Introduction to
Hydraulic Workover &
Snubbing Solutions
History of Hydraulic Workover
Hydraulic Workover “HWO” is a well
workover performed using a hydraulic
workover (snubbing) unit to run and/or pull
tubulars – with or without surface pressure
present on the wellhead.
Hydraulic Workover Techniques in use since
1920’s
First Hydraulic Units developed in 1959
2
Definition of Snubbing
Snubbing is the process of running and pulling tubing, drillpipe, or casing with
surface pressure present on the wellhead.
Snubbing also describes a force-balance condition (or the “pipe-light”
condition) where an external force is required to prevent the workstring from
being force out of the hole.
In some situations, Hydraulic Workover (HWO) may also be used to trip
tubulars into and out of wells with no existing or anticipated surface pressure.
3
Reasons for Utilizing HWO
When CT or Wireline is incapable of performing the task
When reservoir damage is anticipated
When platform infrastructure is inadequate
Cost considerations
HPHT/Critical Deviation - Emergency Work
4
Benefits of HWO Services
Operations are completed while under pressure, well does not need to be
killed.
Reduces Costs by eliminating need for kill fluids
Eliminates risk of damaging producing formation with kill fluids
Compact size, mobile, fast rig up/rig down
Reduces overall costs
Well remains in production
Versatile - Rotational ability allows drilling/milling
5
Misconceptions for Using HWO Services
Ø For “Last Ditch” effort on problem/critical wells in emergency
situations.
Can be used for all applications - routine or critical.
Ø For only “live” well remedial services.
Can be used on “live” or “dead” wells.
Ø For only high pressure applications.
Can be used on low pressure applications as well.
Ø Very expensive.
Can be a very cost effective tool.
6
Safety Considerations For HWO
Thorough Pre-Job Planning
Required Employee Training & PPE
Perform Preventive Maintenance Service to Equipment
Location Safety Meetings Conducted
Location Standards Adhered To
Engineering Calculations Considered
Location Layout of Equipment
7
Hydraulic Workover Unit
Conventional Stand Alone Hydraulic
Workover units are self contained
operating systems consisting of modular
equipment groups that are easily
transported and rigged up
8
Components of HWO Unit
Work Basket and control panel
Hydraulic Jack assembly
Traveling Slips
Rotary Table
Guide Tubes
Stationary Slips
Hydraulic power pack,
accessories, and hydraulic
hoses
Circulating swivel, kelly hose,
and pumps
BOP Stack
9
Workbasket
The workbasket, located on top of
the jack, is used as a work platform.
Controls for the jack, traveling and
stationary slips, BOPs, and
counterbalance are located in the
work basket.
10
Control Panel
Typically there are two control
panels, one for the jack operator
and one for the helper. The operator
controls the vertical movement of
the jack and the operation of the
slips. The helper operates a
counterbalance that lifts and lowers
joints of pipe to and from the
basket.
11
Traveling and Stationary slips
Traveling Slips – located on the
traveling assembly, which moves
vertically up and down as the
cylinder rods are extended and
retracted
Stationary Slips – attached to the
base of the jack and are used to
hold the pipe while the traveling
slips are not engaged
12
Hydraulic Jack Assembly
Hydraulic jack – one or more
hydraulic cylinders configured to
move the pipe into and out of the
hole
Guide Tube – placed in the bore
of the jack to provide the lateral
support necessary to prevent
buckling of the workstring
13
Rotary Table
Hydraulically driven 22000ft/lb Rotary used for milling / Drilling and
fishing operations
14
Power Tongs
Power tongs – rigged up in
the basket to make up
pipe connections
15
Hydraulic power pack,
accessories, and hydraulic hoses
The power pack, located
on the ground or deck,
supplies the hydraulic
pressure necessary to
operate the jack, BOPs,
rotary, counterbalance and
power tongs.
16
Circulating Swivel, Kelly Hose
and Pumps
A circulating swivel is
placed on top of the
tubing and allows fluid to
be pumped through the
tubing during milling or
washout operations
The swivel is connected to
the pumps with flexible
hose or chicksan lines.
