Insaan Ne Kya Socha by G A Parwez Published by Idara Tulueislam
Insaan Ne Kya Socha by G A Parwez Published by Idara Tulueislam
I I I
J •
~(p.YlfL(jwJ ----------------- ",:,",V(t
Of -
y,/ ----------------- _;;..v
.. ~
( j Y. .J ) ~ ; ( J.1( I c., _,.lb ----------------- ~J)e~
54660-.JJ1iJIIJ J25-B
email :[email protected]
web; www.toluislam.com
,.1955 ----------------- J-,J~~f
«(- ;Ll)f2000U.ly. :. I. .1
----------------- r~~1 I
cI./.v. ~....; J'"' ~ ~..::-l",Jv J .;...r ./ (!i-" t",Jb -,_JJ1..J/ {Lf(~Jjr}
·
r
~~.('r'~ vi
,J~YJ'.;llr~ t" .,:,iJ~~),
I~~ I~ }jj'./ _"")I L· _-I, ~
.. ,;tl"Ql~ y- '(;J.J .. A.J \r .JL.&I v- ~ -:
,~('..:,..~~~~ " Jl~d'/~
,Jifr' cr;;1L.(dL-llI~ l'r UJI~~.
~ _;I •. ,,1 .. ~ ~
r~ '';:;'''~~'''~~~~_;;Lct' r~ ~t:t'vj.J.fJj;~tJUt~
r. ·~'lAi,.L!.../YJ"';"'JI r. ~4-I:4~JJ,y./JI
(". .~ci~y'~· 1"1 J.,o/»...{I',,:,W'J_'.J'~JI
s : ·~~J;W .U;~~'l~Ut}1
~I .~I'clLJ,~..l.L,r.JL..i1 1"" .:.:;J?tJUI~.dy
~. .r£ 'r~ ltv;iU,1k...jJ 6"
,,., 4<1/~~)'~~')L'l4J<fJ ~r
~. 1~~~cfr~(v;~J~~J~'
Id ~'-Sb[; .- .
.. ...:=t ~ ... • !;;.I iii
.. .... '!: .' ""
~ " ·~~~(dl.J·J~)Y.
! Ii'" .~~~kljJu, alt
I·, ·<.$J~~ctlj~J~Y.J.t ~~
I·A .Jlyy-.;.:/. (.M~JJ~~ ~~
, I. ·cJ~,yLtJI_..I.JI~t.ai·I~~lj ~
..,. .
J •• . ~·v:~IJ~ ~,
II t .~wt~L·
.. ,
..-;.J jI ( ~/' ._ul .. ;., 1.,,01'/ t . ",/II ..
~ ,",v V",/':'-!? IfI'-'J.CIJ f If
11~ '4-.Juj~ 4:t~lj ~r'
~~:LL~~1.t'.J~t?P'JUI~1 '1~
Itt'" ~iT~.JJJ!.J~ ,,,
•
ttl" . cJl?.Jt:)~;~ J,,~
II~ -=--iL.P'~r'J ~d; ~'"
u, .~J-'''' '"~
U~ .~Jl)J( ""
. .-
II" ~ cJ./ ifif.J;£r JUf ,,-,
J),-",-,;{ ~·;._,Jj4,,~Jib ,,~
U~ ~~~~t;4-V; .~;{JdLJIv...:.C:( ~~~J,I.V _.,Q --0 t....J (,
.. .
• ~ ~ ~.J""if Lclvr
~
I
r (:)r r t;J~
, r ~4-Y":":~u'~'y» . It"· r~I("~..J;JJ .. A;
- .J_"'jL~J',J?,
If"~ .~'liIJ~ .. ~r'~1t ~ t" ....
I~' ·~biJJitJO..tI.?* ~~ Ir, . Jr'ILJ'y
~4t . 4..:Jirrt;:;.·'J ~t ~VJ.U. Ir~ .t;,t~l'~~L
.. l .. nff.iJJu;·· ·
1~'" ·t;)ttJ~~.J;tJU;I~IJLJ9'l I t" ~
tbf" !;JIi(JJ)iI~.c!i0~..c~UUr ,r" . ~ ~~tS.C;:__,q
J,-j:' e: !;J'f(nJ' '1'" 1r, .~~£~.c~(;:'lf
)O~ rtJ.7~fg; ,r,r\ "'- ..I;.¥ ~Ii ..::"..ur.J ... ,~~ ;'.1
10 ~ '.I~ .~~LJU;,"(!iI....lCl It"· ~..w~~!.U'J~JI&"..::"t:(
10'" 1,~t~~).I..~~;t_,.Jii,,"1 1ft .L/~Jr'U'"Ic.Lt~LJ4;t;
Il)" .~U)tcrP~, ~~(..jL
. ..
• . ~ "l
A .. -..::.-V J.L;I
,..- .~. "JIll JJI
~ .,;v (' &oze.< ; lMJ !,..."
101 ...
.. .
i!of t .(.)j'.L 9.;.1y' i~J JLtI .,,~ f~V~LvJ/4.~Wi.~M
I ~. ~' JJi.J~'~J'c..JLUh rJV«? tc:~ (t~y ,-,ty' c..J~~i
1'1' '" J.JJ'~~Ii¥.uU"" I'" ·uJ,;_,,;e,.t
... I, .,
". ! ~-"'t..vJ/lC Jt\~~it7LtA
1"11 I. ~ ';1) I ., '" ..... "
tiP .I:/.~IeV!ftli/~..c~~
III( f" .u;1~b, of . """'~
1"4"1 i4u?ct..l~~,i~!f t ,.1 T(~Y (/'''''<S'~I~~~
1"1' .~cf~~.JJIJ&" ",J!J"'Y ~!i~}.J!'..I~ClLJJ
.~~",..c~~~(<<~ trf t "
1 "I" ~ j;,-,,~
y~" .... .t .. si] ViPLJLUI
I",· .1~ l~7!~p ,,..,
.-~~--,,- II
v"
..=.r t..:;.~!?'.c..::.61 I ~ t' .J jJ.>1 ~('-:; (
·~(cJ,.J»1 IL~ .JI_dJ,L,*,;';LJ:'~ .:
.. '5);./(;,-;, I LA r ,.tW,J (.:., I.;_" J ,; .1:i..t~,t;J
-~~L~~lPd,,~~u:t, ~J+':.!tJf'uL?J.J~
-r';2.J ltJiJ 1:P1.J.J1~ 1 Lq rJty·
J'" ( ~
.Je:-~' I'~ ;4""'~~L:~"':'.iCJI!';2..L(./'1
9~( yj '''~ !t.J!~L;f/.
~;)iiV' Ju I~' ·t..tutJ'::'~J'~._j/.I!SI~
.:jJ(y;;' 1~4 ~~c{fj4 GUJdJ#)
'''~ .(I,jIUbJ~
J~r '4-~(..(-:"_)Ja~t..J.
r.~
Tlr
-:=;c7/ , ! "rV;, C'tJl
'1 iI';.
- cl' r ~
r:
rOI .~~J~~~#J~ t t"',.." .4-tf_;;r;I.::.l;t ........ ;(~
, ItO .. " _I
t'c)l'" ~.Jt;V: ~tL~iv:~ tr'c) . .;..J.t:..[J J' .$<f:(~
~,'-'~,~.lv.;~~ r "'4 .-rL~"'r'JJJLJ,V~~11
II .~'c):;liJ. II .v:fl,j Q'('~jJJ Ut,:,.
rt)r AO:~JicJ)Lj-4v:~J""'l" trq :)J~~).
". ( .. yl
l'O"i .~~~,~i¢J=t~#' ~it~J1:O/,,~.r(.T1
/J ~ J_A~LJ.,_tA rr· ~vJ4-.J;;
" • .. r _
_.., -r=.,~~. l'l"r .Jty(,":';LJ,J_,1? "J ~
" '" ..
~t., :. /L,v. rrr' ~~~~LJu:~t.%1
tl)A .?1('~
.. rr'1"
• t ~ 'c..f'UJ..::-t,:,btc ;..L,-",'r. II .~LI~~JJ~
- 1# ....
"'bQ .,. I~"" "'-"'f., t ••
. ..., ..... ., JV .. . flU '':- ~ .&If c{,/
'J. · ~ ~ .Jfo(' V J( tt.f'~J
1/ ·.::rU ~ '::-l.5:t?; cJtJ'JJ.J /,
J~~~~t~.LJJ.J~ II ~vJ~La-
II ~d.f tr"f ~t.J/~~~~~ljl~
r~· .)~~Ii:!/?-..J£~.Jr rr'L ~,1rJc!fo~J-YLc.f1
.. I
.. ~ - . ~~AtJ)?~~~~PifJ
1/ ~ .J;.v(..f~r' ~1.b, r r"
-"- ~~HJ~;~:.f~.~Uf
¥'1r .~~L.vY~,
l'fI('" .. -.::.. (.!.~t..t.....,. ...w~.J "'fI(q 4~~J'0~~l.J1~
u .... ., ,
h '~~~~v.:(f~L.[~~ r~ • .~J-'''
If .(IItPf. r~1 · ~ 4-).; ~ 1";'~l:..:V
l'fI(~ .. JI'!.tI'_; I)iLvl 1/ ·t..~~J/t~~~4 • !~YVLcJL.h
~~ ,1\
•
r (,;), • •
r cJ""'"
t'''~ , .L"!jr-..:.·:~~~~Lv?L rloff" .~~}
J ~~'~ut.LiL__........t<J.".....u.J.. t"t~ . ~;.iL,,/~..!.~fJ
• • .. , • '1
1/ 'T~~JI,;;tf~ t"'1 .Y(J~
t1 . ·(ua-'J~0 r" . #~L:?
_"
r11 w~IJ)tliJ II .~._
.. -
rCi r • ...;,~I(.MI r,1 , .(.)-,~j§..bJ(,-,"lj.lIV~L
4 ....,./. '-t.~ . )I ~
II ' #"T"JJiJ.{1~r ~L r~t' ·crf..:r..:,...~~ ,,_"j-:,J
-rV~ ;~,~ .J!.t'(.).>t;.J, rLt'" ~
.. ..-\i
If ... •• .. ..
if4-:f"/Y~~l1*JjUI.I; ."
tClr' t" ,. .~l._.....-
. ~J -
tCl~ ... :. 0t ~ • if .. t.;!.J I~.J! !;
~ :
.' L .J "Y~~~~(f'L
.JI'-t r· ;;. 4.-.J
• •
J;~;; -,
YL6 ~u~oJ
r ., --
".." , II .cJ" !.4
4.L~;~tJJ.L~~;,.r<f;' ,..,~ .hqpl
,.. .1 .. ~~jJ~/ ;,..JJ Y J..:::LL d('LuI
,... t' . ~o/V:~.:lf~){ t" ~~":-1?fL
~ -
· ~ '-"lI~.L--=-~;JJt:t . ,&
r·,.. 'I; I · ~r-&.
.. J..!.4J'I" . ..,
... " <I J_
r~r' ~~lJ~Y<.r' ,r'l\ .~N,(!;~~~ .-I LJ.., (
Y'~" ·+~~4~";cJul ,...". ·~Jd?
. , ~J -·W(~··Ju
1/ .~; ·6JiJ6· t'At' ,.4 J.lJU'.,,J'
;~nk-'j~~J;p.(-=-~ r,A" ·V t.:-t,;(;..» v.
r·Iof · t.GJ...Y;.:A,.,f",IL~;.f~ YM ·4Jf-S =1, • q ~ 'eYif~L:Jt;,
":"-'JI
•
cJ.r • "~
r r
rr'4 w4- ~'tJ.J:"~~JcJL..iJ ",.. '" '4-~#'J(Ij\JjJ 1'~4-
.J~;JLJ~J,jl,f' ~, '. ~
II • 7! ~~(/'~ ,If'
r""'A ~-.:"J.;..ar£ ~k'~J r· " ~~WIt£cJLJJ';J...JVtt~
of _., ..
w~y/~~A ~lb~JWl . ~
Y'r'q ,.. ~ . . !()!J~~t~
""
tf.Li,}:J(' ~ ,_;JW"C.)J',r.JUI rIY"" ·4;jL~~ wL(.'\:IU•
rrl " . " " T (/_.IJ/" -. ""I~ ~~'<N+~L:J'.I,'j~JI
/' r: oj • --.I "tJ _ ~:;'l. ~ • ./ ...., ( ~ -.1.A \ •
~'~~~L.JI(.f..'T~.c:-,-,=,,,," r::,~ II " _.I Fi.l ("JIJ. t:J.~ '?.c "
rrr "TJ,,-!!~::U4~~'C: ,..,,, 'V1,,(.y~)FLifL.
.4-- c'rc! Jj(uP~LJi":;"(..f1 t'" • viI' / rr-:' I/,. L.i
r"r'b " .. -: ~cJ I
!.C~-';~if~~~""JI;o., . .. .
II ·u!-: tl' tJ ~
rr'L '1-UiJ_~~uj,~c/? II .uJ~(II;!?
1.i'?~y?.c"';I,.iw."1T- ,..YI _.I~(/J'r
~y.;'7'cJ~t,v~.6'.r; ,.. to r ..:- I.Jt;,'£ J. J; ~ J-I.:
t"r'~ '''~~~~~J~~ r'rll ! ~f_.l'rit; V6r fJI YV'
t"b. 1f,l7'vt~1i 72...c#~l.u" . /1 !!cJ~1
/I wZ-.JiL..,JIJ; r"', .~'~J({;_C;
,. "t (II .~ 6.\..-tC
f,;)r' ClLt. .t'0fJl~yl,;~1
#bL&- ." III
.L" .h
-:. . \', ,."- ~J\;J;l
.,.'- -'! -. '--'
v •
" "III ,..,.,...
.. '~W3
fW b_ d I) • . vJ4tY'-'?~I~~
rr"b
r"'" ·~~J'VIJh. ~rCJl~Li:JWI/~J~~
t"b4. . " ..:,. iJi.i J ~ ~4-if
1/ 1/ '~':~J07.J~ II • ...:,.. I" L.:.,jv: cJW'.J) I~ t.J1
..
...
.:/~k:/~~~~~ II .. .:.. "I,.:ajJ.I~ I£~UI
.,..,,'" .. ~b(~ <..C~JJJ.I~I'c)I,)I/ .:rl(.JU;~1
~r' i4-c.Lli6'~ if ,..I(~ ,I..G .J ,; .:;, f" t;.j
•
r~~ ~~~I L$ II if J1~.£j,jv::~~.JL.:JcJ'.
• ~ j .(;J~J .. ..- . -,.. .
II J .:r.AJi ($I ~ til -:! rlL '~JjLJIliI
... . L·~.f4-~".L~1 - ..
t"~4 • .L.~ ~ c;"'t.::JIJ~~. " ..4-
,._; ~I"J~ 'p~UI~LA' ,.."t~ '.:r(?~d,..~:tf~;'J'('J
II -~L'r!l".J~ ~yC.
"v.t;(("':"f"'L(U<:f:~~1 ..
"'" ft. , rt(',..A,
rqy J Jj I.J../ "::';~J :z {. ~ -It ~
T'4.~ • .. :.;..(~! ~, ~ ~~
, ... f'Y .ff~vjJ~t:&/~~JI
r,,.. .~,j_;&' ...... ~
7 j, .;
.4-.iJ! ..fJ!1~~,fi
II .~lfJ-i~)z.iJ'J)Lt1~-
II J;.&rJ/it.:,PL:Wntfjt"flcA r~q
f .~.... • /.
. ...::..~~ f LLV lA#
.--r of
t" Llo '4I.fu!;.,;.r(:~I..:..,,~~t(;1f
. ,..'. ..~(Hl4.i?S,H
..
.. .::;-1; tfi ":::~L~h "''''~J'~
4JJc.JJ'.JS~~/~':. rl(r
II
II
"::"'JWc..uf4-~o;JI""~~LcI()1 .L ~ J.Jf_..,dd'jv:
· ", :;'''~£~/ci
• J (.:&iV::...::..-~ ~ I~ W 1
• .1 t.:.J~clUtJ_'fclWI
1/ .J L:J:, .... /~JLCJt.J1
?.~f'. r ( .,
t""1~ ~~~U;W¥~('(.("li,lclUJ -
,..1( J .),1JJL.:,tt(L.~1
..
JO h-l':..I.J 1(/) U I
-~(/Jy#~ }P'tJ:Ui"tj,
1/
~ I
rqr . .~tliPL..::;li"r.
..:;, ~7.fc.flcf.JtJ~,,~ fJfPl£vr rqr ·c.t~J1;-~.c()~w4Lj
......
r~ "~;'~~~JLf."I.t~
II '()!.J~~J~-
("II> .d~~u~!"I~LJU) rqq d&tI~~~.IJb()'~"':"'-."~tJ
u~~ dc.dJI,.JIc.01:r"::"L~'" ~ . .::: r ~~ r' ~IJ..:SliJ~-:
..;:-1 (,~LI'.:~.:L 14-0';1 (".. ..:;-Vrr'c)tJu,-~ -:.1"
.Ouj It .~fi#J_;t;1'p..J/~
• " Of .. ,'1 ..I .. , ..
1/ ·, .. 6:~/J)...{iJ"J.lJI~~
r·q ! .:;...J~4~""~ .
1"1. .~ ;U~yJ;.Jt
!I'll' . .::;..Mj';::'~~::':';:{rJ
uf'~ J -r"'1t1"JI'-_,(..";'f"'/'/4Ji~Y /.CIlc,:)lcJL..iI/v,:tr;,,,rJ.fnI!r
.4",,~rJ~;~jIr,:,Jd"'t~if~1.I/.
J!-lL~LfNLJIa.LJ'I...-'LJA;/4-,*f.4-I)~J"....{I'cf.i
~1~U:~~-"~C~~;J{u-?4-d't~~j·A.4~q'Vi.d~L'''J ·4-a:t;...6~?"~I.J"",yd':::"~!-r"'1(~vJu,.¢J l'"r'.,~rC·LJ=*'Ptf,..64 (~t ~~~lr-,Ai vlcJLJl;';;~) 0Pv'
.. . .. w~('t'I;l!,v:V/ ~u IlJt:.;-~"c.U"""~
.. 4-( 4-t J,--", .A,.1;.J ~ J? J:_ .
o: -_l·!r.?~J~J..cv.'f.c/~»v'>VIJ_;141.j:-(~.,;-::~ w 4-yt...4U1"J:=--..::.J. J..., .i.-iLJlp td ~v:? ('v~7 (IN~STINCT) ~ ~JAJPr~4l.'~JJ''''(.i-~J.,('q''pOJ!(~'~Jl.JvC;4'(t(VI
J' 0'()~'1j (U~VI.JI4-~~~ 7"':'~~(:)~1 f~. ~~JI/~J~cJ!,1f
.~LJI"jVl.muJJy..,_;/v:41~tc:ct.!.!J:.;;(#'JJr~.4:S';'-"!frt:
I . ~4-J~~~;'~_)JJ~?~'''::-''Jo.JJ./.
"Df9fl>.(?;J'4:j.{.t'~1¥ JVI($ ;J.:~v.i;JfJJ:vJJw~JJ ~ ,-,/",~/t ~Jtf (;,.,y'~£.J'i JUt r, J..rr/4-""+'J(,_, (..I""f'"»I:U'JiL'J'r'..:.-~~LJ"':J~~J'c.PLf:4-"::'-J!?S~JJJJ2-L L Z'~.J""....ICJIa."': f._(,~~Lf.t.:!I~ (.LtJ:t.Lj:J.,JIfJ/ ?'v:J Jf
.J.i r Lfi., L~
#. "/ ~,
· Lf.J(',J''-/,JY''4--:.
1'(;.~~IPv::~),n~ ~L~i""1-: ~~L"!~,!,,,,) )Je) JL·tLJLJ";;JUI(~"'At;'L",:-".,t(:: rl·-r.-'Jul~/trJVf)J.u.::
i!Y.'().t..-.Ju.14~J'~~ .. J(jJ,J,__.u.~tJJ"Jv£J.-4.i}~L:.Z(''' ... -tf . 4-..1(; (j;....!:J:J" J» If'' -:-' a 1;.r..J) I ( ?u.f.:: .. H"'JJ'j·~('__'LJ .. 0.....(Y.\ .. PjLJJj~
~ ~." Uw:v ~
£tP4:r'/bPI.f1c)W1..r.:;-,,1J. I; J'IJJ'Y'y{ J.1...t()IJJ.,-V:If:,,]JfkJl
~(f~)'f.(~c. rv..r4-!p~)~~~~.~)';iif.f~JJL~Jl
.' .. . .:,..."-(..:) _\..Jif~tli (' JL1J~yfuJ
¥.:,J!Yy ... ~)(.HM--~hJ'r''''l/c)IJif.i· ... k.',I'''';PI('~j.
!J,-~/v!;~;r.vJL.1;pJt,;,~/v'/~V~J.(c..JJutLJ;ff" .~(.Vy~,-:-,t(~~I(""j'Yv}.JJcJt~L{,.)jI.J4J~;~...J/tJJ
L J'h~lif.ft4-;/w:J ~JJ"r' '";~ ~l--'(LJJ W1d"Vf'",:",I;.'('()t'Y'cllJ'!' ':::"yJ ;p.:LtJI !'i-.J..f'/J'r' J .. oJ v~LJv~LtJI/4-~"": ~JJLfI .J)Y.IL~.iJl..iI~J4.If».?;L£.IJI.;f:.I;'td/~~J'J"'~I.f)J.:L..eJrLJ L..-t:J 1.L.,.6i,j 1.J1/L..~t6 -:: ~ ..elfl.J)!L.." !!r.J' JL· ... vJ VI uJ ... .(f(;,;:;;.;,~L(;};J Jr!cJlf'L.If~:A'v.t J ~4'VJ..:JJ"" .4) ! 4- b{~..::)!.lJJP~w.J r",.Yi./cJl/~ f.,~ ((;}'bif t:.,-L;.J ~ J tJ1.~()IJJ,,_/u:J't>"JJ'?£cJl~)I,,!~jJ~~J~..e~.I~b1cJl ~f'rJ1ef_,-::L?cfIYUI""Y"')~.IJ~·f'-rJ",:-,!;:('J'''''~~GJ.1il1k..{ l/.LtlJi:P £1:)1 '2.-/,'~ f(¥i..JOj'fJ"".:L.I~I4-./. F.LJLJI
vrr~vl}·j(~(f./if.fwi?r'''''y'cJtH.L£,.((j;~,;_oJ~~S~' '!:tfvC':::"I.(.;-~r.~~c)'/~"';I;ljH.JJ'J,.rt.J}~t:-:.I.,4·
I(.J.tJ~J t:rl()~tL _(l/lbl..~h~~4.t.:::..J'~VI";;J;.i L;..IIJ'VI JJ I~ 1/.'.:::....; !A: IIJ"'I/I:J!J,LV: .
":-!Jjp~
-v .. or
J":JJI..,..)'~V:4JJ~/t..tVIJ,,(;rJ~J;I~.I3,;({((:))~.l4- Lif I 'wi.:;.) J v,fL~iJY'IJiL(;} ~{.IJI~ / _t:../...,w...{!.::_v: JV- (,,£ jJI,.i,~.c~....{i'._(,l:i'v'. ~Uv-; fJJ.r' v1.:.,-L{ ,6,J...J ;;, ... ;~~ (rr.;..fJ'J(...IJirJ(,jlvIJ_jJI,.JI.L~~£vl:ir~(..~il(.'.c trL»~")'(fI(cJy·'V:~JS)v,_..,JUv(c)jJ!'VV:~J.Jt~y,..JUv
__.,;IoW7[?.ct_;;2....'-~~.ctJ,·ift~jc1.~~,..4;L;J-4...(,(vl.l~~
~J"Vt)'vl~...r{~.....,JcJy4.t.l;~..(cer(JIr.-"'J'~~..cJ'~ !.prJ.I(.. -b/..:;..._,d ';').t,&/...;-; v'V: h I';::_!'; 4- c:'.r,' (:.I!:--.,4..cJ~;; II \0:;-
-?t~(~(A5 t.t~~ e \! ?; .. ·:?V~L(:.IriUf~ (i4-.v..:;..c);.PS tf. t..f...l~;J..:'-?'V &( ~ '4fy;.L",:JY.J ,~j ,u(vS rJ!.f >fvy;
.tiict fu.:f
~V7.uu.'vl·4-l.(cJyL~-=-;U,V'/~t,-~J;k-=-7'; v,£~j(.~imtil.IF~~I~JjL.1f.~'f.I:Ac)~;(J,2(fj)
LJ()!l~u"~cf.~or.LJ,~<.h,{~L_.v,~.J'o-tiJ;<t:d.l~d- 7.tf,.;..{c.J~JJ~cJ0.J~~.lJ,J.1;.Iv:cJ~JM '(;,~Uv('(j':'/~
J t,.,~cf.u:ir::#.:'-dc)i.~~LL r4Jr.:.~J.trJ~*"tC;) ~J,Lv! . ()~'J.uS~.d~'1:rr~~,·,~J,~~L~(jir.r,'~~O'~\y-'~~~.
~ or';;:' L·~ .... ;.; 'J ( tJvtL.J, l..J l I .. .... •
·11~· _J,r'~crtJt.ll J/L:I~~.J ~~I~,j::;~.ZF..::4 e',)~~ ~ .Jf~~~"'~).'J JJ;,..I.lrtJfi~l;~a ,~J~I'~ jrr~_4-"J!? -fi' 'c)!I7..::_",bc:; (MA TERlAL) )l.-'(/'~.::.._,d£tJ."/'(ASc)i.crC~ ::_vl~v:it;.f0~L.J~JvcJl~):t/{cNl;I~~tA_.wJ~ Ju~~~.Jl;wv:,,;>w~(f..ly~if~>t::f~~)~'""'c.r
;::C~IiIJ(LA~1 v'~2 L!:11Ld..:Jb~~! J..:';:;_(i' ~..:"yy.
