From:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Date:
Attachments:
Tara Kowalczyk
[email protected]; [email protected]
Misty Mirpuri
Appeal of FOIA request seeking FOIA request for CIT/OneWest"s 4/14/15 submission -ZFRSSETuesday, June 09, 2015 8:36:02 AM
Not Responsive - Underlying
20150414 Other Applications Document - Confidential.pdf
Documents
INTERNAL FR
Dear Camille and Stephen,
Misty Mirpuri and I are attorneys in the Boards Legal Division working to respond to an appeal of a
FOIA request from Matthew Lee seeking the exhibits that CIT/OneWest have claimed are
confidential and that the Federal Reserve has withheld from Inner City Press as part of its April 14
submission sent to ICP and others.
You had previously been in touch with Amory Goldberg about the Board's initial response to this
request. As you may recall, Ms. Goldberg contacted you seeking justifications for certain redactions
to Exhibits B (Details Regarding Planned OneWest Branch Relocations) and D (Pro Forma and
Related Information) of the 4/14/15 submission. The Boards response to Mr. Lees FOIA request
withheld Exhibits A (OneWest Bank Branch Opening, Closing, Consolidation, or Relocation Policy)
and C (CIT Bank Internet Deposit Data by County) in their entirety. We are contacting you to
determine if any portions of exhibits A and C could be released to the requester on appeal. With
respect to Exhibit C, Mr. Lee asks in his appeal how the release of the column listing the counties
and states in which CIT has bank internet deposits (while redacting the two other columns in that
chart) would cause substantial competitive harm to CIT.
If CIT continues to seek confidential treatment for Exhibits A and C of the attached 4/14/15
submission, on or before June 23, 2015, please provide a statement verifying:
(1) that any information for which confidential treatment is sought has not been made
publicly available (e.g., that it has not been made publicly available in a press release,
SEC filing, or other public filing); and
(2) the FOIA exemption(s) or other legal justification to support your request for
confidential treatment and a statement with detailed facts and arguments to support
such a determination. Under the Board's Rules Regarding Availability of Information
(Boards Rules), a conclusory statement that the information would result in
competitive harm is not sufficient. 12 CFR 261.15(b); see also 12 CFR 261.16(b)(1) and
(e).
The Board retains the right to make its own determination with regard to any claim of
confidentiality. Pursuant to the Boards Rules, notice of the decision by the Board to deny a claim of
confidential treatment, in whole or in part, and an opportunity to respond shall be provided to the
submitter claiming confidentiality of information no less than five days prior to its public disclosure,
12 CFR 261.16(c)(4), and where appropriate, the Board shall delay disclosure for ten working days
from the date of the determination. 12 CFR 261.16(f). Please be advised that even if a portion of a
document contains information that is exempt from disclosure, the FOIA requires federal agencies
to segregate and release the non-exempt portions of the document.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me by telephone at (202) 452-3477 or at
this e-mail address. Alternatively, Misty Mirpuri may be reached at the email address above or at
(202) 452-2597. I greatly appreciate your time and kind attention to this matter.
Many thanks,
Tara E. Kowalczyk
Administrative Law Attorney
Legal Division
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
20th St. & Constitution Ave., NW
Washington, DC 20551
(202) 452-3477 (Office)
(b)(6)
(Blackberry)
(202) 452-3863 (Fax)
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Date:
Attachments:
Salley, Stephen M.
Tara Kowalczyk; Misty Mirpuri
Orme, Camille L.
FOIA Appeal re: CIT-OneWest April 14, 2015 Submission
Tuesday, June 23, 2015 5:07:22 PM
SC1-#3889938-v1-FOIA_Response_Apr_14th_Submission.PDF
Tara and Misty,
Further to your email of June 9th, please see the attached letter.
Best regards,
Stephen
Stephen M. Salley
Sullivan & Cromwell LLP
125 Broad Street
New York, New York 10004
Tel: 212-558-4998
Fax: 212-291-9192
[email protected]
This e-mail is sent by a law firm and contains information that may be privileged and
confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete the e-mail and notify us
immediately.
