0% found this document useful (0 votes)
97 views15 pages

The Coronally Advanced Flap in Combination With Platelet-Rich Fibrin (PRF) and Enamel Matrix Derivative in The Treatment of Gingival Recession: A Comparative Study

prf
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
97 views15 pages

The Coronally Advanced Flap in Combination With Platelet-Rich Fibrin (PRF) and Enamel Matrix Derivative in The Treatment of Gingival Recession: A Comparative Study

prf
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 15

CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig

No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n

n
The Coronally Advanced Flap in ss e n c e
fo r

Combination with Platelet-rich Fibrin


(PRF) and Enamel Matrix Derivative
in the Treatment of Gingival
Recession: A Comparative Study
Sasha Jankovic, DDS, PhD
4DIPPMPG%FOUJTUSZ %FQBSUNFOUPG1FSJPEPOUJDT 6OJWFSTJUZPG#FMHSBEF 3FQVCMJDPG4FSCJB

Zoran Aleksic, DDS, PhD


4DIPPMPG%FOUJTUSZ %FQBSUNFOUPG1FSJPEPOUJDT 6OJWFSTJUZPG#FMHSBEF 3FQVCMJDPG4FSCJB

Iva Milinkovic, DDS


4DIPPMPG%FOUJTUSZ %FQBSUNFOUPG1FSJPEPOUJDT 6OJWFSTJUZPG#FMHSBEF 3FQVCMJDPG4FSCJB

Bozidar Dimitrijevic, DDS, PhD


4DIPPMPG%FOUJTUSZ %FQBSUNFOUPG1FSJPEPOUJDT 6OJWFSTJUZPG#FMHSBEF 3FQVCMJDPG4FSCJB

Correspondence to: Dr Sasha Jankovic


6OJWFSTJUZPG#FMHSBEF4DIPPMPG%FOUJTUSZ %FQBSUNFOUPG1FSJPEPOUJDT 

%S4VCPUJDB4U  #FMHSBEF 3FQVCMJDPG4FSCJBUFM FNBJMESTBTIBK!HNBJMDPN

260
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n

n
"CTUSBDU ss e n c e
fo r
Objective: 5IF NBJO PCKFDUJWF PG UIJT BOEœNNJOUIF&.%HSPVQ
TUVEZXBTUPFWBMVBUFUIFDMJOJDBMFGGFD BU  NPOUIT 5IF EJGGFSFODF PCTFSWFE
UJWFOFTTPGQMBUFMFUSJDImCSJONFNCSBOF CFUXFFO UIF UXP HSPVQT BU  NPOUIT
VTFE JO DPNCJOBUJPO XJUI B DPSPOBMMZ XBT TUBUJTUJDBMMZ TJHOJmDBOU "WFSBHF
advanced flap (CAF) and to compare it SPPU DPWFSBHF XBT  JO UIF &.%
XJUIUIFVTFPGBOFOBNFMNBUSJYEFSJWB HSPVQBOEJOUIF13'HSPVQ8,5
UJWF &.%
 JO DPNCJOBUJPO XJUI B DPSP XBTœNNJOUIF&.%HSPVQ
OBMMZ BEWBODFE nBQ JO HJOHJWBM SFDFT BOE  œ  NN JO UIF 13' HSPVQ
TJPOUSFBUNFOU BUCBTFMJOF BOEœNNJOUIF
Materials and methods:  TQMJUNPVUI &.%HSPVQBOEœNNJOUIF
DBTFT PG NBYJMMBSZ BOUFSJPS UFFUI PS CJ 13'HSPVQBUNPOUIT5IFEJGGFSFODF
DVTQJETQSFTFOUJOHXJUI.JMMFS$MBTT*PS PCTFSWFECFUXFFOUIFUXPHSPVQTBU
** HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO XFSF USFBUFE XJUI NPOUIT XBT OPU TUBUJTUJDBMMZ TJHOJmDBOU
B $"' DPNCJOFE XJUI B QMBUFMFUSJDI m 5XFMWFNPOUI DIBOHFT JO 1% XFSF OPU
CSJONFNCSBOF 13'HSPVQ
PSXJUI&.% TJHOJmDBOUMZ EJGGFSFOU CFUXFFO UIF UXP
&.%HSPVQ
QMBDFEVOEFSB$"'5IF HSPVQT 5IF QBJO JOUFOTJUZ XBT TUBUJTUJ
GPMMPXJOHQBSBNFUFSTXFSFNFBTVSFEBU DBMMZ EJGGFSFOU CFUXFFO HSPVQT GPS UIF
CBTFMJOF BOE BU  NPOUIT QPTU USFBU mSTUEBZT GBWPSJOHUIF13'HSPVQ
NFOU HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO (3
 BQJDP Conclusions:5IFQSFTFOUTUVEZEJEOPU
DPSPOBM XJEUI PG UIF LFSBUJOJ[FE UJTTVF TVDDFFE JO EFNPOTUSBUJOH BOZ DMJOJDBM
8,5
BOEQSPCJOHEFQUI 1%
 BEWBOUBHFPGUIFVTFPG13'DPNQBSFE
Results:$PNQMFUFSPPUDPWFSBHFJOUIF UP &.% JO UIF DPWFSBHF PG HJOHJWBM SF
13'HSPVQXBT PVUPGSFDFT DFTTJPO XJUI UIF $"' QSPDFEVSF 5IF
TJPOT
 BOE  JO UIF &.% HSPVQ  &.% HSPVQ TIPXFE B IJHIFS TVDDFTT
PVU PG  SFDFTTJPOT
 (3 XBT  œ SBUFJOJODSFBTJOH8,5UIBOEJEUIF13'
 NN JO UIF 13' HSPVQ BOE  œ HSPVQ
NNJOUIF&.%HSPVQBUCBTFMJOF 
BOE  œ  NN JO UIF 13' HSPVQ (Eur J Esthet Dent 2010;5:260–273)

261
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig
No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te otn

n
*OUSPEVDUJPO UFSNSFTVMUTZFBSTBGUFS$"'GPSNVMUJ
ss e n c e
fo r
QMF SFDFTTJPO EFGFDUT  SPPU DPWFS
/VNFSPVT QFSJPEPOUBM QMBTUJD TVSHJDBM BHF
"QPUFOUJBMMJNJUBUJPOPGUIF$"'JT
QSPDFEVSFTIBWFCFFOQSPQPTFEJOHJO UIFMJNJUFEHBJOJOUIFBQJDPDPSPOBMEJ
HJWBMSFDFTTJPOUSFBUNFOU5IFZJODMVEF NFOTJPOPGUIFLFSBUJOJ[FEUJTTVF XIJDI
GSFF HJOHJWBM HSBGUT  DPOOFDUJWF UJTTVF JTBOJNQPSUBOUQBSBNFUFSJOQSFWFOUJOH
HSBGUT $5(
 HVJEFE UJTTVF SFHFOFSB UIF SFDVSSFODF PG HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO
UJPO (53
BOEQFEJDMFnBQT5IFTVD Therefore, data indicate that the CAF
DFTTBDIJFWFEXJUIGSFFHJOHJWBMHSBGUT VTFEBMPOFJTBMFTTUIBOPQUJNBMUFDI
JODPWFSJOHEFOVEFESPPUTJTMFTTUIBO OJRVFUPBDIJFWFSPPUDPWFSBHFEFTQJUF
PQUJNBM XJUI SBUFT SBOHJOH CFUXFFO  IBWJOHUIFBEWBOUBHFPGHFOFSBUJOHMPX
BOE5IFmSTUUFDIOJRVFVUJMJ[JOH NPSCJEJUZ " TVSHJDBM UFDIOJRVF UIBU
UIF$5(GPSUSFBUNFOUPGHJOHJWBMSFDFT DBOCFDPNCJOFEXJUIUIF$"'JOPSEFS
TJPO XBT QSFTFOUFE CZ &EFM and later UP PWFSDPNF JUT MJNJUBUJPOT JT EFTJSBCMF
NPEJmFECZPUIFST5IFBEWBOUBHFT GPS UIF NBOBHFNFOU PG HJOHJWBM SFDFT
BTTPDJBUFE XJUI UIF $5( UFDIOJRVF JO TJPO5IF$5(JTPGUFOVTFEJODPNCJOB
DMVEF IJHI TVDDFTT BOE IJHI QSFEJDU UJPOXJUIUIF$"'GPSSPPUDPWFSBHFXJUI
BCJMJUZSBUFTJOBDIJFWJOHSPPUDPWFSBHF  IJHITVDDFTTBOEQSFEJDUBCJMJUZSBUFT
BTXFMMBTBGBWPSBCMFFTUIFUJDPVUDPNF 4FWFSBMDMJOJDBMBOEIJTUPMPHJDBMTUVE
$MJOJDBM TUVEJFT IBWF TIPXO UIBU SPPU JFT SFWFBM UIBU B TQFDJmD QMBUFMFUDPO
DPWFSBHFTVDDFTTSBUFTBTTPDJBUFEXJUI DFOUSBUFEUIFSBQFVUJDDPODFQUDPVMECF
$5(SBOHFGSPNUP5IF(53 BOFODPVSBHJOHNFEJVNGPSUIFJNQSPWF
UFDIOJRVFIBTBMTPCFFOVUJMJ[FEGPSSPPU NFOU PG TPGU UJTTVF IFBMJOH BOE SFHFO
DPWFSBHFQVSQPTFT5IFPSFUJDBMMZ (53 FSBUJPO JO QFSJPEPOUPMPHZ BOE JNQMBO
XPVMEBMTPGBDJMJUBUFUSVFSFHFOFSBUJPOPG UPMPHZ   1MBUFMFUSJDI mCSJO 13'

