

eerr*

eet diiitqee ei in

::z
ilii
:
.

mrowtNm
:
'

%rr,
<

tiiiiil

r<;

b ro d
tf

et

ills, qnee e eoneultbut eut eoofeeU int, qoam P% rrhi, quern

Pbilippl,

1 One 1U1 ee straenlieary nneiiBil teeeld of Um yr lb* otbtr lee tb

umih

give

TbeOwet, ,
King
of

biegof

8yrK
of

Anfr Minor. Afrie*Ceftlttfl.teBn* to 3-941 e.a j lee Meed

ie

ed deprived

e oooqU

iilutiit is 190 e.a

by SeJpio

Tbewwwu

474

mil
inactive
;

ir

it.

,6-17

He nast he followed up in war. For he is be has a legion, he has fugitive slaves, he has an accursed gang of rebels, be si himself headstrong, uncontrollable, destined to s death Um a giadiat erefore, since Dolabella was yesterjwonounoed by decree an enemy, and we 1 wage *r. we must choose a general. opinions have been delivered,! of whi. h approve neither; the one because I always regard it as rt segi riios, save where inevitable; the <> because I think it u^u.lni fta khM <r
I

KM

te er of the mob, and is very little suite dignity, very little to this our order. In the war with Anttochus,* a great and serious war, when the province of Asia had (alien to the lot of Lucius Sespio, and he was thought possessed of too little spirit, too little energy, ami tewasforentr Ing Use condnct of the war to his colleague, Caiui
I srllae, the frthtir of the well-known Laelius the Wise, Publlus Africanus, the elder brother of I.ueius Scipio, got up, and protested against such ignon to the Cssnily, and said that in his brother were round the greatest valour and the greatest judgment, and

mp

that he himself, even at his age, and after his \\ eipkMts, would not refuse to be his legate. he had said that no change was made in regard to Scipio a province ; nor was an extraordinary command sought for the conduct of that war more than it had been in the two great Funic wars* previou which were waged and conHtxhd by consuls or dictators, or in the war with Pyrrhus, 4 or Philip,* or

dm

King

Msw4m

at war with

Rome
475

Its.

Mmknt II Acfci Grark

wfctdi

4toi hi 14 In

Who daiiacd la 131 laa klnrlooi of IVgMbt th of Attala. III who had bagaaln< It to la*
IT

mta

aa Pool Mm. b* t BUgbl 8*4 I**" lUlj. Tb*at vara (I) orar lb* Maditarraaaaa eovti far U ||i ol aayaay (La* Cihtoti of i7) ; (ft to Aaiator U war afatort afttorldatoa, king of I'uota. (Lax

nil fir m ooaani liiiiitf actod lOajaUjr

i

476

miuppM
U the

\i

tii.

17-v

the Achaean war, 1 or in the thini Punic Roman people selected for itself a fit general, Publius Sctpio, but 1. lest determined that be should conduct the war as
V III

With ArurtonJcus* war was to be waged Pabiias Ltrinms and Lucius Valerius as consuls.
it

The Roman People was asked who

was their

pleasure should conduct thr wr I rassuv the con ul, being Supreme Pontiff, threatened to fine his colwa, the rlamcn of Mart, if he abandoned
; which fine the Roman people reordered the Klaroen to obey the Pontiff. But not eircn then did the Roman people entrust the war to a private (tenon, although there waa Afneanus who the rear before had mom| over Use Numantinc*; although he far surpassed all maw repuUtion and valour, he carried two tnbes only. Accordingly the Roman people gave the conduct of the war to the Consul Crassus r.v the than to Afneanus, a private of Cnaeus Pompciu*, that great and p reman, it was turbulent tribunes of the war with who proposed them.* waa assigned by the Senate to a private because the consuls refused it; and so Phihppus said that he sent bin "for the not as proconsul. What then to this election? or what is

ce
It

yet

aat

a
w

aanveaimUy

forget that as himself

mpportad ths

latter lav. rva ualaa,

Sertorfee,

a lieutenant of Marin*, the

to Italy in

aa RalU

83

a.0. fled to

477

makco n
MtaMt
et

I.I

II

rsviwiMM

drii, L.

Cnur,
toflocn
.

in

dcCffCfll

Hn pcriw TO, pfitato

nut iti.|.*utt.
in

Adtentttl cro,

wiM;
Q| -!l
asnbUmo*

QcgMo, rtdebor
Ortnitl*
;

pUcr*
tnodo

habrri, pftinjot,

UbrlU
Cor
tit*

detur nobis
r.

sftcot

popeJo

cUu

cot.

conunJttls,

at

Ml

iiMHlimtolwii
4.

vir, ai

non

ait

cum pa*

diffni

noo paten

At

mam (mud

id ciaudto)

C Caosari odotctccntulu
file

qoo prortidtam re* pobttra ne cogitatum qu Untuai babcrrt, at ine co salvo cose non poaftct, huic estraofdionriam impmam nan damn? esercitu* odimrndes Ml tuipci tcMU dandan fuit qaae cat eotan ratio, aot <jui potest nert, at tine uoperio teneatm us? Non igitar, qeod cat, id etiatunandam cat datum;

Goeaori, patrea ctmsrripti, imj>crium,

MUitea veterani, qui

Illius auctori-

P. SarriUos u-fco

aabdaad

ia

7t a.c too haarfon

pirstaa,

riiii.imi- xi.

in.

o-ao

which that most consistent and

influential

Lucius Caesar, has introduced into the He has proposed to assign the command to a man of the nobility and intrant v. hut a private person >y he has imposed on us ry ureal respousiUlity. Supposing I assent, 1 shall introduce a canvass into the Senate-house; apposing I say No, I shall appear by my vote, as if at an election, to h BOOT to a vary great friend. Bat if our pleasure is that an tion should be held in the Senate, let us be let as canvass ; only let a voting-tablet \\ h\ be given as, as it is given to the people da you compel such an alternative, that , either a man of prat eminence may appear to have suffered ilrfrt if we <L m>t m^rvr with you, or that each of as is passed over, though of equal if we are not thought worthy off the same honour? I overhear tlmt objection I by my own proposal gae an extraordinary command to Hag Cains Caesar > for lie hud given me extraordinary protection; and when I say When the aaaaa the Senate and the Roman people had received from a man such protection as had not even imagined, saeh that without it there be no safetv. was I not to give him an extraMnmand ? I had either to Uke away his army, or to give him the command ; for what method ng an army together Is there, or can without a command? What is not wrested away not therefore be regarded as given: you have wrested from Caiui Caesar his I. Caaacrlpt Fathers, if you had not given It The veteran soldiers who, atUching themselves to
I

479

MAftCUS TL'UJUS CICfitO

eeprrant, %olrlmnl
et legio quart*

Mk ob illo hnprrth
to omtulrr.nt *d

legio

MortU

IU

*m tonUtem
I

et

date

C (Www.
mihl

mpertom
(

MM nrreuuu*. User
cl nihil gent* pruato, oboccffo 1,

Kioto

L Cmir
qoondo
rcfragart

(mm
IX.

|nrUoniio

hnitni
.

rw

est),

iropenum irtutui drdlt

Sed do boo qeideai hort onoo, no

ut

OOOJtoJcO

EMNOboiMO p<fBOt|Of Doi

Dicaro,

CO AiUn
inutile
rei

et

Syrian

oortMotur

poblkoe, tod priot,

qoom

torpe con-

mMboo ftt, rideto. Co cooool deolgortoo obaideatur, com In eo tlberando salu* %it poaJta lone, * popolo Romano peotifen cite poirieidooi|ttC
ouxjoc id brlluro

gtnmm, quo

belio
si

do
in

dignitate,

de Nbertate, de %iu drerrnainu*,

vcm-ril, propoaiU

potrsUtrm qnt* Antooi

omt

decerUtto eomaliboo opUmis et

forUsftfenJa

P.

SerriW

VIII.

20-

tus autbontr.

mma nd, and his name, had on behalf <> wished to by him; the Martian legion and upheld the authority of the Senate and
hit co

the honour of the State only to demand as t general and leader Cains Caesar His coma the UUSSHIui of war gave Cains Caesar, the Senate Hut to a private jwrvm. unoccupied nothing- I bee; you to tell n, I bate to deal with a man well versed nta when baa the Senate erer given

1\

But snongb of

Ibis,

lest

mHiaajajf a

man who

it

my

greet

appear to be and has

|>ose

done
a

me
l

raocb kindness; ami

that not only does not ask, but refuses comBut that ot 'her (irouosa), Conscript Fathers, is not agreeable to the dignity of the consuls, to the severity of the crisis the that the consuls, by way of prove with Isabella, should have Asia and Syria will explain why it is inexI allotted to them pedient to the State, but first consider how dishonouring it Is to the consuls. When a cm elect is being besi eg ed, when the safety of the State
is dependent on bis relief, when pestilent citizens the Roman and murdere rs have people, and when we are waging a war, a war in which we are imskndlng on behalf of our honour,

man mand r

our liberty, our Uvea

If

'"v

man

fall

into

Antonius, racks and tortures are prori the struggle on behalf posed for of all these things has been committed and entrusted to two most excellent and valiant consuls,

481

MARCUS Tl'LUL'S CiCEtO

lit

Ami c t S rriac
ut
fr

nnHBO

MHMI
U
;

aat MMFiBjM HMlUMMfll *ero iu dtctrwanl,

Id rata

rr*UUt

UM.
Uberc Qaod
nui dc

Si aulrta icii pat

4eri tie* poirtt,

..lurat

bio te anioK, qa

IliMIIW

to Blltt 1>MlJill
Facte

Bmlo

cogttar*.

PUI

Id

qalde et eo

tuilium.

hoa ad alum

alia

ei parte cerai

X.

Adda
add
oaDoaaia a isaattouUB palrtaa mlata

SVmo
ti

quit]

un.iluiriutr noatra
1

TVw u,

oo ib Motion

Tat oalr aluraaUv. fur alt eaatattW 4**

mn

ol Caltaa*. carrfcdx at Intr. to relta Utry *1. nmgmd c+\\i* Cbaipin. Tbt
,

mmmc
MM awnroed
udlum'
ar

\i

*i-x. J3

shall

we Ulk of

Asia and Syria, and to appear to

for
itt.r Hrwti.s

caose foe ssjapicion, or ground cround

Ofc>Hanlimnpiwl u "onU

they might have Mid " abandoned,

mow Hon at all of the province hat been aaade at a moat inopportune time For bow o swf men yoor mind, Caloa Pansa, mar be, as It la, directed to the relief of the most valiant and the ooblast of all men, yet the nature of the case a yoo wiithnu to turn your mmd of Dotabella, and to divert to Asia Stria some portion of your care and your But. if it ra poasible, I would HI had even several minds, that yoo might direct Since that cannot be, we wish all towards Motion. yoo with the most excellent and loyal mind you only to think of Hrutos. That indeed you And with the greatest application, as 1 hot two thing*, above all. two great nan can, I do not say, transact at the HI but even think out Ml clearness. kindle that most excellent seal of toots, and not transfer it to some other task in
1

deserted, betravcd. Hot I Mr thai any

JL

Add to that the talk of men, add their suspicions,

who

Copy me, whom yoo have always resigned a province organised and amrippi d by the Senate, so that, dismissing every r thought, I right tjuench the conflagru
add the odium.
praised,
A myself that was devouring my coo: alone, with whom yoo would, having regard to our dose friendship, certainly have consulted had thooght asjyaf closely concerned you, there will

483

MARCUS
c>

Tl

UCEtO
m*ilo

m
.

pf tli law

Ufa*

ip , pi taa tkmgmU

coUegm.

rW

claru*lta..

Mm

pole

MtfMaUr

limn j^rtt. tn ari tUt

ret

u.l.r!.

qua*, |lurnl trmptit el

Vcaa*.

*.
r *l
A

TMlnj

al.ud

a nobis

bM

4 Matai

art

reddite prtoa ,1 MOM ctriUtk qui iU cmcrnwdos Ml ot Iliad jpiua*. qaod da |UO fMH i x| ..i'ii >r.r HHPJOB1

mm BnH

wit

nWRVI
la

mJvo *aKt mum u firr; |tucnt, utitrr:

el

MSM

raal vm,
ijlhh! a^itur,

t"llrruu, pri:iiri.i->

nunc,

nu.

qoac certc

%ct>

Aaiac rivttalaan atqac mrbkwm reltoqoator?

>

"At

IVoy at afafaard ol taa city, *a4 wm aftarwato* It ta. aroonung to too aaooaai, broagkt by Awmi to Italy. Pal^aaafMtaHvMpraaabljaaMtaaffto oaa. 8 o. fa*, a. 4|Fmmu Too word aat to Bag1Mb symbolic of a mfrguoni 4<4

TU rJUdtajR.or baago of Patba, whko vatkaottatl

of
ti

oudtl
<o

Ron.

mnjfpK
be bo

xi

i.

j 3 -a5

amy

who ill believe that the province wms assigned to yoo against your with. I beseech you, eel in accordance with your lingular wisdom, and this report, to that you may not appear to I hat yoa do not care for. And you most the more earnestly, because your moat colleague cannot (all under the tame iusknows nothing, he suspects nothing of be b waging a war he itandi in Im ; be is HgbHmi for his own existence ; he ill bear a province has been assigned to him before he can have any saepltiiai that time has been given to discern that matter. I fear that our armies too, who hsve eeeae to the snnliiir of the State, not under a fixed levy, but in their own voluntary seaj, may have their spirits checked if they think *r bare in thing else in oontcnipUtMJO but the urgent war. Bet if pr o vinces seem to consuls desirable things ae they have often been desired by the noblest men Irat restore to as Brutus, the light and ornament of the community, who ihould be preserved as
1 1

om

carefully as that statue which

fell

down

Iron.

and

is

kept

the

u>t.iv of Vesta,

and whose

Mans we

be safe. 1 Then we will. be possible, lift you to the very sky on our shoulders choose for you the most worthy t r |m>\ uicr now let us set ourselves to the issue we hsve at h
,1m, shall
1

That

issue is

whether we are to

live as free

men

assuredly to be preferred to slavery. And what if that proposal of yours also cause delay our pursuit of Dolabclla f For when will a e waiting until not even a consul come

or die; and death

vestige of the States

and

cities

of Asia

is

left?

485

MNRCU8 TULUU8

vfood

si

confcccnt

of cfa x) Wisj nqi of tbo 11 *ad Rot r he like 10 Mi out b choo and dot Dot gwwrallr nVUr t ill h to forced to more. i a aoU of
I

Um raj

wbm

TW

mil.IITU
- But they

.5-x,. ,o

will scad someone of their own body." opoaal greatly to be approved of by me who * while ago refused an extraordinary command to a

inguished man. if a prival they will tend a own worthy of the office." More worthy than Publius Servilius > But the mi doea sot p oss e s* uch a man. When 1 thought an t should be given to no on am 1 to approve of it beiiu d to
\

Fathers,

army, and a

spirit

proved in the liberation of thr

Mate
Either Marcus Brutus, or both. I ahoold propose simply, as often b done, "in the case ot consuU, or r> Is. one or hod wo not tied l Brutus to Greece, and not preferred his sshrtsnrf should be directed towards lUly rather to Asia; not that we might have a means of row the sphere of operations in Italy, but that the army there should itself have a sup; from over the sen also. Besides, Conscript Fathers, rruft Brutus is detained by Caius Antontus, who holds the grrat and important city of Apollooia. and holds, I think, Byllis, holds Atnantia, is pfenstag on Epirus, is threatening Oricum, and who bos some cohorts and cavalry. If Brutus is drawn away from there to another war, we shall And we have also to see cert i ii and that shore of Italy. And yet I to b voi delays so long ; for he likes to pat on his glove* himself,* and not endure too long the But if Brutus finishes his work, terrors of a siege

XI.

Who then it that man?

47

MARCUS
j

TI-M.1 US CICKBO
.

n miibH
rnim

:ur i\ \rfit I; * rr: jM;llt<-r pr of u n.m, %i belkro perteqaatur. qmw I In (.- om yimuiilw, qomi Ipae per tree, ut editor quuqoe fecit, neqoe in tut s q eJbut confetti wiiif mnii est

mun

Km

Braaai

tl

Qm

Mm

nMi

la taata

caa ncakaaa rt prrturbatkmc

i
Nee

otiua perrre qoatn tnortba.

Mil BnttiM Mt Cat* patriae Itfi a i autctanvraam aaftudkaeil Iteque. * ad noe nihil de Dolabclla )fgiiadn, Uwen ego pro de paUretn, earn eearnt talc* trtate, etoritate, not'rum altrrtu* uun nol* liUte Mtnuni

'

an ftodm aofert

Ml

NumtmturBrotMe&ftpe^iAtttdeerrUrwMtrft, Neqae ei >etodnm

I

edtoUvit ; omnia tan rate Ut; legftooat conarriprit norm, escape! reteres, ctjuiUturn ad at abduiH DalabelUe atque aoajdaai tanto parrickiio obHtani hoetero aat eratcati iodicarK Nam, ai IU react, quo In *< la pari eaajri eiaHh aeAttarct? Quid? C tudine animi et coaaiBi naallli praeditat aonae to it etL nrohiberet Srria coaatlio nrofectns Srrla Dole eat, at problberet belUtn ? qoa lege, qoo mrr rnnU, qoae rei pubfaeae ralutaria ipae war eearnt, legitime et mu habereutar ; eat enini Iti
(

? Imii

airfaa. or e eKHfafa

oien (Facree*).

Th Baiti bad on Jeae 1 allotted Crete to Bret**, narea* to A., m*1 Alnce to Oeeaiea. The aabaeeteat -jameat of Mae. to Aaloataa (PkiL
remdiaWa:
ci.

ML

x. &.

I'll

\I.

u. ,6-xn. 28

that he will do the State more bj pursuing DoUbclU than by remaining in he rill act on his own initiative, as he has r, and will not, in the midst of so many

that rail for immedi-itr help, wait for of the Senate. For both Brutus and Cassias have been already their own Senate in many things. For we most In soeh a general upturn and confusion follow the time* rather than precedents. And it is not the irst time that Brutus or Cassiits has regarded vafctv and liJ^rtr of their country as the holiest lev end moat eieellent precedent. So even if there were no motion before ee for the pursuit of DoUbella, I should think it as good as a decree, when we
>
i

here eminent

mm

of
i

meh

rsJoor, influence,
h

and

arm iev a l ready hate knowledge, and of the other

we

rr|ort

he knew oar minds ?

prorinee
I
I

wait for oar decrees when For he has not set out for his
ias

hurried into that of another,

Macedonia he considered that all things were that yon wish to be yours; he enrolled new old ones; he withdrew i*s cavalry, and in hi* own judgment regarded h as yet not stained by soeh a murder, Had it not been so, by what right ly. cavalry from a con would h
;
i t

Again, did not C*iu GessSus, a man endowed equal gr eatness of mind and judgment, set out from lulv with the rowed object of keeping Dolabella out of Syria? Vnder what law? By what right? Br that which Jupiter himself has sanctioned, that ite should he held as all things salutar lawful and right; for law is nothing else but a

489

mm:,

i.ius

c*

no
tracts

recU
irtur
lr|fi

numine rtwaai

berneoU, prohibene contraria.

paralt Caaal aa,

cum

e>*

pro-

foctau,alieaaa> prortacaua,al bcanioce Irgjbnt acriptU

etereotar, bat vara oppreaata aaaai

lag* naturae.

Sad at aa

laatia

qeoqea

auctorlute

nrmeutur,

Cam P

|iUbrlU. qulquc ciat crodetieaimi

el

Uclrrnmi factnort* mioutr toe*, liulorce far pofmh Roman* a aeoate ladi raU alt, eiai q ai I' DoaabaHaaa bdlo prrar qn rwdn ei ci ejeutrft ti, qui omnia deorum boinine naqac rata novo, at
,

ii*u.l it...

inctpiabill

tcelere

pul

aa patriae

pm

aaMaai

proaaai >*m Sjnrtaai

apMMfa,

ut qui opttmo lure earn

.io

provinHam opt

consul?. A. Allirno legato

r.

trad aft,

<

Crbpo pro coosoK ncrritum acciptfc eoaquc umque ua copiu), at at qua pracr
peiv

paratertt, bell P. DolabelUtn terra mariqoc

Bias belli gerendt causa, quibus el videator, nates,

dam pertineant, ut

iuuUi, pecuniam ceteraque, quae ad id bellum gc iapersndi in Syria, Asia, Bitbynia, Pooto iuepotcetatemque nabeat, utiquc, qaamrumqoc in provincial!) eius belli gerendi eaoaa adar maiut impcrium C. Caaai pro console tit, quam
i

fit,

qui

cam pronnrUm

torn

optiiiclitt,

cum

C.