. l;;ra~J4'/~ 1P-((';)~Jh'::::'l/jJ jJ.::..~A;t'1~V: ·c,.t I~ /LVI·4~FV~~JtJl~JI.:r~"".(ifL)Jt.J~L.:Jwv.;\f c..r-1.v.!' .(1.1~~L.LIJ~fJ~ "'tru:i'V ~yl...,c;':-~A u-4dlir(j'-,: IjP ..::.-J..;;J 1,.itJ.. Vi- 4-"":) J ~.:..-!) (if:) !IrS'll (.':..,.,11
~j~sJ.~4t~WLJ_li4r'~Ic)L.J,L~'f.~c.f'/4-ifJ::.:;_;;LC' ~~.'-l.1"-! 'I II-f:, ., .'{j~ v'4-~ ¥'t:-;: ,;.tJ<')'{uf.';J'.0 w
(~M~jcJp'J"!'.t:tct.~~l"''-L<-7J.,2. L ~ ~ y ~~;-4~4 '--/,"",~~(f'JIi1~r.~A'dft~CJLJ,Lu)'}~~4--L7J"'~I~jcJ~~ ~~~I~).,~//J.tJ,..£"t'"SJ_~J(fI~.JI'u/GJat.l£cJI'.JU> r. 4-.(f~2..Lc)'u.q~J~~~c) yfv.j 4~"'»J!'(~J.'-~ .J."~v.f~ig "p .. *~tpfi. ,:?'4·<.,J,;-"';·A':;"e ~~JJtJtJ1ILJ"'LiiL.J. LJ4 I
;;:fc);;'JN!L..::-~~LJ,J'-~J/~~('C,~~~~L~y(;JIv1~J'
.L~/.&::-)u:,
J-f~cfi/ d!r ;.LJo.;:.-~/,..."...:J'~(.}oW'F.'::- ~.I7'J ~ .. .J4CC/~.IjJ'::"'J!)DJ.~..,G'Iu,...~cJYJ(~£I,);;,f...i.fYufU;(f.~
1.C.;-1. .;;,.._;,;.;,,, JJ;Jt::..~ Iflivr ujd[()J 2..f.:.',,;tI..J..~~!;'v.}J ',/J~.tt~t~a.v,~ttd2-£~Y4jU1J,V£u.A'~u,_;J-V
· L c.f.~.F.'''';.J~J:N~u-''J.,::-''('''''c../.''4-~~I'':::'''d.'vY,L(_,.IPcJl .Lu:"4.J~/d"t;Jyl.JjJ.L~f1/»~LcJ'~A/L.I.!".-.I1 ~rJ~Jc)!Jt.tJ~Lcf.'ilY:L:-;4f"(/~~t::-U~IW.J,
.. I ~ ~ 1:. . ,! /'9 J'" .. * ; ,
~~ifJ_..LJY'v.!Jr/.~~lu-!<~'1.J~~.J'U.J-f!(.tJlly'~~I~Jl
If.. b. .(;"/LfJt::-VL;J'U,~3t r-4~.J+ ttd4~~~cJY/4-~
· l~~~~~~L
.>;l ~! ;jJL.,.t;/J.L~_;'~ ,:it 1t,..;1~~;_;:;'r': 1$..::4
"""-v ~ , ~ T-V''' ~':
..:;.~J"J"~I~ ':::VI4tft'-{~ 'v:f'tJ'.I., .::.-!~JIi~J.t4jJ' .tcJLLY!(' jl--'£ J.t;JLJI.(J~ r:;-..6.1i ~v:. 4-<:!-t.f:o/-'t.r.f.::::. . .;...~(J..+;~~ld'~vl.cc;:J4.d~ uf,-Jlt.I/JI
.. ". .. . - :"
.4--I.,4;(IJI5)~;'jJ
t..(tb, ";;~..::.7($u:: ... cJ' ~ (~~J',ifr;J;;L J~ J'.,M:t V !,--,II:
tv dv:~r/-=-0f,f~J~X'""'I?'vl'4-q~IJ'...::,J'L:I'~.n~
(LJ._.eir.I~~vJ~1.::-~t1>'JifJ)'~!YIu!VI.l(J'f.a..vl.~! .
J' Ji.L..io/.I-'~I~u:LJtj~?-~4-2..vlv.:id;k '_;"J/ £~ruj(;
I~ ~ L..:;J"i:J'k""~ '~Cif.'-"..vtw.' l:: · Lit ~~ v..<'" ,,:1$ :VV'''J
. . . .'L; I~IJ; ..wI t, ~"
"'7 V .. ' v- ..
7Jtv~.I.,!.t...::.t~cf.~;/-~~~L~~ ?Vb.rJ ~t1
. ~~;~~~~~
. V,.., 'I 1-: ..;
~-!-¥uJ"'.I'~e..~"'1: .vJ~t:::-I.I';LcJt.-",jL I":,,, ~.I.14fL":"'1.1
"'"":-" 1i"J '~" .v.r~G:J'6y, ,-:,,~"-;r!/'":"',;t:,v¥! ;£...;'~J':::' t-_;../Vj
.. .'4-~ ,LtI{k.t:r.t.tf'''';4I:;IJ1IJ''!'LIf~
•
-......---~~o---
.~J~,!;~/J'~djJv'4JJ~a~(~J1>~ct.v:~~ k.Z~JJ'c.P"~""'L.1f1 yJJ ... ,~t,...&J'J_e;!>. t,,~"J_(,./;Lv1
'1:-IfJJ;.(JAJ.ifJM.d"~J'V.4':::"If'J~v~YV'~if. ~J~":"'C(v'~'4.J:>JlIy.~~~J~~Jj~~.tl~~'-.Ifr.J vfi~-r;»"lP'...J~AV'~~~JJV,(.!!·Jfn./,lI,..JLtV/..IJ,~t~
~"JV,.!t-J~,;~~;LLj9VJ~t:O(~~f.I~«J,rv!..iJ'/.;u ~,ti"::"-'#~J~;~!..IJU:2..Lc.r.Jf'1irV:..::.J~rt~';J,-/»LIf' ~I.iI'''J~-f'..::fIv1J'v.:fu~AfvVv:cfL~L1'dJLj~ (/f/; ~(.-=-~ tJ'J" L;tif(.C.tJAI~L.r,~1J~L ~~~ t(.(~.1.~~
{~()!·Ji&I~~'T'ik,J'2-If'-::'4-ifVv.:~!vl(.~9Jlilrv:r ~!l{VL~·cJ~~" IrV~V:~'-/JJltb~i.;[b ;, ~1/~ ~;""LJ;'4t'~JJ. -;, j(j LJ.I~4,.tJIYL~I1'~·(t;;'Ifl/
;tp!P~~~r;",v:..,...cfv'/4-t.fJ'?.:;..:I.f1i~·L'rVu.!t~&~/"j
4 f.0~'~~~~~~::~'cJ"4-vt~~Y~ci'~'/~'rlJ ~v.: 'J~?.!-~IY.~"(-UY-1~tlP(Jj'T',,,~";jfo,(.J.~L:J~~~~'
· ~~~>. v:rb'::"'_.4IJ ..::.1~t.Lt:P '-; ~-v; ~ (',,,
iJ1;.t"I},,~ (!Iy'V Le'LJI ,Je~L "'r-'ti~ll-~Lt '1 LfV.L 1.;" · ~JjCtJ'~J J' Jt .'i-J~c.f,J~~J J..~iJ.:' J I-:-'~~Ld
. ~~tdLf:'I",:-,D(JUI'JJi'if.v.:'(j~"~IJ~!(.t'V!_PJJ.l,.;1 't~/= '4-Vr~'4 ,",,1;/,,;,~cr;J'.f1f VJ.V;'.f: ~ ~Lr?¥': lijlj If ..i:.- .. ~J '-r' (I~I~ ·.;...c:'r0'; u ,If' v'4-J"="~.t;;;"",;,;r...., V.
~4I.,JI7"!.V'~~) t!.~~(If~~Vf..?I::~~VL,.?,,=,--=-~ (.S')"::-Vlu.ttd;u:'JIi~J..i.J'!"£.Vlil.t-I~L.-L(jIV:'~!~(;)~1 .fr,()P~'::;"if.(~j"~'.tJ~cfu-dliJ/u::f~Lr..fIJJIJ..)..'1I~J
4£:''w"r-'£1J/ ()"::\.Jf'-"'I.;..rt~ t:/t.(-Lu4{01r VIL(jI '4¥(J.VI?f J' (lJ'IiJJ...iJJ1ct~l.f.I.t~; ~ I{ Vi U ... .:4J.t"%q...::;..v~c:J.t."d
~W~t'.(.bi'"~(fl.?,~~S.,..,O ujt(t,:) if0.ff t(~!.; . .L v:..,.,r -ulL •. :;"I!:AJ'"1lr""~(jI. .. ;, "
~rl('''7-J'''cf."r'L1'"".t'':"' ~h:.·lfo.t...Q..y:''''(.f'J,d,",.~ .• bivJ'aJ.. tt ... ~.;v. ... -i.J/ "':-' C(,;;f L", ~ .. (;' ! ... ~,":", U ti~{)')'-...4(.l"V1 {
if.~y.t) 1f"1 ~""!I.LcJUI ':.,;t )~'~{..J.Ji;~I{V"')1 1/".9- v'/~"VLbff,~/Llrcl.~o(~r";J'~I-6._j)'~J.t")~1r~9
I (~(,,":-,cfV~L~vl.~~tJ..-I?.Jf.:::...\IY.~~
~L_LI~I'
·-r- .. I" /
.,...rf-IfJA:?IcJ4Y.+I~IJIrJ,;"JI';""'!.:{'-r"_),-:-"..}"JY~c:(rI.~l ,,:rJ~!tJ) ~"'JltIiJ( 'Jt.ULm1''"r''~.(Jr.'1::: ~ if..J L.IfJ16,;,,,~.j· *~~l~L~~(;_; ~~(pA6~J.'~aJ',JJ'
.. ",,_.. ,,'" ;' ~ "" '. ~.
'-" , I J _'-" ~ , , I .:::,_ It'I~...-!_ IJ
., "'" ~ . , ~ .. ", _",_.~ ..
6.1J4"C ,,:-,~I..-~Lcj."L~jfJ '-)(./- e.,pt.::-;A, J' ""J(CIQ, (f'fj v:r-:-,'
'4-~J.h (.;1 (' ~ 1J"1V:~~jU:::;.(t:;.c.JJ ,/~d'U:~'4fL..,...L1'Ltt(v~I:1~I::Jy.;.4hwll:Jlc.f.(flfi
JI.pScJ9<.tJ~k ~41Jfu-'~k'-()~fcJ,~J, (,.t;,.. /. A Ivt:t.U"':.'IJfl4-/(Jrf'v:j 'rUf..:;, ~1-rJ /.Ydi!.(
·ifJ),J
~-:
At'1J.t#'u. ~t'''
-----401----~
rr
" .
• .r"';S-;'>·-r'w_:'../«~j(~r"'~~~V-'&-I.T'·~;-~.::.../-I..:JJvl
.4- VV/.v.:WJ{;i?4-,..J7....f1'rc_,~'-/-y.4- (MAlTER~ ~!~.vj(Jt'/u-y:if_,.~ _;~IIf.):'r"' ·L:J.cJ~. ~'i::"~ (' !
.. ... • I J .J , I I _._
, .. ..... ..
'I"':, PdvJ W~~'.o!. .. J'-.ILtU'~q-::_.,w~~ .. A/4-rY/"":-'-" -:.)X.J ~ .
(~Ir'", ~'( "::"'.jL...! 'u.7~.J t.61( I..t l.){PERCEIVE) IJ' _,J£ ~1c)1 (.f.)) (SENSES) (J1F'-:iV;u;.:.(""~'U;;J:_y'(~j_j)(.$ ~{~ )~L~
(PERCEPTUAL (tr ..;:...14-t')I'~" (tr.'.~I"''' ~u.!'f4-;..cU'IYo-?l
.W? KNOWLEDGE) ~11!1 ~ 'Lt J4-./7'IP ! o» f ... Nu: ! .;..\4.., LIv(' U'1·iJ.1'7 rJ ,..(,::",At ~~Ll~,-~,..t4-L .. tt{IJJ~~{r:~~~~/~Vtf".tJ$~.J,tlfJ( ~tY~J) ~IP f 4--r ... I!~,-»J~(IJ(, o.:;..J!'=:7.::=:..if 4-if J) ~ (~~~1Jf ... IJ',1)cJA,t(-'::"',A""''''J'4-t'''~)V:~~/:Y.v.:f(HEART)11'J at,. .. ·AJ.v.:'J , .. .lI.k y, 4 . .:::,-tlr if<MIND) v.:'v' ~;J~c:; ~ ~) "J) "4
J (,.i..-li)j tVI.::::..()l;fJty~_' 4--:: 14-V~~ (MIND) -::.L uk. .:::.-c,.!lIz...>1 .~~(MATERIALISM) ~L44J.,: .. U;-I
· - - "'.' ~J
Jt~g__<fI·~V~d..-f;.rIL_..J~<f')~L·if.~t;~(j!--"--
?<fIJ.::J~<ftfJ_~ (DEMOCRITUSXBORN 470 B.C.)v-o/}!~U; -f.. './(j' J~ ftJJ LJ::;..;,; L~ Vrz.J.A..riflV:~~<f,L~:;JLJl:f ;:;:; . .;:...Vr~~,b~I:'j( ~_, ~,l..li _(c:6~u.:f( kL{l)~~hLJ;~ d L"V::~~cJt'-l.!'7.a..,-,'{v.:i)~I('~L1'vl ... ~I;.~(, ttl
t.VJ/2-Lc,~Y'-/'-i.l"';·if.Lu.. ~k_.;..J~'~/~;LiJPf·v:t~1?
- .~
(ATOMISM}..::x.fgfo'(~d'~£VI~_'I.:,-LH)_./y/~~),~Uti.I(0~ 4J: '- (ATOMS) 1;7.1c)1'_::"(:..' b(LtAVJI:!((' V'_( .:LVI.~!ft.G' .
vru;;t (INDIVISIBLE UNIT) o/'..lJlZ /fl.:;;...JPI6'I . .;.-cf'l~)'tcf.
JNL"l,V~-::&-_'~J'~
~ I ~ ..
. ~ 0' JL (ATO~S)",!9.'j,", _;f.:V(U-: (t)
'4-~~...:!IEjot,J...fi 'r' (EMPTY SPACE) !.IP(.:.I\:-".JJLcJlj"'4~)'/,2_~f~'!~''''' ·~lf'.J
... (INDESTRUCTI LE) / ...... ~J.-:
.. ~LW,lU:~~~_'juJV:~~~~'6'
':7~J~l7.IcJ'- (THOUGHT) _j jl-;'.J_"~~~ t7.'()iI~ J t.Jr~\ t;'
t ,., •
~Q:.- 4- t·, U:",->f &:-
(HISTORY OF WESTERN PHILOSOPHY BY RUSSEL) 4-J;;LL~~7d..
~0;:"{';lL..:. t:6. 4- (HERACLITUS) ~__t.y"'J._.£I' (' (f, cJl:..t
(4c;.f .;.. tfc,;iftJ I) i.:;.-LJ(":, f "':-"" 0: (TIME) ;.. LJ.f'.;- ~ . ~Li.=..
()/;~4- uL-(a..£ ~y.~ J-: ...... 4--=" lJ) j:lv; ~k~~-1j£I./~' '(MYSTICISM AND LOGIC) ~J4-.J~)lif,",~-:.{uJL:tj,,:~~J~t
,:, U:"';JV!Y ":"'.J1o;"' ~. 4- (t (' ~!,.._.J rfli ...J/, ~ ... J";! (B Y RUSSELL pp-9-1O) u.i4.v8£~t&o~'I..;..)tF'L;.L;'4U;/T~~~~J.v:1{j:~Jltvl~r
- .. vvd ~f'; JJlt·4-C'fL(~.yjJ< 4 <y)jJD.J ~v-=,.~Jv~,:?I07;L_;~JI
,,_, . ,
011 ~ ~.,... " .....
• .......,/ J .J • I, J ~ V 'J
.. ., "., ......
.V;().J~;;wltj'~k?;;LL~
t.r1''''fr4t12-=--''''J-:J·~U'~~.k~~J~v.1 .. I .~. •
• ~,..I ".,... ",,\t
l1(.fcJl...h.(L~"'r"-::- ()j~d'·.z.._, ([(,.::h £...::..-'7"' .. ~
t4-t(~"J$~~(J-fJt.Jrt_Y:'4-tl;LLJyIZ-"'£(PuRPOS~~ 4 ·~hti;',i·J."J·h (TELEOLOGy) ~j(..(v'~;J~'4-L:r'e~./~~cJUI4
. .
, .. 7' ~~4l.ft"J a L~ ~ri7J~tf(~u.Jj'~li(.!"1 ~~(~~. ~
_v.....{t¥J?9-cJG'~(1I<::J'.::.,.c:('/4-'~l.l-r.~ ... Jj~()1.4 ~t;:t(,.;-Jfd.../?z._LV,(4.P~,~w ... ,4-Jf'rY:d..£J.oPL .. ....;($(.)'""/4--J:"Jt ··f~(.)'"'lr.Y7-'f.'y"((PURPOSE) .JJJ4-(PURPOSE) c: :~uU)J.' ... dLLd ~u-4"..::-t:(, ~J--0'.1 J../cff" t (PURPOSE)· . 'W .. ~~;~ ~.JIU';( Jk ~ Lt.~JW~.JJ~J
. "-' 4-tf~,J ~&:::.-#.;K &::r~1 '.J(CAUSE) ~~ J <.JJ)--{cJl~-0 ~t(CAUSE)..,::..J:VI~!u-,)J,cJl.JJI'4- (CAUSE)~Sd?V,,,:::j
.:t:o/.f('U'l.i~;'.JJIU; LJJJvf, /.;-jJ'pluJ;1.;'.4- (EFF"ECJ) MECHANISTIC) jij~'4-CIf..::..yf~JJ~(((cJl.~('~,~
.. ~CAUSE ANDJ~) I...:..J,~(li(":"'~ (/4-C~~ i..( .:;....);J';..Jiv'-i.J.!.;{ -=--1J~Jfl,'U:~~-i,,)'u{~j{r:4-J'"~.:::...::J.?j(-J' EFFECT)
~ .. '" . ~ ... :.."" - .
{_,J I..:...... "/.J ..
• N~~ ,
. .:; ... t!J{{ (pURPoSE)~(;~-::'4-
;(".ZJ"£~C:(~,.ji"4-p~~,I0£;:.,d£VJ.I)'~~' I..:.-t:: ?V'- ".Jifl.:;..()~J/..::Y)~dt L~ Ii ?~~"/if..f,i. ..c~~~v~4-LY ~dL.c (NATU_~ LA ,¥S) .::.._?Jr:I-'}
b:.J'~ .. CAUSE
"; to ~ • • ,1
cJI/<.t~L:::-: d- (CAIJSES) L. ..:,..~~ ~v' I f~,:!';'·(dtJI.f()j~t::'f.
, ~LtJ~{(EFFECTS) ~~·L
..:JJ()11i0)()Ili/u.J~I::~Jj,...~fJ4-~,IJ',":-,~"'ki ~
/.:.JjJJj·~/~~.f:::LvJ.fi,_·,-!r'-.tJ&.JY (( ••
. (DETERl\1INISTS)~~&Jl~"'L.---Y"?f ~cJ I.:'-~.P '''''~4-r.,J~ (MECHANICALLY)
.4--Ct,L( v""~£v-I,,>'J.~()P...;v!fv.~~~JwJG~L~~ ~~~vt:::L~Iei~t.JJ c,.J~.:'-t,yi-'Y~.Jtr,~~~~t~ ~-!ju' 'td.~u:fJ~..Jt$J(CREATION)J"1t._:.,~('~£;..a{rl~)~.I~J(
'~~~!J)~~~~,",I"",('J~ U~4L)lpf
· 400 Lr'~V!(.)7 ..,:;L..-~ t:r.: 4- - (ERNST HAECKEL)
...:..~~1:'(r")~ .. lM'~)J~~-:'O)~'f~L"l?;, ¢ ,(L.-£~
cJ W~~~, ~)_..,p"'~i ~''':'''....JU~~I~.J' r',lL-_~ ~~I:......-_
.Lr..(jdL£cJi~''') ~))Z {~....(,;; £J;::.~""; ~IJt.JI" ).JJI ~if.4-(£.,ItA,A.GIJ" "'...:.~(';;;' (».J> , \.OJ";; /. J ~ 11,,), ~J L :r.; J;'. vJ
~~~f~ to" , i~,...tA-cJt)~ ".II,i'''"'t-,J~ ~'-tL~~ !z;AJJJ,(;f')'JuLl~~l~W~-'~4-'. ~l::v~Y('~ ~L-u-£J/(.);!fU7 'i-~'JI,... ~ " J(~(;J I.J fJ~~tJLJI' /
_ ~'~~J.(JJ?'('VI'4-tJ'!z;r'(.JF.4-o{~~~tv"t.f~~(p
~,"J:'J¥'c.rf/&. (THE RIDDLE OF THE l:5NIVERSE: pp 12~13)
~X<.Jt~~ +u: JUJ,L . (PSYCHOPJoA..~Ml·tJ~..-i~'4-(~j(JCI}/(PROTOPLASM),J~j
ASSOCIATIVE CENTRE.S ~ "f '~.) ~ LJI.!AJJ"4 ~(JbJjJ'
"I~ II' .. u ~ .... ,.. .
Lfj ~ ~".~~ vJ.diL,) ~ fL ~j ~~J "J.JJ !J~4--L:t;~ -'li.J.,f"
· '4-~ ~'('~jPIL~)d
.::;..J'\F.{ "':""'~ £()'N"J.J .:;.J...0- ~ ~..(-'A.!lf.Io.::.:)L"_:')'~J.I' r,
'.(GUIDE TO PHILOSOPHY BY .. C.EM JOAD)
~~~J~ ,.., 1\ f~YVLcJU' 17~..::h¢"...{I~~J .. ~.b'%fo"/4--:;~(n'4-lY,4(~[y~if. v-{4J;: 4i..OU ~J'(;;,?IL()lJJ~t:::.-~"JtTj~~' ccY.~6,;.lJI)4J!U:_'Y.JdjJ'·VIi(j£:u:~~!f.;-ty;!!""~-:;.:::;.
. Zif.'(;~J·~J#&V:~!;.."'I('t:::.-~/Ii~~Jkr:--'VI"''';-'''(4- v-r"Z,.;:.fA JY,uj if.rL~; (f ~t())'j~)!~·IJ4.d };£/P''rf "~r.~r
..::,..'''?'J~~(MECHANIS~~~ (DETERMINISM) ~%X;t .,(,)Ji:£ (MECHANISTIC DETERMINISM
~J L 4.f'-4-1$ IJ ~~t.;; IL~ 'J;J~J4-J.r ~ \' ~\J.!..::..- t;.. .. ~ '-~""
. ~v:f£,j
...:. !;.."'~;.ai J,/J L.~,;' e» ~ I~"::"'.:£:~ I&,ALf +1J1f IdIL.::.E I~L ' J(ji ~.f~O;LLiL)...; ... ~.U"1'(J?J/(MIND)JL..i~iJ~;' (ENERGY) J(!i,(4-J'.I~i(CREATfON) J;liu:...::.-t:=" If'1 H,.'-b" '-'~ U?J
.. ~ .
f..ll • _ _ -: IJ~ • '~..J I 4;::..
'Jffo;1..,(IL~'4- ~-''' V/(,fl{~ -::J".,.7I'nl.c.!J~...::. ;i~':"J!.9''' .4-~I)j ,-~J't:t' JJ;-{~J 'tJJ,J)i.JJ4rI,~~Lv'p I,: lJ
.(~'J;ld/;'J'..:;.~r'/4(IrV-::(~""~t}~~kl!4"'JV.lJI/~r.f1 (REALITY)"'-< A:f1 ....... Lv, .. 4- (REAL SUBST ANCE)~ .F.07IJ~ -4(.)J L~_..Il?' t
~if'.tj,.LO:'JL'(t"J~»~~(
L(;!~;J' ~/4.7.'W)+'J./ *. (Jluf.JLo; " L if.u-"iJt,;''-:"f.lJ' . ~ ~.v'L(jI. tY, v..'f~ ",J'yr' ~ t) ~.:.-~~ VJ)
(PHILOSOPHY OF REI.IGION BY BRlGPTMAN: p. 38) .!.
· ~ (PHYSICAL BODY) • .
-':rf ~~J)" ';Vo"fr~t:JI~:~~J~IJ:"'!;~(' jLJ,U=:
cfL4_;~~J1(VJj4-,"Jlf'J~4~~ "
~~1.?t1~7 ~LvIY.J''/IJ.fif.~~.,~,.>>!LVI,.iJI4-(4)'; . '~l~·~.J~If/,(t/nlJ~~Jj~j' (GENERATOR) ~JI'.u
~ · ~ j ~ ~ C~ ~ ~ ',... · ; . ... ~ ~ ~ ~ r" ..' . ,
..... ..i r ' , ~
.~I~l:;,..,,~~;j'cr.L-lP..C~VI2..VI~i::ry~~~.!.,-l/uj.::t"'&rUi!
L,r.JWlff'::"'J.1 '-{~'(4I-J .. (".::.::tf"·~'-dJr'_'?
"-C4uf4~..r1u.!4o'J(STA TE)cJ~f~, L ~"':'/"If 1.t":"'~""/4-.Ji:'''.! 1V4(..(,.LiJILc.e..t~"j'~.1L ~f~)~..:.J~~Jif,JJ'i/J:V:'-:-'!i.'~ ~
~~-1;.rJ~ r'. !~YifLcJL), £. .L/-u.? dh:'''J_./,":-,"", ~4-i;:.G[)I~ -'-it 4"~44-uf~-" 1w4-'A I r-"lJtv'~(4-,-;Lt-'('y)J-'('~v,:,!j"2....v'>4-r\1-'f(~LJW! (:,I' ~ 4J~ck(J~LL./ ~ 4-J ~0 ~~J.J~44-J~~JJv:O'JG· 4.r'J.'(,-"JJ.L.VL~ ~c!"-:-' 1?~lv · ~v.!i ;""-IJ /':::-It::::...l,)iJl J~IJIY
- t ~)u-';~VI (MATE~~LI~T) ~ .... ~:)t....(,.v.tL11i'.::..,,:J'"'=1~41 ~tJ'~Lv'l::,~jy'~~~,J:LV:j2...~cl.4h .. :.~fY.l.u:~vl~ 1,1'"1"~4-&_;f~1(' "::'II~J_, X·I,)~ f.J ~yL:.jv ~v! ~ .tL.lf,r r.J(!~I~?4-(If~JIL('~-!~1~1~4-J~~JY.CJYJ'V:_';'I'f
(" cJ~I'~~'~~t~t....'J~v~~~(f.'~y.?'~IU:if.4-D."Jj_,{" ":;'.J~~J,(r;;:'u:v,t.Jf.tJf:;v:fU:.)'JP'.J~Lv'<I.::.ljJ;JJi/4-C"ctJ..M
Ji:::.~trl.( ~ ~ -4-(~(;/,A.J.i L.f. t ~J'1d{,1()j JJiv, ()J2 1lY' J' MI6~~tj'j'tc!()''7'J)~~4-Ipt".(u:'~~(J.J"YJJ#tS
.. " ,".", ",.