UIFQFSJPEPOUBMUJTTVFTJOSFDFTTJPOBSF CFMPOHTUPBOFXHFOFSBUJPOPGQMBUFMFU
BT4VDDFTTSBUFTBTTPDJBUFEXJUI(53 DPODFOUSBUFT  XJUI TJNQMJmFE QSPDFTT
BTTJTUFESPPUDPWFSBHFWBSZGSPNUP JOH13'XBTmSTUEFWFMPQFEJO'SBODF
)PXFWFS TJHOJmDBOUQFSJPEPOUBM CZ $IPVLSPVO FU BM GPS TQFDJmD VTF
SFHFOFSBUJPO JO SPPUT DPWFSFE XJUI UIF JO PSBM BOE NBYJMMPGBDJBM TVSHFSZ 13'
(53 UFDIOJRVF IBT OPU ZFU CFFO DPO QSFQBSBUJPOUFDIOJRVFTSFRVJSFTOFJUIFS
mSNFE BOUJDPBHVMBOU OPS CPWJO UISPNCJO 0O
The coronally advanced flap (CAF) is UIF CBTJT PG BDRVJSFE JOGPSNBUJPO  UIJT
BTJNQMFQFEJDMFnBQUIBUDBOCFVUJMJ[FE TUVEZXBTEFTJHOFEUPFWBMVBUFJNQMF
GPSSPPUDPWFSBHFBOEEPFTOPUSFRVJSF NFOUBUJPO PG 13' JO HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO
HSBGU IBSWFTUJOH )PXFWFS  TPNF EBUB USFBUNFOU " 13' NFNCSBOF DPOTJTUT
IBT TIPXO UIBU SPPU DPWFSBHF BTTPDJ PG B mCSJO % NBUSJY QPMZNFSJ[FE JO B
BUFEXJUIUIF$"'VTFEBMPOFJTVOTUBCMF TQFDJmD TUSVDUVSF  XJUI UIF JODPSQPSB
JOUIFMPOHUFSN XIFSFJUEFDSFBTFTGSPN UJPOPGQMBUFMFUT MFVLPDZUFT BOEHSPXUI
BUNPOUIQPTUPQFSBUJWFMZUP GBDUPST BOEUIFQSFTFODFPGDJSDVMBUJOH
BGUFSNPOUIT5PCFNPSFQSFDJTF JU TUFN DFMMT  #JPDIFNJDBM BOBMZTJT
TIPVMECFNFOUJPOFEUIBU;VDDIFMMJBOE of the PRF composition indicates that
De SanctisEFNPOTUSBUFETUBCMFMPOH UIJT CJPNBUFSJBM DPOTJTUT PG BO JOUJNBUF

262
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te not

n
BTTFNCMZPGDZUPLJOFT HMZDBOJDDIBJOT  XBTDPOEVDUFEBUUIFIJTUPMPHJDBMMFWFM
ss e n c e
fo r
BOETUSVDUVSBMHMZDPQSPUFJOTFONFTIFE TIPXFEUIFGPSNBUJPOPGOFXDFNFOUVN 
XJUIJO B TMPXMZ QPMZNFSJ[FE FYQMJDJU m PSHBOJ[FE QFSJPEPOUBM MJHBNFOU mCFST 
CSJO OFUXPSL   Moreover, a spe BOEJTMBOETPGCPOFDMPTFUPUIFUSFBUFE
DJmDmCSJOQPMZNFSJ[BUJPONPEFJO13' SPPUTVSGBDF
provides increased lifespan for these PilloniSFQPSUFETJHOJmDBOUJNQSPWF
DZUPLJOFT  XIJDI JT FTQFDJBMMZ FODPVS NFOUTJOBHSPVQXJUIHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPO
BHJOHGPSUIFIFBMJOHQSPDFTT  USFBUFE XJUI &.% XJUI UIF $"'  DPN
4PGBS UPUIFBVUIPSTLOPXMFEHF POMZ QBSFEUPBHSPVQUSFBUFEXJUI$"'BMPOF 
POF DBTF SFQPSU IBT CFFO QVCMJTIFE BGUFSBONPOUIFWBMVBUJPOQFSJPE*O
SFHBSEJOH UIF VUJMJ[BUJPO PG 13' JO UIF DPOUSBTU  )ÚHFMXBME FU BM compared
USFBUNFOU PG HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO This UIF $"' XJUI UIF $"' QMVT &.%  BOE
TUVEZ FWBMVBUFE XIFUIFS UIF BEEJUJPO GBJMFEUPTIPXTJHOJmDBOUEJGGFSFODFTJO
PGBOBVUPMPHPVTQMBUFMFUSJDImCSJODMPU UIF TVDDFTT PG SPPU DPWFSBHF CFUXFFO
UPBDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQXPVMEJN UIFUXPUSFBUNFOUNPEBMJUJFTPWFSBQF
QSPWFUIFDMJOJDBMPVUDPNFDPNQBSFEUP SJPEPGNPOUIT
B$"'BMPOFGPSUIFUSFBUNFOUPGNVMUJQMF 5IF PCKFDUJWF PG UIF QSFTFOU TUVEZ
HJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOT XBTUPFWBMVBUFUIFDMJOJDBMFGmDBDZPGB
&OBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF &.%
 JT $"'VTFEJODPNCJOBUJPOXJUI13'BOE
B DPNNFSDJBMMZ BWBJMBCMF QSFQBSBUJPO UP DPNQBSF JU XJUI UIF $"' DPNCJOFE
DPOTJTUJOH NBJOMZ PG BNFMPHFOJO BOE XJUI &.%  JO UIF USFBUNFOU PG HJOHJWBM
related proteins derived from porcine SFDFTTJPO
UPPUICVET%VSJOHGFUBMEFWFMPQFNFOU 
UIFTFFOBNFMNBUSJYQSPUFJOT &.1
BSF
secreted and temporarily deposited on Materials and methods
UIFSPPUTVSGBDFCZUIFDFMMTPG)FSUXJHT
FQJUIFMJBM SPPU TIFBUI 5IFZ BQQFBS UP 1BUJFOUT XJMMJOH UP QBSUJDJQBUF JO UIF
CF FTTFOUJBM GPS UIF GPSNBUJPO PG BDFM TUVEZTJHOFEJOGPSNFEDPOTFOUUIBUXBT
MVMBS DFNFOUVN BOE UIF EFWFMPQFNFOU BQQSPWFE CZ UIF &UIJDT $PNNJUUFF PG
PGUIFQFSJPEPOUBMMJHBNFOUBOEBMWFPMBS UIF6OJWFSTJUZPG#FMHSBEF5XFOUZOPO
CPOF &.% IBT CFFO TIPXO UP QSP TNPLJOHQBUJFOUT NBMFT GFNBMFT

NPUF UIF GPSNBUJPO PG BDFMMVMBS DFNFO SBOHJOHJOBHFGSPNUPZFBST QSF
UVN CPOF BOEBGVODUJPOBMQFSJPEPOUBM TFOUJOHXJUITJNJMBSCJMBUFSBM.JMMFS$MBTT*
MJHBNFOU  PS**NBYJMMBSZHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOBSFBT 
)JTUPMPHJDBM EBUB FWBMVBUJOH UIF JN XFSFJODMVEFEJOUIFTUVEZBOEUSFBUFE
QBDUPG&.%JOSPPUDPWFSBHFQSPDFEVSFT at the Periodontics Department of the
DPOmSNFEUIFFGmDBDZPGUIBUQSPDFEVSF 4DIPPM PG %FOUJTUSZ *G B USFBUNFOU BSFB
5IF GPSNBUJPO PG OFX DFNFOUVN BOE QSFTFOUFE XJUI UXP PS NPSF BEKBDFOU
CPOFGPMMPXJOHSPPUDPWFSBHFXJUIBDPO UFFUIXJUISFDFTTJPO POMZUIFUPPUIXJUI
OFDUJWFUJTTVFHSBGUDPNCJOFEXJUI&.%  UIF HSFBUFTU EFHSFF PG HJOHJWBM SFDFT
BMUIPVHI MJNJUFE  IBT CFFO SFQPSUFE TJPOXBTJODMVEFEJOUIFTUVEZ EFTQJUF
"OPUIFSSFQPSUJOXIJDIBOFWBMVBUJPOPG UIFGBDUUIBUBMMPGUIFUFFUIXFSFUSFBUFE
UIF$"'VTFEJODPNCJOBUJPOXJUI&.% EVSJOH UIF TBNF TVSHJDBM QSPDFEVSF