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Date:
'
"QQFBM
3FDFJWFE
Matthew R. Lee
Office-of-the-Secretary; FOIA Appeals
Matthew Lee [at] innercitypress.org; Matthew R. Lee [at] FairFinanceWatch.org
FOIA Appeal of FRB Denials of May 5, 2015 to ICP"s April 15, 2015 FOIA Request re the Application of CIT"
Group to acquire OneWest
Saturday, May 09, 2015 3:19:44 PM
May 9, 2015
By email to Office-of-the-Secretary [at] frb.gov and FOIA-Appeals [at] frb.gov
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Attn: Secretary Robert deV. Frierson and FRB Governor in charge of FOIA Appeal
20th Street and Constitution Avenue, N.W.
Washington, DC 20551
Re: FOIA Appeal of FRB Denials of May 5, 2015 to ICP's April 15, 2015 FOIA Request re
the Application of CIT' Group to acquire OneWest
Dear Governor in charge of FOIA Appeals:
On behalf of Inner City Press / Fair Finance Watch (ICP), this is a timely appeal under the
Freedom of Information Act of the Federal Reserve Board's (the FRB's) May 5, 2015
Denials of ICP's April 15, 2015 FOIA Request regarding the Application of CIT' Group to
acquire OneWest.
Inner City Press immediately requested the withheld portions of CIT's and OneWest's
submission of April 14, 2015. Now the Fed has ruled that it can withhold IN FULL
Confidential Exhibit C, CIT Bank Internet Deposit Data By County. Overall, how can CRA
be enforced if such basic information is withheld? As a matter of FOIA, it is illegitimate to
withhold in full, including for example the names of the counties - how would the disclosure
of the names of these countries, most or all of which are publicly known, cause substantial
competitive harm?
ICP is appealing all withholdings, including the unexplained redaction of the address of one of
the branches OneWest would shutter, and the branch closing policy.
Please immediately send all requested information and responses by e-mail to
[email protected] and [email protected], and/or by hard copy by FedEx to:
Matthew R. Lee, Esq.
Fair Finance Watch
c/o 747 Third Ave (hold at location Fed Ex), NY NY 10017 USA
Or regular mail: Matthew R. Lee Esq, PO Box 20047, NYC NY 10017
If you have any questions, please immediately telephone the undersigned, at (718) 716-3540.
Very Truly Yours,
Matthew Lee, Esq.
Executive Director
Inner City Press/Fair Finance Watch
Internal FR
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Office of the Secretary
Freedom of Information Assignment
Request No:
F-2015-00196
Action Type:
Request Type:
Formal
Initial
Request Category:
Requester:
Received Date:
Complex
Lee, Matthew
05/11/2015
Please return this completed form, attaching all responsive documents, to the FOI Section by 06/05/2015.
If responsive documents are available electronically, please email to [email protected] by 6/05/2015.
The Law Requires the Board to Respond to this Request by: 06/05/2015
NOTE: This information is used in the preparation of invoices and for the Annual Report to Congress. Questions may be directed to Denise Harris.
Each division handling any part of this request should report on this form all time it spends on the request in quarter hours by grade level:
1. Search Hours -- Time spent looking for material responsive to the request including line-byline identification of material within documents.
2. Review Hours -- Time spent determining if material is exempt from disclosure
3. Nonbillable Hours -- All other time spent on the request.
-- ASSIGNMENT -Division
Person Assigned
Legal
Grade
FR-31-36
FR 21-22
FR 23-26
FR 27+
Computer
C
Co
mpute
tr
Time Report
Billable Hours
Search
Review
Nonbillable
Hours
DESCRIPTION
all of the exhibits that CIT / OneWest have claimed are confidential and that the Federal Reserve has withheld from Inner City Press as part of its April 14
submission sent to ICP and others.
NOTES
RECOMMENDED DISPOSITION
NO responsive records
Confirmed w/FR Bank (see Note:)
Records not reasonably identified
Deny in full
Grant request in full
Deny in part
Signed:
EXEMPTIONS:
Date:
FR 1415
Page 1
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Date:
Attachments:
Denise Harris on behalf of FOI Requests
[email protected][email protected]Freedom of Information Act Request No. F-2015-00196
Friday, July 31, 2015 12:29:00 PM
2015-0196 - Lee.pdf
Dear Mr. Lee,
Attached is a copy of the response to your e-mail message dated May 9, 2015, and receive by the
Boards Freedom of Information Office on May 11.