·4 ': ( .. " ,,~!.If Vi':' '4- '1 CJ .~ .... .. Vi;' t!;
'-'()j?';~«.d~~(,L:.'!'~JI·4-/.\':;_J)t(SENSES) VI;:d-~'~VI
~ a::4rL{v::f~.J"'J ~J'~JtJJ:L.v,·vffvjI'Jt.J';,~,(" if.u.1 ~4J;;)~GVI~-'O)~(.f":;.J;/4-#~':=-~jU)Lj~j~JJJ)~~ £..., iv'!:;14 vjc.{i 'W-L:-;G..c)'JIJ-(A J.'viwcJ tvM:!'IU:J_,L"; SJ~£~idJJ"hy t:dcJ~'J~?A"k) ~IJc: JI.J:I~IAj~Jl,l{'":4: ,.ort~£'T'ij4-CIf(;/.url.~l('v.r:-1.LJ)(~~ _~~/.L.VI'4-i/...::..d ·~()i$I1fJUJ.....q....{lj{!c;Jl::..--!JV'~JIJ~if""r'JJ~JJ"Jlw:.LI.f().;f iffl ... ) ~ ...f'~J~ (...:.-.,1"" r-4- (~.J"y.!' i.:J; c)!.J) . 4-c;;., L;.i~ i "r'r u: (~\i 9.
~)I.I.t;_~U~.J,"~k.~¥.Lv.f,.(wJ"::'~'4(lf"!{~JI ~~/(L~1I4J'.!J,fCA(,Jf~jS~7);;cJ~~f.tJ'=ft/(i/Tj~
. .
~,:~/'k ... J ~.I::"VLdL.·h ~"0v,, .•. iJ,-,~/';'j/.I."r.'v:.'f J( 1,,::",~~~J.:::..~j£0 ~~
, .... fIt'.. .,,11
, t
, .; • II"
.. •• J • .,
~£f'W" ,,:;,,~. (SWITCH ON) ~':!.I"I4- (SWITCH OFF) ~.J!4-~
.r.Jr:£ ... jJ;4~'_:"/o/n''"i ~:C"/')L::-o/-:_;'-IJ;:dtJJL-.r' 1.4-..J.~~LN. ~JJL- ~~.t.ftr: jjlt,...~_"J~.~-j.17;~[}1 J~JJL __ ;~
... ': "J', . .. v· ., 'W' f ..,... U (J .... , T ..,
(DYSPEPSIA) r,~Y~~L:'l;.;'_. ~1~r~rJ~Jr:;p......G4--I;.,j
1L::.·-;,iuJ." j" £. "':;'" ( (ANAEMIA) (...:;,.,..:Jt'4- I=;>.f~ c{' I!:; 7.v!'CV' )'L"'r'~ '4-~l~.I.1Aj,(~r'::"~Icr.:C(".d:'~I"':.~c.:J'~.;-!:2~)P~J !cJY.!u)~~(BODY ANDMIND)JI.-il~~y),'/.;-L~~:~IY, :t.t~.J.J;J!A.YJV)~'-/"~':")f,~L~LJ...7IUI.J)j~&..!!u/.Uf.Yv!I(.t't
o-o;» ~ W-;Lf~j{ JL.iy-" · .:;-C:,./~#.t:!.. L.~ ~ of JlyU 4--=
~~LiLJfJ"(j_;·,"",i.1 J~i~''':j;f~:(MATERIAL) t.5jL(~1f..
.. ... ....-:;. . .
If.;l ~JI~ ('f~Jyu! (ELEMENrS AND COMPOUNDS) ~~J"::'I~l?1 (£LECTRONS) "::'~.dI(ATOMS)"::'!:;~J~' (PHYSICAL ANALYSIS)
~J"'J,.u)J.Y,'d}IV}if""~w:..~J'''~'''L'';~'4-(If{IrLJ ;:L L.d../if Lv,~ 1.;-p--""jJI,.- -::.u) ifoJ,:j b.::-, PI"')~cJIV)d'
(DESCARTIES -- I590-1650)...!.,7t64~~ffiul'4J~dfJ~('t.5~/~)L 4A'_('-fCJI!:'i~~-,,-.ltt'_»J~J;T.L.vl.I5)~~~L u-'lAI.cC/,ttf (;-4<_,»d!4.JVL~~I~..(~~;.r,;;J;; tl J11 I .- MY~E~':'~'(.l!' ~'!"h,j4;:~((v.'"4v-"4Iv:...::.~( ~41~_j~VI£..::...~; . .:;-_...t""'~"v!HJ"4-,,;"::-/.(J-i,f(O ~~.f(l THINK~ THERE,FORE I AM).JJjJh~I~J"~I~_.rPt~t.tJ1f
rr
· 4-V*J,JljJLJI0J'~-'LL!.vJG':0~~~I~~!-"..4 ~,.;,jJJ:~'~dvJ'IJJJJ.",J,~~)J'IJ;1J J' UJ - Y I •
-:jlJ~t/,)!"rd;v:.....r.~cff,j;'?Lo/."..' .v:-- .)J _
'4<.Yy")L~'4-(r"''';~J",J~''~(xo;~(;.,£v,crf'4-lf,-<i(~~/u:."~L·~)r?Vlv.J~.{j,Po";!?JW~L(''')LJ'~41 (PSYCHO· It~JI_;'J~·~~I"'-'O~Ur-·t~.W' (OCCASIONALISM)
~»l'Y.!.z;~JIYvC-.:.c;j?~VI..~~ ·PHYSICALPARALLELISM)
. ?;J.::.J""L~~).:.t .i~v.! ('~"J ~""~6).w j'4:G~b)j()01JLJ' :u:.J)JJc:)IJC(u:~r;:LVI.d...~~J~~J~LiJ~")~l·lp~L:-:(Jt(jJIPc..t
~t~.~~£VI.~J~J~~J~-::j'!Ji~:'4-LJ.o~~..:JtJ.,i~!, l ~y,LtLJ.rfI.,f;;c?-"f~J!jt"1P':'.t..:..,,~)c:1~ (A PRIORI) J'r
J! JJ...r.; LJ ~G- (CAUSE AND EFFECT) JJ'1~~. (LOGIC)' ~V:..:;,J.,.;:f
'. .'" _,_
~J,J.v.~)~JLJI.f~JLjr:J;,.J,~~)J'~U..!--;-JI.I;':' JI:?JI~JUI~~fiY,U..\·4-l:f:qo")W-;~4-.IIJ4-:;tl.f<iL,jL)1 jG-~O)t'JL)I~~l?'IVI.~Jf.,;.::..iLJ~)L+-J~~~v."f'1-.;l-d1 ~ (4-6.,,0.1 I'-:':'JJ2-(,)1. ~~~.{~I'::::"'() L-iILl' (VJ LcP.'4:~Y. --f'~f4-Jl~~I.t.J.J~¢~S..;;,;.(;J~l) (ACTIVITIES) ~&SOtJl
~)t9'4IJ~~.A.'!£vljL'rJ1~J~JIv:jlJl~~~tt,L~~ ,*J.(.v~'t- tJ ~<:J.7 ~m ll.:-.r.- ';~(If)~#r ,!-L.~~tf!:; ~EVEN:~) u-i" )!'1.:::..~aIJIf(J~£vl»IW ~o_,; i:-;~V::OLJI~':::" "! • ~J;A~(;r...(,(' (MENTAL IMAGES) .,;.-j.r~v.:,-,""Ju'LJ~vt~£ -4-- c:t k<l.tiN-JIi' JU",~ ...i,;J"iU1.t.tLTi~v1!L':»-J tJ~~
(EPIPHENOME (Vr~J"I.ct/v.f}t:-/(BODY) jUy.~)Ij'JIU~ .t:::-J:jvt~ NALISM)
.~~;rL4fJ;I'J~~.,Il1~~'L~Jl)I~( I)
• .. ce:r.-0.7J 111} !-.jt1')~J()V'~4-l0l':-jJul~rO)~ ~ Y l
/1:>;awy.~JIJ"~-rJ,0J¥ tJ w,Lfht ~?7",.i:dJ"414.t...;. Li (c Yl -,~)uj .
J.r.iy ~J-"I" ~ ~I.::..f..-J!~'f.j L~.:::..ci{,j ..•. :rJ'}'
I. ....... ...-! -... ·1" .....
• I ~
.. 1I"'.Itf , .. t/ ~) .'
!:J.P''')LJ~I-:;~J~~d)J/r(MIND)~V:JlfJLJ'~J:Jif.4~L J:_V:.~~JIJ:_A-4,;;_,.t.JJLfit:C:£ (MATERIAL CASUALITY) ~
~IJ.;..(~;,V':'YU~.Lhr·7J"rO;~Lf'W'..Jf~£U;~'U?7~~If~();~ TiJz_").~/JfiJta.:f~fiJ;'~J/.....*:'4.,~V;J( (REFLEX ACTION) "
'4-C~~(LF.'-: ~~ ~ ... ._.; 'J' .'"],. .'"
R-Ufl(Y.J~j"'A~"rJ~r~IUJ~'U.r.r~v.:4-~~VJ'¢'o/.' "JL,ty~~tf.,L;I~J4f:U.4-'-YI).u.:~£U;~")vtJIJ_l:nU;%v)v'4
'-it J.PI .. ~/ ./ .',/ .... r'~,.., ., r ._(:-:. "I':
~ .. ~\Jr.·()~'~~U~~(JU_'~":-/L)JJ'!<.!1.J~~'~~44--
(~ENSA nON OF (,/'I.;JifJ£ ... ::i.J!? L~ L...i'1..cu.~~}.:;.J ~i1ft ~~L JLJ~JIf,-t:~(.(. (MINrj)~L-:-~IJLJ.ktt;"J"L,Gjl HEAT)
. .
..:..-f?_.;.iJ~ rr ~'fYif~dLJ,
(CONSCIOUSNESS) .._,..;. 4&,.;;...':W 6i {,-:-,-",-:, .. ~I~ ~ 1/..:,..!.UzY.tv; ~.L
/. . ~ itIit (r :. ~ . ~ ~ " V (
VI.J-'luJ.E:;...I~~~~'.JJ),b!qJ~L;J1w7,.....:.t~J~5A'·uJJl..;tYJ~IJ'"
• II- ..... :..
"/.J. ( tJ-J .J.~'.J l' ~ I ~ .";':..t.;
oF ~ /-'/'.." .. c...;..' ~ "f ..
~~:-: .~ If, _.¢t;.J'b"'..::.-9 IS c,H I ~~ ..w:,i~~m4- c~Ltw.(
(u~-,:J'U-:::4-~~(f. (PSYCHO'ANALYS'Sx?'V.(,_":~~?-~ tft',J__,.I.J," ~vJ.J_';;;~~t.::,,1JJ (UN-CONSCIOUS MINDJ ,!.Jr;t~J:=!
~:~J_~~(~;,tr.,.~j~U;J;~r~J·).i"fJW.IIJ;~I":;j»1fT-
::;,(f;J' 1 t l.,t I· :.,.tIL c: I.r~ f , It · I{ (CONSCIOUSNESS),
.. ~ J'"
?~~()~.:d.ll~JJ(<f.4-Y~~(»~~~ ,i!1'_;AY.rL£~
k 4-~~?J~J(HUMANMlND) oL.J,~f4-.~cHJ;~~JL u)ts;'JPJ; IJ I}j'~~ L"WJ LJI (U'-;-'f'-£;; ~L J(J ~J,l;; lu / ~I~'-"
~ (HUMAN ~CTIVm.~S~ uLtIJ l .. tL.i·4-..I. ~'?h: Y'" (V1~ t;:t':;"J -.:y..~#~lf~fjiflu:~J~(~~~ifl .. uJJ.-J(.,(.iJ;~.JJI~(J~
.!~ IJ W"'I'
. ~ ,-~,(/(. 1-1'..(
~ . O· . .
(J,.~~/~f~4.tf~~;IJ=:l?(~~}tf~
~~It..d(j': (EXISrENCE) J1"J/Sv,Jk.~v:i')(~;r~~J~jLJ.'"
~4-'J/~S07',~J~";4-c:.CJ-7J/~I,~ "'; t~J,.L~-= ~ ct~ u:i: ,'''' ,'-'Jv:.....:.tJ,.L~JL.JI'~JI j 4-J(/ j~ jl,...ill r ,
-IJI (l~IATE) (f.ij1~f!~:,jj.uJ4.JtL!~dt.£~VJ£(' ___ -"' ... 110A r.....:.t ~A,"';LY!~ r:..;,~'"-"~'j".JJ I~ (DIRECT) ~I-' tL.
(BEHAVIOURISM 13Y J.B. WATSON)
, .r. (INDIREC1) ..Jvfj~)I~~)f,rJr..,.; (ACCUMULATIVE EFFECT)
-.:r-t:r"rf, f.~,,~,,)f~dtLJn..:J.qNt..I'f'f"':'"'-'<!' r'l
L.J.! cJ~ _.)~ 5:!~~ cr.IJ o' • v.:1 ~j ~ I-'.J~I yt..r4;JLJI2..VI(r')
- .~ . ..Jkt~
~"Lf J ~L~)L~ .".;..t..:,.(F, ~ £..:.t::r"5)itfl4'.L(. J":;;VI
(PSYCHOLOGICAL OBSERVATIONS)..:...-4-(YJ~~ (pHYSICAL EXPERIMENTS)
,L (BIOLOGICAL RESEARCHES) ~~ J l!lf'v:tJA;rPJ.~·I~." ;;...,cjJ~ J'V..::..:;fI,,). v.: ,,:-,~I,,/' I~":' ~~ ~L 1,,/",,1' 1£::') ~ (J~)1)".t. ~ rtV1
flt'~~J~GEOLOGY) '!"JJ'! ;;I.,.LI,,/'I-J~I JV( 0: VI): ~ ~ ~;u-fc~~~~).IJ'If.iVr"-~~)""':;') ._to ~. r-;;~--
(LIFE), J_.;;~~c:C~L.d",,,;.ai'~J)f'-~'~"~I,,/'a.:J'VU(;+J"";VIv! (./i) J;7fJ"i..:;."vtt:LJ~,ctltl~J'N! ,.(J";JF,'-I$ ,jI.,.L.Lt£ctJ~;f ~. ~~,rJ.l'j ( .:J'1 ;;~£ U,I.; u-v-L - ...... . I. ,(,. .,. •
~ ~ 0
4t.~:,I)J?(~J'cCJ~(z.If'L,{Ic)~~J:S?L(jI))'?·4-o;~IfJ;"f , Jf.ifl/tf;J.u(J'I';:_t!-,J..:...-;f:;t ~ ... !.?' cJ:;(.J! t,.~V)~)IJ ~~.J1
JvJ;;;/.:V1J' J ~1f~().'I':".r.t t ..::;.,:;;,t" ~UVI V)',fl'k.,,, MJ.i "-.% ~...fI4 ~!rtJ"~k )..:.t:V';:J._.)...-rLl-::-G;Lc)11A7' .t ;_!r,; oJ(SPRING) • '~ 1_;;);';.,I __ ,~t;'LJt,$dJ ~ CI. J(CLQCJ() ~
~~{"~J~",:",~)(5lf~,:,v:'::-J~~.'df'{tJ'ct;f~,;I..:~~~~r~.! fi.'uiJJA~Ol.jI."o/'ty.)~tJA.J~tft!~~~~JI...f~/G.G"tY1.Jy:tfY:~
(SIMPSON tiTHE MEANING OF EVOLUTION": p. 13·14) JJJA";tt;J(,;::...~
(SPRING)? ",'.(I.l'f'~"'(J·:'I..~,i J.J(;Jj'......?.I£cJIJ{.J4~X;$J . c.J~Ir'~~~J)~(IJ).;hV.~V'.r:!..v:'~tS:)~~~~.,fLJ~~~Jk/
. ... .(fJkL-t,:,~,."f~L?'.;!..?:r'L~lJ~.~Oi
..(;jJI~..-Jii!:;Id.- (DARWIN) I;)J~').N!LVI ~ I j> "r:. -I'
~ (THEORY OF ORGANIC EVOLUTION) 9' '.) <t • J) ,
·~.:.:Lf~;J~IJ;I.L.J"';.rV.L.cJ;;d.b(<<.L.~;L-)"._(,1';~~.L.~ "9,.u..-~~Iv.'t-';'(~I;)I~~",~lr.:,,;~ (SP~C.lE~) ~~'~~L~-;-t:
..,_,Lf'I(.)."V: Cf!'; c.J1 ~ 4-JK ..(./.:,)yfi .::....))t cf!J) J ~ ~lP .. CRJ~I'!. • ~f:
(MATE.RIA~ISTS) cf.,L ;.f~ .u.;J....:~u:LJ;.,.f~(~\cr.Jo(,L~~Iy.:;c! LV}o'1~'i~t:,)I",:£~ ~.:::..~t_;aJ;JLt'L~)A.JIJ~;/4--:J1i('cr.4--r ../ 4-~'~('tI.'.:;-(' (VITA.LISTS~ dJy.JJ ~~cC~~l,("U:~.JJ~j~J~
.. "- .... * ~
, __ .,. .I..J.J ~. • '. 0. oJ
II ., ...... ....
dU._(ic)!UvL(0-{.~L!..P t:1tt-::.J4-~~r'cf.4-{ (FINALISTS)
L:-::",."j~.I.'u.; t, ~J;£~~~)tJ?(./'~_' _'~J.I~I4-J ~<.t~" d£.~ 4U (ELAN VIT AL)(L.lf ...... li"~jVI'JL.t.::..V! (VII ALiSTS) .~uf. (l'(~ (OSBORN) ~if(CELLULAR CONSCIOUSNESS) '-. (BUIS)
(SMUTS) .~t{(NOMOGENESIS) ~I (BERG) 4-d (ARISTOGENESIS)
,,::,,,-W.::.- (HOLOGENESlS) ..::...' (ROSA) .4- (HOLISM) (~V'vl...(.jL 4L;f'(GALLOWAY~.(L~~~VI.4L:(cENTELECHY) c:::...1 (TRIESCH)
. '+'./4--::~t,...j'r' vlj..c-,:.r..rt::-J'S~ b(IfLJ}'1~ m~ - .4-ifd'lL~c.I~V'~~~~~l?l~)J/n (PHILOSOPHY OF·~ELIGIO~)
•• J ~ ....., • ... ,
r . -:f: ?:~ /. r' .. • ....
C)~;Ji~JIU~~'-'J~J!W~Ji'LiT14-L)rJ~J.U-{c.b·'J/~h'Jif~u..,,~~
~ ;-~J/('..;jW!po-9' ;v.: .. ~JVUii".n.:L4~C;r~j~(.::.,wJ!4.'=; J.:,L rZe6jJ~~J't.f..;",}.Lr~~T'~·d>.J.A,tJ~L~/J~;($;J'~ (jt..Jj~/~J'~'l--V~J LJIJ~;j~~.J"I·YU(l""-'i 1.J .... J~.( ~~~ ~ t~I~!"/r.rf~tr,:?J.l1v'£r.t.;tjof+~JI4r~t!.dL£ct~jj,f·(;tf.
. , ~~"XSj1
r~~J;;J!")~SJ.."J~LJ:J~Lct;/u;.f~crf4,,v~; ()(;Ju':::'J.U~V)'~(jI)11 ;r/~~~u;,.LJA).r(..,-f:/~
(CHAN~E) 'au3' ~if~,-,",~~J~/4--:~)I~LU~ (CHANCE) '4-"" t;tii!(~ ~ £. (CAUSE AND· EFFEC1) J~) J..::.J. Jy LVI4-Jf.~
.I) I ~..::,.. · ).,11 J J
. ..
.((LJ,~J
.(J'~~(BEHA VIOURISM: v.: (PSYCHOLOGy) U-i\}f !v.i~.tf . !M'-~9v:ct';L+F.~L.Y:0t::-J}icJ,j~J~~~jt,)j~
7J=".c,~l;J~~~J~J~~'JI.$-:-~IJ~ .d;l?-l_LP
(BIOLOQY) ·~~1:::l¢"vIJ(..::,..l:Jii'% ~,";~lf • ~ ....
~..=.J.l.-JJ'A::'};)~-r....(,~if.;'~{~J~J~~/+.A~0L u.t~ .. 't~LJ .. br'411"",""")L~I"),"rt=; ~f:;I..JJ~""~U~ 'JLi)J:;SJ,d&,1 ~.;rC%~; (TEMPRAMENT) c,~( VI~i:I (.1.114- elf ,[(GENES) ~J
. .
~~~(f~ r'9 ~~,...if~c}~1
.L. !7.'~I( tf.)";::!) !4',_,~ i ~A"('u,j~)t.J'7d':'-"l' . ~~I(j/(¥~
... /.1 . t"" •
.. .."- ,
-- H., •• ""' ":
ct"4))lfj4it,Aif":"(.(J'y~LJ5I.z;S+=JWI (H.S. JENNIN~)
.orUY.'~ (GENES)~!f'11'...(~#J" ... &.J"'14-t:.C4 ~ Lf.1J;"_.(V.~ 1.t-'::'1 .... .;J::-~1J'4~~..I .. ,
u: .::.,,~~t.f1',f t.:eJ t.l~ ~L.If_,r -' ~.I.if.~J/~v:cJ~~~~~)
~~ ~c:;.(.f.J.I7~~VI w.1t! if.<.tc..t "cJt.JllV.I"'JI~J~r.J..~ (f.' Luf.;)lj"J~J~..:,JbJAi~~J'Jf~fu~j'tf~IJ~-:/4- uCt~Wlr;.J.~! We ..a?\"~'I.~)C;I·~j .,.1· r. ,..,(j~JC; IAI? I· ...
7"". .... " -~.._,,/ U...., ...... "'/
.. 4--r~~.ir.Ju,G.if.c;-{A.},~I~~)
(THE BlOLOGICAL BASIS OF HUMAN 4.(!_~/(~~J,_.JJ.I/~
• KNOWLEDGE) /. • ~ ~/ -T" .:I,,)j
lJ[f~J~v)'U)~v:dl./Jt..t5d.,t4J,aI~~'<J)~V)c.r.
)4-d (MCBRIDGE) ~~..I"I1'i~kl)~l,.J._j"t( U.~~~I;~'/c..(r~f?"~/Jt.f?a_LtX;~Ir.fI~Iu-1:~Ir'
.. . . ...,.,
- "V!JJ>r )!..t:I;f.l~.-::J-""';"I~'JV
(tHE GREAT DESIGN: pp. 135-158)
- f4,~ (DEAN INGE>?)kr-~.lW
"4-L:"- ~J~y'~~ j 4f1t::JJt/(J_j)[;,. J}f_,dL+.uf
(QUOTED BY VISCOUNT SAMUAI, TN IIBELIEF AND ACTION")
(Li .:;..j;'JJt.f~ j,Dfi.'/..J4-r~L/~):J~4-6.J.,y"I .. j"':""'i..C;Jiful .4/' j1if.{(ENVIROm-iEN-T) J?L..t..JL..1.,rr.'-C ~_" (RAW MA TERIAL~.)1.,..I-
- . - II
~l?1~J~ r· ~~,....t/.LcJl.J1 ·it~ -<.I4~.(~ ~.IJI('..::- i}'£J;~)JI)l--'~I.lJVI 4-t'y.'~~ y&.~ ;d_L"".t;if~~c,)'~yJt-i'u:~~')~-fu:f(rf.~~L~~vl
• 4-1>.:L/,,~,_:,,/J(CHANCE)'~t.;f,Z;,tvil .
JLi~~~~&;-~~v~lt.I';J_~£.~GJ_.IJIJFlJ~1 il~G.(]~SJF,jJ_;I(j'!~f4-if,~'J~U!;_J1~IJ;:JLd''''J.f~
. (THE PHYSICAL BASrS OF . ~c:.C~J;l (3. H. MOTTRAM)~~c.e:'r
cJ~~J;Li.\:),~r;JA'J;'~G..~.L"C:f.(~~~'()! PERSONALITY) ~~~j
cJ~\..o..../Jh( ~!r-_,...;-(uif rJ 1~("~'-.II.;'A.j".J ~ (..:;..lj(j'J!tt ~!;J,(""""" -:v::fV;::Ltffu] If./r (uJ ::!:...'f;:.'iJJeff.? 4-..1., (GENES) ,~) ~~t.r.~rl;.J'lutJ"',t~t:{.J4.~~4U-U!
. ~:k-c:.f~~Lk'l--~t~~I",~LJ r,
J .,...- v .. ' .. V
Yf41(..(!yluJ 1.:;-tC Ir U-1.::..Jy L-=-I';_' CJ. c::: '-',v.r ~4fi Uo"'Jj
( ~, f • c.Jj:f::.~ (,)!
,-:-,cr;'#~.I, ~/VIv'liL (T. H. DOBZHANSKY) ~JI (L. C. DUNN)
:.