263
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig
No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n

n
ss e n c e
fo r

Fig 1  &OBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF USFBUNFOU HSPVQ Fig 2  &OBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF USFBUNFOU HSPVQ
1SFPQFSBUJWFWJFXTIPXJOHHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPO .JMMFS UPPUI
"CVDDBMnBQXBTFMFWBUFEGPMMPXJOHSPPU
$MBTT*
POUPPUI QSFQBSBUJPO

0UIFS JODMVTJPO DSJUFSJB XFSF BCTFODF UBMUIFSBQZ DBMDVMVTBOETUBJOSFNPWBM



PG DBSJFT PS CVDDBM SFTUPSBUJPOT BOZ XBTQFSGPSNFE
IJTUPSZPGQSFWJPVTQFSJPEPOUBMTVSHJDBM 5IF&.%HSPVQXBTUSFBUFEXJUIBDPSP
USFBUNFOUJOUIFBSFBBOEUIFBCTFODF OBMMZBEWBODFEnBQJODPNCJOBUJPOXJUI
PG UIF SBEJPHSBQIJD TJHOT PG QFSJBQJDBM FOBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF &NEPHBJO®,
JOGFDUJPO PO UIF UFFUI UP CF USFBUFE PS 4USBVNBOO  #BTFM  4XJU[FSMBOE
 "GUFS
POUIFBEKBDFOUUFFUI5SFBUNFOUBSFBT MPDBMBOFTUIFTJB SPPUEFCSJEFNFOUXBT
UIBUQSFTFOUFEPOFPSNPSFUFFUIXJUIB QFSGPSNFE XJUI VMUSBTPOJDT BOE IBOE
HJOHJWBMJOEFYIJHIFSUIBOBGUFSJOJUJBM DVSFUUFT 'JH
"OJOUSBTVMDVMBSJODJTJPO
UIFSBQZXFSFFYDMVEFEGSPNUIFTUVEZ XBT NBEF XJUI B OP$ CMBEF PO UIF
1BUJFOUTXJUITZTUFNJDDPOUSBJOEJDBUJPOT CVDDBMBTQFDUPGUIFUPPUIPSUFFUICFJOH
UPQFSJPEPOUBMTVSHFSZ VOEFSBOZNFEJ USFBUFE)PSJ[POUBMJODJTJPOTXFSFNBEF
DBUJPOLOPXOUPDBVTFHJOHJWBMFOMBSHF BUUIFJOUFSQSPYJNBMDFNFOUPFOBNFMKVOD
NFOU  BOEPS UBLJOH BOUJDPBHVMBOUT  UJPO $&+
MFWFMPGUIFQBQJMMBFBEKBDFOU
XFSFBMTPFYDMVEFEGSPNUIFTUVEZ UPUIFUPPUIPSUFFUICFJOHUSFBUFE5IFTF
5IFTUVEZVTFEBTQMJUNPVUIEFTJHO IPSJ[POUBM JODJTJPOT XFSF FYUFOEFE TP
JOXIJDIUXPUFFUIQSFTFOUJOHXJUIHJOHJ BT OPU UP JOWPMWF UIF HJOHJWBM NBSHJO PG
WBMSFDFTTJPOTVJUBCMFGPSUIFSPPUDPWFS UIF BEKBDFOU UFFUI 5XP PCMJRVF SFMFBT
BHF XFSF SBOEPNMZ BTTJHOFE UP POF PG JOH JODJTJPOT XFSF NBEF BU UIF NFTJBM
UXPUSFBUNFOUHSPVQTB$"'DPNCJOFE BOEEJTUBMFOETPGUIFIPSJ[POUBMJODJTJPO
XJUI &.% &.% HSPVQ
 PS B $"' DPN BOE FYUFOEFE CFZPOE UIF NVDPHJOHJ
CJOFEXJUI13' 13'HSPVQ
3BOEPNJ WBMKVODUJPO"GVMMUIJDLOFTTnBQXBTFM
[BUJPOPGUIFUXPUSFBUNFOUHSPVQTXBT FWBUFE UP FYQPTF BU MFBTU  NN PG UIF
QFSGPSNFE CZ UIF UPTT PG B DPJO #PUI NBSHJOBMCPOFBQJDBMUPUIFEFIJTDFODF
USFBUNFOU QSPDFEVSFT XFSF QFSGPSNFE BSFB 'JH
"IPSJ[POUBMSFMFBTJOHJODJ
CZUIFTBNFPQFSBUPS1SJPSUPTVSHFSZ JO TJPOXBTNBEFJOUIFQFSJPTUFVNBUUIF
CPUIUSFBUNFOUHSPVQT JOJUJBMQFSJPEPO CBTFPGUIFnBQUPBMMPXGPSBUFOTJPOGSFF

264
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n

n
ss e n c e
fo r

Fig 3  &OBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF &.%


 USFBUNFOU Fig 4  &OBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF USFBUNFOU HSPVQ
HSPVQ UPPUI
&.%CFJOHBQQMJFEUPUIFSPPUTVS UPPUI 
 5IF nBQ XBT DPSPOBMMZ BEWBODFE BOE
GBDF TVUVSFEXJUIFYQBOEFEQPMZUFUSBnVPSPFUIZMFOF

DPSPOBM EJTQMBDFNFOU PG UIF nBQ 5IF


SPPU TVSGBDF XBT DPOEJUJPOFE XJUI 
EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid)
HFMGPSNJOVUFT DPQJPVTMZSJOTFEXJUI
XBUFS ESJFEXJUIBHBV[FJOYJO BOE
USFBUFE XJUI &.% BT SFDPNNFOEFE CZ
UIF NBOVGBDUVSFS 'JH 
 5IF $"' XBT
TFDVSFEDPSPOBMUPUIF$&+MFWFMCZTV
UVSJOH JU UP UIF QBQJMMBF XJUI  TVUVSFT
'JH 
 5IF PCMJRVF SFMFBTJOH JODJTJPOT
XFSFDMPTFEXJUIJOUFSSVQUFETVUVSFT
Fig 5  &OBNFM NBUSJY EFSJWBUJWF USFBUNFOU HSPVQ
UPPUI
5XFMWFNPOUIQPTUPQFSBUJWFWJFXTIPX
The PRF protocol JOHDPNQMFUFSPPUDPWFSBHF

"CMPPETBNQMFXBTUBLFOXJUIPVUBOUJ
DPBHVMBOU JO B NM UVCF  XIJDI XBT
JNNFEJBUFMZ DFOUSJGVHFE BU  SQN
BQQSPYJNBUFMZ  H
 GPS  NJOVUFT
#MPPE QSPDFTTJOH XJUI B DFOUSJGVHF GPS
13'BMMPXTUIFDPNQPTJUJPOPGBTUSVD
UVSFEmCSJODMPUJOUIFNJEEMFPGUIFUVCF 
KVTUCFUXFFOUIFSFEDPSQVTDMFTBUUIF
CPUUPNBOEBDFMMVMBSQMBTNBBUUIFUPQ
'JH
"GUFSDPMMFDUJPOPGUIF13'JUTFMG 
SFTJTUBOU BVUPMPHPVT mCSJO NFNCSBOFT
BSF FBTJMZ PCUBJOFE CZ ESJWJOH PVU UIF Fig 6  5IFQSFQBSBUJPOPGQMBUFMFUSJDImCSJO 13'

TFSVNGSPNUIFDMPU 'JH
 13'DMPUSFNPWBM

265
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig
No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n

n
ss e n c e
fo r

Fig 7  "VUPMPHPVT QMBUFMFUSJDI mCSJO NFNCSBOF Fig 8  1MBUFMFUSJDI mCSJO USFBUNFOU HSPVQ 1SF
PCUBJOFECZESJWJOHPVUUIFTFSVNGSPNUIFDMPU PQFSBUJWF WJFX TIPXJOH HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO .JMMFS
$MBTT*
POUPPUI