Thank you,
Freedom of Information Office
Federal Reserve Board
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Date:
'
"QQFBM
3FDFJWFE
Matthew R. Lee
Office-of-the-Secretary; FOIA Appeals
Matthew Lee [at] innercitypress.org; Matthew R. Lee [at] FairFinanceWatch.org
FOIA Appeal of FRB Denials of May 5, 2015 to ICP"s April 15, 2015 FOIA Request re the Application of CIT"
Group to acquire OneWest
Saturday, May 09, 2015 3:19:44 PM
May 9, 2015
By email to Office-of-the-Secretary [at] frb.gov and FOIA-Appeals [at] frb.gov
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Attn: Secretary Robert deV. Frierson and FRB Governor in charge of FOIA Appeal
20th Street and Constitution Avenue, N.W.
Washington, DC 20551
Re: FOIA Appeal of FRB Denials of May 5, 2015 to ICP's April 15, 2015 FOIA Request re
the Application of CIT' Group to acquire OneWest
Dear Governor in charge of FOIA Appeals:
On behalf of Inner City Press / Fair Finance Watch (ICP), this is a timely appeal under the
Freedom of Information Act of the Federal Reserve Board's (the FRB's) May 5, 2015
Denials of ICP's April 15, 2015 FOIA Request regarding the Application of CIT' Group to
acquire OneWest.
Inner City Press immediately requested the withheld portions of CIT's and OneWest's
submission of April 14, 2015. Now the Fed has ruled that it can withhold IN FULL
Confidential Exhibit C, CIT Bank Internet Deposit Data By County. Overall, how can CRA
be enforced if such basic information is withheld? As a matter of FOIA, it is illegitimate to
withhold in full, including for example the names of the counties - how would the disclosure
of the names of these countries, most or all of which are publicly known, cause substantial
competitive harm?
ICP is appealing all withholdings, including the unexplained redaction of the address of one of
the branches OneWest would shutter, and the branch closing policy.
Please immediately send all requested information and responses by e-mail to
[email protected] and [email protected], and/or by hard copy by FedEx to:
Matthew R. Lee, Esq.
Fair Finance Watch
c/o 747 Third Ave (hold at location Fed Ex), NY NY 10017 USA
Or regular mail: Matthew R. Lee Esq, PO Box 20047, NYC NY 10017
If you have any questions, please immediately telephone the undersigned, at (718) 716-3540.
Very Truly Yours,
Matthew Lee, Esq.
Executive Director
Inner City Press/Fair Finance Watch
Not Responsive - Underlying Documents
From:
To:
Subject:
Date:
Attachments:
Amory Goldberg
"Orme, Camille L."; Salley, Stephen M.
Freedom of Information Act Request 2015-196 Regarding CIT Group Inc. Proposed Acquisition of IMB Holdco LLC
Thursday, April 23, 2015 10:55:34 PM
20150414 Other Applications Document - Confidential - PLEASE SEE Exh. B and PLEASE SEE Green Highlighted
Part of Exhibit D.pdf
Not Responsive - Underlying Documents
Good evening Camille and Stephen,
The Board received a FOIA request seeking the confidential portions of CIT Group Inc.s Response
dated April 14, 2015, responding to the Boards Request for Additional Information with respect to
the proposed acquisition of IMB HoldCo. LLC.
Having consulted with Applications staff at the Board, it appears that certain information contained
in Confidential Exhibit B can be publicly disclosed in whole or in part. If you continue to seek
confidential treatment for information contained in Exhibit B of the attached PDF file, please (1)
identify the financial data for which confidential treatment is sought (by highlighting such
information in yellow or using redaction); and (2) provide the applicable FOIA exemption or other
legal justification to support your request. Under the Board's Rules Regarding Availability of
Information ("Board's Rules"), a conclusory statement that release of the information would result
in competitive harm is not sufficient. 12 C.F.R. 261.15(b); see also 12 C.F.R. 261.16(b)(1) and (e). In
addition, the loss share amount of $104.2, which is included in Confidential Exhibit D (see page 70
and 72 of the attached PDF file) appears to be public information see
http://www.ibanknet.com/scripts/callreports/viewreport.aspx?
ibnid=usa_3918898&per=20141231&rpt=RCM&typ=html I believe the prior loss share amount was
disclosed by CIT as part of the public version of "Confidential Exhibit 5" to the Application, which
was provided in redacted form on October 2, 2014. Accordingly, please also provide additional
information as to why the loss share amount $104.2 should be treated as confidential business
information and withheld from Confidential Exhibit D.