400

BHHJPFtC
ling

xi.

m. ig-jo

of right derived from the will of the God, bat if nonest, forbidding the contrary. This was the law, then, Caatius obeyed when he set
tltet, if

men obeyed wrr

taw*, belonged to another, but that,

bee overthrown, was

r,

when these had by the law of nature Hut, that this may alto be confirmed by
bit
I

move

that

Pablins Dolabclla, and those that were allies, and abettors of bis most cruel and savage enmc, have been declare! I the Senate of the Roman people ; and whereas the has decreed that Publius DolabelU should be In war. to the end that be who, bj a nsexpiablecrhne, has polluted all the lasts of Gods and men, and has involved himself in a murderous sltaok on bis countrv, may pay to Gods and men the penalties deserved and due It is the pleasure of the Senate that Caius Cassim, proconsul, hall bold the province of Svria with the best possible mtus Marcius Cristitle ; that he sha pos, proconsul, and Loeitts Statins M u r. u v proconsul, Alllenus. legate, their armies, and they shall Ibem to bim ; and with those forces and may have besides enrolled shall attack In order Pnblins Doiabella in war by land and sea. to the waging of that war he shall have the right and power in Syria, Asia, Bithvnia, and Pontn
I

making requisitions, from whomsoever he thii good, of ships, sailors, and money, and other things pertaining to the carrying on of that war and that, vincc he shall come for the earn on of that war, there Caius Cassius, proconsul, si have a greater authority than the man who shall then
;

49

MARCUS TULUUS

ri,

ot

muttfe be!

rot!

futonuM.

UUqae
tk

C Htm

A. Ilirtfae fUtmtU

Iter

eta vklrfrttif, rt public* reca}

practorik ad

Ect Q. Carcili B*mi. prirmti

13 ct praccUri
viri,

ii)iu

quidcm, ted
et nostra

fortii

robusUs et
filn

rictor cicrritiu.

Dei.

Un

regis ct patris ct

rt

magna*
filio

more

in

spcs,

nnm
ml

Quid dkmm de

SoU*MS& UMlmmumtM/0ri*4
Mdng
49
th.nkt aoowthtof

Ua Utke

ifUr

; ;

rmi.ippic
bold that province

xi. hi. 30-xm. 33

Cassius proconsul

when Cains

into that province.

That Kin* Deiotarus the

Md
of the

King Deiotarus the ion, if they shall help ~ass*us, proconsul, with their troops and rea* in many wars they have helped the empire
will
[ile
;

Bomb people,

cam

the gratitude of the

and also if the other kings, h*ll do the same thing, the

people will not be forgetful that Caius Pansa and Aulas llirthss, ipeisli, the one or both of thru., if it seem good to them, alter the re-establishment of the Stale, do at the earl iest moment refer the question of the consular and praetorian provinces to this body In the ssrantisss let the provinces be held by ent holders until a successor for each be
of their services.

And

By tine decree of the Senate yen will hv the ardour of CassJus, and will arm him with lor yon cannot be ignorant of his ; His spirit is as you see spirit end of hie forces. his forces those yon have heard of, brave and d< " men, who, even if Trebonius had been alive, not have allowed the brigandage of Dolabella
.

ictrate into Syria.

Allienus,

my

close friend

connes km, after the death of Trebonius will certainly he unwilling even to be called the legste Quintus Caeeilius Bassus, without a of Dolabella cosnmiavioo, but a brave and disting uished man, has Each of the Deiotari, a strong and victorious army. the kings, father and son, has an army both large and trained in our fashion the son is a man of the natural intellect, and
;

i>e

highest charact

it

am

to say of the

493

mmu

Ki in
}

<

icno

Lt m

"bcUu. "crom etfem del

de

ilk

Tiro

efoet M.
BAmI us
proptoM|vls rege adiutt
la
;le

fts^tlsBSM|ee

mumm el
la

ah ; eqviutu et ptdsstHbm
pree ioct n

brllam;

mo
!ii-flt,

clirrrc

Jin

rt

Irtorta brill iudfcertt

4 fait
is*

Qm

Iii
;

bello

fait

cam mate

tin recta

Mt !!,
Ad ha* lend eat

t ltepersjii

est.

rcges, ettom ditcetot leerunt; tat

eios Id Syria

mow

XIV

Parate habet

laperatorei

re public contra I)olabrllm,

Ule res geasH ante MpsjH

tuiiit

wiiiwiiI
i

>\

r:

iin<]ur untiiaiii l'rtrth<ruiu .tn|" tu lilxri

.'

oa* foUd. by Halm.

inlHiil Bella. Marasa, asd Leamtta to etparala (Hi-70 nc) against Mitbrklataa. king of Pbataa; aad P. 8ariUas Varia aamioat taa prates Is OOida to 7ft
>

Ha bad

wan
494

PHI

in. 33-*". 35

father? whose goodwill to the Roman people is coeval with h own age ; who baa been the ally of oar general io war, but the lea.iown How often have Sulla, Murcnn of that man in the Senate ; in what

of compliment and honour l What Pompeius, who considered DrjoUru to !* bejOnd any man in all the world the whole-hearted friend and true well-wisher and faithful ally of the Roman people > Marcus Bihulus and I were in command in neighbouring and *cre helped by this adjacent provin< tame kiog both with cavalry and infantry forces. There followed this most hitter and calamitous **r* in which I need not say what Dciotarus should hare done, or what would have been the I policy, especially as victory gave judgment in a manner contrary to hi* feeling*.* It in that war he made a mistake, the mistake was shared with the is judgment was right, we should not To these a vanquished cause. will be added other kings, levies will also be add Nor tariff d will fleets be wanting; so great is the wis have of Caseins, so great is his opinion name in Syria and Phoenicia. \ ate has against Dolabella, Conscript aius Cassias a general ready, and not He did only readr but skilled and brave things before the arrival of the valiant Bibulus u he rooted the most distinguished generals and the and fre Innumerable forces of the flam the ruthless assault of the Parthians. His
hall
I

say of Coaeot

ft,

If r

sea Casasr aad Pompeius. bad supported Pompeius.

495

MARCUS TU1XIU8 CICEtO

AnimadrertJ, patret conarripti, e i tndl el * etlam me Brutut. nlmium Cammm urnart, Caiaio

ma dominat
ego
rr,

at prin

mo?

Ncmpe

toe, qui
I>

pabllrae

Qukl?

lirutum

M rodctn UtrorinU naufra

otti.

gta rolligam?
tudlciocun.
1

Ego veto bU*

roorordiar. Irgom.
quaii.

ut rSct

non puMii, qoln coa lam oderim,

paaWoam AUgp
37

ewmwofend*.

;boceniin

qui pro re publics

crpmint accutiOjOe soot C. Gaeaercm, beneAriomm paternonim, bodtrqoe rem pobUeam

tflont

mm

magno

perkolo,,

non

toerl toll

aed etiam commodis aogere debeo. Qui ant mi q coot, ut leptima, ut octave legio, in magna gloria
'

ojaW(M): m

mii i t (Karaar).

tMOJarM^(IUIai).
'

Th#ai tioaofCamr.

Ktfcmxl

to is ch. 6. m*u.

49

PHUJPPM
U
it

\1

ur. 35-37

Tfcsal achiev ement

it

* 1 pass over ; tor as ret welcome to all, let us by the testimony of memory rather

Mi

I have observed, Conscript Fathers, and I have alto beard It whispered, that Brutus, that Cassius reeeJtu ague rated honour from me; more that to Caattas by my proposal is given the position

Hi ii and of s prince. Whom do I hoi. it is the men who are themselves an to the State. What have 1 not always ta ins Brutus in my proposals ? Do you rove me? Should 1 rather pay honour to the Antoott, Use shame and disgrace, not of t Camihes alone, but of the Roman name? or should I baaoar Ceaaoriau*,8 in war aa eaemv, in peace a buyer of Iir slums > or most I collect the ti wreckages from the same brigandage * As for me, I am so Car from honouring those of i quiet* concord, laws, law-courts, and liberty, that I help bat hate them as fully as I love the of a
in
n
!

See," he says, M yon do not offend the veterans " the whisper I hear most of all. I certainly am bound to safeguard the veterans, those, that is, who are sound in principle, but I am certainly not bound to fear them. But those veterans who have taken op arms in defence of the State, and have followed Cains Caesar, the guarantor of the benefits his fa and are today defending the State at risk these I am bound, not only to safegaard. bat also to load with advantages. And those that are neutral, as the seventh, as the eighth 1 think should be esteemed worthy of great
this ts

497

MARCUS TULUU8

see tc et CsJoni tradideruut ad

MM
et

'i

U1

'i

'

hMBfcl putrt

quos

flUm

ornare, sut quiet

XV
? wmrnof,
cupiunt huerarc
?

qui D.

Bmturo oUidionc
*it,

Quibuf

mm BnttI talus cat

?

l**unt Caesi oocoeo odiasc

An

eonim.

dvis quisquam totonun Hk> delectai Tertlo *cro umrn non uulitum MilOWOMllll, ted im ho* t mm cupto quam accrbimim um
inurrrr.

i^uamquam,

pstret

con'

qooutque sentcotist Jtccmu vetermnorutn arbitratu Quod eoruin Unturo faudtum est, quae Ui.U arrugantia, ut ad arUtnum
conscript!,

quod

ratio)

quam quid Unmet quid novae legiones ad lil*randam patriam paratiftaimac, quid cuncta Italia dc vestra gravitate
nobis
arbitror,
Italtae,

sentiai
cut.

cnim semper floret, aetas succedit N Diu legiones Cacaaris riguerunt, none rigent Pinmoj rigent Hirti, vigent Caessris filit, rigent PUnci vincunt numcro, vincunt actatibus ; nimirum
;

49*

PHILIPPIC
honour and
praise.

XI. iiv

37-xv. 39

But the companions of Antonius,

Caesar's gifts, are

now they have eaten up

hrslaglllg a consul elect,

and threaten with fire and sword, and have handed themselves offtr to Sass and Cafo, men born for cnmr and plondor, is there any man that thinks they sh be safeguarded ? Therefore the veterans are loyal, and we are bound even to distinguish then or neutral, and we are bound to preserve thru disloyal, and against their madness we are at war, and have iustiv taken op XV. Who then are the veterans whose feelings we toofead r Those who desire to liberate Deeimus am siege ? As the safety of Brutus is presjftf
;

to them, how can they hate the name of ? Or are they those veterans who stand aloof from either side? 1 am not afraid that any citizen of those whose delight is repose will be indignant But the third class, not of veteran soldiers, but of most savage enemies, 1 wish to sear with a brand of the hit tercet pain. But how long, Conscript Fathers, shall we 1 press oor opinions at the precept of the What means all this conceit of theirs, all so that we even choose our generals as ther prescribe? But I for I must say, Conscript Fathers, what I feel 1 think wr should regard not so much the veterans as what the recruits, the flower of Italy, what the new legions now fully ready to liberate their country, what the whole of Italy feels For nothing is for ever regarding your firmness. Long were the nourishing ; age succeeds to age. lagjona of Caesar vigorous; now the Pansas are vigorous, thr Hirtu. the sons of Caesar, and the Plana, they are superior in numbers, they are

499

\i

t*<

iit i

en

no

500

PHILIPPIC XI. . 39-40

superior in ajre ; assuredly they re alio superior authority, for they are waging * war that is approved of all nations. Accordingly, to these rela

have been promised, to the others they have Lei those others enjoy what they have, there be paid the rewards we have r that, my nope is, the immortal Gods adjudge to be most equitable.
paid.

eae circumstance*, I think, Conseript Pal thai the proposal I made to you should be affirmed. 1
1

ii

was. however. Inst: ass Iotr.

501

I\

PRODUCTION TO PHILIPPIC MI
partisans of Antonius,

still working in his on the Consul Pansa abou of March to propose that a second embassy should be wot to AntonJoc, to consist of P. Sen Icero, C alm s , L. Pbo, and I- Caeiar. There seems to have been an intimation by Antonio* friends that he was now In a disposition to submit to reason. Accordingly on the lint day of the debate an embassy was agreed to, and Cicero himself seems eing no doubt also to have oppn*.

interest, pert ailed

Ibr the safety of

I).

Brutus,

who wu

the next P ScrvtlittS *|**c against thr }>r.>|>osal, and it was abandoned. It was tl.m that the twelfth Philippic was del Gccro said that the mistake made in agreeing to an embassy it waa the duty of a wise man to correct, there being no real evidence of any change in Antonius; that an embassy could do, indeed had done, nothing but harm to thr State; that the ardour of the boroughs and colonies and of the legions would be that, aa no concessions could be made, of peace were possible; and that the of so many criminals to Rome was Finally, he said that he himself was should have been selected as \ as being t>..m the first the bftttf Moreover, he showed the of Antonius. personal danger be himself im urn <!. and pleaded that
Trebotiitts.

Cftl of being treated like

On

53

RODUCTION TO
hit life aboald

I'llll

IITM

Ml

be jcaloatl* guided for the taka of

the end of Mare Panra departed to join

eolleajrve Hlrtlaa before Mafiaa. This peeer* It real It a thirteenth aa

hb

we

lea?

from Clew kliwlf la a

Cuihii (ad /a*. 12. 7) that, after the delivery of the eleventh Philippic, he wm Introduced be M. Sereilloe to a aad mode a ape* la
let t er lo

dCaaaaa.aadaad
that Im bad .Ht woold not alt, lor dccrcce of the SeaeU aanoeftf la hie on faiblna defend lae State." Wc learn from the uror letter that Cicero's
*

the with of

504

m.

tulu

cicti
PIIILIPI'it
\

\M

OBATtO
i

DUODKtlfA

Mil, Icnpi. errsre

im, mi n

miWi urn de

borUtor.

At qui
le

ticio, tk

HMgnitadtnem aim!, qui pinsln

Vot tutcm, patres
tpe
conscripts,

mt
non

errituti.

Irrrrtorurn

aiUU

dcditionit,

qoam aid
cct-

apprlUrr mallent, de impooendit, non

lefttms

COjpUre.

Autrrat

utrm

OCHi

I'wOMldQ.

506

MIR TWELFTH PHILIPPIC

5T M.

OI

TULLIUS ANTONIUS
If.

seems most unseemly, Conscript man, to whose advice on most important matters you often assent, should be deer i*rd. raj. lrd, %h>ul<l rrr. yrt eOMOlfl uy*rlf as it is in voor rosnpanv and together with a consul of the greatest wisdom that I have erred, when two conoalars l had brought us the hope of an honoorabls peace, tfnnu that they were friends of, -re Intimate with Marcos Antonius, they seemed HkeJr to know of some mishap that had befallen msb which was unknown to us. At the house of one ore hi wtfe and children the other was daily writing to, and hearing from him, and was Antonius' avowed partisan. These men, in suddenly invr os to make poaeo thing they had not don< a long lis appeared to be acting not wit! a reason. Their mutation the consul supported. And what a consul If we look for prudence, one that could not easily be deceived ; if for patriotism, one thai would never approve of a peace except when Antonius was yielding and indeed conquered ess of mind, one to prefer death to slavery. But jrou, Cooscript Fathers, did not appear rees ao much to be forgetful of your most wc a. when there come the hope of a surrender which his friends would prefer to call a peace, to
it
I

Tmovom

therm,

that

plat'
tion*,

tosition. not the acceptance, of condi-

My

hopes indeed, and also

believe yours,

507

M\l:

iri.urs.hii:.)

Mic
1

eUam

frotorca

At

vohu habitant oroli mrt. trUttore* % idrUm. Quod at noo tu et. cur a MaocM ct Caleno poHaahaaai,
pari* cat fcrta

meat?

Negat Plao

Atqoaldnaa
Ifatlam hnplk-afa potant.
cat
<

novo

conaflto,

in re nihil

omnino nori

II

DrrrptJ. derapU, inqaaan.

pobtlca.

Quod

klehMnet|uidrtn.rdqtta%l pc rrl i^l-

ncaa;

pracatrfaiierat

acicm

aafanl

D. BniU
Inrludl

aalu.

Qoodai

in hello dart vkarii olereat,

UbeoUr me,
pat

at

D
4

Brotaa

esHtrrrtor, pro
!

dk>

.fi capti am: "Xeiii AUjne har vorr </ Mutioa qokle rcccaacrtt, aadkaaaa Antoruam, r M
'

Donua eidrUtur.

itaqae fracti

tuoms

Recedltigitur.MuUna? " Neacio htttlW "Credo," tnquit Calenoc; M aed iU, ut tencat Vakk hercolea mcaa Uhorandatn cat, dignitatem.
patrea conscript!, at vcatiaia dignitatem amftta tm,

qoac maxima
SO

cat, Antoni,

qoac ncqoc cat ulU nequc

PHII.IITK

\II

..

;-. 4

by my hearing that the house of Antonius was afflicted with mourning, and that kit wife in lamentation Here too I saw that the partisans of Antonius, on whose faees my eyes continually dwell, were depressed. If this be not so, why baa mention been made of peace, by Piso and Catenas especially, why at this time, why so why so suddenly? Piso says he knows of nothing, he says he has not beard of anything ; Galenas says no news has arm. they bow moke these denial* when they think we tn an embassy for peace. What need then for a new policy if la the facts there be nothing

wu

at all
II

new

have been deceived, deceived, I say, Contie cause of Antonius that has script Father been pleaded by his friends, not that of the State. Thai indeed I saw, bat as it were through a mist the safety of Decimus Brutus had dulled the edge of my intelligence Bat If substitute were commonly allowed in war, I would gladly suffer myself to be shut in instead of him so that Decimus Brutus might be let oat Then too we were taken by this Iraw remark of Quintus Fufiu from Mutma, shall we not listen to Antonius ? not even if he says he will submit to the jurisdiction It seemed hard; and so our of the Senate we yielded. Does he then resolution broke down " do not know." Does draw from Mutin* believe so," says Cab ha obey the Sena-bat on condition that he maintain his dign Hercules, Conscript Fathers, vou must stoutly strive to lose yoar own dignity, which is very great, neither exists that of Antoniuv
;
-

We

59

MA KITS

II

per tc perdidiL

S4

Ikim vobama

liquid

Quid autra two IntrgnuB

poteat.*

eat tapawiti, qu-

bomini* cat cmrr iMtiilmlli In errvfr pefai t tfmrc; pcwU rtoca enim

Cmkmth

Dtaraaaa

cat

ilk

caUgo,

diluttt, palrl. uicsnui

quam paalo ante dui omnu, ic not toliu.

Attrndutt%, teulo
libera*.

Admins
-

minim,
t

P.

..

nkm
?

ttmtidmk

gmtWadiqM wolfMb

onoi

cKiotdko

digniUte. ted etiam ape aalutfc

apolktu Antoaiua,

Ad cum ire te kfataai qui no De ok tuum rntio quam rcprebeodatur. Nat reprcsoli Quid? ir foctA*umui Pan doc
tan arcuraUr locates cat
tao*
egit,oisft uti

caeaa paalo Mite

Quid

falaam pcoditkmfe a ee Mttpfeftoncm

dcpeflcft ?

Lnde autem

uU

auaptcio

cat.'

;*trocink>

repentino, quod

subito

soacepit

>

80 luiai

for it*

iisa fiwrfBru

d na.

arvhatkchadloaaj.-laoafli
u> Biin, ** aaa fro* taa ilipriMiiia ia A.

u/ht C

ba wiatr.

mw

Why Mod

aa iibii/ vbara w* can a faaulr that taaj bar girao

aaapa?510

PHII IPPH

XII.

ii.

4-6

area exist, that be mar b? your means recover what

If

he wercabje

m
i

Ins

negotiations nth you, I perhaps would listen to though * but would listen e be stand hnn.you must resist him, or together your dignity you mast resign your liber

Ii

not open

an

rwibaaay has been pi^int. |>cn to a wise man that can be corrected man is liable to err; it is the |>art only of a fool toper*c\rrr in error; for the later thoughts, as the saying is, are usually the riser. That nisi has been dispelled I spoke of just now ; light has broken ; the case is clear ; we see * thing, nor with our own eyes only, but we are warned by our friends. You heard just now the M md, speech of s most distinguished man' Souse, the wife, the children, m Good men were fondoringj my friends monrnteg.* .ding me. that 1 had m the hope of peace And no wonder, Puhlius ica an embassy."
;

for

by your most proper and weighty

tonius had been deprived, I do not say Who dignity, IkjI even of hope of safety would not marvel that you should go to him as an
I feel 1 argue from my own eincrience course at action, identical with yours, is blamed Are we the only ones blamed ? What was Me that the' bravest of men, Pansa, now saade such a precise and lengthy spe< What did he intend but to ward off from himself And what did that a suspicion of trea. the hasty advocacy seHsicioo spring fron ace which he suddenly adopted, being taken

y ?

how my

>

y the

same error

as ourselves.

5"

MA HI
III.

S Tl

LUIS

(^a^Mtemtirai,
cnwttlft.

une tdtenM mat*tk> dent tomoftaJe

Icgatio
eat
.*

QvJd

pebtfene
<!

Prodeme
?

am
U Urn
rt oo

obf

Ob/utura

quid,

ilUm

furUuUmani

popnU

qnid?

rttm-ta

Italian

Mi

qoo ctjcitni commune Inrrndltim runrrit * An rufemo* ette duo puUrout face at cat ( el jirar c tuUme odium in An Ionium, qui
i

jM.lliciU

Hint, qui arm*, qui e totot et nutate et

III. Unpin* rite fndknvr .%it inquam arbi fortiadmc o manti c manftnn r
,

ID
'

,uid ?