17
Hydraulic Workover “Basic Jack”
TELESCOPING
GINPOLE W/ DUAL POWER TONG
COUNTERBALNCE SUPPORT ARM
WINCH
POWER TONGS
WORKBASKET
TRAVELING HEAD W/
BASKET RISER ROTARY AND TRAVELING
SLIPS
GUY WIRES GUY WIRES
TELESCOPING TUBING
JACK FRAME
GUIDE
STATIONARY
SNUB SLIPS
STATIONARY
HEAVY SLIP
WORK WINDOW
STRIPPER BOWL
18
19
Stand Alone Units
Advantages
High Available Lift/Snub Capacity - to 460,000 lb.
High Available Rotary Torque Capacity - to 20,000
lb/ft
Compact (smaller footprint)
Handles Widest Range of Tubulars - 3/4” - 13 3/8”
Vertical RU
Unit can operate as stand alone
Unit can operate as Rig Assist
20
HWO Stand Alone Unit Specs
Data 235k 460k
Maximum Hook Load (lbs) 235,000 460,000
Maximum Snub Load (lbs) 150,000 230,000
Block Speed Down, Max (ftlmin) 178 137
Block speed Up, Max (ftlmin) 223 112
Jack Weight (lbs) 22,000 27,000
Power Unit Weight (lbs) 10,500 11,000
Horsepower (hp) 600 600
Engine (Mitsubishi) S6A3 S6A3
Tubing Size Range (in.) 3/4" to 7-5/8" ¾” to 7-5/8"
Thru Bore Size (in.) 24" 24"
Jack Stroke (ft) 10ft 10ft
Rotary Torque (ftllbs) 11000ft/lbs 22,000ft/lbs
Jack Leg Number & Size (in.) 4 Legs, 5" 4 Legs, 7"
System Pressure (psi) 3,000 3,000
21
Snubbing Unit in Drilling Rig
22
460k HWO System
2” CT vs. 2 3/8” or 2 7/8”
Coiled Tubing
460k JACK Drilling
Drilling
Margin of Over pull 0-30,000 lbs 70-130,000 lbs
Hydraulics* 4700 psi 2400 psi
Rotation Not possible 6000 - 20000 ft-lbs
Buckling >1000 lbs WOB >4000 lbs WOB
Jar Placement Only above BHA Optimally placed
Component Weight Less than 35 tons Less than 11 tons
* @ 2 bbl/min
23
Applications
Fishing or Milling Inside Tubing or Casing
Cleaning out formation plugs in production tubing, liner, or casing
Drilling out Cement and Bridge Plugs
Washing out Frac Materials
Pressure Control / Well killing
Circulating Out Heavy Mud or Fluids
Running and Pulling Retrievable Plugs for Selective Treatments
Acidizing and Washing
Removing Ice and Hydrates from Christmas Tree or Tubing
Running Macaroni Tubing to Pump Nitrogen in Wells where Depth and
Pressure are too Great for Coiled Tubing
Completing Under Pressure
Gravel Packing (Sand Consolidation)
Squeeze Cementing or Plugging Back
Plugging and Abandoning
24
Solids Removal
Washing sand bridges
Washing proppent materials
Foam/Nitrogen washes
Washing with formation compatible fluids
Washing out plugged drill strings
De-scaling operations
25
Drilling – Extended Reach
Drilling out from under surface (complete wellbore package)
Conventional sidetrack
Through tubing sidetrack
Re-entry
Underbalanced drilling
Drilling into underground blowout
26
Plug and Abandonment
Pull/fish existing completions
Set/squeeze cement plugs
Set CIBP
Cut/pull casing
Mill out cement plugs under pressure
27
Completion Operations, Live/Dead, Single or Dual
Running bit and scraper assembly
Milling cement
Tubing conveyed perforating guns
Setting packer(s)
Run completion string(s)
Gravel packing and other sand consolidation task
28
Recompletions and Workover, Live or Dead Well
Pull/fish existing completions
Mill packers
Pump/squeeze cement
Straddle assemblies
Repair casing problems
Run bit & scraper assembly
Tubing conveyed perforating guns
Set Packers
Run completion strings
Gravel packing and other sand consolidation task
Run/pull ESP
29
MECHANICS OF
HYDRAULIC WORKOVER
Mechanics of Hydraulic HWO
Primary pressure control during hydraulic workover
operations is provided by a self-energizing stripper and
through an assembly of stripping rams. The stripping rams
consists of two sets of rams, one on top of the other. There
are opened one at a time to allow the collar of the
connections between joints of pipe to pass through the rams.