Fig 9  1MBUFMFUSJDI mCSJO USFBUNFOU HSPVQ UPPUI Fig 10  1MBUFMFUSJDI mCSJO 13'
 USFBUNFOU HSPVQ

"CVDDBMnBQXBTFMFWBUFEGPMMPXJOHSPPUQSFQ UPPUI
'PMMPXJOHUIFQSFQBSBUJPOPG13' B13'
BSBUJPO NFNCSBOF XBT TVUVSFE JO UIF SFDJQJFOU BSFB XJUI
TJML

Fig 11  $PSPOBMMZ BEWBODFE nBQ TVUVSFE PWFS Fig 12  1MBUFMFUSJDImCSJOUSFBUNFOUHSPVQ UPPUI
DPOOFDUJWFUJTTVFHSBGU 
 5XFMWFNPOUI QPTUPQFSBUJWF WJFX TIPXJOH
DPNQMFUFSPPUDPWFSBHF

266
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot

n
5IF13'HSPVQXBTUSFBUFEXJUITPNF ss e n c e fo r
NPEJmDBUJPOTPGUIFUFDIOJRVFEFTDSJCFE
CZ-BOHFSBOE-BOHFS'PMMPXJOHMPDBM
BOFTUIFTJB  SPPU TVSGBDFT JO UIF SFHJPO
CFUXFFO UIF CPUUPN PG UIF TVMDVT BOE
UIF $&+ XFSF TDBMFE BOE QMBOFE XJUI
IBOEBOEVMUSBTPOJDEFWJDFT 'JH
"O
JOJUJBMJOUSBTVMDVMBSJODJTJPOXBTNBEFJO
the recession area of the tooth or teeth ■ &.%oDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQDPNCJOFEXJUIFOBNFMNBUSJYEFSJWBUJWFHSPVQ
■ 13'oDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQDPNCJOFEXJUI13'HSPVQ

XIFSFSPPUDPWFSBHFXBTJOUFOEFE5IF  (3oDIBOHFJOHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOJONJMMJNFUFST


 8,5oDIBOHFJOUIFBQJDPDPSPOBMXJEUIPGUIFLFSBUJOJ[FEUJTTVFJONJMMJNFUFST
 1%oDIBOHFJOQPDLFUEFQUIJONJMMJNJUFST
JOUSBTVMDVMBS JODJTJPO XBT FYUFOEFE UP
UIFNFTJBMBOEEJTUBMMJOFBOHMFTPGUIF Fig 13  .FBO DIBOHFT NN
 SFDPSEFE JO USFBU
UPPUIPSUFFUICFJOHUSFBUFE5XPPCMJRVF NFOUHSPVQTBGUFSNPOUIT
SFMFBTJOH JODJTJPOT XFSF NBEF BU UIF
NFTJBMBOEEJTUBMFOETPGUIFIPSJ[POUBM
JODJTJPO BOE FYUFOEFE CFZPOE UIF NV
DPHJOHJWBMKVODUJPO"GVMMUIJDLOFTTnBQ
XBTSFnFDUFECFZPOEUIFNVDPHJOHJWBM
KVODUJPOTPBTUPFYQPTFBUMFBTUNN
PGCPOFBQJDBMUPUIFNPTUBQJDBMNBSHJO
PGUIFCPOZEFIJTDFODF 'JH
5IFnBQ
XBT GVSUIFS FMFWBUFE CZ TIBSQ EJTTFD
UJPO  XIJDI SFMFBTFE JU GSPN UIF QFSJPT
UFVN 13' NFNCSBOF XBT QPTJUJPOFE ■13'oDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQDPNCJOFEXJUI13'HSPVQ
■ &.%oDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQDPNCJOFEXJUIFOBNFMNBUSJYEFSJWBUJWFHSPVQ
BOE TUBCJMJ[FE XJUI IPSJ[POUBM NBUUSFTT
TVUVSFTJOUIFEFTJSFEQPTJUJPO 'JH

Fig 14  )FBMJOHJOEFY )*
SFTVMUT
5IF nBQ XBT BEWBODFE TP BT UP DPWFS
UIF13'NFNCSBOFBOETVUVSFEXJUI
TJML 'JH

5IF QPTUTVSHJDBM QSPUPDPM XBT UIF
TBNFGPSUIFUXPQSPDFEVSFT1FSJPEPO
UBMESFTTJOHXBTQMBDFEBOEBOUJCJPUJDT
QFOJDJMMJO7,NH FWFSZIPVSTGPS DBMPSBMIZHJFOFDPOTJTUJOHPGCSVTIJOH
EBZT
BOEDIMPSIFYJEJOFHMV BOE nPTTJOH PS JOUFSQSPYJNBM CSVTIJOH
DPOBUF NPVUISJOTF FWFSZ  IPVST GPS BU UIF CFHJOOJOH PG UIF UIJSE QPTUPQ
EBZT
XFSFQSFTDSJCFE0SBMBOBMHF FSBUJWF XFFL 1BUJFOUT XFSF FYBNJOFE
TJDT JCVQSPGFONHFWFSZIPVSTBT XFFLMZVQUPNPOUIBGUFSTVSHFSZBOE
OFDFTTBSZ
XFSFBMTPQSFTDSJCFE UIFOBUNPOUIT 'JHTBOE
1PTU
%SFTTJOHBOETVUVSFTXFSFSFNPWFE PQFSBUJWF DBSF JODMVEFE SFJOGPSDFNFOU
BU  XFFLT QPTUPQFSBUJWFMZ 4
 VSHJDBM PGPSBMIZHJFOFBOENFDIBOJDBMQMBRVF
XPVOET XFSF HFOUMZ DMFBOTFE XJUI SFNPWBMXIFOOFDFTTBSZ
 DIMPSIFYJEJOF HMVDPOBUF PO B 5IF WBSJBCMFT NFBTVSFE BU CBTFMJOF
DPUUPOTXBC1BUJFOUTJOJUJBUFENFDIBOJ BOEBUNPOUITJOCPUIHSPVQTXFSF

267
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig
No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
ti
teXFFLT on ot

n
HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO (3
 BQJDPDPSPOBM BOE UIFSF XBT B NJOJNVN PG  ss e n c e
fo r
XJEUI PG UIF LFSBUJOJ[FE UJTTVF 8,5
 CFUXFFO TVSHFSJFT 5IF CMPPE IBSWFTU
BOEQPDLFUEFQUI 1%
(3XBTEFmOFE JOHQSPDFEVSFXBTOPUDPOTJEFSFEJOUIF
BT UIF EJTUBODF CFUXFFO UIF $&+ BOE QBUJFOUFWBMVBUJPOPGUIFMFWFMPGEJTDPN
UIF HJOHJWBM NBSHJO BU UIF NJECVDDBM GPSUBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFEJGGFSFOUTVSHJDBM
BTQFDU PG UIF UPPUI 8,5 XBT UIF EJT QSPDFEVSFT
UBODFCFUXFFOUIFHJOHJWBMNBSHJOBOE 0OFXBZBOBMZTJTPGWBSJBODF "/0
UIF NVDPHJOHJWBM KVODUJPO 1% XBT UIF 7"
 XBT VTFE UP DPNQBSF QSF BOE
EJTUBODF CFUXFFO UIF HJOHJWBM NBSHJO QPTUPQFSBUJWF DMJOJDBM NFBTVSFNFOUT
BOEUIFCPUUPNPGUIFQPDLFU"6OJWFS XJUIJO UIF TBNF HSPVQ 4UVEFOU t tests
TJUZPG/PSUI$BSPMJOBQFSJPEPOUBMQSPCF XFSF VTFE UP DPNQBSF NFBTVSFNFOUT
DBMJCSBUFEJONNJODSFNFOUTXBTVUJ CFUXFFOUIFUXPUSFBUNFOUHSPVQT1FS
MJ[FE GPS BMM NFBTVSFNFOUT 3FBEJOHT DFOUBHF SPPU DPWFSBHF XBT DBMDVMBUFE
XFSF SPVOEFE UP UIF OFBSFTU  NN VTJOHUIFGPSNVMB
0OFDBMJCSBUFEFYBNJOFS CMJOEFEUPUIF
TVSHJDBM USFBUNFOU NPEBMJUZ FNQMPZFE  < (3 BU CBTFMJOF ¦ (3 BU  NPOUIT
 