..:cJjJUJ'Lu: ...... c:(t..fIPJHEREDITY.RACEANDSOCIFfY:l4-l~(i.F~
.IM;£Z_.t:J._Y~J',....L L ~!;JPIJJ'lfJ;_ fr...:.t~t.~ ju..;;ji/:L.LJ....{,p ~~J,~,~~!tr,cJl..Jt.~'-!ujt5~v<5;t;,J/<.C~~AJ;iJ (~) ~~I:".t: ,....Q7rU;J.1JFL.J_,l~~,(.t
(THE NATURE OF LIVING MATTER BY L. HOGBEN)
(THE PHILOSOPHICAL BASIS OF BIOLOGY BY J,S. HALDANE) ..,1,1
.IVJ~h.t;
k'J f·~!}i£J;L'" ;~Jj~::f: ~ t.t;.Lf.~, if'(,)"J ~)JL.ijq. l:J.U'~'.IJ~c.!AJ 1~~7.uJ J...~~; ('~';:A:U(jI~l.;ti;"j~ ~tt _t(~LJI.:::;_&9ILu)~)c.J' 4-CIfY.'~I"Jfc.....r:JJ"L~_..l~y-j~"4 r5~l4-lI- [;I,,'u::- .(ff~(. /.::,..::f(.L/.· .. ··· ".;.J"M
0'" ilr' ;r'~) .~~('(Ji'L£
.~/~te~/:)uJ4UN!Lu'
•
U--"d~(t;ft,."U';.v!7L~~ ~(.(..tJJ~J.'~}..,J~-:J: ~ J c?" 4'(,)"'(.f.""";!Ii '~ 'f. ':="1(j7 ";~J I.::;"J".>\ ~!J"'U:~""'.::..if. .UhlJs ,( "::";~J;ht:YOl.J)tr0)/4-15~92.Lq'fii.L~V't-()) {~,
J"' wf~ (;!,,)'))4--: ~~I..:.r.~J""'4-~("'::'lJ(;>(}I ~J()L.r-
. t.· ~.Jr • j :. ... "', '" , ..
{~, cJL:J·CJ,{qJ!t...:.'~~~J~()t'-,Ar7}iuj,dlid-~LJi'LJJJ:_,.I~ . ~"J'~)Ji3'':=''(jdj,Jik.,,~.;ttu.vv:~?y.)~~?('JvJ' .;J; ~.{JJ"t ("(V.J~_.IJI.~J (g)P (1. ..;)J.I) 1:::{. ti_~2- £'o/t:J..-;IPJ;!I't::-
~~JJI""J,>\~~,,)od""'j~~jJL..-~hJ(jII.f.U:I.!4-CIp~J ~ t:~...;J)I- !..f~ZJ'~~fff~ ;~);~ ~ I~~~~HJ.~ (()}"~.HU: ~L'r.'V:'_:"_..Ir'/.J ~4.1J~V ur:?~I~I~_~~JJ r. if. 4;)~-'L--'-")J~
~(;)I.JJJ~ 4-14'4-0::£.» !::N~....1C1'_;/~J(,/'~).~': f.::::v~~
,(~ &-.A;~ t;~'~.,J~h...t,?~VILVI~J~ "" Je..!;,L~L (AN III ROPOLOGY)"cJIJOJt ';'Lc/yLL..::.-l:ft
!:.~V}iJ;"i~+.J~'~.Lu~~1 JW t!. ~£t. tJnl~
~ ;("'~~"'~~~';'1;..v . .. ~ v r_
» .::,~~.4-jr.'~J\L~,J'if.4-~~J-h-~0)/.~ (RACIAL) ~ ~~JI;LY~C~(,~J'''ALtf;'~JluJ4~;_,;t?L:lr:J.JJ'''::'~ ~~,Wr' ~v:..,....,c:rVIJ;'k _(DOBZHANSKY) .JJ I (DUNN) !f'J ~ tp..;:..,H.f.J
'7r'0L1iv:ut~ .r4-~(.i'-I:..4/4-0JI4-J'...::.4IIl'_:"y J#L~ '4- .Jb~ '4--~.t1 .. ~,; r' ,,:,1"; ~I~. '-'" ¥i J~ (' ~lfj...:;) po' V"v.::~V"~
.. ,r4~~
-'JJ..:.~~;..iJ~j'~~.6~7"-=::r~~if'~J'~I~~ ~l;
. ~f t..t~.YJVt, C:~-'~ ~...._. =_---t.L----
(ATOMS) .,;:... C;u!f.' 4-0'::"'1;T.1( ~J.: Ii ~ ) ~j) L~'L~ J.,:... c." r (I)
J-::.f'£~~J_.I_;..j j w. Itt Vl~ . .:::,.~ ~VI.J;.;J( (.1 ~;) 4- C If~
.. (~ifr~.J~ ([~J~'j:)I";:"I;J~4-)ifif. (ENERGY)JL'I}v:-.:.t;:V,~J.liL...,:... ~;O)'cJl i ... ,
. . . . · 4-WJ.:~O~l,.- t..:.-Ir" ('''",Pi Jt:' •
. rf;;J=:tf;;/V:~,~j~~,cA;lj<..tJF.~./.(;P(jf:.rV)~f:,j~JI":;"'W~ {,...,
.(. . ' ...... -:»I4-~\ j(,'K'£I?LiCtj1.:'~ifr~ (el"v: JC'}(f,';~JI~
. .' ~('U:-.::..-t:~ ~~ .~(. ~.A:·.I\"./-".J~'-); ~ii£. P'J~
:c.t.f,J':(~ttvl.i/.~v)/ci,j-:. "':::"'.I!7J ce)'-:"'f·lil' c.P~ J{J (' "D_':..i~ViE..Vlif r!..::-r i:l";;.l4' I r' J~;.»I~ t:--; SA) ~.J"J J:J, 'Iv'S o-£v.~C;~)~.i Jfl~ 1.V;(j. U
-'::"-~-1';..;J~ , (Vr' !~r'~cJw •
•
. Jt~l~t(~I}J~~fiUV"JLL ~c,.,'>~/"'J:J,)~..tJJJ}:1~;.t;;_fLfJ!,J~~J~I"')luV~ .(~, .......... ."., I;."r=- ~.&.'.J)I~ ~I (SIMPLE CONSCIOUSNESS) J"
. _.:;.- c)j),(t('Jyifj(fi (SELF CONSCIOUSNESS)
V jo(f"lt.$ J'( ~..::A£J)-"J~c)Li J~.pJbt...:,.~('V)if." . i ~) ;t.f .::.-1)1# !./i.,.z;.JL)I(t~ .:;-t:r.J)L)J'1;'~D:lIVLctjj Jw. clLJI
, ~~":f;~)"( 1;£
... '-'_' ...
r..::;..fji_~J.,)IJ';L'dl.Jy.(J~J~lcllv.t.L~ ... ~~~t~(')1
~.V; ~;_f.p/.,cr.jL.
L::,:I""?";")'J ,,:;-,h)~4.i¥!.:""A::'} c)1(J' Lr;- ';"I::;..)~J'...:,.~ (i" ~,
. ~..I' f (.J.1 ~.{0IJ..{ t.C J..rL ~J I c.J.l;:!'
.J'. rG,1 ).JyrJ '...:,. ~'..:"t.;..UcJll.$.I,,;J-~ V!lY~?"4tLJut (~I
"--'"' ..... !..oIJ-{ c),
. L;r~~'JAJf~~~~L:ri~'( ~tJ'~IW.~LJI2.."'1 J'~'fX~~t¢V'~4WJ.:dlLc.!9~·~tr:JLJ' '" · fL.'f~(;(..iI(.Ll':~~.JJ IfL.If;T~wLJlj .
(vr~~I!f)..D'~~4-(.f.J~V)JJyf...(,~~W(U~ V)", ,'"
~ ~ ~1.P.i:. t- .:. ~~~ 1-1.P,r. Lif
..IJI4-J iU:d~·;t~~··~v"~/.:.r~r;:'4r}';$-{",_;,J~oft .,~-= ,4'
. ~4U.Jlfa L~/ ~'t($;
()~Jf .;~J(;~(JA·;t ()"'IL'-"~~r'.:.r~t(V'~Wt.JI-4 \,.~
4$ &::-J~ t ~~~:'-'46L. .. J(cJUI'-"'r ~~4-~JIL:r · ~ 'L·LI'~-4t.t~/~~&.'~(J ... )JLJI'JI
~~lP),LtI ~u:i",~(f:!'JUjL~,.~tji,[J4v~~I~I.;.~..,fc)t.JI(YJ .b/~;~ur~iY~ jUcJ!.4;L (ETHICS) ~tfV;vJlP';::_0.J;'JL-":"~JJ..::..-~~tC:~
...
~t..O.:_~
,-_- --------- -- 0 - ---
.. .. ..
)IIU:c)l.::;..~t:.Jlq;~~o;'2..UI~~~t~(ji-,.Jif...LjJIJI
~I...f' (EnIlCS) ~JLliIJt~ '4-.:;:;_ItfJJ)Iicf""'c/.41.(JI~iJ)iiUJ(~ . .:::.........,~~ib-,Jz.QjJ Wt(~'!~"""4-..::::..JItIJLiI..::-'~ 9lt.~( if.4-~
~LJ~-:-(o1~(M?'<.$ d '.J:iJJr'.;;;Lifl r!' (Li }.J4fVl!.A'4-(' ~.,I~)JI.)I(.f-,L- JLJ'VlJ'I/'J()f. ~ ~ \!' ~;fv%~I~ 4;-rt:.fV':;:;_lf ~~~~
1~}t~fTr::JJ";VJ~/~~.4-J::l~,J_,}-/J~~aUvt£~!Y.L~1~
- V~~~vW'k~ ~?J~~?...(,~I.~~~'Jh)~/~Lvl . -4q';'WJIY(.IV,(-=--~;..JJ~/L()/~Lfl~/"r:.: M:"y.f~tr ~t.n4CLr'-')cI.~~4-~~L.JI':::".J{ ~~;..JJ'~ /v.:+!.':-:r ~~lju.f(J7'JI.dJJ~I~"",,cJL.JI~"".u:f(j7C-fi (FREE WILL) "ldJ)Wi'~~1
~rU:j;UJ,L (RASHDALI ,I I_It:- G. ~~~u;f U:U!r"'V"(ETHICS)
~i.f(s: JU;,N)JJc.tv.f' ;t;I,jJ;.c (M OR~;;Y) -,J' (ETHICS) vl-!'-'lIj'..! (MORTALriY).J'I4-L:,f~~(.)jyPtLJ~I(ETHICS) f~/.I;!\.=.~WJ"",.).J,...~4 ~~jV~"tJL.JIL~;JJ
~l.(v:?ft;'j4-o.{(!;J('O.lJ~·IwG~;_t.JJU:{j'£L"'v' ;'d;VtPJ_UI~&f.'t.dL.~J;',,"")4--rlrUIJ,_tcJ,!t4l~J...t.F~ .())J_{,./.~c.J)J)~t;if:Y.f~JtJ,~>!, .LfJ..-"~~.:;-L"~,l:1:cf~
-
(~4J~1) .
~ ~I..$ 4).<9 .Ib;; (jl,;I£(f IkJL..i1 ~ ~I'. £-.=.,: ~J'k1')f." 1£ (f1cP.'
\ .. tY.,J"'· .. ''-ll~'(~ -" . I". (;)l,)lj (fHEORE - ~.J.
~JUI~~cJl,.JjJ~~u..'f'" J.' (li"j/ ItIj 'r .!.;:!..V1. t) 1_,1_'.Iq,;I~t...j .IIJ _.:.; (' J·V~4J' '-(fI(j'.I{J L.lrl::' «'J.r.' J.lf.l.il -: I(jfJ.z..~)1')'';;
~£(fI4-J/t(fI.:;;__,:tf~t;.¥~j"'/.ujg, , IL J "'. (, ~
./J I JL;~ IJ~cJ''i-J~4~~jJ ~~JI' Go L....,;\..I~_.J_,_v_'.....:O;.......;'d;;;;.....· _fw-"_'
)t :bFz.dJ'u-S:o~Lv(jLJI~lb"J.~~ldI~~cff~~'J~
(THE THEORY OF OOOD AND EVIL VBY HASTINGS RASHDALL VOL: II p. 302)
~!f:_;..Jj~ n ~,?,~clW,
~.!IP£{SENSES) (J'1Yo:" ;.J"~ 0; JIi.t Y. -'.J.J lo1J ~.::.. \r),,; ~'J~ .
O~I ~lvJt)IIJ4IfW7£ (SOURCEOFKNOWLEDGE) (~.JJJ
v.kr,..L..L/.:,.i~4.::.. ... :J'JI,..i,~ J"L{'J'I,/I . ~ L
.J)IJ/v!£c.Jl.;~y...:;..~~LcJt.f'xr1 L .. :-".{~ Y.,){
--I u:};wI£J;:;u;itJ; &:riP ~ cf1~ ;;G-./..::J!»~J:J'JA"._j/J'~(J'1,/ (1L.V-I.J:!t 6'" ~ L~jr
.. t I II' I j '"
~ ..,. , ~ ...
l!_!.,' '4tf:~~~;. JI"JL-~ . ..:.JIJ :..;.arV"'~~lJJ'4-J.J .
.:;....,hRAnoNALIST MOV~~#,u:'cJ~'''' ,;I.C"..wiJ,rot'1
(DEFINITION)~JJ/J;Iv:&q!,J_~lont!4tJJ·~U).J))
. .tt! ttl; u: !#UJlcJl
~cl;~.J"'!)))Nu.-/JL.J,~~:Jif.4cJlf..;~ju"YG.~
~~c::o;...' ~.:~ vJ.lJ'.c;-l'r .r ~ .f (AUTHORITy) ~~.J)J.J'7JU'~~LP.J~b"'~~J
. ~ M
4(~~~'~~..f~~ULL1.J~)j~~JI6/~~~~
~JWt~(:I.':') LcJ1/ ~(:.; 1";'/..:)JV,.J"-'rt..:...(U:-,,:-,~Ak '-{.Ii'lcJl
tV~Z4~"'~e'fi"'~).JyJZiLJ'~:-=-,/:,,~~li~~,~~~~L J" ~ Af.4.fiU.~.J"4-'~!JM~ct.lj J~tll,...i,~ ..r(~'l:J~" (J)!..,{'JLJJ,J~~(f·~.~~ ;') 1)j~LlrLv )~~07~J:U'tJ' ~J.f7'~
..
.. (.,{j~J;;-VJ~'J (HUMAN FREEDOM)
di'!JiP"» 1 J"tf' cr.(,J' J'l/'::"'cJh.J£~ti I,..i!)~ .. r~ '1-;JI.Y'I:.::..<.J1;1:
-I ~J:j ,:;,1?1~f~.r 4- ~.J.{JIJ..( {)] ,p.Ld..f.:J l.JJ
~,,~~ t!r'~'-IH .... ~(U' ~)OUI~_J.J ~'f'I~ .. " . .J' 1~ ~~ (ECONOMIC) if~._;zI' ~'·O.J~J ~ LJf~_)L~~~" L.'r (ECONOMIC INTERPRETATION OF HISTORy) _d't.!s,yJ c..~j;U'::::" t.4--JL(
LV ,,::;;:/u: {CO~MUNIST MANIFESTO) ~ J.J~ {J}..(t;; ~ 4~·:)dfJ,.(
"\4~(.;'t/3~(~"'''4'''", .... "J~/~ (ENGELS) ~(ti.JLVI.J"
~u:~v'4.'f~,J4 V~jro)1~",~t~&.ct~J ~ L,;'t U _,~ y"""f.I::-/t,yJt..v"'J,g~fo}L)J ~JI.ll!!.y, 4- b..J!M":;'.;lfOAJ'i!'!:-'J(j~cfV; v.:J~'Jift./tLVI.~('
~4~lfLl/~rv1u:~~t~~)V~J()f';JI w.!.:JJti J.?I!ILJ'...-:".<.O!L~~;.l.iv"1) WI.'" r:J' J(..jI~)!4lJ Ui4~L" J~,J.t?l?{J' ;v.v:J.;;':' (;ti..,}IL;'
J 1...J...t (.# ,,Nt..-t"t t,.Vl(EXPLOITED) ()Ii:;JI (EXPLOITING)
. ~~..,t·t(
)4t::(~L~.Jj~u' ~r't).:iJ~tdrS""""c)Jv.tL(Ii.:...?"",,~J.;)JV'L~J .I~(.?!..:.I& ..t':"'/'J...(J~ ''''''l''J..I!J._: Y '.J~ -:]rl' u CJ '(!Ii .4-
*J!( . lr'v!A·tJj::f:!.1 -!>!~ ifl ."'JICr~ .. ~~I(.f~),L.;'",)rJ1
. 4u.tLf:v~#'.J!f/..I.U;~l'4-01;J#~.J{a..:-'n,;;'/4- .
. "'f4r/u".GLiJlcJl~L:vJj~,-!~1 <TI/'I4('"'~ J(UiJ¥l.:/.-.f' 4-J~~~,!I'~Iu.:~o ~~Lc;_.,r .JJI~>1 c,.)UJV"~J0'V;"J~a.L JA)OL,.j,~~;' ~~I.r;
d ... (w).~,G~::~ J'r~~W!Lt#-:;
J ~lPu"'JI.:;..~v)tr/~J'o.=.J",~v.:y'-'t",..6)l?t/'l:JI1Z .:;- Vif~~J'~14-0J~t~~ fJ.t:'" ~(4~~~'1~~ ~6#J>~I~'~~VI.~4'[~)~?~'_'~J~~t'lJ" £_JAt.J~I,.,J'dt;7tS~';,~JLJI~jj~~r'~l:-'tf~L~~u,iJj ~.J/£~J'ifl.JJIJiA.l-~~LriL~.-~'~.~-~~&tJLJJjV
..::,. r- " .. , ., '/ (.J'
~t.tVI.l' ~~ (..(;._Jj';J,J j(~ ~JJ:;JjcJJ.,Jiu;~ f· ~ t.t~~,
,. .
. ~If~~ (ECONOMICS)
,ru,:lJ~f J"Lplf""J-oL 4.'J~"""L.-Jc)LJI_') Yif~lf,P(j""i..? tl:JUf.<f~!J.fo;':'.;~07~/J'~!,;";(}ic)'U:'~{cJf"L~J-)f*"
.14-l:J'J1v.:"':""~i/I~.u.i 41 J' ~)(L,;? ~~ "7»£J.-4; ~1>c.:J~·jOiG..~.J .. uf~t'""':'f~c.:JWlf~)J~tc()JL...iI'-:"'1.4 ~A'JffliVl..Lif.~o/.4 G ~1)1((;-~IJ(f.ft;b~4cC,,I 4-cbS";')!?cJ\')'~wVJ~...(i'",~~¥}iV~"'4-~yt .
(FREEDOM AND ~rlt (BURTRAND RUSSELL)J;Jr.)/.V~I-::.i! . .4-ifbJ~ O~GANIZATION)
._:.,tJ~1.4ulf;J1(" ~?Jt.JI?vC t;;t ~~.v:t (l: ~".LI(.(c:f.' t d t .l..O~.c OJUr?, ~.c~..::,..~;.ar.t'.I'I~~~L ''-:"1'~
. - '4-tdUIUJL~/~~r40'~rJI
~ 0'lJI.)J~~ L),y,~ J.LiU/J":-"-4v:: ~~IJ.iPJj-:.:::..-,j J';.JiLJ1 .~O' JU( (HISTORICAL NECESSITY) '-:I'Jif! t:J. (~<-tJdLL"JI)1
.#~~;£1J~JI4rr£~J;/~~~JJ£~~4-L:,G;"l('~it--:
J~uli..:.AL~ · "vlt~ .(JL.~/(':)~U:cJl?L~~LvtJ~'(.[I~ :L ~/;'.::'-/) JIf. J-;?"::"II.t'/ (1J;Jl ",,:,,;'J . .:1 r..,/J'4-'';;' ,.I> .I.t iJl:P
~()JUfl
re:L~jfu.:i(~.J1JIJ/Ut.J#~1,t/4-if.jJJ.z~"'..fl--LU1 ,
. /4 ~~-v.:":,,,~v~ uJ ~..r..::J !.I'':::''J;~C1LP
.ctTfI'4'(.~4(£ .. ~~u.~t;/W~ri/L$«~L~uL ~~,~.,t&"'~';;~(J.r~/4-J:U'V,jUI~.~.J(~~.Jj
(QUOTED BY SLOCHOWER IN ~.c;.J,jI-"""J..,VJ
"NO VOICE IS WHOLLV LOST'!)...,; .. ~ I./~,(" r;,", , . -
. ..::Jt'"~ ~~ (J"l1') bJ~JI!!- ":r" ~tJ'1.
, (OBJECTIVE PERMANENT STANDARD) ,J'=="'~wt;J/~~",,~~UiI (j ,
, .L!!_I;tt;U (ABS OLUTE rsunn {IJz-/f! /J_- -tr. .;.4tt'f
...,.... ., ,. (,)(J
. ' ~
/ ~j' ~Jf..iVL~ .. •. C V~) · u" r: "~L. ~; 'WI I rJ
, .. ~
.(./:f
J~tf ,J:./(',-,,;;LvJ~ (pHYSICAL LIFE) JA;~"" hJ~;Jul (r',
, ,
~
.. .:;....~
.~(;)L::"JJJrJ..JJ' JtrJ' J"LHlt.Vlt;.:'rO'A.,tJI.JI~}.a."" (1") ~ ~J; I).J; J';tJ:1;_~J4Yl(',.J/.-/VI~Cf..jlf. (~J
, __ ~J'~;?.2.~L&j'-l"~":'O:f'.f~vl",j._;.(1~.Io.?.~u; OL!b~ f''-!.d,J..--fJ J." '-1'::::-VI'4~ /J-'I"J,=",Ic...IJ;""'v)V{,.N~lf
(HENRY ;-IjJ;-;'4--r~~jt.Jl~jZ'}'VI.JJI4J'fJ()J,,~?~J
;1:t-aJifl ?.:;..d' if..(,~Y.JJJiII) 4t:f~.J;.JI?' /,r.V; !p!JJIL FORD) .
~(rl-"'),.:;..t:IJJO~')~(Li(UiJ()!:-'~;tr.",-,() .. "';~IJUvL..:;.~ .J)I;If£(~~L_"';'-'{'.JJ,J.l'it,.J!jt'J"JU ~11PJ;1(l1(/.if.
J:-:i')Jvf'~~ ~UiJ·OJ4~·J~I:f~~ .. r
r. .Jd- (MAC IA VELLI 1469/1527) J . to'
~ .. p
v~~"'~Zr~vl'4-"';;9 ('~k-'J(ljlo/"(LfJu, r~~J Ji'¥7J~'~~~~/~Jvl.f.!-j(...CT~~~~~fi~v'vt~tJJ .;.)J'tS)v{ ~~VI...:,t:f.uJ),tJJ~J (FORCE AND FRAUD) ~J.J}I,:::j
UI,!f4l:;zJf (.)ljJU!:-,(()'U~~~'--'~{ 4/"',4- 11 j _,;.;.._.(,.;.:LcJj.J~(.fLf~J:t"~L61~jJJ)'f'a.",'Lif~..tl:?'C1-)JIU
... , ... 1' ..../f /
~c-cf. ~ 'f~J ':,J~~LP~~C; I_.;jcf..u:r ~4-'d.Yr'J-'LP~~~I.J ~~
. / ~
.. ;; Lf ~ u I~ "':c..f"LP
_)iJ"~;l( ~~VI (MEANS ARE JUSTIFIED BY THE END ACHIEVED)
~ . .J~(bL(.l (LORD ACTON) ~;.JJJ~Lif.4-~~~'-'or·~ f""~UJI.,L (LORD GREY) ~Jj.JU'JAZv:f~II.i'£IJj'~ · ~<.:J~~
·1;LliI~;.J.:'.JJI..4~ ·;;t I (pRINCESS LIEVEN) ~~~~.LvIJ.'~ ':;f ~ ~ J:. ~() if"'£.-:,.~UJII"::" tJ.(.;o~ ;' 4-.r,~~' o» 0'; 1),(
. -,u.:liLiJwC(WALPOLE) ;'~()'I
(!lcJt.)'~iV/4-~~tVj.~U:t(.f~t5):~~ul--f -=--LiJI~I;trJ(Lt-if.fJu:f';f,;fLIrJr~""~t. .....
·4-CIrXo",~.=:! LwL(.)~
(IDEALS AND ILLUSIONS) (BY STEBIUNG: pp. 13-14)
'4-~!:r,-~dJ!ldtLj~;~j~.F.~~~;';U~
•
....__--_ .. -----
(pROS AND CONS)~l}~LLI;JI'-li~j~.::.- ... trJt;-, Jz7.(£..::,~bj_;..iiJ'~
~/~~~I~...(9.:'~~::Lf~J~J~~u.-;V.t;&YL ~:N~~ l»-1..:.t::If~'.d..dl..Jl!.;.1"tI~V(~r'cJl...il_,j ~J:J_;'; ~tr'':'''~~.J,l('v''~~~~~vJV~t/lJJ~)t4f'~4-I/Jf.,f,J,_f
~l.u:r~~Jif.~~JL(~~/4-~/JJvt~?'~j~)'Lvlf.:r ,J,.,._;;d~'i'VIJJlil~V! (LABORATORYJ~~I~I (pHYSIOLOGISn
- ,c.tlf4~r.::6 f:()..IL!4J~~~L
'4-J~d.!JJ41l1 .2 (' (Li L-i
.~4!. (BARS) '-};..:."'LI:!.t...~J..7,u-i(I')~ ·U I
·~cJ ~j~.JJir)':::"'~ct.J~) ,,..., .~~.Jy~tJ~~Jr~J.J~JJ~uf'~).'litri (tt, .L.~(;/.~JJ(~~if.}i~1 ~~, ""t .~i:'~"~~4-))LJ'/~~if.t~t:1 ,~)
.. • I I IjI /' _I'
.... L -?-~ 1"':'1 .. ~;. ~~JI~M(.(~;· '"
(fHE PROPER STUDY OF MAN BY B. A. HOWARD) ~~V:;IJ,JIL(JOAD) J.(~Lvl .JlIlI(.J~~JIf;:l1i~1kdlJ1Ht...:-l:!Jt!JLJI~I(.; tfli~"L.i,j'f 4y,-Lr'''::'!:-f 'r: 4 J1.t!. dL.iIj'~":(J1
J .t~I~Y"~L/L/J!.Jj(;..-J~,d.if 4-') ((SPECIES) c,i
~u;LftjJJ'.r~ J ~v: ~"'J~ 1~l:-r'hJ'~~.rP' ~~~(.>: -'J"4- 4f'4fJ;"~F.4JtrO-{t~~U'ftf4'y;L~~LJUI(.vi' .,",~LiP/~£,""IF."'''''&"''~~I~':'~'[email protected];i'o,!''- 4!~ vJv.'LI.V-'fo~v-'c)I/oulJf.,j ~-i,~.:. ~.LU-
J~£jLJ~r.'1()tIJ,Z.(.rLc.J..J..(.,'uJ 4/oLLcJ~III~" ...iArf:JtiVjO ~d.l-1.;'~J.9'L(./'Li~'-t'f'"U~~ #uj)f~~,".H>~~"
#4--J~~fVlo;;·4C"t{~'"
OSOPHY:p.