Below the stripping rams are the safety rams, which may
consist of a shear/blind blowout preventer and an annular
BOP. The tertiary barrier, a shear/seal BOP, sits below this
directly above the Xmas tree.
31
Mechanics of Hydraulic Workover
A HWO rig-up is a very tall structure. It consists of a hydraulically powered
HWO unit, which provides the force on a pipe, above string of multi-layered
pressure control components.
At the top of the HWO unit is the basket, which serves as the control post for
the rig-up. Below the basket are the hydraulic jacks, which powers the pipe
into an out of the hole. It consists of two mechanisms for applying force to
the pipe in either direction. Each mechanism consists of traveling and
stationary slips. The traveling slips are used to move the pipe, while the
stationary slips are used to hold the pipe while the traveling slips are
repositioned between strokes.
32
Mechanics of Hydraulic Workover
The Rotary and Traveling Slips
can work simultaneously.
33
Mechanics of Hydraulic Workover
Stationary and Traveling Slips are
both engaged at beginning of
snubbing stroke.
34
Mechanics of Hydraulic Workover
Stationary Slips are disengaged
With Traveling Slips engaged, the
hydraulic cylinders are extended
retracted - lowering the tubing -
and completing the stroke.
35
Mechanics of Hydraulic Workover
Process is repeated as the tubing
is snubbed through the BOP
Stripper rams or annular
36
Ram to Ram HWO Procedures
STEP1: With tree valve
open, BHA is lowered
through snubbing stack –
All BOP rams are open.
PV#1, PV#4, PV#7, PV#8
are closed
BOP #2 Stripper rams are
closed around tubing
above BHA
Tubing is snubbed until tool
joint/connection is between
BOP #1 rams and BOP#2
rams
37
Ram to Ram HWO Procedures
STEP 2: Close BOP#1
stripper rams
STEP 3: Open Hydraulic
PV#1
STEP 4: Allow pressure
under BOP #2 stripper
rams to equalize below
BOP#1 stripper rams
38
Ram to Ram HWO Procedures
STEP 5:Open BOP#2
stripper rams
STEP 6: Snub tubing into
the well bore until tool joint/
connection is below BOP
#2 stripper rams
STEP 7: Close PV#1
39
Ram to Ram HWO Procedures
STEP 8:Close BOP#2
stripper rams
STEP 9: Open PV#4 and
allow pressure between
Bop#1 ans BOP#2 stripper
rams to bleed off
STEP 10: Allow pressure to
bleed to -0- between
stripper rams
40
Ram to Ram HWO Procedures
STEP 11:Open BOP#1
stripper rams
STEP 12: Close PV#4
STEP 13: Again, tubing is
snubbed until joint/
connection is between
BOP#1 and BOP#2
stripper rams
REPEAT THE PROCESS
41
ENGINEERING
Theory
Pressure – Area Calculations
To snub pipe into a pressured well,
a downward force greater than the
well pressure force must be applied
to the tubular. The well pressure
force is a function of the surface
pressure and the size of the pipe.
43
Engineering Calculations For HWO Applications
Collapse / Burst Calculations for Tubing - Based on
Anticipated Compression and Tension Loads
Critical Buckling Load Limitations Calculated - Based on
Unsupported Length & Snub Force
Required Snubbing Force
Required Hydraulic Snub / Lift Pressure - Jack Forces
Well Control Considerations
44
Calculations
Calculate Snub Force P= F/A
F= P x A
P= Pressure (psi)
F= Force (lbf)
A= Area (in2)
45
Example Snub Force Calculation
A well has 1200 psi surface pressure.
What is the well pressure force when
the seal is:
a) Applied to the tube body
b) Applied to the connection
Workstring: 1-1/4” 3.02 lb/ft CS-Hydril N-80
Tube OD = 1.660”
Connection OD= 1.927”
46
Frictional Forces
Force is required to overcome the frictional resistance of the BOP (or
stripping rubber) through which the pipe is being moved. The magnitude
of the frictional force depends on the pipe size and surface roughness and
the BOP operating pressure. Because the frictional force always acts to
oppose motion, it acts upwards when snubbing into a well.