DPMMFDUFE UIF EBUB BU CBTFMJOF BOE  (3BUCBTFMJOF>Y
NPOUITQPTUPQFSBUJWFMZ
$MJOJDBMFWBMVBUJPOTPGIFBMJOHFWFOUT P WBMVFT FRVBM UP PS TNBMMFS UIBO 
XFSF FTUJNBUFE XJUI SFDPSEJOHT PG UIF XFSFSFHBSEFEBTTUBUJTUJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOU
IFBMJOH JOEFY )*
 3FDPSEJOHT PG )*
XFSF QFSGPSNFE PO UIF TU BOE OE
XFFLTQPTUTVSHFSZ5IFIFBMJOHJOEFY 3FTVMUT
TDPSFTIFBMJOHPOUIFCBTJTPGSFEOFTT 
QSFTFODFPGHSBOVMBUJPOUJTTVF CMFFEJOH %BUB PO QSF BOE QPTUPQFSBUJWF DMJOJ
BOE TVQQVSBUJPO  BOE FQJUIFMJBMJ[BUJPO DBM NFBTVSFNFOUT BSF TVNNBSJ[FE JO
"TDPSFPGUPJTHJWFO XJUIBTTPDJ 5BCMF/PQSFPQFSBUJWFTJHOJmDBOUEJG
BUFEXJUIWFSZQPPSIFBMJOHBOECFJOH GFSFODFT JO (3  8,5  PS 1% XFSF PC
FYDFMMFOU TFSWFECFUXFFOUIFUXPHSPVQT(3XBT
5IF TVCKFDUT PWFSBMM QPTUPQFSBUJWF SFEVDFEGSPNœNNUPœ
QBJO XBT BTTFTTFE GPS UIF mSTU  EBZT NNJOUIF13'HSPVQ BOEGSPN
VTJOH B IPSJ[POUBM TDBMF  XJUI UIF MFGU œNNUPœNNJOUIF&.%
FOEQPJOU NBSLJOH OP QBJO 
 UIF NJE HSPVQ (3 DIBOHFT XJUIJO FBDI HSPVQ
EMFQPJOUNBSLJOHQBJO 
BOEUIFSJHIU GSPN CBTFMJOF
 BOE CFUXFFO HSPVQT
FOEQPJOU NBSLJOH TFWFSF QBJO 
 5IF XFSF TUBUJTUJDBMMZ TJHOJmDBOU 5IF NFBO
8JMDPYPO UFTU XBT BQQMJFE UP DPNQBSF EFDSFBTF PG (3 XBT  œ  NN
the pain intensity in the postoperative GPSUIF13'HSPVQ BOEœNN
QFSJPE"TJHOJmDBODFMFWFMPGXBT GPS UIF &.% HSPVQ  BOE UIJT EJGGFSFODF
FNQMPZFEJOBMMTUBUJTUJDBMDPNQBSJTPOT XBTOPUTUBUJTUJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOU 'JH

Postoperative treatment of one side .FBOSPPUDPWFSBHFXBTœ
PGUIFNPVUIEJEOPUJOnVFODFUIFPUIFS JOUIF&.%HSPVQ BOEœJO
TJEF CFDBVTF UIF TVSHJDBM QSPDFEVSFT UIF13'HSPVQ$PNQMFUFSPPUDPWFSBHF
XFSF OPU QFSGPSNFE BU UIF TBNF UJNF JOUIF13'HSPVQXBT PVUPG

268
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot

n
Table 1  $MJOJDBMQBSBNFUFSTNFBTVSFEBUCBTFMJOFBOEBUNPOUITQPTUPQFSBUJWFMZ O

ss e n c e fo r
Baseline 12 months

EMD PRF EMD P PRF P

(3 œ œ œpq  œpq 

3$ NA NA œq œq

WKT œ œ œ  œ 

PD œ œ œ  œ 


&.%oDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQDPNCJOFEXJUIFOBNFMNBUSJYEFSJWBUJWF
13'oDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFEnBQDPNCJOFEXJUIQMBUFMFUSJDImCSJONFNCSBOF
(3oHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOJONJMMJNFUFST
3$oQFSDFOUBHFSPPUDPWFSBHFDBMDVMBUFECZ
< (3BUCBTFMJOF¦(3BUNPOUIT
(3BUCBTFMJOF>Y
8,5oBQJDPDPSPOBMXJEUIPGUIFLFSBUJOJ[FEUJTTVFJONJMMJNFUFST
PD – pocket depth in millimeters
/"oOPUBQQMJDBCMF
p4UBUJTUJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOUMZEJGGFSFOUGSPNCBTFMJOFXJUIJOUIFHSPVQ P

q4UBUJTUJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOUMZEJGGFSFOUCFUXFFOUIFUXPUSFBUNFOUHSPVQT P

SFDFTTJPOT
BOEJOUIF&.%HSPVQ Table 2  1BJOJOUFOTJUZJOUIFmSTUEBZTBGUFSTVS
HFSZ O

PGPVUSFDFTTJPOT

*O UIF &.% HSPVQ  8,5 JODSFBTFE Pain intensity
GSPNœNNBUCBTFMJOFUP Day EMD PRF P
œNNBUNPOUIT4JUFTUSFBUFE  œ œ 
XJUI 13' TIPXFE BO JODSFBTF JO 8,5  œ œ 
GSPNœNNBUCBTFMJOFUP  œ œ 
œNNBUNPOUIT1SFBOEQPTU  œ œ 
PQFSBUJWF EJGGFSFODFT XJUIJO HSPVQT 5 œ œ 
XFSF OPU TUBUJTUJDBMMZ TJHOJmDBOU 5IF  œ œ 
NFBO NPOUI JODSFBTF PG 8,5 PC  œ œ 
TFSWFE JO UIF &.% HSPVQ XBT  œ 4UBUJTUJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOU P

NN BOEJOUIF13'HSPVQJUXBT
œNN 'JH
5IFEJGGFSFODF
CFUXFFOUIFUXPHSPVQTXBTTUBUJTUJDBM
MZTJHOJmDBOU GBWPSJOHUIF&.%HSPVQ XFFLTBGUFSTVSHFSZTIPXFEBIJHIMFWFM
1% NFBTVSFNFOUT XFSF OPU TJHOJm PGFRVJWBMFODF œBOEœ
DBOUMZ EJGGFSFOU CFUXFFO CBTFMJOF BOE P

NPOUITXJUIJOUIFUSFBUNFOUHSPVQT  3FHBSEJOH UIF QPTUPQFSBUJWF QFSJPE 
OPSXFSFQPTUPQFSBUJWFEJGGFSFODFTCF UISFFQBUJFOUTJOUIF&.%HSPVQFYQFSJ
UXFFOUIFUXPHSPVQT FODFE TFWFSF QBJO DPNQBSFE XJUI POF
3FTVMUTPG)*PCUBJOFEJOUIF13'HSPVQ JO UIF 13' HSPVQ "MM  QBUJFOUT JO UIF
BGUFSXFFLPGTVSHFSZXFSFTUBUJTUJDBMMZ &.% HSPVQ JOEJDBUFE HSFBUFS EJTDPN
TJHOJmDBOUMZ TVQFSJPS JO SFMBUJPO UP UIF GPSU 5IF QBJO JOUFOTJUZ XBT TUBUJTUJDBMMZ
EBUBSFDPSEFEJO&.%HSPVQ P
 TJHOJmDBOUMZEJGGFSFOUCFUXFFOHSPVQTGPS
'JH
3FDPSEJOHTPGUIF)*PCUBJOFE UIFmSTUEBZT GBWPSJOHUIF13'HSPVQ
JOUIF13'HSPVQBOEUIF&.%HSPVQUXP TFF5BCMF


