Epoxy

Resin vs Vinylester vs Polyester

Use and Application Overview

Overview
This White Paper explores the differences between Epoxy Resins, Vinylester and Polyester, including
their chemical underpinnings, performance, and cost, and provides a view on CRD Epoxy
components.
Composites are virtually corrosion free and provide virtually maintenance free use, whilst providing
good value and being extremely sustainable.1 Resins are used often instead of their metal
counterparts due to the corrosive susceptibility of metals, which is estimated to cost the US industry
alone around $276 billion a year. Resins can be used to successfully replace many exotic alloys and
metals while providing superior performance and zero corrosion.
This paper is a comparison of each of the resins available, but there will be considerably more focus
on the use of Epoxy resin compared with Vinylester, as Polyester is not suitable for the more
strenuous uses that Vinylester and Epoxy resins are more specifically designed to endure.1 However,
a brief overview of Polyester and its use and applications will also be provided.


Polyester
Polyester is often used for pipes, tanks and high performance components in the marine and
automotive industries. Although it is the most commonly used resin due to the ease of manufacture
which matches that of Vinylester resin, it is very cheap, but with limited structural properties it is not
suitable for use when high structural properties are required, or when use is required in extreme
temperature conditions.2 Due to the unsaturated nature (lots of double bonds, specifically ester
groups) of this composite the tensile strength of it is greatly reduced when compared with Vinylester
or Epoxy resins.3 Polyester also bonds with water throughout its lifetime, gaining weight within the
first few days from manufacture, which is from absorption of water reacting with the double bonds
on the backbone chain structure of the resin, and then losing weight slowly as the polymer is broken
down, leached out of the composite, which is in turn replaced with water. This decreases the
strength of the material.4 Even with Polyester resin reacting to water in this way, for non-structural
work such as coating a boat hull, many marinas use Polyester instead of Vinylester resins due to the
cheap cost and a faster curing time leading to quick turnover makes Polyester much more
favourable.5
Vinylester
Vinylester resins are designed much more specifically than Polyester resins as they are a hybrid form
of Polyester resin that has been strengthened by the addition of Epoxy resin.6 With much more
aggressive chemical environments in mind for the design, they are especially useful when used in an
organic solvent environment.1 They have a higher resistance to greater vibrational loads because
they are more tolerant of stretching than Polyester resins, showing less stress cracking and are

CRD House, 2 Whitemill Crescent, Discovery Park, Ramsgate Road, Sandwich, Kent, CT13 9FH, UK
T: +44 1304 897653 E: [email protected]
www.compresdev.co.uk
Composite Resin Developments
July 2014




therefore able to absorb larger impacts without damage.7 Vinylester resins bond in a similar way to
Polyester resins with cross-linking of side groups along a backbone structure. Although Vinylester
resins are less absorbent of water than Polyester resins due to a more tightly bonded structure of
the side groups which provides fewer areas of access for the water molecules to attack the
backbone and solubilize the side chains, they do still have a degree of water absorption which
weakens the structure.6 This cross-linking of side chains is the reason that Vinylester resins have
outstanding thermal stability.1

Vinylester is not easily bonded to other structures which are dissimilar to itself (such as Kevlar or
carbon fibre), or to Vinylester resin that has already cured (maturing of the material by the
application of heat to encourage further cross-linking of side chains) which can make repair work
difficult, as delamination of the repair resin can occur, although adequate preparation of the repair
site can exhibit reasonable adhesion of the resin.6 Vinylester is extremely durable when compared
with Polyester, and in the marine industry is used on high quality yachts and similar boats instead of
Polyester to ensure that a professional and long-lasting laminate is used, also being used as a final
coating over Polyester to prevent blistering of the Polyester due to osmosis.6, 8
Both Polyester and Vinylester resins require thinning by the addition of styrene, which is a chemical
that emits fumes of a harmful nature (volatile organic compounds - VOCs). These fumes are the
reason that hand lay-up Polyester is banned in many parts of the US, and they also contribute to
global warming which has lead to production facilities in advanced countries that use large volumes
of VOCs having to ensure that emission control systems are in place.3,9
Epoxy
Epoxy resins have generally superior qualities compared with those of Polyester and Vinylester
resins, which are due to the basic structural properties of this resin. The basic backbone structure is
still present, however within this backbone the Epoxy resin contains aromatic groups (ring structures
in this case 6 carbons, also known as benzene rings) making it approximately three times stronger
than Vinylester resin and therefore incredibly thermo stable and able to better absorb much larger
impacts than either Vinylester or Polyester resins without damage.1 The side groups off of the chain
are also much more sheltered from attack from molecules such as water due to the steric
hindrance provided by the benzene rings, which ensure the structure maintains its high amount of
cross-linking, further ensuring its impact resistance and thermostability.1,11 Epoxy resins also have
high resistance to environmental degradation and do not blister like Polyester and Vinylester
resins when exposed to water. With this and the other qualities in mind, they are being used almost
exclusively for aircraft components.1

