Property 1

Case Outline
Property and Intellectual Property
Case Outline – 2 SR [SY 2016-2017]
Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Title I. Classification of Property

Topic Art. Case Title Citation GR Date Presenter Back-up

Immovable 415 Leung Yee v. Strong Machinery Compare with L-11658 Feb 15, 1918 Aberilla Ynawat
Property Serg - estoppel
was applied in
latter
PRC, Inc. v. Jarque 41506 Mar 25, 1935 Alba Victor
Berkenkotter v. Cu Unjieng 61 P 663 41643 Jul 31, 1935 Apostol Valera
Davao Sawmill v. Castillo, 40411 Aug 7, 1935 Arellano Ulangkaya
Machinery and Engineering v. CA L-7057 Oct 29, 1954 Baban Sioson
Navarro v. Pineda L-18456 Nov 30, 1963 Banosan Piodos
Caltex v. CBAA Subj to realty tax L-50466 May 31, 1982 Biter PalmaGil
but movable - not
based on NCC
Benguet Corp. v. CBAA 415 p 1 and 3 10604 Jan 29, 1993 Cabarlo Mangate
Serg's Products v. PCI Navarro and 137705 Aug 22, 2000 Calio Malicay
vicencio case
similar with serg
Soriano v. Galit 156295 Sep 23, 2003 Cavite Piodos
JG Summit v. CA 124293 Jan 31, 2005 Codilla Mahusay
Meralco v. City Assessor In contrast to old 166102 Aug 5, 2016 Crabajales Legaspi
Meralco case -
LGC provided that
this is immovable
Capitol Wireless v Provincial Treas Not under par 5 180110 May 30, 2016 Cruz Latorza
but 8
Provincial Assessor v. Filipinas Palm Not under par 5 183416 Oct 5, 2016 Dingal Lara
but LGC (special
law) prevails the
NCC (general
law)- other
provision
Standard oil vs jaranillo No 3rd party - Building is Real property vs realty tax Chattel mortgage vs real
different from immovable BAA v Meralco estate mortgage
Leung Yee case - regardless if land Caltex vs cbaa
estoppel applies is leased or Benguet vs CBAA- tailings
owned but dam
machinery (dapat Meralco vs city assessor
owner of the Capitol wireless
building ang nag-
install) All improvements -
subject to relaty tax

Movable 416 Sibal vs. Valdez Sugar cane 26278 Aug 4, 1927 Du Laguting
Property are personal
property
because of
chattel
mortgage
law
 Property 2
Case Outline
Laurel v. Judge Abrogar International 155076 Jan 13, 2009 Emuy Honorico
Phone Call -
not property;
hence cannot
be stolen

What was
stolen here
was
business, not
the phone
call
Laud v. People Human 199032 Nov 19, 2014 Escobido Flores
remains are
not property
because
they cannot
be
appropriate
d

Crim pro-
“personal
property”
does not
refer to Art
416 but
something
that can be
moved from
one place to
another -
another law
defines
personal
property

Property in 420 City of Manila v. Garcia L-26053 Feb 21, 1967 Flores Escobido
Relation to the Republic v. Lat Vda. Del Castillo, L-69002 Jun 30, 1988 Honorico Emuy
Person to
whom it Republic vs. Gonzales 45338 Jul 31, 1991 Laguting Du
belongs Republic v. CA, Morato 100709 Nov. 14, 1997 Lara Dingal
Chavez v. PEA 133250 Jul 9, 2002 Latorza Cruz
Morandarte & Ferbrera v. CA 123586 Aug 12, 2004 Legaspi Crabajales
Villarico v. Sarmiento 136438 Nov 11, 2004 Mahusay Codilla
Domalsin v. Valenciano 158687 Jan 25, 2006 Malicay Calio
MIAA v. CA 155650 Jul 20, 2006 Mangate Cabarlo
PFDA v. CA 150301 Oct 2, 2007 PalmaGil Biter
PFDA v. CBAA 178030 Dec 15, 2010 Piodos Banosan
MIAA v. City of Pasay 163072 Apr 2, 2009 Sioson Baban
City of Pasig v. RP 185023 Aug 24, 2011 Ulangkaya Arellano
Fernando v. Acuna 161030 Sep 14, 2011 Valera Apostol
RP v. City of Parañaque 191109 Jul 18, 2012 Victor Alba
LBP v. Cacayuran 191667 Apr 17, 2013 Ynawat Aberilla
Dream Village v. BCDA 192986 Jul 24, 2013 Aberilla Ynawat