~rLVI4-~.lVcf-'J{~L)I<.t~~('vr~:S~li~i.!(}icJl
. .!/4-L::6:::;;~.)wIL (SHEEN)
t.;;...I;JLJI.:::.....>:tcf.'c.tG:.Y.S~VIJ'c.i"t...~~a.;.L~1Ji l(i1cf.1,JY.,":"lliIi...(,v:.fu;u1 ~J.J{tJ.1T,(i"'cJJ~ ~~~r"'~t:~ ~V'F.c.C)~..(J~-::('vtMb.-icJLJ'..rr;;- .... ..i·
. Jjl.:al'£0Yt;;;~_:;J~/u?J:~!t.tYi~~{":"~~4-~?(jt.J~Ld:£.,""I£..,::; ~~~~; u !J·t.f.t!:!-~j'~J'~WIU:(j'Lt ~?CJtJI~.t;';)i'~cJ,AJ(t:; .Ld)'U;.I)IJ'~.t.L~c:f-'.;J.S (.ffd~"~ j J4 ~ l!t¥.!" ';:'laV,·t;.C~(.}:hs;t/J,~t'
~~,,;&""~~~t t'JU, "..rt~1U t2..X j.l_'J~}.L;,~. ~L
II • • ,
(SHEEN --- PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION: p. 343)
cf.:) L)1 ,-:"rfI.,w4 .:;..c?-J{~Jo:'.tl:.ll.·j,v:~t:((I!. ... ~ I LJ L./.I.IJ4!;;l!&V L~LIJ,,-:,,)iv",>L - .... (j (j ~
-:~~Lt.. (FATE OF HOMO-SAPIENS) "':'"'03;1 (H. G. WELLS) {1:r,,(.$l
(:)'~~(:!U'·(Uiir'~j'~u.'1~JJh .£J..k:~'V1
· 4-~h~G..(./'t"J&-':;-~.J":"'J.~~)" Y~v.i;J;'#S;~ ;~_";O.Ju..;()i.t~4~~~L.·h£fJ~£~h'Lfd ~~(./'I,sJ'~a..;~clL.J'~'..:.,. t: ~.J~~~4,..J-::U:
••• ..I!!: • • ,
..;., 'JA !I ~ 7.' ".I J ~ -:JJ ,J J
~.. .., .. w" CI ..
. ~~A,u:<f..;.,)/~~JI~j'~~&:-_.j"~';; (;JWI~t(:))D)4~x·tJ'N~~~.J/{~(./1{WELLS) ~.fu",
(~j~(~~-/j; Air/~4CIfd.~~~/:V:~;"JI~£~·'~/~~~4.;~ ¥1~~I(jft:rif'~£(/ · :J..V!4-J~J ~ ... ~;I.f~ .. J ;J/~ (G. U. PLEKHAN OV) ",=-. =..£C~t..I.'",:", ~VI~.(J./' ~#"J'; j~I..AJJ(.$ ~) .4L:.t"",- (THE ROLE OF THE ~DIVIDUAL [N HISTORY) ~C(d:t
.
tJ¥~W~JJ'Jk,..tf'-':u!~.I~VI;:':'V'-.d/'-:(~I(./'l?I~~
,jt..£'VI.JJ'V? ~~'J t.rIJ ... ~i~'~ /~cPta..~/.~c.JA?t
~ .
.. .... '1 ..... ..,
-4'ct(L"JJ£'::" ii"o;..4 ~REEDOM) .,:; /~I (NECESSITY.) ",:-,F.J
UlJ.,;;}_f.J'.'-r!J~f40'f'1l,s~tu~(,;:';_dM!£VI.(,)j f~(./'I4:k!'U~~I);c,/v:?~~tLcJltJ!.ctfv:!~k.Al'
."_~UVcf.o/1V'''JI;~, ~;;J!? -:: ,J(.J,,-u:f ~J-tlu-V_'?' J;. ~ '. · ·
.~.., 4- 'k J",!;J,,!).!
..., -
;(~)~r'&.,;.vj', ~L).L..:"~~J~K~l;r~l:::'i()lj:fU~t,....(.,.(",,,,~,k,trf~~t'/~o! . r' "T'/.)ic-(),/GJ~JVJAjcJl.I.J'4-l'~<1~J.JliJ!~vi..t~~J,,~'!JJ
. .~~Jt.G .~J/t~'f ~1c.f4-! ~JIJ'.A~LJI
~ 6 ~'e""V.J...cJL)1
o
.1)1: .::,.)V~ .:...JJ.:::..:JiL;;£V'"':-"~"¥;
. .
~).J ~ "01 I ...:!.t t...:,.... :.,IJtL...,,).I- J.. .. ,'1.1 "."
~ v ., .. .. --r- Of •• .\;1
d.lf'~'-=-,y'(;J'4- t( ~~ c-"-tf~,f~'J ~JJ.I~,Lvl~ J/v[r,
. • 4 v:i.l~IJ/~~·~
(£J'Yr'JJJ.-?,~~~~LVIJv:i'~!J'J~~/~(jL.J'~~~;
•
;C).j'v:t~
L",rF4tu=~LcJU':4-~t;:tJ'JhuJJJ£"'::;~((£JL/fal'~'
~~'J1~/&v'~o.JI;N...:,.I.jIJi,.;:LVlt~,J;"J'~1.Ii .4-JtJ$(f, VJLL~J:J' ~ t VIJ"v" J' l,...--J;J..:L.VI4-l:t' ... /JfJJf/c'LJI( M .
. .~cttp. .
•
. f~~~~I;L L~L~fV£~~JJUfc.a~~or(~,
Jtp..J/~(J~·;tv~a_VI~JA·;t.r.t$J.iJ"'L.-.r./;;~ r. ,
. ./
. .~~
· 4-c't.- bJIJi!NfJi{JIPc.rI~ ... r"A_,/cJL..I·II~ III' JK~'...:,.t::r;.4-'~~~J/'::"L.,....o-LcJLJ'~ubJ~u'('r)
. ~~
IJt.cJ)JJ';, ~".&~~~~.~~J!,p.J,::i~"::'-.I!Tt~..iIIt"; .f~r,t:J.'..::.~~(I.A~,!;!_'-"J.J£:.'.I(.(":A'..I;)
~ ·....:.c~zVJ'vJ.;~Jiv:~r{;~LflJ.'td~t"'J ~ t() .
'. ~IJ~4-J~;eJIJJV
l ~ f.1'.t.;& C: utl~ LcH.)I»J..::.t:r'~ ~qv .I~tf'":""4J ~:Jt(;tJl~It.tV~t.;.,;JtJj~"J,!t..J1'-";(V~cJ,taL~tc.Jt
:.~VJ"~)}4-VJf,~4-ifJJP"'I;)~((PROBLEMS) J"-,,LjA)JU, u:1u/'Lj~~LUi'd)_")vJL:Jf'~(IJ.r~~~~';:J,~:)jJ.vj) _~JJ'}.
!~./J!I-""'d0l./LJ ~.iJ L.J I/':;"J'~ .2..£Af' ~(f/((d'0"'fr.· "
. 1i?d.~(,)L(J"'MI'T- V'J"('jl./~;~tfl~j;'
~4C .
. l .... ~
~ ~
£_
(PHYSICS)
L"*JW<I)
...
¢JJ.r'1S :/.::-v:I:JI.JJ1t..C 4f. ....t::tLt.J:f -w 4.~"y1J'CIo!¥.: . ~.:::. ... ·~V"..::.- !;jl:J!A(.(.~ 1;;...C!L~<S~i .:;-1/.,1:' ~.4-f.J}'*M vlf.J!.I.j4-.J~,pt"'~~.JJI~I-..Lc.rIMtrY,'~\Z1'J/J"d'rU L ~ATOMS) ~'~J.=tI~I.:?'I''-l'tJVJf~L~;6 ./~tJjj 1.'~.(f,<S~J'!4jLv.!" V.lr~;~U~.JJI....c~o; j{'iJ:Jc;~L,;:fcA )_y'LiJ.r'tf;~r;i._.[.\L.4-J.LiJr:L~I;;I;JIO:'JLiJr:4;f~L# tJ~J,d_¥''4-j~/f's·flVi''I''':''I;jif,I.''~'':;'I;j4;(.1;y'':;'I;;L ~.i:iUvL,{J~L (ATOMISTS) .J~~JL(;(-:: .LJ:t,~L",dL 2. ~4'()! (PHYSICS) ~~v!,,~ LcJ."",.,tJ..~~J ,;lLcJ;"'cJ~'
~ J-Joi....(,( J~ '~:'YJl'r£:;..tif( ~J Lu!~.IJcJI/~~~o.t::'tI ~
'WJIJ';"'~ (PROPERTIES) (Jj.JJI (CHARACTERISTICS) if~L",
~.4'(ANALYSIS) 'I!;l(r~,-(.t (LABORATRy) Jr"u-1"-:-''JfIJI
(.: 1...{i'ct;:f.W .. ..t; f"JIJ:f.Jr:/ r!J~ vi: A I (' L~r:~<.tc..r.fJ;Jf~L~'"'l"'I.(MOLECULE) .J,,",~j(J~4ftr'0Lc:lIl'JJc(~~.JJ1
.tL.f:o ..... cl~(.t (ELECTRONS);/. ~;4/.~'I'
cJ~J~("~v,J2Y~dj~'J,.;;!t (ELECTRICITY)~~V'':''~~
(ETHERIAL ENERG ... ~I" .. -, ..... J' ,,~ .... ~. (' (ELECTRO ._:.,U'.I.
~j~J;i.i!.J;-tfjV9-~f1J~LU:I!~J;'~I· ~ ~ili L
~.u.·~'t;;JJ,'JJ.fb"'"vl~Jlf«H. H. TURNER))) V ." "/ ~l
(PURE ~d'k~(~~(ENERGY) J~ljJ~U!f;;Jj4"L.t:/.~JL
MOTION)
. C:!...U14J'"t.a.LcJLJ'(£ .... _;..;l('v,~4-1/ (pRE MOTION) "'~.z W:J.?'~).;~~7£.~..r;r.u;if/t!!: .... ;L .. PJJ'~W.:.Gff ,.c"1iL)JLJW"4-\f)y·J~JJ--,SvL ~)Jt..:.t.;'*AP,~.J"'WJ.'J. fo((.."j&' ~ .,:..!;;'LifJ L~~~~~J."':"".::!.:-r" ct!ui Jo",j{ ~ (fJ y.'~ (WILLIAM M~DOUGALL) J,~J.{.4--J4't~,L (SThlBOLS) &..:i~~i
•
(BRITISH ASSOCIATION FOR THE ADYJ\NCEMENT OF SCIEl'!CE) '-.t,.'1rl",",
:., l,iif Lr,- LkJ~tv!lf"~»""L '(;'L£ ~J,..~:U/_..,.JUvt('if~Lu.:~JlJt,...(fl'r(J"!" ~(v.:4J-+~G"~ttlPt;,Icf..tf;r:,~JzU).'t.d~Jj(J.·;j JLJt'~'.!;'/t,...~::y t~~~~p'~..:J~PJ~~
~L(..r.\:A;&"'($JL~1 ~ t '-l1J~21-9-tJ~;
.,... r: 0;...... • A""-.r-,. r'
"H·lj,JJI~J ••••.••..••.. , ...• r 41.o.r' /.::::...._:.,J;.J'"'JL~~)L¢' I.oV'1
... • oI!'.
~!J, Ij'~ ~ , ···4 ,..) ~~~ ~ • .. 4- ,ct',,; ,
~ LJc!.i"J,4-JJ'I,P'.:.v ..... SJ ~J} tJlJ...", -i.C~t (ATOMS)
4! (THE LATEST IDEAS IN PHYSICS)
l. (INTRODUCTION TO THE FOUNDATIONS OF EINSTEIN'S THEORY·OF GRA VIT ATION)
~ ..
(.f)v.Or'-:-".:::.)~tv'4-~lfif~t~~JvLfh~""""r: (U (ElECTRONS) ..:,,~J. ~.-.::. ~A <.fj"~~.4--f:ya;)r,_' ~tI'
.c..J.7~"Jt..G'.JV~t~t::( 4:-J/~..:.j)ii,-:,".,}J ~ .d...1.::"id'17~ £'J L~LvlJ'..::.~J', " r( -:: -14-c:J'~?/ . ..,:..~~ (,1I~v.t V)-1 ;_'.Y.:;,~r'" J L(LI.;J4....:,,)'V'0((.Ij(~L~,.,JJ
(BOTfLED UP WAVES) q~.IyJ.U:"(."w..;.c..t'! (,1£ (WAVES) ~J !J'::"'VI ... LLti'4-Clftf~.JU!fr'rUJIJWI.V);tO)lfu9.'
.J.If?V:<J~~t t:a.tfJ~,,~0'wr.ivJA~.,-J Jjl~t..d i k (A.;..J 1f • .J ".,) ~Ii' .~/L!r.;.r..:.t::" ?LJ~dL Li.:; 1.I;'ucJl
(THE MYS~RIOUS UNIVERSE) 4~
-4-if~:::"<.Jut~W~J/':;Lo"~ju~1 :. '''''LJ . I.
~-:'- b ~ '7 »» ~
(1f~~!.J/4-~~o:'.JJ~I~~J.WLcrl!-lcfj' 11).. ~ •
~~W'£~19..1."'-li·(INTER-RELATED~VENTS)~J'?'i/-="o~JIJL4 L' ~JLkV!· (TIME -- SPACE)-JJj~-cJL)':/c.tt;~~L:PI~
~/·L/"~~~.J.J£ .... 'J~;d~J~J~uJ .. JJj£;~ ":I!~
~'Jt;k'~~f .. -TW I..tJj~""J'?U'dJjL;.f4-'J#"L "W~~;.J"_'L~.I~~jL'-r"I~~J!"~~L~~,_(,/L,~ ~4-*t:I.,.iAlf"'~)tI' j,JY~f~thv_,J
t1 (QUOTED BY IQBAL IN HIS LECTURES: p. 49-53~
1;¥/.:.r'J,f.f,~~"'~-'JIU)'y'uji.u-:'IJtJL.:::..-);'~tcJ~d(r~~.J~';~.~/~lt~4-;JA( (CONDENSED THOUGHTS) ~1Jli'41
.-I?'J(.J.!r.9.'io!:Jt:v: •.••.•. 4- ~'~Al<.t..::.6£~I( i)"~IJ.~t,J~ ():4- (THING) ~~.'7-0~()!W.fu:1Wfo~4--J)Ji.J.JAr ~~J"'J'<EVENiS) ~.Ivt4- (ACTION) Jf i:c.tf 4T- (Fo.RMULA) 1I/.JIil.tJr~tJ~ 'i4-~J-IJ()I;t}.LJJl;.,).I,~
: Ik "{-1tj_,,,)'~.I.fl(b~~ L':JIP""JL "u4'4-W./ &J .;:LUi':=:; . .~~~"':Lf'~.J 2'! t ..l.~j\t .. LL'V",J L •••••• ,~ '"" L-Y,' u:rvt u.!VI.Jlj" u.~'J'V~/v.7#'f~."'(CONDlTl~~ ~~V::;WI£ (OUSPENSKy) ~
.. 4--J.I.' (CONDITION) ~,;fv:r'::::"($JtJf(BLINDNESS) cJ.,t;~I,::J.:;.'t~'::::"J:'~~~~ L~~f$~~~.Jl.;-t .. I ;t"!.::-tl~~~
~J~J.~I"J:~.~L-:~C7.~Vlr~~~~~t::(OJ~t(~
elJJ.:+""(.C-.::" 1~;i;!f,.,;(J! ~ t:G,P";JJ ,JAJf4--A lPJ ~~J~ ~~I~
~~ • JI/f/"""I".J. J"
.~''':'~Okl~~(,) .. AfUI. ~OY:
--------()--------
d. (QUOTED BY IQBAL IN HIS LECTURES: p. 49~53)
.
c! (MATTER IS AN ABSTRACT MATHEMATICAL CHARACTERISTIC OF
EVENTS IN E'MPTY SP ACE') SHEEN: p. 203)
l" ~ (MATERIALITY IS THE CONDITION OF EXISTENCE IN tlTIME AND SPACE TERTIUM ORG\NUM: p. 213)
~~:/..:- t;:~~if~ .~::lrv:~;:J V)~~Cij.J'" J"::"~;cSJ~ (h t":l'~~ ... IZGI£O'L..IJI~~/""~""L.::::...e;,jpl£cJli ii,
.. jfrt.(j,f
.J~ul,_...-"J~u-v. jiLl- .J~~ L:il'::_'J._ -).JJI Iii'
----(~J--(LIFE AND CONSCIOUSNESS)
..::,.1 j:1~':::::"'L.lC 1~)'Lul.J/1 ~ ~ , (SIMPLE CONSCIOUSNESS) (SELF CONSCIOUSNESS)
l:;;)4-~L:-'!..L~if~~L..::,.~cM • I I ( .. ~ • • c,G-i'U:J..fJ v)tifl.J~'" ":.dI~.t1I:Y.G-" L u::t.l J ~(j OJ )j)
•
;,2 .U;j,~.~ (BIOLOGIST) r5.~~J;~.J1t; (1. S. HALDANE}4-
. -r- ;
.
~14JyzJ.JV. (THE PHILOSOPHICAL BASIS OF BIOLOGY)
f.('..::..4LUj""LJ2k'/IJ.::·\.JJJIv:d~L.:-~c.rI"" ._:., ~~J~cj'.§.(.}!fI'Ji~t ~~JI:-?IJ~~$~ (~Ct, u::?O.J!AJJt.tv:L;:'~~'Ut.JJ ... J'»:~~~J'~tf;t'f4f~ Jf~~'r(,,(Mt~~((if.~~J.JJ,~~L~t::L(rJ~v',1 ~"J01~~LJ")IJ..!J.,~'.~/~tVNj""
IV;· .k~JJ'~. ~U)~~..,;:..t;; "J'-: vJU:~ l.!:,.p; 7"-.Jl!'IL (SPACE) cJ~.J~'~;;;('::"Aj;iL (TIME) ,:.~J(.jj
J:GJ;~~)Ltv'c:=~ 'fL#t:J-t..i"Jf;~4"tJ:;;t
/u.f- -rf."'I.!Zv:"ifrf(iY.::l:'Lr1, :-d..If.L~ I;JWlo;,;
, ,~, ~o'l.~':::""'JLV)VI'::"-ljJ{.J,
,t. .. THE SCIENCE AND PHILOSOPHY • ~ -;
O. "',. .. O{
(PHYSICO - (~"J~:::R~)if~G-""j"'£yfIlCJWy.j'4-Jl'.
~i',L\;/~Vlctf4-...s..,l.«P ARTS) 17.1+ e.(:Jr.~ - CHEl\1ICAL MACHINE)
ur~"';~'~LJY"...:;-~~v:'t,..t;~juJ.!../r:i'.J~J)(~/
",V::;~j~!£'V'.u1J?/V:(P~T~~ cll~fu ~"";.iV)""4u.i.L;,,)J ~...(,/JL,.:~"':;(i
Jto/I/-;J1.t{J ~.i~I""v: "1.~ ~ 4 .~; o'.::...cr. .::rbCJI( NJi
U; ,...:;);~ -::/I:;.-':J.Iii-::JU;~1Jvo J'J!1f'" vi jc)lf '-:-"!'U#I.$ ~v:fI~,.0~t~j)l./.;JI~~,,~jv:(:).tY1( t.U"!~;r,
~ U::).,(~~Jf r#~..::JIjy'''';;''';/h'f.dJl (r11J(~'-'~'4-V.::..-1lt..,t/~.u10)/~t~1:'Jv""",f'j~
(.!!,..., .v.j lv!L-=-~:;.JJ~IK
· .'4-dJ!.JJ,._(y.u,tff
• t':J.:ai£ (BIOWOY) .. ;:.).}'t k..-Irt.( ~JfJ'_,;;/ +".f~-:. ~f~v'f' (IS OBJE~TIVEL Y REAL) '4-~~UllP~ tii~.:=.t1;.7~~ut. ~/u:ft$ cJ~':::""J;S-=--1;..JUJ~' J~ t:ft' ctf'.~~.r':J,Jtc..tc)~J ,(:)L.l.( t.JJ ~~ (A,pPL Y) ~/1tIV
•
~t.J}:UV£~ft#JUljuA.~~£¢JJu~·t~) ~~~
..
• .. Jt#
..f~ _;.i _; ~4--l:.H;
~1I?)'~.u.i~uf~,,",I<.t(-M~....((. ... .J.J4.t,-'-.:~..::,.~cJ' .
~~!J~yJtJI4CIpGY~4rlcJLiv.",'»r;.z_lrtt~# ~i.CJf~lt.r-'u:uJO:;'vLcJt~&:'-{MECHANISMY ..:.:f'~
,f""Ji''J::;LifI.:;-~fi'~.JJ1~41~''''4-L'";'~ r-~:,,-....{i'£' if.t(':JJU;;{',.~~;£.;:.A?1;.;tfr;.'4-J ,,;~w.J~ fi{tl / t/&.,t '4-~ /rMAINT AIN) ,i ~ ~1-:,f4-J.t'1t; ~\)'" J;'£tJ:f~lf·'f'i-w.,!(j,.~~~(J'f~o-J'+'.JJj4--J" if'LcJlf4-i.,~~Jtcpf-< .. "",j~I~~-::tr ... :;~J;-J}, tf';~~':::J:)IJ.IJ~f' (EVENT) ,b.~~.~f..q¥ '-.II.- ~~_...;'4-'.(v.i (PARTS) '-J.{,.(£ ~ tfl(: Jtr: 'Ii (!" 4!!.. L('~4(1f0:~;-'~~:-Jl'J,:Lif~cJl~:(,/)~~LP'::-_ -:A.t..:.~_,J .... .J(,)-,;./;Jt~VIf''::'-'Jk/41~..f',::,-,''''''LIi .L»!.I-{'-/"m~uJ2...';J>vA'(.~':::"'JI.Ao·vLL(.if.'''-?~.iJ. u-"t4o .Iy2z ~tf'4-J;.,.; ~t!r~*L-:!~~ ';VV') uJ
...:,.. ~r' _,,;:' ~ .~ .p ,/ It
~O()JJ-<~,,,,_,;:~·~rt.f.v'~~'-c)L/~'()~-'F,"'~)-{~~
o¥'tcf.J'4Y 'Ill i~Yv.ldLjI
~ j/~Y'-:; I~ -4-JIfr, d"'" +cf.'} f ~..; ~ (' i'.o/.I({';£CH.lJI O?-~~.JJIG-)(MAINTArN) O:-=r~'!4I?~""~J!~
JViJ~q'/,L_v.'f 6(/'(' J. 41:1)J' )/.:L",",I...y.~fi~,;" IU!; ~~(..(Q lof .V!1L)~II."':_";~lP~ J~ 4J'~...::.-u"/~ · .. ·····4 ~~J~4- _/f.JJ '40- u;-",j(MAlNT AIN) 4ft.,i/. v.f'-:( r.c;.1 ;:_..,;.J('~ u-'J~
t<- ~:./.t.I.f4-_,;..JI.;!I._(,4-Lf. .I~.;:(, -:: if. ~ a:::'41~.i ""'
J/Li.f"".JJ'I'~ 1,).'14-~ .J(REPR O'DU eE) i,..1.:,1ct.="J.'4
.. f~.i7~J'7VLLPt("jiAJL~ifll~.(,)>:; (PARTS), (;Jk~L":"\:=~V'~_.(,~I(A. V. HILL) J....!J1u.:J'i(J'~}-dJ~ 4~4-l:/ b}.it.ruf "~~':::-J''";' ;:( 2...JI' L1 ,;,if~-:2..(._..L._, 1& ~ o:
~te.i>lq~ ~ ~ ~~V~cfL.Jt .
tS'r~c(,Ifu3r."f" 44-):;t.F,jv:. (PROTOPLASM) ..::..b"';)L o,i) if'~4J-6.!".:::;...u '..:.~ y'kL..:..l?'o J7.4-.2..(. q. uh~ ~UJ!!'£UI~~~:';G. (FUNCTION) ~~I~/._:,.A"..it'd.-
r-..:..~J"y.2.~.4- (SELF REPRODUCT;ON) ~I;~} U" (fIG. /.-,).~jAJt!j'''r'J~y...:..~ J' ;...(t:J ~d~v.i a .~L .J.JJI~.J l:f~~..i'~Jh'L._:!..tl?'J" We..£VI.JJI4-(,,~if(MULTIPL Y)
~Ji1J1;,t:#.tf'lfV::JV~ltJ.~J~rJ~;IJ~''Tl1-.J
.~(cr:;£lJJ'j 'l€1" J:;/Gr!aJi.J~(c.6')~ (TERTIUM .oRGANUM; p. 103)
':4d./J:r~~~A:.;()' d."J~'J.~ /~J.'J~/J'~~~~)(.$4)J~~4-
{,):~I).fJ~L'_:"~.~U'J'_:"JJI:£cJ?J(~~l1~'cJ~~ ~~~l--rL
.;:(.y u-::(.J~ ~t.hJl&(_";;;L;1..:;'!'4(.'! .... j ~u:'4-
. (~~, ·U'J'~£icfijLACy-J~~CiIVJclL;i~~J~j £'\':U)I~JtJA;":r4..bYrJU:;UJlcJtd... (VISCOUNT SAMUEL) ~c.fl
'~(.)~~\r~11.;&vL,j'()'i~.{(~()Y'}....-::j(~Iij&~
(HANS DRIESCH) ~j~~,,~(l.JiL~i.t~U(BELIEF AN~ ACTION) i~/~~.J-L(VITALPOWER) "~,j'..I .t~;f~lf.1/ .. ~ w.£j,.Ji'L I~
If (~GENT) ,J...-1,41...{t.::!..W,.J"...cd ,(,J;IJC 1;-::cf.4~.I~JJ'4 / (CONTROLLING AUTHOPITY) .. ~ £('CONTROL) ~UL! 4---~.J¥"
~.J:::J..y (ENTELECHY) Ji,S ~£,/ "1.:::'.Ir ~L~tJ: ~)
--~4--.-J::::--~};;~~)iJ-~-' w- .. ~-~- . .It-v~- .. -· .. -tr u'---, ~u;-. ;:£- • .I (~VI('c.rld"L-g.£.I1 L.I' 1# J. ~
1 t,.,.... LI~ ,.1 1),
-: .. .."
tf(CONTROL) ..J;V~1-:,v.:(ENTELECHY) VIJ~£y~'ii1;r1j-v') ,%.-'J J 4--).(; ~~'-.l~J~;MZlf()7t:1 ,~4.L:J'~;jV£(./'"1 ~~Jlf~
(CONTROL)~~ t.J~~If;L~"4-o;""'J;J.(~~A1!Lt.Lt.(V.I"'L ~(4-~..c (ENTELECHY)J.{(~y'V"4-~'''''O~'f(f,~L-L (THE PROBLEM OF INDIVIDUALITY: p. 38)
(LIFE C,~LLS)...::.~..t.tf.L:f(jf~~fU-,~j,...P.'L.J.._;;!?M; VI!;t~c,,)~JtJ..:!.I~~~~4~.iJ(.)~~u~L~I,..J.4-t:~~/.(
,.,..4 (E. B. WILSON) :o{:.,Jtiv6(CELLS) ~~~~J~~tfjl¥DI"'"
(THE CELL IN DEVELOPMENT ~~ iNHERlT A~C~ • • • .. •
. ~')~~~U:-=-~VI'4()V~""'~ ~V..l. -: J'y . .;.. (GAP) u;...fv.:ut":,{?1i i,.!.JJYl..<'I'...:;1 Jliq Y~~b~,Jt.GL..:J.~ .. Jfb4C,)v4'U;v'~.. H t;L!