CRD Epoxy Resin Components
Among the many reasons why CRD Epoxy resins out-perform Vinylester and Polyester resins is its
increased impermeability to water, and the bonding qualities it possess. The ability to adhere to
Aramid (Kevlar), Carbon fibre and fiberglass, in addition to bonding to most materials very well

CRD House, 2 Whitemill Crescent, Discovery Park, Ramsgate Road, Sandwich, Kent, CT13 9FH, UK
T: +44 1304 897653 E: [email protected]
www.compresdev.co.uk
Composite Resin Developments
July 2014




(allowing the use of it for repair work to be undertaken easily), CRD Epoxy resin is often the first
choice for many situations as it forms a virtually leak-proof barrier and is extremely durable.12 CRD
Epoxy resins also do not change weight throughout its lifetime, even in post cure. This is because no
styrene is used to form CRD Epoxy resin components which means that no solvent evaporates from
the formed resin.9 Instead, an amine is used as a hardener which acts more as a catalyst of the
bonding and linking of the side groups of the molecules and when mixed in the correct ratios, means
that a complete reaction takes place.10

Conclusion
Effectively, all resins are virtually non-corrosive when compared with their metal counterparts, and
are an ideal substitute where corrosion or performance under high stress is needed. Polyester is
suitable for work where no structural properties are desired due to being cheap and having a quick
cure time, allowing high turnover for businesses such as marinas repairing boat hulls. Vinylester
resins are a hybrid of Polyester and Epoxy resins, meaning that they are suitable for the majority of
structural applications, and especially in aggressive chemical conditions, but are still slightly
permeable to water and are not particularly suitable for repairs or layering as they bond poorly to
dissimilar structures, or even themselves if the surface is not carefully prepared. Vinylesters are
more expensive than Polyesters.
CRD Epoxy resins are much more suited to extremely strenuous tasks such as enduring vibrational
loads, are more water resistant and environmentally stable than either Vinylester or Polyester
resins, whilst providing higher tensile strength and thermal stability. They form a much more
complex structure than the other resins, without the use of styrene making it more environmentally
friendly and safer to manufacture. They bond very well to almost any material and do not lose their
structural properties with time.
Emma Bennett-Huntley (BSc Chemistry)

CRD House, 2 Whitemill Crescent, Discovery Park, Ramsgate Road, Sandwich, Kent, CT13 9FH, UK
T: +44 1304 897653 E: [email protected]
www.compresdev.co.uk
Composite Resin Developments
July 2014

http://www.compositesworld.com/articles/vinyl-esters-make-tough-parts-for-highly-corrosive-applications
http://www.ncsresins.com/unsaturated-polyester-resin
3
http://www.scribd.com/doc/135402772/Epoxy-VinylEster
4
http://www.multihulldesigns.com/pdf/Why%20Epoxy%20is%20Preferable%20to%20Vinylester%20and%20both%20are%
20Preferable%20to%20Polyester.htm
5
http://www.netcomposites.com/guide/polyester-resins/8
2

http://ncspldc.org/ncspldc/topics/epoxy_resin.htm
7
http://composite.about.com/od/Resins/a/Vinyl-Ester-Vs-Polyester-Resins.htm
8
http://www.netcomposites.com/guide/vinylester-resins/9
9
http://composite.about.com/od/professionalresources/a/Vocs-In-Composites.htm
10
http://www.netcomposites.com/guide/epoxy-resins/10
11
http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Organic_Chemistry/Hydrocarbons/Aromatics/Properties_of_Aromatics/Aromaticity/Aroma
ticity/Benzene_and_Other_Aromatic_Compounds
12
http://www.amtcomposites.co.za/sites/default/files/media/howto/Advantages%20of%20Epoxy%20over%20Polyester.pd
f

CRD House, 2 Whitemill Crescent, Discovery Park, Ramsgate Road, Sandwich, Kent, CT13 9FH, UK
T: +44 1304 897653 E: [email protected]
www.compresdev.co.uk
Composite Resin Developments
July 2014