Icgionam noatrarum nrnrot nonne

.

hit
I
.*

con
Ipt*

incidimas? Qab est infiammaU nnino futurut sit ipc pndf

siliU

.id

obku
hoc

ilU

Mart

cnclrstit

et

divinn legfto

n
fluent

et moUietar atqne illnd

pulchenimom
jrladii,

tomen nmtttrt

e&ndent

> A. bad OiayllymipitJ (et /ftO. ii. 30) to ooloaj at Capaa. Hi ooliuiiati war ejtotad by taa Cupoana,

IMIII.llTir
1 1 1

XII. in

7-3

But If there bat been an error, Conscript induced by a vain and fallacious 1. the- be<t harbour "nUnee is a -f coun what advantage to the Sutc can our cmhav
-

v to

njore? Whalready hurt and injurml vou not think the Roman people's Boat eager and steadfast longing fot tin i t ivtcf f of liberty has been lessened and weakened ~y bear o! an emlausr for |>eace ? What do of the boroughs? What of the colonies? -will be filled What of the bole .: with the same teal with which it had biased the common conflagration ? Do we not rr ill be repe n ta nce on the part of those that hare proteased and maniicsted hatred against AntonJus those that have promised money, promised arms, and have devo* In what soul and the safety of thr State ? a, that is in these days a second fashion v Iged Roaii, approve this resolution of yours ? then disloyal citisens, and east and shut t That is the city, that, I say, from which, when it made a valiant effort to crush him, Antonius was by force rescued. 1 the sinews
tajufa

of our legion
hljsilll
ll

is

likVl
li

hope of peace Ik- offered in legion, though a legion of a will on this report grow god-like and div languid and soft, and lose that most glorious n words will fall down, their sj irop from their hands. For, as it has followed the
for

war

if

5'3

MA1CUS TUIXIUS
le gretiore odfto

debert

mm m

Antonium

et

ImpenUore wutn, ted

rr U,u.t

at bQetcni ct

Aittooiam;

MttUaeJ rot; quitt

Mtrte
stri

M^nm

AMfttevit

ill

mm

Qtfd

tmt u*, ooi belle

ienun.de

r
I

tolu

ftnsetefitJbtt*,

ted ettem invito

..*

A.

not am so nnee

mine deekrente*

ted etctofto tuompiitnn

Quid.'
ud.turoro

GnUta quo tandem pnUttt? ilU rn.ro hum*

belli

propel,

endi, odmli i btr endi, tnrtlnrndl principal

OrfHe D.

BmU

notum ipoum. ne diemm U

it

tnnie, vine, peennia belli principle, nnnot

cmdelJUtt M. Antool
r,

totem corpus untur; omoet aequo

wore, boforv ih#? look
to ar

nom

j1

tmnti.

All Hommti

nek

ta

U*-in f of tao 4*. TV onoiet aUodod Hirtm. and Ceeaar Octortooa*

54

UueToI

I'HILimc
t will

XII. m. 8-iv. o
it

not think

owes a greater hatred

lle.

te-

Weareahamed

nit legion, shamed before the Fourth, which, est eemin g our authority with cu,ual loyalty, deaei Antonius, not as being a consul and their general, but as an enemy and opponent of his country ; we are sha med before oclore that most loyal array composed two legions, which has been already reviewed, 1 and has set out for Mutina for if it hear the name of peace, that is, of our (car, though it maN retr. For why, when the HI assuredly halt trumpet sounds the recall should it hasten
;

And what ts more unjust than this that we should, without the knowledge of those who are waging the war, decide on peace, and not merely ut their knowledge, but also against their Aula IlirUu*, that most illustrious consul, or Caius Caesar, one by the blearing of Heaven born for this rrfaii, whose letters declaring their hone of victory they wish for I have in my hand do you think see? They tech to conquer, and have desired to win that sweetest and (isirest name of peace, not
by bargaining, but by
victory.

Again, with list feelings, pray, do you think Quel will hear of this thing ? for she has the prensniururr in repelling, and conducting, and sustainGaul, Hindi followed ing the burden of this war. will not say the 1, of I r the serf

DeehDUS Brutu*, has laid firm the foundations of men, and money; she too has the wsr with presto ted her whole body to the cruelty of Marcus Antonius she is being drained, devastated, burnt all the injuries of war she suffers with with ire

mm,

5'5

MAKCUS TLIJJU8
10

pertrolom
(

ftCTTitotm.

Bl ut

quad moilme aWrmt, rmb dncn dtavrnint. Frcrmnt Idem dom lo todcm room croot ci propter u
lit

nottro*

toiurU olkaoti o etMiu puUb*jitur

qoot republic*
,

qtu e, qoo MultU rrboi form, nihil eooeedi potest * est inritotoo od picim Aotoolo*, bcUom Mini lcgatl repofmmtc mr, ted poroil Deoofitmlum a Motto* dmredcret; legato* Et od
In
i

mm

wpnl

mm

quom

Una, com mWt amadou od cntoro > aujui turn oo pcccoai, cpme noeooacoT improiM omalno, tod Umen aliqoo modo pome con<
fucrlt

ooodum

erot vestrif
to Social

Urn groeibos Umque moltif

raaemm {Jm Utii) on

to* l*x Fooiptl eooth# cm,manii* ad prohahi j tf foO fimoootao eo to*

War

inNnc

CL/W.

OL 9 aod

9.

\il.
If

IV.

Q-V. II

only abe may repel the danger of to my nothing of the remaining parts aul- for they arc all alike the I'ataviaits have hut oat some, and cast out others of the emissaries of Antofnut ; they have assisted our commanders ith wMicr,and what was principally larking ;th arms, The rest have done the same, who were formerly In the same case as Patavi and who, because of the wrongs of many years, were tt'c and yet thought to be alienated from there it very lilllr wonder they arc faithful, now thej have been admitted to the franchise, *
slavery.

And

tout
I

it

they always maintained their loyalty. 1

these, then, are hoping for victor?, shall we ofer them the name of peace, that is, the despair

of victor.

\nd what if no pence be even possible? For what kind of peace is that where no con e c ation can be made to the man with whom you make peace ? oins has on many occasions been invited by us he has preferred war. Knvoys have been sent' though I disapproved vet they have been sent ; orders have been issued he has IIwas solemnly warned not to obeyed them beaUgi Brutus, to withdraw from Mutina he has And shall we v. pressed the siege more v< -eat for peace to a man who has send en>
I

messenger of peace? Do we think be more moderate in his demands In 1 presence than he was formerly when he sent his orders to the Senate ? And vet then he asked things ious, hough they seemed wholly n d not as yet ight in a way be conced* cut to pieces by the verdicts, so severe, so
5'7

MARCUS TULXJU8 CICBBO

dcUta.br.
lata*

tudirare.

Lefts ttttettna tuque nee populuin

prruUio

maHtaJtatet
;

eb ro n

i* cr UbuUr. quae ret dccretis vertrii reoiUUi > giK-lu ce, quae drcrrrisiua, obrucre, I 1

tacerdoUa. regpa reek-runt

no

nui nan

lejrtoob

Ut eUrtue BrendUi profuses ttagvif

vetiuU
toilet

eluatur,

ouro elut prardlratio crudcliUtu pote

preetereeai, quae

edia

oprrum cirrum

afuUoaa
13

taetra eaenieieiiU. celeri indicia latro>

cintiqe* reaUgie
llu.c
igitur
i

mpoHu

atqee tropero perricidar

!

quid haberaea, per dees fmmortalea tamus* An GallUm ultiman

eat

itum

quod remit? Quid

brllum,
etiatn

aliud

noo pecem

(acrrr, ted

diferre

Dee totem propsgare brllum, ted eoooedete He ooa ricerit, si

*

at *

or Military atoak. worn, Tea i u*n of war 2 a*. Fk%L r. U

!.

me by

irtiiaaa,

510

rmupnc

mi

ii-vi.

to ignominious which you passed on him be requires hat we cannot in any way give unless we are first willing to confess we have been U In war ttave decided that false decrees of the Senate have been catered at the Treasury can we decide Wc have resolved that that re genuine' laws have bee* proposed by violence and in defiance of the auspice*, and that by them neither the whole people nor the commons are bound ; do you think they can be upheld? You have d that lies bee cinbe ialcd seven hundred millions of sesterces of public money ; can he be acquitted of peculation ? riuniptinm from taxation for communities, priestly office*, thrones, have by bin been put up for talc shall those advertisements be again posted op which yon by your decrees have torn d<
;
.

* e can rescind our decrees, can we also eipnngn the memory of the facts any future feneration forget by whose crime
\
I

>

we have worn this unseemly gariU gh lood of the centurions of the Martian legions
>

shed at Brundisium may be washed away, can the washed away? To pass story of over intermediate events, what length of time shall obliterate the most foul memorials of his works around I the proofs of his crime, and the traces of his brigandage ? To this savage and fool murderer what conII raven 1 name, can we make? What is that but and an army? not making peace, but prolonging the war? not

roasioe

then.

.1

only e ft tending war, but also surrr be not nave conquered if on any terms

he

5'9

M ABC US TULUUS
to

CJCRftO

banc rbee
prrdlti

nn

He eenertlf
nr<

Ann

tot

Hires

nrfftrium

pone or rnnonrqu<-. qui vro rclkii Mint, fcrrr nun

*

in

>.rU-

(mm
fore f
,

en

fa*

MM
In

romihb
oculm

virtot

prqirtiaain

Pbottr entr

Antnnium conmUrt in %prnuilrm rumul^MtiW mlmngilr MipplcU ccUru, ncqor

If.
,

MuttrUv Stkm
tta

forte

pmx non

mt pa
riri,

1. to trnrttutu.

Puoni, aii>|>lu*4mi

prne-

cUr rot

lc

noo

turn

la contione

aolm te hoc tare UodnU n

aecrtrrint
?

aj lull*, dixit, dens peaalee et tedes patriae relieta.

mm, elquod
16

di

omen

rem pHWm

VII. Qunrro Jgitur I

tnai CnHaeroci recepti

tr.

L. Plea,

MOM

tolcrebilc

cenee* HvtUti

fore ?

Aut uio too, n>

Polloww

of

of

wbom

httlo

U know.

C. in

flktf.

IcnibllMi,

5*>

PHIIJITN
of arms

\II

vi

13-viL 15

citr with his followers?

By

force

of all things; re at the strangest; a host of in aoth ens are away from Rome, !> tneir ne farious loader ; none the less to see to those of their number that are left in the find intolerable What think you ? When man? of them shall have burst in on us at once, tea wo hove kid down our arms while they have
shall
I

we now bold the mastery

wo not by our own

policy

before your eyes Marcus ilar, add to him Lucius hoping tor a r ononis hip ; ill up with the rest and not of oor own order only who look for honours and commands ; do not despise even the Tiros, the Mustelav the peace made with them will not be peace, but a pact oi slavery. A noble utterance made by that moat emir man Loctos Ptso has been justly praised by you, Panaa, not only in this assembly but also at a ^ld he would depart from rf< Cblic meeting
paternal

would abandon his household Gods and his home, if may the Cods already have Antonius had crushed the

VII |ask yon therefore, Lucius Piso, would you not think the State was crushed if so many disloyal, audacious, guilty men were admitted back? lien r lordly endured while they were not yet stslaid with so many murders do you think, now they ore covered with every kind' of crime, the State will find than tolerable? We must either,

believe

me, adopt /our advice, yield, depart, and jtfb needy and vagrant; or our necks

5"

MARCUS

III!

1 fucdiu M-r

rruoc

**;

iunipatou.
I

am

ceptmu*, mvenUitem

om b tou uU nctmumi
r

mHtcrentur ?

eccipicndsm, car nan rogsmur

1

pnstnUmUm, mm llmiwui.
tcnscro
it?

In hoc ego Icgitta

qutdnn A
6rt, ot t

ceteris,
si

IU

quid

peccandi potrsUs a
>*broda

me

ratio foil,

riltandatn
lr gaU*

rum M. Aatoni latrr> men tamcn persona ad ktem pecem couv Ego niimquam rntnimr fuit dcligeuda

mittrndos ccnsui, ego

cgatorum
1
-

-..I.

in Mm diccre, Pacem ipaam si adferrent, quonmtn i^i. !! i-t -*

fc

,,

princeps agorum, ego semper ilium appeilavi bostern,

alii

cum

alii

adversarium, semper hoc

1*

Hum, cum

tumult um

Nee beec
egi,

in seaata solum,

eudcm sd
m
1.

populum semper

neque solum
of

in tnsum,
riii.

For ti

amiac;

torn oh

el FkO.

PH1UPP14
la oar

Ml.

ttt I5 -i 7
fall

mat* be given over to brigands, and we must

count at us Pansa, are those most noble exhortations of yours with which the Senate was aroused, the Roman people kindled by you, and not merely hcanl. hut learned the lesson, that nothing is to disgraceful to a Roman as slavery* Was it for this we bare assumed military garb, taken up arms, and sifted all our tooths from the hole of Italy, that, when we had a most efficient and numerous army, envoys ice from should w tent for peace ? If to rr Antoaias, why are we not so asked In Am I to if to demand it, of what are we afraid ? be one of thai embassy, or to mil myself up with that policy in which the Roman people wfll The result sent from the rest? ill be that, if any allowance or concession be made, the misdeeds of Antonius will always be at my n%k, a% thr |**rr of misdoing will appear to
r
I

ova

hare been conceded to him by roe. But if peace with the brigandage of Marcus was the last Antoaias Is to be considered. man who should hate been chosen to bring about It was I who never thought envoys that peace. should be sent; ho, before the return of the they brought embassy, ventured to say that Peace herself, since under the name of peace who was the Id be rejected lurked * I who always called chief adviser of military garb haw aa enemy when others called him an adversary, always called this a war when others called it a tumult 1 And this not only in the Senate 1 always took the same line before the people; and not onlv mius himself have I always inveighed,
'

5*3

MARC

S Tl'l.l.lt'S

ra.oulotiaunt.lntoUmdrnkiur
It

AnUml

Ml tro|>rr imertu*.
pod

lUquc, at oUcrrs ct Ucti pc

obUU

Inter or
fc

itur.

ftn>|*i dvc% quad vkkmt, mc uiMiuum rtrrebojtt, dc uic

it

qukdrm

lUam

rt

poteroocnitto hottcin pAtriAc, illuin rommunr robbcam est ed quo modo piriam mini ani crudeHmimum bo*M|KC'tii * tdrre

ex quo mibi odium In

i\r

in.

ft

rrln

:tn.

.Tit

.fr%>

C.

Wr*

uomib to gir too opinion

to* I prujiaoH
1.

fwi,

of A. portomns ao boiog faroorablo or not to A

rmi.HTir

\II

-mii

but also gainst his abettors and gents in both those here and those with Um, m a word against the whole house of Marcus A
i

Aceordftngtv, juat as disloyal citizens were alert and joyful at the prospeet of peace, and were congratulating one another at if they had conquered, o they proteated against ray being an envoy as being prejudiced ; they complained of nic l they also dlstt eated Servilios; they remembered that by his votes Antonio* had been pierced as with stabs; that Lucius Caesar, though a brave and nrvcrthrlrv. his uncle tli.it
;
j

intimate friend; iron yourself, Psnsa, though a most energetic and valiant consul, they already think inclined not that it h or can be to, but your ; pence has created a suspicion in many aaind has changed. That I should be Is of Anthese persons* t!
his

was Ms agent: that Plso was

we nave once begun

and we most humour them, to be obliging. VIII. Let set out with the best of omens, but let set out st whom Antonius rosy not be
lly
;

Hot If yon are not conce rn ed about Ant yon ought, Conscript Fathers, at least to con rate spare my eyes, snd mske some me. For with what counteace for a just grief. I say not the ahall I I*- hie to lrk upon of the country my hatred to him on that on to yon as well but how shall I it is co is my particular cruel enemy, as who him look on Do his most bitter harangues about me declare? meet or can I that iron of made so me think yon

>

mm

5*5

Muii
c *,

>

ii

ixius

cicmo
-urn la

qui ci dr pafficiua) aaaaCBBBBB' TBJO rUiuUi, bOM 0004*1 H U;l I*.

me ameoibum el port* rt adimra? Atquc idem mr A^ttnu. Utru lulur, roUcap Uatoot rum A 4 uiUr pnim|uunumnAurruiUrrt.dc
i

tnci*

boob

tr d*r

U
iptaai

Um

quidem

mi crcdUurom puUnt
cnira dc

Noa

T.

importune*, lam tcr lr rata buatc mro, rd csritate rci pabbJCM.

nee id

fit

fartidfto

imiMiiii, Quid? ttUr

a)

cat, pracaertoo

caw raUoocm? quar mioi i If rn cum Dolabella icccn t,

el popalo

Bomano

rilU

meut

(alio,

quae piurima

a
1
'

curb, acnUutib, peVtcuib ctiam, propter acerbauajaoai oatalaai bbc ooMBB toisuuriuii perfeccraa. at aoo ooataraoi
qui
riftiUfe.

adit

Tat aUaafc
la

to

aakaowa.
:

L.

AM.:

ef.a.

I,

tW mnimmrinu
raapi

a *7l

(Wsm
I.

1 AO. it 5. IX (/fat il 6 ad I' Vcattdia*

;

ullu. ffartilia
Of.

and latWia

d. /%J. lid. II

Ad. si.

21

IS.

516

Hill IIMMi

in.

io-ai

on the man who lately at a public meetim:. when he at making gifts to those who appeared to him to br the boldest among his band o ers, tf he ga%r mv pHMssfssBl feO IVt.ssius of rl.mtuu.
I

who, after the wreck of a splendid patriuionv, was east on these Antonian rocks? Shall be able to look on Lucius Antonius, whose cruelty I could have seeped had I not defended myselt with walls end gate and the seal of my own borough ? I
I

thsi

same Asiatic gladiator/* the brig, lie was the colleague 'of Lento and Nocula, %li< giving golden coins to Aquila the centurion, said he gave them as part of ay pnonssloni for had he he gave them as part of his own he did not n Aquila would believe him. My eyes, 1 will not endure Seta, nor Cafo, nor the two
i

Bcstia, nor Trebellius, nor Titos Planens. I cannot see with equanimity so many savage, wicked enemies, and that not because simahnrst on my part, but from love to of any

two tribunes elect/ nor

mm

But I myself;

will

control

my

feelings

and command

my

most

iost gi

What! Conscript Fathers, do you .ureal. not think I should take some concern for my life ? M indeed tcrr little dear to me, especially as has made death desirable if it be only i without tortures and racks but to you and to the Roman people my life should not be cheap. inlets perhaps I deceive myself, who, she 'jcs, votes, aye, and by my M k'> many perils I have faced on account of the most bHter hatred towards me of all disloyal men, hsve
;

5*7

m in

ruuius

a nu

*b

infrro

lie iidite,

mm

Aurrl abrrrrt a

a damo. certe In (ttur uulii praeatat

obi
ail,

EtrurU

cat, id est In via.

Uotooe ono

capita ease
re*

Die mihi praeterea, Pana, Vrotidiat

cai fai acaapcr amieaa,

anteqaa ilk Urn apertc

QakJ?

ai

Aocanam, at

dicit

* L.

Taaratfcfof D.Brata. at Cn. Pomp*iM taa joaagar waaa flyios from th

rtttaaald ol Maaa^rfkr. A* to Veat. cf a. p.

.T.T3T
Ml

Si

UPPIC

XII

na

ji-ix. a 3

not to be harmful to the State for I would too arrogantly. This being so, do yoo think I should have no thought of my danger ? IN *hile in the city and at my own bowse, n< -sf many attempts have been made on me, though here not the fidelity of friei alone, but the eyes of the whole community guard me What think you } that, when I have entered on a journey, moat of all a long one, there are no mbuihri to be dreaded ? There are three ways to Mttttao, whither my imagination hastens that i may behold ee soon as I can that pledge of the liberty of the B o i n people, Decimos Brutus \ Jsj whose embrace 1 would gladly breathe out my 1st cat breath, when all my actions during these |i*%t sanntha, wl.cn sj] Mi> propoesli have Attained that goal bare set before me. 1 There are then three ways, as I have said by by the lower the >er sea the Flaminian middle the Cassian. Now attend, pray yon, and consider whether my suspicion of from probability. The Cassian di Do we then know, Panes, in what districts the authority of Lento Caesennius the septei now prevails? He is certainly not with us en But if he is either at home, or in mind or body. ruria, that is, not far from borne, be \% certan on my road. Who then guarantees me that Lento Tell me besides, it content with one victim?* ways Penes, where Ventidlus 1 is, whose friend wee before he became so openly y to the a ss ia n, I can avoid the C tc end ell good men. keep to the Flaminian. What then ? if Ventfcnew bee gone to Ancone as he is said to have

529

rate ml
14

P.

CmaH.

ToU Com*
<jui

X Hbrr ego mr *il commit t*r,^ per la Miburtoum, at code d

ate autoono
caotodik.

Trrmlnollbu

Itoque in arte.

^ jtir VffO iwiMinmi loco pfo nt rccamrc. .^cno me nana \Vc*i timtdoa, ormo Umrf couUor. Ret decUmt

<

lUquc
ubi

ipoi,

dedcrunt,

ne dkom mibi. mc omlvom odbuc re

publics coascnrotit

Ttmidc boc diemm; do eoim quid*

Mlmi.i
ut
Igitar mti*

viden conta* ,
P.

mUt

proridas,

Pi IBM II

irMM. MB WM

OMjM mtoHbUM ooomy

UfpW

ttOOT

(in

uattml Town* to thw eoootrv in M MUr" oor fanoorlj rfo/ira. C. boas bo if fimiiUy on coord. An Hook pcoUbS, to bit osDo from Homo in 66 8, of too moio. mob boo bo mood toot too obJof

mm

530


PHILimC
done
shall

XII.

ix.