269
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig
No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
ti
te evi on ot

n
%JTDVTTJPO Therefore, there is no consistentss e n c e
fo r
EFODF TVHHFTUJOH UIBU TVSHJDBM UFDI
5IF QSFTFOU TUVEZ DPNQBSFE UIF FGGFD OJRVFT FNQMPZJOH 13' BSF TVQFSJPS UP
UJWFOFTTPGUXPQFSJPEPOUBMQMBTUJDTVSHJ UFDIOJRVFTVUJMJ[JOH&.%DPNCJOFEXJUI
DBMQSPDFEVSFTJOBDIJFWJOHDPWFSBHFPG $"'JOBDIJFWJOHSPPUDPWFSBHF
FYQPTFESPPUTEVFUPMPDBMJ[FEHJOHJWBM 1PTTJCMFBEWBOUBHFTNBZCFSFMBUFE
SFDFTTJPO.FBOSPPUDPWFSBHFBDIJFWFE to the marked increase in WKT achieved
XJUIUIF$"'DPNCJOFEXJUI&.%JOUIJT XJUIUIF&.%UFDIOJRVFBTPQQPTFEUP
TUVEZ XBT  BU  NPOUIT QPTU UIF NPSFUIBONPEFTU JODSFBTF JO UIF
PQFSBUJWFMZ5IFTFSFTVMUTBSFWFSZTJNJMBS TBNFQBSBNFUFSPCUBJOFEXJUIUIF$"'
UP UIF POFT SFQPSUFE CZ /FNDPWTLZ  QMVT 13' " OBSSPX CBOE PG BUUBDIFE
XIFSF SPPU DPWFSBHF BU  NPOUIT XBT HJOHJWBIBTCFFOSFDPHOJ[FEBTBQSF
  BOE .PEJDB FU BM XIFSF JU XBT EJTQPTJOHGBDUPSGPSHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPO
 It is important to mention that 5IF&.%HSPVQJOUIJTTUVEZQSFTFOU
PUIFSTUVEJFTIBWFSFQPSUFEIJHIFSSBUFT FE XJUI B OPUBCMF JODSFBTF JO 8,5 BU
PG SPPU DPWFSBHF TVDDFTT XJUI UIF $"'  NPOUIT DPNQBSFE UP CBTFMJOF 5IBU
DPNCJOFE XJUI &.% 1JMMPOJ FU BM re JODSFBTF XBT BQQSPYJNBUFMZ  NN
QPSUFEBNFBOTVDDFTTSBUFJOUIF 5IF13'HSPVQTIPXFEBNFBOHBJOPG
USFBUNFOU PG HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO BGUFS  NNPG8,5BGUFSNPOUIT"SPDB
NPOUIT5IFSFBTPOGPSUIJTEJTDSFQBODZ FUBMEJEOPUDPOmSNBOZHBJOPG8,5JO
CFUXFFOEBUBGSPNUIFQSFTFOUTUVEZBOE UIF13'HSPVQBGUFSNPOUIT5IFEJGGFS
1JMMJPOJTSFTVMUTNBZCFSFMBUFEUPWBSJB FODFPCTFSWFECFUXFFOUIFUXPHSPVQT
UJPOTPGVONFBTVSFEQBSBNFUFSTTVDIBT JO BVHNFOUJOH LFSBUJOJ[FE UJTTVF XJEUI
nBQUIJDLOFTTBOEnBQUFOTJPO BUNPOUITXBTTUBUJTUJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOU 
5IFSPPUDPWFSBHFTVDDFTTSBUF PC GBWPSJOHUIF&.%HSPVQ
UBJOFEXJUIUIF$"'DPNCJOFEXJUI&.% 'SPN UIJT PCTFSWBUJPO JU DPVME CF JO
JO UIJT TUVEZ TIPXFE TJHOJmDBOU SFEVD ferred that EMD may have a modest
UJPOPGUSFBUFEHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOBOEB FGGFDU JO JOEVDJOH LFSBUJOJ[BUJPO PG UIF
IJHI MFWFM PG FRVJWBMFODF UP UIF SFTVMUT HJOHJWBM FQJUIFMJVN " SFQPSU CZ )ÚHFM
SFDPSEFEGPS$"'DPNCJOFEXJUI13'*O XBME IBT TVHHFTUFE TVDI BO FGGFDU
UIF QSFTFOU TUVEZ  SFDPSEFE NFBO SPPU GSPN&.%POHJOHJWBMFQJUIFMJB5IFBCJM
DPWFSBHF BDIJFWFE JO UIF 13' HSPVQ JUZPG&.%UPJODSFBTF8,5 IPXFWFS JT
XBTBGUFSUIFPCTFSWBUJPOQFSJPE DMFBSMZOPUBTDMJOJDBMMZTJHOJmDBOUBTUIF
NPOUIT
"SPDBFUBMQSFTFOUFENFBO POFPCTFSWFEXJUI$5(
SPPU DPWFSBHF PG  BGUFS  NPOUIT 5IFDVSSFOUTUVEZEJEOPUQSPWJEFEBUB
VUJMJ[JOH13'$PNQMFUFSPPUDPWFSBHF UPFWBMVBUFUIFBEEJUJPOBMFGGFDUTPG&.%
JOUIF13'HSPVQXBT PVUPG UPUIF$"'JOSPPUDPWFSBHFQSPDFEVSFT 
SFDFTTJPOT
BOEJOUIF&.%HSPVQ BTUIFHSPVQUSFBUFEXJUIUIF$"'BMPOF
PVUPGSFDFTTJPOT
5IFPOMZQVC XBT OPU QBSU PG UIF SFTFBSDI QSPUPDPM
MJTIFE TUVEZ SFHBSEJOH UIF VUJMJ[BUJPO PG )PXFWFS  B TUVEZ CZ %FM 1J[[P FU BM
13' JO UIF USFBUNFOU PG HJOHJWBM SFDFT SFWFBMFE UIBU B DPNCJOBUJPO PG &.%
sion presented complete root cover XJUIUIF$"'EJEOPUSFTVMUJOBEEJUJPOBM
BHFJOUIF13'HSPVQPGPOMZ SPPUDPWFSBHFBTDPNQBSFEUPUIF$"'

270
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te n
ot

n
VTFEBMPOF0OUIFPUIFSIBOE 1JMMPOJ PGDPODFOUSBUFE1%(' 7&(' BOE5('  ss e n c e
fo r
SFWFBMFE TJHOJmDBOU PVUDPNF JNQSPWF UIFNBJOHSPXUIGBDUPSTGSPN13'5IFTF
NFOUTJOBHSPVQXJUIHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPO HSPXUIGBDUPSTNJHIUFOIBODFTPGUUJTTVF
USFBUFEXJUI&.%BOEB$"' DPNQBSFE IFBMJOHCZJODSFBTJOHUIFBOHJPHFOFTJT
UPUIFHSPVQUSFBUFEXJUI$"'BMPOF5IF BOE NBUSJY CJPTZOUIFTJT EVSJOH XPVOE
QPUFOUJBM BEWBOUBHF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI IFBMJOH
&.% JT SFMBUFE UP UIF OBUVSF PG UIF BU 4PNF SFDFOU TUVEJFT FNQIBTJ[FE
UBDINFOUCFUXFFOUIFTPGUUJTTVFBOEUIF UIBU HJOHJWBM UJTTVF UIJDLOFTT JT FTTFO
SPPUTVSGBDF#FDBVTFPGJUTNFDIBOJTN UJBMUPNFBOPSDPNQMFUFSPPUDPWFSBHF
of action, EMD may enhance the devel BOETUBCJMJUZPGDMJOJDBMPVUDPNF BOEBO
PQNFOU PG USVF DPOOFDUJWF BUUBDINFOU JODSFBTF JO UJTTVF UIJDLOFTT IBT CFFO
XIFOBnBQJTDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFE)JT EFTDSJCFEGPMMPXJOH$5( 5PUIFBV
UPMPHJDBMSFQPSUT IPXFWFS TIPXDPOUSP UIPSTLOPXMFEHF UIFSFJTPOMZPOFQVC
WFSTJBMSFTVMUTBTUPUIFBCJMJUZPG&.%UP lication UIBU TFQBSBUFT SPPU DPWFSBHF
JOEVDFQFSJPEPOUBMSFHFOFSBUJPOGPMMPX CZUZQFPSIFBMJOHQBUUFSOXJUISFTQFDU
JOH SPPU DPWFSBHF QSPDFEVSFT While UPUJTTVFUIJDLOFTT"SPDBFUBMTIPXFE
UXPTUVEJFTTIPXFEOFHMJHJCMFBNPVOUT BOPUBCMFJODSFBTFJOHJOHJWBMUIJDLOFTT
PG QFSJPEPOUBM SFHFOFSBUJPO    one BGUFS  NPOUIT JO B HSPVQ USFBUFE XJUI
SFQPSU EFTDSJCFE B TJHOJmDBOU FYUFOU 13' 5IJT NBZ CF UIF SFTVMU PG HJOHJWBM
PG QFSJPEPOUBM SFHFOFSBUJPO PDDVSSJOH BOEQFSJPEPOUBMMJHBNFOUmCSPCMBTUQSP
XIFOVUJMJ[JOH&.%JOSPPUDPWFSBHFQSP liferation related to the impact of con
DFEVSFT5IPTFQVCMJTIFEIVNBOIJT DFOUSBUFEHSPXUIGBDUPSTGSPN13'*OUIF
UPMPHZ TUVEJFT PG UIF DPOOFDUJWF UJTTVF QSFTFOU TUVEZ UIF BVUIPST EJE OPU QFS
HSBGU XFSF QFSGPSNFE XJUIPVU DBMDVMVT GPSN HJOHJWBM UJTTVF UIJDLOFTT BTTFTT
OPUDI NFOUJOUIF13'BOE&.%HSPVQTCFGPSF
5IFCJPMPHJDBMJNQBDUPGFOBNFMNB TVSHFSZBOEBGUFSUIFFWBMVBUJPOQFSJPE
USJY QSPUFJOT NJHIU FOIBODF TPGU UJTTVF 'VUVSFTUVEJFTXJMMFWBMVBUFUIJTQBSBN
IFBMJOHCZJODSFBTJOHUIFBOHJPHFOFTJT FUFS BT B QSPNJTJOH QPUFOUJBM QSFEJDUPS
BOE NBUSJY CJPTZOUIFTJT EVSJOH XPVOE PG SPPU DPWFSBHF 5IFTF TUVEJFT XJMM
IFBMJOH provide additional information related to
3FTVMUT PG UIF IFBMJOH JOEFY JOEJDBU UIFFGmDBDZPG13'VUJMJ[BUJPOJOHJOHJWBM
FE OPUFXPSUIZ JNQSPWFNFOUT PG FBSMZ SFDFTTJPOUSFBUNFOU
XPVOEIFBMJOH mSTUXFFLQPTUTVSHFSZ
 *O PSEFS UP CF NPSF QSFDJTF BOE PC
JOUIFHSPVQUSFBUFEXJUI13'NFNCSBOF KFDUJWF JUIBTUPCFFNQIBTJ[FEUIBUUIF
DPNQBSFE UP UIF HSPVQ USFBUFE XJUI QSFTFOU SFTVMUT  JO UFSNT PG SPPU DPWFS
&.% 5IJT PVUDPNF NBZ CF SFMBUFE UP BHF QFSDFOUBHFBOEDPNQMFUF
BOEJO
UIF FYUSFNFMZ FMFWBUFE EFOTJUZ PG mCSJO DSFBTFJOCVDDBMLFSBUJOJ[FEUJTTVF EPFT
mCFST EFUFDUFE JO UIF 13' NFNCSBOF OPUTFFNUPCFTVQFSJPSUPUIPTFSFDFOUMZ
" IJHI EFOTJUZ PG mCSJO mCFST QSPWJEFT QVCMJTIFEGPSUIF$"'BMPOF 
BEEJUJPOBMTUBCJMJUZUPUIFXPVOEBOEQSP #PUI FWBMVBUFE TVSHJDBM UFDIOJRVFT
NPUFTSBQJEOFPBOHJPHFOFTJT The im QSPWFEUPCFDMJOJDBMMZTVDDFTTGVMJOUIF
provements of HI achieved in the PRF USFBUNFOU PG HJOHJWBM SFDFTTJPO $MJOJ
HSPVQDPVMEBMTPCFFYQMBJOFEBTBDUJPO DBM JNQMJDBUJPOT BOE NJOPS BEWBOUBHFT