J'J...:;.,I) I .. _~..IJI~J V; I~ Jh';: ~ ... (,- ~ · t
.~6'~I'J~~.rV:~~"~JI~·t.!)"~/vt~)~jt-'p. (/.~r-~'aTifIVL~L~~~JL.;?~~AfP~JAJP
o: ....... £1.w1.1r.f,d,rJ ~W!-:-.d()w/.a..LJiJ.:#.~t:.C\VkL:::
J:;;-;)iiJ~L(.t.tJLPV:ELEMENTARY PHYSIOLOGydJ;I~(HUXLEY)J::(
A{£u--1t)V~~~ ··l:;I~L .. p{~~(fj~';_J;:e,)if..WV. 41! v-1. 1~J .;~ ~~L - ,v:ct'~.) ,-:-",.,IL(~w...I(CLUD. BE~ARD) ('~~Jif. .d..~; .a: lG~Jtfi t( ifJ i~~vIT ALISTIC. THEOR'lI~;
. ,Of.
(GENETIC ENERGY) ,.::-Id.. (c. M:WILtIAM) .L;'uCtENTELECHy) (~
--
(GIFFORD LECTURES)
•
--~-- ". ----_
.:;-~Jv:='J..:;G-~tb:J.~:=.;.d.U)I);..;;if.~-:~'-~~1 (jet. ~J I J",; 'uL ~Uv£J!?~cJC&.~~~IJ--f~ct.U:cJl J ~ ~
~_l:-J~U~(~(~VI.~~!:G~L:I ~j~ ~f'.4-~~"_"':> ~.4-J~f:rtLt,(~(j:~£JA~~JI~JL';!"~Ct.~(.$~((/
~L"~v.:;'#J/U:(CURVE) V~)I (STRAIGi-h LINE) r~fc,..
l£:[3/J__-4~J'~~V'·~r¥");U:~~~..:;:('hf~4~
., l? '....(,>'4(.'" .T.'~':::_"" (STRAIGHT LINE) r~ (CURVE) b?if'
~~._{ILv~~UVj~J~J""'~/~~~~_'~~ ·!Jvf;((o;j,~~)JW~)~j ;;:_"~IiJ'~/J,...1t/(p.Orr)
·4-0G-(f;Vr-rbjtY"ff~,.,dtf~)~t£2 L.- ~{(~"{~j'~
. ~I~~~
vtJ~f.j/4.40i~1·~~&- .. brlo~01~IJ~;/~
. (CREATIVE EVOLUTION: p. 53) • .;..L'f,.)/G-.b)V r
;; 4-AAf' L:tIJ ~L(,j'-J.7J;1~<.t(./"'v&.(rJ: V:~"r'o/.J)J4 ·~(V..J~J'cf~lJV.Jt-'~vlkL,1~>~/V:V'v:,_:,,~'J1
(INTRODUCTION TO THE PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION: p. 96)
_ ··M efjP £J ... ·/bLf'..-i;sv: J-%"t ~t;~~jf-?(g1_" .f'~J~2.....c':!'-:}'LVI_')I4-P (UNIQUE) Y...{P(J ... )
-.:. ,/ r\ ·
.Ab .. .....tl FAC ...
-I.:;..dv.£4' (JOHN CAIRD) ~.F._;)'idl_'AJ'i~('J-;i.t;:"
(CHEMICAL/(;$'JV.if'Jft~·j~lfJ~u.:iif.J~--4J/~JVJJ~~ ~4 .... .u,,~~1 I(' J"':J.fcf~,%I-'f .;,-J?I~'::" CONSTITUENTS) ~~4-rlf~J~Y~~'~4/cPROTOPLASM~)1>. '4J1~L L~~I~ct.W9.L(if~~;JL"J ~("t.t~"t-'t~q;JL:I ...:-l?",Luu4£vl . .:;...L-r,-O) l·~;'LdM; W~)I'(XI:7.I~~
-02..~~~V:~~oJL~_';7.4-t.r.JAtt'.;7.lofl~~c:C~Lf'k~ £ ~~JI<J.1L~~~J6~f. ~L:r:~UV(JV"J<.Ilj~~VI~ <.(.~J~~ujf,·~lf'Vu.:f~_,_;?/t-I;.r'J~)lj~ (' u'I~I,""..J'~/"'_'JI.c.Jf: J0,'J~.f. .:;..J4tUV(t!i4I ~d(JWI41!.LJ2~¥Lk~4~~/.;tr~/'-r'4IIJJt::::...cf: ~';~(,V';.:f)l..ytd~(-"4JA,J.f~ c.:I ... .J;1.'1:; w_,z,g;...- »IJ
..
-rj~Uj?~:L~~J..:;.4£I~Ilo.1:G!It;:J4JI...(,A4- 1jt_'~~)~.2.-a.UzJ-:,tj ,.:;-J Lr~~ ~1J.UJGJFL~I2..L~ift~JI
"'('J ... ,;~ Vi. (~~-,:,jJ(,/."::'I.Ii(.Ai lJi'J""~PI -~L"o;_.{_;";((CAREER) t:!....L~J,4-J~clJ~J (CAREER) &~,.;L_J:.,t~/yr()jjtYJ~,A~~(L""J"£(CAREER)
'" .
~};f'." '-l.7~~J' (SPECIAL EXPERIENCE) If • • ~
4--~.J::~l'J~~~;k;_./1U,G.VI'4~ ~t;l_'..t,.J.' J~/~14J r~I~LJq:J'VJ.4-)F./~~~ .. ~'t!J"Cj-)t.5J~IJ~"
. .c;-~_hLti'~»Ju~L~Jd.v'?4-J?~~~)'~f~'f~J~
(RECONSTRUCTION OF RELIGIOUS THOUGHTS IN ISLAM: p. 42)
.JJ~"J~IJ_.IU;J.:L.. ~ ~J£:. C~~~L .. ~L~v:~ r~ i I~,AJ L1
~ I_".~; :r.J ... :;-0;~,(.~ ~v7-v:vWJh.!~",; I]&IP(.,YSc#"...4
O;f'Y)J.J ~J~~)~ .G:.--if.4(.,.fl;-J~;J. V'J)L G;l.(..J~'~ (SPONT ANIETy)
- .~/i~~VI.J£~i.?(.(JI'~'~4c[fo' ~A(-!4u-Chlvlj(~~/~~)~JfttJ:»lvJrJ~;~G2..tJl
~J~fk4b,-~~L.,~!j~(u.;J/...::6J~'.d(L."j~,; ~».JJ~~J,J~,'~;£J~luJ4_~'2..vl~J~J d"~Uv~t~;tJ'''JJ,.4-~l'l~~~~lf,~;j4~OJJLf: ~tJl'i!--rjfJ ;., 1F.~»UV(J>(./1~J~_'~4~~'VI);;rv( JI'¥JI4c:dd~J~J'ti'L~Y44L:}f~/o-"4-L-£~t~ r'~~LJ'~;$.l..k?'~'vl~lJj4y(;;~;~£()jj
(..e,~" ~4-'J~~~.J~J~
... /. .... ~~" -6./..,,/ .. • -.J," ~ r .. ~t'f
~LJ(),J C l,,?Yu-o. ",J~u a.:;t ... fjj.,,.t~if.'J(.:)).JI)-'F~!i_.lJIV '1)~j
_.~4L:1v: (ORIGIN OF SPECIES)
Wf'(BY CHANCE) ..J~'""J..tu..r4~~LJY.~J~LJ..(}! {J.,t..4 (,!I(. 4..1"'; JI":"/(..f' ":::'-c)I.u.;,-"d~,.bJL>.- ;(;11-:: .u!~
. Ui/uG.-d-.fr"" Jl' J~~I
~I
. .4-dv.:,:-,~o/i:t' "':"'c:(I..n~-'~£UI
~'!lvfi.t"';J"I~",,£J,.;;L..:.~r2jlVf4--...p{Ju:.:Ji'''J;·i(!
LV~),Lt\JJ~~Ji;~;J'J~(/~~~tq,t~;~#,j~v..~£.?
• 4-f.lJ,J~~U!~~Jif~lj,;(~~_..#/)L,J'~~v~
·4-w~J.(.lJITWJx.J~II}:?Jt;..!;J~'-lkt\JJi.".?;'''';VIJ_,;; ~JI .. ~IJJ_":;(S)MPSON) "~1r~ ~l;'-~Ir, .. ;cr9' lirLfd-cJ,;;j~
~~~~£,-,Yct;lJJ}-1~ .... t.f.(..((.rII.ff.J4-:....,..,F.rV,~~!.>.;.;!.f~~4J...;1J' ~;
~, .... 4-f;l~'":"C}£Vl,;;J;;_.lJJI4-W~t?J([J_/tY//VI. ,.,., ·4-/<\~W'~t~£.,.f'~~,(;lf ~(J,.;;~I,J!li~(&V~ c.rt;ifJ~~~J!J·li~&.::.-t:r: .. ,.y1~q~-'j~~L)~~JJ,
. fvlf~J,4-itofcdjl~ ... w<frJt.itJUI~~JI~~~~(s-Y
(THE MEANING OF EVOLUTION: pp. 134. 135)
----- ... ----..
uj~/.f~fJJO:~;:J~~~J Lu.:~~ (.AdifL~ ~~J~ ..
~AP;'(.....;s(,Lu,.:J~..(, './ :. ,. f J." ~ , tp._..IJ) , ... ~ .. ~~
-=---L:OUrw~, (~RNST CASS1RER) (~'4".;'.fJ!P('V# .~4~v; (AN ESSAY ON MAN)
~~IJ(:j'!4FL.~~14o.;r~t,...~ ~.f'~,-:"I~~~L:LiLI~ (EMERGENT EV OLUTI ON) _(j;.;IJ~ '(f,.,I¥7v.f( OR) GIN AL C~~N) --:.A!
, .~,t~'~Nr-:,~ .. (';Df~~£:.,;,jLweti' t""'.~_i~AR .. ~~,
.. V " .. ~i , r f# r I \.I '-" --r-V. H ... ~";' "
..
3¥tc,tf:,~4~ ~ r ~~Y~~LJ'
-.~4t/4~~J0b(j.'(SIMPSON) ~JI ~Lt4-_..;~.;~·J·"'~AfUV?f~(LiLJ~)j4-~~~CJLf._.I-:;if.M'~I~
(THE MEANING OF EVOLUTION: p. 25). ~;(.r:Uj~lcJ~,I.::Ll,:,1
~I(MA ITER) ".>L ~4J_,;~.;:::_./,*"~.I~/"' ;C;iy2.h'l 411
,.., .. (' b ... r" j~ I' "'J ~
(5/, V j"JY()VJ'- (FORM) \,.: ....... ,-tP'" ,(FORM) ~ ~/yJJ L-_=-"'~"""::;""""_;;;;;""~
1'.,r1J-!')._:.,.;J"'lt..::)(PJ!k,IJ.)l ~QL~JJI.:-'J~I4-'f)l._eLr.JO u-(~4J~>':J;f""::"-J~N!L~~'_.:;-J..ri~P~ILtJl,t,;:tJ~JS:~1 ~vlcJvi...L~~1J)~0L.17~c-".:A;.JL"JL~L,t,JL (FORM) Io-::'J~"
~t::..dl;L!?I4r-'d';L(COMPOUN])) ~._(r.rV;J_Jd~U:~UJlcJjj 'trljL).:7.I.t.tcllU',j.cj~4-(r,"~~~.tIif.J.lJff ;j~.V;d..f....;Jj )l?I'.:::..I~:...(W. J..ofl.t 0 ~d..(.;i,J.lJt r.lJI~.ru.:~lY'" Lv I. .s L_ti.;6- ,,\
~~t..;t.U:A7.IJljLlr~J.ti~"cf..i.l~f';JI~~-iL/drJ04J'
-. ~
J ~ If"':'-(;.: ~~OJ a.vl~Y;-;<fjL (FORM) ~.I~ 4-.Jv.:1J~. (FORM)
.::::.,,1,./4- ~ ((;.t.nJ5:·-:p.t+",#..t~'''A/(FORM) J')(":'"i; h;P1."J, (DECADENCE~ .;;...-~J;)UItC"r""JIJ~;
_~ -:or .
(./tJtt~~.!{~J) ~~ i..C~ ~t~ c: (§fo'JJLU::,,;,-)Oj
~ '-'.i·dL~J"')L'J~~ (THE NATURE'OF PHYYSICAL WORLD~~ I
.., d'..If
.; :::{3'!i JJb~ d (. ~4- ~;fJ.;~t .. ,.f-;..ar~ JWI;J;t..,...,~0L-~;
#.;-_.J~~~yf~;,-, .. A'''clli'4J~..L';';(/'I.;~.J!4~,1_,J J;L(r~h.~~~(f:JhL~~~~f~)I~l:4,,{J:;
.~J~~~
-, 4-~ (t;.-'7"'''
L;..iJjpJ.J~~L(f'14-~~.w'...£iJ'tA;IJ41~vA .. ~":,,,
- 4-ct "tA "';, (., jJ'oh}}vf.J'J~J,J,Jo..:..f{..:,~"!/vJ~£~f0~iJ"
'f~~~'JJ';';J:4-~AfJ~'J,-""LJAJ4fV~-:1 ~~:..~
_Jw~tl1~-?~-:-,~t(if.~~I":"JJI""'~! 4U~(Vt L... ,1 =-_
~ISJ":;lt (CONSCIOUSN~SS) ~yJ~4l ~V!ybj'.r- ~\....r~~~Lift~ (HUMAN THOUGHT AND _jULJI (SIMPLE CONSCIOUSNESS) ; .Ir!J..
. ,. -: .. . ,~ ,
'T-2,tJ;!»;6LMI'4-L:r.~~il~/()'k:·vl":"~6#i:tAi"~~(
1~;lt9-'-:,,:,",I.4-~J)"'..:.:!'JJfhJ1(JiJ'~-iA!#~4-""'Jlz;SIJ!~..:Lvl
oJ (RICHARD MAURICE BUKE AUTHOR OF COSMIC "CONSCIUSNE-8S") a..r (C. F. TERTIUM ORGANUM BY P. D. OUSPENSKY)
.. I., I ... :~' ~ J
tf "l,.Jl)I~ 4CWcPSYCHE) ~ (MIND) JLJI~;:(~'.cfJI,.)I
.4-' cI OR EGO) fl.1 kGiJI,.iI(~j(? ifl~,:!I'4-L:i'..t~~.,~: l"_,ru.:f<JI.~':~ .,4c:J'&-';-J1.::..r ~t 6"tf.!L (BRAIN) J LJI~l J.J) IjJl..JI"'" ~-f~}i-iJ:7.....6~~WlPVlt'J;d,G..of;;JijJ£~j'6~J(.j;
I,,,.~~ k~. 0L.'_;.:;JJ'J) t LJ..IJlj 1J'~LV1''4-d l-,J • .::...
· ·4 y,~ ~.::-~(....J t~~IOl,.JI, ·14-r~'-1~JI;:l.' ~~l{'cJ '.,IJI~ J,,/(..IY (;:!-tJLJI~'::"'<..C u-=" 4- (PRl~M) .J_'::;'~ ;-!';J (,LJ£;,('LJtl '$UJ~ k~~Ct,~ ~.I7<..C~.Jr'~~~ ~~~.Jlt; (THREE ..: JJ.~~ ~l J."~ C ~ 2- ~ l::'()"'I($.JItju--'rJLJI~;.,c if. 4- "-4Lf tL~ 1;:'rL;.JLc5.;If _( 4-~ ~tt'V', c:;...~G.' -DIMENSIONS)
i::..v~~~~/AC'r~~h~.?-.JjLt,LJjUI~'J{(
.. ,., ? . Po , . AI _r{. / I"" ~ .. it J ';' ~ r '"
t.t;.tVlt~li~~j"'·V-'..J~J~VIJ~~j~f.;''''~",-L.L''i
)i..ru.i~-:tJJ0-/~~f~)Jt.C4.J!i~~J.'~J~~V~JrJ( J?t'.Jq¥t;tL~A'L,;.[{~~J~vj('t;;u'LlJjLtt~;~r
(MANIFEST A nON»_,f~~£<.tJ~/.L"J.~)I~JIJJ~~~"J1 d;iJ ()1~c:ML.\Pfi"''';'hJl~w:.w~~,(::,) .;..cCJj"-,JI4-l"J"JV,
(TERTIUM ORGANUM: p. 164) .'(4.;;jj~
. ~j~J~;tJ.,d,v,~/tcr.(~"",;~jJ.~..4 • LJI
~ ".I •• ~ LJA! .. i W," t;;.JI" .... LL. I~LI' '/
;jj...J;7Ii.:'J~~jJ'~(J_y,L0L)IAI:'LJt.-~~4r~VJJ~J~. )4- JJZlJ ~1,.i~JdA(~":'li)I~.~~(:1i....fi';'J'(~'v :r,»"Ifr!!"'M ._ r~¥()7J~fL~~~~~~;u(,N!L'-'..(()1/;,:'~~T,~) :L r; .I), ~ ~.J}';;;!_j£.!-AI
• .. 0: •
. L~.IJI«;-:''',:+'='''';f
". .
d- c::::- ~ .. ,,/) L if: J 4~ :'1}
'1'" -.. ~ " /'
L- ~cJ' L-Y; ~7 4J~ d~ 15.1;/
~.I v:( 2-IJ .I~J .J".;/; ~ 0 ;;i:.
J-: ~ ~ ~, '-/!
'4-.A~~~\i'~.'" JLJI~JI~UVJ'r'JlJl~ A~",IJ!:;JuL~~M . 4-~~~t-~~jr'~/L:!-Vj.#~ ~~(;J~vr.o/.";':"'..!..(. c.tVI~ L..:./ftJlr.F.t::;-!.f1I./!_iJ£ ... ,,;-).,,[ 41.:..(/· ~".J:,/" j; (if u=:...,fJt..r.
;,-:Lr:~J¥:_;'~J~~£(;:;~JI.~~)rr-~JIJ~~J;I~J~ JtLJWl.Jr 4Ll:>0IJL.ij~ "u! "4Jdl..-:;f4;1IV~I. JI:\f -".if.,:,:;-l,..
. ..uj .. dJi.::
.J6~~~-:.(d4JI)L..::.~;..rJ'~ ~ ~!:~.
t>!JLil4-JIa:,...a.J1/v';~0J'7if.J»'';'' (MEMORy) 4-~~,.rv ~
tf;~v.1j1,...L~'~(,Jb.)v:$IJLJj,;,j<~ 1,j'1'4-)!rJ.JLi,h" .. ~1t t/.~!JD/rJAJ..AIVJ;I/~VI.JJ'~Clr"!"/,Jijf.p/~~+.r~)I~.J,t~J~;;JlPtI'
~,;;- ~ ~;(;.C,t::vt ~~ i:T' D ~v:fuf~("~4IU/~~.I~'~ u,r.ti"v:';.Q{l,..tirl·~'f;:flif.::..:'v:;Lvl~if.Z~IJIY-.lkl~lJL{ Jt)!ur~"J~;~;VLPtfv::;~v'r4Jl.f.YrV?o#S\;.H~. ~~!JJI4- -l"J;u.f'j1ii4('.J LJ6L,.JiJ"'.;::;.~..( Sc)L..i~ f4J.17 e IJIFI~/.,ISt,L) .
~t~L4?" t:. t:. ~~Yv2~LJ' ~L.V~ G ,a;"rYr[FL"JI;'P6'~ (BRl\lN CELLS) ...:-~L~L~!~J l' ~ ,/;J'~. {":"-~~"4L,=,,/.i _;y()i.J'J Vl~':;';~ c)'.IJ'_4-L"'r.'.:.JiJ(,
.4- I;,J!.hJ:" -1J'JJJ.iJI d, 1!-i4~ tt::.tJ"I:d..(./'l4t .4JI.J/~ ~~J (/"1.u..'f"Aj ~\;l C,lud.';.:; ~)j )4-Ilu!'b",{J.t~
~"(~_'L~_'/ ~~=.JJ/~~'~,!(}_'),1L1Lil!/~ v::~~J~~ ~I
~~4~~\J_,;?fcf.i f"~,+,-'1 ~ ~J -'~~ ~~...: ,£tJ' ~,;!_~J,':::'-I ~,;!_'r'.t7
, h ~
//~ 1/. .. • · ~ .J ..
..J ~..L.(,I,.J;i1 ..... ~~1f,~.... J..; ,... os • N."
. 4- ~ -I.; iJf-:1.fi ~I,...LLr. ,l(~»)_' ~.,.J ./!.ii'A, ~ Ji.f«''';'' ~o..r''lI V'U:~~VI·~t::~~/d~r'~ftJ";/~VI~L:J - t. ... ~ -:- f u-f.?~"';~.Li· (MAITERANDMEMORY).,...c1'J' ~ (.;. c)L,...J../.
"::"'~At,/J4-rY(6 'JJb )ij'J~£.~~f~~ v(.,.$J.ljuV:~cf V~I.I~'~'JJ~.I)Itt.t J ~~~r ~ ... iLV'.i'~u£.'J~J (pERCEPTIONS) (INTENSITY) ._:...~~/4...t (RECOLLECTION) (u: J rI.t~j~)II:~)~t;;LPJ:
':"'/U:\JPtJ)~J1j.J.I'-'='" ~A~JI·vf ,;. V J' L iL) !Ji.9 LP':£' ~y JJ_.IJI ~ 4-0/ l( L:J1~-'A1'!4r-1 (pp. 3l4R15) ~4-J)r'(KIND) ,,)J.'~~r(DEGREE) ~J
-./4-Li?'LJVW!4-WLJv.,~ '9~j. .. !J~ ~~\.,I)JJ fU/~£.Jij1P'iL_'·~~~~(iLJ~(,/t&~f.'~1L..,,7 ~~1; (PRESENT) J1P-:,4l?)~Jt,;if~u.~U~JL~.JJI4l:aC l~,~~t~~~·~J~.,t)ij1P.~r;.:_:lPJ)~'J~lP~~f
.. ,~·t4;UJlcJ!,JlP~~I..IJI
~Vl.i'~)~ .J~k..t(AI~I.c::.."L· (SPIRIT) "~~/4-;:,~ ~;~~..:..tC"cJl"',u.t";" (IMJi.a:!.L1:,.I) ~1C:.'lI'((.J.t L:-0~.J
, ~"'''' ... ) . .:;..J,:"4J()t'IJh.,y,U'f',,,,,'4J;'JlC...:;¢'r (FREEDOM)
. ~
'1 I .. ~ .. ~~J ~ t( ~V ,N ~Jti t '-lIlt.:)
• : .. ~ '·uJJ1;J ~u.:~,..,J'",:,,!&JU U% ~J Lit( ""u.(.!!:!.I.~Jo';1
. .(u:f":;'-'f?/L~k ~.::..l.::i-v'4-G ... t;'::""H'::"''r~
o .