23-x. 25

I be able to reach Ariminum safely? mains the Aurclian. Here indeed I shall actually bare a guard ; fur here are the lands of Publm. Oodiua. The whole household will meet r me to stay because of our most

tioue friendship!' X. Shall I entrust rorself to these roads who lately at the irrminaJia ci rh I was k u the same day, to go into the suburbs? house- walls I protect myself with tout a guard of friends. So, if I may, > my place ; here rp watch land sentinel ; here I have my fixed garrison : Let other men hold camps, and conduct affair of war let them hate their enemy for that u the chut thing I, as I do and have always done, ill, in conjunction with you, pr that I and the affairs of the r s fia this oJBcr, although I see the Roman people nan is leas timid than cs it on my beba I, yet no man to more cautious. Facts are eloquent now twenty years that even- villain makes me hit single aim. And so !*rv have paid the penalty, * 11 not say to myself, but to the State wry safety I the State baa up to now ensured to secure its own.
;
1
I

I was beset by a picked force of the powerful men, I fell purposely that I m be able to ri*r again with the utmost honour. 8 Can I then be thought sufficiently cautious,

That much know that when

shall

my

with some

tii

to a

man anything may happen yet

and OMwar, would not protect him gainst the liu*. lis returned amid acclamation* in
53'

MARCUS TULUU9 CSCBIO

pobltra

tenants?. Ml
u >t*rttt

)pM fl|ifllniMln>ll I
ClUwwtti.
ji
<
(
*.

ftnlUlUe
t-'tj

ttlaprrslkMr
I

Q*u

'U{J*"T

rrl#it
>

-t.

Ulta et Cfrto rt *i

Al WBt.
)ti

* dM*<dttrr uuf! mi rn

b homftnc

ntmto ftcfarwt aoa rrtit

e!

ei.

ntL

el

2.

53

PHIMITIC

\!l
If I
I

,6

estml

meaelf to

to

ad to perilous?

Those

wot e handle lor reproof of their tolly. *

ofmehi
sav it -that we should be wee not on h guard u, far wise sa? that he who ee to be the guard of many should in* of the eon! of hie owe life. When roe ere fie Bid found be the lew* and the ewe of the Uw. eowrte, owe weed not ho afraid of anything, or look far e word against ewer* kind of eeiheeh ; for who fta breed daylight, or on a military road, or when moo wee ell elteoded or of high position, would But three nwwjriorotlcioi dero to eeeho eo atuck For the heoe wo weight et t hu mass or to m/ case maw who ofers eee rinlotico will out only drc*l eo penalty he will actually gang! of brigands and far Theee thing* I provide agaioet in the c 1 cwo easily look around eae to eee from where
1

mm

eee wooing, and where I am proceeding, what oo the right hand, and what upon the nell I be able to do the eeeee in the bypaths of the Apennine*, where, even if there are no ambomhea aa there mar be very easily - ret ray mind will be ansioos, end eo enable to attend to But oppose I bare the detsre of the embosoy? eeeoped aeebeohce, here ronnounted the Apennines;
1

to

5JJ

m\h in n
tur>

uun

r1

\u\m\
a

hammm

C wm

aa *f* r *

&* of

hmi

Hmrmm
514

party

toOaa

PHILIPPIC

XII. . t6-

wfll be elected ? If one ontside the the other look to theroaehthink or death will be immed. >t know the man's I know bit unbridled riole. thr of bit character and thr aerajrerr of
.

wkb

tee,

when th man

it

rnniniiJ .th wrath

am

to call ron?" by neceaaitr an

i*rtt

He
"

replied.

enemy/'

Imn

Ml
.

* a
*a in that

of
nmt-litr

not eeckinjr to but to be admi SulU and Scipio, the one with to it tbcmaclrea. thr fewer of tbe noUlitr. thr othrr with hii allien t"~tween tbemfelrea bet* Ode* and Teanam the Uwi and conditions or. eothorUr of the Senate, the eawVngte of the people, did and the ri*ht of mUmmAip not altogether maintain rood faith ; jet it was not rd bj emlenc and dang'

535

it Of

BO

N ty aw* tttH Hit

ny

ptw

ot bitti

toMiM |1irtfp|iiiirii,

536

IMIII IPPIi

XII

MI Oh

the amid U>c brigandage ot Wr cannot, or, If the be equally safe \ can, I do not better I en. But outside the enp, what camp shall be
f He will never come we pro into hit. It remains *h be received and dis-

shall lie in

oar o
it

of

all bis

demands
it

Uu

vour returned: 1 shall hare 1 shall by my vote refer hstcrcr they it legal, nor here by this oar order in the
in

om
atalL

he eustom of our the Senate any

at I shall so act tn the conference. think, no dissent, is it not to be feared that tile intMuatioiusd crowd of soldiers may consider tint Moot it being deferred through me? that the new legions do not dbapprove of my policy ; far that the Martian and the Fourth legion, at
I

And

Hue* hare no object but honour and glory, will What then? At to 1 know far certain.
even they themselves with to
are we not apprehensive how ly strictness? for they hare beard faint things of me ; unscrupulous men have Their interests, I, to them many stories I are the beat witnesses, hare always supported s ; but vote, my authority, tod my speeche

537

mm

IULUU8

rl

M lulr

rr*

nam

II

ws,

|**

SM

imiivhiiI,

nd SI

Man, qvi

an at Mc^Mtat^n hahmmt mil mmL> m aMt DO

tmmU&mmk

net t

fW* Mt Jm

PHil IPPH

\!l. hi. 19-30

rbo are unscrupulous and tarbulent, \ ther are no User bettere their own parU doobt brave men. bat br their recollection of their r plaits os behalf of the liberty of the Roman people and the safety of the Stele, they are too bas> sphUcd and apt to refer all oor polieiee to the teat of thee? ova violence. 1 am not afraid of their their impulses. thought cape these considerable dangers, Aod if be fully safe? do joe think my ret hen I, after my wont, here defended your authority, end maintained my own good faith and tredfastnrm tow ards the State then not only those that bete me. bet those too that envy me, arc to be dreaded. then be guarded for the Sute, and I my life let it be preserved, to far as honour or nature shall
i
I

*th either folio* the allow, for my counts 1 *>r if it must be met before, tabic decree of This being so, although th glory.

r
<o

to my

the least

doci
I

this
ill

em bum

go mfrlr.
I

act

out

"ill gauge the In all thing*. Ccmscript Father*. hole policy of thb matter, not by my on dai but by the advantage of the Sute and as to that, since there Is ample time, I think that much should shcu into nmsldi ralion again and again and that particular course adopted hieh I shall judge to be most of all in the interest of the Sute.
;

539

aODUCTIOS TO PHILIPPIC Mil

abut
of
to

April

letters

advocating peace wci

hy the Senate from d Plancos, toe eo% the governor Gaul, u>d from Lenidus, the governor

tend

I to be 8; but that of Lepidus nee Ml tasrvtved. There upon the Consul Han*, having left for the tent of war to join his ~ enutus, the Ore Praetor, about the 9th the Senate to the Temple of Jopitrr to the letter* The letter of Planctu was

Hither Spain. to . as*

The

letter of Plsncus

Fm*

10.

of religious inform. lenatr was adjourned to the following day. that day Cleero proposed a rote of thanks to Plai and woaid hare carried it had not Titiua the tn at the rou aaat of Scrvdias, interposed his veto. On the nest da?, however, Qeero appeart to bare earried

not

a Mbseaajcajt dav Servilhis proposed a vote of to l^epidua, adding, however, a recommenda bon to leave the qa tstion of peace to the \ which required Antonius frst to lay down In support Cleero That was earried.
>

the thirteenth Philippic. Antonius has) written an insolent letter to Hirtius and Caesar, which the former had transmitted to Qeero. In tins letter Antonius 1 in the H tilted all hit grievances. death of Tu bosses, and resented the decree daring Dolebella a public enemy. He affirmed his

At

thai juncture

aam

54

itODUCTlON TO PHI
to the

1 Wnglky ppc*! to bj BMHiag Omt add*!** of

UH*

TW

ndcr to Srrril**

Altar
.

tlto

fajuJ

ftanmi< *4

i*.
|

4*

I hfe

U*k

<

fc-

W<U Omm Uta* Mi

f

ft-ft fell U tfe )UrdfcrftMftiiM4 M*f* I t-4 tW fend f rvrfag WmH* at Mlim wfco

is

! ttftkuM m NMHitMB I^VMt

iW frm.
c4

u U * ;" Wf <rftWyr*4UltaofiUlWrtori k m lull Uya l Uw iwl^IlM of Au.

Kg

IUmUm am iUhlfatl^ic-orf lu. UiW.

lM0i tft
*

|Jm

|4i

M tllll
HltJPI'li
i

A TRRTIA DBC1MA

Aprtoriffe

Ma
i

twpto

il

in imliiirtu

trd

44

in* THIRTEENTH philippic

1118 CICERO AGAINST

Oi M 1UU U ANT0NIU8

of this war. Cbmcrtpt Fathers, ten against disloyal and

citterns.
I

lest

son*

l<r*re %hould

quench our sr

roc toe %*cry name of peace roeocery as llbcrtr. slhsm. while peace itself bring* oat only delight Nov it stew to sae that s man dors not safety. bold dear oar pmale hearths, or the public laws, or bo ddighta in dltcord. . ths rtgbu of msaiuii o/ cstlacns, la ci il w*r that man should, think, be ejected from the ranks of bis fellows, be conines of human nature rr it *rrr Sulla OT MaHuS. OT DOth r Oetartus, or Clnna, or Sulla again, or the jlsitns and Carbo, or any other who ha* war, that man I account a citisen Imm-i For why should I he held aecwrard by the State. 1 whose acts we defend I apenh a* the last of them. while we confess their author himself was jt slam r There >* then nothing fouler than tuch a csUsen, than tech a man. if we can regard either as
,

am or as a man one ho desires civil s Bet we meat contxirr this first, Conscript Fathers, whether peace b poaaiMc with II men, or whether
there

agreement

ibie, In which an a sort of war tint a law sanctioning slavery. foe (wees Ante with Scipio Sella either made or make ; bet there were no grounds for despair of an
is
;

545

mm:

m w Exm aoao

P.

VNwiilii

B..

CMlMrto:

In MUKw of

ih.

/%.l H.

*1

8mb.

I. 0 A* puiaid by

AlMiii

A AOL L

i.

546

PHILIPPIC

XIII

,.

,-i..

e political condition if thrv had agreed on nna had been willing to estabash ta, Uie cooditton of men in VM might have remained health/. the In the last Pbmpeius had relaxed somewhat of hlf amVillality, and Caeaar much of hU cupi<: have beeo permitted to possess a its of a com on-

8Mb

But what is the present portion? can there be with Censorinus, Ventidius, wrth the Antonii llli, Necula, Munatius, Unto, Saxa > (cm by way of illustration; you lets tee the countless numbers and the of the rest. Add to these those wrecks fnends, the Barbae Cassii, Barbatii. n ton us' fellow -gam birrs and com, Mela, Pontius Coclius, Cras> th-ir fbilowmg lisrr K .nl fVhal these must be classed the the lead' of the Larks* nd the rest of the veterans, a foe jurymen of the third panel, 1 who, now b rs ha usted and Caesar's thill own property are devour ed, have become covetous of our
II
' i
II

I.

*sty right

iaitchered

many

hand of An too i us with which he O ratified and sat citisens

!

nedtrratt which sir sliall make with the Ant areos hall attempt to violate it the coti*cicntiousM ill call him back from the crime hef* shall lr |Ur m thi< city for those men there will be no place for the city itself. Set before ysssjr evra their faces, especially those of the Ant their gait, their look, their countenance-.
|

547

MARCUS TOLL!

III

Ojm decrrrfctte,

coa Irjv rrftmtta, ptf rta U*H lulfcw dUrcta

t

..r.rf.u, ..

ium

..niiiiuni

l"Um

iuJt

fcl

i,m
Mart,

!,
rt.

Ill

In

oral* lurrrlmt

nrai licrUt. in

u
**m

f^r del

Ml
i

ralkme

tcctk.

Quid
li

tjptoi

m*ai

|Ml

wttfc lum.

Tkii

Ml

I'HIlIi'i

it.6

Chase the pirn;

walking by their a reek salts sad threatening speech think you will iapa the very fa them, and in particular, when 11 greet us kind! ibh j, atjtlrr m each one of as III. By the immortal Gods! do you not recall what resolution* Ton have psesed against those men ? You have rescinded t ho sets of Marcos Anton annulled his laws yoo have deckled they

W hat

yoe have set afoot levies through the hole of lulv his colleague sod partner in all vYHt this enmes yoo hate sdjodfed on enemy Wen he a foreign man what pearr i% (waaihlc enemv. it could hardly he after tuch treatment, yet
;
f

Sees, mountains, wide regions gbt soon hi would intervene ; you might hate a man you did not es upon your see.* These men will faten eyes, and when once they get the power- upon yessr throats; for hi what pens shall we confine aurh savage beasts f Bet, It may he ssid. the iasues of war are uncertain. .e part of hrave men, as you should be, to display courage for that much tbcv can do and not to dread the whims of fortune. Hut since from 'ul\ but also wisdom, this our order n is required -though these qualities seem scarcely

us sever them- fortitude bids us awvernoir fight, it kindles a righteous hatred, it urges us to the 1 ealls us t<> the peril. What says V . si.r sjsmlsjoi mor. ui otmaseJs, she Woks to the future, she is in every respect more guarded.
.

549

MAftCUS

TULUU8 C1CMO

Aul
lappUrr')

* mm mm. UirtUi

mm

II.
.!r

r^

M. Upidt

vd

f*

(V.t).

TWolWr M&odan*tfur

umi im onv tu

Im w.htA/j sploiu wr.

jootify
fete

10
*'

wi

it limn tjnutf*.
i
14.

U M kimmTwrn fck Mtton to C. <W #W

in

II

ol

U utU

Im poor, ad did oot tK imfwrAtoc." Umagk

ifc him by

TWtn
550


PHILIPPIC
\|||
,u.

6-1*. 7

mm

It her opinion r for we mutt obey, and eonrlneion as beat that it founded roott prrcrpU. If this be her precept, that I should thinl nothing of more consequence than mv life, should not contend at the peril of my life, tboald aroid all risk, I will atk her Even a utt be a slave? ' If the say vertly to that U adorn, however learned he ma\ II not hearken But if the shall reply : " N thy life and ptnon, thy fortunes, thy private paattsssnni. but only at ranking them after liberty, and onlr at deeiring their enjoyment it >t be had in a free State, and not sacrificing liberty for thane, but for the take of liberty flinging them asif thr* rre very mranteet of injustice, * bear the voice of Wisdom,
:
I

God.

Therefore

it

when

we can be free, let us up with peace but if

;

no quiet
a chance c
fight

it

possible, let

we

shall either

has been by their deaths enjoy

State; or, If we are crushed mar Jupiter avert the omen (we shall tare, if not with the breath of life, at least *ith the fame of our

beer.

be mid, Marcus Lepidus. who hat mot, Imperator, who it Pontit and the Utt civil war deserved well of the State, Huence, Consrt* us to pes Raihera, It greater with roe than that of Marcus Lepsdea, whether no account of hit owns merits 01
IV. Bet,
it

will

*j

*swat

lor lifwjes*ffse*s*>t of 8.

Poaipstas tothe8laU:

el /I

~an.S. pffM.
55

MARCUS TULUUS

librrmtL

Talk

Ifttur tit ct
|Kjl)ll

A fC
rult

M.

Lrpidttt.

Frnrclmrr,

ti

Ulrtn

55*

ITU

Mil

,v.

T-9

the greatest of all that be entertain* hit present feelings the Suir. huh has been always de
life.

ant

Umo a;

For hen by his inriuence he Magnus, a most noble youth, the peace, and
I

the utmost think by this bene greater than r, I propoaod you agreed to have and to cspreaa the boot bopea of bias. The Sutc holds alarms Lfptdos bound by many great pledges. His birth la of the noblest, there are all bis honour, his

of ercg war, then

st bed

priesthood, hi*

own numerous cm-

of the city, and the monuments of his of bis ancestors, a moat respected wife, ost to his desire, a private fortune not bet pore of the staio of civil bloodshed. boa been injured by him, many i< and pity bare been made free. Men a en may make a slip in judgbe cannot in any way be at
I

pains wishes for peace. Admirable' be can bring about each a peace as he lal brought about, under which peace the State will again see the son of Cnaeos Potnpcius, and will bast back to her bosom and embrace, it s restoration not only of him but of her
af

553

MM'.i

IS

1!

II

0L/ft4.
<

15

iW
554

to iwt * of Fort **! ronoM, m. I 01 Ui

tMM

mm

oo* a

u pvtkM by a iwh^i IW hlki ivom ! memm Omiti "ft** lafHaiiiil

rt a !* omt of
ol

Stote is* !.


PHILIPPIC Mil.
own
Mlf.
iv.

9-f. ,i

This

HAM l the rostra with an honourable

the reason

why you voted him *

in,

and a tnompo in bis abvencc. For although he had done hi war great thing* and d vl ug a trial jot o grant * could not be made to him which waa mode tsth or to Locioi Aesnilius or Seipio Aemilianus, or to the older Afnrmnus, or to Manus, or Pompeius, who hod condoc t od greater wart; but because he to an end a civil war, the first on him the

Wr

ftp

It

von think then. Marcus Lcpsdus, that the be In the State tneh citisena as the likely to find Pompeios? In the one if
deration, integrity
;

in

them

them,

pom over

in

my mind

of brigand loft, crime, and an

an working any wickedness. In the nest plare. Conscript Father, which of you, I entreat yon does not see what Fortune herself, For without st called blind, has teen ? acta of Ctcsar, which for the sake Use
will be open to back at a price not less bought it for; the house, I say, of Cnaeus Hut -.ter'fact! hssson will buy bar

lefend. his
I

own house
it

he

will

buy

hare been bewailed long enough and

fully

You h**r

vol,-,!

t..

I\>ii|*-iu

mi ^
4

tfrcat

as a conquering enemy would have realised from his But, having father goods in a partition of booty. regard to my friendship and connection with his father, thai disposal of the sum I claim for myself.
flftr saflliua Attfc In about 2.000.000: tsstkm (Dio 46. 10) Aat.s rsss was voted en Aat fins

!,

App.

555

MARCUS TUI.UUS

A*

u> iImm.

no.

to.

T*

iU*o* KM

U
556

Colkgv

Aigin

io c a* !!! by <mt fife

!

-.

lyt \U*af63a.C,
t wtrt

ol

lot)

1ft

PHILIPPIC

XIII.

ri

ii

ill bey back h pleasure-ground, hit boose, ami certain urban properties, which Antonius holds the stivcrplete, the garments, the furniture and hthst glutton ha* I. he will be
;

The Albao and Formian

Dolabclta
;

Toacwian. and lrt ilioie Mutina and besieging Decimus Brutus- lrt Ansrrs' be driven out of the Falernian. There are others, perhaps, hot they slip from my memory. soy too that those who are not of the number of our til restore to the son the possessions of at the price they are. It was to ssy aodacious, to lav hands on any 1 g out of that pruprrtv but who will be bold enounoble master is restored ? Or ill reUti pot that fellow restore it, be who embracing the patrisBosiy of hit master, as a dragon does s treasure, n of Caesar, has lore of Pompeius, 1 t)
I
1 1 1 1 1

estates he also from Antonius the who are now attack

lh< cststrs in LoeSJSls

And

that

hundred million sesterces * which you,

Conor rlpt Fsthcr. hoes promised the young man srlll be so allotted as to make the son of Cnaeos to have been settled in his patriby
ssjsj

thr Senate; the rest the Roman people wrry out in the case of a family it has marked bn the First it will | ss the worthiest. pUrr of Ktts lather, tl>' figihip to which, tool '*i what I received mat nominate him as a col le* gue.* Which mtnr f the two the shall we the more willingly san

Ut

L Rasa*/* M. AmL I6U

sd., p. 377,

and

Oc

Ik

557

MARCUS TV M. US CICRtO
I

>

Mibi hoc

|.

Itlw

nammi l

dlffaHotcm

et

fbrtUM

natrUi

Mi
ft* vcfo

em*

patrfc

(mVUi m tew molU qwun

iuc ctfcu bor

ih qui Mffeolcr furtltrr luqot

,
;

M. Lrpido

tarn
rrt

tcastai

pspmjM

pobllcM ewe, noa mob. f*o Ma" Quid ta>

turpi*, ri

lirt-Ut?
IBJIMI

pt nik ki rant, d Quid litem turpi Mt foedtet at quod

flu* cootrm

MCdt
pstram

trnatum,

cofitfli

rive,

contra

cicrvituiu onccra P

ond

vcro

55

PHILIPPIC

XIII.

v.

la-vi. 14

pm

of Jupiter the Best and Greatest of Gods, and messengers we re ? w the tto will the people? Pompeius or To me indeed it seems that, by the if of the immortal Gods, Fortune has that, la spite of our confirmation and of the acta of Caesar, the son of Cnaeus should be able to recover his dignity and
interpreter

:o(huUI
re is tnrnrthrea else, Conscript Fathers, which I do not think I should pass over hi silence, the met that those illustrious envoys, Lucie* Paelu, Qulntus Thcniiut, and QsJm Fannius, whose limemHtlng and steadfast good will towards the Stale vou hare realised, announce that th< j tamed aside to Msaalis in order to meet Pompeius, and iaragiilnd that he was most ready to go t alutsaa with his forces, bat feared to offend la* But he to the tea of a father vataraasw 1 achieved much with wisdom no less than with bravery ; so you understand be was ready in spirit,
it, too, that he dues not appear to act with greater assumption than h>>r if he scare us with an army baits hie character he date not bear in mind that that army belongs to the reatc and the Roman people, indeed to the whale State, and is nut his own. " Hut he can use it es hst own."* What then ? are good men to do every tasng they have the power to do, even if those things ere base, are pernicious? even if it will be altogether And what ran be baser, or fouler, or lees decent than to march an army against the one's country ?
>

sad not wanting In judgment. And Marcus Lrrwdus should see to

559

MARCUS TUU.K

qi

ri

art

u,u

Hi

tr

l-Mo

.urfirr

n .m
afau

AA^Ud hiUcfllii(0^,Ui<im fat/f

,

).

vi.