271
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
CLINICAL RESEARCH pyrig
No Co

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
TVDDFFE JO EFNPOTUSBUJOH BOZt e
n ot

n
PG13'NFNCSBOFVTFBTHSBGUNBUFSJBM DMJOJDBM
ss e n c e fo r
BSF SFMBUFE UP BEWBODFE UJTTVF IFBMJOH BEWBOUBHFPGUIFVTFPG13'DPNQBSFE
EVSJOH UIF mSTU XFFL QPTU TVSHFSZ BOE UP &.% JO UIF DPWFSBHF PG HJOHJWBM SF
BEFDSFBTFJOQBUJFOUEJTDPNGPSUEVSJOH DFTTJPO XJUI UIF $"' QSPDFEVSF "MTP 
UIFFBSMZXPVOEIFBMJOHQFSJPE5IFBE JUNVTUCFNFOUJPOFEUIBUUIFCMPPEDPM
WBOUBHFPGFBSMZIFBMJOHFWFOUTSFMBUFE MFDUJPOQSPDFEVSFMJOLFEUP13'QSFQB
UPUIFVTFPG13'XBTSFDPSEFEPOMZEVS ration presents additional discomfort for
JOHUIFmSTUXFFLQPTUPQFSBUJWFMZ CVUBQ UIFQBUJFOU
QBSFOUMZJUEPFTOPUNBLFBOPUFXPSUIZ " QPTTJCMF QPTJUJWF UFOEFODZ PG 13'
JNQBDU PO UIF ZFBS DMJOJDBM PVUDPNF VUJMJ[BUJPO TIPVME CF CFUUFS FWBMVBUFE
0OUIFPUIFSIBOE &.%VUJMJ[BUJPOQSP JO TUVEJFT JOWPMWJOH B MBSHFS OVNCFS PG
WJEFTCFUUFS8,5BVHNFOUBUJPO TVCKFDUT/PIJTUPMPHJDBMFWBMVBUJPOXBT
0O UIF CBTJT PG UIF SFTVMUT BDIJFWFE QFSGPSNFEJOUIFQSFTFOUTUVEZUIFSFGPSF
JOUIFQSFTFOUSFTFBSDI JUNVTUCFFN UIFFGGFDUPG13'POPWFSBMMSFHFOFSBUJPO
QIBTJ[FEUIBUUIFQSFTFOUTUVEZEJEOPU DBQBDJUZSFNBJOTUPCFEFUFSNJOFE

References
 .BUUFS+'SFFHJOHJWBMHSBGU therapies for the treatment of )BSSJT3+(53GPSSPPUDPW
and coronally repositioned HJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOBTZTUFN FSBHFBMPOHUFSNGPMMPXVQ
nBQBZFBSGPMMPXVQ BUJDSFWJFX"OO1FSJPEPOUPM Int J Periodontics Restorative
SFQPSU+$MJO1FSJPEPOUPM o %FOUo
o  &EFM"5IFVTFPGBGSFF 8FOOTUSÚN+- 1JOJ1SBUP(
 .JMMFS1%3PPUDPWFSBHF DPOOFDUJWFUJTTVFHSBGU .VDPHJOHJWBMUIFSBQZ*O
VTJOHBGSFFTPGUUJTTVFBVUP UPJODSFBTFUIFXJEUIPG -JOEIF+ ,BSSJOH5 -BOH/1
HSBGUGPMMPXJOHDJUSJDBDJE BUUBDIFEHJOHJWB0SBM FET
$MJOJDBM1FSJPEPOUPM
BQQMJDBUJPOBTVDDFTTGVM 4VSH0SBM.FE0SBM1BUIPM PHZBOE*NQMBOU%FOUJTUSZ
BOEQSFEJDUBCMFQSPDF o $PQFOIBHFO.VOLTHBBSE 
EVSFJOBSFBTPGEFFQXJEF  -BOHFS# -BOHFS-4VC o
SFDFTTJPO*OU+1FSJ epithelial connective tis .D(VJSF., $PDISBO%-
odontics Restorative Dent TVFHSBGUUFDIOJRVFGPSSPPU &WBMVBUJPOPGIVNBOSFDFT
o DPWFSBHF+1FSJPEPOUPM TJPOEFGFDUTUSFBUFEXJUI
 #PSHIFUUJ" (BSEFMMB+1 o coronally advanced flaps
5IJDLHJOHJWBMBVUPHSBGU  3BFU[LF1#$PWFSJOHMPDBM BOEFJUIFSFOBNFMNBUSJY
GPSUIFDPWFSBHFPGHJO J[FEBSFBTPGSPPUFYQPTVSF derivative or connective
HJWBMSFDFTTJPOBDMJOJDBM FNQMPZJOHUIFiFOWFMPQFw UJTTVF1BSU)JTUPMPHJDBM
FWBMVBUJPO*OU+1FSJ UFDIOJRVF+1FSJPEPOUPM FWBMVBUJPO+1FSJPEPOUPM
odontics Restorative Dent o o
o  /FMTPO485IFTVCFQJ ;VDDIFMMJ( %F4BODUJT.
 3PDDV[[P. #VOJOP.  UIFMJBMDPOOFDUJWFUJTTVF -POHUFSNPVUDPNFGPMMPX
/FFEMFNBO* 4BO[. HSBGUBCJMBNJOBSSFDPO JOHUSFBUNFOUPGNVMUJQMF
1FSJPEPOUBMQMBTUJDTVS TUSVDUJWFQSPDFEVSFGPSUIF Miller Class I and II reces
HFSZGPSUSFBUNFOUPGMPDBM DPWFSBHFPGEFOVEFESPPU sion defects in esthetic areas
J[FEHJOHJWBMSFDFTTJPOT TVSGBDFT+1FSJPEPOUPM PGUIFNPVUI+1FSJPEPOUPM
BTZTUFNBUJDSFWJFX+$MJO o o
1FSJPEPOUPM 4VQQM )BSSJT3+3PPUDPWFSBHF $IPVLSPVO+ "EEB' 

oEJTDVTTJPO XJUIDPOOFDUJWFUJTTVFHSBGUT 4DIPFGnFS$ 7FSWFMMF"6OF
o BOFWBMVBUJPOPGTIPSUBOE PQQPSUVOJUÏFOQBSPJNQMBO
 0BUFT58 3PCJOTPO.  MPOHUFSNSFTVMUT+1FSJPE UPMPHJFMF13'*NQMBOUPEPO
(VOTPMMFZ+$4VSHJDBM POUPMo UJFo