--_ .. -~L6LJk ,_ ~,~c(pLr~~. r"'1 (.s, ... ,/ ,,-
~..... ~..JJ I • "'t~ ~ ()7iJ I!! 'I ,
-u;.;:!...~~ t,..;::.....:.-LJi,- 'JJL ~ BRAIN .. ., )
(A NEW MODEL OF THE UNIVERSE)~cr'J;I') "4J!J~U"A)I~~ cJ'"I'
. .' "~4~~
~f.:::J~L.·':;";!J~~..4-J.:;WL"J~~JL:'Lt~:;fAiul if'1.::..L}iJ~(4.c:Ctp~..:: ~\t"~?'"~;;;?""";"!.IJj~j~L' ...{I.e)) 4d'1} IJ;'~ ~ '::'/JJLrvJ'if. .LIP!( ~ j~.,r4'z;J' ~}..f.''-l',;vJ!,.;;I..:..r.£_/I(tJL(!JI..::.~Lt.LJ'C>!l.\vk? ¥#'/I-:;,",.I~},~Sif.l.~"'~'I'.(J.Uv4,"/JJ·I./JJ_lrli
~? t,v:f(jf J'£:::_I.U;L~ ~t:::-~ut"t.AL?t,1'; t;Ju{cft.Jj
t?JLJI.l'4~L..::.~$~.;;.~~UI.-"::"'}':h.:,cr.:..-
. ,..r.;..." - .W-(IMMORTAL) l)~uL·
~Y~~J~~VU:~.It":'Ii~I£~~~~~t(J:i:' Ji'lP~-1","I~!J'rIP1}Jk,..J,...v~I<~U/i~I.~"!7-~1 Jl.UV!d~( (1) (.t.Y (J.!1~~.t*~LP£ ~ ~~Jt1~.u.1 ~(~~,
... :'''
(INDIVIDUALITY ~.::.c~~hfv,t {CONTfN"UITY AND P ERMANANC E) "
.e.~~_"}lz;- fi L'(fJ LlfJiJ"'-'J 1.4{ ,Ji5 lPA ... 1f" AND ~IQUENESS) juWI.Q..J\".L/":"(~J""'Vj.~t(",uLif. (MIND) ~t(SELF) FiJwl
· ~ (WILDON CARR) ~!4~X"'J~t~I/~'L (INTELLtCT) cf ~(!;"ciPG":"~9::lL"JI"'::'~_I~;4-IJ~t(lJ~IO)LJLJI)
D ~"";VI.cr~tt;Jf~~~J?IJ."'f4--Clf_"'Y1'U:~W.JJI"T-('f..r~~ /;t.'J.4o<4wCvj~~~r;:(',-,'G."Wy.V:.iLinJ.r'I!Ztf.£·~.!.¢/S »~tZLl£;..;~t~~4··4Jt.o;J-4'("'~~)I£:A;.f'4cP
U:.J~t:::...-:"b-rL~llj(.u;#~~(....J'GJ'~'~I"'I·4-#;.J~~JV ~vf'I:J1:ifLJ~IL~'~~"~-rd;:;_~:Juf'-=-~;..J,)j4Ji ~~~...(..J/,..r;;~L>1 (CONCRETE ACTIVITY) ~"Y'....(,
~tii;~;tW:~.4~1li~;£,.::l£...('I,,;("..zAJIiMj.J( '7..r1~~J" L~tJl.:r~L.J1 ~,.t~~fu ~(IJ 'J) ~i!:V.::;;1.?
~~ ...... ~ , /. .. ". ;' . // ., • ", L ..
¥4J J~;;V ,if,;,o"""/ ~,J'6J.J4L'f!r'j~~c..t.::;;LlL#cJJ(j .40 ,-UJJ'
J~-{J~'L~~A;-~~6r'('-=-~~k}.~/ ":'-lj,I~? IJ/JGJJ
~~,
JI:v./1;Jji"",~~·.:hV)'v?'4-C~(' Jf~£u LWIct-";-h~Lff ~.:;:..J" f,.z.; .. ?"~£J1j iLJ!J"'~if. v..J~/.{.r, ~ f4-~ (TYNDALL)
(C.F.CA[RD: p [03)
o .
/Jl,--.r£U.U,'J-'y.~~tit;/;IJ!£~L.tJ~M~40Ld.fo~;-~~~c..t~~41~f . .:;..r.UiJ(J"..fA~fi' £.('~...{tJ'J', JIIJJ~I4£'J,..:; I JLJ~ ~r..;~Jf?d:iWlid:4-~/.~~)J'~K..;.)Jt.J'fJ.J.( .a.-Lv'fJ~~/~;.J~L"lJj"t~Li(cJW0=~~,,_I)~F,
(SOUL) ~.J" (-(70 ,Ji.$"J ~·· .... ('!I,b..IIJIIJ"'jJ'·· c» ~ ~J!CI,...L''T'''v:..:.t?c!, ... · .
(.{r£rJ~'. .
AMI'uj..:i~(:)£::_(~ MAX PLANKJ~v-Y",tJt"~~~~,,JJ JI1-!i}"'JI..,.JIIJL~IC~ 4J~10 JI(~~ifJ~ (J. W. N SULLIVAN) . ~~/~~~(.f.~~£VI! 4-~1fV~);· d..'~.~lf~~~~ f·4--IJI~tAJL'UI7W\f'~!"";(f.
. ·.;.J./,_:,VI ~ 4-'J.' ... .r.d..!/T.!,J.tJ../_.&f, ~.£if.
(PHILOSOPHICAL ASPECTS OF MODERN SCIENCE --- JOAD)
~Vr.~UJI4-..J I) ~S(.f. IJ ~~p!:-;2,t:::.r~Atf~ d;J LL,,~'-'..Y!·,(P ~~~4-U ptl...f~~~-,tJ~S:~t~'LJj/'-I.J 4~"Jo/1~£ "4-J..("':~J.fJ,::-()",..:.t::~"L .. )t~I;./;~Af"'.5)p.,1
-~ A.~I~'-"Ij (SCHRODINGER) .;.11
9':;'JJ~~J:~/Lctlf~k~u:~tpUJwIJ1~~ .
(QUOTED BY MARSHAl.L URBANE IN "HUMAN AND DEITY!!: p. 366)
{BROAD)~J~(.J.! (MBANS AND ENDS) ~cr~1 (ALDOUS HUXLEy)
-~/4ct~.I'7L)J,,;t-:.»~L ~IJ.::.JLJr~L",4(~r'if,)jLJI~~':;;"~~~Vtx
.. t.I;f e,.r £ t:f..,j)~.f LJ.A) tJ~J.~ e/;'f'
• •
(' (SPIRJ'D U:.J·J;I'L (MA~) ~~?4-~"~!;-<..J_,b(trJ~~~';;..i(r.~ y~~tt;a...£.A.i.lVf;{ '-ltJ....;' .. ~1 (IMMA TERJAL) "')..v.J~~~ 4-~"1IJ.JU.t - t:J'rY.'IJ'I,,;,~i'JW\'i"'~UIf..t:1!Vet.-!;lV'Iid.iflU::V&~ "j,U..lli3£JJ,JI~~J
.&::.1
1\1
~, "'f)f;r'~;Ai~tc'LJlcrf~~JJ'7,,)'~~O-~(.,f.J~;Jwl
V. · . ,/ ,. ,.~ J ~. I L ... •
I.u.:r~~ 1'U7 r.iJO.: v1cJ ...... , ~ ••.•... ·4~;;J ~..,:..~J.'~(UiJ
· w¥ ~Jt (SYMBOLS) ~J..~J~4#'l::J"'Jl~J",,.t.1JLL (AN ESSA Y ON MAN)
~S/4t:J'~'~Luf'~' ~JJ~1~'JJv~ t;.;,J~t.J) ~t::::-L::~t (S YMBOLS) ..:.,. !J~t~ ~ ':>l-t Ii u ~'I; t~j
..:.!..;.as'IJ'~'::""Ii;'~}J)iLc)J'4-t~JWJ;S~~.Lf4uJ ~~f-d'~L*7i !..;J"r'l:-iL~JS-:-~(~ ~'::;_cJ.f",
U~J '4-l")r(.!JJ#,r'-:-I;"'.JIr,':::"(JLf;l;J ~J.("(' ?;v.:(j..i~tflJ'~)S
/..!.- (SYMBOL:) ..... J~r.::::...;..I;J;!t.tJl.JL:-~~~£1f
.4-~~~~).I(IJUI .. 1Jl'J~J~~~f#'J'i~o'~ (SCIENCE AND THE UNSEEN WORLD)
-.
(HEALTH'-:-' .. J;I (H.P. N~WSHOLME)Y.L;.t.IJ·· 'i~ )J1PJ"! ~i • ,..:. .. V~
-s 4 ~v: DISEASE AND INTEGRATION)
r.~e.)'vf((rIU'..-:-~L~;JWJW.:J~J'JJ4.c:.:'r~fY); ~~cajJ"J.J~lkl;(.,£(j~~J~"'JIJrj ~£Uj~ 1}4r;(, ..1,J..;(;fj"JI jJ..?tc)LJI~.v.;4"V,,((/."u.lut J .: ,,:1.~WIIv
..-!
<.tcJl.~~~c;)L~hJ.'''J'''~yJ)_.IJ'4-C'.Yi(if.J:,,_;,(~~_/Lp~~)U! ~~Ju'~}t)1~4·~c;J~IJ!((.~)~·'}~/~Ct'~4~JWI:"'_:(-4~ ~ ~>-::A'v.1 "J) I{' (0 EGREES) ~!..JViL v) ))(,;!'J!'.i.1,.'1 JO;; t ,w"tCrJf.o.f:
(INTRODUCTION to tHE ~+'.L.v.~.I..9~'.:~':"i.Z,J,' _ ... _ ~U.U',*'J '4t~~-<:~.I''-''JV: PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION)
",s4-~~~L)t?I().!u~ (ORGANIC) "'::'-~"';I'JI{INOROANIC) ~~(:,JlPJ""f~')'4-Jf,J'O~G&;V.v:ft(j-iJ:~I.:,ltO-y'
o ~~ .f(..l1:JLtJ j~ r/, ~l::UiL..:Jv.:f'utJ~ Jf/;:t.J..,;t;'J ~4-J~G.aI
. r /, (.Ij.~ 'Ay~u;'fI.{cf.(/.tJ ~';"I{'.::.r},cJ..1 Y-o' 4.$ J,;i I, 'tr~':';~G0'7V/J;J-ftc), .. J~u:f~~~V"-='.J,..,t,:,-~oj~
.4--1?~OI'1rJ-f""'JI t ..:Jj;J;f~c)I.,J ~c)tJJI~~wt;;
· 4l1~~ L..(;')\.Cdt,...il,.lJj~~~/I,,_;, i~~~lf'~l:r,", ;')~£UI
')":4-tr;~J-"'~Ltc)IJu.tO~ ~u..J · ''''~¥JJGJ~Lc)t.J1 ?~tJ~V:cJl"4-~;:-U;UI..?I~()"IJ;I~IU:-;"JI~~1t""'()'" "'N"'~..4N.wf~Jv ~!J;i~I::J.._Lr.:' .. {P';~)'-rL:;:""V1(
J.' .,~., v ' (h-~-'
O/~~ If,.::;jtf ~1..Jjtt.:..t)Ut, ~ ;~JJf~J~cJt~.LYL~ .~&{
·~'yJJU7tLiL(,iUIv4LcJ,.c;-J,:~J~~tlJL~j~'/~"~1
.. . ..
" .. ... ~.. .
1.-N~;:~1:((':lJ(JL.ai(/.J.:;J.u..-..c~!~"::'J.,IJ"';'"I( ... ~
..::.-w,Ai.~I.!f( .. ~.:....:.,)Jd"...c 'r.j(-'J' '1'..::.- ?t!...: '...4(~t,..j-:"'J'''i- rft
( r..-A -~ > • ..1rJ!r-'Ji"~W'~4-~(J~I(Ii"""'1
- 4-~/~Lf(..(~()""" 'fJ)t:::.cr.6tvt~~.~~,""/))~~,!:v~jr~~~~
~~~I07';"'JI4l;4(Vof~~I}~uf4.rt,t;e,Jt.r,JJ;,; (jt:.".IJ~ •. ~-4."fJ4r£L!'I'-- (EVENTS) ~J!.P'(j'~L!'1.4t4LPI J' iJ"IM ~(,(,~Iy.I(. f'.J.~~..;..t;;J'LJk LfI;.J..: v.'f..; .... ifL.?lJ£j'::::""('~4-J,;~J""-"~..c.. jj~) .4-~J~~J~; 't.1j~J; I G-)f cJ!>;"o1cJlJljl"~O.lJI6!J..::. cJlY.lf.cJl),J. LJru:':' J{cW~~$)f::-~ ..... \-'!&li.:J/F.·~..?t:~?J~t
. tY4r ,~ •• / ,~, .~.~~
Ai ~~~~~·LJ"; (~.IA;~A1LJI/~~A f"1.JD, ~A.t!L~kri'.'1
v .. ' , .. """,. v. "'" j f 'I • t...I v.o:~t ........
o: U"!.J(v.1~;iw;JcJ(?<I'c!LJI..G iii"~ '4-t,r~JI4...il,;;:;..cJ!Y.lf.c!t..i1 VJtJ'''I.'LwF.}'V:'~ .. t;LI~,1ujJt;r{f~uJ'44f...Jt.{J,~.:;. ~!?
'4-J.P...ti~I.:{~tiY.o/IJ~LJi){;;4:.-(4'v1~~~"'~I"'J
,,4t.t'(SIMPSON) 1f.,,:",~ul,.{1:f • • •
•
.-....-. ,II ••• 4-,.I!.cl 'HIL-it ,...- ~ ......,;;;.._;..;........;::~_..c__.._.~_
H." ....... \of ~ .. oo
~~~lj'Tc)y.~/cJWlfL\I~j .. t ••• '4cJ!tf~cJt.J,J~ ...::.-H?J 1.1111.(.1"': ILct(..iIW/.futd~·16.(IL~LP(llcJlf ~
cJUI40'".J~LfWP'~L!'I ... "'I't.JJuf~~/'u:~u: &lcJy',dIJl'U:.:lUi~~J~!r!t~YitiJ'7"fc..flcN4jcJ~-4
c'_."tw:.,.:f_,:[ .l ... h~I •. OO·
~.4.4-cJ!d(&J1....f'cll)l 4-.::..i'>!~I)I'''''A'u.i
J!,~}ytr~~4u:v'cr9~~".JVd' .J.-'..i~u;:,'J11f,4.tif.cJltf
(It'~ -t!.." .4-~..,I~..Iu.;
..t.ur~,::;w;to;...rj!r.?').I'~L.AJi~L~~I.,n •• ~ ct.
-14~lh.~A":~ ,I ~ c) ~
~;4-";IJ4-~Uky~J&~G~t2..JMtfJ~~ (TENDENCY) cJ~U;~£~Jt-hJJt.:lr.J!trV~Jt.::~J~';"» -6.riJ.!~~..;.(:Ic;tif~'_(v4--="::,, i;)UIr.4-CIr*f4J.cC:.c (,j; ';~Jt4-('(DEGREES) ~lf.Jjj)J)(j:~4.tc;)I.<..dJ,J;.f~/JJ
.q. (DIFFERENCE OF KI1>ID) %jU:~I .. v"(INTENSITY) ~~
(CREATIVE EVOLUTION p, 142)
~4-~/~Lii.Jj~v'
~ , .
~ W t(;~ L:.: r;" '-::Jr!J IJlc.t"'c;,: v:r I...t I · . Jr: 4-~""1 tfr't"'::-·~ ..:.J~L(' (INTELLECT) .;,.;J£I.fl&v:i (J'1t (INSTINCn
~L.r=40r~h'~~~"".4-~.Jcf.~~(udJaJiJAivlF..:r)~ qAt;..JJ,.Ic!I.d,(4-(~L( J2;;;!J.itU7.,;:.kA,j'(.$~,tt'lJ:..4 ~2..()1~(.,(uJJJc)t41:~·4-r~~JI~,)!J._,r *~~ ~J~..c:Lot~.d~.v.7J~ (COMPL1MENTARY) ..f;-(o/JJ~)Y
. . ~. ('a:.., · (.$i.Pf..;j;l»1.~;!,
J: (INTELLIGR1\JCE) .;njLc)l)'.JJI(INSTINCn ~~."':dct.
U ~JLJIJk3AJi4-J"'r~ (r'~UJJI;J'f:~I.,j/~k'~c:J'..::....:-d~, ~&..:,.7(.,tlJ.lI~Jlj~~ If~JJt.J-I(/.'f',1JI tl:rJUJI,,;Lk(~Ju;~ 'ill)
~~L(f".~I1?J(.l1~Ii~U'(j'~'';JIc;)V1J>'J~I''crf c) l4::-'11811).t • 1r2..(6.~ cJ' (J.( ~L,..C.JI" t,.. "i ~~I~..?(...Jr;J t$v.J;-:C
. lH'" , t'~r, ~4--C_:":~J~
(TWO SOURCES OF MORALITY AND REL[GION)~~I~tt.Ic)a.
,~,i4-tK¢r'~J"J;lj ~''2 tf.~4I.f' .rr:"'-dfj~ f..:_ ~1?:1"4- c:lu: .c;-_.j,li~~JWj~~-:! j" .Jv.:f.:~:!~t~,~~~~~ ~~a...U'
i~V~U,
•
(CONSCIOUS )L.!,,,vvtiN,fM'4~'rW'~;,J~lk M;~'~:;~Lvt.:.,-tW~ OF DIMENSIONS) ~t'J__,(J_~'1 ~l/1.?l (CELLS)._:.,L"j; ;fo.J/ .-
-7:1" -. 4·"f .. .. ... ~ " I
..::,.~("tf.A .... ~j£,-="I,,'-I.iJ.....,; (ONE DIMENSIONAL)· .. ~
Lvl~cCv.:f($'~?~ILr~v'~"::,,,.JL!'~ (STRAIGHT LINE) :~f("JPfiJfJ}u/c.t1t'-'O (TWO-DIMENSIONAL) i.4-Jr~ ...::.~¥.~ ~~.;_/-~r.4-J..r7~~ (SURFACE) ~·..::.c:r;L1t\:Jt2-V'~~~
(THREE DIMENSIONAL) cJl.J1 ~ ... ~-=--~ ~ ;. · f~~" LCfU;';-VVl
~1JI.t~ .~c:t d t..>1Jfrjr.t! ~ (f"",* '~I,;LJ' _fo' 'J~-,(. 4-'?' d IJ (fECHNICAL)tYtJ}.~~J (DIMENSIONS) JW~"4-~.£j-Alif.r{CUBE)
t0~J~Lt-:I~/.:.J'VI#,J~'--.Af~t~4.u: ()I.. ' c:,-.J~g/~,p£r.i j:;J 'JjJ~/'J.J..r7v:f 0 (~J t;;JI())~J.'.,/~
o/.~)VI.::;..J'rcf.(LINE) _,dc::...~JIJ.~I,;j' (pOINTS) u)t1>iWj'~
1.)j;t;J())- ~J' VI( tc (CUBE) .::;.. Jlf(:1. t-' j ..a:..'r~tJ...Il,..;-I,;/ (LINE!»
~ (fHROUGH PERCEPTION) ~bJ;?f=)9~d~v.i.:f.tff~~~
. (CO~CEPTIJ AL KNOWLE~E) .::;).v.i ::G.fi'.ii~r: dA ~d'rui {~L
~~ ~~,~~(~.-!!~;.cdl?$~(SP~RE;:~_f~4:'4::{
..; '.~i.P,~-:~".A(j .. J.J)',t,.ic,. ~~~ ~f~~ I
~".J;"!.-- ,~ !'/'vl1t.JJ4 (COLOUR) ~..:J/(.~~.;:f .,/ ~ J_l.,:;';":"I4-l:'" (ABSTRACT COLO~R) ...!~ .rJl"U!i'Jif1h.Vc::.4 If' (pERCEPTIJAL KNOWLEDGE) (O'?'..:J/".J:J_v.'Lf:/ (CONCEP1)
~"J' (CONCEPTUAL KNOWLEDGE~ (o1:,..&1:.PJ~ .. .:;..e£'.::,.~.u..
.~';-~J-"~"~.JI~?J~~.4-L:t
(CONCEPT),,~4~.i.c:...!'!.t1.::.,.kAiVI~ (CONCEPT) ~Ji(..4J.(..::.,~S;(I~....{I'2-L._~~ __ ~-
'lr'yl...(I2-L,,~ '~!:J":':~'(I)JiAI~~LVI-! -r.~/L.d 1f.(1J c:G-..c~j~ !t~~ ~kJ.Jr:;l'.~~'4-L'" :f~:,_(,(1/t'''''~
J~c:CtI;J.':'''''( Ii-,~~ U~,~t 'Iat 1;:1"f...~ ~qy, .:;..
(.:) ~ ) ..,'J I.,J~ JL...iJU;UvL, t;;b1J;t *,h~ ~~1f'G~j.fJ Ji&'~4U"',
'" (!? .:::::..cJV.::,;L-I.r.".0:;.. ~_,.PJ' cJl,)l"";/ cJV/lIU,)(J j I(;V (LAN G U AGE) 4.~IL:1.~A (:ONCEPTUAL ~~W:r'DGE) t J,,;o;e.-L..::- ~~d.~ J!~J(J~AJiflJ~nu(J~'4-J......u:t~'::;"~J~~
~!;J(JVIi.t"JJc.rI.J&.~ -;:j';: 1:.:';; If (INTELLEClUAL PROGRESS)
.r , .!.f';"''f~~Y;uJ...IJ':;Ltiv'G..U'I . .i;w",,.;u4!-L (CONCEPTS)
JIJ~"jLYk.~;'6!UvL,~~~/f~~t~T~~~cJl
(CONSMIC CONSCIOUSNESS: p. 27, 28)
.. 1.--1J(J:(~/~ ~ .;j~;t~.li/.:;...J'oc;-:~,.JJ(J~&.f,,,",~ L(Jr~,--,cJY l ~~14~(CONCEPTUAL KNOWLEDGE) (JJ..;.1 ...... .f"VI . .t'~ ~.2... "'1.~($liJl,..::,.L1'':=:'''':'''.I~L,.,,r(rlt''_4't .. ~f.~ ~~~..;;t ~/&--.t1~
\01 .. _ • ,-I r-- '. ~ -r
. ~r;:,tM'4$-h·h6IJbWI.JlI
?t~,~/ "I, i~YV~cJ(.J1
(SULLIVAN) ~lfj'4-I:.I:?~ C;ljlt.tf'~;:; ~ .. ULlt~JW'"~~JW'~u:f '--,1r,1J~·4.cl;(~v..-;? LJ;~JtPL,.cr~-,1r,' (AI.ii~I~·V..~.
(L1MITA TIONS OF SCIENCE) ~1'f-OIJ~,,(..:t'f.J,J)~~~
(EGO) ~, ~ (SELF) 0~ (MIND) ~.aL jlJ~~ 4-*IfLl'~ _J;~VI~P.v:f.lb!.y.td (MIND) dWI~~..f~"¥.-r~..:.;t~'-!i4
.. snr~vl'-J.i4"(WORLD OF CONCRETE) -:;", V,.J'-'iJ~,t.JL.J{"'.I14 #~J~I~#L(rI.J(,,"~l;;~~,JtJJJ;:_Lv,jvi~I~1Y,:'::jUJ~JUI~· ti:)I.:::-~~J'1."fr;?.JvJ4h(. c.?' £'IfIIfJtv)vf').1r'4-'~J L41lfJ Lr.
u{:'-='4-~'-~j~:~~J~{~"j~I'7~LLJ~"~:~J)L (BASIS)~ ,~Lviq~d¥"tJkvl/tY~/v.f.fjjVL.-'-.I~~Lv:"~4~ (' ~ crt VI~"~/(./"'~l~vfQcUNSEEN WORLD) II t:Jt~l.::..IJJ1._,
~i....('~IJ.''':"''O''VI.4- (SCIECNE AND THE UNSEEN WORLD) It (~
A,-},.a:.~ L.t:; rJP,.;;;.!! ~ JJ: . .j'1 JLJ/~",:",c1vI41 ~~\I'!,~
,,-,,4J;;j Y,v:JiL,OJI4-'rf ..... uJY'if..:;.J'..:,.(J.; )1"':1 .. j~. ~ (-; 1 :-
. • ~,-!I 0,-, AI
.. '4-
JtJ!Ar~v>~..:.C~:.(4..;..(~~-*~/.L~ c::...~cJlcJLJld~~kpt~,'?"if,t.t.r~~.tt?~~.".,Jk.
~~ /~v!f~1/. ~4J_;if~~JI~JG~~IfSV.~~Ltf.
Jr'~j?~ · •.... u' .... ~J!.J;jlv~~I~ (CONSCIOUSNESS) !tJ".J~".J''UL;t ct'if..r.!V:,,";'JL~;tJ¥())tt.f.J~£i;.~~1 t:,~if~~~1f~..;CI"J/4-J~,_:,M4-t,r~J!r~~I,f 4~J..,)~",f;1 .. :",!/ ~ U~u:vf' ~t.t'UJ t._.; N/JJ .-;"l"f.,l J~tI.,jI~V:uJY"="'"J'I~J)'4-tlrJ !:=JJWif,h.r.u)J.ljjl·W
l:;":-'U~CcJlj\.$ .L.)~&.:.-l.!vJ.I,U: iLJ"-.J~~$4o;:~~;W; .J~I,fi~;Jr.~t:.z!;'u:.Pf 'JL.i~ M~(";'.!'i,.m~U1d.JrJ'1 LiL)~~~(.:::..J_'r£cf.'4~.Ijl~tcJJI)...(It.ijJJJ-'jJluPI
-:,,~~Y,JI.r'£ULt:~J'J1. .V1L'rJ4.J~J"/-v~':T.j(tJ ~~~k,/~J!y~'ltJl~J{t5f.~lr~lu:fI!:-;J)'eL
~(.i'v.'1! if. f'~ £..:.. if"t.f.\ .. : .• 1f4t. Ib'''::'v_.J,~~L,
rJ./.,cX;~v;4~;LifJf'-),r. ~t.JJ ~'r/(S YMBOLS) "::"1~ 1(,:)'
.JJI51...;...-t: !I.(.1.!;r'if.4-~t.r-'!e....(v...::.~~~~v.:..L>'l ctfi~tf.v::J...:.F;1"J,L}~~tJtjl(.. (MIND) ~ yc}LJ'4-"
~"lr..::;'..~~..c~ L .fV".LItJt..:.i}>'()1/'::'J,L:-I~y,.t w.~ ;t:UJLJI;.-JSJi~.Ui.:f$"'dJ-=.:i1't!:-=Arfj~
~1~(.).7~"J4~1L)'H~/ct.·,j~f'~if'~~$ti1r~';;:_CJ£,jL
L t 1 tI '" '" I . I"" :. • Ir .. 1",.,
~ J .fj4-vtt~ Jvt::.-.,I?, .;~.... 1IY.u!i"~·
iv9(rC")"JJr',.c01~~~4-~J'J-.:.I...t~Ifi.t~J ~ ':f.:lj~ l{.ht'~J.JS,jL'yJ! J.,,.;:.J !f.'Suj L.J1f'?k.0'if-t.Jj
. ~~~J~j
J~LJ'JU~;u=tM(jv~~~~/LJ1~l.,'Jf/Lf.JI.:.,..;4'
..