14-vu. 15

it to not lawful for any man to net bto country ; if by '< lawful allowed by the law, and the o/ oar ancestors. For what

seasartly lawful, nor, if

to
It

there there fare also permitted. aa to vour ancestors, your

behalf.
will

will

reatot

an enemy,

With extend the

of our rule ; the Senate and the will obey. If they ahull happen to
VII

Ifyoo think of tbeae thin*, you are M<

Nlifu
to

the great-grandson of ; but if you coolawful for men to measured by of terming to prefer to follow to your family, and those new
uriesus,

"

Masimus

you interpose your I do indeed praise _Jder whether dotes; so to not For although there resides in you

But

if

to arms,

man of very noble birth should have, yet the Senate does not despise itself, and never to truth has it been more dignified, more Weare all of us carried Sllllirill, mini iiOauMUlIM alone by a oery seal to recover our liberty by no man s authority can such ardour of Senate and we fight in status people be quenched ; " we hate our arms cannot be wrested from our OUT wrath hand* ; no note of retreat or o( recall from war can even the utmost I hope far the best
;
;

itua

. '

561

V
MAfta
1

;luus

cici

Mil At

amatbu* rnt Irm to rspcdrt wliaai wmt

i:

btftaas;

a?4

fta

' i liilMiHiH

a*,

aai fartaaatf art,

t

Tii, H mil

ifluT

iili

I.

mto)oui

In II

lb pfvml

wh ad L V M a*fca*dh 14 dmirmi a
f tat jar.
..

rail

tf

L.

PHILIPPIC MIL

tii.

,^..

t;

the

rather than be slaves. baa got together an unlieatcn army; two ant consuls are present with their forces; various and large reinforcements of Lucius t consul elect, are not wanting; the conIn the safety of I tectums Brutus a single gladiator with a gang of moat savage
;

to waging war against his country, against Household (iads, against our altars and hearths,
- we to yield to this man r conditions we are to listen ' is it are to believe peace is possible ? his risk of our leing crushed.* HI! Bat his I am not afraid that a man who cant fortune eteept with the safety of good Nature- m tinbetray his own safety. first place makes good citizens, in the next, Fortune II j;mk1 <>l help* them fof that old be safe hut it U in those that Who is more are fortante this Is more apparent fortunate than LepwJus, as I have said before ? who His sadness and his Is also of sounder principles > it tears the Roman people saw at the Lupcrcalia how east down, now overcome he was, when

to tats

mans man we
I

mw

Anton tuv by placing a diadem on Caesars h chant to be that man's slave rather than his colHad he been able to refrain from all his langoi Other outrages and eiimc% yet, on aecount of tins action alone, I should think him worthy of he himself could endure >r if psmsshmert slavery, whv was he setting a master over us ? and If has boyhood had suffered the lusU of those that 1 as he also to set up oar children a master and a tyrant ? And so when
I

563

MARCUS T

It

Qo* ral

n UrWrU
|mb
ft

Imh

H !!>
(quid
mfctrllto

eat

Aram

tjrf**o>) 1mm

Itytarfc acrmpmkmntmf.

Pnmi,

for

to

Indc tt <|o faff,

ki

f)<*>

Mtlnrr d

I d rn)r

pita*

.,

rf*cbU!

Qm
rtrtai

19

IX. Garaarti rami

lorrrdibOb

at itlltM

UtnmH

haaiilaa crudrb r

funUmdt

MM

I-

PHILIPPIC

XIII. fHL 17-UL 19

was elaiu, he showed himself towards the of the world at be wished Caeaar to be towards us. For la what barbarous country was there ever any tyrant aa savage, at cruel as/ in this city, when fenced by the arms of barbarians, was Antonins? ed to come into mn If not as free men, at least in safety; under

tbese
it

wby sbould I call him mrr benc hes were occupied by ituraeans.

loddenly to Brutuiisium that he the city in battle array ow inhabited by the of burghers bet formerly by colonists, be with the blood of most valiant soldiers ; at the very lap of his wife, a woman not only most avaricious but also most cruel, he bntrhtiiil picked centurions of the Martian legion. From that place la what a frrnsy, with what eagerem, did be berry to our city, that is, to the slaughter \t which time the immortal Gods of every patnut! at, though we did not expect
It was the incredible and Heaven- inspired Career that stayed the cruel and maddened ef e brigand of Caesar whom that madman thnegbt be was hurting by edicts, not realising that whatever fic charges he was aiming at that meet mmlitt ef young men In truth recoiled on the imiiij of bit own boyhood. He entered the end wttb what a following, or rather line of bat ic groans en right and left of the be threatened householders, marked end openly promised to portion out He returned to his supporters. the esty

IX

For

of

rug

..

565

MARCUS TULUUS
i;

mlifttn

0U

Tib

cr.

raium* mil

n. 19-21

then followed that pestilent harangue

thai oune the of the Senate by a consul was prepared Ban; 1 when suddenly
race to to the Capit for hamper!- the

for he knew the legion had halted at Alba news is Drought his of the Fourth. Dumbfounded by this. of referring Caesar's case to he resit of, not by main roads, hut lis Senate; by by-paths hi has general garb, and that very day denetsj of the Senate, yns ? and all of them were recorded faster than they From that time it was not a m. were drafted but a race and flight into GaoL He thought Caesar was following him with the Martian legion, with the Fourth, and with the veterans, whose name he could not endure for fright, and, as he was penetrating into Gaol, Decimus Brutus threw bin preferring to be surrounded with all the waves of war than that Antonius should retire Ml Mutina on his prancing as a fenced had fe kind of bit for his frensy. And when be bad
!

when entrenchments, and wnen works and ano esjuenenments, the dignity of a moat prosperous colony nor taw majesty of a consul-elect deterred him from hit treason, then 1 call yon and the Roman people to wttnrte. and all the Gods who preside over this cityagainst my will and in spite of mv protest e consular envoys were sent to a leader of
In the eitv with

brtgsmds end gladiators Wknwns ever so barbarous, so cruel, so savage, He did not listen ; he sent no rcj so ferocious > he swill end set at nought, not only those who us by whom those

567

MARCUS TULUUB
to* rrvtt H,

wo

IliOo iwlaiW.

Pnataa

mod

iUgMtM lit If fit, 4"" HlM m> modo awvpL R da rvHIo dam qat 4a flftfM iwmmjMi wv*tt*r
Hirtte
i

dvWtw Mi
ii

mm

iib

nf

lli/t^rl

n** pit

pnrMMtM,

rid doknite dk*t;

im

ct

tot

5 6*

PHILIPPIC

XIII.

ii-i. 23

Afterwards, what crime, there the traitor did not perpetrate ? la be^rctnic oor colonists, an army of the topic, a genera), a consul-elect; he is of loral U of lot. citixens ; a most hideous the land is thr*4trntfig sll good men with crucifixion h this man, Marcus Lepidus. what la noauhlr. hen It seems that no possible of htsn can satisfy the Roman people? X. Be* of any man has so far been capable of a of this our order and the Roman people wHa thai moat outrageous beast can pswatbly esjst, let hum assuredly cease to doubt hen bo ha heard this letter which I have just While I rem. received from Htrtiu* the consul. and bfiefy comment on It clause by clause, I beg yon* Conoirlpt Fathers, aa yon have hitherto done,
ii? is
1

Md been tent

1 - Anton, u. Il-.rtiu af OMaWf Ho neither calk himself a general, nor Hirtius a That is clever eassnal, nor Caesar a propraetor. onoufh : ho preferred hunself to lar down a name ss not his than to give them their own. When | heard of the death of Caius Trcbon say )oy as not greater than my grief.** See what ho says is the cause of his joy, and who! of has grief: your decisioo on the question of

pence ill be easier. nat a criminal hot paid the penalty to the 1 ashea and bones &f a most illustrious man, and that the pooor of the Gods has been revealed before the end of the rr*r \U<- |.ni%hrnrnt for munler being 9t ih*r sjssjsii Iniicted r Impending, is mattef for
I

fcjotcnag,"

569

MARCUS T

XI.

c
iy

o(

$7o

PHII.II'I'lt'

XIII

in

a Spartacus !> for by what fitter iiame should iv' a man whose atrocious crimes make Cs tillee appear tolerable; hare you dared to that we should rejoice that Trebonius has paid the that Trebonius Is a criminal ? for what crime it that on the Ides of March he withdrew you the destruction you deterred? Come, you at this let us tee st what you are annoyed. UoUU-lU has at this crisis been adjudged * w killtnjt an matin, and that the son * seems dearer to the Roman people than the father of hit country, it matter for
:

Whet

lament that Dolabella has l> What do you not understand alt oxer Italy, by the despatch of the Consuls, by the honouring of Caesar, finally by the assumption of military garb, sou have adjudged a enemy * And what cause, you criminal. hare you to groan that Dolabella has been adjudged
!
I

the Senate, when sou hold that int. but set before of no account, y ports If as a ground for waging war the utter Jettioilhwi of the Senate, am) the inclusion of all and all wealthy men in the fate of But he callt Trebonius the son order. 'man knight as if in fact th^t And to us. the Cither of Trebonius who has acknowledged children by Fadie, to despite the low birth of anyone ? Hot the bitterest thing is that you, Aulus

Htrtiau,

Caesar

though you haye been distinguished by hin in a position in d left by him ll lill, and yoertcH--
571

UA* is

ii

ins

itftwiUft.
.j.im!.

Ym

Qd
('IT

Mid

1.1

tarft

thdtocforirt

Kt ut venefir* h*ec hbcrctur otmidiaoe,"

ftoHU-.

m*

TW
57

pUj

PHILIPPIC
certainly cannot
"

XIII.

xi.

*4-, 5

deny that Hirtius was digby Cienr, but those distinctions, when Sit on virtue and energy, have liutrc. But you, who cannot deny yon were distinguished by the ssojo Geeaar, whot would yon be if he had not bs sto snd so much on yon? Would your merit have ssiti l i d yon on to any height? would pane birth > Yon would have wasted every day of your Ms to brotheU. in eooluhops, to gambling, in A tof, as you oaed to do when yon deposited your beard your wiu m the bosoms of yonr actresses. 1
lis hhw a boy whoso he has felt, and shall be not only a man, but a very brave man That name Indeed belong* to his age, but it is too. one not to bo oniiiloiud by a man who bestows his own madness on this boy as material for glory. Von who owe everything to a Mr owes eertaialy. and discharges the debt nobly n Oseaar were the father of hit country, as tee name him my sentiments 1 will reserve why is thai youth not more truly her father from whom we

Gael, to

criminal hands? I oat ion should strive to show that Dolabella

authority of Verily a baae action, by wl. a most distinguished order is defended against the marine as of a most cruel gladiator 1 M And that this she-poisoner nhould be liberated
(t

meaning, being baiag added by

573

MAtCUS TULUUB

Hirtm. Ml

IW*.
it

Ip

rw

!)*

a
i

nj
s.

ii

d.

/*/ si

Ct/V

$74

I'HII.imi

\III.

xi.

25-xn. 26

too dare to call the man a she-poisoner who has dbwO i Mut remedy for your poisonings ? w! too new lUnnibal (or any other cleverer general), von are besieging an as really to be besieging yourself, without the power, if you wished, of extricating yourself from that pmitkwi - Supposing you retreat, II farces will follow you op on all sides ; supposing where yon are, you will be caught. A ssuredly yon rightly call a %hc poisooer the man by whom yon sen your present ruin has been brought

-That yon should strive that Cassius sod Brains powerful as possible/* You would imagine he was speaking of Censor, mis. or Venbdiuv 1 or even the Ivetl And why shou ld they begrulge power to men who
nsar be as

are not onlr most loyal and noble, but also allied 1 them in the defence of the Stater Truly ton* regard these things as you did the what things, prsyr): M you used to call the of Pass p< Ins the Sena* I. Should are rather call your camp the Senate ? is yourself, manifestly a consular, when has been utterly torn out of every there are two praetors who

would get anythinga ground

the beoefactioos of Csessr Philadelphia* Anniui and the ir sent* ftullins : foresee sediles, that boxer's dummy on which I tried my lungs and voice/ Bestis, and that patron of good faith and swindler ot ? creditors, Trrl*-ilu-.. und Hani mptur. i and rained the prop of the friends of ami Qusntns Caelraa, n Antonius by way of
for
rs,

we uphold

575

ruixi
III

uo lurr

m
Hmmd
.,1

Q~

VrrU ml.

ct *t*L L

Hoc

Uml

nt

ftliA

***,

Decimal iwiMri mJio

ar! 11.^1

rtm.

d.

JW

5 il

ii

rtMMWof

IM
P.

Um hnml I a MMjr.
576

OodiM

*. 1.

PHILIPPIC
t

XIII

nt, ,6-xni. 27

stave*
ita;

an enter* mment ordered to be lashed by (H the septetm irate > re Lento and ! then there Is thr |>et and darling Locius Antonius;* aa tribunes, first

of all thr two tribune* r,r,t, I'ullus Hostilius, who with good right m%cnbed his name 00 the gate by which, ben he mold not betray him, he abandoned the other tribune elect is one Insteius, brigand, they my, though they report that st mi he was a temperate man '-as a mixer of Other farmer tribunes there are too, eapeeiallr, who it lie Imd loved the would hare burned the Senate-bouse* for that enme, he returned in arms to he had been opelM by the laws. on to him and moat of those It com him. But one thing surprises me, which in the of this rmnens It generally said, as it were proly, that he cannot die unless his legs hare broken,' They hare been broken, and he But tarn, aad many other things, mast be put to AootU . credit ^<tos ss alwj there, sprung, I suppose, from i\ 1 Mores; 9 accordingly he nibbled The memory of the Deeii has indeed after a long interval through But how can I pa over Saxa m frllow fetched from the remotest nations that we might see ae tribune of the commons a
4

i
l.

#.

Who
6

John anssss hs has hssu crucified H .* of a faaa " bs is bora to bs hanged Phil. cf. /ractoi crur* I'oUeatia of store ban oat
. aweu, If as waa a family oauia of the Deciao ta the sanootnr aUadad to, of. I'kU. xi. 6.

Mmrm
Aa

am

577

I\*>pr..

ct

frrci

ffcwi)* turn

I.

p.

%i.V

MMamtolMi
8m* m 7.t
to J. f

MM

of

M*oi
57

(MMMMOTof

mn imc
MB we
otaee It

xiii. xn.
as

, 7

-x.v. 29
?

bad never teen

a citizen

om of the
fit

In the
all

Saeernas; but they

likeneat that
I

of them

mfw

eoeh a

common

may mistake

names. And certain! the of Philadelphia, the quaestor, t be ay nothing of so noble a v. to be envying Antonius his possesThere si also a certain Asinius. a by himself: he saw the Scnatealler Caesar's death hr changed his suddenly became a Conscript Father. dost know Sextos Albeeiua, but 1 never met as to say be was unworthy of
;

think I hovo passed over some but concerning thai occ to me I could not be silent. he relies and is the Senate on whu h Senate iii which we were ten iiis war would not at all; audacity would hi led to authority But what a protection the others would bee vosj can understand from this: I, the esse left of many, crushed and broke with your the aodacitr of* an exulting robber. But if Fortune had only not robbed us of Sen ma Sulraciu*,* and before that of his colleague Marcos Marcel u and what otixcns, what men - they ! if the State had been able to keep the assssjja, warm lovers of th ry, who were together espelled from lUly ; or Lucius Afro.. or Ptiblim I^ntulus, a that eassssjmmate general eJltasj of singular worth in other ways but especially my recall ; or Marcus Bibulus, whose he State has ever been justly
1
;

umd

579

Vtrwm ^:tur

rripmhht
Co. fumpci
*
.

foil

Co.
>

nr AnUmmm

Qui cfO

practorfi

ttfctt

tfcaUuiu

a
-In

commkfatfc Vaio

Mf

cmf**."

m Gafe fmlre

puUt

tc litigare.

AmtmC'i


PHILIPPIC Mil
;

nv. ao-*v. 30

or Lacms I>omitiu, i most distinguished or A p pint Handles, a man at eminent for birth ss for loyalty or Publiut Scipio, a man ot distinction aaJ moat resembling his ancestors lart the Senate of Pompeius
;
;

Which thru was the State, that Pompeius be living, or the purchaser of Pompeius' con? But what men the former I the chief of them was Marcus Cato. A em**too in virtue smoog ail nations. Why should the rest of those most Illustrious men ? 1 am more afraid of jour enumerating them than of
en nVsysrohm
for
il

in passing

What

es-acdOea

there srere!

what isjimsiil Why my and the) smmmw of the Senators was such that those trim did not come Into that camp had need of
strong

m< what ex -tribunes more? The dignity

XV

mm Yon
-

Now attend to the rest of his letter. have had the vanquished Cicero for
l

" general"

the

more gladly

he certainly mys
nqoished
I

it

mnrflsmg

^
I

to

care nothing.

that apart from the

SUte

For it it cannot be

Macedonia with garrisons." <", no Yea, and we have wre* family. your from Icsmneretc yon have entrusted to Varus, a man twice 0*1*^" rrCaiut! Mr thinks be Is arguing w M You have sent Casaius inU> Syria,"

rm

M\n us

Ti

mi

aeum

.-

to

^r^^ryELC
OD.
*-.

rf.

to

J-

ft

Ml
5*'

C
/.

PHIMI'PIl- Mil
l>o
asjr

iv.

30-31

yoe not then

cm, and

feel thai the world lies open to that too have bare nowhere outside jour ye

loot?

Yoo have allowed Case* to hold the

tribune.

What then ?
re

Were we

to espel from the State,

like a Manillas, a Gaeeetios * a

man through whose secured the impossibility of the same and many things of the same kind, ever
the Lnperci the Julian

oftrf wards?

the Luperci? and not of that day* 1 with unguents, naked, be dared, amid their groans, to orge the Roman people to be slam? Yon have taken away the veterans' colonies, fhoogti planted by law and by decree of the Sena Did wo take them away, or on the other hand Yet ratify a law passed at the Comitia Centuriata ? conldn whether it is not you that hare ruined the* veteran, who had been rained, and planted them In a position from which they themselves already leel they will never escape. Von are muoilaiiif to restore to the Mastilians what has been taken from them by the laws of war. I do not ergo* as to the laws of war the argument to mote eatv than neeeamir ; bat notice this j> Consevipt Father*, what a born enemy to this State Is ; who so bitterly bates that comm he knows has been always most friendly to

Thar aad baas ladussd by Caesar:

cf. Past, viii

583

qui i*t.

(OraQf )

mm mmtnmw mmmi

Th* mmf

m+*9

hmm

Uv

g Uw

b>U oJInlit-jM iwt 1

t*fcfcaiwi

WWbiMonrU>M

(Wt-..

fwti

5*4

IBfUPttC Mil
ef

xvi.

3,-33

"Yarn repeat thst no surviving adherent

P iawfu ins is bound by the Hirtian U Who, 1 ask. now mentions the Hirtian law?
utik. the

proposer himself regrets no less bo*r against whom it was pasted. In my it Is wot right to call it a law at all ami, rrti if ,t :*- * 4 . r ought nut |Q regard it as
l
p

Uwef Hfctfcs*.
Brutus
with
the

Von supplied Apnlrv "

money

of

If the State had armed an excellent man Hil all its forces, what good man, pray, would regret it f For without money he could not have supported an army, or without an army have taken your
i uu ays hteaedewsos, men

of the eiecution
i

of Petraeus and
the

who had been given

.rvr

itizcnship,

ana

sjwc%i inriMii oi

did not approv e what we had never even Assuredly in such disorder of public of. we ought to have given serious attention to oat rascally (ireckUngs Vou did not care that Theopompus was stripped and dmrn oat by Trebouius, and took refuge in
adrift."

We

We were henry charge against the Senate bout Theopompus. that eminent man, about as to where in the world he is, what he is hi a word, whether he is alive or dead, who
!

cither

knows or cares? Vou look on ServiasGslba

in the canip girt with

the hliaaiial dager

I make you no reply as to Galba, s most brav he' will be prcmt himself, snd etiadfaet crtisen that dagger vou reproach him with will reply to
; j

55

M \KCU8

TULUUt OC&tO

mtfimmmmmmmmm

ncr**U

ImfmltelU.

* ..r.Ulrm,
pghiiaiifc

Mir;
1MB hot

XVII

rt.

4 Q*

O Mt Ml
rt
rt in

M
I U rmt4M
i

s.

FoOT*

Md

tfc

Ibrtte

PIIll.llTlc

\l||

n.