47
Total Snub Force
The weight of the pipe itself acts downwards and
therefore helps to lower the pipe into the well. When
first snubbing into the hole, the weight of the
snubbing string is usually negligible and may
generally be ignored. Therefore, the maximum
required snubbing force occurs as pipe is first started
in the hole.
Max Snub Force (lbs) = Well Pressure Force (lb) + Friction
Force (lb)
F MAX SNUB = FWP + FFRIC
48
Tri-axial Stress
There is more than one stress that can be exerted on the tubing
Axial Stress (compression or tensile)
Radial Stress (burst and collapse)
Hoop Stress (shear)
Torque
49
Von Mises Distortion Energy Theory
50
Buoyancy
As more pipe is run into the hole, the buoyed weight of the snubbing
string increases. Eventually, the buoyed weight equals the well pressure
force. When this happens, the pipe will no longer be forced out of the
hole by the pressure-area force. This is generally known as balance point.
At balance point :
Buoyed string weight(lb) = Pressure Area Force(lb)
W = FWP
51
Required Hydraulic Pressure
The snubbing and lifting forces required to run and pull
the workstring are produced by a multiple hydraulic
jack cylinders. When snubbing, the cylinders are
pressured on the piston rod side; when pulling pipe,
the cylinders are pressured on the opposite side.
52
Pipe Buckling- Inelastic/Elastic
After the required snubbing force is established,
it must be confirmed that the workstring can
support this compressive load without buckling.
With increasing compressive load, buckling will
first occur in the maximum unsupported length
of the workstring.
53
Engineering Calculations For HWO Applications
54
Downhole Tools for HWO
Working against pressure requires
special tools in the snubbing string. To
enable making and breaking of pipe
connections as the workstring is
tripped into and out of a pressured
well, fluid flow through the string
must be prevented. This is
accomplished with backpressure
valves located near the end of the
workstring.
55
Backpressure Valves
Backpressure valves (BPVs) serve as check valves in the
workstring. They permit fluid flow in one direction only. Two types
of BPVs are typically used in HWO:
Ball and Seat BPV
Flapper-type BPV
Profile nipples provide a measure of pressure control redundancy
incase the BPVs should fail
56
Bottomhole Assembly (BHA)
The BHA can be designed for specific applications.
Overshot assemblies when conducting fishing operations
Mills for working through damaged wellbore or pipe
Jars and bumper subs for sticky conditions
Specifically designed jet nozzles for HP cleanouts and scale
removal
Pump-off assemblies
Sliding sleeves
Completion BHAs
57
Workstring
During HWO operations, the workstring is routinely subjected to
compression loads that can be much more severe than those
encountered in normal workover situations. Consequently, there is
a greater risk of tubular failure due to buckling.
Due to these concerns, workstrings are specifically designed for
the application.
58
Workstring Connections
All connections must be properly made up. (Stabbing guide, Thread
dope etc.) Over torque or under torque should not be permitted.
Torque supplied from rotary, power swivel, PDM must not exceed
minimum make-up torque.
59
Stabbing Valves (TIW)
Stabbing valves should be full opening valves and have an inside
diameter at least equivalent to the workstring inside diameter.
Must have the same connection threads as the workstring
Must be tested with BOPs
60
Why Safety is such a concern?
SAFETY is the PRIMARY concern in Hydraulic Workover
Operations.
• Working under pressure
• Working at elevated heights
• Working around heavy equipment and pressurized lines
• Working with hazardous fluids and gases (Zinc Bromide, H2S, N2)
• Working in hazardous environments (extreme weather conditions,
noise)
• Pinch Points
• Tubing Handling Procedures
61
Designing a Job
Identify the proper Hydraulic Workover unit for application (max
70% of snub/pull force)
Design proper workstring/tools for applications
Design proper fluid and pump program
Pre-job models (hydraulic and force)
Equipment design (BOPs, flowback iron, choke manifolds etc.)
Running procedures
62
Safety / Escape Devices
PPE
H2S Equipment
Escape devices
Stair Towers
Ant fall devices
Slides
Low Speed Decenders
Fall arrest poles
Work Platforms
63
Questions and Answers
64