421 Cebu Oxygen v. Bercilles 66 S 481 L-40474 Aug 29, 1975 Alba Victor
422 Laurel v. Garcia 187 S 797 92013 Jul 25, 1990 Apostol Valera
424 International Hardwood v. UP 200 S 554 Aug 30, 1991 Arellano Ulangkaya
Chavez v. PEA 133250 Jul 9, 2002 Baban Sioson
RP v. Barandiaran 173819 Nov 23, 2007 Banosan Piodos
Heirs of Malabanan v. RP 179987 Apr 29, 2009 Biter PalmaGil
SP of Bataan v. Garcia 174964 Oct 5, 2016 Cabarlo Mangate
 Property 3
Case Outline

Title II. Ownership

Limitations
Topic Art. Case Title Citation GR Date Presenter Back Up
Doctrine of Self 429 People v. Narvaez L-33466 Apr 20,1983 Calio Malicay
Help
Camarines Norte v. Quezon 80796 Oct 11, 2001 Cavite Piodos
MWSS v. Act Theater 147076 Jun 17, 2004 Codilla Mahusay
UCPB v. Basco 142688 Aug 31, 2004 Crabajales Legaspi
Villafuerte v. CA 134239 May 26, 2005 Cruz Latorza
PB Com v. Trazo 165500 Aug 30, 2006 Dingal Lara

Right of the 430 Spouses Custodio v. CA 253 S 483 116100 Feb 9, 1996 Du Laguting
owner
Aneco v. Landex 165952 Jul 28, 2008 Emuy Honorico
Heirs of Limense v. De Ramos 152319 Oct. 28, 2009 Escobido Flores

434 VSD Realty v. Uniwide 170677 Oct 24, 2012 Flores Emuy
Heirs of Julao v. De Jesus 176020 Sep 29, 2014 Honorico Dingal
Ibot v. Heirs of Tayco 202950 Apr 06, 2015 Laguting Du

Rights of Accession
Topic Art. Case Title Cit GR Date
What owner owns 437 NPC v. Ibrahim 168732 Jun 29, 2007 Lara Dingal

With Respect to 440- Tacas v. Tobon 30240 Aug 23, 1929 Latorza Cruz
what is Produced 444 Bachrach Motor v. Talisay-Silay 35223 Sep 17, 1931 Legaspi Crabajales
Torbela v. Spouses Rosario 140528 Dec 7, 2011 Mahusay Codilla

With Respect to 445 Bernardo v. Bataclan 44606 Nov 28, 1938 Malicay Calio
Immovable Villasi v. Spouses Garcia 190106 Jan 15, 2014 Mangate Cabarlo
Property
Daclison v. Baytion 219811 Apr 6, 2016 PalmaGil Biter
Provincial Assessor v. Filipinas Palm 183416 Oct 5, 2016 Piodos Banosan

447 Pacific Farms v. Esguerra L-21783 Mar 25, 1970 Sioson Baban
Heirs of Orosa v. Migrino 99338-40 Feb 1, 1993 Ulangkaya Arellano