The Board retains the right to make its own determination with regard to any claim of
confidentiality. Pursuant to the Boards Rules, notice of the decision by the Board to deny a claim of
confidential treatment, in whole or in part, and an opportunity to respond shall be provided to the
submitter claiming confidentiality of information no less than five days prior to its public disclosure,
12 C.F.R. 261.16(c)(4), and where appropriate, the Board shall delay disclosure for ten working days
from the date of the determination. 12 C.F.R. 261.16(f). If we do not hear back from you on or
before May 1, 2015, the information in Exhibit B will be released.
Sincerely,
Amory
Amory R. Goldberg
Counsel
Legal Division
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
202-452-3124 (phone)
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Date:
Attachments:
Auten, Taylor
Amory Goldberg
Orme, Camille L.; Salley, Stephen M.
RE: Freedom of Information Act Request 2015-196 Regarding CIT Group Inc. Proposed Acquisition of IMB Holdco
LLC
Friday, May 01, 2015 4:20:18 PM
SC1-#3856773-v1-Letter_to_the_FRB_dated_May_1_2015.PDF
Amory,
Please find the attached letter in response to your email below.
Best regards,
Camille Orme/TCA
Sent: Friday, April 24, 2015 2:55:34 AM
To: Orme, Camille L.; Salley, Stephen M.
Subject: Freedom of Information Act Request 2015-196 Regarding CIT Group Inc. Proposed
Acquisition of IMB Holdco LLC
Good evening Camille and Stephen,
The Board received a FOIA request seeking the confidential portions of CIT Group Inc.s Response
dated April 14, 2015, responding to the Boards Request for Additional Information with respect to
the proposed acquisition of IMB HoldCo. LLC.
Having consulted with Applications staff at the Board, it appears that certain information contained
in Confidential Exhibit B can be publicly disclosed in whole or in part. If you continue to seek
confidential treatment for information contained in Exhibit B of the attached PDF file, please (1)
identify the financial data for which confidential treatment is sought (by highlighting such
information in yellow or using redaction); and (2) provide the applicable FOIA exemption or other
legal justification to support your request. Under the Board's Rules Regarding Availability of
Information ("Board's Rules"), a conclusory statement that release of the information would result
in competitive harm is not sufficient. 12 C.F.R. 261.15(b); see also 12 C.F.R. 261.16(b)(1) and (e). In
addition, the loss share amount of $104.2, which is included in Confidential Exhibit D (see page 70
and 72 of the attached PDF file) appears to be public information see
http://www.ibanknet.com/scripts/callreports/viewreport.aspx?
ibnid=usa_3918898&per=20141231&rpt=RCM&typ=html I believe the prior loss share amount was
disclosed by CIT as part of the public version of "Confidential Exhibit 5" to the Application, which
was provided in redacted form on October 2, 2014. Accordingly, please also provide additional
information as to why the loss share amount $104.2 should be treated as confidential business
information and withheld from Confidential Exhibit D.
The Board retains the right to make its own determination with regard to any claim of
confidentiality. Pursuant to the Boards Rules, notice of the decision by the Board to deny a claim of
confidential treatment, in whole or in part, and an opportunity to respond shall be provided to the
submitter claiming confidentiality of information no less than five days prior to its public disclosure,
12 C.F.R. 261.16(c)(4), and where appropriate, the Board shall delay disclosure for ten working days
from the date of the determination. 12 C.F.R. 261.16(f). If we do not hear back from you on or
before May 1, 2015, the information in Exhibit B will be released.
Sincerely,
Amory
Amory R. Goldberg
Counsel
Legal Division
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
202-452-3124 (phone)
This e-mail is sent by a law firm and contains information that may be privileged and
confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete the e-mail and notify us
immediately.
Not Responsive - Underlying Documents