-3-x*ii.
1

34

c yr

have enlisted soldiers, either mine or rat sram , on Uie plea that it was for the destru. of Ca esar i murderers ; and then these same soldiers
*

"Yosj

wh

H MM MM

their quaestor, or their general, or those their own fellow soldiers." Of cosrw we cajoled, we deceived them' tl.< Martian legion, the Fourth were ignorant n

the ratarana did out know what was being d< coot supporting the auth<> oate, 1st liberty of the Roman people they wished to the death of Caesar, which all men deemed
!

was 700, no doubt bay were happy and prosperous wretched man, not only from your situsion, bat especially in not feeling how wretched you Bet listen to the greatest charge. la short, what it there you have not approved 9 done, which, should he come to life again, would
;

by dietiii y
I

It

doneb,
for I suppose he will bring forward of some rascal. pumpeius himself base we *rr it we have indeed copied
f
'

Oh. bow aewsPompehsBl - Or his too. should he be able

Mr

til

to live at home." be able, believe me; far in a few days be ato bis father's house and pleasuress
I

Lastly, you my peace U impossi er let out Brutus or supply him with c< hen my so; but I think that, even

if

what you sal yea and the State.

cr be peace

you do between
587

MARCUS TULLIl
f

hot

iiUnUn taw

>ui

lhu

iv*U-

''fi

'

N.nnr

rr

- * ,
I

A.'.
5

Aa


PHILIPPIC
XIII. ivu. 34-36

the opinio* of those veterans of coerses ore still open 1 have seen no coarse so open to them as to begin ' the general whom with such seal and they h*e have set out to pervert them with Msed gifts. cy so osnfiUJ whose resolve it is to pursue est fowl enemy with a most just war? But you my you are bringing aid to the besieged
it tills

WWII

sil

" tig safe, and _ do not mint: where thev wish, provided only they suffer him to perwh who ha dcaer*c How kind In a word it was by the liberality

of Anton*

It

those soldiers deserted tftmtf themselves in a panic to an U though, had it not been lor them Dolabella not have offered a tacrince to his general Antomws too had dose so to his colleague.' * You wntr that mention has been made of peace natc. and that the envovs sre five consuls. Is dinVult to believe that those who drove me I offering most equitable terms so thinking o( yielding as to some of them ing moderate or thr hardly likely too that those who Dolabella an enemy on account of a most can at the same time tpare me who am of

that

wa

that he confesses he Dolabella in all with partnership s into has entered ma acts ? De yon not see that from the one fount

Does

it

seem a small thing

woe ffcr-rr. m eoUaefes ate.!..**

in the oonsutahip.

589

MAftCUS

TULUUS ClCEtO

llirtft riU
hmhc

IM

,*.

I*

Id

piMkil

tofdttnH, at

trU mm

ttutmsrH

Wfcrrt

TW
$y

M)AflL.MlUai

PHI!
well
II

a 36-jmu .38
.

the crimes?

He

himself in fart confesses

shrewdW mmigh inclrr,! -that tfcOM who <ieDoUbe IU an enemy on account " of a most

edeed ""os H seems to

ho
!

Antonias

cannot spare

baa the asm

I What would to do with a man who has not to the record of a letter hit arran with i msa betls that he should slay Trchoiiiui with tortures, and. If he eoold. Bents and Cassius too, and that be h lmsr tf should hold the tame pun over our head* ? Oh, s cttiten to be preserved along with o nehteoos ami so just complains that his terms have Ix-m re eh fair ami modest terms that he should knee Farther Goal, a province most adapted to the renewal and preparation of war; that the Larks hnuUI it a yi'Murti tti thr third |*n.|. tint is to me to the 1 hat there should be a sa fe refu^: Slate; that his acts should though no trace of his consulship He was providing also for Lndus Antonius, mains. that moat fair parti turner of private and public land,
|

dm

Norwla and Lento as colleagues. do yon rather eonsider which is in taste and more beneficial to your party, to death of TreUnius or that of Caesar;
is more fitting that we should battle so that the cause, so often slaughtered, of the Pumpesans should more easily come to life, or should ss|ise together, that we may not be a derision to our
.

had been slaughtered,

It wt

or be

CU, sad an Mpportars.

59

MAftCUS

TULUU8 dCttO

la faro to

^,1

MB
\\\

~<MbM.

toft

Cut

Tl/^j

CkL

m4 k party.

59

PHILIPPIC

XIII.

itiii.

38-nx. 40

may that be the fate of you and * Wiich is to better ta*te >" he says. And m And so la Una war there it a question of taste Party," you madla the forom. in' the Senateirfartooi war, yoa have undereountry yoa are blockading tag a consul-elect it is war are waging, and with them all Italy is in arms against ; U too call that a M part v," or rather a revolt M fo avenge the death free the laaaaa people? or that of Caesar ." We sufficiently the death of Trebonlus when Dolabella was aa eactny; Caesar's death is most easily by oblivion and silence. But mark his rhea ha thiaks the death of Caesar should d ha atoyeats death not only for the perof that dead, bat also for those who did
! ;

XIX

- For

whichever

of as

falls

those enemies

Sera a spectacle Fortune herself so far hat avoided, that she might not see two armies of eae body fighting with Cicero as trainer, who is so
will profit
1

that he has deceived you with

the

of speech with which be boasted Caesar

former gibes but I will brand IrtsjTwniTthe truest marks of infamy, and will hand Usting memory of men. I "a bias down to not aa unskilful one 1 deindeed And Uilair"T sire the slaughter of the worst, of the best the victory, fall,- he writes, " will be to our pro6t"

of me, ss

if his

rest success;

593

MM-

U8

II

II

KKO

bono

rtti,

lUe * art. ** ^*" tmt "* Ok

!*-?

^^
A.

:*<#>* i

Bjr

hMf OW%H 7

? fro

R~~

(m

PHILIPPIC

XIII. xix. 40-43

What splendid profit, wherebv, if you are -which may the tod forfend !- theirs 111 1 d death who cipire without tortures
that H>rUoa

the rictor will be a

I

He says

and Caesar 1 were M deceived by roe by tne an* iowert of speech.' What riowrr of srxpray, haw *m ao Car been bestowed by me roe on llirtiusr Hirtius? far to fini r more and finer ones are doe. But is tt the other Caeaar yon dare to aay waa de<

met tau,vooJmy.sJewhimatthcLupercalia; an why have yon. moat ungrateful man, abandoned * his Bet mark now Una ereat and noble
1

man s aawMHt parity and nrmneat

raaoliad to endore no inaolu to myaelf or and not to deaert the party Potnpeiu hawed, nor to permit the vctrrane to be removed their abode, nor to be dragged one by one to nor to betray the pledged faith I hare given
1

am

lo

me

ftt awdi,

loaeeowt thereat; this

loyal fcl low

cannot aban-

don the "pledge he gare to Dolabella," that hsUset What pledger One for the roasaacre of of men.
and of the boat uWatttw, the partition of j Italy, the d t f na tati on and plunder of the provinces? For what elee was to be ratified by pact and pledge between Antonlna nod Dolabella, those moat shameless

murderr to be

false to

my

alliance with

LopJom* the

Yon

in aJhancr with

*cn, as he

Upidus , or with any I will la hot with any sane

man
awosjld

Yowr endeavour is to show that Lepidus be regarded at either disloyal or insane. though to speak no& ivour

man

it

difficult- especially

about

595

v
*)><*.

<

.;.

TW

&**m

f
>

r.(

Ih.

tpimlmmmm* m
toil!

yf

Wto

iW Suu. Ul

1*11!

<5-x*45
;

1 hall never tear shall have the 1 of him bile I can. Lepidus wished to joor f re nay, not to abc -anity. Yoo, atoreover, ' _ not merely the loyal, bat among the M and, though word does not exist at all' in the Latin language, 1 yon In your divine loyalty introduce a new n

Nor

to

betray

Planet*,

the

juirtner

oj

Plancna a partnc/ ? hose remarkable and Ilea Inonjrtd loyaltjr ibedt a luttre on the State- unless prrhapa you think be it coming to your aid* with MS nsost valiant legions, and the greatest force of cavalry and infantry of the < auls and who, if before his arrival, do not pay the penalty to port fa this war. For, although irst ccoars are the more useful to the St he Inst are the more welcome. Hat now be palls himself op, and at the end
-

n
I

tread the path of an upright purpose, the

Gods

hall, as
If

vasist

me,
I

will

Bat

another fate await me,

m
1

you

will suffer

waaas cossowered, Pompeians are so insolent, what they will be aa conquerors it is you* rather who
Anticipation of jot i you not against " Pompeia
Sta.e

ours is a tin but with the universal All Go** and men. aVf highest, middle, and
i

may

and foreigners, men and women,

freeasen and
slavea, bate

We have felt you. a true one wc shall feel

it

Thai A. was eosd.

597

c
.

Hru'.um

ut

lit

Uttrrt

Quo

rt

UDMHi

l*".*'

pttrUr

(rttos

<|<*i

{Ml

duo U

TWii fafMtf

W Omm*

\UtktoUWWml
59

f*rt j

Hlll.llTir XII!

vv 45-47

wtll

die with an

o ponder on these things with yoereasier mind and with

:

- Finally, the sum of my decision tends to this I e** bcr injunc inhVtctl bv my JlHllnjf if cither tfreyr themaelvea are willing to forest the commission *+ * dy with me to avenge Caesar's <f

ear

eftfcer

yom know Antonms' resolution, do yon Aulas Hftrtmu or Caios Fanaa, the <x to pea* over to Antonios, besiege Brutus, o attack Matins? Why do I apeak of Htrtmsr Will Caesar, a young man of Anal moling, be able to restrain himself esartmg a penalty for his fathers death in me raws Brutus So whm thry had read

thai letter. the* jm '"*

'

1
i

hi* siege-works. M^r-works. his

And

proved hi mself greater, hare been born by dm the greater kindness of the mmaortaJ Gods for the service of the Stat< r bees beguiled by any phantom of or by filial feeling, and understands that the greatest doty of a son consists in the preBut if there were a taveattoo of me fatherland. party ccamVt though Urn name of part? is altogethm i immt otrnM Antoomoaml \>. difind the pertr of Caesar than first of all Caesar, man of the wannest filial feeling for the nsa and Hirtius, who of hit pareti two wings when thst word held as' was truir applicable? But what parties to the one side the authority of the
w

oaW."r "to approsch

a physical

599

MAMCUS TL'LMl'S HCEHO

oonm, V

mm IMmqm

mrtitfto.

iMlljMl.i.fr^dMMl

+*mmmdm p-tfarN J pwilirth

irtui rt fartaM*. lok. *

ildwrtli

*.!!;.

CT

fii

Ml

ir*

tUf flO^j
W4tl
f tl
;

lilt

n<fctl,

wmH
bitfer*

wja rl nr

Om Uwwm

f J.

PHIUPFK

Mil

xx. 4 7 -xxL49

the liberty of the Roman people, and the safety ol the Stale re act as objects, to the Othot
r of food men and the partition of the tad of It* t os cone at last to the clause " I do not believe envoy* are coming" well he knows me! oming "and well it may he when we o the Instance of Dolahclla. * I supwtll have rights more sacred than the two be it In arms; than Caesar be b ; than a eonsal-elect whom sdiog; than fclotina Hoi lie is behit country which bo threatens with

the

msnur r

they come
ttoss

to

I shall learn their demands." Would any and racks fall upon you yoo hut someone like Ventidius? 1

For the qoench'ing of a rising conflagration we sent men of lodotinf yon rejected them are we now nd them into a blase so great and so firmly settled by delay when yoo have made for yourself no room I do not say lor peace but even for urrcn<l This letter. Conscript Fathers, I have read, not because I thought him worthy that I should, but that by the man's own confessions you might see all
; ;

his Uiiotiiai laid open. Marcos Let**, richly

It

it

with this
as he

man
is

that
all

endowed

with

the gift* of vtrtoc and of fortune, would,

this letter, at tost desire to
fire

if

he saw

make peace, or think it with water," as some poet anything than that the State
tiaios

the only

Roman who hsd

;

a. Jav

mi

m H
7.

,ju.
|

Hs wasgi vrn
j

Oatt. la. 4

Plok Ami. 34

pn*lio funeral. and fragn. 5 of

6oi

MM:.

II II

1 1

>

of t*. It* o<

M aM

tru

Wk

NUfUmf
L.
I

ch

PHILIPPIC

XIII.

ml

49-50

to agreement with the Antonii, or the b the State These men are monsters [prodigies] to the Sute. Better were

of ours should be shifted from her

nigratr.
if it

were possible, to

where she should " not hear of the doings

than that she should expelled by Caesar's r. and be that of Brutus held in check,* within her walls. Our first prayer is to conquer; in the to regard 00 chance of fortune as 00 behalf of the honour and liberty of remains ss not a third, bat the I, to incur the greatest turpitude of life through This being so. on the question of the r< and the letter of that most illustrious aw Marews Uptdos, I agree with Serrilius;* and propose thai addition "That Magnus Pompeius, the son of Caacwa, has acted agreeably with the disposition and the seal towardf the State of his father awd Ma ancestors, and with his own accustomed virtue, energy, and go) will, in promising the Senate Kasnan people the assistance of himself and
" of the Antonii,

men who were

We

of those with him; and thai thss action is welcome and aWMptatdc to the Senate and Roman people, and that Una action will redound to his honour and
dignity."

Una may either be added to the present decree of the Senate, or can be separated therefrom and independentlr registered, thst the praise of Poaaneia* mar appear in the Senates own decree.

IKTBOl

It)

PHILIPPIC

XI v

'he 15th of April an engagement (wl>

dtmittud by Senrhw Gelba in a letter to Ci. aW #. 1" HO) took plate at Fomm GaJlorum, the
mndrrn Caatrl Hranro, bct*rr tl, r for. cs of and those of Pan*. This was the first battle of bf uttna, m which t& Consul Pansa was mortally
r,

tonJaa

Antonio* had gained a victory panic h At the same tile A Etonia n party jMncd in a conspiracy to the Capitol, murder Cicero, and massacr. it*. A fake report was also spread that at aiming at the dictatorship, and would ftppear in pablftc preceded by the fasces. Ag.. Una claim Qcero was defended on the 20th before the people by hi% friend Apuleius the tribune, and flat people " with one voice/' as Cicero says in his ipet i h (PkU. 14. f>), M declared that he never had a taosjgttt but for the weliare of the State." Two or three boars aAer the meeting the true report of the of Aatooios arrived at Rome, and the turn thnnks, and *-r to the Capitol t* "It was an ovation/ be ate to bat boose. an, -and waU-nigb a triumph " (Pint 14. 5). Cocnutu. the city praetor, sumOn the Slat mooed the Senate, and P Servilius moved that dress aboald be aaaamed and a public thanksgr prorUin^.l In the debate Qcero spoke tualb Pbilippic, opposing the first proposal, but
'*

false report that

atmmt

60s

iMtoDucrios to philippic xn
IhtXhrtr* be

IW iiyriniiooH ported UtW)ottlMr,ari)

of lit j dor, ad

mmk k otmld
-,th

otrle Imprtofa trio

poblftr

uiW b*d *U. P

TW tficcco

bo ad fan. boj eoinjpr of Oo Uic as fcogbt lb* toroad Utile Motioo. m wh*b Aatoatoo wot

no

Umh

km Mid to I! root of * loo otto loooi ot

rl oflci

ooi

Htrtftoo,

iboVc. 11. Upbloi

.qjiioIii

010 irtlToV

4,

Aatowfctcoo o.l.o,om

77

M II I.I.I OH A TIO

NS M rill I. If PR A Qt'AfcTA DEI

i

III

t ei lftttffc.qi

1
et *

III

lin

rn Or Id,

*Md

mpBtimmm, pnjim ori prticmli m& m?

brill r,|

Qaac ftutnn est bU tmtcatla, at la bodkOTNNn f dktm WlUtll Mtrtar, drtodt cm ffU nwl
i

Id

!. trtnimlr
rurn turj**

t JlMtidtw.

Atqc

III!

H1LIPPIC 01
S CICKHO AGAINas
i

\!

TUL.

\i

wioNIUS

which has been read, Conlearned that the army of accsj rsed enemies ha% beta art to pieces and dispersed, I laid alto Irarnrtl what we all of us esj all? Wmg fur, and think baa followed from Uie whi.-h h*% lcrn IchJeved, nain.lv. that victory Dectmnt Brutu baa already come out of Mutina, then, a am account of hi* danger we had assumed uld mfttUry garb, to on account of his sa wrthoot an? doubt propose that we should return to our anrim! | fr %t But twforr the event which the
letter

fro the
I

script Father.

Imr

tum

t'..r has Ihtii r p.rttcl, Jit for a most importml glorious battle; hut reserve the return to garb uf he completion of victory. ion of this war is the safety of

ii.

HaflJfl

tttgetij **it*

Deelmu* Brutu. Rut Kit does the proposal mean that our dress shooM be changed foe to-day, and that to-morrow *ben bould jro forth in military garb? we once return to the dress we desire and For it let os see to it that we keep it for evermore.
not only disgraceful, but not even pleasing to the I Gods themselves, that we should depart from their altar, which we approached in the civic gown. Id sswuic the garb of war. A KmsjIss! Psftflsfft, th*4 certain Senators favour thai svsmosaJ, their wish and design being this : as they
hi

IsjjiiiH

609

'U.kfagrWfforlW4

6lO

PHILIPPIC XIV.
day
will

i.

3-u. 5

Ik a very glorious one to which, on ceo we shall return to ct%ic drcsa, they desire to rob Inn. of thai honour that it nuv not be that on crount of a single peril the tonatii people assumed military garb, and on of ht safety returned t He gown.

h on

this reason, and you will find none for so But do you. Con proposal tiers, your authority, abide by your detenninal your numorUs, as vou have often made plam. that the issue of all this war centres in the fa single mmt valiant and eminent man For the relief of Decimus Brutus were sent toe chief men of the common that tat say and murder l*rt from ; for Use preserv ation of the same Decimus chosen by lot baa set out to war, rtm. hose weakness of health his strt of spirit and the hope of victory have rc-esUM wli' id raised an army by his own ind had freed the State from the first out>rder that no such crime should

Take aar

to relieve the same overcome some pain on private What was country. by hi* ft object in holding levies, raising money,
arise, baa set out
1
.

Senate against the st encouraging us, and calling the Roman cause of lib* rty, but the u From him the Roman people in Brutus r fall aasosahly to earnestly demanded with one voice mi Brutus that they set that merely before their own advantage, but even before

6n

Mill!"

'

If...

Prill intcTi>co%|

Mil rfciuot rirtMM Mil

nrr,

ikfMt m*

to

6ia

PfHUmC
.

<

....

of daily food.

Poitiers,

ought 'to hope

it

This object we, on too eve of

.,

tult.l

rilled already ; but it httin^ that the of oor hope be reserved for the actual iter by our haste to have anticipated of the immortal Gods, or by our lolly %f*sed the might But ti 'Ay declares your fotBog OO this matter, I will eotne d frt^n the consuls ami thr propraetoi I My trst say a few words which are |kt
I

>-1ual let
III
I

be swords of oor legions and our armies

dififwd, Conscript

TWy

Fathers, or rath, r the two battles of our in Ibo third one of Caesar. that our blood was Use blood of cncsuic, th< oldiert w as supreme, a moostrous crime? if it was of t>t. H long tlien shall he who has sur) tasted my ? all enemies in crime be without the nan or soldiers to or do yoo wuh the In doubt vhrthrr they should !>< plunged deen I u a otiten or into an OJ rfirmv \ou 1< DOl C.lll hill) ill tie our thanks, welcome Ofl Gods when there has been slain a so," he says, u for the " for victory otor anprincipled and audacious men that n the name the most illustrious Senator* gives tnem Such % to urban law suits, BOTES tlwt brand mtmu H inr war. are ejecting ore forging wills. I im their neighbour*, or cheating itffipUnf*,; far it is
becss
id. so

the

Mood abed

in

1 1

4st*tnoa, tot inuBsasr of tha publn th*

6rj

MARC

'S

11

fi.i;

(<>flr

to a.

I.

ML

614

PHILIPPIC XIV.

in. 7 -,t.

ith these vices and such like whom it csntosnary to call " bad 1,or aoaV esse moat savage of all brigands is carrying on an war against four consols; 1 he is waging mm ar against the Senate and the Roman ; all amen though the I Im works is to Us threatens with destiealiun,dnMtii' tad racks; Dolabellas brutal and savage that no barbarous people could acknowledge, ho testifies was committed by his advice ; and
it
'
1

have attempted in this

city,

had not

spelled him from this be has shown in the calamity

erlltssmof Parma. There most bound by the closest ties the authority of this order and the
dignity of the Roman people, were pot to death in the moat ctwel ways by that vile wretch and monster tortus Antonio*, that mark for the hatred of all Gods too bate those they should sac the Gods as well. My mind recoils, Conml drrads to utter what I iiildrrn and wives of the men oV For the infamies to which the Antonii of Parma
2 to their own disgrace, they Hut to hose Iniirtrd by violence on others. they offered them is disastrous shamemat ith which the life of the Ant.mii is there then any man not bold enough to he admits i, by whose crimes ? surpassed been has Carthaginians of the cruelty the For m what city, when hehadcaptn Hannibal as savage as Antonius has been in Parma, which he had seised by stealth ? unless perhaps he
:

615

MARltS

It

II

It

iiawilpH

Mid

bdm*

I.

~/W tt
If

IW Ml.