448 Ignacio v. Hilario L-175 Apr 30, 1946 Valera Apostol

Tayag v. Yuseco 14043 Apr 16, 1959 Victor Alba
Ignao v. IAC 72876 Jan 18, 1991 Ynawat Aberilla
Pecson v. CA 115814 May 26, 1995
Pleasantville Dev’t. Corp. v. CA 79688 Feb 1, 1996
Parilla v. Pilar 167680 Nov 30, 2006
Technogas v. CA 108894 Feb 10, 1997
RP v. Judge Ballocanag 163794 Nov 28, 2008
Sulo sa Nayon v. Nayong Pilipino 170923 Jan 20, 2009
Arangote v. Spouses Maglunob 178906 Feb 18, 2009
Cabang v. Basay 180587 Mar 20, 2009
Navarez v. Alciso 165907 Jul. 27, 2009
Tuatis v. Escol 175399 Oct. 27, 2009
Fuentes v. Roca 178902 Apr 21, 2010
Benedicto v. Villaflores 185020 Oct 6, 2010
Angeles v. Pascual 157150 Sep 21, 2011
Torbela v. Spouses Rosario 140528 Dec 7, 2011
Communities v. Nanol 176791 Nov 4, 2012
 Property 4
Case Outline
Vda de Roxas v. Our Lady’s Foundation 182378 Mar 6, 2013
Aquino v. Aguilar 182854 Jun 29, 2015
Bliss v. Diaz 213233 Aug 5, 2015
DepEd v. Casibang 192268 Jan 27, 2016
Christian Spiritists v. Mangallay 101483 Mar 18, 2016
Pidlaoan v. Pidlaoan 196470 Apr 20, 2016
Lim-Rosario v. Lim 206534 Oct 24, 2016

449- Congregation RVM v. CA 126363 Jun 26, 1998

451 De Vera vs. CA 97761 Apr 14, 1999
Pada-KIlario v. CA 134329 Jan 19, 2000
Heirs Durano v. Uy 136456 Oct 24, 2000
Ravina v. Villa Abrille 160708 Oct 16, 2009
NHA v. Baello 200858 Aug 7, 2013

BPI v. Sanchez 179518 Nov 11, 2014

Padilla v. Malicsi 201354 Sep 21, 2016

452 Martinez v. Baganus 9438 Nov 25, 1914

454 Enriquez v. De Guzman 28721 Oct. 5, 1928
Geminiano v. CA 120303 Jul 24, 1996
Editha Alviola vs. CA 117642 Apr 24, 1998
Pada-Kilaro v. CA 134329 Jan. 19, 2000

457 Grande v. CA L-17652 Jun 30, 1962

Zapata v. Director of Lands L-17645 Oct 30, 1962
Agne v. Director of Lands L-40399 Feb 6, 1990
Agustin v. IAC 66075-76 Jul 5, 1990
Vda. De Nazareno v. CA 98045 Jun 26, 1996
Heirs of Navarro v. IAC 68166 Feb 12, 1997
Bagaipo v. CA 116290 Dec 8, 2000
Siain Enterprises v. FF Cruz 146616 Aug 31, 2006
New Regent v. Tanjuatco 168880 Apr 16, 2009
Office of City Mayor v. Ebio 178411 Jun. 23, 2010
RP v. Santos III 160453 Nov 12, 2012
Narvasa v. Victoriano 182908 Aug 6, 2014

458 Govt v. Colegio De San Jose 53P423 Aug 29, 1929

461 Baes v. CA 108065 Jul 6, 1993

With Respect to 472 Santos v. Bernabe 31163 Nov 6, 1929

Movable
Property

474 Aguirre v. Pheng L-20851 Sep 3, 1966

Quieting of Title 476 Sapto v. Fabiana L-11285 May 16, 1958

Bucton v. Gabar L-36359 Jan 31, 1974
Coronel v. IAC 70191 Oct 29, 1987
Fernandez v. CA 83141 Sep 21, 1990
Mamadsual v. Moson 92557 Sep 27, 1990
Pingol v. CA 102909 Sep 6, 1993
 Property 5
Case Outline
Heirs of Olviga v. CA 104813 Oct 21, 1993
Secuya v. Vda. De Selma 136021 Feb 22, 2000
Metrobank v. Alejo 141970 Sep 10, 2001
Foster-Gallego v. Galang 130228 Jul 27, 2004
Portic v. Cristobal 156171 Apr 22, 2005
Calacala v. RP 154415 Jul 28, 2005
Bank of Commerce v. San Pablo 167848 Apr 27, 2007
Rico v. Rufon 525S477 04-1822 Jun 25, 2007
Butuin v. Caoleng 157567 Aug 10, 2007
Tandog v. Macapagal 144208 Sep 11, 2007
Clado-Reyes v. Spouses Limpe 163876 Jul 9, 2008
Guaranteed Homes v. Heirs 171531 Jan 30, 2009
Lasquite v. Victory Hills 175375 Jun 23, 2009
Acosta v. Salazar 161034 Jun 30, 2009
Eland v. Garcia 173289 Feb 17, 2010
Philiville v. Bonifacio 167391 Jun 8, 2011
Green Acres v. Cabral 175542 Jun 5, 2013
Tappa v. Bacud 187633 Apr 4, 2016
Extramadura v. Extramadura 211065 Jun 15, 2016
Heirs of Castillejos v. La Tondeña 190158 Jul 20, 2016
IVQ Landholdings v. Barbosa 193156 Jan 18, 2017