. .. .. ..
.:!-1.JJI-(,)j'T-' ~ 4$fJ-"~ <:ONSC~O~SNES.S) "'~ ~( .. .trl£t.n ~ .
~:'4~,:;",,::,v~"fiJ'~'~~~':;"Ic!..(.Z ~h:~~v. ~tty.4L~u:u.n.:.J,JJ}f.l""'J~'';'''J.L;t.:;..~JJ;~':::''/Jv.
JJ w' -~lf,j0W'i,~.~JJ.JII.4<" (RE~ON) .,I:;:)J'.fLb:~~j(~( ~-::(jIf.J4fu:'L~JJIffV'.4l;Y:LI~~ru--ZY (~Iv:tJJ1!-
----0----
~JLt.t~/t..::.1£,;i' J~d..)';J IL(~'J(.¥' /V1d...I7~..::..VIY''!'41..;.
.o:L.__;)U""u:f"P /cJ '-,J '4- ry' V'~ L ~d L ~ MIJL.J'~!J~'-=-)Jc.:tij
w ~ ~~~. "~ .. fy, .,
vJ!.4-mif'it.J!t;, 1:& ~ iJ',ffM..r~~..6Y'~'ifl(,/.'i· -ibJi ~JL,.,,....u ~~~.i~LI ~J~( r: .... t""A~ JJ) rr .. .:::-& i;;..J(Jf'
, ~. ,/'.
'tu:kj;."tif.l?fv,A'}u!i.d/'4£t,tS;Lt ~J~Y! !.:~ •
...t.:.~~~IJ!I,/)J.fr~*,Jv~J! (;:l'iftd~fJ vPi./_,..#ti./I(,·4-~""lrCi'X"1J 'iJ.iU"'LP-LvrJ t,}....., II) L '0:;(/J'J.'4,;.c~"'r1:JI~I../i~klP}t(JJ~J!jJ.,'tcll"")I(
l~' .~ltJ.:i'r.f.J.fcP~I4-~ /4-~~_,it:~1
(.wvi":=,/lIt?i''-:"'?'.J tlj(f;'4-~"~J.; 1:!-~J'~.Jft~ "::')Jt:iI;~1JJ~~t#~',j'J",:J~Lc)ljt.CJ..y~ 2-L J_1)p .. ~,t ..... ~(1L.vl.4-C4'l{ (NATURAL LAWS)
. .4c1~~~u'!'/...::..jJ¢,}
("CREATIVE FREEDOMII"BY J.W .. MASON: p. 6)"
t:Li./'~v:f"'J'1J;~cJ)t;~,~,!,,;,~~'!J4~'/¢Li'J-;~ cJ!r:,*jt~~t:~~i'~jIiJt:I~VI'4GCJ~ltr'fI.:d ~fJ~Jj~ If} LI:!-d-iJJj.i~~I..r.fc,'r~J""'~fH'.tV.( It..i ~ ct",.u:fJ;,ta-! /t;I'fJ_(HUXLEY) d.~~~'!l.J"'uf1fV:Jf,,,)v-t~t
. ~ ~
.0;. ...... ' .'
. ,.
(;)jli~l:Iw6-'14c:t(..;Li.:::.~~IfJL')(/.F. . .£:.~if.(~
... .. .
(THE NINETEENTH CENTURY I FEB. 1886) • .:;..Llf.r7.,.....li
L ;:" (...;r:.'.d.~t:¥t~ l..'-r'f'v.'J' ..... '-l~ .... " (;'J~ jI LIf ..... vr-i.::
. A~/-.!Ip't~ .. !~(,(,J._::.,~t1,}~l.w~
1 .... V.':-'Gi4J6~ '..:.JIf.'If,jIr,JG6..L(.JUi'- :")/~J;~I:-(.
'f-~()LAJ~~1~".J~L~W.J~-'T4:AC.I~I.I
. ~u.:/d"J""J' v,/Zlrv.;'i (..1"
/4t:t~vL' (THE MYSTERIOUS UNlVERSEl ~c:(~,!r.:"j;y.{ ... l::(,,(1
~')Iifl:1J1tI'J/4-,J tr U)U~¥. to f.~,,4-'/t(($ CJj~V~t,,1-fl/Y4-J' ~J'J_/~~V1,Lrf·t,Jjcr!;J ~~~~;l£J:J~/~LJL,&L£~K~LJ~~
~Jf."v~VI.t..tL.~"('~"_('J'~.I'JY'::""Y~ (v:u:~~vtj'/:L'-"'~()i,t;~)tf'~;:'4c.C~.I~'~)vi £(_",;u!f(,J,;(J;J~ &1r-.~_I.%l:JIJ~J.~.{u,..lj'J;I~L~,
.::r~/~V4~~/~~hUiI,~,J.f'~V~t,,~JJ '1><1.;/.; ~ /J. 4,..::.r;, J)1(tJ~.I,Lt .'::-JJ;.~/cJjJ# rL(--'vlf
. 4~
.~t.:v:f .(u::~ £.::. i':f"~~,..:;,wt~L/4-L;J{~}~~~ '.lJI
(NATURE OF THE PHYSICAL WORLD: pp. 30,31)
()1C#': tt?~~'4~~,G_,)i~a.ifL~~L (SHEEN) d!
j Ij~L1/~C:('~ J&'~~4~?'~iIJ.L~~LJ~)J;t;f~J~c1 ,,:;,,c£>l'Vi': 'vj t5:4v": rLv'(' ('~..:Jt '-".4- 4c.9J.h~v.~~J~l('~~r'Hi~J'~J~b,' u&.v-'r.-L+;J/ 4-;fr;l~~ v: J,L.1JJ~(£/(f.'':''')J (-,.; .1::fJ),I.::J~(£~~LJ,t5jl}i'~~,iI~
(THE GREAT DESIGN: p.52)
0.' (EDINGTON QUOTED BY DEAN INGE IN GOD AND THE ASTRONOMERS), .! (THE PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION: p 156)
• .J, •
(THE CRlSIS OF CIVILIZATION)..,... ~I (ALFRED COBBAN) t,;/. V~J.I.;
~'4-~<.t (: • ,jj~J'it.tt.I!J.wIt~vIAljJJI)J".::f..G~;..J-::~
.qv~ ;~v ('v"..:" j::~yI (tf"",J~'~~(./jl-:!I.4--W.l..JG,, \4~,
..
"~~.JV:&;- f~tJl (W. N. SULLIVAN) ~
(/..JVlJJ·u:,)I.I:VIl.".~Il:LVI.;:,..~c,.r-1..;Iv"4(;..~J:,I-:-,IJ~V .f)or'V>I.-2...£~f~'" t.(~''''' ftH~-%u.i1iU!\ ..... ,.4-~ .4/',,"J,.:1~~L,.. L.~JJ" ... ,,( ..:..t)\-{J'i ..4J)N IJ' 4--...lJ_.pA"'(j1
($JZ~/t.I'~~v{;.Aj:r~"JuL;r¥~~U~oIJIt..$,;V
(LIMITATIONS OF SCIENCE: p. 182) .. ?-~Lf.;; t" L,..
• lit Lf2.1J'1'4-4V"Jt':::"_,/If;~ L~I~L/~,:;:"vl )'I4;J~IJ,~JJtJtfJVt!.;~NI:'t;v:~LJ?JiV:~1
u! .; li ct ;~;~JLJ,,,)..(4 jJv.:.oI~~j .4-i.J;.'-/-~ ~d':~'f ~"':ItJ:!d"~I~"J~f,,'tc;..oI"L.!J)J~.J~~Liv1.c;......:~..::;~ J!..s~v:u;/.;~'t..ft{":)L~~vt~~~¥!4-IJu'4-j .~ ~'Q.~~LJr6.LcJl.cc:..-h~»~J't.f.Jj'~d'/:~
'*' A ... Jo ~... .,., / • • • • "
~IAI~cJl'<1 J~~.Ji:iek.t.V"It-"A;~uf'.uJJt;JtJj~
~fJj~~'~~u1f7~)'J~~"IJ.J~.{..:JL"lJ.i'cJ~)L tft~'~JI4Lr.,J'~"p~c.JLv~'.._:,~£(I~£c:/."v14.i (;J;.e.(LtcJl_.I"~I,.JJI.Vj4-..J_d'..:.t}or~~~U)'~~.-:.()J(../..$ ~~~£li. t::;,-L".!:~,J,~.,J~V~i~IJt..JJ~ l}1.L(.);1'y."1. L,...-
'1?Idv}~.uJ k ~~{ ""i~'~V-:'~~":'y~C.llcJi,....i,~ L ~ . ~ /"-;;k, ;;€:~ · ~ ,/
~'ct1L~ "fI ~~V.dr(jtJ1 '
<.f=:;..JfF.4-J~d..~JI;S <.T1'";-'~4-~Ji7..:iO':::'-"!?IL L..::..I;:" ~L~'f4-':'(;!l.L::-'(!f ~ I.u:dd:;o; .1t~~~J l
J ,; L ~ ~~~k!' --:-,' /&Jf '(.)1.yfuvL ,,; L '! A -k;0~~ ~v..;-)Jc#~j/d-/:f~t,t-::~/,-:,,~.o:~IJ':f(j;~'J/ /~cP.'.r.4.wcf.,jLr'tf'Jy.:;:_~ct-·lj.L~bJ.Jj.._;J
....:..1.)~tLf'~ .... /!J,;-~ L{'cJ'· uJ J_~dljjL .. =A1::·i'~.J1 . uj.Jf-j;'';~H~JV't.~~c,!$:fJ (MA THE MATIC At EQUATIOIN
Co r . v:f~i G)'J'ctij ;_Y;~l;;Lr.))LJ';:V;ct·,;t:4:jf4
.:>. (' J/ • • •• r;~/~ j ... I (,) :.J~v~'f_;'P~, , .. --- ~ - - - - - ~~ - ·ut..:." _)jcF'l 'r v I.> y~..:.c.J"
J:~L--£c.t·,jt$lt.f. ~ 'i J6 ~"hi' £4- t>;- ~ ~Jt,.'" rf'~ ~,'-' {~,t~ptJf-:;,)Vt.:t·lj 4'!.-:;" ~~'-J.!c.t·lj~",J/ LVll4t£.J
(SYMBOLS) .:;..1~'vW/oiIJcJ,(}'vt.:a(f'~Y;v::?~, ! :nJ(...4u: ~ JciL,,~O! ........ v.;' 403. j, 1:\?'Lf'~.J;L
. c,..t./.:f (tjt::'-J~t ~ jtJct-'~j ";:'.APJ~t# 4J ~J ~.I~
(SCIENCE AND THE UNSEEN WORLD: p".32)
.._..,c(r,~ (MAX PLANK) .I_" :.r"'fUt
.. v., " """".
(UNIVERSE IN THE LIGHT OF MODERN PHYSICS)
;J;~JVI~~ t;£~~'~ H ~ If'~ dL ... t:.:.b1::) ..
..::-~~ 4-~.C:u.!'i<.P"'.J~' • 4:Li; ~"j~'rl.lY!r.~1/- "!1d..~:f-
~)1~cCJ;Jz?VI"""':U:J~~.:;.JJ""(4-[lfLf''-')aJct-~1¢-}(.1!I)L
U',f~/fu;~v,.LvJ~Jf~L,;wt.JWI~)ct·lj-:.JJ'.J'(P;4I!~S
? uf.' t~i:C..:;,~~;tLC), .. ilF.4-~Ii~? ....{tAl!.ll,£.,:..I..-....i£-~~ _"f(,Jj':6JV;J'tJ~C:(;f.'~~~~
.;ffiu:fJtt~L·ctjjL~JvIJLf"~~.J.JJI...(uU;~~l--'~~~JtIJ .~ 1'.r:·,j~:._lLt;}, t"'l
""",-tv.. , " v
"JI.4-h.~Cil..c..::.?ctjj~I::'~~(~~~~r1-:-,IG ~'L';~ .
. ,. .t)7v:rJ~~J¥~~¢'J.. .
;;IA~ '-if. v.i~J' ~,,_,JoiJ 7,(/. d1r L..::. ~~_,..IiiJ ~(. j-=-..G r,;Y
I) '.I'.J)~~~~ ~ c~o.Jk c,~tf?"!'4(j~,d~L~~v'..fC;IVV .
. ..1~J1 ~~AJ' '1.-~. L~,... ....... /~~.I' , •• W,
. .lJI • .:;..Vjof ~ I..-L'!-! 'uJ~v1l(h5J 'Vi \ .1> ~~(DETERMIN]SM) ~~;:LvJ.tJJJ;.;,jJC!!"lj;:~'~7(y) !4-J.J1~IJJ..~V:(./'1!4~ .. U.{;~IJ#, i.e;..
. O-~~LJ.UvLJ:1'J..:JJVI~";:~ .. iss,> "I~' . ·
. ., · ./ ~(. , ....... ,. JJ
,.~ .,,... .... J.. ", . '.'
u-1~~¥"'4:frf0JJvf'4J."~(jP"»?~)j.171b-6~
U L.;-!. 40L Irlii, JUJr'(SPIRIT) Cthv..J.tvL (M~}!fR) DJ ,,,,,...L..-L- L":"('
.f'{.~~~.£.fttJ (UN.SEEN) ~~hl¢..L~14.::;..~mJY~VJ~ ~ l~l:JJ~I.!i.A}('(SPIRIT) ld~l~vtW';"""~.lIJ/tY£VIV:~~/ lj L,;, .... ~), ~ of r..::.~J,U:&.j1 'aL~~·Ll,.:J';JI;:- ~LJ~~l!)u.:"r·
. ~/.tt.(j~)()'!.)/4--~&" (BRINGLE PATTISON) ~JI;u'<..JJ.b·IJ.IIL ;~I~~~It.£/~L6u:~~".,~)",,~L;I./J'~J."~jiiJ((CREATION) -:;~~~vJJ(f'L;J,J,JJJa_LJj(./'t(. .. t\.,iI4~~k(j~)~/~ V,t~Ii)""1~~cJ,~j'IJJIL...s'':~.I';.JJ'J''.I.J'C,J~U'f:V:.I~~C4.
.: ..f;"{JJ~~JIV('GJJ£.~""'t'J-· (UNSEEN OR SPIRITUAL WORLD)
&:.r ~ v(./.-=-' ~"" I ., . .,
(ABSOLUTE FREEDOM) ~O.J~rJ;I~I,;e;)aL~t.v. IJJ-'f
0'- t: . ~ l.».!"!Lr cL ..;;..rJ- . ...[,/'-t;"' 'j'4'.d.ul V)V IJJ 1.1.% i::,kJ
4- (SUPPIrnSSION) ~ ~} ·~v,~ eli ;(fJLLJ-1.f'(.$";;4 ~~U~,JJI~~J.fo)I;~~I.d.~t;~.J~~~ (ADDITION) ;t..;,
•• "t ..
~-4(L...?vyLJV~04~~;l~.JL;(.Yi tf'~-I,~~vJ I~ '4-r~f.J (PURE MOVEMENT) ~..:»~ (Et:.JERGY) u ~~)·u;IJLulf.Ld"
I
",t.et~,)'c..t .. ~ID)L .~J1", fotifl (SOLID ITY)..:;:)"r))IJ)s;,L .
0L~lFm'~~~) l,t..;;.IS" l.(/."J.lb.,.lt~v .... -f'''''().!f ~ 4-(lf,.;'J~u:J~I}~~~~t;J")L~")L..r4-J('ifv~~.:.r . t"UJ,..oIJ;Iu-'[.,~'VJ} .:;-t;.:'1""'-'J"~J-1"&;J;'>.Lj~~ J(gJ)t4l"IU:-:$~MU;~)L .t:.,..J:;;I!iI.:.. lFJ.Uo..IIJIIJJIP'J.I-M l_,J", _.};j f~Jr,;J:f'FJ..JJ ~ C: ~liLl~, 4-C:)JljJ.~dV £t~1
(CREATIVE FREEDOM (~, .~~cJ)~.J""~ (DEVELOPMENT)
"~~£~k,-,?JI::-~ (PU~ SPIRIT) U:~4~)(~r;Jy£d 'err (CREATIVE Jr!i(J:?,J~J4-J/~J.j~J(;j""JifV\ ~ /.(1"
.~'11( (CREATlVJ', IMPETIJS)1-i!J!t ACTIVITy) (,) ~), _I
(CREATIVE FREEDOM) (~, ... JI;> ... : gJ ~'.~
(/~I,;S Uj~IJ It, ... 1110'1 (NICHOLAS BERDYEAU) ~;:~
(EXTERIORISATION AND OBJECTIVISATION OF SPIRITUAL PRINCIPLES)
.. .. i..W.~)iUJIL
dl THE DIVINE AND THE HUMAN: p. 5 I)
?f~"~y q , ~~YV~~WI
C- ...:.Jo(...-Jt)L" (,h '~""/4-d~£"" (JULIAN HUXEL Y) d:l, ~s.:rIJ)/ (REALISE) / ........ ~I
. I of 'I
(RELIGION WITHOUT REVELA TION:-p. 84.\- -
-:)4-c:i~ £""(4-6.1' ~.::..v0i(r.) dl'W.I.t.; .4-~cf.';(f"';IJ.(A£,}J,:~·10..:.t;:V;;
(TijE PHILOSOPHICAL BASIS OF BIOLOGY: p.12S)
_. vJ ~"-' ci'vlj\J(..[!.
~ .. ... II
"t.....:%'IJ ....:,.. ~ (' /4 -:~VVI4-J..::...(~~",=", ~~'.lDI.i!_.jjf
(SPIRlTUALISATION OF ~.::.,.1;..""~!JJIJ,;.:::... (MATERIALISATION OF SPIRIT)
.L (8 PIRI1) s: -» 1J:.1 tll).J ";';.I;j .;.::-;;( if.41f~ 1.r"~'J! MA TIER) cf.~:;-ql'~~~...::<.1"';' .. ;V~. ··tw'JL ,,)V'''''''' JA"~""r'r4'Ji)'
~~l.(I'~VI;;-l--.;cJL£ (SPIRI1) l~' /".. •• .:;"~I~~~JI4-J~.I,'I~(PERSONALITY) • < --~L-
. t .J:.,J:xL.(G_"lcll~'4-l:f.l? Jjtf~L).:;.·,L,; L (INDIVIDUALITY) /.. .. +'.£,-,!)}~ ... :A::r&;L~.IJt~~C)l)4-J~/.t;:f~/dJJt J'V.~ (SPIRIT) .J4.,e'J'4J..t~UO~LAf.lu.~'r'~L (8PIRI1)
.40L·I}?J~ljvlJ.vjtJ;;J,~~u.J/J~rJ;
~!~JL~y q 1\ ~yY~dLJ.
(EMERGENT EVOLUTION).,.(;;;'J~~/~ L'JJt. . .lJ~:~ £'jL ~;j1! ' .,::,.,;{ (C.L LOYD MORGAN) Jy..J.J..'t;;J(
(SUPREME ~1~_"~£liJ~Iu--'1,Jur:L:.G9"~~J~~I(.)!
(.~4-Jt;r:~.v'(l1cJl;:" ~,~:, :?~c.( /~~ MIND) .JJ'~~JI~.r."c:(,(f(..J.At·,L~d,J.;j.;lJ'V:~t.IJ~~G!'-1.Af"
S~)J4~~~y.·4-~~!,(.;!~~~lt...(~~~;,
.4~UV~V"(DIV1NE AGENCY) ~"JLJ 'J~~JWJ'~vC~..Ii"
. .. ,:... .,
,,~y-~~~~~i('~(,f J'J~,..ar" JIJL)'~~~{t ~~,J
.JJI/IJJI"'~ £",;;.,rljtJf~;Lfd.. c:"" JiJ'cJl'/JJI"AlU HJ-'~~44- J L"vt(:.f.~~~£(..t'iJ~U' JLvrdJ.$LjJtL:' "ls' ~J' I~;P ~)I ';iI" ? "(it; ~,.J H#J •••• ~ •••••• (..(.2......:J~ldJLW.~Ju/~(.)! ~..t;"~J.J..~'Jj~ ~fjc.;::'I,J..(c.tf')JLy&:GLf4Jfjl~';.IJJ .. oA
~4j{(J''';';i~
. '4~(~'::"/.JJ
trot '-:J~~tt.lJI#¥;tt';f~~GLI-:;V:()).lUIff4~~X ~/;Jt.;.4-';,·(~~~~",'tf.tAPJfM~'f.C-v'~~
(THE GREAT DESI GN) 4»I':::"J."."tcJj(oJcJ~;"J I _ (..,J.::;.. ~
. ...·.~Lr.yJ;J l::.,.*~~-.d~~.J j;..JLJ.~';;4.J~
"i,L;L__;.iv,4c:-fv:" ~(;:'L (THE NATURE OF THE PHYSICAL WORLD)
b(JU~-4"r: (SUPERNA1URALISM)/"::"'~IJ)'~JH4W7'" ~4)/(/~'J;;r-j4-J'!7IJ:.'J,,~t!JI4t:iJ d~ "v:.~ t;:Lvl.~
u?'t~l~/ q ~ ~lfyyi~L.J1 .
~/Jv.:;.,jUlIJj'<f.1~~~"I"'!k!..ULLLI.J~""1~~~J..-" .::::. f\ rr' -r,. ~tr' ~'-:-'c(~.J~L~;~~JlP.
-----0----
,1' ,oj . . h
~1 L ""lJ" I1A1!+'~.lJf~t,...'-.JIr,"" i~.::::...,::..~.: • /' ~'C~' ,
~Lt!JLJ~d.~UI . .:;-f.~~'ffr....(,~O,~}(,).J~y., l& .. -
• ldl ':v, ... ./ &,..; t: c: 11.f::orJ{;L.iI~ .:G,~,::::,vl'4f.J.4, ",:-,~II>'._:....t,
tdJi'!U'J~L~.~~tJ:: kLi(~~J:~;;J'JJit-:,.:..f .~;J ;1 ~".1~~~Y~~~:)..:..-t:'~ ,l;:Lv'~ .. ;/u:1_).(.JL:;'~~~~')L-:~ ~(J (;;f14-~~ ){,)~d. ... .,...rVI~ L,;q4--b~V:Vt.UwIYJ'N;l;
~v.&1 ~J~ ~, uL..Jj .L"':'/""'''.£~I.::- ... r4J..:y_';.t~ ":;"jl:.if '4-' ~Jj ·~.JY...J;..Jl (MYSTICISM) ~",::~~(~(rljb-1J...t:; (r" Zit-4'v,.~A; J~JJ~J.J(j(...J·,J~;~~¢i~Jt~(..!()y~...;.,C1'~;.!~
O.Ji,....L(j.,:'\/r;.,rll~ r~.bY,'J~~ J¥" ·4-~.Jl'llf<\ '-y?/( ..LC:clt:.....? LV'lu.~h .Ui't.-!? ~:~t eJl"" 1:~'-1.J'" 11iI!L..t;f~o-:~) ,k:., I::'~ 4~t.4-::) br:iJtJ(..il~ LuLcL ~.4fJ'..;..~.J' J:.II'~?,;~~
"y (tr' ~.t"~[)/....(,t", t» ... -r;.l.J':d?",,_,t'~~I~kLj;'"r"1 · ~~~SL.I~W~'J?UiLr;L"N;ttLf~I~)"o".1.1';""/~.4--~
f1 ,)J~ Ii!:... J~W;:_L. , ~ · i "I '*; iI .. ~".
~ "J"j.":"'V~L~~~~I:.''''V:jL.tIJ;[); (, '-, v H';~) ifJJ'(..:.~u ~td J(..:.I':::"~J"' VIJ,jL .~~"Y'J ~JVl,..'~:L.'; L.r.:~~~~y~.t:;..';L""';~JI";""~.i(fd:../J:.!.'jj"jtl'lcJl~'';' '--I.¥;.J~4..:Jp'L~t.f,tf. (DEAN ~GE) ~ri."':l,.f,~;td-I~
-""/4
~td-~"??' I .• !~Y~dt.J'
·~?,.tl{V!JJI4"/Tu.:-J~ )~,t, u:!I:!Jif.;! '~JJc,t?JcJl;
(G9Q.ANDTHE ASTRONOMERS: p. 13b· .
~ .. ;' .. ~ III '!A/ .' ~ ~ - I · "
.:l...::.,·r~.J(J.lZr..::..(,f'(...JL;iI .... J.Ii.{'~VI _ A 'I '.
~~~vlck'4.(l'~IIvLv_';:J.:.il~1 V- V/J... ~<A
~~~~J;J,U:~JJ;J ir:'4~LJI.~6u1 ~uj' tLlt: .. _ ~ I
(/,:1.-1:;. ;!:./v:fJ-'"JC'lj rr L ":;'~'J :LvI. t,)j ~~!J tJ.:t('~~(,'-;-/";"~u!f,fJJJJ2....t7J~~~~4(;~
~Jj.';;'~JJ{~~~.y~:~J()!~j -:-,,,t(JL.Jj2..(./'14 ~ ,LJlu~~~J j,J_»~£;:T.v'~~..,~ -:~;{
(LECTURES: p. 40)
. ·1 V;2!.cV"
/~;L.L~Uv4)/c::....yd'-'Vi:l"IJ~j{;J_L~v
r' U;J1.orL-=-d ;:f' M!s j)~~~ l,.J)I~ ,'-J:_,f IJjJJ ~.J,IL
. (LECTURES: p. 107) ~4"~"J'J-:.('(./',jvJ~JJtf.J4~lYjJ_(./'1 -
4jl-r',d./"'(,£iJ:. •. ~ (N ATIJRE) ...:-jJ A '4-J»Uv(...:.._P; V~~ PLVI~..=.';JtJl~4-#6.,~~(f~".J~lj ~.i:4ttJ',.!iPc::!...J1
. (LECTURES: p. 54) :4L~L(~I~)J~'-!Jy.(r-,~jJr