Mi
a W,

iU

ft-

6t6

i'iiimppic
it

in

1v9.11

ad of the

not to be regarded as an enemy uf tins colony, real towards winch he is of the same Hot if he 1% without any doubt the enen mice and boroughs, what think you is he lusted for to glut the \ the city which that f Si surveyor Saxa had already
'a

by bis teo-ioot rule r I Recall, in nssae. Conscript Fathers, what our fears bate been these two days past * from most unscriij u
without tears could look OO his children, his bss home, his roof, hit familiar House!, ..Id (Jods? All were thinking either of a most shameful death Do we hesitate to call or of a swoat wretched flight. If any suggest cssesswee the authors of these fears ? a harsher name, I will gladly asaent to it with the a milder one I word I am scar
;
.

Accordingly, since we are bound, from the letter rbich baa been read, to decree thanksgivings most justly due, and since Scrvilius has proposed them, I will 10 all increase the number of days, especially as they are to be decreed in honour, not of one, but of three generals. But my first task shall be to
cull

them Impcrators by whose

fort
sYl

valour,

judgment and

bs*f been rescued from the utmost and death. For to whom these perils of ears baa a thanksgiving been decreed a out bss being called Imperator, though his exploits snuy mar have been very small or sometimes none at all a thanksgiving should either not by the previous speaker, or the " honour should be award, d

good

617

UAH

in KM
i

ritT.Ro

lori t is

led iniurW dolor fHI

ow
r

prortcr

Koojw

ovtfc

a b

rn

TW
Moior oltW
61

ionrtlM

PHILIPPIC XIV
to

r*.

,i-*.

new and
anyone
had
killed

special ones are

dec.
a thousand or two Gauls, or Thracians, the would style him Imperator according to tins bat prevailed; now, when so many a multitude of enemies do I say.> yea, 1 repeat, enemies, hose domestic enemies of ours dislike thai name -shall we award the honour of a thanksgiving to most ll lnstrions generals and yet deprive them of the name of Imperator? For with % amid what joy and congratulation, liberators of this city to en n temple, when yesterday, on account of their exploits, the Unman pls carried me from my house to the Capitol In ovation,' and all but in triumph, and

thcoce brought
only,
is

me

back home

For that, and that

opinion a true and genuine triumph when* to those that have deserved well U ate, iy is borne by the unanimous voice <>: For if, amid a genem ng of the they were congratulating one man. it urned i a groat certiorate of merit; U thank* to one man, it is so much a greater; if they did both, no more magnificent testimonial can be
In
.

my

ay saw,

.ou then speaking of your own self?" sol Indeed, I do so unwillingly, but the sco by a sense of wrong* has made me rood my habit. Is it not enough that en without knowledge of \irtue thanks to served the State are reell oho f shall envy search for a charge of rash*

619

MUU

HUH
In

Mi
14

||

Atiiiiwiirii.i.

te

cm

pOMrt,

tirwn l

^m
A
t

q*4 Ui>
I

to rr

pat* *

rgo,

qft

CatitftMM fcwt

h*r

IMH
Cm.

Hi

cju

crtiirrrt'

tndr

VI.

almtte

!!! tout

inM

hm
Mtk
I

m,u

lnw JOk mn otM m inbhwn tMW

I

WinP>IHt

mil

ItM * CM*

K n t1>
i
.

TV# uti' *

^a K WW.

M-WX MM. Wy
by IU1.

TW

>

Ciwr tn

ranjpm
I aaletv

\iv. v

3 -vi.

who devote all their care of the State > For vou know that last few dart there has been a Wuii that at the Pad hathat is, to-dayneed to come down ml I, the agine this tale was concocted r, or brigand, or Catiline, not red that no such thing could be nosss l h to the State. Is it to be thai I who. when Catiline had this design, removerthrew him. rruhed him, tbooid myself soddeolr prove a Catiline ? Under what auspices r those fasces ? how long should I, an aug should I possess them> to whom should I transmit them To think there wot any man so wicked as U as to believe it i, or rati c sprang

Sthe

i'

.*

When, as you know, within the last three or days a depressing report from Mutina was us, puffed up with joy and it d gathered into one place, into that met place of the Senate which proved unpropitious to their own frcoay rather than to the State* There, as they were planning our massacre, and
V
I

iuig

the tasks
>tol,

among themselves, who should who the rostra, who the city -gates,
flock

that this fact should result in inv unpopuli in peril to my life, they spread abroad that hoot the fasces ; they proposed to bring the When this had to me with their own bands. a* it were, with my consent, then an fcsjsjsj itom attack Of) me, as against a tyrant, by hired bravoes

thought the citiscns would

around me.

6ai

M\!.<

m KM lOi mo
Af*\tkm 9 trfbwN
pi

IUq~ F

mro

|>rrwlantaK|uc i*m lad

C.pn*mh*r

6ta

PHILIPPIC \i\

15-m

was organised ; after which a massacre of you all woold laws followed. This plot the event, Conscri pi
bare; but proper time the of all this wickedness shall be disAad so Pobttos Apuleius, the tribune of the tom aaw M. the witness, confidant, and helper ever aha* my comoUhip in all my counsels and perils, could not bear the grief caused by my grief; he held a very great public meeting of the Roman people sentiment* were identical with his. At thst while he was proceeding, in accordance with d Intimacy, to free me from the maces, the whole med fasj that no thought of mine on pwbtas Wfcsrs waa other than entirely loyal. After the holding of thai meeting, within two or three hours and letters with the Tor ; to that the same day from a most unjust odium, but me by the collective congratulaof the Roman people. I have interposed these remarks, Conscript Fathers, not so much as an apology for myself for I should n a poor wav it I were insufficient! v exculpated might as that in yoor eyes without a defence ad tee, as I have always done, certain persons of too puny and narrow a spirit to regard tli< virtue of tion,notof envy. rensaswort: Great to the field open in the State, as Crassus used wisely to say ; many are they for whom the path to
laid
1
, I

fiupc

would indeed those chiefs of the State who after my consulship, though I myself gave way to them, saw me not unwillingly 623
I

Is

open.

vi

\ftCUS

TUtXIUS

Ti 0*Uo< ife Uuni a fcmrt* fVbpfN*.

miUPra
to

\iv.

ru 7-19
this

the chief place!

But at
1

Um

hi

so great
I

e dearth of resolute mod brave

consulars,
filled,

*
see

am

when

utterly careless, other

abide bv the cause Uiey have and regulating their opinions not always e of the State, but now by hope, and iiut if anyone is anxious to there should be no Boat foolishly if he with virtue by means of vice for, as speed wrtue is by speed, so in br by virtue. Will you, if my feelings towards are most loyal, in order to overcom<yowrself entertain feelings the most treasonable ? or, if yon see that good men nock to me, will you Not so should 1 wish it, to your aide the reprobate
ittoo to
;
.'

oral so? the soke ol the State, in Uic next place also But it leadership were at issue, a of your boouor r ought, what, pray, could I ha I

for b%

oil votes

cannot

l>c

overcome,
it, and Could it

by good perhaps I might be, and willingly. tins, remarks That the Roman people
ledges of
it

certain' persons are annoyed.

be that men should not judge of each man according to each man's deserts? For as of the Senate man people most truly judges that es a . period of the State has this order been more Irss or more courageous, so concerning each of us, and meet of all us who on this bench express our enquire, and long to hear what each ' opinion was, ml thus they think of each one
.g to their
1

view of his deserts.

mind

that

on the twentieth

of

They keep December 1

625

MABCUS TUIXJU8 OCBtO

TV. Ui#

ai

U tfU

PHILIPPIC XIV.

VII.

IO-VHI. 2,

was the chief instnimerr recovery of our HbevtT t that I since the Kalends of January l to this boar have watched over the State; that my noose and my eon have been open day and night to advice and warnings of all men; that by my and my encouragements, might be, have been it r by votes of the Kalends of January have envoys that 1 have always called so that I, who r, always this a war; been the adviser of genuine
.

hostile to this name of a pestilent Have not I too always regarded I'uhlius as an enemy when others wished for In in

lad the consul* been willing to allow t4 mine to go to a division, by the r weapons of all those

woo Id long

since have fallen from their

Hot what was then not allowed, Conscript at thss time not only allowed, but also that those who are enemies in fact _ be hiamlfrt in plain terms, and declared by Before now, when I had votes to be enemies. " war," not onot but and enemy and the tmns moved my proposals from the no pnmV. bat in the present case that cannot any
Is

be done ; for, according and Aulas

I

|
.

be

to the des|iatches of be consuls, and of propraetor, we are giving our qoesUon of honour being paid to tl><

<.l

Mr VSM
at

just

now proposal

Umsdufftvtnf

the

same

time

unconsciou K

6*7

m UlCUS

TULUUS

h JH^JrrUra

,|.i.;.. '.*..i,.i

iirf'.'....

ii

.*

t+* r

w Hull

r.
1

P.
1

MTtHC
il ii

MM
m

tie

bCM

Km

bell

Ml

ItW
totfflf

2
A

HRteMic
f fty*
fa fl? ft

l|

U AfU: tClCM

Wm

tf

M.A.

raiupp
rd thrm
;

in.

j,-

M
I

It

to be enemies for a thanksgiving has been decreed in civil war. Voiced do say ? has not been drmandrd even in a victor's
I

waged a

civil

war

when he had

legions into the dtj he expelled those be ehoae; those whom he could he slew; - no mention of a thanksgiving. A serious it followed ; no thanksgiving was to Cinna though be was victor. Sulla as avenged the victory of ( thanksSenate. 1 Did your 'abbas Servtlius, send yon yourself any the moat calamitous batth u to move for a thanksnulla? da! D4 Hut he sent rtainlv he did not with. Sea afterward about Alexandria, al but for the battle of Pharsalia fat tint battle had destroyed bold a triumph
i
I

who ought have

lived, and even conquered, ng the safety ami prosperity of the *me thing had happened in former For when *** consul the thanksto me, tbongh there had been no an was not on account of the slaughter of but on account of the preservation of and unprecedented proand
I

erase our you mutt either puW haoktgiving though they demand it for t successful cxploiu a thing that has or by decreeing to BO one but

<

to bsf you must necessarily declare those against whom you make your decree.

629

MAKUS
IX

TUIJJUS
el a*.

k*m H-wtl

U*?. rl

crw. qui

t.|ur

.trturur

Quld>

rri

!:

rr,

~:.<

fej

F4r--ftl>frnatl

TWi4
6jj

COM

mm
;

\iv

,. ,

4-a6
effect,
I
:

nat. therefore, Scrvilius

docs in

also

do by word*, when I call them " Inipera tors' ibis very name I adjudge as enemies both those who hare been already conquered and those who sun ben I call the victors Imperators. For by what name shoald I better rail Panm, although he has a nasne 1 of the fullest honour? by what Hirt He fta Indeed consul but the one name springs Iras the bmdncse of the Roma people, the < from bit valour and bis victory. Again, Caesar. 1 one by the favour of the Gods for the benefit of should I hesitate to call him Im|>crator?
i

first turned the savage and foul cruelty of Antonio* away, not only from our throats, lnt smi vitals. And of that one day great, ye immortal Gods, were si took the lead of all of heroism battle in cootltct with Antonius, a general worthy of the Martian legion, as the legion was If Pansa had been able to worthy of its general. check its most vehement onslaught the affair would bwsw been ended in a single battle.* But when the legion, greedy for liberty, had ini|ietuously burst tutu the enemy 's line, and Pansa himself was righting in the foremost ranks, after he bad received two wnds he was carried out of the battle,
!

bb
this

State.

truly regard

man, not only as an !mpcrator,but a most noble

Imprrator, who. having promised to satisfy the State estber by death or by victory, has achieved the one mav the immorta l Oods avert the omen of the

other
*

mm smmar la tbs firs* eattla of Matioa.

63'

Taa

tassMlswaity of

ma MartUaa

nougat Psasa's fores*

4r Hi/tk> qlr*

Mi

HuhUbui

It.

tofefTYt, <|Vft

MuUttt palfnfwftm tfNPCWSl

hfi |w f

i..".r? ..^r.lr

, 11 , ) v

lf

s;um!rn,H .,urlM
1

MK
iJmi pMcfc octo tectat.

AHM
ftb

ua toot, qoo mifiiM csaot

cUt*

UU

A*

tfcM**

of

6jt

miUPflC
X.

XIV.

x.

7 -a8

What

Kll I my of Hirtius? who when he of the afair led out two loj ml and valour; the Fourth, which had

tonius aod formerly

atUched iUelf to

Martian, and the S< omposed of the veterans, which showed by this l>attlc that the of the .Senate and of the Roman people was door to those soldiers who had preserved Caesar's fMll. 1 WMa these twenty cohorts, but with no cataln. IlirUoa, himself carrying the eagle of the Fourth legion no more glorious figure of any general
toe

MM
u

there In historycame t with the three ry of Antonius, and overthrew,

'arious

enemies that were

of Jupiter the Best and of the immortal of the city/ the liberty of the and oar lives and Uxlics, so that Ight, and very few companions, under the CO iiiihoouj by panic, the chief and leader of the brigand took to flight Oh. what supreme happiness that of the rery son, which, before its sett 111 the corpses of urderers were strewn on the (eld. saw in flight with few followers Antonius hesitate to call Caesar in hot, Imprrator ? I Its age assuredly will not deter soon from soch a vote, seeing that by valour he -ome age. And to me the services of Caius Caesar have always appeared the gr iter in proporreason of his age, less to be tion as t for, when we gave him tin- general's 1 wr at the sat? .nf< rr<! OH him I. urs which that name implied, and, as he has fulfilled them, he has by his own deeds

Hi

MARCUS TULUUS

CICftftO

Am

u,

ua a

614

mupMc
mm, one of the
t

\iv.

x.

ts-i,. 3 o

the Authority of our decree. So this young highest spirit, as Hirtius most t writes, protected uh a few cohorts a camp fonm il legions, and fought a successful battle,

UMfMMjJj
c

judgment, and good

generals of the

Roman

people

dav and

in several places, the State has

propose, therefore, in the name of those a pobhc thanksgiving of fifty days; 1 the in the most complimentary terms I can, I m the rote Itself. <> our good faith and if to declare to our most valiant soldiers how snftodful of them we are, and how grateful. Wherefore I propose that oar promises, including those *c have engaged r on the at tJr rluse of the war, should by to-day's * for it is fair that the decrrr be r especially such soldiers as these are, should rak in honour. And Vln it were to our power, Conscript Fathers, to pay their doe rewards to them all we will, howover, be careful to pay with usury those promises we have made Hut that is reserved, as I hope, for the Mftor, 1 to whom the pledged word of Use Senate ill be mode good ; and as they, at a most difficult v it* l.ivr adhered to t. it behoves us sjflsJi for But it gret their resolve. that they should It cosy to deal with those who even when they say no word seem to solicit us ; what is more admirable, and greater, and most incumbent on a wise Senate, si to accompany with grateful memory the valour of prodigal of their lives for their those that h
1
t
!

63s

M\IUl
II

II

11.11 H

ahrrvin

'

<t

j* |*'.r >*

pg0

rrddJU' V Ml l,4ri.

Uftft* e%t. t

rrddtUc *JUr
Uboribos ci

iPUOIi
tefmll
G 36

I'lllUITlc
sake
.11

XIV. . 31-im. 32
||

irred to

Would that more ideas in my mind Two things at

!

least

not pass

01
I

h especially oecur to

the one relating to valiant men. thr tthrr to

lasting glory of
th.

me, most

of the

warning and

griff of their relations.

t XII re my * Fathers, that to the soldiers of the Martian legion, and to those that, fighting bv their side, have fallen, there Aiaed a monument in the noblest possible shape. Great and marvellous are the services of this to the State. This legion was the first to

from the brigandage Alba; this came to Caesar's aid;

I

l>\

copying

the Fourth legion has won an equal The Fourth conquered with ic au o a of valour. lorn of a single man of the Martian some have O fortunate fallen In thr cry boor of victory. death, the debt to nature, best paid on behalf of country! yon I reffly regard as born for your cou n try ; your \rr\ name is from Mars, so that it seems the seme God begot this city tor the world, Might death is disgraceful and yon for this 1 so tictory glorious; for Mars himself is wont to claim out of the battle line the bravest as his own. Those impious wretches then whom you have 1 n amon* the shades below pay the penalty but vou who have poured out your **i hsst breath in v.ctonr have won the scats and abodes Brief u the Kfe glean us by Qatar*; af thr pleaa. hot the memory of life nobly resigned is everlasting. And If that memory had been no longer than this the greatest life of oar, who would be so mad as, by utmost height of I, to strive for the
this,
.

637

\i\iu

in

n |

*.-*

Otfft

PB1UPPIC
nd
glory
t

\iv.

nt, 32-11.1.

34

>

It

hu

been well then with you,

uj

bile yon
for

liveti

also

HMtan

roar virtue cannot be entombed, rt to the forgetfulocss of those who now are, or m the tHenre of pott. trbea, almost with their the Senate and the Roma have rearrd to too aitomiorUl moiuiinrt t. There have <llir, and lUlian wars many bNI to the
great, yet on none of these has of such a kind been bestowed. And would could bestow greater, since from you we have received what Is greatc turned from thr furious Antoniui you, while he was
;

most revered ;

striving to return, repelled hm fore be erected a mass of splendid

re shall

there-

workmanship and

uacripUoo cut, an everlasting witness to your divine valour; and to your praise, whether men shall heboid your monument or shall hear of it, Merer shall language of the deepest gratitude be Thus, to eschangc for life's mortal state, silent you will hae gained for yoursr H Conscript Fathers, the guerdon of fame Is being paid to cftisens most loyal and most brave by the honour of a monument, let us console ho*e best consolation is indeed Mich this: for parrr.t*, that they have hi sUunrh bulwark* of the State ; for children, that thrr families models of valour; that they have lost husbands whom they will more fitly praise than mourn ; for brothers, that

MM

they will trust to nod in themselves a resemblance And would that we to virtue as well as in body. could by our votes and resolutions wipe the tears (roes all their eyes, or that some such public orstion

639

.'.*.

.1

4
MVi

km

*-'i

ilk

ir
't

Itbrrtatcn

*p

/i.i*

wr w*

PHILIPPIC \!V
contd be
i

xiii.

34-xiv. 36

hlr eas tid to them as to make them lay aide their mourning and aorrow, and rejoice m' that, whereas manv various kinds of death im|>end over Men, 1 that which was the most glorious kind of all has been the fate of their kinsmen ; and that they are neither un buried nor abandoned and yet this too b deemed no piteous lot when net for the of the fatherland nor burnt *ith humble by srattered graves, but * with ad offerings, and beneath a pile that s the memory of ete rnity an altar of Store it ill Ik- the greatest consolao those near to thrm tint on the same rnonufa recorded the valour of their kindred, ami the of the Roman people, and the good faith of the Senate, and the memory of a most cruel war, fn which, bad not such valour of the soldiers been shown, by the ti r nann of Marcus Antonius the name

of the Rfinwi people would have perished And I also propose. Conscript Fathers, that the promised to give the soldiers when the e stabl is hed should be fully paid had el, now the time has come, to the vising victors; and when anv of them to whom those promises were made nave fallen in their propose the same rewards should bt given to their parents, children, wives snd
l

111

XIV. But that

I

may
"

at last

sum up

in a proposal,

"Whereas Caius Pansa, coi made a beginning of conflict and with the enemv by a battle in which the Martian with admirable and marvellous valour has the liberty of the Roman people, an

move

as follows: Imperator, has

641

It

II

II

-'

ttrtatr.

PHI

\IV.

xi*.

36-38

Cwkm Panaa

followed bv the legions of recruits ; and himself, consul and Impcrator, while "ffagcd amid the weapons of the enemy, has
red wounds; and whereas Aulus Hirtius,coiiMil I roper he heard of the battle and what liad happened, with the most couraand excellent spirit led his army out of the
1

and attacked Marcus Antonius and the army tmj, and made an utter slaughter of his
his iiii innv that be tmpiiti itj t urh not a single man and whereas Caius Caesar, peofwaetor and Impcrator, has by his skill and care iefended ht camp, and routed and slain the forces of the enemy that approached his camp on that account the Senate considers and declares that, by the valour, generalship, kill, firmness, steadfastness, greotaeaa of mind, and good fortune of those .tor*, the Roman people has been freed

lost

most disgraceful and cruel slavery. And they have preserved the St*t< the too HiQjpln of the immortal Gods, and the goods aad fortune* of all citizens, and their children, in f, their lives, the r, and at th< decrees that on account of those feats of and happily achieved, Caius ell, Impcrators, i\ llirtius, consuls and their absence Marcus <oe or both of th from
ih

was

Coroutut. the urUt) praetor, shall institute a public : daji it all tfw eoodici of the |fcaJtafrftaf

* And whereas the valour of the legions has proved worthy of their most noble generals, the Senate been will, with the greatest seal, now the State has republished, make good the promises heretofore

Go*

643

~,w.
IftW

WC IMAM yn i irt a IW MM bM MUmU

ft
i

ft*

ft

PHILIPPIC XIV.

x,y.