Title III. Co-ownership

Topic Art. Case Title Citation GR Date
Definition 484 Spouses Si v. CA 122047 Oct 12, 2000
Mercado-Fehr v. Fehr 152716 Oct 23, 2003
Ocampo v. Ocampo 150707 Apr 14, 2004
Sanchez v. CA 152766 Jan 20, 2003
Herrera v. Fangonil 169356 Aug 28, 2007
Balus v. Balus 168970 Jan 15, 2010
Pascual v. Ballesteros 186269 Feb 15, 2012

Shares in benefits 485 Jimenez v. Fernandez L-46364 Apr 6, 1990

and charges De Guia v. CA 120864 Oct 8, 2003
Mendoza v. CA 199 S 778

Right to bring 487 Punsalan v. Boon Liat 44 P 320 18009 Jan 10, 1923
action for ejection De Guia v. CA 120864 Oct 8, 2003
Wee v. De Castro 176405 Aug 20, 2008
Plasabas v. CA Mar 31, 2009

Right to 488 Adille v. CA L-44546 Jan 29, 1988

reimbursement Aguilar v. CA 76351 Oct 29, 1993

RA 4726 490 Sunset View v. Campos L-52361 Apr 27, 1981

Condo Act
Alteration 491 Javier v. Javier 2812 Oct 18, 1906

Rights regarding 493 Mercado v. Liwanag L-14429 Jun 30, 1962

ideal share Acebedo v. Abesamis 217 S 186
Bailon v. CA 160 S 738
Sps. Cruz v. Leis 125233 Mar 9, 2000
 Property 6
Case Outline
Del Campo v. CA 108228 Feb 1, 2001
Sanchez v. CA 152766 Jun 20, 2003
Heirs of Balite v. Lim 152168 Dec 10, 2004
Metrobank v. Pascual 163744 Feb 29, 2008
Heirs of Co v. Gervacio 157537 Sep 7, 2011

Partition 494 Fabian v. Fabian 22 S 520

Ceniza v. CA 46345 Jan 30, 1990
Bicarme v. CA 51914 Jun 6, 1990
Delima v. CA 46296 Sep 24, 1991
Arturio Trinidad v. CA 118904 Apr 20, 1998
Tomas Claudio v. CA 124262 Oct 12, 1999
Santos v. Santos 139524 Oct 12, 2000
Austria v. Lichauco 170080 Apr 4, 2007
Herrera v. Fangonil 169356 Aug 28, 2007
Monteroso v. CA 105608 Apr 30, 2008
Alano v. PDB 171628 Jun 13, 2011
Heirs of Co v. Servacio 157537 Sep 7, 2011
Rizal v. Naredo 151898 Mar 13, 2012

Essentially 498 Aguilar v. CA 76351 Oct 29, 1993

indivisible object Reyes v. Concepcion 190 S 171 56550 Oct 1, 1990

Title IV. Some Special Properties – WATERS

Art. Case Title Citation GR Date
Ownership of 502- Republic v. Lat Vda. De Castillo L-69002 Jan 30, 1988
Waters 503 Taleon v. Sec. of Public Works and L-24281 May 16, 1967
Communications

RP v. Candymaker 163766 Jun 22, 2006

Filinvest v. Flood 165955 Aug 10, 2007
Fernando v. Acuna 161030 Sep 14, 2011

Use of Public 504- Honorio Bulao v. CA, et al., 101983 Feb 1, 1993
Waters 506