272
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
JANKOVIC ET ALopyrig
No C

ht
t fo
rP

by N
ub

Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n

n
$IPVLSPVO+ %JTT"  "SBVKP.( -JOEIF+(53 %FM1J[[P( ;VDDIFMMJ' 
4JNPOQJFSJ"FUBM1MBUFMFU USFBUNFOUPGEFHSFF*** .PEJDB3 %FCFSOBSEJ7$
ss e n c e
fo r
SJDImCSJO 13'
BTFDPOE GVSDBUJPOEFGFDUTGPMMPXJOH Coronally advanced flap
HFOFSBUJPOQMBUFMFUDPO BQQMJDBUJPOPGFOBNFMNBUSJY XJUIPSXJUIPVUFOBNFMNBUSJY
DFOUSBUF1BSU*7$MJOJDBM QSPUFJOTBOFYQFSJNFOUBM EFSJWBUJWFGPSSPPUDPWFSBHF
FGGFDUTPOUJTTVFIFBMJOH TUVEZJOEPHT+$MJO1FSJP BZFBSTUVEZ+$MJO1FSJP
0SBM4VSH0SBM.FE0SBM EPOUPMo EPOUPMo
Pathol Oral Radiol Endod $BSOJP+ $BNBSHP1.  8FOH% )àS[FMFS.# 
o ,FOOFZ&# 4DIFOL3, 2VJOPOFT$3 1FDITUBEU# 
%WPSBL 74 )BSWFZ1  )JTUPMPHJDBMFWBMVBUJPOPG .PUB- $BGGFTTF3()FBM
&TUSFMMB-' #SPXO+ .D%PO DBTFTPGSPPUDPWFSBHF JOHQBUUFSOTJOSFDFTTJPO
BHI %WPSBL".'JCSJO GPMMPXJOHBDPOOFDUJWFUJT EFGFDUTUSFBUFEXJUIF15'&
DPOUBJOJOHHFMTJOEVDFBOH TVFHSBGUDPNCJOFEXJUIBO NFNCSBOFTBOEXJUIGSFF
JPHFOFTJTJNQMJDBUJPOTGPS FOBNFMNBUSJYEFSJWBUJWF DPOOFDUJWFUJTTVFHSBGUT
UVNPSTUSPNBHFOFSBUJPOBOE QSFQBSBUJPO+1FSJPEPOUPM BIJTUPMPHJDBOEIJTUPNFU
XPVOEIFBMJOH-BC*OWFTU o SJDTUVEZJOUIFCFBHMF
o 1JMMPOJ" 1BPMBOUPOJP.  EPH+$MJO1FSJPEPOUPM
,BXBTF5 0LVEB, 8PMGG $BNBSHP13PPUDPWFSBHF o
-' :PTIJF)1MBUFMFUSJDI XJUIBDPSPOBMMZQPTJUJPOFE )VBOHM /FJWB&' 4PFISFO
QMBTNBEFSJWFEmCSJODMPU nBQVTFEJODPNCJOB 4 (JBOOPCJMF75IFFGGFDU
GPSNBUJPOTUJNVMBUFTDPMMB UJPOXJUIFOBNFMNBUSJY of PRP on the coronally
HFOTZOUIFTJTJOQFSJPEPOUBM EFSJWBUJWFNPOUIDMJOJDBM advanced flap root cover
MJHBNFOUBOEPTUFPCMBTUJD FWBMVBUJPO+1FSJPEPOUPM BHFQSPDFEVSFBQJMPU
DFMMTJOWJUSP+1FSJPEPOUPM o IVNBOUSJBM+1FSJPEPOUPM
o )ÚHFMXBME4 4QBIS"  o
%PIBO% $IPVLSPVO+  3PNQPMB& )BMMFS# )FKMJ-  .VMMFS)1 &HFS5.BTUJDB
Diss A, Dohan S, Dohan A, #FSOJNPVMJO+1$PNQBSB UPSZNVDPTBBOEQFSJPEPOUBM
.PVIZJ+1MBUFMFUSJDImCSJO UJWFTUVEZPG&NEPHBJOBOE QIFOPUZQFBSFWJFX*OU+
13'
BTFDPOEHFOFSBUJPO coronally advanced flap Periodontics Restorative
QMBUFMFUDPODFOUSBUF1BSU UFDIOJRVFJOUIFUSFBUNFOU %FOUo
**1MBUFMFUSFMBUFECJPMPHJD PGIVNBOHJOHJWBMSFDFT #BMEJ$ 1JOJ1SBUP( 
GFBUVSFT0SBM4VSH0SBM TJPOT+$MJO1FSJPEPOUPM 1BHMJBSP6FUBM$PSPOBMMZ
Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol o BEWBODFEnBQQSPDFEVSFGPS
&OEPE&o -BOESZ3( 5VSOCVMM SPPUDPWFSBHF*TnBQUIJDL
"SPDB4 ,FHMFWJDI5  34 )PXMFZ5&GGFDUJWF ness a relevant predictor to
#BSCJFSJ# (FSB* &UJFOOF OFTTPGCFO[ZEBNJOF BDIJFWFSPPUDPWFSBHF "
%$MJOJDBMFWBMVBUJPOPGB HCL in the treatment of DBTFTFSJFT+1FSJPEPOUPM
NPEJmFEDPSPOBMMZBEWBODFE QFSJPEPOUBMQPTUTVSHJDBM o
nBQBMPOFPSJODPNCJOB QBUJFOUT3FT$MJO'PSVNT )XBOH%BOE8BOH)-
UJPOXJUIBQMBUFMFUSJDImCSJO o Flap thickness as a predictor
NFNCSBOFGPSUIFUSFBUNFOU /FNDPWTLZ$& "SU[J; 5BM PGSPPUDPWFSBHFBTZTUFN
PGBEKBDFOUNVMUJQMFHJOHJ ) ,P[MPWTLZ" .PTFT0 BUJDSFWJFX+1FSJPEPOUPM
WBMSFDFTTJPOTBNPOUI "NVMUJDFOUFSDPNQBSBUJWF o
TUVEZ+1FSJPEPOUPM TUVEZPGUXPSPPUDPWFS EF4BODUJT. ;VDDIFMMJ(
o BHFQSPDFEVSFTDPSPOBMMZ Coronally advanced flap: a
)BNNBSTUSÚN- )FJKM-  BEWBODFEnBQXJUIBEEJUJPO NPEJmFETVSHJDBMBQQSPBDI
(FTUSFMJVT41FSJPEPOUBM PGFOBNFMNBUSJYQSPUFJOT GPSJTPMBUFESFDFTTJPO
SFHFOFSBUJPOJOBCVDDBM BOETVCFQJUIFMJBMDPOOFDUJWF UZQFEFGFDUTUISFFZFBS
dehiscence model in mon UJTTVFHSBGU+1FSJPEPOUPM SFTVMUT+$MJO1FSJPEPOUPM
keys after application of o o
FOBNFMNBUSJYQSPUFJOT+ .PEJDB' %FM1J[[P. 3PD $BJSP' 3PUVOEP3 .JMMFS
$MJO1FSJPEPOUPM DV[[P. 3PNBHOPMJ3$PSP 1%+S 1BPMP( 1JOJ1SBUP
o nally advanced flap for the (3PPUDPWFSBHFFTUIFUJD
)FJKM- )FEFO( 4WÊSE USFBUNFOUPGCVDDBMHJOHJWBM TDPSFBTZTUFNUPFWBMVBUF
TUSÚN( ½TUHSFO"&OBNFM SFDFTTJPOTXJUIBOEXJUIPVU UIFFTUIFUJDPVUDPNFPGUIF
NBUSJYEFSJWBUJWF &NEP FOBNFMNBUSJYEFSJWBUJWFB USFBUNFOUPGHJOHJWBMSFDFT
HBJO®) in the treatment TQMJUNPVUITUVEZ+1FSJP TJPOUISPVHIFWBMVBUJPOPG
PGJOUSBCPOZQFSJPEPOUBM EPOUPMo DMJOJDBMDBTFT+1FSJPEPOUPM
EFGFDUT+$MJO1FSJPEPOUPM o
o

273
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
70-6.&t/6.#&3t"656./
Copyright of European Journal of Esthetic Dentistry is the property of Quintessence Publishing Company Inc.
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright
holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

You might also like