38

made to our legions and armies and whereas the Martian Region has been the foremost in eon
;

into conflict with tlir enemy, and ha* contended s<> sueeessfallv with superior nambers of tlie enemy as to slay many of them and to take some prisoners

and poured out their

have

without

any reluctance
},c

eomv

sake valour the soldkn of the remaining legions have, on behalf of toe safety and the liberty of the Roman people, met with drath that it is the pleasure of the Senate that Caiut Pansa and Aului Hirtios, consuls and Imperators, 000 or both of tli* then n honour of those that have shed their bsourl 00 behalf of tli ilerty, and fortunes of Roman people, 00 behalf of and the temple* of the immortal Gods, take steps for the letting out of a contract for the erection of monument of the moat noble kind and shall command the urban quaestor* to give, appropriate, and pay funds sor that work, that there may be extant, to the Use everlasting memory of posterity, a r Heavenerhne of or most rn. Inaprred valour of our soldiers and that the rewards e Senate has before appointed for the soldiers lr paid to the parent*, children, wives, and brothers >oae that have fallen in this war for the sake of - country and that the same rewards be given had they to them a* should have be* their victory, to thr snldfer* themselves who have
\

whe reas with

similar

645

imi irnctS

3 Or.
Or.

/'

Ol^rpUUlMnl S UtwIWC.fn. Afaf f IK.

\
# /

/*

*r!t^.um

iiutairu

rmtkdtmm dur*mi emprvprr,

u,

^ d mmkm
III
it

fmmt mttt mmmi

{SOmLBakmdV

/~
vW

#7/. iXi,p.gs;.Jmkm.)

J.

*W Up

)<*4 At King

Mil

HI

PASSAGES WHICH ARE QUOTED BY THE

GRAMMUtlW
but win*
1. ii

mil. 11

\i:i

mm
the

xi

wi

i\

Mama
!

Tullius in

Philippics,

Book IV:
tling

What

did this senatorial decree emus.

voorself sccrTtlv out

J9.)

1
S.

Marco Tolhen
n.

Bool

XIV:

hcutatc, not to

know where

to turn.

181

Ihe controversy has been Pkti deckled. That quarrel was not decided by wsr. nd.) (Am, Mesa. iimed aside from his l**\rrm\t% l did not turn aside even for a purpose. (Area. unirlc.tr, p. 225, L. Those whom we now commonly call muleteers, that Is to say, those that drive and control beasts of oked to vehicles, the ancients used, as you but they properly called , to call coachmen d on tote that, far their own pn o beaineas hi beasts of burden of this kind, although I'tulipptca Cicero had called \ cntidius a muleteer faff the reason that he had contracted with the Revenue to supply the beasts of bur nit com ry for an army. (Scholiast Bob. ad Or. pro 10. Vol III p. 286. 2, cd. Orelli.) Ventidius after f Caesar the dictator, as Tullius Ml lotto 1 nd in the I'hilippics, was, by Haloj the patronage of Antonius and Augustus, advanced to such a stage of eminence that the command of wot was entrusted to him. (SchoL on Juv. the vii. 199, p. 287, Jahn.)
,

Uc.

Mm.

647

;;

IXDKX
WMM, lit;
Wlttii. 7
1. 117;
doaaed by Ctav for return from Htriw,
,

it

bh.
ir.3;

U. Ml:
order. 7, reties by. ,
[?.'

afc

MS; Omw'i 1M; rota tbc

wfrl* noJRlloloo5et

eeeoafee. 13, let *? : alected from Dapa*,!! .mtrnm Verro'.tarm, 167

mjtKjItij aWoaayteftaotbre. If*"** jy ***l ajjea^aby, *

Mm

to

Room la battle array

afc

, 1

71

laflW Oca. Oaeaar

fatbarV

"jt
of lew*, ft;

aad

1. lav; aaaatorlal decree*,

1*7.11; obtelneCI. O.ol from the

ataoatiwila

for

bis

U; refneUU. Xing for bribe, 137: appoint*

aTniafal
all**,

oe*.
|

til:,

km ,fct_Qrl
4,

111
tiaaar

lurj.

1.
to

' r

.>
ii

U>:,
fill |

lit.

fa t ttt.

! * m
n

atiaaytlaaa, as. lift, *7 : recaB bat oailtebl* tudr, 11. 161 boa ba alio exclude frost the Illegal proIrate, Oat; to Senate oo let Jane, 171; " ico Oeeemr' people, 171; not
I

**
at

17

CI
J

o* 1Kb Septula, Si ;M

Kmn

ilium

In (>,t..l*.\

in

< a y, 17.

to in oror

649

von

SSL'S:

'j* .

t.

*-~u

''

1*1

650

; ,

INDKX
3;

C*em

j l ii.m U^^Hi.M.U^U *.% if tmmd a m

i
i

lliil

il lj

enemy of ell traitor*, W; a low of t. 101, , 73 Ombar. T. AnnJua, a fratricide, 473

7 J; pan on name of. 4 79 China, L. Cornellaa, tyranny of, comMfndwtththatof A..171; kepi no bod j fuard. 371: cootroTeny of, iih Octaem* on right* of new 171. M7; compered with Mart end Vmla,*47; and with A.

Ci

gt njhptOa.iHl; Mennpfimrio
I'

th* tritur.r. murl.T

of,

ujnted by O,
nof,S7;

M; Odm'
re-

riota at funeral of

test, the rhetorician, efraatoflaai

IWti..

vm
.

-a n.-^-ifrOj-m, Willi
diilii
.1. torHonily
.

to

w^^-, ot rwwH, Oat. i to I HI li Ddii.ll. I 4*

^^ Own M

CWord. Temple

with repard ptabablT prim i a. A.* DfMNiin level Mtrfocr. 16t of, Second Philippic purport* to nave bore oVUTcmi In, 7; efn^de* by A- with armed men, t 7
lotto I

Um tribune'e brother, ate by A.. S3; A.t

rottte,L.Yerm*,epertfeanendNrrnt
of A.,

U
to

* Ffj|l

A. onthetnd
.

jiltll
ii

It;

OfU, exempted by

Ml: A.' brutal treatment of, 3I7.&77. nfOTof A.,391 A. from tribute,

1M
run Um.
pomr-ril.

r^

murdered

It.

7* mi InnospJckma meet ptac*forthedUoTal.3l t7; CtorJo, O. a toneomte of

iafamou relation ith. 109, lit; dMrt the cau> of the Senate

Cidea of
Cylherto.

HritelaCQMMr. n CMi, one of A.'i

A/,
companion
by
A., 133;

raecally

In

hie

"divorced

formerly i of P. Vouunnlo* KutrepaJna, US. 4

tin

nrni IMttVthe
471
;

DeHo Moe, K, davota.

nibbling D., 577 himself a* a

for

hU defendant a rktim

at Vta,

M
i;
tt.

.brtb.

"S^SSiST^ IM; kortiUljotOMnr

IM;

mamn

kb kbgdom

bjr

65

A
I

si.

Z7VS^lHjT^S

SHiV^S' Sfc
wit

<S1.

M,tn
. 1

llB I

I . Hll

lfA.

ffc J

JL

Hi

lil

l^J

ai..*<Hr*-t^*t.

:. C.**

i*-

.ur^^

i.ifki^rifi,
*.
'

-0*-,.*

iii ti T
i

B in O^ttt

.in:
a

It.

652

INDIA

W. M7.

%."

mm mMW *
4m
nftat of.

Mt by AW*l A- U rmka

UM-ohU4

w.

ttl. 14; Um>

i

Mtj
L.

bftUlo of , 0; of
of, 7. 1243;

.*;*, 141. 27

tUw! 'sr^
of,

"" FOjomm
a
*.

* riMsfWfWi
I?

a Mfto M. Bratw In,

of

fMk

fnflnwir

r*15*y ^: 2?^ i-^LT

ft;

top T*.

m.
41

A. ad A
Ml lit
of.

bMm
*W
of

Ha A.,

gHart, by
0ftiraratlfr

ff.
. rt l
,

'-Hl.l

ex. 41m ft*

if.

J(#Liii 111 n

Iff;

Oof

rif ,o7.iT>Vi.... *

IWr3op*d *
r^AT.
13.

f O oif HnWf w M and

j

of.l44

0.

.. ,, of, II,

bir

429. Un.l.ir

Hah.
;

of 13.

ilnowid by litou,

ifrirf.

cUIm

rvoM 41t hWijJm

of.

imiii

Ommmt*
ktafty

Updo, aod'bw ooot

UtW
pfopraotor,
10,

bo*, 14, 4t7;

JO,

of troop., 18,

Mb mm mmbTommbmm. M,

4lMMM4ftT. mb

MkMt

*U;

611;

mjm, u. in; "llMMMV-M>MMU^bytM.U

mm

wStrior of iWfcote, IN, 117, 117;

fag*** gfr

Wj **

*.,*>*/

xt-

OOjIoTTOd OO, 101

653

*4 tr> te

**k Ml

.....

SETS: cA*n*.

I J:

w^itaLm. m*mimJ

i^ Mat +m,jfc
M hlW

^_

<
S4

b W. Mi-

IM>EX
of.

417;

ud UtCM,

q.4;

of,

411

of.
to

it

7,

*.

lit;

<Vpuaon.
71;
of doer, 33

flSltov.ftt;
tt; 4*7

fc-4 ootioc

WJWMSdb in lilt,

MWrf.^n.

1.141

M^r-l .111

l7ihMMrk.||

111;

boMtby

A.'.

.*
ImUflld
of A.. 71. S7S, ttt.

nb lh M^w
t

r. it*

^mMam or afaMfM.lM

j^j^j

||

444*
;

of A.. 17$. 447 too

now ood by
of

poUoa

isd, o~*~d
Am.
oPMt
ot

by Omom tho oroofA*M,1.4$l; Of of bk

ThMtw-

Mat

tl. tt. 4$; drawa A. of tb# mufdM. tt.

mordor

of.

br

TToMlnlM, 4$7-44$: CV. oology of. tU: a. rrfoW u deoib of, $49 voto of. 7; Tto by A.

of

M. 117; ret by TOU oa rmbMoy to A., low m to droM

L,1H
1...

by
QoJho,

HMThM. Mi CUlt7.

lotto Of

id

a
In

of.

M. M7;
n

OB

hHt

1st Jin.. 254.

:.
of, o. Jarirt.

117.

411

655

SOU

THE LOEB CLASSICAL

LIBRARY
VOLl'MF-S

ALREADY

PI

HLISHED

Latin Authors

HI VW Imp Vol IN. tmj Imp. rwM) O ne Am (Mbtamobtbosbb). W. Ml(MMk R*B*d by & OmIm a* Imps miui Orr or Ooo. 7 Vote. Vol. I.
(Too*
t

i bjr J. C. Rolf*.

3 Volt
Adling.

o.

E.

W. Wot*
U.

(1931V

1 Vol*.

'I

EtWyb WM.

Bute,

(tmdlmp.)

IVohv

(ftW / mp .i

B.KBB*
!.

iVoU

(tmdlmp.)

**d D COBBOLAT* ITtOMB PBIIIBBtf lil (bb% /p.) rt rfLK. Rood. f. ft It** a oat*. AriK Bod 8r*wt*B Wam, A. O.

**
I

^nWm

r.

A
H

O. PMkott.
J.

(A /mm

s is

Edvorda,

K* Kcbt*ca i

ViMo

(10* Imp.)
H. B. Ash

I Kb Robttca.

ft*

/ r^^w.
B*.
)t

Cttrmmh; TtBtrtAC*. J. B. Pootfatoi Pbb(ISA Imp.) /p.) J. W. Mookait. W. O. Spoaoor. 3 Vol* (Vol. L >*. Voi* II. ad III. fnd Imp.) ad Obatob. O. L. HondfioBBOO mnd H. M.

W.

AoHnnvm.
II.

fftd

Imp)

H. Gaptaa,
1)8

l>OU I UO-OBOM ;
(Willi

I'ABTmONB

fW*H*m
II.

D*

Orotorr

/BB)
,

Da

U f iiuo a, ota.
ma.

KanaOB.

IUrkh*m

(4* /mp. rw iiKi. )

H.

HL M. Hobbatt. %a 1>bobc Bad Acadbmica.

Ronkham.

Imp.)
.

biOmrm

Wahor

S Vol*

(7* Imp.) MiHor. E. W. Saturn Bod H. Rook.

boBB>

(ft* fnt I>b RarvBueA oad Db Laotacs; Somrnnt Scrnoww. W. K*r~ nA/mp.) T t T B. DS AmCTTtA. Db DlTWATIOWB.

BAM. P0 FlaOOO. P0 MUBBW A. POO 80IXA.

(ft*

Imp

.V-.

limn
fl

u v

TL
\.**

ft* /*. VI. % 111. su

Mi .-

iA /-*.
It

JUL >W |. #

On
(4* /
,

'-*>
J

CMJtapi)
.'

Vol,.

(6m Imp. (Vol I. 11A

(>rf /Mp.)

/-p. Vol
Ooit
i

Twm mirnm.) ond Kx hwm

II

A. L. Whooter.

hrnmum
M.

Mm.
lit

H. D.

Rmh

HimHIoo,

8ica
!

AroooLocnrroas.

IBM Imp. wmimd.)

om

//>.. II. 5th /mp..

u* /-

^H.
fftOfloili

Lottvoo. McJm..ir. Trn-tetioo r*vid by W. M. .noon .i|A 1 Vote II lUckhom ond W. H. 8. Jooeo. HnWOftl. Vu Vote I Rnrkhora. Vote. VI. and Joml (Vote I III 3rd /Mp.. Vol. IV. tnd H.

W) L

&

H.

E.

Bolter.

(7* /mo.)
J Vote. tVote. (Vote.I.ondIV.4A/wp..

W)
t
/

UKturo.)
T

Wormingtoo, VoL II. d.f

A lu M Uc ririoW.)
I

4 rote.

VoL

I.

vius.

rd

Law or
mrTION*.

XII

Vd

IV

timUtmp)
II

>

im

ft* / .r.^i. Vote.

1111 tnd Imp.) Arocouacrmm*. Cf. P*roinc*.

M p. iimii Aoopt
Mooaum
II

"..
R.

IVote

Vol.

I.

Kmnui
\

Fob
HooAt Emu.
ate
I

ond

III.

M. Oummoro, fmdlmp.)
Vote.
rovteoi.)

I
(V<

Vote.

ond

III.

tnd /Mp.

f. J. Milter.

S Vote

(Vol

I.

41* Imp..

Vol

II.

>d

/-p, nrinf)
D. Do*.

W.

B. Anderooa.
(Vol.
I.

* Vote

Sv?**J.
~* /-p
>

1 Vote

2nd /wp..

torn* Smb*
4Mb

J.

t Vote, (td Imp.) -'A /p.. Vol. 1 Vote. J. c. Roite.

Mooter,
)
<

II.

U Mr Wo. rr- . <WA Imp QmmUKtA. >Uir> Hwttnn H. Moore ond J. JockC. Awo.lo. * HwTOOton : Tncm (Vote, L ond LL 4* /Mp.. Vote III. ood IV. 4 Vote.
T.
Po ooon.
I
<

/#.

ijuinl Di * too co.

AOBtCOLO and

\mT

T^irrir'johoftefi^iont.

S Vote

(1A Imp.)

TnrrruUAH
N...M,

Arof
0. H. Rondoll J. H. Mooter.
(2nd /mp.)

R- 0OYor.

Morrrrro Fw*. Til oOM I > rtocrvs.

DBLoMOoLomio.

R.O.

(3rd Imp. reoteed.) Kooi 2 Vol. <2*l

Imp

**.

r run,

'Li

I** J-

.V4

Ml
4.

/*, TL
H.

M O. Mm Arnr
Tfc

%*

Afvua

sVatealsV

nmm
fWmrm ilium.
or
t \ te
i

Mn
II

I'

Unkind.
Robert*.
..

A. I* rVc* { Mono* avd Fonts* Uk Imp, rswW.)

MllVUL W

lUya

(3M /. rvruwi.)

W.MMt
L

ll*..

41A / *,

rrW.

iVok

I AlSA*t>ai M

(fed /mbl rstesoi.) (with I'dOILUO.

Aunirnu sad
Vcm

M a
l

Ikdsta.

K*v. K. Ibffe
-''wi

#i

/*>.)
I

Vote.

laj.

H
il

Vok ACTryptuus. )umm FfSynss. y

*fa*r%n.
i
i

(2nd imp.)

aad

aad

I.y

Vtuvwort*. (Vd/mp.)

OHM*

4|
1

II
i

rwiaod
I

by

riMBWilll

(A /mp.) a. OsssUs. iiurrtc* atd Mi*oa Oma/mp.|

.

uW

si;
Hainsiassa
til

<>aoa* ad Da Falsa llrd/s* rrw Minus, Axoatmo*. Asj' .

%**.

AlVWW.Vo;
|

I T

<ta*Tlo

vCRAM
l.Sodfaip.)
1

utu
Ill
*

*r*n.

Km KMr. "TT
-.

W Vols.

(Vols.

II

Vtf/wp.l**

-IX lad/.)
II.

ism sad
Vote. Vote.

L*msx Crosby.

6 Vote

WlUWlaWt^**?!
Vat
Vai
%
I

MOBl
II.

TatX

mm

Vols,

I.

IX sod X. nd7-.Pi

KM.
I.

Oldlatbor. Uoar.

/*#.

v-

_ or
Mis

tei

mm m N
A. CMdfettew.
J

Row*
Vote
\
\
i

ml
3rd /s*p..

8pol-

<Voi
.

I.

II.
II.

Ud

oWN /p.

A I...

Tate. Ill

mtf

JL

&

sad I V. ft* :s:.*ti : J Vote A. Ooteom.

WM

V-ic

TiA.-p.Vol
hin*pp

Imp

Il:r-

\m irons.
Loks

M
ai>
I

iVaL

I.

>d

/-p..

VoL

II.

fts

It

**

tit

Ml

/f.

Vl IY

w/-,
%

fV-4.

/.

it

a
W.

ttlLT

M.&

Wu

**

II

IV

M /-

TTIH 111!

4 **

.V-A

**

In**

v*

M#mi
.

r-rtt

Yi v.

m /I, riTi*
t
to.

n.
I

/f.

WUMf w
til
\

<* WfM>i>
1*4
.

M
VU
IY
i

Y*

^ M
II
I

vtt

**/,.
t

/*.
i

Vft

mIY.N'fVt
i.

->l

I'./r.rr..

f^-y ^
.

v,

t* f*
r.

a W.4M hWMI

IfeflAMMML

&

Oka. Cocxt-mt *. Titwiooow%

Iter,
t **. (Yet
I.

A.
>

W.

Mar.

(ft*

M iW

Lmnot flsucm
by

to.

J
I.

m4U[m/^, to.lU if. ad

!!

VL

irwiH

K k
V

Wyilnrtt/.
/-

10 Vote.

ood VI.
l*ii..

Vote. Vo*.. \ #.. Vol IV. 4<A

I

Imq and Rev. O. H.

Coteon. Imp^ Volj

(Vol11 VII
.

IX. 2nd

wugiteowioij Vote.

Ttmmt laHun

only

Ralph
P.

T Lira or Armixoorca of Tyawa.

S Vote.
(Vol.
I.

4IA
:

Imp.)

lAot*B.

CaixorrBAroo

Dcocftirrtoiia.

!**.r,..

.*^i /a.)

tad

KcwArtr

NT Cove Wn|ht (2nd Imp. L *# J. K.loodya (I* /. *

l

Um

or raa

Soraim.

OunH.
'uriu.
N

AinAi>. Hirrraacsca, Tar Loraaa,

M.

Umb.

(2nd

PlATo

r*Ktfnrto*.
4<A

Htrrtft*

nun

II

foU.

OmaATaa Imp
)

HirriA.

Lm

rro,

PaAaoo. Pbabdbcb.

fear*

Laoa Faotaoooao. Maw twin mm

W.R.M.
(5<*

Lm.

O. Bury.

1 Vote

(3rd /*p.)

tmroosva. Uomiu.
Paul borey.
S

W.

R, M. Lamb.

PwJTot RcrrMJo. Voi II 4* /*)

Vok. <VoL

44

Jmp*
R. M.

^BrAVV. Paitaaca.
..

II.N.Pmrlrr; lo.

W.

EtmmaolSonttT. H. M. Fowlor. (** Imp.) BrtrroLAB. Cutua Cirrorao. M VW /aeo.) lUr. R a iw.rv C. Bo) Vote. I.-V. F. Pimar*? MotAUA U Vote.

imm
(Vote.

>

Voi VI. W. C. HalwhoU M .lnoo.oodW.C. H#*mboW. XII

Sad
/
r |
.

I. -VI.

end X.

r.nutt
.

Ltvaa.

Prrnn.

||

VII

an.1

XI

3*1 Imp.

Vote. Vote. III.-V. and

II

"

W. rvTuoa.
Vol.
,

Vote,

Hnrroav or too
.

Waml

^4 Imp.

loovmooVV
TooVIII. >W
>

Vcre* tran*. (3rd Imp.) A- . Rev. R. G. Bury. 4 Vote. (Vol. I. 4<A ^1 Imp.) Vol. II. <WA (Vol. I. I0<A Imp. J Vote. 9eorr.

(Ind/ip.) H. B. Dewing. :milmp.) NUXBTBO.

omTSo OoMtiriT.

Horoeo

/e>p.. Vote. II.. III..

CBAOArrooe. TooorooArnro , A I> Kno,. (3rd /".p .)

f

(Vote. I L. Jooeo. 8 Vote. IV VI.. end VII. 2nd /mp.) Hkbodb. nd Bd o, o J. M.

tVtk

SmUImn

IS

t'KI

f\M\f ION-

GrM*
A,

IS**.

"%

I/'/'//*

iMfM

.:

...